Discussion Locked

the Future of Servers, Netware vs Windows

0 helpful
16 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Vol 14 of Connection Magazine posed some really interesting views towards the furtuer of Windows Servers vs Novell's.

With the roll out of Netware 6.5 that comes bundled with Apache web Server, my SQL and PHP/PERL (AMP), Novell's open source promises are now coming true.

But with performance that FAR exceeds anything from Windoze, will there be a market change in the near future or is Novell positioned to make a slow crawling comeback?

"Novell tests indicate that MySQL running on Windows can only support about 50 users while the same database running on NetWare using equivalent hardware supports 1200-1300 users"

The new AMP server with PHPmyADMIN customization utility will offer a more customizable Web Access interface than Windows. ZenWorks offers faster Middle Tier logins with Zen delivering 3MB of data (policies and applications) to 600 users in 3minutes of rolling logins, whereas the Windows server only handled 300.

With NetWare outperfoming Windows Server in test after test, what is the future for Windows servers? Why even look at a Windows NOS when there are more cost effective, scalable solutions from an open source NOS?

For now, I see Windows being used in desktops siomply because of it's market depth and user friendly GUI. With Ximian/Novell merger and open source NOS, how long will it be before people start to realize that Netware is still the true champion of the NOS?

16 replies

by pgm554

NW has had the advantage of doing more with less for quite some time. A 386 with 16 megs of ram supports 50 users on 3.12 quite easily.

However,we are dealing with a corporate mentality that goes with a "good enough" mantra.

Ignorance,deception,and lies are Novell's greatest enemies.

I had to install a Xerox copier/printer on one of my clients networks.The guy they sent to install it was an MSCSE(21 and fresh from a M$ bootcamp no doubt) and knew nothing of how to install it in a NW network.He said the only thing he knew about NW was that they stole directory services from M$.

They are (Novell) still having trouble getting the word out .Here is a excerpt from an Infoworld review of Zenworks:

But Novell, in keeping with its long tradition of ultra-quiet marketing, has had a Windows-only version of ZENWorks available for quite some time. The company just forgot to tell me about it. (Little strategy tip for the folks in Utah: "New product" equals "send a press kit.")

by oz_media

I agree that they haven't pwered themselves to the same guerilla marketing tactics that Gates did, probably why they still have prestige.

with the Ximian and Open Source additions, PHP, SQL etc, Netware is gearing up for a hard industry hit. As a MCNE I can't wait to see the lost MCSE souls when all the big money jobs are in Netware (they already are but nobody knows about it).

Then we'll hear, "I have an MCSE and was wondering whether I should get my CNA because I can't find work, waaaaaa."

Some people can't see the 'Trees' through the 'Forest', soon they won't see the 'Forest' because of all the 'Trees' .

P.S. I hope you bitch slapped the MCSE who said Novell stole NDS! That's Billy's trick.

by pgm554

I don't know where the guy got his information, but I asked him two

questions.

1. How long has AD been around? Gee, since 2000, I guess.
2. How long has NDS been around? Early to mid 90?s (after a few hints from me)

He seemed a might confused on dates, but not totally convinced. (M$ brainwashing)

Maybe Novell should hire the deprogrammers from the 70?s and 80?s that were used for getting people out of religious cults. M$ a cult? Hmmm,
if it quacks like a duck?

His only redeeming quality was that he hates NT.

It's guys like these that fog up the differences between good, better and best.

Whenever you hear M$ at a product launch, the mantra is "best Windows yet".

They can't compare themselves to Novell or a decent UNIX solution, because they are not better or even equivalent.

by robotech

After getting my MCP, I got a certificate, a fancy tie pin, and a swipe card type ID thingy.
Microsoft also sent me a package the other day with Windows 2003 Servers and Exchange 2003 Servers.
Novell needs to get the word out, Novell needs to market, Novell needs to do stuff and send us stuff that we can install them and show them to our bosses. That's the only way they will authorize a move to a different NOS.

We have reached the point where many NT servers, or older systems in general are reaching their limit. Microsoft realizes that there are a lot of older systems still out their (do I hear Windows Update), so they are targeting these systems that were never upgraded by sending the IT people like myself literature and Evaluation software.
Novell needs to send us not only sample software, but give huge price discounts to the first 1 Million persons to convert to a Novell network, as well as sending us brochures like: 'How to upgrade from Windows NT 4.0, 2000 to Novell 6.5 .... nuff said.

by pgm554

You want free software?

WWW.NOVELL.COM/EVAL

Lot's of free stuff.You want discounts,they got discounts.

As for the how to's,if you don't know Netware ,call in a consultant.There are white papers,but unless you know the products inside and out,it's like upgrading to AD from domains.You want somebody that's done it before.

Interested?

www.cpu-tech-services.com

Authorized Novell and M$ partner.

Have laptop ,will travel.

by pgm554

Sorry, the old page doesn't work .Try this and watch for xtra spaces in the URL when doing c&p.

download.novell.com/pages/PublicSearch.jsp

by oz_media

"Novell needs to get the word out, Novell needs to market, Novell needs to do stuff and send us stuff that we can install them and show them to our bosses. That's the only way they will authorize a move to a different NOS."

I get monthly neqwletters, CD packages, mailouts etc. all the time (probably because I'm a registered NwtAdmin with them). The job of a good IT department is to test, evaluate, report and develop new practices to improve company sales, reducr operating costs and improve efficiency. I don't feel it is up to Novell to convince your boss but for you to research, document and present your ideas to the boss yourself, that's why you have a job, you are supposed to know what is nest for the company.

the two companies I switched had several MCSE's who couldn't keep up with the crao they had installed. I made a case and presented it to the employers along with ROI and TCO statements. This and the fact that they had to pay me (ONE GUY) about 1 1/2 times a single MCSE salary but again ONLY me convinced them to go my route. Three MCSE's are looking for work and I increased my salary.

Novell didn't do it for me, they just provided my tools.

by robotech

I used to work with a consulting company that had a very good Novell Engineer, and he admitted that Microsoft had better marketing strategies than Novell.
I've been getting stuff from CDW, Microsoft, and other people, just by being the Network Administrator. The point is, if Microsoft is sending me software that is user friendly and also telling me how to implement it. If they are showing me that 75% of NetAdmins use it, then why shouldn't I go with it?
Novell needs to get stuff into my Inbox, because the truth is, I'm too busy evaluating Microsoft stuff that they sent to me to be out there researching something that I don't even know exists.

by oz_media

As a net admin it is YOUR resposibility to ensure that you ahve adequate product and competetive knowledge. If one company throws themselves at your feet and forces their product on you, as a net admin, it's YOUR JOB to see if that products stacks up against others on the market, not the vendors.

If I fix my neighbour's transmission for $300.00 and the shop that advertises heavily charges him $1200.00 that's HIS problem for not researching his options, not MINE.

Your job is to know what is best for the company, your their network administrator. Just like the office administrator is responsible for buying office supplies at competetive costs and finding out about new products that will benefit the company.

Netware's not new, in fact VERY old, you can't tell me you hadn't heard of Netware when you were taking your certs.

by robotech

I couldn't reply directly because there was a message saying that the maximum message level was reached. Anyway, a few months ago I had to upgrade a newly acquired client?s network from 10Mbps to 100Mbs. My first step was to upgrade the backbone. I had to keep the upgrade cost at a minimal, but at the same time produce results that would be obvious to everyone.

As far as network hardware, I had five vendors in mind.

LINKSYS (before they were bought by CISCO), CISCO, 3COM, NETGEAR and D-LINK.

I started out with LINKSYS because they came out on top as far technical performance and price. Perhaps 3COM had something better, but after checking 3COM?s Website as well as via CDW, I couldn?t find what was required for that specific job.
Having gone the way of LINKSYS for the initial part of the project, I tried to move into the second phase of the project two months later. Believe me when I say that among these manufacturers only D-LINK had a switch that could support two or more fiber ports at 100Mbps. Not even LINKSYS who I bought the first switch from had one that could support two fiber modules. Their sales team even told me that the Gigabit switch could talk to the 100 Mbps switch over the fiber connection, but my diligent RESEARCH on their website showed that the Gigabit switch only supported 1000Mbps fiber modules, which would communicate at that speed only. In the end they had to send me an e-mail apologizing for the blunder. In the end I had to purchase two D-Link DSS-24+ switches that can accommodate two fiber modules at 100 Mbps.

Since the client only has one Windows 2000 Server that does everything, I decided to add a second NIC and do load balancing. However, load balancing is only supported in Advanced Server. I did my RESEARCH and decided to do enable round-robin in the DNS properties. This allows every other request to go to the second NIC, effectively dividing the bandwidth between both NICs. My research paid off, everyone was happy with the increased speed, and I saved my client almost $7,000.00 by not implementing a Gigabit network that they didn?t need. CISCO makes the best hardware, but in that case they didn?t have the solution that I needed to implement right away. LINKSYS dropped the ball by not having a 100Mbps switch capable of supporting two fiber modules, D-Link did, and got our business. It doesn?t matter how good you are, the question is, what can you do for me TODAY???????

Needless to say, I?ve established a lasting relationship with that client, hey, I got another check from them yesterday :-).

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=3&threadID=138979&start=0

by oz_media

It doesn't really address the point in question.
I assume your response was to my last post.

You had stated tha Netware didn't do what you wanted it to so you went to MS server 2003. The next post stated that you must have done something wrong to not install Netware successfully on your first try. You then slammed the poster for giving you a hard time becaus eit wasn't your fault but the MOBO was dead.

My point was that you had no reason to slag Netware becuase it was a hardware fault not Netware's, to which you posted the last message.

I just don't see how it fits, it makes sense and you made a relatively educated decision but how does that fit the rest of the discussion?

by robotech

After reading your reply I think I now understand the kind of person I'm dealing with. Selective tunnel vision. Just in case it missed your advanced Novell brain, I was able to do RESEARCH (something you implied I couldn't do), and I came up with a solution that saved my client money, lot's of money. Surely even you can realize the benefits of saving money, right?

I work with small to medium sized companies that have a very small IT budget and no IT department, which is why they hire me (a consultant). With all the virus outbreaks etc. that have been going around, not one of my clients got hit by a virus. Sure some employees were sent virii via e-mail, but they died in the mail server's antivirus software.
I really don't care if Netware servers can walk on water and sing the star spangled banner. What I want is a solution that I can implement now, and development tools that will allow my programmers to bring a software into service within 4 - 6 months or less (depending on its use of course). If Microsoft has it, I'll go with them, if Novell has it I'll go with them.

By the way, cheap doesn't mean bad. And frankly I think Windows XP is darn expensive.

by oz_media

WHAT MAKES YOU THINK THAT NETWARE COULDN'T PROVIDE THE SAME RESULTS FOR LESS MONEY?
I also work with small to medium sized businesses as a contracted netadmin. THAT's exactly why I install Netware. It is more cost efficient, and requires less maintenance and on-site servicing /updating.

But your first post basically slammed Netware and said MS worked for you. BUT...You never compared the costs of maintaning a Netware shop with those of a MS shop. THERE you would see a difference. Initial outlay of software costs is only a small part of the solution.

I'm not saying you were right or wrong, just that you slagged Netware and the said how Microsoft server had sent you a CD and that you'd have no trouble installing MS as OPPOSED to Netware.

The problem was a hardware fault, so your statement holds no water.

by robotech

At least I had the guts to come back and say I made an error, that the MOBO was at fault. The thing is, my clients already have systems in place and they want the easiset and the most cost effective upgrade path. If Netware has it, send me stuff in the mail like Microsft does. Microsoft actually tells you how to upgrade from other NOSs to Windoze, and they even provide the tools. I think Netware is just learning about the rate of change in the technology field and what they need to do to compete with M$.

Let's see if they can live up to their promise.

by oz_media

I don't really think that Novell is wondering how they can gain a marketshare from MS.
THey have been in the business MUCH longer than Microsnot and generally apply to a more demanding installation that MS can't meet the needs of.

They have a niche, you might say.

Funny things is though, MS has never even held a candle to Netware but with everyone running out to get the MCSE cert, Windoze is sold to many companies as recommended by their IT staff.

Talk about openig you rown can of worms.

This discussion is not going anywhere now so I'll bid you farewell and wis you the best of luck with your future endeavors.

P.S. I didn't mean to imply that you made the wrong decision, it was just the way you were saying MS would save the day, NOT!

This discussion is closed to new replies.