useless information thanks everyone its been fun*** time to wrap this up **
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by debirch
by ccummiskey
I wonder if the same questions relate to speech when you are traveling at (or faster) than the speed of sound. Assuming that sound requires an atmosphere to propogate, and light does not, this may not be a fair comparison. But in terms of the speed of the contained environment, and what goes on inside the bus, versus what an observer sees outside the bus may point to come interesting comparisons?
Maybe someone already knows this, but here's an interesting related question that is probably measureable... if someone (stationary) outside of the Concorde spoke to someone inside (traveling faster than the speed of sound), I am guessing that the position of the speaker would be relevant. If the speaker were behind the Concorde, the sound would never catch up, and those inside would never hear what was said. But if the speaker were ahead of the Concorde, would they hear a "fast-forward" version, or a squeal, or?
In turn, if someone outside of the light-speed bus threw a ball to someone inside the bus, it would depend on their position... if they were behind us, the ball would never catch up to us, so there would be nothing to catch. But if they were in front of us, would we see it coming? Would the image of the ball in front of us have accelerated past ultra-violet and only be measureable as a radio frquency?
by ittbowser
It is half full of beer, and half full of air. Therefore it is still full!
ITTBowser
by ittbowser
addition and multiplication work both backwards and forwards (i don't remember the term for that right now)
2+3=5, 3+2=5
Subtraction and division are not recursive! there it is.
2-3=-1, 3-2=1
Once you subtract the $5 from the equation, then divide it back to the original, it breaks down.
Of course, there is still $30, it's the math that doesn't work backwards.
by dmlr
by neil_essex
by neil_essex
by neil_essex
by fkasner
Aside from requiring an infinite energy to assume this condition it would also be true that no object could get out of the way at this speed. And the light could not get to the object and back again (it moves only as fast as the vehicle) so why bother?
FK
by mdpetrel
by desmodeus
by mdandrea76
What would you observe if you were travelling backwards at lightspeed while looking into a mirror?
Some base assumptions must apply here:
1. Your mass wasn't infinate meaning your eyes are actually functional and the said mirror doesn't break
2. Your gravitational pull doesn't cause the end of the universe (kinda stems from the mass assumption [see 1.])
3. EXTREME accelleration: 0 km/h to 1,079,252,848.8 km/h (in a vacuum) in 1 second - so as not to take infinate time to reach lightspeed
by gregk
Within Einsteinian mechanics
As your velocity increases your mass increases. At the speed of light your mass IS infinite in the matheematical sense. This is a classic "divide by zero" issue which all computer geeks hould be aware of.
As your velocity increases, time slows down. It stops when you reach lightspeed.
As your velocity increases, your length decreases. At light speed you become two dimensional.
All these observations are from the POV of an external (different frame of reference) observer. You will not be aware of them as all your measurements will be from within your own frame of reference. From your POV, you will simply fail to reach light speed.
What you will be aware of is an enormous acceleration which may read as a gravitational pull before you black out and then die, given the acceleration you have posited. A grasshopper hitting a windscreen will be better off.
As I said in another post: Look up the math and do it.
by mdandrea76
"At the speed of light your mass IS infinite"
"It [time] stops when you reach lightspeed."
"At light speed you become two dimensional."
...these are also assumptions based on an unproven yet widely understood and accepted theory.
I am aware of Einstein's special theory of relativity, the math involved, it's conclusions of time dilation, of mass gain and of length contraction. My gravity assumption stems from mass as they are directly proportional - the more mass an object has, the more gravitational effect that object has on it's environment, not from accelleration. I am also aware that travelling at light speed is all but achievable given our current understanding of physics and propulsion technology - hence the assumptions in my first post. So... let?s put Einstein's theory aside for a moment and return to my question.
Allow me to rephrase:
If it were possible to travel backwards at light speed and by some, yet unknown, means maintain the mass, form and length you and the mirror you are holding have while stationary, what would the person holding the mirror observe?
This should not read, "Is this or my assumptions possible given our current understanding of Einsteinian theory?"
Would one speculate that everything would be black, as no light (incidental or reflective) can reach your retinas? Or would light travel relative to the person/mirror - in which case they would see their own merry self? Will such an event tear the very fabric of space-time, causing the universe to be pulled inside out - analogous to pulling of a tee shirt super quickly? Will we see strange creatures from an unknown parallel dimension sucked through the theoretical tear?
This is all speculation and of course none of it can be proven, at least not in my or my children?s lifetimes. I am interested in what fellow techrepublic readers will speculate.
by giledwin
by gregk
by nwarfield
by gregk
I thought this whole thing was within the physics framework as we understand it today. This includes Einsteinian mechanics, which has had quite a number of successes, and no known-to-me failures (I have been out of Astrophysics for quite a few years now, & while I still keep an interest, I no longer follow every event). However, since it cannot be reconciled with quantum mechanics, there is probably some replacement theory just waiting around the corner for some lucky Nobel winner to be to discover it.
Incidentally, Science by definition cannot be proven, only disproved. That's what makes it science.
I choose not to postulate what we might see under some yet to be developed theory of motion.
by wdante2
by paulgilmore
by myron.brown
by paulgilmore
by dmlr
by paulgilmore
by paulgilmore
by mdandrea76
Yes you are right. Some of the mass captured in a black hole's accretion disk past it's event horizon - the point at which the gravitational pull will "never let go" - gets converted into high energy X-rays emitted through the poles of that black hole's rotational axis. See here: http://www.space.com/scienceastronomy/astronomy/blackhole_jets_020606.html
The X-ray particles are extremely high energy. Quoted from the article above: "In one quasar called 3C120... Marscher and his colleagues detected jets of particles moving at 98 percent the speed of light."
by mdandrea76
Black holes do move: http://www.space.com/scienceastronomy/supernova_backhole_021118.html
Also, black holes have infinite density due to their extreme gravity but not infinite mass.
by bigjoedan
Of course you will need the headlight on.
You travelling at the speed of light doesn`t necessarily mean that you are light. so you still need light to see, without it you might hit buildings on your way, and of course you know what will happen to you...
You never drink exactly half a pint. It always ends up empty. :-)
You ever notice, that if you get a pint in England, you get more beer than if you get a pint in the USA?
by mikiel
The question is cleverly phrased to confuse the reader. The two dollars the bellhop got were part of the $27 given and shouldn't be added to the 27 as the story leads the reader to believe.
The three men gave $27. The manager got $25 and the bellhop got $2. The end.
(25 + 2 = 27)
If you prefer, the three men gave $30. The manager got $25, the bellhop got $2, and $3 were refunded.
(25 + 2 + 3 = 30)
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending