Discussion Locked

The Financial [i]Crisis[/i] as I understand it to be

0 helpful
62 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Not being a financial expert, the following is put into my own layman terms.

The bailout ..... or rescue plan ..... or whatever it's being called today, is less about keeping large Wall Street financial firms afloat, and more about keeping the financial lines of credit open - and not just at the top end on Wall Street, but all the way down to the individual consumer. It's not just about protecting the fat-cats on Wall Street at the expense of the normal guy on Main Street, but rather it's about protecting them both. It's not just about facing the mortgage problem, but rather the whole financial system on which it's based.

These companies, for any number of reasons, are simply running out of money. At the top end, these financial institutions lend money to each other, who then in turn, lend it to institutions all the way down the financial line. If the money and/or credit flow is interrupted - or dries up - at the highest levels, the ripple effect will be felt all the way down the line. Companies like ACME Widgets, who use short term credit to buy inventory, might not be able to borrow operating capital - even though their credit rating is perfect. If they can't buy inventory, they can't manufacture their goods ..... and they can't sell their goods ..... and they can't pay their employees ..... and you know the rest.

I know of a guy who actually finances his small business with a $10,000 line of credit on his Visa card. His credit rating is as close to perfect as you can get. He tried to make a purchase for supplies to complete a project, and he discovered that the credit card issuer reduced his line of credit to $500. They simply didn't have the money to extend him credit beyond that.

Sure, we could put the blame where it's deserved and let the upper echelon of the financial world crash and burn. But it will be felt all the way down to the guy who might lose his job because his employer can't get the credit to keep his business going. Of course, that guy who's now out of work will rely on government social programs to provide for his basic necessities (a bad thing), he'll be unable to pay his mortgage (another bad thing), and on it goes (to more bad things).

When a financial crunch is placed on the whole system, people will buy fewer automobiles, and Detroit, as a result, will lay-off more people (as if they're not hurting enough right now). Housing starts will drop, and the unemployment rate in the construction industry will rise. Small business will close their doors because of poor sales. The effect will be felt everywhere, not just on Wall Street. And can anyone predict what might happen to the value of 401(k) and other retirement accounts?

It's a domino effect, and as much as I find it distasteful, I simply cannot cut off my nose to spite my face. I've heard numbers as high as 90 percent who are against the plan - any plan. Well, I guess that puts me in the 10 percent minority. And it's really kind of ironic, if you consider my ideology - an idealist who's well-grounded on a firm principle of less government. (And Delbert, that does not mean [i]no government[/i].) But I'm also a realist, and we don't have to let it happen. It could have been avoided in 1929, but the wrong measures were taken. I believe we can avoid it today.

I'm also one who is suspicious of those prophets of doom and gloom. That's the problem with these politicians presenting everything as a [i]crisis[/i] - the healthcare [i]crisis[/i], the climate [i]crisis[/i], the homeless [i]crisis[/i], the world food [i]crisis[/i], the handgun violence [i]crisis[/i] ..... Everything's a friggin' crisis. It's no wonder people can't differentiate between a real one and a fabricated one. This one, however, I believe. And I don't believe it because of what any politician might say, or how loud they sound their warning bell. I've been listening to people I trust - ones I know who are very well informed and financially savvy. I won't say who or what, but I believe this is real.

The way I see it, there are three choices:

1. Do nothing and take our chances that none of the above will happen and/or the recovery will be less painful than some people predict. Personally speaking, I'd be fine with this option. It certainly fits my ideology of less government interference and control. Moreover, I'm also certain that I'll survive, regardless of what happens, and I'll find a way to meet whatever challenges that might arise.

2. The Fed could simply pump out more cash - hoards of cash. Of course, we all know the tolerance level for inflation is not much more than 3 percent. How about 10 percent? Or 20 percent? Does anyone remember the late 1970s - high inflation and even higher interest rates? Well, I survived it once, and I could certainly survive it again.

3. Take the right measures to avoid it and/or reduce the fallout. I'm not smart enough to know the details of what that might be, but I like this option better than the first two. And the realist in me, in this case, trumps the idealist who keeps beating me on the back of the head. I like the plan as articulated by Larry Kudlow. If done right, perhaps it could be a win-win. And I'm always in favor of seeking the win-win solution.

http://article.nationalreview.com/?q=YWE3ZTg5MDZjOTI2MDA4MjYxMGQ3ZDg1YzI5MTBmOWE=

However, I call on the investigative reporters in our illustrious media to discover who's and what's to blame - without political pandering or favoritism - and bring the case to the court of public opinion. Fat chance. They already know George Bush is to blame.

Who's to blame and/or what's to blame?

[i]"From the perspective of many people, including me, this is another thrift industry growing up around us," said Peter Wallison a resident fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. "If they fail, the government will have to step up and bail them out the way it stepped up and bailed out the thrift industry." [/i]

Read the whole article:

http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9C0DE7DB153EF933A0575AC0A96F958260

Gee, it was even predicted! In 1999! But of course, the American Enterprise Institute is a Conservative organization, so it's okay to dismiss them.

Politics stinks. And big, intrusive, social engineering government sucks. I shake my head in disbelief at people who want more of the same. These things are never taken as a lesson, or so it seems. Why is that?

Just wait until they get their scummy and greedy little hands on your health care. Turn your head and cough - because that's exactly what they will have you by.

(Sorry about segueing into that little rant at the end.)

62 replies

by oz_media

I started looking for a copy of the actual proposal to see where it was strong and where it lacked or caused enough question as to be turned down, but i got sidetracked with AC/DC tour updates and never got back to it. I checked teh Whitehouse.gov site, nothing there either.

Is this going to be hidden from public or are such proposals usually open to public viewing?

by shasca

As of 8am MST this morning Fox news reported that the original pulled documentation has grown from the two to 300+ pages because of all the added by-ins for House Republicans. Good luck getting a copy of a never ending growing document.

by delbertpgh

That would be the document that Paulson showed up with before the House banking committee, the thousand-word proposal to entrust the Secretary of the Treasury with $700,000,000,000, without oversight, restriction, or recommendations as to its employ.

I'd like to see that one myself. I presume he had it typed up, and not just written on a napkin.

by oz_media

I went through it quickly and found that is simply a list of ammendments to describe and illustrate the application of the terms within the original document; it doesn't actually include the proposal though.

by the scummy one

to a much lesser degree than it was. And that the new draft includes all kinds of write-ins that have nothing or little to do with the economic crisis just pisses me off more. Especially when it comes to an extra cost in the 100 to 150 Billion dollar range, bringing the entire package from 700Billion to 800-850 Billion!

What should have been done, was to try to get the most basic failing points taken care of, and try to fix the system. As is, only a small percentage of loans were in default, but risk was there for more. So why just pull out the big guns and try to take everything (at the taxpayer expense) giving an 'out' for the foolish or greedy?

If the bailout was for 100-150 Billion, to cover the defaulted loans, with a small percentage to cover loans about to default, and maybe another 100 Billion to cover longer term defaulted loans over the next 5 years, then that would have been a better solution.

The creditors were way too lenient on loans if only 3% default and the entire economy is screwed over and needs a bailout!
Make these financial institutions suffer longer for their fallacious loans. Make those who signed up without understanding them, or thinking about the loans suffer longer too! Make them EARN their home.

My take on the Wall Street plunges is of retaliation. They wanted to be bailed out and when they werent they acted like a spoiled kid and started dumping stocks. This was to make a point that everything would crumble if they didnt get their greedy little way.
Personally, I think the govt AND companies should start paying LESS attention to the WATB's on Wall Street, and pay more attention to working on their companies to get them to grow and prosper.

by tonythetiger

the government will bail you out. So just take your grocery money to the riverboat and gamble with it. In fact, take ALL your money and buy lottery tickets. There's no risk. We'll save you if you lose. Heck, we'll even let you buy chips with a credit card.

by delbertpgh

I think the threat is as serious as it comes; this could be the onset of another Great Depression. Something needs to be done to get liquid money into a banking system that, if it goes flat, will dry up credit lines for everyone from farmers to Ford.

I'm also worried that somebody will do exactly the wrong thing with that $700 billion (not counting the extra $105 bn that the Senate stuck on top.) I'm putting a lot of trust in Secretary Paulson to get this started right. If he goes and sprays money at the wrong side of the problem, then all we get for it is more debt and a deeper crisis.

God help us all.

by jmgarvin

We are putting a band aid on a sucking chest wound. We are dumping money into a rabbit hole...

The EU is hurting, China is hurting, and the US is hurting. The only way out at this point is to take our lumps. The average American is going to get hurt the most, while the rich will float through, as usual. The poor will be the hardest hit...not only are they hurting now, but it's going to get MUCH worse for them.

by jellimonsta

Robin Hood: The poor are going to be absolutely thrilled. Have you met them at all?
Randall: Who?
Robin Hood: The poor.
Randall: The poor?
Robin Hood: Oh you must meet them. I'm sure you'll like them. Of course they haven't got two pennies to rub together but that's because... [nudges Randall] they're poor.

by jmgarvin

It's no wonder the people are pissed. This whole Bail Out has been scam after scam after scam...

Why don't we just sell the country to Amway and be done with it?

by oz_media

You did that in the 80's, I just figured Dexter Yager didn't want to run for president so they handed it to Bush in exchange for a promise to buy Triple X vitamins.

by Former member

and it is a simplistic view. The bailout amounts to a debt of $75,000 per person in the U.S.

Rather than give this money to the various corporations, would it not be better to give it directly to the citizens? With the money in the hands of the citizens, they, the citizens, would be the ones that would decide just what they wanted to do. The corporations, who have sorely mismanaged what they had, would then court the citizens.

Of course, we could regain the money in either case by getting out of the mid-east and not spending it in the first place.

by the 'g-man.'

I have watched countless times people; including yourself takes some high ground on what should happen in ?other countries based on your own ideals. There problem with that.

However the quickness one can abandon these ideals or at least start to when it is realised that the actions afoot can personally affect them starts to pang on the hypocritical.

Hey I?m not criticising you personally and actually agree with what you are saying but I just can see how you (or any others) who oppose this kind of government interference wholesale, can support more to solve the problems it created.

by notsochiguy

...when it is cheaper for Milton Bradley to use actual US currency in their games as opposed to 'funny money'!!

by oz_media

Its pretty clear now that the 700 Billion was just the very tip of the iceberg, what they are not to exceed in outstanding debts at any ONE time. But having an ongoing 699 billion is okay.

This would in turn mean that the debt schedule (as slack and vague as it is) can be paid back in pop bottles and it doesn't matter, as long as they don't exceed over 700 billion at any one time.

by maxwell edison

If you look at how I see the three possible options (and there could be others), my [i]option one[/i] would be to do nothing, and I indicated that I'd be fine with that even though it would mean a potential personal hit to me. There are a lot of innocent bystanders who, through no fault of their own, are the ones who might take the biggest hit.

As you know, I'm a huge advocate of less government. As you also know, I place a great deal of the blame for this mess firmly in the lap of big government - and it's an argument for less of it, not more of it. I simply don't believe this is a case where we stand by and do nothing, and as such, one has to consider the question, who or what is the best entity to avoid a bigger problem?

I don't know of too many sources that could raise 700 billion in capital other than through government means. Delbert is continually accusing me of wanting NO government in our lives, when I've only argued for less. LESS does not equal NONE. And just because I support one government program, or one case of government involvement, out of one hundred presented, it does not mean I'm caving in because of a personal stake. I've said no to the previous 99 things government has wanted to do, but I say yes to this one - only because I see this as a case where doing nothing would actually make the overall economic situation worse, AND if that happens, in the long run, it will ultimately result in even MORE government involvement in peoples' lives.

The plan Larry Kudlow articulated seems to make a lot of sense to me, especially since it's one that will possibly result in less government in the future, and, if implemented correctly, not cost the taxpayers a dime. Did you even read his piece? That's what I'm in favor of.

Out of my three possible choices, which do you think we should do? Or is there another choice that you' like to present?

Sometimes people are faced with conflicting principles - like the dedicated pacifist, but one who will definitely raise a fist when directly threatened. There aren't many Mahatma Gandhis among them.

By the way, I've been criticized by others for being inflexible with my less government positions. Now that I show flexibility and an exception, I'm criticized for compromising my principle. Oh well, that's life in the political arena.

by the 'g-man.'

1.Bail out the REAL ESTATE DEBT only, not
offer some massive pot for all BAD DEBT.

The only DEBT that the Gov should be
attempting to BAIL is the REAL ESTATE.

Any other would ammoiunt to paying of a
gambling debt - not on, they + investors knew
the risk.

2. State own the whole thing, top to bottom.

3. Nothing - Survival of the fittest.

EDIT - Notice how it is not working - they
now want MORE!

by maxwell edison

I'll stand by my position that something had to be done (which was the better option than doing nothing), but I wanted it widened to include removing the things that started it in the first place. And the added earmarks tacked on at the end were disgusting.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=275105&messageID=2606967

All or nothing:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=275105&messageID=2607070

by delbertpgh

Hubbard, formerly on Bush's Council of Economic Advisors, and now chair of Columbia's school of business, and an American Enterprise Institute guru, says the proposals so far miss the point of taking pressure off of the housing markets. If more people default, it will drive real estate prices further down, pushing the whole process that much further.

Hubbard proposed that the government underwrite 5.25% 30-year mortgage refinances for anyone who wants it, with a 5% principle reduction. I'm not sure what limitations there would be on principle reduction.

I heard this on the radio this morning, an NPR piece that said Hubbard and Soros (conservative Republican and liberal Democrat) seemed to agree that unless the pressure is taken off the real estate market, the rescue would not work. I can't find this in print anywhere on the Internet. http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=95329928

Hmm. Don't know what to think.

by netman1958

"Lawmakers voted 263-171 to pass the bill, a comfortable margin that was 58 more votes than the measure garnered in Monday's stunning defeat."

"Of the 263 supporters, 172 were Democrats and 91 were Republicans. On Monday, 133 House Republicans joined 95 Democrats in rejecting the measure."

by the scummy one

and that just plain S*cks.
so we delayed the inevitable. I was reading last night from CNN (I think) that this would likely not do enough good, and depending on circumstances, a new bill in as little as a year and a half we could be asked for up to 1 trillion bailout package :0 :0 :0

by jmgarvin

I just can't imagine somebody being taken advantage of like that (and at the same time being stupid enough to be suckered into it).

by the scummy one

the God of Scum :^0

And the God of Scum says -- Buy Me A Damned House Already!!! :D

:^0

What is wrong with suckers these days. I heard 1 is born every minute, but they seem to be the only ones breeding anymore :0

I do believe that the movie Idiocracy got a few things right...

by ontheropes

First I've ever heard of Prosperity theology. I learned something new today.

"Adherents will reap rewards if they prove their faith to God by contributing heavily to their churches, remaining mentally and verbally upbeat, and concentrating on divine promises of worldly bounty supposedly strewn throughout the bible."

Gag! Retch!

I'm sick and tired of organized religion, have been for awhile. I see nothing, nothing around me that's going to change that.

Thanks for the article. I just knew that it was all God's fault somehow. :|

by w2ktechman

to work at home -- nothing needed in the office. On the radio they had some financial lawyer telling people if they qualify for a bailout.
1 guy called in and said he didnt agree with the bailout, and that many people were stupid for signing if they didnt understand the terms.
He went on to mention that 75% of the 'troubled' loans were refinances and equity loans. He went on to mention as well, that many of the people that took out these loans went on to purchase boats, cars, etc. that they could not afford otherwise.
The financial lawyers response was We dont want to hear it, these people qualify under federal law. Then he promptly hung up on the caller as he was trying to make another statement... LOL -- add insult to injury -- we are paying not only for peoples homes (because they were stupid) but also their cars, boats, and other toys!

by pringles86

I wish I would have known I could have had other people pay for my toys... I don't think I could live with that guilt tho.

"We don't want to hear it" and hung up on him, haha.

by w2ktechman

I could bought a house in '02, in the bay area, had it double +, got a 250,000-400,000 equity loan, bought a Yacht, Ferrari or Hummer (or both), quads, rafts, and banked a lot. Then gotten a 'bailout' :0
Damn, I really screwed up!

by dixiedi

It's a shame we can't put your post somewhere where the entire country can see it. Minus your little rant at the end. That part would be focused on and all else negated because of it. LOL

I agree with even your rant except it's not President Bush's fault. Yes, he signed the deregulation but it was meant to allow people of lesser incomes (it was being heavily pushed during the Clinton administration) to buy homes they can afford. Not to buy homes they can not pay for. Families making 30 - 40 K could not buy because they could not save enough before deregulation. After deregulation, we could buy. When I bought my home we had only my income, and I was already on my way down "can't work anymore" lane. But I had a variable income, $600 - $1600 gross/week and that was good enough after deregulation. (Before I bought this house I was a happy life-time renter and would have stayed that way if it weren't for that last landlord, he drove me to home ownership and the resulting requirement to stay in one place.)

Ok. point is, deregulation was to make it easier for those like me to buy a home. Widely variable income, low income, etc. It was abused, not by Pres. Bush but by Main St and Wall St. Whle everything was going well nobody complained, there were a few who saw it coming, but they were not listened to. Why would anybody listen to them, like you said, they cry crisis so often everybody is tired of hearing it. DC can't seem to agree on anything, much less the prospect of something that good goinng sour.

by jamesrl

Eevryone is quick to blame the government and the wall streeters, but equally culpable are the people who signed up for mortgages they can't afford. Those zero down mortgages, no princple mortgages, no paper mortgages, all just craziness. The financial institutions were crazy for making them such a big part of their portfolio (not managing their risk) and people were crazy for ignoring reality and signing up for more than they could possibly afford.

I don't know about your specific case, but I've heard a lot worse. People who bought houses with sliding mortgage rates that balooned up every 6 months. They could barely afford the first low intro rate, they could afford it at all after 2 years and they were counting on using the equity (of which there is very little earned after 2 years unless your house appreciates in value) to help pay their bills. Thats insanity.

This is societal. Not just the government or wall street. Its too bad that people who were and are responsible are paying the price.

New report came out that says Canada's banking system is the strongest in the world, our banks weren't hurt that much by the credit crisis, and yet our market is diving just as fast as the dow. Because we depend on trade for our wealth - both raw materials like oil, potash, uranium, wheat and manufactured goods like cars and widgets. For our foreign customers (like the US) to buy those goods, they use credit, which is in short supply right now.

My assessment is that much of the market drop of the last day or two is based on fear. The market priced out the issues with the financial system last week. But fear is a powerful force on the markets.

James

by maxwell edison

That's the lesson to be learned.

What the feds did with the mortgage and financial industries - trying to make home ownership available to those who cannot afford it, guaranteeing payments, etc. - is the very same thing they're starting to do with the health care industry; and some people want the feds to take over that entire indusrty.

NO, we can't let that happen. That's the lesson.

by tonythetiger

that they (politicians) all look at it like that... who gets the credit... We'll probably never know how many good ideas have been lost like that :(

by av .

McCain should be trumpeting that fact more. Everyone needs to know that he had the right judgement to recognize how serious the situation was and he acted on it.

McCain might get a passing comment from Obama in a speech, but no more than that and only because they have to admit that he was right.

AV

by av .

But I don't think alot of people did. John McCain should show this in a TV Ad so that people can see for themselves that he had the foresight to do something about the mess before it got worse. I don't see Obama's name on that letter and yet many people think that, because he's a Democrat, he's naturally better at handling our economy.

If he wins, alot of people will be disillusioned very fast with his imitation of leadership. Talk is cheap.

AV

by tonythetiger

But they don't have a clue as to what they should be doing... that's why their approval rating is, what? 11%?

by av .

He picked her because she isn't a Washington insider. Yeah, she isn't a media darling either, but she continues to energize the conservative Republican base.

AV

by jmgarvin

She's a poor choice because she is pretty clueless when it comes to a lot of the topics America is facing. She has a very small world view and she just isn't a good choice to be a heartbeat away from the presidency.

by av .

We had no deficits. We were all wrapped up in the Clinton impeachment and John McCain was thinking about running for President.

It wasn't until 2006 that they saw the writing on the wall, but at least he saw it.

AV

This discussion is closed to new replies.