Discussion Locked

Tired of Window's Bashing, try Mac Bashing

0 helpful
138 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

138 replies

by tony

if you can honestly get someone to pay $250 for a mac that old chances are it's not going to be to someone you actually like. Same applies to old pc's. With new machines barely costing more than that, at least on the pc side of things there just isnt a real compelling reason to buy anything old thats already more steps behind than something with a warranty and some life to go.

You might be able to actually get that kind of money, but not with any good concience about it.

Tonis

by tony

it's only trivial when you know and are familiar with how your OS works. Which comes over time as you need to do something that requires knowing how to do it.

It would be great if the same procedures to deal with troubleshooting applied to both sides. You might find more people compelled to really not care what OS they use. But realistically with Windows far dominating for so long with far more users the momentum to set any "standards" on procedures on the mac side has never come close to happening.
If the real desire was to get people to stop using windows and move to OS X, then they would stop trying to do things differently and give those typical users who need to do these things the same procedures to accomplish things.
Otherwise they really arent going to convert anyone on any real scale ever. They'll just contiunue to keep some of the past users who don't want to learn the windows way do things and possibly get the occasional new user who has to learn some way of accomplishing things no matter what they get on.

Thinking differently with computers can be great when your trying to solve a problem, acting differently is usually the reason for causing problems.

by wjacomb

I am a Mac / PC Support Specialist in Australia

1. The Mac OS is superior to Windows in every way and form -
always has been.

2. Windows DLL goes south - re do windows if you want it right
- and thats not two hours thats more like 10, cause you have to
redo programmes users data e.g. reimport into Outlook etc,
Install Windows Updates

3. OS 9 / X equivalent goes south - just do a custom install a
replace the defective part. 30 minutes at worst
4. Its a lot tougher to create viruses for Mac than Windows - I
have seen only one mac infected in 3 years - PC's every day.

I shouldn't complain PC Viruses make me good money but
they are certainly a waste of the clients.

4. The Macintosh HD drivers have built in fail safes which make
the storage of data more robust.

5. Have you worked on a G4 or G5 case - they are a breeze
although I will admit that an Emac or Imac can be painful

6. Okay replacing components means avoiding Apple when they
can which is why real Apple Techs actually know what PC
Components they can use and where to source second hand.

I don't mind valid criticsim of Macs (or rather Apple) but your
remarks indicate that you should tells us what prescription / non
prescription drugs you are on - it is only fair to the rest of us.

Oh yes, before I forget your remark about passwords - look up
and use key chain - users generally discover it for themselves by
using the online help function - and you claim to be a Mac Tech?

by mjwx

nor does the infernal keychain. this gives another password to the users that complain about needing one.

as for stability a properly configured operating system should remain stable for some time windows, mac or otherwise.

P.S. i need to remember atleast 4 passwords off the top of my head at any given time, plus 5 more which arent as important and a further 5 which i have written down because i just cant remember 14 passwords at once when most of them change every 6 weeks. Mac users complain about one.

by mchall

the line where he said "I can't speak for OS X." This is what's commonly known as a "disclaimer". jardinier was only offering a historical perspective of past versions of the OS (with both pros and cons), not a criticism of the current one.

Never assume.

by ibanezoo

...but how much do you actually use it? Our Macs have someone in front of them nearly 24/7 (yes, really... we never close) and they are every bit as frustrating as a PC and in some instances more so (installing printer drivers comes to mind...). They are generally being used for image editing, design, layout, and printing... they get ALOT of use around here.

by ibanezoo

The applications are the same (Adobe CS, Quark, various graphics applications). The hardware is obviously different... Some things are caused by users doing stupid things, I would say the majority are just crashing due to bad programming or whatever...

by mchall

I program for PCs at the office but have been using a Mac PowerBook G4 at home and on the road for about a year now.

HARDWARE:

From a pure hardware cost standpoint I found that for my budget and the features I wanted there was not much difference between Apple and other major notebook manufacturers like Dell. At first glance PC notebooks appeared cheaper, but once I started adding features to the base configuration the price rapidly went up. The PowerBook came fully loaded with everything I wanted.

One of the things that gave me pause were the updgrade limitations for Apple laptops. RAM upgrades are easy. Everything else is pretty much out of the picture. If you're a gamer and are used to upgrading your audio and video cards periodically you may be a bit disappointed. On the other hand I recently read a study that said Apple owners use their machines for an average of six years, which would imply that the gaming industry does not drive the technology on Macs as hard as it does on PCs. The new chipset may change that as it makes a wider range of media cards accessible.

There are a lot of good reviews surfacing regarding the new chipset, so I won't give it broad coverage here. Most indicate that stability has not been a problem and speed increases are greatest on native code (versus legacy code using the Rosetta emulator). Few software incompatibility issues have been reported.

SOFTWARE:

The hidden cost of switching to an Apple is in the software. If you must have MS Office then Office 2004 will set you back a couple of bills. If there are "PC only" programs you need to run you'll need to pick up Virtual PC. If you're lucky some of your old software will have both PC and Mac versions on the same disk. A few companies like Blizzard do this.

The flip side is that Apple machines ship with an exceptional suite of multimedia software. If you're an amature musician, shutterbug or director then you'll find plenty of tools to feed your hobby. I've also found the Safari browser to be comparable to Firefox, complete with tabbed browsing and robust RSS support.

DEVELOPMENT:

If you truly want to get geeky you can. OS X is Unix under the hood, so the command line is not far away. Apache comes pre-installed, so LAMP (or would it be XAMP on a Mac?) development is readily available with a quick install of MySQL. Perl comes pre-installed as well. Apple also offers its XCode tools for free on its site. None of this is much help if you're a .NET developer, but it is more cost effective. Since Apple is not a pure software company they have a vested interest in making it easy for developers to get started building Mac-specific programs that consumers will want to use. MS, on the other hand, is about selling software, including development tools. They have made it cheaper with the introduction of the "Express" product line, but Visual Studio and MSDN subscriptions can come with a pretty hefty price tag depending on what features you need. Ultimately what you use comes down to how much you want to spend and what audience(s) you want your software to reach.

by davin123

I have an iMac G5 and an iBook G4, they are linked by Airport with no problem ( I never thought I would say this! ) It just took Apple support 3 days of continuous phone support to make it so. Hurrah for support.
The system freezes about once a month, I have reinstalled the system 4 times now and have lost all data on both Macs at once when I renamed folders, eg from "Documents" to "Documents iBook" so I knew which is which. The keyboard is upsetting as there is no deleting key ( delete does backspace )
Software is buggy, Microsoft Office for Mac loses all Excel comments when saving and transferring from a PC. I confess I use a PC for important stuff backups, it is kept clean with minimal software. Virtual PC works usually except for some installer programs like for Nastran, I use it for the important stuff with a Maxtor external 300Gig drive.
Dealing with files is a pain, Finder doesn't find what I want, there is no real simple Paint Shop Pro equivalent or Windows Picture and Fax Viewer, etc. I want to do stuff not solve puzzles..
All in all I will pursue this Mac business as I have an eternity of years, from a Vic 20 to the first IBM PC and on, to grumble about Microsoft and a steady procession of blue screens to give me high blood pressure. I must confess that I am becoming more fond of Microsoft nowadays though.
To end on a good note, the phone support from both is extremely good, even in the Antipodes. The hardware warranty seems to be problematic though from what I have read and the number of unofficial Apple retailers is growing. Also annoying that my iMac G5 hardware has been superceded twice now when it is only 6 months old.

by leobloom

As I already posted previously: I have been working w/ PC's since 1988. In 1994 I bought the MAC because I worked at a place that had a few and I wanted to learn more about them. I have 4 computers in my house and the kids prefer the PC so I end up using the MAC. If I WAS a mac guy, I'm thinking I would have bought another since '94.

As far as a cost difference, around the time when I purchased it, my sister bought an intel 486 pc and it was less than 100 dollars cheaper than my mac. Both came with similar bundles, except where she got MS Works my MAC had Claris works.

Regarding cost/benefit, I did not do any cost benefit analysis, I merely searched e-Bay to see what I could get for my MAC and what I could Get for a PC. The purpose of the post was that despite what people say about MACs they do seem to retain value longer, for what ever reason.

by wlbowers

Good grief bubba, turn on key chain.

And it's not the Mac's fault you have problems getting it on a
windows domain. What did you think that Bill was gonna make it
easy for you.

I have 7 computers in my home alone, not including my
business. 4 are Macs, 2 are PC and 1 is an ipaq.

I have reloaded both of the PC's at least 3 times in the last year
out of complete necessity. And dang dud I'm a consulant. I fix
these things for a living.

I haven't touched the Macs since they were installed. the iMacs
are over 3 years old.

And dang dude where are you buying your motherboards. I can
get you a 1.8gig G5 CPU for $1449.00.

Motherboards are just as reasonable.

Bash Apple. Not gonna happen here.

Lee

by mjwx

1. the keychain still doesnt fix the problem 2. it only remembers the first password and doesnt change it every 6 weeks.

this is a corperate enviroment as much as i would appreciate help on this issue home networks are different. so this is for the record MAC'S DO NOT SUPPORT DOMAIN LEVEL AUTHENTICATION.

P.S. i cant authenticate against a print server (so much for getting around the driver issue).

P.P.S. it's been a long day so i apolpgise for my rudeness.

by krazykyngekorny

If you are running Win2K or XP, there is a caveat.

Microsoft says they will run on FAT32. Don't you believe it.

Switch to NTFS and knock out well over two thirds of the problems. Gates engineers won't tell you that, but experience will.

by mchall

why play Diablo II when you could be playing World of Warcraft? Buying a new machine is not necessarily a sign of a bloated ego. Some buy for the fun factor. When the game you want to play is too macho for your old machine then it's time to consider upgrading or replacing it.

I see this as more a factor with PC gamers than Mac users. PC gamers who want to maintain bragging rights for being on the bleeding edge can get into a new 512MB vid card for upwards of $600 right now. Do this everytime Nvidia or ATI release a new vid card and the costs can rapidly add up. Conversely, I recently read a study that said Mac owners use their machines an average of six years. Split the cost of an iMac over that period and you're not looking at that big of a price differential.

Stock 20" iMac: $1700/6 yrs = $283.34 per year

PC vid card (assuming chipset upgrade every 18 months): (12 months * 6 years)/18 months = 4 upgrades * $600 = $2400 -or- $400 per year

I would suggest that frugality and reliance on old hardware strictly comes down the individual owner regardless of the hardware or OS.

To your point, this is certainly not a "need". If you don't have the time, inclination or disposable income to upgrade then it certainly makes sense to stand pat with what you have.

by jmgarvin

Macs are based off BSD Unix "on top of" the Mach Microkernel.

I agree with the one button mouse thing. While multi-button mice have been available for a while, I wish the laptops came with built in with at least a two button mouse. The single button is annoying.

I'm also concered about the move to the x86 and the kernel performance, but we'll see

by dlthompson471

I use it for standard home use, Word Processing, Spread sheets,
Photo and Music storage, hosting a personal web site, I also
have MySQL and Postgres running on it for personal education of
those two products. About the only other thing I use it for is
streaming photos and music to my TV through my Tivo box.

I do understand your frustration with printer drivers. Especially
in the early going with OS X. I don't have to deal with that
because I found a printer that works well with it (Canon IP4000).

by krazykyngekorny

I must agree about Linux, BUT...at the moment it is much more difficult to get the installation set up for easy operation- not easy enough for a non nerd. IOW, it needs mor refinement to be ready to compete with Gates.

OSx is already there- Linux isn't.

by mjwx

But first my complaint was not that we can?t get Mac?s onto the domain (which is a SBS 2003 domain (before 10.4 Mac's had a problem with .local but it?s still not perfect)) but the users need to enter a password every time they open their mail/browser/access file server all of which they can do. They just need to enter a password each and every time (I?ve already explained that the keychain is useless).

Apart from a few specific Microsoft issues (like sharing colanders in exchange) Mac?s can everything they need to (mail/internet/storage). But it is difficult for both the user and the admin (me) because Mac?s have trouble cooperating with the domain. a good example of this is they cant authenticate against the print server (we have one printer running AppleTalk).

A few days ago Office for Mac started having a problem with the fonts (corrupted or cant access) I cant get to the machine in question right now to tell you the exact error message.

My problem in short (if you?ve gotten this far i should probably thank you for patience) is that as the techie in charge of the Mac?s I spend more time (per machine) giving basic functionality to a Mac (in a corporate environment) than fixing serious problems on XP machines.

Probably TR's fault but the URL was half cut off. Probably what that ://tinyurl/ thing is meant to fix. someone's gonna have to tell me how to do that.

by wlbowers

Sorry I had a brain fart. I know about tiny url.

http://tinyurl.com/buk9q

Description of what Microsoft did for Non Macs. Might be to rich
for ya'll though.

We set an online laser and dedicated it to the macs. They were
all in the graphics dept.

Lee

by jake2006

that there are all user levels on all OSes. I have seen secretaries on
Linux. If you judge an OS by its users, Windows is the dumbest by
sheer numbers of ignorant users.

by jake2006

teach the man to fish. There are tons of applications on the Mac
that produce the same file formats as their PC counterparts. And
tons of apps on both platforms that have proprietary formats.

If he is running OS X, he can just print to a pdf file and the world
can read it!

by jake2006

Fire the whiney tech and replace him with one that can deal with 4
Mac users. Saves on training costs.

by jake2006

Plenty of old Macs in use doing email, worksheets, word processing
and access the internet. Macs could access the internet out of the
box back when you had to jump through hoops to get a PC to do
the same.

by jake2006

The value is based on no only the speed of the hardware but the
software. Did you forget this was a Mac OS bashing topic? The
value of the older Macintosh is the ability to run the Mac OS and do
useful work.

by jake2006

The real truth is that people like what they first get used to.
Case in point, many years ago I worked at a university and we
were evaluating desktop publishing programs to support one.
There wer e three contenders that we tested. There were three
testers. Remember that this was in the early days of desktop
publishing and none of us had prior experience outside of word
processing. we each started with a different package and rotated
through all three. End result, each of us liked the first package
we tested best, and had judged the other two by what we
learned frim the first one. so if something was doen differently
in package two, then to us it seemed inferior to the way it was
doen in package one.

by wlbowers

The reason that Mac is going to the Intel processor is because
people like you can't fathom the fact that a RISC processor
running 2.5 gig is faster in applications than a CISC processor
running 4 gig.

You look at a number and get tunnel vision.

I have a 2.5 gig Mac that is crapping all over a 2800+ AMD
Athlon. Using the same programs doing the same operations.

Photoshop doing filtering and processing of a 1200 dpi photo.

Lee

by snarfiorix

You argument by picking a single operation with a single app and throw in tunnel vision?

Eat my SQL 2005 on a AMD Athlon 64 FX processor
Intel hypertreading only slows it down....

And if you want to go server based...eat my AMD Opteron

by wlbowers

It's like riding a Harley. If you can ever afford one you will never
go back.

Mac user since 1988

I work on PC's.

Lee

by neildsouza

The computer was made to make your life easy. Only us dumb
humans want to complicate that simplicity. Why would you want
to use an 8 button mouse, bro?

That said, the Mac OS is the most sophisticated system. Even
more sophisticated than Windows. It's UNIX to the core. So it's
better, right?

The Mac rules as a simple and easy to use machine. The learning
curve is very short. The advantage... even your granny would be
able to use a Mac.

Tell me again why you want to complicate that process?

Unless you're that nosy guy that threw a fit when the world
introduced laser mice. Why? Coz he could clean the balls
anymore!!!!

by sonicbridge

Started with Apple in the 80's and have been enmeshed with PC's since. Bought a G5 in September last year and still haven't cracked open the OS Manual. I'm sure I will eventually find something other than the mouse to complain about; but please let me enjoy the bliss a little while longer. I still own both. PC for practical business matters and Mac for my creative endeavors.

by wlbowers

Naw! it's because a Mac person can do more with one button
that a PC person could do with 3.

Control click brings up contextual menus. And they change with
what you click on.

I have installed and programmed the logitec 4 button mice for
PC users only to have them call me to remember what they were
programmed for.

To scared to click on them I guess.

Keep trying though.

by hiredgun469

Sounds like you just have bad luck or you just don't know what
you're doing. I bought my first Mac in 1995 and I have NEVER
had to put a penny into a repair. Not even a battery!! I still use
this machine. It's not my main Mac right now, but it still does
money making work for me. My father-in-law is on his 4th PC,
because they either become slow with programs that are
installed or they just stop working. And around my small town,
in order to get something to work you have to pay them $75 an
hour and after just 2 or 3 hours you almost have a new PC
payed for. Macs are solid machines and yes like every computer
they do have some problems. But overall they're rock solid.
And now that the OS is UNIX based, there is so much more you
can do with them. So if you're a Windows user and like to hack
the backend code or whatever...hack away. Have you ever dove
into the Terminal? I could write all day about this subject, but it
would be a waste of time. But I would like to say one other
thing, and that is that I hate when uneducated people say, "but
you can buy thousands of programs for a PC". Sure you can.
You can for a Mac also, but reguardless of the platform, after
selecting about 20 - 30 programs, the rest are either programs
that do the same as other ones, but may have a different GUI.
Or they are just crappy, buggy, worthless programs. The first
20 - 30 are money making productive programs and the others
are time wasters. Also keep in mind a lot of the Windows
"inovations" are ideas stolen from the Mac and then done wrong.

by mickeymac

as a 'lefty' you should appreciate the one-button-mouse. There is
no confusion about which is the 'right' mouse button, even when
you are "cack-handed"!

This discussion is closed to new replies.