Discussion Locked

To lease or to buy??

0 helpful
18 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm looking into a complete revamp of a network with around 25 users and was wondering about the pro's and cons of leasing the new desktop pc's

Any advise would be great!

18 replies

by jck

leasing means no maintenance where owning would when your warranty runs out. leasing also means you can get tech upgrades at intervals. leasing sometimes is less expensive for short term use.

however, leasing means you have no assets from your investment.

depends on what your situation is. if you have no support staff for them, then leasing is best because the vendor supplies it. if you have an IT staff and you have other places you could use the PCs later because the latest tech isn't necessary, owning could be a good option.

by charliespencer

"leasing means no maintenance where owning would when your warranty runs out."

Most desktop leases I've seen are for three years. If you purchase, the major vendors offer upgrades to a three-year warranty, so this is kinda of a wash. If you do purchase, make sure to get that extension.

by Member 23340214

Unless you are a video production house or some other industry that requires all equipment be cycled regularly so you can stay competitive, I would recommend buying.

Even if you plan to buy new equipment every few years, it might be an incentive if you offered the older equipment for cheap to the employees. Something to consider.

by charliespencer

I don't know much about that line of work, but I guess you're better off buying.

Most of your workers are doing Internet-based social networking, searching the web for content, generating / responding to e-mail, creating mass mailings and personalizing them from a database of contacts. You probably have some database programmers, but I suspect most of their heavy lifting is done through servers and not on the desktop.

You may have a minority that's generating content that requires publishing or heavy-duty graphics / video content. I suspect they're a small enough minority that you're better off purchasing your fleet, upgrading those few power users every 24-36 month, and letting everyone else use their system until it dies.

Make sure your hardware will support Windows 7 since you're going to be keeping these systems for a while.

IT in a political party? Sounds interesting!

by Member 23340214

I agree with Palmie, that your best option is to buy. I would even entertain the notion of thin clients for the bulk of your people. Thin clients are more secure and the user can't do anything to mess things up too much. It would make your life much easier. Provide workstations to those who need more than the usual Office apps. Try to centrally administrate everything, and remap all Documents folders to a server, both for security and for safety.

by poppatab

I can't add much more to what the two gentelmen have put before you. A good test is to calculate expense of all things concerned for 3-5 years. After that amount of time replacement should come up again. The organization's cost effective choices should come around. Do not just go with the cheapest price range; all to often less is horrible instead of more. A NFP organization should be able to drive a better bargain as opposed to a FPO. Not knowing the particular business type will cripple any remarks as to how to manipulate a good resolution for you. In some situations like a small business; a good thing to do is take the computing to outside sources that provide a smaller TCO as opposed to inhouse TCO. If the computers make the money for the operation; you should already have an IT system that can specialize operations to your need. Too many answers to the general question.

by hal 9000

But the main thing to look out for is that if you lease and have any Data Protection Policies in Place that you have to comply with you'll need to do something as you do not own the actual hardware and when it is returned to it's owner you'll need to do something to make sure that the Data doesn't get loose from the company.

The leaser is quite within their rights to on sell any Data that they find on HDD's when they get them returned as it is their Data to do with as they please. Could be very damaging to the company and result in large Law Suits depending on what they actually do.

If there are Issues with Data protection I would say Buy as it's cheaper in the long run but if you are looking for just a Tax Break Lease and pay a lot more over the Lease Period that what you would pay to actually own the hardware.

I have one client who has a Lease Toshiba NB over a 3 year period she's going to be paying $3,850.00 AU for a $2,500.00 NB and has to send it to the Agent to have any work performed on it.

So you do the maths yourself and work out just how much you'll end up paying for the use of the unit and how much will be involved to securing your Data from being on sold.

Col

by drowningnotwaving

I sell software to leasing companies. Captive, commercial, 1st, 2nd, 3rd tier lendors, banks, floor-plan, construction et bloody cetera. I have a fair understanding of how leasing works, as it's our software that does it.

There are hundreds of lease options and nuances.

Some people have said that the vendor includes support.

They only do that if you [b]pay for it[/b]. They are generally known as "full-service" leases where the cost of service/support is built into the monthly lease payment.

Same as a car lease - I can choose to just lease the car, or I can include services in the lease (and I can usually pick from a list of services that I want to include or exclude) or I can get a 'wet' lease where they include running costs as well. It's your choice - at one end of the spectrum is convenience and service, and at the other end I get more car for my dollar. Just remember that the more services you include, the cost goes higher than market rates as everyone along the way is adding their 0.75% margin.

So its often cheaper to lease the PC's and organise a separate service agreement on monthly charges from the vendor, as the vendor and lessor are not adding their margin and brokerage on every lease payment.

You need to speak to at least 3 credible lessors - typically the vendor (especially if it is awell-known vendor Dell, HP or the like, and get a lot of options.

Although the truth is, right in the present economic climate, unless your owners / directors are prepared to guarantee the lease with their houses, the chance of a small-medium-sized business getting a lease is slim at best.

Also MAKE SURE you understand the full implication of the lease, especially an Operating Lease. When you return the gear it will usually be expected in its original box with matching serial number, including the foam packing in good condition, including all cables etc (and sometimes even the manuals). This is where a lot of leasing companies (especially vendor-lessors like HP or Dell) make HUGE profits on their operating lease - they will charge you their exorbitant retail prices for all these things. It's in the contract that the machinge has to be returned in original condition for on-selling. (In Asia-Pac some vendors are known to charge $100 for the cardboard box for a PC they sold for $800!).

Beware of the "inertia" period at the end of the operating lease - this is where the lease is actually finished, but for whatever reason you basically don't change the machines and keep on paying the monthly rental. This is pure GOLD for the leasing company as their costs of funds have already been secured in the normal lease period. Nearly all your monthly payment is straight profit.

You can sometimes negotiate a 'stepped' inertia payment such that, after 3 months following the end of lease, the payments drop to 75%, and after 6 months / 9 months similar drops. Not all lease companies will discuss this, and none will do it in "hindsight". You have to secure this at the commencement of the lease.

Eyes wide open, do the research, get options and don't forget to haggle on the rates and terms. Good luck!

by charliespencer

There are probably a number of user who travel to state / local party offices. Those guys are definitely going to need some form of mobile system and a VPN solution. Depending on the workload, they may need full 'desktop replacement' class laptops, although the highest-end netbooks might be acceptable. I'd field-test a couple of netbooks but go with laptops until the tests are done (3-6 months, although it would be good to include a campaign season if possible).

by Member 23340214

A thin client is a small desktop box that contains limited storage and processing power and relies on the server to do most of the processing. This semester we are experimenting with putting HP thin clients in the library for student use. It has Windows XP SP2 in ROM and we have it set up to restore to a default configuration after the student logs off. That means any changes they tried to make to the system (like screen backgrounds and such) are immediately reverted back to our standard desktop. They are easy to control through group policy and very inexpensive. If something goes wrong, just reset the box. All the applications and user data are stored on a server anyway. They have made my life easier and I'm recommending we replace all the publicly accessible PC's with them. Maybe the reception desk as well.

by joer

To lease versus buy seems like it's more of an accounting issue than a technical one. There might be technical differences, to be sure, but don't dollars, depreciation, write-offs, etc. drive that kind of question?

by drowningnotwaving

Cash flow, ability to pay, tax position, effect of ownership on balance sheet, capacity to guarantee etc etc.

I.T. has a little to do with it, but in general it's 95% a business decision.

by Member 23340214

Yes it is something you want to involve accounting and the CEO in, and it is ultimately their decision, but IT must be able to draw a clear path for the business to follow. The CEO has already defined and (probably) enforces decisions be made in accordance to the mission and vision of the company, and IT is supposed to understand those concepts and make recommendations for technology that are in line with that and that even promote or further the mission.

The idea that IT is disconnected from the business isn't healthy.

by drowningnotwaving

... my comment had nothing to do with the connection of IT and business, really.

Same as relocating to a new office: Many, if not all, staff can be involved in establishing the requirements of a new office. They can all provide input to space, services, location, style, etc etc. They can provide input to the colour schemes as well!

But the decision to rent or buy the office space has nothing to do with the general staff.

Given also the comments from people on this thread, presupposing the LeaseVBuy decision according to the industry the company is in, or the type of hardware they are buying, I would think the evidence is substantial that those people have little understanding of the business issue at hand.

edit shpellink.

This discussion is closed to new replies.