Discussion Locked

useless information thanks everyone its been fun*** time to wrap this up **

0 helpful
135 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I was sat here on a saturday night when the bulb blew, and I can up with an interesting thought (well I thought so ).And here it is ....

If you were traveling at the speed of light, would there be any point in putting your headlight on when it got dark?

anymore cunumdrums would be appreciated.

135 replies

by bfilmfan

If they have a will detailing instructions on funeral arrangements, where the will stipulates.

If they have no specifications and have surviving relatives, where the relatives say.

If they have no family, the embassies of the country of the citizenship will make those arrangements.

by neil_essex

If it takes 7 men 3 hours to dig a hole 2 metres by 6 metres, how long does it take 3 men to dig half a hole?

by fhenskens

Particularly seeing as Time, Velocity and Mass are all relative.
You would indeed be dead because it would take you an infinite amount of time (until the end of the universe) to achieve light-speed.
On the upside, if you were travelling standing-up towards it, you might be able to shave a few centimeters off your waist-line. At least from the perspective of the "stationary" observer. On the downside the lucky lady would probably only see you for a fraction of a second :P
And the big kicker: When you do finally reach the speed of light you will have - that's right - infinite mass. How do you shag someone when you're dead and weigh more than all the suns in the universe combined? Also, you'd have your very own infinite gravitational pull. From your perspective, the second you went lightspeed, the entire universe would be sucked in to join you. All one big happy family, here! :)

Less coffee needed.

by maecuff

asking for puzzles, how long before someone posts the question about a plane crashing on the border between two countries and burying the survivors?

Oops..not long, eh?

by jdclyde

a chicken and an egg are laying in bed

the chicken lights up a cigarette and smiles

the egg says, guess we answered that questions.....

by jaqui

you buy a pint of beer
drink exactly half of it.

is the glass half full or half empty?

by maecuff

Deep breath..there. Better? Remember, until last call, you can always buy another one.

by mjwx

Either/or. It just means still have half a pint of beer to drink after which the question is irrelevant.

What happens when an unstoppable force hits an immovable barrier?

by expresso

i think something in your statement is going to be not true

like it's only gona happen once ie hit or hits

by bigbigboss

Half a pint left in a gallon cup is not half full, and not half empty. The cup was very empty to begin with. But who is drinking only a pint this days...

by rsprouse

Assuming the beer was in a glass to begin with, if you drank exactly half of the pint the glass is now LESS than half (full/mt) because the glass the pint was put into would have had to be COMPLETELY full. Glasses which hold a pint have a little more volume than one pint.

But the biggest question is where does it say the pint of beer starts in a glass?

by jdclyde

trying to breath new life in the old monster.

I can see you in the place of Gene Wilder screeming "It's ALIVE!"
[i]
as the chicken lights up another smoke.....

by tony hopkinson

Well no, according to the theory if you were travelling at the speed of light through space, your speed through time would be zero. Time for you would stop, you wouldn't percieve it was dark, it would never 'get' dark and you wouldn't be physically capable of changing anything.
I've often wondered if we ever did achieve light speed, how would we stop without bumping into something, because time would be frozen no internal event could ever occur. Of course since we have a mass we cannot travel at 100% of the speed of light (except through a total vacuum) therefore some time would pass. If we got close by the time you realised it was getting dark, it would be light again.

by jdclyde

if you turn your light on BEFORE you hit the speed of light, it will have a head start on you and then when your both traveling at the same speed it will light up everything in front of you.

Not that you would have time to hit the brakes if you see something you don't like......

by metro_au

light cannot reflect back to you .. and everthing would appear black .. you cannot see where you are going..

by expresso

that's how you see it not how he see's it

the point ,,can you see's it (close your eyes and say it, still dark , huh?)

by Member 25348569

Hey, let's just not bury the survivors unless they ask for it! Poor bastards have just lived through a plane crash and you want to deep-six 'em. :(

by jdclyde

Actually got one with that! :D

BAWAAHAAAHAAHAAHAHAHAHAHAAAAAHHAHHAAHAHAHAAAHAHAA!

by jaqui

where do you bury the living dead?
[ not that they would stay in thier graves anyway ]

by stargazerr

but I couldnt resist .. I luurve this one :D ..

Q: What is the difference between Jurassic Park and Microsoft?

A: One is an over-rated high tech theme park based on prehistoric information and populated mostly by dinosaurs. The other one is a Steven Spielberg movie.

]:)

by lodai

If a Tree falls in a forest and no one is around to hear it, does that mean the evil IT micromanager is lurking around the corner watching me type this from my work computer?

by jdclyde

there are always animals there to process the vibrations into sound, so yes it does make a noise.

no animals, no people to process vibraions into sound and it stays only vibrations. (waves.)

by rm antala

It depends... is the evil IT micromanager's Domain part of the Tree that fell?? or his Domain in a separate Forest?

by Member 25348569

in size, composition and value, I could give it a go. But I don't. None of it.

I would guess that the trunk full of nickels would be much more likely to trash your car's suspension so even if it was worth more, it probably would end up costing a lot more. Unless, of course, you've got a sodding great gas-guzzling SUV with overhard suspension, destroying the environment and ripping holes in the ozone layer.

You bastard!

Sorry, I'm having a bad day as I was unable to save the whale.

by dogknees

If the things you want to look at are travelling at the same velocity as you are, then Yes, turning on the headlight will help you see them.

My conundrum (and it's a real-world problem!)

If you had a device that could reliably detect a suicide bomber in a crowd. What is the best thing to tell the crowd, or to get them to do?

If you tell them to run away, more will be hurt, because while they're closely packed, the ones near the bomber shield the others from the blast. If they spread out, more people get hit.

So, what is the best thing for people to do in this situation?

Not a comfortable thought.

Regards

by expresso

no chages or what if's

kill the bomber, he was going to die anyway

in fact he wanted to, give him part of what he wants, i want to keep my part.

by gsg

The point is moot... Einstein said something to the effect that we can never achieve the speed of light. It is possible to get close, but you can never achieve it.

by old guy

Star Trek proved Einstein wrong! They went all the way to warp speed. We just have to catch up to their technical ability. :^O

by cuteelf

Tell the Einstein theory to the last guy I shagged.
He went at the speed of light.

Cute

by expresso

Eistien some say was wrong , i realy think he just left some thing out

traslation === ein stein === one glass (or cup)

by sykandtyed

Black holes do not emit light because they are moving faster than the speed of light.

If your moving at the speed of light, anything you launch will move at your relative speed plus the speed the object was launched. Of course you will evenually over take the object and bump into it. oops!

by nixon_public

But I do know that black holes absorb light (ie do not emit light) due to having sufficient gravity to pull the light into it and keep it from escaping. In this sense, light is acting as a particle. (Light is know to act as both a particle and as a wave). It has nothing to do with the speed of the black hole, which could be sitting still in space, but which most of the data I've read suggests that they do rotate very fast (but not light speed fast). The current scientific data is one of the reasons that the Disney movie "The Black Hole" is so obsurd. No ship could hold onto the edge of a black hole when even light that crosses the event horizon is forever trapped. Also we cannot see a black hole. It is detected by the absence of light in a local area.

More recently there has been sightings of a radiation emitted from the poles (a black hole is actually sphericle like a star). I'm not sure of why this is, but I will conjecture that is has to do with so much trapped photons of light that maybe they change state in some way that we on earth can't normally detect and this is essentially the "escape" path out of the gravity well.

As far as launching something that moves at my relative speed plus launch speed, I see no reason to assume that I would overtake it. I do have my doubts that I could indeed launch anything at light speed, but since I've never traveled that fast, all I could do is conjecture.

by ijusth1

black holes do NOT move. What happens is that their mass becomes a sigularity and thus infinite mass. The escape velocity becomes faster then the speed of light. To understand how this works consider this: to escape the earth you need to get to approximately 25k MPH. To escape the moon it think it was only 6 or 8k for the Apollo guys. Just ramp up the mass and eventually at infinite mass it is speed of light.

by gregk

This and other posts indicate that most of the posters have never done any astrophysics, or even more mundane branches of physics...

Black holes are not travelling FTL. They are incredibly dense. Thus their gravitional attraction is enormous Thus EVEN light cannot escape once it crosses the event horizon. Paradoxically they DO emit light (ie EM radiation) in accordance with the laws of thermodynamics. This is believed to come from the event horizon.

Anything launched by a body travelling at the speed of light will (from the POV of an external observer) travel at the speed of light. The idea that speeds are additive is a misconception, This is NEWTONIAN mechanics. Einstein proved it wrong.
However, it remains a useful approximation at non-relativistic (ie normal) speeds.

Look up the math. Do it for various velocities. Let it sink in, then do the math again. This stuff does not work well with analogies.

Don't forget to do both Special and General relativity math. General explains how to work out what happens once the two observers are brought back together again, and are at rest relative to one another (Hint: acceleration)

Incidentally the only real world (terrestrial) application I am aware of (there are sure to be others) where Einsteinian formulae are required over Newtonian is in the calculations required to make GPS systems work. This is because the time dilation effects need to be taken into account for the clocks.

Incidentally, Einstein has been proven wrong in at least one area. He made a famous statement that "God does not play dice with the Universe" Sadly Quantum mechanics (the dice) is still with us God is still rolling them.

To get back to the original question...
Turning the headlamp on is useless. From the external observers viewpoint, the light from the torch and the traveller will travel at the same speed. The observer will hit any obstacle at the same time that the light does. It will not have time to reflect before that presumably catastrophic event.

From the travellers viewpoint, the light will appear to travel away from him at light speed, but we must remember that time has stopped for the traveller. Any way he can measure that movement will be with a clock that has stopped.

The net result is that SPLAT will come without warning, and since the traveller has infinite mass (and therefore infinite momentum) at this moment, we will be able to answer that other chestnut about immovable objects and irresistable forces ion the aftermath.

Incidentally, light can travel at less that the speed of light. This results in among other things, the very observable Cerenkov radiation that surrounds water immersed nulear reactors.

by sykandtyed

Black holes do not emit light because they are moving faster than the speed of light.

If your moving at the speed of light, anything you launch will move at your relative speed plus the speed the object was launched. Of course you will evenually over take the object and bump into it. oops!

by rush2112

1. if you were traveling at light-speed in the DARK, what would be in your WAY that you would want to SEE? Afraid you might crash? Well at that speed you wouldn't even feel the crash.

2. As YOU you would not be able to accelerate to that speed in your current bodie as the pressures that would be applied to your cells would cause severe and fatal damage to you.

3. Where is the universe is it EVER completely dark? And why would you be traveling there in the first place?

4. How many replies on techrepublic does it take for a useless information thread to change a lightbulb? :)

by darknerd

Simply turn the headlights on before you start, then the light will always be ahead of you :)

Please let me know if that is crazy..

by stratti79

Let me think...
The lights will have a fixed range. You will travel to the range at the speed of light but along the way you will have produced more light to go in front. Im not a physicist but it makes sense.However as I said earlier your visual cortex couldnt possibly process the information at that speed you would only see a blur like on a rollercoaster times millions so close your eyes and wait for the boom

by bigbigboss

What you see illumintated by your head light is not the light that emits from your head light, but the reflection back from the object you try to illuminate, coming back at you at light speed...

Now, try to answer that question again.

by avid

yes the light would be in front of you always, but, you could also turn it on in mid travel and it would still be in front of you. the theory that nothing moves faster than the speed of light is not completely accurate. the universe, for example, is said to be 14 to 16 billion years old and to have originated from a single point. if nothing can move faster than the speed of light then the universe could not possibly be more than 16 billion light years across... but it is. check me on this. i could be wrong.

by nixon_public

Read the folling link for an article that explains all this better than I can.

http://www.sciam.com/article.cfm?articleID=0009F0CA-C523-1213-852383414B7F0147

The gist of the article is that the further away objects are mving away from us faster than the closer ones, and that all of the objects further than 16 Bil LY's are moving away faster than light speed. That being possible because the limit of light speed is only a limit within our universe, not a limitation on the movement of the universe itself.

by =rob

"If you were traveling at the speed of light, would there be any point in putting your headlights on when it got dark?"

"Simply turn the headlights on before you start, then the light will always be ahead of you :)

Please let me know if that is crazy."

I think you might have something there.

I think (and this assumes that light works like other waves or particles, and that you could withstand going at such a speed)...

If it is pitch dark, the only way you would see an object is for the light to travel from the headlights, ?touch? the object, and reflect back to your eyes. That would take twice as long as the light from the headlights just going forward ?touching? the object.

(Light travels at about 186,000 miles per second. Light from the sun takes about 8.3 minutes to get to Earth.)

Let?s begin with the idea that you start traveling at the speed of light at the same instant you turn on the headlights Let's say an object is ten light-seconds in front of you. By the time the light from your headlights reaches the object, you have traveled about 1,860,000 miles too, and the light reaches the object as soon as you reach the object. You would maybe see it for a teeny weeny fraction of a second.

Your idea of having the lights on before you go is interesting. Let?s say you had the headlights on for ten seconds before you started traveling. The light would be ten light seconds (1,860,000 miles) in front of you. (For purposes of this explanation I will avoid the fact of the light being very scattered even if it was a conventional laser.) Now that object, the one that is ten light seconds in front of you, would reflect the light back to you before you reach it. Oh look, here comes Christian Doppler.

The Doppler Effect, and perhaps other phenomena described by a host of other scientists and mathematicians, would alter your ability to see that object clearly. If you are traveling at the speed of light toward the object that is reflecting light back to you at the same velocity, distortion might be serious. Already, you would see stationary things (staying in one place relatively as you travel toward them) appear at the windshield over 11,000,000 times faster than highway speed of 60 miles an hour. Can you grasp that rapidity?

Remember that humans are unlike light in that they don?t typically go from zero to 11,160,000 m.p.h. instantly. You would probably have to ramp up to that speed. So, just turn on your hyper-super-extra-fine laser headlights and go. By the time you reach the speed of light, you?ll probably be far away. Send me a postcard to let me know if you were right.

by stratti79

The simple answer to that is no point because there is no way the visual cortex in your brain could process the images flying toward you at the speed of light so close your eyes and wait for the crash

by bigbigboss

Your eye is receiving light coming at you at light speed all the time, and I hope it is processing them well enough for you to conceive what is going on around your. Unless... either in the world you are in, light do not travel at light speed, or, your brain is actually too slow to perceive images.

by rcfoulk9

If one turned on the head lights prior to initiating movement a beam of light would be projected forward at 186,000 mps. Since terminal speed would match the speed of light being projected the light being reflected back from any object encountered would necessarily need to be from a static stream of quanta with which you were moving in tandem (hence you could actually turn your lights off once you reached light speed). The difficulties surround the dissipation of light that would occur because the light stream from head lights is not covalent and would deteriorate somewhat in accordance with the rule of squares. Hence the amount of light that could be reflected back would progressively reduce beyond intensity useable by the human eye. There are other problems but I guess in summary it could be said that there would be some near term benefits from having lights on prior to and up the point that acceleration matched the speed of light. But then there's that other pesky problem of whether one lives long enough to be accelerated to the speed of light without being killed by our limits in tolerating g forces. That would take a little calculation.

by jdclyde

I stab them too, and sometimes even bash them with a club!

Every boy has to have a hobby! :D

philosophy smostophy! I see someone that I can hose down with some cold water, gunna take my shot! Your next! B-)

by expresso

leaving out the fifty million arguments to go with this...............
or how ever..........

simple sample you are in your ship (you can choose what kind) your hand moves with your body, at greatest an arms length. if you hold a flash light it moves with you. zero to light speed doesn't matter because ever thing is inside with you. including the flashlight. so it acts normal to you. (theory of relitivity or is relativity)( at least that is what my wife says about relitives or is that relatives)

oh ,,, to get back in step! this here flash light can be an important tool or a whepen(i don't think i know how to speel tthhaatt)

if you look across the ship(inside) it's a tool
if you shine it out the window(front)
your speed (ship)and the light(flashlight)speed add together (don't quote me here but i think this is near right)

angstom is a mesurment for light
this is the distance between the light particles or waves (just like the ocean)as time goes by and you recieve them (see them or view them).

so to make a long story short
you just killed your buddy with the flashlight ,
because.....he was comming to you in his spaceship at light speed, as you are approching him at light speed and you shined your flashlight at him at light speed.
don't get it .... ?
lightspeed + lightspeed + lightspeed = ??

lightspeed (to) ultra violet (to) xray

ouch that hurt

by #1 kenster

I can't believe no one's thought of the deer stuck in your headlights. Would Bambi even see the headlights coming? Bambi would become Boombi in any event.

by ggallman

If you were traveling at the speed of light, when it got dark, if you were to turn on your head lights, the beam of light would leave you at 189,000 miles per sec. Your time would slow so that your perception of the light speed would be the same as if you were sitting still.

by nickelsilver

Assuming the speed of light to be a constant, the reply must be that the scene surrounding you at the moment you attain the speed of light and no other scene is what accompanies you until such time as your velocity decreases. Think of that scenario as one in which there is no apparent passage of time. Therefore that scene cannot darken unless you decrease your velocity below that of light. Absence of time can be equated with immobility, death, frozen momentum, so you couldn't act to turn on your headlights.

Even if you could, relativistic theory has it that your mass must be infinitesimal to achieve that speed or conversely your energy of acceleration infinte, which is why a particle of light is equated to that of a photon.

If you were able to turn your headlights on whilst travelling at that speed ( putting aside problems associated with the predicted spaghetti conformation of mass attaining that velocity, eg., stripping of particles from atoms as they fall into a black hole and pass beyond the visual threshold ) you would have to exert additional energy that you wouldn't posess. Even if you could exert extra energy, the expenditure of that energy would subtract from your velocity requiring you to exert yet more energy to compensate and so on ad infinitum. That is, it is impossible to methodically increase your energy output whilst travelling at the velocity of light.

Ipso facto you could not expect to be able to turn on your headlights and maintain speed of light. From a modeller's point of view, as light from a point source travels in 360 degrees simultaneously any light emitted travelling at any trajectory other than your own will act as a brake on your progress. What if your headlights were lasers? You would at best reduce that effect by the efficiency of your laser. However, the point of generation of the light beam prior to funelling the light into a laser, is that point at which light will exert its spherical radiation and its consequences upon your net energy.

This outcome is logical speculation as space itself would be warped by such an event and the outcome of that is unpredictable. So there is no reason not to attempt it if you can and see what happens!!! There were real fears that the detonation of the first nuclear device would produce an unstoppable chain reaction that would ignite the world's atmosphere!

There is also the improbability you could accomplish your goal by behaving in an equivalent manner without costly net expenditure of potential energy ( I am here acknowledging the improbabilities of electron tunelling phenomena! ).

As a natural philosopher with some psychic abilities, I see phenomena of this order as the way 'souls of the living' and 'echoes of souls of the dead' are transported beyond the temporal world. The tyranny of time is a state of perception of a soul embedded in its temporal plane of existence, of an egoistic personality which can only appreciate its material immediacy.

by jrwooton

I belive that you would still need your lights on because it is all relative to you in that situation, even if you were traveling at the speed of light, the light from the headlight would be travleling at twice the speed of light, sort of like piggy baking on the beam. just my input.

by cuteelf

If a chemist makes something that is sooo powerful, it cant be stored in anything....

Where will it be stored?

Cute

by computab

THE speed of light is invariant, 299,792.5 Km/s. But if you saw a space ship in your flight path 200,000 km ahead, you would not be able to react in time before the collision.

by oldmicro

Given that reaction time is about 350 milliseconds, and that a human can survive only about 10g's. The ability to see and avoid any obsticle at speeds only a tiny fraction of c makes headlights completely useless even at speeds as slow as 10 miles per second. Perhaps this is why even jet airplanes use radar, instead of headlights, except when landing, or taking off, which is done at speeds much slower than the speed of sound.

by Member 25348569

but that's not what will happen. Because the source (you) is moving at close to the speed of light, the light coming from your headlamps will be shifted out of the visible range and into the high-energy gamma radiation - how energetic depending on how close you are to lightspeed relative to the object in front of you.

A photon is the quantum unit for electronagnetic radiation. Although popularly - but incorrectly - reserved to describe the quantum of the electromagnetic field for visible light, it refers to [b]any[/b] such radiation, including gamma.

by rick_from_bc

There was a young fellow named Fisk,
At fencing, exceedingly brisk.
The speed of his strike -
So much faster than light -
Foreshortened his foil to a disk.

by gjs1

Fortunately, the school that gave me an engineering degree required me to take a course in Relativity just in case a question came up in Geekend edition.
Unfortunately, I cannot remember where I put my copy of "Relativity for Engineers". My memory is hazy about a course that I took many years ago. Gedanken (Thought)Experiment: Observer A in Reference Frame A sees Observer B in Reference Frame B (travelling at nearly the speed of light) turn on his headlights, but because of Lorentz-Fitgerald [Square root (1-v^2/c^2)] contraction he barely sees any beam length ahead of B; But in frame B, by Michelson-Morley experiment, Observer B sees normal headlight beam.
TR Length restriction prevents more complete reply.

by nxg13

Ok, so you're on a school bus and it is travelling at or near the speed of light.

Someone at the back of the bus throws a baseball to someone at the front of the bus.

The classic question is "is the baseball travelling faster than the speed of light?"

That's not my question at all. I wonder, "Will the person at the front of the bus ever see the baseball coming?"

No quibbling about whether a school bus could ever reach those speeds... it's all a question about the light.

-- Nick

by gregk

All the people on the bus are travelling at the same velocity (approximately). Thus they are all in he same frame of reference. Thus, they can safely ignore what an outside observer thinks about what is happening. From their POV, the ball is thrown at say 50mph. It arrives at the other end of the bus in a few seconds & is hopefully caught.

A person outside the bus, however, sees the ball travel incredibly slowly (discounting the inherited speed of the bus) and that the ball takes minutes to hours for the ball to travel from one end to the other.Then he notices that all their (the passengers) watches are going very slow and realises that nothing seems abnormal to them. Unless of course they look out the window.

I am ignoring of course, the difficulties of observing all this detail as the bus has travelled a LONG way in the time it took the ball to move from one end to the other.

by fore_thought

Yes of course he will...to the person at the front or back of the bus, the baseball is traveling at normal speeds...to an observer outside of the bus, the baseball just traveled back in time... =)

by fore_thought

Yes...but only if its night time.

If you are traveling at the speed of light and you turn your headlights on, the source is also traveling at the speed of light. Which means the light coming off of it would travel at the speed of light relative to the source. How fast do you think you are moving through the universe right now anyway? How do you know that when you turn your head lights on at night that you aren't infact in the middle of your conundrum?

by dmlr

3 men walk into a hotel looking for a room. The hotel manager informs them that he has only one room and that not one of the other hotels in the area have rooms available. The men agree to take the room. The manager charges them a total of $30 for the room to which each man contributes $10.
Later on the manager gets a conscience as he knows the room really only costs $25 and he just wanted to make a couple of bucks on the guys. He sends the bellhop up with $5. On the way up, the bellhop realizes that he has 5 singles for 3 men. He can't break that up evenly. So he decides to give each man only $1 and pocket the $2. He explains to the men that the room was actually $27 and gives each man $1 back.
Now each man has given $9 towards the room and the bellhop kept $2. So 3 times $9 is $27 plus the $2 the bellhop kept is $29. They gave $30 originally, where's the other $1?