Discussion Locked

The war is over: let the peace begin.

0 helpful
138 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

138 replies

by asleep_at_the_wheel

Iraq's future is in the hands of the Iraqis. I hope they don't look their gift horse in the mouth. They should just mount up and ride on to freedom and prosperity.

by asleep_at_the_wheel

People in the middle east have been hating each other for one reason or another for a couple of thousand years. It ain't gonna change overnight.

by john_wills

Peole in Europe have been hating each other for quite a long time, but they have a tradition of democracy and fight more with ballots than with bullets. In Yemen the shift from bullets to ballots is going slowly, but they're on the way. In Iran a couple of decades of democracy have got the people to lethargy: at the last local elections the turnout was at about U.S. level.

by asleep_at_the_wheel

It looks like you're running out of legs to pull. Being called out to the middle of the street at high noon, it looks like to me.

by cactus pete

First of all, everyone can claim that they were at least a little right, and can claim that others were at least a little wrong. Often, that is enough for ego.

As for thousands of body bags, we have yet to get an accurate number of Iraqis killed. Totalling up both [all?] sides [and it's not quite over, body-count-wise, I dare say], I'm sure there are thousands.

As for the terrorist attacks, I wouldn't expect most of them to happen during the war. The infamous terrorist bin Laden liked to embed 'meaning' into the dates of his attacks, usually putting them on or near anniversaries of what he perceived as wrongs. If he's alive and spewing, you may count on futher attempts.

It is no less a delicate time now than it was a year earlier.

by john_wills

The Arab uprising hasn't happened yet, but it may well unless elections are held soon, say in 6 weeks: the administrative apparatus is in place, and inter-party hostility should take the heat off the occupiers for a while. But the interventioners seem to have been wrong about the WMD: none have been found yet.
One of the things on which I agree with Ayn Rand in Virtue of Selfishness is that a free country has the right(not the obligation) to conquer a despotism, but not to set up a new despotism: the conquest must lead to democracy, of which the central part is elections.

by mallardtooxx

Man, the Duck goes on hiatus for a few days and I miss on of the best constructed and well played burns on TR in a long time! Well played Max. Colin he nailed you, he nailed you real good, I would just walk on this portion of the thread because itis a credibility issue. There is such a thing as playing out of your league, Colin your staunchest support is even out on this one, let it go, just some friendly advice.

Max, once again you redeem yourself and I must say again well played!

-duck

by hal 9000

But I do worry thta other Nations in the Middle East will not accept a democratic Country so close to themselves giving their own people some sought of hope for a different future.

Also the fundulmist Islamic clericks are the really dangerious ones and they will take every oportinuty to stir up trouble. They worry more than anything else about whats going on in the Middle East, what most Westeren people don't understand is that these people are taught to hate right from the first time they are put to the breast for thier first meal and it will take generations for this to come to an end.

I know to our way of thinking its wrong but that is the way it is and if they don't hate the Westeners or as we are called over there The Infidialsthen they will transfer this hate somewhere else as it is a long deep rooted part of the society. A similar situation was in Northern Irland with the IRA who vermently blamed the British for the death of many Irish people in the Great Patato Famine of 1600 something and they still think of it as yesterday, This is how they justify their actions as they draw on all the wrongs of history to place blame now and they firmly believe what they are doing has the blessing of their church and fellow counrty men even as they are killing them.

This is something that is not going to disapear over night.

by cactus pete

Here's your chance to say that you were oversimplifying just to get to a point within the character limitation...

But just to clarify what I'm getting at - the Irish have bad feelings towards the British for more reasons than an arbitrary blame of a famine that occurred centuries ago.

International conflicts are seldom so simple.

All that said - I believe that most conflicts get rolling [not necessarily started, but the momentum builds] because of the general ignorance of the population as a whole.

Soldiers rarely *know* why they're fighting.

That brings up another question in my head - does anyone think that the terrorist grunts who carry out the acts are doing so because of idealism, or brainwashing, or what?

by hal 9000

Like all terriost acts it all boils down to what they where taught to believe from mostly a very young age although this is sometimes different owing to something that a person percieves as a direct unjustified attack upon themselves that requires some form of retrebution.

I can't rember the guys name but I think it was something like Timithoy McVain {don't know about the spelling or if the names correct but I think you will know who he is}. From what was reported over here he put a truck load of explosives outside a building that in part housed the IRS and blew it up to get back at teh IRS {the facts might not be strictly correct as it's from memory and it might not have been reported correctly here}. But as it was reported here it wasan attack on the IRS as he had some sought of fight with them which he could not ever have a hope of winning so he resorted to terriost like activity.

Quite a lot of people unrelated to the organisation where killed/hurt as a result of his actions and when caught he got what he desirved though some of the victums relatives might say differently but it was a good example of someone fighting back against what they percieved as oppression {I agree it was misguided and unacaptable} but in his mind he was doing the right thing.

by mallardtooxx

It is not as black and white as Brainwashing or idealism. To say they are brainwashed is to say that all of their religion is as such. To say it is their idealism is to say that is the Ideal for the entire religion. I am inclined to think it is more of an opression issue than anything else. These people have nothing, they are dirt poor, they have no hope for their families and they are only able to provide for them in one way. If they agree to blow themselves up in the name of someones cause they will get to the promised land, they will have I believe 26 vestal virgins, and, best of all, their families will receive much needed money from the group. In a region where there are Very distinct class lines, and all of the money resides with a very few people, there is no wonder in my mind why this happens so regularly.

I don't really think it is a matter of the terrorist grunts having no free will because there is no such thing there. I think more than likely it is a matter of if I die who cares, I am going to the promised land and that is fine with me. That is not brainwashing, that is part of their culture that is spurned on by the Very rich few so they do not have to die themselves. If you have nothing to live for it is easy to die, if you have everything you want in life you sure as hell are not going to blow yourself up to get anything. A prime example of this is Ossama Bin Laden he wanted to strike us, if he were brainwashed into his terrorist ways he would havebeen on the plane; but since he is very wealthy he instead got other grunts, who had nothing, to do it for him. All it takes is money to get the job done, that is pretty much universal and that is what makes me inclined to believe what I do.

-duck

by john_wills

The Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, whom I suppose we can count among the mullahs, believed that Iran would not remain Islamic unless it remained democratic; he thought that democracy would help to perpetuate Islamism. That is why Iran now regularly has elections to the presidency, to the legislature and to an electoral college which appoints the Supreme Leader and so, indirectly, the judiciary. The executive is appointed by the president with the consent of the legislature. Like any state with division of powers, Iran has gridlock, and there is a lot of frustration, but that holds for other democracies too.
In Yemen, another Moslem democracy, there is a party hight Islah, which corresponds in policy to the Taliban in Afghanistan. At the election before last - I do not yet know the results for the latest election - it got about a fifth of the seats. So it knows it can get some of what it wants without violence and also knows that it does not have enough support for a succesful revolution to be likely.
I do not favor Islam, let alone Islamism, but I opine that the mullahs are less dangerous than Jerry Falwell and the secular inhumanists would have us believe.

by mallardtooxx

I want to thank you for making a point here. I respect your opinion now and will no longer berate you for it. You have proven a thoughtful contributor and have made this a more meaningful discussion simply by changing your point of attack slightly, that to me shows a large amount of cognitive reason.

-duck

by hal 9000

To be a joke but you can't blame me for returning the favour can you?

Oh by the way I didn't see the other posting until latter but I did take some little offence to it particuarly when you said words to the effect that I would probably believe what you had said about ringing the President.

Anyway for some reference material that you consistnly clain that I fail to provide you with have a look at a vedio called Doomsday Gun it is put out by HBO and is the true story of the attempt to built what was then called the super gun and was designed by Gerald Bull the person behind the Harp which was susposed to be capable of lauching objects into space without all the costly rocket/shuttle projects. Of course when it was proved sucessful funding was pulled but that's another story.

by hal 9000

Notification of this little off shoot of the main thread but in answer to your questions Max four means 4 years and yes you are correct there is an US housing facility for married/Family members of the base personal that is close to the town I don'tknow about the 19 KM's bit but it sounds about right so I would agree with you on that one because it has been a long time since I've been there and the town of Alice Springs has no boubt grown somewhat.

And I'll agree that the town of Alice Springs does derive quite a bit of income from the US personal and their families but not in the way that you consider as most of the food is flown in from the US and only Australian things like virginamight are bought in town buy the families of base personal. Also any repair work on applicences in this setlement arn't done by town repair men but rather these faulty units are generally replaced with new items and the faulty bits just dumped these range from airconditioners to tosters and everythingin between. There may be some repair work done by local tradesman of the structures like panting ect but this hardly applies to a vast income to the towns people. Where the money does get spent is on entermainment facilities in the town as there is bugger all else to do up there unless you want to watch the sand move across the ground. On most ocassions the base personal who live near the town stay on the base for their work period which was whenI worked there 10 days on then 5 days off and it is durring that 5 days that they return to the settlement to their families. Another great source of spending in the town comes about when staff are transfered back to the US or elsewhere and most of their private possesions are sold off at Garage Sales {let me know if you don't understand this term as I'm not sure that you have any in the US}.

by hal 9000

The actual base is a very long way off and Max I extend you an invitation to come to the Alice and I'll personally drive a car with water and food while you attempt to walk to the base from either the town of the US settlement, This will save your life as I'm not prepared to see you die over something as silly as this.

The 3 hour trip to the base is by buss that is provided by the base for the personal. I personally never caught this bus but always drove but I was informed that it was a 3 hour ride in the buss by people that actually used it.

Do any of you still think that I don't know what I'm talking about?

Sorry but I can't remember the rest of the questions as I can't directly read them so I'll leave it there and if you want more details please feel free to ask.

by hal 9000

It's this type of thinking that has to be stoped and thats the hardest thing to do. The Irish that sympathise with the IRA firmly believe what they are doing is correct and fully justified and chose to ignore their religious leeder when he pleads for them to cease and desist their actions, they see this as accaptance to continue.

Now the radical Islamic clericks don't discourage this type of action they incourage it so it is much worse and these radicals are well originised so they are the real threat to the current world civilization who they happly sell oil to for the money then treat all westeners as the infidils who deserve to die and use the money from the sale of the oil to reak havock upon the rest of the world. Sometimes they stay in their back yards and sometimes they go outside their homeland and attack to what reasonable people perceive as unrelated objects like what happened on Sept 11 2001.

The main question is how to break this mind set and stop the radical clericks having so much power to sway their followers. If you have an answer I'd like to hear it as I don't know where this will all lead.

by hal 9000

While the battle might have finished the War certianly hasn't so I wouldn't start counting body bags just yet the worst may yet come and unless things are put right in a very short time there will be a real problem arising in Iraq.

First the water and power must be rebuilt and then a way to place a popular Iraqie administration in place and then when all that is finished there just might not be a blood bath but if things are left as they currently are it will lead to a very real problem. From whats been reported so far we have had the ability to destroy things but so far we lack the equiptment and parts to replace some of the vital things that we have managed to destroy.

I know it will take time to rebuild but will the people accept this while they are dying of thirst ect?

by john_wills

It is not necessary to rebuild the water and power before holding elections. The liberators can continue administering things while the elections are going on then hand the task over to the government which results. It may be that the elected government will ask the liberators to stay on in certain capacities for a while - they surely would not object to the U.S. paying Bechtel to rebuild a lot of thngs -, but we must get away from the idea that the road to democracy is long: it is not.

by maxwell edison

As a rule, at least in my community, the money changing hands at garage sales is not counted when determining impact to local economies. Even if it was, in the case of Alice springs, a town with a population of around 22,000, in order to generate 37-52 million dollars in income (as estimated by the Alice Springs city council) that would mean that EVERY resident of Alice Springs would have to sell $1700-$2400 worth of bric-a-brac each and every year.

I love garage sales - that just might beworth the trip!

by hal 9000

Who is susposed to despise everything Americian I must tell you this {Oh I forgot the biggot bit as well}. I had to log off to watch my weekly doese of Star Treck, and I don't own anything Americian as I'm susposed to hate you lot so I guess that explaines just why I've spent so much money on various parts from CA for my VW Bettle from suppliers like Autocraft, Scatt, Sway-Away and countless other US parts suppliers {on my current motor I only bought $80,000.00 US in parts from the States.

Then theres my AR speakers and the Velonia pistons that I use in my Ducati not to mention that every computer that my company builds has an Antec power supply in it. So as an Americian Hatting Ass, Biggot with a closed mind I'm prety patethic arn't I Max? {I think that I got all that you've called me but I'll happly add anything if I've missed them.}

by maxwell edison

Colin, you continue to greatly understate the contribution of your fellow countrymen, especially the fine residents of Alice Springs.

According to Territory MHR Warren Snowdon (Labor), as reported in the ALICE SPRINGS NEWS, May 9, 2001, "Pine Gap is probably the biggest employer in Alice Springs." That's more than a few beers and some garage sales, and it's more than just some minor repair tasks. (At least it seems to me.)

Mr. Snowdon also went on to say, "(Pine Gap) has a substantial economic impact on the town: If Pine Gap were to close, for example, and our friends from the United States all went home, that would have an immediate and dramatic impact upon the social and economic fabric of Alice Springs. They make a great contribution to the community."

Moreover, Alice Springs Mayor Fran Erlich says, "The Americans have been and still are fantastic for Alice Springs. They are very much part of the community and they bring a lot of money into the town, and stabilize our economy."

I cut and pasted these quotes from the Alice Springs News:

http://www.alicespringsnews.com.au/0814.html

Colin, why is it that the news reported in that community differs from what you've been asserting?

by mallardtooxx

If they are to get anything done over there they must first gain control of the masses. The only way to do that is to put the government in place. Without a ruling body of Iraqi citizens to govern them there can be no rebuilding without resentment. We are not out of the woods but as john said here we are not as far out from democracy as we think.

-duck

by hal 9000

Postings above.

Now all that we need is for the Powers That Be to Do The Right Thing and then everyone will be happy.

The sooner the better in my humble opinion it can't come soon enough.

by oz_media

You must have been glued to CNN and FOX news to feel that the US conducted a smooth job in Iraq.
Killing your own soldiers is a mistake, killing your allies is amother big booboo, bombing the wrong buildings, oooops! And finally, after the Britishmoved out of a secured are, the US Marines take over and within three hours, riots, and oh yeah, US Marines killed a bunch more "Unruly" Iraqi citizens. But when all is said and done, in an interview with the offending Marines, thier only retort is"we're taught to fight, not keep the peace".
Right on George, way to run a country!!

by hal 9000

Max from your original posting you seemed to be under the impression that all of Alice Springs derived a benifit from the Pine Gap base well in a way this is correct but the main econimic impact is in neich markets which do cater for the personal from the base and their families. But this income is not spread evenly across the Alice it is confined to neich markets after all there are quite a fe people working on the base and many have families so they do kave an impact on the Allice {you would have to be a moron to believe differently} but they don't spread the benifit all across the Allice it is restricted to only a few markets like entermainment, schools ect {and the Americian parents are very active in school workings} but these are limited areas. With that many people up there they must have some form of impact on the local comunity as there is bugger all else to do anywere around the place even the closest major city Darwin is quite a few hours drive up the road {i won't quote a time here as I've never driven it so I don't know exactly but it is a very long way off}. Also the turisot industry gains quite a lot from the Americian personal and the families like trips to Ayres Rock or what ever they call it now. And as for the garrage sales bit the Americian personal that arrived and that I worked with where intregued by this form of disposing of articals that could not be carried away when transfered so I was under the impression that they had never seen this before but it just may have been the people in question or the fact that when a garrage sale is set out most of the people in the Allice come and not just the Base Personal this could also have been the reason I don't know but it was quite a topic of conversation and merriment amoungst the Americian personal so you can make your own ideas about that one.

by hal 9000

Nearly all my hand tools and air tools are bought from the Australian distributers of Snap On tools now, before they came into existance I used to import these items from the US as well so I cna't see how you can acuse me in any way of disliking America or its products.

by hal 9000

From my personal observations at Allice Springs the people all get along together there are naturally fights between some people but in general there is none of the then and us senerio going on there or there wasn't when I was there and I can't really see that changing as most people in that remote place have to rely on each other just to stay alive as it is a very desolate place a long way from anywhere.

What most people don't understand is the distance involved to the nearest city which isDarwin and thats a very long way north and if you want to go south then its at teh very least a couple of days drive into South Australia and a semi major population center with very little in between. There are a few towns on the way but these are mostly around fuel stations that are required just to keep up the fuel suplies to your car. I've never traveled across any other country that is as vast and as unpopulated anywhere that I've traveled and this is what most people don't understand. In Europe if you drive a few hundred miles straight down a raod you will have crossed several borders. In America they do have some long distance between places particuarly on the western side of the country but nothing as vast as what the distances arein Australia. There is only one worse place to trave here and that is from Adeliade to Perth a long straight road with nothing to look at for a few days and you have to doge the Roadtrains {for our Americian cousins semi trailers with up to 4 -5 trailers} these things just thunder along and hevean help anyone that gets in their way you just avoid them.

by hal 9000

Anyway back to the Allice it is a very friendly place where everyone gets along together very well and the US base personal families do a horendious amount of work for the schools that their kids attend. If you like isolation but still have all the mod cons then the Allice is the place to go as once you get out of town there is very little around and particuarly now as we are in the middle of one of our regular droughts it would be even worse than normal. Any thing that you buy in the Allice isexpensive just because of the freight involved in getting it there so it's a very expensive place to actually live but ti is also the staging place for the personal of Pine Gap and the tourist industry that goes out to Ayres Rock so they have a lot of tourists through the place. Now you've all heard the expression of the camels armpit well the Allice doesn't even rate a mention there as nobody in their right mind would go there to live volinatery they would have to have a very good reason like the work that they are contracted to and here I'm talking about Australians who have been contracted to work at Pine Gap. {Max this description is something that you will never find in any newspaper/web posting}. But if you like this type of place then it is perfect and owing to the remotness you must band together just to survive. {Max would you like to find an artical about the Aboriginals in the Allice?} I don't think you will unless it is about some new programm that they are trialing but the native people of Australia really arn't welcome in certain parts of this town and ther eis a lot of racial hatred {which of course is never reported}.

by hal 9000

So Max you will have to have been there for some time before you can offer an opinion of the place or you are just the same as a newly pasted Under Grad who thinks that they know everything from their study but in actual fact have no real experienceso they don't really know what they are talking about.

Just a friendly suggestion Max Quit while your ahead before I bury you. AS you have no actual knowledge of the place and you can not even come close to knowing what it's like just by sitting in your airconditioned office reading web postings as you have become what you claim to hate a know all with no pratical experience on the subject that you are waffling on about.

by maxwell edison

I think we've beaten this dead horse all the way to the glue factory.

And since you admitted that I'm ahead in this debate, I'll quit.

How gracious of you to make such a concession.

by hal 9000

Equially it is not true for others You are particuarly refering to the Palistien population under Jewish control in the occupied lands after the 6 day war. And you are totally correct on in what you have stated about the conditions in which they live.
But the same can't be said for the Tamel Tigers or for that matter the we'll go back quite a few years and have a look at a terriost in South Africa called Nelson Mandella or the people who fought fot inderpendence in Indonesion controlled Timor.Both of these where called terriosts buy the governments of the day and then latter on became Heors and Liberators. So I guess you could say history is fluid and those called terriosts today just may be called Heros tomorrow.
I don't like it but thats just the way it is.

by hal 9000

But I'm no longer getting any notifications of new postings so I'mm willing to let this one die if your Max and we have betten this dead horse not to the glue factory but inside it and started watching the processing as well. But just because it's in the newspapers dosen't always mean that it is right. A very good example is what is being said about Australias Governer General from the church report into sexual abuse that may have occured under his time as Archbishop of Brisbane. The report is somewhat critical of some of his actions but as it was a church inquiry I don't give it that much creedience as any wittnesses could not be protected from Libal action from any party who they where to accuse of any sought of action so the reality of this report is that it is less than usless. It did highlight some problems but I am of the firm belief that the problem is far greater than has been exposed in this report and will never trully be uncovered while our current Federal Government fails to act and hold a Royal Commision into these allegitations where the wittnesses will be fully protected and just then we may get to the truth or at least some of it.

Sorry Max but I think that I've just agreeded with you again.

by oz_media

Rent a copy of the left wing Bowling for Columbine. K-Mart pulled amo from the shelves because American childeren were killing each other with it. You don't need to look too fat in order to see mass destruction, it's in your back yard.
Now if youcould all focus on what your own country is doing to educate its people and prepare them to live together with less hatred towards the rest of the world, you may get on track.
The only two times America has been attacked on it's own soil, it has been devastated whith it's pants down. You're right in saying security is too tight in the wrong places if all the ships weren't in the same harbour, Pearl Harbour would have been a lot less devastating. If your "Homeland Security" had their eyes open, they would have paid attention to the subtle (and blatant) threats to your country and the WTC may still stand tall (god rest the souls of those lost).
Bottom line, for a "Super Power" you sure do get your asses kicked a lot. Good thing you'renot part of Eurpoe, logistics would have seen the US eliminated a LOOOOOONG time ago.

by cactus pete

It's more complex than that, surely you can tell.

If you can't, please provide me with the address of this Eden in which you live.

by oz_media

I just don't understand what your post means. You say it is too simple, what do you mean, America educating it's people not to kill each other?

Other countries do, as a result, they don't kill each other, at least not in the massive way that US citizens do. It is just as easy for me to buy a gun as it is for you. I just don't need one.
In fact the same show previously mentioned states that Canada has a higher percentage of gun owners than America. I haven't watched the entire Bowling forColumbine, I don't necessarily agree with some of the views but the facts have been revealed and the sources interviewed.

As for the Eden in which I live, Northern Vancouver Island. Simply stunning!! I have been to quite a few countries and seen some truly amazing scenery but NOTHING compares to Vancouver Island for peace, beauty and solitude. Living here is like being on a permanent vacation, even if I do remote network into Vancouver, it's while on my porch with birds chirping and the waves hitting the beach. Check out a few web searches, you'll soon see why Western Canadians are so content with the country and politics are not relevant to us, besides, we have the best bud.

Not having strong religious beliefs myself, this must be Eden.

This discussion is closed to new replies.