Taxation in excess of 50% of gross income
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by sleepin'dawg
I seem to have missed that somewhere. I'm curious!
Max is usually very private on religious matters or I seem to have missed something. On religion, I wouldn't have any idea of his beliefs but fiscally we are more or less in agreement. Or is this a MrMiami style of attack, to ring in facts not in evidence so as you can make some sort of falacious point. Again, I'm curious.
Dawg ]:)
.
The reference is in this post:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=172659&messageID=1763652
And you're right. I tend to keep my religious beliefs and my faith pretty much to myself. (No point discussing, arguing, etc.) And I do think it's a private matter.
But when Chas was spouting off about playing Robbin' Hood, and doing it in the name of doing God's work, for Pete's sake (How misguided is that?), I gave an alternative view of what God may have intended -- something called God-given free-will. I wouldn't exactly call it "instruction on the meaning of the gospel", as absolutely suggested, but I guess I did use the G-Word -- and even capitalized it!
Playing Robbin' Hood in the name of doing God's work is not too unlike that David Koresh fellow who raped little children in the name of God -- forcing your own warped sense of "whatever" onto other people.
by jdclyde
are because most young parents are the ones that NEED the most help as raising kids is expensive (let me tell you).
It is to give people a hand when they are just starting out.
We have similar programs for first time home owners, to promote a more stable home environment.
Of course today with our disposable marriages, it throws a lot of that right out the window.
.
Representative government does not mean that two wolves and one sheep gets to vote on what's for dinner.
by thechas
Gee Max,
Isn't that how the current Republican Congress is approaching just about everything?
That is in part why I think our government works better if the Senate is controlled by the opposite party as the Presidents.
Neither party can advance an off center agenda.
We get fewer new laws and restrictions.
We get centrist judges and appointees rather than ideologues.
The only negative of a mixed Congress is that it takes a little more lard (pork) to grease the wheels in order to get a bill passed.
Chas
by thechas
While the ACLU still fights to keep religious references out of the US government, the Christian right is working every bit as hard to make the US a nation governed by Christian principles.
Again, with our representative form of government and the majority of US citizens describing themselves as Christians, Christian morals and desires will be an ongoing facet of US laws.
Let me ask you what you think would happen if we were to eliminate all funding for those on welfare or Social Security who are not physically disabled?
Would they suddenly go out and get jobs?
Very doubtful, as most of them have few or no job skills.
Also, what employer is going to take a chance on a former welfare recipient with no job history?
What happens to those who earn so little over their lifetimes that they are not able to save anything for their later years?
What happens to those who become sick or injured and have no money or health care plan?
Even if you are not Christian, it is part of the DUTY of being a member of a civilized society to look out for those less well off than yourself.
We seem to have forgotten that a civilized society exists for the betterment of all! Not just those who are smart, talented or skilled.
Chas
by thechas
I have no currency to give you.
In fact, I don't even get a paycheck or a pay stub.
Funds magically appear in my bank account, and just as magically disappear.
If I did have currency, I could not give it to you as the US currency belongs to the Federal government.
You would not want someone else's property would you?
Chas
by thechas
My co-workers loved your description of me.
When I told them that I had been described as an elitist liberal zealot, they either congratulated me, or had an astonished expression.
It was among the laughs of the day today.
The big joke is the project I am working on.
I think to a person, they would not use either elitist or a zealot in any description of me.
Those who have some knowledge of my political views see them as too eclectic a combination for any traditional label such as liberal.
I did not mention you by name, so your anonymity is intact.
Thanks again, I shall where your label as a badge of honer!
Chas
.
.....I've drudged through entire sections of the US budget, as released by the OMB (Office of Management and Budget). I've even ordered the CDs in the past, but it's just about all on-line anymore. I don't always read through it, of course, as that could be a full-time job in and of itself, but I have browsed from time to time.
http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/fy2006/
But I generally rely on sites that do a breakdown. It's easy to tell the good ones from the others that attempt to slant something one way or the other. And if you look at enough, you can get a pretty good general idea of some accurate numbers. Some Internet searches for budget or federal spending will produce scores of results. (Liberals are afraid to cite specific numbers and sources.)
One such site:
http://www.kowaldesign.com/budget/percentages.html
http://www.kowaldesign.com/budget/
The Heritage Foundation and the Independence Institute are also good sources. However, they are generally seen as either conservative and/or libertarian sources, and liberals will simply dismiss any conclusion because of it. What they don't consider, however, is that their conclusions are pretty much on the mark. I'd be interested in seeing a liberal counterpart to either of those organizations, and compare budgetary information and conclusions. I'm sure there may be one, but I've yet to debate a liberal who would use one as a source.
Heritage Foundation:
http://www.heritage.org/Research/Features/Issues2004/budget-spending.cfm#FF
http://www.heritage.org/Research/Budget/
http://www.heritage.org/about/sitemap.cfm
Dr. Walter Williams, Professor of Economics at George Mason University is, unbeknownst to him, a real mentor and guru in my eyes. (A Ph.D.-Type Doctor)
http://www.gmu.edu/departments/economics/wew/
Read through some of his syndicated columns. He has a great way of presenting complicated issues in an easy to understand and down-home style.
And look at this link, especially. It provides a real nice breakdown tree of where the dollars actually go (by agency):
http://www.kowaldesign.com/cgi/Budget.pl?estimates=
Department of Health and Human Services - 644 billion
Social Security Administration - 583 billion
NASA - 15 billion
Department of Defense - 475 billion
Department of the Treasury - 441 billion (mostly for interest)
etc.
I find it absolutely incredible, absolutely, that we spend over ONE TRILLION DOLLARS (actually, 1.2 trillion) each and every year on just Social Security and Health and Human Services alone, and more people aren't just totally outraged by it. Not only that, some of them want even more! (That's $4,300 for each and every man, woman, and child in America -- but it doesn't go to each and every man, woman, and child in America)
In 2005/2006, the federal government will spend (and they can't spend it if they don't first take it) about 2.5 Trillion dollars. That's over $8,000 for each and every man, woman, and child in America -- but it doesn't go to each and every man, woman, and child in America. And our total national debt is about $20,000 for each and every one of us.
And then there's:
State Taxes
Local Taxes
Gasoline Taxes
Sales Taxes
Property Taxes
etc.
etc.
etc.
And then there are people who want even more. And I'll tell you something else, I've lost absolutely all respect for people who want it to continue, and especially want more. They are, in my opinion, literally stomping on individual liberties and ruining this country in the process.
Where's the outrage? And where is it going to stop?
.
You're conveniently forgetting, or failed to see in the first place, that I consider the Republicans no more than "baby-Democrats". They all do it, I agree.
I blame the greedy, the ignorant, and/or the elitist voters who demand their elected representatives "give them something" in exchange for their vote. I find it absolutely appalling and disgusting that people feel justified in voting themselves other people's money. And I don't give a damn if they're Dems or Repubs. They are all running this country into the financial ground.
I'm standing on principle here, Chas, not politics. And I'm not some high and mighty rich guy sitting in a mansion wanting to protect my millions. I'm just an average working stiff, just like you.
Your ACLU - Christain right tirade is nothing but silly political platitudes. Get real. No one is trying to install a theocracy. But it's you who cite Christian principles as your justification for more government -- it's easier to do with a government program. You said it, remember? Why not speak to the issue and speak for yourself instead on going off on a silly tangent filled with tiresome platitudes?
You asked, "...what (do) you think would happen if we were to eliminate all funding for those on welfare or Social Security who are not physically disabled?"
That's being disingenuous again, Chas. No one is advocating eliminating these programs right now, immediately, and across the board. I, for example, have suggested we phase out Social Security over a 50 year period. We simply need to change the dialogue to reverse a very dangerous trend.
You asked, "What happens to those who earn so little over their lifetimes that they are not able to save anything for their later years?"
And to that I say family and themselves. But you say other people. But if a person goes through life knowing that "other people" will be taking care of him in his old age, he has absolutely no incentive to see to it himself. People got along just fine before Roosevelt screwed it all up, and they can get along fine again. Why do you want government to take care of you, Chas? Can't you do it for yourself? But it's not really government, it's other people. And if your answer is that you can do it for yourself, but you're speaking for the "other guy", that's where you earn the elitist title.
I could go on and on. but you just don't (or won't) get it.
The role of government in America is not to provide equality of outcome or to provide womb to tomb care for its citizens. It's to guarantee and protect individual liberties. And government is failing miserably.
.
You said, in a different thread, not once, but multiple times, that you don't trust your fellow man. You said that you have lost faith in your fellow man. You said it, and I could easily find the messages.
But on the other hand, you are in favor of expanding government programs to take care of the "fellow man" that you don't trust. That's like saying you don't "trust" the thug, so you'll just give him your money in a preemptive move.
And if it's for you:
Why don't you think that you have the capacity to take care of yourself? Why do you need government to take care of you?
by sleepin'dawg
now that you've explained it, it makes sense, as you put it but what is Absolutely's point in trying to misrepresent you??? I guess they will go to any length, even twisting your words, to win their arguments. Interesting to say the least and sorry to intrude on your privacy.
Dawg :(
.
Neither by you or by absolutely.
Actually, I believe that absolutely and I are somewhat in agreement on this issue, at least in principle.
I think our National Health Service is a fine example of that. I?m particularly interested in healthcare because I used to work in the NHS and I?m getting to an age where I anticipate using the resources sooner rather than later! Some history and current problems of the NHS.
The original ethos behind the NHS was the belief that, through the provision of universal and complete health care, free at the point of provision, the NHS would eliminate significant disease and thereby work itself out of a job. Not an idea that too many can find fault with, surely?
The NHS began in 1948, created by the post-war Socialist Government. All hospitals were acquired and administered by the NHS and all treatments became universally available at no cost at the point of provision - the whole being centrally funded by taxation. All hospital staff became salaried employees of the NHS (The State). General Practitioners (Family Doctors or Primary Care Physicians) managed to remain completely outside the direct employ of the State with countrywide primary health care subcontracted out by the NHS to UK GPs acting as individual private businesses.
Most of the electorate still believes that there is intrinsic value in a universal and complete NHS but, unfortunately, no-one can agree on exactly what constitutes 'complete' health care and no-one can say what the actual benefit of attempting to provide this using the NHS might be. Politicians have found the NHS a useful political football, any accusation that the opposition party's policies might damage this ethic carrying great political value such that an unworkable idea has become a sacred cow and no politician dared question the practicalities.
Another real problem that the NHS has is the infrastructure. Chronic under-funding since its inception means that the NHS infrastructure is close to third-world standard in some places.
One of the problems with the system of funding is that it is impossible for taxpayers to make a well-informed judgement about the value for money they are getting because they have no knowledge of the amount being paid, let alone any ability to vary it. Nor is there any clear contract laying down the services their payments entitle them to receive. So long as taxpayers are unable to see how much they are paying it is impossible to judge whether the system is affordable.
Even the ?social? aspect has issues as concerned taxpayers are unable to judge whether or not they are paying a suitable amount for the poor.
We, as consumers are in a weak position because we have no way to influence resource allocation except at a General Election. There is a lack of choice of alternative providers which results in only very limited ways to express dissatisfaction.
Under the NHS monopoly General Practitioners and hospital managers have weakened incentives to provide high quality care. Because of political interference, clinicians in the UK are often not able to act in the best interests of patients by following best practice. The Treasury has interests of its own which do not necessarily coincide with those of consumers.
Since 1948, funding health care predominantly from general taxes has proved to be an ineffective way of bringing the expectations of patients into balance with the treatment capacity of the system. The system is, and has been, grossly under funded and understaffed with health professionals being underpaid. Nurses, particularly, are underpaid to the extent that the NHS is mainly staffed by foreign ?imports?. The current government are pumping more money into the NHS but ? as it takes ten years to train the most junior doctor to a point of usefulness ? any improvements are likely to be long in coming.
The key fact, however, is that we still pay a much lower percentage of GDP towards healthcare than any other western country.
Our biggest problem is that even if we were to replace the NHS, what would we replace it with and how would we go about it? Possibly, if we just raised our funding to the French level, we would get a better system. If we raised our funding to the US system then the sky?s the limit.
Should we follow the US model directly? It?s perceived over here that in the US, if you don?t have health insurance and you get ill or have an accident, you die. That?s obviously not the case. However, those of us who travel to the US believe that we have to take out medical travel insurance for $millions.
Correct me if I?m wrong; most people who have health insurance receive their coverage through the workplace with employers paying for most of an employee?s health insurance. Like us, then, the employees are partly or completely isolated from the direct cost of their treatment and have little incentive to economise.
My reading around still suggests to me that the US health system is, nonetheless, discriminatory. Work-related health insurance gets generous tax breaks whereas many, usually low-paid, workers find it difficult to obtain affordable cover because their employer does not include health insurance as a workplace benefit. That isn?t acceptable, surely.
You do, however, have a safety net that guarantees access to hospital care regardless of ability to pay with funding from Medicaid and Medicare payments, state and local grants, etc. Unlike the UK, patients share the costs by means-tested contributions according to income. What your statistics do show, however, is the uninsured often wait until the later stages of illness to get the care they need and old folk have to make a judgement, not made on medical grounds, as to what drugs they can afford.
Health care providers generally offer a higher standard of care than over in the UK, as they are subject to selection by insurers. Waiting lists are very short in the USA and VERY long in the UK because of our under funding and lack of both personnel and good infrastructure.
You have one problem that we do not and that is poor quality care caused by overuse, misuse and waste by providers performing unnecessary or unnecessarily expensive procedures because they profit from them. This is especially easy where the consumers have little reason to question the costs.
Because the majority of health care in the United States is delivered through private-sector programmes, the system overall is better than ours in encouraging continual innovation and new technology. Pharmaceutical innovation and new medical techniques and technologies are rewarded by policies that, for the most part, pay for these advances. The downside of this is seen, for instance, in the lack of investigation into treatments that are not seen as relevant to the US population ? anti-malarial drugs, for instance.
Despite the fact that your health care is the most expensive in the world, many remain uninsured.
The French model is interesting. Employers pay 12.8 per cent of payroll, employees 0.75 per cent, and all residents 7.5% of all income into funds independent of government. French people can see on their pay slips how much they are paying and reach a reasonably well informed view about the value for money they are getting.
I think one of the key facts is that they generally pay doctors? bills for minor treatment at point of use, before receiving reimbursement from the insurance agency and are thus aware of the costs of medical treatment.
French social insurance ? since 2000 ? has universal cover on the basis of residency rather than employment and the poor in France enjoy a high standard of care, and rich and poor alike have the power to choose providers.
To quote from the Economist:
?Its hospitals gleam. Waiting-lists are non-existent. Doctors still make home visits. Life expectancy is two years longer than average for the western world.
For the patient, the French health system is still a joy. Same-day appointments can be made easily; if one doctor's advice displeases, you can consult another, a habit known as nomadisme m?dical. Individual hospital rooms are the norm. Specialists can be consulted without referral. And while the patient pays up front, almost all the money is reimbursed, either through the public insurance system or a top-up private policy.
For family doctors too, liberty prevails. They are self-employed, can set up a practice where they like, prescribe what they like, and are paid per consultation.?
If we check how much we all spent on healthcare as a percentage of GDP (2003) then the figures get interesting:
7.7 United Kingdom
14.6 United States
9.7 France.
And you have the higher GDP per capita!
The French system provides this service to everyone in the country and does it for less than half the cost per person of the U.S. Their healthcare system is in deficit, admittedly, but even if they decide to raise taxes to cover this, their costs will still be less than half of the US per person.
I don?t know what the drawbacks are to the French system. Still, there would have to be a lot of drawbacks to make their system less attractive than either of ours. So why not adopt it? Well, that would be socialised medicine. Can't have that, can we? After all, everyone knows that when you socialise something it automatically declines slowly into anarchy and uselessness. Right?
Neil
p.s. Check for population health - especially when related to healthcare spending - and you'll see why I picked on the French.
by absolutely
It's completely possible I was still irate about something I had read in another thread and inserted answers that belong on The Evolution Lie over here. That one really gets under my skin, so as of a few minutes ago, I have quit.
Classifying me with MrMiami definitely got my attention, I will tend to this right away.
by absolutely
by absolutely
of Welfart (I'm keeping that typo!) and Social Security, but I hope I remembered that it should be done gradually, with respect for people who were offered a promise, although the government had no right to make that promise.
Let me ask you what you think would happen if we were to eliminate all funding for those on welfare or Social Security who are not physically disabled?
A: I don't know
Would they suddenly go out and get jobs?
A: Some of them, I suppose.
Very doubtful, as most of them have few or no job skills.
Also, what employer is going to take a chance on a former welfare recipient with no job history?
A: An employer who just needs a body to do some menial labor and doesn't care about job history. Ex-convicts and work release types find jobs, so I guess work history isn't everything.
What happens to those who earn so little over their lifetimes that they are not able to save anything for their later years?
A: I don't know.
What happens to those who become sick or injured and have no money or health care plan?
A: I don't know.
General answer: I did not agree to be responsible for all of society. I have not forgotten that a civilized society exists for the betterment of all, and I have not forgotten that individual property ownership and personal incentive are greater contributors to the betterment of all than universal entitlement programs, which diminish both personal property rights and personal incentive to achieve.
This is also a good time to point out that wealth is earned in a free society, and that earning money means (1) producing something of value to society & (2) trading it to willing buyers in exchange for capital. The moral significance of being rich is that the rich have already done more to contribute to society than the poor, as proven by having engaged in more of these mutually beneficial, voluntary exchanges.
by absolutely
True, health insurance spending here is sky high.
You have the right impression of the US system's arrangement with regard to employment. It is not required by law that employers provide health insurance, but it is so widely offered that a job that doesn't include health insurance probably includes a paper hat and a memorized script that concludes with "would you like to Super Size that?"
Not being a soothsayer, I won't predict that all things socialised will inevitably decline (slowly or otherwise) into anarchy and uselessness. It took the USSR 70 years to become entirely useless to itself, and it was communised, not socialised. But the French motto "liberte, fraternite, egalite" (Is that right?) is too much like Group Think for me and I just don't like the idea of getting services now, while I'm poor, at somebody else's expense (nothing is free), with the personal cost that 15 years from now, when I'm quite wealthy but not yet "filthy rich", I will be paying for somebody else, as well, who has no intention of ever paying their own share.
Now, I'd like to juxtapose two of your paragraphs because they illustrate my point as well as anything I could express, plus I tend to ramble.
"We, as consumers are in a weak position because we have no way to influence resource allocation except at a General Election. There is a lack of choice of alternative providers which results in only very limited ways to express dissatisfaction.
"Because the majority of health care in the United States is delivered through private-sector programmes, the system overall is better than ours in encouraging continual innovation and new technology."
Your observation about the system in the UK is what I would call an intrinsic defect of any socialised (now you have me spelling things the British way, it's going to take me days to get back to proper American English!) system. And the profit motive is a very powerful incentive, especially to the most innovative and industrious people in the world. And I honestly do not mean Americans, but any person who sees the promise of being rewarded for invention will be more interested in the attempt.
Your use below of the word discriminatory bothers me. When used alone, "discriminate" only means "choose", which is a right that is taken very seriously on this side of the Pond. When referring to a palate, "discriminating" is seen as sophisticated, but when juxtaposed with race or gender, it is rightly considered sub-human.
"My reading around still suggests to me that the US health system is, nonetheless, discriminatory. Work-related health insurance gets generous tax breaks whereas many, usually low-paid, workers find it difficult to obtain affordable cover because their employer does not include health insurance as a workplace benefit. That isn?t acceptable, surely."
It is perfectly acceptable that low-paid workers find it difficult to obtain affordable coverage because doctors are not health care providers, they are citizens with equal rights to the poor, who have the additional virtue of having completed medical school, which they choose on the basis that it was a lucrative career, which perhaps they also expected to enjoy. (It is not my place to make any assumption as to their willingness to work for the pure reward of helping others. They may give their surplus to the charity of their choice if they consider it surplus.) Doctor's are within their rights to discriminate on the basis of ability to pay and employers are within their rights to discriminate on the basis of ability to perform profitabele work. Poor people are not within their rights when they demand to be kept alive at anybody else's expense. Neither are more egalitarian members of any other economic stratum within their rights to make the same demand on behalf of the poor.
I am a Christian, but I believe it is the duty of Christians as individuals to contribute to charity and do charitable acts, not the duty of the government. Coerced charity (welfare spending and other "entitlements" is not true charity, it is legalized theft, the government taking from one citizen (taxes) to give to another ("entitlements"). True charity is that which is freely given.
As stated in 2 Corinthians 9:6-7:
"But this I say: He who sows sparingly will also reap sparingly, and he who sows bountifully will also reap bountifully. So let each one give as he purposes in his heart, not grudgingly or of necessity; for God loves a cheerful giver."
http://bible.gospelcom.net/passage/?book_id=54&chapter=9&version=50
by sleepin'dawg
Sorry for that. I should have looked closer.
Dawg ]:)
.
I said (to Chas), "No one is advocating eliminating these programs right now, immediately, and across the board. I, for example, have suggested we phase out Social Security over a 50 year period. We simply need to change the dialogue to reverse a very dangerous trend."
Perhaps that was an awkward sounding statement, and I should have worded it in a way to make it clear that I was only speaking for myself. How about this:
Yes, they should be eliminated, totally and completely, at least most of them, but it should be done gradually, not all at once. Especially in the case of Social Security, since it involved taking other people's earnings to fund the program, those earnings should either be returned to them in a lump sum, plus interest, of course, or phased out gradually, perhaps even over a 50 year period, so those who paid into the program throughout their working life would get back a reasonable return like they were promised. And I think the choice should be left up to the person who paid. In my case, give it back to me, and I will manage my own retirement account, thank you very much.
But I believe that you and I, absolutely, are absolutely in agreement on the issue, at least in principle.
My take is this. I believe that those people who are such fervent advocates of not only keeping, but expanding the myriad of transfer of wealth programs, fall into one of seven categories, or subsets of the categories (some of them may fall into multiple categories):
1. They are lazy, greedy, and selfish, always looking for something for nothing, and always wanting money for nothing. (And "money for nothing" only goes to Mark Knopfler -- and chicks for free, too.)
2. They have literally been brainwashed into thinking that the roll of government is to provide for their every need, from womb to tomb. They really are ignorant of how the "system" works. The people who are deathly afraid of taking personal responsibility may be a subset of this category. Another subset of this category may those who constantly use the pie analogy, but speak of the American pie as limited and something to be divided up equitably. In reality, however, the American pie is unlimited in size.
3. They feel extremely guilty that they have been dealt a better hand in life than others; or they feel guilty for their success because they see others who have not been as successful. They need to do something to eliminate that guilt, so they have to either give away the fruits of their own success (their own hard-earned dollars or their personal time -- or both), which very few of them do, or they espouse government programs to do it for them. (It's much easier that way.)
4. They actually believe that people are stupid. They actually believe that some people are so helpless and pitiful that they don't possess the capacity to take responsibility for their own lives. Personally speaking, I give people a lot of credit for having the ability to manage their own life and for creating their own possibilities. These people give them no credit at all. (An absolutely terrible way to view your fellow-man.)
5. They are elitist snobs who feel they are better than others, but have to put forth a facade of caring. I put people like Barbra Streisand in this category. There she is, sitting in her mansion, high on the hill, reaping millions of dollars (for which I do not begrudge her -- more power to her), while advancing a political agenda to take money from people who earn a great deal less than her, and who have a great deal less than her, so as to support the give-away programs she advances and advocates. Sure, they write the occasional five or six figure check for various causes, but they don't do it without reaping some tax or accounting benefit, and they seldom do it without highlighting it in some gala event to, yet again, put the spotlight on themselves. And then they hire the illegals, and pay them a pittance to tend their gardens -- and sometimes, tend to their kids.
6. They are corporate-type elitists who know that such government programs only serve to keep people dependent on government, thereby guaranteeing them a source of cheap and ignorant labor. They don't want people to realize they all have the potential to not only control, but to create their own destiny. They don't want people to rise above the level of mediocrity.
7. Those who are advancing a political agenda -- the socialist class. Those who truly do desire a socialist form of government. (Franklin Roosevelt really did fall into this category. He even had a socialist vice-president at one time.) A subset of these people (they are socialists, but just don't know it or care to admit it) are the equality of outcome crowd. (A close cousin of the "pie analogy" crowd, since the pie is limited.) From all according to his ability, to all according to his needs, and everything will balance itself out in the end - isn't that wonderful.
You know, I would guess that the people who really need some form of help would rather not rely on government programs to get it. Sure, they would be equally reluctant to accept private charity as well, but the "truly needy" are probably the most honorable of the bunch. And you know what else, I believe these types of people probably make-up less than 1 percent of those who are the beneficiaries of a government transfer-of-wealth program.
But my point is that we need to change the dialogue and change the expectations on government. To advance an agenda to eliminate all transfer of wealth government programs immediately is not realistic, it would be committing political suicide, and it would kill "the cause". That's why the libertarians can't garner more support than they do. They are right-on with their desires, but too radical, at least in today's political reality, in their proposed implementation. The monster that took 50 or more years to create, will, in all likelihood, take 50 or more years to kill. Perhaps not 50 years, but it certainly can't be done overnight.
And the BIGGEST thing that could lead to the change in dialogue, and to ensure that almost every American citizen would never need government assistance, is education. If our public school system, in addition to reading, writing, math, etc., would teach an ongoing curriculum -- throughout one's educational life -- on personal responsibility, money management, AND the proper role of government (and it's not to manage transfer-of-wealth programs), people would learn everything they need to know to live a life of self-responsibility. It's no wonder the socialist-types and the liberals want to maintain the strangle-hold they have on the American public education system. No, they don't teach self-responsibility, but rather everybody is a victim. And to think, they are teaching the voters of the future.
by absolutely
except that you have thought about it all much more carefully than I have. I agree with all your observations, except the ones I had never considered!
My strongest conviction about this issue is what you mention in point 2. It is impossible to support a welfare state without blanking on the question "how?" Because anyone who asks that question will notice that the most abundant societies are those where production is most rewarded, and that they personally are motivated to work only when there is a reward for them. In other words, people are selfish, and if their pursuit of happiness is thwarted regardless of their effort, the sane ones regard their effort as meaningless. Selfishness is not a curse or a virtue by itself, but it is a fact of human nature and must be accepted and respected in the sense that any fact of reality is respected.
Point 3. reminds me of something I remember Dennis Rodman saying about his gambling habit. He was self-aware enough to notice that he felt guilty about his wealth, and felt an unbearable obligation to just fritter some of it away. Not his exact words of course, but impressive to me that he was so honest. Pretty sure it was Rodman...
As for solutions, I don't have any confidence in the public school system to improve substantially. The only hope I see for this country is private debate societies for young people. Might be 100% pocket protector kids for a long time, but still, public political dialog is no better among professional politicians than a Fox News shouting match, and the only pattern to the resolution of the issues that are "debated" is pragmatism. If more voters were familiar with the rigors of formal logic...and we are never going to get a sizable fraction of the public to take college logic classes in either philosophy or math departments...
Oh, and the libertarians. I was talking to one recently, and was very disappointed in the answer to my question: "Why tackle such fringe, alienating issues as drug legalization?" Answer: the Libertarian Party is not trying to compete so much as to educate. I don't believe the two major parties can be brought into line by a party that is not trying to compete.
by absolutely
Leftists cannot count, it's a prerequisite! 65 million dead Chinese peasants, 30 million in the USSR, 3 million Cambodians (in a country that only started with 7 million, I guess we can't even say that communism is "inefficient"), means that anybody who favors State redistribution of wealth or a command economy in any sector either (1) cannot count (2) is clinically insane, for example does not believe that history is fact or (3) most likely, plans to be a Party Member when the Red bleed the Blue-Bloods here in the States.
Thanks for the info. I hope to stay off the Miscellaneous long enough to become better-informed.
by absolutely
Nevertheless, your bank account offers you the option to withdraw your funds as cash, aka government promissory notes.
Also, having used your Bible to support the premise that the government may tax me to add convenience to your performance of your (not my) religious duty (I have none, as I have chosen to use my First Amendment rights to freely exercise no religion whatsoever), you are now morally obligated by your own assertion to obey ALL the Scriptures, including Jesus' instruction to sell all that you have and give all the money to the poor. I am poor. If you do not give all your money (That means everything that an accountant would consider an asset.) to the poor, then you are a hypocrite who invokes the Bible to support his personal beliefs, and ignores it when Jesus' beliefs are too inconvenient.
PS If the "next life" is so important to you, go on to it, but don't use it as an excuse to violate my rights in this one!
by absolutely
Visited
http://www.kowaldesign.com/cgi/Budget.pl?estimates=
Eliminated Medicare, Medicaid, and Social Security funding, and didn't touch anything else! All we need to do in this country to turn our deficit to a $1 Trillion Surplus is stop giving away free lunches for the lazy!
Sorry to anybody who once received government aid and was never lazy, but I know that without government handout programs that treat hard luck and intentional lack of effort the same, private programs would do a much better job of helping people locally who are really in temporary need. Very simply, government redistribution of wealth is immoral, illegal and impractical. Every "good" thing it is claimed to do is better done privately.
by absolutely
by absolutely
by absolutely
To what is production lost? You mention urban sprawl, but certainly when family farms are "lost" to sprawl they are fairly compensated and sell voluntarily, right? Unless the farms are stolen, there is no loss to the farmers, only a voluntary exchange of property. And I do not feel that equivalent produce grown overseas instead of here is a loss to me. Do you?
Then later you mention the difficulty of making a family farm economically viable. So, do you mean that the American public should consider the needs of a few family farmers above their own needs when considering the justice of tax policy?
I've found it difficult to compete in the PC operating system market because there are large firms already making what most consumers are willing to buy for the prices offered. Why does the farming industry deserve different protections from the same competitive economic principles?
Finally, your fixation on agricultural and manufactured products is unexplained, just offered as if they are problems with no justification of that conclusion. This is why overseas manufacturing is not a problem.
American ingenuity is responsible for more breakthroughs in science and advanced engineering than any other country, and that is our greatest competitive advantage. It doesn't bother me if parts are manufactured overseas, because intellectual ability is uniquely potent in free socities, and the US has essentially cornered the market on personal liberty, just for lack of willing competitors. Sure, the advantage is slipping, but there is still no document on Earth that guarantees the right to succeed according to one's ability more completely than the US Constitution. Factory workers never "made this country great". They did great things for their families, I'm sure, but on a national level, factory workers did nothing more than implement the great ideas of the inventors and entrepreneurs who made this country great. Excessive taxation will destroy that trend if it is not put to a halt, and fast.
by absolutely
I used to wonder, now I am sure that religion is not the right path.
Not only do people do shady things in the name of what they claim to believe about God, their beliefs are totally beyond examination or accountability because they are "personal". Such beliefs are, by definition, not ultimately justified by the real world, but by somebody's claim of an afterworld. Whose?
Now, considering the immoral things you have seen and heard from religious people, can you think of any positive behavior that you can positively attribute to religion? Aren't most good deeds dones more for personal reasons than because "Jesus would"?
The "laboratory of federalism" was shut down starting with FDR and his "New Deal", and the Federal Government has been expanding ever since, taking more and more powers that should be reserved to the states.
(I assume you already knew this and were just being sarcastic :-) )
http://www.answers.com/topic/new-federalism
The judge is Louis Brandeis, who said "It is one of the happy incidents of the federal system that a single courageous state may, if its citizens choose, serve as a laboratory; and try novel social and economic experiments without risk to the rest of the country."
Also, check out the 10th Amendment: "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people."
by bfilmfan
It was my understanding that a large percent of the budget is now spent on servicing the debt on federal bonds, etc.
I agree with you that a large portion of the budget is spent in an arbitrary fashion and soemtimes for no damned good explicable reason.
So in keeping with your thought, here is what I would do once I am elected President of the United States of America:
Day 1 Activities:
Minute 1: Cancel all innaguration festivities.
Minute 5: Invite Chief Supreme Court Justice to issue Oath of Office in Oval Office.
Minute 10: Thank Chief Justice and announce to staff there will be a press conference in 10 minutes.
Minute 20: On national television, immediately announce Executive Order (whatever number it will be) "As of this date, all corporations which claim rights, privileges and legal status and are incorporated within the borders of the 50 contiguous states now must manufacture, assemble and design all products within the borders of the United States. Those corporations which do not choose to abide by this order are hereby declared to be a Firm of Foreign National Origin and shall be subject to such tariffs, import duties and restrictions for products being originated in the nation of creation, manufacture, assembly and development."
Minute 22: Sign Executive Order into law. Immediately order Justice Department to enforce.
Minute 23: Announce next Executive Order, "In accordance with the determination that the 2nd clause of the 14th Amerndment of the Consitution was never ratified and enforced, all Amendments to the Consitution from July 9, 1868 until the voters Civil Rights Act of 1964 are declared null and void and shall be required to be resubmitted and properly ratified in accordance with consitutional law."
Minute 25: Sign Executive Order and immediately order Justice Department to immediately seize all assets in the possession of Government agencies such as the IRS, amongst others.
Minute 27: Immediately announce next Executive Order, "This executive order recognizes the rights of individual nations to determine their own destinies. All US Armed Forces are to begin orderly withdraw from all nations where they are subsequently based to be restationed in the United States of America within 180 days."
Minute 28: Sign Executive Order. Order Justice Department and DOD to begin enforcement.
Minute 29: Look directly in the camera and say, "We are just getting going here. The next executive orders are in order:
All US energy production is to be converted to low-pollution, highly-renewable energy sources within 4 years. This includes all electical production, automotive and heavy industry.
The H1B level is hereby set at 1000 individuals per year.
The United States Armed Forces are hereby ordered to secure all US borders immediately.
All illegal aliens within the United States borders are to be immediately rounded up and expelled.
All officials to elected to office at the federal level are hereby limited to 1 six year turn per lifetime.
Finally, I conclude that the United States Budget shall be balanced and shall not rely on any debt.
I suspect at about minute 30, I would be dead.
by absolutely
TheChas has still not transferred to me his electronic assets, leaving unsupported his claims that (1) he is a Christian (2) money is not property.
No, I never expected that he, nor anybody else, would sell all that they have and give it to the poor. I just wonder, did Jesus really expect it?
by absolutely
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending