Discussion Locked

Taxation in excess of 50% of gross income

0 helpful
138 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

is slavery.

By definition, paying more than 50% of gross wage, salaries and tips (or more than 50% or profits in the case of businesses) means that the benefits of personal production do more to benefit others than to benefit the ones who earn it. Whether the earnings are paid directly to a single feudal lord or distributed according to an indecipherable array of regulations does nothing to change the fact that someone other than myself is in fact treated as the rightful owner of my work, my time, my life, and only after the government subsidizes Kenneth Lay's privilege to commit fraud, George Bush's privilege to fund "faith-based" projects and convicts' cable television (the least of these offenses) do I get to enjoy the leftover scraps of what I earned for the lot of them. That is slavery.

138 replies

by jck

If your taxation gets you free medical, dental, vision, life insurance, etc...it's not a bad deal.

I was paying in the 31% tax bracket in the USA, then also paying over $5k a year of my *net* income into medical, dental and vision insurance (about another 9% of my gross). And, I wasn't even making 6 figures.

The only flaw I can see with high-taxation schemes is the government having services for those who are able bodied and can work to ride the system for a living. If you have no skill, the government should train you and place you in a job you're physically able to do. No one should ride the bus for free.

That way, everyone contributes something, except for those who are mentally or physically incapable.

by montgomery gator

That is a very rough estimate (guess), but most working Americans benefit from maybe only 1/2 of their taxes, the portion that goes to national defense & security, the transportation infrastructure, law enforcement, and other vital government functions. The rest goes to "entitlement" programs that are legalized theft from one segment of society to another. They should not be called "entitlements", since no one should be entitled to free money from the government.

My taxation does not give me free medical, etc. That comes from my employer, along with deductions for a portion of it from my paycheck. I do not want to have socialized medicine, that would just make taxes even higher, and make medical care too overly regulated and bureaucratic.

We need less spending and less regulation, return the Federal government powers to those that it is limited to in the US Constitution. We lost too much of our freedom and tax money starting with the "New Deal" socialist programs and it has just gotten worse. And it is not just the Democrats. Even though I voted for GWB (just because Kerry would have been worse), he has expanded the Federal government social programs too much with his Medicare prescription benefit and "No Child Left Behind". The Federal government has no business being involved with that stuff.

If government is to take care of "entitlements" and education, it is the individual States' responsibilities to decide what to do and how to do it and how much in taxes to pay for it. There is no justification in the US Constitution for the Federal government to spend money on social programs and regulate education. Powers not specifically enumerated for the Federal government are left up to the individual States, according to the 10th Amendment, which has been grossly ignored, especially starting with FDR and the "New Deal".

We need a return to limited Federal government with the individual States as sovereign when it comes to these issues to do as they and their voters decide without Federal interference and without Federal tax money.

by jamesrl

I have ranted on this before, but socialising medicine does not necessarily mean more bureacracy than private insurance. In fact the studies have shown that approximately 10%-12% of Canadian health care dollars go to administration, while in the US its 20%. The Canadian system costs less. And there are studies to show that the outcomes aren't worse, despite all the horror stories. The study of systems worldwide show that for some situations you are better off here than in the US, and in others the reverse. Japan spends more per capita than the US, has more hospital beds and more diagnostic equipment, yet isn't markedly better in outcomes.

James

by roger99a

That was finally settled in 1865 when the Federal Government restricted the rights of individual states to seceed from the Union. Those rights have been erroding ever since. If you really want to fuss about taxes then you should calculate the amount of taxes that aren't taken from your paycheck, like sales taxes, gasoline ect. Here's a nice tax story. A couple of years ago I built a small boat. I paid sales tax for the lumber using money I had already paid state income tax on. The guy that delivered the lumber paid fuel tax and property tax on the delivery truck. The lumber yard men paid income taxes. Their employer paid income tax on the profit made from the lumber plus Social Secirity taxes for the employees. Now every year I have to pay property taxes on this boat or I'm breaking the law. The government will, in a few years, make more money on this boat than I paid for it.

by absolutely

I voted for Badnarik (Libertarian) because even though he was sure to not win, the two major parties are corrupt to such an extent that they cannot be said to represent anybody's interest, even their own. They blow like leaves in the wind. A vote for any third party candidate is a vote for competition, which is what is really most needed here.

by mhasf

With Bush coming from a BIG OIL BUSINESS background, one has to wonder where the money is really going. Now he wants to give his buddies land to build their refineries on! C'mon America, wake up!!!!

While we in California are some of the highest taxed in the nation, we are forced to drive on roads that are in rediculous shape. We don't even have really bad weather... I have seen better roads in New England where they have to contend with ice and the like. I could go on...

by jessie

As a former welfare recipient, I can tell you that the MAJORITY of the people ON welfare are NOT the ones that are just too lazy to work. They're the ones who ARE working, but they're single parents with kids in daycare and they're making minimum wage. Or they're two parent families, both minimum wage earners, with kids and it costs more to put the kids in daycare than they BOTH make combined in a week of working.

"Well, they shouldn't have had kids then." Great! Easy for someone who's never had a condom break, or been the .01% for whom the pill doesn't work, or whose religion DOES permit them to use birth control, to say. And what about the ones who could afford all of their kids when they had them, but got laid off from the only job-provider in town (because manufacturing is cheaper overseas) and they've got 4 kids to feed and clothe and educate?

There are government programs to help people get training, but the waiting lists are about 3-5 years long, and there's about 100 pages of paperwork to fill out just to get on the waiting list. And GWB has taken away a good portion of funding for the Pell Grant which gives to lower income students to help them pay for college.

Don't call me lazy until you've walked a mile in my shoes.

by jamesrl

I know that Ontario has workfair - draconian to some, but there is an option for training instead of work.

I've never been on welfare, but I did live in co-op housing, where some of the residents were on welfare or other forms of social assistance. Like any group there was a range of people, there were those unable to work, and those unwilling. I saw this first hand, as in co-ops everyone has to pitch in and do maintenance of shared facilities.

In Canada there are fewer excuses, there are subsidized day care situations in most provinces and training is available without a wait. In Quebec they implemented $5 a day day care. While this is subsidized, there should be an offset as people move out of welfare and into paying jobs, where they will pay taxes.

In the long run, investing in education is the way to get most people out of the welfare trap. The availability of high school equivalency, and job skills training does impact the nimber of people on welfare, and an investment in training can pay big dividends by lowering the welfare rolls and creating a tax payer. I don't have any qualms about my taxes going to that type of program.

James

by anykey???

When my first child was born we received some goverment assistance, this particular program help buy certain groceries for my wife and child and helped me out so much it is unbelievable. I hated to use the vouchers though, you would be at the checkout and people would give you looks and things like that, it made me feel like a failure to my family. those feelings also gave me the drive to make sure that I didn't fail and do the best I could for my family.

I also agree on the daycare issue when all 3 of my kids are in daycare during the summer months, it costs me $560 a month, and $440 a month for the younger 2 the rest of the year. I live in a small midwest town, and have been told by people living in larger cities that I am getting by pretty cheap!!

I think that instead of welfare giving so much for free,they need to offer free daycare, that would be in exchange for other assistance. This allow the parent(s) to go out and get a job,or schooling giving them the ability to support their family not our tax dollars. I believe form my personal experience that when you provide for your family it give you the drive needed to strive for more. That way people have a reason to get off the couch other that looking to see if this months check has come yet.

by jdclyde

you only hear about the most extream.

Everyone knows about the professional welfare queen driving an ENVOY to pick up their welfare check. Yes they are out there. Doesn't mean everyone on assistance is going that.

The system is there for the people that need that short term help and it should stay there.

I know that it is hard to get off the assistance too because everytime you try to improve yourself you get penalized by the government.

The fact that you did it is GREAT. You put in your time and pulled yourself up with a lot against you. A lesser person would have just gone along for the ride. Your not a lesser person.

My mom found herself on welfare when I was five and my brother sever when she got divorced. She now has her masters and is an administrator at a regional business college as well as being an instructor.

by jck

I simply stated no one should ride the bus for free that is able to work.

I mentioned nothing about those who are working and are still below the poverty line.

My comments address the tens of thousands who *are* on welfare, who do *not* work, and who probably never will because our government is content to pay them to sit and do nothing.

As for having kids: If you can't support yourself, why should you have kids? You seriously want me to think it's okay to bring a life into this world that needs food and water like you do, when you can barely provide food and water for yourself? That's real love and compassion.
Having sex is human nature, but it shouldn't be other people's responsibility to carry the financial burden of anyone else's sexual activities or mishaps. Sex *is* an optional activity. You don't have to have it to live.

As for religion not allowing birth control: If you're single and so devout of a religious person and Christian, I think that you'll find that most established Christian religions that condemn the use of birth control also condemn marriage before wedlock. Hence, you're already a traitor to your own religious proclamation before you refuse the condom or the pill and you commit the act of sex before being married. Anyone who is single and Christian that claims to refuse birth control because of their beliefs and has sex out of wedlock is one case for which your argument without base. As for the married folks, there's something called family planning...and again...sex is an option...not required.

As for government bureaucracy: I know people that have sat on their a** and been on welfare all of their life and never even bothered to sign up for anything. They don't want to work for themselves. I don't blame them. Who wants to go deal with a**holes all day?
Fact is tho, they should automatically be put on the list to go for some training, even if it takes 3-5 years waiting to get it. And when their number is called to get training...if they don't show up and there is no extenuating circumstance to prevent them from coming...they get dropped from the dole. That's where government is failing the working folks...they're not making able-bodied free-loading people get off their keister and do something to contribute. We're like "oh...that poor person...they must be so down". Well, they're gonna stay down unless you lift them up and get them back on their feet. Get them off their butt tho. I don't care if they make minimum wage. As long as they contribute *something* to society in the way of becoming part of the working community, at least they're making an effort to warrant public assistance if they need it.

As for people who lose their jobs that have a family: Again, if they're working to do something for themselves...there's no reason they shouldn't get public assistance until they get back on their feet.

As for GWB: Don't blame me. I voted for John Kerry and previous to that the Libertarian candidate Harry Browne. I told people what an a** he was from the time I met him briefly at an event in Oklahoma. So, he's not my fault. Don't even take it there with me. He's another mistake other people made...not me. If ya don't like him, he'll be gone in about 33 months. You gotta wait just like me...or, figure out how to get him impeached.

You took all my comments out of context...if you make $5 an hour and work and do you're part, you're not freeloading or "riding the bus for free".

As for walking a mile in your shoes...let me tell you about poor: I've lived on $20 a month before because my parents were too proud to take public assistance when my mother was laid up in the hospital with cancer for weeks and weeks and we didn't have that second income to pay bills. So if you wanna talk about living hard, I can relate. I've been poor. And my parents were even poorer than that as kids growing up in the post-depression era. So, don't act like I don't know what it's like.
Just because my parents made it and worked their butts off all their lives doesn't mean I haven't had to live in a house and not use electricity because it might get cut off if I do, ot that I haven't eaten a diet of 12 for $1 ramen noodles and 8 for $1 generic canned vegetables for months before because that's all we could afford. So yeah, I've been there. Did you think cause that I have a good job I haven't "been in your shoes"? Only reason that my family hasn't been on welfare was because my parents believed in working *hard* for what they got and didn't believe in taking help from others unless it was *needed*. Believe me...I've suffered. You just assumed I haven't been poor.

And as for school financing, I went to school on a scholarship cause I made good grades and excelled at music and I WORKED. I didn't get a free ride from mom and dad. I worked for what I had. And, I didn't get grants or loans because my parents worked and were "above the line". There's nothing that says if you're poor that you can't make good grades and get into college on a scholarship. That's a misnomer. Grades are about effort and achieving scholastically...not about your income level.

So, don't think I haven't walked a mile in your "shoes" until you know my "shoes" weren't worse than yours.

by absolutely

I am sorry the thread took this turn. It is not right to blame individual recipients of any particular assistance program for the faulty decisions which none of us have corrected (by which I mean government schemes to redistribute wealth on any basis other than production, and its value on a *free* market). Those of us who see the inevitable long-term dangers inherent in the appearance that socialist ideology can work "if it's done right" are responsible to explain, CALMLY, why it cannot. Alienating people who once received welfare is a lousy way to turn voters. Whether or not welfare helps some people is a point I am not interested in disputing, and I hope to convince some free market folks here that it's a USELESS discussion to have, no matter how deplorable a welfare queen is, in the context of the general problem. The poor are NOT receiving federal subsidies in larger amounts than the rich! Corporate welfare costs $400 billion in just the agriculture industry, about half in the form of price supports and the other half as direct subsidies. Then there is the "regulated" energy industry. Steel. And so on. To the haters of the Welfare recipients, please have the honesty to recognize that being a multimillionaire on the dole is a much greater crime than surviving badly on the dole, and even indulging in a few frivolous toys!

Dwayne Andreas of Archer Daniels Midland gave $100,000 to the Democrats days before President Clinton ordered 10 percent of the country to use ethanol (one of Archer Daniels Midland's main products). Dwayne Andreas owns a private jet. Let that set your perspective before you insult a poor welfare recipient, or even a middle-class one in a SUV.

by absolutely

If my "taxation gets" something for me, that thing is not free!

If I'm being taxed for something for which I have no use, I'm being robbed.

If the "free" medical, dental, vision, life insurance, etc that my taxation gets me is inferior in quality to what the same quantity of hard-earned money could purchase on a free market, then I have been robbed. Same is true if I earn $500,000 annually, and 90% of the money I pay to the government for health care is spent on other people's health care. Something I have earned is replaced by nothing, or by something inferior. That's robbery.

The public good is not in my private interest. My private interest is. Each member of the public has an overriding interest in his or her own private good. I will not consider helping somebody who has just been stupid to avoid the consequences of that, and no government has the right to contradict my decision. I am interested in helping my friends, who I know to be of respectable, honest character, should they experience hard times. I'm sure the same is true of everybody else.

The fundamental flaw with high-taxation schemes is not the inevitable resultant abuse, it is the moral premise. I would very much like to hope that in a hard luck situation I could count on my loved ones, but it is NOT MY RIGHT to expect anything from anybody, except to be left alone to succeed or fail according to my ability, not according to any anybody else's need!

Stay out of my way, let me succeed, and there will be so much more production than if I help the incompetent to pretend that they have something to contribute, there will really be a lot more wealth given freely than if the productive process is stifled in the first place by consideration of parasites as "part of the economy".

by jdclyde

You will hear many scum bag politicians jumping on the idea that it isn't "fair" that all these people are so "poor" while these other people are so rich.

So to make the poor poor feel better we will try to drag them down to your level. Much easier than trying to get you to life yourself up to the rich level.

Your people who bring in the 6+ figure salaries do not work the bankers hours. Plan on 60+ hours minimum. A business quote I heard before is "day light is for wimps" because if you leave work that early you aren't going to make the big check.

I personally decided how high I needed to get to live comfortably with my family and still be able to do things with that family. I could get about $20K more a year just by moving about a hundred miles south, but that paycheck is not worth more to me than my friends and family.

The other point is the stigma that has been placed on being poor. Being poor is not a thing of disgrace or make you less of a person provided you put in an honest days work for an honest days pay. Think back fifty years, and most people were what would be concidered poor, but they were not degenerate leaches out looking for something for nothing.

If you look at all the poor poor today, how many of them have at least one car? More than one TV in their house? Cable TV? Cell phone? Smoke? These things are not cheap, and if they are so poor how do they get it all? Or is that a big part of WHY they are dirt poor, because they BLOW all their money on crap like that? YOU DO NOT HAVE A RIGHT TO HAVE A BIG SCREEN TV. You have a right to get a skill, seek employment and EARN that TV.

Another point, how many poor people do you know that are over weight? Two issues with being over weight, you eat too much (costs money) and you don't get enought exersise so they must not be working too hard to get through the day.

Our poor poor are better off than many of the people in other countries because they DO GET FREE HEALTH CARE and they do get free food.

Not everyone who is poor is that way because they got laid off, and I would bet that they make up a very small percentage of people who are now concidered "poor".

I am not rich, and by the time I pay off my student loans that it took to get my job I will get to start paying for my boys to go to college so they can get a good job and live comforably too. But I am not poor (anymore) because of hard work.

Expect more from people and you get more.
Expect less and you get less.

by salamander

Now for a very unpopular view...

I'm of the opinion that taxation should be proportional to the amount of services used. A single, self-supporting person who's pretty much just utilizing the post office, police/fire, and national defense services ought to pay less in taxes than people with children who are using more social resources...because they're using less stuff.

Frankly, I'm looking forward to voting down another property tax levy next Tuesday to fund more teacher salaries. Administrators in our district make more than $100,000, habitually. The money's not going to the kids. On property tax issues, I'm of the opinion that if you don't own real estate that's going to be taxed by a levy, then you ought not be able to vote on that issue. That's voting to spend other peoples' money, in my view.

by jamesrl

Though you remind me of the Simpson episode where the people without kids passed a law.....

I will state for the record that I have kids, but I thought the same as a bachelor. Education is an investment for the whole society. Societies with more education tend to have more wealth and less crime. But I do agree that too much money is diverted to administration.

In Ontario, the conservatives dealt with that by consolidating school boards to reduce the number of them. They also reduced the number of legislators (members of Provincial Parliament) from 125 to 100, so it wasn't just school boards picked on - and they put a cap on the salaries of trustees, and forced boards to balance budgets.

With regards to property tax, whether you pay it directly through taxes, or indirectly through rent, you are paying property taxes. When I was renting, I resented the fact that a rental unit costing 100,000 would pay 6 times the tax that a house in Toronto that cost 100,000 would. You can bet that its reflected in the cost of the rent.

James

by salamander

I did think of the Simpsons when I typed that.

I agree that we need some consolidation and some reform of the educational system here in the U.S. There does need to be some consolidation and refocusing on priorities. Fewer legislators would be nice, too.

I don't begrudge children a decent education. There's just imbalance in the system regarding how it's distributed, and I don't want to contribute any more to that administrative black hole than I have to. And frankly, if kids want to play lacrosse, their parents should have to pay for it. The school I went to didn't have lacrosse, so I was obviously greatly deprived as a youngster. :)

That's an interesting point re: rent, that I had not thought of. I may go in search of data on that. Thank you for bringing it up.

by jdclyde

Well that is a change from what I am used to seeing posted out here.

It seems that with the global nature of this group it has a definite socialist leaning.

The idea of people being responsible for themselves? What a silly idea. It would never happen.

As long as there are a lot of "poor" people that are able to vote on how the money that is earned by the "rich" people, it will continue on with this robin hood policy of leach from the rich, and give peanuts to the poor. Notice that many of the social programs for the poor poor are never aimed at raising them up to not me poor anymore. They are there to create dependance so that there will be a permanent voting base of people that are looking for a government that will give them something instead of a government that will remove obsticals so they can go out and advance themselves.

If Kerry was in office our taxes would be even higher than they are now!

Clinton wouldn't get rid of the marriage penalty tax "because they would loose too much revenue".

One party talks about "Affordable health care" while the other talks about "Free health care". Nothing is free. It just means that is one more thing that people can pass off the expense to someone else.

You don't feel like going next door and stealing their money, so you have the government go in and steal it for you.

Fines are a tax for doing something bad.
Taxes are a fine for doing something good.

by salamander

It's the slippery slope of politics. Each politician has to promise to give people more goodies than the previous one did in order to get elected. Nobody ever runs on a platform of "I'm going to give less."

I agree entirely with your point re: government should be removing obstacles.

by anykey???

a politician that actually had a stance on something and defended that stance until the day he/she died, did not change his/her stance to what will get votes, was honest, respectable person and stood up for something.

We need more illiterate politicians,so that they cannot read what the current polls say they need to endorse.

Also get rid of any politician that accepts money from lobbyists, that is not a stance that is a paycheck,

hell I'll vote for whoever you want for $500 bucks, let me know, I even accept PAYPAL(sounds pretty shady when it's put like that huh)

by roger99a

I think it is assumed that everyone born gets a chance to grow up and pay taxes. These kids that are being educated (poorly) will also one day pay property taxes for the education of the next generation regardless of whether they choose to spread their DNA around or not. You had the benefit of the education and services available when you were too young to pay for them and now it's time to chip in. Wasting money though is another issue. I'm not against forcing government institutions to live within our means.

by salamander

I think that taxation should be more proportional to the amount of services used, and we're probably not going to agree on that. I've no problems paying my share at all. I simply think that fairness demands that people who use more resources should pay more for the resources they are using. If I mail one letter at the post office, I pay thirty-seven cents. If I mail two, I pay seventy-four. If I want to ship a package across the country, I might pay three bucks. That seems fair to me.

I don't think throwing more money at the education of children is the answer, honestly. Many other countries, with far fewer resources, raise children who, on average, outperform U.S. children on virtually any measure of standardized testing. I don't know what the answer is, but I'm pretty sure it's not *all* about the money.

My mother, who is a baby boomer, and I had an interesting conversation about the difference between her generation and my generation the other day. She noted that U.S. culture is a heck of a lot more child-centric now than it ever was when she was parenting my brother and I...that there's something strange with my generation. I can see her point. More money is spent now on kids (privately and publicly) than there ever has been, but they seem to be less successful now. Hm.

by absolutely

...and I supposedly "benefited" from public education (nobody ever has, nor ever will, be better off with public education than if it had been left to private enterprise), you assert that I must accept that as an unalterable fact of the Universe, and pay my share? How about this: you got mugged last month, but then you took a self defense class that taught you confidence as well as self defense. You're better off for it, so the whole experience was a net benefit, and now you must accept mugging as your civic duty! Chip in, and take one for the team! It doesn't stand to reason to claim that having been victimized once entitles the perpetrator to continue victimizing me. Don't diminish the moral significance of individual rights as an absolute in every case with trivial claims of "some benefit" in any particular case, as a justification for mutual slavish interconnectedness.

It appears that you accept that public education is an inferior version of what is offered at private schools. I agree with that. Then you claim that it is my duty to help perpetuate it. That is irrational. Because a bad decision was made once, without my consultation, does not obligate me to assist in making the same mistake until the human species drives itself extinct from terminal ignorance.

"You had the benefit of the education and services available when you were too young to pay for them and now it's time to chip in."

You could just as well present that argument to a freed slave after the Civil War, and with as much validity. I didn't ask for public education nor was I asked to agree to any terms in exchange for the receipt of it, therefore I am under no obligation for having endured it. I owe nobody any debt for "education" that was required of me by law in the first place.

by montgomery gator

..The income tax in the USA has dependent deductions and child tax credits. It should be the other way around, with higher taxes for people with more dependents, using your argument (which I do agree with). And do away with the Earned Income Tax credit. We need a Flat Tax system, a straight percentage, without special deductions. More efficient to collect, more fair to the taxpayers.

by salamander

I've got nothing to add to that, except agreement. Interestingly enough, the very wealthy would object to the flat tax as much as the very poor, as such a system would close a fair number of loopholes. Absent a good way to determine proportionate use of resources, the flat tax would certainly be the fairest realistic tax system.

by absolutely

First, I believe that primary to the goal of attributing costs to those who incur them, the child credits and the marriage credits are based in religious beliefs, and are therefore prohibited by the Constitution.

I don't believe in adjusting for estimates of "use of government services" because government services are not commodities. They are to be resources available in emergency scenarios where one's inalienable rights are in jeopardy or are being violated. As such, we each pay our fair share while hoping never to need to call the cops.

by anykey???

because, where I work is in very close to some of the goverment housing. There are a COUPLE of cars parked out there with wheels on them that cost more than many of the beaters that I have ever owned. Seeing a situationlike that burns my @ss.

The problem seems to be that nobody can figure out a way to get it fixed because they are too scared of not getting reelected. but that is just my opinion

by jdclyde

Can't say anything bad about poor people. That is discrimination you know.

Yes, I have known people personally who would be on the welfare with three kids from three dads. Never married to any of them. She has a live-in boyfriend that they don't report is living there so all living expenses are covered leaving his meager check for playing. Goes a lot further if you don't have to pay rent and utilities! Not people I will have anything to do with because they have no intention of changing ANYTHING in their lives. "why should I go to work all day just to make the same amount" is something I have heard more than once.

by jdclyde

I too had a rough time. Let me tell you from experience, that the pill is NOT a safe bet! My boys were conceived while on that.

When they were born I was the only one working, and I made $7 per hour. Guess what? I made too much money to get ANY assistance. Ain't that just great. Family of four on $7 per hour. Put my self through school at nights and worked in the shop during the day average 10 hour days. If I wasn't at school or work I would take the boys so the ex could get some down time to out see friends or just sleep. This was the start of me spending all my time with my boys and it never stopped.

I am now not rich, but middle class even after the ex leaves. She is oh so screwed this year for her financial aid because it will be based on our joint income last year. She won't get crap this year! Bwaahaaahaaaaaa!

by jdclyde

that is one of the things she was waiting for before walking out on me.

She is on a dual degree and just got the first. she was waiting to get a degree, get a job and fix up the house. (which is why I didn't do a single thing around the house for the last three years.)

Matter of fact, I have done more to the house since she has moved out than I have since we moved into the house. And I still have five rooms to go yet! Man is she pissed at me now! Wait till she sees the rest of the house! does my evil heart good.

by jessie

"As for the married folks, there's something called family planning...and again...sex is an option...not required."

I see... so because birth control, whatever method you use, be it natural family planning or the pill, is not 100% reliable, poor people shouldn't have sex... and if they do, and get pg, they should abort the child?

"There's nothing that says if you're poor that you can't make good grades and get into college on a scholarship. That's a misnomer. Grades are about effort and achieving scholastically...not about your income level."

Actually, that's not true. You can consult all those government studies and statistics if you'd like, I'm not going to go looking for them. Schools are funded by their school districts and the poorer school districts don't get the funding that the more well-to-do get. They therefore get the "left over" teachers that have a degree in education but can't get a job in a more well-off district (where the pay is better). So yes, being poor DOES mean you get a lesser education. It DOES make going to college more difficult. Scholarships are GREAT but they're for the top performers and if you were the one who worked your butt of and got B's... does that mean you shouldn't be allowed to go to college? Because that is what's happening under GWB (and no I'm not blaming YOU personally for the election of GWB) funding for Grants is being cut, and if you or your parents don't have good credit, you CAN'T get a school loan! Therefore, the poor are screwed, and they end up on welfare.

And I never assume that anybody has not been poor... I just said, don't call me Lazy until you've walked a mile in my shoes. Just because I WAS at one point a single teenage mother and was on welfare while I went to a tech school, doesn't mean I'm lazy. And it doesn't mean that others who are on welfare are either. Your parents were too proud to take handouts. There's absolutely nothing wrong with that. But don't come down on me because I'm not too proud to ask for help when I need it.

And as for religion and pre-marital sex... well, you can talk that issue over with the 3 bastards who repeatedly raped me between the ages of 6 and 12.

JCK, you're an interesting person... you make broad generalizations about people and then want to get all offended and say you never said anything about ME personally, when I come back at you and tell you that not all people are like that.

by jck

a statement about people taking a free ride on welfare was supposedly a generalization about all people on welfare. Nice try. Go back and read *carefully*. I told you no one should "ride the bus for free"...then when I thought you were thinking that I meant that as "all people on welfare", I clarified it for you that I meant "freeloading" people who didn't work. You're just drawing this out. I've stated and clarified what my point was and what I meant by my statement. You've kept assuming.

I have NEVER advocated abortion...you've brought that up with no provocation. I don't know where that's coming from. So, I refuse to address any supposition that I'm for a whimsical abortions. And just to let you know I haven't been before, but I *am* now offended thank you.

As for government studies, you bash GWB but then send people to look at studies his presidency has commissioned. hmm...another interesting idea of yours. What's wrong with this picture? Don't think GWB is running the government right, but you send people to look at the work people he's appointed have done. Hmm...something about that...makes no sense to me.

As for having sex: I don't care if your financially unable, mentally unable, or just unwilling to support a child...you shouldn't have kids. I was addressing the impoverished because we were discussing welfare, and I had been addressing and clarified my point to be those who are freeloading off the system.

I'm sorry that you were raped...I really am. But I have to ask you: what does rape of a child have to do with consentual sex participated in by someone on welfare?? We were talking people on welfare.

And as for me calling you lazy...let's make it clear...I NEVER CALLED YOU LAZY. go back and find the quote where I said "Jessie, you are lazy". I never said single teenage mothers on welfare are lazy. I never said single mothers are lazy. I was...again...addressing people who are on welfare that do not work, and I went so far as to clarify that for you.

And as for children from poor areas not being able to get good education because of poverty: Tell that to Colin Powell, Dr. Jocelyn Elders, and Clarence Thomas...those are just a few people who grew up in poor as dirt areas who worked their way up. Because you live in a poor area of a city or state doesn't mean you don't get books to study.

Again, I'm sorry you were raped as a kid. No child should suffer through that. I know all too well, whether you believe it or not.

And Jessie...you're interesting too...but, don't think that everytime someone mentions anything you've ever been associated with...that it's about you. Because, it is not and never was. I've never pointed a finger at you (other than now you implied I'm somehow inclined toward abortion).

You get way too offended over stuff that isn't even pointed at you. And, you not only come back and tell me things but then make stupid implications like that I'd consider abortion as a solution. That's just f***ed up.

Sorry...but that pisses me off...I'm proof I can keep my unit in my pants even tho I've had strippers try to take me home dozens of times. You don't need a pill or a piece of polyurethane or lambskin or rhythm to keep babies from happening. You just gotta control your urges.

And like I said...you don't need sex to live. You're indulging a carnal desire.

I'm done with this conversation. Sorry, but implying I'm gonna think abortion is an alternative for anyone (not just poor people) pisses me off. You've implied a lot that doesn't really bother me, but bringing that up was too much. You can question my opinion. But, implying I would turn to abortion as a solution was just the end of it.

by jessie

[i]a statement about people taking a free ride on welfare was supposedly a generalization about all people on welfare. Nice try. Go back and read *carefully*. I told you no one should "ride the bus for free"...then when I thought you were thinking that I meant that as "all people on welfare", I clarified it for you that I meant "freeloading" people who didn't work. You're just drawing this out. I've stated and clarified what my point was and what I meant by my statement. You've kept assuming.[/i]

Perhaps YOU should go back and read carefully. The point of my post was NOT that there aren't any people who "ride the bus for free" but that government sponsored training is next to IMPOSSIBLE to get! I haven't been assuming ANYTHING.

[i]I have NEVER advocated abortion...you've brought that up with no provocation. I don't know where that's coming from. So, I refuse to address any supposition that I'm for a whimsical abortions. And just to let you know I haven't been before, but I *am* now offended thank you.[/i]

I did not bring up abortion "with no provocation." You said in your previous post [i]"If you can't support yourself, why should you have kids? You seriously want me to think it's okay to bring a life into this world that needs food and water like you do, when you can barely provide food and water for yourself? That's real love and compassion."[/i] Given that 3 of my 4 children are here due to birth control failures, and I'm married, one MUST derive from your statement that either my husband and I don't have sex at all ever again until we can afford children, we become permantly sterilized, or we abort the children we cannot afford. I cannot believe that you are telling me that poor people shouldn't have sex? Which is the only other logical derivative of your statement if one is to NOT ASSUME that you mean abortion.

[i]As for government studies, you bash GWB but then send people to look at studies his presidency has commissioned. hmm...another interesting idea of yours. What's wrong with this picture? Don't think GWB is running the government right, but you send people to look at the work people he's appointed have done. Hmm...something about that...makes no sense to me.[/i]

I did not direct you to studies funded by GWB. I'm sure there are plenty of those out there, but there are a whole lot more coming from other sources.

[i]As for having sex: I don't care if your financially unable, mentally unable, or just unwilling to support a child...you shouldn't have kids. I was addressing the impoverished because we were discussing welfare, and I had been addressing and clarified my point to be those who are freeloading off the system.[/i]

Perhaps you could point out to me where you distinguished between freeloaders shouldn't have kids, and the merely impoverished shouldn't have kids and tell me also why that wouldn't lead me to assume you meant abortion in the case of accidental conception?

[i]I'm sorry that you were raped...I really am. But I have to ask you: what does rape of a child have to do with consentual sex participated in by someone on welfare?? We were talking people on welfare.[/i]

You'd be surprised. Having been raped as a child, I know that it skews your idea of sex and love, not to mention your self esteem and sense of guilt (blaming yourself for things not in your control). And I think you'll find that a good number of women who are on welfare or who have children by more than one or two fathers were molested as children and tend to repeatedly get into relationships where they are abused.

[i]And as for me calling you lazy...let's make it clear...I NEVER CALLED YOU LAZY. go back and find the quote where I said "Jessie, you are lazy". I never said single teenage mothers on welfare are lazy. I never said single mothers are lazy. I was...again...addressing people who are on welfare that do not work, and I went so far as to clarify that for you.[/i]

I didn't say you called me lazy, I just said you SHOULDN't call me lazy until you've walked in my shoes... very different.

[i]And as for children from poor areas not being able to get good education because of poverty: Tell that to Colin Powell, Dr. Jocelyn Elders, and Clarence Thomas...those are just a few people who grew up in poor as dirt areas who worked their way up. Because you live in a poor area of a city or state doesn't mean you don't get books to study.[/i]

They are the exception, not the rule, and probably because they had parents who believed in them, which is even more important than a good teacher. And many of the impoverished in our society are so beat down, they don't believe in themselves, let alone in their children.

[i]Again, I'm sorry you were raped as a kid. No child should suffer through that. I know all too well, whether you believe it or not.[/i]

[i]And Jessie...you're interesting too...but, don't think that everytime someone mentions anything you've ever been associated with...that it's about you. Because, it is not and never was. I've never pointed a finger at you (other than now you implied I'm somehow inclined toward abortion).[/i]

I never said it was about me personally, just that you make too many broad generalizations and when I refute them, you get your panties in a bunch.

[i]You get way too offended over stuff that isn't even pointed at you. And, you not only come back and tell me things but then make stupid implications like that I'd consider abortion as a solution. That's just f***ed up.[/i]

I get "offended" when people make broad generalizations. All people are different. We all come from different backgrounds and experiences. If a generalization goes much past "Poor people are poor." then it tends to run into a whole lot of things that simply aren't true for those who are being generalized about.

[i]Sorry...but that pisses me off...I'm proof I can keep my unit in my pants even tho I've had strippers try to take me home dozens of times. You don't need a pill or a piece of polyurethane or lambskin or rhythm to keep babies from happening. You just gotta control your urges.[/i]

[i]And like I said...you don't need sex to live. You're indulging a carnal desire.[/i]

No, you don't need sex to live. I've never once met a marriage counselor, doctor, priest, or anyone else for that matter who thought that abstaining from sex in your marriage was a good way to keep your marriage alive though, and don't tell me you never said married couples shouldn't have sex. You've implied all over the place that poor people should abstain from sex so they don't have babies they can't afford.

[i]I'm done with this conversation. Sorry, but implying I'm gonna think abortion is an alternative for anyone (not just poor people) pisses me off. You've implied a lot that doesn't really bother me, but bringing that up was too much. You can question my opinion. But, implying I would turn to abortion as a solution was just the end of it.[/i]

And see my above discusson points on this one... thinking that you advocate abortions is the next logical step from many of your own statements.

by anykey???

seemed to me that it was an observation from someone that has been there and done that.

I do not believe that anyone here would belittle you or anyone else for accepting assistance, because all of us know bad things happen to good people.

I do think that the common belief of most people that make up the middle class is, help them help them selves, but do not take my hard earned money from my family and give it to people that abuse the system, people that expect me to work so that they can live in relative comfort, people that have 10 kids spaced out perfectly so that they never have to work. that is HORSESH*T

The way the goverment fixes the problem is by lowering the income levels at which people qualify, which denies the people that are contributing from getting the help they need, so that they can continue to contribute.Then what happens some of them give up, and then they qualify and think why go back this is better than it was.

The programs need to be setup to allow people to contribute, it should by no means be a free ride.

When it comes to kids, I agree that for some goverment sponsored sterilization should be considered, but as in my case I was 19, making $7.00 an hour and still living at home,but I was able to purchase a small home for my family, because I used all of the money that was saved for my education as a down payment which was 2% of the $35,000 I borrowed (thanks mom and dad.) I don't care how you try to calculate it I WAS NOT getting a free ride from my parents.I was able to squeak by but I needed some help and the goverment provided it.

That was nine years ago, and I have been told the income guidelines have since been lowered, now how would I haved survived if I did not qualify, beats me.

I do now have regrets from time to time that I worked my arse off instead of going to college, but my hardwork allowed my wife to get an associates degree in graphic design and get a decent job(although in a different field)maybe my turn is coming up?

As for religion not accepting birth control, they can tell you that you will go to hell for using birth control, yeah so what, it's probably better than the life I'd have if I couldn't resist and ended up with 50 kids, I apoligize for that, but I have seen some things from so called religious people that have me wondering if it is the right path to follow or not.

by jck

you guys have fun with this. I'm done with it.

I hope she doesn't ream you for wanting to sterilize some people...you know it's their right to have fertile sperm.

by jessie

No, JCK, I wasn't directing that at you necessarily. I was merely pointing out that even though government funded training would be a GREAT thing, it's mostly not available at this time. And here I go with a huge generalization of my own. There is a common misconception that training/college is available for all who desire it and have the drive. This is simply not true.

By the way, I'd LOVE to see the scientific community come up with a way to sterilize people with 100% effectiveness at the beginning of menses. Reversible at such time as they desire children.

That'd be the end of abortions, the end of crack babies, the end of teenage motherhood, the end of babies in dumpsters...

The key though, is that it has to be reversible. This ONE thing, would mean the government could cut it's "social programs" budget almost entirely and spend more money on education for all.

by jamesrl

I went to a church picnic last year, where one of the women talked about the fact that she got pregnant despite the fact her hubby had gone through "the procedure".

Turns out these things can reverse themselves in rare but not unknown cases. Yes there was a little tittering, but he actually went to the doctor and was given a fertility test.....whether that was a pass or a fail depends I suppose on your perspective...

James

by anykey???

I was not trying to pi$$ in anybodies wheaties, I am really truly sorry if I offended anyone with that sterilization comment.

I agree with Jessie we need to do something about all the horror stories you hear about what people do to their children. Those stories anger and sadden me at the same time because they can be prevented.

My comment about goverment funded sterilization was coldhearted and I apologize

by jessie

Sterilizations not working are not nearly as uncommon as people think. I knew a woman who had her tubes tied, they grew back, she got pg and had another child. She had them TIED AGAIN, and the same thing happened... AND AGAIN... and after that her husband got fixed too. As of right now, they don't have any further children.

I've also known SEVERAL people who were told they would never be able to have children who subsequently conceived without the aid of infertility treatments.

by jessie

... the biting is one of the best parts! :)

People who make snide/judgemental comments about what people should or should not do in regards to birth control... irritate me... like it's any of their damn business! A woman I worked with a few months ago, when told that my husband and I are expecting our 5th child, said, "You'd think by now you'd know what causes that." Which is one of those flippant comments that just got on my nerves. So I said, "I do. And if my husband wasn't so good at it, it wouldn't be a problem." She turned a lovely shade of red and the guys that were in the room got a good chuckle out of it.

by thechas

It's easy to complain about your taxes.

It's easy to say cut spending.

It's even easy to suggest cutting programs that you do not personally see a direct benefit from.

So, a simple question, what government spending would you cut?

Start with programs that directly effect you.
Make sure that you look at the actual amount of money that could be saved from any spending cuts.

Then, when you suggest cuts to programs that directly affect others, envision what the impact of those cuts would be.

The 3 largest areas of the US federal budget are:
Social Security
Defense
Medicare / Medicaid
They combine to well over 60% of the federal budget.

While I am no fan of making life easy for criminals in prison, privileges like cable TV make it easier and safer for the guards and wardens to keep life safer in the prison.

When I look at our federal spending, I see many areas where we NEED to spend more.

Welfare: We need to spend more money short term to train and educate those on welfare so that they can get a decent job and contribute to society.

Environment: We need to do much more to encourage renewable energy sources and reduce pollution.

Chas

by absolutely

I don't. Do you?

You claim:
"Welfare: We need to spend more money short term to train and educate those on welfare so that they can get a decent job and contribute to society."

But do we really? Right now, they're COSTING us money, so where do you see a NEED for them to "contribute to society"? I would be satisfied for them to stop looting from society. That would, at least, be a guarantee of a collective improvement for all of us who are presently contributing to the system. The need of some is not the concern of all. Charity is voluntary in a free society. (Undoubtedly, there will be those, like Jessie, who do train and educate and contribute to society, but as I will describe later, they will do so even more successfully in a freer economy.)

I still have to complete my senior year of college before I get my BS, and from mid-January until March 15th I was unemployed and receiving worker's compensation. I was just about to apply for food stamps when I finally found my present temporary assignment.

I would not CUT any programs. What I would do is totally eliminate every program that is inconsistent with the US Constitution. That means courts, prisons, police and defense remain. The list of what ceases to be funded by the government would take too long for any of us, but they are prohibited by the Constitution, which provides for the coining of money, patents and other limited measures to ensure a free economy.

"Amendment X
The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the People."

So, a FEDERAL Welfare system is in fact not permitted by the Constitution!

However, the EPA, for example, has a valid role in ensuring that companies do not commit assault on their communities in the pursuit of short-term profit. That does not mean that every wild flower will remain untouched, but they would exist as a contract agency to assist forensic scientists gather evidence in pollution cases. They could even be as pro-active as they are now, as long as they establish HARM TO PEOPLE as the standard for punishing pollution. It is a company's right to make its own property ugly, even an eyesore, but not to emit poisons.

Now, I understand and respect your instruction to start with programs that directly affect me, and after the assistance of the justice system in keeping me safe in my person and my possessions, the government programs that are most important to me are worker's compensation and federal financial aid for college. Gone. But in a free economy, less of the GDP will be diverted by the government's DEMAND, BACKED BY THE THREAT OF FORCE, "from each according to his ability, to each according to his need." What this atrocious little clever use of repetition and meter seeks to cover is that CHRONIC need is ALMOST NEVER the result of giving an honest effort. (Exceptions, of course, to those with work injuries. Inherited or accidental injuries outside the workplace are unfortunate, but not a burden to be "spread around" except inasmuch as the community is willing to help, individually." True dead weight ought to be jettisoned. Not waterlogged passengers (temporary hard times), I mean the career bottom-feeders. I would not be afraid to seek work in such an economy if it were instituted tomorrow, because when money stays in the hands of those who understand how to create wealth AND EXERCISE THE DISCIPLINE TO DO SO, I can more likely find a job with my variety of skills, and whatever my skill set, profit margins will be higher for my prospective employers. The argument of undeserved wealth is off the table because undeserved wealth is ALWAYS gotten by some sort of corrupt involvement with government. Such a thing just cannot happen in a free economy. Those who would bring their unearned wealth from the past into the free economy would either learn to be productive on a LEVEL playing field, or part with their loot.

Before becoming a radical for laissez-faire capitalism I was a Bolshevik. I really still think there is no PRACTICAL reason for everybody not to have lunch. But now I see that somebody has to at least cook it, so there is really nothing free.

I began to be converted when I took a class called China's Politics and Economics from a professor visiting from China. He lived through the Cultural Revolution. Among the things that I learned: Mao never knew about the 65 million peasants who died during his various 5,7 10 Year or whatever Plans. His advisors were too afraid of what would happen to them as the Administrators of his grand utopian vision to tell him that the plans were failing. Absolute power corrupts the entire system. To be accountable for success or failure, people in power must be accountable to those experiencing the good or ill effects of their use of power. More immediate to our American mixed economy, bureaucrats with discretion to "re-allocate" trillions of dollars with the stroke of a pen are LESS accountable to the voters than are business tycoons!

Given the rarity of even beginning the process of impeachment, it's fair to say that on average, if a politician is failing in his job, we have to wait until the next election. If a doctor (I picked this as an example of a professional with vast potential to harm us through negligence, incompetence, what-have-you) makes a mistake on the magnitude of, say, misplacing $2 trillion worth of Pentagon funds, his license would be revoked in a heartbeat. Even without licensing authorities (which ought to always be private), word of mouth works. Same is true for manufacturers, repair technicians, every other entrepreneur. People vote for their favorites all the time, and the reward of payment can be revoked much more quickly in a capitalist market than in one that is government-operated, even by the best-intentioned administrators.

But to be pragmatic, I'd start with government assistance to corporations. Assistance to the poor should be eliminated, but gradually enough for people to truly be able to make practical plans. The government has given the impression for generations that it isn't necessary to do so if you're just willing to live on a subsistence level, and inexplicably some are. It is our moral obligation to withdraw that implicit promise with respect to the fact that the promise has been made, if not with our consent, then also without an eloquent enough, consistent enough argument to prevail.

But being rich through government aid is unforgivable. If I believed in hell, I'd send Kenneth Lay there personally. Instead, I believe that his existence must be pretty worthless in the first place to desire money without the true rewards of success: talent, ingenuity, perseverance, dedication and the confidence that can only be earned on merit.

Finally, I think the valid concerns about the availability of personal self-improvement and keeping the Earth inhabitable, and pleasant, well into my geriatric years, are best served by removing all obstacles to the productive people most able to decide what skills are most productive and how to convert energy rationally for long-term concerns: the professionals who are already working in those fields.

We need to HAVE more to spend more, and we MUST be free to decide for ourselves, individually, what is the best use of the money we earn, individually.

by roger99a

the problem with capitalism is that the most important thing is money. It's more important that people, health, the environment, right and wrong. It's also consumer driven, and consumers are marketing driven, and the whole society is controlled by marketing. Marketing is the most powerful of the evil gods of capitalism. They give us disposable everything, convince us we must have items that didn't even exist last year, and sell us SUV's. And Viagra. Why would anyone need to advertise a product that your doctor has to prescribe? Shouldn't he tell you about it? Anyway, marketing via capitalism drives consumption. We use, discard, and buy another everything now days. We don't expect anything to last anymore. Who has a 20 year old refrigerator? We expect it to die. We get a new cell phone every year and discard thousands of batteries containing heavy metals right into our ground water because it costs too much to recycle them, or it's too easy to just pitch it in the trash. Sorry this turned into a rant. The point is we cannot count on Capitalism to do the right thing. It will always do the thing that costs the least or makes the most money. Capitalism will break the law. It will poison you. It will not love you. And it's still the best system we've come up with yet.

by montgomery gator

I could not say it better myself. Capitalist economics and free markets bring the most freedom and prosperity. Adam Smith was right. Marx, Lenin, Mao, Stalin, Hitler, and all the other socialist tyrants must have been smoking some real bad crack.

by montgomery gator

..Those programs for which the Federal government has no authority under the constitution. That would include #1 and #3 on your list. I would also cut all welfare and federal spending on education. Let the individual states take care of it, as they are the ones with the constitutional authority, as they see fit.

Regarding renewable energy, let free enterprise take care of it, there is money in developing new energy sources. Just have the government get out of the way, allow deductions from taxes of all R&D as a current expense. About 100 years ago, free enterprise found that crude oil could produce an abundant and cheap (at the time) source of fuel (Diesel and gasoline) for the new automobile technology. Now, there are private companies researching alternative energy sources, such as BioDiesel and hydrogen fuel cells. Auto makers are implementing more energy efficient cars, such as the gasoline-electric hybrids, already on the market. Have government reduce regulations on new power plant development, especially alternative energy sources such as nuclear and hydro power, which do not have atmospheric pollutants. Encourage domestic oil exploration and development (remove restrictions on Federal lands where the government can get revenue from oil, gas, and coal leases), encourage more use of coal, attack the energy crisis on all fronts, increased supply, more alternatives, and more efficiency, just remove regulations that are preventing private enterprise from implementing them. There is lots of money to be made from new energy technology and more efficient use of energy.

by montgomery gator

I would cut "entitlements" to business and corporations, also. Corporate welfare distorts the free market. I include farm subsidies and price support programs with corporate welfare.

by absolutely

The value of capitalism is that every transaction is voluntary. Purchasers can change their minds at any time, and businesses that are no good fail before they can do much harm. Unless everybody on Earth is stupid, in which case we shouldn't be trying to devise a system to help them, should we? Economists teach their subject to freshmen with a few simplifying assumptions, one of the most necessary being the rational purchaser. (The word consumer is offensive, as I have a brain as well as a gut, and I also produce for every penny I am paid, including those I spend on the terrible disposable things.) If sometimes, some purchasers are less than rational - your evaluation of rational - that does not give you, the donkey gang or the elephant gang the right to impose your version of wise choices on me or anybody.

Advertising is used by the advertiser in the interest of the advertiser, that is true. But to convince people (with brains) to buy the second time, the disposable products have to at least have some value.... But if your complaint is that advertising is superficial, uninformative (in a society in which "average intelligence" were not an oxymoron, advertising could appeal to rational buyers with objective, "just the facts ma'am" style), then doesn't the blame belong to the unwashed masses who are so easily swayed by it? Without a market...

I say people who are convinced so easily deserve to be parted with their money! Most of the shortcomings of "capitalism", particularly short-range planning, are actually the shortcomings of socialism. The ones you observe are symptomatic of our mixed economy. For one thing, the unpredictable matrix of uninterpretable laws governing business means that it is impossible to plan far into the future, not that people in business suits magically lose all concern for their offspring.

I think brainwashing is the most salient point to make in this context. Our hyper-regulated school system teaches everybody the same thing everywhere, the curriculum decided...how? By whom? According to what standards? I don't know, but I seem to have the impression that "# of graduates" is more often discussed than it ought to be, and "intelligence of graduates" less often. I see no evidence that the few competing paradigms in primary and secondary education are doing anything to keep the public school system on its toes, as a competitive industry would be. There are just too few people wealthy enough - and even fewer who choose to spend their wealth on private education - to challenge the public school factory system's hold on its captive audience. Because they're all spending $10,000/students*year for $80 worth of learning! Students who are taught only to memorize the events of history, not to question their significance, context or motivation, also never have their own convictions called into question, if they are good enough to have any convictions at all. They never have to defend their beliefs and assumptions, and they never develop the habit of questioning their own motives, impulses, etc. They would in a free society. We do not now live in one. Don't blame freedom for the problems of today, freedom is long gone.

Of course "we cannot count on Capitalism to do the right thing", but we can count on it to allow us to do so. We ABSOLUTELY can count on the self-interest of individuals who love their lives to do what's best for themselves AND THEIR COMMUNITIES. Isn't the reason that you care about all the concerns you've cited because you have an idea of a better world? Don't you think that if you see people acting contrary to your conclusion, they must hold a different premise? Why would they do that? I say it must be because they have too little freedom, not too much. No, even in the general case, freedom is not the answer. Intelligence is. And there is nothing stupider than forcing unifomity on individuals.

Please don't apologize for ranting, though. In the first place, I think it's why there is a "Miscellaneous" section. In the second place, as a habitual ranter, I feel self-conscious when you apologize for a shorter post than mine.

by salamander

...the U.S. political system has degenerated to the point where a substantial number of people vote only to vote for the lesser of two evils: "Well, I voted for so-and-so, because at least he's not Kerry/Bush/whosoever." The major parties have consistently offered the public an astonishingly poor array of mediocre candidates that pander to their most extreme elements in the last few years. Voting for a person that you can't trust on the issues that matter feeds the machine...a lukewarm "anybody but HIM" vote for either of the major parties is taken as a mandate for the entire platform.

Yeah, I stood out in the rain for two hours to vote for Badnarick. I don't think it was a waste of my time, or my vote.

by sleepin'dawg

all the other miscellaneous taxes. So you think you have it tough??? Your maximum income tax rate runs in the 38% region. Whether it's your politician or ours, they have no scruples when it comes to buying the votes of the welfare class. Evading taxes is illegal but it is not illegal to arrange your affairs so as to avoid the worst of the tax bite/grab. All politicians are the same; they will do anything to get re-elected, up to and including selling their own grandmothers. Honest politicians??? An oxymoron!!! Show me any politician who ever left office poorer than when he entered and that applies to liberals or conservatives. They may start out with the best intentions of being honest but by the time they leave or get voted out, they're just another bunch of venal crooks like their predecessors were and like their replacements are about to become. To think otherwise is naivite in the extreme. Having said all that; consider the alternatives.

Dawg :(

by jamesrl

As for Taxes in Canada, you have to look at overall taxes, not just the Federal rate. Some of the studies have shown that when all taxes, Federal, Provincial/State, Municipal, are taken into account, some US jurisdictions have similar tax rates to Canadian ones. Someone living in Alberta, where there is no sales tax and provincial taxes are low, is probably better off than in New York City.

In general, Canadian taxes are more "progressive" in that people in lower brackets pay less than US counterparts, and people in higher brackets pay more.

As to honest politicians, like I have said many times, I worked in politics, and got to know many of them. Some were honest good, people, some were bad, as in many other areas. I do know many politicians in Canada who took a pay cut when they got elected. Many MPs are lawyers, some doctors, some ran companies, and almost all of them made more money in private life than in public. I don't think I am naive at all. There are more opportunities for politicians in the US to make money as lobbyists when they retire than in Canada.

James

by davidfacer

I run my own business from home, and the Government sez they want MORE small business - yet it seems so stupid that I, as the only income earner for my business, have to submit to such high taxation. There is NO incentive in this situation for individuals to HAVE their own businesses - basically forcing us back on the already overcrowded and glutted salary market or being a slave to the Taxation Department. It seems to me that the politicians dont WANT to see this country get ahead.......the Roman Senators stated it quite well - a citizen's duty is to work, pay taxes, and to die - not be an individual. They were HIGHLY suspicious of any one they thought ambitious.

by sleepin'dawg

There was no social security, no unemployment benefits, no social welfare programs and no old age pensions and yet, people survived. No economic system works forever and that includes capitalism, without hiccups but note this, capitalism is the only system that consistently recovers. Ask the Brits and the Swedes where socialism got them. They had to resurrect a measure of capitalism to get their economies back under control. Communism as experienced by the Russians flopped miserably and Russia still hasn't fully recovered. The Chinese economy was in a shambles until they instituted free market economic practices; read, capitalist practices. Fascism and/or Nazism was a hodgepodge of racism, nationalism and state control of politics, culture and the industrial commercial economy. Individual freedoms were to be curtailed unless beneficial to the state. That fell on its a$$ when the Germans took to enacting its terrible racial policies and invading all its neighbors. Capitalism is in need of rejuvenating but it still more or less works. People need to be made to understand that there is a definite cost for their social safety net and that they should not expect the state to be constantly holding their hands, while the politicians must understand there is a finite limit to how much taxation the populace can endure. Until then we'll just have to muddle along with what we have and b|tching about the gang of crooks that we laughably refer to as politicians. There is not one of them with sufficient backbone or brains, for that matter, to bite the bullet and truly overhaul the economy properly.

Dawg :(

by absolutely

I think that you have just provided the key to this puzzle, Dawg. People who see themselves as the beneficiaries of the welfare state really believe that the option of welfare is good for them, even in the long run. The hardest thing is to counter that assumption without insulting. It's already happened on this thread, I'm sorry to say.

Although I completely relate to the sense of revulsion at the thought of my hard-earned dollars being spent on frivolous, wasteful, destructive habits, we can only win this argument in the public sphere by remembering that not everybody who responds angrily to criticism of welfare is faking their indignation. I believe Jessie was totally sincere.

In general, I believe that just about everybody feels some sort of discomfort when they contemplate that they are receiving anything they haven't earned. The point to make, with as little emotion as possible, is that in a free economy there are just fewer tough breaks to go around and more money to help in the times of difficulty that do occur.

To make that point, we need to emphasize the false nature of the zero-sum paradigm. The real beauty of capitalism is not that it works as a compromise to people's immoral lust for excessive indulgence. In fact, it does not. Such behavior is no more productive than simple laziness. What capitalism does reward is production that is useful to OTHERS. Every economic exchange in free business is based on two premises: the buyer gains an advantage by buying the product for sale and the seller gains an advantage by selling it! Better than magic because nothing needs to be up anybody's sleeve.

The ideas of "checks and balances" in government, the role of "the adversarial process" in court, and perhaps most of all fierce competition in sports all repeat a contrary view, which gets incorrectly attributed to capitalism in far too many conversations in my experience.

Let's change the theme of this thread to "Commonly believed fallacies about capitalism".

by sleepin'dawg

As socialism does you throttle ambition and inspiration. Capitalism inspire us to rise above that. There is nothing wrong with our politicos that a few feet of good solid hemp and a lamp post wouldn't fix. Several well conceived lynchings would go a long way in rectifying things. Socialism is destructive and stultifying; Capitalism is constructive and inspiring. "'Twas always so, 'twill always be."

Dawg :(

by jamesrl

I've argued for years that we should close the high end loopholes and make the tax flatter.

There are many millionaires in Canada who pay no tax. These are not for the most part people running businesses and creating wealth. These are people who inherited great wealth and spend a lot of time and energy avoiding taxes. Some of them invest in risky businesses with the intention of having a loss so they can use it to pay less tax - how crazy is that?

Have a minimum tax. Lets call it 10%. No one pays less, no matter what deducations they have. Then start closing the silly loopholes.

Make the tax systems simpler. I studied economics in university, have some knowledge of accounting practises, and yet I still find it better to pay an accountant to do my taxes - thats not the way it should be.

Lower corporate taxes - this may enage some people, but a corporate tax is like a tax on tax. If you stop taxing companies, shareholders and owners will earn more money, which will then be taxed. But lowering corporate taxes also helps create jobs.

James

James

by absolutely

Thank you, I believe I do rock ;)

And I return the compliment.

John Stossel, who used to report for ABC News about the terrors of carelessly manufactured products of amoral businesses has recently had a book published called "Give Me A Break". He has become a laissez-faire capitalist, and makes points that could be incredibly useful in presenting this topic in public debate, or to bull session Marxists, if you know any. Most impressive to me are: corporations receive more welfare than poor folk, and being destitute is statistically correlated to an even more dramatic curtailment of lifespan than smoking, or any other behavior!

by montgomery gator

1. Have election day right after April 15 (Tax Day), when income tax is fresh on the minds of the voters. The voters would be more likely to vote for people who lower taxes and cut spending.

2. Make it a requirement that in order to be eligible to vote, you pay more in taxes than you receive in direct entitlements. Right now, we are getting dangerously close to the point where at least half the voters pay no taxes, or get more from the government in entitlements than what they pay in taxes. Instead, it should be the people who pay for the government who have a say. Those who do not pay taxes, or get more in entitlements than pay in taxes, see no reason to limit taxation and government spending. They are the ones more likely to vote for the "Bread and Circuses" candidates than the ones that advocate less spending and lower taxes. "Bread and Circuses" contributed to the fall of Rome and may be the downfall of the USA.

by sleepin'dawg

Rule #1: Get elected or re-elected.

If that doesn't happen; no matter how honest or dishonest the politician, he will be ineffective and dead in the water. This is why ALL politicians will lie, cheat, beg, borrow or steal to be elected or get re-elected. They would willingly sell their souls to achieve this aim and many of them have done just that. They are all slaves to the various interests that have backed them and come hell or high water, will never betray that. To expect them to do otherwise is to be naive in the extreme. The office of President of the United States is limited to terms. Why shouldn't all elected officials be limited to a fixed number of terms. It will never happen because that might curtail the power of "vital interests" and thus, corruption rolls merrily along and is endemic to the whole system.
This is a problem within all political systems but perhaps more so in capital systems because of the potential volatility of the democratic process and therefore, we are hung upon the horns of a dilemma, to which I will leave you to determine exactly what it is. It should be understood that this isn't all bad, especially in light of the alternatives.

Dawg

by absolutely

Greeks didn't let their slaves vote. Of course they were wrong to have slaves just as it was wrong in this country. But their reasoning on representation was sound: people who are not part of the system...are not part of the system! If you don't contribute you don't have a say. That's completely fair, AND DEMOCRATIC.

by av .

Poor people have little money and the rich have lots of tax shelters.

People that have a weekly paycheck with taxes taken out are the most taken advantage of. They don't have all of the tax options of a consultant or independant worker.

It just isn't fair for the middle class. Poor people should have to work if they are able. People on welfare should have to pay it back. They get job training too, for free. It should be like a student loan. No free rides no more. Only the really needy should be entitled - disabled people, sick or elderly.

I still can't get over the fact that we have millions of illegal people in this country that are entitled to free medical, education and all other kinds of programs that I can't qualify for if I was down on my luck! AND I've paid into the system for years!!

Bread and circuses it is. Its deja-vu all over again.

by absolutely

...both involving the definition of "rights".

(1) Once you earn it, it's YOURS. We pay taxes to PROTECT our rights to what is ours, namely our lives and our property, which we purchase in the first place with the productive use of our time, which is a PART OF OUR LIVES. We do not pay taxes to share what is ours with whoever has not earned it. Hard luck is exactly that.

(2) If you haven't earned it, in voluntary trade with someone who agreed on the exchange for mutual benefit, you have NO RIGHT to it. Hunger, cold, disease, are problems, not sources of entitlement. That doesn't mean I don't want to help the needy, it means I don't expect to be FORCED to help ALL the needy just because of their need. When need is recognized as a legal source of entitlement, it creates a lure of its own, just like a tax loophole for the rich. JUST EXACTLY LIKE a tax loophole for the rich, except that poor people who see that upward mobility is very challenging, see a loophole that allows them to put forth no effort at all instead of putting forth the incredible effort necessary to start qualifying for any tax loopholes.

by thechas

I basically agree with cutting corporate welfare.
Along with that, we should also move away from taxing business income so that we all can clearly see how much our government costs us.

I suspect however, that corporate welfare is a lot less than people think.

Most of what is classified as corporate welfare is actually tax breaks to support research.

Without the tax break incentive, many companies would not invest in long term research.

As to farm subsidies, I don't agree with eliminating them entirely.

We need to support family farms and maintain the ability to grow enough food to feed ourselves.
The cost of farming has risen dramatically over the past 20 years with little or no increase in what is paid for crops.

Now the corporate mega farms are a different story. They should be subject to the same rules as any other business.

In place of farm subsidies, one option might be eliminating property taxes on active family owned farm land.

Chas

by absolutely

Where is the data for your claim "(m)ost of what is classified as corporate welfare is actually tax breaks to support research."? I do not believe that to be accurate.

by thechas

Without the price supports and economic aid, many farms would go out of business. We already import meet and produce because it is cheaper than domestically produced.

Just what manufactured products are still made in the USA?

Even the US brand cars have at least 20% imported content.

Even the defense industry suppliers rely on imported parts and labor.

Without government grants and tax breaks, even more of our basic needs would be produced overseas.

Chas

by absolutely

How *exactly* do you claim that government involvement--in what would be a pure capitalist system without government involvement--keeps prices LOWER than they would be without government controls?

Consider the quantity of land in this country that is suitable for agricultural use, and the relatively few domestic mouths eager to consume it.

Also, please consider whether it is the responsibility of family farmers, or of the entire nation, to *guarantee* that family farmers can make a *good living* with a simple, antiquated agrarian lifestyle. I have noticed a peculiar pattern among so-called "Republicans", who claim to favor free markets until the topic of the "family farm" rears its ugly inbred head. Why does that particular lifestyle choice make free market competition taboo?

The fact is that the vast majority of agricultural production in the United States happens quite successfully on large corporate farms. So why am I, as an urban citizen of the same Republic, expected to give a rat's tail feather if some people have to sign up for career training, learn a trade, etc? It happened to cobblers, blacksmiths, most masons, why exempt farmers from the knowledge requirements of the 20th century?

by roger99a

It would seem that you value your education no more than you would value being mugged. That argument makes no sense to me.
The concept is that giving everyone in a society an opportunity to get at least a minimum education will be a net benefit to that society. Since not everyone will be able to afford a private education for their children we have public education that is available to every child regardless of the financial abilities of their parents. It's not a child's fault to be born into poverty. To deny them an opportunity to get an education perpetuates this poverty. That's why we all chip in and make sure that an education is available. The inefficiencies of the current system do not invalidate this argument. I will agree that an education system in private hands could very well be far superior to the current corrupt public education system, but I still believe that we should have equal opportunity for all children regardless of their parent's ability to pay. We would be better served, I think, if we privatized the whole system and used a voucher system to get some competition into the mix. I also think we should all chip in for the benefit of our society.

by absolutely

It is not true that I value my education--meaning the valuable facts and skills I learned--no more than I would value being mugged. What is true is that I value paying taxes for other people's brats no more than being mugged. I was trying to address the circularity of your reasoning, which simply went as follows: You received public education. Public education was provided because tax revenues were budgeted for it. Public education benefited you. Therefore, you are obligated to the society that educated you, to pay taxes to the same society to educate others. But I did not CHOOSE to receive education that was public, and I had NO PART in the choice of the funding for my own education, because at the time I was not offered the option to vote. It is immoral to hold anybody responsible for anybody else's choices. It is immoral to claim that in exchange for receiving a publicly funded education which I was not offered the option to decline, I must now agree to fund the same absence of choice for today's kids. I hope that clears up my previous post.

Now, I'll respond to your next concept: "that giving everyone in a society an opportunity to get at least a minimum education will be a net benefit to that society." I'll just repeat what I said before about welfare: I'm not interested in them benefiting me, I'll be satisfied to let them stop leeching off me!

If it's true that it's not a child's fault to be born into poverty, it's most often their parents' fault. If parents have the option of putting their kids through school with their own money or sentencing their kids to destitution, they'll think carefully about having kids, as they ought to do anyway. To deny parents the responsibility of thinking about their choice to have kids, denies their humanity. The inefficiencies of the current system do invalidate your argument. So do the inefficiencies of the USSR and the People's Republic of China under Chairman Mao.

by roger99a

School kids don't pay taxes. And yes I know that we are supposed to be responsible for our own children, but if we all had to pay for our own kids education there would be a lot of kids that would go uneducated. OK, I know there are a lot of kids that go uneducated anyway, but that's a flaw in the system, not a flaw in the concept of the system.
Property taxes are just evil anyway. It's not right to pay taxes on your income and then have to pay sales tax on the stuff you buy, and then have to pay property tax on something you've been taxed on twice already.

by absolutely

Then what exactly is the flawless concept, and what flaw in the system is responsible for preventing your flawless concept from working?

by salamander

The point was made by another poster below that the U.S. tax code gives deductions for having children. Kids use government resources. The more kids you have, the more deductions you get, and the less taxes you pay. I honestly don't think that there should be such a deduction. If somebody has kids, they should pay a under higher tax burden for their education than somebody who has none. Just my $.02.

by roger99a

Not much of your federal taxes go to education anyway, but tax deductions are a seperate issue from spending on education. Maybe the child tax deduction is a reward for raising more future tax payers.

by absolutely

We import SOME meat and produce, I believe, but not all of it. Most of the vegetables I'm likely to find in a grocery store on the west coast are grown in California. Furthermore, one of the main provisions of government "farm support" is artificial inflation of prices, not reduction. So, if anything, LESS food would be imported for US consumption, NOT MORE, if corporate agricultural welfare were eliminated.

ADM has some sweet deals to keep the price of sugar high. Wheat farmers are paid to NOT grow wheat. So, instead of competition which can drive prices down and eliminate the need to import, OUR OWN GOVERNMENT is subsidizing elevated supermarket prices that, you claim, are leading to importation of foreign food. That's your argument FOR subsidies?

by thechas

My argument for subsidies is for family farms, not corporate entities like ADM.

The only reason that we do not import more grain, meat and produce is the price supports.

My point is that without the price supports, land set-asides, and other aid to family farms, is that farming and agricultural production in the US would come to an end.

If the price farmers are paid for their crops were to fall any lower than it is, all of them would go bankrupt within 3 years.

Farming in the US is squeezed between urban sprawl and the high cost of materials and equipment.

On a very real level, income for farm families from farming has dropped over the last 20 years.
It is the very rare farm operation that does not have some other form of income that pays the bills.

In the Midwest, a lot of our produce comes from South America.

In the West, the cost of harvesting your produce is born on the backs of migrant workers some of which are paid less than the minimum wage just so the land owner can come out barely ahead.

We need to support both family farms, and research and development in order to keep our country strong.

Chas

by absolutely

Also, if the parents aren't pulling their own weight, it's likely that they're neglecting to teach their children the same values they themselves are not practicing, not raising future contributors to the system as you suggest.

by montgomery gator

I noticed during the winter, that a lot of the produce in my local grocery store came from South America. Grapes from Chile, for example. However, during the summer, the grapes in my local grocery store come from California. I believe the seasons have something to do with it. We import grapes from Chile during the winter when it is summer in the USA. I do not know if they do so, but I would not be surprised if Chile gets California grapes during their winter (our summer). Similar pattern with fresh tomatoes. During the winter, they come from Mexico, where parts of the country have very mild winters. But during the summer, a lot of the fresh tomatoes are from the midwest.

by absolutely

means dead thread. Thanks for the contributions, it looks like the welfare statists have very little in the way of reason to offer for their policies, eh? Just "I FEEEL it should be easier!" and such.

by Member 25348569

I don't think that there's any real chance of an argument.

You have all of the logic on your side and we have all of the warm, cuddly belief stuff on ours. Bit like religion, really. Just that we've more sense than the religious sorts. We can promise "Jam Today" and you don't even have to go to church. One man, one vote and YOU get to pay for your neighbours five kids by five different blokes.

Bummer, isn't it.

Neil :D

by absolutely

Are you a Whig or a Tory?

Actually, I don't remember what either of those if for, but I think they're both of the past.

What I really want to know is during which part of that post were you being facetious? First, you say "we have all of the warm, cuddly belief stuff" as if you're on that side, but then you parody the welfare state...Hold on, are you one of those "It isn't practical but it's good" sorts?

by maxwell edison

.
But first, a simple breakdown:

In an earlier message, someone suggested that 60 percent of the budget was spent on Social Security, defense spending and Medicare/Medicaid. I don't think that's a good way to look at it. Defense spending should always be a stand-alone consideration. Moreover, grouping defense spending together with those other two is tantamount to a bookkeeping trick, and it's very misleading. Let's start calling apples, apples, and oranges, oranges.

Instead, let's look at it this way:

A full 60 percent of annual spending goes towards money transfer programs, of some form - period. Money taken from the person who earned it, only to be given to a person who did not earn it. 15 percent of the budget is spent on interest on the national debt. 15 percent of the budget is spent on defense. And the remaining 10 percent is spent on everything else.

If our budget is hemorrhaging money, which it is, the logical place to look for cuts is the area in which the most money is spent. Moreover, if you consider that only 50 years ago, 60 percent of our budget was spent on defense, while only 15 percent was spent on money transfer programs, the exact opposite of what it is today, you can easily see where the problem lies. And if you consider the fact that 50 years ago, there was no significant annual spending deficit to speak of, and the national debt was so small, that it was, for all practical purposes, non-existent (especially relative to what it is today) the answer is quite obvious. Moreover, if you further consider the fact that the exponential growth in money transfer programs over the last 50 years was the primary -- or sole -- contributor to the growth in the national debt, then the 15 percent spent on interest payments for that debt could also be attributed to money transfer programs as well; meaning that a full 75 percent of federal spending goes towards money transfer programs, either directly or as a result of, either today's or yesterday's. So the people who suggest that defense spending is causing our financial woes are quite mistaken.

Our 7 or 8 trillion dollar national debt was caused by one thing, and one thing only -- money transfer programs. Our country was better off without them; our families were better off without them; our financial stability (and financial world standing) was better off without them; and we need to get rid of them - all of them - period. We need to phase out Social Security completely (over a 50 year period). We need to stop forcing people to pay for other people's medical care. We need to stop forcing people to pay for other people's problems and poor choices. We need to stop forcing people to pay for other people's retirement. We need to stop paying children to have children. We need to stop. We need to stop. We need to stop.

My simple answer:

It's not only wrong to take a dollar from the person who earned it, only to give it to a person who did not, but it's a recipe for financial disaster. So we should stop doing it.

(By the way, how did I miss this thread? This is my absolute top issue.)

by absolutely

& therefore did not know who to invite. Apologies.

Where can I find records of the trends you described? I mean, I found them in your post, but what is your source?

I think the real challenge is convincing the ever-increasing masses of poor folk that the welfare state is in fact NOT in their self-interest. A few well-placed statistical citations are convincing to an intelligent fashion-Leftist, but what about the huge welfare voting block? They seem not to have long enough memories or something to notice that over the course of their lives, wealth redistribution schemes have been correlated with more difficult business environments, which directly lead to lower wages...

by maxwell edison

.
I am "absolutely" in agreement with you, in that one's sources should be questioned and verified. I've called so many people to task for spouting off unsubstantiated statistics, but were unable to back them up. I can back up everything I say.

I have a variety of sources. And when time allows, I'll assemble them and post them. (Later today or tomorrow.)

However, the money-transfer advocates could be confronted with all the facts and proof in the world, but for some reason still let their emotion trump their logic. (And they will say, "yea but how about....." and then cite yet another anecdotal case.)

Edited Part:
I hate making grammatical and/or word misuse mistakes, so I corrected it. Thank you, absolutely, for pointing that out.

by thechas

http://archive.parade.com/2005/0410/0410_tax.html

The above links to the archive of a news magazine article I read that included a pie chart that showed the numbers for my 60% comment.

My point of that comment was that those 3 areas being the hardest to cut make it very difficult to reduce Federal Spending by any significant amount.

The root problem of the Federal budget is conflicting priorities and legislative compromise.

You want a strong defense and limited social spending.

I want limited defense spending and higher social spending.

What happens is that members of Congress end up trading votes to gather support for the projects and spending important to their constituents.

Social Security in particular is very hard to cut, restructure, or even vote against benefit increases. Any vote perceived as being against Social Security is almost a guarantee of defeat in the next election. Very few members of Congress are willing to give up their jobs on principle.

If GWB had provided specifics of his Social Security reform proposal prior to last fall's election, he would have been soundly defeated.

Every bit of Federal spending has a constituency behind it. As does every tax break and deduction.

The best way to end a Federal spending program is to eliminate the need for that program.

If we had some form of national health care, we would not need Medicaid and perhaps not Medicare.
I don't have a specific national health care proposal.

As to welfare itself, the best way to eliminate it would be to spend whatever is needed to educate and train all current recipients so that they can get and hold a decent job.

Enough for now.

Chas

by absolutely

will you address my complaint, which is that OTHER PEOPLES' financial needs are not MY RESPONSIBILITY?

by maxwell edison

.
I just disputed grouping a non-transfer of wealth program with two transfer of wealth programs. It's putting an apple into a bag of oranges.

But if defense spending is 15 percent of the entire budget, and I'm certain that it is, then (using your correct numbers and my correct numbers, but stated differently) that means Social Security and Medicare/Medicaid together are 45 percent of the total budget, and the rest of the money transfer programs are another 15 percent of the total budget.

And I don't think the sentiment to eliminate welfare by spending more on welfare, but just calling it something else, makes much sense. You think that "The best way to end a Federal spending program is to eliminate the need for that program"....by what? Creating yet another, but different, program? I respectfully disagree. I think history has shown that the more federal programs that are made available, that almost by magic people will be crawling out of the woodwork "needing" it. I suggest to you, that if the federal program wasn't available in the first place, that people, in general, would find a way to meet their needs without it, and they would be forced to rely on themselves. A federal program is a great analogy and example of the saying, "build it and they will come". Well, make it available, and they will take it.

Absolutely everything you say is just the same thing, but by a different name. Call it Medicare/Medicaid, or call it a national health care system. It's still making one person pay for the health care of another. It's still taking the dollar from the person who earned it, only to give it to a person who did not.

Moreover, if you want to give other people the shirt off your back, knock yourself out. Nobody's trying to stop you. But to espouse giving the shirt off someone else's back is just wrong.

by Member 25348569

but then I am from a different culture.

Not Whig or Tory, that is, but a bit of a Welfare Statist in that I quite like what the NHS has done for the UK (and I worked in it for over ten years) but I believe that there are now huge societal problems in the pervasive nature of the Welfare State and I'd like it cut back a bit (a lot?).

So, yep, I am probably a "It isn't practical but it's good" sort.

Neil

by absolutely

At least you say it politely ;)

I expect NHS is National Health System? I'm sure that it's made for greater convenience for people needing stitches or some cough medicine, but I also suspect that quality of care for people in urgent need will degrade, if it hasn't already.

And what about this article I read in the Economist some months ago, about something like new nuisance laws in the UK? Things like playing music too loud in public can now get a person "blacklisted" essentially, so that playing music too loud thereafter is punished by laws originally intended for more serious offenses than playing music too loud? Is that the kind of thing you mean about the pervasive nature of the Welfare State?

Now, at the risk of seeming belligerent--and I don't mean to be, I respect what I've read elsewhere and think highly of you--when you profess "It isn't practical but it's good", what are you trying to practice? If it really is good, what makes it impractical?

by Member 25348569

When I've checked a few things re different healthcare systems and why the French blow both of us away in level of care and health of the population.

More on "Absos" as well (anti-social behaviour orders)

Neil

by absolutely

I actually did not mean to question the validity of your sources, but to know them in order to cite them myself.

btw, antidote is a cure, anecdotal evidence is poison :)

by thechas

Your rep representative government has decided that you are obligated to support those in need.

Prior to the creation of Social Security, it was very common for people to work until they were physically unable to work. Then, their son or daughter took them in and cared for them until they died.

When it was created, Social Security was foremost a jobs program. The goal was to entice older workers to retire and make room for young workers.

As for welfare and Medicaid, that grew out of the abject poverty that developed in the inner cities when working people moved out to the suburbs.
It became a Federal mandate to allow for a common level of support and care across the nation so that the level of support for those less fortunate did not vary from place to place.

For those that consider themselves to be Christian, it is our duty to look out for those less fortunate than ourselves. Using a Federal program over personal giving is just easier.

Chas

by maxwell edison

.
First of all, our representative government shouldn't be able to decide anything that's not allowed in the U.S. constitution. I challenge you to show me where, in the constitution, it gives our representatives the authority to take the personal property of one citizen and give it to another. Furthermore, I believe the whole notion is constitutionally flawed, and I wonder how they get away with it. Of course, these very same "protectors" of the constitution got away with advancing slavery as well. And unfortunately, you're right, at least in one regard -- but who was it that said a democracy is doomed to fail when people realize they can vote themselves favors from the public coffers?

You said, "Prior to the creation of Social Security, it was very common for people to work until they were physically unable to work. Then, their son or daughter took them in and cared for them until they died." Okay, great. And what's wrong with that? Why should a person expect someone else to take care of his aging parents? You take care of your parents, and I'll take care of mine. And you know, but you just won't admit it, that in the quest to take care of all these aging parents, government has made it more difficult for a person to take care of not only him or her self, but his or her own children as well -- and it's those very children who will have to figure out how to get America out of the financial mess that resulted.

This is about the tenth time I've seen you evoke being a Christian as justification for money transfer programs. First of all, that's constitutionally incorrect -- and you know it. "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof..." Second of all, in my opinion, Christ's teachings were geared towards giving of yourself to those less fortunate, not giving of other's selves - and again, you know that. Christ never taught us to take something that belonged to one person and give it to someone else less fortunate. I think you are confusing Christ with Robin Hood. One was from Nazareth, and the other was from the Sherwood Forest.

Moreover, I believe that God gave each and every one of us a free will; and I further believe He intended for us to use it. Everyone is free to make his or her own life's choices, good or bad, right or wrong -- per God's plan. And each and every one of us is free to use that God given free-will to determine our own outcome and to determine whether or not we help "the needy". In my opinion, it is you who are interfering with God's intentions by interfering with the free will of others.

And why is it that whenever you people (and you all know who you are) are confronted with logical arguments to dispel your socialistic notions of equalizing outcome, you always resort to "the needy" argument? Social Security is being paid to millionaires. Medicare is being paid to millionaires. People who are less well-off are being bilked to pay money (in cash, goods or services) to those who are better-off. And again, you know it. Farm subsidies are being paid to huge farm-related corporations. Not all of the people to whom these money transfer programs target are "needy". To the contrary, most of them are not; and most of them are capable of taking care of themselves -- if the government just got out of their way and let them do it.

Your argument is pure nonsense, anyway. Poverty in America was in a steady decline every decade, for the most part, throughout the twentieth century -- until the war on poverty came along, that is. The myriad of social programs haven't done a dang thing to solve anything; they've only created any number of dependent classes of people. The dollars from government don't do anything to make people more free, but rather serve to chain them down. And not only that, Chas, but you are an absolute fool if you believe that the transfer-of-wealth zealots care about "the needy". Sure, they use "the needy" as justification for their arguments, but their real purpose is to equalize outcome and to control the population. I challenge you to name one government social program that solved a problem. Instead, the initial problem always seems to get worse and worse, at least if you listen to the transfer-of-wealth zealots.

And for the record, I blame President Bush a great deal for not taking a stand on the transfer-of-wealth issue. Democrats are terrible, and Republicans have turned into nothing but baby-Democrats. Give me a Barry Goldwater Republican. George W. Bush has abandoned the conservative principles that should drive this effort, and one that would allow people to live as God intended -- free to make use of the free-will He gave to us all.

And it's a shame that even Ronald Reagan didn't heed his own words spoken twenty years before he forgot them:

http://www.reaganfoundation.org/reagan/speeches/rendezvous.asp

Stop interfering with my God-given free-will, Chas. And how dare you do it while evoking the will of God as your justification. Using a Federal program over personal giving might be easier for you, but it's wrong in my eyes. But I suppose you self-centered zealots always find it easier to give away other people's property. And yes, Chas, I have learned to see you as one of the most self-centered and elitist people who visit these threads - a self-centered zealot who desires to force his will on others.

by thechas

Max,

It still amazes me that you somehow contrive that currency minted and owned by the Federal government is your personal property.

Were we still on the gold standard, I could see part of that argument.

Still, our US currency is a promissory note from the Federal government that has only the value that the world markets determine it has.

Aside from the fact that other people place a value of goods and services on money, it has little more personal property value than Tech Points.

If you are so concerned about "personal property", let the government have ALL of their money back and exchange your services on a barter basis.

Money, status and social rank have no real value to me. Otherwise, I would have worked for a Masters degree and be in a job robbing people of their wealth.

I do find it very interesting that every time you challenge me to think about what I believe in and what I desire for the future of our country, I find myself moving ever further to the Left.

I believe in a loving God who does not want us to restrict our brethren to the consequences of poor choices.
It IS Gods will, and the duty of ALL Christians to do ALL that they can to aid those that we can.
Yes, we are called to help those who are lesser off first. But, there is nothing wrong with helping those who might appear to be better off than we are.

Jesus himself saw nothing wrong with the Roman taxation on their subjects.
How does that go?
"Give unto Caesar that which is Caesar's"

Let the City, State, and Federal governments take what of their money they desire. It won't do any of us any good once we pass on to the next life.

Chas

by absolutely

But the Constitution DOES guarantee that your interpretation of Christianity cannot be imposed on me by the federal government. Whatever you might claim "separation of church and state" means for judges who want to litter their courtrooms with crucifixes or 10 arbitrary demandments, there is no possible doubt among thinking people as to the meaning of "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion". So you have no legal right to dump your onerous Christian duty on me for the sake of your personal convenience. I'll let maxwell instruct you on the meaning of the gospel, but when the issue involves government it's the First Amendment that takes precedence. That means that if I want to pray to Satan, I have that right, but if I want YOU to pray to Satan, I do not. The exact same holds true for worship of any other imaginary, fictional, mythical character, Jesus included.

"For those that consider themselves to be Christian, it is our duty to look out for those less fortunate than ourselves. Using a Federal program over personal giving is just easier."

Bully for you. And for those that do not consider ourselves to be Christian--or who have a different interpretation of their faith--our sense of duty is our personal concern, not yours.

by sleepin'dawg

Valid promissory notes are also calculated into your net worth. When politicians take to buying votes from the poor by depriving the middle class they are devaluing the currency by paying out cash for no return of goods and/or services. Welfare is a millstone around the necks of the middle class and breeds (boy does it breed) a class of people who see welfare as their God given right rather than a priviledge. So the wise man is forced into avoiding taxes which further erodes the system rather than leaving him the money he has earned, which if he invested properly just might provide jobs for some of these indigent peoples. There are thousands of jobs going unfilled because our own people are too lazy or too proud to get off their butts and take them. If welfare was applied as a form of workfare, then maybe we wouldn't be so dependant on foreign immigration and might not be so open to the threat of terrorism. If these people want welfare set them to scrubbing toilets in hospitals and perhaps lower the overhead of our medical establishments. These are the only people in the world who know what a free lunch is, because they're getting it.
BTW before castigating me; Several pundits have stated that as many as 45% of welfare recipients are supplementing their welfare by working under the table, receiving money on which no taxes are being paid. Now, doesn't that just thrill you no end???

Dawg

by maxwell edison

.
To suggest that it's not is a trip down la-la lane, and your definition is no more than a silly word game.

Currency represents the value of goods and services, regardless of who technically "owns" the currency. If the government takes a person's money, the government takes that person's services and/or the goods (property) that could have been acquired. People don't shove their money under a mattress. People use it for the betterment of their lives or their family's lives -- or if they choose, for the betterment of other's lives. For the government to take a person's hard-earned currency is denying that person's family a better future. For the government to take a person's hard-earned currency is to take that person's services. Thus, the originator of this discussion called it tantamount to slavery -- it's at least indentured servitude.

And I don't care how far left you finally admit to have moved. You've always been an extreme left-wing thinker as far as I'm concerned, regardless of what you called yourself. And your smug, pompous, and elitist attitude is making me resent liberalism all the more. And quite frankly, I'm glad that I finally goaded you enough for you to finally admit it. It just goes to show that you've been living your life dishonestly. But liberals are indeed dishonest, as it's the only way they can get their way -- so you fit-in quite well.

Great, you're out of the closet. But the liberal argument will lose every time because it's based on emotion, not substance, and the bottom line is that they have to acknowledge that they must take the property -- oops, I mean goods and services -- from the person who earned it, in order to give it to a person who did not. And not many liberals admit it in such a way because they realize how repulsive it is. But as I said, I'm glad you finally admit it.

by maxwell edison

.
I have several missions in my life:

Among them include, but are not limited to, the following:

1. To make sure my son grows into a responsible, self-reliant, and honorable adult. I'm well on my way.

2. To remain totally self-reliant myself, regardless of how much of my "goods and services" the government takes away from me, and to ensure that I can remain that way for the rest of my life. Regardless of how difficult the liberals in government (of both major parties) want to make that for me, I'm headed in the right direction, but still have a ways to go.

3. To defeat the evils of liberalism. Liberalism robs people of their own self-reliance, and thus their own self-respect. And I can't think of a more mean-spirited and evil thing to do to a person. And in that regard, you ain't seen nothing yet. I've only begun to fight. (And now that you're out in the open, so to speak, then.......)

by absolutely

Still want to pretend it's not property when I'm talking about YOUR currency?

Put up or shut up. Seriously. Hand over all your money right now, or you are a hypocrite. I recall Jesus holding them in the lowest contempt of all sinners.