Discussion Locked

The war is over: let the peace begin.

0 helpful
138 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Well we have discussed the pros and cons of engaging in a war with Iraq; we have discussed the various events that unfolded during the course of the war; and now I am guessing that some folk would like to give their prognoses of what events may occur as a result of the war.

My only comment at this interim stage is that, when true self government is established in Iraq, some fanatical Islamic cleric may be the people's choice as leader, and try and turn the clock backwards.

138 replies

by oldefar

Iraq would not be the first country to choose temporary security over essential freedoms. Every democratic nation today faces that threat on a recurring basis.

Will the US now have a "Bush Doctrine" that serves as a deterrent to the most despicable types of leaders? Has a line been drawn in the sand? Syria has become a bit more agreeable, and North Korea is now backing down a little.

I don't think its rational to expect that from this point forward all will be right in the world. Allies will become enemies, enemies will become allies, freedom will grow in new places and die in old places. People will continue to be people. Maybe we have moved a tad ahead on the evolutionary path, maybe not.

At least today, the Iraqis have anopportunity for a better future. Another window has opened for Middle East peace. Now what's going on with Ireland?

by john_wills

If the U.S. were interested in democracy in the Middle East it would, before conquering enemy despotisms like Iraq, have stopped funding and arming other non-democratic states in the region. The Israeli state keeps a third of its citizenry in disefranchized exile on the grounds of ethnicity and religion; Kuwait disenfranchizes half its citizens on the ground of sex; Sa'udi Arabia and Qatar are even worse. Yet all these states buy lots of weapons from the U.S. So the U.S. is not mainly interested in democracy in Iraq either.
Although democracy is unpredictable, it is quite likely that a democratic Iraq would be more anti-Zionist than its despotic predecessors. Also, the longer the U.S. is engaged in Iraq the longer it will take for the U.S. "Free Palestine" movement to restart independent of the loony left. So we know what policies Jay Garner will be pursuing.

by mallardtooxx

okay simple equation.

Peace + Middle East = removal of nation of Islam/death of Christianity

This is in no way meant as a slight of the Islamic faith, nor is it a solution so before everyone goes up in smoke hear me out.

If the Middle east is to ever have rest there has to be a fundamental purging of the extremists. There can be no more suicide bombings, there can be no more Jihad there can be NO MORE SENSLESS VIOLENCE.
This War was justified and right, George Bush made a difficultand dangerous decision with grace and dignity. This is no longer an issue of the US vs. Saddam and Iraq it is a question of muslims vs christians again. We are on the verge of a modern crusade and with people like john spouting off is zionist crapyou know I am right.
This has nothing to do with politics anymore it is back to the basal claim made by the two religions, "we are the chosen ones" it matters not who speaks it or believes it. This war will never truly be over until one side beats the other and I am quite certain that will never completely happen, just ask the people of Jerusalem.

-duck

by john_wills

Mallard is thinking along the lines of someone from Al Qa'ida, but Al Qa'ida has it wrong. In yesterday's SF Chronicle was a picture of the Buddhist interment at Arlington of a soldier of the allegedly Christian U.S. When Al Qa'ida suspects reach Guantanamo they find a USN Muslim chaplain ready to lead them in prayers and do whatever else a Muslim chaplain does. On the other hand, Tariq Aziz, one of Saddam Hussein's top men, is a Christian, one of a small but old minority in Iraq, while Antun Samas, George Habash and Hanan Ashrawi, all prominent Palestinians, are also Christians, belonging to a large minority - for some centuries the majority.
It is fair enough that a member of any church claim his church's doctrines to be the right ones,but such claims need not lead to war. The Middle East had for centuries a better record of religious tolerance than Europe.
I throw out the opinion that if people have democracy they will line up on political - e.g. libertarianism vs communism - issues rather than religious ones, and gradually do so less violently. But it suits certain people that democracy not spread in the Middle East.

by mallardtooxx

only the point of democracy in the middle east. They have no want to be free of the ties that bind them and that is their choice.

You comparing me to Al Qa`ida is another thing altogether. First off, you have no basis, second you have no clue and third you have no proof. If my words ring of that terrorist group then you are needing to stop reading into what I say because you are way off base.
I can appriciate taking a stance based on your religion. That is okay, but in this day and age trying to connect my train of thought to that of AL qa`ida is really grasping. I see this for what it is a conflict of culture, I will not however try to act upon it by marching blindly to my death nor will I try to blow up innocents so i can get my vestal virgins from Allah. You my friend need to reappraise your statements, although you yourself are so blinded that you will say I am following my zionist masters when you don't even know what I believe.

The fact that I even felt compelledto respond to this refutes your statement proving it is not I but you who are wrong here bud. If I had their mindset I would say nothing and stab you in the throat with a smile, which do you prefer?

-duck

by jkaras

Call me a pessimist but there will never be peace in that region. The hatred taught as real fact will never change till the people are properly educated. The flaw in that plan is that during the war many Arabs from many other countries that were highly educated still had the blind hatred towards Isreal as the source of their problems. Further evidence is the study where arabic and jewish children were forced to spend a summer together where eventually they played with each other shedding their prejudice only temporarily. After they went back to the real world they still said they liked their counter part but they were still the enemy, that the retreat was only a utopian dream. The fact is we gave them their freedom, they didnt earn it any more then the French did. Since they didnt earn it they will never respect it and blame the short comings on us and not fully embrace it striving for a better tomorrow. If you want something bad enough you got to work at it and not have it handed to you. They will not see prosperity for years to come. Will there be a boom in tourism to Iraq? Will the poor be able to buy businesses? Who will pay for the education of the masses? These situations will not be easy with further war reparations imposed as all the previous debts erased from the Saddam regime. With no one wanting to take a risk who will invest? Certainly not Iraq itself further becoming dependant on other countries for support stoking the fires of resentment. Lastly the social change for female equality will rally other arabic nations to oppose or fear the impending change. I am sorry to admit this point and doubt I will ever witness this peace but I couldnt be happier to eat my words when proven wrong when this happens.

by oz_media

the US did such a horrendous and embarrassing job of 'infiltrating' Iraq (from Attack on Iraq (little resistance found), to Operation Iraqi Freedom? who are the US media trying to fool ??)
Typical American attitude, they MAY be a threat, if we're scared, we must kill people. (Kinda like L.A., killng each other out of fear).
Unfortunately, Bush thinks that the Wild West still exists, this redkneck thought process has created a big mess that the rezst of the world foresaw and avoided. Well....you're on your own now, time to clean up and build a new Iraq.
Good luck ! I just wish the US government knew how to run their own country before dictating how others run thiers.

by maxwell edison

And this is from a guy who thinks the USA did not “win” World War II,

https://www.techrepublic.com/forumdiscuss/thread_detail.jhtml?thread_id=123935&message_id=747626

and only had a “somewhat” important role.

https://www.techrepublic.com/forumdiscuss/thread_detail.jhtml?thread_id=120523&message_id=725618

(What would the outcome have been had American sat on the sidelines?)

Your anti-American sentiment and continuous America bashing is growing old. Why don’t you stuff a sock in it?

by sullyman

WWII was won by the Allies, not solely by the US. We will never know the outcome of WWII without US involvement, we can hypothesize, simulate, and debate but the answer will never be known. People can write all they want about the US involvement, support, dollars, commitment (reluctant at that), but at the end of the day the Allies won the war. It was a team effort, and there is no I in team. (Corny I know)

When the US is trying to sell a war to the world, they talk about coalitions. But, when the war is over the US wants all the credit. By claiming the US won WWII,you are in fact disrespecting the veterans of the allies that fought that war.

by sullyman

My views are not secret on the whole war, but come on get a clue. The US military performed a nearly text book invasion, the precision and timing displayed has not been seen ever in the history/art of war. As far as the rest of the world cleaning up the US mess, let me point out that it was a coalition that invaded Iraq not solely the US. Now, you do have a very small point about US policy, but that thread has been beaten to death so moving on......

by admin

funny thing, eh? We keep killing people down there and they keep hating us. Hopefully this round of diplomacy will go better, either that or pick one name out of a hat of three and kill everyone else.

Self government and Theocracy are always at odds. Check out Cromwells work in the west.... That's the problem with the false freedom that claims anothers action are preventing them to be free from what THEY want to do. Democracy doesn't work without a healthy dose of tolerance. Unfortunately, the Middle East seems to be historically short on tolerance.

by hereinoz

The Middle East short on tolerance? Indeed true. Unfortunately, so is Maxwell when confronted by another's opposing view.

There are, no doubt, some highly altruistic people in the US wanting the world to be a better place, but after 40 years ofwatching the US play International Policeman, we in the rest of the world are getting tired of their subterfuge and double dealing too. Do we want an International Policeman? Probably a good idea, and one that is great for peace, but do we want onethat is prepared to let despots like Pol Pot in Cambodia, Pinochet in Chile, and Saddam Hussein in Iraq (in the 80's) do their worst because it suits the US, but take out the regimes that don't do or say the right thing.

A very complex issue, notthe simple Clint Eastwood / John Wayne type of thing that some of the US media would have us believe.

Let's hope the US can do their best for Iraq and really benefit the Iraqi people. Having been quite scathing of the US's motives in the past, and being still suspicious of them, I don't envy them a very difficult task of resurrecting a country that really doesn't want to be a united country in the first place.

Alan

by maxwell edison

When a non-American spews his anti-American venom in the most insulting and questionable manner to a mostly American audience, it's called giving opinion. But when an American stands up and challenges the veracity of such talk, it's called intolerance.

What's wrong with this picture?

by maxwell edison

On one hand you summarize the foreign policy of the United States in a very simplistic (and very inaccurate, I might add) manner. On the other hand you say it's a very complex issue. Which is it?

And again, what's wrong with this picture?

by admin

As far as Max goes, well, I want everyone to know that I in no way was trying to say he was intolerant in the above post. While I disagree strongly that Patriotism and seeking peace are opposites and believe that supporting ones country sometimes does and sometimes does not call for war, I don't harbor anything against Max. I think he was hurt deeply at one time by anti-war protestors and carries this and I tried to point it out as a friend, never meaning to become the arch nemesis (or vice versa) of the one with deadly silver hammer.
Well, anyhoo, Peace and Patriotism go a lot better in my opinion whenever possible and I don't care who speaks out against peace, saying that those in the military don't believe this (ask 20 of your military friends privately if they would prefer to 1. go into battle or 2. not have to and you will find the reluctant, yet 100% willing and efficient soldier is the very epitomy of a good citizen military) but I know that the majority do prefer peace when possible. Most of the people who really are trigger happy are screened out.

by admin

The thing that really puts me off is when I hear sayings that put people in boxes they don't fit in. It's easy to try and depersonalize someone and say they are Muslim or White or Right Wing or a geek or any other way of cramming someone into an image you can write off, ignore, kill or torture and not feel bad about doing it. I don't like this process and will speak against it wherever I see it. That includes Max. I think he tolerates a lot, and is obviously a survivor. I respect that is peoplewho put people in boxes they don't fit in. It's easy to try and depersonalize someone and say they are Muslim or White or Right Wing or a geek or any other way of cramming someone into an image you can write off, ignore, kill or torture and not feelbad about doing it. I don't like this process and will speak against it wherever I see it. That includes Max. I think he tolerates a lot, and is obviously a survivor. I respect that and appreciate having him here. :)

by maxwell edison

We all know about the anti-American and anti-war sentiment that was has been so widespread all across Europe of late. Without getting into the particular details and debating points, it’s too bad that the source(s) many Europeans got their information from – the information on which their opinions have been formed – was, shall I say, quite tainted.

How was it tainted, you might ask? Well, one of the people leading the charge against the United States was Great Britain’s Labor Party Member of Parliament, George Galloway. Of course, we all know that when someone like that speaks out in such a controversial way, newspapers and television news outlets all across Europe (and elsewhere – including the U.S.) would pick up the stories, editorials written on those stories, and more stories were born from the original. And as the old saying goes, a lie will travel 10,000 miles before the truth puts its shoes on.

As it turns out, the “honorable” George Galloway was on the payroll of Saddam Hussein, to the tune of 3 million dollars a year, for the past 10 years.

http://www.mrc.org/cyberalerts/2003/cyb20030429.asp#1

Another lie that has traveled more than 10,000 miles is the one about the United States supplying arms to Iraq. The real fact is that from 1978 up to now, France, Germany, China and Russia accounted for almost 90% of arms sales to Iraq – many of those sales in direct violation to UN sanctions. While the United States, on the other hand, accounted for LESS THAN 1%, and none after 1990. (The remaining 9% being divided among other nations.) Does anyone want the source for that claim? Well, either find it yourself, prove me wrong, or wager me $100 dollars and I’ll provide links to scores of sources. (U.S. dollars, since it’s the American economy that props up the entire world.)

I’m not the intolerant one. All I’m d

by hal 9000

Looking at Europes relutance to become involved in a conflict in the Middle East.

Put simply if the conflict was to get out of hand with a massive influx of Islamic fundimalists then Europe would have felt the force of this and not the US which is half a world away. It's very easy to start something especially when you know it can't come and bite you on the BUM but the countries of Europe didn't have that luxioury did they?

by maxwell edison

Sullyman,

Your point is well taken. I should have phrased my rebuttal a bit differently so as to include ALL the forces involved.

However, my point was that the U.S. had much more than simply a "somewhat" important role. I would consider it amost vital role - in fact, THE MOST vital role. True, the war was not "won" by only the U.S., but it surely would have been lost without it.

(Somehow I can't help but think that you really did know my point and you were just being rather nit-picky. But that's okay. I'm rather nit-picky myself when it comes to "accuracy in reporting".)

Regards (and yes, you may call me),

Max

by tomsal

As an American citizen, with a great respect for our armed forces, whose grandfather served in WWI, WWII and the Korean war, and who has a fondness for WWII history in general -- I agree with you.

It irks me when people say USA won WWII, or that any single country won any war for that matter.

WWII was proof-positive of what kind of power can come from teamwork. The allies during WWII represent one of the most powerful military forces in the history of the world. This was largely due to teamwork, communication and all serving a common goal with intense committment.

God bless the military of the world -- sure some of the world's militaries want my country destroyed and me dead as an American citizen -- but from their POV they are protecting their families, their loved ones -- self-sacfrice on that level is simply too powerful for words.

by oz_media

As a self appointed Site Moderator, you should spend more time learning social skills and stop reading SCi-Fi.
Links in your previous posts are dead.
I couldn't see if you were implying that I had problems finding work or not with your post regarding my work as a motivational speaker.
If so, I have NEVER been out of work for more than a day or two since I turned 18, and yes I was a speaker for several employment agencies, youth programs and sales training agencies. You seem to be really upset when someone doesn't agree with your point of view, blind as you may be, you still have your opinion (TR's message board would be blank without it). Someone had agreed somewhat with my opinion that the US refused to enter into WWII until they were threatened and now say that the US WON WWII, this seems to upset you and caused you to post dead links to my previous posts. This is pathetic!
My 11 year old son has better debating skills than that. Start the pickup and load up the shot gunsfor some coon huntin, sure you're gonna find a lot of like minded pro American patriots out there. Too bad really, I used to love the USA but dudes like you have really screwed it up for the millions of intelligent citizens in your country by posting uneducated and quite ignorant opinions. Hilter had overrun MOST of Europe before the US entered the war, thanks to your late attention, this advance was turned around and inevitably the Germans were pushed back by the sheer size of the Allied armies.
Hitler had not successfully advanced into England because of the logistics and manpower required to cross the English Channel,he was nearly in a stale mate condition by the time the US joined hundreds of thousands of OTHER countries troops to invade Normandy. I guess Canada didn't even show up, in your opinion.

by hal 9000

You've really done it now you've managed to upset poor old Max and you will never hear the end of it. But I did like the way you avoided the inevitable question of "Why Did America Enter WW11" it wasn't because they where the slighest bit interestedit was because the Japs Bombed the shit out of Pearl Harbour that got them interested otherwise they would have remained netural and continued to make money by selling weapons to any buyers. It's kind of like Sept 11 someone gave us a bloody nose sowhere going to pile the shit on them but this time they didn't have a country to attack so they have just made up enemies who arn't in a position to fight back. Why do you think they have left North Korea alone they got their fingers burnt 50 odd years ago and don't want it to happen again. Then worse was to happen the invinicable warlords of the US actually lost a fight in Nam. They then settled down and learnt their lessons now they only attack a country that is incapable of defending itself against the all conquering US army. Even in WW1 they had to have one of their cruise ships sunk before they would become involved. So they arn't the Worlds Policemen but nothing more that the School Yard Bully who throws a temper tantrumn if they don't get their own way. They have consistintly used the UN to justify their actions in the Middle East and now they want to ignore the UN and get the sactions removed from Iraq without first going through the requirments of the UN. A tiny bit hyprocialdon't you think.

by maxwell edison

You said, "..it wasn't because they where the slighest bit interested it was because the Japs Bombed the shit out of Pearl Harbour that got them interested otherwise they would have remained netural and continued to make money by selling weapons to any buyers." (sic sic sic sic)

Now will you do me a favor?

Do a little research on something called "lend lease" (late 1930's - early 1940's), and then repost your opinion.

(The "lend lease", by the way, was actually "give away". But you'll find that out on your own - if you do the homework.)

by hal 9000

Netural = Greedy?

All that I said was that the US was remaining netural until Pearl Harbour was all but destroyed durring WW11 I can't find any reference to greedy in the posting and I'm looking at it now.

As far as the US not being paid for war materials by Australia well your wrong there admittelly they may not have recieved much in the way of money but they did recieve payment in Kind as they removed most of our telcomunications equiptment and took it back to America along with other items of interest to them, and I didn't have to look it you as my father was directly involved in this and he often told what and how the loans where repaid to the US {before he died] after the war ended.

Then there where the war reperations derived from the Axis states which almost completly whent to the Americian Government, so the US wasn't all that much out of pocket after it was all over but from your comments it seems to me that you have rewritten history in a similar marrer that Japanhas as their school students learn nothing about Japans involvment in WW11.

by hal 9000

How much the US pays Australia for the use of land in the middle of Australia as a rental/lease I think the place is called Pine Gap and it's one of the biggest US bases outside of America sure it doesn't have that many troops stationed there but itdoes have an international airport where Australian Customs are not required for any incoming/outgoing aircraft {this required an Act of Parliment} then there waas the Development of the Holden which the Australian Government paid for and built a production facility and then 2 weeks before mass production was to begin in a deal with the Americian Government it was sold to GM for 1 Pound {that was about $2.00 US then} and there where numerious other companies sold off to the US directly by our Goverment through your Government for far less than their value. This pratice continued on until the Mid to Late 60's.

Then there was the purchase of the F1-11's before they where anything more than a drawing on a piece of paper {which incidently where given to the US by the British as they where only interested in building the Harrier and the Sparrow designed by Barnes Wallace was given to the US and renamed the F1-11} and didn't the CEO of McDonnald Douglas go to jail for breach of contractin supplying a substandard wing root pivot in the F1-11?

So before the kettle starts calling the pot black you should know what your talking about.

by thechas

I find it interesting that many Texas based companies already have contracts to work on rebuilding the infrastructure in Iraq.

Should the US government, or a new Iraqi government be in charge of who rebuilds the country?

Aside from capping anydamaged oil wells, I don't see any justification for US based firms to be first in line to profit from the destruction.

Interestingly, a couple of articles even pointed out that Iraq does not have enough oil to pay for the rebuilding.

Further,will the US need to maintain an occupation force in order for the US companies to get the lion's share of the work?

We are already seeing the people of Iraq protesting the US occupation. How long before we let them run their own country?

Chas

by admin

"How long before we let them run their own country?"

The only possibilty for the Middle East to have self government that I see possible is, ironically, for the people in America to rise up and Democratically demand that we stop our policies of preemptive action and profiteering in the Middle East. They aren't strong enough to do it themselves. They don't have the advanced weapons, they don't have the resources. Instead of keeping them weak, I hope that we all start to use our strength for Healing, Peace, and Justice. When enough of us do, our leaders will have to follow.

The truly strongest person is the one who builds true strength in others. ~

by jardinier

Yet again, a discussion that was started off on a serious note has degraded into a personal mud slinging match.

However I will add a few non-personal comments about Aussies. But please bear in mind that I was born in 1941, there were no war casualities in my extended family, and history was my worst subject at school. So I appeal to everybody to overlook any minor digression from the facts.

I can assure Max and anyone else that Australians are MOST grateful for America's contribution to WW II. While our brave diggers held up their end in the jungle fighting against the Japanese, without America's intervention we would quite likely all be speaking Japanese now. Similarly if the UK has not won the Battle of Britain when their air powerwas outnumbered by the Germans by a ratio of ten to one, as far as my memory serves me, The English would all be speaking German.

by davehoskins

Well, I am only speaking now as a combat Marine Veteran of Viet Nam, and had the pleasure of working with some of your diggers there. And, they were great to work with. Good people, good fighters, and of course, good at partying when the time was right. And, in reference to the mud slinging that I have read in this discussion leads me to believe that there are some people that are definitely educated beyond their intelligence.

by jardinier

The people of Australia seem to suffer from an anti-hero syndrome.
Our folk hero is Ned Kelly ... an outlaw and bushranger.
Our favourite song, "Waltzing Matilda" is about a hobo who committed suicide when sprung for possessing stolen goods. And this song was touted as a replacement for the British National Anthem, until common sense prevailed and "Advance Australia Fair" was chosen.
We commemorate the memory of our fallen war heroes on Anzac Day, April 25, when the landing at Gallipoli, based I think on incorrect intelligence or directions from central command, led to one of most outstanding and tragic bungles of the war.
A favourite national pastime is knocking down tall poppies, be they politicians or successful entrepeneurs.
Yes, we're a strang lot.

by maxwell edison

And now you can buy shares of stock in a brothel - yes, a brothel - on the Australian stock exchange! It may be a good investment, but I do wonder about some things:

It kind of puts a new meaning to a rising portfolio, doesn't it?

I'd like to see their assets list.

What's the latest Market Maker Spread?

Will there be a lot of splits.

Can you buy a call option?

A lot of mergers are anticipated, I assume.

And then there's all that insideher trading going on.

by jardinier

While I presume your posting is intended to be humorous, it has inspired me to point out that quite apart from the idiosyncrasies mentioned, Australians are also a very creative and innovative lot. [See the item "Clever Australians" on the Science News page of my website. And the items listed are merely a sampling of original Australian inventions and scientific advances.]

As prostitution is so frequently referred to as "the oldest profession," it does not surprise me in the least that it has taken an Australian to give it due recognition as such in the world of business.

by hal 9000

The shares in question where originally sold at 50 cents each and by the close of trade today they had more than doubled in price to $1.08 per share. It seems that someone knows when there on a good thing and what is even more interesting is it wasInternational Investors who bought most of the shares traded.

I particuarly liked the bit about Insider Trading it seems that we have learnt far more from the Americians that what is good for us.

by hereinoz

What I am saying Maxwell is that foreign affairs ad the international situation is a very complex issue, not the "With us or with the Terrorists" simplistic theme that George has espoused.

Does that make my point clearer, and the picture less fuzzy?

Alan

by theboomanchu

After reading through many of these posts, I am blown away how many of you have such a problem with military action. First of all, how many of you have the inside intelligence of our Commander-In-Chief?

Second, do you think that the freedoms we enjoy today came from being "nice" and "politically correct"? NO! They came to us because we have fought over the years to maintain the freedom that we had to fight for to obtain in the first place.

If our leaders in the late 30's had had the foresight that our present Administration has, and had intervened earlier, 6 million Jews, as well as many others would not have had to die.

Too bad France and Germany don't (didn't) support us in this action. France needed "Proof". The last time, the "Proof" marched into Paris under a NAZI flag. As far as Germany, I guess they have nothing to gain from it themselves.

If you think we are absolutely wrong in what we have done, I invite you to move out of this country (where you have thefreedom to say what you think, largely because of this type of action) and move to one of these middle east countries. Then try to voice your distaste for what the government is doing. You will be killed!

One other thing I would like to say. If we are ever in another conflict, and you are one of those who want to be a "Human Shield" for enemy soldiers, let me know, and I will gladly buy you a one-way plane ticket to your destination!

by sullyman

Question?

How did the military action in Iraq ?Protect? our democratic right to free speech?

by sullyman

You said

Snip- If our leaders in the late 30's had had the foresight that our present Administration has, and had intervened earlier, 6 million Jews, as well as many others would not have had to die. -snip

How can you make a certain statement like this? If the US had entered WWII earlier, who knows what have happened. The Germans might not have attacked Russia, thereby the AXIS army would have been close to 2x larger than it ended up being. You can make assumptions, but making statements about the past that have no historical fact behind them is way out in left field.

by theboomanchu

I will agree that it is a bold statement, although it is no more assuming than your reply when you said "thereby the AXIS army would have been close to 2x larger than it ended up being". The fact remains that over 6,000,000 people died at the handsof a madman, and probably would have not, had we intervened earlier. If we had taken a "no war" point of view, it is very possible that most of the world including ourselves would be speaking German, and living under "The Third Reich" From what history shows in the short life of "The Third Reich", human rights were virtually non-existant. Likewise with Iraq, the human suffering under Hussein was immeasurable for over a decade. The only thing we should have done different, was finished it during the gulf War.

by hal 9000

Why stop at Iraq if your only excuse is the liberate the people in the Middle East? There are numerious other countries in the Middle East who are as bad if not worse than what the previous Iraq Government was. Why not just invade the whole Middle East to free all these people from the oppression that they are suffering under? Remember that most of the people involved in what happened Sept 11 cam efrom Saudie Arabia so why not invade them as well even Ben Laden is one of their citizens {if he still lives}.
The rubbish about Iraq having Weapons of Mass Destruction seems to have already been answered as if they had these weapons surrely they would have used them on a force that they had no chance of defeating if they had of used these weapons they might of evended things up a bit if only for a short time. But more to the point why attack Iraq when Nort Korea is far more of a threat to your country and every country around it as well? Could it be that the US is still smarting from the conflict that they endured 50 odd years ago and can't bring themselves to start it all up again? Or could this country actually be in a position to fight back?

by thechas

The US is now in pretty much full control of Iraq.
So, how come we have not found any solid evidence of the WMD?

Could it be that this military action was actually part of a complex plan to provide profit opportunities for Bush and Chenney's oilindustry friends, along with the bonus of a re-election boost?

In general, I am not opposed to a justified military solution. However, I see no clear justification for the action in Iraq that could not be applied to numerous other countries.

As the last of the 'super-powers', the US has a responsibility to use it's power justly and wisely.

Chas

by hereinoz

Spot on, Chas.

I find I have been asking myself this same question recently.

Now you won't get an argument from me about the fact that S. Hussein was a mongrel, and Iraq generally will probably be better off without him.

But I do also wonder, given the ease with which the "Coalition of the Willing", of which my country was/is a part, over-ran the Iraqi army, how much of a threat did this country pose to world peace in any case.

If no WMDs, and no significant threat, and no altruistic desire to give the Iraqis a nicer place to live, why did it happen in the first place??

And here is the contentious bit:
Is it perhaps designed to take the people's mind's off the parlous state of the US domestic economy?

by generalist

There is always the possibility that Iraq has been developing WMDs but destroyed them and much of their supporting evidence before the first explosions hit. That would be one explanation of Iraqi reluctance to let inspectors in and cooperate fully with them.

Think of WMDs as being a poisoness pea in a shell game. The WMDs get moved around as the inspectors get closer to guessing where they are. People watching the shell game and the inspectors get a little suspicious when they see odd things going on behind the scenes.

When the 'cops' arrive to shut down the game, the poisonous pea is destroyed or hidden in odd places and replaced by a normal pea. The operator of the game yells 'Police brutality' and the 'cops' have to deal with the politics of defending themselves to the rest of the world.

Of course the poisonous pea does leave traces that are hard to find. And that evidence is not as dramatic as finding a missle filled with nerve chemicals or weaponized smallpox.

I suspect that if the above scenario is true, we'll start finding odd things happening like contaminated wells and plague hot spots. We may even find containers with WMD substances hidden in containers of mere hazardous wastes.

by maxwell edison

http://www.cia.gov/cia/publications/iraq_wmd/Iraq_Oct_2002.htm#01

or

http://tinyurl.com/attq

----------

http://www.iiss.org/news-more.php?itemID=88

or

http://tinyurl.com/attv

----------

http://cns.miis.edu/research/wmdme/iraq.htm

or

http://tinyurl.com/atug

----------

http://www.cdi.org/terrorism/iraq-wmd.cfm

or

http://tinyurl.com/atuq

----------

Chas, do you want to wager $100 that they will be found - and showcased to the world? When will it happen, you ask?

My guess is that the proof will be provided just after the Democrats (especially Tom Daschle) go ballistic and very public questioning it - making big fools of themselves, of course - and it will happen closer to the 2004 elections than to today, perhaps in February or March of 2004.

GW is a very honest and honorable man, to be sure (unlike his predecessor), but he's also a very savvy politician. And he's going to love watching the Dems bite themselves in the ass on this one.

by admin

But I do have a problem with my government taking away the rights of it's citizenry through the threat of a constant enemy in a perpetual war that respects no International boundaries whatsover.

As you have said: "First of all, how many of you have the inside intelligence of our Commander-In-Chief?" and I am sure I don't really everything that is going on. Growing up in a military intelligence household gave me a healthy perspective on this. We may well have been justified in Iraq and everything is not released yet. The Commander in Chief has the responsibility to weigh the citizens voices with this intelligence and act accordingly. This is proper. However, I still strongly disagree with the absolutely childish inane nonsensical addresses and information that is being released. If they can't tell us, well, so be it. This is necessary at times and we understand this as a people. However, after it is safe to release the information, it should be released. In the meantime we shouldn'tbe threatened with generalities, smoke, and mirrors.

The reason IMO that people at TR are generally more thoughtful about these actions is the reverse of what you are saying. It is because we are TRULY patriotic and love our country and people (including those outside the US who contribute) so deeply that we do not want to see it marginalized or become a nightmarish war-mongering bully. We instead want to retain input into our government as responsible citizens and lead it into a direction of peace and prosperity whenever possible. We are generally intelligent critical thinking people in this field and if by "good US citizen" you mean: "act stupid", well- NO thanks!

Someone once said: "What good fortune for the government that the people do not think." hmmmmmmmmm..... who was that??????

by hal 9000

Its coments like this that make it worth reading through some of the other stuff.

It good to see that there is some sembelance of Common Sence in the Good Old US and it's a great pitty that there arn't more like you.

by theboomanchu

That my friends was Adolf Hitler.

I agree Admin, and I would like to add that in my opinion, there has been way too much media coverage of the war. I do not want to bury my head in the sand by any means, but the world politics is the reason I vote for those I vote for. I don't have the smarts nor the inside intelligence to even think I know what the best thing for us to do as a country is in a situation like this. How can any executive decisions be made based on public opinion, when the vast majority of the public base their opinions on those of the liberal media? How can any of us truely know whats going on half a world away, when the only info we get is from a source that is biased.? Personally, I would rather not have to sit down after working all day, to watch a little TV, and have to listen to a play by play script of the actions going on. I would Rather hear on occasion when there are some headlines about a major victory or defeat.

On another subject:

I also have a very difficult time dealing with absurd regulations which compromise MY liberty coming about because of something unrelated. IE, Airport Security increases and it is now illegal for ME to even bring a nailfile or clippers on an airplane because terrorists hijack planes with PLASTIC (non-detectable by security means).

In response to the hijackings, K-mart pulled and will no longer sell ammunition. In response to that, K-Mart will never see my shadow again.

COME ON AMERICA, WAKE UP! Ifwe don't stop this kind of Bulls&%t, it won't stop

by maxwell edison

On 11th March 1941, the U.S. Congress passed the Lend-Lease Act. The legislation gave President Franklin D. Roosevelt the powers to sell, transfer, exchange, lend equipment to any country to help it defend itself against the Axis powers.

A sum of $50 billion was appropriated by Congress for Lend-Lease. The money went to 38 different countries with Britain receiving over $31 billion. Over the next few years the British government repaid $650 million of this sum. (What is that, about 2.5 cents to the dollar?) How much did the other countries repay? Do you want to guess?

While you're researching this, find out the amount that went to Australia, and how much you guys paid back. That's a challenge for you, Colin. Are you up to the task?

Now what was that you were saying about the "greedy" Americans "selling" weapons to "anyone" before WWII?

Take it back, Colin, and redeem yourself. Or, if you prefer, ramble and babble on as the fool you appear to be.

by admin

the world would have probably saved us when our resources ran out. The reason we didn't join though, was quite different. Many many people with influence in America supported the NSDAP as it seemed in sync with many American ideals.

Check into the private financing by George Herbert 'Bert' Walker if ya don't believe me...
Do some searches on G. H. Walker and Company, Union Banking, Harriman & Company and Brown Brothers around 1930.

Of course if you don't recognize Bert, you might recognize his son-in-law and major right hand man and employee, Prescott Bush.

So, if we got in early, we of not only not had enough weaponery stashed, we would have not had near the financial resources yet either... 2 things that are extremely helpful to winning a war.

by cactus pete

Max, I think you'd enjoy reading "The Coming War with Japan" from the late 80s. Obviously, you won't agree with all of what's in there, but I think you'll find it interesting - particularly the whys they give for the participation in WWII.

by maxwell edison

I have heard of that book, but never did read it. Perhaps I'll look for it in the near future. Whether or not I agree with it, however, may surprise you. (And I assume you meant Japan's reasons for the war.) From my recollection of WWII history, my short answer for the attack on the naval fleet docked at Pearl was in retaliation for a couple of things.

First there was the United States' support and aid to China, who was battling Japanese aggression into Manchuria and mainland China. And atthe same time the American government imposed an embargo and economic sanctions against Japan - aircraft, armaments, and so forth - AND gasoline AND OIL. Japan was being choked and starved in their need for the dreaded barrel of OIL (Japan has - andhad - virtually zero domestic oil production capability.), and they occupied what is now Indonesia for control of their vast oil reserves. In addition to the U.S. cutting off their supply of OIL, the naval fleet parked at Pearl posed a threat to their occupation of the Dutch East Indies (Indonesia) - and their need for OIL.

So that's my short answer.

by hal 9000

Maybe I'm wrong but I thought that what is happening in Iraq is only Part 2 of the War on Terror. First there was Afganistan and then Iraq whats next?

And China isn't a threat at the moment as they have a big enough problem of their own making called SAR's which will hold them back for years so this and the Country Leaders will do quite a nice job of holding back development in China so they will not be a real threat for a very long time if ever. However North Korea is a different story right?

by hal 9000

Our current Prime Minister is comming over there or is already there so you you keep him for us?

No wait a minute that's prpbably not a good idea as if he was to stay there in the US it would leave Abott & Costello in charge over here and those two bear no resemblance to the Americian pair who where so very funny.

by maxwell edison

Pine Gap is nowhere near the largest military facility outside the United States. In fact, it’s not really a military facility at all, but rather an intelligence and reconnaissance facility operated primarily by the CIA. It collects and interprets satellite data, and – as some believe – is used as a staging area for contact with extraterrestrials. It employs about 1,000 people, many of whom (but I can’t really confirm this) are probably Australians. I would even guess that many of them are Australian technology professionals. (Now this is an “on-topic” message.)

In addition to the lease payment made to the Australian government, private Australian citizens receive payments for the lease of their privately owned land. In addition, the facility is a source for economic prosperity for the local residents of Alice Springs. For example, local companies are contracted annually to supply goods, services, and labor for the facility. In addition, local contractors were hired to construct the facility and provide roads and support services.

Bases outside the United States (and inside, for that matter) are ALWAYS a boon to local economies. In addition to the added security provided by the presence of United States military personnel, the economic windfall is another reason why so many countries are more than happy to host them. Often times when a U.S. base closes, the local economy literally dries up. So tell the residents of Pine Gap that we say, you’re welcome.

I called President Bush on his private cell phone and asked him how many millions of dollars we pay the Aussies for the land lease agreement at Pine Gap. He said that he would have to check with the general accounting office, but whatever it was it was too much. He did say, however, that in addition to those payments, John Howard has promised to polish his cowboy boots once a month.

by maxwell edison

By the way, the F-111 was designed and created by General Dynamics Corporation (of the U.S.).

http://tinyurl.com/atn1

http://tinyurl.com/atk8

Provide a source for your "designed by the British" claim, or remain as you are - appearing to be full of hot air.

In addition, the design for the Harrier is credited to British aeronautical engineer Sir Sidney Camm of the (British) Hawker company. The U.S. Marines have about 100 of these.

http://tinyurl.com/atl8

Call it full of hot air, blowing smoke, living in the fog of ignorance, or simply misinformed and misguided, you sure do come up with some, shall I say, interesting fabrications.

by cactus pete

Well, the coming war with Japan, as a title, is a huge conception to ponder... Your short answer is, of course, correct - but where they go with the likely future is fundamentally a left field hypothesis. Akin to "What if the US had never entered WWII?" Just setting you up for the potential let down...

by admin

I did not previously realize you were such a close personal friend of President Bush!

You must be from West Texas. Growing up my young life around Del Rio, I understand the closeness and common thinking of the people there. I was actually quite removed socially as my Father was in Military Intelligence and my Mom and I hung out with the other families that had loved ones in Southeast Asia most of the time, but I do understand the closeness there of both the Intelligence folk and locals in their respective groups. Anyway, I hadn't realized you were so close to our current President personally. If you didn't have those views, heck, you would be a security threat with your knowledge..... :)

by maxwell edison

The United States was not paid back for any of the aid they (we) provided to anyone during WWII. (If there was any at all, it was very negligible.) There were no war reparations. The U.S. rebuilt and paid for the rebuilding of Europe and Japan.

You're welcome.

(Are you for real?)

by maxwell edison

I presume that you realize that my "calling President Bush" comment was made with my tongue firmly planted in my cheek. (But don't tell anyone, especially Colin, because it's obvious he'll believe anything.)

by admin

There have been no articles on politics at TR to date that I am aware of...

by john_wills

On Sunday Yemen, an in many ways backward and a bigotedly Muslim country, had elections, the latest in a series. No-one had to conquer them to impose democracy; indeed the anti-democratic forces are strongest in the region once ruled by Britain, which liked to see itself as a nurturer of democracies.

Intervening to bring democracy may not be a bad thing, but first do no harm. The U.S. subsidizes and arms many despotisms. U.S. President Carter put a stop to this for America, issuing an executive order under which weapon export licences would be issued only for democratically elected governments and rebels against despotisms. Ten years later every American country except Haiti and Cuba was a democracy. That does not mean it was a just society, or that it had a liberal economy, or that basic human rights were widely respected - think of the high murder rate in the U.S. -, just that it was a democracy, which had not been the case in most of America before.

Why not do the same towards the whole world? Not every democracy could buy arms - one thinks of Iran and India - but democracy would be the first hoop the toy-greedy military would have to go through. Even without co-operatin from such arms sellers as Britain, Germany and Russia there would surely be some effect, and the U.S. example might shame those arms merchants into a similar policy. Ten years on would perhaps be the time to consider forcible democratization. But the U.S. motive in Iraq has obviously not actually been democratization.

by cactus pete

Were you suggesting that Bush is holding information back so that the timing of his release would benefit his reelection?

That would be less than good for his integrity.

by hal 9000

Can't you read I never claimed that Barnes Wallace had anything to do with the Harrier but he did design a swing wing fighter bomber called the Sparrow this design was GIVEN to the Americian Government by the British Government as they wanted to proceed with the Harrier project NOT THE SPARROW PROJECT.

Now as far as Pine Gap goes the US doesn't pay anything for the land that the base is on and I will grant you it is not one of the biggest miletary bases outside America but it is one of the biggest Intelagence Gathering Bases outside mainland America. And no the locals don't gain much from the base directly there are a few CIVILIAN CONTRACTORS bought in {I was one} but all the equiptment is flown in and all the building materials are also flown in and all the construction is done onsite with the personal who work there. The only finical benifit that Alice Springs gets {which is about 3 hours drive away and there are no speed limits in the Northern Teratory} is when the Americian Personal come into town to buy things that they don't have on the base they also sell their possessions when they are transfered off the base to where ever. Every so often a large group of the personal of the base go into town with their families for some enternatinment but other than tourist income Alice Springs derives very little income from the Pine Gap Base and all the civilian contractors are employed for very specific tasks and come from different parts of the country in the 4 years that I worked there I never once saw a person who was born in Alice Springs performing any work on the base however I did see quite a few others like myself who where moved there from other parts of Australia for whatever we where employed for.

Just how far do you think that your army [whatever} could go without the intelegance that is derived from these places?

by hal 9000

President G. Bush hates cell phones this is a well reported FACT.

So I will find it diffictual to even believe any of your statments now after such an obvious LIE.

by hal 9000

President Bush again and ask him "Why did not Saddam Hussain use his WMD against the poor invading COW when they where invading the country?" As you have you have often stated this despot was more than willing to use thes weapons on his own people why was he not prepared to use them on the "infidells" whom most of the Arib World hates?

For an out of control despot didn't he show remarkabke restraint?

by thechas

I don't make foolish bets.
I know that something will eventually be found.

We have been speculating at work that even if Iraq actually has no WMD, the CIA or another agency will assure that there are some to be found.

So, if the WMDs are shown to the world in early spring of 2004, that only adds to my position that the primary reason for the Iraq war was a complex re-election plan for GW.

This way, he has another 4 years to pay back all of his contributors.

Yes, in may ways, GW is a more Honorable man than WC. However, I actually trust WC more than GW.
WC was more overt with his agendas and actions.
GW is much better at keeping his true agenda hidden.

Chas

by maxwell edison

I find it very interesting that some people would trust the motives of Bill Clinton over those of George W. Bush, while others' "trust factor" is exactly the other way around. How can two otherwise intelligent and informed people have such differentopinions about the same person? It's almost as though two people go to the same movie, and one sees an 1800's western while the other sees a futuristic science fiction flick. Chas, with all due respect - and you are indeed one of the "good guys" whoroam these threads - but how on earth are we not describing the same movie?

It used to make me want to throw up whenever I heard Bill Clinton say "...because it's the right thing to do". (And he said it a lot.) It made me sick because I knew his only motivation was to advance his (or his party's) political or personal agenda, and he showed time and time again that he didn't give a rat's ass about "doing the right thing" - generally speaking. A person is either honest, honorable and trustworthy, or he's not. You can't be a righteous person at work and a scum bag at home, all in the same day. You're either a good person or you're not. It's as simple as that. George W. Bush has restored dignity, honor and trust to the office of the White House, and about 75% of the American people, I might add, agree with me. (30% of all voters are registered Democrats.)

I'll never presume to know all the behind the scenes goings on, or claim to be a foreign policy expert, or expect to know the latest intelligence information, nor am I in a position to know what to do with all that information if I had it. That's why we "hire" a President (and others) to act on our behalf. It doesn't matter who - or what party - is in the White House. When it comes to those things I feel that I have to trust the good judgement of our elected leader.

(continued...)

by maxwell edison

I can certainly understand why and how that trust can be violated, because Bill Clinton showed (me) that he didn't deserve that trust. And believe me, I was just as vocally opposed to much of what BC did as many are about GB right now. The difference, I believe, is that BC acted in ways that only served to violate our trust. But what exactly has GWB done to show anyone he's not trustworthy? The answer is nothing. You may not like him personally, or you may want to advance the causes of the Democrat Party platform, and that's fine. A good policy debate is what makes the wheels of freedom continue to turn. But to fabricate or suspect or to take a pound of lies from an ounce of truth - all for the sole purpose of bringing a person down, so tospeak, only shows that one is blinded by partisan politics.

I trust that George W. Bush is acting in, what he believes to be, the best interest of the country - no more, no less. I couldn't say that about Bill Clinton when he lobbed a few dozen (or was it a few hundred?) cruise missiles into an aspirin factory in Sudan and up a camel's butt next to an empty tent in Afghanistan - and all the day before his Monica hearing. And believe me, in my case, it's not a partisan thing either. I felt (and still feel) the same way about Jimmy Carter as I do about GWB - he's honest, trustworthy, and honorable. I may disagree with some of Jimmy Carter's views, but he's not advancing a personal agenda, and he really is a good man. Just like George W. Bush.

"Planting" (or hiding) something to save face would be a Bill Clinton tactic. Neither Jimmy Carter nor George Bush would ever do such a thing. They are both much better than that.

by thechas

Believe it or not, I nominally think of my self as an independent minded Republican.

I live in one of the staunchest Republican areas of the country.

For the most part, the people I associate with at work are Republicans, or at least lean toward the Republican view.

Why then, is there a general feeling of mis-trust of GW within this group?

I am not alone in my belief that GW is the best President that big business could buy.

Further, except for upper management level businessmen,there is a growing sentiment in Michigan that it will take years to undo the damage that John Engler did to the state over the course of his 3 terms.
The favors to his political friends has left our roads, school system, and environment in a shambles.

Like GW plans, the Engler tax cuts have left the state unable to fund needed services.

Just as you cannot spend your way out of debt, government cannot tax-cut it's way out of an economic slump.

The cynic in me has yet to see a politician without ulterior motives and a hidden agenda.

With WC, the hidden agenda was out in the open.
You could see right through his spin.

Yes, GW has brought 'dignity' back to the White House.
He also has an experienced team that is focused on their agenda. That is why he is able to smooth-talk the American people, and have his message stand.

Chas

by maxwell edison

You are blinded by your own cynicism and misguided by your own hate and contempt. You should really open up your mind a little bit. It might help you see things as they really are instead of the way you've fabricated them to be.

by admin

Cynicism is: "1 the attitude or beliefs of a cynic or 2 a cynical action, remark, idea, etc. "

and a cynic is: "a person who believes the worst about people or the outcome of events"

So let's l;ook what Colin said: "Very well said
Its coments like this that make it worth reading through some of the other stuff.

It good to see that there is some sembelance of Common Sence in the Good Old US and it's a great pitty that there arn't more like you."

So you would say that Colin, who actually said something POSITIVE (that there is commen sense in the US) and said something personally good about a US citizen (me) is being cynical? Actually, by definition he is finding the best about people here. I can kind of understand it in other threds, but here.... I didn't get the feeling Colin was spewing cynicism, hatred or contempt- quite the opposite is actually occuring if you read the post you are referring to.

I can only figure that: a: you got quite lost in the threads and misposted, or b: since you stopped arguing with me but disagree with my views that you are making a somewhat transparent attempt to accuse me indirectly of hatred, cynicism and contempt because you see him as less of a threat and an easier target. You disrespect both of us if this is your attempt.

I see nothing cynical whatsoever in this comment you have responded to.

by maxwell edison

".....and it's a great pitty that there arn't more like you." (sic sic)

My message was intended for only one person, and it was not you. (As I consider you one of the "good guys".) In addition, it was more than just this one message that compelled me to make my comment - a comment, I might add, that is accurate. If anything, it was too kind. You may like him, but I think he's an ass. (I'm not alone either, but I may be the only one to say as much.) If you haven't read his garbage, do a search and become enlightened.

by hal 9000

I ever meet was a Bill Pyle {at least that's how I think he spelt his surname} and he was a friend of my fathers I meet him before I was 10 years old and he was the nicest bloke I've ever meet. All my brothers and sister used to call him Uncle Bill and he came over every few years to visit my father. They where friends from WW11 as they worked together somewhere in Queensland Australia. I never knew what he did but I surmised that he was in the Army or something similar and was preety high up as he seemed to come over quite a lot but both he and my father never spoke of the war years well at least in front of me or my family but he was an accepted member of the family and a loved member as well. When My father died he attended his funeral and stayed for a few weeks just to make sure that everything was allright. Now while my father was alive they exchanged letters birthday presents, christmass presents and numerious phone calls they where very friendly.

by hal 9000

Now when ne died naturally my family was informed and I flew over for the funeral where I stayed with his widow and did what little that I could do to help her. She was most insistant to me that he was having a miletary funeral as she said that he would have wanted this. I always susposed that he was in one of the forces in some capacity so this was not too much of a shock but what was a shock to me was at the actual funeral he was burried as General Pyle now I already knew that he was in the miletary and in all probability fairly high up but I never expected this position and he never said anything about his time in the service ever. He was the nicest unasuming person that I have ever meet and he was full of praise for all the help that he recieved hare in Australia whenever I saw him. He also had the time ti listen to me and my brothers in an interested way and I was under 10 so as a child I couldn't contribute much to anything but I was always made to feel welcome in his presence.

by hal 9000

What was an even bigger shock time was that when I was introduced to several of the high ranking officers at his funeral they imediatly said that you must be my fathers son and they mentioned my father by his christian name as if they knew him or that they certianly knew who he was. I only knew that he was a public servant untill his retirment and there where a few occasions when I went into where he worked as well as a few accions where I found a pistol that my father carried at times I never knew why he had this weapon and was never told. By I have baised all my opions of Americians on Bill's actions and have always expected most of your fellow countrymen to behave as he did and I have nothing but respect for him his wife and the rest ofhis family. This atitude has been carried over to all Americians that I've meet since and while I accept that there are a few bad apples in any nation I believe that most are good and respecitable and threat them as such.

Even at my time at Pine Gap this opinion was not altered as most of the Americian personal that I delt with where very similar to the way Uncle Bill behaved.

by hal 9000

It is only since I have been submitting postings to the TR forums that my opinion has altered to a small extent and prinicapy you and Bob are the reasons for this as both of you show the paronia that I saw at Pine Gap where every one thought they where about to b got at and always ran around hiding things that where realitively unimportant. Now I realise that you have served time in the miletary but you have to get beyond this thinking of paronia as it is holding you back and is extremly bad for your health. The truth is nobody is out to get you and all I'm doing is expressing a different opinion to yours which I'm entitled to and I will fight to the death to allow you or anybody else to do the same it is only from examining different opinions that we learn. Personaly I don't know what a Republician or Demorcrat is and actually I have no interest as I have no political leanings and I'm certianly not interested in the inner workings of the Americian Governmant I just accept the curent Administration and get on with the job in hand it really makes no difference to me.

But what I do find ofensive is someone treating me like an idot for example claiming that they have rung the US President and asked for an opinion. If you think for a single moment that I would even come close to believing this riducilious statment you are a fool and are only showing yourself as a silly little boy and not the adult that I have previously given you credit for.

So have a LONG THINK on this before you make any further ridicilious statments. Up are acting like a kindergaten child who is not getting his way in the sandpit and wanting to packup your bucket and spade and go away and not play any longer.

by hal 9000

Modern Politions have and it doesn't matter which country/party that they come from firstly and formost they are politions whos only agenda is to get reelected and if it does the country some good well so much the better but this is not as importantas doing themselves/parties good.

You can call cynical but I personally don't trust any politions I see them as a necessary evil which we will continue to need until a better system is brought forward. But I can asure you both that it will not be politions that bring another system forward as that would dimish their power base.

The Chas is right we all have the best Government money can buy and this is the basic root of all the problems MONEY. If all politions where given a set amount of money to spend on an election campain and could not accept donitations from outside interests they would hold far more respect in my eyes.

But this will never happen as it is not in the interests of Big Business for this to hasppen because if itdid they would lose their bargining base with the pollies and any way to impose legislation that suits their business. Democorcy was a fine institution when it was first set up in all countries as the people who stood for election genenually wanted to help/build the countries but this has by now degenerated into who can get the most money to campain to get their message across to the people and they often resort to scare tacatics rather than Active Policies that will benifit the country that they alledgely represent.

And Max it is not diffictual for 2 different people to go into a picture theatre and see the same movie but see it in different ways. This is because we all interpurate the same input in differnt ways acording to our oun beliefs political leanings and so on and so on the list is almost endless.

by hal 9000

It is the difference in observing facts that make us unique in the history of this planet and what makes it so interesting to live now.

If we all believed the same thing it would be a booring place to live and there would be nothing to talk aboutor even argue in groups like this one.

by hal 9000

I hope you don't lower yourself to a heap of Gomer Pyle jokes from the previous listings you are above this stupitdy or you should be.

It is bad enough that you fill your responces with links to articals that you don't thak the time to fully readand bais your whole critisium of me and my observations on the headlines and 1st paragraph. The listing above on Patton was a perfect example of this.

I have in the past agreeded with your opinions and will not doubt do the same in the future when I see things the same way as you do or see the same possible results but for a different reason but do not think for 1 minute that I am taking every chance to argue with you just for the sake of an argument because I honestly have better things to do and I have no reason to pick a fight with someone that I've never seen nore am ever likely to see.

There is no point in this type of action and is in my eyes a pointless waste of my precious time which I don't have enough of. I also have only posted coments that I have direct knolledge of and never placed a comment that I did not firmly believe in but I do like this site because it gives me a chance to learn what others in the world are thinking.

There is one fatal error that you have fallen into is this might be a US based site but it is surcribed to from most parts of the world so it is in fact a world wide site that is open for public discussion and not only US for residints.

by maxwell edison

If you read the "tongue-in-cheek" nature of my "calling the president" comment (and the subsequent comment that shortly followed), and didn't see it for how it was intended, I would guess that you're the only person who took it seriously. But why amI not surprised?

Colin, it's called humor, satire, etc.

You're the only one who missed it. What does that tell you?

Are you really that oblivious to the obvious, or are you now just being disingenuous?

by maxwell edison

In reference to the facility at Pine Gap, you said (and I'm quoting you directly - message 76136), "the locals don't gain much from the base directly", and "Alice Springs derives very little income from the Pine Gap Base".

However, I'm a bit confused.

The city council of Alice Springs, the local community near Pine Gap, said in a statement the following:

"The Alice Springs Town Council has reaffirmed its
support of Pine Gap as an important contributor to the economic and community life of our town. The Council has recognised Pine Gap as integral to the economic and community support of Alice Springs. The total economic contribution has been estimated as $37-$52 million per annum. More than half of the people working at Pine Gap are Australian, so it is an important employer. Mayor Fran Kilgariff said Pine Gap had provided Alice Springs with not only increased economic wealth, but also an active American community that has contributed greatly to the lifestyles and culture ofthe rest of the town's people over the years."

See link:

http://www.alicesprings.nt.gov.au/council/news/pr_20020903.asp

or

http://tinyurl.com/ay4w

Now Colin, here's where I'm confused. Should people believe what you say or what the city council of Alice Springs says? And why should we believe the one over the other?

Thanks for your help.

by maxwell edison

In reference to the fact that you really did work at the Pine Gap facility for four years (That was FOUR YEARS, wasn't it?), you said (and I'm quoting you directly - message 76136), that Pine Gap is, "about 3 hours drive away" from Alice Springs - and there's no speed limit either, so one can assume that you can really fly down the highway.

However, I'm a bit confused. Let me explain why.

I was just browsing various Web sites recently, and I ran across the following one. (Some people wereplanning a protest ouside the Pine Gap facility and were providing some information.)

http://www.anti-bases.org/nmd/us_base_pg_alice.htm

or

http://tinyurl.com/ay5j

Colin, this site claims that the Pine Gap facility is a mere 19 kilometers (slightly less than 12 U.S. miles) from the town of Alice Springs. (You know, the one that derives no economic benefit from that American base, contrary to what the town council says.) Since I can briskly walk about 4 miles per per hour, it seems that I could probably walk from Pine Gap to Alice Springs in less than three hours.

Now Colin, here's where I'm confused. Since the time you worked there - for FOUR YEARS - was the Pine Gap facility moved or did the town of Alice Springs move. AndI suppose if one does the math, considering a 3 hour driving time at 100 KPH (give or take - no speed limits, you know), one could surmise that either the town or the facility actually moved about 300 kilometers.

So here's where I'm confused. But by answering this simple question, I'm sure you can clear it all up.

Did the town move, did the facility move, is the Web site I referenced wrong about the distance (and if it's wrong, please provide a link to something more accurate.), or did it really take you 3 hours to drive (no speed limit) 19 kilometers?

Thanks for your help.

by maxwell edison

Oh, nevermind. I don't want to bore you with minor little details anymore. And besides, I'm sure the folks who read these threads can figure things out for themselves.

Have a nice day.

by maxwell edison

Surprise, surprise, surprise. I think Gomer Pyle was great.

Reasons I loved Gomer Pyle:

He represented the best - The United States Marines.

He was ALWAYS honest.

He was always genuine.

He always found the good in things.

He alwayssaw the good in people - even Sgt. Carter.

We could all do well by emulating the fine and honorable traits portrayed by Gomer Pyle, USMC.

by jardinier

When I started this discussion, I was of course referring to the war in Iraq, and seeking people's views on possible future events for which the war in Iraq may have acted as a catylist

by jardinier

While I was attempting to correct my misspelling of catalyst, bingo, the unfished posting was sent.

So to continue, I was not intending to start a war of words at Techrepublic.

However I am pleased to see that my posting has brought forth a great diversity of viewpoints, which I think is very healthy.

by jardinier

Sorry, I had to back-track a little to re-enter the discussion.

But the discrepancy in the distances quoted between Alice Springs and Pine Gap can be readily explained by the likelihood that Colin was driving a French-designed car with a defective odometer.

by asleep_at_the_wheel

OK you guys, time to fess up about who was wrong and what you were wrong about. The predicted thousands of body bags weren't needed, no Arab uprising, no massive terrorist attacks at home. What gives? And what else were they wrong about?