vista is a DUD ! (wham baam thankyou maam!)
This is page 16 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 16 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by lasersteel
MS (and many others behind the scenes) have invested too much in DRM not to make it happen. You are mistaken if you see this as suicide attempt, even if it is clumsy.
End users will end up paying even if they go via Open Source as a lot of the images and content have already been bought up by Microsoft. Besides, anyone who thinks Open Source is "without cost" doesn?t understand the business of running a business. DRM will apply irrespective of whether you use MS or Open Source eventually.
Software As A Service (SAAS) is also rumoured to be part of the business ?licensing? model of the future and behind the scenes you have the telcos (baby bells in US), the ISPs and the movie/music industry who all intend to share in the $ revenues that will flow from DRM. Font licensing revenue is also on the agenda under DRM.
In essence you are fighting a losing battle.
Having said that MS does need to be more adaptive to suit the market as they just don?t understand the business drivers and the costs of doing business at the grass roots level.
?We are the ones who let them invade our workspace and now we can't get rid of them?, as our businesses, in most cases, rely on their software in one form or another, if not for internal use or communicating and doing business with our trading partners.
If you wanted to kill them off you needed to do it years ago, when there was an opportunity to do so, which is lost I believe unless you invent a better mousetrap and don?t even suggest that Open Source is that better mousetrap as it does cost!
MS has got big, fat dumb and happy because we, the end users kept demanding more and more features and inclusions in the software and now that the software has got big, fat, bloated, and expensive ?we? are complaining. Doesn?t add up to me! Would we have been better off keeping low with our demands we might have been better off? I doubt it.
Like has been said before, this sort of debate and ranting went on over Win95, Win98, WinNT, Win XP for those of us that are old enough (I've been in the computer industry in one form or another since 1973) to remember.
I?d venture to say there will also be detractors complaining about the UBAVista (Mark II version) or whatever name it goes by, and we'll be arguing the same again.
The bottomline - performance means different things to different "applications or uses? of the software. eg; games, vs accounting, vs techno ?experts?, vs defence, vs government, vs manufacturing, vs research vs education etc.
We all want different things in terms of performance for the out-of-the-box operating system delivered, so there is no one size that fits all when it comes to performance.
MS is here to stay and I am not paid by MS to say this, it?s just a fact of life, and though it may change shape (due to perceived loss of customers churning to Open Source etc), it will be around a long time.
It certainly needs to get a better understanding of how business works and what drives the cost of business and then they might deliver a leaner, stable operating system (patched once a year instead of 30 times) with installed applications that work tirelessly without interference/virus attack/security attack so that business can get on with life and do what business needs to do.
They have started to do this with Vista Ultimate (with Bit Defender) but leaner and secure are contradictions in reality under these circumstances!
by gsaravin9
buzzwordas one.We are not going to use vista for a long time as the costs are prohibitive,
ta mick
by gsaravin9
unless there are other companies getting into the operating system market then we deserve what we get.But as time rolls on we may get alternatives to ms & windows.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
ms is trully stuffed after their release of vista with so many problems it's all happening at once.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
taken from msdn:
The World As Best As I Remember It
Alert reader Bobby is Back!
Broken Windows Theory
Vista. The term stirs the imagination to conceive of beautiful possibilities just around the corner. And ?just around the corner? is what Windows Vista has been, and has remained, for the past two years. In this time, Vista has suffered a series of high-profile delays, including most recently the announcement that it would be delayed until 2007. The largest software project in mankind?s history now threatens to also be the longest.
[I originally deleted the rest of this post of my own volition, without any pressure whatsoever from people within the company, because the discussion around it wasn't constructive. I've now restored the original content unedited. More discussion on this topic here. - Ed.]
Admittedly, this essay would be easier written for Slashdot, where taut lines divide the world crisply into black and white. "Vista is a bloated piece of crap,"? my furry little penguin would opine, "written by the bumbling serfs of an evil capitalistic megalomaniac."? But that'd be dead wrong. The truth is far more nuanced than that. Deeper than that. More subtle than that.
I managed developer teams in Windows for five years, and have only begun to reflect on the experience now that I have recently switched teams. Through a series of conversations with other leaders that have similarly left The Collective, several root causes have emerged as lasting characterizations of what's really wrong in The Empire.
Useless Trivia Sidebar: Broken Windows Theory
The original broken windows theory, first coined by Wilson and Kelling, describes the purported phenomenon whereby an abandoned warehouse with no broken windows is mostly left alone, but as soon as one window is broken, it acts as an open invitation to passers-by that it's open-season for rock-throwing.
This was generally accepted for many years as being true, but is recently coming under fire from different angles. We won't delve into those here, since we mostly commandeered the phrase because it sounded good, not because it actually has anything at all to do with our subject matter.
The Usual Suspects
Ask any developer in Windows why Vista is plagued by delays, and they'll say that the code is way too complicated, and that the pace of coding has been tremendously slowed down by overbearing process. These claims have already been covered in other popular literature. A quick recap for those of you just joining the broadcast:
Windows code is too complicated. It's not the components themselves, it's their interdependencies. An architectural diagram of Windows would suggest there are more than 50 dependency layers (never mind that there also exist circular dependencies). After working in Windows for five years, you understand only, say, two of them. Add to this the fact that building Windows on a dual-proc dev box takes nearly 24 hours, and you'll be slow enough to drive Miss Daisy.
Windows process has gone thermonuclear. Imagine each little email you send asking someone else to fill out a spreadsheet, comment on a report, sign off on a decision -- is a little neutron shooting about in space. Your innocent-seeming little neutron now causes your heretofore mostly-harmless neighbors to release neutrons of their own. Now imagine there are 9000 of you, all jammed into a tight little space called Redmond. It's Windows Gone Thermonuclear, a phenomenon by which process engenders further process, eventually becoming a self-sustaining buzz of fervent destructive activity.
Let's see if, quantitatively, there's any truth to the perception that the code velocity (net lines shipped per developer-year) of Windows has slowed, or is slow relative to the industry. Vista is said to have over 50 million lines of code, whereas XP was said to have around 40 million. There are about two thousand software developers in Windows today. Assuming there are 5 years between when XP shipped and when Vista ships, those quick on the draw with calculators will discover that, on average, the typical Windows developer has produced one thousand new lines of shipped code per year during Vista. Only a thousand lines a year. (Yes, developers don't just write new code, they also fix old code. Yes, some of those Windows developers were partly busy shipping 64-bit XP. Yes, many of them also worked on hotfixes. Work with me here.)
Lest those of you who wrote 5,000 lines of code last weekend pass a kidney stone at the thought of Windows developers writing only a thousand lines of code a year, realize that the average software developer in the US only produces around (brace yourself) 6200 lines a year. So Windows is in bad shape -- but only by a constant, not by an order of magnitude. And if it makes you feel any better, realize that the average US developer has fallen in KLOC productivity since 1999, when they produced about 9000 lines a year. So Windows isn't alone in this. [KLOC data comes from ?Worldwide IT Trends & Benchmark Report 2001?, produced by META Group (now acquired by Gartner)]
The oft-cited, oft-watercooler-discussed dual phenomenon of Windows code complexity and Windows process burden seem to have dramatically affected its overall code velocity. But code can be simplified and re-architected (and is indeed being done so by a collection of veteran architects in Windows, none of whom, incidentally, look anything like Colonel Sanders). Process can be streamlined where inefficient, eliminated where unnecessary.
But that's not where it ends. There are deeper causes of Windows' propensity to slippage.
Cultured to Slip
Deep in the bowels of Windows, there remains the whiff of a bygone culture of belittlement and aggression. Windows can be a scary place to tell the truth.
When a vice president in Windows asks you whether your team will ship on time, they might well have asked you whether they look fat in their new Armani suit. The answer to the question is deeply meaningful to them. It's certainly true in some sense that they genuinely want to know. But in a very important other sense, in a sense that you'll come to regret night after night if you get it wrong, there's really only one answer you can give.
After months of hearing of how a certain influential team in Windows was going to cause the Vista release to slip, I, full of abstract self-righteous misgivings as a stockholder, had at last the chance to speak with two of the team's key managers, asking them how they could be so, please-excuse-the-term, I-don't-mean-its-value-laden-connotation, ignorant as to proper estimation of software schedules. Turns out they're actually great project managers. They knew months in advance that the schedule would never work. So they told their VP. And he, possibly influenced by one too many instances where engineering re-routes power to the warp core, thus completing the heretofore impossible six-hour task in a mere three, summarily sent the managers back to "figure out how to make it work."? The managers re-estimated, nipped and tucked, liposuctioned, did everything short of a lobotomy -- and still did not have a schedule that fit. The VP was not pleased. "You're smart people. Find a way!" This went back and forth for weeks, whereupon the intrepid managers finally understood how to get past the dilemma. They simply stopped telling the truth. "Sure, everything fits. We cut and cut, and here we are. Vista by August or bust. You got it, boss."
Every once in a while, Truth still pipes up in meetings. When this happens, more often than not, Truth is simply bent over an authoritative knee and soundly spanked into silence.
The Joy of Cooking
Bundled with a tendency towards truth-intolerance, Windows also sometimes struggles with poor organizational decision-making. Good news is that the senior leaders already know this and have been taking active steps to change the situation.
There are too many cooks in the kitchen. Too many vice presidents, in reporting structures too narrow. When I was in Windows, I reported to Alec, who reported to Peter, to Bill, Rick, Will, Jim, Steve, and Bill. Remember that there were two layers of people under me as well, making a total path depth of 11 people from Bill Gates down to any developer on my team.
This isn't necessarily bad, except sometimes the cooks flash-mob one corner of the kitchen. I once sat in a schedule review meeting with at least six VPs and ten general managers. When that many people have a say, things get confusing. Not to mention, since so many bosses are in the room, there are often negotiations between project managers prior to such meetings to make sure that no one ends up looking bad. "Bob, I'm giving you a heads-up that I'm going to say that your team's component, which we depend on, was late."? "That's fine, Sandy, but please be clear that the unforeseen delays were caused by a third party, not my team."
Micromanagement, though not pervasive, is nevertheless evident. Senior vice presidents sometimes review UI designs of individual features, a nod to Steve Jobs that would in better days have betokened a true honor but for its randomizing effects. Give me a cathedral, give me a bazaar -- really, either would be great. Just not this middle world in which some decisions are made freely while others are made by edict, with no apparent logic separating each from the other but the seeming curiosity of someone in charge.
In general, Windows suffers from a proclivity for action control, not results control. Instead of clearly stating desired outcomes, there's a penchant for telling people exactly what steps they must take. By doing so, we risk creating a generation of McDevs. (For more on action control vs. results control, read Kenneth Merchant's seminal work on the subject -- all $150 of it, apparently).
Uncontrolled? Or Uncontrollable?
We shouldn't forget despite all this that Windows Vista remains the largest concerted software project in human history. The types of software management issues being dealt with by Windows leaders are hard problems, problems that no other company has solved successfully. The solutions to these challenges are certainly not trivial.
An interesting question, however, is whether or not Windows Vista ever had a chance to ship on time to begin with. Is Vista merely uncontrolled? Or is it fundamentally uncontrollable? There is a critical difference.
It's rumored that VPs in Windows were offered big bonuses contingent on shipping Vista by the much-publicized August 2006 date. Chris Jones even declared in writing that he wouldn't take a bonus if Vista slips past August. If this is true, if folks like Brian Valentine held division-wide meetings where August 2006 was declared as the drop-dead ship date, if general managers were consistently told of the fiscal importance of hitting August, if everyone down to individual developers was told to sign on the dotted line to commit to the date, and to speak up if they had any doubts of hitting it -- mind you, every last one of those things happened -- and yet, and yet, the August date was slipped, one has to wonder whether it was merely illusory, given the collective failure of such unified human will, that Vista was ever controllable in the first place.
Are Vista-scale software projects essentially uncontrollable by nature? Or has Microsoft been beset by one too many broken windows?
Vista is meant to be the operating systemt the standard for operating systems to be judged .
Deep in the bowels of Windows, there remains the whiff of a bygone culture of belittlement and aggression. Windows can be a scary place to tell the truth. When a vice president in Windows asks you whether your team will ship on time, they might well have asked you whether they look fat in their new Armani suit. The answer to the question is deeply meaningful to them. It?s certainly true in some sense that they genuinely want to know. But in a very important other sense, in a sense that you?ll come to regret night after night if you get it wrong, there?s really only one answer you can give.
yeah,yeah that's certainly true
mick
by gsaravin9
from zdnet:Microsoft's own antivirus software, Live OneCare, is unable to fully protect Vista users against viruses, and one of security firm McAfee's antivirus software packages also fails to protect users, according to independent research released Friday.
Security news site Virus Bulletin, backed by a team of security researchers based in Oxfordshire, U.K., tested 15 antivirus software packages used by businesses and designed specifically for Vista, Microsoft's newest operating system. The packages were released to businesses two months ago.
The researchers tested whether each of the antivirus products would stop a set of viruses known to be currently circulating. In order to be awarded a pass, the software had to detect all the viruses with no false positives.
But out of the 15, four failed: Microsoft Live OneCare 1.5; McAfee VirusScan Enterprise version 8.1i; G DATA AntiVirusKit 2007 v17.0.6353; and Norman VirusControl v5.90. The other 11, including software from CA, Fortinet, F-Secure, Kaspersky, Sophos and Symantec, detected all the viruses.
"With the number of delays that we've seen in Vista's release, there's no excuse for security vendors not to have got their products right by now," said John Hawes, technical consultant at Virus Bulletin. "In these days of hourly updates, it's always a surprise and a disappointment to see major products missing them (viruses). Vista cannot fend off today's malware without help from security products. It certainly looks like people upgrading to the new platform are going to need additional security solutions."
Joe Telafici, vice president of operations for McAfee's Avert Labs, told ZDNet UK that, in his opinion, Virus Bulletin had not used its latest antivirus updates, causing the failure. He said McAfee would issue further results with the updated software.
Microsoft pledged to improve Live OneCare. "We are looking closely at the methodology and results of the test to ensure that Windows Live OneCare performs better in future tests and, most importantly, as part of our ongoing work to continually enhance Windows Live OneCare," a company representative told ZDNet UK.
On the subject of Vista, the Microsoft representative added: "It's important to remember that no software is 100 percent secure. Microsoft is working to keep the number of security vulnerabilities that ship in our products to a minimum, through our Security Development Lifecycle process, and that work is paying off. The release of Windows Vista is the first Microsoft operating system to use the Security Development Lifecycle from start to finish and was tested more, prior to shipping, than any previous version of Windows."
ta mick
by bionicbron
by gsaravin9
That's exactly what i've done.You are spot on regards the hole in the desk that's pretty right.After all these years as loyal customers
you'd think that ms would make another service pack or edition for xp.No they want a new windows so they can make more money.
Until such time as vista is more developed i don't think too many people are ready to part
with their hard earned money.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
by ang2006
Here are some more problems reported with Vista from the komando.com newsletter:
Ipod problems:
APPLE RELEASES ITUNES REPAIR TOOL FOR VISTA
Nobody ever said upgrading to Vista would be easy. But it seems that many iPod owners have been hit particularly hard. There have been a number of reported compatibility issues with iTunes 7.0.2. For example, some iTunes purchases won?t play on Vista.
There have also been problems with syncing and ejecting iPods. There are things you can do to make the transition smoother. First, enable disk use on your iPod. Connect the iPod and right-click it in iTunes. On the Summary tab, deselect Enable Disk Use and click Apply.
Also, deauthorize your music before you upgrade. In iTunes, click Store>>Deauthorize Computer. Enter your Apple ID and password. Click OK.
Firewall Problems:
My old computer broke. Since it was under warranty, the store replaced it with a new machine running Vista. I really wasn?t ready to make the switch. But now I have no choice. I tried to download ZoneAlarm, but it won?t work on Vista. That means I?m left without a decent firewall. Can you recommend one that will work on Vista?
Steve in Joplin, MO
I received this question on the show last week. I told the listener to go with Windows Vista?s firewall. It can be configured to be perfectly satisfactory.
But Vista?s firewall isn?t for everyone. It is difficult to configure. And, unlike ZoneAlarm, it won?t prompt you to allow outbound connections on the fly.
The Vista firewall is an improvement over the one in Windows XP. It can be used to block outbound connections as well as incoming ones.
Unfortunately, though, outbound connections are allowed by default. And configuring it to block outbound transmissions is probably beyond most people?s comfort level. Nonetheless, I?m going to explain the firewall?s configuration. Then, I?ll tell you how to do it easily, for a mere $50!
You may want another firewall. In the past, I have recommended the free ZoneAlarm firewall. But ZoneAlarm?s Vista firewall is not ready, as you point out. We could not find any free firewalls for Vista.
However, you can purchase a firewall. Norton Internet Security 2007 ($70) works, although Norton Personal Firewall does not. Or, you can use McAfee?s Internet Security Suite (starting at $50).
This just continues to confirm my fears of too many problems associated with Vista. And the beat goes on????.
by gsaravin9
people who have recently bought vista were shocked to learn vista will not perform unless you have proper drivers.Trying to run unsigned drivers is asking for trouble.
Also even if one buys the latest hardware or software there is no guarantee that it is going to be compatible.Just because someone has said it's vista ready doesn't mean it's ready.I have seen people simply go
back to XP.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
Pretty soon heads will be rolling at the ms camp.As the return to shareholders will not be fully realised.Ms has gone over budget on vista it is ms's biggest money spending system .Sales are depressed at the moment.People are buying pcs but are not installing vista.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
Throughout the testing of the past releases, it was strikingly evident how incomplete Vista's code was. Various incomplete features, missing graphics, place-holder text messages, and a plethora of bugs, left many feeling very underwhelmed, and increasingly worried by the next operating system from Microsoft.Worried they should be as a lot of promises were made to fix this or that & it fell on death ears.
My testing revealed how much slower is vista to xp in that one pc magazine journalist said that "now Vista appears little more than an ill-performing version of XP with a glorified interface".
We are also told vista is mean't to be this revolutionary os.Others are saying that "Unfortunately Vista provides little to no benefit for end users compared to that of the previous version of Windows, released five years ago in 2001."
There seems to be too much bloat & too much resource hungry features.For example When xp starts it uses about 250 to 300mb to do it.
Where as when vista starts it continues to gobble up resources at over 500 to 550 megabytes.Also even at idle vista seems to gobble much more resources than xp.
One would be astounded at what really goes on when the system is idle.
Boot up time can take longer on vista by as much as 15 to 20 seconds hardly awe inspiring.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
i have tested vista & is slower than xp.That's with the final product!As to your criticism of spelling try & type when you have acouple of wonky keys on your keyboard.
Just to let you know, i know of heaps of people who won't upgrade to vista & those few that did have gone back to xp!!
At this moment the only use for vista is a rather expensive coaster!
ta mick
by gsaravin9
We are all using XP until & if Ms get's it's act together it is a big flop.You can only use the dvd as an expensive coaster!
ta mick
by gsaravin9
it as a coaster or hang it from the mirror on your car!
ta miock
by gsaravin9
by vista & a plethora of compatibility problems.No one gives a damn at the moment.Heaps of people are stuck with an os
that does not perform to expectations :result all are going back to xp.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
Why Vista is defective by design
14th February 2007 Ashton Mills Internet, Kernel Knowledge, Vista, Windows
Vista's DRM features have been drawing ever more criticism, but it's just the latest step among many that takes liberties out of the hands of users and into the media megacorps. So what are you going to do about it?
Even Vista is, of course, just the most recent example in a litany of anti-consumer devices designed to protect monopoly distribution for the media cartels and, most certainly, Microsoft at the expense of the you, the customer.
In his recent column on Forbes, Bruce Schneier covers off all the essential arguments, including Microsoft's interest in implementing DRM, which I couldn't have said better myself. In my piece on 10 reasons not to get Vista, some of the comments in response suggested that the point about the inclusion of DRM in Vista was unfair, that Microsoft's hand was forced by Hollywood. Which is, of course, a gigantic load of wombat poo. As Schneier puts it:
"It's all complete nonsense. Microsoft could have easily told the entertainment industry that it was not going to deliberately cripple its operating system, take it or leave it. With 95% of the operating system market, where else would Hollywood go?"
But the problem didn't start with Microsoft. Copy protection, and its newer perverted cousin DRM (Digital Rights Management, or more accurately Digital Restrictions Management) has been around for a rather long time now. And it's not that products shouldn't be protected, it's that frequently these protections comes at a cost to the very people who it isn't intended for -- those who legitimately buy the products.
The problem is that, while piracy is real, Hollywood and ilk make the assumption that everyone in the entire world is guilty until proven innocent. Apparently it's all too hard to do the right thing, so why not just treat everyone as guilty and be done with it?
It doesn't matter if you legitimately purchased your DVD or CD, it doesn't matter if you wish to format shift this product you own to another device you own, and doesn't matter that you routinely go out and buy more music and movies to enjoy -- you're a criminal, deal with it.
As DRM has absolutely no use to the end user, and in fact hinders their experience of a purchase, DRM infused products have been termed 'Defective by design'. Because lets face it, they are. There's even a website for it.
And why should you foot the bill for a copy protection mechanism that doesn't apply to you? Eric Raymond put it best in the Jargon File with his definition of copy protection:
"copy protection: n.
A class of methods for preventing incompetent pirates from stealing software and legitimate customers from using it. Considered silly."
Decades from now our children will look back be in awe at the irony this period of human history produced. Lets cover the facts shall we:
Fact: DRM and copy protection doesn't stop piracy.
We've had these in place for decades now. I can remember playing games on a Commodore 64 that came with a 'code wheel' to prevent anyone without the wheel from playing. Today there is Safedisc, Laserlock, Securom and others to prevent games being copied.
Yet games are still pirated.
For DVDs we've had CSS and CDs all manner of perverse copy protection systems -- one of which could be bypassed with a felt tip pen, while another installed a rootkit (both courtesy of Sony).
Yet DVDs and CDs are still pirated.
Even Vista's DRM has already been broken.
Fact: DRM and copy protection hinders legitimate users.
Since DRM and copy protection is applied to the products on sale, naturally it's the people who buy the products who end up encountering it. Pirates? They rip it out and the pirated versions of software, DVD and music have no usage restrictions, and no hindrance.
It doesn't get clearer than this: The only people who experience copy protection are same people who support the product by buying it.
I can already hear the children who will inherit our legacy laughing.
Fact: DRM and copy protection has cost billions.
Between Hollywood, Sony, EMI, and the gaming publishers I can't imagine the volumes of money sunk into these schemes. Yet piracy still occurs. It doesn't take a genius to realise this is dead money that -- here's a crazy idea -- could have been spent actually producing products that people want to buy, and turn a profit.
Unfortunately, it also adds to the cost to produce these products, so the end user ultimately has to foot the bill for the paranoia of the media and entertainment megacorps that see the world through pirate-coloured glasses.
So let's summarise...
DRM doesn't work, it hinders legitimate use, and it has exorbitant costs through which ultimately users foot the bill.
And we only need to look to current events for yet another example of how pointless and expensive the pursuit of copy protection and DRM really is. As this Boing Boing blog describes, the AACS copy protection system that forms a part of both HD-DVD and Blu-Ray has already been broken (just like CSS before it on DVDs), and puts it succinctly like so:
"AACS took years to develop, and it has been broken in weeks. The developers spent billions, the hackers spent pennies."
So why does the Hollywood mentality still persist?
Because the industry just doesn?t get the future that's bearing down on it. The RIAA and MPAA especially are a middleman the world no longer needs, and they are fighting tooth and nail to hang onto the past. As legal, downloadable, music and TV distribution has shown the future is an on-demand online market where content producers sell direct to the consumer. No one needs the MPAA or RIAA anymore, but they don't want you to know that.
Finally, all of this could be averted if the flawed reasoning that people are inherently criminals was actually thought about for a picosecond -- if the majority of people really were thieves, there isn't a business on this planet that would still be standing.
The fact is, while piracy is real (and is real eveywhere -- you can bet the local fruit shop loses a few apples a week), that the majority of the human race will buy products rather than steal them, because we all have an understanding that the world just wouldn't work otherwise.
Hollywood, for one, wouldn't have got as big as it has if this wasn't true. Where did all those profits come from, even in age before digital restrictions where people could still copy VHS tapes? Funny how Hollywood didn't collapse. Instead, it's bigger than ever.
So here's the message to the big content producers of this world -- stop trying to protect your B-grade products from being stolen (have you seen some of the shit movies that make it to DVD?), and start investing money in making A-grade products people want to buy. Economics will do the rest.
Heck, for a teeny tiny fraction of the millions of dollars wasted that's been wasted so far, I could give you the next Star Trek franchise.
And what can you do about it? Be vocal. Let them know. Don't buy DRM products, and when you see them on the shelves fire off an email telling why you didn't buy it. Help them to understand that keeping you happy is in the best interests of their profts. When there's enough noise, change is inevitable.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
heaps back than xp.So why would anyone waste their money on an os that doesn't perform.At the moment some people that have upgraded have found that there aren't many benefits attached to vista as predicted there are huge tecnical hurdles & as much time as 2 years to get things right!
ta mick
by gsaravin9
are you the one that's upgraded & done your dough??
ta mick
by hal 9000
You buy the thing and then pay M$ a lot of money to fix the problems in the OS because it doesn't work right and M$ get paid feedback to what they need to start to fix.
This is typical M$ Product Release Strategy since the DOS days though now the problems are far bigger and far more time consuming to fix and consequently you pay M$ far more to be told that, that bit isn't working yet call back in another week and pay us another Thousand $ only to be told to call back the week after that. :D
This is the perfect Money Making method that M$ has employed since the beginning of their products and as they make so much money out of it they are unlikely to change things ever unless Laws are changed and they have to provide the support for free like they do in AU because under our Law they have to supply a [b]Marketable Product[/b] which currently Vista isn't.
Col
by gsaravin9
Some of the advice i've had over the years
is not worth paying for.As for vista they are going to generate heaps of money because of all the associated problems.At the moment all my pcs & my client's pcs do not use or recommend vista usage at at all until such time as it's fixed.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
compatibility & stability reasons guess which software they'll stay with.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
From zdnet forum by david berlind
Trouble in Vista paradise? Large software vendor warns of major compatibility problems and burdensome remedies.
Intuit, developer of one of the world's most popular accounting applications used in small, medium and large businesses (Quickbooks), has notified its customers by email that Windows Vista is incompatible with some of the features of Quickbooks 2006. According to the email (see a complete image of it here) from Intuit senior vice president of QuickBooks Brad Smith:
You may have heard about the upcoming release of Microsoft's new operating system, Windows Vista. Microsoft has made significant changes to how software runs on Windows Vista.
I'm sending you this important service alert because you are using a 2006 or earlier version of QuickBooks software.
Since QuickBooks 2006 and earlier versions were developed and released before the introduction of Windows Vista, these versions may be adversely affected when used on computer running Windows Vista.
This will impact Simple Start, Basic, Pro, Premier, Payroll and Point of Sale, as well as other QuickBooks products and services. We recognize that your QuickBooks software is an important business tool and apologize for any inconvenience this may cause you.
Smith's e-mail goes on to describe what action is required on behalf of Quickbooks customers. For example, if they're not going to be running Vista, they don't need to do anything. But, if customers are upgrading to Vista, then they need to spend more time figuring out whether or not they'll run into compatibility problems based on what features of QuickBooks they use. To do this, users are advised to visit Inuit's Web site where the software company provides very detailed information on the affected features and what the remedy is.
Unfortunately, for many of the features, end-users are advised that they must switch on Windows XP compatibility and run Windows Vista with system administrator privileges. However, one of the cornerstones of Vista's security and a long-time recommendation of Microsoft is to run Windows (even XP) as what's know as a lesser privileged user or LPU. When running Windows with system administrator privileges, the risk that malware could enter the system and damage precious system files thereby destabilizing or ruining a PC altogether goes way up. Malware would of course have to find its way into the system in the first place. But security experts including those at Microsoft have always urged extreme caution when it comes to running Windows as a system administrator. Doing so gives software that's installed on a PC (including any malware) access to sensitive areas that it wouldn't otherwise have access to (thereby increasing the chances of a catastrophic event). So, in essence, one remedy is to deactivate one of Windows' most important security features.
Beyond that, there is still another list of QuickBook features that are incompatible with Vista to the point that even switching into the XP Compatibility and Administrator modes won't help. Here, the only remedy is to upgrade to QuickBooks 2007.
According to Intuit spokesperson Rachel Euretig, QuickBooks 2007 was launched in the Fall as a version of the software that was designed to be Vista compatible. Euretig told me that prior to that, there wasn't much Intuit could do on the Vista compatibility front since the operating system was still in development. In an effort to be as communicative as possible, Euretig says the company is still searching for potential problems and taking a proactive stance when it comes to notifying customers of its findings.
Still, ZDNet reader Al Chartier who was the first to tip me off to the problem says he's not satisfied. According to Chartier, Intuit's suggested remedy means that he must pay $200 for QuickBooks Pro 2007 (editor's note: Right now, Intuit is offering the software at a $20 discount) Euretig says that QuickBook customers who purchased Quickbooks 2006 on or after July 26th are entitled to a free upgrade to the 2007 version. Euretig also said there is no special upgrade price for existing QuickBook customers. All customers (new or existing) must pay the same price. According to Chartier, " I won't be buying any more Intuit software."
In the bigger picture, the problem with QuickBooks raises new and very serious issues for Microsoft on the eve of Vista's launch. If the software title was a small and very vertically oriented program that falls into the category of collateral damage that Microsoft must accept every time it releases a major new version of an operating system, the damage would be minimal. But Intuit is a software bellwether and QuickBooks one of the most popular software titles in the industry (Update: Euretig says that at the time of QuickBooks 2007's launch, there were 3.7 million active users of QuickBooks).
Not only should the compatibility questions and remedies cause small and medium business users to reconsider any plans to upgrade, enterprises may need to put the brakes on as well. Intuit offers an enterprise version of its tools (starting at $3,000) which means that any large business that's a QuickBooks customer that's thinking of moving to Vista may have to think again. Not only must they examine how many users within the business might be impacted, they also must (a) look at the cost of upgrading should that be the only other remedy and (b) wait to see if other software vendors begin to issue similar warnings. Based on what Intuit's Euretig told me, the company is still looking for problems other than the ones listed on its Web site; a situation that can only mean that other software vendors are doing the same. In other words, the full x-industry backwards compatibility report on Windows Vista is still in flux.
Earlier today, my colleague George Ou posted a blog on how backwards compatibility problems between ActiveX and the new version of Internet Explorer 7 are causing most of South Korea to hold off on upgrading to Vista because of how incompatibilities could interfere with that country's banking system.
Another fire this snafu is sure to fuel is rhetoric from the part of the Web 2.0 camp that offers alternatives to locally hosted programs like QuickBooks. For example, this problem with upgrades is exactly the sort of problem that NetSuite CEO Zach Nelson uses to justify his browser-based hosted solution over his competitor QuickBooks. With browser-based hosted solutions such as NetSuite, compatibility with the browsers is all that's important (and something that hosted solution providers like NetSuite have plenty of time to resolve).
I've reached out to Microsoft for its take on the issue with the position that Intuit is indeed a bellwether software developer and how incompatibilities with its software could cause the entire industry to take a deep breath. Not only does this affect potential upgrades to Vista on existing systems, the problem also has ramifications for hardware vendors who are hoping to capitalize on Vista's launch by offering a slew of new systems that are pre-loaded with Microsoft's new flagship OS. I've yet to hear back.
Intuit, developer of one of the world's most popular accounting applications used in small, medium and large businesses (Quickbooks), has notified its customers by email that Windows Vista is incompatible with some of the features of Quickbooks 2006. According to the email (see a complete image of it here) from Intuit senior vice president of QuickBooks Brad Smith:
You may have heard about the upcoming release of Microsoft's new operating system, Windows Vista. Microsoft has made significant changes to how software runs on Windows Vista.
I'm sending you this important service alert because you are using a 2006 or earlier version of QuickBooks software.
Since QuickBooks 2006 and earlier versions were developed and released before the introduction of Windows Vista, these versions may be adversely affected when used on computer running Windows Vista.
This will impact Simple Start, Basic, Pro, Premier, Payroll and Point of Sale, as well as other QuickBooks products and services. We recognize that your QuickBooks software is an important business tool and apologize for any inconvenience this may cause you.
Smith's e-mail goes on to describe what action is required on behalf of Quickbooks customers. For example, if they're not going to be running Vista, they don't need to do anything. But, if customers are upgrading to Vista, then they need to spend more time figuring out whether or not they'll run into compatibility problems based on what features of QuickBooks they use. To do this, users are advised to visit Inuit's Web site where the software company provides very detailed information on the affected features and what the remedy is.
Unfortunately, for many of the features, end-users are advised that they must switch on Windows XP compatibility and run Windows Vista with system administrator privileges. However, one of the cornerstones of Vista's security and a long-time recommendation of Microsoft is to run Windows (even XP) as what's know as a lesser privileged user or LPU. When running Windows with system administrator privileges, the risk that malware could enter the system and damage precious system files thereby destabilizing or ruining a PC altogether goes way up. Malware would of course have to find its way into the system in the first place. But security experts including those at Microsoft have always urged extreme caution when it comes to running Windows as a system administrator. Doing so gives software that's installed on a PC (including any malware) access to sensitive areas that it wouldn't otherwise have access to (thereby increasing the chances of a catastrophic event). So, in essence, one remedy is to deactivate one of Windows' most important security features.
Beyond that, there is still another list of QuickBook features that are incompatible with Vista to the point that even switching into the XP Compatibility and Administrator modes won't help. Here, the only remedy is to upgrade to QuickBooks 2007.
According to Intuit spokesperson Rachel Euretig, QuickBooks 2007 was launched in the Fall as a version of the software that was designed to be Vista compatible. Euretig told me that prior to that, there wasn't much Intuit could do on the Vista compatibility front since the operating system was still in development. In an effort to be as communicative as possible, Euretig says the company is still searching for potential problems and taking a proactive stance when it comes to notifying customers of its findings.
Still, ZDNet reader Al Chartier who was the first to tip me off to the problem says he's not satisfied. According to Chartier, Intuit's suggested remedy means that he must pay $200 for QuickBooks Pro 2007 (editor's note: Right now, Intuit is offering the software at a $20 discount) Euretig says that QuickBook customers who purchased Quickbooks 2006 on or after July 26th are entitled to a free upgrade to the 2007 version. Euretig also said there is no special upgrade price for existing QuickBook customers. All customers (new or existing) must pay the same price. According to Chartier, " I won't be buying any more Intuit software."
In the bigger picture, the problem with QuickBooks raises new and very serious issues for Microsoft on the eve of Vista's launch. If the software title was a small and very vertically oriented program that falls into the category of collateral damage that Microsoft must accept every time it releases a major new version of an operating system, the damage would be minimal. But Intuit is a software bellwether and QuickBooks one of the most popular software titles in the industry (Update: Euretig says that at the time of QuickBooks 2007's launch, there were 3.7 million active users of QuickBooks).
Not only should the compatibility questions and remedies cause small and medium business users to reconsider any plans to upgrade, enterprises may need to put the brakes on as well. Intuit offers an enterprise version of its tools (starting at $3,000) which means that any large business that's a QuickBooks customer that's thinking of moving to Vista may have to think again. Not only must they examine how many users within the business might be impacted, they also must (a) look at the cost of upgrading should that be the only other remedy and (b) wait to see if other software vendors begin to issue similar warnings. Based on what Intuit's Euretig told me, the company is still looking for problems other than the ones listed on its Web site; a situation that can only mean that other software vendors are doing the same. In other words, the full x-industry backwards compatibility report on Windows Vista is still in flux.
Earlier today, my colleague George Ou posted a blog on how backwards compatibility problems between ActiveX and the new version of Internet Explorer 7 are causing most of South Korea to hold off on upgrading to Vista because of how incompatibilities could interfere with that country's banking system.
Another fire this snafu is sure to fuel is rhetoric from the part of the Web 2.0 camp that offers alternatives to locally hosted programs like QuickBooks. For example, this problem with upgrades is exactly the sort of problem that NetSuite CEO Zach Nelson uses to justify his browser-based hosted solution over his competitor QuickBooks. With browser-based hosted solutions such as NetSuite, compatibility with the browsers is all that's important (and something that hosted solution providers like NetSuite have plenty of time to resolve).
I've reached out to Microsoft for its take on the issue with the position that Intuit is indeed a bellwether software developer and how incompatibilities with its software could cause the entire industry to take a deep breath. Not only does this affect potential upgrades to Vista on existing systems, the problem also has ramifications for hardware vendors who are hoping to capitalize on Vista's launch by offering a slew of new systems that are pre-loaded with Microsoft's new flagship OS. I've yet to hear back.
Well that means there are huge issues with vista & it doesn't look like they are going to get resolved.
ta mick
and it is because Intuit is lazy and designed it wrong. But then genius that you are. You already knew that. Why do youy think that Quickbooks was never certified for Windows XP. It was because they took shortcuts to communicate via the registry which MS has said since Windows 2000 came on sale, was the wrong way to do that.
]The Korea news is just that OLD news.
Just let the thread die=I am.
MIke
by gsaravin9
accountants occssionally & none of them want vista on their systems because of the unknown.They can't afford to loose money & time on vista.
They are quite happy to stay with XP.
Similarly i don't know of any financial institution or insurance companies that are ready to take up vista now or in the immediate future.There's too much at risk!
ta mick
Ps michael you were off for a while i thought you might be sick
by hal 9000
I walked into Jaycar and bought a Back wards Clock Movement and fitted it to the M$ Provided Partner Demo Readiness Toolkit along with a stand. It confuses the hell out of everyone who sees it as they all think that they are going mad because it's going back wards. :D
They only supplied a RC2 Beta Version that was supposed to be provided in November and came in early February after the Production Version went on sale to the General Public.
Col
by gsaravin9
perhaps ms could make use of such a clock with an addition of a cuckoo on it to remind them of their dud os.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
give me the wrong advice at times.i don't beleive you should pay for advice unless you go to a lawyer.
I usually consult with my colleagues & i go back to the manufactures.One has to reminisce on the early days of dos.They were sort of hectic by the seat of your pants survival days.I miss those days as now there's hardly anything to do as it's all automated.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
it's a big mother of a flop.People are comparing it to millenium release.as everyone knows millenium was a hideous failure.Vista?s development cycle has suffered some serious, well-documented problems. Group projects with that many internal difficulties and delays rarely turn out well. To make matters worse, many features that were to be included in Vista, such as the WinFS file system, were cut. Add that to Vista?s high system requirements, and many users might decide not to buy the expensive new hardware needed to run an expensive, unproven operating system, especially one with such widespread developmental woes. The tech world has changed drastically since the days of DOS and Windows 95, and it may no longer be possible for a single company to enjoy near-ubiquity in all aspects of computing.What does that mean for Microsoft? If Vista flops, Microsoft?s monopoly will not vanish; sheer inertia alone will see to that. But it will erode at an increasingly rapid rate, especially if aggressive contenders, like Ubuntu Linux and Boot Camp-equipped Intel Macs, can make inroads. The failure of Vista would not doom Microsoft-Office alone would see to that-but Microsoft might well suffer a serious loss of power and influence.
So is Windows Vista a coming triumph for Microsoft, or a catastrophe in the making? Which potential future do you see coming
true?
ta mick
by gsaravin9
BigPond and Optus broadband slip on Vista
7th February 2007 Dan Warne Internet, The Invistagator, Vista
Customers of the largest Australian internet providers face a wait of a month or more before they'll be able to easily connect PCs running Vista up to broadband.
The problem stems from the largest providers' use of cheap USB broadband modems rather than the marginally more expensive Ethernet ones that don't require drivers.
The drivers required for the USB modems aren't yet available from all modem manufacturers.
In fact, Telstra is refusing point-blank at this stage to connect new ADSL or Cable customers if they're running Vista.
An Optus customer service representative told APC it would not be able to connect Vista users to Optus broadband until 1st March.
Whirlpool.net.au News Editor Phil Sweeney said it was time for providers to stop using cheap USB modems and spend a couple of dollars more per modem for ethernet models.
"USB modems made more sense in the past when computers didn't have Ethernet ports built in, but these days they cause more problems with drivers than they're worth and they're generally considered to be less reliable," he said.
He advised broadband users to check if their USB modem had an Ethernet port on the back as well and use that instead. However, he conceded that people might not be able to get much help from Optus or Telstra in configuring the modems, as neither company provides tech support to Vista users yet.
However, the problem this time round is compounded by the fact that most new computers being sold at retail now have Vista pre-loaded.
Microsoft's stance on the modem problem
A Microsoft Australia spokesperson said the lack of drivers for USB broadband modems "Microsoft does not develop specific hardware drivers for broadband modem or other devices. This is the responsibility of the hardware vendor to develop the driver to meet new rules for device drivers in Windows Vista. Most companies are offering updated drivers via the vendor web site for download."
"Vista has been in development for more than 18 months and the public date for launch known for about 3 months previously. At launch more than 1.5M devices work with Windows Vista and more than 4,200 hardware and software products have been through the rigorous Windows Hardware Quality Lab and Windows software testing process and received either a Certified for Windows Vista or a Works with Windows," the company said.
Microsoft Australia could not immediately provide a list of USB modems that Vista supports in its shipping driverbase, but forwarded the enquiry to Microsoft USA for response.They are still waiting.
What the ISPs are saying
Telstra BigPond has published an FAQ stating that it will not be able to connect new customers to ADSL or Cable if they are running Windows Vista on their computers.
"Whenever a new operating system is introduced, hardware upgrades are required across the board. The launch of Vista means ISPs worldwide will be beholden to their hardware/modem suppliers for Vista drivers," spokesperson Bronwyn Winley said.
BigPond only has drivers for its wireless broadband card so far, and if you buy a new Vista computer and want to get ADSL or Cable connected, don't call Telstra.
OptusNet said it already supported six operating systems but "only recently learned that Vista brings with it some problem elements that require us to change our systems."
It is now "fast tracking" the training of staff to support Vista users and expects to have this completed in "coming months". The telco said it would work with customers on a case-by-case basis if they had problems with OptusNet and Vista.
On request for further information from Optus on whether the USB modems it has distributed to customers have Vista driver support but it refused.
Netspace Managing Director Stuart Marburg said his tech support team would start supporting Vista in coming months, but needed to make sure enough members of the helpdesk team were trained in Vista before officially supporting it. He said Netcomm had supplied Vista drivers for some of its newer modems -- NB5 and NB8W, but Marburg said he wanted the technical team to test the drivers further before officially supporting them.
iiNet said it had trained all of its senior tech support staff on Vista and put Vista machines into its call centres. However, it said ongoing training of all the rest of the tech support staff was ongoing, so it was possible that customers may initially reach someone not yet trained in supporting Vista. In such cases, the customer could generally be transferred on to a Vista specialist perhaps at some indian call centre.
Internode said its long-standing policy of supporting any operating system that included TCP/IP holds true with Vista. "Internode as a matter of policy sells and prefers to support ethernet based modems for ADSL due to their demonstrated advantages in terms of compatibility and lack of USB driver issues," Internode Managing Director Simon Hackett.
What the modem makers say about Vista compatibility
Linksys told APC it was planning to support Vista on "select" devices and it has published a list of models that are currently supported or have drivers "coming soon". An ominous footnote at the end of the page states "If your Linksys product does not appear on any of these three lists, there is no plan to support the product with Windows Vista."
Linksys models listed as having Vista drivers "coming soon" include AG241 and WAG54G.
Billion Australia said the company had only ever shipped a small quantity of one USB modem at the request of a particular ISP, preferring instead to sell Ethernet models that did not require drivers. He said Billion Electric in Taiwan had not announced plans for Vista driver support for this model, BiPAC 7001, at this stage.
Belkin modem product manager Anthony Malone said "Our F5D5730au v3000 has USB drivers for Vista. We are in final testing and should have them posted to our web site by mid Feb." Belkin will offer tech support on products the company has been able to qualify as working with Vista.
NETGEAR said none of its current ADSL modems or modem/routers include a USB port. However, some older single port-modems, the DM602 (discontinued in 2004) and the DG632 (discontinued in 2006) included a USB port, but also included an Ethernet port. "At this stage, it does not appear NETGEAR will be able to release Vista-compatible USB drivers for either of these devices. However, both devices do also contain an Ethernet port which does not require driver support, and will therefore work with Vista," the company said.
"All NETGEAR's router and modem products are administered using a web GUI, and are able to be administered from a Vista PC without any need for an update. NETGEAR is currently rolling out formal support for customers using Vista. In the meantime, support is being provided on a best-effort basis. "
D-link said it was working 'full steam ahead' on Vista drivers for its USB modems and had added 20 drivers in the past day (including drivers for its current-model DSL-200 and DSL-502T USB modems) to its tech support site.
The company is offering tech support for customers having difficulty getting their modem working with Vista, and is currently in the process of setting up a dedicated Vista page on its web site to make it easier for customers to get drivers.
Netcomm said it had released drivers for the NetComm have released Vista drivers for the following products:AM5066, NB1, NB5 series, NB6 series, NB8W, NP542 / NP543 / NP544 and would have Vista drivers for other wireless and USB products "shortly".
Draytek, Thomson/Alcatel and OPEN Networks were contacted but are yet to respond.
... and then there's wireless broadband
Wireless broadband services that use PCMCIA cards for laptops are also beholden to their hardware providers writing Vista drivers.
Unwired said it had already produced new drivers for customers with the PCMCIA card and customers could either call in to get a CD posted to them, or download them from the Unwired web site when they're made available in a few days' time.
"Like most people, we've known about Vista for a fair while -- we've been monitoring it for the last 12 months and been working with the developer for the last two months," Unwired spokesman Tyson Bowen said.
Competitor iBurst said it had beta drivers available and expected to have final drivers available by the end of the month.
The Telstra BigPond Wireless PCMCIA card has Vista drivers available, however customers would need to download and install the latest BigPond Wireless Connection Manager software.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
NVIDIA owners threaten class action over Vista drivers (or lack of them)
6th February 2007 Dan Warne PC Hardware
Sprung: an NVIDIA video card with "Windows Vista Ready" labeling in-storeGPU giant NVIDIA is facing a possible class action by irate users who claim they were mislead by "Vista ready" logos on NVIDIA graphic card packaging.
The threatened lawsuit stems from the fact that NVIDIA is yet to ship final Vista-compatible drivers, while its arch-rival ATI released final drivers on the same day Vista was released to consumers.
A website -- www.nvidiaclassaction.org -- has been set up to collect the grievances of NVIDIA GPU owners.
NVIDIA's latest beta Forceware drivers, version 100.59, work for some people but not others. The company has been struggling to get GeForce 8800 cards working properly under Vista, despite marketing them as having DirectX 10 compatibility.
An earlier version, 97.46, is listed as being WHQL certified and is not listed as a beta, however a bold disclaimer notes, "These NVIDA Windows Vista drivers are under development. This version is not fully optimised for full 3D performance and may not include all available features available on different operating systems. NVIDIA, along with the industry, is continuing to update its Windows Vista drivers to ensure maximum performance on 3D applications and add support for features."
The company goes on to say, "These drivers are provided "AS IS." NVIDIA MAKES NO REPRESENTATIONS OR WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND WHATSOVER AS TO MERCHANTABILITY, COMPATIBILITY, PERFORMANCE, APPLICATION OR FUNCTION, AND DISCLAIMS ALL SUCH WARRANTIES TO THE FULLEST EXTENT ALLOWED BY LAW."
In other words, "they may not work -- don't sue us."
The problem with that is that NVIDIA has been marketing many of its graphics cards as "Vista ready" for months, which, it could be argued, has influenced the buying decisions of thousands of people.
While NVIDIA may argue that "Vista ready" means something specific, consumer law generally uses the interpretation of the ordinary consumer to judge what an advertising claim actually 'means'.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
Logitech, Creative, NVIDIA driver disgrace
1st February 2007 James Bannan PC Hardware, Vista, Windows
OK, time to rant for a bit. Vista is out and I?d like to be able to upgrade my main home computer. I?ve got the software ? all I need to do is throw in the DVD and I?m away.
Why do I want to upgrade? Well, I?d like to be able to put forward loads of cogent arguments as to why Vista is such an incredible operating system for home users, but I?d need to ingest a few mind-bending substances before I could.
To be honest, other than some nice extra applications and a new look, I can?t think of a single, substantial reason for any home user to spend the bucks and move away from Windows XP.
I?m only considering it myself because I?d be letting myself down as an IT journo and desktop administrator not to.
And yet, I can?t upgrade. Why not? Well, I have this embarrassing problem of owning a Creative Audigy 2 ZS soundcard and a Logitech MX3000 keyboard/mouse combo.
They?re great products and I love using them, but apparently both vendors approach new operating systems with the same amount of trepidation as you?d approach a cobra.
The final, shipping version of Vista has been out for two months now to business and hardware vendors and now every version of Vista is commercially available.
And yet, Creative is still only offering beta drivers. Still, that?s better than Logitech, who aren?t offering ANY Vista solution for current devices using SetPoint at all. Actually, that?s not exactly true ? there is version 3.3 of SetPoint available, which supports a couple of the very latest Logitech keyboard/mouse combos, but nothing for other, reasonably recent devices. Guess there?s little benefit to being a loyal Logitech customer.
Considering the sheer length of time manufacturers have had to get their drivers ready for Vista, it?s nothing short of disgraceful to find two apparent industry leaders caught in such a position ? incapable of offering their customers a smooth transition to a new operating system.
Actually, make that three industry leaders ? NVIDIA won?t have their final-release Vista drivers out for about another month. AMD had theirs out the same day Vista was released. Intel had the vast majority of their final release drivers out when Vista RTM was released. Pay attention the rest of you ? it CAN be done! You?re just waaaaaay behind!
I?ve spent a lot of money on my system and I?m certainly not going to spend more on it just because a couple of manufacturers haven?t got their act together. Guess that Vista upgrade is just going to have to wait -- either that, or I upgrade my hardware to something compatible and vow never to buy Logitech, Creative or NVIDIA ever .
ta mick
by hal 9000
I was asked to ring back when I had a solution to the problem and tell them how I had worked around the problem. That was with SP1 for XP.
I guess that shows just how much I ring M$ for help but it also shows why I don't need to as I'm pretty much left on my own.
But my all time favourite was back in the DOS days getting an error message that Device 6 was missing. After spending hours on the phone to M$ I was eventually told that I had failed to fit the CPU on a P 90 so I asked how I was getting a screen display without a CPU? Their answer was I had forgotten to fit the CPU a wipe of the HDD and reload cured the problem as it was obviously a install problem but I still get a good laugh whenever I think of that one. :D
Col
by gsaravin9
I'm not overly pleased.It's got it's deficiencies.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
what i have said still holds.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
heaps of people are switched after they have tried vista & think it's aflop.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
Vista is a flop like Millenium
Hi,
I have been working in the industry for a long
time and this OS is not up to my expectations.
I believe it is a big flop just as the Millenium OS. It is bulky and not user friendly. Menus are to say the least awkward and when I tried to default to classic windows settings it took me some time to get there. All in all I rather stay with WinXp and keep upgrading 'till
the release of something better.
Sincerely,
David
well need we say more
ta mick
by gsaravin9
thanks for your "continued" contribution.
Keep up the good work i'm proud of you son.Mustn't use up the reserve fat we need it for the spring time!
ta mick
by gsaravin9
in the final analisys ms is the one who got it al wrong!
ta mick
we don't get anything but headaches from ms.
by gsaravin9
if you look at what's happening you'll agree.
ta
m
i
c
k
by gsaravin9
KOREA: Vista incompatible with some Korean websites
Improved security of Windows Vista causes problems for users trying to access some websites
Korea Herald
Tuesday, February 20, 2007
By Hwang Si-young
Microsoft Korea launched Windows Vista, Office System 2007 and Exchange Server 2007 for home PC users on Jan. 31 this year, promoting the latest operating version's enhanced security and three-dimensional graphic functionality. But despite much fanfare, the new system's strong security features are creating problems in Korea.
"As Koreans do a lot of commerce transactions and download government data via the internet, the incompatibility between the Vista and internet sites has surfaced as a new problem," said an official at the Information Ministry.
Internet transactions account for about 20 percent of the nation's total commerce deals. Koreans downloaded 1.43 million government-issued documents last year. It is, however, not uncommon to see shaky screens when a Vista user wants to download data or view video clips on major portal sites as the content is all or partly blocked.
The incompatibility occurs as Vista is stripped of the "Active X" technology, a security tool used by most Korea-based internet shopping, government and online gaming websites. Microsoft Korea cited Active X's vulnerability to vicious codes as the reason for discontinuing the technology.
Faced with resulting possible technical glitches, commercial lenders such as Shinhan Bank, Woori Bank and Hana Bank have taken proper measures. Users of these banks' websites can expect normal services regardless of which type of system they choose. Other commercial lenders and brokerages such as Samsung Securities and Korea Securities said they will take steps no later than March this year.
Online portals including Yahoo, Naver, Daum, and Empas, and internet shopping malls such as www.auction. co.kr, www.interpark.co.kr and www.ticketlink.co.kr, are currently offering normal services. Lineage, a popular online gaming service, said it would make its program compatible with the new operating system by the end of February.
Meanwhile, experts have divided opinions about Vista's future success in the Korean market.
"Windows Vista's functional enhancement will lead to increased demand for more powerful PCs, more memory capacities, including flash memory and dynamic random access memory chips," Chung Chang-won, an analyst at Daewoo Investment & Securities, told The Korea Herald.
"The launch will help boost the liquid crystal display market as well, which has been a bit sluggish for the past two years. Twenty-inch or bigger LCDs, considered fit for three-dimensional graphic and video clip viewing, will be in high demand thanks to the debut of the latest operating system," he said.
Skeptics, however, said the launch will only have limited effects.
Chung Woo-chul, a software analyst at Tong Yang Investment & Securities, said companies will not go to the trouble of changing their existing office systems as long as they are not inconvenienced at work.
"Companies were willing to change software and IT systems in the past, but things are now a bit different except for new start-ups who have to set up all new software and systems," Chung said.
Date Posted: 2/20/2007
ta mick
by gsaravin9
The Register ? Security ? Vista security overhaul questioned
User Account Control: insecure by design?
By John Leyden → More by this authorPublished Monday 19th February 2007 12:40 GMTInterested in this story? Receive others like it on your desktop as they break. Security researchers have taken issue with Microsoft's implementation of a security feature in Vista that is designed to stop users from routinely running systems in admin mode.
Users of Windows XP and older Microsoft operating systems habitually ran PCs in admin mode, which gives unrestricted access to the system. As a result, malware attacks carried the ability to take over compromised systems which wouldn't normally be possible if a machine was running in user mode.
The User Account Control (UAC) security functionality of Windows Vista is designed to address this problem by obliging users to run their Vista PCs via a normal user account by default. Users are asked to switch modes and enter login credentials when they request a task requiring admin credentials.
White hat hacker Joanna Rutkowska discovered that users attempting to run an installation file need to do so in admin mode. That means users are confronted with the all-or-nothing choice of granting an installed program complete system privileges or abandoning an installation altogether.
"That means that if you downloaded some freeware Tetris game, you will have to run its installer as administrator, giving it not only full access to all your file system and registry," Rutkowska writes, adding that Win XP gave her the ability to add permissions to her normal (restricted) user account that isn't possible with Vista.
Mark Russinovich, a technical fellow at Microsoft, argues in a detailed response that the design of Vista's User Account Control balances security and usability.
Rutkowska acknowledges that Microsoft has improved the security of its operating system with Vista but warns that the security shortcomings of UAC can not be so easily dismissed. "UAC is not perfect [but that] doesn't diminish the fact that it's a step in the right direction, implementing a least-privilege policy in Windows OS," she writes.
Rutkowska takes issue with Microsoft's contention that flaws in UAC controls don't in themselves create security bugs. She points, by way of example, to a security bug she has discovered which allows a low integrity level process to send WM_KEYDOWN messages to a command prompt window running at high integrity level as among the types of problems she is seeking to highlight. ?
ta mick
by gsaravin9
Vista raises the bar for flaw finders
But the battle's not over yet
By Robert Lemos, SecurityFocus → More by this authorPublished Wednesday 31st January 2007 11:54 GMTReceive articles like this on your desktop as they break, click here. Microsoft launched its latest operating system - Windows Vista - on Monday, a move that will make finding easily exploitable vulnerabilities a lot harder, according to security researchers.
In a launch event in New York City, the software giant took the wraps off both Windows Vista and its Office 2007 productivity suite. Long awaited, Windows Vista brings together a number of security features, some aimed at hardening the operating system against attack and others designed to encourage users to make security a priority when using their PCs.
"None of the features in Windows Vista, either individually or together, are meant to be bulletproof," said Stephen Toulouse, senior product manager for Microsoft's Security Technology Unit. "But the defense-in-depth will significantly raise the security level compared to Windows XP."
The launch of its latest operating system comes five years after the company restructured its approach to software security with the Trustworthy Computing Initiative. The revamped strategy - prompted by the Code Red and Nimda worms that struck a massive number of the software giant's customers in the summer of 2001 - led to a massive push to educate developers and provide tools to weed out software bugs. In 2004, Microsoft refocused Windows XP Service Pack 2, making the update almost completely about security.
While other applications, including Internet Explorer 7 and Office 2007, have benefited from Microsoft's secure development lifecycle, the development of Windows Vista was the first time the software giant's consumer operating system was designed from the ground up with a focus on security. For example, the operating system enforces least-privilege rules of access, requesting the user's password to execute certain higher privilege tasks. The software giant has also improved the operating system's firewall and revamped the Security Centre to give more information to users. Internet Explorer 7 brings additional security enhancements, such as limiting ActiveX controls and significant anti-phishing features.
For security researchers, however, it's what's under the hood that matters. Three major features will make Vista more difficult to exploit even when vulnerabilities are found: Kernel Patch Protection, Data Execution Prevention, and Address Space Layout Randomisation.
The controversial Kernel Patch Protection, also known as PatchGuard, limits the practice of some software developers of creating add-on features for the operating system by patching the kernel, the core system software. Many security software makers have criticised the feature because it limits their software's ability to modify the core features offered by the Windows operating system.
"This is especially popular among anti-virus products, which sometimes use exactly the same hooking techniques as some popular malware, like rootkits," Joanna Rutkowska, senior researcher for COSEINC Advanced Malware Labs, said in an email interview with SecurityFocus. "This is not good, not only because it may have potential impact on system stability, but it also confuses malware detection tools."
Such restrictions are good for the overall security of the Windows platform, but it's not comprehensive by any means, Rutkowska said. PatchGuard only protects against modifications to code and static-kernel objects, what Rutkowska calls type-I infections. It does not detect modifications to dynamic structures (type-II infections) nor does it detect modifications to code running through hardware virtualisation (type-III infections), she said.
Track this type
ta mick
by gsaravin9
Bookmark With Del.icio.us
Digg This Article
Search With Technorati
Print This Article Date: January 25, 2007
Author(s): Rob Williams
Does performance suck on Vista when compared to XP? That's what I was set out to find out. I was worried at first, since the performance in Beta 2 was quite bad. While there is indeed a performance decrease, it's quite minimal as you'll find out.
Last summer, I wrote an article entitled "Windows Vista Beta 2 Performance Reports" which attracted a lot of attention. In fact, it proved to be our second most popular article of 2006, so it's clear that people who are looking to purchase Vista truly care about whether or not they will lose a good deal of performance when making the move.
Well, that article was more for fun since it was indeed based on a beta operating system. I noted there that when the RTM became available, I would revisit all of the benchmarks mentioned there and come up with a more appropriate conclusion. I received a lot of criticism for that article, but most people didn't seem to see the "Beta 2" in the title. I was completely aware that the performance seen there did not reflect the actual performance differences in the final release.
I will admit one thing, the RTM is -far- superior to Beta 2... there is no comparison. I have been using Vista Ultimate RTM full time on my Windows rig for over two months and haven't run into any serious problems, except for a few of my favorite applications that still do not function. I've found the system to be much more stable overall and speedier as well. It still has lingering issues, but I mention most of those in my rant article from this past Tuesday.
Back to performance. This article will not go into depth like the other one did. In fact, it will be split into two articles. There is a gaming performance article on the way, but we are still awaiting final drivers from NVIDIA before proceeding with it.
Testing Overview & Methodology
For our performance testing today, I will be using my Intel dual-core rig. The goal of the article is to show the direct performance decrease you will experience when making the move. Take note though, that the difference on your system may vary from my results, especially if you are using an older machine. I chose to use a "midstream" PC to benchmark with, as most people reading this may have a similar setup. If you use a computer that's more than 2 years old, with a small GPU or one that has only 1GB of ram, you can expect Vista to not run that seamlessly.
I will be comparing the performance from a freshly formatted machine with both an XP Professional and Vista Ultimate installation. I will be using a variety of synthetic benchmarks and also real world benchmarks that touch on multi-media tasks. All tests are performed on machines that are -not- altered for the best performance. Normally when we benchmark memory or a CPU, we disable many services and close needless programs before doing so. This will not be done here, as realistically, this is not what people do prior to crunching a video file or playing a game. No post-install third party applications will be left running though... just default system services.
Testing System
Intel E6300 Dual Core @ 1.866GHz
ASUS P5N-E SLI 0307 BIOS
Corsair 2GB PC2-9136 @ DDR2-1066 4-4-4-12
ASUS EN7900GT 256MB
Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 320GB
Corsair HX620W Power Supply
Corsair Nautilus 500 Water Cooling
LG 18x DVD-Burner
D-Link WiFi Card
NZXT Apollo Case
Prior to benchmarking, the system is "cleaned" up. Needless scattered files on the desktop are removed, and post-install applications are closed down if they are running in the background.
Throughout all of these charts, you will see many deltas. These symbolize the advantage or disadvantage Vista Ultimate has over XP.
SANDRA 2007
First up is SANDRA, one of my favorite benchmarks.
XP Professional
Sandra Arithmetic
MIPS: 17116
MFLOPS: 11906
Sandra Multi-Media
Int: 102632
Float: 55427
Sandra File Systems
Avg. Read: 63MB/s
Latency: 8ms
Sandra Memory
Int: 5773
Float: 5775
Vista Ultimate
Sandra Arithmetic
MIPS: 17037
MFLOPS: 11905
Sandra Multi-Media
Int: 102281
Float: 55338
Sandra File Systems
Avg. Read: 61MB/s
Latency: 7ms
Sandra Memory
Int: 5782
Float: 5717
.
Delta
- 0.46%
- 0.008%
Delta
- 0.34%
- 0.16%
Delta
- 3.28%
+ 14.8%
Delta
+ 0.16%
- 0.66%
There's very little difference here so far... less than 1% all around.
Cinebench, Sciencemark, 3D Mark 06
The same goes for here with Cinebench, but I started to see even larger differences with Sciencemark where the delta was closer to 3.5%. Super Pi also proved 19 seconds slower under Vista.
XP Professional
Cinebench 2003
Single Thread: 312
Multi-Thread: 581
Sciencemark 2 (Lower is Better)
Mol Dyn: 83.72s
Cipher: 15.39s
3D Mark 06
4907
Super Pi
32 Million: 25m 0s
Vista Ultimate
Cinebench 2003
Single Thread: 312
Multi-Thread: 579
Sciencemark 2 (Lower is Better)
Mol Dyn: 86.58s
Cipher: 16.06s
3D Mark 06
4693
Super Pi
32 Million: 25m 19s
.
Delta
- 0.00%
- 0.34%
Delta
- 3.41%
- 4.35%
Delta
- 4.56%
Delta
- 1.27%
The 3D Mark score is about 300 points lower on Vista, but please don't take that result too seriously at this point. NVIDIA is working around the clock on final Vista drivers, so the performance may improve when they are finally out the door.
Hard Drive Benchmarks
Overall with the disk access benchmarks, the only tests that had a rather large differences was with the burst and minimum speed tests. In both HD Tach and HD Tune, the Avg. MB/s proved no different at all, which is good to see.
XP Professional
HD Tach
Burst Read: 134.5MB/s
Avg. Read: 66.2MB/s
Latency: 13.4ms
HD Tune
Min: 30.6MB/s
Avg: 62.3MB/s
Max: 76.3MB/s
Latency: 13.4ms
CPU Usage: 2.6%
Vista Ultimate
HD Tach
Burst Read: 120.7MB/s
Avg. Read: 66.2MB/s
Latency: 13.4ms
HD Tune
Min: 36.6MB/s
Avg: 62.3MB/s
Max: 76.5MB/s
Latency: 13.5ms
CPU Usage: 7.7%
.
Delta
- 11.43%
- 0.00%
- 0.00%
Delta
+ 19.6%
- 0.00%
+ 0.26%
- 0.74%
N/A
The only thing that stands out to me here is the fact that HD Tune required over 5% more CPU power during usage. This could be the result of Vista forcing a Windows XP program to function. By default, it did not function in Vista, but adjusting the compatibility fixed everything.
Real World Benchmarks
For some light real world testing, I chose a few programs to conduct multi-media recoding. For Sony Vegas, I took a 50MB .divx file, recoded it to a high-definition profile and added a watermark. For Nero Record, I took a DVD from Volume 4 of the Family Guy collection and recoded it to fit on a backup sized DVD (4.5GB). Lastly, for LAME, I first ripped Voodoo & Serano: Cold Blood to a single .WAV file. Then I ran than through a "lame -b 320 vns.wav" command.
XP Professional
Multi-Media Recode (Lower is Better)
Sony Vegas: 18m 38s
Nero Recode: 9m 56s
LAME Recode: 3m 59s
Vista Ultimate
Multi-Media Recode (Lower is Better)
Sony Vegas: 18m 21s
Nero Recode: 10m 31s
LAME Recode: 4m 07s
.
Delta
+ 1.5%
- 5.87%
- 3.34%
Interestingly enough, Vegas proved a touch better under Vista, but it fell short with the other two tests.
Final Thoughts
I don't necessarily recommend Vista to anyone at this point in time, simply because it's not needed. In the two months that I've been using it full time on my Windows machine, I've run into too many weird bugs that I would have liked to have avoided. This ranges from applications not working, quirky UI glitches or hardware drivers not working as well as they should.
That aside though, it's no secret that many out there are dying to install it on their system, which is fine. As we have seen from the performance results above, should you stick with XP to save on performance? Hardly... there was not much of a difference between XP and Vista overall, I'm actually quite impressed.
As I mentioned earlier though, if you run an older machine, you probably will see a greater slowdown than I did. My test rig consisted of a nice processor, midstream GPU and 2GB of ram. If you run a last-gen CPU, low-end GPU and 1GB of ram, chances are good that you will have a sluggish running system.
What should you take away from this article? The fact that Vista actually isn't -that- bad performance wise, if you have a decent machine. It's leaps and bounds above the performance I saw in Beta 2, so I have no major complaints. In the months to come, companies should be continually releasing more Vista-friendly drivers, so the stability/performance side of things should get even better.I thought it was better??
ta mick
by gsaravin9
Windows XP vs. Vista: The Benchmark Rundown
Patrick Schmid, Achim Roos
January 29, 2007 09:16
Is Windows Vista Faster Than XP?
Our Windows Vista coverage began with a hands-on diary by MobilityGuru's Barry Gerber, followed by an assessment of gameplay under Windows Vista by graphics presidente Darren Polkowski, as well as a complete feature rundown of Vista. Barry took the new operating system and its look & feel with a grain of salt, while Darren was disappointed because OpenGL support was dropped along the way, meaning that Windows Vista currently offers horrible performance for graphics applications utilizing the Open Graphics Library.
We are sure that mainstream users will appreciate the improved usability of Windows Vista, and the average office/multimedia user will likely never notice the lack of OpenGL. However, a chapter on the overall performance of Windows Vista requires more dedication. In particular, two things require an in-depth analysis:
Basic Windows Vista Performance
How does Windows Vista perform compared to Windows XP? Will applications execute equally quickly, or will they even run slower due to the new features and the AeroGlass interface?
Windows Vista Performance Enhancements
With SuperFetch and ReadyBoost, Windows Vista introduces two features to make use of today's technology in order to improve the user experience. This means that more application data should be actively cached into all available memory (SuperFetch), whether that is physical RAM or a USB Flash memory device (ReadyBoost). Microsoft's goal was to create balanced performance by removing delays in everyday work.
This article deals with basic application execution under Windows Vista Enterprise, which is representative of the other editions. We put together a high-end test system and performed a comprehensive benchmark session both with Windows XP Professional and with Windows Vista Enterprise to see if there are differences. And indeed, we found that there are some...
Software And Vista
Although the main Windows Vista core has undergone lot of modifications, many of your applications will work with Vista. There is, however, no guarantee. You should definitely try any essential software on Windows before you upgrade.
Process scheduling and thread pooling have been improved in Vista; a deadlock protection mechanism and hardware partitioning for virtualization support were added, together with many more features.
We tried lots of different programs under Windows Vista Enterprise, and came up with a list of software that definitely works.
Games
Call of Duty 2
Far Cry
F.E.A.R.
Unreal Tournament 2004
Applications
Adobe Acrobat 8
Adobe Photoshop CS2
Autodesk 3DSMax 8.0
AutoGK 2.4
Hamachi
KeePass 1.06
LAME MP3 Encoder
MainConcept H.264 Encoder
Miranda Messager 0.5.1
Microsoft Office 2003
Microsoft Office System 2007
Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.1
Mozilla Thunderbird 1.5.0.9
Nokia PC Suite 6.82.22.0
Ogg Vorbis 1.1.2
OpenOffice 2.1
Picasa 2
Putty
Skype 2.5.x and 3.0
SmartFTP 2.0
Sungard Adaptive Credit Risk Calculation 3.0
SonyEricsson PC Suite 1.30.82
SQLyog 5.22
Symantec AntiVirus 10.2.0.224
UltraEdit 32 12.10
WinRAR 3.70
XviD 1.2.0
Benchmarks
3DMark 06
Cinebench
PCMark05 Pro
SiSoft Sandra 2007
SPECviewperf 9.03
In other cases there were some issues.
We found Vista updates for the Futuremark benchmark programs 3DMark and PCMark, as well as the popular data compression tool WinRAR. Lots of video-related software such as DivX could no longer be installed; new versions are required. The popular audio player WinAMP 5.32 throws up an error at startup, yet it works properly. Quake IV can still be executed, but the installation program did not work. Applications that run their own memory management won't benefit from Vista's SuperFetch function. For example, Adobe Photoshop takes care of creating a temporary work file every time it launches - Vista has no access to this process and cannot speed it up.
There are some types of software that you should only use if they have been specifically designed for Windows Vista: firewalls, anti-spyware and anti-virus software needs to be Vista-Ready.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
is a complete flop in performance gaming.
check it out for yourselves.This should put any ideas that ms has given us an improvrd system to xp rather a big bloat.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
xp wins hands down.Confirming all allong what i have said as far as needing to upgrade they recommend a clean install.
Once again time is on my side all my years of testing etc etc has confirmed that vista is one giant flop!!
ta mick
by gsaravin9
what aflop 64 bit is telling people that it's ready when it's not.
Vista x64
One of the major changes on paper for Vista is that x64 now becomes an equal platform with the x86 version, as using the Vista compatibility logo on any hardware or software requires that the item in question works under both the x86 and x64 versions, but the reality of the situation is not as rosy. Along with the other limitations of the OEM versions we listed above, only the retail versions of Vista are shipping with x64 and x86 together; the OEM versions are only sold in an either/or fashion: you can either get the x64 or x86 version, but not both at once. It's possible that this will be trivially easy to work around, however it's something that should be kept in mind if you're purchasing an OEM copy.
As for how well the x64 versions of Vista work, in our first article we called x64 the black sheep of the Vista family, as it was clearly behind the x86 version in terms of compatibility and performance. While we had hoped that Microsoft would remove the gap between the two versions, in our testing this has not completely been the case. Vista x64 is still the product of all the compatibility problems of Vista with all the compatibility problems of a still-young 64-bit platform.
This is not to say that Vista x64 hasn't improved; if anything it has improved more between Beta 2 and now than the x86 version did, if only by virtue of having more ground to cover. The performance gap we initially saw between the x86 and x64 versions has dissolved away in most cases, so x64 no longer means taking an immediate performance hit in benchmarks. However we can't shake the feeling of Vista x64 still being slower, even if the benchmarks don't show it. We've had multiple editors use multiple machines, and general performance in particular just feels slower. At this point we still are unsure why this is, but it's a very real condition that hurts Vista x64.
On the positive side, driver support for the x64 version seems to be about as good as the x86 version (although more testing will be required to completely confirm this). The biggest problem as far as support goes is the applications. Not every application is happy working under the Windows-on-Windows (WoW) compatibility environment for 32-bit applications, and this is on top of the applications that don't work with Vista period. There are very few major applications available with x64 binaries, so without 64-bit applications everything still remains in the 32-bit world for now. Furthermore, as we will also see in our graphics tests, having a 64-bit application doesn't necessarily mean we won't see any performance issues.
At this point Vista x64 is certainly usable if you need it, but we wouldn't recommend it unless you have a specific reason to go that route (i.e. applications that can use more memory). Except in a few cases where 64-bit code is clearly faster, the primary purpose for Vista x64's existence is to resolve the problems of 32-bit addressing space, and we're just not at the point yet where even most enthusiasts are pushing that limit. Once applications begin to push the 2GB addressing space limitation of Win32 (something we expect to hit very soon with games) or total systems need more than 4GB of RAM, then Vista x64 in its current incarnation would be a good choice. In the meantime, Vista x64 shouldn't be used until it's needed or SP1 comes out - whichever comes first. The black sheep isn't ready to rejoin the flock quite yet.
I don't think so it needs to get it's 32 bit in order & maybe later.
My God what a complete flop.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
once again what a flop:
Networking Benchmarks
Just to get a quick idea of what these new features can do, we ran our usual networking benchmark suite on a pair of ASUS P5B-Deluxe motherboards using both the on-board PCI and PCIe connected gigabit network controllers (Marvell 88E8056 and 88E8001 respectively). We used two tests for this, a multiple small file transfer test consisting of about 450 files totaling 600MB, and a large file transfer test consisting of a pair of ISO images totaling 3GB. In order to keep the load on our D-Link Gamer Lounge router consistent, we also had the WMV-HD version of Terminator 3 streaming in the background. We tested Windows XP SP2 for a base score, followed by Vista with Compound TCP switched on and off.
Unfortunately for Vista, neither test is particularly favorable. Compared to XP when Compound TCP is disabled, Vista is anywhere between 25% and 50% slower than XP in terms of the total time required for these tests. Without the ability to separate Vista's networking stack from the drivers for our NICs, it's impossible to tell if this slowdown is the fault of the networking stack being worse for this situation, or if the Vista drivers for this line of Marvell NICs are not quite as tuned, so as a comparison to XP this test is inconclusive. Either way, for this particular setup Vista ends up being slower at file transfers than XP.
The one bright spot however is that when enabled, Compound TCP is clearly having some effect even on our low-latency network. The 5% or so boost in Vista's low scores won't bring it back above XP, but it clearly proves that Compound TCP does have a real-world effect on performance.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
Dell can't make hand-built Vista machines
Can't get the wood you know
By Nick Farrell: Monday 26 February 2007, 06:51
PUNTERS WAITING for Dell to custom build high-end hardware with Microsoft's new Vista operating system might be waiting for Godot.
According to Information Week, Dell has been forced to admit that two of its top end custom built gaming machines can't run Vista.
Two of Dell's high-end PCs, the XPS M1710 notebook and the XPS 710 desktop, both gaming computers, are still shipping with XP because of driver incompatibility with Vista.
A spokesDell said that there were some compatibility problems with some of the peripherals. Dell said that this was the same sort of problem that every hardware outfit has when there is a major shift on an operating system.
However that has not stopped Dell recommending Vista for products that can't use it. Information Week tells the sad story of a bloke who wanted to buy a Latitude D420 notebook because it was recommended as Vista compatible. Then he discovered that all he could have on the laptop was a Bluetooth hardware, a DVD burner and an Intel processor with biometric reader, nothing else would work
that's it folks
ta mick
by gsaravin9
Tuesday 13 Feb 2007 - 09:08
Windows Vista's powerful new graphics engine may be one of its hallmark features, but it's engendering complaints from a key segment of potential early adopters: hardcore gamers.
A small but significant number of games written for Windows XP either crash or creep along slowly on Vista, according to numerous complaints by game enthusiasts in online forums.
"Formatted PC, installed Vista, updated any drivers possible. Now half [of my] games will not run, or run with corrupt graphics," lamented one poster on Jan. 31 in a discussion forum at graphics chipmaker Nvidia's Web site.
"You installed Vista. You deserve your problems. Heh," replied a second poster.
Most of the problems have been found in popular first-person shooter games such as CounterStrike, Half-Life 2, Doom 3 and F.E.A.R.
Games, especially first-person shooters, tend to strain a PC's graphics capabilities much more than business or even multimedia applications.
Besides the occasional crash, the most common reports appear to be games whose animation speed, measured in frames per second, suffers under Vista.
Experts blame still-flaky software drivers, Vista's complexity and a dearth of new video cards optimized for Vista's new rendering technology, DirectX 10.
That's despite promises from Microsoft that Vista is backwards-compatible with XP's graphic engine, DirectX 9, and that it will support existing games.
Meanwhile, games written to take advantage of DirectX 10 have been slow to emerge. And one Nvidia executive predicts that gamers may not routinely see games optimized for DirectX 10 until mid-2008.
It's not that bad, says Microsoft
Chris Donahue, manager of Microsoft's Games for Windows group, says the company has tested 1,000 popular games from the past five years. Most work well with Vista, he said, declining to elaborate how many had problems and why.
Vista's DirectX 10 is reportedly a complete rewrite of Microsoft's graphic engine that should allow games written for the platform to run much faster and display more textured, lifelike images than under DirectX 9.
DirectX 10 is so advanced that even Vista's advanced desktop interface, dubbed "Aero," relies on the previous-generation DirectX 9 technology.
Leading game publishers such as Electronic Arts Inc., PopCap Games Inc., Vivendi Games, THQ Inc., Slam Games and WildTangent Inc. are busily creating games taking advantage of DirectX 10, according to Microsoft. Microsoft, through its MSN Games group, is also releasing a number of less graphically-intensive "casual" games for Vista.
But so far, Microsoft has only shown off -- and only via screenshots and video clips -- a handful of games that truly take advantage of DirectX 10. And many of those improvements appear to be subtle ones that only the most avid gamers will notice.
Nvidia on the hot seat
Besides complaining to Microsoft, users are compiling lists of games that do and do not work on Vista, such as the collections at zetafleet.com(download PDF), compatdb.org and NTcompatible.com.
Graphics chipmakers such as Nvidia Corp., Intel Corp., and Advanced Micro Devices Inc. subsidiary ATI Technologies Inc. are rolling out drivers for existing graphics cards running their chips.
But chipmakers are being criticized because of the slow appearance of those drivers, as well as their unreliability -- even those that have been certified by Microsoft's Windows Hardware Quality Labs (WHQL).
Moreover, graphics chips optimized for DirectX 10 have yet to emerge from Intel or ATI, though the latter is expected to ship its first DirectX 10 processor, the R600, by midspring, according to unconfirmed reports.
Santa Clara, Calif.-based Nvidia has released a processor for DirectX 10, the GeForce 8800. The drivers for the GeForce 8800, however, remain in beta and are not WHQL-certified.
Some users are so disgruntled that they have created a Web site threatening a lawsuit.
"Our [quality assurance staffers] didn't expect there to be an extraordinary number of bugs, but people are hammering pretty hard on Vista, and there are obviously some parts that we missed," said Daniel Vivoli, senior vice president for marketing at Nvidia.
While pointing out that other vendors such as mouse and keyboard maker Logitech International SA, sound card maker Creative Technology Ltd. and Cisco Systems Inc., as well as its wireless print server subsidary, Cisco-Linksys LLC, have also gotten complaints for malfunctioning Vista drivers, Vivoli acknowledged that Nvidia deserves the criticism it is receiving.
"Early adopters of Vista are the PC enthusiasts, and that's where we have 90% market share, so it's not surprising we get more heat than ATI," he said.
In response, Nvidia has created a page where users can directly report any problems with Vista drivers.
It is also devoting heavy resources to fixing those drivers until "everyone is delighted," Vivoli said.
Games slow to level up
So when will Vista-optimized games arrive?
Besides driver problems, the lack of DirectX 10 video cards on the market so far has prevented game publishers from rushing to the new technology. Even Halo 2, Microsoft's massive hit for the Xbox that it is busily porting over for a release later this year on Windows Vista, will still be based on XP's DirectX 9 technology. That is changing. Nvidia said it plans to have an entire "top-to-bottom" family of GeForce 8800 chips by the end of the year.
Microsoft's Donahue, citing unnamed forecasters, predicted that up to 9 million DirectX 10 graphic cards or chip sets will be on the market by the end of this year.
Microsoft is also working closely with game developers to train them in DirectX 10, though it is stopping short of offering financial incentives to move to the new platform.
"I'd be very surprised to see any games that hit the market from this point forward straight out not support Windows Vista," he said.
But others equally plugged into game developers doubt such a quick timetable.
"DirectX 10 is a different way of programming. It's harder," Nvidia's Vivoli said. "I think it will take 12 to 18 months before we start to see all of the gaming titles coming out on DirectX 10."
see ya mick
by gsaravin9
Microsoft fined $1.5B in patent suit
Monday 26 Feb 2007 - 08:53
A jury in federal court in San Diego has ordered that Microsoft pay US$1.5 billion in damages to Alcatel-Lucent for infringing on patents for MP3 encoding and decoding technology.
Alcatel-Lucent, then called Lucent Technologies, first filed suit in 2003 against Microsoft customers Dell and Gateway for infringing on 15 patented technologies it said were being used in the Windows client operating system.
that's it guys
mick
by gsaravin9
alarm bells.
Norton Goes Online
FEBRUARY 26, 2007 | Symantec today rolled out a combination security and online backup service aimed at preventing identity theft and the compromise of other personal data for consumers.
The service includes antivirus, anti-spyware, anti-phishing, two-way firewall, and behavior-based malware detection.
"Most importantly, this [rollout] has all of the transaction security technology," says Roland Trolup, Symantec's vice president of consumer products. "The behavior-based protection system defends against crimeware to detect anything that will steal your identity, credit cards, and passwords," such as keyloggers.
The service is aimed at users who want an all-in-one security solution that does most of the work in the background, and with minimal user interaction. Norton 360 also tunes PC performance by diagnosing and fixing any related problems.
Putting all your eggs in one security basket may be convenient, but it can also be risky, some experts say. "Norton 360's all-encompassing approach to end-user security appears to be a good thing at first, but further inspection will reveal this to be a bad idea. Diversity is a great form of security, and relying on all of your security from one vendor opens you up to problems," says David Maynor, CTO of Errata Security.
"Symantec, just like every other AV vendor, has had problems in their software in the past. When you are 100 percent reliant on them for security, how can you be certain they won't have more problems in the future?"
Norton 360 uses Symantec Online Network for Advanced Response (SONAR) technology for behavior-based malware detection to spot new threats in real-time, and the service also removes rootkits in the kernel.
The new software-as-a-service also performs Web authentication to protect against man-in-the-middle attacks, Symantec's Trolup says, and performs vulnerability assessments to ensure strong passwords and to detect vulnerabilities.
"It checks for browser vulnerabilities, misdirected addresses, too... And it makes sure the computer is configured properly," he says.
For backup, it comes with a two-Gbyte, automated online store. "Over one half of consumers don't do backups, and one of the beliefs is it's too difficult... This automatically does backups for them, so it's simpler," Trolup says. Symantec offers additional storage, too, at $29.99 for 5 Gbytes; $49.99 for 10 Gbytes; and $69.99 for 25 Gbytes.
Norton 360 runs with Windows XP and the 32-bit version of Vista. But some of the security features in Norton 360 won't work out of the box with the 64-bit version of Windows Vista, Trolup says, due to Microsoft's PatchGuard.
"Much of the new behavior-based malware detection against crimeware, screenscrapers, and keyloggers is disabled on the 64-bit version," he says. "The net effect is it's less secure. In fairness, it will give us mechanisms as early as Service Pack 1 to turn those back on."
well guys i was right ms has opened a can of worms.
ta mick cheers!
by gsaravin9
PC Makers' Changing Faces, Apple's Coming 'Bypass Vista' Campaign
Print Version
E-Mail Article
Digg It
Reprints
By Rob Enderle
TechNewsWorld
02/26/07 4:00 AM PT
The last time I saw an effort to displace the PC with Macs in business fail, the cause was the lack of Exchange compatibility. If this is fixed, we could see Macs actually move in business again. Leopard and its surrounding applications have been focused almost specifically to take Vista out at the knees, and I don't think we've seen either Microsoft or Apple with this kind of focused effort on the other -- ever.
there is always the option.
ta guys
mick
by gsaravin9
Vista replacement scheduled for 2009
Microsoft preparing next version of Windows
Tom Sanders in California, vnunet.com 13 Feb 2007
ADVERTISEMENT
Microsoft is preparing to launch the next generation of its Windows operating system by 2009.
Ben Fathi, corporate vice president of development at Microsoft, said at the RSA Security conference in San Francisco last week that the next Windows could take two and a half years to build, putting the final release at the end of 2009.
The launch could put Microsoft back on a release schedule that would see a major operating system launch every other year.
The company previously released new operating systems on a biennial basis, but took more than five years to develop Windows Vista.
Vista was delayed in part because Microsoft pulled engineering resources off the project to work on Windows XP Service Pack 2, an update that overhauled the operating system's security after a slew of attacks against the software.
Fathi suggested that the next version of Windows would contain some of the features that the company stripped from Windows Vista.
Microsoft pulled improvements including a new file system dubbed WinFS, the UEFI Bios replacement and a set of advanced security features from Vista to prevent further product delays.
The company is planning to add support for UEFI through a future update. Instead of implementing its new WinFS file system in its desktop operating system, Microsoft plans to integrate pieces of the technology into the SQL Server database, ActiveX Data Objects and other Microsoft products.
Microsoft has not spoken recently about what is left of its Next Generation Secure Computing Base strategy, which envisioned a bolted down, compartmentalised security structure that would automatically contain attacks.
Kevin Kutz, director of the Windows Client at Microsoft, said in an emailed statement that the company is not yet ready to provide guidance about the next Windows version.
Microsoft has scheduled a Professional Developer Conference in Los Angeles this Autumn.
The events for software developers occur only in years when Microsoft feels it has something new to talk about, and typically cover upcoming Windows versions.
by gsaravin9
Partners report 10 annoying Vista problems as conflicts dampen debut
By Paula Rooney, CRN 19 February 2007 09:20 AEST Platforms & Applications
Vista users facing a higher than usual number of conflicts.
Partners are annoyed by the abundance of software and hardware incompatibilities surfacing as Windows Vista is deployed to more early adopters.
The software giant launched Vista and a companion update called Windows Vista Application Compatibility Update to the market on January 30.
That update, KB929427, handles some of the more problematic application incompatibilities, but the nightmare is far from over, partners say.
It's typical for these conflicts to appear shortly after an operating system is released. The big problem with Vista is not only the number of incompatibilities with existing applications but also the lack of drivers for critical hardware components and hardware peripherals, partners say.
One partner said he is surprised by the lack of Vista drivers available for basic hardware components that keep a PC running.
"Customers upgrading Vista in place may find getting support for existing hardware very challenging," said Phil Aldrich, North American Microsoft Practice Manager for Dimension Data North America, a US$3.1 billion solution provider.
"Tons of vendors haven't done Vista drivers and that's left a big hole in support. I can understand when it comes to printers and scanners, but when we're talking about hard drives, chipset controllers and video cards, things that run the PC, it's surprising," he said. "It's not just peripherals but primary component manufacturers aren't ready, and that unusual compared to the previous releases of Windows."
According to various solution providers contacted by CRN, here are the 10 biggest problems faced by early adopters of Vista out of the gate:
1. Lack of available drivers from ISVs causing application conflicts;
2. Lack of available drivers for existing and new peripherals and hardware components;
3. Buggy drivers;
4. New security feature often flags existing applications as suspicious and interrupts service;
5. Few applications aside from Vista and Office 2007 take advantage of user account control;
6. Customers are confused by Office 2007's ribbon-like user interface;
7. The OS automatically recommends which Vista versions is best for each PCs configuration. This will cause small businesses to download different versions of Vista;
8. Benefits of Vista and Office 2007 running together are not obvious. Partners and IT staff need training for maximum ROI;
9. Deployment isn't easy. Partners should use either Business Desktop Deployment tool, "lite" BDD no-charge tool or other tools;
10. Hardware doesn't run Windows Vista well.
Some speculate hardware and software manufacturers have invested little in updating their current products because they expect most customers will buy a new and associated products to run Vista.
Aldrich maintains, however, that many installed PCs are properly equipped to handle Vista and Office 2007 and the idea that customers must buy new PCs is a myth.
Partners and IT pros are also facing problems with peripherals.
"There's not enough drivers out there. Peripherals manufacturers are not all up to speed with Vista, so be careful what you buy," said Anthony Rodio, chief marketing officer at Supportsoft, a Redwood City, Calif., partner that provides helpdesk support for Windows Vista to enterprises and consumers. "People want to use the functionality in Vista and there are some multimedia, video and sound devices that support Vista, but many peripherals have to catch up."
He noted, for example, that Microsoft's own recently released Zune is not Vista compatible. And he added that one of his technicians recently bought an up-to-date webcam for Windows Vista and it didn't work.
The lack of available Vista drivers for existing software applications is a nightmare, partners say. They don't understand why Microsoft and its ISVs have dragged their feet for so long in developing drivers for existing applications.
The Windows Vista Application Compatibility Update is a package of updates released on January 30 that fixes application compatibility issues with applications like Adobe Photoshop, AVG AntiSpyware, Google Desktop 4 and Roxio Easy Media Creator 7.,5.
But that Vista patch introduced problems with another version of Roxio one partner is using. He reported it to Microsoft but it hasn't been resolved yet.
"So many things just don't work and won't ever work and that's the problem," said Brian Bergin, president of Terabyte Computer, Boone, N.C. "Smartphones, fingerprint scanners, video drivers and both ATI and nVidia's cards are questionable at best, not to mention that many business applications don't work. Microsoft did such a horrible job of working with vendors on legacy XP-Windows 2000 application-hardware compatibility that everything is up in the air."
One of the beauties of Vista is the added security, but in order to use it, you must have updated hardware and drivers for applications," said Aldrich. "And none of the large ISVs have done it."
New security features in Vista are compounding the incompatibility issues, Supportsoft's Rodio said.
"Windows security is nice, but it may interrupt some existing applications you are running, like a travel service or something that Microsoft flags as spyware and interrupts," Rodio added. "It will likely disrupt stuff you've done in the past."
Incompatibilities dominate the list of most common complaints registered against Windows Vista since it shipped on January 30, say several partners who support consumers and SMB and enterprise customers.
Many ISVs have pledged to release Vista drivers in the second half of 2007 but partners should expect a flood of support calls for customers who deploy this year, experts say.
Paul DeGroot, an analyst with Directions on Microsoft, a newsletter in Kirkland, Wash., said it's not surprising to him that hardware manufacturers are not investing in new Vista drivers for older hardware.
Although some maintain that Vista runs happily on a Pentium 4 with at least 512 megabytes of RAM, he and others expect most customers will migrate to Vista through new PC purchases.
"I'm guessing that most of the hardware manufacturers will initially ship drivers for Vista only for new products that they're shipping about now because there wasn't demand in the marketplace for Vista drivers. In addition, Vista will be heavily related to OEM sales, and the OEMs may be selling compatible accessories with new PCs, so the aftermarket business will see less Vista-specific traffic.
Evidence speaks for itself with the likes of michael herid snr singing vistas praises
regardless ms has nothing to worry about.Ms is not fixing the problems quickly enough has only itself to blame.
ta guys mick
by gsaravin9
FRANKLY SPEAKING
Is The Penguin Listening?
By Frank J. Ohlhorst, CRN Tech
12:00 AM EST Mon. Feb. 26, 2007
Have you seen Apple Computer's latest Macintosh commercial? It's the one where the Mac guy and the PC guy are trying to have a conversation, but Windows Vista's user-account control guy gets in the way by asking "allow or deny?" for every exchange.
FRANK J. OHLHORST
Can be reached via e-mail at fohlhorst@cmp.com.
While that may be a humorous oversimplification of how security works with Vista, it does drive home a point: Vista does put a great deal of burden on the end user to decide if something is safe or not. Of course, Apple's answer is to buy a Mac and avoid all of that hassle.
Well, there is another alternative: It's called Linux. If you're looking to upgrade your customers' OSes, now is the time to consider Linux as a viable option. What is really needed is a commercial Linux marketing campaign. I can picture it now:
The Mac guy, the PC guy and a penguin are all standing around having a conversation. The Mac guy, of course, would be pointing out the flaws of Vista, but there would be a twist, the Penguin would be asking, "Why do I have to buy a new computer to avoid all of those Vista problems?" And then the Penguin would jump on the PC guy's shoulder and throw snowballs at the Mac guy. Perhaps the Mac guy would wander off muttering something like, "Those damn inexpensive alternatives!"
OK, now that I have had my fun with the idea, let's talk about the reality here. Businesses will be faced with a choice in the near future: What operating system should they run? For most, just switching to a Mac will be not possible, while for many the cost of upgrading to Vista may be prohibitive. And for others, doing nothing is not an option.
Simply put, solution providers willing to discard preconceived notions and target those must-do-something (for security, compliance or performance reasons) customers can make a convincing argument for the Linux desktop and perhaps reap some income, while solving many of their customer's problems.
Commercial Linux vendors need to pay attention. The year 2007 very likely will become the year of change on the desktop thanks to Vista and the next generation of the Mac OS, and if the commercial Linux vendors don't seize the day, the future may very well become bleak for Linux on the desktop.
Hopefully, Novell (SUSE), Xandros, Mandriver and the other commercial Linux vendors out there will actively dive into the channel and build relationships with system builders to make the Linux desktop an obvious choice.
ta guys mick
by gsaravin9
February 26th, 2007
Problems arise with Vista?s validation
Posted by Ed Bott @ 6:41 am
Categories: Windows Vista, WGA
In Focus ? See more posts on: WGA, Vista
+5
9 votes
Worthwhile? Last year, when Microsoft announced a new anti-piracy infrastructure for Windows Vista, I was skeptical. Here's what I wrote at the time:
What's most distressing about the SPP announcement is Microsoft's continued insistence that its anti-piracy tools are nearly perfect and that innocent victims never suffer from errors in their code. ? Microsoft insists that "most customers should never be affected by having a non-genuine installation." That reassurance would be a lot more comforting if there wasn't already a solid base of failures in its current WGA program.
And now, only weeks after the retail launch of Windows Vista, early Vista adopters are experiencing a wave of validation and activation problems.
I first heard about this a couple weeks ago, in a post that recounted one user's experience with a new game called 9Dragons:
I signup for the game and download the client, install without a hitch.
I am playing the game when all of a sudden I get popped out of my game back to desktop with a message that my copy of Vista isn?t Genuine.
[?]
I tried to revalidate my copy of Vista only to be told that it was still not genuine. When I uninstalled the game and tried guess what it worked.
As it turns out, that was just the tip of the iceberg. A quick scan of Microsoft's Windows Vista Validation Issues forum turns up many similar examples, with users who paid for a retail key being told that their copy is "no longer genuine" and that the key is in use.
The underlying issues were identified by Microsoft a few days after Vista's release to manufacturing last November and publicly disclosed in this post on the Windows Vista Validation Issues forum:
There are several threads in this forum that refer to Error 0xc004d401 causing non-genuine status or preventing activation. In those threads, we have discussed 3 applications that have been identified as conflicting with Vista software licensing technology (which causes the issue).
The offenders included PC Tools Spyware Doctor (updating to the most recent version fixes the issue), Trend Micro Internet Security and PC-Cillin Anti-Virus (the issue goes away if you install version 14.56 or later), and nProtect GameGuard.
That last product is the killer, as it turns out. This anti-cheating package used in a variety of online games has previously been called out for behavior that resembles a rootkit. The program's action apparently triggers the anti-tampering features in Windows Vista. As I wrote last fall, that's not good news for the user:
The most chilling part of SPP is its new code to detect tampering. As Lindeman explained to me, "If the Software Protection Platform determines that the core binaries of your system have been hacked with, you will get a notification that operating system has been tampered with. Reinstallation is the remedy." And the clock starts ticking immediately. When an anti-tampering warning first appears, you have three days to reinstall or otherwise fix your copy of Windows Vista or shift into reduced functionality mode.
Unfortunately, getting a fix for the GameGuard problem isn't as easy as it should be. According to Microsoft, each game manufacturer has to acquire the fix and then integrate the new version of GameGuard into their product.
On January 30, the date of Vista's retail release, Microsoft published Knowledge Base article 931573, You may be prompted to activate Windows Vista on a computer on which Windows Vista activation was not previously required, which lists the following symptoms:
You may be prompted to activate Windows Vista on a computer on which Windows Vista activation was not previously required. Although this problem rarely occurs, it may occur during typical use of a Windows Vista-based computer. For example, this problem may occur under one or more of the following conditions:
You install a device driver.
You install a program.
You run a new program.
You remove a program.
The article goes on to report the reasons that the problem occurs:
This problem may occur because a specific system setting is removed when a program runs with administrative credentials. The removal of this system setting may cause a BIOS validation check to fail. The BIOS validation check is part of the system activation process. Therefore, you may be prompted to activate Windows Vista, even though the system did not previously require activation. For example, this problem is known to occur when you use Intuit QuickBooks 2007. However, this problem may also infrequently occur when you install other programs or device drivers.
Give Microsoft credit for taking ownership of the problem and not throwing the blame back on third-party developers. The KB article contains this unequivocal statement:
This problem does not occur because of an issue in the installed program or device driver. This problem is caused by a system problem in Windows Vista.
At this point, there's no telling how many people are affected by the issue. In some cases, at least, the only fix is to reactivate over the phone, a process that involves convincing a support tech that your installation is legitimate, reading a 50-character product ID over the phone, and then typing in a matching 50-character ID
Well guys i did say there were huge problems with vista did'nt i.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
see the latest on quick books by george ou.You don't know the whole story.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
is only 10.9 % faster.
Windows Vista Benchmark: 64-Bit Faster Than 32-Bit
December 6, 2006
The 64-bit version of Windows Vista operating system is for about 10.9 percent faster than 32-bit Vista, according to the GeekBench benchmark for 32-bit and 64-bit Windows platforms.
Both 32-bit and 64-bit tests were done on a budget AMD Sempron 2800+ powered desktop PC, featuring Asus K8U-X motherboard with 512MB of main memory.
The 32-bit Windows Vista Ultimate achived 99.8 GeekBench points, while the 64-bit version of the same OS gained 110.7 points. The higher number of points is better. This Windows Vista 32-bit vs 64-bit benchmark consist of measuring integer performance, floating point performance, as same as memory and stream performance.
Windows Vista Ultimate 32-Bit 64-Bit
Integer
Performance
Emulate 6502
single-threaded scalar 47 45.8
multi-threaded scalar 46.7 62.1
Blowfish
single-threaded scalar 106.5 118.7
multi-threaded scalar 106.5 119.6
bzip2 Compress
single-threaded scalar 160.1 172.3
multi-threaded scalar 157.6 95.3
bzip2 Decompress
single-threaded scalar 129.1 139.4
multi-threaded scalar 133.6 143.9
Floating
Point Performance
Mandelbrot
single-threaded scalar 108 77.6
multi-threaded scalar 108.1 98
Dot Product
single-threaded scalar 50.9 150.9
multi-threaded scalar 50.6 150.2
single-threaded vector 124.4 196.5
multi-threaded vector 122.2 196.6
JPEG Compress
single-threaded scalar 104.8 103.9
multi-threaded scalar 105 103.1
JPEG Decompress
single-threaded scalar 97.8 115.3
multi-threaded scalar 97.9 114.4
Memory
Performance
Read Sequential
single-threaded scalar 139.2 137.6
multi-threaded scalar 143.3 142.7
Write Sequential
single-threaded scalar 110 109.9
multi-threaded scalar 116 115.1
Stdlib Allocate
single-threaded scalar 129.2 92.2
multi-threaded scalar 126.9 92
Stdlib Write
single-threaded scalar 40.9 88.2
multi-threaded scalar 42.1 96.8
Stdlib Copy
single-threaded scalar 59.7 100.3
multi-threaded scalar 66.4 105.5
Stream
Performance
Stream Copy
single-threaded scalar 103.9 106.2
multi-threaded scalar 104.5 106.2
single-threaded vector 97.3 96.3
multi-threaded vector 95.7 95.1
Stream Scale
single-threaded scalar 118 118.3
multi-threaded scalar 115.3 116.1
single-threaded vector 97.2 98.9
multi-threaded vector 95.6 97.1
Stream Add
single-threaded scalar 95.1 97.8
multi-threaded scalar 91.5 93.3
single-threaded vector 107.4 108
multi-threaded vector 103.4 103.7
Stream Triad
single-threaded scalar 84.1 90.2
multi-threaded scalar 81.3 87
single-threaded vector 86.4 87
multi-threaded vector 83.1 83.2
OVERALL: 99.8 110.7
So why would anyone bother is the 64 $ question!!!
ta guys mick
by gsaravin9
Chip makers AMD and Intel think the 64-bit version of Microsoft Windows Vista operating system will not take over the enthusiast market in 2007, The Inquirer reports.
?Without an exception, they all think it?s too early and the drivers won?t be that polished for 64 bit either. AMD and Intel have CPUs which can support 64 operating systems but the drivers are still lame, unpolished and slow compared with 32 bit,? the report says.
Intel also said that Vista 32 is fine as it will address 2.75 or 3.25GB from the 4GB of memory, if provided.
thanks guys, cheers mick
by gsaravin9
CNET editors' review
Very good
7.8
out of 10The good: Windows Vista Ultimate does improve some features within Windows XP; fewer system crashes than Windows XP; Windows Vista offers better built-in support options.
The bad: Windows Vista Ultimate does not put Search on the desktop (it's buried within applications, within the Start Menu); optimized only for the Microsoft Windows ecosystem (for example, RSS feeds from Internet Explorer 7 get preferential treatment); there's simply too much and not all of it is implemented properly; no new software yet written exclusively for Windows Vista; and there are too many editions of Windows Vista.
The bottom line: Windows Vista is essentially warmed-over Windows XP. If you're currently happy with Windows XP SP2, we see no compelling reason to upgrade. On the other hand, if you need a new computer right now, Windows Vista is stable enough for everyday use.
Read editors' review below
Average user rating from 205 users
Average
5.5
out of 10
I still say why bother there are other factors that cnet has left out.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
Microsoft Vista team reads iTWire and responds to Vista problems
By Alex Zaharov-Reutt
Thursday, 07 December 2006
In my recent article ?More problems with Vista final release?? I detailed a couple of the problems I?ve been having with the final ?RTM? business version of Vista that was released on November 30. A ?Software Design Engineer in Test? from the Windows Experience Team at Microsoft has been in touch to get more details!Have they fixed these preoblems NO !
Related stories
Virtualization software Parallels updated at last
F5 claims Vista SSL VPN first
Accounting package supports Vista and Intel Macs
Attacker mocks victims, says Symantec
Security firm warns of first Office 2007 vulnerability
It?s always nice to know that not only are ?you? reading this article, but that the companies we write about are reading too. In my recent article on Vista problems I talked of intermittent crashes when hibernating or sleeping, and a problem where the colours in Vista look washed out when resuming from a successful hibernation.
While the crashing after hibernation or sleeping has not, as yet, returned, the dreaded colour scheme washout is still appearing, with my own quick fix of changing the colour scheme to 16-bit ?Vista Basic? and back to 32-bit ?Vista Aero? still working for me to get the colours back to normal, with the colours looking darker again.
I?ve just sent off an email to Microsoft?s Vista Software Design Engineer after he requested more information on the configuration of my computer. He asked for the info ?so we can try to reproduce the problem in-house and root cause the issue?.
Getting this kind of direct request for info from what would appear to be exactly the right person (or one of the right people) at Microsoft is very cool, and is certainly much better and quicker than contacting Microsoft Australia people who would probably have had to refer me to their US Vista counterparts anyway.
I?ve only just sent the email before posting this article, so I?m not expecting an instant response. Indeed, they may ask me to provide even more information as they try to replicate the problem and work on a fix of some kind.
As soon as we get an update, we?ll let you know. Until then, thank goodness there?s a workaround! I?ll also be updating Microsoft if I experience any more hibernation/sleep ?crash? issues.
Update: I received another response back with instructions on how to save a file in Vista that will give Microsoft a more detailed look at what's happening in the system, and a request to please send the file over so they can continue their investigation.
Until then, I?m going to happily keep on using Vista. Yes, Mac fans have just told me to ?Get a Mac?? but as a tablet PC fan that isn?t an option. Maybe if Apple release that rumoured Apple Tablet after all with a dual-core chip inside I could be tempted.
I did want to purchase a MacBook to run OS X and Vista at the same time, but for now I?ll wait ? there?s still a lot of great work going on in the OS X and XP/Vista space with the Parallels software and more, and waiting a bit longer is actually a good thing as Parallels keep on improving, with the latest version allowing you to place Windows program icons on the OS X desktop and running Windows software in its own screen.
It?s the best implementation of Mac OS X running Windows software while still in OS X, but if the rumours of OS X 10.5 ? Apple?s upcoming operating system ? to be able to ?natively? run Windows alongside OS X are true, the Parallels people might be quaking at the thought. Unless Apple buys them up and uses their solution to offer the same capability from an OS level.
So it?s all a waiting game. Waiting for Jan 30 for the consumer Vista launch, waiting for an email response from Microsoft, waiting for the Zune to be sold down under and waiting for a better MacBook from Apple.
What I'd most like to see happen now, beyond getting every manufacturer in the world to get a move on with the latest Vista drivers for all of their hardware? Getting this colours issue fixed in Vista, the operating system I (mostly) happily use all day, every day. It's only a little thing, consdering there is a workaround. But it's always the little things that matter, isn't it?
After that, I'd simply like to see Microsoft work as hard as they can to get all of their partners focused on getting all software and hardware to work seamlessly and flawlessly with Vista. Now that Vista is out, there can be no more excuses!
Goodness gracious me are people finding out
about these problems now when i have pointed them out months ago.
it's now 28 february & ms has still not resolved much of the issues.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
Windows Vista Media Center MCMLookalike project now has downloadable source code and markup
I previoulsly posted an introduction to a new open source Media Center Markup Language (MCML) user interface widget library started by Steven Harding that is called MCMLookalike. I found via Niall's blog and Ian's blog that the first downloadable code package is now available on the SourceForge project site for MCMLookalike at https://sourceforge.net/projects/mcmlookalike.
I am really excited to see an effort like this getting started in the community. One of the things that we did not have enough time for when creating the Windows Media Center SDK for Windows Vista was building up a library of reusable controls for developers to use in their applications. The MCMLookalike project aims to fill this type of void so that developers can focus more of their effort on fine-tuning the UI and building really nice functional experiences instead of needing to implement a set of building block UI controls before they can get started with their unique experiences.
If you haven't already, I encourage you to download the MCMLookalike project and take a look at the source code and markup (and contribute back new code/markup when you're able to). The project includes not only MCML files, but also a Visual Studio 2005 project that appears to have been created with the project template we included in the Media Center SDK (and it is cool to see that this template is useful!). The project also includes an installer template for a Visual Studio setup/deployment project so you can build an MSI and install this application to try it out within Windows Vista Media Center as well.
A couple of notes about the MCMLookalike download after I spent a few minutes looking at it:
I strongly encourage you to use WiX v3.0 and the Votive Visual Studio 2005 add-in instead of the Visual Studio setup/deployment project to build installers for Windows Vista Media Center applications if possible. I've created updated sample setup projects for the Q podcast sample application (here) and the Z sample application (here) that are a part of the Media Center SDK. I understand that there is a learning curve for WiX that is a bit steeper than the built-in Visual Studio setup projects, but hopefully these samples and the accompanying blog posts can help get you past most of that.
The app.xml file included in the project doesn't contain the correct assembly strong name, so you cannot use that file with RegisterMceApp to register this application - registration will succeed but the application will crash when you try to launch it from within Media Center. The assembly version number is incorrect and the strong name key value is missing. If you're like me and tend to try to prototype your application during development and don't want to uninstall/reinstall an MSI every time, you can fix the app.xml and register the application that way instead of using the MSI (but only do this during development - shipping applications should be delivered as MSI-based installers).
ta dr mick
by gsaravin9
Windows Vista source code management
Several people ?in the know? wrote about the difficulties in the Microsoft Vista code development. Starting with a post of Joel Spolsky on the strange solution of the nine different shut down-options in Windows Vista, continuing with a post of the developer in charge of these options, about how he worked a year on this feature, without any real progress on it, followed by people who criticized the complicated source code branching model, Microsoft uses. Joel Spolsky wrote the latest article in the discussion, noting that Microsoft?s model isn?t bad at all, it?s the only way that works for a product that?s THAT complicated.
Well, I don?t agree with him 100%. He notes that Microsoft works on an own source code software, which they adopt to their needs, that is incredibly fast and everything. But Linux? Yes, it?s Linux that is the competitor to Microsoft in this area, and I don?t want to be a fan boy now, but there?s something very unique about Linux?
It?s created of thousands of small projects, each running separately in its own source control systems, being closed from each other, communicating just over well-documented APIs. That?s the way to go. Look at Debian - as much as I don?t like how the project is influenced by radical developers that don?t help the project at all, they manage a 300-million-code-lines-project, with thousands of packages, dependencies, etc. without a big number of paid maintainers. Windows Vista on the other hand is said to consist of ?just? more than 50 million LoC, but is inflexible and slow, and makes it difficult to maintain/develop.
The way to go for software development, especially with big projects, is the following:
Separate the project in small parts.
Separate anything that could be used by any other application and out-source it to a library with a documented API.
If you want to implement a user interface for a feature, ask for the API and then stop to care about the developers that develop the feature and start designing your UI. This UI should then just access the API which should have been completed long before.
Compile small libraries without the need of using many other APIs.
Define the API in the beginning, and make changes as rarely as possible.
There is some redundancy in this list now, but it?s extremely important to have everything separated. Then, you can let a team decide, how many options to shut down the computers should exist. Then, you let the kernel developers develop them. Then, you let the shut-down-UI-design-team design 10 prototypes of possible UI. Then, you let the start menu-UI-design-lead decide which is the best to fit together with the other parts of the UI of the start menu. Then, you let the general-UI-lead decide if everything?s ok.
This is still a complicated process, and simply not having that many people to decide over a feature/UI/etc. would be even better, it would be more practical for companies like Microsoft.
Of course, every team should have it?s own branches, of course not everybody should work on a central source control system. But, dedicating teams to certain libraries, and deciding in the beginning which functionality should be there, then developing the functionality, then developing the UI, would be much better than what it?s currently (according to the post of the Microsoft developer that used to work on that team), where everything?s done at the same time:
The UI team creates a prototype.
The kernel team refuses it, recommends something else.
Some other team refuses that, recommends something else.
? (20 times the same thing)
Some strange compromise which should make everybody at least not unhappy, is chosen.
The point is: Make Windows Vienna (the code-name of the next-generation Windows) more modular. Devote a year?s time in seperating the components, defining internal APIs, try to remove dependencies, etc. In this time, don?t create new features or anything. Just make the development easier. After that, slowly start to develop features again. Define which libraries need to be created, and find out how they can be developed to be dependent on as little other libraries as possible.
But in the end, I doubt that Microsoft will and *can* do that. Working just on making a product more modular doesn?t generate any money. It just makes the development process easier. We?ll see if that?s enough for the executives to do ?the right thing?.
Well one can only hope the new windows system vienna is a step in the right direction.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
Introduction
This article talks about root finding in one dimension. It discusses about some algorithms than can solve the problem f(x) = 0, where f is a given function and x is a real variable.
Background
Many algorithms can be found on the Internet, with their source code. My job here was just to translate them in C#, sometimes modify them a bit, and essentially embed them into a convenient framework, a la, C++ STL.
About root finding
How can a computer solve an equation like f(x)=0? As you can imagine, root finding algorithms don't "solve" the equation. They "only" provide (in the best case) one approximated solution, using iterative methods. Starting with a given interval, that is assumed to contain the solution, the algorihtm reduces at least by 2 (using the Bisection method) the length of the interval at each iteration. It stops when the length of the remaining interval reaches a pre-defined value (called Accuracy).
Basically, this works fine. But it can happen that the Accuracy can not be reached. To prevent the algorithm from iterating infinitely, you should prefer to stop it when the number of iterations reaches a certain value (called Iterations).
Now, you're almost ready to use the code. But you should be interested with a special improvement. Suppose you don't know the function f you're working with. How can you determine the range the algorithm has to start with? In this case, you have to use the OutwardBracketing. Given a growing factor, the algorithm will iteratively grow the initial range until the function f changes its sign between the bounds of the range. Note that because f is supposed to be continuous, this ensures that a solution lies in the grown interval.
Using the code
Using the library is very easy. The library provides six methods, among the most usual ones. Each one is embedded in a class, which itself inherited from the abstract RootFinder class, like it is shown on the picture:
The most difficult of your job is to choose the good method. This will be discussed later. Suppose you want to solve the equation f(x) = 0, where f is defined like this:
private double f (double x) {
return 3x*x-1;
}
The two solutions lie in the interval [-1;+1]. Suppose you want the positive root. Don't forget that the algorithms provide a unique solution. If you choose a too big starting interval, the algorithm may go wrong, or give you the solution you don't want. So, you have to start with an interval like [0;1].
private double FindRoot (double x) {
// Create the root finder object, that contains the algorithm
BisectionRootFinder finder =
new BisectionRootFinder (new UnaryFunction(f));
// Define the accuracy you want for the root
finder.Accuracy = 1.0E-04;
// Prevent overflow
finder.Iterations = 30;
// Compute without bracketing outward
double root = finder.Solve(0.0,1.0,false);
return root;
}
The root r of f on [0;1] is r = sqrt(1/3). The Accuracy ensures you that the approximated root r' provided by the algorithm will verify :
Abs(r'-r) < 10e-4 (Accuracy)
except if the algorithm reaches the maximum of iterations you passed it (30 here).
Which algorithm may you choose?
If you have an expression of the derivative function df of f, use the Newton-Raphson method. It's stable and converges quickly. If you don't have an expression df of the derivative function of f, the answer is not easy. It depends, in fact, on what is the most important for you. The Bisection method will always lead you to a good approximation, but not as quickly as the others. The three methods False Position, Secant, and Ridder converge more quickly, but can fail in some cases. The Brent method seems so to be the most efficient method.
Points of Interest
The code source of the algorithms can be found everywhere on the Internet. Building a framework for one dimension functions is not easy in C#. In C++, you can create functors and arithmetic operators on template classes. In C#, you cannot. Okay, handling pointers on functions is very easy with delegates, but that's all. So, how can we build an efficient framework for functions in C#? To be honest, I think it is impossible. That's the reason why I don't provide such a framework. Creating an abstract class Function and derive it as needed is not necessarily the solution. What I propose in the downloadable package is a static class, named Functions that can help you with handling the functions: addition, substraction, and composition.
Have fun mick
by gsaravin9
Ms ain't doing much in the face of lack of sales.A lot of people are totally dissapointed with vista.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
Vista's "wow" gets put on hold
We're still puzzled why Bill Gates passed on the geek capital of the world for the launch of Windows Vista and opted for an event in New York instead. As a reward Silicon Valley has responded to Microsoft's biggest software launch ever... by completely ignoring it.
Microsoft chose Time Square in New York for the official unveiling, but in San Francisco it settled for a basement bound CompUSA computer store in the downtown area. The shop opened its doors at 10pm for a special event featuring San Francisco 49ers quarterback Alex Smith. For nerds with jobs, the store opened early this morning at 7am with a special performance by local radio personality Joe Rock.
The nightly opening brought out a small crowd, which reportedly didn't buy more than a dozen of Vista boxes/systems (it went for discounted printers and memory instead). The morning event meanwhile can be described only as a Complete Failure.
We showed up bright and early, hoping to witness a stampede for this revolutionary software, or at least some excited Microsoft fans eagerly waiting to get a copy of the first new Windows operating system in more than five years.
Store shelves were stocked to the rim. Demo machines were finely tuned to show off the next-gen operating system and the staff was ready to pitch their wares. But not a customer in sight.
Maybe it was because many customers were hesitant to migrate to a new and largely unproven Windows version that in many cases requires costly graphic card updates. Or perhaps is a 7am release event just another demonstration of Microsoft's continued misunderstanding of its customers.
Microsoft marketeers resort to Starbucks, as Windows Vista failed to provide any eye-opening experiences this Tuesday morning.
Perhaps someone like michael should have been there & mingled with the crowd to add to the excitement.
What a complete failure once again predicted by me months ago & rejected by dopes like michael hereid snr.(now ostracised) however never to come back on this thread again. He has proved what a complete fool & a simpleton he is a BIG DOPE to boot !
ta mick
by gsaravin9
Last week, the media went schizophrenic over the Windows Vista speech recognition ?loophole? which allowed anyone with a microphone to have full access over your computer. Granted, you must also be partially-deaf, turned your speaker volume to full, carefully place your microphone next to the speakers, turn on speech recognition and train your speech profile as if you were someone else. It might sound incredibly challenging to get this exploit working properly, but the media assures this exploit is a ?fatal flaw?, so obviously Microsoft is to blame and Vista gets a big red ?Fail? on security.
This week, two top Swedish security experts only to be named ?Long? and ?Zheng?, to hide their identity from Microsoft, exposes many more ?fatal? security flaws inside the newborn operating system, Windows Vista. Here are the two most dangerous exploits you should be concerned about.
The first exploit is a bug inside the keyboard and mouse subsystem which enables the targeted system to be hijacked and maliciously delete files, folders, music, torrents and other important sounding stuff without the user?s authorization or control.
Details of how such an exploit works are sketchy, but leaked documents reveal the keyboard and mouse APIs offers unprecedented amount of control over an operating system, allowing anyone and everyone to have full access to your computer with or without your authorization. This exploit allows anyone ranging from younger siblings to gang leaders who could use brute force, such as a punch or tickle, to gain access to your keyboard and mouse cursors and perform malicious activities such as browsing The Inquirer or deleting vital fraudulent financial documents.
A second exploit highlights a serious flaw inside the popular Windows-platform development tool, Visual Studio. An undocumented feature inside this software is said to enable the ability for malicious users to compile and execute unsigned and potentially damaging source code. If users somehow come across malicious source code and decide to copy, paste, compile and execute within Visual Studio, the resulting application could change wallpapers, block access to YouTube, increase the volume and other serious irreversible damages to the computer system.
Nobody knows exactly how or why Microsoft has designed Visual Studio to include such a dangerous and exploitable feature, but several self-proclaimed security experts has voiced their anger to Microsoft for such questions actions. ?Putting lives at risk like cars on the road? says one expert, ?cheese sandwiches are really good, but this is horrible like a tomato sandwich? insists another - drawing a connection between operating systems and lunch snacks.
Whilst both exploits are said to affect the entire industry of operating systems, ?Long? and ?Zheng? insists that only Windows is affected due to its massive user-base and pretty wallpapers. Both security experts warn if users do not switch to another operating system, Apple and the Free Software Foundation will be really upset.
Microsoft officials gave me a weird look and did not wish to comment at the time of writing.
Next week, keep an eye out for the exclusive report on why Solitaire is a fire hazard. How the end-game fireworks might burn down your operating system. Not to be missed by every innocent Solitaire player.
Last, there may well be some security flaw in Visual Studio. I did point these problems months ago,well vista is a complete joke isn't it.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
you have to see it to beleive it.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
a waste of time.Hardly a reason to upgrade.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
A dystopian future - looking beyond Windows Vista
by Sander Marechal
If the thought of Microsoft Vista's DRM restrictions, restrictive EULA, version confusion and user lock-in has you scared then you definitely do not want to know what the lads from Redmond have in store for the next version. If this patent application, covered by Groklaw here, is anything to go by then the next version of Windows, Vista+1 is really going to give you nightmares.
In simple terms it's a modular OS, much like Linux, whereby every package will have to be bought separately, has been heavily DRM'ed and will be licensed under different licensing terms. And I'm not talking about applications here but about things that people see as core OS functionality, such as basic networking, internet access, running multiple instances of one application, using an USB device (licensed on a per-device basis), etcetera. You'll even have to pay separately just to be able to install third-party applications or to use the new RAM you bought.
Well we can only hope!
Ta mick
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
you have other players getting into the op system production that will take away the monopoly from ms.Pretty soon ms is going to pay for it's ignorance & complacency.
The public are slowly catching on to the lame duck ms has released.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
current evidence showsWindows code is too complicated. It's not the components themselves, it's their interdependencies. An architectural diagram of Windows would suggest there are more than 50 dependency layers (never mind that there also exist circular dependencies). After working in Windows for five years, you understand only, say, two of them. Add to this the fact that building Windows on a dual-proc dev box takes nearly 24 hours, and you'll be slow enough to drive Miss Daisy.
Windows process has gone thermonuclear. Imagine each little email you send asking someone else to fill out a spreadsheet, comment on a report, sign off on a decision -- is a little neutron shooting about in space. Your innocent-seeming little neutron now causes your heretofore mostly-harmless neighbors to release neutrons of their own. Now imagine there are 9000 of you, all jammed into a tight little space called Redmond. It's Windows Gone Thermonuclear, a phenomenon by which process engenders further process, eventually becoming a self-sustaining buzz of fervent destructive activity.
Let's see if, quantitatively, there's any truth to the perception that the code velocity (net lines shipped per developer-year) of Windows has slowed, or is slow relative to the industry. Vista is said to have over 50 million lines of code, whereas XP was said to have around 40 million. There are about two thousand software developers in Windows today. Assuming there are 5 years between when XP shipped and when Vista ships, those quick on the draw with calculators will discover that, on average, the typical Windows developer has produced one thousand new lines of shipped code per year during Vista. Only a thousand lines a year. (Yes, developers don't just write new code, they also fix old code. Yes, some of those Windows developers were partly busy shipping 64-bit XP. Yes, many of them also worked on hotfixes. Work with me here.)
Lest those of you who wrote 5,000 lines of code last weekend pass a kidney stone at the thought of Windows developers writing only a thousand lines of code a year, realize that the average software developer in the US only produces around (brace yourself) 6200 lines a year. So Windows is in bad shape -- but only by a constant, not by an order of magnitude. And if it makes you feel any better, realize that the average US developer has fallen in KLOC productivity since 1999, when they produced about 9000 lines a year. So Windows isn't alone in this. [KLOC data comes from ?Worldwide IT Trends & Benchmark Report 2001?, produced by META Group (now acquired by Gartner)]
The oft-cited, oft-watercooler-discussed dual phenomenon of Windows code complexity and Windows process burden seem to have dramatically affected its overall code velocity. But code can be simplified and re-architected (and is indeed being done so by a collection of veteran architects in Windows, none of whom, incidentally, look anything like Colonel Sanders). Process can be streamlined where inefficient, eliminated where unnecessary.
But that's not where it ends. There are deeper causes of Windows' propensity to slippage.
Cultured to Slip
Deep in the bowels of Windows, there remains the whiff of a bygone culture of belittlement and aggression. Windows can be a scary place to tell the truth.
When a vice president in Windows asks you whether your team will ship on time, they might well have asked you whether they look fat in their new Armani suit. The answer to the question is deeply meaningful to them. It's certainly true in some sense that they genuinely want to know. But in a very important other sense, in a sense that you'll come to regret night after night if you get it wrong, there's really only one answer you can give.
After months of hearing of how a certain influential team in Windows was going to cause the Vista release to slip, I, full of abstract self-righteous misgivings as a stockholder, had at last the chance to speak with two of the team's key managers, asking them how they could be so, please-excuse-the-term, I-don't-mean-its-value-laden-connotation, ignorant as to proper estimation of software schedules. Turns out they're actually great project managers. They knew months in advance that the schedule would never work. So they told their VP. And he, possibly influenced by one too many instances where engineering re-routes power to the warp core, thus completing the heretofore impossible six-hour task in a mere three, summarily sent the managers back to "figure out how to make it work."? The managers re-estimated, nipped and tucked, liposuctioned, did everything short of a lobotomy -- and still did not have a schedule that fit. The VP was not pleased. "You're smart people. Find a way!" This went back and forth for weeks, whereupon the intrepid managers finally understood how to get past the dilemma. They simply stopped telling the truth. "Sure, everything fits. We cut and cut, and here we are. Vista by August or bust. You got it, boss."
Every once in a while, Truth still pipes up in meetings. When this happens, more often than not, Truth is simply bent over an authoritative knee and soundly spanked into silence.
The Joy of Cooking
Bundled with a tendency towards truth-intolerance, Windows also sometimes struggles with poor organizational decision-making. Good news is that the senior leaders already know this and have been taking active steps to change the situation.
There are too many cooks in the kitchen. Too many vice presidents, in reporting structures too narrow. When I was in Windows, I reported to Alec, who reported to Peter, to Bill, Rick, Will, Jim, Steve, and Bill. Remember that there were two layers of people under me as well, making a total path depth of 11 people from Bill Gates down to any developer on my team.
This isn't necessarily bad, except sometimes the cooks flash-mob one corner of the kitchen. I once sat in a schedule review meeting with at least six VPs and ten general managers. When that many people have a say, things get confusing. Not to mention, since so many bosses are in the room, there are often negotiations between project managers prior to such meetings to make sure that no one ends up looking bad. "Bob, I'm giving you a heads-up that I'm going to say that your team's component, which we depend on, was late."? "That's fine, Sandy, but please be clear that the unforeseen delays were caused by a third party, not my team."
Micromanagement, though not pervasive, is nevertheless evident. Senior vice presidents sometimes review UI designs of individual features, a nod to Steve Jobs that would in better days have betokened a true honor but for its randomizing effects. Give me a cathedral, give me a bazaar -- really, either would be great. Just not this middle world in which some decisions are made freely while others are made by edict, with no apparent logic separating each from the other but the seeming curiosity of someone in charge.
In general, Windows suffers from a proclivity for action control, not results control. Instead of clearly stating desired outcomes, there's a penchant for telling people exactly what steps they must take. By doing so, we risk creating a generation of McDevs. (For more on action control vs. results control, read Kenneth Merchant's seminal work on the subject -- all $150 of it, apparently).
Uncontrolled? Or Uncontrollable?
We shouldn't forget despite all this that Windows Vista remains the largest concerted software project in human history. The types of software management issues being dealt with by Windows leaders are hard problems, problems that no other company has solved successfully. The solutions to these challenges are certainly not trivial.
An interesting question, however, is whether or not Windows Vista ever had a chance to ship on time to begin with. Is Vista merely uncontrolled? Or is it fundamentally uncontrollable? There is a critical difference.
It's rumored that VPs in Windows were offered big bonuses contingent on shipping Vista by the much-publicized August 2006 date. Chris Jones even declared in writing that he wouldn't take a bonus if Vista slips past August. If this is true, if folks like Brian Valentine held division-wide meetings where August 2006 was declared as the drop-dead ship date, if general managers were consistently told of the fiscal importance of hitting August, if everyone down to individual developers was told to sign on the dotted line to commit to the date, and to speak up if they had any doubts of hitting
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
Operating Systems
Brampton Factor: Vista complaints
It's not 'green', it's pricey - and what does it say about modern software development?
By Martin Brampton
Published: Tuesday 20 February 2007
Martin Brampton sounds off on the ways Windows Vista fails to live up to its promise - and what it tells us about the stagnant state of software engineering today.
Windows Vista has arrived and if you buy an off-the-shelf PC you will almost certainly get a copy. Vista has been described as the biggest software development ever attempted. I've been puzzling over what that might imply.
But before getting down to some programming issues, let's digress to consider the environment. There seems little hope of IT being able to make 'green' claims so long as new software makes existing hardware obsolete. Yet again, Microsoft is launching an operating system version that will not run on many existing systems. There will doubtless be token resistance but it will inevitably be difficult to avoid the move to Vista.
One might think the situation is saved by the lack of any obviously compelling features in Vista that would persuade people to upgrade. Unfortunately, life is not so simple.
Not only does the Vista technology place stress on systems, Microsoft's pricing gives extra incentives to throw out perfectly usable computers. The retail price of Vista is exorbitant and the upgrades are not radically more appealing than previous versions of Windows while coming with irritating restrictions. To get a half decent price for Vista, the buyer is pushed towards OEM software, which is less than half the price of the equivalent retail version.
Taking Amazon prices as a guide, Vista Home Premium costs a staggering ?197, while the OEM product is just ?68. Doubtless the big PC makers pay a lot less than that, especially as we know that US prices are generally lower than UK prices. There are similar price differences for applications such as Office. All this means that Microsoft is giving strong financial encouragement to the scrapping of computers and their replacement by new machines.
One might think the situation is saved by the lack of any obviously compelling features in Vista that would persuade people to upgrade. Unfortunately, life is not so simple. Upgrade is likely to be forced as one thing leads to another. It only takes one vital upgrade of one application to a version that demands Vista to force the move. So it seems we need to suspend belief in the 'greenness' of IT at least until Microsoft issues a new operating system that works on all existing hardware and costs less as an easily installed upgrade than a new OEM deployment.
What about the actual development of Vista, though? It is widely believed that Vista contains something like 10 million more lines of code than XP. One commentator thought there are around 2,000 Windows developers, and so in the five or so years since XP, they appear to have each contributed only around 1,000 additional lines of code.
Others then contended that was a reasonable rate of production. Research from Steve McConnell, author of the book Software Estimation: The Black Art Demystified (Best Practices (Microsoft)), indicates annual rates ranging from 3,200 lines of code down to 1,600 per year, reducing with size of project. Someone else has claimed a national (presumably US) annual average of 6,200 lines, although no source was specified. The Vista figure was further defended on the grounds that operating systems are complex. That is an inadequate argument, given that only a very small portion of Vista is, truly speaking, an operating system.
All of these numbers raise another curious issue. When I was a young programmer, several decades ago, it was considered that the average rate of code creation was around 20 lines (tested and documented) per day. If we suppose 200 effective working days per year, that equates to 4,000 lines per year. That figure relates to third generation languages and sizeable corporate projects, above the size of McConnell's smallest projects.
This puts computer industry hype into some perspective. Despite numerous 'advances' in both technology and technique, it would appear the creation of software takes just as long today as it did many years ago. There is no sign that any of the numerous expensive tools or the many heavily documented 'new' development methods have had the slightest impact. That is a sobering thought.
It could be argued that different development languages are now used, yet there is actually little real change. While moving from assembler to third generation languages undoubtedly made life easier and perhaps more productive, fourth generation languages failed to maintain that progress. Always too specific to particular kinds of problems, they inevitably ran the risk of introducing huge overhead into projects for which they were unsuited. So nowadays, we see most development in Java, C++, variants of Basic and so on. Little different from techniques used in the 70s, especially if we take account of the invention of Smalltalk during that period.
Another interesting consideration is that the usable lifetime for software may well have already peaked. Much of the code forming the so-called 'legacy' that caused such anxiety at the millennium was written in the 70s and 80s. It was kept in use far longer than its authors ever expected, and far longer than most software from earlier periods. The signs are that most software written today is scrapped after much shorter periods than the 'legacy' despite the fact there is little sign it is produced any more easily or cheaply.
Now of course I do know that lines of code is a very poor (sometimes contrary) way to measure the creation of software. Yet it is the one enduring measure that allows us to do very simple calculations. Those calculations are useful because they cut through the obscurity that otherwise surrounds a highly complex activity.
But getting back to Vista. Some more solid arguments in favour of the Vista developers' productivity include the fact that some XP code has been scrapped, and even some of the code originally written for Vista was scrapped in the face of changing priorities. What is still of concern is that it is hard to see that Vista is a worthwhile result for the efforts of thousands of developers. If we have failed to increase productivity significantly over several decades, does it really make sense to devote such a huge resource to a mere operating system?
by gsaravin9
of vista benchmarking:Several published reports and open-source proponents have raised concerns about this terminology of the Vista license, claiming that it limits the Windows Vista benchmark results that can be published because of the inclusion of the .Net Framework. While benchmarking is still possible, Microsoft is in control of how that information is released, and the company can change the rules on the "conditions" Web site at any time. This could make it difficult for anyone to get a clear idea of how the operating system and certain components perform, critics say.
"To be in control of what is published seems to be the logical consequence of Microsoft's policy," said Joachim Jakobs, a representative for the Free Software Foundation Europe, via e-mail. He cites several instances in which this behavior around benchmarks is consistent with other efforts Microsoft has used to control the use of its software, such as the company's litigation against companies that it claims violate its patents, and the company's continuing antitrust tussle with the European Union.
Microsoft said Tuesday that on Thursday it will clarify issues raised by changes in Vista licensing -- including ones around benchmarking. User concerns over Vista licensing began several weeks ago when it was disclosed that, as part of the changes, Microsoft is limiting the number of machines to which users can transfer licenses to one.
The limitations on .Net Framework benchmarking are not new -- they have been around since Microsoft introduced the development framework. But benchmarking and other limitations in Windows Vista bring to light a larger issue about the operating system's licensing in general, said Michael Cherry, an analyst at Directions on Microsoft in Kirkwood, Washington.
"My bigger issue with the license in general is that it's just indecipherable," he said. "There are a lot of terms that are probably more important to me than benchmarking, but how do I find them among these obscure things that are unclear about what I can or cannot do?"
Joe Lindsay, CIO at Secured Funding Corp., a mortgage firm in Costa Mesa, Calif., agreed that licenses for commercial software are getting particularly hard to understand, and he thinks it's driving more people to view open-source as a viable alternative.
"These licenses are getting increasingly more confusing," Lindsay said. "Part of the reason people find open-source so appealing is [they think], 'I just want software. I don't need a lawyer, I need an OS, some hardware and a programming language and then leave me alone'."
However, Lindsay said he wasn't troubled by any limits on Vista benchmarking, since "most people who?ve been around awhile know that benchmarks are not worth the paper they are printed on."
Similarly, Lindsay said he is unfazed by all the hype surrounding the imminent arrival of Vista, saying his company is looking at it but will only upgrade when it can justify the cost.
"Vista is just an evolution of Windows XP," he said. "It still requires a mouse, a keyboard and a file system, and it runs Office. Is it really that revolutionary? No. I want it to read my mind. When it can do that, then I?ll be impressed."
Well plenty of indication of how low ms will stoop.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
Windows Vista's 90-Day Report Card
Microsoft's new operating system vista
By J. Nicholas Hoover
InformationWeek
March 10, 2007 12:05 AM (From the March 12, 2007 issue)
Ninety days after its release to business customers, Windows Vista has cleared the first hurdle--serious security flaws,not yet so far. But it has stumbled badly on the second--user acceptance--as two big government agencies shun Microsoft's new operating system for other reasons.
Only two weeks after the consumer release of Vista on Jan. 31, CEO Steve Ballmer advised Wall Street to cool its expectations. "We're driving it hard," Ballmer said in a Feb. 15 presentation to financial analysts. "But I think some people have gotten a little overexcited."
CIO (and pilot) Bowen may ground Microsoft software
Ballmer's warning proved prescient. Two weeks later, InformationWeek learned of a memo written by Daniel Mintz, CIO of the U.S. Department of Transportation, that placed "an indefinite moratorium" on upgrades to Vista, citing "no compelling technical or business case for upgrading."
About the same time, the Federal Aviation Administration--which is part of the DOT but managed separately--put a freeze on Vista upgrades. CIO David Bowen says he may drop Microsoft's PC software, Office included, in favor of Linux-based PCs and Google's new online business applications. Among other problems, Bowen says Lotus Notes didn't work properly when tested on Vista. "When you consider the incompatibilities and the fact that we haven't seen much in the way of documented business value, we felt that we needed to do a lot more study," Bowen says.
Microsoft can't take lightly the decision by two major federal customers with a total of 60,000 PC users to sidestep what's usually a well-worn path to the next Windows operating system. And a successful implementation of Google Apps by a big agency like the FAA would be a cue to CIOs elsewhere to consider that alternative themselves.
Microsoft is diplomatic about the snubbing. "Every organization has its own process for adopting software," says Shanen Boettcher, general manager of Windows client product management.
Hardware and software compatibility are among the concerns voiced by would-be Vista adopters. Parts manufacturer Quality Trailer Products pushed back its Vista deployment plans after experiencing compatibility issues during testing. "We took a good long look at it and figured it would be awhile before we do anything more with it," VP of IT Carl Weddle says. The company has a few 1980s-era terminal emulators that work fine with XP, but not at all with Vista.
Application compatibility is a factor at the Transportation Department. A number of applications and utilities in use there aren't Vista-compatible, according to a memo issued by the DOT's Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration. They include releases of Aspen, Capri, ISS, and ProVu applications.
I definitely agree application compatibility & other factors have contributed to vista non acceptance.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
There are plenty of other reasons companies are holding back--like having more important things to do. "We really haven't had time to advance much beyond setting it up and letting our network guys mess with it," says David Moore, CIO of Spectrum Labs. The medical laboratory network has been tied up with server upgrades and patching systems for the earlier-than-usual shift to daylight-saving time.
The most likely way for Vista to get onto a business desktop is loaded on a new PC that's part of a company's normal equipment upgrade cycle. But even then, some companies are wiping Vista off the machines to maintain consistency in their computing environments. "Even if we get a new PC, we're putting our XP image on it," Moore says.
Still, Windows Vista has begun, or is about to begin, creeping into companies. Engineering company Wright-Pierce will soon bring in new Vista-loaded PCs. However, it won't replace Windows XP on existing PCs until it sees how users like Vista first.
Boeing is evaluating Vista for application compatibility and security while assessing the return on investment. "If we determine it meets our business requirements, we could see migration to Vista beginning mid-2008," says Radha Radhakrishnan, VP of computing and network operations at the aerospace company.
Microsoft says Vista rollouts are in line with its expectations. Two early indicators--support calls and application and device compatibility--are about where it would have expected, Boettcher says. Microsoft last week couldn't name any customers that have deployed Vista on more than a few hundred PCs, but a handful, including the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center, plan to have Vista on thousands of PCs by year's end.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
there isn't any.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
According to MS .But, pure and simple, it grieves us to say, Vista doesn't stack up as the mighty blockbuster investors and geeks alike supposedly had been panting for.
A few other factors worth noting: Mr. Ballmer cautioned against anyone out there being "somewhat too bullish." He was distinctly wary that Vista might trigger a new PC boom. For those who like to argue that sector rallies precede fundamental gains, pray tell what the lack of buoyancy in the stocks of HP (HPQ), Dell (DELL) and Intel (INTC) suggest as to the Vista adaption cycle?
Abelson goes on to quote from the very skeptical Fred Hickey as to what we should expect from the rest of Tech:
Fred Hickey, proprietor of the High-Tech Strategist and treasured Roundtable member, had very low expectations for Vista and, as far as he's concerned, they've already been fully met. As is not uncommon with Fred, he put his money where his mouth is, buying put options on Microsoft ahead of the product's splashy introduction, and has the profits to prove it.
We chatted with Fred on Friday, and he remains very much of a mind, as he wrote earlier this month in his newsletter, that Vista is "not an epic disaster for Microsoft" because "ultimately, businesses and consumers will resume their regular upgrade patterns and buy PCs that come pre-loaded with Vista." However, he's convinced its effect on the "PC food chain" stacks up as another and very much sadder story.
Spurred in part by a study commissioned by Microsoft that concluded Vista would generate $72 billion in related hardware, software and service revenue, Fred relates, what he calls the PC food chain -- distributors, resellers and solutions providers -- went wild and hugely overbuilt in preparation for a post-Vista release boom that is clearly not coming.
The result, sighs Fred, is that through the length and breadth of the industry, from semiconductor companies to electronic retailers, there has been a massive inventory build-up -- which, he contends, is a prelude to a disaster. He suspects that the first tremors of real trouble will be felt a few weeks hence, when some dismal earnings forecasts begin to seep out.
What confounds him and could greatly exacerbate a collapse in techs is that investors continue to be bullish on them despite six long years of underperformance by the sector. Besides Microsoft, his most recent published list of stocks he's negative on includes Best Buy (BBY), CDW (CDWC), SanDisk (SNDK), Texas Instruments (TXN), Lam Research (LRCX), KLA-Tencor (KLAC), Nvidia (NVDA), Research in Motion (RIMM), Apple (AAPL), Microchip Technology (MCHP), STMicroelectronics (STM), Amazon.com (AMZN), International Rectifier (IRF), Dell (DELL), Novellus Systems (NVLS), Xilinx (XLNX), Motorola (MOT), Applied Materials (AMAT), NetLogic Microsystems (NETL) and Fairchild Semiconductor (FCS).
Well i have been vindicated
ta mick
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
v
i
c
t
o
r
y
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
in the pc mag the reviwer admits to heaps of problems bessetting vista & he mistakenly compares vista with win95;So Vista is likely to turn out just like Windows 95: a great platform on which developers will build and extend applications and create new ways of working. But Vista is obsolete in the same sense that Windows 95 was. Windows 95 went on to become the dominant OS, but it was the applications that went on top of it that reshaped the computing landscape. My guess is that, looking back, we'll say the same about Vista. That is a wrong observation as compatiblity issues dog vista & it's not the same!Also Paul Phurrot writes heaps of crap & renegs on it quite often 65 mistakes in vista case in point & then sings t's praises!
& the second review is full of errors also he resrves his opinion as he does not know how vista will tun out.
by gsaravin9
but there are huge hardware & software problems &failures that either ms or anyone
has even attempted to solve.Unsigned drivers
etc is a pain in the butt.
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
it is a viable alternative to what's available.
mick
by gsaravin9
with so many people staying with xp you would wonder what all the who ha with vista was about.
But if anything like the response in this thread with lame responses from people like
oj (ostrich jerk) michael.& poor responses like Hal 9000 & then going into hibernation.
I would have expected a more healthy debate.
I just rely on the testing of what i have done & others which is in agreement with my opinion.
If anyone likes to make a healthy response rather than poo poo this thread.
Well i have been right all allong!
ta mick
by gsaravin9
lame duck.Xp is much faster than vista.Compatibility is still a problem with stability & forget 64 bit pie in the sky.
Vista was mean't to be the "killer" op system.This has not eventuated,sales are not picking up as more & more people don't want to upgrade.Ms should have released a new service pack for xp rather than a new system called vista.Vista is set to go the way of millenium os.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
do they realise it's crap that's another story!
they probably don't have the smarts to figure it all out.
ta mick
Sort by Trending