Terrorism -- the war that America MUST win
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jaqui
the constitution and charter of rights butchered isn't a war against the people of the us by the us government?
I never said that there are not other bad governments, but the us has taken second place, as they are activly working on making the us worse than it was, in India the situation is not new, it has been like this for a long time.
a situation normal-all screwed up government is better than one that has started making it worse for their citizens. [ you know what to expect in thes.n.a.f.u country, you don't in the changing country ]
by tonythetiger
by sleepin'dawg
[b]despite anything the UN says.[/b] Nowadays the UN has become a platform for third world propaganda and that means mostly Islamic nations of the fundamentalist variety.
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
.
It doesn't "necessarily" mean one thing or the other. But my opinion is that there is a huge faction of silent supporters. Of course, I can't prove it. But to me, the silence is deafening.
Is there even one person who is a silent supporter? Of course, there probably is. How about one hundred? Again, one would be safe assuming as much. How about one thousand? How about one million? Is it as many as one hundred million? How about one billion? Probably not, but I'd bet it's somewhere between one and one billion. And whatever the number, it's too damn many.
by sleepin'dawg
1. The terrorist extremists represent the true religion of Islam.
A: In a sense they do because as long as the so called peaceful Muslims remain silent they are ipso facto condoning terrorism and as such have to be looked at in that light.
2. It is the duty of every Muslim to kill as many Christians as possible.
A: True in the broad sense that we are supposed to take an eye for an eye; a tooth for a tooth. The so called [b]peaceful Muslims[/b] deny this is true but our eye for an eye business is in our old testament and many Fundamentalist Christians still believe that. What it says in the Queran is that it is the the duty of every Muslim to bring truth and enlightenment to the infidels and if necessary by way of the sword. Christianity is not specifically targeted.
3. There is already a jihad under way which will continue until Armageddon and the return of Christ.
A: Hello!!! Ever hear of that wonderful group called Islamic Jihad. They're on and off the Islamic hit parade. Plus every jumped up Iman or Ayatollah loves to proclaim Jihad. When people take to labeling my society as the "Great Satan" and pledge to destroy that society; I hope you will pardon me all to hell if out of personal experience, I am inclined to believe them. Now one thing I do know; Arabs and by extension fudamentalist Muslims are not very big on organizational skiils. I joke about it and say if they were in the middle of a brewery they couldn't organize a decent drunk.
Like you I am not a Christian and most definitely not one of the evangelical fundamentalist variety. Do I have prejudices against Arabs and Muslims??? Yes I most certainly do but I am not a hypocrite about it. I am totally honest and above board about it and will say it right out to any Muslim's or Arab's face, "I do not trust you and suspect you, perhaps in error, of being a murdering son of a b1tch." You have to understand I lived among those people for slightly in excess of a year and a half. When I first got there I had no prejudices whatsoever. What I didn't know about Arabs and Islam would have filled a library but I was determined to do the job without any bias. After a year and a half I still tried to be unbiased but it was extremely difficult to be so because I had learned very painfully on a personal level that your Arab friend of today is just as likely to shoot you in the back given half a chance, tomorrow. He'll have no particular reason for that but that he has a gun, you're there and he feels this overwhelming urge to shoot something or somebody. Sorry it had to be you. Believe it or not that was the gist of a very uncomfortably real conversation that I had while bleeding like a stuck pig. Fortunately some one else blew him away and put a bandaid on me. I still remember that conversation for its surreal quality. Just in case you have any doubts about my feelings, biases or prejudices let me reiterate. [b]The only good fundamentalist Arab Muslim is a dead one!!![/b] Clear enough and honest enough for you???
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
by sleepin'dawg
:(
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
On NORAID and the IRA. And on what Al-Qaeda is, for that matter.
What we do with Al-Qaeda is we hunt them down and kill them. We pay people to hunt them down and kill them. We bribe governments, organisations, [b]anyone[/b] to hunt them down and kill them. But we keep it quiet.
We starve them of funds by emptying every bank account that even sniffs of terrorist funding - we can apologise later if we're wrong.
What we don't do is invade Islamic countries and give them huge numbers of even more disgruntled supporters, suicide bomb fodder and the like.
I believe that the Iraq war's direct consequences were the Madrid and the London bombings. We have the death testimony of one of the bombers.
by jardinier
I would never be able to find it again now but I read the FULL document prepared by the UK Attorney General advising Tony Blair of all the legal ramifications of invading Iraq.
It was a complex legal document but the advice was quite clear and unequivocal.
You like finding information on the net so I daresay you could find it for yourself, just as you could readily find remarks by GWB about his feelings toward Muslims, instead of copping out and telling me to find the information yourself.
It is quite out of character for you to NOT back up references to GWB with specific quotes.
by barghesthowl
Why is that an interesting fact? Well, let's look at Christianity at about the age of 1400 years or thereabouts.
What were the Christians doing then?
-They were fighting wars of conquest against "infidels", see "Crusades".
-They were brutally suppressing dissent internally (nice things did not happen to heretics in 1400 or so, it generally involved a stake and a torch or some similar form of...erm...encouragement of repentance.)
-They had no issues with swordpoint conversions. (Yes, this is terrorism.)
Most Western religions have had their violent phase(s). Seems to happen when you get the idea that yours is the "one true way". Islam is most certainly not the only one.
.
.....not me.
Nonetheless, I'll do your work, and I'll find a reference that will conclude that your assertion is incorrect.
by jardinier
What appears not to be common knowledge is that around the 11 th - 12 th centuries, when the Christian church was busy burning books -- probably setting back the development of science by several centuries -- Muslim scholars were travelling all around the world ACQUIRING knowledge, including keeping alive the knowledge of the early Greek philosophers and scientists.
Did you know that our numerical system -- 1 ? 9 and zero -- was invented by Hindus and brought to the West by these Muslims scholars?
When Islam started to regress, this knowledge was kept alive primarily by European Jews.
We owe much of our culture and civilization to the Muslims.
Next point. European colonialism. Marco Polo had travelled to China and discovered gunpowder which the Chinese used for fireworks. Western Europeans quickly learnt to use gunpowder as a weapon -- a weapon which allowed them to invade, ravish and destroy much of the culture of many parts of the world, notably South America where they managed to wipe out altogether the Mayan civilization.
And these Christian colonizers -- under the banner of: "For God, gold and glory" -- were as bloody minded and ruthless as the Muslims have ever been.
But to keep a balance in this post, Muslims invaded India but did NOT succeed in destroying Hindu culture which has continued unchanged, unlike the culture of many lands invaded by Christians colonizers which was destroyed or corrupted beyond repair.
Christianity has become the predominant religion in the world (33 per cent as against 22 per cent Muslim) to a considerable extent by VIOLENCE.
.
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/chronicle/a/2002/12/01/MN101166.DTL
http://www.slate.com/?id=117525
http://www.religionnewsblog.com/1198-.html
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/551169/posts
Shall I continue? I could post a hundred links, from both liberal and conservative sources.
How about from the White House itself?
http://www.whitehouse.gov/infocus/ramadan/islam.html
http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2001/09/20010917-11.html
Now can you recant that comment of yours, and never say it again?
.
Go ahead, describe your plan.
by jardinier
Max, you have not located the statement by the UK Attorney General to Tony Blair, and so I will stand by my clear recollection of the content and summation.
Nor did I say that GWB considered that the terrorists represent the true Islamic faith. I merely posed the question:
[b]And then we must consider George Bush -- who identifies with this loathsome form of Christianity. Does he also believe that the terrorists represent the real Islamic faith?[/b]
However in retrospect I should not have left that question unanswered.
Concurrently with this dscussion I have been participating in theological discussions at an American Christian website.
Almost all these people are rabid fundamentalists, whose attitude towards Muslims I have stated elsewhere.
I am glad you have reassured me that President Bush does NOT share the views of these people.
wipe the contempt off my screen so I can read my rply (See !)
It's the same one that gave us Yassa Arrafat and Jerry Adams the statemen. Good intelligence, targetted assault and a really clear public assessment of exactly who is the bad guy. That's their public not yours.
The current strategy seems to me to alienate the very people who could wipe out the terrorists in a short space of time. That's the people on the ground, the ones hiding them, failing to report their activities, offering material support for their activities, that's your general ordinary joe who doesn't like having a gun stuck in his face and even less so by a foreign infidel.
There isn't a single plan, a magic bullet easy strategy. The details of other successful outcomes probably won't apply, but the goal is not to kill the terrorists, that simply can't be done, it's to take away the environment in which they thrive.
.
Well, I agree. And, in my opinion, that's exactly what's being done.
By the way, that "contempt" comment flew right over my head. You, or me, or what?
including this sort of bonehead. He insults himself and his own people, no one individual can claim to have won any war, started one sort of, finished one no. Reagan himself would never have made such a claim. Neither he nor Gorbachev nor any other leader could or even would have had any realistic impact without a massive amount of support from the people they lead.
What a craphead.
The actuality of democracy should in time produce moderate behavior in the voters, but terrorists can and do exist in democracies, probably more so if anything since they have a very obnoxious habit of using our own freedom's against us. The current strategy is making more enemies not less, making more sympathisers not less, so how can it succeed ?
If democracy truly gains a foothold and majority backing in Irag and Afghanistan , the terrorists will target them, they will still have the useful support of a minority and they will not go away. I'd like nothing better for you to be right, but in our wars against terrorists, I never gained any feeling that general punitive actions against the population in which terrorists hide had any good effect whatsoever apart from short term political ones. It was the irish people who made the IRA come to the table not the english, waht we mainly did was endure, but we are good at that. Placing a democracy in Iraq might eventually cut out a lot of Iraqi terrorism it won't affect anyone elses though, unless you are planning on imposing democratic freedom through conflict across the entire planet.
by jdclyde
an oil rich country is looking to build a nuke plant?
As for inspectors in Iraq. Don't embarrass yourself by saying they never had weapons? They used chemicals on their own people once and would have done it again.
sorry if I didn't create enough shades of gray in my direct questions. The just sounded like fair questions based on your previous statement.
by jdclyde
by levannah44
Hello Julian. Just thought I'd better touch base with the TR crew again after my unintentional absense, and this very thought-provoking article seems to be as good a place as any to do it.
This is very scary. Am I imagining it, or is the above article another way of talking about this 'clash of civilisations' thing? Mainstream Muslims, as I see it, already appear to have adapted many of their laws and customs to suit a democratic and more modern system than their Islamist counterparts (a word I notice isn't used in the article to differentiate between terrorist Islam and ordinary Islam), and, as far as I can see are quite content with that.
My marriage-niece is Lebanese, although I should immediately add, not Muslim, but Christian, a Maronite, one of the oldest sects of Christianity still around. But she is Arab and Lebanese, and, along with the rest of her large family, that's what matters!
Recently in this country, we've had some pretty nasty rioting among what appear to be white supremist groups of youths and the Lebanese community. It began in Sydney, but has spread to other states, which is why I mention my marriage-niece, who is scared out of her wits, I can tell you.
Things have quietened down a little at the moment, but no doubt could re-erupt again at any time, especially with the Commonwealth Games here next year in March. I sometimes wonder if these global sporting fixtures will become a thing of the past if terrorism triumphs, or even if it just gets too much for the authorities to handle besides anything else.
Unfortunately, I can see where the writer of the above article is coming from, and it isn't very pleasant. Islam has done some wonderful things in the past; the golden age of Spain under Islam, before it was conquered by the Christians, was one such time.
Then, Islam, Judaism and Christianity all lived side by side in common harmony and co-operation. Culture in general, science and the arts all prospered, and who could wonder why? Such an atmosphere was conducive to learning!
It'd be nice to think such a time could be re-born again on a global scale, but the way matters are pointing now in this 'non' war, I don't hold out much hope for that.
And even if religion wasn't one of the core issues (yes, I know; we've been through it all before in other threads, and I'm not going down that road this time!) in this battle, and it was purely politics and culture at loggerheads, the democracy sponsored by the west is not the same kind of democracy the Islamic countries of the world want.
The more 'westernised' we all become - maybe I'd better just say 'modernised' instead - the more remote religion becomes in our lives (or should, that is!) Church and state (politics) never sat well together, and they certainly don't these days.
Nevertheless, if that's the kind of democracy Islamic countries want, then let them have it. If it works for them, so be it. If we truly want a planet where all cultures/religions can live in harmony and co-operation, I believe we've got to let them have what THEY want, not what we think they ought to have, just because it (sort of) works for us!
I doubt at the end of this 'war' any one country will come out on top. Perhaps there'll be no 'west' or 'east' anymore, and we'll be one truly global community.
Unless, of course, China has anything to do with what happens. In my part of the world, China is a country to watch very carefully, definitely a 'sleeping dragon' that's waking up.
What would a world be like if China dominated it, as could well be the case in the very near future? China is still a country which doesn't tolerate religion very gladly; indeed, it often persecutes those who practice even some quite ancient religions. They certainly persecute those practitioners of Falon Gong, a mild, meditative form of religion from the way I see it, so one can only imagine what would happen if they were able to get stuck into certain forms of Christianity, even Judaism and Islam!
If the above article is supposed to be a wake-up call towards our awareness of the 'real' purpose of the war on terrorism, and whether we (the west) stand to lose or not, how about another wake-up call to the domination of China in our world system and what could happen under them?
Are we in for a rude awakening either way?
Gret
by jardinier
you offer a fresh viewpoint, especially with your detailed knowledge of all the religions that were born in the Middle East.
You may care to read a post of mine earlier in the discussion: "More about Islam and Christianity."
I am sure will be able to elaborate on my post and correct any historical errors.
You may also like to refer to the burning of the Great Library of Alexandria, which I have hinted at but got my time scale wrong.
I am sure you will remember your article:
"THE EIGHTH WONDER OF THE ANCIENT WORLD" which is posted on my website.
by levannah44
I've already read your post about Islam and Christianity, Julian, and found nothing wrong with it. What you say is basically how it was anyway, so I don't need to elaborate. Well done!
As for the Great Library, there were other (minor) attempts to burn the place down for various reasons, the most famous one, however, being that which followed the assassination of Hypatia, the librarian at the time.
She was a neo-Platonist, a modernist for her times, and it was the Christians who rose up to kill her, lead by the Bishop of Alexandria at the time. The Christians saw neo-Platonism as opposed to the teaching of Christianity, as laid down in the Bible, and the developing dogma, which was why they killed her.
However, many of the books were rescued and fell into Arab/Muslim hands at a later date. It was solely on account of the Muslims (Arabs) that so much was saved or preserved, and later translated from the Greek to Arabic, and later, to Latin as well, a task where many Jews helped their Muslim neighbours.
Julian, you know my natural optimism, even idealism, and of course it would be wonderful if such a society as existed in Muslim Spain could exist again throughout the world, but I have grave doubts of it ever seeing the light of day.
I watched a programme on SBS tonight called the 'Battle for Islam', showing Islam in a selected number of Muslim countries (Pakistan, Indonesia, Malaysia and Turkey, to name some of them) trying to reinterpret Shar'ia law in a more modernist way to reflect our times.
This is exactly what I was talking about in my last post; there ARE those who seek to reinterpret (not change) these laws so that they do, indeed, reflect the 21st century. We just don't hear enough about them.
Did you know exactly the same thing exists in Judaism? There are those Jews - Lubaviches and the like - who will always only see the law through narrow blinkers, and not all the persuasion in the world will ever change their minds about its divinity and unchangeableness.
They throw up their hands in horror at the thought of female rabbis, for instance, or women being allowed to read from the scrolls (just a couple of instances picked at random), but, when the ancient law is reinterpreted with an awareness of today's
values, there's really no confusion.
Indeed, on some occasions, these really orthodox people won't even recognise us as Jews; we are 'deliberately' be-smirching the divine word (etc. etc.) and are no more than 'token' Jews at best, if that.
Now look at Muslims. It's practically the same scenario - an ancient law being reinterpreted more moderately and modernly by moderate imams while the fundamentalist sections, mainly Islamists, point the finger and say it isn't even Islam.
The only real difference is the guns, or the kidnappings, etc. I've yet to hear of a really religious Jew taking up a weapon and pointing it at a progressive Jew in the name of the law. In the name of politics, yes, but not the law - yet.
Now I'm going to backtrack and have a read of a few more of the posts in this discussion. It's most certainly a very hot topic, and one, I think, that's not going away in a hurry.
Good on you, Julian! You always think up the best ones!
Gret
by levannah44
Hello Julian. Just thought I'd better touch base with the TR crew again after my unintentional absense, and this very thought-provoking article seems to be as good a place as any to do it.
This is very scary. Am I imagining it, or is the above article another way of talking about this 'clash of civilisations' thing? Mainstream Muslims, as I see it, already appear to have adapted many of their laws and customs to suit a democratic and more modern system than their Islamist counterparts (a word I notice isn't used in the article to differentiate between terrorist Islam and ordinary Islam), and, as far as I can see are quite content with that.
My marriage-niece is Lebanese, although I should immediately add, not Muslim, but Christian, a Maronite, one of the oldest sects of Christianity still around. But she is Arab and Lebanese, and, along with the rest of her large family, that's what matters!
Recently in this country, we've had some pretty nasty rioting among what appear to be white supremist groups of youths and the Lebanese community. It began in Sydney, but has spread to other states, which is why I mention my marriage-niece, who is scared out of her wits, I can tell you.
Things have quietened down a little at the moment, but no doubt could re-erupt again at any time, especially with the Commonwealth Games here next year in March. I sometimes wonder if these global sporting fixtures will become a thing of the past if terrorism triumphs, or even if it just gets too much for the authorities to handle besides anything else.
Unfortunately, I can see where the writer of the above article is coming from, and it isn't very pleasant. Islam has done some wonderful things in the past; the golden age of Spain under Islam, before it was conquered by the Christians, was one such time.
Then, Islam, Judaism and Christianity all lived side by side in common harmony and co-operation. Culture in general, science and the arts all prospered, and who could wonder why? Such an atmosphere was conducive to learning!
It'd be nice to think such a time could be re-born again on a global scale, but the way matters are pointing now in this 'non' war, I don't hold out much hope for that.
And even if religion wasn't one of the core issues (yes, I know; we've been through it all before in other threads, and I'm not going down that road this time!) in this battle, and it was purely politics and culture at loggerheads, the democracy sponsored by the west is not the same kind of democracy the Islamic countries of the world want.
The more 'westernised' we all become - maybe I'd better just say 'modernised' instead - the more remote religion becomes in our lives (or should, that is!) Church and state (politics) never sat well together, and they certainly don't these days.
Nevertheless, if that's the kind of democracy Islamic countries want, then let them have it. If it works for them, so be it. If we truly want a planet where all cultures/religions can live in harmony and co-operation, I believe we've got to let them have what THEY want, not what we think they ought to have, just because it (sort of) works for us!
I doubt at the end of this 'war' any one country will come out on top. Perhaps there'll be no 'west' or 'east' anymore, and we'll be one truly global community.
Unless, of course, China has anything to do with what happens. In my part of the world, China is a country to watch very carefully, definitely a 'sleeping dragon' that's waking up.
What would a world be like if China dominated it, as could well be the case in the very near future? China is still a country which doesn't tolerate religion very gladly; indeed, it often persecutes those who practice even some quite ancient religions. They certainly persecute those practitioners of Falon Gong, a mild, meditative form of religion from the way I see it, so one can only imagine what would happen if they were able to get stuck into certain forms of Christianity, even Judaism and Islam!
If the above article is supposed to be a wake-up call towards our awareness of the 'real' purpose of the war on terrorism, and whether we (the west) stand to lose or not, how about another wake-up call to the domination of China in our world system and what could happen under them?
Are we in for a rude awakening either way?
Gret
by levannah44
Sorry for the double post! Don't know what happened there. I must have been away for too long!
G
by jardinier
It's just a glitch in the website, which you will see mentioned in earlier posts as you scroll through. [Is TR ever free of glitches?]
But now that I have your attention (no response to emails) will you please help me to straighten out the Christians at meetchristians.com
There is a debate raging about the meaning of the creation stories in Genesis.
I know you have explored this in detail in some earlier discussion.
I have already used one of your articles from my website about "Hell" which was very well received.
Membership of meetchristians.com is free and I have already invited you to join.
You will find the battleground every bit as bloody as here on TR.
It is fairly urgent to post your views on the Creation stories while the topic is still hot, so I will be greatly appreciative if you can send me this material.
There is a small number of very scholarly people at this website which partially compensates for the Boring Born-Again Bible Bashers.
by jkameleon
by levannah44
Islam is not terrorism. Islam (the word) means 'submission', the submission in this case being to God, or as Muslims refer to him, Allah. Islam is a particularly peace-loving religion.
What is terrorism are those fundamentalist Muslims (like the Taliban) spewed out of madrassahs (special religious schools) brandishing their own interpretation of their faith. They're called Islamists, and have nothing whatsoever to do with ordinary Muslims.
Islamists are purely political people, and terrorism is a war of (mostly) politics, not religion.
Gret
by jardinier
I have done a quick search but it seems an elusive statistic.
Perhaps being closer to home you can come up with the figure. It would be interesting to compare the number of IRA victims to the number of Muslim terrorist victims.
I've found one that I'll cut-and-paste. They seem about correct as Tony Blair talked about the IRA post-911 "I don't think the IRA would ever have set about trying to kill 3,000 people"
From a victim's support site: "In Northern Ireland 3523 people lost their lives as a result of the troubles. Out of this number 2054 have died directly as a result of actions perpetrated by the Republican Movement - the prime constituent being IRA - in their sectarian campaign against the pro-British people of Northern Ireland . Of these 2054 people murdered, 279 were aged under 20, 183 were women, and a colossal 446 were Roman Catholics - a staggering total 47% higher than that killed by the Police and British Army put together (304). Overall, Republicans were responsible for two thirds of all terrorist killings during the troubles."
----------------------------
Hmmm. Having done this search I found out a lot that I didn't really want to know about punishment beatings and shootings by those Fearless Freedom Fighters (turns to spit).
In dishing out "paramilitary justice", both the Republicans and Loyalists shot over a hundred under-20s each and dished out crippling punishment beatings to another couple of hundred each.
I suppose that the contempt of terrorists for their victims is matched by their contempt for their supporters.
It's interesting, though, how the "Troubles" progressed. The government made the huge mistake of Internment and applying a different level of justice to suspected terrorists and the Irish in general. This surely aided support if not active recruitment. Only when we stopped could we begin dialogue.
We're doing the same again with the Islamic terrorists. Well, actually, we're doing rather more. We're not just locking people up without trials, we're cluster-bombing them.
.
Dang, I hate missing a good jab. I need to pay closer attention.
.
.....between those (many of those) who are on opposite sides of this issue.
The first is partisan politics. I know with 100 percent certainty, that there are people with whom I've debated this issue who would NOT be opposed to what's going on if it was a Democrat administration. And, I will concede, that there are current supporters who be opposed if it was a Democrat administration. And this applies to not only people like us, but to our fearless leaders in Congress as well. Although I do believe that not all Republican leaders would be as adamantly opposed as today's Democrats are. In discussions like these, however, I've seen too many people just debate and argue whichever side of the issue advances their political preferences. It's happened before, and it's happening here. I'm not one of them, however, as I've stated several times, I'd even support a Democrat President Lieberman in this effort.
The second difference might be described as long-term goals versus short-term instant gratification. The short-term instant gratification camp might have been in favor of going into Afghanistan to get those directly responsible for 9-11, but then they're gratified, and they would be satisfied that they've done enough; they got their revenge, or their justice, or whatever it is they were instantly seeking. Contrast that to a long-term vision for the transformation of the whole region. The issue, in its entirety, is much more than just 9-11 and Afghanistan. It's much more than just Osama bin Laden. And it's much more than continuing the failed policies and failed sentiments of the past forty years.
If you were to talk to today's Japanese business leaders and ask them to describe their business plans, you'd get some answers that were, in many cases, forward looking a hundred years or more. Not in America. America has been called an instant-gratification society, and rightfully so. And it's evident in not only the usual short-term pleasures people personally seek or their utter failure to plan for their own future, but in how they fall in the political spectrum as well. Just like people vote themselves the dollars that belong to others -- all at the expense of our collective and personal long-term financial stability -- they vote themselves the easy way out in cases like dealing with terrorism.
And it's also the short-term gratification people who are content with maintaining a primarily defensive posture. One of the reasons I'm so impressed with the efforts of President Bush is that FINALLY, someone went on the offensive. Think back to that movie when a guy stuck his head out the window and proclaimed for all to hear, I'm mad as hell, and I'm not gonna' take it any more. In my opinion, it's about friggin' time somebody FINALLY voiced such a sentiment, and FINALLY took the fight to them. After forty years of fulfilling our self-gratification by remaining in a defensive posture, or just a short-term retaliatory posture, we're FINALLY seeking a very long-term goal by taking it to them and by trying to transform the entire region. We are on the offensive, pure and simple. And we will settle for no less than unconditional surrender or total defeat. And personally, I will support anyone, Republican, Democrat, or otherwise, who shares that vision.
One more final thought. What would the collective terrorists and their supporters hope the United States does? I believe the answer is voiced every day by the Democrats in Congress, and by those outside who support them. And why in the hell would we want to do the very thing the terrorists want us to do? Read the statements made by Saddam Hussein during his ongoing trial. Read the comments uttered by the Democrats in Congress. The similarities are very telling. Osama bin Laden and Saddam Hussein do, in my opinion, have allies in the United States. They're the ones with a big D after their name.
as far as I'm concerned. Perceived inaction on the part of politicians of all stripes definitley was . Appearing to take no action against your enemies is politically unviable after all. No doubt if GWB had not invaded Afghanistan, many of his opponents would have been shouting for it calling him a coward and an appeaser. That is partisan politics in a nutshell, doing what's right comes second best to doing something different.
There have always been arguments about how to prosecute a war and to be quite honest best way to win is a moot point, because either you did or you didn't. When and I do mean when, we defeat, obviate or convert this current bunch of terrorist gits, a multitude of commentators will sit down and try to decide whether the invasions were right or wrong. Fools will try to apply this learning to next time.
All me and you are arguing about really Max, is this.
Does the increase in support for terrorists engendered by the necessary pragmatism of war outweigh the amount of damage to the terrorists done by the war and could there have been a less ambiguous way of achieving our common goal, which is stopping Islamic fundamentalist terrorism.
PS, I would have paid the afghan drug lords to take out Bin Laden and the Taliban and sent in a Shi-ite killing team to take out Hussein. When this was discovered I would have been impeached, the latter would not have bothered me though, as I'd have got to see multi national peacekeeping forces in both countries emplacing democracy.
At least it's a possible scenario, and I wouldn't have needed to dirty my country and democracy with Guantanamo, hatred laws, Belmarsh, Abhu Graiv rendition, quasi legal phone taps, courts martial et al.
Not 20/20 hindsight by the way, my last choice would have been sending in the troops. I would have made the decision to go in without hesitaion if that was my only option, I'm less than sure it would have been though. Political suicide would not have held me back though.
by levannah44
Julian, my sincerest apologies for not answering any of your emails. The trouble is, I can't get into my normal browser (no viruses; I don't know what it is) so I've had to use another browser, which I hope is only temporary until I figure out what's wrong.
I know there are unopened emails in my normal browser, but I can't get at them, which is frustrating, to say the least!
Please feel free to use any of my posts from TR that you think may be relevant to the topic of Genesis and creation, or anything you may have of mine on your websites until I've caught up with myself again!
I'll have a look at this other website later this morning. I've just decided it's late and I'm off to have some shut-eye!
Tomorrow (they say) is going to be ghastly - 36 degrees (ugh!) and gale-force winds, wonderful for spending a day at the computer!
I'll be back!
Gret
by ciderick
Seems to me terrorism depends upon which side of the fence you are on, this can also change with time. I kind of remember Rambo 3 as being Sly battling his way to save his general - aided & assisted by 'Our brave brothers, the Afghanistan Freedom Fighters' in their holy mujahadeen. Hmmmm, an american fighting alongside Al-quaida like terrorists & earning a fortune in the box office from Americans such as yourselves going to see their hero help the underdog.
& also, I notice you speak about the IRA in an earlier post - let's not forget they got an awful lot of funding from sympathetic Americans.
Funny how things get turned around isn't it.
by ciderick
I try my best not to have a point in my postings coz some dumb arse will attempt to answer them with personal attacks.
I will keep it this way in future to save you the bother of having to write them Max, I kind of like just the question mark... ;-)
.
First, I'm glad I put your mind at ease concerning President Bush's sentiments in that particular regard.
And second, I'm not going to take the time to verify what the British Attorney General may or may not have said, or try to put it into context. But then again, I didn't quote him, you did. Moreover, I wasn't challenging that; I was challenging the Bush assertion you made. Could the British Attorney General have said it was an "illegal" action? Sure, I suppose he could have. Heck, we have Americans saying the same stupid thing. And I don't think Americans have cornered the market in making stupid and unfounded comments.
But personally, I don't care what the Brits do. I want their support, of course, but it shouldn't matter when it comes to establishing our own goals and policies.
Remember, nations have neither common friends or common enemies, only common interests. And if a common interest can garner their support, then that's great. If not, our interests and actions should remain unchanged. So I'll let the Brits speak for themselves. They don't need me meddling into their business -- especially commenting on a stupid statement one of them may have made.
At the time of the invasion, the Attorney General made the following points which Mr Blair obviously did not heed and, I'm betting, hoped would not be made public.
This is not, obviously, the full document but paraphrases the Attornet General's points. As the governments chief legal advisor the AG should, perhaps, have been listened to.
1. In law, there was a strong argument that it was the job of the United Nations - not Mr Blair - to rule whether Iraq had defied the UN's order to disarm.
The AG set out how it may be judged that it was the function of the UN Security Council, not an individual country such as Britain or America, to decide if Iraq was in 'material breach' of UN Resolution 1441 which gave Iraq a 'final opportunity to comply with its disarmament obligations'. He pointed out that although Mr Blair could, in theory, make the decision, a court could decide otherwise.
2. The AG questioned whether Britain could attack Iraq by using UN Resolution
The wording of UN1441, a warning of 'serious consequences' if Saddam continued to flout the UN fell crucially short of permitting military action. The exact wording had important implications. It did not say 'all necessary means' - UN terminology for war, used when Saddam invaded Kuwait in 1990.
3. The AG urged caution about going to war without a second UN resolution.
He said Mr Blair could go to war without one, but it would be much 'safer' and desirable to secure a second resolution giving specific approval to military intervention.
4. Mr Blair was warned of the risks of relying on the earlier UN resolution used to eject Saddam from Kuwait.
The legal advice was that Britain and the United States had no right to go to war by 'reviving' UN Resolution 678, passed in 1990 when Saddam invaded Kuwait. Resolution 678 did not permit them to invade Iraq itself. The limited nature of Resolution 678 was one of the chief reasons the Allies did not try to topple Saddam when he was ousted from Kuwait in the 1991 Gulf War. In principle, Resolution 678 could be revived; in practice it could be difficult.
5. The AG drew attention to UN weapons inspector Hans Blix and his search for weapons of mass destruction.
On March 7, 2003, the day this legal advice was written, Mr Blix reported to the UN Security Council that 34 Iraqi al-Samoud missiles had been disabled. He said Iraq was being more helpful generally and that no weapons of mass destruction had been found so far. By the time Mr Blair received the AG's legal advice, he would have been aware of Blix's latest report.
6. He explained that the American government's position on the legality of the war did not apply in Britain.
The AG explained the legal stance taken by George Bush and why he faced none of the legal restraints confronting Mr Blair. The US Congress had given Mr Bush special powers to declare the war legal in American law. It also detailed why, in the US view, a second resolution was unnecessary.
You may believe that you had a legal right to go into Iraq. The advice to our Prime Minister from his chief legal adviser was that we did not.
.
....that's just all fine and dandy. But I am glad you cleared that up.
.
That was very informative.
Thank GOD there are some Brits, like yourself, who don't say stupid things.
By the way, if there is no God, who do you and/or your women partner(s) talk to during an orgasm?
the old British favourite of "Talking to God on the big white phone" - head down the toilet, "Ohhhhhh! God! Not again!"
Even I might call up on a deity in times of [b]real[/b] emotion - good and bad - I just don't expect an answer.
:D
by tonythetiger
not for the statistics , but for why the answer would matter. My guess in percentage terms is that the IRA, their brothers in arms and the illegal groups that opposed them are well in front. Not only that, how far do you want to go back. Discuss the troubles and in five minutes, people are talking about Oliver Cromwell, ten and we are back with the Plantagenat kings. Foolishness. Trying to pin the tail on the donkey at this stage is an utter waste of time, that's the search for justification for further atrocities or for further injustices. It's we are more right than you, not an argument you can ever win.
I don't care who's got the biggest head count. The IRA git who shoot's into one family home and misses everybody is just as bad as a follower of the prophet who set's himself off on a bus. Intent is all I measure.
I'd execute both of the 'uckers without a qualm, 'successful' or not.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending