Discussion Locked

Ubuntu Linux - It Just Works... well, except for that.... and that... and..

0 helpful
185 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

185 replies

by slayer_

-Note, I had my Ubuntu Experience 5 months ago, so allow for version changes that may have fixed bugs in what I am going to say.

As to the topic poster, I had 99% of the problems you had at first install on my machine, plus a few more, and I never could actually get the printer to work nor my sound card. Both were compeltely incompatible. They work with every Windows system, 3.1 and up, but not with Ubuntu.

So what is the proper Linux choice.

Here is my specs

200 mhz machine, P2 with MMX
256 RAM (SD Ram)
33 gig HDD (Would like at least 25 gigs free after OS install and all needed apps)
Soundblaster 16 AWE64 sound card (ISA Card)
ATI Xpert@play video card (4mb, PCI card)
Cannon BJC4300 Printer on a serial port (non USB)
Not sure what the network card is, install for it is on floppy disk. It is PCI however.

AT the moment this system is running Windows 95 and is my web/FTP/File server at home. As you can imagine, its fairly unstable. I had ubuntu doing the server parts (after a month of tweeking) but the printer never did work, over a network or locally (thus the demise of Ubuntu cause I had lots of legal documents that needed printing).

So what is a good Linux for me that can install Apache, an FTP server (don't care which), Database server (mysql preferably), PHP and all that web stuff :).
I also want a GUI interface, one that is intuitive becauce I am a Windows wizkid, not Linux, I have tinkered in Linux, done some Linux courses, but it still baffles me and I want to spend as little time as possible trying to configure it, and I want it still useable as a workstation as well, word documents, etc. The occasionaly ancient Windows game like X-com series. I don't require a GUI to configure apache (i've messed with it enough to know it fairly well) but the FTP servers, it would be nice to have a GUI for it, same with MYSQL (I found GUI's for both of these on my last Ubuntu attempt so I would asume they still work).
Lastly, the machine cannot crawl, on Ubuntu, loading a sudo session of the file explorer honest to god, took 10 minutes, I would enter the command, then walk away, it wouldn't even change the mouse curser or anything to show it was working, I just had a timer to go off after 10 minutes and I would walk back and maybe it would have finished loading. That is completely unacceptable. (I tried two different GUI's, the first one was the default one, the second wa ssome blue one that I don't know the name of)

Now this should be possible, if Linux is so great as people say it is, it should be able to do what Windows 95 can do (At the very least).

So please, advice would be appreciated, as I really don't want to install XP on such an old machine.

by slayer_

Sorry, consider me a nub, I see 3 options, Mandriva one, option KDE or GNOME (I know these are GUI's but I don't know the difference) and then below those it says Madriva Linux free 2009.

Which should I choose? And to verify, Mandriva will meet my needs, because it is a pretty big hassle to install a new OS (after backup the server etc.) get everything set up, to find out it doesn't work as I need to too and require me to go back to Windows 95 and go thru the painful process of setting up that again (Just use your imagination on how difficult it would be to make a Win95 machine into a functional webserver, requires about 4 hours worth of solid effort)

And thank you for the response.

by slayer_

I think it is more likely that Linux popularity in business will fall on it's face competely because users will be too concerned with job security and other problems, to be able to learn a new opperating system. And any change that big costs a lot of money, not to mention any windows software that is almost guranteed not to work on Linux.

However, homeuser usage may spike because people don't want to dish out money to MS for the OS. Also when Windows 7 is released and flops out and anouys people, there will be yet another spike.

Basically I see business use flatlining, and home uses going up in the future. (linux will always be the prefered choice for web servers, so no worries there)

by jaqui

on the ftp mirror you can browser the folders to get 2008.1

the 2009 wants 512 mb ram so is useless for you.
[ newer GNOME and KDE desktops are windows vista, tons of resources needed for f*ck all in functionality addition, only tons of eye candy ]

by neon samurai

I had cut a 2009.0 liveCD for my quick and dirty desktop needs but found a notebook on the weekend it couldn't boot on; chewed itself trying to load KDE4.1's desktop.

I'm going to recut my 2008.1 liveCD for adhoc needs.

On the desktop, I hadn't yet found reason to upgrade to 2009.0 so it's happily chugging along on 2008.1 Free still.

by jaqui

it's bloated into uselessness as far as I'm concerned.
and dolphin is another stupid mistake the kde team made.

by slayer_

I was selecting canada as country so it wasn't showing a mirrior for it, I'm in now ftp://ftp.gtlib.gatech.edu/pub/mandrake/official/iso/2008.1/

Which file do I want?

by jaqui

mandriva-linux-free-2008-spring-cd1-i586.iso
mandriva-linux-free-2008-spring-cd2-i586.iso
mandriva-linux-free-2008-spring-cd3-i586.iso

all 3, less download of packages after install for what you want to have the system for.

and the wizards in the DrakXtools [ Mandrake Control Center ] will get apache, mysql and php working just fine. same as proftpd.

addendum:

Mandriva 2008.1 runs fine on an old Dell Inspiron laptop, 266MHz cpu with 128 MB sdram. it will work fine on your system.

it will take a custom install to have it install everything at once, the desktop install won't install apache, mysql or proftp

by slayer_

Does that requirement include a GUI?

Also if it has something similar to the package manager in Ubuntu I'm sure I can figure that much out :).

What will be the HDD space requirements when this is done?

Also is this for sure going to allow the use of a serial port printer and ISA card for sound? (The two main problems with Ubuntu I had)

by neon samurai

A good project that attracts developers will grow and evolve until a project better at those functions succeeds it. The Linux kernel could be dropped if something better came along fitting into that function (maybe HURD will get a billion dollar grant with no strings attached).

OpenOffice seems to be loosing steam so we'll see if a fork of OOo or another suite entirely replaces it.

The anarchy across the entire community is probably not much worse than the anarchy across the entire win32 or Apple community. Those later two have there own central authorities that keep the os development on track but each is only concerned with a single OS or group of OS versions. In the same way, Red Hat and the other distribution developers keep there own OS on it's own track. The fact that development goals differ from distribution to distribution is not an issue since each is a separate entity. As for the individual distro goals. Debian Stable speaks for itself. Ubuntu continued to evolve towards an unscary different for regular users though installing by hand is always going to present issues that a preinstalled OS won't. Mandriva's EEE version would be interesting to try after Xandros and PCLinuxOS though in the case of PCL your getting .deb back end with mandriva's draketools on top.

Overselling is definately a risk though. Just as many people have been sold 2000k gaming rigs and a 500$ OS for checking there email, I'm sure more than a few EEE consumers have been rushed to the checkout before finding out if they need a notebook with embedded OS or platform for a specific application or game. Bumping sales figures by pushing units out the door without considering the consumer needs helps no one.

by neon samurai

I could guess it brings over all the blank spaces if it's just doing a binary copy. I noticed that it makes use of dd so that would do it.

runs of a liveCD and can place itself in ram freeing up the disk writer.. I'll take slow for that.

by neon samurai

I've had a couple of purchases that couldn't go back to the store. Not broken but opened packaging or missing receipt and it's off to Ebay. Nothing like paying 120$ so you can sell it off at a third that cost. On the buying side though, I've got some good deals at other's resale expense.

I'd be tempted to go with the 900 series though it becomes a tossup between it or a full notebook at that point.

On the up side, Maemo 5 is going to be completely open source code so the few personality traits in my N810 will be fixed (mm.. yummy true NIC support for monitoring mode).

by Member 19291532

The entry level netbooks all have very small SSD HDs and smaller screen sizes.

When you step up to the bigger screens and large physical hard drives, you open up a can of worms...

MSI Wind with a 160gb hd? Acer or ASUS... or Lenovo. All offer very formidable netbooks in this category, and they all offer a balance of attractive features and a few significant disadvantages, for right around the same $350-$499 price range. Which also puts them frighteningly close to low-end full fledged notebook prices from makers like Acer.

So, having bought a Acer dual core 15.4" laptop for my daughter for the Christmas before this most recent Christmas, for $450... with 2gb of RAM, Vista Home Premium, and 240gb hard drive... It was hard to decide to drop $400 for a Netbook and add another $120 for a 500gb hard drive.

But it was about form-factor and requirements. I've got the 17" notebook for full fledged PC requirements. I wanted something like a LOADED iPod - is the best way I could describe it. The netbooks are more like computing appliances than COMPUTERS, and that was part of the allure. I take the netbook with me along with my work notebook to work. I take it with me to class. I keep it around at all times. A NOTEBOOK is... a notebook. That extra 5.4" of screen makes a big footprint difference.

I went with Lenovo because when I weighed everything else, it was all very close, with MSI probably second... and so I gave Lenovo points for name brand and for my experience with Thinkpads throughout the years. Totally arbitrary and gut-feeling. MSI, I've had a lot of experience with, too, and to be honest, ACER, ASUS and MSI are all top-tier "2nd shelf" DIY brands. They're not ECS or Shuttle, but they're not HP or Lenovo, either. And MSI and Acer are both brands that are marginal in their niche. Lots of good stuff, every now and then a turkey. The HP and Dell netbooks were never in the running for me, for a variety of reasons.

But ultimately, whatever you decide, once you move away from the almost toylike nature of the Eee PC 701, it becomes a real tough decision that absolutely starts to bump against that "cheap notebook" ceiling.

by neon samurai

For a quick test, the liveCD One is fine but it stamps everything to the physical drive when you install from it.

Mandriva Free with a custom install is the way to go. Install only what you need and the dependencies are modest; no everything KDE is a dependency for anything KDE.

I do a minimal install to get past the first boot then add the rest through urpmi so I get just what I want. If you go this route you can get X and draketools up quickly or pick them during the custom package selection. As long as you have draketools and rpmdrake selected, your pretty much set to do the rest by GUI after that.

Like Jaqui says though, you can do your full package selection by browsing the custom install (check "choose individual packages") or select by package types (don't check "choose individual packages").

by neon samurai

Once you get past the first boot and into a GUI with draketools, dig around in "configure my computer" until you find the hardware tool (under "system"?). It will automatically scan your system and try to install anything that is missing.

If that does not detect and configure your audio then try sndconfig (soundcfg maybe?) it was the old terminal based wizard for detecting and configuring ISA audio. It favours soundblaster but if it works you'll get an audio file played to confirm right away.

The printer will depend on CUPS supporting it unless the vendor has a Linux/CUPS driver available for download.

8 gig is probably more than enough for the root partition though you'll want to put /home on a separate partition with as much space as you plan on storing under your user. If your going to do http and ftp then you may want a separate partition for /var also (/var/www and /var/ftp separate instead for industrial web and ftp uses).

If your not sure and you just want to do a test install, dump it all on one partition or only cut a seporate /home that you can zip up. You can see how much space the different areas will need then decide how to partition if desired.

note: a separate /home means I can reinstall the OS and have my config in /home/user ready and waiting after the reinstall.

by slayer_

Is there a good step by step I can read to get a light weight custom install as you describe? (I haven't seen the installer yet so I do not know what to expect)

by slayer_

Soundblaster 16 AWE64 ISA With IDE CD support.

Also I had tried sound config command line in Ubuntu and it did not work (I don't remember why not). The closest I got was editing some file and it made the card produce static instead of sounds.

And as for printer, as far as I know there is no linux drivers for it other than what are built into it. Which were apperently the USB drivers. The drivers it had would turn the printer on, but would not print.

by neon samurai

If not, I never had a problem with sndconfig (soundcfg?) detecting it but that was a while back also.

The installer is very graphic and easy to work with. I still go half way through the install wizard just to use the partition tool before pulling the CD out and installing whatever OS I'm actually putting on a machine.

Try "pefect mandriva desktop" or "perfect mandriva 2008.1 desktop" and you should get a few links to howtoforge with lots of pictures. I don't know if they walk through a custom install though.

If possible, you can always install a few times on a VM if this is your primary machine your using to test with. Then you see the installer all the way through to your desired desktop before formatting a physical drive.

by slayer_

I use the micrsoft virtual machine program on my monster machine all the time for running Vista VM's and XP VM's. Will it understand a Linux install? (I tradtionally have issues because my CD drives on that machine are both attached to a RAID controller)

And for the sound, it was apperently the ISA that killed it (from what I gathered from the responses to my help requerst on the Ubuntu forums), and apperently the AWE64 was a driver enchancement or something for MIDI files that doesn't exist for Linux :(

by lathan_devers

Umbuntu 8.10. No problems. Worked great until I applied updates from the internet. It then killed the network card. So had to do some research on my XP computer to find solutions. There is a lot of good help from Linux users. The OS was very good in my opinion but as was stated earlier, you have to be willing to tweak.

by Member 19291532

Yeah, that is a pretty common experience, across a lot of different hardware.

And that is one of my complaints. I know Windows Update often causes problems across a wide variety of hardware - in any large IT shop auto updates are regarded with a tremendous amount of suspicion for this very reason. "Regression test first before going into production". But the few times I've had relatively minor issues with a Windows Update *personally* -

1) The issue is addressed *quickly*. Not quickly as in "free-beer we'll get to it eventually" quickly, but quickly as in, a few days generally, a week occasionally, and rarely if ever longer than two weeks.

2) Doing a rollback to an auto-checkpoint almost always resolves the issue caused by the update, immediately. So often it is generally my first, no-brainer troubleshooting approach when I encounter a machine acting "differently" shortly after an auto update rolls out.

This, to me, is another example of where an OS that has the motto "It just works", should be going to pains to make certain it is living up to that claim. "It just breaks and is relatively difficult to research and resolve and might take awhile for an actual fix to be released"... just doesn't have the same ring to it, no?

And something like wireless is critical and significant today. It it was just breaking parallel and com ports, that wouldn't be such a big deal. If it was just making USB2.0 run at 1.0 speeds that would be something you could live with. But having WiFi iffy from the get go, with erratic results with WPA and WPA2 reported across the board, and having updates BREAK even that little bit of functioning WiFi...

Seems bad. Seems like something that you would want a team working on day and night for as long as it takes to solve the problem.

But you're not going to get that out of people who have day jobs and do what they do out of passion. Hard to follow your passion when you've lost your day job and can't pay the bills.

Not to be critical. It is just the catch-22 that I see Linux caught in. I mean, I assume Canonical has some full time developers working on the OS and these issues, much like RedHat or the other distros with major financial backing - but I can't imagine it is anything like the resources Apple or Microsoft can bring to bear.

Speaking of which, the only auto update I've ever had trouble with from Apple was an iTunes Win32 market issue - and that was fixed a few days later.

Which is really my point. It is a shame, but t seems to be the reality of the situation, from where I stand.

by neon samurai

When your talking about hardware support that's a kernel topic so you'd have to count both canonical and the active kernel developers that contribute to the Linux project. With hardware specifically you also have to consider how open the manufacturer is with drivers, source or interface specs.

Microsoft and Apple both have resources but it becomes a matter of how much budget and kernel development team members your willing to dedicate for how long. Would they have more than a few hundred developers each for Darwin's or the NT kernel?

Microsoft has the advantage of not providing the hardware modules (we get to download them separately from driver support sites). Apple has the advantage of a small hardware library and very control appliance.

I'd like to see what would happen in kernel development if more hardware manufacturer's took the Linux kernel developers up on the offer to write drivers for them. They provide the hardware interface specs and support across all BSD and Linux will appear.

In your case, I'd have to look at what support the wifi chip maker provides. Broadcom has a few NIC that require using the Window driver inside a wrapper.

by neon samurai

both my awe64 and audigy2 worked fine for audio but an audiotech working in midi may notice differences I didn't. audigy2 was detected by draketools where the awe64 was old enough that I had to use the sound config script. My only complaint about the onboard audio I'm using now is that it's 5.1 and I'm not sure I'm getting all five channels out of it. No issues really though.

VirtualPC may be worth a try. I think Microsoft has it playing nice with Suse now so it should accept other distributions well enough provided it's VM bios includes "boot from cdrom". VMware Server is an easy install also and has support for a longer list of OS but that would mean installing another chunk of software; you'd have to decide if VMs are worth it for your needs along wit migrating your existing VirtualPC images.

by slayer_

I mostly just use VM's as a backup server (for when 95 fails me) and as test machines, or for visiting naughty websites safely :).

And the occasional time I'll boot up a 95 or 98 VM (Which interestingly won't work if you use hardware virutalization...?) for when I want to test software compatibilty, or I want to work on one of my really old programs that require the older libraries of Windows 95. (Such as TMM, http://www.download.com/Trevor-s-Music-Mixer/3000-2139_4-10532051.html)

by Member 19291532

As it relates to Linux, anyhow, is development cycle is too erratic and slow - no capital incentive. A labor of love is often neglected, labor for wage is tied to quality of life.

MythTV would be a great example. I've been an avid BeyondTV Win32 proponent after months of trying to wait for MythTV to mature, years ago. It didn't develop fast enough and I needed something stable, reliable, and intuitive THEN. I've heard great things about MythTV now, and I know BeyondTV faltered at one point. Difference is, BeyondTV corrected *quickly* because sales were tied to perception of quality. MythTV has a casual, laid back development cycle. That doesn't work for me for my application of a PVR/DVR.

Open Office has *never* seemed to have much promise to me. When I first played with it, it was, frankly, horrible. Hopping from distro-site to distro-site in South America, from month to month. Sun never really seemed interested in actually growing it, once they had acquired it.

The problems that plague Ubuntu right now or recently - including ATI graphics issues, wireless issues, broken Flash plug-ins... they are all issues that would get top priority in the Win32 or OS X world, but they kind of languish on Linux. At least, that has been my perception. Apple releases a broken iTunes, and the buzz gets loud, and it is fixed QUICKLY.

The Samba/CIFS issue with FreeBSD on gb Nics has been public knowledge for months and months, and I haven't seen a lot of incentive displayed to correct it.

It is just different. If all three evolve, Linux evolves like a shark or turtle.

:)

by slayer_

I won't even touch an application that requires .net to be installed, I keep that junk off my computer. .net is just another bloated layer for micrsoft programs to be coded on and it prevents apps from being run on different OS's, even different Windows OS's.

We actually have clients running Windows 95, so no .net for them, we code in VB6 for them.

Also for many of my projects, I needed an EXE to run to actually install .net, I chose VB6 for this again as its requirements come built into XP. It's kind of like the perfect solution, use VB6 for all your windows programming needs and ditch .net, yes its not object oriented, but you can code in an object oriented way if you actually want to, VB6 just doesn't enforce it on you. Also form quirks are pretty irritating (like if you check if a form is loaded, the check itself will actually load the form).

Actually for anything non visual, we use VBS :).

by neon samurai

self motivation can be powerful than wage slavery.

I?m sure it?s not true in all cases but I?d put my money on the self motivated developers who choose to work on projects of interest over the one?s assigned a project and a deadline to reach a pay cheque. I?d much rather a project I happen to get paid for versus an assignment motivated only by the pay; I?ve tried both. Even if the developers are passionate about the project, they still have a deadline, limited time and limited resources on a wage gig. The projects that interest bug money get attention from paid resources also; the kernel being a good example still.

It does mean that projects less interesting to developers get left out like MythTV. I?d like to see more development in the area of tv tuners and apps myself. In the case of BeyondTV, users would be out of luck had they not self corrected. Us Longbow2 game lovers are in that very position, the original developer is long gone though the game is far from dead. With a custom built rig or some hacks, one can get the game running but there is still interest. Heck, if I could afford to by the source and release it that?s probably the one program I?d choose.

OpenOffice seems to be having a number of problems recently. The majority seem Sun induced by holding development back and alienating any developers that do take interest in the project. Jack has an article about it out in the last few days.

The SSH issue got a lot of attention from Debian developers once discovered but it has a lot more important for the platform than CIFS support. That would be my guess anyhow. Microsoft would be all over a CIFS issue like the Vista one that potentially ate files in transfer but they?re still tip-toeing around security design issues. Linux supported USB and Bluetooth standards faster, MS and Apple support other hardware bits faster. In some areas it balances out. In some areas it still out of whack (GPU support, ATI specs are finaly open but the module is playing catchup. I still need ndsiwrapper for my Linksys wrt54G pcmcia but the tinkpad NIC is supported natively.)

I?d really like to see what the three OS could do with published interface specs. Apple supports it?s hardware plus the BSD list. Microsoft get?s bleeding edge drivers from vendors for gaming hardware. Linux supports the hardware it knows about and reverse-engineer?s support for hostile hardware as best it can. What if all three gained equal access to the info to write drivers?

by slayer_

I wonder what would happen if the modern latest and greatest games worked on Linux without a hitch or the need for emulators or anything. And Linux could be used by hardcore gamers.

Oh how I would love to see that happen.

by Member 19291532

When I was younger. But now I almost exclusively play console games, so I don't care as much. I suppose there are still a lot of PC gamers out there that this is relevent to, though.

They tried with Quake III Arena... it was available release day on Linux.

Too many problems, not enough demand.

Of course, Linux still wasn't very mature at that time. I think they were counting on the Linux community being more technically inclined to support the application, and that didn't happen with people who had Linux and bought the retail boxed game.

by slayer_

Linux would completely destroy windows in gaming performance. If linux has the ability to unload its visual components and any memory wasters, and free up all possible resources for the game running, I bet it would run sweet.

But I supose the question is, is it up to game producers to make Linux versions, or is it up to Linux to work for Windows games?

I am honestly not sure what needs to be done to make a Windows game work on Linux, I don't think worrying about the different folders would matter, just install to home directories??? I supose DirectX API's would be broken, so perhaps all games should be coded in OpenGL (I asume Linux supports OpenGL).

Permissions shouldn't be a problem if everything is saved to a home directory.

If more than one user was to want the game, then I am not sure. Also somethign to function like the system registry would be needed (I am not familure enough with Linux to know if something similar already exists)

by jck

i wish i lived up there. i'd love to pick your brain on weekends.

i am gonna get openSUSE and try that, since I have been MS oriented for 15 years.

I am moving into Java/JS/XML tho, so I am seeing the light! Now all I gotta do is learn a Linux-based GUI well enough to write code for Linux lol

by Member 19291532

Evidently a dude I worked with at Intel was a room mate with Carmack for quite awhile in college.

From everything I've picked up, Carmack hates DirectX and working with the Microsoft graphic engine.

If I recall correctly, Quake III Arena for Linux was an attempt by ID to explore the viability of breaking away from having to deal with Microsoft specifications for graphics in relation to coding.

My direction here is that I think someone like Carmack is probably very receptive intellectually to making his applications available for Linux. The fact that Quake III Arena seems to have really been the first and last attempt to co-release a major title for Win32 and Linux at the same time illustrates that for some reason, there was an obstacle to pursuing this commercially.

One of my gut feelings is that people looking to cut corners on the cost of their OS generally aren't looking to PAY for their video game entertainment. But there are probably a lot of other reasons, too.

by slayer_

PC gaming is generally dying off. There are very few good games out there, except for online games, where PC's still rule. Online games SHOULD be made to work on Linux

by neon samurai

The consoles have take a chunk of the gaming market but PC gaming is far from dead. We're also still seeing the latest gaming hardware released for PCs due to the modular design. Use the PC to see what technology can really do then shrink-wrap it into a console to stagnate a few years before taking the latest gen hardware to shrink-wrap the next generation of consols.. and so the hopscotch game continues.

Granted, the library selection of PC games is not the long list of genera and titles that it once was.

regarding DCol's comment, I though ID Software was still releasing everything across platforms. It was one of the few game development houses that didn't pander to the single DX platform. Have they stopped releasing across platforms?

While non-MS will always lack directX, there are some very nice benefits to native non-directX development. installing flightgear was a total of checking the box beside it in the package selector. Adding my unlisted flightstick to the game was nothing more than copying an existing config file. On my win32 gaming box, I still can't get sound out of Assassin's Creed and copying a device config file is not an option there.

MS has done a lot of work to get the game industry addicted to directX though. For now that means a gaming win32 boot and a *nix production boot.

by neon samurai

That's the reports I've heard anyhow. Even with having to WINE in the WOW client, it tends to work better on top of linux. Think what would happen if the mmorg's wrote more than the server deamon with native *nix support.

Problem is they usually do a half arsed attempt at the secondary platforms. There was a native game engine for Neverwinter under Linux but no installer. The people who where really interested had to install it manually then copy over the game content from an existing win32 partition. I commend the developer for providing a native client for the game, I just wish it hadn't been such a second class citizen handout. The non-MS folks are ready and willing to pay for quality native games.

by slayer_

I personally had no issues with the game, and I was actually impressed with how well it ran, my 9600 GT is well outperforming the PS3 in that game, even with max graphics and highest res, xfire shows 40 fps in desne population areas. The game takes very good advantage of having duel core processors.

No sound? I have to question what you are using for sound, I am guessing that AC97 garbage that used to come as onboards.

I didn't know NWN was on Linux, that was such an awesome game, but yes that is extremely lazy to not even make an Installer for it. Though what, 5 years ago, on Linux the best you could get was RPM's that required you to search the internet for dependencies, and each dependency would have 10 more dependancies until you were pulling your hair out in frustration. Perhaps this is why making installers and such was just too much work for them. Though these days I do not see the excuse. If game developers starting making Linux versions, that hardware manu's would start making Linux drivers and Linux would really take off for home users.

I've always believed the gaming industry is what drives the computer industry. Why else would we only have duel core processors at 3ghz each, and yet have video cards with 140 processors at 1ghz each?

by Member 19291532

Are greatly exaggerated.

There was a point, in the 80s, after the console crash, where PC gaming dominated. The Commodore 64 alone was probably the most responsible for this trend. And it lasted for a long time, carried by the development of the 386, 486, and Pentium and the arrival of VGA, advanced sound cards, and eventually 3D graphic GPUs. Titles like Wolfenstien 3D, Doom, Duke Nuke 'Em, Quake and the Wing Commander series were clearly superior to anything possible on a console at the time. The CFRP genre also arrived in force during this period of time. Power and modular upgradability were important factors in this PC dominance of gaming, but additionally, the I/O of these games led themselves to non-tradition (read, no dpad, no joystick) input devices. Most of these games played best with a mouse and a keyboard. Not the strong suit of console gaming. The NES, Genesis, SNES, all of these lived in the shadow of PC gaming dominance, and during this period, a lot of people were saying that console gaming was dead.

Then the PS-1 arrived, with addictive gameplay and incredible graphics and gameplay that was more dependent on a quality d-pad. PC gaming could not as easily accomodate this model, and the graphics and processing speed was pretty impressive. The tide started to turn.

In turn, rampant cheating on online multiplayer FPSs on the free for all internet kind of destroyed the communities that surrounded these games - and people just started getting tired of this genre of game.

Consoles have advantages that PC gaming will always struggle to achieve. You know the guy on the other end doesn't have a better graphic card, more memory, or a better processor. You know the game is *going* to work, with all the features, on your console - just the same as it will for anyone else with the same console. you've got a standard interface and don't have to deal with the weird calibration issues that still seem to trouble PC gaming devices. (Why does my USB d-pad eventually start pulling to the right, just like my old d-pad that plugged into the game port of my sound card? Why can't they fix this on PC gaming?)

On the other hand, with a PC, you don't have a limited lifespan on the entire unit. You can upgrade the modular components. If you're younger and on a tight budget, you don't have to worry about expensive and dangerous mods to get around certain "issues". I mean face it, that has been a traditional appeal of PC gaming for a lot of PC gamers. Backwards compatibility issues aren't as much of a problem for PC gaming. There is a lot more freedom in every way, with PC gaming.

I'd say it follows cycles, and right now some real powerful consoles are dominating the market, and the youth demographic is more oriented toward all things that the console market delivers on. This same broad youth market is kind of pushed away from PC gaming for many of the same reasons. The whole "tech knowledge" factor is higher for PC gaming, and it seems a lot more of the younger gamers are more interested in the gaming than in getting the game to work.

In the middle of that you've got the Wii really mixing things up...

But, if something innovative and unique that gets a huge mindshare arises on the PC platform, that could reverse.

Just follow the titles, from those above, through the GTA series and the rise of the rhythm guitar games, and you can see the clear evolution to today's console dominance. Get some kind of Guitar Hero killer app going that is better suited to PC gaming, and it may be a complete reversal. It has happened before, I have no doubt it will happen again.

by slayer_

There are fewer games being produced, even those that were traditionally PC are coming out on consoles. About the only game types that haven't made a move are MMORPG's and Click and move RTS games.

The SNES actually had a mouse...

Also game developers have gotten lazy, turn back the clock 10 years or so, and 3D games were made to support DirectX, DirectDraw, OpenGL, 3dFX, any anything else that was populour, they also usually had "Software mode" that was always guaranteed to work, it would just look nasty.

by Member 19291532

There are economic factors at play as well.

Games are as big budget as movies, now, and often employ the same talent pool as far as voice actors and such (some famous actors have even been 3D modeled into games as character actors).

That puts a lot more pressure on the industry.

Along with that, you've got this influx of titles of various degrees of quality - that kind of mirrors the Pre 83/84 crash oversaturation of the consoles that killed the Atari 8 bit era.

There will probably be another video-game crash and shakeout, and it'll probably go dormant for a few years, and then someone will come out with something new and must-have and it'll spread again.

I think we're also at a convergence point. Playing Fallout 3 (and a couple of other immersive, cinematic tiltes) kind of brought this home to me, but the Wii and iPhone also seem to point to a possible direction. Gaming is going to change in some significant ways in the next 10 years. We're getting to the point of very immersive I/O and graphics approaching practical virtual reality. Not quite there yet, but I think it'll be coming. At the end, consoles and PCs may be replaced by soome new model of content delivery for electronic gaming.

And really, what we are doing now isn't VIDEO gaming in the retro sense that I grew up with. Those games were like digital boardgames. Today's games are interactive cinema. Like digital "Create Your Own Ending" books in a visual format. Calling them "video games" anymore is really something of a misnomer.

by slayer_

For the simple matter of options and hacks.

Example, Need for Speed Most Wanted, the Motion blur is painful, but a quick hack turns it off, can't do that on a console.

Change graphics qualities, fix slowdowns (slowdowns on consoles are painful).

And of course, online abilities, keyboards rule!

by neon samurai

I've often said that gaming pushes hardware design while porn pushes networking and multimedia. Gaming is the older of the two for computers though.

triple sli graphics cards, multiple cores, fast storage including sata and raid on every motherboard today.. yeah.. gaming has always driven the hardware forward.

As for Assassin's Creed; the game engine is fantastic and story seems well done. I got no audio during the cut scenes and about half audio from the in game engine.

win32 + dx9 latest
asus striker 2 formula, included audio daughterboard, 4 gig ram, quad core and a single nvidia 880 gpu. audio is 5.1 flowing to 5.1 speakers. All hardware driver latest versions from asus installed.

Now, making a refined dos boot disk tuned to a specific game is a non-issue and tweaks for a game since have never been a problem (LB2, crippled but flyable still). If it's just some odd adjustment then I'd sure like to find the howto discussing it.

Full audio in every other game I've tried.. broken in Assassin's Creed. I'm nearly ready to rent it for my console just to see the story outside of the game engine.

by kmdennis

Send me your address and I will send you a harddrive. I cannot believe you ruined what would have been a useful post, by talking about a 4GB HD! >>> Ubuntu is pushing 3.4gb for a full install. That leaves me around 600mb free.<<<<
I will buy it an send it to you for free! HD is so cheep these days, it is not like VISTA and all, which will end up about 10GB after Office 07 and a few updates. C'mon now, you seem like a wiz, so lets keep that belief going.

by Member 19291532

Is actually *know* what you're talking about and understand the technology on the table.

The EEE PC has a 4gb SSD non-mechanical "hard drive". The same kind of cutting edge drives that are in the Mac Airbook and other ultra light and ultra portable notebooks.

They don't *have* a traditional HD, generally, and do not support a traditional hard drive. In that sense, Linux is supposed to be very well suited to these devices, precisely *because* of their limited storage capacity.

In fact, the SSD drive in the EEE PC is hard wired and non replaceable, and has a limited write life cycle. To that end, I've actually gone ahead and installed Linux on that particular machine to an external 8gb SD card.

But my guess is that this entire post is going to be over your head.

FWIW, one of my first upgrades on my Lenovo netbook was to replace the meager 80gb hard drive with a 500gb hard drive. That is over twice as much storage as on my 17" multi-media notebook.

by slayer_

Thats like what we used 10 years ago, running Windows 95/98.
95 was a 200 meg install, 98 is 500 megs, far better solutions for netbooks :).

XP seems to be a gig that bloats to about 3 gigs by the time its booted up twice and has patched up lol.

Linux sounds like a great solution, use a live CD lol.

I don't know if this matters, but the best Linux LiveCD I've ever run is Knoppix, instantly compatiable with all my computers, and I could actually burn CD's with it (Love having two disc drives :)). Why can't all distros be this awesome?

by jlabadessa

I have a need to run a variety of VPN clients to establish connections to several different Firewall/VPN appliances.

For the time being, I am testing a basic VPN PPTP client session to a an appliance that supports PPTP. Very easy to configure this in Windows via the built-in VPN client.

If I have success with PPTP, then I will investigate which firewall/vpn appliance vendors offer VPN client software for Linux. I would imagine most do, but have not gone down that path yet. Starting with PPTP & going from there..."walk before you run" approach.

Your success with Ubuntu has peaked my interest & I am going install that OS into VMWare Server...this is a great FREE tool that makes life alot easier when experimenting with various OS. Recommend it to anyone setting up test environments.

I will keep plugging away. Thanks & best of luck in 2009!!

by Member 19291532

Probably prevents me from having the right answers for you. I would imagine that this is something that *nix supports "out of the box" - but that configuration may be a little more obscure and difficult for someone used to a Win32 environment.

There should be good information out there, though. One thing to learn sooner than later about Linux is that doing a google search with the words "HowTo" is generally the best first place to start. In your case, I would google for "Linux Ubuntu VPN PPTP HowTo" and see what kind of hits I get and refine the search from there.

I used to use VMWare quite a bit, but I've been out of the loop on the VMWare front for quite awhile. It is a great tool for scratchbox environments. With Ubuntu, check out Wubi, which is a great way to install a full fledged Linux on a Win32 box without being disruptive at all to your Win32 environment. Uninstall is as easy as "remove application" from the Win32 control panel.

by slayer_

This is going to sound strange, but try changing your Audio drivers to a generic one provided by Windows. I am not sure which.

Otherwise, I can say the surround sound in it isn't to spectacular, the voices always sound distant except when you kill someone, then it is crazy loud. I run a 4.1 Wide setup, it understood my wide setup just fine but that is the issue I had, ignorable thats for sure, but it certainly scares you the first couple times. I am running a soundblaster Live 24 card however. So of course I never have compatibility problems :).

by Member 19291532

Heh. I missed this branch of the thread.

Dude, I'm going to tear out my Atom processor and put in a Z80 instead so I can go back to the true glory that is CP/M on the hardware it was inteded to run upon! Bring on the BDOS errors!

Anyhow, all of the netbooks get a bad rap for quality of build. With their diminutive size, they feel VERY toylike. The EEE PC is probably one of the worst on initial impression. Yet, once you get used to it, the construction feels pretty solid. I've heard the Lenovo called cheap too, and I don't really get that. Of the two, the fact that the Eee PC is non mechanical (no mechanical hard drive) makes me think it is probably the more solid of the two.

I think it is really subjective, the opinion on the build quality of a product. This probably would be a good thread to discuss somewhere else. I really like both of the ones I have, and they seem...

Here. I bought my daughter a low end core duo Acer notebook 15.4" machine about a year ago. It seems far cheaper to me - for example, there is a lot of flex in the lid/screen area. My Lenovo ThinkPad and HP DV8000 notebooks seem far higher quality.

My Lenovo feels a lot higher quality than the Acer overall. The Eee PC seems a little better quality, but not greatly... but that is just "quality of material" and "fit and finish".

by Member 19291532

Yeah, but you've got to think about what these things are designed for. 4gb is actually pretty reasonable with a fairly tight "ceiling" for just about any current OS. These devices are loaded up with USB and memory card slots, and THAT is what they intend you use for content storage (thumb drives and SSD cards).

So, for example, the Eee PC made me realize I wanted a large thumbdrive. I got a 32gb thumb drive for Christmas, and 64gb drives are available (and occasionally dirt cheap). So, you're talking about 36gb of solid state, non-mechanical storage that is also in a VERY small form factor. The advantage is that the "data" parition is easily portable from one device to another. Right now, on an Eee PC 701, if you really wanted to max things out... I think SDHD cards are up to 32gb. So, 4gb on board, a 64gb thumb drive, and another 32gb in the SD card slot, and you're talking about 100GB total, and not a single mechanical hard drive anywhere in the unit. That is pretty impressive.

Now... the PROBLEM that arises is, for example, when an OS insists on installing something into a directory on the system drive. For example, large portions of Microsoft Office want to be in C:\Program Files\Microsoft Office and in other areas on C:. In Ubuntu, unless you jump through some hoops, everything ends up in one of the default directories under /.

With 4gb for your root partition/system disk, you can accidently hit the ceiling pretty easy by adding a simple app. In my case, with Debian, Wine caused me some grief.

XP is smaller than Ubuntu on a default install - especially being that some things like Open Office, Pidgen and Gimp are "default system install" apps that "can't" be uninstalled (using the add/remove app). Even after the couple of patches - although you're right, XP starts up around 1gb and quickly grows to about 2.5gb.

It is actually easier to pare down XP and get rid or redirect some things than it is to do the same with Ubuntu, as well. The EEE PC comes with basic instructions on this, and there are a ton of sites on the web that expand on it.

by slayer_

How to move where program files is stored in Windows, so that you could move it to a thumb drive or SD card, down side is dont forget your card or chances are your system won't boot.

4 gigs still seems a bit small, I would like to see 10 gig drives, that would be perfect (for XP, Vista is another story)

When XP has used up its 2.5 gigs of Memory for itself, then page file. Which at 128 megs of RAM should be 192 megs, not too bad but will need to be increased probably to at least 512, so that is 3 gigs used, if you use hibernation that is even more memory lost. And we haven't even installed anything yet... Upgrade to IE7 and you lose more space.
4 gigs is just too small.

My Windows DIR at work here is 4.67 gigs, thats just the Windows folder, thats already too big for that computer.

by Member 19291532

And mine actually has 2.5gb.

But no pagefile. Same with Linux - no swap.

The modifications made, to Linux, Win32 or OS X are to move away from journaling filesystems (Ext3) and to disable swap/pagefile space - again, because the SSD has a limited write cycle lifespan.

But there are also creative work-arounds to use the external memory (usb drive or SD card). On my EEE PC, I'm now running Ubuntu 8.10 booting from an 8gb SD card.

Worth noting, that SSD drives are available up to about 64GB currently. The EEE PC SSD drive is non-replacable and hard soldered, so it isn't an option, and a 64gb SSD drive is expensive, so it isn't really that great of an option. Part of the allure of these little rigs is that they're relatively cheap.

But like I said... I've got 44gb total storage on my EEE PC, including the SD card, thumb drive, and built in SSD - which isn't really that bad.

by charliespencer

Copy the program directory from C:\Prog Files\WhateverApp to wherever. Run COA, specify the original directory path, and the new path. It changes the registry, .ini files, etc.

Warning: as always, back up your registry before starting.

by slayer_

Or was this just a myth? Because that sounds like the perfect solution for netbooks.
I suppose page file isn't that important if you have 512 megs if RAM under XP, XP tends to only chew 360 megs of RAM when let loose. Thats plenty left over for web browsing and email. Forget a virus scanner though, accept for maybe Avira??? Your 2.5 is plenty for anything however. What are you running virtual machines on that thing??? lol

But 2.5 gigs, thats 3.75 gig page file from default windows install, basically after installing Windows, until you adjusted this to be off you would have no SSD space.
How does that work out? Or did it go off by default?

by neon samurai

Vista has a function to use unused flashdrive space as ram/swap but it means your data is moving at the transfer rate of the USB bus. Since usb is still slower than hard drives, your just slowing your machine down or no noticable gain.

With an Eee, I'd be looking at write limits of the SD also. having a swap file constantly read and rewriten may reduce the lifespan of the SD.

With Linux based OS you want to stick with ext2 or the distro default. Journalled file systems like ext3 and RieserFS are going to eat the SD's write limit with constant journal entries.

On my N810, I have the same problem. The internal storage is inaddequate for my full prefered install. The internal ram is enough to not upgradable. Of two SD possitions, one is a non-replacable 2 gig flash chip so everything beyond that is left to the removable SD slot.

- I do a simple clean build on the internal flash storage
- I leave the GPS maps and swap file on the non-removable SD
- I partition the 8 gig removable SD with an OS partition (ext2) and the default expected storage partition (fat32)
- I close the clean OS to the SD OS partition then install the rest of my application list

ext2 means I get natively supported partition file types for Maemo Linux to run from. ext2 is not journalled so my filesystem does not eat the flash chip's write limit.

booted OS on a partitioned SD means I always have the clean OS on internal flash as a system rescue. I can replace the SD card with a new or bigger drive if the OS hits the storage write limit. I can install more than 512 meg of stuff (that's right, my PDA OS install tops out at 800 meg right now B) ).

All the other benefits of a good OS/Data separated system apply just like a Windows box with C: and D: drives.

Things like the SD write limit may apply to the Eee also. I'm not sure how boot loaders are for it but you could run from an SD or external hard drive from the sounds of it; the only speed restriction would be the usb bus.

by neon samurai

I have latest audio drivers on my desktop and managed to get them in. (another company that doesn't believe in a well written upgrade script but anyhow.. update done).

My current theory was that the game worked perfectly with DX10 but audio was broken under DX9. I'll try the generic audio drivers though and see if they are any better.

I do get the distant voices effect with headphones under NeverWinter. The audio is full through the speakers but with headphones, I need to keep the plug out one "click" to get proper audio. I'm guessing the headphone jack on the 5.1 speakers is also 5.1. I think I'm going to confirm that with some good gaming headphones. It still doesn't explain why Assassin's Creed is broken through the speakers as well.

Bah.. what can you do..

by slayer_

You can enjoy really loud sounds of peoples agonizing deaths. It's Carmageddon all over again. The perfect stress reliever.

I love when games store their SFX in WAVE files so you can simply open em up, and increase/decrease volume as needed.

by slayer_

It should wear out first instead of your SSD.

Replacing an SD card? I just bought a 512 meg SD card for 3 bucks. I'd say its worth it :).

USB however doesn't sound that handy.

by slayer_

Thanks,
dumb question but how do you backup the registry in a way that it can be reversed? I tried export but I noticed I can never reimport (or perhaps I just did it totally wrong).

I could definitly use this to shuffle some of my files around on my drives.

by jack wallen

on any given day i can throw Ubuntu at a machine and it will install without a hitch. XP or Vista on the same machine and I am spending far too much time tracking down drivers installation CDs.

everyone always says how easy XP is to install, but have you ever installed XP when it DIDN'T detect all of your hardware and you DIDN'T have drivers for everything and you DID have to spend far too much time tracking down drivers?

sure there are pieces of hardware that Ubuntu might not support but that list is growing smaller and smaller every day. and here's a little trick for you to try. instead of downloading just Ubuntu, download Ubuntu, Mandriva, Fedora, SuSE, and PCLinuxOS. one of those distributions will work.

by brian doe

...burned the t-shirt!

Most notorious of these for me were flashcard readers and sound chips (especially Realtek). Even Vista failed to find drivers for the Creative sound card in one of my computers! And who can forget that wireless card support for XP was essentially broken until the release of SP2 (and even Vista struggles with wireless connectivity)?

by brian doe

(Reposted because I somehow sent it to the wrong branch)

You make a lot of good points in your post and, overall, you are correct that Linux (including Ubuntu) is not ready for the "It just works" distinction. However, you failed to mention the real reason it doesn't "just work" for a large majority of the users reporting problems.

The single biggest reason Ubuntu doesn't always "just work" is not Ubuntu's fault. It is the unwillingness of many major hardware manufacturers to develop drivers for Linux and to open their source code for third-party development. It is also the unwillingness of the providers of many major multimedia codecs (such as Adobe's Flash, Apple's Quicktime, and others) to allow unrestricted distribution of their codecs. These mean that Canonical (and other Linux distro providers) are unable to include them with their installers.

However, the situation is getting better. Ubuntu 8.10 supports a lot of new hardware not previously supported, and Canonical has gone to every extent legally possible to connect its users with required drivers and codecs.

When I first installed Linux (Ubuntu 7.04) about a year and a half ago on an older laptop, I ended up becoming more intimately familiar with the inner workings of xorg, vim, and ndiswrapper than is healthy; however, when I installed Ubuntu 8.04 (and later 8.10) on my new HP Pavilion laptop, it very nearly literally "just worked". Just 20 minutes after I booted off the install CD, I was able to log onto my fresh, new Ubuntu desktop and even access the internet through my Intel wireless card. Within seconds, Ubuntu notified me that the nVidia restricted driver was available and, two mouse clicks later, it was installed. The first time I attempted to play some of my media files, Ubuntu offered to download and install the required codecs for me. Same for the first time I visited a Flash-enabled website.

Yes, there were a few hiccups. For example, I had to manually install a few files so that I could access my cifs network shares (which, ironically, were hosted on a server also running Ubuntu). And then there was the infamous SUDO bug with Ubuntu 8.04.

Until hardware and media codec providers open up and give the Linux community more sincere support, Linux (including Ubuntu) will never be able to earn the "it just runs" distinction. But it's mighty damned close.

by slayer_

Too bad no one is able to make an automated driver converter to convert windows drivers to linux drivers.

by neon samurai

ndiswrapper is a Linux module that wraps itself around a windows network driver so it can be used by a Linux based OS.

In the short term, there are some places I'd like to see wrappers developed but ideally, they shouldn't be needed as they are just a work around for a non-technical problem.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Screw it. I have to have Windows for work, so if I'm know I'm going to want Flash for something I just boot to Windows.

Outside of that, I've had no trouble out of Ubuntu. Installed first to an old HP laptop, then to a desktop I built back in '02, that I dual boot with XP. 'buntu suits me quite nicely outside the pita that is getting Flash to work/notwork/work/notwork.

Linux is getting easier to deal with all the time, but it doesn't 'just work' out of the box. I'm a gonna keep playin', anyway. :D

by brian doe

Just go into Synaptic and search "adobe-flashplugin", select it for install, and click "Apply". It should remove the buggy Adobe Flash 9, and the even buggier libflash-plugin packages.

by brian doe

"We have begun to look at a possible desktop replacement for our programmers and providing them with a virtual Windows desktop so that they can continue to use .NET for their programming."

Please forgive my ignorance; I am still relatively new to the programming scene (currently taking a Java course in college); but, why .NET? Why not a cross-platform solution like Java or Mono? Are there any particular advantages to .NET that a more open language doesn't have?

by Member 19291532

Was so clearly inferior to using the MadWIFI native drivers on Ubuntu with the EeePC 701 atheron drivers... it makes me wonder how limited it is in the other cases where ndiswrapper has been suggested to me.

I mean, I guess if nothing else were available, ndiswrapper and limited functioning wifi is better than *nothing at all*, but it points out another strategic limitation for *nix in competition with Win32. If the best that *nix can do is manage to implement a crippled version of the available Win32 drivers, Win32 is going to have the advantage on delivering the full features of that particular device. I mean, that is a no brainer. At that point, you've got to ask yourself, "What is the advantage I get out of running the crippled function available through Linux versus just running Win32 and getting the full feature set available?" I suppose for some people on a tight budget, or with other things to spend their money on, the idea of being able to save that money on the licensing cost is good enough. For a lot of other people, having the reliable, consistent ability to connect to a variety of hotspots with a mature set of applications and utilities to view, edit and manage those connections is going to be worth the licensing cost of Win XP or Vista.

I'm using Ubuntu fairly frequently and finding it useful. I just don't see it replacing my primary OS on my primary machine, at this stage of OS maturity. It still lacks too much.

by neon samurai

I think my old wrt54 pcmcia card may still need ndiswrapper unless that broadcom chip is covered in the newer kernels finally. If there is a native driver rather than a wrapper that's usually the far better way to go though. ndiswrapper is only giving you part functionality of the wifi card's Windows driver; modes are limited, signal strength measurement or changes are limited. The wrapper is enough to get it connecting if not supported natively.

by brian doe

This is another example of where corporate greed (or fear, or God-knows-what) causes trouble for Linux users. The latest Linux kernels support nearly all of the Broadcom chips out there. The devil in the details, however, is that Broadcom chips require firmware that must be loaded each time the card is initialized - and, of course, this firmware is proprietary and closed-source, so no Linux distro can legally include it, and the open-source community can't touch it.

Despite that, Canonical has tried to make life as easy as possible for those afflicted with Broadcom cards and have an alternate means of connecting to the internet. Ubuntu will basically download the Windows driver, then use fwcutter to extract the firmware from it. For those without an alternate means of connecting to the internet, it gets a lot more dicey; but when you have hardware from manufacturers who refuse to work with the Linux community, you have to expect such complications.

by Member 19291532

My problem is... well -was-, that I had first installed 7.04 on the EEE PC. I guess now I've reinstalled 8.10 on both the SD (7.04 remains on the SSD) card in the EEE PC and as a Wubi partition on the Lenovo S10. I'm not sure his suggestion works for 7.04. I also find that some of the difficulties may be related to what version of Flash a particular site wants (Flash 8 and 10 seem to be what sites call for). It seems like I have no backwards compatibility issues in Win32 with Flash, but I'm not certain on *nix.

I've been using the toy site "spinmaster.com" as a benchmark, simply because it is the site that first brought my attention to this problem, although I think CNN video also requires Flash and has been a problem for me. Seems like it TRIES, but I never see the video, or I see the first frame, but it won't play.

I'm going to do some testing right now, try his fix, and see how far I get.

by Member 19291532

On the Lenovo with 8.10, it looks like I got Flash 10 installed and working fine at the sites I mentioned above. Unfortunately, whereas 7.04 with MadWIFI started working (consistently) with WPA/WPA2 on my wireless network here at the office (for no known reason), 8.10 is having the same problem with failed authentication.

Seems like I traded one set of annoying minor little issues for another.

by neon samurai

Since the hardware is 32bit your not crippled by Adobe's choice to still not compile the 64bit Linux flash player. That flakey networking isn't helping anyone though.

by brian doe

Unless you have a specific need for it (accessing 3G networks, for example), I recommend replacing the default Network Manager with WICD. Network Manager has gotten better over the last few versions, but still leaves a lot to be desired (including problems remembering your network's passkey). WICD is extremely versatile. For example, you can store profiles for every wireless network you come into contact with, including passkeys, DNS info, and even whether or not to use DHCP. I can use a static IP here at home, use a different static IP on another network, and a dynamic address on a local hotspot, for example. Even Windows can't manage that sort of thing well!

by Member 19291532

You've got to download the Broadcom source from Broadcom's site, compile, make install, and run a couple of scripts.

Otherwise, it seems to be a well documented issue that there can be issues with WPA/WPA2. Especially with Netopia setups, for some odd reason. Although I'm also having problems connecting to a WEP 128b with SID broadcast disabled at the same location.

But I can get into my secured network at home, and I can get into any open network - so, it isn't worth messing with to me. Being that I have it dual-bootable, I can always just go into Win32 if I'm in a location that requires WPA2 or has AP broadcast disabled.

I suppose I *could* look at NDISWrapper with the Win32 driver as an alternative to the native Broadcom driver.

But it is just such a hassle, and the worst thing is, it means that to do EVERYTHING I want, I need to rely on Win32 at this point. That defeats the purpose, speaking from a purely academic perspective. The Wireless networking in Ubuntu in particular does seem to be fairly poorly implemented. But, it was always real difficult in Debian too. In all fairness, in Debian I usually had to end up doing a LOT more gruntwork to have a chance of getting wireless running right.

by neon samurai

I use backtrack as a liveCD around home but it doesn't have a simple wireless connection manager nor does it provide very good support for WPA2. I can get connected with little grief on WPA but not version 2. As a result, I just stick with Mandriva 2008.1 liveCD unless I need a bt tool.

It would be nice if broadcom would just get the hardware supported in the kernel but I'm guessing it relies on a firmware that broadcom is not willing to provide open specs and source for. That seems to be one easy way to be kept out of the kernel tree anyhow.

by iposner

So you're running Win95 and coding in VB6 in 2008? This is the posting of a dinosaur - the surprising thing is that (from reading your profile) you're quite inexperienced, but jaded already. Not a good trait in our business.

Firstly, .NET is not "bloat" - it offers a range of functionality and deployment options that could only be dreamed of in VB, so you're not comparing apples-with-apples. And since .NET is broken down into many DLLs, you don't have to load the whole CLR in order to run an app (as if...)

Secondly, if you actually had some serious real-world .NET experience, you'd find that the strong typing combined with the rich CLR API would slash your development time and associated costs. And these savings alone would pay for you to upgrade quite a few workstations to Vista-grade machines.

Since you only graduated in 2007, I'll give you some extremely useful advice -- go get a job with a company that has budget to use today's technology, not that of yesteryear. Otherwise you'll be stuck in Win95 world for longer than you might imagine.

by j-mart

It doesn't cost a vast sum of money ( free basically ) so if you don't like it nobody is forcing you to use it. My take on Linux distro's is as you get them for the cost of downloading and burning them to a disc try them they will mostly perform useful tasks each distro will have strengths and weaknesses and often if you have a particular task picking the right distro for that task can make a difference. Those who have the skill can always "roll their own" to get a system that will do what they want.

Linux is great value for the money. I purchased Mandrake 9.2 boxed Power Pack edition a few years back and used it as my only home OS for several years, much cheaper than XP ( Mandrake 9.2 came out in 2003) the boxed set had the advantages of being a bit more polished and as part of the cost covers licensing BS proprietary codecs, flash-player already set up, my home computing needs, not into gaming, good quality home office tools, much better security, a license that allowed me to install on all of my machines, not just one machine, I only have Mandrake 9.2 on one older machine at home now with my newer machines running 64 bit Linux OS's. I have always found the Linux OS to be much better "value for money" than anything I have purchased from Microsoft over the years which in spite of "premium" price is a far from trouble free OS requiring add on anti virus software constantly updated to keep it functioning. I have Ubuntu working very well on one of my machines 8.04, a special version with an NC machine controller EMC2 it comes on one disc.with a low latency kernel works great. Sometimes a bit of work and research is needed to work around problems and selection of the hardware used in a machine is a big part of keeping things simple this is the "cost" of using Linux, and in my view Linux for my uses is the best value going.

by joe233

Well if your using the OEM bundled version of XP for your Eee PC 701 of course it just works. I think normally XP SP2 is over a 4 GB install so you wouldn't have much space other wise. I have an EEPC with an OEM bundled linux install and it dose just work also. If I tried to pop retail XP on there I'm sure I'd be pulling my hair out.Have you tried installing Vista on your eepc ? (just kidding that was a joke) :)

True Linux doesn't just work. but Windows doesn't necessarily either on the various hardware combos. Most people get Windows OEM from the PC manufacturer though with tailored, pre-configured and tested driver installs. OSX just works because of the 100% confirmed Hardware software compatibility.Theres a trade off in supported devices and proprietary pricing here of course. Comparing an OEM version to a general release is kind of apples to oranges though. If you bought an OEM bundled Linux PC I think it would be far more likely to just work.

by dkeith45

I am just toying with Ubuntu this week. I downloaded version 9.10 (700 mb) and installed it on an old 20 gig drive.

I must say... the installation went flawlessly. I was surprised that it detected my LAN and just about everything very nicely... except for one major thing. My display. It was set to an unacceptable 800X600, which sucks on my 21" monitor. I tried the built in software update tool, and allowed it to install the Nvidia driver for my GeforceFX5200 card... only to find upon reboot, that my display was now maxed at 640X480! Arg. I then downloaded the driver myself from Nvidias website, but can't figure out how to install it... but don't know if that would make any difference anyway.

What is most frustrating, is despite much searching on Ubuntu's website and help forums, I can't find any info on how to install a hardware driver independent from their built-in method. I've also asked on the forums for help, and after three days, no answers.

This is a bummer because otherwise Ubuntu looks great. I sure wish there was a way to fix the display problem. Is it just Ubuntu that is at fault? Maybe another version of Linux would do better? Or maybe I just need to add a different video card?

by dkeith45

I just discovered something quite by accident yesterday. A client called and said her WinXP system was displaying everything way too large for some reason. I logged in and sure enough... her display settings were fine, but everything was way too large. I poked around a little and discovered the "Zoom" setting. It had been set to 400%. Once put back down to 100% everything was fine again. I then pulled out the old Ubuntu 9.10 drive for my system and sure enough, there is a ZOOM setting there too. Although I can't find a way to force it to stay at 100% like I can in WinXP, and have to Zoom out several clicks every time I open a new browser link, at least I can now see what is going on LOL. So it's a fix of sorts.

by n-line computers

I've used Xp and I've used several Linux distros. They all have issues. But I find Ubuntu or Mint to be the easiest to use and keep running.

Yes the OP is correct that it doesn't work "Out of the Box." I've yet to find anything that does. My last Xp install took 6 hours with updates, antimalware software, patches, applications, etc.

Ubuntu has it's issues but the once the installation bumps are past I find Ubuntu more stable, faster, and less hassle to use then Xp or any other flavor of Windows.

I like not having to reboot after every small configuration change. I like not to have to worry with virus issues. I like not have my computer slow down for no reason other then registry bloat. The famed WinRot and all Windows workstations seem doomed to get. I like that my duel boot Vista/Mint laptop boots faster in Mint then Vista and has most of the same functions and even desktop gadgets.

Ubuntu is not perfect but it is for the most part better then Windows.

Got Troll?
(Edit: Note this all applies to the OP of this topic. Not the guy I replied to. I thought this was at root of the thread.

Ha ha I made a root joke in a Linux thread. I kill me.)

by old ben knobi

I find this debate surprising; with people saying that they can't get Ubuntu or Linux Mint to work and that they'll stick with Windows.

I managed an IT support company for over 20 years, from MS-DOS to Windows Vista and I can truly say that Windows in all its form was our biggest curse. Hardware was mostly fine: we had an audited hardware failure rate of less than 3% from 1998-2004; if there were problems requiring customer support they were mostly Windows related. Driver installs to connect devices, viruses, blue-screens, unexplained crashes, applications that failed to load, you name it, we had it. After I retired I still supported friends and family on a pro-bono basis; there were fewer setup problems 'cos users changed their kit less often than businesses, but viruses and malware were frequent and problems caused by automatic updates, usually Windows, Java and AV products, were a recurring frustration. I spent many more hours on support than I wished to and there was no escaping the commitments.

In 2008, unable to cure a nasty virus infection, I moved a relative to Ubuntu as an experiment, still using Firefox & Thunderbird as in Windows. Since then I have moved 32 users to Linux, either Ubuntu or Linux Mint; they are friends and family and range from 13 to 80+ years old; I have NO support overhead. Let me repeat that: I now have NO support overhead. Yes, I have had to learn about Linux but it was much easier than the same with Windows. Yes, there have been some setup problems but they have been mostly easy to solve via the support sites and forums. Yes, a few were difficult but none so bad as the worst Windows problems and all, still, much quicker to research and resolve.

The experiences for my users were similar and, for them, astounding because of the new life which their PCs developed. Six year-old laptops booting to a ready desktop in 30 seconds, not 3 minutes; closedown in 10 seconds, not 40 or 50 or more; lots of applications running at the same time without crashes, etc. And all without any cost for the software. It also meant that they did not buy new laptops to cure the lethargy of their computers with Windows. The even got a choice of operating environments.

My conclusion is that Linux does work; it works well, it gets better and slicker each year and is a brilliant performer, extending the life of peoples computers. No wonder the computer industry, and especially Microsoft, are afraid of Linux. It's good and it's free of cost; if the public ever gets wise to Linux then Microsoft, and even Apple, will have problem.

This discussion is closed to new replies.