Discussion Locked

vista is a DUD ! (wham baam thankyou maam!)

0 helpful
1,924 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

1,924 replies

by gsaravin9

I was frank & to the point simply without fear or favour some people can't accept that.I have assesed the inner workings of vista & have recommended that it will not function like the other releases be it vista beta or vista actual release.Being 29 years in IT ,i have inner contacts with MS & secretely they have assured me beta or no beta vista will not see the light of day as there are severe performance restrictions in the 64 bit architecture.I'm frank about it i have checked it out by going to the source code etc .trust me it is crap.it is all pie in the sky.

by gsaravin9

i know that i'm right i'm not agains't anyone or system.I have simply found that we are all led up the proverbial garden path once too often.i'll say it again that i have thouroughly testedvista & it has major shortcomings that will be fixed in time,& because i'm such a talented & experienced person i beleive that vista will not see the light of day as a full release.In saying this i'm not against anyone.This is not going to make it as there are
major design flaws & problems so expect MS to abandon it soon!In speaking i have experience & it is not an off the cuff comment.I can back it up!

by gsaravin9

You people are attacking me instead of going out for yourselves & seeing first hand of what is really happening.Coupled with this you treat it as i have spoken too soon & i know i havent as i have contacts within microsoft.I know what a beta release is.I can also tellyou what vista is really tryng to bring is mostly cosmetic that won't show much benefit.I don't know how you can dissagree with me when you can see a lot of people have allready agreed on some of the problems.Also we are heading into a new grey area
64 bit architecture all i'm saying is that it is happening toofast without due regard for proper hardware or software to handle it.Not only this
people have said that the future will be with 128
bit.256 bit,512 bit up to 712 bit operating systems.I would like to see what operating system they have planned???.All i'm saying is i have examined the details & vista does not answer the needs of the 64 bit architecture as i have tested it thouroughly.
expect performance in the 32 bit area.

you can agree to disagree you are entitled to your opinion.My recommendation is i know i'm right!

by steve.marshall

You almost... almost, put up a constructive critical post there !

Unfortunately you threw it away at the end with "My recommendation is I know i'm right!" You know nothing, all you know is that the current Beta is flawed which is something we all know, that's why its still a beta release.

Your entire argument is flawed as you lack the understanding of hardware and software life cycles. Software forces hardware vendors to up the stakes, and I assure you, that if MS are bulldozing for Inetl, AMD etc to produce chips that will take advantage of their OS they will.

When the PII's + where realeased to the general public did you honestly believe that they were the greatest and latest chips that Intel were working on ? I know for a fact that they had 1.2g development processor in the works when the PII hit the market place. Do you not think that manufacturers already have their own beta programs for hardware to put the Vista platform on ???

You continually seem to be trying to infer that you have omnipotent foresight into Microsofts plans and expert knowledge on the major chip manufacturers... well... I'm afraid that it is plainly obvious through the absolutely trash posts you have made that you are either a child troll looking to try and impose your biased and short sighted views on people that have a good understanding of the laws of progression. Or, you're some kind of tech in what is obviously an over paid and poorly managed position otherwise you would have been fired years ago... 29 years experience... don't make me laugh, 29 days maybe, and probably fresh out of school with the business sence of a Gibbon.

You have discredited yourself so many times the only real reason i'm posting here is due to rubber knecking syndrome, can't resist looking at a disaster site, and you Gsaravin are clearly the disaster...

If you were in beta, i'd scrap the project immediately.

by gsaravin9

i know that i'm right i'm not agains't anyone or system.I have simply found that we are all led up the proverbial garden path once too often.i'll say it again that i have thouroughly tested vista & it has major shortcomings that will not be fixed in time,& because i'm such a talented & experienced person i beleive that vista will not see the light of day as a full release.In saying this i'm not against anyone.This is not going to make it as there are
major design flaws & problems so expect MS to abandon it soon!In speaking i have experience & it is not an off the cuff comment.I can back it up!

by gsaravin9

dONT SHOOT THE MESSENGERi undestand what betas are etc etc so i for one will not criticise microsoft because i hate them ,i don't hate them
you all got it wrong i have evaluated their system &it has simply got major short comings
at least stand up for what you beleive.In so doing i have received over 100 replies,i have really stirred up a hornets nest .I think people will be stirred up for a change & ask pertinent
questions like have they reached the end of the road for the operating systems.At least i'm honest & i have 29 years of experience to back it up.

by steve.marshall

A messenger delivers information, be it good news or bad, you... as the proverbial carrier pigeon have done nothing more than pooped on the "head" of debate.

You have done nothing but bad mouth Vista without any constructive comments to back up your points, in fact, you haven't MADE any points at all.

Discussion is about debating an issue, thing, question, none of which have been opened to the floor by you.

We have had numerous amounts of duplicate posts yet infinitely devoid of any real content and your (limited) resume posted more times than I care to remember...

I ask you, if your JOB is to test operating systems, do you submit product reports in a similar fashion ?

Sample:

"Microsoft Vista OS review by gsaravin"
"This operating system is Krap"
"End"

Ya know, I would expect this kind of stuff to come from a 12 year old forum troll, not someone who has aledgedly spent 29 years in the industry... I would suggest you review you debating techniques...

by gsaravin9

You people are attacking me instead of going out for yourselves & seeing first hand of what is really happening.Coupled with this you treat it as i have spoken too soon & i know i havent as i have contacts within microsoft.I know what a beta release is.I can also tellyou what vista is really tryng to bring is mostly cosmetic that won't show much benefit.I don't know how you can dissagree with me when you can see a lot of people have allready agreed on some of the problems.Also we are heading into a new grey area
64 bit architecture all i'm saying is that it is happening toofast without due regard for proper hardware or software to handle it.Not only this
people have said that the future will be with 128
bit.256 bit,512 bit up to 712 bit operating systems.I would like to see what operating system they have planned???.All i'm saying is i have examined the details & vista does not answer the needs of the 64 bit architecture as i have tested it thouroughly.
expect performance in the 32 bit area.

you can agree to disagree you are entitled to your opinion.My recommendation is i know i'm right!

by joe

Having been around as long as you claim, is this your first experience with a beta rollout? You make comments as though you think a product in this stage of development should be bug free. Vista, like it predecessors is built to utilize the hardware of tomorrow. When Windows 2000 was first announced its hardware requirements were well beyond the current norm. Most systems had 64-128 mb of ram when Windows 2000 was in development and there were people then making the same statements as you have made. (?vista requires basic i gig of ram,100 gig hard drive,dual processor core at least 3 gig processor.compatibility is a big issue?). Do you really believe that the way ram in personal computers has exploded that we won?t see 2gb as the standard in the next 12-8 months? Dual Core processors are becoming the norm. As always in the past software developments have pushed new hardware to be accepted. I can not tell you the number of times I have had to replace most of the hardware in a clients network in order to implement a new Operating system. This is normal in the IT world.

With IT experience should come some wisdom about these things. When NT5 was in development (later renamed Windows 2000) there were many more issues with its beta than I have seen in Vista. We had serious site replication issues as well as kernel issues and many other problems which meant Microsoft had to keep moving back the rollout date. However bad the problems were and no matter how many experts like yourself said Windows 2000 would not see the light of day , it did and it has become the standard.

In your original statement ?vista is a crap system? I would disagree that it is crap. I would say that it is not ready for production and that Microsoft has a way to go before this is ready for production. Microsoft is already talking about moving release dates back. A trait that has happened to every OS they have developed.

My basic complaint with your thread is that I am not sure what you were expecting. When I saw that you have 29 years experience then I really got confused about what a veteran of 29 years and what must be numerous OS changes in those years was thinking whey you wrote your comments.

by jcdyson

Clearly you have missed the point of why my esteemed colleagues and I are saying. It was not my intention to incite terse comments I was merely stating that the comments you put up were subjective, appeared ill-informed and your argument is not backed up with factual evidence. As for your comment "I was frank & to the point simply without fear..." The only frank statement you have made is "Its Crap!!" You state that you have been in the industry for 29 years and as such I would expect a backed up factual argument showing, 1.that you have objectively reviewed the beta and 2.the reasons you feel, as you not so eloquently put it, "It's crap".
With regard to your statement "...there are severe performance restrictions in the 64 bit architecture." Um cutting edge technology!!! Currently I don't know of many businesses except those in video or 3D rendering that need to use the power of 64Bit. Until it [64bit] becomes main stream we will have teething problems and therefore it will take time for applications to truly utilise 64bit as opposed to the current 32bit architecture we are used to. I don't expect that we will see great improvements in 64 bit in beta releases of Vista and envisage that the first production release will be similar in that respect. Remember the first production release of 2k you had to go out and obtain drivers before you installed it however once the first update was released everything ran a lot smoother. The reason 2K was problematic was that it pushed the boundaries of technology in similar ways to what the 64 bit Vista release is going to do.
Therefore by making unsubstantiated ill-informed comments you do nothing to sway people in favour of your argument it in-fact detracts from it; Thus I stand by my original statement that you sound more like a newbie straight out of academia than an alleged experienced veteran with stated 29 years experience. Furthermore, it seems that you have never been involved in any sort beta release program and would not have a clue in how to submit an objective well informed argument. It you were my software tester and you submitted something like the comments you started this post with I would have you thrown off the project quicker than you could type your own name.

by gsaravin9

You people are attacking me instead of going out for yourselves & seeing first hand of what is really happening.Coupled with this you treat it as i have spoken too soon & i know i havent as i have contacts within microsoft.I know what a beta release is.I can also tellyou what vista is really tryng to bring is mostly cosmetic that won't show much benefit.I don't know how you can dissagree with me when you can see a lot of people have allready agreed on some of the problems.Also we are heading into a new grey area
64 bit architecture all i'm saying is that it is happening toofast without due regard for proper hardware or software to handle it.Not only this
people have said that the future will be with 128
bit.256 bit,512 bit up to 712 bit operating systems.I would like to see what operating system they have planned???.All i'm saying is i have examined the details & vista does not answer the needs of the 64 bit architecture as i have tested it thouroughly.
expect performance in the 32 bit area.

you can agree to disagree you are entitled to your opinion.My recommendation is i know i'm right!

by mypl8s4u2

Please note that the ramblings are to be regarded as an ?opinion?.

Loaded Vista build 5291
Installation: The installation is the standard 2GB+ DVD variety and takes a long time. The good thing about the installation is that now you have two progress bars. The first one is labeled to the effect that user input will be required till this bar has fully progressed. The second bar then resumes the process, and this is where Vista?s setup will tell you that your input is no longer required. All you have to do now is wait until the installation process is completed, and delve right into it. According to our test results, it took approximately an hour before 5270 was fully installed.
We were quite surprised by the amount of disk space the installer required. It needs a minimum of 8GB+ of free disk space, which goes on to show Microsoft's capitalization of cheap storage. Personally, we think that 8GB for a mere OS is a bit too much to ask, but considering Vista is still in Beta, maybe the required disk space will trickle down in the final version. It might even go up, so if you have a 40GB hard disk, be prepared to spare 20 percent of it just for the OS.
The upgrade option is currently available only if you have Windows XP with SP2 (a service release we personally detest so we did a fresh install), or if you have a previous build of Windows Vista installed. We didn?t have that either. When making a fresh install, it will not format the drive but will simply move all current Windows files to a folder labeled windows.old (quite possibly, it simply renames the Windows folder to that). The downside to this is that during the boot-up process, you will see both options for the OS, and thus you won't be getting a clean and thorough install, which is a pity to say the least. You can, however, change this by editing the Advanced System Properties, but unlike in Windows XP, where you can create modifications and change the OS name altogether, here you can simply choose the default OS from a drop down menu.
An interesting quirk that we came across was that at the login screen, the display didn?t cover the entire screen (we used a 15.4" widescreen display), but just a small portion of it. This happens only at the login screen, but once inside, there are no issues whatsoever. Apparently Vista is having some issues with widescreen displays, but it's nothing serious.
Also, the system did not automatically take the native screen resolution of 1280x800 but was stuck at 1024x768. We had to manually correct it. Normally in XP, the screen resolution gets set automatically (for LCDs). Perhaps this is another pre-Beta 2 quirk.

by hal 9000

Release of Vista will take up less Disc space if you look at the actual install it copies all the install files to the HDD and then proceeds to install from there. Once the Install files are copied across the DVD isn't accessed again during the install.

I did a clean install on a [b]Blank HDD[/b] and had no problems in formatting the drive actually I formatted it into 2 partitions each about the same size on a 200 GIG SATA Drive. The Upgrade option is at best a Nightmare to work with but what I found the most interesting was the inability to install quite a lot of software.

Even some new MS Software wouldn't install admittedly it was a game but the latest Age of Empires wouldn't load while some old 98 game installed without a problem though the graphics where lousy.

Personally I'm waiting for an AV product that will install before I begin serious testing. I've singed up for the Trend Micro Beta Testing Program and until that becomes available latter this month I'm only having a play at the moment.

Col

by gsaravin9

The problems you have come accross is the the tip of the proverbial iceberg.When we later find out that either our hardware or software will not work either in the realm of 64 bit or 32 bit as drivers for vista are incompatible.So in essence people will be forced to buy new systems & new hardware.Don't think that i'm anti microsoft & or anty vista far from it.We just are going to be at the mercy at whatever comes our way.Like many we'l be the ones suffering!
As i said i have done some core testing & i have found big compatibility problems & i know beta is beta but will they fix it in time for release.

by ju1ce

But again, it's a beta. The graphics were nice, but I couldn't get passed picking my drive. It would not detect it and it is a known issue that SATA v2.0 support lacks severly.

by jmgarvin

1) Download and burn. Normally, not a big deal, but it took forever to download and MS shutdown the bittorrent sites. Burning it wasn't that big a deal, but it does take a DVD.

2) Installation. Wow, what a friggin' nightmare. First my key (that MS gave me no less) was invalid. Ok, great...whatever. I'll just upgrade. WRONG. The upgrade explained that my copy of XP was not upgradable.

So, after getting my key issue sorted out, I had to wait about 1 hour for it to install. I can do a full 7 gig Fedora Core 5 install on the same machine in about 45 minutes. What's the deal with Vista?

3) First boot was smooth until it hardlocks in the boot screen. A reboot later and it's just fine.

4) Logging in and farting around is pretty uneventful. I have to say that the GUI is a great way to waste screen real estate. I don't like the buttons. I don't like how they made the Sleep button the "shutdown" button. I don't like how changing users is relegated to >>.

5) UAC is a farggin' nightmare. Users will NOT put up with this. Most of the time a user won't understand why they have to accept or decline and they'll just accept. So UAC has done nothing. How about actually FIXING your architecture MS.

6) Speed and reliablity. Blech. It's pretty top heavy and it locked and killed stuff (or wouldn't run it at all) regularly. I felt like I was using Win95 when it first came out.

My take is that Beta 2 is pretty much what the consumer will see. I see UAC as a way to hold vendors hostage. I don't see any complelling reason to move from XP to Vista.

So what's the deal MS? Is this why everyone is jumping ship?

by moira

Can I just ask which build is being discussed here? At the moment I have 5384 installed and working but have 5456 ready to install.

Anyone know if I can do a simple upgrade? Is the newer version significantly better?

by mustangj369

and tailor it to their hardware with proper drivers, it should be quite stable. Upgrading will be another matter as you're on your own as far as getting the right drivers and configuring the os to your setup goes. The older the hardware, the more difficult this will be.
You said your copy of XP was not upgradeable. Is it an OEM version that you have?
Commodity box builders like HP don't recommend upgrading the os's on their machines and may not make drivers available for and will not support such an upgrade. You'll have to hope the ones built into Vista will work, especially if you have to do a clean install to load Vista in the first place.

by gsaravin9

When we later find out that either our hardware or software will not work either in the realm of 64 bit or 32 bit as drivers for vista are incompatible.So in essence people will be forced to buy new systems & new hardware.Don't think that i'm anti microsoft & or anty vista far from it.We just are going to be at the mercy at whatever comes our way.Like many we'l be the ones suffering!
As i said i have done some core testing & i have found big compatibility problems & i know beta is beta but will they fix it in time for release.

by gsaravin9

When we later find out that either our hardware or software will not work either in the realm of 64 bit or 32 bit as drivers for vista are incompatible.So in essence people will be forced to buy new systems & new hardware.Don't think that i'm anti microsoft & or anty vista far from it.We just are going to be at the mercy at whatever comes our way.Like many we'll be the ones suffering!
As i said i have done some core testing & i have found big compatibility problems & i know beta is beta but will they fix it in time for release.
i have gone beyond & tested the core functionality in comparison to XP it is mere cosmetic changes but in trying to function in the 64 bit architecture i have found huge poroblems.I for one would not want to be critical as if it was as easy to install as is to function.

by gsaravin9

When we later find out that either our hardware or software will not work either in the realm of 64 bit or 32 bit as drivers for vista are incompatible.So in essence people will be forced to buy new systems & new hardware.Don't think that i'm anti microsoft & or anty vista far from it.We just are going to be at the mercy at whatever comes our way.Like many we'l be the ones suffering!
As i said i have done some core testing & i have found big compatibility problems & i know beta is beta but will they fix it in time for release.

by gsaravin9

When we later find out that either our hardware or software will not work either in the realm of 64 bit or 32 bit as drivers for vista are incompatible.So in essence people will be forced to buy new systems & new hardware.Don't think that i'm anti microsoft & or anty vista far from it.We just are going to be at the mercy at whatever comes our way.Like many we'l be the ones suffering!
As i said i have done some core testing & i have found big compatibility problems & i know beta is beta but will they fix it in time for release.

by jcdyson

Win2K pushed the envelope on hardware and the first release of it saw that you had to get the drivers for you system before you installed the system subsequent releases you did not have to so obviously software drives hardware developement and vice versa. Again you are speaking as though you are new to the whole Industry.

by gsaravin9

weare moving from a 32 bit to 64 bit architecture
there ara major complications as to availability of drivers & more to the point 64 bit software.this is a major hurdle.If it were as simle as installing vista then thats ok.there are huge problems to overcome.

by gsaravin9

you show no respect at all ,think of all thepostings on these threads you'll see funny that,they all agree with me & you have taken to agree but you have decided to knock me personally i have more experience than you & i have personal
contacts with developers at Microsoft,i know what im takinga aboutyou dont.i suggest that you don't stay here & go somewhere else as i started this thread & it doesn't matter as we don't need people like you!.

by steve.marshall

... unfortunately for you, it is I that is at the advantage as I have not declared my experience (40 times might I add) in broken english and poor grammar.

You are the person declaring you have 29 years experience but everything you have posted thus far points at the diometric opposite.

I show no respect simply because you don't deserve any, respect is earnt, It would appear you haven't earnt your salary for the last 29 years (If your demonstration of testing OS's in this forum is consistent with your work methodology).

Nobody is disputing that Vista has issues, people are suggesting that your original post and subsequent garbage posts are completely unwarranted, inacurate and bland.

Just because you started a thread doesnt give you sole ownership of it, anyway, starting this thread is little to be proud of. All you have achieved is making everyone painfully aware that your posts are a complete waste of time and only really open for people to rip apart in a moment of distraction during their real jobs.

I would reasses who you regard as "We" too... I have not witnessed anywhere on this thread anyone suggesting that you are right on the money, that Vista is a complete load of garbage and will never hit production... please correct me if i'm wrong... I will "sit" corrected if so.

by gsaravin9

I finally got my hands on a copy of Windows Vista Beta 2 and wouldn't you know it, the motherboard in my test system bit the dust. My goal in testing Vista was to use the same system throughout the entire beta program in order to see how my hardware would fare with each successive release of Windows Vista. So I ordered a new, comparable motherboard that carried the same onboard ATI RadeonXpress 200 graphics system with 128 MB of shared memory and accepted my AMD Athlon 64 3400+ CPU. However, I did decide to add another 512MB chip to bump my RAM up to 1GB.

More Adventures in Beta Testing Vista

by gsaravin9

GET GET OUT OF MY POSTING!!!OUT OF MY POSTING!!!GET OUT OF MY POSTING!!!
GET OUT OF MY POSTING!!!
GET OUT OF MY POSTING!!!
i HOPE YOU GOT THAT! YOU INSULTIN PIECE OF SH..T

by daveo2000

It isn't [b]your[/b] thread. It is [b]a[/b] thread on a publicly available forum which you have chosen to contribute precious little in content and far too much in repititious rambling.

Just for fun, check out the posts by HAL9000. He has even responded to one of your posts with thoughtful commentary. He has a history of thoughtful commentary. I have never seen him post the same text twice. You could learn something from him if you tried.

He also knows how to turn off the Caps Lock key. It is a toggle that reverses the function of the Shift key. You can tell when it is on because your text comes out like the posting just prior to this one when you said "i HOPE YOU GOT THAT!". Did you get that? It isn't a Vista function so please don't blame that on MS.

By the way, nobody is in your posting. A posting is what you do when you hit "Submit My Comments". Sometimes there are other postings between your postings. That happens when somebody thinks you have said something worth replying to or when you actually wait more than a minute between submitting one post and submitting another with a different subject line but the same old message.

As a last thought, go out and have a non-caffeinated drink and a nice healthy meal... nothing with to much sugar in it. Get some sun, take a walk and find a nice young psychology student to talk to. Preferably somebody studying anger management and interpersonal communication. You have clearly got some issues to work through.

I am looking forward to see how you flame me.

by mustangj369

Actually, I'm amazed it's gone on this long. You've made your position crystal clear, ad nauseum, ad infinitum, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera.
Time to give it a rest and find something else to b*tch about. OK?

by gsaravin9

I thinkwe have createda monster i hope it goes to more than 400 responses which would be a record.I would probably make it to the tech republic top 100 list.
It's been good to get in on the discussion as long as we don't take it seriously,we can all have our say.I'm pretty sure we can bitch about a lot of things.But vista has got on everyone's goat!.i know people like to typify it to other releases & betas but this is a whole new ballgame.
might i say please go ahead & contribute as much as you want youve got nothing to loose but get it off your chest! all the best

by jcdyson

I am not normally one for burning people publicly but I quite frankly can't stand this any further. Yes you might make the TR top 100 list but it will be for making the most stupid, ill-informed, unsubstantiated, non-factual comments of all time. I get the feeling we are in a high school chat room and there is one of us not realising that they have made some of the most impetulant remarks known to man. I again restate my previous opinion by saying you have missed the point that just about every person(not your own) on this thread has made and are not willing to see the wood for the trees. If you?re about creating records and making top 100 lists then I would suggest you?re in the wrong industry and definitely on the wrong forum. I would suggest you go back to your secondary school chat room and argue your little heart out because it is obvious that you are failing to see what my colleagues and I are saying. I further suggest you stop trying to play with the big boys until you learn to debate issues objectively. Your 15 mins of Fame (infamy) is up.

Before you spit your dummy and say get off my thread, you troll, you ONLY STARTED it. Nothing says that you own a thread because you started it. The only thing you own is the opinion you have so poorly expressed.

To my Esteemed Colleagues I feel it is time that we let this thread die a very timely death as it is clearly about inciting an argument for arguments sake. I say let him pull up stumps take his bat and ball and go home as it is clear he has no idea of playing with the bigger kids.

by steve.marshall

Although it's been slightly amusing reading the completely misinformed, misdirected and child impressionism so wonderfully performed by our ignorant and socially inept gsaravin, I don't wish to contribute any further to what is a total waste of my time. (none of the previous should be regarded as unsubstantiated insults, but observations based on the demonstrated ineptitude of the aforementioned)

One of your key points (I use the term "points" loosely) is that the inherent drivers in Vista do not work. As someone who has 29 years (That is Earth years and not dog years right ???) you will know that MS issue advice to the hardware vendors and distribute the software maps for them to build drivers for the OS, the hardware vendors then issue their product listing on what they view as viable or potential projects in their line (There is a transparent but tight relationship between the key vendors that you are obviously unaware of, seems a little strange considering its aledgedly your JOB to know this). MS will produce basic compatability for current hardware whilst building the OS in beta purely as a cursory excericise, we are not testing hardware compatiability during Beta, we are testing funtionaility and content, nothing more.

So, if you wish to find fault in Vista for not being able to support your ageing hardare blame the hardware manufacturer you nublet, not MS, sheesh, get a clue !

As for you knowing more than me, you know NOTHING about me, I have not bragged about my career, but as you mention it, I would be the person that employs the person that employs the fecking idiot that employs you... I'll say no more than that.

This is no debate, it can only be seen as a PR excercise briefing the general TR board reading public that should you ever come across someone that potentially could be gsaravin IRL you should instantly turn around and walk the other direction, if for no other reason than to prevent yourself doing hard time for "justified" manslaughter (Although any judge with an amoeba sized common sence will be very very lenient).

May this thread rest in pieces...

by gsaravin9

Go someplace else as you have not really contributed much.If you have than please tell me what is regarding vista!!!
Because you have nothing to contribute why waste time & space.If you have anything tangible lets have it otherwise you have nothing to say as you don't know>i've been in it for nearly 30 years & i know more than you!

by ivefallen

the problem with everything you say is the way you present it. You don't sound (or act) very professional and that is your biggest problem. It's people like yourself that are the bane of IT's existence. It's not too late, you know.

by jcdyson

For the sake of the Gods mate!!! You have just proved that you are a dead set doof when it comes to beta testing esp since your comments were based solely on beta 1. In your posts you claim to have tested them all, yet you come out after in excess of 100 posts and say Oh "I finally got my hands on a copy of Windows Vista Beta 2" I fail to see any reason for me to even remotely consider anything you have said in the past or in the future as anything better than utter Garbage. Your whole credibility (if you had any from the start) is now shot down the proverbial and as for your comments of 29 years exp don't make me laugh. It is my belief that you have only been in the industry since morning tea (another words 3/5ths of stuff all) and should get some time up before you go shooting your mouth off again!!!

by gsaravin9

I'd like to see when you have started a thread,you think you know everything & you don't.You are just plain jealous of me that i've had so many responses.If you go i for one i'm not going to miss you or your rantings.By criticising me you feel that you have something over me that you are more gifted or more intelligent
or you think yo know more.You know nothing,you have not proved anything.If you think i'm stupid why stay & rant & rave how much you know.I don't feel that i need to speak with you just go someplace else!!!

by gsaravin9

you have not offered anything tangible on this thread apart from ridiculing me ,you are not a friend of mine nor do i want to be friendly with you so why don't you leave & go someplace else on another thread.You have proved that you know nothing
about computers or systems you are an abject failure as far as i can see good ridance!!!

by gsaravin9

You have nothing to contribute that's tangible in regards to vista you keep straying off the topic.
you are merely conjecturing here maybe this maybe that with no real evidence or proof of what you are saying.your on the same boat as everyone else.All i'm saying that vista is not all what is cracked up
to be & i don't think it is going to make it in the 64 bit arena.in a nutshell thats what i'm saying & that's what i'm sticking to.Whether it is popular or not.

by gsaravin9

You have nothing to contribute that's tangible in regards to vista you keep straying off the topic.
you are merely conjecturing here maybe this maybe that with no real evidence or proof of what you are saying.your on the same boat as everyone else.All i'm saying that vista is not all what is cracked up
to be & i don't think it is going to make it in the 64 bit arena.in a nutshell thats what i'm saying & that's what i'm sticking to.Whether it is popular or not.

by ivefallen

Quotes

"GET OUT OF MY POSTING!!!"

"You are a stooge for microsoft!"

"No one has asked you to stay on this thread!"

This is straight from the horses keyboard, you being the horse. As I stated earlier, it's not about what you say it's how you say it. If you ever expect to be taken seriously, you may want to brush up on your grammer and your attitude. Right now, you seem less like an IT professional and more like an arrogant fool. A thought for you to ponder:

"There is no sin greater than ignorance"

Rudyard Kipling

by gsaravin9

you have the right to be heard i didn't attack you guys personally remember you guys started to get derogatorynot me you tried to ridicule me as if i dont't know what i'm talking.

by gsaravin9

WE know that this is beta but you have not really acknowledged that there are major faults or problems
with vista beta.you say you have minor reservations but i have major reservations that i think that it's not going to make it in the 64 bit architecture!That's what i mean by vista i'ts crap.I base this on my own testing & research!.

by gsaravin9

we have a bunch people who are sitting on the fence with unconvinced opinions when some of us know allready that we are going to get gloom from doom.
amen to that!

by gsaravin9

so are your comments as you simply say that's beta ho hum whereas i test systems & hardware & write reports evaluating the operating systems.You on the other hand do nothing & critcise other people who do.You don't have much to contribute where as i have
to the point that i'll repeat it that vista cannot adequtely cope in the 64 bit architecture thats why i've said it's crap & i have tangible evidence through my thorough testing procedures.
there are other major problems such as overheating
of chips & video cards in that more is required of them as they are pushed beyond their limits.In essence pushing limits beyond normal 32 bit seems to be in no no land.I have come accross other problems that is that where dynamic links fail to work all together & software that is 32 bit will refuse to function.Ive tried testing with 64 bit software & experienced crashes & instability.

by gsaravin9

s it someone who trusts you to do your job? Someone who can show you the ropes? Someone who will go to bat for you even when it means taking a certain amount of heat? Find out what TR members have to say about this issue.

by gsaravin9

i don't think it is the same as there huge hurdles
to overcome whilst some peoplae say vista will perform ok others are saying its not.

by hal 9000

With the 32 Bit Version and the 64 Bit version is about as useful as the 64 Bit version of XP nice to look at and a great idea in principal but not much to call home about when it's all said and done.

This isn't so much because the 64 Bit version is utter crap but because there is still to little 64 bit software available. AMD has had 64 bit CPU's for at least 3 years now maybe longer and we've yet to see and real development in the 64 bit programs.

My main beef with MS however is the fact that they are going to insist on Digitally Signing all products to work on Vista which will mean that there is no cross platform development as part of MS Agreement to get Digitally Signed is not to develop drivers or software for other OS other then Windows.

I see this type of action as at the very least Illegal but as is typical of MS they will bring on the technology and worry about the Law suits and Court Rulings latter long after any competition has disappeared. This I do not like about MS and the way that they do business. I don't like the way that MS ring their partners and attempt to get you to sell pirate software either, it sucks of entrapment particularly when I know that I've had no complaints against me for anything MS related.

I do the right thing by MS and I don't expect to be treated like a criminal by them for doing as they say but I'll live with the fact that I know that I've done the right thing and I have a very big stick in the form of [b]Free Legal Protection[/b] to fight any court battles though I would prefer to stay away from those places.
Currently about the only thing that MS can complain about is the fact that I've installed the same Beta copy of Vista onto several different computers but as there isn't anything preventing me from doing this they really don't have anything to complain about particularly as I'm constantly feeding them problems as they occur.

Is 64 Bit the way to go Yes but if MS is the way to go 64 Bit is a different question. I've got several different Linux's that will all run quite happily on a 64 Bit CPU along with 64 Bit software none of which is currently available for any Windows OS.

Maybe here Linux has the jump on MS [b]Again[/b] and will finally leave MS behind in the dust where it quite rightfully belongs. While MS has bags of money to throw at advertising they don't have deep enough pockets to develop all the 64 Bit software that will be required by business and they certainly can not compete on the Games Market across the entire range. MS has to stick to it's small corner in the games market and just hope for the best.

Col

by gsaravin9

i don't think expreassing an opinion about a product
is really knocking MS.I for one would like to see them be successful.Bu after evaluating all the betas i'm convinced that it wont't make it in the 64 bit area due to major technical reasons.

by gsaravin9

vista beta whil'st it's beta leaves a lot to be desired but in the actual testing it leaves a lot to be desired.with hardware functioning & software.there are problems

by florida_rob

I have tested the last 2 builds at our firm and found that it runs better, smoother, and faster than XP. I admit it doesn't like some 6 year old PCs, but then again neither do I. What products have you tested it against?

Also what universe do you live in when you say users are going to give up on Microsoft's OS? Maybe the few IT-savvy geeks (like me) will move towards Linux or alternatives but the average Joe User is still running ME or XP and is very satisfied.

If you don't like MSFT, that's fine. You're entitled to your opinions- but before you predict the demise of a market-dominant product in the real world you need to offer a viable alternative-- which currently doesn't exist. Yes, I know Macs are better... Yes, I know Linux is more stable.. but until Macs break through the $600 price point they won't take on any major market share, and until Linux looks and operates like Windows with full compatibility it won't either. Criticize all you want, but the market has spoken and it likes Windows- and spare me the conspiracy theories. I have 2 words for you: Xerox and Polaroid. If the market didn't like it, it wouldn't be there. Fast food burgers are horrible for you and there ARE alternatives available, yet people still buy them by the millions-- so they must be offering value to the public, much like Microsoft is doing. When the cost outweighs the benefits, and that day will likely come as it did for US Automakers, electronics manufacturers, etc. but it's not here yet.

Again, you are entitled to your opinions.. but they would hold much more water if backed up with facts. What products aren't compatible? What drivers aren't available (and that is more vendor's faults than MSFT's- it is THEY who create device drivers for their products)?

It requires more memory? So what? Are you still planning on running a box with less than 1GB? My daughter's PC has that much and all she does is surf the internet and type reports for school (on OpenOffice, I might add).

I understand the animosity that exists in the world towards Microsoft- and some of it may be justified- but any well-written critique should include specific facts to support your thesis.

by gsaravin9

whils't a lot of people have minor reservations i have major ones.I don't think the current hardware is capable of handling the full capabilities as people will make do with what they got.If you must know i don't prefer windows based systems.i prefer a linux but i woul like unix the most as it is the stablest of all.
i'm not anti this or anti that i'm trying to stimulate a bit of discussion.There is no wrong or right answer it all depends on the circumstances.
i have tested every beta i know it will take time
i hope they fix things on time rather than wait later.all the best

by florida_rob

I have tested the last 2 builds at our firm and found that it runs better, smoother, and faster than XP. I admit it doesn't like some 6 year old PCs, but then again neither do I. What products have you tested it against?

Also what basis do you have for stating that users are going to give up on Microsoft's OS? Maybe the few IT-savvy geeks (like me) will move towards Linux or alternatives but the average Joe User is still running ME or XP and is very satisfied. There may be no real reason for Joe User to run to the store and buy this OS on the midnight of its release, but corporate users are already gearing up for it, and features such as Sidebar, SideShow, UAT, Defender, and Aero Glass themes may offer users benefits once they start seeing them. No basis for that statement other than the users I deal with read the Tech section of the WSJ and like to jump on new features that will make them more efficient and secure.

If you don't like MSFT, that's fine. You're entitled to your opinions- but before you predict the demise of a market-dominant product in the real world you need to offer a viable alternative-- which currently doesn't exist. Yes, I know Macs are better... Yes, I know Linux is more stable.. but until Macs break through the $600 price point they won't take on any major market share, and until Linux looks and operates like Windows with full compatibility it won't either. Criticize all you want, but the market has spoken and it likes Windows- and spare me the conspiracy theories. I have 2 words for you: Xerox and Polaroid. If the market didn't like it, it wouldn't be there. Fast food burgers are horrible for you and there ARE alternatives available, yet people still buy them by the millions-- so they must be offering value to the public, much like Microsoft is doing. When the cost outweighs the benefits, and that day will likely come as it did for US Automakers, electronics manufacturers, etc. but it's not here yet.

Again, you are entitled to your opinions.. but they would hold much more water if backed up with facts. What products aren't compatible? What drivers aren't available (and that is more vendor's faults than MSFT's- it is THEY who create device drivers for their products)? What hardware/PCs did you test it on? I've run it on HP NC6000 (1.6 GHz Pentium M), 6230 (2.0 Pent. M), DeskPro (800 MHz P4), Motion Computing M1200 (P3 Mobile 933 MHz), Evo d530 (2.6 GHz P4), HP dc7600 (3.4 GHz P4), xw4300 (dual P4 3.4 GHz), ThinkPad T42 (PM 2.0), and a home-built box (AMD Duron 1.6 GHz). Memory ranged from 512 MB to 2 GB on most machines except the portables, which had 512 MB. HDD ranged from 20 GB (DeskPro) to 120 GB dual RAID on the xw. I had driver issues on the Motion, but it's an older PC and I didn't expect Gateway to have drivers available for the Beta. Ditto the direct-to-disc burn feature on the nc6230. Totally within the expectations for a beta release test.

It requires more memory? So what? Are you still planning on running a box with less than 1GB? My daughter's PC has that much and all she does is surf the internet and type reports for school (on OpenOffice, I might add). Now that memory is relatively cheap, please justify me why this matters.

Is the source code bad? What parts are faulty? In what way? I don't claim to have looked at the source, but what constitutes bad? One programmer's schlock is genius to another.

Is multitasking slow? For what applications? I've run Office 2007, 2003, various Sungard financial apps, home-grown stuff, and a photo editor. Done them all while running Sidebar with RSS feeds and had no performance issues. Is the slowness the fault of the application, the network, the user, the hardware, or the OS?

I understand the animosity that exists in the world towards Microsoft- and some of it may be justified- but any well-written critique should include specific facts to support your thesis.

by researcher75

Interesting that you should comment about "6 year old machines" - this must of course refer to factory build like Dell etc; - I think what most of this discussion refers to is self-built and it is quite possible that factory builds will have had additions that would have entailed upgraded hard drives which would have possibly meant obtaining OEM OS and the like, so making the original machines self build. Then there would be the other additions that would mean different drivers, all this adds up to that maybe installing Vista on a clean drive is the best way forward, and I MEAN CLEAN!
That is what I intend to do when I eventually get the disk that I paid for two weeks ago - try the beast to upgrade an XP installation on my new self-built machine first and then if it is not succesfull, clean the drive and start from scratch????!!!

by gsaravin9

you know factory built ones are much sturdier than the ones that have been assembled in a shop.
good luck with the clean install.i hope you have all the drivers!

by gsaravin9

i have support from other people in this thread to confirm what i said was right you wrong.I win this time.take back your silly & stupid remarks.

by htos1

I was thinking of forgoing vista and using XP64 in my new box that's coming online soon.I don't need bubblegum and balloons to do audio,video and file archiving.Now,don't get me wrong,I don't flame windows and Microsoft particularly,but XP64 will be all I need for a few more years.I guess I'll live if I can't install IE8 on XP64.

by gsaravin9

precisely what i have been saying that people such as yourselves are not ready to ditch your old systems just yet.You probably spent thousands of dollars & now you don't want to upgrade for upgrade sake.you are happy as you are.
well done & good luck to you i'm in full agreement

by domingo a. trassens

Microsoft is not the ?God? of the software. It frequently makes a lot of mistakes that the users help to fix. This is true! The Windows? father never creates the ?perfection? as a divine creature but there are a long distance between the ?perfection? and a ?crap?. Could you write something better than Vista and run with your ?creature? the millions of different PCs hungry for new software through the globe?

by gsaravin9

you know we as consumers pay a lot of money be it to microsoft or whatever & often our hopes are dashed as the sum total of the pc hardware +software often fails & we have to send a message
to developers of software or hardware that we are not happy!
good on you Domingo all the best ,muchos gracias!

by hal 9000

MS is in the business of writing Software & OS's and as of the 22 May 06 they had devoted 1,000,000 man hours to the development of Vista and that's only the 32 Bit Version. Those figures come directly from MS at the MS Road Show that I attended on 22 May 2006 in Brisbane AU so either the Marketing Department of MS is less than truthful or that have spent that much time in attempting to develop this new OS.

Now MS has a group of people who specialise in writing OS's and have performed this operation several times previously. The fact that they have spent so much time in developing the current Beta 2 Version of Vista and I'm only referring tho the 32 Bit Version here not all 14 different versions that will eventually hit the market just one which is the platform from which all the rest will spring eventually. As of the 22 May 06 they had invested 1,000,000 Man Hours of Development and at that late stage where still finding 5,000 problems per day. Now I'm not saying that I could write something that would make Windows redundant tomorrow but to me it seems that MS has spent a Hell of a Lot of Time and Effort to make a MESS!

From my very limited play with the different versions of Vista currently available I can say it has excellent [b]Eye Candy[/b] but once you start to dig under the hood that all pails to insignificance as the OS itself leaves so much to be desired. First it copies itself to the HDD and then installs itself so the first 3 odd GIG of HDD Space is taken up by the install files. Now I can understand why this is done this way because it is so large that if they relied on the DVD to read the files from and then extract we wouldn't be sitting around for an hour or there abouts it would be several hours waiting just to install the OS. Currently I run Virtual CD on my XP HDD's and I do this because it allows me faster access to the data contained on those much used drives up to 100 times faster so I'm supposing that the same applies here to Vista by coping all the install files to the HDD it speeds up the install dramatically and I very much doubt that there will be many Home users willing to sit around for several hours waiting for Vista to install on a Pentium Extreme with 4 GIG of RAM on a 200 GIG SATA HDD and with a 256 MEG Video Card.

On the machine that I've installed Vista it's one of the faster ones and it still takes around 1 hour to fully install I don't dare think how long that install would be if it was read all off the DVD that just doesn't bear to think about. A SATA drive is at least 10 times faster than a IDE DVD Drive so you do the maths and work out just how long it would take to install Vista from a DVD ROM. And remember it's only an OS with a few items built in it isn't a complete Software Package. Even the SUSE 10 which comes on DVD doesn't take that long to install on the same hardware and it's a complete software package which Vista certainly isn't.

So instead of asking someone can they write something better as an excuse to accept the junk that MS is currently dishing out look at the actual thing and see what you think of it. I know if I was allowed half the resources that have been devoted to Vista so far I could come up with something better. Would it sell though Probably Not mainly because I wouldn't have the advertising Budget that MS has to flog rubbish to the masses.

Many years ago if in doubt buy IBM as no one ever got fired for buying IBM well today the same applies to MS if in doubt by MS as you'll not run the risk of loosing your job by buying a MS product though you'll most likely drive the Technicians who have to support it to [b]Mental Breakdowns[/b] but at least you'll keep your job even if it drives so many completely over the edge. All you have to hope is that when the techs finally [b]Crack[/b] they don't decide to take it out on the person who has exposed them to such rubbish if that was to happen they you really would have a [b]Big Problem![/b]

Personally I'm planing on a [b]Very Long Hospital Stay[/b] when Vista gets released and starts to be taken up by the business community suffering from the newly discovered disease [b]Information Overload[/b] and when I get out and come back to work supporting business again you lot will have all the bugs worked out so I'll not have to do it all myself [b]AGAIN![/b]

There is no doubt that the current Beta release of Vista will improve before the product release but will it improve enough to make it usable by the masses?

Col

by gsaravin9

I have noticed that it's that dreaded cycle repeated again ,with vista being the worst.No one has the answers to all the questions,we have to wait & see.I reckon taking a holiday while it happens might help.I think that microsoft have developed vista with too many things that can go wrong.I for one wan't a system with less spills & frills,a compact & lean system so that less chances things can go wrong.I think that they need to rethink what is it that consumers want less complex & more stable systems.
I still have major reservations is it is a huge mess waiting to be unleashed on the poor consumer.

by gsaravin9

I don't know if anyone's mentioned it but when i was testing vista beta.The lack of drivers & the availability of drivers at the present time.I tried using 32 bit ones & some did not work in the 64 bit area.you'll find that some equipment is not detected at all & may be fiddly to install.

by hal 9000

Waste much time with the 64 Bit version of Vista. Currently XP 64 Bit lacks the necessary drivers, most of the current generation of Hardware Sold lacks the necessary 64 Bit drivers.

Right at this point in time while 64 Bit will eventually be the way to go we are not there yet with so very little of the available hardware & Software Combinations supporting 64 Bit computing.

Personally I was happy if the 64 Bit build of Vista picked up the most commonly used parts of the computer that I installed it on so it worked with the M'Board, CPU, RAM, Sound Card & Video Card the items not picked up where not worth attempting to install drivers for as even if you could get the currently available 32 Bit drivers to install the software to drive the hardware will not install and work correctly.

64 Bit is for latter on when the general Industry starts to embrace 64 Bit computing with Open Arms. Even the current 64 Bit Linux versions which are complete packages are not heavily used and while the hardware may be available it is not being fully utilised at this point in time. Even sales of the 64 Bit version of XP aren't great so while currently it's a novelty it isn't anything earth shattering right at the moment. Even MS lacks 64 Bit Applications and once you over look Sharepoint there are no 64 Bit MS Applications currently available.

The 64 Bit argument is for latter not now as there is currently so little available to consider using it on.

Col

by gsaravin9

It's a more of wait & see I don't think it'll be all ready.I'm like you i'll stay with xp.

by hal 9000

On their T 4X series of NB computers. It is easily cracked provided you retain the original M'Board. What will happen here is that any suspect will have their entire Computer seized and probed and it doesn't rely on entering a Encryption Key as this is already built into the M'Board. If you follow IBM's current trends on saving data when a M'Board needs replacing in one of the T4X series of NB's you'll see that they can copy the encryption key from the M'Board even when it barely works. It's even possible to remove the chip and read the encryption key directly off the IC as the Encryption Key isn't stored in Volatile Memory but is hard coded in the IC.

So once you get over the Media Hype you can see that this is a Non-Issue.

Col

by gsaravin9

We have positive statements that security problems have been fully resolved only to see that people can circumvent security in a different way.Once we go through the media hype we can only have chuckle as the mind boggles of all the problems we have to face whether it be through hardware hacking or software hacking the system is not foolproof.

by hal 9000

I can remember when [b]Sasser[/b] was hitting the place hard we had shut down all external connections into the network to prevent any infections so the Boss when he tried to log on after watching the morning news hit a brick wall so he decided from that single incident that the network was down and unworkable. :)

What we had done was to lock down the internal network and block any VPN's into the place till we could get our grubby little hands on the computers and scan them for problems. We didn't want a Trusted Computer infecting the entire network. :^0

It was really funny when the Boss hit the office he was ranting and raving and when he finally stopped to catch his breath I said "We don't have any problems here but for basic security we have shut down any access points till we can clear all the NB's that you people have to prevent any infection." Of course with all his Porn Surfing over the weekend he had picked it up but it would have been our fault if he had of infected the system. :D

Col ]:)

by gsaravin9

some of the hdd i've tried were not recognised by vista.100 gig maxtor sata drive,seagate 80 gig
harddrive.no matter what fidling i did in bios etc i could not access the drive.Whilst you did install vista & got it running the minimum recommendation is much higher especially when you are running 64 bit.Most of the hardware printers,modems,video cards were not detected.
When using vista i noticed that video cards were
getting hotter & chips were getting hotter so better cooling is a must & i noticed that some video cards were strugling to display basic information.I suspect the drivers in windows to be suspect as they will not work with some cards.
I would recommend certainly running dual core with some applications requiring it.
Also i noticed that vista gobbles a lot of resources that i would recommend more ram & extra hdd space.

by researcher75

Now that I have received the Vista CD and installed it over XP, I am inclined to agree with gsaravine@.... but as it is only a BETA build I don't care to make such brash statements.

It has faults does this BETA build, and I wonder WHY! - MS has given us the dubious entertainment of a three to four hour install period and an even longer period of trying to get Windows Explorer to do something exciting?

At first when it eventually got to the desktop, most things were ok but then I discovered the machine didn't like my graphics card (Brand New Sapphire Radeon - bought for the purpose)- I eventually obtained a Vista driver software set from ATI.

I was then invited to download Office 2007 which didn't function (It is tops with XP!) and then I was updated with several files for both Office 2007 and VISTA.

From that point on, Windows Explorer was out of action and all that happened was a continual stream of error reports being generated and sent to MS. (Hope they can read them?)

If this excellent idea is to get Mr Gates or his successor loads of dosh then someone in his employ has a lot of overtime to get paid for.

I will now reformat the drive and try a clean install on a clean drive???

Researcher .....

by hal 9000

Don't bother with the 64 Bit version as you'll be giving yourself a world of pain & suffering.

MS was claiming that they where sending both versions when they posted them if you've only got the 64 Bit version I wouldn't bother even attempting to install it as there is so little available for it and so many problems.

I cheated though and started from blank Drives when I installed it as I didn't want to hose a XP install and I certainly didn't trust Vista to upgrade properly.

I found that 2007 Office installed OK on the 32 Bit version of Vista but I can't say that I'm overly impressed with it as it currently stands. Granted I prefer Word Perfect Office but even taking the step from Office 2003 to 2007 was a major headache and I never did find a way to open a Power Point Slide Show well at least in MS Office but Open Office 2 worked like a dream on Vista.

Col

by gsaravin9

I asked microsoft re upgradability & they said you might experience some problems try a clean install first.I said that a few of the harddrives are not even recognised under vista & they said compatibility is not an issue with them but is with the manufacturer so try them.On the issue of graphic cards they said
some graphic cards will work & others will not work at all.I did state that they should at least disclose what they have found on their website so that people will avoid buying cetain hardware that
will not work with vista.

by mustangj369

I sent for the DVD's and both 32 and 64 bit versions are in the package. You're right about the 64 bit version. It just isn't worth the trouble at this point.
My first install was an upgrade over XP Pro SP2. It took 2:15 from start to finish. Only hardware issue was with the soundcard. Everything else worked well enough, just slower than I expected. Vista will tax most any system to it's limits and then some. Then I did a clean install on the same machine and this took only about a hour, with the same results.
Graphically speaking, Vista is a nice package, but I don't really see anything in it compelling enough to make me want to upgrade from the known and stable XP installs I already have. Vista will eventually come my way when new pc's are purchased in a year or two. This will be the way the vast majority of users get it.

by gsaravin9

What i have found to some extent vista will clean install from the 32 bit dvd .It will function to some extent but i have found compatibility problems as to working with certain hardrives will not allow installs of vista as well as certain motherboards,other software will not function.Installing software over software is a problem in some cases as vista is not backwards compatible.Also drivers availability is a issue.
Also i have found that the video cards were running at a hotter temperature as well as strugling to keep to the high end scale.i know this is just beta but i have contacted several
manufacturers & they have said that microsoft
never even consulted with them about driver signing & to make matters worse they didn't
even consider making adjustments in the vista betas
or the final release.I said what shall i do with this particular graphics card & they said "ditch it & buy another one".On the issue of hard drives if you bought one of those 200 gig hardrives that
won't function properly microsoft is not interested
in your predicament as they are involved in software not hardware malfunctioning.

by jcdyson

With Vista there is no point in upgrading from XP to vista it is the best to do a clean install because i do believe with that you will have no where near the problems with the application once you do this. The problem is vista has a different structure to what XP has and dont think that MS has done much with the upgrade function therefore it will have conflict after conflict until the release of the polished product. I recall the beta of 2k had similar problems with upgrade from 95/98. I definitely recommend a clean install with any beta release anyway esp if you have the install DVD.

by daveo2000

Oh, Col! Here I was feeling young and impetuous and now you break my bubble!

The first drive I had to pay for was $600 for 10 MB and that was mail order. The ones in the local ComputerLand (remember them anyone?) were selling for $1000 installed (and they would keep your floppy drive that it replaced).

That drive was for my 5-slot PC (pre-XT) with a rocking 4.33 MHz processor and 256K on the motherboard!

by hal 9000

What I actually meant to say was that we couldn't conceive things getting any cheaper when we got to the the $100 per MEG for RAM and a $1.00 per MEG of HDD Space.

That was the price that just couldn't be broken or so we thought way back them. I've just bought 4 GIG of DDR RAM for under $300.00.

Now how many cents is that per MEG? B-)

Col

by gsaravin9

your just trying to upset me & have a go at me & insult me.This thread should stay as a vista thread & lets keep it that way.Wew may agree to disagree but you have a right of say provided you show a bit of respect.

by hal 9000

Like the Beta Release I'm personally planing a long hospital stay recovering from [b]Information Overload[/b] till all the bugs have been worked out. :D

Actually that will be till the Quacks consider me [b]Recovered[/b] and I'll be able to stretch that one out a very long time. Sneaking away to access a NB on the web will help keep me in the place for a very long time so I'll have some idea of how many problems you guys are having. :p

Personally I've found very little that will actually run on Vista at the current time there isn't even a AV product available as yet though Trend Micro should have their Beta available on the 16th. The really funny thing is that every Windows Program on the Open CD works perfectly on Vista but none of my bought programs will run properly if I can even get them to install. I've even resorted to games to try and the latest MS Games will not load but a 98 game will load and play but the graphics are crap. :)

Anyway enjoy all your [b]Undocumented Features[/b] I'll be putting up with Hospital Food which is almost as bad. :^0

Col ]:)

by jmgarvin

I've found that even on "modern" hardware, that Vista has issues.

A) If you leave the machine on for long periods, it tends to hard lock. I'm not sure if it is a driver/hardware thing or a Vista thing.

B) The driver support and the app support is pitiful, which means weird problems.

C) It's a sad commentary when OpenOffice works better than MS Office on an MS platform. (hint OO works better in Vista than MS Office)

D) Vista is clunky even on new hardware. The LONG install doesn't make me very happy either. Has anyone tried to image Vista?

E) Flaky graphics. I sometimes get odd graphical artifacts floating around on my screen...SPIFFY.

As it stands, this isn't even a beta, but more of an alpha. It has a ton of bugs and it looks like vendor support is going to be iffy at best.

On that note, has anyone seen a pricing structure yet? Why would anyone buy anything but Ultimate? How much is Ultimate.

I'm going to guess $699, but hey, I'm an optimist

by gsaravin9

Im sorry i ever called it CRAP because it's seems to be jinxed.I was hoping that it would come good but judging by what one of the developers of the source code said it would be lucky to come out given the problems with the source code.Also to read the glowing reports on the MSN website & they have a side dedicated to hardware
compatibilty.The developer said you would mainly hope to use the 32 bit rather than the 64 bit at this moment.He made me aware of the huge insurmountable problems involved & the complexities involved.He doesn't think that all the problems will be resolved thats the way it's been in the past.All in all it's a sorry tale.As Hal 6000 has said maybe it's time to closeshop & go o/s on a long holiday & hope it will all go away.

by gsaravin9

i have found that internet explorer 7 exhibits weird symptoms & doesn't work properly with vista.Other things become apparent while you are searching.I have experienced more errors on internet explorer errors than ever before with any other system.I found that Mozilla or Fire fox refuses to function & experiences freezups & makes browsing difficult.Furthermore when you try to save files it can't save them properly.
Other problems are dynamic link libraries don't seemto function properly with vista as well as
exe files that normally work with one op system will
not work with vista as it doesn't recognise them.
I have spoken to microsoft that they said things are being looked at but cannot garrantee that the final release will be so squeaky clean as other ops releases.So expect some weird surprises I guess that said i don' think that people will be ready to ditch XP just yet.

by hal 9000

And remember that Ultimate is the second top version the Enterprise Edition is the only one that comes with Software Assurance. Well that's what they where saying as of the 22 May 06 and I'm guessing that they have got a lot more Bug Reports since them.

Col

by hal 9000

I never use them and on the rare occasions when a customer has one I always do a clean install with the Upgrade CD and just pop in the old version of the product to allow the install to proceed.

Anything less than a clean blank HDD is a waste of time and effort as far as I'm concerned.

Col

by gsaravin9

I've seen first hand & it is so bad that the amount of people that have said they have problems installing beta vista 1 & beta vista 2 this is on the MSN website.Also people that have bought new equipment hoping to install vista have come to grief as the equipment will not work with vista,coupled with this either existing software & more importantly new software will not work at all with the beta Vista 2.I know it's beta time but it seems to be hit or miss with both the hardware & software as no one knows for sure.From my testing of beta 2
i found complete instability of the system.Where as others have found some stability
but experienced weird symptoms.

by gsaravin9

did you know that win 98 & win milenium will no longer be supported for updates.There are 50 million users out there.This is crazy.

by alexcoop

vista, which comes from a company KNOWN for it's illegal & immoral business practices and famous for it's deceptions and outright lies. and let us not forget their wonderful tech/customer support or the way they shaft (steal) people by the MILLIONS. and people are surprised.
i've yet to find ANYTHING redeeming about vista, but i will buy it. why? i support microsucks products mainly because that's what the market is. personally i'm switching to linux so i can get some real work done. and bill gates can $@%^&&*^ himself with a chainsaw.
alex

www.alexcooper.org