Unionize IT Now!
This is page 8 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 8 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by tonythetiger
but unions haven't. They are obsolete. Competent workers don't need them. If you cannot get what you think you are worth, then it is your thinking that is wrong.
What the CEO makes is none of your business. What the guy working next to you makes is none of your business. Maybe if you spent more time working and less time worrying about what other people make, you'd make more.
Bureaucracies make you rely on bureaucracies. Got naff all to do with being socialist.
Certainly most socialist governments tend not to be minimalist, but there again so do most 'capitalist' ones. They both have as many rules they just have to enforce, the only things that changes is who is the bad guy.
Socialist governments tend to squeeze the middle class, capitialist the lower. Upper class never get squeezed that's what campaign contributions are for.
You could have a mimimalist socialist agenda, or a minimalist capitalist one.
It's just no one has had the bottle for steps one and two
1) Shoot all the lawyers
2) Shoot all the civil servants who think we work for them.
While they are out of the way, go through the rules and get rid of the self perpetuating cruft that these two groups have wedged in there as part of their early retirement plan.
Then anyone who wants to add anything similar back in, shoot them as well.
by psifiscout
Yes, I do recall the history of the industrial revolution, but that is not a true picture of todays environment, we have Federal Labor Laws and Regs (many instituted by the actions of unions) but in many arenas unions have outsayed their welcome, and become like a leeching relative that came to vist for "a few days" that turned into permanent stay. Unions did serve their purpose for a while, but in somce ways have become like the abusive business owners of the slave days. In a union shop you MUST be a member to work (and pay due in order to do so), if the Union says "STRIKE" you strike (even if you disagree with the union and prefer to work), and if you happen to have a union "brother" who like to be a 'slacker' on the job, the union will protect the 'slacker's' job even if it causes other union workers who are good workers to work even harder to pick up the slack.
I would rather work where I am rewarded by the boss for a job well done, and walk off the job if the employer is reticent to do so, and not give a part of my check to a union boss who uses the money to support an organization that dictates to me when I can or cannot earn a paycheck that I deem fair.
by bpa_leo
You're absolutly right. We are getting shafted in an industry that has adopted the Wal-Mart model of
duing business. We need to organize ourselves and become a cohesive force that is able to negotiate a better living standard for ourslves. We work our arses off and find that more and more our rates keep dropping while CEO's get richer. Enough is enough! UNIONIZE NOW!
by tonythetiger
with the way Walmart does its business. They employ people who your buddies refused to hire, then they make them as successful as they can be. You can't stand that can you? You can't handle that someone can do something on their own, without a union daddy to help them, so you want to impose your inabilities onto everyone else!
Excuse me, I have to go puke!
by bg6638
Unions were started for excactly that purpose way back when. Now they are political organisations.
Politicians however are the same everywhere in unions or out, for sale to the highest bidder, who just happen to be avaricious corporations !
We may need unions again, when our children get turned into sweeping brushes. At that point they will band together fight the state, the law and the bosses, gather momentum, decide the best way forward is to sponsor their own members as politicians, even set up their own party. The wheel will turn full circle again.
May be one day we will learn.
"I'm putting myself forward to represent all us chaps in out fight for equality", should gain an immediate response of a damn good kicking.
Find someone with a sense of duty who doesn't want to do it. If they show signs of enjoying it, another kicking might be in order.
by apotheon
The problem most Socialists have with logic is that they seem incapable of examining the consequences of the policies they envision and espouse within the larger context of the world in which they live. Important factors get left out of their theories, thus providing inaccurate conclusions to arise from their misconceived premises.
That all applies in this case for this reason:
You've completely misjudged how socialism relates to capitalism in terms of the requirement for bureaucracy.
Capitalism is, by definition, an economic system wherein the means of production are privately owned and operated for profit (typically by means of gainful employment of labor). The "for profit" part of that is a statement of the mechanism used to sustain the system's administration so that it doesn't collapse in upon itself, and requires no outside intervention for sustainability.
Socialism is, by definition, an economic system wherein the means of production is collectively "owned" and democratically operated by the society at large, with employment of labor being at the whim and behest of the democratic process. In small enough groups, this is viable in a minimalist system that can even equitably deal with the democratic process and ethical treatment of participants, so long as it is assumed that a person may exile him or her self from the system at any time (the converse being a state of slavery). By "small enough groups", I mean (by my own personal guesstimate) roughly twenty or thirty people at most. Beyond that, bureaucracy is necessary merely to manage the democratic system of operation itself.
Thus, any significant socialist economies require bureaucracy, and increases in the size of the economy have a tendency to require disproportionately greater increases in the size of the bureaucracy.
No tongue in cheek here.
by tonythetiger
As the size of bureaucracy grows (not just in socialism), and the more of society's work product is used to maintain it, the lower that society's standard of living becomes.
Big government, no matter who is running it, is a leech.
by tonythetiger
by the.erinyes
by absolutely
by jeffin90620
Unionization has been a hindrance to economic expansion for decades. In the socialized economies of Western Europe, economic growth has been a third of that in the United States, in part because it is so hard to fire people that businesses don't hire. Unemployment ranges from 12-24% in unionized countries in Europe.
Last weekend, there were riots in France over the proposal to make it easier for businesses to fire people. The unions (and the governments) look at jobs as the property of the employees (i.e. the means to pay people money outside of the government dole), instead of what they are (tasks to be performed).
If businesses cannot adapt, jobs cannot be created and unemployment rises.
by the.erinyes
Thought I'd share some professional comments on the job market!
In France, the young people are rioting. It?s not March Madness. It?s just everyday insanity. They are protesting a new law that would make it easier for employers to hire and fire people below 26 during a two-year trial period. You?d think this would be welcome news to the slackers: youth unemployment in France is over 20%.
In the States, however, where almost everyone can be hired and fired (unless you?re a member of the New York teachers? union), the 2006 crop of US college graduates is facing the best job market since 2001. ?Business, computer, engineering, education and health care grads in highest demand,? writes a Reuters correspondent. Here in Baltimore, there are help wanted notices in shop windows, on business signs, on billboards, even jingles on the radio.
?We are approaching full employment ,? said the chief executive of Challenger, Gray & Christmas.
In fact, competition for young workers is heating up. Employers have to compete on salaries, perks and benefits.
Writes the blogmeister of moonbattery.com:
?You don?t have to be Adam Smith to notice that there is an inverse relationship between the health of an economy and the degree of government interference. A demented state of affairs in which private businesses are not allowed to fire employees goes a long way toward explaining why the jobless rate of French youth is 23% nationwide, and 50% among the poor.?
?Anglo-Saxon? Adam Smith, however, may have a difficult stand against the institutionalized statism bred by generations of Marxists and neo-socialists who have used the past half century to turn large layers of French and European society into passive dependents on state largesse.
It reminds me of some fellow students I met at the University of Aberdeen in Scotland back in the 1980?s, who were planning to ?go on the dole? for a few years after their graduation. This way, the young Scots would be getting paid by the state for doing nothing, could do anything they wanted - and still feel like victims of ?the system,? the English AND Maggy Thatcher.
That?s called the European Trifecta!
by tonythetiger
by absolutely
Although capitalism has never been fully implemented anywhere, citing 21st & late 20th century economic dysfunction on capitalism is completely dishonest. There was more capitalism in the United States before World War I, before taxes took a virtually uninterrupted upward turn, which coincided by the way with an ever-increasing disparity between rich & poor.
Today's neo-socialists have one thing exactly right: the extreme disparities in distribution of wealth do not correspond to productive ability. What they have not yet admitted is that those disparities are directly caused by the government's right to interfere in the free function of competition, which they continue to support.
Worthless morons.
There are aspects of what some would call IT that are safe, but pulling wires, replacing a burnt-out power supply or dead hard drive is not really IT. That is just a computer repair. It does not pay that well and has little room for growth.
PC support can be done from anywhere. The company I am at uses remote access to do maintenance. They just log on to YOUR computer from theirs and fix most problems or install upgrades - this COULD be done from anywhere - including India.
"Development" is what most of us probably think of as IT. Programming, Data Analysis, etc. This area has been moved in a lot of shops to foreign countries. Sure a lot of the code is poor, but they make up for it in volume. This is the scariest area.
I would NOT advise most people to enter the IT job market. The outlook is shaky at best.
As to a union... Remember what the big companies dis in times past. They just hired others to do the work. Only now, they won't have to walk by the picket line. They don't even have to live in your town - or even your country.
by ssmaguire
I now begin to realize that unions are a double edged sword. I work within a school where one of my co-workers is absent so much I don't even realize she works there. On the other hand when she's there she eats voraciously, word to the wise don't put your hand in front of her month, otherwise you won't be able to work in IT anymore.
Unions are like insurance, they are there we you need them. They have served as a "check and balance" system, thus keeping employers from overstepping bounds and abusing their employees. They in reality bring to the table a sort of "Purchasing Power Parity" or PPP for short. The unions of today have lost their strength, since no one really belives they have power anymore. This is misinformation, that employers love to instill in their employees. Fear motivates people to sometimes be complacent in things.
The whole tenet (principle) of capitalism is to capitalize your assets. An employer's asset in this case would be the workers. Without workers, an employer cannot sell goods or services.
Well that's just my take. But as of today, the labor market is so fluid, that employers look for comparative advantage in any way possible. They do not see the consequences of using lowest cost inputs to make their products.
Take for instance Dell, which had to replace millions of motherboards in their PCs since they burnt out after a year. Now if Dell didn't decide to cut corners and save on production costs, they wouldn't have to pay the increase in support costs.
The only problem is, is that Dell's profit margin is razor thin, about 15% to 20%. They don't really have much wiggle room to weather storms. Their existence is rooted upon the prinicple of volume, and Just in Time manufacturing.
It's like walking on eggshells, eventually things will crack.
Another instance of extreme outsourcing is Boeing, who is sourcing parts for their new aircraft from about 10 different countries, to be shipped to Everett, Wash. where they assemble the pieces.
Considering each plane costs upwards $16 million dollars, while development costs are in the tens of billions. One small mistake costs big money.
the reason is,
microsoft and many other big companies are pushing to increase 6 year work visas from 65,000 to 115,000. that means lower wages for americans and less jobs for qualified IT workers.
by jaymiller25
I've read a good deal of the posts in this thread. It seems this topic comes up at least once a year. So, I feel the need to give my .02
- Unions in IT: I don't see it as beneficial. They served their purpose in the "old days", during the Industrial Revolution to give workers a safe work environment, etc. That was very necessary. IT doesn't need unions. Many of the people who are for unions in IT very well may be working for a place that thinks it's okay to take advantage of the IT staff. To me, that's a more localized issue than a global IT issue. I just can't see unionized IT doing any good for us.
- Outsourcing also came up. I think this hot button topic is losing steam & has been over inflated recent years.
- Companies are seeing it's hard to manage outsourced projects. I know many folks fighting this battle today.
- From what I'm seeing, mainly development jobs are being outsourced. BUT...if you look around, many of them are coming back due to management & communication issues.
- I also see the threat of being outsourced is higher is you work at a large corporation. The higher-ups in a large corp will mainly only look at the initial savings...where smaller companies will see the bigger picture, including quality.
I can say w/ confidence that all of our jobs will not be outsourced. From a business perspective, it just wouldn't be good business...and there are too many IT functions that can't be outsourced.
IT is a great field to be in. I have zero worries about my future. The secret is to always show your value to whomever you're working for...and the thought of outsourcing you will never come up. It's those who don't add value to the organization & are just "coasting" who should be concerned, as the business units are slowly learning more & more about IT functions.
Like I said...just my opinion...none of which is etched in stone...
by heml0ck
by jeffin90620
My girlfriend's uncle works in IT for an international manufacturing firm. He travels about half the year. He has a very nice home in an upscale community with 4 kids (one in college and the second on her way in a year or so). Drives a Lexus.
The thing is, he knows his stuff. I work in engineering, not IT, but I make a good wage, too (better than the $50 an hour you are demanding). I get this because I know my stuff, too.
You really don't have much to fear from those without a good education; they will fill the cheap jobs you don't want.
Jeff
by heml0ck
membership was mandatory.
If you are that good, you can continue with the consultant line.
For me right now? Get the pointy headed managers in line, and quit abusing their staff.
by rka
by gfuentes5
Make sure you are willing to fight the mafia... cause thats who runs the unions, dont forget the corruption factor, dont forget pricing yourself right out of the market, dont forget creating a new enemy, the Non-union worker ...who by the way will always be a threat even if you own market share!!!
Of course theres pension funds, apprenticeships, medical and dental benefits, employer organizations who must form a partnership to represent themselves against you for collective bargaining agreements, government sanctions, rules, local and county entities, offices that require staffing and ...
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending