Discussion Locked

Terrorism -- the war that America MUST win

0 helpful
145 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

A friend has just sent me the following item, and I think that the opinions and statements presented therein are self evident. As it is addressed to the USA, I have left it as such, but of course it applies equally to all non-Muslim and especially Western countries

By: Major General Vernon Chong, USAF-Ret.

A "Google" on the General found him to be a retired Air Force Surgeon and past Commander of Wilford Hall Medical Center in San Antonio. He is real and is connected to Veterans affairs, and these are his thoughts. Whether you agree or disagree, I think they are well worth reading and thinking about. Please for once, forget "democrat and republican". Focus on the seriousness of the issue.

General Chong's article

To get out of a difficulty, one usually must go through it. Our country is now facing the most serious threat to its existence, as we know it, that we have faced in your lifetime and mine (which includes WWII).

The deadly seriousness is greatly compounded by the fact that there are very few of us who think we can possibly lose this war and even fewer who realize what losing really means. First, let's examine a few basics:

1. When did the threat to us start? Many will say September 11th, 2001. The answer as far as the United States is concerned is 1979, 22 years prior to September 2001, with the following attacks on us:
* Iran Embassy Hostages, 1979;
* Beirut, Lebanon Embassy 1983;
* Beirut, Lebanon Marine Barracks 1983;
* Lockerbie, Scotland Pan-Am flight to New York 1988;
* First New York World Trade Center attack 1993;
* Dhahran, Saudi Arabia Khobar Towers Military complex 1996;
* Nairobi, Kenya US Embassy 1998;
* Dares Salaam, Tanzania US Embassy 1998;
* Aden, Yemen USS Cole 2000;
* New York World Trade Center2001;
* Pentagon 2001.
(Note that during the period from 1981 to 2001 there were 7,581 terrorist attacks worldwide).

2. Why were we attacked? Envy of our position, our success, and our freedoms. The attacks happened during the administrations of Presidents Carter, Reagan, Bush 1, Clinton and Bush 2. We cannot fault either the Republicans or Democrats as there were no provocations by any of the presidents or their immediate predecessors, Presidents Ford or Carter.

3. Who were the attackers? In each case, the attacks on the US were carried out by Muslims.

4. What is the Muslim population of the World? 25%.

5. Isn't the Muslim Religion peaceful? Hopefully, but that is really not material. There is no doubt that the predominately Christian population of Germany was peaceful, but under the dictatorial leadership of Hitler (who was also Christian), that made no difference. You either went along with the administration or you were eliminated. There were 5 to 6 million Christians killed by the Nazis for political reasons (including 7,000 Polish priests). (see "http://www.nazis.testimony.co.uk/7-a.htm"). Thus, almost the same number of Christians were killed by the Nazis, as the six million holocaust Jews who were killed by them, and we seldom heard of anything other than the Jewish atrocities.

Although Hitler kept the world focused on the Jews, he had no hesitancy about killing anyone who got in his way of exterminating the Jews or of taking over the world - German, Christian or any others. Same with the Muslim terrorists. They focus the world on the US, but kill all in the way -- their own people or the Spanish, French or anyone else. The point here is that just like the peaceful Germans were of no protection to anyone from the Nazis, no matter how many peaceful Muslims there may be, they are no protection for us from the terrorist Muslim leaders and what they are fanatically bent on doing -- by their own pronouncements -- killing all of us "infidels." I don't blame the peaceful Muslims. What would you do if the choice was shut up or die?

6. So who are we at war with? There is no way we can honestly respond that it is anyone other than the Muslim terrorists. Trying to be politically correct and avoid verbalizing this conclusion can well be fatal. There is no way to win if you don't clearly recognize and articulate who you are fighting.

So with that background, now to the two major questions:

1. Can we lose this war?

2. What does losing really mean?

If we are to win, we must clearly answer these two pivotal questions. We can definitely lose this war, and as anomalous as it may sound, the major reason we can lose is that so many of us simply do not fathom the answer to the second question -What does losing mean? It would appear that a great many of us think that losing the war means hanging our heads, bringing the troops home and going on about our business, like post Vietnam. This is as far from the truth as one can get. What losing really means is:

We would no longer be the premier country in the world. The attacks will not subside, but rather will steadily increase. Remember, they want us dead, not just quiet. If they had just wanted us quiet, they would not have produced an increasing series of attacks against us, over the past 18 years. The plan was clearly, for terrorists to attack us, until we were neutered and submissive to them. We would of course have no future support from other nations, for fear of reprisals and for the reason that they would see, we are impotent and cannot help them. They will pick off the other non-Muslim nations, one at a time. It will be increasingly easier for them. They already hold Spain hostage. It doesn't matter whether it was right or wrong for Spain to withdraw its troops from Iraq. Spain did it because the Muslim terrorists bombed their train and told them to withdraw the troops.

Anything else they want Spain to do will be done. Spain is finished. The next will probably be France. Our one hope on France is that they might see the light and realize that if we don't win, they are finished too, in that they can't resist the Muslim terrorists without us. However, it may already be too late for France. France is already 20% Muslim and fading fast! If we lose the war, our production, income, exports and way of life will all vanish as we know it. After losing, who would trade or deal with us, if they were threatened by the Muslims. If we can't stop the Muslims, how could anyone else? The Muslims fully know what is riding on this war, and therefore are completely committed to winning, at any cost. We better know it too and be likewise committed to winning at any cost. Why do I go on at such lengths about the results of losing?

Simple.

Until we recognize the costs of losing, we cannot unite and really put 100% of our thoughts and efforts into winning. And it is going to take that 100% effort to win.

So, how can we lose the war? Again, the answer is simple. We can lose the war by "imploding."

That is, defeating ourselves by refusing to recognize the enemy and their purpose, and really digging in and lending full support to the war effort. If we are united, there is no way that we can lose. If we continue to be divided, there is no way that we can win! Let me give you a few examples of how we simply don't comprehend the life and death seriousness of this situation. President Bush selects Norman Mineta as Secretary of Transportation. Although all of the terrorist attacks were committed by Muslim men between 17 and 40 years of age, Secretary Mineta refuses to allow profiling.

Does that sound like we are taking this thing seriously? This is war! For the duration, we are going to have to give up some of the civil rights we have become accustomed to. We had better be prepared to lose some of our civil rights temporarily or we will most certainly lose all of them permanently. And don't worry that it is a slippery slope. We gave up plenty of civil rights during WWII, and immediately restored them after the victory and in fact added many more since then. Do I blame President Bush or President Clinton before him? No, I blame us for blithely assuming we can maintain all of our Political Correctness, and all of our civil rights during this conflict and have a clean, lawful, honorable war.

None of those words apply to war. Get them out of your head. Some have gone so far in their criticism of the war and/or the Administration that it almost seems they would literally like to see us lose. I hasten to add that this isn't because they are disloyal. It is because they just don't recognize what losing means. Nevertheless, that conduct gives the impression to the enemy that we are divided and weakening. It concerns our friends, and it does great damage to our cause. Of more recent vintage, the uproar fueled by the politicians and media regarding the treatment of some prisoners of war, perhaps exemplifies best what I am saying.

We have recently had an issue, involving the treatment of a few Muslim prisoners of war, by a small group of our military police. These are the type prisoners who just a few months ago were throwing their own people off buildings, cutting off their hands, cutting out their tongues and otherwise murdering their own people just for disagreeing with Saddam Hussein. And just a few years ago these same type prisoners chemically killed 400,000 of their own people for the same reason. They are also the same type enemy fighters, who recently were burning Americans, and dragging their charred corpses through the streets of Iraq. And still more recently, the same type enemy that was and is providing videos to all news sources internationally, of the beheading of American prisoners they held.

Compare this with some of our press and politicians, who for several days have thought and talked about nothing else but the "humiliating" of some Muslim prisoners; not burning them, not dragging their charred corpses through the streets, not beheading them, but "humiliating" them.

Can this be for real?

The politicians and pundits have even talked of impeachment of the Secretary of defense. If this doesn't show the complete lack of comprehension and understanding of the seriousness of the enemy we are fighting, the life and death struggle we are in and the disastrous results of losing this war, nothing can.

To bring our country to a virtual political standstill over this prisoner issue makes us look like Nero playing his fiddle as Rome burned -- totally oblivious to what is going on in the real world. Neither we, nor any other country, can survive this internal strife. Again I say, this does not mean that some of our politicians or media people are disloyal It simply means that they are absolutely oblivious to the magnitude, of the situation we are in and into which the Muslim terrorists have been pushing us, for many years. Remember, the Muslim terrorists stated goal is to kill all infidels! That translates into all non-Muslims -- not just in the United States, but throughout the world. We are the last bastion of defense.

We have been criticized for many years as being 'arrogant.' That charge is valid in at least one respect. We are arrogant in that we believe that we are so good, powerful and smart, that we can win the hearts and minds of all those who attack us, and that with both hands tied behind our back, we can defeat anything bad in the world! We can't! If we don't recognize this, our nation as we know it will not survive, and no other free country in the World will survive if we are defeated.

And finally, name any Muslim countries throughout the world that allow freedom of speech, freedom of thought, freedom of religion, freedom of the press, equal rights for anyone -- let alone everyone, equal status or any status for women, or that have been productive in one single way that contributes to the good of the world. This has been a long way of saying that we must be united on this war or we will be equated in the history books to the self-inflicted fall of the Roman Empire. If, that is, the Muslim leaders will allow history books to be written or read.

If we don't win this war right now, keep a close eye on how the Muslims take over France in the next 5 years or less. They will continue to increase the Muslim population of France and continue to encroach little by little, on the established French traditions. The French will be fighting among themselves, over what should or should not be done, which will continue to weaken them and keep them from any united resolve. Doesn't that sound eerily familiar? Democracies don't have their freedoms taken away from them by some external military force. Instead, they give their freedoms away, politically correct piece by politically correct piece And they are giving those freedoms away to those who have shown, worldwide, that they abhor freedom and will not apply it to you or even to themselves, once they are in power.

They have universally shown that when they have taken over, they then start brutally killing each other over who will be the few who control the masses. Will we ever stop hearing from the politically correct, about the "peaceful Muslims"? I close on a hopeful note, by repeating what I said above. If we are united, there is no way that we can lose. I hope now after the election, the factions in our country will begin to focus on the critical situation we are in, and will unite to save our country. It is your future we are talking about! Do whatever you can to preserve it. After reading the above, we all must do this not only for ourselves, but our children, our grandchildren, our country and the world. Whether Democrat or Republican, conservative or liberal and that includes the Politicians and media of our country and the free world!

145 replies

by ciderick

Oh dear, that's a very biased document there - do you ever stop & wonder why America is the target of these attacks? Maybe it's because of jingoistic views like yours - The English & Irish were fighting for a long time but that doesn't mean that the English should declare war on Protestants & Catholics the world over. It doesn't even mean that the English should declare war on the Irish (who, to be honest, kind of had a reason to be miffed). The Anglo/Irish thing is also a good example of how talking can aid in solving problems, although not perfect at least there is a real chance for peace there now.

Oh, you mention that America has been criticized for many years for being arrogant. The writer of this document is extremely arrogant (& narrow minded & possibly the worst advert for the American people, whom I love for their generosity of soul & openness to strangers)!!!

Torture is wrong, killing is wrong, everything about war is wrong - This means you & the terrorists. Two wrongs NEVER make a right.

I am so glad Mr Chong is retired. I just pray that the armed forces of America avoid giving a man like that office ever again (Now if you guys could just get rid of George W you may have a chance).

by barghesthowl

Maxwell, I've actually seen some decent posts from you, but most are garbage like this. If all you're going to offer is a personal assault on someone, don't bother.

by tonythetiger

or even the most targetted. America is just the country that has a leader dumb enough to try to do something about it.

by maxwell edison

.
I think you know, probably more than any other TR peer, that I've been consistently saying the same thing General Chong has said in that article, albeit not as thorough and articulate. This IS NOT a political issue (Democrat versus Republican), but rather a very serious national security issue. You can probably remember back to my many messages, and recall that I've suggested that world leaders -- including U.S. leaders -- have been ignoring the seriousness of this issue for close to forty years. I've cited all of those attacks on America, and I've suggest how every president (of both major parties) since Jimmy Carter has dismally failed to really address the problem. War was declared on America in the 1970s. But it took 9-11 for the U.S to FINALLY declare war back.

This is the one ..... First New York World Trade Center attack 1993 ..... that should have been the real kick in the butt for us. Did you know that the real plan for that attack was to collapse both towers amid a lethal cloud of cyanide gas, something that would have killed tens, if not hundreds of thousands of people? But they screwed up, and the gas wasn't released into the air. And the main perpetrator and planner of that attack entered the United States with an Iraqi passport. No one will ever convince me that Saddam Hussein's Iraq wasn't secretly waging war on America and supporting terrorist efforts towards those ends. I've simply seen too much evidence to suggest -- to prove -- otherwise.

And I've also said it before that I would support ANY president of ANY party who recognized this threat for what it really was, and one who was determined to face it head-on. See my high praise of Democrat Senator Joe Lieberaman to prove my point. And now he seems to be an outcast in his own party.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=186410&start=0

I would support a Democrat President Joe Lieberman in this war against terrorism, just as I support a Republican President George W. Bush, and just as Democrats and Republicans both supported President Franklin Roosevelt.

My God, I wish Americans would get their heads out of their asses and see this for what it really is. What will it take for them to put politics behind them, and put the security of their nation first?

Many thanks, Julian, for posting what should be a very thought-provoking article.

by jdclyde

for OZ to jump up and down and threaten to hold his breath over the quote:

[i]"2. Why were we attacked? Envy of our position, our success, and our freedoms. The attacks happened during the administrations of Presidents Carter, Reagan, Bush 1, Clinton and Bush 2. We cannot fault either the Republicans or Democrats as there were no provocations by any of the presidents or their immediate predecessors, Presidents Ford or Carter."[/i]

From every discussion over the last few years, he has informed us stupid americans that this is false. No one is envious of us. They just hate us for our arrogance.

It really is amazing how many people see it as more important to sabatage the war just to make Bush look bad. Nothing else matters but politics as usual?

We have seen that this IS a real threat. Like he says, not all Muslims are looking to kill non-muslims, but there are a lot and that number is growing. And no, it isn't JUST Americans they are looking to kill, as we see the majority of the attacks over the last 20 years were NOT on the US.

In the mean time, lets keep checking Grandma before she gets on the plane and let that young male of eastern decent just stroll right on through to keep from hurting someones feelings. That is MUCH more important than to keep a plane from blowing up.

A good read indeed.

by ciderick

Very important to have ones head up ones arse as opposed to ass - makes a difference...

by thechas

I fully agree that America and the rest of the free world cannot afford to lose the war against terrorism.

The problem that is leading us toward doom is the lack of leadership in the Oval Office.

The war in Iraq is at best a vendetta against the regime of Saddam Husein, and a resolution to the first gulf war!

Prior to the US invasion of Iraq, there was only 1 terrorist group in Iraq, the ruling family, and their primary target was their own people!

As a serious terrorist threat to the US, Iraq in 2002 would have been at best 10th on the list.

Afghanistan would have been 1st on the list.
Followed by Iran.
Then Syria.
Saudi Arabia likely still ranks in the top 10 for both funding and training terrorists.

After Afghanistan, if our "leaders" were truly concerned about the terrorist threat, we should have invaded Iran and Syria long before disposing of Saddam.

Some will say that regime change for Iraq has been part of US policy for years. While that is true, so has regime change in Cuba. Yet, since the early 1960's, no one has suggested invading Cuba!

Unfortunately, the (lack of) leadership in the Oval Office has sidetracked the real war on terror with potentially dire consequences. The war in Iraq has weakened the US on both the domestic and the international political stages. GWB has succeeded in creating a divide among the people in the US wider than any previous President. Along with continuing lose of support globally.

The wrong battlefield was chosen, and our children will suffer the consequences.

Chas

by maxwell edison

.
You said, "The war in Iraq is at best a vendetta against the regime of Saddam Husein, and a resolution to the first gulf war!"

You couldn't be more wrong, Chas. Al Qaeda had training camps in Iraq. Not to mention the fact that Al Qaeda terrorists who escaped from Afghanistan sought refuge in Iraq.

You said, "Prior to the US invasion of Iraq, there was only 1 terrorist group in Iraq, the ruling family, and their primary target was their own people."

Again, you couldn't be more wrong. The most obvious example of showing where you are wrong is the fact that Saddam PAID Palestinian terrorists to kill Jews and westerners. And what about the 1993 attack on the WTC? Contrary to what you asserted, that WAS outside Iraq. (Not to mention the "Saddam ordered" attempted assassination of a former U.S. president in Kuwait.)

You said, "As a serious terrorist threat to the US, Iraq in 2002 would have been at best 10th on the list."

Will you please list one through nine? I'm curious.

You said, "After Afghanistan, if our leaders were truly concerned about the terrorist threat, we should have invaded Iran and Syria long before disposing of Saddam.

Are you suggesting that's what should have been done? Should we invade Iran and Syria right now?

You said, "Some will say that regime change for Iraq has been part of US policy for years. While that is true, so has regime change in Cuba. Yet, since the early 1960's, no one has suggested invading Cuba!"

Include me in your "some people" definition. The Iraq Liberation Act of 1998 does indeed show that a regime change in Iraq was a matter of U.S. policy. (Signed into law by President Clinton, by the way; and passed by the U.S. Senate by a vote of 99-0.) But will you please share with us a similar policy towards Cuba?

You said, "The wrong battlefield was chosen."

What was the RIGHT battlefield?

Your problem, Chas, is that you WANT to believe something, so you consider it fact. It doesn't matter how wrong it is, in your mind it's fact. But in reality, it's still wrong.

And a final question. What makes your opinion more correct -- AND more qualified -- than General Chong's?

by thechas

So Max,

Where is Iraq mentioned in the text of General Chang's remarks?

If our war is against Muslim terrorists, should we not go after the countries that most actively support the terrorists?

Even GWB is starting to admit that the intelligence used to justify invading Iraq was in error.

When you stack up the bodies, Saddam was definitely a much greater threat to the people of Iraq than he was to the rest of the world.

To be brutally honest, I have zero respect for, and question the intelligence of anyone who believes anything said by GWB!

GWB couldn't lead lemmings to a cliff!

Chas

by tonythetiger

As they say in real estate: Location, location, location!

Even if Sadaam was never there. Even if there were no training camps. It was still the right place.

by maxwell edison

.
....is wisdom.

You are the epitome of a person who works from a desired conclusion, going backwards seeking reasons to justify that desired conclusion.

I truly wish for you the wisdom to see facts as they really are, to see evidence as it really is, to see people as they really are, and then draw your conclusions accordingly, just letting the chips fall where they may.

And for God's sake, Chas, let go of your absolute hatred of President Bush. Hate has NEVER hurt the intended target, only the bearer of the hate.

Chas, you are SO smart. But you are equally so unwise.

by thechas

Max,

You may not believe this, but I am considered the wise one, and the source of knowledge among my peers and friends.

If you want some really far out stuff, you should hear what comes from the left of my position at work.

Perhaps part of why I considered myself to be a centrist is just how far to the left many of the people I work with are.

Among the people I work and socialize with, less than 10% actively consume ANY news or informed commentary. And, most of the ones who do seek out information limit themselves to right wing talk radio.

They are blind as bats when they go to vote.

Outside of this forum, NO ONE has ever challenged my theories or conclusions.

Chas

by barghesthowl

Someone -did- suggest, and try, invading Cuba (google "Bay of Pigs"). It was a disaster. The economic sanctions against Cuba, slowly but surely, are working, however.

Same was true of Iraq-the sanctions had crippled them, Saddam's regime would likely have imploded within 10 years, and it was certainly no threat to anyone outside Iraq's borders.

Iran? North Korea? THOSE are threats. Oops! Our troops are tied up in Iraq, and we can't make a credible threat against them!

by jdclyde

going after these other countries that you have this accurate intellegence on? Do we go in with our military? Or do we ask them nicely to play nice?

What would you see as a credible threat to IMPOSE on them, and what would you have us do if they didn't fully comply?

by jdclyde

Until Bush came along, every other time we were attacked it was treates like a common criminal case where we would attempt to pick up a few people and put them in jail.

No one would actively go after the places that trained the terrorists and gave them safe refuge. That is why the Taliban thumbed their noses at us. The were used to Clinton and figured at worst we would shoot off a few missles to save face and then run away. They had NO IDEA that we would walk in and clean the hornets nest out of the rafters.

We need a clear policy. We see where terrorists are training, level it. We find a source of funding for terrorists, cut it off.

Anyone that is a friend or allie to terrorists is an enemy to the rest of the world and MUST be treated as such. No matter WHAT the UN says.

by maxwell edison

.
......"who believes anything said by GWB!"

That would make a pretty big list -- a HUGE list, in fact. And there are some pretty impressive people on that list.

That's what I mean, Chas. You are absolutely blinded by your hate. You just characterized well over 100 million people. And that's just American voters. If you're pompous enough to judge them and deem yourself so much better than them, it speaks volumes to your true character.

Personally speaking, I'd rather be in their company than yours. Much less stench.

by davidwjohnson7738

The invasion of Iraq was wrong.. It was an example of reading what one wanted from the available intelligence. Unfortunately intelligence can't tell you everything.. Intelligence like history books tends to be biased by the writer.. Sometimes intelligence is asked for a definative answer to a question but all that one can do is present the evidence (not forgetting to also state the apparent validity of the information) and then allowing the recipients to make a decision. The hardest part is seperating the wheat from the chaff and finding the needle in the ever growing haystack.

The only reason the US did not invade Cuba (other than the aborted effort of the Bay of Pigs affair) is that leaving Cuba alone was a condition that helped end the Cuban Missile Crisis.

The United States and the American people do not have a good reputation outside of their country. They love your money but would rather not deal with you.

As for GWB either you detest him or you love him.. there is not much middle ground here. I personally do not like the infringements and trampling of the constitution all in the name of anti-terrorism.. George Orwell's Animal Farm seems to come to mind here.

The General seems to be a tad racist in his dislike of Muslims. Could it be that Muslim states control a great chunk of the worlds oil? I don't believe that religion is the evil here.

by jdclyde

[i] Intelligence, like history books, tends to be biased by the writer[/i]

History books biased? Oh yeah. There are still people out there that think the civil war (in the US) was fought to "free the slaves".

As far as Intelligence. The information that was given for justification is the same as other countries were saying, not to mention what Clinton and Kerry were saying up to ten years ago.

To go the step to say Bush lied, well, is a lie.

by sleepin'dawg

in the way of history;have you? You believe all this garbage about Islam being a religion of peace. Well if you studied the history of Islam you would realize its goal since it's inception has made it a religion of conversion by conquest. Back around 600 AD or so good ol' rug merchant Moe got his snoot in to some wacky type tabaccy and out of his halucinations he decided to fire up his own specialized brand of religion. For what its worth all his so called teachings were recorded by others due to the oft overlooked fact that the ol' rug salesman could neither read nor write. At first this was a bit of a hard sell but ol' Moe persevered and he established his religion amidst a pantheistic culture which also had a couple of other monotheistic religions in the area i.e. Zoroastrianism and Christianity.

Now while ol' Moe wasn't big in the reading and writing department and while he was nuttier than a fruit cake, he wasn't stupid. He figured the Son of God routine had been pretty much locked up by JC and his gang and Zoroastrianism was only hot with the Medes and Persians. He needed a hook and he found one. None of this love thine neighbour or the meek shall inherit the earth stuff for him; no sirree Bob. He came up with a pitch that had some real pizzazz. He knew he couldn't pass himself off as the son of God but he could certainly call himself a prophet and not one of your run of the mill prophets like Moses, Jacob, Abraham or even JC. Oh yeah that was his way of handling the son of God problem. Deny he was the son of God turn him into a prophet; the next one down the ladder from Moe. As the last and supposedly greatest of God's prophets, it became sort of like my prophet is tougher than your prophet and he had a nifty way of proving this. Either start believing in our prophet or we'll kill you.

Now you didn't have to love your neighbour or stay peaceful and wait for your reward in the next life; you could raid your neighbour steal what he had and if he didn't see your way of thinking; kill him. If perchance you got killed yourself, not to worry. Because you were out spreading the good word, God will look on you favourably and you'll get seventy-two virgins all for yourself alone. Now this was pretty damn attractive to the great unwashed and you can trust me on this, there are very few more unwashed than Arabs. So the neighbour would save his arse by converting but after a while he would ask the embarassing question,"Why am I getting burned here? Where's my piece of the action? I'm a convert in good standing." And the neighbour was told if he wanted his piece he would have to go out and convert a few sorry-assed souls.

Needless to say the neighbour was thrilled with this. He'd get his and in the process either save some souls for the prophet or win glory for himself by dispatching a few infidels. And thus the armies of the true prophet grew and swept across North Africa. Eventually there was no more room on that continent so they jumped across to Europe. In less than two hundred years they had made serious inroads into Spain, Southern France and Italy; as well they were pushing around the eastern end of the Mediterranean. Charlemagne pushed them out of France around 875-890 AD but Isabella and Ferdinand didn't get rid of them from Spain until around the time Columbus sailed for the new world. It was in the same time frame that the Ottoman Turks took Constantinople for the forces of of Islam. They may have lost at one end of the Mediterranean but they made up for it at the eastern end where they proceeded merrily on their way up the beautiful Blue Danube until they were literally knocking on the gates of Vienna. They also grabbed off most of the Balkans in passing. Along the way the message remained essentially the same but it was lessened somwhat from convert or die to something closer to convert or we'll make your lives a living hell.

This of course was to be expected because Judaism from which Islam is sort of descended, had eased up on the severity of the old eye for an eye business prior to the establishment of Islam. Now this was not all one sided, far from it as modern day Muslims like to remind us. The western guys retaliated in a half assed fashion by endeavouring to throw a few donnybrooks called the crusades. The Christians gathered up their armies and either crossed the Mediterranean or marched around the eastern end. Anyway there was a lot of huffing, puffing and straining and while thousands of people were killed or murdered, the crusades were largely ineffectual and doomed to failure. The main reason was the length of the supply lines; the Muslims worked with internal supply lines the crusaders with long external lines going back to their home countries. Also on a technical basis, what there was of technology in those days, the Muslims were better off. The Arabs of those days were better educated in mathematics, science and philosophy while the crowned heads of Europe could barely write their own names.

Now I have mentioned mostly Islam's attacks on the west and Christianity but you have to give Moe's boys credit because they weren't strictly against Christianity; they also turned their attention against the Hindus and Buddhists. Just recently they astounded the world in the depths of the depravity and stupidity they could sink to when the Taliban destroyed two statues of Buddha, each over a thousand years old that had been listed as World Heritage treasures by the UN. You don't often get to see such a celebration of bigotry and indifference on such a grand scale.

By the mid 1700s Islam had pretty much shot its bolt and has been reverting to a state of barbarism far from the education and civility it once displayed for its time. It has become primarily, especially in the Middle East, Pakistan and Afghanistan, a religion of fundamental reactionary terrorism and as such should be stamped out with as much force as required. Looking back over history you can see at no time did the other religions of the world instigate any attacks on Islam but rather attacked Islam in retaliation to attacks and incurrsions launched by Islam.

Today we are inundated by immigrant and refugee scum from these so called Islamic nations. They come to us uninvited and demand that we adapt to them. I demand to know; why should we??? They walk around treating their women like crap, demanding special places to pray five time a day and as a matter of respect everything should come to a grinding halt while they pray??? Not bloody likely in any company of mine. Now you might say I'm a prejudiced bigot except for one curious fact. Once I was on the point of hiring a Muslim and I was curious to find out what his requirements regarding prayer would be. He pointed out that there were special dispensations in the Queran that covered the situation. A Muslim does not have to strictly adhere to a set schedule of prayer if it is not convenient to do so. He asked if I had ever been to any Islamic countrie and I told him I had. He asked me if I had heard the calls to prayer and having heard them did everything come to a stop until the prayer times were over; his example was did the buses stop running. I had to admit they hadn't and he explained that Islam's Queran covered that situation and others like it and only the most backward and fundamental reactionary Muslims adhered to that sort of behaviour. When you go to Indonesia or Malasia countries with large Muslim populations, outnumbering the Middle eastern Muslims, you never see anything like what you see with the Middle Eastern, Arabic or Iranian Muslims.

These people want to come to live in the west then I say they should adapt to us not us to them. Further down this road you come to the fact that most of the current practitioners of terrorism are fundamentalist Muslims. These are the people that place guns in the hands of children and send them out to kill. These are the people who convince teens and preteens to strap explosives to themselves and then send them into crowds to blow themselves up and kill the unbelieving infidel.

I lived among that type of people for a year and a half. When I first went there I was part of the UN peace keeping forces and I was greener than grass. I had no preconceived ideas about Arabs and Muslims. When I left at the end of my tour I had acquired prejudicial ideas earned through bitter painful experience. My prejudices dictated that the only good Islamic Arab was a dead one and while I was there I did what was necessary for my own survival and that involved a certain amount of wet work. In the latter years I have modified my belief somewhat. Not all Muslims are evil but most of the fundamentalist sort are and experience has taught me , the hard way, if you scratch a fundamentalist muslim you will find a terrorist not far beneath. If he is not one today he will be one soon and the only solution is the same as it was forty-three years ago when I was posted in Rafah Egypt; search and destroy.[b] The only good one or safe one is a dead one.

Dawg[/b] ]:)

by maxwell edison

.
.....NO ONE has ever challenged your theories or conclusions.

And I do it so well. You're not used to it, are you? It's no wonder you can't take it very well.

by m_a_r_k

It's a war that every democratic nation needs to be involved in. The enemy is elusive and is able to hide anywhere. One nation alone cannot win a war like this with missiles and bombs.

While I agree that terrorism needs to be eradicated with whatever means necessary, I don't agree that a roving band of suicide bombers and airplane hijackers can take down a country the size of ours or even hold us hostage. Terrorists have been attacking little old spunky Israel for years. It's had no effect other than to cause Israel to kill a few thousand Palestinians in return. So far, the Israelis are way ahead if you're keeping score.

In the above, I am referring to terrorists trying to nickel-and-dime us to death with an occasional rabbit punch. But what do you think the U.S. would do if we were hit with a massive wave of terrorist attacks inside our borders? I don't know the certain answer to that. But in the days after 9/11, I was scared for the future of my country for the first time in my life. And I was scared for the rest of the world for how we might respond. The scenario that I imagined in my mind was a continuing spate of terrorist attacks that went on for days or weeks. The American people would demand that our leaders find a way to stop the madness. What would be our choice to end this? Obliterate the likely source. Aim our nuclear arsenal at the center of the Middle East and work our way outwards until the whole place is nothing but a pile of radioactive soot. I don't know if this would solve anything at all. But desperate people do desperate things in desperate times. If you are faced with your own death at the hands of a madman, wouldn't you fight back with any and all means at your disposal? If you're blindfolded and can't see your attacker, you'd grab whatever your desperate hands could find and you'd use that weapon to lash out at whatever was within your reach.

At any rate, I advise every American to keep a loaded shotgun within reach at all times. When the terrorists come, they'll have a fight on their hands. Bring back the good ole days of the wild, wild West!

by jaqui

in fearing what the leadership of the us might do.

problem is, they formally declared war on terrorism, sent the troops out and simultaneously, without declaration, started a war against the people of the us.

almost every bit of legislation that has been passed in the war on terrorism is actually a direct attack on the people of the us, and works to undermine the constitution and charter of rights and freedoms.

by stargazerr

Look at what is going on in India ... Is that not terrorism?? People,innocent people, are being killed every day in this country for the simple reason of Kashmir ...

The terrorists are not fighting against US ... they are fighting against everyone .. They dont ask you your nationality before bombing you ... Many non US people died in the attack on te WTC ...they dont care which country you come from as long as they can achieve what they want ..

]:)

by jardinier

"As it is addressed to the USA, I have left it as such, but of course it applies equally to all non-Muslim and especially Western countries."

And especially those who became involved in Iraq.

Thanks to our Prime Minister -- for reasons unknown -- joining the COW, Australia has now became a serious target for terrorists. Quite likely you have heard of a recent incident in which a potentially serious attack within our country was nipped in the bud by Intelligence.

by m_a_r_k

I just wanted to reemphasize that most Americans don't feel like it is our place to be the world's policeman and that this is a global issue that requires a concerted effort among all nations (even Muslim nations).

I don't know how you can blame the Australia terrorist plot on your country joining the coalition. Your country is a target because it is a freedom-loving democracy. Many non-coalition countries have been targets of terrorism. Bombings in Bali and African countries and the recent one in Jordan come to my mind immediately.

by m_a_r_k

I just wanted to reemphasize that most Americans don't feel like it is our place to be the world's policeman and that this is a global issue that requires a concerted effort among all nations (even Muslim nations).

I don't know how you can blame the Australia terrorist plot on your country joining the coalition. Your country is a target because it is a freedom-loving democracy. Many non-coalition countries have been targets of terrorism. Bombings in Bali and African countries and the recent one in Jordan come to my mind immediately.

by stargazerr

What about a country which has a third of muslim population ?? Do they not have a right to join the war??

]:)

by maxwell edison

.
It's obvious you haven't read enough of my posts to get a good feel for them (or me). For if you had, you would realize that I couldn't care less what you might think.

by barghesthowl

That if you'd prefer to make yourself look the fool with childish namecalling, I suppose no one can stop you. But really, either act your age, or let those of us capable of having a rational, intelligent debate do it.

by maxwell edison

.
You apparently see yourself as some sort of self-appointed civility monitor around here, not only in this discussion, but others as well. And you, of all people, a guy who gets "bleeped" in your own messages.

Do us both a favor; if you don't like to read what I write, don't open the book, and don't click on any message with my name on it. And if you do, spare me your opinion. Like I said, I don't care what it is.

You're the one with the problem, not me.

Now shoo.

by barghesthowl

I was far more concerned about the PATRIOT Act's repercussions to the "rights of my children" then sporadic terrorist attacks.

That's right, I said SPORADIC. These are not the Germans, these are not the Nazis! They don't have an army and a navy that can even remotely rival our own. They're an organized crime syndicate.

Do we need to take organized crime seriously? You bet we do. Do we need to GIVE UP OUR CIVIL LIBERTIES, in order to fight it? Give me a break.

I -MIGHT- be willing to accept a temporary situation if a definite timetable or exit strategy were provided. Yes, some civil liberties were given up during WWII. Some of that was called for and a good idea (rationing), some of it was a terrible mistake (internment of Asian-Americans). But we were fighting two superpowers, and WWII had a very clear end-the minute the second superpower surrendered, the war's clearly over.

This time, we're fighting some nebulous enemy who is not anywhere near superpower status, but may occasionally do something nasty. That's not a war, it's just criminals. Cops have been catching criminals for years without any PATRIOT Act-and yes, sometimes, our civil liberties mean that a criminal gets away with it.

I'd rather be dead then lose my freedom. What about you? This is hysteria. The terrorists are no "Nazis", the Muslim movement into France is normal immigration (which has been going on for centuries), and yes, Virginia, the vast majority of Muslims ARE peaceful-THOSE ARE THE ONES WHO FLEE THE TERRORIST STATES FOR FRANCE, OR SPAIN, OR THE US!

by jaqui

the Patriot act et-al actually make the us more of a N.A.Z.I. sate than any other government in the world. they also make the US second only to China for repressive laws against the people of the country.

by jdclyde

TR has been like this for over a week now. Some "fix" they put in really fixed it all right.

Kind of like taking a dog to the vet with a WORKING wang, and "fixing" the poor guy and now it doesn't work anymore? You call that fixing? I call that breaking! Oh my! :O

by danlm

I thought that the article as written was very though provoking. Like everything else I read on the war on terror, I will kick back and think about it before I make any judgment on it. It supported some of my beleifs and challanged others.
With regard to your comment "NO ONE has ever challenged my theories or conclusions". You either run around a bunch of weenies that give and take conversations, or you just surround yourself with like minded people.
I for one am challanged all the time on my oppinions, and I look forward to it. When the challenge is well thought out and properly presented, it makes me look over my oppinion again to see if it is correct. If my oppinion changes due to the argument or challenge to it, I freely admit it. Both discussions and reading of various material make up my oppinion, as it should yours.
I also will freely admit that I do like GWB, but do I agree with all his positions. Of course not, and have I changed my mind on some of what I did agree with. Yes I have. But, I do beleive he is fundemently right in taking on the terrorist problem by taking it to the streets with them. They did it first, we turned both cheeks mutiple times. Its time to slap them back, and hard. Do I agree with Iraq, that is one oppinion that I did agree with but have sence changed my mind. BUT, I do feel that terrorist activities were occuring in that country directed at us. Would I have made it the top priorotiy, no.
I agree with what was previously said about you allowing your hate of our current president to blind your oppinions. You seem to be highly inteligent, and I do not hold any rancor against you because of your oppinion. But I feel your oppinion is soly directed againt anything that President Bush does, and does not take in the complete picture. You said you dont beleive anything that president bush says or does. But in the same post, you posted that Afganastan would be your top priority. President Bush went into Afganastan first. You saying you don't agree with that? Or are you saying that it was a correct decesion? Please state your oppinion more clearly. I have the impression that if it was any other president, you would have said. Yes, the president was right to go to Afganastan. But, I disagree with his decesion in Iraq.

Dan Miller

by barghesthowl

I'll continue to read on anyway, thanks, it takes a good bit more then that before I'll quit. And I'll keep right on calling you on it when you act that way. It's not acceptable behavior for an adult.

And yes, I said "bullshit". I was not swearing -at- someone (I was using the term in relation to a story about a liar that someone related), so I fail to see how that relates.

by jardinier

Sadly, to the best of my knowledge, there has never been a serious discussion at this website about the REAL reasons for the invasion of Iraq.

Could it have had something to do with the fact that Iraq contains 112 billion barrels of proven oil reserves, the second largest in the world behind Saudi Arabia?

If there was no black gold under the sands of Iraq, I imagine Saddam Hussein would still be seated on his dastardly throne.

However the "war" is a fact which will have its third birthday in March, 2006.

At present there even seems a possibility that some good will come of it.

But this discussion is not about whether or not this war was justified and appropriate, but about how to deal with the terrorist threat NOW and in the future.

by danlm

Think about this. Iraq also sits basicatly in the middle between some of the countries most hostile to the United States.
I always wondered that if one of the reasons that we invaded Iraq was to get ground troups in the area with support supplies. Now, if say Syria or Iran were to be implicated in a seroius attack on the United States. We already have the troops in place to put a serious slappen on them, instead of having to build up the forces first.
Its been mentioned about the oil as a reason, President Bush getting even for his father, and Sadam being involved in 9/11. But I have heard no one mention the fact that of the three nations(Iran, Iraq, and Syria). That Iraq was probably the easiest to invade. Once there, we now had a ground and air base right in the middle of other hostile countries that we could strike from if the need arose?
I don't know. Me, if I was declaring war on terrorism which for the most part is sentered in the Middle East. I would want to take out the easiest country first. Get situated, set up the supply methods. Get the troups on the ground. Then look around and say to the rest of the nations that you suspect that are sponsering terrorist acts against the United States. Ok, you said what now? Your going to do what now? Seems to be a different story now that I'm sitting here looking over your sholder doesnt it?

Dan Miller

by maxwell edison

.
"...that if one of the reasons that we invaded Iraq was to get ground troups in the area with support supplies."

Of course it was.

And please, don't repeat a lie. NOBODY in the Bush administration EVER said that Saddam was involved in 9-11. Why do you repeat that falsehood?

by stargazerr

that the TR guys havent been anywhere near the discussion concerning this .... Blind and deaf on purpose, do you think?? :p

]:)

by stargazerr

India goes through a war against terrorism almost every day ... The (Indian) news doesnt even bother to report if "only a couple" of people die due to terrorist attacks in Kashmir (which is almost every day)... if the number is more, we get a small headline ...

The attack or attacks on America are blown up to this proportion because it poses as the strongest nation in the world ... what about all the other people who die all around the world every day??

Iraq is constantly on the news because "American troops" are out there ... would it be the same if it was some other country heading that operation??

The prime example of terrorism is what is happening in Kashmir every day just because we wont agree to give up Kashmir ...

Terrorism is something that the whole world has to unite and fight against .... Why is it only America the country that MUST fight and win this war?? The key word here is UNITY ... If we dont unite in this war ... we will just keep fighting amongst ourselves ...

]:)

by tonythetiger

If the United States (arguably the most powerful nation on the planet) succumbs to these thugs, what hpoe do the other nations have of standing up to them?

by m_a_r_k

Many (most?) Muslims are peaceful people who have families and jobs and hobbies just like the rest of us. Any nation that wants to stamp out the evil element is welcome to join. As I alluded to in another post, even a country that is 100% Muslim are welcome. They'd be vital allies.

by stargazerr

You will not believe this .. but most muslims in the town where I live (in India) think they ought to go and live in Pakistan ... they hang out pakistani flags, celeberate when pakistan wins over India in the cricket match .... Hate us (non muslims Indians) ...

People like that really tend to shake ur faith .. dont they??

]:)

by jdclyde

you have matches between bugs, and then celebrate it? Hope they put this on a big screen, so more than two people can watch at a time! :p

And yes, we WOULD believe the way your local muslims act. Too bad they don't just GO to pakistan, if that is what they want so bad, huh?

by Member 25348569

He states "Note that during the period from 1981 to 2001 there were 7,581 terrorist attacks worldwide" and then proceeds to list eleven specifically relating to the United States. From this base, he ramps up the rhetoric just a little too much for my liking.

Speaking as a citizen of a country with far more experience in terrorism over the last fifty years than yourselves, I have to question the way that you're going about it if you want it to stop.

We managed to stop the IRA and we had to swallow some real sh:t to do it but things are looking that we might have seen the last of the bombings by those guys. Now we have the new threat from the Islamists with more home-grown bombers and my worry is that we are now inextricably linked with the US in this "war against terrorism" and we will suffer our own version of the consequences if you get get it wrong. We, the UK, have to face the fact that you haven't listened to us so far and are unlikely to do so in the future.

It is my belief that The War on Terrorism can't be "won" by the means outlined by Gen chong, above. Should we "defeat" the current enemy of Al-Qaeda, we will, by that time, have alienated some other group and the cycle will go on. There are enough military resources and enough disgruntled people in the world to ensure a steady supply of people with a grudge against you and me and the will and the means to attack us.

The first aim of the terrorist is always to breed suspicion and hostility to minorities in our own communities. This type of hostility immediately aids the terrorists in their recruitment. In the minds of the terrorist planners - not the bombers - the London July bombings were an attack on our values as a society and particularly on our tolerance for those from different cultural and ethnic backgrounds. If we react badly towards Muslims either on a personal or governmental level, we aid the terrorist planners in their recruitment of the next set of Subway Bombers.

Defeating the terrorists also means defeating their poisonous belief that peoples of different faiths and ethnic origins cannot coexist. The article at the head of this thread in no way contributes to this goal.

If the UK faces the threat of militant Islam then it's worth remembering that 10 years ago last July the massacre at Srebrenica happened, when we and the other nations of Europe failed to protect 8,000 Muslims from being annihilated in the worst terrorist act in Europe of the past generation. Osama bin Laden is no more a true representative of Islam than General Mladic, who commanded the Serbian forces, could be held up as an example of Christianity.

Bin Laden was [b]our[/b] creation - a product of the Western security agencies. Throughout the 1980s he was armed by the CIA and funded by the Saudis to wage jihad against the Russian occupation of Afghanistan. It may surprise you to know that Al-Qaida, literally "the database", was originally the computer file of the thousands of mujahideen who were recruited and trained with help from the CIA to defeat the Russians.

With absolutely typical lack of foresight, it never appears to have occurred to anyone that, once Russia was out of the way, Bin Laden's organisation would turn its attention elsewhere - to the West.

I believe that the west's current response to terrorism compounds that original error. So long as we respond to the struggle against terrorism as if it were a war that can be won militarily, we are doomed to fail. The more we emphasise confrontation, the more it silences moderate voices in the Muslim world who want to speak up for cooperation. Success will only come from isolating the terrorists and denying them support, funds and recruits. Surely this means focusing more on our common ground with the Muslim world than on what divides us.

Just my 2p's worth

by stargazerr

Not many people would believe that Bin Laden was actually a creation of select western countries ...

He was no more a jehadi than I am ... All he cares about is terrorism ... He is just an experiment gone wrong ...

]:)

by maxwell edison

.
...then you should remind us of the FULL story, as it really was in 1980.

But first, consider this. Nations have no permanent friends and no permanent enemies. Only permanent interests (Benjamin Disraeli).

In order to see the events of 1980 in an accurate context, and to fully understand the whole story, one must consider only the interests and issues and considerations that were the driving force behind the decisions made in 1980. Judging those events by today's standards is not only grossly inaccurate, but it's downright silly.

In a nutshell, in 1980, Russia didn't invade Afghanistan to gain control of only that territory, but rather as a first step intended to culminate with the seizure of all the oil fields of the entire middle east. Had the Soviet's plan gone forward as they had hoped, after Afghanistan would have been Iran, Iraq, and even as far west as Saudi Arabia. Do we agree on this point? Or do you believe the Soviets only wanted Afghanistan as a place to build vacation homes? I'll assume we agree up to this point.

The United States and Great Britain (I had to throw you guys into the equation, of course) had two choices. Our first option was to just let the United Nations handle the Soviets and the situation, and then stand back and watch the entire middle-east fall under Soviet control. Our second option was to do something else. I believe the latter was the correct choice. And I'll assume that you're still with me on this.

And that leads to one of my favorite questions, therefore what? Therefore, we were again faced with only a couple of choices. (And this is conceding, of course, that all diplomatic efforts up to that point had failed.) We could have taken-on the Soviet Union head-on, sending our own armies into Afghanistan, or we could have done something else. Again, I believe the latter was the correct choice. We were faced with not only one bad choice, but TWO bad choices. There was no good choice here. Are you still with me, Neil? Do we agree up to this point? Great, we are still in agreement.

What is that "something else" that we did? Well, the answer is obvious. We waged yet another proxy war against the Soviets -- and we won. But we were faced with, as I said, a bad outcome. But it was not as bad as the other potential bad outcome. Are we still in agreement? I'll assume we are.

So how about if you finish the story? And finish it without the benefit of hind-sight. After all, with the benefit of hind-sight, I would have bought 100 shares of Microsoft in 1983. Unfortunately, we never have that luxury.

by Member 25348569

This is not a reply to your page as I want to do it more justice. Also, alas, I can't remember exactly what my thoughts were when I first heard of the Afghani-Russo conflict. However, I do not remember being too worried about the threat to my lifestyle and I was reasonably well informed, politically, way back then. Maybe the fact that we had North sea Oil helped to cushion the likelihood of the West having no energy supplies.

I do agree with you that it may be that we initially thought that the Russians planned the annexation of the Middle East via Afghanistan and it might even have been that the Russians thought it but it wasn't very long before both we and they realised that they weren't going to do it that way!

Considering the nature of Afghanistan at the time then I would have thought that one option with the Russians back in 1979 was to leave them to it. Military intelligence at the time did say that a lot of the Russian soldiers were conscripts, very poorly trained and ill-equipped to wage a war in such mountainous terrain. The idea that they would have been able to suppress the country sufficiently to then be able to march into Iran and, presumably, Iraq and Saudi Arabia via that route would have been very quickly abandoned.

The Afghani guerrillas were initially poorly organised but still managed to pen the Russians into Kabul within a year or two with finance and weapons from Pakistan. That way they would have tied up the Russians for decades.

Given that, though, we still had to go and organise them, supply them with [b]proper[/b] weapons and train them so that they could do better! [b]That[/b] was a political decision. [b]That[/b] was the mistake.

More later...

A different perspective on the [b]start[/b] of the story.

by tony hopkinson

Are seriously saying that charging about sticking guns in peoples faces, turns them into terrorists?
I mean it should be obvious to them that in our pursuit of nasty terrorists, it necessary to stick a gun in everyone's face and ask them
'Are you a nasty terrorist'.

Heads up people, terrorists do not wear uniforms, head coverings and beards do not count as uniforms, lack of a christening certifcate or evidence of no visits to a church do not count as a membership. Stop going for easy and politically safe targets and judging success based on their eradication, particularly when you've left a bunch of terrorised civilians in your wake of trauma and destruction.
War on the Taliban can be justified, war on Saddam can be as well, but not by 9/11, 7/7, Madrid, Eniskillen, Munich or any other terrorist atrocity. Wrong target. To hurt terrorists you make them fight their own civillian support base for the resources they need. The loss of some rich benefactor or friendly government might temporarily hurt them. Nowhere to hide out while they prepare an attack cripples them. It means they have to make themselves an easy target, all the misjustified wars in Afghanistan and Iraq have done is give them more places to hide.

If there was any merit in the current strategy as part of our camapaign against the IRA we would have attacked Washington !. We didn't, and not through lack of bottle either, what we did was show irish americans what a nasty bunch of turds the IRA were. It was something we turned out to have in common, neither of us liked f'ing terrorists.

The rise of the Bin Laden political party is an unpalatable conclusion to this conflict, but the same was (and still is) said about Adams and the late Arrafat, even Mandela who at least in certain sections of a population were 'guilty' of equally attrocious acts.

by stargazerr

If it was indeed Invasion, America has done a good job ... seeing that the people there are not happy with the american troops being in their country ..

If it was originally called "Help" ... I would say ... "Bollocks"

]:)

by Member 25348569

You would never claim that he was an effective President, would you? I also reckon that the CIA were likely out of any real control - much as they have been for a while.

The Saudi's were the ones who are probably most responsible as they matched the US dollar for dollar in funding and also encouraged the influx of foreign "jihadists" into the Mujahadeen. In this, they were supported by a very enthusiastic CIA so the US doesn't escape the blame.

Britain, of course, is historically responsible (as we usually are). We invented Afghanistan from a bunch of random states as a buffer between Russia and India and when the Afghanis finally got a bit of national identity and pride, they kicked our arses and kicked us out! [b]That[/b] is what the Russians should have picked up on.

Still, what's done is done.

As to how to deal with them now they are no longer "freedom fighters" (oh, how true is the old saying), well, we don't go and invade another Islamic country! Especially one that kicked out the Russian army and still has most of the weapons we sent them.

And then invade another one before we've cleaned the first one out properly.

And then think about invading a third...And a fourth

by barghesthowl

First, had we had the troops available, Iran and N. Korea likely would not have dared move so brazenly. They know we're tied down, and are going to take full advantage of that.

Secondly, had one of those states done exactly as they're doing now, and refused to allow inspections or back down, I WOULD in fact support use of force.

by jdclyde

you would have us in Iran and/or N. Korea instead?

Ok, we march into Iran. Now what? How far do we go? Do we just destroy the army and weapons or do we take out the government that forced it to go that far to remove the threat?

What if the UN didn't back us on this action either? Do we still act?

And what steps should/would be taken BEFORE we go in? In Iraq we had the UN weapons inspectors and many broken UN resolutions. What is the justification used to go into these two countries?

Please take these for the honest questions they are, not as an attack or trying to be argumenative.

Of the two, I think N. Korea would have acted exactly the same way regardless of if we had troops available or not. They remember the last time we were there.

by barghesthowl

While it is very satisfying to see these scenarios in simple, black-and-white terms, in reality they're very grey.

Iraq was allowing weapons inspections. The reason was simple-there wasn't anything to find. Now-should they have done that sooner? Absolutely. But when the threat of force caused them to back down, we should've let them, not fired away anyway. The sanctions were working. Corruption in oil for food might've let Saddam make some palace additions, but the regime would've collapsed within ten years.

Iran may well be undergoing a revolution soon. The best way there for now is to let that take its course-a revolution from within is much more likely to produce a stable, sustainable change then an occupation from without.

N. Korea? Quite simply put, this isn't 50 years ago. If we were to go in now, we'd win this one. And in that case, with what they're doing (making no bones about building a nuke), I think you might have seen some support for use of force from allies. Now? Well, now, they probably have them already, and just may be crazy enough to use them-and the fact that they can only reach the West Coast of the US (not to mention Tokyo, Hong Kong, and most certainly Seoul) is not much comfort. Lot thornier situation, that is.

An interesting aside-while Iran certainly is not the most trustworthy place in the world, did you know they claim stridently that they do not wish to develop a nuke, only power plants, and recently offered to let the US in on building and overseeing them? That's certainly not the behavior of someone that wants to hide something...

by maxwell edison

.
Former President Carter has been giving President Bush a lot of criticism on this issue (and in very poor taste, if you ask me). Wouldn't it be something if President Bush publicly criticized President Carter for making poor decisions in 1979 and 1980 that led to this whole mess? We're lambasted for "creating Osama bin Laden", per se, but it was President Carter's decision to do so. Moreover, it was President Carter who "lost" ties with Iran as well!

No, it'll never happen. President Bush has too much class to do that.

Have you noticed, by the way, how little President Bush really attacks and criticizes other people. He'll question policy; he'll disagree with opinions; but I can't recall a single time when he stooped so low, I mean resorted to actually attacking other people -- like those people who attack him. He definitely takes the high-road.

by Member 25348569

The money for given to the Mujahadeed fighters by the US ramped up from around $30m in 1980 to around $650m by the end of the war in 1989. As agreed, the Saudis matched it dollar for dollar.

Hmmm. I'm not too well up on Presidents but I don't believe that it was Jimmy who was Head of state for 80% of that time.

by maxwell edison

.
Bush (43): January 2001 thru January 2008

Clinton: January 1993 thru January 2001

Bush (41): January 1989 thru January 1993

Reagan: January 1981 thru January 1989

Carter: January 1977 thru January 1981

Ford: (Late) 1974 thru January 1977

Nixon: January 1969 thru (Late) 1974

Johnson: November 1963 thru January 1969

Kennedy: January 1961 thru November 1963

Eisenhower: January 1953 thru January 1961

Truman: (Early) 1945 thru Jaunary 1953

Roosevelt: January 1933 thru (Early) 1945

Okay, that's far enough.

Let's blame Roosevelt. I like to blame Roosevelt for everything. No, come to think of it, I'd rather blame Johnson. He's probably my least favorite of all -- the stupid "war on poverty", the Vietnam debacle, and all.

Actually, I can't "blame" Bush-43 at all. Here he was, some ignorant country bumpkin from Texas who rode his daddy's coat-tails into the White House (if you listen to his detractors, that is), and then, 8 months later, POW -- the biggest kick in the pants we've ever had. And I actually give credit to Bush-43, because he's the ONLY one on the list who actually did something about it.

You gotta' love ignorant country bumpkins.

by tony hopkinson

Strangely as I'm not a big Bush fan he was doing quite well with me until one sentence. He basically said those who were against the war in Iraq were appeasers of terrorism. Lost everything he'd gained with that.
No ones arguing about the what, it's the how. You don't beat terrorists by giving them what they want and you don't do it by bombing the house next to the one they were staying in full of people who foolish dressed in the same style and went to the same mosque.

by montgomery gator

Like Max said, maybe you double-posted because you have your head up your arse!! :-)

Seriously, how are you dealing with the NYC transit strike, if your location information is accurate?

Also, Max, like myself, are some of the resident supporters of the War on Terror, as you might have judged by his response. Remember, your own country's troops are fighting alongside our troops in Iraq and Afghanistan.

by montgomery gator

It's fascinating that this should come out of Europe. Matthias Dapfner, Chief Executive of the huge German publisher Axel Springer AG, has written a blistering attack in DIE WELT, (The World) Germany's largest daily paper, against the timid reaction of Europe in the face of the Islamic threat. This is a must read by all Americans. History will certify its correctness.
EUROPE - THY NAME IS COWARDICE (Commentary by Mathias Dapfner CEO, Axel Springer, AG)

A few days ago Henry Broder wrote in Welt am Sonntag, "Europe - your family name is appeasement." It's a phrase you can't get out of your head because it's so terribly true.

Appeasement cost millions of Jews and non-Jews their lives as England and France, allies at the time, negotiated and hesitated too long before they noticed that Hitler had to be fought, not bound to toothless agreements.

Appeasement legitimized and stabilized Communism in the Soviet Union, then East Germany, then all the rest of Eastern Europe where for decades, inhuman suppressive, murderous governments were glorified as the ideologically correct alternative to all other possibilities.

Appeasement crippled Europe when genocide ran rampant in Kosovo, and even though we had absolute proof of ongoing mass-murder, we Europeans debated and debated and debated, and were still debating when finally the Americans had to come from halfway around the world, into Europe yet again, and do our work for us. Rather than protecting democracy in the Middle East, European appeasement, camouflaged behind the fuzzy word "equidistance," now countenances suicide bombings in Israel by fundamentalist Palestinians.

Appeasement generates a mentality that allows Europe to ignore nearly 500,000 victims of Saddam's torture and murder machinery and, motivated by the self-righteousness of the peace-movement, has the gall to issue bad grades to

George Bush... Even as it is uncovered that the loudest critics of the American action in Iraq made illicit billions, no, TENS of billions, in the corrupt U.N. Oil-for-Food program.

And now we are faced with a particularly grotesque form of appeasement. How is Germany reacting to the escalating violence by Islamic fundamentalists in Holland and elsewhere? By suggesting that we really should have a "Muslim Holiday" in Germany?

I wish I were joking, but I am not. A substantial fraction of our (German) Government, and if the polls are to be believed, the German people, actually believe that creating an Official State "Muslim Holiday" will somehow spare us from the wrath of the fanatical Islamists. One cannot help but recall Britain's Neville Chamberlain waving the laughable treaty signed by Adolph Hitler, and declaring European "Peace in our time".

What else has to happen before the European public and its political leadership get it? There is a sort of crusade underway, an especially perfidious crusade consisting of systematic attacks by fanatic Muslims, focused on civilians, directed against our free, open Western societies, and intent upon Western Civilization's utter destruction.

It is a conflict that will most likely last longer than any of the great military conflicts of the last century - a conflict conducted by an enemy that cannot be tamed by "tolerance" and "accommodation" but is actually spurred on by such gestures, which have proven to be, and will always be, taken by the Islamists for signs of weakness.

Only two recent American Presidents had the courage needed for anti-appeasement: Reagan and Bush.

His American critics may quibble over the details, but we Europeans know the truth. We saw it first hand: Ronald Reagan ended the Cold War, freeing half of the German people from nearly 50 years of terror and virtual slavery. And

Bush, supported only by the Social Democrat Blair, acting on moral conviction, recognized the danger in the Islamic War against democracy. His place in history will have to be evaluated after a number of years have passed.

In the meantime, Europe sits back with charismatic self-confidence in the multicultural corner, instead of defending liberal society's values and being an attractive center of power on the same playing field as the true great powers, America and China. On the contrary - we Europeans present ourselves, in contrast to those "arrogant Americans", as the World Champions of "tolerance", which even (Germany's Interior Minister) Otto Schily justifiably criticizes.

Why? Because we're so moral? I fear it's more because we're so materialistic, so devoid of a moral compass. For his policies, Bush risks the fall of the dollar, huge amounts of additional national debt, and a massive and persistent burden on the American economy because unlike almost all of Europe, Bush realizes what is at stake - literally everything.

While we criticize the "capitalistic robber barons" of America because they seem too sure of their priorities, we timidly defend our Social Welfare systems. Stay out of it! It could get expensive! We'd rather discuss reducing our 35-hour workweek or our dental coverage, or our 4 weeks of paid vacation... Or listen to TV pastors preach about the need to "reach out to terrorists. To understand and forgive".

These days, Europe reminds me of an old woman who, with shaking hands, frantically hides her last pieces of jewelry when she notices a robber breaking into a neighbor's house.

Appeasement?

Europe, thy name is Cowardice.

NOTE: I checked on Snopes.com to verify that this is real, modified only very slightly from the original German when translated.

http://www.snopes.com/politics/soapbox/dapfner.asp

by montgomery gator

http://www.snopes.com/rumors/soapbox/chong.asp

I checked Snopes.com on this one, and although I do agree with just about everything in this article, it turns out it was not written by Gen. Chong. He was in the chain of multiple forwardings, and somehow his name got attributed to it. It has not been determined who was the original author. The story as to how it got attributed to Gen. Chong is interesting, though, showing how Urban Legends develop.

The unknown authorship does not diminish the truth of the essay, though, in my opinion.

by maxwell edison

.
I ALWAYS check Snopes for these types of email letters. But I didn't on this one.

However, I have seen these comments before in a "true" context, just like you, and I agree with most of them.

But I will admit, I was duped. I thought it was real.

Gee, thanks a lot, Tom.

by jardinier

As you have said:

"The unknown authorship does not diminish the truth of the essay, though, in my opinion."

And as I said in my initial post:

"I think that the opinions and statements presented therein are self evident."

So I would have posted it if the tooth fairy was the author.

It has served its purpose in kicking off a very good discussion with serious input from a great variety of perspectives.

by maxwell edison

.
Unknown authorship does not diminish the truth of the essay. To prove that point, all one has to do is try to refute anything said in the essay. And nothing can be seriously refuted.

by Member 25348569

Again, not sufficient time to really think this through but I will post an example or two of how the logic in the title piece is a little tortuous. This guy is actually doing some of the terrorists work for them by whipping up anti-Muslim feelings.

First of all, up until the start of the Iraq War there were eleven quoted attacks on the US of which two were on US soil - three if you count 911 as two incidents, which the author does. This is out of a world total of 7,500. OK, so 911 was a biggie but there a shed-loads of reasons why that one succeeded beyond the wildest dreams and nightmares. There hasn't been one since 2001 and we're nearly into 2006. Yet the author suggests that this is all aimed at [b]you[/b].

"President Bush selects Norman Mineta as Secretary of Transportation. Although all of the terrorist attacks were committed by Muslim men between 17 and 40 years of age, Secretary Mineta refuses to allow profiling." But there haven't been any attacks since 911 so the only thing that profiling would have achieved is the sort of alienation that helped get us the London Bombers.

The piece is not all wrong but some bits of it are dangerously naive and counter-productive to the goal that we all want - freedom from fear.

by maxwell edison

.
I'm not "anti-Muslim" at all. To the contrary, I'm more of a "live and let live" kinda' guy. However, there are those radical "live and let die" Muslims -- the terrorists; and then there are the others who are, and have been, for the most part, standing by, just letting it all happen. And they've been letting it happen for decades

Look at the "non-violent" Muslims, and I'm talking about the ones in the middle-east, who have not only failed to take measures to stop their violent brothers, but they stand by in silence letting it happen. In my mind, that's not acceptable. In my mind, that's approval by failing to do anything significant to stop it.

An analogy might be this. What if Pat Robertson and his ilk (a very small percentage of Christians) literally declared war on all non-Christians, in general, and all Muslims in particular? What if their mission in life was to kill as many Muslims as possible? What if they exported their violence, and went into Syria, Saudi Arabia, Jordan, Iran, Iraq, and so on, and perpetrated the kinds of attacks on them like we've seen against westerners? What if our governments and the majority of our populations, in the US and UK, didn't lift a little finger to not only stop it, but also failed to even denounce it?

Sorry, their silence and inaction for all these decades speaks volumes. Until the violent Muslims are pursued and captured -- en masse -- by the non-violent Muslims, this is one westerner who just won't defend them. Their silence, in my mind, speaks to their approval.

by jardinier

Actually Neil, the author goes to some length to distinguish between peaceful Muslims and terrorists. He gives a reason why peaceful Muslims don't speak out and dissociate themselves from the terrorists -- because this would put their own lives in jeopardy.

Many times in these TR forums the peaceful Muslims have been criticised for not speaking out. This guy gives a feasible reason as to why they might not.

I frequently say to people that the greatest challenge facing the human race today is for Muslims and Christians to learn to co-exist peacefully.

The terrorists don't help, but neither do the (mostly American) fundamentalist evangelical Christians who assert that:

1. The terrorist extremists represent the true religion of Islam.

2. It is the duty of every Muslim to kill as many Christians as possible.

3. There is already a jihad under way which will continue until Armageddon and the return of Christ.

Because I am in regular contact with these kinds of people through Christian websites (no, I am not a Christian -- I just enjoy the debate) I know the intensity of their hatred towards ALL Muslims.

This attitude is surely fuelling the fire.

And then we must consider George Bush -- who identifies with this loathsome form of Christianity. Does he also believe that the terrorists represent the real Islamic faith?

by Member 25348569

But never completely! :p

The main thrust of the article was the "Muslim Menace" and they author goes a bit over the top. And as for "speaking out", why should Muslims speak out? The majority of Muslims just want to get on with their lives and raise their kids. Did right-wing Christians apologise for the KKK? Or apologise for the anti-abortionists who bomb doctors homes? Maybe some did but did it make any difference.

You know my thoughts about things done in the name of religion so you know I'm not an apologist for Muslims! We have to talk. If they blow up another building or tube train then we still have to keep talking. Eventutally, unless we overreact, they will run out of suicide bombers.

The article lists eleven terrorist attacks in twenty or more years made on American targets and then describes it as if the whole planet has risen up against the USA. Those attacks were carried out by a handful of nutters. What does the US do? It invades somewhere! Not one, but [b]two[/b] f*cking countries in retaliation!! And our idiot leaders go along with them! Gah!

I suppose that the final step is to nuke Mecca to a radioactive glassy plain. That will teach the Islamic hordes a lesson!

The strange thing is that no-one seems to realise that there are better ways. Libya was put under UN sanctions after Lockerbie and has been quiet since then to the extent that she has agreed a ?2 billion payment to the victims and normal relations are being resumed. It might have taken ten years but it worked!

Saddam Hussein was being brought into line by UN sanctions. Yes, I know there was corruption and all of the other things associated with too much untracable money but are the economic systems of the US, UK and OZ whiter than white? Enron!

The writer's use of Spain as some sort of example is very flawed logic. Had the invasion of Iraq not happened, Spain would not have been involved and the Madrid train bombing would probably not have occurred.

The same reasoning applies to the London Tube Bombings, more so because one of the bombers recorded his thoughts and gave Iraq as the reason for his actions.

I'll stop now. Steam is coming off my keyboard...

by jdclyde

[i]"Does he also believe that the terrorists represent the real Islamic faith?"[/i]

President Bush has repeatedly over the years separated between the extremists and the people that just want to live their lives in peace, and even spoke out against violence against muslims Americans in the US. One of the largest muslim populations in the US is here in Michigan. There are a lot of racial tensions there, but they are mostly between black americans and muslim americans. Been quite a bit of violence over the last few years between the two. I haven't HEARD of anything else happening down there. (Dearborn)

I go there on business and for training and have NEVER had an issue.

by m_a_r_k

[i]"a reason why peaceful Muslims don't speak out and dissociate themselves from the terrorists -- because this would put their own lives in jeopardy"[/i]

One billion peaceful Muslims are being held hostage by a few hundred terrorist-minded Muslims? If that's the case, I have no respect for any of them. Like Pres. Bush said in the days after 9/1l, "you're either for us or you're against us". There can be no in-between where human lives are at stake.

Editor's note: And why does the second one in 9/11 in the previous paragraph keep getting fouled up? In this paragraph it comes out right. ?:|

by stargazerr

Its hatred against the muslim community which turn out to be terrorists or extremists .... I have grown up with a muslim community that silently agrees with all that Bin Laden is doing ...

They, themselves, would never hurt a fly though ...

]:)

by maxwell edison

.
You asked, "Does he (President Bush) also believe that the terrorists represent the real Islamic faith?"

Julian, why don't you answer that question yourself? Why don't you read, verbatim, what President Bush has said regarding that very question, and then draw your own conclusion? I could find his words that would satisfy me enough to know the answer, and so could you.

You mentioned things that radical Christians say that fuels the fire. This is not unlike the things you (and others) say that only fuels the fire of contempt and misrepresentation towards President Bush. Why is it wrong for radical Christians to do it in one context, but okay for you to do it in another?

Go ahead, Julian. You have the time, and you have the ability. Answer that question for yourself. And then, please, put it to rest.

by jardinier

Then why did Tony Blair risk his political career by joining the COW if it was not for the oil?

He had already decided to join the invasion well before it was launched, and against the advice of his Attorney General who said the invasion would be an illegal war.

The British electorate subsequently punished Blair for sending troops to Iraq, by giving him the smallest majority of a ruling party in the history of British democracy.

The poor Australians alas -- fooled by a frequently repeated lie by John Howard on a domestic matter -- rewarded him for getting us involved in the war. A Labor government would not have sent Australians to Iraq and no doubt this would not have impacted adversely on our alliance with the USA because the USA needs Australia for its geographical location.

For those who may not already know, the live telecast of the first moon landing was only possibly because of the radio telescope at Parkes, NSW.

And nobody can convince me that Australia's involvement in Iraq has not greatly increased our priority as a target for terrorist attacks.

by maxwell edison

.
Why do people keep saying that?

1. Saddam Hussein WAS in violation of numerous United Nations resolutions. This, in essence and in fact, nullified the cease-fire after Saddam's invasion of Kuwait.

2. From the U.S perspective, our Congress passed resolutions authorizing the president to proceed. This was, in essence and in fact, a declaration of war.

All the legal bases were covered.

by tonythetiger

Iraq is the best place geographically. If you think it is intended that the US leave Iraq, ever, you are mistaken. Iraq will host a friendly permanent Allied military presence. Like Germany. Like Japan.

by maxwell edison

.
We'll probably see a decline in numbers to the 50,000 range within the next few years. And I think It'll stay there for a long time.

Iran and Syria are next. And then Saudi Arabia. There are enough people in Iran, for example, at least judging from what I've read, that could rise-up and overthrow the radical Iranian government. And with such a huge source of support on their western border, they just might be successful.

This is gonna' be the domino theory put into action. I predict that the middle-east of 2055 will not even come close to resembling what it is in 2005. And that's the long-term goal President Bush has established. It's too bad that John Kerry and his ilk are content with the status quo. They're only making it more difficult to accomplish.

by sleepin'dawg

If they could somehow describe the problem; what seemed to set it off; is it a hardware problem or a software problem and what steps are being taken to fix the problem. We're all tech people here and maybe there is something to be learned here that might help someone else with a similar problem. Or possibly someone may have a cogent suggestion about something that may have been overlooked. It would help aleviate the annoyance factor. BTW do not hit back when you get page not found and then hit submit for a second time. that will give you the double post. Hit refresh and you'll find your post where it is supposed to be without the annoying double post. Anyway it's an idea.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jdclyde

Sure, I will poke fun at them, but that is because I don't believe in discrimination so I treat everyone badly. :p

The have made a lot of changes to the site. Changes break things. People that never work to improve something just because they are afraid of breaking something get no respect from me. These guys are working on improving all the time and seek the users input regularly.

Not to mention, I know I sure get my moneys worth!

(food for thought)

Which brings up a point. Maybe when a developer brings out a new feature, they should have that developer be the one to introduce it? Then they can get the direct feedback on the likes and dislikes, and then take it back to how [b]I[/b] want it!

by montgomery gator

The Letter to the Hebrews is of unknown authorship, and that does not diminish the truth in it at all.

My personal theory is that Silas (Silvanus) wrote it, but that is just a guess. Luke, Paul, and Apollos have also been suggested as authors, but most scholars rule out Paul because its writing style does not match up with his other writing. I suggest Silas, since he is known as a good writer, having served as editor for both Peter and Paul, was in the circle that included Timothy (mentioned in the last chapter), and the Letter to the Hebrews was written by someone who was a good writer familiar with greek, but familiar with Jewish customs and scripture, and that describes Silas.

by stargazerr

The first thing we want, is to send those guys to pakistan ... Lemme tell you a little story ...

I once went to one of my colleugues houses in this mini pakistan area (in my town) ... Had to fetch a book I had lent him .. He had a padlock on his house when we got to it. I figured there was no one inside .. so him and me went to his office and sat down ..

After a while the guy asks me ... would you like to meet my wife?? .. I said OK ... the whole house was dark with the exception of this one room at the very end where his wife was ..

I sat down and started chatting to the wife when 11-12 other girls (around the age of 15-16) turn up .. Turns out, they were nieces of my colleugue ... After talking to them for a while, I learnt that they dont go to school, dont have a TV in the house, are not allowed to go out of the house and seem to think that they exist to get married and have kids ...

They had known I was coming and since I was the only contact they had had with the outside world in ages ... they were pretty interested in me and thanked me profusely for coming to see them ...

When I was ready to go, the colleuegue padlocked the house again ....

This incident scared the life out of me and I kept thinking about the poor girls and how many people are living an existence like that ...

]:)

by m_a_r_k

?:| How can you sit on the fence when some nutcase with a bomb strapped to his torso walks into the same restaurant in which you are having a pleasant dinner with your family?

by Member 25348569

With such a complex issue as international terrorism, I have to be allowed to take a difefrent stance on some aspects of the issue. I [b]hate[/b] the fact that your country and mine invaded Iraq. It doesn't mean that I'm in any way against the final goal which, I presume, is that we all live and let live. I just don't think that dropping cluster bombs is the way to do it. It doesn't mean that I don't support the troops now that we're there. I do!

I have a different perspective. My country didn't suffer the appalling strike of 911 but we've had our terrorists and more that you! I've lived in London for many years. A target for the IRA and now for Islamists. The office that I worked in was wiped clean by an IRA bomb. The shop where I bought my morning paper was trashed and - ironically - two Muslims were killed. One of them used to sell me that morning paper. It's likely, by the way, that some of your more misguided countrymen funded that bomb. It's also reported, but not admitted, that the CIA tacitly approved and, as I hear very little good of the CIA, I can believe it. A good friend was sitting next to someone who was killed by an anti-gay nail bomb in the Admiral Duncan Pub.

Terrorism is not just a Muslim thing. Terrorists do what they do to get heard. To get in the papers. To get their message over. They come in all sorts as well, those we can negotiate with - the IRA, PLO - and those we can't such as Al-Qaeda.

The way to attack the latter sort is to kill them - simply that. Also, cut off any and all of their funding, by control over bank accounts and by controls over misplaced charitable giving that goes to terrorists.

As I said above, the IRA?s major source of revenue was well-intentioned Americans giving to seemingly legitimate organizations - NORAID, for example. With that money they bombed my city - and killed many, many more innocent people than Muslim terrorists in my country.

The US needs to mobilise intelligence, political and financial skills - not military - and stop Saudi citizens from sending monies intended for, say, religious education that are, instead, turned toward the support and recruitment of young would-be terrorists. Distinguishing between legitimate charities and supporters of terror is not easy, but the means of doing so must be found and the money pursued.

Money is at the heart of everything. Recruitment, training, and even suicide bombers. One of the promises made to suicide bombers in poor countries is that surviving families will benefit. In the Palestinian Authority the relations of suicide bombers are well provided for.

America is good with money! Use that skill.

by montgomery gator

Those Americans that supported NORAID were wrong. They were mainly the supporters in Boston of that drunken Jabba the Hutt lookalike Ted Kennedy (who is also suspected of supporting NORAID and the IRA terrorists). Most American either did not know about NORAID, or they knew it was a terrorist supporting organization, unless they were blinded by ethnic pride.

Also, the IRA and Al-Qaeda are different in one respect. The IRA could be negotiated with and reasoned with. Al-Qaeda has not shown that it is capable of good faith negotiation, their goal is the domination of the world by Islamofascism.