Discussion Locked

The US War censorship

0 helpful
163 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

163 replies

by admin

It seems to me that the arguements for some sort of censorship are pretty valid.

1. Lack of censorship may increase hatred and therefore bloodshed.
2. Lack of censorship may give away locations and other data important to saving lives and increase bloodshed.
3. The tools of information warfare may seem like or outright include some censorship, but an information war causes considerably less bloodshed than one based on firepower.
4. By saving lives on both side and reducing bloodshed, appropriate censorship may actually lead to an easier time of reconciliation and peace, since less people will have blood lost by family and friends and carry these personal grudges forward.

There were probably more points that I missed gleaning from the conversation above, but it would seem to me that you may want people to be aware that censorship is occurring than actually wanting it to be lifted.

by oz_media

I suppose the main point I am trying to get across here is that even with careful reporting so as not to jeopardize missions or lives in Iraq, I have seen several sides to this conflict.

Those that see the bloodshed and completely anhor war as a whole (which I do not).

Those that see and understand the effects of war yet feel it deserves proper justification as it is really more gruesome than most would expect.

Those that think it is all happy children and better schools and hospitals.

garion (not to point a finger at the person by teh information put forth) provided several links (we have all seen before) of pictures depicting children waving and laughing, Us soldiers helpin gand smiling with them, happy school kids etc. I think what is being misse dis that first of all, these kids did go to school under Saddam's leadership, they had many buildings destroyed and infrastructure damaged as a result of all the wars with neighbouring countries over the years, but Saddam hadn't SHUT down all these places himself.

Secondly, these images show the side I fear that is the only side seen in the USA. Whenever I see US news here, it is always about the positive rebvuildin gand happy Iraqi's, which is all fine and well deserves to be considered positive news. What I don't see is all the negativity and death, injury, destruction and fear in Iraq (which equals the happy people at least) being shown in the USA.

Do we NEED to see this? Well in order to make an educated and warranted decision regarding whether or not to supoprt war I think everyone needs to understand the true face of war, and it certainly isn't pretty. now I KNOW this war is neccessary but how it is sold to the public and justified is what bothers me, it seems to be a very deceptive and one sided view shown on the US networks. Now I know we have INternet access and alternate opinions and pics from around the world, but from even those who are here on TR, I see NO interest in seeking out anything other than what is said in america. any other report or viewpoint shown is immediately dismissed as outsideer's spewing Anti-American sentiment and therefore when we show images, we have peers who show the pretty side.

Of course there's a calm after the storm man would never have gone to war in history if there was no positive end result, the means of achieving it is being clouded over though. Do we NEED to see this? I think so, it allows us to make more humane decisions, something the Atrmy doesn't like to promote 'humanity' as it would effect those that are trained to put aside personal feelings of humanity in order to perform the horrible job they are faced with.

WE THE PUBLIC need to see both good and bad images, if it disgusts you then so be it, perhaps there would be less support for immediate action with questioned motives.

by jamesrl

There comes a point at which we have to shut up and start looking forward.

If you really want to blame someone for screwing up Iraq, blame Britain. When the Ottoman empire(who were allies of Austro-Hungary) collapsed after WWI, Britain took what was 3 separate provinces(one Kurdish in the North, one around Baghdad and Sunni, one in the south and Shia), and made 2 countries (Kuwait was part of the southern Shia province).

I didn't agree with the invasion(the second time, the first was entirely reasonable) but it doesn't matter anymore, because its done. We can hope to learn from it for the next time, but there are more pressing things for the moment - like restoring order etc. If we spend all of our lives in the past, we can't improve things for the future. We can disagree about the past, but we don't disagree on the goal of a peaceful prosperous independant Iraq.

James

by jamesrl

I did agree that porn was readily available. The cases that Max cited were particular gay bookstores which were overly agressively targeted(one in Vancouver, one in Toronto) and had many books blocked. Recent court case on the Toronto bookstore found it to be unfair BTW, so now they get whatever they want. But again, the books being sensored were on the edge of obscenity ie depicted pain and humiliation, not just sex.

And with regards to books I do know of many incidents of german books banned here because they incite anti-semetic hatred. Do a google on Ernst Zundel and all his books - written here in Canada. I personally support those bans - to me its like the law which says you can't incite a riot. There is a fine line though. Always going to be issues which straddle that line, and we may err on the side of caution - so be it.

James

Yes the US did censor the Abu Ghraib images. They claimed it was because of pending litigation. Don't be so cynical we did the same with the Somalia affair - where our soldiers did much the same thing on a smaller scale. The Canadian government witheld the pics for some time, until they were presented at trial.

I don't need more pics to know what went on at Abu Ghraib. I don't need pics of bodies hanging of bridges - its enough I know it happened.

James

by oz_media

I suppose it all depends on how it is used. It works well and sounds fine in spoken English but written it seems that that 'double that' doesn't fit.

When writing, often words that will fit the spoken language don't fit any other way, perhaps voice inflection helps or even natural pauses in speech that that would apply to, that that isn't understood in written language. I actually ran across a THAT THAT when I was posting the other day and spent another 5 minutes rewording my post so that that wouldnt be misinterpreted or seen as a typo.

by maxwell edison

.
......that would unequivocally deem it correct or not, and that's what my question was about. Whether or not it "sounds" correct is besides the point (but certainly something to consider, and something I did consider).

I was thinking that Julian would probably chime in, since he's probably the most proficient grammar expert on these threads, and he may or may not. It depends, of course, on whether or not he even sees the question; and then it would depend on how he feels at the moment.

I was looking for a specific rule of grammar that identified such cases. I have yet to find one that either validated its use or prohibits it.

I usually avoid such cases, but I let this one slide just so I could go off on this tangent and open it up to discussion.

Julian??????

by maxwell edison

.
I must admit that that attempt at humor flew right over my head. I was so focused on finding a "technical" answer rather than a "theoretical" one, that that aspect of you message did not even register.

I'll try to make sure that that doesn't happen again.

(Score one for Oz in the humor column. Take one away from me for missing , what should have been, the obvious.)

by jardinier

After both of us researching the background to the article: "Bush -- How I will rule the world" -- The ONLY fault you could find with the Sydney Morning Herald was the actual heading of the story. The story originiated from the New York Times, and we agreed that it was fundamentally valid, and I also conceded that the New York Times had introduced a small amount of bias.

And of course you have conveniently forgotten the occasion when you told an outright lie about searching the archives of the SMH for items about Jordan and WMDs.

You lied about the search, which I was readily able to demonstrate that you could not do without paying money to access the archives of the SMH, and while you claimed to have found no references to Jordan and WMDs, I readily found five.

Is your brain still running on a 286 computer with 4 MB RAM?

Upgrade your memory, Max, or shut the hell up.

by maxwell edison

.
I did search, as you suggested, but I didn't find any references. Perhaps your search skills and efforts, in that case, were more effective than mine. But I certainly didn't lie.

And as far as the headline versus the context of the story, it shows two things. First, it proved that editors are misleading people with their headlines. And second, it shows that people read only the headlines, as you based your entire argument on that headline.

By the way - are you suggesting that their were (are) indeed WMDs that escaped Iraq in the days before the war? Great, I'm glad we are finally in agreement on that issue.

But for the life of me, I can't figure out why you're so mean-spirited. For God's sake, Julian, be civil and "lighten-up" a bit. I certainly understand how constant "back-and-forth" dialogue can cause a person's emotions to get the best of them (Garion and Oz in these current discussions), as you and I (and others) have both fallen prey to that. But the last couple of attacks you've thrown my way, came totally out of the blue, they were totally unprovoked, and, I might suggest, in very poor taste and totally uncalled for.

by jardinier

I would like to especially thank Garion11 and Maxwell Edison for their input to this most amusing discussion.

It is much, much funnier than The Three Stooges or the Marx Brothers.

Perhaps we should ask TR to start a new discussion category "Humour," to accomodate certain individuals who make such absurd statements as to provide a source of amusement to the majority of peers who are sane and rational.

by garion11

LOL, well first of all thanks. But the honor isn't all mine, there are many more such as Oz, YOU??, James, several new/other recruits...err I mean members, which I never met before also contributed to this humorous thread. So please spread the "compliments" around.

"Sane and rational" is very relative but whatever. As far as Humour category is concerned I agree, TR should have one. We can just forward all YOUR posts directly over there. Ta Ta!

by oz_media

How long did it take for you to come up with such a witty retort?

"As far as Humour category is concerned I agree, TR should have one. We can just forward all YOUR posts directly over there."

You simply epitomize the type of person described in another post I made about psychology and self assurance, personal fear and insecurity. Maybe you need to find yourself, before you start calling me more names, that is also the most common 'reflex' from that same type of person.

"I know you are but what am I?"
:-)

by maxwell edison

.
All I can suggest is that the person who harbors such feelings is the one being hurt.

(Yes, Julian, hate. It's obvious that you harbor such feelings.)

by jardinier

Maxwell, you have previously said that you relate to many of the ideals of the Libertarian Party, but you have not to my knowedge ever stated that you were a Libertarian.

I have always understood you to be a Republican with strong sympathy for the ideals of the Libertarian Party.

Do you belong to the Libertarian Party? Have you ever voted for the Libertarian Party?

I do clearly recall on one occasion that you admitted to wasting your vote in one election by voting for Ross Perot.

Perhaps it is YOU who should define your political allegiance(s).

by garion11

Go somewhere else and let the adults speak. You are very late to this conversation and your point is moot.

by pooksmin

Ah, yet another comment to deepen the general feeling in this discussion that you are a blubbering idiot. I've actually been following this discussion for ages - it's only now that you've made me laugh hard enough to join in. And as for me leaving the adults to speak - perhaps you should do the same considering it's you receiving all the "ageism" comments about what your mom will let you do and that you'll eventually learn with age. I choose to rather continue this discussion with decent folks who write well written posts rather than those with such limited vocabulary. Go and read a book - you might find some alternatives to "F*ck" and "dude".

by maxwell edison

.
....that you haven't read every message of every thread in which I've participated. But I have indeed, on several occasions, aligned myself closer to the Libertarian principles than those of any other party. And I've mentioned my Ross Perot gaffe on several occasions as well, usually in the context of "third-party" voting discussions.

But in summary, I'm also a realist, and I know that we have a strongly embedded two-party system in America that will be with us for some time. The Democrats and Republicans are, of course, those two parties. Sure, an independent might get elected once in a blue moon, but I can't recall the last Libertarian to be elected to national office, and they presently hold absolutely no seats in either the Senate or the House. There are, however, a handful of Libertarians holding individual state seats, and I certainly could - and would - vote for a Libertarian for a state position, but not national.

The party that holds the majority in both houses of congress has the most power. In fact, they have almost all the power. They chair the committees, they hold a majority in the committees, and they "hold all the cards", so to speak, in setting the agenda for that particular congressional session. For example, if a lawmaker introduces a bill, it must first go to committee for review. The bill could then either be passed on to the full floor of the House or Senate for debate and vote, or, as so often happens, get "held-up" in committee, never even being introduced for a full chamber vote. Moreover, they wield much more influence in the selection of our federal judges - all the way up to the Supreme Court.

So although I am more closely aligned with the Libertarian party in principle, the realist in me throws my support to the Republican party. After all, the Republican platform is closer to the Libertarians than the Democrats - much closer. And the last thing I want is for the Democrats to have control of either the House or the Senate - or the White House.

As far as your message title about not knowing what I believe, I would challenge you to find even one inconsistency among the hundreds of messages I've ever posted. To the contrary, I might even suggest that I'm the most consistent person who posts messages in these threads. With all due respect, Julian, I believe that you have drawn too many conclusions about me, for whatever reasons, but I'll not speculate on what those reasons are.

If you're confused about my positions on any particular issue, ask me to elaborate, and I'll be glad to indulge your curiosity by repeating what I've probably posted a dozen or more times. (I really should save all my messages for the convenience of recycling them. Since I'm always 100% consistent, it would save me a lot of time.)

However, in a nut shell:

I don't believe in the forced, government controlled, distribution of wealth.
I strongly encourage charitable living by caring for those less fortunate - but not forced by the government.
I believe that the government, in such cases (charity), should be the last resort, not the first stop - and it's never an "entitlement".
I believe that each individual has the inherent responsibility to take personal responsibility, and not become a burden to society.
I believe that a strong family unit is vital for a strong America - and for the well-being of the individual.
I don't believe in the death penalty - for either criminals or the unborn.
I believe that life begins at conception, and abortion takes a life.
I believe in maintaining a strong national defense. Okay, I'll admit it, I want the "biggest dog on the block".
I believe in full and unencumbered individual liberty. It stops only when it might infringe on the liberties of others.
I believe that "social" drugs should not be illegal. (No difference between an adult drinking a beer or smoking a joint.)
I believe that a person becomes an adult at 18 - period. (The 21 drinking age, for example, should be 18.)
I believe in a total free market economy.
I believe, as former president Calvin Coolidge said, the business of America is business.
I believe that a company has a right to hire whomever they please. (In the context of labor unions versus "right to work".)
I cringe at the sight/thought of "hyphenated" Americans. It's divisive, at best, and weakens America from within.
I don't believe in affirmative action programs - they are, by definition, discriminatory.
I believe in parental choice - and responsibility - when it comes to educating their kids.
I do believe in maintaining our public school system, but not in the government setting the "agenda" or curriculum.
I believe in competition in the public school system, not the government monopoly that exists today.

I could go on, but if I missed any area of particular interest, ask away.

I will admit, however, if there is any inconsistency in my various positions, it's in the area of gay marriage. On one hand, my "individual liberty" position would suggest that it should be a personal choice. On the other hand, however, I believe that the "gay marriage" movement would be harmful to the efforts to maintain a strong family unit. I believe that a child, for example, is best off being raised by both a mother and a father. I would not, however, outlaw any sexual behavior at all, nor do I judge anyone for their sexual preference, as it's a matter of personal choice. This is an issue I have yet to totally reconcile within myself, and "could" be swayed to support gay marriage. At this time, however, I'm against it.

I might also say, that not all issues fall under one particular party's umbrella. If I have one hot-button issue, however, it's the first one on the above list. I was swayed to vote for Ross Perot in 1992 on the single issue of fiscal responsibility - my "hot button" issue. But like I said, I had a temporary lapse in judgement, and I let my emotions rule over my reason.

by maecuff

You are wasting your time. Garion obviously has an intellect rivaled only by gardening tools.

by pooksmin

Thanks ;-) Don't worry, I'm not going to bother anymore. I have been a member of TR for a good 3 years now - just never really got involved in discussions, especially ones like this as I joined this website to read about technology, not politics. I enjoy lively debates and interacting with people with different views but it really gets frustrating to hear people hurling foul-languaged abuse at one another (I'm to blame too). I'm quite sure that no-one in this discussion, even Garion, actually supports the murder of hundreds of thousands of people and most of just wish that the world had never come to this. If we actually sat around a table in person we'd probably be quite surprised at the faces behind the alias', we'd probably be civil to one another,and we might even strike up a couple of unlikely friendships. Who knows - see you around.....

by maxwell edison

.
Were you being intentionally evasive, or simply so intent on attacking me that you overlooked my question?

Since you called me "extreme right-wing", would you mind defining what you consider "extreme right-wing" and why you put me at that particular place on the political spectrum? While you're at it, would you please answer the same question regarding President Bush?

And please, no rhetoric, just logic and reason based on ideological principle.

by mrafrohead

The day that I discovered the truth that is spoken here, I was very sad.

I never thought that here in America that our government would lie to us. But they do.

Some may say they aren't lying, they just aren't including all of the facts, but to me, if you are hiding something then you're just lying.

There are a bunch of points that I could make, but it would fill the screen. If anyone really wants them, I'd be more than happy to fill them in.

Newho - I found this all to be true after this war started. Our press won't report a lot of what is actually happening. I have found that I need to be reading the news from outside of my own country because the news in my country is either not totally inclusive on what happened, or even just a blatant lie.

I honestly thought that we were better than that, and that we didn't have anything to hide...

What a sad thing this is...

mrafrohead

by oz_media

I seem to remember a completey different side of you, what happened?

I would be interested in asking you about some of the misinformation as I also have seen ome interesting things that I have never included here.

Peer mail me if you have time, I don't want to drag another rant out on TR, they segue too easily and the focus is lost (often by myself too).

by mrafrohead

Basically what happened is I started to read news outside of my own country and realized that what is said here isn't what is said every where else. Also I experienced on more than once occasion, something in the news that happened that wasn't the greatest of "moral boosters" happen to us, but wasn't reported by our news outlets, but it sure was every where else in the world...

I'll shoot ya a note and we can talk about it more.

by mrafrohead

@gralfus:

What you are listing above as censorship is true, but only covers part of it. Granted it is IMO the most drastic part of it, but there is still more.

IE... Just not reporting the truth.

Case in point:

Remember maybe a month ago, the three British POW's that were rescued??? Betcha didn't know that there were also 8 US POW's that were rescued. I have a friend that was involved in the mission. I knew about it WAY before it was reported. Even more than that, they did not report that there were any US troops. To discover that, you would have to research a foreign news agency.

Do you remember reading about when we had BinLaden cornered in the Afghan mountains??? I sure as hell didn't, at least not on any US owned papers. But I was able to read all about it on the foreign sites.

Not including facts because they may be seen in a slightly negative or even grey light is not appropriate. Either you include it all or you include nothing. And if you include nothing, you're still a liar as you know what is going on, but continue to say all is well when it is not.

I would have never expected this type of treatment to happen to our citizens in our own country, but it does go to show all of the conspiracy theory crap I have been reading as long as I can remember actually does have some credibility to it.

Mrafrohead

by mrafrohead

Telling the enemy our location is bad. But I don't think that that is what Oz is getting at.

From what I'm getting out of this, he is talking about just straight misinformation or not being told anything at all or just denying what is said.

Giving out coordinates and plans of actions about to take place isn't news. That would be strategy. Though if you had a few soldiers that were captured during the excercise, then that would be news and should be reported as we have a right to know that. Just not telling us is wrong.

Personally, I like to know whenever one of ours is captured. And by one of ours, I mean anyone on our side no matter where they are from. I am not a religious person in most of y'alls aspect, but I at least like the chance to wish to them luck and strength in their time of need and their families also. If it's not reported those wishes and prayers from others may not make it to them as we wouldn't know.

But not telling your countries own people that your troops have been captures/killed is BS if they are withholding the information because they are afraid it may look bad. Sometimes the truth just plain sucks ass, but it's still the truth and that's that.

Mrafrohead

by mrafrohead

Per OZ:
"Personally I don't think it's the governments bunsiness to diffuse what MAY change my feelings or decide what is appropriate to see and what isn't if my son or daughter is in a foreign land."

That's it right there...

When your government is "feeding" you information instead of letting you decide, that's just plain wrong.

With that happening, we may as well be in a communist country where we no longer have the right to our own opinion. I don't want my government making my opinion for me. I should be fed ALL information possible so I can make an educated opinion from the truth.

What is happening with our news right now is akin to the boy who cried wolf.

by mrafrohead

Would you honestly believe that your own government would lie to you?

I never did until I saw it with my own eyes. I still have a hard time believing it too...

But it did happen, and unfortunately that's that.

But when you talk of naive people or just stupid people, I don't necessarily think that that is what is going on. It's just that we trust our government and it's hard to believe that they would allow this type of thing to happen. Even though they may be the cause of it.

Hope that this helps clear things up a bit.

mrafrohead

by oz_media

My trowel has traveled with me for a long time, always there always ready to listen when I need a tool to chat with.

As for the hoe, well it has it's weaknesses as it thinks it's th emost important toll in the shed and if it weren't for him, the other tools would all just rust.

So while I give Garion less credit than a gravy boat (which can actualy be useful), I will say he in no way comes across as useful or as intelligent as my garden tools.

Although he does fit the descriptions, "not the sharpest tool in the shed" or "what a tool".

by oz_media

A little "piss ant" Canadian has attacked you with mere words??

Did you wake up today?

by maecuff

I truly meant no offense against your gardening tools.. I take it all back. How about this instead.. He has cognitive abilities equal to french fries?

by maxwell edison

.
Veteran gets rude welcome on Bainbridge
.
.
.
Walking the parade route with his mom, younger siblings and politically conservative friends, Jason Gilson, a 23-year-old military veteran who served in Iraq, heard words from the crowd that felt like a thousand daggers to the heart.

"Baby killer!"

"Murderer!"

"Boooo!"

----------

I'll bet CBS, NBC, ABC, CNN, The New York Times, The Washington Post, and other news sources don't report this story.

http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/jamieson/181422_robert09.html

by oz_media

It actually would create sympathy for the soldier as even I aree it is a completely ignorant action.

I think it may be a ood media approach for those that are supporting Bush to show such footage, it is almost Pro-America as there wouldn't be THAT many people who felt the same. The soldiers are fighting a war, thay didn't start it, they were sent to it, perhaps these ignorant people are suffering from vietnam protestor flashbacks (those were the hippies and Seattle still has a large population of followers of that era, just look at grunge and EMP).

I think these people represent the true left wing radicals you are all accusing others of being.

To Air such hatred toward what most people (including myself)consider heros will in turn create sympathy for them as well as support for GWB for supporting them.

This would be considered typical reverse reporting or reverse psychology.

by maxwell edison

.
I will admit that when I first saw that news story, I didn't initially think about news bias or political ideology, or anything even close. My first thought was of the devastation my own brother felt upon his return from Vietnam (after three months in a hospital) to the very same thing - only magnified a thousand times.

It's enough to make a grown man cry. I just can't imagine such mean-spiritedness.

by mrafrohead

Maxwell I find it quite interesting of ALL of the news sources that you pulled this off of a Seattle paper... It's where I'm from...

To comment on this particular post, I have to say this.

Those people that were reported in the article, you have something to say to the vets, I invite you to try to say it to me first.

I drive the white car with "I SUPPORT OUR TROOPS" painted on the back window. I'm always open to people that have something negative to say about our troops. Just waive me over, I'll make time for you.

I wrote that on my window when the war started because of all of the protests that were happening in my area, I wanted our troops to see something positive. I also wanted those pansie ass protesters to have a chance to really voice their opinion.

None have. I have found most of them to be cowards.

I'll close on this note, should anyone want to comment on what I write here do it to my face or not at all. My dad fought for your right to speak the filth that is spoken, but he also fought for my right to knock the teeth out of the cowards head that speaks the nonsense.

Mrafrohead

ps - those troops that are fighting aren't there because they want to be. everyone is entitled to their opinion, but THINK before you speak. they and their families are risking EVERYTHING for us to stay in our comfortable homes eating hot meals safely.

by jamesrl

Let me be clear, I didn't ever support the war(unlike some Democrats in the US who seem to have been on both sides).

But that doesn't mean in any way I blame the troops or think that anyone should harangue harass or abuse the troops. I heard some interviews of a protest outside of a naval base on NPR, and frankly I was disgusted. The troops did not vote for war - they had no opportunity to say no. They are risking their lives for whatever cause the president assigns them to. Their dependants should not be harrassed because they want to go on base to go to the PX.

And I will add that while the draft was on during Vietnam, Canada welcomed draft dodgers. And I don't have a problem with that. But those who joined the US military voluntarily should not be given sanctuary in Canada if they decide they don't want to fight. They didn't join a democratic institution, they joined the army, where you follow orders.

I understand your frustration - but knocking heads won't resolve anything and it will only further divide people.

I would also add that people have a right to free speech - and that doesn't mean just to have free speech only when you agree with it. You either believe in the principle or you don't. I believe those protesters at the naval base have a right to make their point, just not close up and personal in people's faces. Free speech should not include physical intimidation.

Frankly I think placard waving is overrated. Meaningful dialog doesn't take place at high volumes. The loudest voice isn't always right. I've walked through many crowds of demonstrators to get to meetings - if anything they turned me harder against their positions as opposed to changing my mind.

James

by oz_media

I suppose the difference is that MANY Canadians wouldn't be surprised that the government lies, in fact most people I know think the Canadian government is completely full of S**t. Nobody trusts the politicians here, sure they aren't 100% crooked but enough that nobody gives them the enefit of the doubt. Every country has a government, most have a corrupt government, we just think it could be worse I guess.

I for one have never thought for a second that there is a government on Earth that doesn't BS to achieve its motives, they look out for themselves, sometimes the people gain minor benefits that we chalk up as having a good government.

by garion11

Now butt out of my posts to other people, unless you feel that there HASN'T been enough attention on YOU. You know women love attention, Are you a woman Oz? Have you been deprived as a child, which leads to hijacking of all the threads by you? I noticed you post more than anyone in every political thread...Have you been to a psychologist recently?

"You simply epitomize the type of person described in another post I made about psychology and self assurance, personal fear and insecurity. Maybe you need to find yourself, before you start calling me more names, that is also the most common 'reflex' from that same type of person"

Who called you names? I called you names in other posts, there is a difference, you deserved those. Here I simply stated that Jules should spread the compliments around as I felt that I shouldn't take all the credit:). Now for once in your life atleast be honest about that.

by maecuff

Just wondering..why is it an insult to ask a man if he is really a woman? How is that a bad thing? I suppose we can add misogyny to your list of undesirable traits..

by oz_media

I'd never leave the house, I wouldn't even get out of bed, except for a soapy shower with a girlfriend, (hey I can believe whatever I want to okay?).

Sorry, I'll drop it there. ;-)

by oz_media

I knew your only reply would include slamming myself with derogatory comments.

"Now butt out of my posts to other people, unless you feel that there HASN'T been enough attention on YOU. You know women love attention, Are you a woman Oz? Have you been deprived as a child, which leads to hijacking of all the threads by you? I noticed you post more than anyone in every political thread...Have you been to a psychologist recently?"

Point made I suppose, you certainly fit the insecure.

by oz_media

As unfortunate as it is, every country has people like this. Too many people have simply seen opposirion to the war and not really understood why people are opposed. Therefore the radicals and extremists (if they are different) will automatically compare it to Vietnam, which was MUCH different yet just as ignorantly focused against the wrong people (those who did their duty to the country and not those who made it that way or why).

We will see this in any war eve when the groups are smaller un number, it must be expected as sad as it is.

This is another reason I have chosen to select WB as the reason behind my personal issues with Iraq. Only one man can make it happen when it really boils down to it, and it certainly isn't those who go to war, it's the 'one' who starts the war.

by maxwell edison

.
There's certainly a faction in America that is slanting news of events in a way that is favorable to the current administration. Conversely, there's a faction in America that is slanting news of events in a way that is not favorable to the current administration. Which is more prevalent? Well, I suppose it depends on where you get your "information" from.

However, if you look at the international news sources, you'd be hard pressed to find any that are particularly favorable to the current administration. Therefore what? Are you then going to decide to believe everything you read in the international press? In my opinion, one would be foolish to do so. I've shown, on more than one occasion, that this "international" press is so biased against the Bush administration in particular, and against America in general, that they resort to lies, mistruths, and misrepresentations. The example at the following link is only one such instance.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=155210&start=0&tag=search

(Read the whole thread to get the overall picture.)

While it's certainly a good thing to understand what others are saying and thinking about us, it would also be wise to have an understanding of why they are saying it, and what the motives of saying such things might be. That is not an easy thing to do.

However, a person in the USA can certainly get some balance in his or her quest for "the truth". If you read a story that originated in the New York Times, for example, read about the same thing in the Washington Times. If you read Time Magazine, look for some balance by reading National Review. If you watch CBS and Dan Rather on television, balance that with Tony Snow on Fox News.

If you're looking for one source to tell you the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, you may be searching for a long, long time.

The last thing I would rely on, however, are the words uttered by those in the international media. They have an agenda, to be sure. And one such example is a desire to have a "European Union" that rivals the strength (economic strength, in particular) of the USA, and one way to achieve that desired end is to knock the USA down a few notches. Don't just read "what" they are saying, but also consider "why" they might be saying it.

by mrafrohead

Maxwell,

I completely understand what you are saying and why you are saying it.

Though my experiences don't IMO have anything to do with either party or showing anyone in a different light.

My experiences are as below (OZ since I'm writing it now, I guess I won't need to send the e-mail ;)):

First, In Afghanistan maybe a year ago, we had BinLaden cornered. I read it in MULTIPLE foreign media outlets. Not once did I hear mention of it in the US.

I don't think that that would help or hurt anyone. It's just the news. But I couldn't find a thing on it in any US outlets.

The latter, which to me is much more serious.

We had three British troops (POW) recovered from Iraq a month or so ago. Did you know that there were actually eleven people recovered??? Eight of the eleven were US troops.

Did you hear of those eight US troops that were recovered in our news? I didn't. Granted, I don't follow the news religiously, but when something like that happens, I tend to monitor it a lot. I saw nothing, but I did see the three British people.

Now the funny part is this. Those eight troops that were recovered, I knew about that whole thing well before our news even started to show about the three British troops. I think it took about a week before that part even hit the news, but they left out the part about us being there...

Why is that? I don't think it would help or hurt anyone either. Well, actually, maybe it would help. I think it was more of a ploy to hide the fact that our troops had actually be captured.

The fact that they were recovered should have been a time to rejoice and IMO should have been covered. Not just for the troops that were saved, but also to recognize those that did the saving. A friend of mine was involved in the saving, that is how I knew about it...

Newho - I hope that this answers some questions...

Mrafrohead

by oz_media

"...we had BinLaden cornered. I read it in MULTIPLE foreign media outlets. Not once did I hear mention of it in the US.
Well I seem to remeber it being brought up in discussion herem but was VERY quickly dismissed (to the best of my recollection) as, they will not say for sure as it would jeaopardize any missions, but f he is found he WILL be captured. I think a FEW people even insisted that this proves they are effectively workin gto capture him and will very soon. But it was neither repeated nor followed up on. Just heresay from leftie activists I suppose.

As for the US and vritish troops, this is very controversial as a Canadian POW held in Iraq was set free apparently after the US had also agreed to free several Iraqi prisoners in trade for US soldiers. THis is unconfirmed in the US, under investigation in the UK, and the guy who was freed swears his life on it that he saw a document outlining that the US would 'TRADE' the releases. Yet nothing is confirmed, as always, any reason for doubt will cause reason to dismiss it entirely, if it is questioned it simply cannot be so.

Although the above is unrelated, it is not too favourable that America isn't making snow cones for the kids and having face painting afternoons at the schools. (Have you seen the US army website and the candy coated pictures on it? You wouldn't even think they were being shot at as they pose with happy kids that were probably fairly happy to be kids before)
The war is over remember? Just a few stragglers hanging on to a last thread, not terrorists and insurgents killing Americans every way they can, this is definitely not war in the sense of active combat.

Whether you had viewed all this and still agreed that you get the same news in the US as everywhere else is not important. The fact that you were open to an alternate opinion is what makes your opinions valid, the fact that you KNOW you are seeing a pretty side is valuable in validating your position too.

I understand the pro-war side completely, and even agree to it, in my opinion as it was not justified properly BEFORE sending troops to Iraq.

They now have to sabe face and to do that, you MUST censor the negative media and turn all the pro-war supporters against it so strongly that it will never be contested.

by maxwell edison

.
I've been on the "biased media" band-wagon for some time, citing example after example of how the main-stream media in the USA is not reporting what could be construed as good news from Iraq or Afghanistan. The "main-stream" media consists of the normal news outlets one might see - CBS (Dan Rather), NBC (Tom Brokaw), and ABC (Peter Jennings) on the 3 major networks, and The Washington Post, the L.A. Times, and the New York Times, the "source" from which most local newspapers get their stories. Local papers pull their stories down from these big three in the print media, and local television pulls their stories down from the three major networks. If that's all a person sees, you are absolutely right - the reader/viewer will not get the whole story, or in some cases, they won't get the story at all. (But for some reason, many people have not agreed with me. Oh well, to each his own.)

Heck, I knew about those things you mentioned, but I read the other sources I mentioned as well. The Washington Times, for example, carried that bin Laden Story, and I even started a discussion about it. It was interesting that the Washington Post or New York Times did not carry the story.

I'm not suggesting that you never read anything from the foreign media. To the contrary, it's good to read those guys. But I would never read ONLY those guys, I'd read the others - and more - that I mentioned as well.

Not a biased "main-stream" media??????

Case in point: Who was the last Republican presidential candidate endorsed by the New York Times?

New York Times Endorses Al Gore (2000)

New York Times Endorses Bill Clinton (1996)

New York Times Endorses Bill Clinton (1992)

New York Times Endorses Michael Dukakis (1988)

New York Times Endorses Walter Mondale (1984)

New York Times Endorses Jimmy Carter (1980)

New York Times Endorses Jimmy Carter (1976)

New York Times Endorses George McGovern (1972)

New York Times Endorses Hubert Humphrey (1968)

New York Times Endorses Lyndon Johnson (1964)

New York Times Endorses John Kerry?????? (2004).......I'd bet $10,000 on this - any takers?

Here's a great source to "weed out" media bias - bias by either slanting a story or by omission.

http://www.mediaresearch.org/

Happy reading.....

by maxwell edison

.
If you're looking for some "one-on-one" dialogue with someone outside the USA to discuss such things, I would suggest that you be very careful in dealing with our Canadian friend, OzMedia. He simply cannot be trusted. And you don't have to "believe me" either. All you have to do is take a look at his track record on these threads, and the "Real OzMedia" is as clear as day.

If you want some more level-headed conversation with one of our Canadian neighbors, I might suggest you shoot James Linn an email instead.

by oz_media

Must you be complete and blithering indiot in EVERY post you make? You NEVER offer anything but slams against myself and yet you accuse me of the exact same thing.

You are as many have said for a long time, TR's number one hypocrite. You constantly accuse everyone of doing exactly what you do and then pretend you have the most logical thought process and ADVISE people on how to avoid conflict. You are the BIGGEST hypocrite I have seen EVER, not just online. In fact for someone who claims to be open to possibilities, you are nothing of the sort and simply ONLY agree if people agree with YOU, yuor way or the highway.

You then blame me of the exact same thing, perhaps this is why I always say you are blind, you point a finger but don't understand that you are doing the same thing.

Maxwell, YUO have created mroe arguments over tha past few weeks than ANYONE including myself has in our history here. EVERY single posty from yuo is a negative blast of myself or anyone who thinks like me. You are a bully, overbearing, obnoxious, arrogant, incorrect, hypocritical etc., yet this is just another HATE speech from Oz against Max, the poor hard done by patriot who never causes any conflict, who is NEVER wrong, who is America's most favoured citizens.

You are the most tiring and incorrect person I have ever encountered, I have TRIED to play civilly with you and it is futile, you insist on turning every comment I make (even when I have outright agreed with yoru views) into a pissing contest. Give it up already, neither muself nor anyone else is interested, there's nothing to win and yyou just make yourself sound like a little beeeeatch.

If you want to go toe to toe and get it over with, I have offered to either come there or you are more than welcome to come here, I can wipe your miserable face over Canadian soil and be done with you, if not, shut the hell up and get on with your life you pansy ass little yank.
( apologies up front to Yankees, you aren't all as anal and blind to yourselves as Maxwell).

by maxwell edison

.
If you're looking for some "one-on-one" dialogue with someone outside the USA to discuss such things, I would suggest that you be very careful in dealing with our Canadian friend, OzMedia. He simply cannot be trusted. And you don't have to "believe me" either. All you have to do is take a look at his track record on these threads, and the "Real OzMedia" is as clear as day.

If you want some more level-headed conversation with one of our Canadian neighbors, I might suggest you shoot James Linn an email instead.

by oz_media

Well I poseted a half post but it never showed up, so as in many cases trhis will probably turn into a double post.

Now, mrafrohead knows VERY well who I am as we were actually opposed toe to toe on our opinions before. Yet I welcome his rebuttals because unlike yourself, he at least makes some sense without resorting to name calling and then posting ALL over TR about how HE has figured out who I am and nobody else is aware of my political position. Must you tend to your babies this way and demoralize them as ignorant or unable to stand up for themselves and reach their own conclusions by posting all over TR that YOU the great Maxwell has broken the code and knows all about me, which you have proven so many times you actually have NO idea who I am or what I stand for other than what I feed you. Why do YOUR former peers write me and give me kudos for not letting you bully the forums as you seem to enjoy so much?

Anyhow, mrafrohead is a big boy and can defend himself, for some reason you seem to think I am baiting him whilst I actually agree with him and he has been a MUCH bigger man than yourself, MUCH bigger for being able to open his eyes and realize you are mainly left in the dark (on many important issues) in the USA and that only the best is shown there, whether left or right wing reporting.

Since my first day here, that has been my only beef. GWB is full of S**t and you guys buy it like dime store candy. You simply cannot hear enough from him. Now if mr afrohead had looked at al sides and THEN deicided he still supported Bush, well so be it, he at least has a good stream of mixed information with which to base his comments on. He would also be completely able to understand the perspective of others who didn't see it his way and then offer his reasons for sticking to his guns. Instead of simply flaming the post or poster, discounting the sources and those behind them. THis, as you do so often, is not a heads up view that you seem to think you have (based on your core values and other retarded BS), this is an opinion based on what is happening and a view from several sides, not just "Mine is the best so even though they say otherwise, I stil like mine."

So go crap in your own backyard and let people get on with their lives. I honestly have never met a ruder and more ignorant human in my life, well there's Garion your pen pal but he's just a follower and knows it but still likes to play the game.

by mrafrohead

"Well I seem to remeber it being brought up in discussion herem but was VERY quickly dismissed (to the best of my recollection) as, they will not say for sure as it would jeaopardize any missions, but f he is found he WILL be captured."

This may very well be where I initially heard about it, but I verified it repeatedly. Checked and never saw it in our news. I read a lot from TechRepublic, but I do not consider it to me a news media outlet, therefore I don't count this as a source. I consider this as a place where friends shoot the poop...and learn!

In regards to paragraph 2 - they were not traded. I probably shouldn't know what I know about it, but I can honestly tell you that there was no trading. It was an infiltration and recovery and blood was spilled in doing so. There were over three camps that were raided to find these troops that were saved. I will leave it at this, as anymore could get my friend in trouble.

As for the war being over, not in my opinion. Maybe on paper it is. But paper can lie. Just look at my checkbook. I make it all work, but on paper it shows that I dont' make enough for my spending... ;p

Along with the fact that my cousin has been over there since the beginning... He is STILL in constant battle. He is STILL being shot at regularly, and I think that he thinks things are worse now than when we "technically" were at war.

by oz_media

I was referring to a very recent case where the reporter claims he was released after the US made a deal to release Iraqi prisoners in the USA for the release of himself and others from Iraq.

UK has seen the documentation and it supports the claims but has not been pubically released pending further incestigation.

He was actually quite pissed that he was traded for those much more harmful to society than himself, but is keepig his statement very vague as so many legal issues wsurround the case.

I didn't mean to imply this was related to the instance you spoke of but it does mirror the same 'coverup' or unreported acts that we often don't hear about, not because they jeopardize missions but because they are not favouring the US position.

by admin

Here's the irony to me. The people yelling, they pay taxes either income, sales or via some way they are financially supporting that soldier. I doubt all of them refuse to buy anything with a tax much less not pay income taxes. It is they, in fact, that should turn and hurl insults to themselves (hopefully in private) if they really believe these things.

If I knew that lads address I would send him a thank-you card. I am serious.

by generalist

If "Love is Blind" then "admin@133tcentral" wouldn't have mentioned that he didn't think that the country was perfect and that he felt that the media was skewed.

by generalist

It is common logic that the government would control information coming out of a war zone, especially if the information could be used by the enemy. Unfortunately, with modern communications, it is fairly easy to gather a lot of seemingly disconnected information and create a reasonably accurate picture of what is happening in an area. And if that information comes from the media of your enemy, then you have to spend fewer resources to gather it.

Of course, government control isn't the only type of control. A lot of American media is profit driven so additional censorship is applied to what makes it past the government censorship. And when you add in the lawyers, things get even more interesting.

Showing images of fallen Americans could easily drive a person away from watching the evening news or buying a newspaper. That would affect the bottom line so it isn't done often, unless there is some sort of newsworthy spin to it. This type of media control would NOT be at the government level.

Showing fallen Americans could also get the media in trouble with the legal profession, especially if family members find out that a loved one is killed before the military officially reports the death. A sharp lawyer and a grieving widow or widower can get a lot of sympathy from a jury and cause a lot of financial grief to a media outlet.

From a different viewpoint, media censorship by the media also means that the ratio of bad news to good news is skewed too. As a result, we get to see a lot of the sanitized bad news and very little of the good news.

Last, but not least, you have the most basic form of censorship, personal choice. If you don't like what you see, or if it is a pain to access, then you'll ignore it.

by admin

"Last, but not least, you have the most basic form of censorship, personal choice."

You win my vote for "best thought" in this. :)

I wish I would have thought to point that out. Ultimately it is we, ourselves, who provide the best most positive form of censorship. It would be nice if everyone worked on exercising it in a way that required less of it from our governments and media. I'm not holding my breath, but I will contribute as I am able. :)

by generalist

Claiming that a military organization has someone cornered is wonderful news fodder and can make attention getting headlines in lots of places.

It is also the height of media stupidity because it gives the cornered person or group a 'small' hint that they had better be VERY careful when moving around and that they might want to put more effort into getting out of the trap.

The 'cornered' comment reminds me of an instance in WWII where some good old American Congress critters claimed that the Japanese were having problems sinking American subs because their munitions weren't set properly.

The Japanese corrected their 'problem' and started sinking American subs.

Not long after that there was a complete news blackout on American sub activity.

This discussion is closed to new replies.