Discussion Locked

vista is a DUD ! (wham baam thankyou maam!)

0 helpful
1,924 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

THE DEATH KNELL OF VISTA HAS ALLREADY BEEN SOUNDED!!!!PROVING I WAS RIGHT ALL ALL ALLONG.To prove i'm right just look at the Amazon prices & you will see xp home $10 dearer than vista home.It has derfintely turned ugly!
With so many members of the elite!! at tech republic etc giving vista the thumbs up when in fact they were merely speculating.Please look at the evidence don't take my word & you'll see i'm right!!

Well Guys & Gals SORRY to dissapoint you all, recent testing has shown VISTA to be outperformed by XP by a whopping 15%!!A lot of it due to the way the op system is designed & it's non functioning as an op system.As predicted vain attempts to rewrite source code at the last minute or lack of & reports of positive spin did not help the lame system. Recent release of vista has proven to a lot of people that it is a complete waste of time.VISTA=DUD!Guys & Gals i have been totally vindicated as my thread has tried to tell you the truth.While Other threads are simply speculating at tech republic.
MS have pretented to show by using terms like vista ready & packing features that people don't realy need & using catch words like "killer product" with complete abandon when in fact it has been a complete DUD!
There are no real benefits attached.Compared to xp it is much slower.Heaps of people have tried the os & have gone back to XP just as i had predicted!
Microsoft also has attempted to cut
Support Time for Some Vista queries...
Vista will go the way of Windows ME and I think Microsoft knows it that is why they have allready announced a ... Gee, do ya THINK MS knows Vista is a dud? ...
When compared, test results actually show vista to be outperformed by xp.
Hey guys MS has finally admitted that VISTA IS A complete FAILURE !!!
Well,Well Heh Heh I have been totally vindicated!!!!!!!!!!!
Well hell nothing short of total vindication for me ,Bill Gates
admitting to vista failure & him stepping down due to vista being a DUD!
You have Acer chief admitting to vista being a failure & refusing to partake of it!
You also have people like Dell,Hp,& others refusing to use vista due to stability & security issues.Dell vista sales have been drastically curtailed as the company & others do not openly recommend use of vista in new systems.
Vista critical issues have not been fixed as redmond procrastinates.Sales of vista have been dwindling.
Vista performance testing is still woefull
as the"lame" system is licking it's wounds
the death knell has allready been sounded!!
Well ,well we are now in january 2008 &Recent aussie lab testing has confirmed that comparison tests between vista & xp have been shown to be 15 % now it has been checked & can be as bad as 22%.Why a lot of it in the way the source code has been put together like wham bam thankyou maam!!
Guys i'ts April 1st 2009 we are waiting for
the next windows win 7 need isay more about vista its all been said bfor.
ta mick

ta mick

1,924 replies

by georgeou

"vista is a crap system why because it is a resource hungry system"

No, Vista utilizes the hardware you already have more efficiently. The 512 MB minimum is the recommended minimum memory. That extra RAM is used to boost performance with things like SuperFetch but Vista will actually load on much less RAM. Vista is taking advantage of modern systems with 512 MB ram or more and doesn't just let that RAM sit their idle which disk seeks slow the system down.

"it crashes moreas to compatibility issues"

What can I say, it's called a beta.

"it is not backward compatible."

It's often the very same complainers complain that Vista didn't drop legacy support and should have been written from scratch.

"it has also security holes more than you can poke a stick at."

No, it's much more secure than any other desktop operating system with the new security model.

"it is much slower in multi tasking than xp"

No, it's really not.

"whereas vista requires basic i gig of ram,100 gig hard drive,dual processor core at least 3 gig processor."

No, it doesn't. But it can exploit modern hardware like never before to deliver a better user experience.

"compatibility is a big issue.A waste of money why bother as there aren't too many functional reasons to buy."

No, compatibility is as good as it can be. As for a waste of money, that's for individual users to decide.

"Obviously therare problems with stability as the kernel is not fully capable of working in the 64 bit chip architecture comfortably."

Again, see definition for "beta". But 64 bit is fully supported and "comfortable".

So tell me, what beta builds have you tested? Or are you just speculating?

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.
well you got ms stooges like michael hereid
snr beleiving all is well with vista can't accept the enevitable that ms has produced a crap system.

by aaron a baker

The Bottom line with Vista is that unless a person "Actually has tried it out" they are in no position to talk.
From then on, all we get is what's been said by someone else who didn't try it and on it goes. I for one would like those of us who have NOT used the system to be the ones to read about it from the experienced user. Anything else makes no sense. So there's no point in flaming, your blog tells us A-You're angry and B- at something you know nothing about and do not understand.Get with the Program.
I would advise doing like the rest of us who Don't have Vista and read.
You might learn something.
And for god's sake, stop listening to the blathering fools around you who haven't tried it either.
Good or Bad, I want to hear it from an experienced user and not a theorist.
At the very least, A Pro ;)
Regards :)
Aaron

by neil higgins

Unless you've dabled with the beta version,now 2,I have'nt,simply trashing Vista,is stupid.A good read is at longhornBlogs.com
I wont be installing Vista from "the off",as I want to see what problems occur,and they will,due to the enormous mish-mash of configurations "out there",but after a period of reflection,and a good look at one of the full release versions next year,in a home situation (family members have said they will buy),I shall dabble to my hearts content,and see what happens.
Read,review,but above all dont destroy with words,a product that is'nt out till 07.If you dont have the "bottle",or chance,to be beta tester,or after a long "test" period of one of the final public release versions,then you can say you dont like it,or it's not for you.Kicking Microsoft seems to be the norm.I often have a little dig now and again,but writing the code for a new OS is no easy task,and one which should be appreciated.Really.

by w2ktechman

I loaded the latest (beta2) on an HP-Compaq tc4200 notebook.
From previous versions, beta2 ran smoother and faster (but took longer to install). It eats up almost 80 MB Ram less than previous versions tested. I was much more comfortable with this release than previous versions.
That said.. It stil needs lots of work. System resources are more in control with it, but many drivers are still unavailable or cannot install. Perfect example, I could not get the pen driver loaded (tablet pc). It failed every time, but when I erased the drive, setup XP and installed the driver, then upgraded, it worked fine. So the driver worked, it just wouldnt install.
But I tested the BOOT recovery option again, I havent done this since the first build. It still does not work well. I moved ntoskrnl.exe and booted, it errored (expected), instructed me to recover, asked for the disk, and ran a process. After a few minutes it asked if I wanted to run system restore ???? for a missing kernal? I said no, and it scanned for another 5 min or so and told me that nothing was wrong with the boot environment???????? This really needs some work.
Then I tried the new search. Unless I am searching the cd drive or the directory that I am currently in, it will not find anything. This may be an option that was disabled purposefully, but it is one of the 'highlights' of Vista, so why would it be disabled?

I didnt go further because it still needs a lot of work. I played with it for a day and blew it away, just waiting for a better release, or at least one where I can search and actually find something.

by unclerob

concise, polite and directly to the point:
excellent reply, you could give a course on discussion responses!

I get tired of reading flames, it's nice to read something positive.

Thank you, it's a good start to the day.

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by ronaldchilcoat

Microsoft is the perfect example of what is wrong with monopolies - Vista is reported to have 50 mil lines of code! No one at microsoft knows what is going on in the code - no one except the antichrist (Gates) has been there that long. Nothing with 50m lines of code an be stable (I say that having spent over 30 years in IT)- by luck of timing and stupidity on IBM's part - Gates and company became a virtual monopoly on the desktop - and now we all suffer for it. Not only will Vista be full of security holes and a resource hog - but it will have many more "Big Brother" "features" built in. Just try to dup a new dvd with Vista. I for one have decided to begin learning lenux I stopped using Internet Explorer,& Outlook and always look for something other than Microsoft software for any application I want. You will not see anything good come out of Redmond until Gates & Co. have some real competition.

by yobtaf

The bottom line is: If you want to be part of the world you will need
to use Vista at some point. I will get it when I'm good and ready
(and that will depend, in part, on when MS can get it together). I
don't like the "Big Brother" features and MS getting involved in DRM
issues. All this just tightens its clamp on the OS business. I just
wish it was possible for PC users to have another choice other than
to use Linux.

by emar1000

I don?t necessarily like everything MS does but you know what? Deal with it. I respect your over 30 years of exp. But instead of bashing do something about it. Get some business savvy and start pushing the OS of your choice. It wouldn?t matter who is heading up the best OS out there. The same bashers now would be the same bashers then. It doesn?t take a rocket scientist to do a search of other OS?s security flaws.

Oh and 80% of the time I use Linux.
Its just a favorite past time to bash the leader. Be a little more constructive.

by gsaravin9

monopoly is right!
have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by dlmeyer9

George got it right except for this answer:

"it has also security holes more than you can poke a stick at."

No, it's much more secure than any other desktop operating
system with the new security model.
_______

Sorry, George. OS X still rules in this area. You can trot out your
list of "vulnerabilities" and you can claim "obscurity" all you want
- the "more secure" Vista being tested by <1% of the market
over the past year have been hit by more malware than the
"more vulnerable" OS X users (>2% of market) have seen in the
past several years ... not that that's such a difficult standard to
exceed.

Still, in the WINDOWS world, it is "more secure". This is a Good
Thing.

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by mr.wiz

I've loaded and run every beta for Vista that has come out. In fact, I'm loading the beta 2 that was just released right now. I've been impressed with Vista so far, and it works pretty well, even with pc's that don't have a gig of ram or a 100 gb hard drive. The system I'm loading right now has an 80 gb HDD, 512 MB RAM, P4 2.4 processor and on-board video. I don't get Aero with this machine, but it runs quite well.

by neil higgins

at Microsoft,over something or other,but to just call Vista "crap" is silly.Think of all the hard work the guys/gals are doing at Redmond.Think of all the beta testing which goes on.Think of all the data reports,and meetings that go on,to make sure all the bits fit.True,I wont be installing Vista,as I've said on another thread,but to just put the OS down without seeing it in action,is incomprehensible.
A tongue-in-cheek remark is one thing,but to simply "trash the thing" is off-line.

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by jim lovejoy [ibm]

Same here Mr.Wiz. I have loaded Vista on aprox. 15 different platforms, of all ranges, and configurations. I have seen no real major issues. For a beta, I have been impressed. Although my real interest is in the Server product, this does look like a good replacement for XP as long as the hardware that it is installed on is not outdated. If your trying to run it on PIII, stick with 2000, or XP.

Once it?s released I will use it on a dedicated machine, and confirm that all the numerous apps that I use are compatible. As always, if I find any issues, I just open a case with Microsoft, and they are always happy to jump in and solve any issues that I bring to their attention. After 30 years in this business, I have never had a more professional experience with advanced support then with Microsoft.

I have used every OS that has been out there since the late 1970?s. Some were innovative for their time, some were crap. One thing is for sure, Vista will not be crap when it?s released. You can bank on it.

by gsaravin9

it's truly crap! have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by jardinier

I note that you have been a member of TR since August, 2002, you have absolutely nothing in your profile, and this appears to be the first post you have made.

So do us all a favour and fill in your profile so that we know who you are, what are your interests, and what experience you have had with IT.

There has been quite a lot of discussion about Vista at this website recently, so I would recommend that you read some other discussions and get a much wider range of viewpoints.

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by hitoweruk

If we were to even consider your opinion as valid, you would have to first make your message readable! Perhaps, if you are too lazy to write properly, you are also too lazy to properly review software that is very much in beta!

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by aaron a baker

I'm glad you concur. There has been an incredible an absolutely incredible amount of hype and built up tension regarding a product that, for all intents and purposes, "Doesn't Exist Yet" and yet all this back and forth between those loving it and those hating it.
It's not Vista they hate, it's Microsoft and they can't wait to get in there and start looking or thing to go wrong, just so that they can rant and rave some more.
If ever there was an exercise in futility, this is it.
I think you'll find that as time goes on, the rants/raves will die down and the truly intelligent members, will read up on what the "Experienced" Vista user think's and why.
Many users, different experiences, should be interesting.
when you consider the line up of Pros and Experience that we have in our little Tech Republic Family.
It's not going to be boring, that's for sure.
Regards
Aaron

by gsaravin9

vista is not going to make the line as there are major faults inherent in the system.
have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by inspiredfunk

I have to confess that I have made no posts under this ID before, but I have often enjoyed the posts of other users. This is not one that fell into that category - it looks as if you have read a review on a Linux site, taken the 5 top criticisms leveled at Vista by marketing people (many of whom have not yet seen the Beta 2), and jumped on the anti-Microsoft band waggon.

I can't blame you for that - but supporting your arguments with facts, rather than loose statements would be more effective.

You have to remember that, despite any bad feeling towards Microsoft, they have done more to bring standardisation to the computer industry than any other software company. I do not say this as a fan of Micro$oft, after all, their licensing approach is not, perhaps, the most cost effective - but with all the pirating of MS products that goes on, perhaps this is not a surprise.

Vista Beta 2, which is the current subject of lab tests for me, has proven to be a reasonable beta release. We have not found the "compatibility" issues to which you refer, with the exception of a few slightly more specialised hardware components (which, in truth, are not supported AT ALL by Linux). For general components, we have had no significant problems.

For backwards compatibility, granted there are a few issues, but testing these issues is a part of the Beta process - and Microsoft has made great efforts to fix many of the issues identified in the last Beta release.

As for security, our view is that the security of Vista is significantly better, more integrated and more coherent that that provided for XP at this time. Of course there are still a few holes, but again, this is a Beta!

Our core criticism against Microsoft would be one of expectation management - this product was supposed to hit the streets in production a few years ago. In the interim we continue to patch existing operating systems in a model which is more effective for the enterprise than the home user.

FYI - before I am accused of "working" for Microsoft, my core home systems are based on SUSE and Mandrivo Linux, my web servers run predominantly on proprietary UNIX platforms (with the exception of Sharepoint on Windows Server 2003).

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by ang2006

the final judgement on the Vista system. The post by gsaravine was very angry and with many unsubstantuated charges which George promptly put down(Not to mention I am very suspicious of anyone who types like they are 4 years old) I, at least for now, am pretty much satisfied with XP as it it is worlds above the former Windows offerings. If Vista becomes the Cadillac and XP is then the Chevy---I'll likely take and keep the chevy for awhile as it runs just fine. After all Microsoft sells enough caddies at too high a price anyway, God Bless 'em!!

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by verd1

gsaravin
I really believe you are just an anti-Microsoft person. You are "one of those" people who hate Microsoft no matter what they do just because they are a sucessfull company. Thanks very much for the post as now I know who's post I will not waste anytime with. Maybe you should just GROW UP and go back to your Linux box or Mac or Free BSD or whatever it is you use, just do not write anymore useless posts like this one. In fact maybe you should just get off Tech Republic all together.

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by researcher75

Trying to follow these Vista tracks one has to have the sense of an olde Virginian I think? one source says "Whoppee" and another say" Yuk!" - it seems to me that there are problems with Longhorn come Vista but one hopes the delayed release is going to straighten them out. Running 3 machines on XP Home for some while now, I have found they seem to develop individual characteristics, dependant upon the build. To crapize Vista at this stage is a little harsh I think as if it is anything like the thought that went into Office 2007 which I am using with very good results, then Vista will be the perfect partner to provide an even better base for programs.

Roy

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by gfdgary

Calm down, gsaravin. The release is still BETA so take a pill. I'm using release 5381 on an AMD 2600+, 1.5 gig ram, and a older nVidia 6200/256mb ram video card. Works fine, programs open extremely fast, and the GUI is very pleasing. Oh, and I have it installed in a 35gb partition on one of my older 80gb, 7200 PATA Western Digital hard drives. The only problem I had was it did not recognize my 250gb SATA drive intitially.

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by dean_nr

I mean, if you're talking about Vista after it's gone gold and is available in stores then _maybe_ I could understand the gripe. But if you're talking about a beta system that's being used on machines that were designed with windows XP in mind, then there's gonna be some issues at first.
I mean when windows 3.1 was that 'standard', do you think windows 95 didn't hog resources? Do you think windows 95 didn't have issues with PCs built for a DOS environment?
So unless you actually have access to time travel and managed to snap a copy of Vista from Best Buy 2 years from now, quite poo-poo'ing on an unfinished product. That's like complaining to a chef that his meals are garbage while he's still preparing it.

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by wiske57

I recently quit using a well known A/V product after paying to upgrade to the 2006 version. The problem? Required more system resources than I could afford. Vista will sell; I can see you haven't seen it run, (on good hardware.) Think of why I may be saying that. Vista requires a lot from the system and more opinions than mine have been changed in the last few weeks. 98SE did all that I needed to do, I had no reason to upgrade. D'uh, well maybe I better as I have 25 machines to support that will be upgraded. XP will do all I need to do. Why would I upgrade? Sound repetitive?

by npinchot

"I had no reason to upgrade. D'uh, well maybe I better as I have 25 machines to support that will be upgraded. XP will do all I need to do. Why would I upgrade? Sound repetitive?"

If everybody said that everyone would still be using green text monitors that have no graphics mode. That's a bit of an exaggeration but you know what I'm sayin. I'm not saying Microsoft is great or Vista is great (not saying it's bad either). I'm just saying technology evolution is a good thing.

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by emar1000

I use to work with a couple people with this same type of attitude towards MS. They really are good people but the attitiude they had was less than tasteful. Suppose you are right, Vista is a resource hog. Ya so? It should be expected that it will use more resources. Common sense should tell you that. Personally I am looking forward to seeing what it can do. I just wish I had a beta to try.

by hal 9000

Or probably more correctly the first Beta Release of Vista and not the preproduction Longhorn platform should be available sometime around 3 weeks from the 22 May 06.

MS is attempting to have the [b]Ultimate[/b] version of Vista available come November 06 but at the current time this is still up in the air and could be pushed back depending on what problems that they run into.

Currently Vista represents [b]1,000,000 Man Years[/b] of work well at least according to the MS Marketing Rep that addressed us at the MS Road Show on the 22 May 06 and currently they are finding 5,000 problems per day in the code so it should still be quite some time till the Retail Version becomes available.

And Vista will run on a lot less than 512 MEG of RAM and a Dual Core 3 GIG CPU it's just with the lower Video RAM available some functions will not be available to the user which I personally do not see as such a bad thing as Vista will cut back and only allow the systems to run that the computer has the resources for.

Currently the Beta Version of Vista should be arriving soon and I'll be downloading it and having a play with it on a [b]High End Workstation[/b] before I even begin to think about if I like it or not. On Friday Local Time MS sent out a MS Bulletin setting up for those wanting to try Vista and when they make it available I'll load it to a system along with the Office 12 or 07 product also in Beta and give it a run. Currently I have the Office products downloaded & I'm just waiting for the Vista OS to become available before I load them up and give them a run.

As far as comparing Vista to XP it is a [b]Resource Hog[/b] which requires far more in the way of hardware but by the same token the same was said about XP before it was released and today a 3 GIG CPU is one of the smaller ones available and with the cost of RAM being [b]As Cheap as Chips[/b] who cares if you need a couple of GIG that RAM will still cost less than the 1 MEG that we used on the old DOS days.

Being one of the Dinosaurs here I can still remember paying $100.00 per MEG for RAM and a $1.00 a MEG for HDD Space now it's really much cheaper than that and a computer built to make full use of the newest MS OS when it eventually becomes available will still be much cheaper than a 286 was when new. When the DX60 486's where new I broke the bank by installing 8 X 16 MEG RAM Sticks [i]that's right I had 128 MEG of RAM on a 486[/i] on the M'Board with a 500 MEG HDD and a 256 Colour Display adaptor.

I can still remember having to fight with the sales person for that 500 MEG HDD because it would be [b]Unfillable[/b] in his words and that was before Windows in any form was available.

Personally before I make any decisions on Vista I'll [b]Suck It And See[/b] and then make my decision from there. But no matter what with the Latest Generation of Dual Core HTT CPU's available there is one thing that is certain [b]XP CAN NOT RUN THEM FULLY[/b] so unless you are pushing a wholesale switch to Linux by this post you are way off the mark. :D

Col ]:)

Just one thing I forgot to add Vista will be coming out on a DVD not a CD as there is over 1 GIG of it to load. So MS has finally made good on their word and is finally releasing their Software on a DVD which they have being saying that they have been going to do for several years now. But if you want to work with a really [b]Low End[/b] computer you can get it on CD's for a while from it's release though I personally don't know any system builders who are still using CD instead of DVDs in their systems.

by alvarocervantes

I think an OS should be an interpreter of the hardware, not the other way around. So basically I don't see why we have to adjust to MS rather than them creating a pure OS which could be very light since no applications have to be there. An applciations disk could be added and we install whatever we need or want. We all know that MS OS it is not just an OS but a marketing devise so we continue filling the landfields with palstics, metals and silicon.
My advice, recycle and use Linux in your old computers.

by hal 9000

The NB which has above average Specs has proven a bit of a mixed bag with Vista. It refuses to boot from a DVD though it will boot quite happily from a CD. [i]Chalk up one to MS for their great new OS[/i] I generally run Debian on the NB and it works perfectly even the Web Cam and WiFI built in devices but it seems that it can not boot from it's Dual Layer DVD Burner when you insert a DVD I'm still waiting for a BIOS Update that will hopefully cure the problem. :D

As for the Dual Xeon it's my new Workstation and can not be called anything but new eventually when I get around to finishing it off I'll have several different Distro's installed to boot from and no doubt a copy of Windows not so much because I want it but because I have to service it and I keep forgetting things when I don't use it enough.

But I'm no where as nasty as one Nix Developer that I've meet who runs Nix on his NB with IE loaded on the desktop so just about everyone thinks that he running Windows with some new advanced settings. :^0

Now if only I could move all my customers over to a Nix Desktop I would be so much happier and have far less work inflicted on myself. :p

Col ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

in the transition to XP from 2000 and in 2000 from 98 SP II and prior to that from 95 and prior to that from 3.11. Microsnot unfortunately produces some of the most bloated code possible and endeavours to introduce all kinds of bells and whistles that few have really asked for in real world circumstances. Unfortunately many of these items are ill conceived and poorly implemented, thus opening portals for all sorts of malware. So many of these things are so seldom used that quite some time can pass before anyone becomes aware of the vulnerabilities.

Rather than see a more complex OS loaded with assorted features that over 90% will seldom if ever use, why can't MS produce a faster more secure OS and make the additional features available as plug-ins. They could still sell the new and improved OS and have an additional market for the plug-ins for those who are truly in need of these things.

We have been evaluating the first beta version of Vista and are presently entering upon an evaluation of beta 2. As with our transition to XP, so far it looks that we will be holding off as long as possible before making the switch. The fact that they were publishing security patches to the first beta even before it was published, speaks volumes. Hell they still haven't got Office 2003, never mind 2007, running glitch free without vulnerabilities still coming to light, never mind the XP OS. What discourages me is that after reporting a minor glitch to MS, we were apparently provided with a patch, that while fixing the glitch, opened up two or more potential problems.

I am not actually performing the evaluations myself because I no longer have the recondite skills necessary for the task; my focus being primarily on the hardware front but I still have the ability to comprehend what my people are telling me. So far, as with XP, the advice is to wait until others have sorted out all the glitches that are sure to arise.

Make no mistake about it; we will transition to Vista eventually. We will have no choice but this doesn't mean we have to be happy with the switch. One would think that a company with the resources of MS could do a better job of publishing a fast,
secure 64 bit OS than what they have achieved so far. Our glitch or problem list is now over seven legal sized pages long and growing. God alone knows what it will be like when the 128 bit systems start coming on line in 2010, with the rumour that 256 bit and 512 bit systems may be seen before 2015.

It is interesting to note that the laptops carried by astronauts aboard the shuttle and the space station have only recently switched to 486s, although that is changing as I write this. The reason for using such old tech, is that it has been thoroughly debugged. There is talk they may be switching from Intel to AMD systems but why this should be so, is unclear to me. It isn't a hardware problem but a software one, in the area of backwards compatability.

As a point of interest, who is running IE7 and other than the supposed tabbing feature, is it really any improvement over 6??? It's like all other MS products; riddled with security holes and a resource hog, never mind the fact that it is unnecessarily bloated beyond belief.

My personal opinion is that MS has too many coders including their pet projects into the overall system and there isn't sufficient supervision as to what should be included and what excluded. They get away with this because hardware development is light years ahead of software development and will continue to be so for the foreseeable future. I am not kidding about 128 bit systems, Intel has that in the fire already with the rumour that AMD is prepared to leapfrog 128 bit and go straight to 256 with 512 in the background. Imagine dual core chips in this range. The reason for these new chips is OSs based upon voice activation. Say goodby to mice and perhaps keyboards. We will all be like Scotty in Startrek, "Hello computer?" Forget fingerprint readers and retina scanning, voice print recognition will become the standard for machine security.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by mustangj369

Is the software growing in complexity and ability to take advantage of the latest hardware capabilities or is the hardware being made more powerful to keep up with the needs of advanced software?
At the moment, you're right that hardware is ahead of software, and Microsoft is just trying to make the best use of what hardware is out there. Yes, Vista qualifies as bloatware, I suppose, but look at all that it can do. True, many of these features won't be used by a lot of people, particularly enterprise users in the case of media functionality, and your idea of providing these as plugins has merit, but MS can't be pilloried for trying to market a complete computing experience in one package. It's one of the reasons for their success.

BTW: I've read that most astronauts carry their own laptops on space missions because NASA's are too old. The reason for that is it takes as long as 7 years for NASA to certify hardware for space. There must be reasons for this lengthy process other than durability testing, such as budgetary restraints. No need to upgrade to the latest and greatest if what you've got does the job sufficiently well.

by sleepin'dawg

is over twenty years old. Yes they do carry their own computers but they still require the NASA ones, which plug directly into the onboard computers and controls. The personal computers may lack the capability and you must remember that most mil standard hardware has been redundantly debugged to the nth degree. By the time this has been accomplished the technology has moved on. You would be amazed at how old some of the hardware technology is, that NASA uses but it isn't a matter of bugetary restraints so much as it is because it is something that has been proven beyond a doubt to work without fail, [i]most of the time.[/i]

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by patl411

ur sayin it reuires 1 gig ram? i ran it fine and fast at 768... dual core? i have a athlon 2800+.. thats single core and 2.14ghz.. not 3ghz... and the hdd i used was a 30 gig....maybe u have never tried runnin it... becuase it ran nice for me

by mustangj369

The MPAA and RIAA wrote the DCMA and paid its way through Congress. If Windows pcs are to have access to protected content, they must support DRM. I don't like it any more than you but I can't write checks to compete with Hollywood.
As for other choices, there's always Apple. Oh, wait. They have their very own DRM (FairPlay - well, fair to Apple in any event), don't they?

by jdudeck

Certainly we aren't so addicted to Hollywood that we need DRM'ed content, do we?

For that matter, I still use W2000. It is far better than XP in most ways. Vista is a no-go for me. By time that W2000 won't run on current hardware, Linux will have gotten good enough that we can walk away from M$ altogether.

by sir_cheats_alot

someone will find a way around DRM, they always do. i have a copy of Win2k Pro, but i encountered stability issues with SP4 and it crashed out and i was presented with the BSOD. after being forced to reformat four times, i reinstalled XP w/SP2 and haven't really had many problems since...so i can't say win2000 is any better then XP. As Far as Linux goes, i'm already using it...in fact i'm using Ubuntu 5.10 "breezy badger" while i type this. I must say Linux has come a L O N G way in the last few years. now there is a way to read and now write to a NTFS file system under linux. WiFi is now supported. From what i hear Myth TV works quite well now. Linux is making some very nice advancements now...except grub...that never seems to change. There are a few Distros that are targeted at the expected migrating windows users. while some don't support proprietary format out of the box, the codecs are in repositories for download, so with a little effort those coming from windows shouldn't have too much trouble(given the great support of each respective linux community, and of course google ;) ) i have NeverWinter Nights diamond edition v1.67 working under linux (and it hasn't crashed once by the way), so i'm perfectly happy on linux.

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by tryten

Run vista virtualized under an Linux distro....
I am currently doing that with xp pro. Or when its possible run something like DSL (damn small linux) virtualized. With a good system you can run both without a problem. And when something gets infested with DRMs reload them. Virtualization is so fun.

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by gsaravin9

The bottom line is that they were to release 64 bit & it has many shortcomings & the future is not rosy with DRM.
have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by moira

People seem to love bashing AOL in a similar way to Vista (and by implication, Microsoft). Usually they're people who have barely done more than dabble with either and just think it makes them look kewl and 1337.

I have beta2 and have had a go with some of the earlier builds. My only real criticism is the need to have a 3D graphics card for desktop apps. Many, many people never need more than onboard graphics for all the programs they use, why should the OS alone demand this? And I've seen the difference, Vista really does lose something when you can't view the fade in fade out menus or the spectacular graphic effects properly.

Yes it takes a lot of space, but look how big hard drives are now. Is there really going to be a problem with users not having enough gigabytes to install it? Yes the permissions issue is well irritating, but MS have been forced into this position in rather the same way as we're all forced to have house contents insured.

I do think if they hadn't hyped up the release of Vista quite so much with all these versions which will quickly need replacing once the 64 bit OS builds come out, and they hadn't then got hopelessly behind schedule with code that had to be rewritten etc, they might have made it easier on themselves. At the end of the day though, we can't really criticise the product until it's launched.

by willjamr

"I just wish it was possible for PC users to have another choice other than to use Linux."

Heard of BSD? It's *not* Linux.

by gsaravin9

yes vista is another system...And with lot's of shortcomings.You wonder why they are pushing it so hard i'ts themight $.
have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by fxef

Vista may carry us on a turbulent ride, but it's not going to sink. XP has us spoiled with it's solid foot print. Now this is just my opinion but moving to Vista from XP is going to be like the switch from 3.11 to Win95.

FXEF

by w2ktechman

What about Mac??
Besides, the only real issues with Linux for beginners is installing apps, setup config, and app availability.
I am currently running Linux SUSE 10 on KDE and have gotten pretty good at the basic things. I cant play a DVD yet (trouble installing media players) but after 2 days of it I was able to get myself up and running with Thunderbird email, Opera and Firefox (and Konquerer) browsers (all 3 are working), dual screen on a notebook, setup background and some security, setup printers, figured out how to communicate with my XP boxes, etc.
In other words, it originally took me longer than that to learn Win 95. I can do most of my work with SUSE now, with just a few days of getting to know it.
However, I still wish for a better install system. I hate browsing for companion files and making 7 or 8 downloads and installing them all (in a certain sequence) to get 1 program working.

by jumpa

I do not and never have understood the requirements for backwards compatibility within an IT environment (which it seems is the main thrust of Tech Republic). I would love to know why it is a requirement when PCs and servers generally get replaced/updated every 3 and in the very worst case 5 years.

There are sectors in which backwards compatibility could be required such as industrial control. I'm a H/W designer (yes I know I shouldn't be here) who designs such boards and it always astounds me that people would want to run low bandwidth/slow devices (eg my pet hate the ISA bus) on processors that are several hundred times faster than when these devices were state of the art. If it didn't show a complete lack of understanding it would be funny when I get complaints that under XP the ISA bus doesn't run any faster and sometimes considerably slower than on their old 286 or 386 machine with a cut down version of 95 on it (these people generally love doughnuts and have a son called Bart).

Microsoft have missed a real trick here. I'll admit I'm not their greatest fan but they really should have elminated as much backward compatibility as possible with Vista. To run all these devices you don't need Vista and you could argue probbably shouldn't even be running 2000 or XP. To have a machine capable of running XP or Vista and using these archaic devices is going beyond a joke. It's a bit like buying a Ferrari to drive 10 meters so you can get there that little bit faster only to find out it takes longer to get in and out of a Ferrari and therefore the overall journey takes longer.

There are 2 major upsides to eliminating backwards compatiblity. First there's less code in the OS so less to go wrong and probably increases efficiency. Second there's less hardware in your system which a. makes it cheaper, b. makes it more reliable, c. makes it cooler and d. makes it cheaper to run as it uses less power. Oh yes - e. stops driving me insane everytime something I have to design in goes obsolete :-)

by hal 9000

I don't know of too many people who want ISA or even VESA supported but they do want to be able to open a Doc that they made in Word 2 years ago in the new version of Word.

This is something that isn't always possible.

Actually I don't know of any people who would attempt to plug in [b]Old Hardware[/b] to a new system unless of course it's a USB Stick or something like that and there is always the Digital Camera but there shouldn't be an issue with Backward Compatibility with USB Devices.

Although I'll admit to liking it if possible to plug in my SCSI Slide Scanner and having it run on XP but I can buy a new Driver CD from the maker it's just that it's such a messy business that I can't be bothered so I keep a Win 98 unit around just to scan in Slides and the like. What is my main gripe here is that when I bought that scanner they already had XP out but no drivers available for it and now they want me to pay for them. And no it doesn't have an ISA SCSI Card as all the M'Boards that I use have the SCSI built onto them.

But here's a reasonable question for you with the changes in M'Board design when are we going to start seeing the next Generation of Plug in Cards for the sockets that are already available? Even the higher Speed PCI sockets have very few devices that actually will plug into them once you remove the RAID Adaptors I don't think that there are any and on my newest Intel M'Board there are 3 of these sockets. Granted most people would use one of these as a Server Board but I need a High End Workstation so the Dual Xeon suits my needs quite well.

But on a recent Intel Chip Set M'Board that I used there where only 2 PCI Sockets 1 PCI Express and 3 PCI Enhanced or whatever they are called. Now I know the benefits of this new socket but as yet I haven't seen anything at all to actually plug into them. Any idea when these new devices will be hitting the streets?

Col

by emar1000

I find it interesting that you don't know of any people who would attempt to plug in Old Hardware to a new system.

(?It?s an everyday occurrence whether it is in a business setting or a home user. ?)

I also have never had any issues opening older office documents with newer versions of office. But then again if I do there is always ?Open Office?. I don?t think MS should have to make something backward compatible to where it will cost them money. Users need to learn to get up to date. As for your SCSI Scanner ?blame the maker?.

I know you are saying they should, But I have heard more than one person complain about MS not making their products backward compatible. Why should they cater to those few that refuse to upgrade? I personally would rather not have backward compatible STUFF. Spend the money, or keep what you have and stop complaining.

(I repeat) This was not an attack on you personally.

by sir_cheats_alot

Hey, it's only a Beta! On top of that, i have to agree with the others...work on your grammer a while. Yes, i'm well aware that it is a resource hog. I personally won't be getting it, because i refuse to spend $200+ for a 256Mb graphics card, and another $80 for another 512Mb RAM chip...even though i should just because i'm a gamer. Seriously a 128Mb video card, and 256Mb of RAM should be plenty to run both A OS and a game. the reported 15Gb install for the OS without anything else is a bit rediculous. I, as a logical, semi-intellegent individual, will wait until Vista comes out before i bash it...It's common courtesy :p
yes, yes i also know my spelling sucks...it's not exactly a focus point in school these days.

by inspiredfunk

"it isn't a matter of bugetary restraints so much as it is because it is something that has been proven beyond a doubt to work without fail, most of the time."

... and the fact that the build contract go to the lowest costing, technically compliant bidder!

by unclerob

tell us how you really feel!

Vista is still a beta.
Unfortunately maybe your specific system has some hardware compatability issues with Vista which is why you're having such a bad experience with it.

You mention security issues, since this OS hasn't been released for mainstream consumption, I think it's a little early to say that it has "security holes more than you can poke a stick at". I wasn't aware of any existing security exploits against vista already. And I'm not saying there won't be security issues with Vista, all in all it should provide a more secure environment than we're currently experiencing with WinXP SP2.

Vista won't be for everyone and until some finite hardware specs are released letting people know what hardware they have to purchase in order to run Vista, it's a little speculative to say that Vista won't run unless you have 1 GB of ram and a 3GB cpu.

In the end, no one is forced to run Vista, you can only run Vista if you purchase it (beta's don't count) and if you don't like it, don't buy it. That's probably the greatest power you & other consumers have over Microsoft, send them a message that you don't like the software by not purchasing it.

This wasn't the greatest discussion to start, there are other Vista discussions in place where you could posted your statement as a reply instead of starting your own thread.

Just my 0.02 cents cdn.

by red_wolf9

Has anyone noticed that GSARAVIN has not posted since the original flame?

Let the thread die already.
Friends don't let friends feed trolls.

by moira

There was an initial post regarding ageism in IT or something like that - deliberately designed to be provocative and get people's backs up.

Turned out to be written by someone who actually held the diametrically opposite view and was merely trying to see arguments which would in fact, back this view up.

by hal 9000

Is you have a business running smoothly and then at the end of your current [b]Tax Cycle[/b] you replace your existing Hardware/Software combination and suddenly you are unable to read some Documents that are current or maybe even a Template that you have made previously in the supposedly [i]"Same Product!"[/i]

With my stuff that isn't a problem as I run 4 different Office Suites on my NB but as I do work for [b]Small Business[/b] this does have an effect on them which is very hard to justify when they run into it.

I just haven't run into a problem of needing to try to fit older hardware to a new computer other than external devices like Digital Cameras when it comes time to replace the units I replace the complete units though I'll admit that I do very little [b]Home Users Work[/b] all my customers are Small to Medium Business so I don't generally have a problem with this.

But the main problem that I've seen is that with the way that the Tax Cycle works these business are hitting every second product so while the document may open generally any special formating is either lost or so messed up that it has to be created again. Now if this is a half page letter it's no big deal but when it's a 25 Page Tender that is used all the time by these business as a Template it is a different story and this is where things begin to hurt.

Incidentally no Foul taken and [b]I do Blame the Scanners Maker[/b] so much so that I refuse to buy the XP drivers for the Bloody Thing. :D

Col

by emar1000

didnt stop to think a little further. After reading your reply it just popped in my head (i hate to admit I opened my mouth first before thinking) but I did. When joey bag of doughnuts business down the street upgrades to office 2007 and I still have 2003 yes it would cause issues. Not to mention the time and money involved. I was just thinking of "interoffice" issues. Hey sometimes I do get small minded :-P

by !thebear

Please be patient. By the time Vista actually arrives we will all be a year older and we will have new computers.

Remain calm.

by mjd420nova

I'm going to save my opinions until a full version is released. From the responses I've read, few are pleased with the performance. My estimation is that you must have a fast processor, and preferably a dual core one. The drivers seem to be the down fall, and I'm sure that when the full set gets out, that will have been fixed. If it turns out like MS expects, it will be my next OS to play with. I have already begun shopping for the parts to put together a functional system that would handle it. If it's as fast as touted, I may be able to finally combine all of my needed peripherals into one system without needing multiple platforms.

by researcher75

My sentiments exactly mjd420nova - I already have the motherboard the new ABIT AN 32X Series 939 socket with a 2GHZ system bus for a dual core AMD CPU and 2GB RAM DDR 400, we should get some interesting results?

by hal 9000

When all the different versions of Vista are finally released there are supposed to be 7 versions of the 32 Bit OS and 7 of the 64 Bit OS.

Right at the moment the stumbling block is the 64 Bit OS as there are still insufficient Drivers available for it and even less software support.

The above rant may be correct regarding the 64 Bit Versions but then again exactly the same things apply to the 64 Bit Version of XP as well but I very much doubt that it will be true of the 32 Bit versions when they become available.

There is however one thing that I'm still in 2 minds about but this will mainly apply to NB's if you need some extra RAM you can plug in a USB RAM Stick and that can be used as System Memory. While the idea sounds like a good one to get out of trouble in the short term it will have to affect the performance of the unit when this is being used.

Col

by gsaravin9

I have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i do't think too many people
ar ready to ditch their operating systems.

by gsaravin9

I have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by nehpets

You seem to have just copied your original post, and pasted it into hal a dozen new posts?
Whats the point?

As for people "dumping" operating system....
MS don't care about you, or other individual upgraders...

When you buy a new PC, you will get VISTA...
Corporates with SA, will get Vista...
and MS will get the numbers...

end of story, its just history repeating itself....

by gsaravin9

this ishappening because of vista th cut & paste function doesn't work properly & some letters do't appear.you are spot on.

by gsaravin9

this ishappening because of vista th cut & paste function doesn't work properly & some letters do't appear.you are spot on.I'm sory i'll just ditch vista &go to xp.

by jcdyson

Beta Release!!!!
Mate the releases that we have seen are just that Beta releases they are not even close to a polished product. I am not going to get into a slanging match about what quals you have because regardless of how many post nominals you have, experience is the thing that counts and honestly with the comments you have posted you are sounding too much like a newbie straight out of academia for me to get into anything of the sort, esp. when all you seem to do is cut and paste the same post over and over sounding like a broken record. A Beta is released to the IT community within MSDN and TechNet etc to allow us Professionals to evaluate the beta not go out and try and run everything that can be run on a polished OS such as XP or 2K. Naturally there will be some instability, and compatibility issues for some hardware/software with a Beta it?s because it is just that a BETA release. It is definitely not for general release nor should you even contemplate putting it into your production environment. I have ?played? with the latest release and whilst I have some minor reservations in the recovery and search functions as previous posters have eluded too, I am happy with what I am seeing and once the production version is released (and only then) will I make any harsh judgments or consider releasing it to my fleet.

by gsaravin9

the long delay is that they are having major tchnical
hurdles
have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by gsaravin9

Microsoft has a long way to go let's not kid ourselves i have really tested vista & it has major short comings not like the other predessessors. ihave recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by gsaravin9

you speak a lot of sense when you say that,i don't speakharshly it's a fact.
have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by gsaravin9

i respect your right to use any system you want.
have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by gsaravin9

have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code.I would hasard to guess they dare not
release vista just yet!Further to this as Hal haspointed out the major shortfall of the vista system is that it seems to be too bloated.There are not much drivers around,theres not much software around.For those of you who are asking
my background is I'm masters in computer science i specialise design,analysis of projects using new operating systems.You name the system i've done it.So far i've tested all versions of vista
& unless microsoft comes up with the goods ie if they can provide a water tight vessel(operating system) personally i don't think too many people
are ready to ditch their operating systems.

by steve.marshall

I don't often post here, I find it more interesting to read many of the discussions and usually find that someone has suggested or made comments similar to those I would like to voice, so do not feel it's worth repeating them.

Unfortunately it doesnt look like our friend gsaravin has the decency to do the same. I have gone through this thread now and am actually repulsed by the lack of objectiveness and relevance of any of your posts, this repetition of your "background" serves little relevance and its credibility stripped with every re-enouncement of your credentials... Just makes me feel that, even if they are true, it is more likely that your nothing more than a junior tech or tech student that has had the chance to play with a BETA for the first time in your career/life.

If you look at ALL of the MS OS BETA's historically driver databases have never been complete until release (and even then had amendments with service packs fairly swiftly after release). Have never been final working release version (erm... read BETA) and therefore are expected to be buggy, the WHOLE POINT of you having access to the BETA is to test it prior to release and comment on the problems you find with it...

Try to remember that your posts reflect future relevance and insight on other discussions... I for one will certainly be ignoring anything that contains your sig, prejudging them as worthless blathering, which maybe unfair, but you have set your own value that will unfortunately deface anything else you write before it is even written.

This may be deemed as harsh, I hope you take it as so and try and gleen something from it to take with you in the future.

Anyway, getting bored of this whole thread, completely pointless and as you have so painfully missed the point of the entire pre-relase program you are very likely to miss the point of this post so will not waste a moment more on it.

by joe

Your reply to this thread was well stated. As a 24 year veteran of the IT industry I could not agree with you more. If gsaravin is not a rookie he certainly is acting like one. I spent 10 years as a Microsoft and Cisco trainer as well as many years designing and building large corporate networks. Maybe this is the first beta gsaravin has ever seen. He should read the early beta reports from any Linux implementation, they are almost identical to the beta reports for Microsoft. I doubt that Microsoft will make their deadline for release, they have never made one of these deadlines going back to windows 2.0 (yes there was a windows 2.0)
What really gets me is gsaravin acts like everyother software vendor releases pure clean code. I remember, 12-15 years ago,a Novell rollout during the early days of pc Raid technology. We installed it and all the clients data was destroyed by what turned out to be a software bug, this was in a production release. Thankfully we had good quality backups.

The bottom line is that beta is beta and don't think production release 1 is perfect either. The fact is this is the world we live in get use to it or get into a different line of work.

by gsaravin9

this is my thread in this discussion if you don't like it get off
you are entitled to your view butyou are utterly wrong when you say i'm a junior tech.I have found major design faults in vista that you don't seem to comprehen fully.we know it's a beta but i'm telling you that vista will not make the light of day seriously.my job entails looking at such systems & i have spoken my mind & i have the backup to proove it!This is my thread i started it get off!

by gsaravin9

you are entitled to your view butyou are utterly wrong when you say i'm a junior tech.I have found major design faults in vista that you don't seem to comprehen fully.we know it's a beta but i'm telling you that vista will not make the light of day seriously.my job entails looking at such systems & i have spoken my mind & i have the backup to proove it!This is my thread i started it get off!