vista is a DUD ! (wham baam thankyou maam!)
This is page 19 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 19 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by gsaravin9
Mike Reavey, operations manager at Microsoft?s Security Response Centre, revealed last Friday that Vista is vulnerable to a flaw that allows a malicious hacker to escalate user privileges within several versions of Windows.
Proof-of-concept code that exploits the code has been posted online, Reavey said in a blog posting, adding that Microsoft isn't yet aware of any malware that takes advantage of it.
"Initial indications are that in order for the attack to be successful, the attacker must already have authenticated access to the target system," wrote Reavey.
"While I know this is a vulnerability that impacts Windows Vista I still have every confidence that Windows Vista is our most secure platform to date. As always, we here at the MSRC encourage everyone to enable a firewall, apply all security updates and install anti-virus and anti-spyware software," he added.
Vista is Microsoft's first operating system release in five years. The company had repeatedly emphasised that it is more secure than previous versions, having been extensively rewritten.
One major change in Vista is that users accounts are created with administrator privileges turned off by default, unlike in XP where they are automatically turned on. Microsoft has cited this change as a key security change, as these administrator powers can be used to turn off other security measures.
As such, this flaw could put Vista users at risk. However, Mikko Hypp?nen, chief research officer with Finnish security company F-Secure, has already said that the flaw it should not concern corporate or individual users as a malicious hacker can't take advantage of it unless they already have access to their machine
by gsaravin9
It's very difficult to implement a 100 percent-efficient kernel protection."
To stage the attack, however, Vista needs to be running in administrator mode, Rutkowska acknowledged. That means her attack would be foiled by Microsoft's User Account Control, a Vista feature that runs a PC with fewer user privileges. UAC is a key Microsoft effort to prevent malicious code from being able to do as much damage as on a PC running in administrator mode, a typical setting on Windows XP.
"I just hit accept," Rutkowska replied to a question from the audience about how she bypassed UAC. Because of the many security pop-ups in Windows, many users will do the same without realising what they are allowing, she said.
Microsoft has touted Vista as its most secure version of Windows yet. It is the first operating system client to go through the company's Security Development Lifecycle, a process to vet code and stamp out flaws before a product ships.
"Windows Vista has many layers of defence, including the firewall, running as a standard user, Internet Explorer Protected Mode, /NX support, and ASLR, which help prevent arbitrary code from running with administrative privileges," the Microsoft representative noted.
After the presentation on bypassing the driver shield, Rutkowska presented a way to create the stealthy malicious software she code-named Blue Pill. The technique uses Pacifica, a Secure Virtual Machine, from chipmaker Advanced Micro Devices, to go undetected.
Blue Pill could serve as a backdoor for attackers, Rutkowska said. While it was developed on Vista and AMD's technology, it should also work on other operating systems and hardware platforms. "Some people suggested that my work is sponsored by Intel, as I focused on AMD virtualisation technology only," she said, adding that is untrue.
vista is a security joke!
by gsaravin9
Vista migration: the rocky road
Oliver Rist, Information Age
12/05/2007 14:16:52
Certainly no coincidence, Microsoft has decked out its much-anticipated OS upgrade with beautiful landscape wallpapers -- vistas, to be exact. But, as calming as these background images may be for end-users getting acquainted with Vista, for IT directors, the landscape approaching an enterprise rollout of any new Windows operating system has always been rocky.
Convincing management with compelling ROI, quelling grumpy user rebellions and making sure the whole thing doesn't blow up in your face are by now well-known impediments along any Windows migration path. It's enough to make IT departments considering the journey downright cautious.
And cautious many are. "The majority of companies, particularly in the medium and large sector, are telling us that it's going to be between one and two years when they actually adopt Windows Vista," says Stephen Minton, an analyst at IDC. According to a recent Equs Group survey, 26 per cent of companies plan to migrate to Vista this year, as opposed to 53 per cent in 2008 and 16 per cent in 2009.
All this reluctance despite the fact that Microsoft has gone to great lengths to make the Vista deployment process as easy on IT administrators as possible -- probably more so than with any previous version of Windows. Yet deploying Vista will still be as big an architectural leap as going from Windows 98 to Windows 2000. As such, expect no shortage of hurdles along the way.
Chief among these hurdles, ironically, will be users themselves, as many IT managers already en route to Vista land are finding that their users simply don't want Vista.
What they're really after are Office 2007 and Exchange 2007 -- business-critical apps they perceive as essential to getting their work done. So much so that almost any thought of winding your way toward Vista should lend credence to bringing one or both of these platforms along.
The whole hog or not at all? "It's the Microsoft trifecta," says Mike Connelly, vice president of IT at training and productivity-tool provider FranklinCovey, referring to the confluence of upgrades to Exchange, Office and Windows. Connelly has already rolled out Exchange 2007 and is currently rolling out Vista and Office as a single package. "Microsoft's marketing has made the combination really compelling to our users. And it's easier all around, since for our users, Vista hasn't been that much of a learning curve. Office is the big jump, so we're trying to give them all the functionality up front."
"Office 2007 is definitely a driver for Vista deployment," says Larry LeSueur, vice president of infrastructure and security at Avanade, an Accenture-owned consultancy that specialises in large Microsoft consulting projects. Avanade currently has 33 Vista rollout projects under way worldwide.
"The ability to create custom and ongoing applications using Vista and Office 2007 is simply too attractive for our customers to ignore," LeSueur says, citing custom business research apps Avanade is helping to create in the oil and gas industry and the health-care sector using Office 2007, Office SharePoint Server 2007, and Exchange 2007.
That isn't to say that Vista on its own is an industry dud. It's more that companies deploying the new OS right away are, for the most part, largely dependent on Office. Administrators at these companies simply can't ignore the fact that Vista was released in conjunction with quantum leaps forward in, arguably, Microsoft's other two most popular platforms.
"More so than ever, the operating system is just such a small piece to the user," says Stan Foster, research fellow and Microsoft specialist at Hewlett-Packard's service division, which helps HP customers manage rollouts and provides additional services such as managed desktop outsourcing. "It's the applications that are important to the business people. All these components [Vista, Office 2007, Exchange 2007] have individual benefits, but combined -- that's where the action is."
And though it may not simply be a matter of whole-hog deployment of the Microsoft trifecta or nothing at all, from a planning perspective, it's certainly easier to consider Vista, Office, and Exchange as a holistic combination rather than starting over from scratch each time.
Both Office 2007 and Exchange 2007 offer significant, new, user-facing features that could well influence management buy-in far more than Aero's pretty face. Figuring out the right feature combination means charting the best course to ROI, and that, in turn, is the best path to getting management on board -- a path that requires identifying the combination of these three platforms that will offer the most to your user set and then building your rollout plan around those features.
Fortunately, this is one area where Microsoft has done a considerable amount of work -- especially from an eat-your-own-dog-food perspective. "For us, deploying Vista definitely meant deploying Office 2007 simultaneously," says Ron Markezich, vice president of managed solutions at Microsoft, and formerly the company's CIO.
Microsoft at present already has 64,000 Vista desktops deployed and previously had 107,000 Exchange 2007 mailboxes rolled out. Markezich cites the new Windows Imaging capability that's included with Vista as a key driver for the decision to perform both product upgrades at the same time.
"It's just so much easier than with previous imaging packages," says Chad Lewis, Microsoft's Vista deployment product lead. "Remember, we don't just deploy Vista or Office once, like our customers. We've had to deploy several builds of both at regular intervals. The ability to keep our WIM [Windows Imaging Format] file library small and easily tailored has made the whole process just so much easier."
Microsoft has configured its upgrade process to allow certain users to upgrade their own machines at their own pace when going from Windows XP/Office 2003 to Vista/Office 2007. But once on the new platform, Microsoft uses a forced SMS (Systems Management Server) 2003 upgrade process to make sure that users on Vista stay current with new builds. "The nice thing is that we can use the same WIM library for both operations," Lewis says.
Gut check: software compatibility That's a rosy picture Microsoft paints for its own wares, but even with this brace of new deployment tools, Vista's radically redesigned new innards will still have a significant impact on mission-critical line-of-business apps.
"Software remediation is definitely the most important upgrade step across all our customers. It really drives the rest of the rollout process," Avanade's LeSueur says. "Our own internal rollout, for example, we're halfway through, but our accounting department will have to come last because one of their critical software applications is going to need more time to become fully Vista-compliant."
Figuring out what's running on the network -- including a full software and hardware portfolio -- will be the most crucial prep step for every enterprise Vista rollout. Fortunately, much of this can be accomplished with existing desktop management tools.
"[Vista has] been a great business driver for us," says Tony Thomas, senior product manager at Numara, the software company behind Track-It, a popular desktop management and asset management platform. "In fact, we're creating a customer Web portal specific to Vista deployments, including the steps you should take, the features we do and don't offer, and the ability to ask questions. We want to help them as much as possible with this process, and our software puts us in a unique position to do that."
In addition to the portal, Thomas says Track-It has received new features specific to the Vista predeployment process. "We've added reports designed specifically to let our customers see what machines are equipped to run Vista and what their overall software portfolio looks like," he says. "The intention for us is to facilitate the planning as much as we can, then facilitate the rollout, and finally give them the tools they need to measure ROI."
And those are the right brush strokes whether you're using Numara's or another system -- but don't expect such systems to do all the work for you. No desktop management system catches everything. A complete software inventory still takes serious staff legwork, which drives up costs. The trick is to keep those costs as low as possible.
A key worry that many readers have expressed in terms of software compatibility rests with desktop antivirus. With the redesigned Vista kernel, existing Windows XP antivirus packages won't run on Vista. This situation has folks with hundreds or thousands of antivirus client licences concerned about how upgrading will affect their budgets. Fortunately, antivirus vendors are taking the sensible approach.
"We had no problem with having to purchase additional Symantec licences," FranklinCovey's Connelly says. "Under our corporate licence, this was considered a feature upgrade, and we didn't have to pay anything extra. Symantec got us the code, and we've made it part of our WIM files." Although grateful for Symantec's stance on the redesign, Connelly isn't leaving well enough alone. He's taking the opportunity to evaluate other desktop security platforms, notably Windows Live OneCare -- yet another benefit of an organised software remediation and planning phase.
Gut check: hardware performance "Definitely, a managed desktop resource is a huge help when planning for Vista," HP's Foster says. "But you're still going to need to do some heavy manual lifting. There's no escaping that." And it's with hardware where this lifting will be the heaviest, especially as hardware assessment will be a far more important part of the Vista migration planning process than it has been for the past couple of Windows generations.
When it comes to hardware, Microsoft has been downplaying Vista's requirements. The truth is that the OS is built to take advantage of the latest hardware developments. As such, deploying Vista over older hardware will generate issues. That means surveying the hardware landscape is another critical step -- one that simply cannot be done with software tools alone. And then there's that other thing ...
"It's the testing," Foster continues. Older hardware needs to be tested for optimal performance before a rollout, and that's strictly a manual process. "Hardware that's even a year old may have compatibility or performance problems. Video is the one everyone talks about, but RAM is just as important, as are older versions of things like Wi-Fi or Bluetooth," he says.
Not surprisingly, you'll get the same message from the big hardware vendors. "Sure, you can run Vista on old hardware, but don't. Do it on new hardware, and you'll be better off all around," says Greg Bryant, vice president of the business client group at Intel. That "all around" refers less to features than it does to a perceived ease of deployment when new hardware is involved. By waiting for current hardware lease agreements to run their course, enterprises can reduce the rollout process to simply saving and restoring user data. The new operating system and application portfolio can be handled by the hardware vendor or VAR.
"We're getting a lot of customer interest in that aspect of our service offerings," HP's Foster says. HP's service division can help HP customers with hardware purchasing and post-purchase support, but the division also specialises in custom support as well. Customers can define a desktop software library, and Foster's crew will test for Vista compatibility, build the WIM libraries, maintain them, and even roll out the images, either at HP's site or at the customer's.
"A completely outsourced corporate desktop is becoming one of our more popular service offerings," Foster says. "For many customers, it's just the easiest way."
That's a tempting carrot at first blush, providing both an easier implementation and gleaming new hardware. And Intel's Bryant sweetens the deal with the mention of enhanced features. Which, of course, sounds like what a motherboard salesman would say, but when queried on specifics, Intel really does have features to back this up.
"We've specifically optimised our CPU line for both Vista and specific apps in Office," Bryant says. "Take Excel, for example. Our Core 2 Duo is specifically designed to boot the performance of large Excel calculations -- and we're not talking a small number, either. We're talking about 300 per cent of improvement of the same calc run on hardware that's only a year old."
Intel has also done serious work on Vista's mobile side. InfoWorld testing has shown that notebooks with last year's embedded Intel graphics chip set -- the most popular mobile graphics system for the "value/business" notebook segment -- don't have the juice to run Aero. Vista's own installation process automatically defaults to the non-Aero view when installed on these systems. Intel knew this would be a problem going forward and beefed up its chip set earlier this year.
"We can't comment on how hardware OEMs implement our chip sets," Bryant says, "but we can say that the integrated graphics line does currently support the full Vista graphics load." This was borne out in a quick impromptu test I conducted on a Gateway M255-E delivered last May running the then-current Intel graphics subsystem. That machine couldn't run Aero. Gateway then sent the same model in November, armed with a Core 2 Duo CPU and a newer Intel Graphics Media Accelerator chip set. That machine is running Aero without difficulty.
"New hardware definitely does make a difference," Bryant says. And he references not just graphics oomph but management muscle as well. New versions of Intel CPUs and chip sets will incorporate features such as out-of-band management, remote updating, advanced hardware diagnostics, and similar goodies. And again, Vista-specific features are included here on Intel's part as well.
"Our Active Management Technology provides these new management and security features," Bryant says. "As far as Vista goes, we've built features specific to the Vista desktop firewall directly into hardware, which means that security is no longer software-only."
Of course, both Foster and Bryant represent hardware manufacturers. Talk to an everyday IT administrator and your answers might be different. "The new hardware's great, but we're not waiting for it," FranklinCovey's Connelly says. "We've tested it, and we think it runs fine in 512MB or 1GB. The WIM tools are good enough that we can do the OS rollout right now and give our users the Office features they want without waiting for new hardware. We can add those advanced features later."
According to Connelly, FranklinCovey's network carries approximately 800 distributed users, placing it on the small end of the enterprise rollout scale. Although the lower desktop count undoubtedly had something to do with Connelly's decision to run his rollout across the existing hardware landscape, this isn't a trend that's relegated to the SMB segment. LeSueur says Avanade's large enterprise customers aren't following the hardware lease rollout plan, either.
"Enterprises are evaluating Vista based on internal TCO, not initial hardware costs," LeSueur says. "With Microsoft's advances in software deployment tools, scheduling the rollout around lease agreements doesn't interest them. Better to focus on software compatibility and mission-critical testing." Just get your users what they need. Hardware purchasing doesn't have to be affected at all.
Too much too quickly? It's the first time in more than a decade that Redmond has released this many product platforms at once.
Microsoft, as you'd expect, is extremely pleased with the current state of its deployment tools, as well as its product release schedule. And make no mistake, consultants such as Avanade's LeSueur and HP's Foster see no downside to a large volume of simultaneous Microsoft platform upgrades, either. That would be termed "bread and butter" to those folks. But IT administrators living without Microsoft consultants aren't quite as happy about having to swallow so much at once.
"It's definitely a concern," Connelly says. "I'm a cautious guy, and typically, I'd be doing the server upgrades first, one at a time, and follow those with the desktop upgrades. But Microsoft releasing three new platforms at once doesn't happen very often. That's put us in a spot, plus we were moving to Microsoft CRM as well." So at the moment, Connelly has separated his server upgrades from his desktop upgrades, but he is forced to roll out several new desktop platforms simultaneously while still testing a new server back end. "So far, it's working fine, but it's definitely a worry."
The cautious perspective to be sure, but that's not to say it can't be done. Justin Ainsworth, senior IT manager at Sierra Nevada Brewing, is in the same boat but is taking the Redmond product blitz in stride.
"We're just taking it one step at a time," Ainsworth says. "Being in the Vista TAP [Technology Adoption Program] program definitely helped. That gave us a lot of early experience that's really paying off now that we're rolling out companywide. Also, you should very closely check out the Business Desktop Deployment [BDD] guide materials. That's very good stuff and definitely worth reading before a rollout."
Overall, the perspectives Connelly and Ainsworth offer are well representative of the current viewpoint IT administrators have on Microsoft's product cornucopia: It's a lot of material, but taking it one step at a time will see them through. Their confidence in and appreciation of Vista's new deployment tools are mirrored in InfoWorld's testing -- as will be demonstrated in an upcoming Test Center review currently in the works.
"This time around, the key is really the planning," Connelly says. And although that's true of any Windows upgrade scenario, this time Microsoft's new deployment tools seem to be making the effort worthwhile.
Making it to the end of any Windows migration journey is arduous and painful. Thankfully, those embarking on this path are not alone. Advice abounds, much of it worthwhile. Everyone we spoke with emphasised that taking careful stock of both the software and hardware landscape should be the critical launching point for any migration to Vista. And rather than worry about budget concerns or hardware purchasing issues, mission-critical business drivers should dictate the schedule of your deployment.
Most important, the act of rolling out the software is all about preparation. Take the time to test Microsoft's deployment tools and become familiar with the deployment guidelines presented in the BBD.
"Yeah, there's a lot of stuff," Sierra Nevada's Ainsworth says. "But we're just taking it at our own pace."
Words to live by.
[sidebar] Vista/Office upgrade offers threats and promises
By Dale Dixon
Here are five practical steps for a smooth Vista/Office upgrade
There's both opportunity and risk in a combined deployment of Vista and Office, but organisations can tip the scales significantly in the right direction by following some practical steps.
On one hand, deploying Vista and Office 2007 at the same time is a good opportunity to avoid the pain that can accompany staggered migrations, such as a major Operating System (OS) upgrade followed by an application suite upgrade six to twelve months later.
However, on the flip side, it's a major task to ensure all company PCs meet the hardware and software specifications, that all applications are compatible and that licence costs are optimised based on real business needs.
Here are five recommendations to make the process easier:
1. Don't install more software The first step in a successful deployment of new software is taking an inventory of existing software across the business.
One of the challenges in taking software inventory is the number of software solutions that require a software agent to be installed onto every PC to gather the information. This is somewhat self-defeating, because rolling out a new piece of software to all desktops can be a lengthy and costly process in itself.
When a software vendor offers a "zero-touch" solution, ask them what they mean: is it a true zero-touch solution, where a PC can be analysed without new software being installed, or does it still require installation of software using a managed process?
2. Get the right level of detail in software inventories When planning for a software upgrade, you'll need to know both the product names and major versions of products installed on desktops, as well as the specific patch level of each product on each PC.
Some software inventory solutions will tell you that one PC has DesktopApp 1.23.4 while another PC has DesktopApp 1.30.0, but from a licensing perspective that may be the difference between DesktopApp Standard 2000 and DesktopApp Pro 2003.
Likewise, some inventory solutions base their data collection on the installer evidence logged by Windows; others look at executables and their version numbers, but most have difficulty correctly grouping the many 'dot' releases of programs and providing a summary report.
Your inventory solution should ideally have an application recognition database that can identify software based on a number of factors. The database should be large enough to cover less common programs, and it should be flexible enough for IT to define their own applications for custom applications.
3. Don't get bogged down by manual analysis Companies that have gone through the lengthy process of collecting software and hardware information by hand from each PC have learned a valuable lesson. The practice of compiling this information and making decisions based on it can be a time consuming process in itself.
Inventory needs to be taken in a short window of time to ensure a 'snapshot' is captured, and the data then needs to be analysed quickly, so that the data doesn't become outdated before decisions are made based on it.
By the time a manual audit is completed, analysed and actioned, it's likely that the results will be significantly out-of-date, both in terms of software that will have been installed in the meantime and hardware that will have been upgraded or retired.
An auditing solution should be able to handle the whole process from beginning to end for you. This will perform automated data collection and analysis of both software and hardware information, with the end result being a list of hardware component upgrades you'll need to install into each PC in order to make them Vista capable. You will also get an understanding of how many PCs are going to need to be replaced entirely.
4. Keep a lid on ongoing licence costs Two of the most common ways companies "lose" software licences is through PCs being decommissioned and employees leaving the business.
But organisations are often unaware that thousand-dollar copies of Photoshop or other expensive applications that may have been purchased for special projects are now sitting dormant on staffers' PCs.
Worse, for specialised applications, organisations may discover years down the track that they've been paying inflated software maintenance fees due to dormant licences that no-one thought to check each time renewal rolled around.
A central licence database and an automated way of collecting both licence and usage data is the crucial element in taking ongoing control of this problem. Further savings can be realised by tracking and monitoring application usage and reporting on little-used licences that could be redeployed to other users across the business in place of new purchases.
This is the only circumstance where a solution can't be "zero touch", as it is necessary to install an agent on the client to accurately meter the usage of software applications (not just measure whether an application is open).
From a compliance perspective, you should ensure the ongoing auditing application you deploy is able to identify the application versions, extract the relevant software licence information and link that to purchase orders to provide an authoritative central licensing database. If your organisation is formally audited for licensing compliance, there will be no last-minute rush to compile the information and no nasty surprises at the end of the process.
5. Don't forget the small things
It goes without saying, but it's not only PCs that are affected by a major operating system upgrade: it's also printers, scanners, PDAs and other peripherals that connect into the PCs and the network.
A category of peripheral that's often forgotten in major system rollouts is mobile phones. Depending on your organisation's choice of handheld platform, don't forget that your audit should include the capability to include these types of devices also.
Even if you're not planning to deploy in the next 12-18 months, you still need to start planning now, especially around application compatibility due to the deep changes to Microsoft's latest OS.
Why bother!!
by gsaravin9
testing has shown Planet Company of Heroes
Company of Heroes/Vista Performance Charts
Aaghh, another Vista news piece. And to make it even worse, it's bad news! GameSpot has compiled a Company of Heroes performance chart, comparing CoH's performance in XP vs Vista. And the bad news? XP has an advantage of 5-20 FPS, depending on the resolution. So if you're really concerned about performance. Company of Heroes. Unless you have a GeForce 8800 GTX, because let's face it, even its lowest result of 164 FPS is more than enough for anyone.
Guys what did i say its a piece of crap?? i was right testing has proved it.
by gsaravin9
as compared to vistaWindows XP vs. Vista: The Benchmark Rundown
Patrick Schmid, Achim Roos
January 29, 2007 09:16
Is Windows Vista Faster Than XP?
Our Windows Vista coverage began with a hands-on diary by MobilityGuru's Barry Gerber, followed by an assessment of gameplay under Windows Vista by graphics presidente Darren Polkowski, as well as a complete feature rundown of Vista. Barry took the new operating system and its look & feel with a grain of salt, while Darren was disappointed because OpenGL support was dropped along the way, meaning that Windows Vista currently offers horrible performance for graphics applications utilizing the Open Graphics Library.
We are sure that mainstream users will appreciate the improved usability of Windows Vista, and the average office/multimedia user will likely never notice the lack of OpenGL. However, a chapter on the overall performance of Windows Vista requires more dedication. In particular, two things require an in-depth analysis:
Basic Windows Vista Performance
How does Windows Vista perform compared to Windows XP? Will applications execute equally quickly, or will they even run slower due to the new features and the AeroGlass interface?
Windows Vista Performance Enhancements
With SuperFetch and ReadyBoost, Windows Vista introduces two features to make use of today's technology in order to improve the user experience. This means that more application data should be actively cached into all available memory (SuperFetch), whether that is physical RAM or a USB Flash memory device (ReadyBoost). Microsoft's goal was to create balanced performance by removing delays in everyday work.
This article deals with basic application execution under Windows Vista Enterprise, which is representative of the other editions. We put together a high-end test system and performed a comprehensive benchmark session both with Windows XP Professional and with Windows Vista Enterprise to see if there are differences. And indeed, we found that there are some...
Software And Vista
Although the main Windows Vista core has undergone lot of modifications, many of your applications will work with Vista. There is, however, no guarantee. You should definitely try any essential software on Windows before you upgrade.
Process scheduling and thread pooling have been improved in Vista; a deadlock protection mechanism and hardware partitioning for virtualization support were added, together with many more features.
We tried lots of different programs under Windows Vista Enterprise, and came up with a list of software that definitely works.
Games
Call of Duty 2
Far Cry
F.E.A.R.
Unreal Tournament 2004
Applications
Adobe Acrobat 8
Adobe Photoshop CS2
Autodesk 3DSMax 8.0
AutoGK 2.4
Hamachi
KeePass 1.06
LAME MP3 Encoder
MainConcept H.264 Encoder
Miranda Messager 0.5.1
Microsoft Office 2003
Microsoft Office System 2007
Mozilla Firefox 2.0.0.1
Mozilla Thunderbird 1.5.0.9
Nokia PC Suite 6.82.22.0
Ogg Vorbis 1.1.2
OpenOffice 2.1
Picasa 2
Putty
Skype 2.5.x and 3.0
SmartFTP 2.0
Sungard Adaptive Credit Risk Calculation 3.0
SonyEricsson PC Suite 1.30.82
SQLyog 5.22
Symantec AntiVirus 10.2.0.224
UltraEdit 32 12.10
WinRAR 3.70
XviD 1.2.0
Benchmarks
3DMark 06
Cinebench
PCMark05 Pro
SiSoft Sandra 2007
SPECviewperf 9.03
In other cases there were some issues.
We found Vista updates for the Futuremark benchmark programs 3DMark and PCMark, as well as the popular data compression tool WinRAR. Lots of video-related software such as DivX could no longer be installed; new versions are required. The popular audio player WinAMP 5.32 throws up an error at startup, yet it works properly. Quake IV can still be executed, but the installation program did not work. Applications that run their own memory management won't benefit from Vista's SuperFetch function. For example, Adobe Photoshop takes care of creating a temporary work file every time it launches - Vista has no access to this process and cannot speed it up.
There are some types of software that you should only use if they have been specifically designed for Windows Vista: firewalls, anti-spyware and anti-virus software needs to be Vista-Ready
??What i s Vista Ready according to Ms anything they say that it is !!
give me strengh as vista ready doesn't mean anything.
by gsaravin9
HAS UNDERPERFORMED XP BY MILES !!
Vista: Benchmarking or Benchmarketing?
Patrick Schmid, Achim Roos
April 19, 2007 07:35
Can Vista's Performance Indices Replace Benchmarking?
Vista: Benchmarking or Benchmarketing?
Patrick Schmid, Achim Roos
April 19, 2007 07:35
Can Vista's Performance Indices Replace Benchmarking?
Vista: Benchmarking or Benchmarketing?
Patrick Schmid, Achim Roos
April 19, 2007 07:35
Can Vista's Performance Indices Replace Benchmarking?
There is a lot of variety in the hardware market: hundreds of types of processors, motherboards, hard drives, graphics cards and other components to choose from. And although consolidation has been going on for several years, leaving only AMD/ATI, Intel and Nvidia as the main players, along with a few motherboard makers and storage giants, finding the right products still can be an exhausting task. This is where benchmarking comes into play, because it helps to measure qualities and characteristics by applying a certain metric. Windows Vista now provides a built-in benchmarking solution to assess component and system performance, but does the so-called Experience Index correspond to what Tom's Hardware and other tech publications find on the test bench?
We will talk about benchmarking fundamentals on the following page, but I'd like to forestall the issue of synthetic vs. real-world benchmarks. Typically, using so-called real-world benchmarks is considered the proper way of technical benchmarking, because you use real applications to measure performance or assess capabilities. Although this creates a lot of work for reviewers, real-world software provides very relevant results. A great example is our popular Interactive CPU Charts, which compile almost 30 different programs and benchmarks across most processors on the market. Simply select your application and you'll receive results that are relevant to you.
Yes, the CPU Charts also include synthetic benchmarks - these were designed to specifically measure certain performance aspects of components. But synthetic benchmarks can be created with a certain focus in mind, resulting in test runs that may be less relevant, while real-world applications reflect what people actually use. The common attempt to create trust in synthetic benchmarks is finding industry-wide support, resulting in industry standard benchmarks.
Microsoft is in an excellent position to create an industry standard benchmark on a consumer level, because Vista will be the dominant operating system for new PCs by the middle of this year. A built-in benchmarking solution would not only allow users to assess and compare the performance of components and systems, but be a powerful marketing instrument for the whole industry as well. Microsoft developed a comprehensive but simple to understand rating scheme, called the Windows Experience Index. It includes both performance and feature evaluation, expressed as a single number; Microsoft would like to see performance indices on both hardware and software retail boxes. This would allow users can check whether their scores were good enough to run a software package they intended to buy, and to compare possible hardware upgrades to match or exceed the Experience Index required by the software.
The advantages of such an all-in-one benchmarking solution are pretty obvious, but how well does the Windows Experience Index really reflect real-life performance? As the name says, it is an experience index that was specifically designed for Windows Vista. We decided to check how the Vista results compare to our own in-depth benchmarking.
Well one can draw ones' conclussion that it's all marketing hype there is no wow factor or what MS is saying is to make more $$$$$.It does not give a real hoot
about the poor old consumer.That might sound like MS bashing but it's the cold hard truth!!!
Guys i regard you as far more intelligent, any comments????
by gsaravin9
Vista: Benchmarking or Benchmarketing?
Patrick Schmid, Achim Roos
April 19, 2007 07:35
Benchmark Basics
There are two basic types of benchmarks: real-world benchmarks, which are based on software or application scenarios that people all over the world actually use, and so-called synthetic benchmarks. This latter type consists of programs that were specifically designed for the sole purpose of stressing a system or specific components for testing. 3DMark and PCMark by Futuremark, and Sandra by SiSoftware are typical examples of synthetic benchmarks. Examples of real-life benchmarks would be a script running several tasks on Adobe's Photoshop, transcoding one video format into another, or running a 3D game.
Both benchmark types return either a composite score or a more tangible result such as the time required to process the benchmark workload. This can also be a certain metric such as frames per second (graphics), calculations or iterations per second (processors), megabytes per second (hard drives or main memory) and many others. Depending on what you're benchmarking, you'll receive one or more results, which have to be weighted before you come to a conclusion. You may want to put emphasis on a certain result, depending on your requirements.
While some synthetic benchmarks, such as 3Dmark, have managed to become an industry standard on a consumer level, we still prefer real-world benchmarks because these typically return more tangible results. For example, 65 frames per second in a particular game at particular settings means more to most users than 6583 3DMark scores. Is this a lot? 65 frames per second certainly is enough to provide smooth graphics. But you could argue that the 3DMark score could be compared across completely different systems easily - because all that counts is the score - while the direct comparison of frames per second leads experienced users to ask about system details.
In any case, benchmark results are only worth the work if there are results to which you can compare. Getting frames per second performance of a brand new graphics card at several resolutions is worth little if you don't also have the results for its closest competitor, and maybe its predecessor. The very first step is creating a consistent test setup, which must not be changed as you alter the target parameters (e.g. varying graphics cards on a test system). It is also helpful to define a baseline to facilitate rating the differences. If 65 frames per second equals a baseline of 100, for example, 73 frames per second would be 112, or a 12% increase.
It is crucial to be diligent, to make sure that all results are actually reproducible. One part of this is to verify results; the other is to find out if a particular benchmark shows a lot of variance. Running each benchmark at least three times turned out to be reasonable, but the more variance you find, the more repetitions you should run. If you still get varying results after ten runs you should probably drop the benchmark and find a more accurate solution. Working with benchmark results, you can either calculate an average, or take the fastest/slowest result. Which approach makes most sense highly depends on the type of benchmark.
Finally, you should be aware that Windows Vista is capable of optimizing application startup time with its Superfetch feature, which pre-caches frequently launched applications into available main memory. This is particularly important for benchmarks that launch multiple modules - think of a benchmark suite such as BAPCo's SYSmark, which launches one application after the other. Vista will recognize the pattern as you run the benchmark multiple times, and it will have the individual applications launch faster, improving the benchmark results over time. Here you should either train each system, or disable the Superfetch service.
by gsaravin9
Vista: Benchmarking or Benchmarketing?
Patrick Schmid, Achim Roos
April 19, 2007 07:35
Windows Experience Index
Windows Vista isn't just the smarter, more beautiful Windows operating system: it is capable of assessing the performance of the system upon which it runs. Microsoft created the Windows Experience Index (WEI) to rate system components such as the processor, the main memory, the graphics subsystem and the primary hard disk. These results are called sub-scores. Windows uses these sub-scores to create the WEI score, which resembles the lowest sub-score.
The WEI value is a simple number between 1 and 5.9, where 5.9 is the highest WEI score you can reach today. As soon as there is faster or more advanced hardware, Microsoft intends to introduce higher scores of 6 and up. Microsoft says there is no schedule for updating the score range, but it should be done approximately every 12 to 18 months.
Vista's WEI scores are not just a simple number; they follow a certain base score definition that is called the score level:
Level 1 (1): Sufficient performance. Ready for office applications, web browsing, email and IM communication, basic educational software
- older or entry-level computers, ultra-portable devices
This is the minimum score to run Windows Vista.
Level 2 (2.0 to 2.9): Adequate performance. Aero graphics, improved system responsiveness, but same application profile as in level 1.
- low-end and mainstream computers
Level 3 (3.0 to 3.9): Up to date system performance; Aero graphics, average 3D game and graphics capabilities
- mainstream PCs with graphics capabilities
This is the minimum score to reach Vista Premium certification.
Level 4 (4.0 to 4.9): High system performance, capable of handling HD content and high resolutions in 2D and 3D modes
- high end PCs, enthusiast PCs, desktop replacement notebooks and enthusiast notebooks
Level 5 (5.0 to 5.9): Highest performance available today.
- kick-butt computers
As Microsoft adds level 6, the level definitions might change, but existing scores won't. This way, it will be possible to compare old and new computers/hardware easily. Microsoft puts emphasis on the benefits of the WIE for hardware and software purchases, which is an obvious step from a business point of view.
There is a nice blog by Nick White on the Windows Experience Index that we recommend to everyone who is interested in more details on WEI: Windows Experience Index: An In-Depth Look
by gsaravin9
What An Incredible Piece Of Bloatware
Reader post by: Stating
Posted on: March 15, 2006, 9:21 PM PST
Story: Will your PC keep pace with Vista?
Why one earth would average Joe User need so many computer resources just to do basic tasks on their computer? We're not talking about mapping the human genome here for Christ's sake. Computer hardware is already getting too expensive for a lot of folks. How are computer vendors going to absorb the cost of an extra gig of ram, faster processors, faster hard drives, and faster graphics cards without passing it along to the consumer. Dell's going to have to yank the 1 year warranty and charge $200 for shipping. Is that $650 entry level laptop now going to cost $1,000? Or $1,200 if you want it to actually run well?
I've got customers running a 20th century OS (Windows 2K) on 20th Century hardware (P4 128 meg ram) and things are just dandy. Now all of a sudden, a mere 4 years later, they need 8 times the resources to do the same things? How is this progress?
by gsaravin9
up attempts on vista What's New Since RC1?
While we saw a great deal of changes between our initial review of Windows Vista Beta 2 and Release Candidate 1, it should come as no surprise that there have been far fewer changes between RC1 and the final version we are looking at today. For better or worse, RC1 was the last chance for Microsoft to implement any changes in Vista that were design changes; everything since then has been in the realm of last-minute polish and bug fixes. As a result, certainly Vista is in better shape than ever before, but at the same time it means that design issues we identified have not been resolved.
Given that, prospective users of Vista are going to find that our previous complaints about the User Account Controls still stand. We still find it's a good idea and a major improvement over the lackluster security features of previous versions of Windows, but even with the improvements Microsoft has made to it, it's still too annoying from a power-user perspective.
When Vista first entered widespread public testing about a year ago, a series of screenshots were circulated showing the worst-case scenario for the number of operations required to permanently delete a single file. At the time it was six operations ranging from confirmation of the delete to granting security permissions to empty the recycle bin. To Microsoft's credit they've reduced that somewhat, but we can still replicate that situation and come up with a worst-case scenario that takes four steps. Two of those steps are the required confirmation for deleting the item and then emptying the Recycle Bin, but the other two are security confirmation steps and while it's admittedly nit-picking, it's overly redundant to require two security steps to delete a file; this makes it twice as hard as it is under any previous version of Windows. UAC security will be accepted up to a point, but even one more operation than is necessary is going to quickly cause UAC to end up disabled by those who know how to do it.
Similarly, launching an application that requires administrative rights is still more difficult than it needs to be. As we touched upon this briefly last time, with the launch of Vista a lot of common 3rd-party applications will continue to require administrative privileges to run correctly, and it will continue to be this way for some time until everyone has had a chance to retrofit their applications for Vista. Unfortunately, every time one of these applications is launched the user needs to approve the application, and like the deletion scenario this gets increasingly redundant as the same applications are reused day in and day out. A pre-approval method or some other system is desperately needed for Vista's UAC system if the goal is to maximize security while minimizing the number of users disabling these advanced security features. Otherwise there are only so many orange screens that one can stand before UAC becomes a victim of its super-secure design.
One of the few noticeable changes since RC1 has been the driver situation with Vista, which has steadily improved since we first looked at Beta 2. Between the final driver submissions for RTM and a much smarter Windows Update, Vista was able to install drivers for all of our hardware in one of our test systems, other than the driver for a PhysX card. Working drivers were found for our motherboard, video, sound, network, on-board SCSI, and even TV cards. This is likely the high point for Vista as newer devices will ship without drivers built in to Vista, but nonetheless it's a refreshing experience after the amount of work required to completely install a set of drivers on XP. With the ability to load drivers off of a USB drive at installation, it should never be that bad again either.
The one weak spot as far as drivers are concerned continues to be audio and video drivers, but that too has been improving. We'll take a look at later with our benchmarks of Vista, but video performance is much closer to that of Windows XP compared to our first look at Vista, at least as far as DirectX 9 titles go. DirectX 10 and OpenGL are not as clear as there are no DirectX 10 games (and they will require Vista regardless) and AMD is still working the kinks out of their new OpenGL driver for Vista. For audio, earlier concerns about the new audio stack breaking older games has been partially resolved as Creative Labs has released a DirectSound3D-to-OpenAL wrapper that works with some games, showcasing that it's possible to work around the stack changes.
Even with a lengthy preview article, there is still a lot of ground to cover when taking a close look at the final release version of Windows Vista. We have attempted to create a comprehensive look at the new operating system, but even then there are still plenty of items that will have to wait for another day before we can truly evaluate them. The big question that almost everyone is going to want answered is pretty simple: should you upgrade to Windows Vista now or wait awhile longer?
In practice, SuperFetch depends a great deal on how predictable a user is and how much extra RAM a computer has. Veteran computer users will be slightly dismayed at first to find that Vista is actively attempting to use the entirety of a computer's RAM (down to 0MB of free memory remaining), which is effectively the opposite of how XP attempted to conserve as much memory as possible. This looks worse than it actually is, as cached data can immediately be thrown away to make space for an application as required, but Microsoft has nonetheless attempted to clarify things since Beta 2 where the Task Manager would only show total memory usage. Now the Task Manager makes it clear how much RAM is being used for program execution and how much is being used for cache, but this will still inevitably spark a few debates on if full RAM usage is really a good thing. Given that RAM tends to be a low power device operating at near full power all the time (especially on desktop machines), we feel RAM is the ideal underutilized component to try to fully exploit, as it doesn't incur the extra power costs of running at full load like a CPU/GPU do.
by gsaravin9
Test your router's compatibility with Vista
Posted on 29 Mar 07 at 18:31 by Grant Holliday in Windows Vista |
The Internet Connectivity Evaluation Tool checks your router to see if it supports certain networking technologies, like IPv6 tunnelling over IPv4, and traffic congestion protocols.
My Belkin F1PI241EGau from iiNet scored the following:
Basic Internet Connectivity Test - Supported
Network Address Translator Type - Not Supported
Traffic Congestion Test - Not Supported
TCP High performance Test - Not Supported
UPnP Support Test - Supported
Multiple Simultaneous Connection States Test - Supported
Test #2 failed with the following results:
Sending a Router Solicitation frame with ConeBit off
Waiting for Router Advertisement
Didn't receive any Router Advertisement frames from the Teredo server
Test #3 failed with the following results:
Trying to load library nsi.dll
ECN is disabled
Turning on ECN for testing
Trying to connect to the test server www.microsoft.com
Successfully connected to the test server
Fetching the webpage /windows/using/tools/igd/StaticContent/igdprobedocs/ecn/test.txt from the test server
Failed to fetch the webpage from the test server
Test #4 failed with the following results:
Trying to load library nsi.dll
The current Auto Tuning Level is set to Normal
Trying to connect to the test server www.microsoft.com
Successfully connected to the test server
Testing with webpage /windows/using/tools/igd/StaticContent/igdprobedocs/ws/test13.txt of size 8192
Fetching the webpage /windows/using/tools/igd/StaticContent/igdprobedocs/ws/test13.txt from the test server
Failed to get the webpage from the test server
Clipboard Image Monitor
Posted on 21 Jun 06 at 00:40 by Grant Holliday in Resources, Windows Vista, TFS Bug Snapper | 3 Comments | 1 Reference
The idea was thrown up on our internal mailing list by Matty Cosier:
?Wouldn?t it be great if TFS Bug Snapper could use images from the clipboard? Then I could use SnagIt or the built-in Windows Vista Snipping Tool to take screenshots!? (or something like that)
Clipboard Image Monitor is a small utility that sits in the system tray and watches the clipboard. If an image is copied to the clipboard this utility saves a copy to the filesystem.
Download the MSI installer from ProjectDistributor (~400K)
Download the source from ProjectDistributor (~65K)
By default it saves PNG images to %TEMP% with the filename ClipboardImage_00000.png
Instead of running a timer and polling the clipboard I?ve used code from Ross Donald?s article on using the Windows API to add another Clipboard Viewer and watch for WM_DRAWCLIPBOARD messages.
Icon is from the cool (and free) IconExperience set.
The next step is to integrate this into TFS Bug Snapper.
Vista Performance Ratings
Posted on 28 May 06 at 20:03 by Grant Holliday in Windows Vista | 1 Comment | 1 Reference
Seeing as we?re having a swinging competition, here?s my contribution from Windows Vista?s System Performance Rating screen. (Press WinKey+PauseBreak)
Sorry to break the news to you Geoff, but I don?t think 5 is the maximum ? maybe it?s opened ended so it copes with lots of new hardware.
No doubt Mitch will beat us all given enough time to get his new laptop.
FIX: Can't connect to Virtual Server 2005 on Vista
Posted on 26 May 06 at 23:20 by Grant Holliday in Windows Vista | 1 Comment | 1 Reference
Further to my last post on installing Virtual Server 2005 R2 on Windows Vista here?s some more guidance. Since Vista Beta 2 was released a couple of days ago I?ve helped numerous people in the ?office? get Virtual Server up and running on Vista.
After installing IIS with the required components (refer to the massive pkgmgr command line in the other post), Virtual Server installation won?t complain about IIS Admin any more and will install OK.
However, when you try and connect to http://localhost/VirtualServer/vswebapp.exe, you?ll get an obscure error, something like ?No access to application data?.
The solution
Right-click on Internet Explorer in the Quick Launch toolbar
select Run as administrator
enter the Virtual Server admin URL, all should be fine.
Obviously the reason for this is that the Virtual Server admin tool needs administrator credentials to be able to manipulate the service. Internet Explorer runs as an unprivileged user in Windows Vista, so you need to run IE using admin privileges to fix this.
IIS7: Direct .NET Integration mode (PREFERRED)
Posted on 23 May 06 at 22:16 by Grant Holliday in Windows Vista | 1 Comment
So I?m trying to get Darren?s SingleUserBlog V2 up and running under Windows Vista and IIS7 so I can debug the Readify Bloggers OPML webpart that doesn?t seem to be working (even though it?s a valid OPML file)
So the first step was to open IIS Manager and select ?Create Application? under ?Default Web Site?. Then setup like follows:
After this I browsed to http://localhost/SUB/ to be greeted with the following error:
Description: This application is running in an application pool that uses the Direct .NET Integration mode. This is the preferred mode for running ASP.NET applications on the current and future version of IIS.
In this mode, the application should not specify ASP.NET module components in the / configuration section. Instead, it should use the / configuration section to load ASP.NET module components.
Fortunately it provides two options for moving forward:
Migrate the application to work with the Direct .NET Integration mode (PREFERRED).
Move this application to an application pool using the Classic .NET Integration mode.
I chose to go ahead with the PREFERRED method, because it?s in capitals. You can change the configuration files by running AppCmd.exe which is a tool which automatically migrates your old config, to IIS7?s new config format.
%systemroot%\system32\inetsrv\APPCMD.EXE migrate config ?/?.
However, this doesn?t work for me. I get this error when trying the conversion:
ERROR ( hresult:c00cee02, message:Command execution failed.
After creating a vanilla Web.config and trying to convert that configuration, I found that when I removed the XML definition from the top of the file everything worked fine. Go figure.
Remove:
So now I have a modules and httpHandlers section for SingleUserBlog that looks like this:
And a working SingleUserBlog install on IIS7 on Windows Vista. But no debugging. I set a breakpoint in Visual Studio then hit F5 and get this:
Unable to cast object of type ?System.Web.HttpDebugHandler? to type ?System.Web.HttpApplication?
Now I?m lost. But at least I know I can run ASP.NET apps on Vista/IIS7 with little change.
Installing Virtual Server 2005 on Vista 5365
Posted on 21 May 06 at 12:00 by Grant Holliday in Windows Vista | 4 Comments | 3 References
Virtual Server 2005 requires IIS and the IISAdmin service to be installed. However these are not installed by default on Windows Vista.
Thanks to NickMacKechnie?s Weblog, I found the list of IIS components that are required.
Use the following command line to install IIS before installing Virtual Server 2005:
start /w pkgmgr /l:log.etw /iu:IIS-WebServerRole;IIS-WebServer;IIS-CommonHttpFeatures;IIS-StaticContent;IIS-DefaultDocument;IIS-DirectoryBrowsing;IIS-HttpErrors;IIS-HttpRedirect;IIS-ApplicationDevelopment;IIS-ASPNET;IIS-NetFxExtensibility;IIS-ASP;IIS-CGI;IIS-ISAPIExtensions;IIS-ISAPIFilter;IIS-ServerSideIncludes;IIS-HealthAndDiagnostics;IIS-HttpLogging;IIS-LoggingLibraries;IIS-RequestMonitor;IIS-HttpTracing;IIS-CustomLogging;IIS-ODBCLogging;IIS-Security;IIS-BasicAuthentication;IIS-WindowsAuthentication;IIS-DigestAuthentication;IIS-ClientCertificateMappingAuthentication;IIS-IISCertificateMappingAuthentication;IIS-URLAuthorization;IIS-RequestFiltering;IIS-IPSecurity;IIS-Performance;IIS-HttpCompressionStatic;IIS-HttpCompressionDynamic;IIS-WebServerManagementTools;IIS-ManagementConsole;IIS-ManagementScriptingTools;IIS-ManagementService;IIS-IIS6ManagementCompatibility;IIS-Metabase;IIS-WMICompatibility;IIS-LegacyScripts;IIS-LegacySnapIn;IIS-FTPPublishingService;IIS-FTPServer;IIS-FTPManagement;WAS-WindowsActivationService;WAS-ProcessModel;WAS-NetFxEnvironment;WAS-ConfigurationAPI
Vista: Windows Flip 3D
Posted on 1 May 06 at 21:53 by Grant Holliday in Windows Vista | Post a Comment | 1 Reference
Today I discovered one of the neat new features in Windows Vista, that is Windows Flip 3D.
Just like alt-tab, Windows-tab (Flip 3D) allows you to ?flip through open windows in a stack?.
Why is this great? Well, it let?s you preview the whole window before you switch to it. I guess this can save you time. All I know is that Win-Tab is going to take some getting used to after years of alt-tab?ing. (Although alt-tab still works as it used to)
Vista/IE7: Changing the default search provider
Posted on 30 Apr 06 at 18:59 by Grant Holliday in Windows Vista | 2 Comments | 1 Reference
Search is everywhere in Windows Vista. There?s a search box at the top of Internet Explorer and just above the Start button.
But if you just can?t get used to the default Windows Live search, then don?t fret. Head over to Add Search Providers to Internet Explorer 7.
Add your own Search Provider
You can also add a search provider to any search engine you like using JavaScript. Checkout the OpenSearch specification for more information.
window.external.AddSearchProvider(?URL?)
Search my site
Click to add holliday.com.au search provider
Example
Holliday.com.au
Holliday.com.au Search
Vista Fix: No sound through speakers on Dell laptop
Posted on 30 Apr 06 at 18:24 by Grant Holliday in Windows Vista | 44 Comments
I have a Dell Inspiron 9300 which has the SigmaTel C-Major Audio device.
The Vista 5365 installer doesn't have the drivers included but Windows Update includes a version. This version will install and work fine with the internal laptop speakers.
However, when you plug headphones or speakers in ? they don't work!
Downloading and installing the latest Audio drivers for Windows XP from the Dell support site will fix the problem though.
Workaround: Vista 5365 Explorer runs really slow
Posted on 30 Apr 06 at 18:20 by Grant Holliday in Windows Vista | 2 Comments
On Build 5365 of Windows Vista there is a bug with SearchIndexer.exe which causes it to crash continuously and slow down Windows Explorer. Thankfully I found a fix on this forum.
Symptoms
Windows Explorer is really slow. Folder contents take forever to display.
File | Save As../Open.. has a lag of about 5 seconds.
You keep getting the ?SearchIndexer.exe stopped working and was closed? errors
Causes
System Locale is not English (United States)
Workaround
Go to Control Panel
Under ?Clock, Language and Region? select ?Change the system language?
Select the ?Administrative? tab
Select ?Change System Locale??
Change the current language to ?English (United States)?
Restart when prompted
by gsaravin9
Windows XP and Vista Performance Comparison
Monday, 12 March 2007
Article Index
Windows XP and Vista Performance Comparison
The Test Machine
Results - 3DMark06
Results - PCMark05
Conclusion
Page 1 of 5
Even before Windows Vista was publicly released, there was a lot of concern from people beta testing the O/S. Running Windows Vista seemed to have a large performance drop for their PC when compared to Windows XP. Was it true? Or is it just scare tactics from Microsoft haters?
It is widely known that you need a much faster PC to run Vista than you do to run Windows XP. Microsoft recommend a minimum of a 1Ghz CPU and 1GB of RAM to run anything better than Vista Home Basic (I.e. Home Premium, Business or Ultimate) , and a Directx9 capable video card. I would hate to try and run Vista on a 1Ghz CPU, it would just be painfully slow. So when specing-up your new machine, make sure you at least double the minimum recommended RAM and CPU speed, have a dedicated PCI-Ex16 video card with 128MB of RAM or more, and you will be fine. If your video card supports DirectX9, you should even be able to run Aero.
Vista may include a host of new features, look a whole lot better and tingle your inner geek in all the right places, but most people just want their games to run smoothly, their office applications to open quickly and run without fuss, and the internet to be as fast as possible, so why would you upgrade to an operating system that will serve only to slow you down? Well we?re going to run a few quick tests to either prove or dispel the rumours.
What we?ve done is setup a high-spec machine, and we?re going to do a standard load of Windows XP Professional SP2, run our benchmarks, then a standard load of Windows Vista Ultimate and perform the same tests. The graphics tests will be run using 3DMark06, which runs on DirectX 9, not DirectX 10 as is written into Vista, so whilst it won?t be as true a comparison of possible performance as we would like, it is the best we can do at the moment, and tests current 3D software, which is what matters. 2D application tests will be performed by PCMark05. Whilst these are both ?artificial? benchmarks as it were, they perform a wide variety of tests, with 3DMark simulating current and future game rendering systems, and PCMark simulating everything from rendering web pages, to 3D Performance, 2D Image rendering and Hard Disk usage, all in one neat package.
Windows XP and Vista Performance Comparison
Monday, 12 March 2007
Article Index
Windows XP and Vista Performance Comparison
The Test Machine
Results - 3DMark06
Results - PCMark05
Conclusion
Page 2 of 5
Test Machine Specs:
ASUS Striker Extreme nForce680i SLI Motherboard
Intel Core 2 Duo E6700 CPU
Corsair TWIN2X6400 2GB DDR-2 Memory Kit
2 x Gigabyte GeForce 8800GTX 768MB PCI-Ex16 Video Cards running SLI
Western Digital Raptor 150GB 10,000rpm SATA-II Hard Drive
OCZ GameXstream 850W ATX Power Supply
Certainly a bit higher-end than most home or office PCs, but this will allow us to run much more intense tests and be able to spot any differences more easily.
Windows XP and Vista Performance Comparison
Monday, 12 March 2007
Article Index
Windows XP and Vista Performance Comparison
The Test Machine
Results - 3DMark06
Results - PCMark05
Conclusion
Page 3 of 5
The Results:
For 3DMark06 we ran 3 different tests, one with the video cards in SLI mode, one using only a single video card, and another in SLI mode using 8x Anti-Aliasing to try to see if there?s more of a difference when the 3D system is pushed hard. All tests were performed at a resolution of 1280x1024.
As you can see above, there is around a 5% performance increase using Windows XP under both SLI tests, the single card test showed a negligible difference, but still in favour of old-hat XP.
There were a few tests within 3DMark that showed a massive difference between the O/S?s, specifically the shader tests. The simple Vertex Shader test showed almost a 50% drop in performance under Vista, with XP running 369Million Vertices/sec versus 186MV/s under Vista. The shader particles test also showed Vista had a 25% drop from XP, and the pixel shader test a 15% drop in performance.
3DMark also performs Batch Size tests of moving triangle systems, starting with 8 triangles and moving up with 32, 128, 512, 2048 and finally 32768.
This test demonstrates graphics card memory throughput by testing how many triangles per second can be drawn. In these tests both versions of Windows improve at close to the same rate as the batch size increases, until (as you can see on the graph above) Vista seems to hit a wall, indicating a big problem with memory throughput under Vista. Hopefully this is only a driver issue that can be fixed by nVidia in the future.
by gsaravin9
This articlle from ozhardware website proves once for all.We can see an overall performance decrease of about 15% in Vista compared to XP, and when looking through the results, the main culprits are the graphics memory tests, where XP was a massive 11 TIMES Better than Vista!!! XP was able to pass through 3600frames per second compared to Vista?s lowly 312FPS. Again, hopefully future driver releases can help fix this issue, as that?s just pathetic.
Video playback of a WMV file also suffered greatly under Vista, giving just 30.8FPS compared to 69.1FPS under XP. This means Vista would struggle to do anything else while a WMV video is playing, quite poor really considering the hardware we?re testing on.
HDD performance was generally better on XP, but only by a few % barely worth a mention really. The only areas Vista excelled in were rendering transparent windows (i.e. like the Aero theme) and audio decompression. For transparent windows, Vista beats XP almost 4-fold, with 2671windows/sec under Vista, to 713windows/sec under XP. Microsoft has obviously optimised this process quite well for Vista to make the Aero theme run smoothly. Audio decompression was twice as good under Vista, working at 2665KB/s compared to 1371KB/s under XP. Unfortunately audio compression is the same under both, so you won?t be able to rip your CDs to MP3?s any faster.
by gsaravin9
Vista: Over 40 million copies sold . . . but to whom?
On Tuesday, as he kicked off Microsoft's annual Windows Hardware Engineering Conference -- aka WinHEC -- Bill Gates said more than 40 million copies of Windows Vista have been sold in the operating system's first 100 days of availability:
And now we can go back and talk about some of the success that was driven by the launch, talk about the Vista First 100 Days. We've really been amazed at the customer response. I mean, we knew that [Windows] Vista would become the standard version of Windows. We knew that the industry was stepping up to take advantage of those capabilities, but what's happened in the last 100 days has been beyond our expectations. As of last week, we've had nearly 40 million copies sold, and so that's twice as fast as the adoption of Windows XP, the last major release that we've had. What a liar!! They havea habit of bending the truth a little!!
If you think about that, that says that in our first five weeks we've matched the entire installed base of any other provider of similar software. So just in five weeks we've gotten out to those levels. . . Proves he is a damn liar &knows it.
This updates numbers released by Microsoft in March, in which the company said 20 million copies of Vista had been sold. But both now and then, what Microsoft isn't saying is almost more revealing than its public statements.Yep sure they are lying to the consumers.
The company's not breaking the numbers out. It's not saying how many copies are being sold as retail upgrades, how many are being sold pre-installed on new computers and how many result from PC owners turning in upgrade coupons they got with systems bought late last year.
And Mary Jo Foley of All About Microsoft brings up an excellent point -- many of these copies may not even be in the hands of consumers yet:Good point Mary JO.Sometimes she does ask pertinent questions!
As Endpoint Technologies Associates analyst Roger Kay notes, the 40 million is the number of copies Microsoft sold to the channel, not the number of copies sold by the channel and directly to customers.
I do think Windows Vista is a dud on the scale of Windows ME -- operating system I think ms is just fudging the figures.
by gsaravin9
hoping ms comes good.
I recently spoke to an HP representative in person - at a local retailer - and informed him that I was having to buy my new computer from Gateway and not from HP, as I had been planning to do since January, because HP refused to sell me a computer with XP installed rather than Vista - and was not providing drivers that would allow me to install XP myself.
This individual explained that Microsoft was blackmailing the industry. He actually used the word "fined", saying that Microsoft "fined" any manufacturer who sold a computer that did not have Vista installed.
When I spoke with a Gateway salesman on the phone, he explained they had originally only sold new computers with Vista, but that only the week before they had started selling computers again with XP installed due to large numbers of customers who were asking for this. You have to pay a premium for XP and this confused me until I heard what Microsoft was doing.
Microsoft is able to do this because all installations of Windows, whether XP or Vista, must be registered, or your computer will shut down and will not operate. If the computer vendor refuses to pay the "fine", Microsoft will simply not recognize the XP installed on your new computer as legitimate. Microsoft's explanation is that they no longer support XP as the operating system of choice - they want to force the pc world toward Vista. ( XP will probably be unattainable by the end of the year. )
You may ask why Microsoft is so insistent on the changeover to Vista, when there seems to be strong consumer resistance to the new OS. You know, they could sell and support both operating systems at the same time. If Vista really is such a superior product, over a very short period, the consuming public would naturally move into the new OS.
The answer is controversial, but designed into Vista are several things equally controversial: 1) Digital Rights Management, 2) Protected Video Path, and perhaps most controversial, 3) ..." a revocation mechanism that allows Microsoft to disable drivers of compromised devices..." ( source, Wikipedia). The bottom line seems to be that, for the first time, Microsoft is now able to dictate hardware design, giving it unprecedented control over the entire computer industry.
This just proves what a bunch of shonks Ms are in the industry trying to blackmaileveryone!!
by gsaravin9
From info news
Do you not remember the realease of EVERY OTHER os microsoft has released, it will have unchecked/sorted bugs for sure - just as long as they are generating money from it, who cares if the bloody thing doesn't work!
by gsaravin9
From info news
one user says VISTA It sucks.
Some people think it wont suck. unless you connect it to a vacuum cleaner. Then it will just crash it because the drivers aren't 64-bit aware. Then it won't suck. But the good thing is that Bill Gates is retiring soon...Microsoft will never be the same again.
No, it?s not at all certain that 90% of the world will be running Vista. What IS sure is that Vista will help drive more intelligent people to Mac or Linux. Frankly, I think Bill Gates may even give the word Vista a new definition:
1. Proper Noun - The last operating system released by Microsoft before it became the world?s THIRD largest software manufacturer.
2. Verb - To screw yourself by doing something incredibly stupid.
Combine Vista with Zune, and you have an even bigger joke. No wonder poor Bill Gates is coming unhinged, making an ass out of himself on TV and blatantly lying about Vista. This is even making it easier for people to understand the truth about the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation - it?s a fraud, too.
by gsaravin9
From info news
Do you not remember the realease of EVERY OTHER os microsoft has released, it will have unchecked/sorted bugs for sure - just as long as they are generating money from it, who cares if the bloody thing doesn't work!
by gsaravin9
user reports at infonews
I have both a Windows laptop (provided by my employer) and a Mac minitower (my personal computer). The Windows laptop get very frequent up dates as Microsoft finds more flaws in its OS. I have had a couple of updates just this week. The Mac get updates every few months many of which are more to update compatibility with new technology rather than to correct flaws in the OS. So, I would say that the Mac OS is much better than Windows in this respect.
Add a Comment
by gsaravin9
user reports at infonews
I have both a Windows laptop (provided by my employer) and a Mac minitower (my personal computer). The Windows laptop get very frequent up dates as Microsoft finds more flaws in its OS. I have had a couple of updates just this week. The Mac get updates every few months many of which are more to update compatibility with new technology rather than to correct flaws in the OS. So, I would say that the Mac OS is much better than Windows in this respect.
Add a Comment
by gsaravin9
lying about vista.
Vista It sucks.
Some people think it wont suck. unless you connect it to a vacuum cleaner. Then it will just crash it because the drivers aren't 64-bit aware. Then it won't suck. But the good thing is that Bill Gates is retiring soon...Microsoft will never be the same again.
No, it?s not at all certain that 90% of the world will be running Vista. What IS sure is that Vista will help drive more intelligent people to Mac or Linux. Frankly, I think Bill Gates may even give the word Vista a new definition:
1. Proper Noun - The last operating system released by Microsoft before it became the world?s THIRD largest software manufacturer.
2. Verb - To screw yourself by doing something incredibly stupid.
Combine Vista with Zune, and you have an even bigger joke. No wonder poor Bill Gates is coming unhinged, making an ass out of himself on TV and blatantly lying about Vista. This is even making it easier for people to understand the truth about the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation - it?s a fraud, too.
by gsaravin9
Vista: Slow and Dangerous
The security program in Microsoft's new version of Windows is so annoying you're likely to turn it off. And that's risky
by Stephen H. Wildstrom
Related Items
Podcast: Vista's Slow, Annoying Ways
Story Tools
post a comment
e-mail this story
print this story
order a reprint
digg this
save to del.icio.us
When I write a column, I almost never feel I have had enough time using the product under review. Even in the rare instance in which deadlines aren't bearing down, I often realize later on that I've missed a fair amount. In the case of Microsoft's Windows Vista, flaws that I thought would grow less annoying with extended use have actually become more troublesome.
Most of the time I spent testing Vista was with sluggish pre-release versions. I expected things to improve when I ran the finished software on PCs configured for the new Windows version. I now realize that Vista really is slow unless you throw a lot of hardware at it. Microsoft (MSFT) claims it will run with 512 megabytes of memory. I had recommended a minimum of a gigabyte, but 2 GB is more like it if you want snappy performance. This is especially true if you're also running resource-hungry Microsoft Office 2007.
The most exasperating thing about Vista, though, is the security feature called User Account Control. UAC, satirized in an Apple (AAPL) ad as a security guy who constantly interrupts a conversation, appears as a pop-up asking permission before Windows will do a number of things: change system settings, install programs, or update antivirus software. UAC may well be necessary to block malicious programs from secretly installing themselves or hijacking your browser settings. But Microsoft has designed it to drive you nuts.
Turn-Off Temptation
A recent experience demonstrates what I mean. I was working away when Windows OneCare, Microsoft's extra-cost security program, suddenly popped open a window asking me if it should give a program called wercon.exe access to the network. To begin with, this is a question that would mystify nearly everyone. (It turns out wercon.exe is a tool that sends error reports back to Microsoft.) When I clicked O.K., UAC asked me if it should let OneCare proceed. You would think Windows would be able to figure this out for itself and that these different security components would work together. But Vista leaves it all to the user to sort out.
There's a real danger here: UAC is such a nag that many folks will just turn it off, which Microsoft has made quite easy to do. Disabling UAC is especially tempting if you have set up limited accounts for your children that let you restrict the sort of Web sites they can visit, the programs they can run, and the amount of time they can spend on the computer. With limited accounts, the kids will have to find a parent whenever a UAC window pops up. But if you give them unlimited accounts to deal with UAC requests, they can undo any restrictions.
Unfortunately, turning off UAC severely weakens Vista's defenses. In a study of Vista security, Symantec researcher Orlando Padilla found that without UAC, Vista's resistance to hostile software was similar to that of Windows XP. Before Vista, Windows promiscuously let programs install new software and make system changes without any notice to the user. UAC goes way too far the other way, requiring intervention for many innocent actions. The version of UAC in Mac OS X works much better, rarely popping up except during a software installation or upgrade.
Immediate Pain
As for general usability, I still have trouble finding once-familiar features that have been hidden in odd places. For example, unlike XP's My Network button, an item on Vista's main menu called Network does not give access to any network settings.
Things don't have to be this way. I've spent as much time with the redesigned Office 2007, and it feels quite comfortable. I'm sure I'll get used to Vista's quirks, Microsoft will smooth out the rough edges, and, in time, Vista's many attractions will outweigh the drawbacks. For now, though, it's a pain.
Wildstrom is Technology & You columnist for BusinessWeek. You can contact him at techandyou@businessweek.com.
by gsaravin9
Vista: Slow and Dangerous
All Reader Comments
page 1 of 10
Albert223
Jun 6, 2007 7:56 PM GMT
The Vista project had a vision which due to a mid-course correction just ran out of time. Get it out of the door was the mantra. Well they will pay a big price for this down the road as the company stock is reflecting. Vista is not flying of the selves where I live. XP is selling strong and at a premium. This is not like XP. Vista demands upgraded hardware and the consumer is spending their money on other things.
by gsaravin9
Smarty Pants
Jun 6, 2007 3:43 PM GMT
Annnnd you people are surprised whyyy?
by gsaravin9
BummedSon
Apr 29, 2007 3:57 PM GMT
I recently bought a low end computer for my mother and all I could quickly obtain was Vista. Today "low end" means 1 gig of memory, a core duo processor and basically good hardware. But Vista is SLOW, and the screen is so busy with eye candy, that it is really annoying. Mind you, however they removed such clutter as title bars for things so you can't tell what some windows are for, and they added the most annoying UAC I've ever seen. Nothing is easy to find and ... ugh, I can't go on. If you are getting a new PC, search for one with XP.
by gsaravin9
Chris Nielsen
Apr 28, 2007 10:02 PM GMT
I had to buy a computer last week to replace mine. I was running Windows 2000 because I never liked or needed XP. I really tried to like Vista, and with 512 it was not that slow on my 3.3GHZ machine. But it was like working with a MAC in that you are kept from the OS and the UAC was driving me crazy. Sure it's kind of pretty, but not much more than XP and who needs it? Anyway, when I installed Office 2000 and found that Outlook would not work correctly, I decided to make a backup of VISTA and install win2k again. I was going to make TWO backups of my VISTA OS, just in case, but after the first one, I was informed that I was not ALLOWED to make a second one. WTF? I'm now looking into getting a machine and running Linux so I can learn it and prepare for the day when my Win2k no longer works for some reason. This is the worst upgrade I have seen from Microsoft and their failure to produce a version of Linux just tells me that they still don't have a clue.
.
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
people than at tech republic.
These people are a bunch of fence sitters
& can't comment for quits.Got no brains is better!!My challenge to you all 1. 5 million
members to let you know & challenge you to prove that vista is better than xp!!!when i know it to be false vista is slower by 15% than xp.
Prove it lets have some feed back
by gsaravin9
Adobe Production Studio CS3 will be Vista compliant, will the new version of AXIO Utils.Probably never!!
Vista is a hog (albeit a pretty hog ...), and should be avoided for any serious production at this time.
I (and others) suggested to Matrox that they not waste the time on Vista until it is actually usable. I expect that it will be awhile ...
Benchmark tests done by independent labs, for instance, show render times (for popular 3D applications) under Vista are approximately 10 times longer than under XP Pro.Well guys & gals i have been vindicated.
by gsaravin9
intel & Amd that Vista is not recommended os only xp.
Vista is slower by 15 %% to xp.Gaming rendering is slower by 10 times.
well guys & gals totally vindicated!!!!
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
Well no one fixes flaws in their op system after release like ms does.
I rest my case
by gsaravin9
performance but not many have blamed ms for their critical flaws in their op system.
Not NVidea's fault?
Reading Peter Gutmann's original paper "A cost analysis of Windows Vista Content Protection" he was completely right in his predictions, that Vista would want graphics cards to do the impossible, and that Microsoft would then transfer the blame for high end cards not running well from the actual Vista operating system to the graphics hardware vendor.
This is a classic example. Nvidia cards have always been one of the best brands of card on the market because of the drivers pulling every inch of power out of the cards. Now the goalposts have been moved and much more is expected of the card by the operating system BEFORE high powered games get to start utilising the GPU and it pushes Nvidia cards over the edge.
Guttman writes: "As part of the bus-protection scheme, devices are required to implement AES-128 encryption in order to receive content from Vista. This has to be done via a hardware decryption engine on the graphics chip, which would typically be implemented by throwing away a GPU rendering pipeline or two to make room for the AES engine.
Establishing the AES key with the device hardware requires further cryptographic overhead, in this case a 2048-bit Diffie-Hellman key exchange whose 2K-bit output is converted to a 128-bit AES key via a Davies-Meyer hash with AES as its block transformation component. In programmable devices this can be done (with considerable effort) in the device (for example in programmable shader hardware), or more simply by throwing out a few more rendering pipelines and implementing a public-key-cryptography engine in the freed-up space."
This is particularly of interest to NVidia users as previously ALL the available pipelines were used by the drivers to provide extra performance. Vista evidently requires that the entire workings of drivers be altered to suit itself, and the higher performance a driver previously was, the harder it will be for it to adjust to deliberately cutting out some of it's performance ability.
So I ask again, is this REALLY all Nvidia's fault, or the product of a fundamentally flawed requirement of the operating system?
by gsaravin9
Dell offers Windows XP again but wants you to buy Vista
Posted Apr 20th 2007 12:00PM by Brad Linder
Filed under: OS Updates, Windows
Dell is paying attention to the feedback gathered from its IdeaStorm site, and it's making some changes. No, they're not offering a system with Linux preloaded just yet. But they are bringing back the option of ordering a new PC with Windows XP.
While Microsoft plans to kill off Windows XP by the end of the year, many users are still a bit nervous about running th newer Vista operating system.
There may be compatibility issues with software they need to run, or they might just not feel like learning a whole new operating system when they're perfectly happy with the one they've been using for the last five years. And most people remember that Windows XP got a lot better with Service Pack 2, so they might be holding out for Vista updates.
Anyway, Dell is offering new computer buyers the choice to buy a system preloaded with Vista or XP. But as you can tell from the chart above, they try to stack things in favor of Vista by pointing out all the things it can do that XP can't. Noticeably absent from the list? Boot up quickly.
[via CyberNotes]
ReadPermalinkEmail thisLinking BlogsComments [10]
Recent Posts
Watch commercials and get free stuff with AdPerk (6/27/2007)
Earthmine takes on Google Street View (6/27/2007)
MySpace targets YouTube with MySpace TV (6/27/2007)
Adobe Lightroom 1.1 in the dark, no wait, its online again (6/27/2007)
Microsoft introduces Live Folders and Live Photo Gallery (6/27/2007)
Reader Comments
(Page 1)
1. So few people want Vista, that a gigantic OEM ( first of many? ) is bringing back the previous generation operating system? Yet the operating system maker is going to kill of that very OS?
I think we are reaching "The Singularity"...
...where Microsoft's hostility and contempt towards its paying customers causes its own self-extinction.
Posted at 12:59PM on Apr 20th 2007 by Todd
2. I think item 2 incompasses boot up quickly:
"Excellent speeds for Startup, Shutdown and Resume times."
Besides which I've found the boot up speeds faster than XP on my machine. But I can imagine it being slower on an older computer.
Posted at 1:11PM on Apr 20th 2007 by Jean
3. Whoops, you're absolutely right. That would cover booting up. I've found that Vista definitely boots slower on my system than XP. That said, the sleep function does work pretty well, so I rarely shut my machine down entirely.
Posted at 1:12PM on Apr 20th 2007 by Brad Linder
4. I'm amazed at how many programs don't work with Vista. I don't understand why this is, but its a show stopper for many businesses. Two examples:
Sonicwall VPN client
Trend Micro officescan client (enterprise anti virus)
Posted at 2:24PM on Apr 20th 2007 by Myron
5. Its not their fault nobody fixed their crapplications/drivers on time and its not their fault that they are trying to make $.
XP is six-year old tech - get over it...
Posted at 2:42PM on Apr 20th 2007 by Gyp Joe
6. "Its not their fault nobody fixed their crapplications/drivers on time and its not their fault that they are trying to make $.
XP is six-year old tech - get over it..."
It's not Microsoft's fault, per se, that some applications don't work on Vista -- that is, I think it would be unreasonable to hold them to 100% backward compatibility -- but it *is* Dell's fault for pulling the option of keeping XP even though they must surely be aware that some popular applications haven't been updated.
Try to put yourself in the shoes of a developer. You spend a lot of time and money making an application. You sell it somebody. Now, that same somebody comes back a month or a year later and wants you to spend more of your time and money updating it so that it will work with their new operating system -- and they probably expect you to do it for free. Why should you? You advertised that it would work in XP; you never said anything about Vista. It's basically an act of charity (or marketing/garnering goodwill) to update your product for free.
As for XP being "six-year-old tech"... what's so new about Vista? Oooh, sparkly! Wow, it uses a 3D card to accelerate rendering... that's, um, useful? Seriously, what does Vista do that XP doesn't, other than suck up extra RAM to prettify your environment?
Posted at 3:49PM on Apr 20th 2007 by James
7. I think microsoft and the OEMs are realizing they came on a bit strong with the vista launch. basically, with all the developers being lazy (and YES it is third party developer's faults in most cases. In fact, if the developers weren't lazy in the first place their applications would still work on Vista and all we'd be waiting for is driver support) I don't think Vista is likely to meet a large portion of people's needs this early on.
Should people make the switch anyways and get used to the next generation of Windows? Yup. But should Microsoft or Dell be forcing it when it'll happen over time anyways? That's just bad practice.
This winter buying season's going to see the release of SP1, as well as ANOTHER year (video card delvopers have had a year and a half before the release with the new video stack...so maybe with 50% more time...) of updates and drivers and new versions of applications...
No, this won't be the corparte market, the one needed for vista to be a success, but the home market embracing it this winter will be the bit indicator of how quickly vista will take over.
And BTW: Ideastorm is one of the single worst and most abused sites on the internet. The fact that Dell is actually taking advice for from this gathering of rabid fanboys and evangelicals is disturbing. The vast majority of people requesting XP again are more than likely Linux people DESPERATE for Vista to fail.
Posted at 3:56PM on Apr 20th 2007 by spencer.r
8. "Try to put yourself in the shoes of a developer. You spend a lot of time and money making an application. You sell it somebody."
Actually in almost ALL of the cases...programmers invest as little time and energy into a application as possible...which leads to bad compatibility when Vista asks for applications to use it's apis and libraries the way they were supposed to be used.
Posted at 4:00PM on Apr 20th 2007 by spencer.r
9. "...The vast majority of people requesting XP again are more than likely Linux people DESPERATE for Vista to fail."
Vista HAS failed:
"...So while Microsoft spent millions to promote Vista in China, the company apparently sold just 244 copies of the operating system during the first two weeks it was legally available in China."
Posted at 4:10PM on Apr 20th 2007 by Todd
10. So you give ONE report of a country that is well known for it's rampant piracy having problems selling legitimate copies of Vista...ignoring the fact that the article is compleatly off topic to try to misrepresent the facts of the matter.
And actually comments on the next line that the PIRATED version of Vista is in HIGH demand on china's black market.
Vista has outsold XP in it's opening months world wide as a whole in the past few months. It hasn't failed. It isn't ME. It isn't Bob. It's a new operating system that comes with it's own collection of headaches. XP was almost the exact same way(bad drivers, incompatible programs, and frustrating restrictions), and the fact that most people don't remember that shows how short the memory span of the internet is.
by gsaravin9
How do you expect Microsoft's new Vista operating system to go over with consumers?
A smash hit A middling success A mild disappointment An abject failure
306 votes
(10%) 1411 votes
(43%) 1142 votes
(36%) 340 votes
(11%)
Total Votes : 3199
responses
As usual, Microsoft will be trashed for developing a huge, pig of a program that doesn't do everything the way people want it to, yet it will be hailed as too complicated. Windows is in a no-win situation with any release. They are the big monopolistic bully with the huge cashflow that everyone loves to hate.
I personally believe Windows is an outstanding application that, despite it's massive monopoly on the market, continues to add more features that are integrated into the operating system instead of charging extra for them as stand-alone programs. My only complaint is the speed at which they are able to deliver these additional features. They have become too large to be agile. <>
And I predict the security for this version will be no better than previous versions. Expect patches upon patches to plug holes that dubious programmers exploit for sheer sport. But don't blame MS for the security issues - blame the rogue hackers that spend countless hours searching for a way to destroy others' good work. Nobody could effectively anticipate every way a community of punks could try to penetrate an operating system that is so widely used and poorly understood by endusers.
And no, I am not a programmer, nor do I even work for a software company. I am an accountant by trade.
suspect that most consumers will not upgrade to Vista unless by default. But eventually, it will happen.... probably because it will come with the new PC that we'll all be buying some time over the next 3 years.
I tried Linux on one of my home PC's last year and I could not find an internet content filter that would adequately protect my daughters from the filth that is out there. There probably is a way to do it, but the convenience of using Windows XP is compelling for a busy family man. For all their faults -- and we all fall short -- Microsoft makes it easy to stay a customer.
Posted: Thu Jan 18, 2007 8:26 am Post subject: Re: How do you expect Microsoft's new Vista operating system to go over with consumers?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I don't really care. I'm sure it will be at least a mild success. In my humble opinion software is supposed to facilitate our work and our lives and should otherwise be invisible. It is not supposed to become the work or even be of particular interest to anyone outside of the software development industry.
There is nothing much more annoying than having to spend time figuring out why the latest patch didn't work or going out to buy new peripherals because of software changes when the old ones work perfectly fine.
Computers are appliances. Most people would be very upset if they had to replace their refrigerator every couple of years.
i have been using vista for almost a month now.. and there's nothing in there that should of taken 5 years to do ... things work pretty much the same as in xp ... seems to me that there are several new features but those are not worth the upgrade price tag or the hardware upgrades....
perhaps security is better but perhaps not.. the main thing i've noticed is that there is a nagging message that shows up right before you install stuff.... surely hackers can find a way to get around that to install malicious software.
It offers no innovation - all of it's great new features have been part of OS X for a while. There is some security improvement, but fault will be found.
In my environment I run a combination of Windows, Macs and Linux boxes. The Macs never crash, even when MS office or explorer lock up. The users really enjoy the ease of use and reliability (not to mention the quiet). These still can't be beat for graphic design work.
The Linux boxes are great at server tasks; DHCP, email, security, DNS, etc - but users still find it too intimidating to be thought of as a desktop. (though I've seen Ubuntu and like it)
Windows - it's familiar so people use it and it works well for general office tasks.
What will it take to crack the Windows near monoploy? I have no idea - but we're stuck with Vista for the next few years.
I am currently running Vista (production version) on one of my computers that was previously running XP. Functionally it works the same as XP just a lot slower. I am sure there are new features in Vista that eventually I will see how they will benefit me and make my life easier, however, all I notice today is the significant slow down in performance (my PC has 1.8GHz Celeron with 500MB Memory). This coupled with the lack of drivers for printers and other peripherals underscores the question that one should ask themselves prior to upgrading, what is it in Vista that I need that XP cannot provide.
The reason that I installed Vista was to test my company's software products and make any necessary changes to the software and installation to support Vista. This is an important point as like myself and my company other software vendors will need to do the same and most likely made changes to their programs to support Vista. What this means to the general population of customers that migrate to Vista out of the gates is a certain percentage of the programs that run under XP will not perform correctly in Vista.
I would expect than in a year from now many people will have moved over to Vista and be equally as pleased with it as they are with XP today. However, like any software early adopters will have to fight through the bugs not only with the operating system but with the drivers and other 3rd party applications.
Bravo, thats exactly what I've done. I downloaded a beta version of Vista and found it to be bloated and slow. I wiped the computer clean and installed Ubuntu Linux. It's rock solid stable, visually pretty, fast, and using the Linux package "Wine", I can run any Windows program. And it's free.
don't see any need to "upgrade" to Vista. My fear, however, is that I will be forced to use Office 2007 when others with whom I deal start using it. In typical MS fashion, documents created on Word 2007 will not be readable by Word 2003. The recent Mossberg review of Office 2007 left me wondering if Microsoft actually reads any criticism on behalf of users.
shit yes
by gsaravin9
Support Notice
G/Technology Vista statement
The current 9.33 or earlier G/Technology application suites have not been certified against the Microsoft Vista platform. Currently, there are no plans to certify the G/Technology 9.33 application suites on Microsoft Vista.
G/Technology will include Vista client support in the 10.0 platform. This release is planned for August 2007 and will include full certification of all clients on Vista (Desktop, NetViewer, MobileViewer, NetExport client).
Following the 9.4 release, testing will be performed on 9.4 maintenance releases on the Vista operating system. Any faults attributable to the operating system within the G/Technology software will be corrected and included in a post-RTM 9.4 maintenance release. Expected availability for this release is Q3 2007. Functional changes to take advantage of Vista capabilities will be considered in the future but are not currently planned.
FRAMME has a core dependency on MicroStation/J from Bentley. MicroStation/J is compatible with the commercial version of Windows NT 4, Windows 98 and Windows 95 on Intel compatible computers and workstations. At this time, we are not aware of Bentley's plan for this version on the Vista operating system.
Initial testing by Intergraph of MicroStation/J running on the Vista OS has been successful. However, the tests to date have been very limited. Beginning in Q2 2007, a simplified set of validation tests will be exercised for the FRAMME products. Any faults attributable to the operating system within the FRAMME software family will be corrected and included in fixes releases. This support extends only to the 04.00.08/3.4/1.3 and 04.01.00/3.5/1.4 releases of FRAMME and FRS / Field View / Web View respectively. However, no full certification on this operating system is planned for any future release. The FKT products (Rulebase Builder, Nucleus and Function Library) are excluded from this test plan. No future releases of this suite are planned.
Functional changes to take advantage of Vista capabilities within the FRAMME suite of products will not be implemented.
There are no plans to test the currently released versions of InService on the Vista platform. InService 8.1, scheduled to be released during the fourth quarter of 2007, will support the Vista operating system.
by gsaravin9
Despite Microsoft assertions about the improved reliability of Vista, many in the industry are taking a wait-and-see approach. Microsoft?s previous operating system, Windows XP, required two ?service packs? issued over a number of years to substantially improve security, and new flaws are still routinely discovered by outside researchers.
On Friday, a Microsoft executive posted a comment on a company security information Web site stating the company was ?closely monitoring? the vulnerability described by the Russian Web site. It permits the privileges of a standard user account in Vista and other versions of Windows to be increased, permitting control of all of the operations of the computer. In Unix and modern Windows systems, users are restricted in the functions they can perform, and complete power is restricted to certain administrative accounts.
?Currently we have not observed any public exploitation or attack activity regarding this issue,? wrote Mike Reavey, operations manager of the Microsoft Security Response Center. ?While I know this is a vulnerability that impacts Windows Vista, I still have every confidence that Windows Vista is our most secure platform to date.?
On Saturday, Nicole Miller, a Microsoft spokeswoman, said the company was also investigating the reported browser flaw and that it was not aware of any attacks attempting to use the vulnerability.
Microsoft has spent millions branding the Vista operating system as the most secure product it has produced, and it is counting on Vista to help turn the tide against a wave of software attacks now plaguing Windows-based computers.
Vista is critical to Microsoft?s reputation. Despite an almost four-and-half-year campaign on the part of the company, and the best efforts of the computer security industry, the threat from harmful computer software continues to grow. Criminal attacks now range from programs that steal information from home and corporate PCs to growing armies of slave computers that are wreaking havoc on the commercial Internet.
Although Vista, which will be available on consumer PCs early next year, has been extensively tested, it is only now being exposed to the challenges of the open Internet.
?I don?t think people should become complacent,? said Nand Mulchandani, a vice president at Determina. ?When vendors say a program has been completely rewritten, it doesn?t mean that it?s more secure from the get-go. My expectation is we will see a whole rash of Vista bugs show up in six months or a year.?
The Determina executives said that by itself, the browser flaw that was reported to Microsoft could permit damage like the theft of password information and the attack of other computers.
However, one of the principal security advances of Internet Explorer 7 is a software ?sandbox? that is intended to limit damage even if a malicious program is able to subvert the operation of the browser. That should limit the ability of any attacker to reach other parts of the Vista operating system, or to overwrite files.
However, when coupled with the ability of the first flaw that permits the change in account privileges, it might then be possible to circumvent the sandbox controls, said Alexander Sotirov, a Determina security researcher. In that case it would make it possible to alter files and potentially permanently infect a target computer. This kind of attack has yet to be proved, he acknowledged.
The Determina researchers said they had notified Microsoft of four other flaws they had discovered, including a bug that would make it possible for an attacker to repeatedly disable a Microsoft Exchange mail server simply by sending the program an infected e-mail message.
Last week, the chief technology officer of Trend Micro, a computer security firm in Tokyo, told several computer news Web sites that he had discovered an offer on an underground computer discussion forum to sell information about a security flaw in Windows Vista for $50,000. Over the weekend a spokesman for Trend Micro said that the company had not obtained the information, and as a result could not confirm the authenticity of the offer.
Many computer security companies say that there is a lively underground market for
internet hacking.
by gsaravin9
Microsoft officially launched Vista for consumers in January, promoting the operating system as the most secure version of Windows yet. It is the first client version of Windows built with security in mind, meaning that it should have fewer coding errors that might be exploited in attacks, Microsoft has said.
Yet the "critical" hole that affected much older Windows versions also hit Vista. The vulnerability lies in the way Windows handles animated cursors and could let an attacker commandeer a PC when the user views a malicious Web site or e-mail message.
The cursor flaw lies in the operating system code. This means that any application that relies on the operating system to handle animated cursor files could be an attack vector. This includes alternative browsers, such as Firefox.
Video: Hacking a Vista PC
Determina experts explain how to exploit animated-cursor flaw.
It is a flaw that should have been caught by Microsoft's code-vetting processes for Vista, called the Security Development Lifecycle, some experts said. The flaw is also evidence that faulty code from previous Windows versions has been copied into Vista, they said.
"It is a little premature to attack the whole effort altogether, but this is something that the Security Development Lifecycle should have caught," said Amol Sarwate, a research manager at vulnerability management company Qualys.
The buffer overflow vulnerability in the cursor function in particular should have already been fixed because a bug in the same Windows component was patched two years ago, said Rohit Dhamankar, manager of security research at TippingPoint, a seller of intrusion prevention products. That should have prompted re-examination of the code, Dhamankar said.
Microsoft disputes that it should have caught the cursor bug before. People who say so don't understand security vulnerabilities because not all bugs are created equal, said Stephen Toulouse, senior product manager in Microsoft's Security Technology Unit.
"In the case of the cursor vulnerability, even though something may look similar to the outside, that doesn't mean the code is anything alike to the previous vulnerability," Toulouse said. "The SDL was never meant to catch every single vulnerability, period."
But Dhamankar argues that Microsoft forgot to recheck all the possibilities that could lead to a buffer overflow after the original bug was found and patched in 2005.
Mulchandani agreed. "The dirty little secret is that Microsoft clearly did not write Vista from scratch. They did not completely build a whole new code base for this operating system. Every version of Windows since Windows NT has had this flaw in it," he said.
Microsoft does acknowledge that Vista will have vulnerabilities. "There are going to be other vulnerabilities. The SDL is not a process by which no vulnerabilities will ever occur. There is no process on this planet that can do that," Toulouse said.
Now on News.com
The iPhone has landed
New GPL reflects software shifts
Putting the 'super' in supercomputer
Extra: IBM 1401 Mainframe, the musical The cursor flaw is like a sign post for the bug hunters. Hackers will now be looking for bugs in similar Windows components to find ways to attack Vista.
"This has been a very significant break and it definitely gives a big pointer," Dhamankar said. "If more such errors are found later, Vista is not going to be able to offer the great protection that's claimed."
Still, Microsoft's Vista security promise doesn't fall apart because of this single vulnerability. Vista is more secure than XP or any other Microsoft client operating system, Sarwate said. "If you consider Windows 2000, XP, 2003, I would still say that Vista is more secure than all the other operating systems," he said.
Mulchandani also said that, while Microsoft has taken way too big a bite at the security message, Vista is more secure than its predecessors because of features such as User Account Control and others that limit privileges on the operating system.
And that's just the goal Microsoft was aiming for, Toulouse said.
"You have to look at Vista versus XP. A lot of people are holding Vista up and saying in a vacuum it will reach some nirvana of security," Toulouse said. "Our whole goal with Windows Vista was to create a fundamentally more secure operating system than we have ever created previously."
by gsaravin9
Microsoft better at patching XP than Vista
Submitted Sunday, June 24, 2007 @ 11:30 PM
Microsoft company information - ( Microsoft News )
infoworld.com -- A Microsoft security executive released data Thursday showing that, six months after shipping Windows Vista, his company has left more publicly disclosed Vista bugs unpatched than it did with Windows XP.
by gsaravin9
Vista Performance Shootout: Upgrade Vs. Clean Installation
Benchmark Test Bed and Software
As we always do, we took meticulous care to generate fair, accurate and repeatable scores. We performed all of the tests on the exact same system, altering none of the hardware. For the Windows Vista tests, we used all of the same driver versions. The computer's graphics system is an ATI X1900 XTX CrossFire configuration; we enabled CrossFire through the driver interface and it remained on for all of the tests. Nothing was overclocked for these tests.
The system was configured as follows:
Motherboard ASUS A8R-MVP (a sturdy and well-regarded CrossFire board)
CPU AMD Athlon FX-60 (it's a classic)
Memory 2GB Crucial Ballistix
Graphics ATI Radeon X1900XTX CrossFire (Catalyst 7.1)
Audio Creative SoundBlaster X-Fi Fatal1ty (driver v.2_13_0001)
Storage Seagate Barracuda 7200.9 300GB
The performance tests we used were:
PCMark05?Default run. (Note that this benchmark failed to run on the Vista upgrade. It simply closed without so much as an error message, probably because of an as-yet-undocumented incompatibility. Since this report is intended to compare a Vista upgrade to a Vista clean installation, the results were useless; we did, however, provide the results of the XP baseline tests and the Vista clean installation test for the sake of curiosity.) UPDATE: After many hours of fidgeting with Windows, uninstalling programs, and searching deep for incompatibilities, we managed to get the benchmark to run in the stripped version of Windows Vista. It simply refused to run in the raw in-place upgrade. We're continuing our investigations?in the meantime, the pertinent results chart has been updated.
3DMark06?Default run at low resolution (1024x768) and high resolution (1600x1200)
Doom 3?Ran with default high quality settings at low res (1024x768) and high res (1600x1200, 4xAA).
Half-Life 2Lost Coast?Run with default settings at low res (1024x768) and high res (1600x1200, 4xAA).
Company of Heroes?Run with default settings at low res (1024x768) and high res (1600x1200, AA enabled).
F.E.A.R.?Run with default settings at low res (1024x768) and high res (1600x1200, 4xAA).
For encoding benchmarks, we used the MainConcept MPEG and H.264 encoders to encode a WMV HD video clip of The Magic of Flight (IMAX). We encoded the clip as MPEG-2 and H.264 files respectively, to the default NTSC settings.
Note: We ran each of the performance tests three times and averaged them, rounding to the first decimal. In the case of Doom 3, which skips and starts on the first run of a timedemo, we ran the tests four times and threw out the first run.
by gsaravin9
Once again more & more people are coming out & expressing themselves.
Vista a dud, says Acer's LanciFont Size: Decrease Increase Print Page: Print Correspondents in Frankfurt | July 24, 2007
THE head of PC maker Acer, Gianfranco Lanci, has hit out at Microsoft's Windows Vista operating system, saying that the "entire industry" was disappointed by it.
Few buyers have purchased new PCs specifically for Vista, Acer's chief says
"The entire industry is disappointed by Windows Vista," the head of the world's fourth-biggest PC maker told the Financial Times Deutschland in its online edition on Monday.
Never before had a new version of Windows done so little to boost PC sales, he said.
"And that's not going to change in the second half of this year," Mr Lanci said.
"I really don't think that someone has bought a new PC specifically for Vista."
Microsoft's operating system commands a market share of around 90 per cent, with Apple and Linux accounting for the rest.
While the industry had waited for years for Vista, the software was not really ready when it was launched to great pomp at the start of this year, Mr Lanci complained.
"Stability is certainly a problem," he said.
Well i said that nearly a year ago that stability would be a big problem.
Once again i have been totally vindicated.!!!
ta mick
by gsaravin9
slower than xp by 20%.
well vista is hopeless for gaming.
ta mick
by gsaravin9
The reasons given for stepping down are related to Gates wanting to spend more time working for the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, for which he?s been working part-time . But looking at recent events and the situation at Microsoft, you can?t help but wonder if that really is the (only) reason for Gates stepping down. With the company facing a number of issues, and being in the middle of the ever delaying Windows Vista and Office 2007 development cycle, I?m sure he could have waited and picked a better time for his announcement, say, after Windows Vista and Office 2007
I think the reason for Gates stepping down is that he is basically admitting his failure. I?m not sure if he is doing it himself, or if he?s being pressed by others to do it. But he, or others around him, have probably come to realize that his performance and his results as Chief Software Architect have not been very good in the last 3-5 years, and only seem to get worse. Gates himself has said that he feels very excited about things like voice recognition, tablet PC, unified filesystems and many other things that he feels that he still needs to help realize and it doesn?t make sense to me that someone who is excited about this would step down and go focus on unrelated things at the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. It seems to me that if he was really excited about his work at Microsoft, he?d want to stay. That?s not an unreasonable assumption to make for someone as passionate as Gates, if you ask me. It looks like it?s just not as fun anymore for Gates, not fun enough for him to want to stay, in any case.
One of the biggest failures of Gates is Windows Vista. When Windows Vista and Office 2007 miss their release dates, people often begin to blame Steve Ballmer. And as CEO, he has the ultimate responsibility, but the real guy in charge of Windows Vista is Bill Gates. Afterall, he was the Chief Software Architect, and the most senior technical guy responsible for making Vista development a success. And the way Windows Vista?s development went is nothing to be proud of to say the least. It?s a classic case of overpromising and underdelivering.
I still have the PDC 2003 DVDs with all the sessions about the various new technologies and features that would make their way into Windows Vista. It was very exciting to see that, but very little of those features are going to make it into Windows Vista. Microsoft has been either completely removing features out of Windows Vista, even major ones like WinFS, or seriously scaling back other planned features. What remains now of Windows Vista is just a tiny part of what it was really supposed to be. And even then, its release is continiously being delayed. I?ve tried beta versions of Windows Vista, and the quality of the beta releases are less compared to previous betas I?ve been in. When Beta 1 was released it just seemed like they had to release it just so they could keep their promise of releasing it on schedule. There were such obvious bugs in it, I kept wondering how people missed those. The answer, ofcourse, is not that they missed those bugs, they just didn?t have enough time to fix them and have a more quality Beta 1 release. Even the Beta 2 release lacks quality. And just like they released Beta 1 just because they had to keep their promise, they promissed to release Windows Vista by the end of the year for businesses, with the consumer versions being released in January 2007. I don?t know about you, but that seems rather odd to me. If the consumer versions can?t be finished by the end of the year, why can the business versions be ready then? Weren?t all the versions supposed to be released on a single DVD?
It just looks like they?re saying that the business versions of Windows Vista will be ready before the end of 2006 just to lessen the impact of another delay for the short term. . I?ve been saying before that they should have taken the time required to do it right, instead of giving out unrealistic release dates. The whole issue they?re having now is because of their own stupidity.
One of the major screwups that Gates was in charge of is WinFS, which was supposed to make it into Windows Vista. It was so important in fact, that it was called one of the pillars of Windows Vista. First it was taken out of Windows Vista, and it was said that it would be released after Windows Vista was released as an add-on. And now, it?s been announced that WinFS will not be released anymore as a seperate add-on. It?s been broken up, with bits and pieces of it going to SQL Server and ADO.NET. So there will not be a relational filesystem anymore. Take the time to read that blogentry with the announcement, and notice how Microsoft is trying to make it sound like this is a positive thing. You really have to appreciate the attempts at deception there, because they?re quite good. Here they are, essentially announcing ?Hey, we?re going to stop working on WinFS, and we?re not going to release it anymore as an add-on for Windows Vista?, and they expect you to fall for the positive spin they put on it, trying to deflect your attention away from the fact that they failed to deliver what they promised. And according to the announcement, we?re supposed to like this because it was done ?based on feedback they received.? I wonder who they got that feedback from, since last I checked, everyone was hoping WinFS would be released and bring us a relational filesystem. And we?re talking about what was once considered a pillar of Windows Vista!
Why can?t they just admit they screwed up? Just admit WinFS was too difficult a task for you, and explain why you can?t finish it, instead of trying to fool people. And WinFS was one of the things that Gates stood behind and wanted to get into Vista really badly. Together with the rest of the whole Vista mess, I think this is why Gates has stepped down. His other efforts like the tablet PC and Origami were also not very successful. If these are really the reasons why he?s stepping down, you have to wonder why he doesn?t just come out and admit it. The senior leadership at Microsoft just doesn?t seem to want to admit their failures these days. They don?t seem to want to hold themselves accountable. And if they do, they just ?retire,? often with a 1 or 2 year transition period, not actually taking any blame and making their exit seem positive.
And now, the one guy that was setting the example for everyone else at Microsoft has left them. Yeah, I?m talking about Robert Scoble. I don?t think you?ll find anyone who won?t admit that Scoble has a done a lot for Microsoft?s public image, particularly, making the company seem more human. As early as 2003 he put up a list of points on his old weblog, explaining the things companies need to do if they want to put up a company weblog. Those points are exactly the things Microsoft needs to do right now, and I?m surprised they haven?t been paying more (any?) attention to the points Scoble listed there. I?m quite sure Scoble probably told them about those things much earlier and often as well, but it doesn?t seem like people were paying attention. At least, the senior management at Microsoft didn?t even seem to notice. I don?t think Ballmer or Gates even took the time to try and talk Scoble out of leaving Microsoft, which is a clear indication of how much they valued what he was doing for Microsoft, and how much they understand the need for what he was doing at Microsoft.
Microsoft is dealing with a number of problems right now, and in a future post I?ll talk about those problems and about the things they need to do to make things better for the future.
by gsaravin9
The reasons given for stepping down are related to Gates wanting to spend more time working for the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, for which he?s been working part-time . But looking at recent events and the situation at Microsoft, you can?t help but wonder if that really is the (only) reason for Gates stepping down. With the company facing a number of issues, and being in the middle of the ever delaying Windows Vista and Office 2007 development cycle, I?m sure he could have waited and picked a better time for his announcement, say, after Windows Vista and Office 2007
I think the reason for Gates stepping down is that he is basically admitting his failure. I?m not sure if he is doing it himself, or if he?s being pressed by others to do it. But he, or others around him, have probably come to realize that his performance and his results as Chief Software Architect have not been very good in the last 3-5 years, and only seem to get worse. Gates himself has said that he feels very excited about things like voice recognition, tablet PC, unified filesystems and many other things that he feels that he still needs to help realize and it doesn?t make sense to me that someone who is excited about this would step down and go focus on unrelated things at the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. It seems to me that if he was really excited about his work at Microsoft, he?d want to stay. That?s not an unreasonable assumption to make for someone as passionate as Gates, if you ask me. It looks like it?s just not as fun anymore for Gates, not fun enough for him to want to stay, in any case.
One of the biggest failures of Gates is Windows Vista. When Windows Vista and Office 2007 miss their release dates, people often begin to blame Steve Ballmer. And as CEO, he has the ultimate responsibility, but the real guy in charge of Windows Vista is Bill Gates. Afterall, he was the Chief Software Architect, and the most senior technical guy responsible for making Vista development a success. And the way Windows Vista?s development went is nothing to be proud of to say the least. It?s a classic case of overpromising and underdelivering.
I still have the PDC 2003 DVDs with all the sessions about the various new technologies and features that would make their way into Windows Vista. It was very exciting to see that, but very little of those features are going to make it into Windows Vista. Microsoft has been either completely removing features out of Windows Vista, even major ones like WinFS, or seriously scaling back other planned features. What remains now of Windows Vista is just a tiny part of what it was really supposed to be. And even then, its release is continiously being delayed. I?ve tried beta versions of Windows Vista, and the quality of the beta releases are less compared to previous betas I?ve been in. When Beta 1 was released it just seemed like they had to release it just so they could keep their promise of releasing it on schedule. There were such obvious bugs in it, I kept wondering how people missed those. The answer, ofcourse, is not that they missed those bugs, they just didn?t have enough time to fix them and have a more quality Beta 1 release. Even the Beta 2 release lacks quality. And just like they released Beta 1 just because they had to keep their promise, they promissed to release Windows Vista by the end of the year for businesses, with the consumer versions being released in January 2007. I don?t know about you, but that seems rather odd to me. If the consumer versions can?t be finished by the end of the year, why can the business versions be ready then? Weren?t all the versions supposed to be released on a single DVD?
It just looks like they?re saying that the business versions of Windows Vista will be ready before the end of 2006 just to lessen the impact of another delay for the short term. . I?ve been saying before that they should have taken the time required to do it right, instead of giving out unrealistic release dates. The whole issue they?re having now is because of their own stupidity.
One of the major screwups that Gates was in charge of is WinFS, which was supposed to make it into Windows Vista. It was so important in fact, that it was called one of the pillars of Windows Vista. First it was taken out of Windows Vista, and it was said that it would be released after Windows Vista was released as an add-on. And now, it?s been announced that WinFS will not be released anymore as a seperate add-on. It?s been broken up, with bits and pieces of it going to SQL Server and ADO.NET. So there will not be a relational filesystem anymore. Take the time to read that blogentry with the announcement, and notice how Microsoft is trying to make it sound like this is a positive thing. You really have to appreciate the attempts at deception there, because they?re quite good. Here they are, essentially announcing ?Hey, we?re going to stop working on WinFS, and we?re not going to release it anymore as an add-on for Windows Vista?, and they expect you to fall for the positive spin they put on it, trying to deflect your attention away from the fact that they failed to deliver what they promised. And according to the announcement, we?re supposed to like this because it was done ?based on feedback they received.? I wonder who they got that feedback from, since last I checked, everyone was hoping WinFS would be released and bring us a relational filesystem. And we?re talking about what was once considered a pillar of Windows Vista!
Why can?t they just admit they screwed up? Just admit WinFS was too difficult a task for you, and explain why you can?t finish it, instead of trying to fool people. And WinFS was one of the things that Gates stood behind and wanted to get into Vista really badly. Together with the rest of the whole Vista mess, I think this is why Gates has stepped down. His other efforts like the tablet PC and Origami were also not very successful. If these are really the reasons why he?s stepping down, you have to wonder why he doesn?t just come out and admit it. The senior leadership at Microsoft just doesn?t seem to want to admit their failures these days. They don?t seem to want to hold themselves accountable. And if they do, they just ?retire,? often with a 1 or 2 year transition period, not actually taking any blame and making their exit seem positive.
And now, the one guy that was setting the example for everyone else at Microsoft has left them. Yeah, I?m talking about Robert Scoble. I don?t think you?ll find anyone who won?t admit that Scoble has a done a lot for Microsoft?s public image, particularly, making the company seem more human. As early as 2003 he put up a list of points on his old weblog, explaining the things companies need to do if they want to put up a company weblog. Those points are exactly the things Microsoft needs to do right now, and I?m surprised they haven?t been paying more (any?) attention to the points Scoble listed there. I?m quite sure Scoble probably told them about those things much earlier and often as well, but it doesn?t seem like people were paying attention. At least, the senior management at Microsoft didn?t even seem to notice. I don?t think Ballmer or Gates even took the time to try and talk Scoble out of leaving Microsoft, which is a clear indication of how much they valued what he was doing for Microsoft, and how much they understand the need for what he was doing at Microsoft.
by gsaravin9
Recent testing of vista compared to xp has shown that vista is slower by 15%.
Also chief Bill Gates stepped down because of the vista failure not because he wanted to devote more time to his part time charity Bill & Melinda Gatesfoundation.Only gullible people people beleive that!This has been the end of the road for ms & it's cohorts.Well the idea of releasing of an op systems before they are finished are long gone.Vista is long gone & cannot catch up at all as there are critical performance woes. To counteract this ms hopes to stop issuing updates to xp at the end of this year where people will be forced to partake vista.
Allready selling of vista has virtually dried up you have acer chief saying tha vista is a complete dud & they have gone back to xp.
Other people like dell & hp & others are not openly recommending vista.They are offering xp & vista has been sidelined by use at your own peril.There are still security issues & stability issues.
Well i have been right so far my predictions
have come true.After years of testing op systems etc vista is the pits where a system is unfinished to the point it becomes unusable is unleashed on the gullible public.
I was right,i was not merely speculating as some of you have stated!!!
mick
by gsaravin9
I recently had a chance to speak to some developers who are working on vertical market software solutions, and they HATE Vista. The DRM features are making it difficult to get certified audio drivers for specialty cards, networking issues are delaying development, and Vista's security is causing massive headaches for the whole development team. This is after 1.5 years of time developing for Vista. It is almost to the point that they are unsure as to the future of their product, because Microsoft is saying they will cease supporting/selling XP in December.
On a consumer level, the different versions of Vista seem to be causing some problems as well. People are buying cheaper versions and not understanding why they don't have Aero and other features they need. While this is a consumer research problem, some of the responsibility falls on Microsoft for taking such a poor approach to naming and selling Vista. Throw in the stiff system requirements, and Vista is just not going anywhere fast.
Vista may be the last full OS release from Microsoft as we know them now. They need to make MAJOR changes if they are going to remain competitive beyond the pre-installed user base.
Wellneed i say more folks than to say i was right all allong!!!!
ta mick
by gsaravin9
The entire industry is disappointed by Windows Vista,? the head of the world?s fourth-biggest PC maker told the Financial Times Deutschland in its online edition on Monday?.Never before had a new version of Windows done so little to boost PC sales?..?And that?s not going to change in the second half of this year,? Lanci said?.I really don?t think that someone has bought a new PC specifically for Vista,? he added.
Hmmm...I thought 'Vista' was doing rather well (according to Microsoft):
"But probably a better measure overall of the interest in Windows Vista has to do with the sales results. What has that awareness translated to? And the results have been fantastic. As of May, the last time we reported numbers to you, more than 40 million copies of Windows Vista have been sold around the world, by far a record for Microsoft paid-for software, and certainly outpacing XP due to the interest in Windows Vista, the pent-up demand, and certainly the largest PC market that exists today than the last time we did a major PC platform update?..
It's all true folks
by gsaravin9
Last Updated: Tuesday, 6 February 2007, 11:42 GMT
E-mail this to a friend Printable version
Windows 'fails' active virus test
Vista comes equipped with several different security tools
Security tools that work with Windows Vista have failed tests to see if they can detect viruses circulating online.
Microsoft's Windows Live OneCare security tool was one of four products that failed independent tests carried out by the Virus Bulletin.
The security testing group found that Live OneCare missed far more active viruses than any other program tested.
To pass the tests anti-virus tools must spot and stop 100% of the malicious programs used to attack them.
Attack profile
When Vista was launched on 30 January, Microsoft chairman Bill Gates claimed that it was "dramatically more secure" than other operating systems.
Work began on Vista in 2001 and prior to release Microsoft said that some of the delay was due to efforts to harden the operating system against viruses and other malicious programs.
Vista cannot fend off today's malware without help from security products
John Hawes, Virus Bulletin
Version 1.5 of Windows Live OneCare was co-launched with Vista and uses the same scanning "engine" as the security tools bundled with the operating system. Typically users pay a yearly subscription to use Live OneCare.
The Virus Bulletin tests try to catch out anti-virus software with a variety of malicious programs including bots and worms known to be spreading online, file infectors, polymorphic and macro viruses.
While Live OneCare did manage to spot 100% of the macro viruses it was tested against, it missed some wild viruses, polymorphic programs and file infectors.
Live OneCare caught 99.91% of the known active viruses it was tested against. This left it vulnerable to 37 separate malicious programs.
Other anti-virus products that failed the tests included G-Data AntiVirusKit, McAfee VirusScan Enterprise 8.51 and Norman Virus Control 5.90.
In a statement, Joe Telafici, vice president of operations for McAfee Avert Labs, said Virus Bulletin had not been using the most up to date version of VirusScan Enterprise at the time of testing.
"McAfee is currently working with Virus Bulletin on this discrepancy and to make the updated test results available," he said.
"The tests conducted in our secure labs were against the most significant viruses and worms affecting real-world users," said John Hawes, a technical consultant at Virus Bulletin.
"Although many improvements have been made, Vista cannot fend off today's malware without help from security products," he said.
Jo Wickremasinghe, Windows Live OneCare product manager, said in a statement: "We are looking closely at the methodology and results of the test to ensure that Windows Live OneCare performs better in future tests and, most importantly, as part of our ongoing work to continually enhance Windows Live OneCare to ensure the highest level of protection and service that we can provide our customers."
by gsaravin9
Basically there are problems in these areas
Thread priority and scheduling
File-based symbolic links
Canceling I/O operations
While clock-based time accounting might be OK for diagnostic tools that report thread and process CPU usage, use of that method by the thread scheduler can cause unfair CPU allocation. By default, on client versions of Windows threads are permitted to run up to 2 clock ticks (6 if in the foreground). However, the thread might get virtually no time on the CPU or up to 6 ticks (18 if in the foreground), depending on its behavior and other activity on the system.
unfairness that can occur when two threads that have the same priority become ready to run at the same time. Thread A runs until the next time-slice interval expiration when the scheduler assumes it has run for the entire interval and so decides that Thread A's turn is finished. Furthermore, Thread A gets unfairly charged for the interrupt that occurred during its turn. At the next interval, the scheduler picks Thread B to take over and it runs for a full interval.
the Windows Vista scheduler does not count interrupt execution against a thread's turn. This means that on Windows Vista a thread will always get at least its turn on the CPU and never more than an extra clock interval of execution, resulting in greater fairness and more deterministic app behavior. Figure 2 shows how Windows Vista responds to the scenario shown in Figure 1 by giving both threads at least one time slice interval of execution.
The various task keys specify how much preference threads associated with different multimedia types get for CPU and graphics processor resources (though graphics processor resource management is not implemented in Windows Vista
A major difference in the way Windows resolves symbolic links and directory junctions is where the processing takes place. Windows processes symbolic links on the local system, even when they reference a location on a remote file server. Windows processes directory junctions that reference a remote file server on the server itself. Symbolic links on a server can therefore refer to locations that are only accessible from a client, like other client volumes, whereas directory junctions cannot. To address this, Windows Vista supports the new symbolic link type for both files and directories.
Many file system commands have been updated to understand the implications of symbolic links. For example, the Delete command knows not to follow links, which would result in deletion of the target, but to delete the link instead. However, because not all applications may handle symbolic links correctly, creating a symbolic link requires the new Create Symbolic Link privilege that only administrators have by default.
On Windows Vista, the I/O completion processing is performed not necessarily by the thread that issued the I/O, but instead by the one that is waiting for the completion port to wake it up. This relatively minor change avoids needless thread scheduling and context switches that can degrade the application's and the system's overall performance. To improve performance further, a server can retrieve the results of multiple I/O operations from a completion in one request, avoiding transitions to kernel mode.
In Windows Vista most I/O operations can be canceled, including the open file I/O that Net View and Explorer use. Applications have to be updated to respond to end-user requests to cancel I/O, however, and many of the Windows Vista utilities that interact with devices that have timeouts have the necessary support. The file open and save dialogs that are used by virtually every Windows application, including third-party applications, for example, now enable their Cancel button while trying to display the contents of a folder. The Net command also cancels its synchronous I/O when you press Ctrl+C.
You can see the benefits of I/O cancellation by opening a command prompt on Windows Vista and typing:
net view \\nonexistentmachine
The command will hang while Windows tries to contact the nonexistent system, but you can type Ctrl+C to terminate it. In Windows XP, Ctrl+C has no effect and the command doesn't return until the network operation times out.
Another type of I/O that has caused users problems in past versions of Windows are those that device drivers didn't cancel properly because there was no easy way for them to know that they should. If you've ever terminated a process, but subsequently saw it lingering in process-viewing tools, then you've witnessed a device driver failing to respond to a process termination and canceling I/O issued by the process that hadn't completed. Windows can't perform final process cleanup until all the process' I/O has either finished or been canceled. In Windows Vista, device drivers easily register for notification of process terminations and so most of the un-killable process problems are gone.
I/O Priority
While Windows has always supported prioritization of CPU usage, it hasn't included the concept of I/O priority. Without I/O priority, background activities like search indexing, virus scanning, and disk defragmenting can severely impact the responsiveness of foreground operations. A user launching an app or opening a document while another process is performing disk I/O, for example, experiences delays as the foreground task waits for disk access. The same interference also affects the streaming playback of multimedia content like songs from a hard disk.
Windows Vista introduces two new types of I/O prioritization in order to help make foreground I/O operations get preference: priority on individual I/O operations and I/O bandwidth reservations. The Windows Vista I/O system internally includes support for five I/O priorities as shown in / but only four of the priorities are used (future versions of Windows may support High).
I/O has a default priority of Medium and the Memory Manager uses Critical when it wants to write dirty memory data out to disk under low memory situations to make room in RAM for other data and code. The Windows Task Scheduler sets the I/O priority for tasks that have the default task priority to Low, and the priority specified by applications written for Windows Vista that perform background processing is Very Low. All of the Windows Vista background operations, including Windows Defender scanning and desktop search indexing, use Very Low I/O priority
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
Net firms tackle Vista headache
Some new PC owners have faced problems getting online
Windows Vista is causing problems for some new PC owners hooking up their machine to a broadband connection.
Some old installation discs that simplify the task of configuring a PC for broadband have refused to work on machines loaded with Vista.
One reader was warned by Virgin Media that it would be "weeks" before its software worked with Vista.
Other net service firms have also admitted that the appearance of Vista has caused some hiccups for users.
Disc delays
Microsoft launched the consumer versions of Windows Vista on 30 January and anyone buying a PC since that date is likely to have it installed on their brand new machine.
Many are thought to have suffered the same problem as Swansea-based Rob Evans who found that he could not use his existing Virgin Media account with his new PC from Tesco.
After ringing Virgin for help he was told that Vista support may not be forthcoming for some time.
A spokesman for Virgin Media, formerly NTL/Telewest, admitted that its discs did not yet work with Vista but added that Mr Evans was now using his broadband service.
"We can get people online without the installation disc," he added. "It's not that it does not work, it's just the disc."
The spokesman said that other net service firms were also known to be taking time to get to grips with Vista.
Microsoft launched Windows Vista to consumers in January
"It's such a big product that to train staff up on it fully and make sure all your services are tested and compliant takes time," he said.
A spokesman for BT said: "I think we are now supporting it though we did have some issues with it."
In particular, he said, Vista was conflicting with the Norton security software that BT sells with some of its broadband bundles.
"That's now been ironed out," he added.
The spokesman said BT had created a help page devoted to Vista to make it easier for people to get their PC connected.
Net service firm Tiscali advises its users to back-up important data on their Vista PC before attempting to connect it to broadband.
Andrew Ferguson, editor at Think Broadband, said: "I suspect Vista is going to break a lot of things as it makes some major changes to how things are done in Windows."
"Many places aren't up to speed with Vista yet," he said.
by gsaravin9
The humble office printer can damage lungs in much the same way as smoke particles from cigarettes, according to a team of Australian scientists.
An investigation of a range of models showed that almost a third emit potentially dangerous levels of toner into the air.
The Queensland University of Technology scientists have called on ministers to regulate these kinds of emissions.
They say some printers should come with a health warning.
The researchers carried out tests on more than 60 machines.
Almost one-third were found to emit ultra-tiny particles of toner-like material, so small that they can infiltrate the lungs and cause a range of health problems from respiratory irritation to more chronic illnesses.
Conducted in an open-plan office, the test revealed that particle levels increased five-fold during working hours, a rise blamed on printer use.
The problem was worse when new cartridges were used and when graphics and images required higher quantities of toner.
The researchers have called on governments to regulate air quality in offices.
They also want companies to ensure that printers are based in well-ventilated areas so that particles disperse.
by gsaravin9
that both the ATi Catalyst driver and nVidia?s nTune software can be used to write arbitrary registry values without performing the proper checks and ?could be used as an attack vector to circumvent Vista kernel protection.? Rutkowska continued with, ?The whole problem in NVIDIA is that the driver doesn?t do the proper checks and can do a write for an arbitrary registry.?
But the problem doesn?t end there. Further investigation discovered that the computer doesn?t even need the bad driver installed for it to be used as a method of attack. ?The attacker could just include it as part of their own rootkit and then use it to exploit Vista,? she said.
Her point was that the driver could be posted on any website and used to build a rootkit and it would not be possible to claim that it was intentionally done because a $250 driver signing certificate was easy enough to get from a Microsoft partner site.
All this implies that the user would first have to download the file in the first place from a third party and not directly from nVidia or ATi. The thought of someone doing that almost sickens me but I know people do it and I?d advise them not to do so. That doesn?t negate the fact that this problem exists but in order to fall victim to it, you yourself have to download an infected file.
Besides, the Catalyst software and nVidia?s drivers are fairly resource heavy and on my systems, I have everything but the basic driver support disabled. It?s a good idea you do the same, for security?s sake and because it will improve your startup times.
by gsaravin9
and in this case it has been accused of not accurately portraying computers through the use of the ?Vista Capable? logo program. This was supposed to tell consumers that a computer could run Vista but there is a dispute over which version of Vista it applied to.
The company says the ?Vista capable? logo applied only to computers that would be running Vista Basic and that some manufacturers were installing Vista Premium which would obviously lead to system slow downs and sluggishness. Microsoft claims this is not its fault.
In this logo program is also ?Vista Ready? aka ?Premium Ready? which describes faster systems that are capable of running all the advanced features of Vista without a problem though sadly confusion among these programs is not sitting well with consumers. Doesn?t common sense say that a $300 computer won?t run Vista well even if it is ?capable,? I think it does.
A federal judge has ruled that the lawsuit against Microsoft and its ?Vista capable? logos will go forward. On Tuesday, U.S. District Court Judge Marsha Pechman denied to dismiss this suit on two grounds that Microsoft?s attorneys were attacking but a third issue was considered.
Currently there are two plaintiffs listed in the case who are now seeking that it be raised to ?class action? status. In an email to Internetnews, Microsoft said, ??This is the first step in the process and we welcome the opportunity to put our case to the court in due course.?
If the case is not settled, a tentative trial date has been set for October 28, 2008, US courts are nothing, if not slow.
by gsaravin9
My dvd chucks Massive hangs again. In the interest of fairness I should mention that the Vista Kernel seemed to have no problem with my DVD (in fact it seemed to be reacting to everything without problems at all). It pretty much seemed Windows Explorer to be the one that caused all the problems. Why a crappy process like explorer that accepts arbitrary extensions is in control of all the key life-saver key combinations that can get you out of a hang like this, is beyond me, but there you go.
Anyway, I finally extracted the file I needed from the DVD. How? Well, I put it in my older laptop, which it running now Kubuntu 7.04 (more about that in a follow up post), copied the file to my home directory and then copied it over the network (thang goodness for samba!). Not a very pleasant experience overall, and just adds to my already big distrust of how crappy Windows Explorer in Vista is.
by gsaravin9
Want proof that Vista is Crap?: reader comment from Penguinisto
Posted on: August 18, 2007, 10:51 AM PDT
Story: A bump on the road to Windows Vista
Then look no further than here:
http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,1895,2171472,00.asp
"Maybe it was something in the water? I've been a big
proponent of the new OS over the past few months, even going
so far as loading it onto most of my computers and spending
hours tweaking and optimizing it. So why, nine months after
launch, am I so frustrated? The litany of what doesn't work and
what still frustrates me stretches on endlessly."
...and on page two of the article (after a litany of Vista
problems...)
" I could go on and on about the lack of drivers, the bizarre
wake-up rituals, the strange and nonreproducible system quirks,
and more. But I won't bore you with the details. The upshot is
that even after nine months, Vista just ain't cutting it. I definitely
gave Microsoft too much of a free pass on this operating system:
I expected it to get the kinks worked out more quickly. Boy, was
I fooled! If Microsoft can't get Vista working, I might just do the
unthinkable: I might move to Linux.
well a lot of folks are just doing that
by gsaravin9
hardly any has been deployed.
A bump on the road to Windows Vista
IT managers are saying "not so fast" as they move toward the OS, despite Microsoft's optimism about quick adoption.
By Ina Fried
Staff Writer, CNET News.com
Published: August 15, 2007, 12:01 PM PDT
TalkBackE-mailPrint del.icio.us Digg this
Businesses that had been thinking of a quick move to Windows Vista may be rethinking things a bit, according to a new study by Forrester Research.
"IT managers are finding themselves pulling back their initial Windows Vista deployment plans," Forrester analyst Benjamin Gray said in a report issued this week.
High ImpactWhat's new:
Businesses are moving to Windows Vista less quickly than originally planned, in part because of application compatibility woes, hefty hardware requirements and a lack of clarity around when the first service pack will be issued.
Bottom line:
Though slower Vista adoption would be a strategic blow to Microsoft, the financial impact could be muted, so long as businesses and consumers keep buying new PCs and its volume license business remains strong.
More stories on this topic
That said, Forrester notes in the first line of its report that it's not like most businesses are really going to skip over Vista.
"For the vast majority of businesses, Windows Vista is a matter of when and how, not if," Gray wrote. "This is thanks in large part to Microsoft's dominance in the corporate client operating system market."
While Linux has made considerable inroads in the server world and Apple has been able to substantially boost its market share in the consumer market, the corporate desktop remains solidly in Microsoft's domain.
But Microsoft has made the case that not only will businesses adopt Vista, they will do so quite quickly.
In September, Brad Goldberg, general manager for Windows Client product management, predicted that Vista would be put in use by twice as many businesses in the first year as Windows XP was in the 12 months following its October 2001 release.
Research firm IDC said that Windows XP usage was at 10 percent after a year in release. But IDC analyst Al Gillen said in September, talking about Vista, that "for them to do 20 percent in the first 12 months of availability is almost impossible."
Though slower Vista adoption would be a strategic blow to Microsoft, the financial impact could be muted, so long as businesses and consumers keep buying new PCs and its volume license business remains strong.
Forrester finds that many businesses are focused on issues like making sure they move to Vista before support runs out on older operating systems. Windows 2000 remains in the extended support phase until July 2010, while Windows XP remains in mainstream support through April 2009, and in extended support until 2014.
"When it comes to Windows Vista, Microsoft's biggest competitor isn't Apple, Novell, Red Hat or Ubuntu (just to name a few)--it's Microsoft itself," Gray wrote. "Businesses have, for the most part, been running either Windows 2000 or Windows XP for the past four or five years. These (operating systems) are mature, thoroughly tested and have been proven 'good enough,' making the business case for Windows Vista even harder for a lot of companies."
Another area of concern for businesses is the lack of specificity around the first service pack for Windows Vista. Although Microsoft has been making the case--and Forrester concurs--that SP1 need not be a critical milestone, some businesses are awaiting that release before migrating their machines to Vista.
Now on News.com
Mortgage meltdown: Tech stocks' gain?
Week in review: AMD's scramble, Google's gamble
Is the digital pen getting mightier?
Extra: Space cadet school
"Most of the IT managers we spoke with cited SP1 as the reason they have yet to seriously consider deploying Windows Vista into their respective companies," Gray wrote. "Whether right or wrong, experience tells IT managers that the first service pack is Microsoft's official blessing that the new OS is complete."
Microsoft has not said exactly when that release will be available. It did say, as part of an antitrust settlement court filing, that a beta version will be out this year, but it has not said when the final version will be issued.
And, although Microsoft initially touted the ability of older programs to run smoothly on Vista as a strength of the new operating system, Gray notes that "application compatibility doesn't look as good as we had hoped."
"We heard application compatibility success rates that ranged from as low as 60 percent to as high as 90 percent," Gray wrote, noting that the figures have improved over time.
Also, Gray said that many businesses are finding Vista is not a good bet for their older, but still-in-use PCs. "Hardware compatibility is hard to get around with PCs older than 12 to 18 months," Gray wrote.
by gsaravin9
What's new:
Businesses are moving to Windows Vista less quickly than originally planned, in part because of application compatibility woes, hefty hardware requirements and a lack of clarity around when the first service pack will be issued.
& thats the truth
by gsaravin9
vista.Bottom line:
Though slower Vista adoption would be a strategic blow to Microsoft, the financial impact could be muted, so long as businesses and consumers keep buying new PCs and its volume license business remains strong.
by gsaravin9
Gates sizes up the Web's next generation
Microsoft's chairman says it's time to embrace new Web trends, from programmable sites to ad-funded hosted services.
Video: Rebirth of the cool
Video: Gates keynote at Mix '06
By Martin LaMonica
Staff Writer, CNET News.com
Published: March 21, 2006, 7:10 AM PST
See all Newsmakers
TalkBackE-mailPrint del.icio.us Digg this
newsmakers Think Web 2.0 and think Microsoft? Not necessarily.
The company has long provided the tools for building Web sites. But it's been a couple steps behind when it comes to some of the bigger ideas and business models that have surfaced around Web 2.0, such as advertising-based software.
In addition, Microsoft has long made devices--whether it's the PC, server or handheld--the center of computing design. Now Web sites are becoming programmable, allowing people to "mash up" data from different sites.
To try to capture--and participate--in some of the buzz around Web 2.0, Microsoft organized a conference in Las Vegas called Mix '06 aimed at Web developers and designers. After his keynote speech at the conference Monday, Microsoft chairman and chief software architect Bill Gates spoke to CNET News.com about the push into hosted services, competition with Google and mobile computing.
Q: A lot of the buzz and thinking around Web 2.0 has come from outside Microsoft. Is this conference an attempt to get more involved there? And does that concern you at all?
A: Gates: Well, for the key new technologies that enable us to take the browser to a new level--DHTML, JavaScript, XML capabilities--we've been the pioneer.
If I'm a consumer or small-business owner, I could get a lot of applications in a hosted version, from project management to word processing. In that world of Web applications, how do you make Windows Vista a must-have?
Gates: Well, Vista is probably more relevant now than ever because, as you're browsing, you want to download Active X controls and have a security framework in there. Having the kind of "reputation" services we built into Vista makes the community value more important: We know which Web sites are phishing Web sites. We know which controls people have had a good experience with. That kind of reputational value may be one of the biggest things people get out of Vista.
Video: Gates on
Web 2.0
In interview with CNET News.com, Bill Gates says Microsoft is ready to mix it up with rivals.
Likewise, the ability to download code and compartmentalize it--that's kind of a breakthrough that's come out of the fact that we're down the learning curve on security--way more than any other company--I can say 100 times as much. In the last three years, it's been our biggest R&D priority, and we've made breakthroughs.
Vista, in terms of rich media--people are doing movies more. People want to organize and find those things. They want to work offline as well as online. We picked the things where people want Windows to (work) better.
People are designing applications with the Web in mind. In the past, you've been more Windows-centric with development tools. Will you be pointing developers to write applications where the Web is the development platform?
Gates: The Web is where a lot of code is being written, and you can go back to the year 2000 and the .Net initiative. .Net was designed to let people do state-of-the-art Web sites. In fact, .Net's success has been the primary platform for building Web sites. It's been quite phenomenal.
People are using other tools--around scripting, PHP and all that. But we've come in and really targeted that market. And as people do richer Web sites, we think the richness of what we've done there will go beyond the scripting-language-type approaches, which are fine. But more and more people will do sophisticated things. So there's nothing dramatic here, in the sense that the Web just happened.
The Web is evolving. There's a little bit more maturity now, in terms of business models with advertising coming in, with some of the late-'90s mistakes understood. But we're probably, as an industry, making some of those same mistakes. And that's OK. The ferment, the creativity, is incredible to see.
You've been talking about the Web as a development platform for years. Internally at Microsoft, have you made the switch?
Gates: (Microsoft's) first company meeting around software as a service goes back over seven years now. We said it's a lot better for us and customers. Instead of viewing software as a one-time thing--you buy a new version, you're using that--if we have a continuous relationship (with) something like Watson, where we monitor what people are doing and the drivers they are using, Office Online can get templates and download new things.
It's letting our software innovation be more connected to the user, more customized to what they want. It's a great paradigm for us--to create new value. We did underestimate advertising, so an element of what we're doing there is catch-up.
There was a major demarcation when Ray (Ozzie) put out his memo last year, really saying the primary applications model will have everyone delivering through the Web, monitored through the Web, updating through the Web. And many of these services, like storage or authentication, that you think of as long as they work.
by gsaravin9
Active Directory or SharePoint on premise--we've got to get those out (so people can) simply connect up to them. We're making great progress on that.
That's what makes this industry fun. Even Microsoft, with incredible research capabilities--the marketplace will come along and show us to put more into this and what is not paying off. We've got to be very dynamic. So far, throughout our history, our epitaph has been written 10 times, and so far, we're still alive. It's fun to see we're going through another one of those cycles.
And particularly, people think Google was born on this (Web application) paradigm, and (are wondering whether) any of the traditional software companies understand and can actually push this paradigm. Here at this conference, clearly, we're saying we've got the best tools for this paradigm, and we want to know where we should take it.
Last week, you said you're going after IBM. As you look at the next generation of applications across the board, who do you think is your primary competitor? Is it IBM and its platform, or is it Google and its Web platform?
Gates: When it comes to supplying enterprises and having that long-term relationship, we and IBM are hotly competitive in doing that.
Video: Mix '06: Gates keynote
From the stage of Mix '06, Bill Gates discusses building new online applications.
In terms of thought leadership, if someone said who's cool right now, obviously, Google would be high on the list there. Really, one thing they've done that's been key to their success (is search). We have to provide a better search experience--and get people to think about search in terms of these tasks, these contexts. We think we have a lot to contribute there. Not many people are brave enough to compete with something with that kind of scale and momentum. Well, we are.
Google bought a little company that does an online word processor, and there's talk of it doing an online calendar. Do you think it could assemble a Web "office" and compete with what you have?
Gates: I think they can do anything they want. Remember Orkut? That was a great social-networking thing that I don't think has been heard of for the last few years. They came out with an instant-messaging voice-type product.
Certainly, there will be lots of ways that people offer software over the Internet. There will be so many companies doing these things. It's not really appropriate to look at just one.
Not many people are brave enough to compete with (Google), with that kind of scale and momentum. Well, we are. The idea that there will be complementary capability, where using rich-client capability and Web capability--that's a big theme from us. You can look through our history. We've been pretty rational as the fads roll through. Yes, there's a lot to be said for that, but that doesn't take away from the fact that you want--when not connected to the Internet--access to your information. You want richness and responsiveness that local applications can provide.
There's a lot of experimentation with business models. Are you concerned that some of the business models are not quite baked?
Gates: Well, I think we'll see the same types of things we always see, with lots of new companies and new ideas. Ninety percent will not be distinct enough or not have the right business model, and those will go away. And yet the 10 percent that emerge will show new and neat things. Take all the companies doing video today. If you asked me today which ones will be here five years from now, I couldn't really say and yet--I love using them. I think what (they've) got there is neat and exciting.
I do think some of the bigger players, like ourselves, Yahoo and Google, will be in that space, offering those capabilities as well. But there's room for some great success story to come out of it. I think it's a bit unclear, though, now how far it can go.
What problems do you want Ray Ozzie thinking about, as one of your chief technical officers?
Gates: He's a phenomenonal person, in terms that he thinks like a developer and thinks like an end user. He'll sit down and literally do story boards--if I want to do this scenario, how can I do very few screens to get to that?
Everything he's done in his career has been a leading-edge thing. He, more than anyone, is thinking: What is a "Live" application? How is it different from a classical application and, therefore, what services should Microsoft provide? He's gathered a top group of Microsoft people, and he's driving that idea of how to design a platform. But because he's Ray, he's keeping in mind those end-user things.
We wanted to hire Ray for decades--literally. But the timeliness of his coming in and knowing he's shaped his mind around what these new applications look
by gsaravin9
like is phenomenal for us. Having someone full-time thinking about that evolution is very, very important.
From a business point of view, what do you think is the bigger opportunity? Is it selling the servers and tools, or is it the advertising?
Gates: Well, advertising--nobody really knows what the limits to that are. There will be experimentation to having you watch ads while you're doing anything on the computer, because people will see if they can't make money that way.
I think the thing that will jump out over time--when you're in the context of buying, when you want to organize a trip, an event, pick a gift--will be tools far beyond search that help with that.
There is debate that just doesn't go away, between the Web services protocol stack called WS Start and the simpler approach of XML over HTTP. Do you think that you overengineered Web services?
Gates: I feel super good that we did the hard work (with Web services) and made that an industry standard for rich interoperability. The lead times for that--figuring what standards body to put them in, the testing with IBM products and all those things--that is the one we really needed to put the energy into. Now we can circle back and say, "OK, let's make sure that the tools for all that spectrum are very strong."
When do you think ultramobile devices will become mainstream devices--and even a PC replacement?
Gates: Well, it is a PC, and for a lot of people, it will be their second PC. And I'm a total believer in the tablet--I think it will be totally mainstream. Whatever it takes, Microsoft will be behind it to make it better and better. If I'm critical of us, I'd say that making it easy to have multiple PCs (and having) your "state" just show up on those PCs--that's been partly holding people back.
The Origami--you want to take it to meetings with you, but you don't want to think about syncing before you walk out to that meeting. (The information) should just be there.
You were critical of the $100 laptop idea for developing countries that's come out of the MIT Media Lab. Can you tell us what alternative approaches you're pursuing?
Gates: Anybody that is doing low-cost PCs--that's great. We love low-cost PCs. I do think you do need to think about the cell phone. We're doing some things to let it display on a TV-type screen. Because it's got a network, because it's got a business model, that will often be your first PC (equivalent, in a developing country).
Or (there could be) a shared PC where you go to a community center and you want a large screen and multiple people can stand around it. The PC industry is very, very competitive, so all the varieties (are) going to get tried. I think countries should let their marketplace figure out where's the training, where are the communications networks, where's the content.
It's a very complex thing that probably doesn't lend itself to a top-down approach, but everything that drives computing out to more people we are very, very enthusiastic about.
But you seem to prefer a cell phone attached to a TV?
Gates: No, I don't prefer any--to be clear, I think there's going to be a variety of form factors that relate to the different environments. After all, the communications cost is really the hardest thing here. We have PCs down at $200--and that's fine. Some of those even have a battery in them. So you don't miss out there--where you miss out is the broadband connection, the curriculum, the support--all the elements that can make it relevant.
Because, after all, we don't just want PCs out there. We want them out there connected and used and relevant so that they lead to more economic success. Certainly, between Microsoft and the (Bill and Melinda Gates) Foundation, I spend a lot of time in developing countries, looking at the realities. It's very complex to make sure you get all those pieces lined up.
by gsaravin9
The Microsoft chairman said, in essence, that the development world has changed with the advent of new Web technologies that give people any time, any place access to their data--a far cry from the PC-centric world of the past. "Everything we do now, we have to be user-centric, not device-centric," he said.
Gates also pledged to bolster the company's development efforts on Internet Explorer, which he said has lagged in recent years.
"In a sense we're doing a mea culpa, saying we waited too long for a browser release," Gates said. "I expect us to move very very rapidly there because we see great opportunities."
Gates said that Microsoft is already working on the next two versions after Internet Explorer 7, which is due later this year with Windows Vista, a long anticipated update to Windows XP.
On Monday, Microsoft released several product updates, including a "refresh" of the Internet Explorer 7 Beta 2 preview, and Microsoft's Atlas AJAX Web development kit will have an updated license allowing customers to run Web applications built with Atlas.
The term AJAX was coined last year to describe a combination of Web technologies, including JavaScript and XML. More and more developers are using these tools to build more capable Web applications that can replace older generations of "fat client" desktop systems.
This week, Microsoft executives will explain in more detail the company's full arsenal of software and Live hosted services for building Web applications on a range of devices including desktop PCs, mobile phones, gaming devices and Media Center PCs.
The expansion of Web-connected software to a larger group of consumers is something that can't be ignored, the company says. "More and more activities are happening online. Whatever industry you look at, that's where people are spending time," said Charles Fitzgerald, general manager for platform technologies at Microsoft. "Our latest Web technologies (can be used) to drive better customer connections online."
Moreover, the popularity of "mashups," which let developers combine parts of one Web site with parts of another, has driven a new way to look at Web sites. Increasingly developers can think about Web sites as "components" in their applications, Gates said. "This is a powerful idea whose time has come, and we're really just at the beginning."
Video: Mix '06: Gates keynote
From the stage of Mix '06, Bill Gates discusses building new online applications.
Gates on Monday also discussed the changes to Web usage that will come from the broader adoption of RSS (Really Simple Syndication) and related Microsoft-led initiatives, including Simple Shared Extensions for sharing calendaring information and Live Clipboard.
"You can think of RSS as the start of the programmable Web. As Web sites start exposing their APIs, amazing things happen," said Gates.
Microsoft intends to build deeper RSS support in Windows Vista and Internet Explorer 7, allowing people to subscribe to Web pages as well as podcasts and photos.
The Mix '06 conference is also an effort by Microsoft to attract more Web developers and designers to Microsoft products.
The company's Expression line of designer tools is being built to foster better collaboration between technical programmers and designers. The tools are expected to be released later this year.
Now on News.com
Mortgage meltdown: Tech stocks' gain?
Week in review: AMD's scramble, Google's gamble
Is the digital pen getting mightier?
Extra: Space cadet school
Overall, Microsoft is hoping to prove to developers that it understands the new realities of online development, ranging from things like AJAX to software-as-a-service development, pioneered by rivals such as Salesforce.com.
Adam Gross, vice president of developer marketing at Salesforce.com, noted that Microsoft has been very successful with traditional Windows developers. But it has not been as successful reaching "Internet developers."
"Until now, Microsoft tools have been very Microsoft-centric. I'd like to see how they are really going to approach the Internet as a development platform," Gross said.
by gsaravin9
GUI: Features: Ease of use: Value:
Everytime I visit this site I read about a new bug of Vista: programs that run perfectly on XP fail on Vista, it needs a Huge amout of memory and HDD, and there's nothing needfull in the new features. It's just like Nero. They wanted to develep their software and it's GUI getting more terrible with every version, and some feauteres worked before just not work. I will NOT get Vista until XP becomes totally unsupported and I recommend you to do the same. (Maybe if XP becomes unsupported I will switch from Windows to an other OS.)
by gsaravin9
You are obviously NOT talking about Microsoft here! Of cause Vista will have bugs! Just wait and see.
You will hear very clearly and very loudly the bugs and annoyances Vista has.
Vista looks better than XP. However, on performace, XP is a thoroughbred steed and Vista is an Ass.
If you are talking performance, XP leaves Vista at the starting post.
I find it remarkable how Microsoft can code such an inferior product.
I would NOT use Vista even if Bill Gates gave it to me!
Heck maybe in 5 years when computers are able to handle Vista with ease and XP is so dated, but certainly not now, not next year 2007 and likely not 2008.
If it ain't broke, don't fix it! XP with SR2 works just fine. It took long enough for XP to be working properly. I am not going to gamble on Vista.
Vista should have run FASTER on the same hardware as XP. That would have been a winner. However, Vista is a dud. A lemon. A show pony. It has all the false glamour of Windows ME (the bean counter operating system).
Vista this and Vista that. At the end of the day there is NO good reason to leave XP! Not for the next few years anyway.
by gsaravin9
GUI: Features: Ease of use: Value:
What is faster than Vista, uses less RAM than Vista, is a smaller install than Vista, runs more software than Vista, runs more games than Vista, is able to do everything that Vista can do with a few 3rd party installations?
Windows XP
In every way, except eye candy, Windows XP is a superior operating system than Vista.
You can run XP on hardware that would grind to a halt with Vista.
That game you are getting 100 frames per second may only get 20 frames per second if you install Vista.
There is no good reason to install Vista.
Vista is the Windows ME of tomorrow.
Bloated to the max, needing new hardware and for what?
Not only did Microsoft drop the ball with Vista, they damn well blew it to shreds.
Windows XP is far superior to Vista.
Sure have a play with it for curiosity, but to play that game and use that software lightning fast, keep XP. Or spend a lot of money to get new hardware, and not notice a speed or performance increase at all.
How Microsoft can code such an inferior operating system to XP and claim it is better is astounding. They must take the public for fools.
Vista should be faster on XP type hardware - NOT slower if not unable to run at all.
The people at the top at Microsoft have lost touch with reality in their money castles.
Vista sucks.
by gsaravin9
In every way, except eye candy, Windows XP is a superior operating system than Vista.
You can run XP on hardware that would grind to a halt with Vista.
That game you are getting 100 frames per second may only get 20 frames per second if you install Vista.
There is no good reason to install Vista.
Vista is the Windows ME of tomorrow.
Bloated to the max, needing new hardware and for what?
Not only did Microsoft drop the ball with Vista, they damn well blew it to shreds.
Windows XP is far superior to Vista.
Sure have a play with it for curiosity, but to play that game and use that software lightning fast, keep XP. Or spend a lot of money to get new hardware, and not notice a speed or performance increase at all.
How Microsoft can code such an inferior operating system to XP and claim it is better is astounding. They must take the public for fools.
Vista should be faster on XP type hardware - NOT slower if not unable to run at all.
The people at the top at Microsoft have lost touch with reality in their money castles.
Vista sucks.
by gsaravin9
There's a lot to like about Vista. But it has some fatal flaws:
DRM limits what you can do with your software and media content (including music). Media lovers, beware!
WGA and Product Activation, what a pain! This also includes MS spyware.
$260 to upgrade to Ultimate? Are you kidding?!
You don't even get *all* of the much-vaunted security features unless you get the Ultimate edition!
Fatal flaws make Vista abysmal. And let's not forget, this is "Version 1.0" software with lots of bugs. MS is pushing Service Pack 1 out to us before the end of the year to fix what should have been fixed at release date (today)! This is nuts.
by gsaravin9
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
More fatal Windows Vista exploits
Published February 6th, 2007 by Long Zheng
Last week, the media went schizophrenic over the Windows Vista speech recognition ?loophole? which allowed anyone with a microphone to have full access over your computer. Granted, you must also be partially-deaf, turned your speaker volume to full, carefully place your microphone next to the speakers, turn on speech recognition and train your speech profile as if you were someone else. It might sound incredibly challenging to get this exploit working properly, but the media assures this exploit is a ?fatal flaw?, so obviously Microsoft is to blame and Vista gets a big red ?Fail? on security.
This week, two top Swedish security experts only to be named ?Long? and ?Zheng?, to hide their identity from Microsoft, exposes many more ?fatal? security flaws inside the newborn operating system, Windows Vista. Here are the two most dangerous exploits you should be concerned about.
The first exploit is a bug inside the keyboard and mouse subsystem which enables the targeted system to be hijacked and maliciously delete files, folders, music, torrents and other important sounding stuff without the user?s authorization or control.
Details of how such an exploit works are sketchy, but leaked documents reveal the keyboard and mouse APIs offers unprecedented amount of control over an operating system, allowing anyone and everyone to have full access to your computer with or without your authorization. This exploit allows anyone ranging from younger siblings to gang leaders who could use brute force, such as a punch or tickle, to gain access to your keyboard and mouse cursors and perform malicious activities such as browsing The Inquirer or deleting vital fraudulent financial documents.
A second exploit highlights a serious flaw inside the popular Windows-platform development tool, Visual Studio. An undocumented feature inside this software is said to enable the ability for malicious users to compile and execute unsigned and potentially damaging source code. If users somehow come across malicious source code and decide to copy, paste, compile and execute within Visual Studio, the resulting application could change wallpapers, block access to YouTube, increase the volume and other serious irreversible damages to the computer system.
Nobody knows exactly how or why Microsoft has designed Visual Studio to include such a dangerous and exploitable feature, but several self-proclaimed security experts has voiced their anger to Microsoft for such questions actions. ?Putting lives at risk like cars on the road? says one expert, ?cheese sandwiches are really good, but this is horrible like a tomato sandwich? insists another - drawing a connection between operating systems and lunch snacks.
Whilst both exploits are said to affect the entire industry of operating systems, ?Long? and ?Zheng? insists that only Windows is affected due to its massive user-base and pretty wallpapers. Both security experts warn if users do not switch to another operating system, Apple and the Free Software Foundation will be really upset.
Microsoft officials gave me a weird look and did not wish to comment at the time of writing.
Next week, keep an eye out for the exclusive report on why Solitaire is a fire hazard. How the end-game fireworks might burn down your operating system. Not to be missed by every innocent Solitaire player.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
by gsaravin9
------------------------------------------------------
Vista screensaver inspired WMP visualizations, ?Psychedelia Visualization Pack?
21 Comments Published August 31st, 2007 by Long Zheng
Correct me if I?m wrong but I think it?s been at least two Windows releases since any new or updated Windows Media Player visualizations. Sure, what comes in the box are still visualizations by definition, but I couldn?t consider any of them eye-candy. Recently, a new visualization pack made by two Microsoft employees in their spare time is worth checking out.
Stephen Coy, the designer of the Windows Vista screensavers and Tim Cowley, a software engineer on the Office team have come together to release a visualizations pack for Windows Media Player called ?Psychedelia? two years in the making. But don?t worry, no LSD drugs involved.
As a requirement to run these visualizations, you will need a graphics card that supports at least shader model 2.0 (most DirectX 9 graphics cards will), which might seem like a high requirement for visualizers, but how else are you suppose to create visual magic right?
Included in the single package are 7 visualizations with over 40 variations in total, including
Album Art 3D - 3D cubes with the album art of the song you?re currently playing
Bubbles - inspired by the Bubbles Vista screensavers also featuring the album art
Distortion - distorts the album art in a 3D waveform
Hypnobloom - hypnotic checkered purple rings
Ribbons - inspired by the Mystify and Ribbons Vista screensavers (as seen above)
Gigertron 3D - 3D layered visualizer bars
up cuber - a pigment arrangement of 3D hexagon cubes
I?ve never been a big fan of visualizers before but I?m hooked onto ?Ribbons?. If you?re looking for some awesome WMP visualizers or something to match your Vista screensavers, then give Psychedelia a try. It?s a reasonably light download at 5MB but best of all it?s free!
Continue reading ?Vista screensaver inspired WMP visualizations, ?Psychedelia Visualization Pack??
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
My name is Windows Vista Service Pack 1
4 Comments Published August 30th, 2007 by Long Zheng
Surprise! Pop some balloons and whack some Pinatas because today is Windows Vista Service Pack 1?s coming-out party. The party started a little earlier than scheduled but nevertheless it is now in full force, and you?re all invited! Do you want to meet him? Know when he?s coming around to your place? And why is he so cool? Then check out the word who got in the party early.
Nick White, Windows Vista Team Blog - Announcing Windows Vista Service Pack 1 Beta
Brandon LeBlanc, Windows Vista Team Blog - Windows Vista Service Pack 1 Beta White Paper (unabridged audiobook coming soon)
Mary Jo Foley - The shroud of secrecy is lifted: Vista SP1 beta due in two weeks
Joe Wilcox - Yes, Virginia, There Is a Vista SP1
Josh Philips - Windows Vista SP1 Beta ?In a few weeks?
Service Pack 1 is currently scheduled to tour select users, MSDN/TechNet subscribers and the general public within the next few weeks, ?later?, and first-quarter 2008 respectively. I heard he?s quite the handyman.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Microsoft shuts down popular Windows patching package, AutoPatcher
12 Comments Published August 29th, 2007 by Long Zheng
Microsoft Legal defies logic today by forcibly removing a free and trustworthy software package which makes updating Windows more convenient and accessible.
AutoPatcher, for those who don?t know, was an impressive Windows community project that combined publically available Windows hotfixes and security updates each month to form a single package that could either be installed in a batch or burned on to an CD. To those who regularly format their computers or fix other people?s computers (for which I share you pain), AutoPatcher not only saves bandwidth but precious time downloading each individual update from Windows Update.
It is not hard to imagine AutoPatcher violated some clause in some terms of service somewhere, but why Microsoft would act on it, and act on it now is unbelievable. If AutoPatcher could be as ?malicious? as Microsoft suggests, then why haven?t they acted on it sooner?
AutoPatcher has been an extremely active project since 2003, distributed somewhat 40,000 copies monthly over just the official download mirrors, not counting other popular sources such as Bittorent and even leading PC magazines worldwide. I might even go as far as to say some people depend on it.
The Microsoft official quoted on Neowin argues because Windows Update is more accessible now in other browsers like Firefox, AutoPatcher is more of a security concern. Did they forget AutoPatcher patches Windows? And what about those users who don?t have a fast-speed internet connection? Or maybe even no internet connection at all? Should those people visit the library each week to just keep their Windows up-to-date?
Reasoning aside, AutoPatcher could well sidestep the legal roadblock by a simple but unproductive workaround. Microsoft argues updates should only be downloaded from the official Microsoft servers to prevent third-party modification, therefore AutoPatcher could instead of pre-bundling the updates, just fetch the updates from Microsoft?s own servers (HTTP downloads) to form a similar package on the user?s own computers at runtime. Might take a bit longer, but you can end up with the same package. As far as I know, you?re still allowed to archive Windows updates, thankfully.
As Microsoft continues to play down the importance of service packs in favor of Windows Update, the ability to collate and backup updates will be come more useful than ever. For that reason, I hope AutoPatcher, or a new project, will solve the problem without attracting the hounds.
----------------------
by gsaravin9
I heard lots of rumor from various poeple at different IT company's comparing Vista to Windows ME and indicating that Vista is largely being ignored in the business community. Alot of businesses I deal are buying Vista but then down grading to Windows XP.
My own experience has seen laptops with a T7200, 2GB of RAM and X1660 chipset run like a slug and a laptop with T5500 chipset with 512 MB of RAM almost unworkable becuase it is so slow.
Even desktop computers with Core 2 duo chipset and 1 GB of RAM do not come close to meeting my performance expectations when running simple applications like word 2007.
I still have consistent problems with drivers on older and some newer equiptment espcially printers and scanners. I've normally resorted to Windows 98 drivers becuase they work more effectively than the VISTA drivers.
Does anyone else get the impression that Vista is one big bug and next year its probably going to be swept under the carpet with a replacement? I do know that some IT companies are putting an offical complaint to Microsoft about the OS.
by gsaravin9
nothing but total vindication
Microsoft Extends XP Sales to June 2008
Thursday September 27, 7:06 pm ET
Microsoft Adds 5 Months to Windows XP's Shelf Life
REDMOND, Wash. (AP) -- Microsoft Corp. said it will keep selling its Windows XP operating system beyond January, in response to demand from customers.
The company decided to extend the deadline until the end of June to give customers -- particularly small businesses -- more time to switch to the new Windows Vista.
ADVERTISEMENT
"Maybe we were a little ambitious to think that we would need to make Windows XP available for only a year after the release of Windows Vista," said Mike Nash, a corporate vice president for Windows product management at Microsoft.
While software retailers and major computer makers like Dell Inc. will stop offering XP next June, system builders, or smaller companies that make and sell PCs, will still sell the older operating system until the end of January 2009.
Nash said Microsoft's policy in the past has been to discontinue an old operating system four years after its launch. But because Vista reached consumers more than five years after XP, the company had to revise the rules.
"Making it available through June was a little bit better" for customers, Nash said.
In April, Dell, which had all but stopped selling XP to consumers, said it would bring back more XP machines after customers asked for it. At the time, Microsoft responded that only "a small minority of customers" were still interested in the old operating system.
Microsoft is also extending the availability of a version of XP aimed at customers in emerging markets, Windows XP Starter Edition, until June 30, 2010.
by gsaravin9
Big Code
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
By Jack Ganssle
Embedded.com
(10/05/05, 02:28:00 PM EDT)
Pundits (and many other sources) predict Microsoft's Vista (ne頌onghorn) operating system will comprise at least 50 million lines of code? assuming the troubled OS is ever released.
50 million lines of code. The scale is staggering.
Expect a staggering number of bugs.
Though it?s easy to poke fun at Microsoft, I?m impressed with the company?s recent performance. Windows XP is, at least for me, a very stable product. The much reviled update service seems to be working; reports surprisingly suggest Internet Explorer has fewer security vulnerabilities in recent months than Firefox.
But any 50 MLOC program is a monster. How will they test it?
Well-written C and C++ code contains some 5 to 10 errors per 100 LOC after a clean compile, but before inspection and testing. At a 5% rate any 50 MLOC program will start off with some 2.5 million bugs.
Testing typically exercises only half the code. It?s hard to devise tests that check rarely-invoked exception handlers, deeply nested IFs and nested loops. So the 50% test coverage number suggests Vista could ship with some 1.25 million bugs.
There are better ways to do testing that do produce fantastic programs. Code coverage, for instance, can insure every branch and conditional has been taken. It?s required by the FAA?s DO-178B level A standard for safety-critical avionics.
But the costs are unbelievable. It?s not unusual for the qualification process to produce a half page of documentation for each line of code. A 50 MLOC program?s doc might be 25 million pages long, consuming 50,000 reams of paper - a stack 2 miles high. Will Vista undergo this rigorous evaluation? Probably not.
Maybe Microsoft routinely uses a very disciplined approach to software engineering, including the mandatory use of code inspections. Again, the numbers are interesting. Since good inspections typically find 70% of the system?s mistakes, after inspection Vista might have 50 million * 0.05 bugs/LOC *0.30 defects left after inspection, or 750,000 bugs. If testing finds half of those, they?re still shipping with some 375,000 problems.
Bummer.
What if Microsoft were certified to the highest level of the Capability Maturity Model? Level 5 organizations employ a wide range of practices to generate great software. A CMM5 project typically ships with 1 bug per thousand lines of code. For Vista that works out to 50,000 bugs.
This isn?t an anti-Microsoft rant. It?s a peek inside the problems any organization has when building huge programs. Though we do indeed have ways to build better code, the costs are huge, and scale exponentially as the program size increases.
The largest commercial embedded systems I?m aware of are some cell phones which have around 5 million lines of code, generally a mix of C, C++ and Java. Though few if any of these companies work at CMM level 5, that 0.1% bug rate would yield 5,000 defects, a hopelessly buggy product. One can only hope that the most important features (like making a phone call) work well enough for most users most of the time.
Firmware size doubles every 10 months to two years, depending on which surveys one believes. Programs are gigantic today, and will be simply unbelievable tomorrow.
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
Mark's Blog
Mark Russinovich's technical blog covering topics such as Windows troubleshooting, technologies and security.
This Blog
About
Email
Syndication
RSS 2.0
Atom 1.0
Search
Go
Tags
No tags have been created or used yet.
Archives
August 2007 (2)
July 2007 (1)
June 2007 (1)
May 2007 (2)
April 2007 (1)
February 2007 (1)
December 2006 (1)
November 2006 (1)
October 2006 (1)
August 2006 (2)
July 2006 (2)
May 2006 (1)
April 2006 (1)
March 2006 (2)
February 2006 (1)
January 2006 (3)
December 2005 (2)
November 2005 (6)
October 2005 (3)
September 2005 (1)
August 2005 (2)
July 2005 (2)
June 2005 (3)
May 2005 (2)
April 2005 (6)
March 2005 (8)
Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
A few weeks ago a poster with the handle dloneranger reported in the 2CPU forums that he experienced reduced network throughput on his Vista system when he played audio or video. Other posters chimed in with similar results, and in the last week attention has been drawn to the behavior by other sites, including Slashdot and Zdnet blogger Adrian Kingsley-Hughes.
Many people have correctly surmised that the degradation in network performance during multimedia playback is directly connected with mechanisms employed by the Multimedia Class Scheduler Service (MMCSS), a feature new to Windows Vista that I covered in my three-part TechNet Magazine article series on Windows Vista kernel changes. Multimedia playback requires a constant rate of media streaming, and playback will glitch or sputter if its requirements aren?t met. The MMCSS service runs in the generic service hosting process Svchost.exe, where it automatically prioritizes the playback of video and audio in order to prevent other tasks from interfering with the CPU usage of the playback software:
When a multimedia application begins playback, the multimedia APIs it uses call the MMCSS service to boost the priority of the playback thread into the realtime range, which covers priorities 16-31, for up to 8ms of every 10ms interval of the time, depending on how much CPU the playback thread requires. Because other threads run at priorities in the dynamic priority range below 15, even very CPU intensive applications won?t interfere with the playback.
You can see the boost by playing an audio or video clip in Windows Media Player (WMP), running the Reliability and Performance Monitor (Start->Run->Perfmon), selecting the Performance Monitor item, and adding the Priority Current value for all the Wmplayer threads in the Thread object. Set the graph scale to 31 (the highest priority value on Windows) and you?ll easily spot the boosted thread, shown here running at priority 21:
Besides activity by other threads, media playback can also be affected by network activity. When a network packet arrives at system, it triggers a CPU interrupt, which causes the device driver for the device at which the packet arrived to execute an Interrupt Service Routine (ISR). Other device interrupts are blocked while ISRs run, so ISRs typically do some device book-keeping and then perform the more lengthy transfer of data to or from their device in a Deferred Procedure Call (DPC) that runs with device interrupts enabled. While DPCs execute with interrupts enabled, they take precedence over all thread execution, regardless of priority, on the processor on which they run, and can therefore impede media playback threads.
Network DPC receive processing is among the most expensive, because it includes handing packets to the TCP/IP driver, which can result in lengthy computation. The TCP/IP driver verifies each packet, determines the packet?s protocol, updates the connection state, finds the receiving application, and copies the received data into the application?s buffers. This Process Explorer screenshot shows how CPU usage for DPCs rose dramatically when I copied a large file from another system:
Tests of MMCSS during Vista development showed that, even with thread-priority boosting, heavy network traffic can cause enough long-running DPCs to prevent playback threads from keeping up with their media streaming requirements, resulting in glitching. MMCSS? glitch-resistant mechanisms were therefore extended to include throttling of network activity. It does so by issuing a command to the NDIS device driver, which is the driver that gives packets received by network adapter drivers to the TCP/IP driver, that causes NDIS to ?indicate?, or pass along, at most 10 packets per millisecond (10,000 packets per second).
Because the standard Ethernet frame size is about 1500 bytes, a limit of 10,000 packets per second equals a maximum throughput of roughly 15MB/s. 100Mb networks can handle at most 12MB/s, so if your system is on a 100Mb network, you typically won?t see any slowdown. However, if you have a 1Gb network infrastructure and both the sending system and your Vista receiving system have 1Gb network adapters, you?ll see throughput drop to roughly 15%.
Further, there?s an unfortunate bug in the NDIS throttling code that magnifies throttling if you have multiple NICs. If you have a system with both wireless and wired adapters, for instance, NDIS will process at most 8000 packets per second, and with three adapters it will process a maximum of 6000 packets per second. 6000 packets per second equals 9MB/s, a limit that?s visible even on 100Mb networks.
I caused throttling to be visible on my laptop, which has three adapters, by copying a large file to it from another system and then starting WMP and playing a song. The Task Manager screenshot below shows how the copy achieves a throughput of about 20%, but drops to around 6% on my 1Gb network after I start playing a song:
You can monitor the number of receive packets NDIS processes by adding the ?packets received per second? counter in the Network object to the Performance Monitor view. Below, you can see the packet receive rate change as I ran the experiment. The number of packets NDIS processed didn?t realize the theoretical throttling maximum of 6,000, probably due to handshaking with the remote system.
Despite even this level of throttling, Internet traffic, even on the best broadband connection, won?t be affected. That?s because the multiplicity of intermediate connections between your system and another one on the Internet fragments packets and slows down packet travel, and therefore reduces the rate at which systems transfer data.
The throttling rate Vista uses was derived from experiments that reliably achieved glitch-resistant playback on systems with one CPU on 100Mb networks with high packet receive rates. The hard-coded limit was short-sighted with respect to today?s systems that have faster CPUs, multiple cores and Gigabit networks, and in addition to fixing the bug that affects throttling on multi-adapter systems, the networking team is actively working with the MMCSS team on a fix that allows for not so dramatically penalizing network traffic, while still delivering a glitch-resistant experience.
Stay tuned to my blog for more information.
Published Monday, August 27, 2007 8:00 AM by markrussinovich
Comment Notification
If you would like to receive an email when updates are made to this post, please register here
Subscribe to this post's comments using RSS
Comments
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Great article Mark, thank you for giving a clear explanation of the problem.
Monday, August 27, 2007 2:32 PM by Tom
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
is it the reason that explain why my games are A LOT less performant with windows Vista? does playing audio in games and having Teamspeak (or ventrilo at the same time) reduce the graphic and procesor output for my games because audio is at higher priority (especially in MMORPG where the network is important)?
is there a way to put this value back to normal?
thanks
Monday, August 27, 2007 4:56 PM by Serge Munger
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback
Running XP I just tried playing an MP3 file, a video file and downloading several files from the internet all at the same time. The audio and video files played perfectly and there was no slowdown in my network speed.
"mechanisms employed by the Multimedia Class Scheduler Service (MMCSS), a feature new to Windows Vista"
Seems to me Microsoft tried to "fix" something that wasn't broken.
Monday, August 27, 2007 5:28 PM by Richard McBeef
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Very useful to know. I've spent a good bit of time trying to figure out why my file transfers were so slow. During all of that debugging, I probably had a music file running in the background...
Serge: Games performance is probably more related to video driver issues. My understanding is that the new Vista video driver model is theoretically just as fast as the XP video driver model, but it requires a lot of stuff to be re-written by the driver developers for best performance. Until it all gets re-written, they're using pieces from the XP driver (changing Vista's input to what the XP driver expects, then changing the XP driver's output to what Vista expects), and the result is that some tasks are done less efficiently.
On my laptop, I could hardly get any video files to play without glitching. CPU usage would go up to 100% and stay there, even though the media file played just fine with only 20% CPU usage on XP. Then by accident I was running another program that was incompatible with Aero and forced Vista to switch into the XP-style video mode. Suddenly my video started playing back smoothly at 20% video usage, just like XP.
Monday, August 27, 2007 5:37 PM by Doug
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Serge,
I don't own Vista yet, but the first thing I thought of when I started reading this post was "games". Good question...
Monday, August 27, 2007 5:42 PM by Matt
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Mark,
A sincere thank you for explaining the issue in detail and not ?suger coating? it?you might renew my faith in Microsoft.
Monday, August 27, 2007 6:47 PM by Anonymous
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Running XP I just tried playing an MP3 file, a video file and downloading several files from the internet all at the same time. The audio and video files played perfectly and there was no slowdown in my network speed.
Monday, August 27, 2007 5:28 PM by Richard McBeef
*****
It won't effect your internet speed; just your LAN speed.
Monday, August 27, 2007 7:07 PM by Dr.Butt
# Solution found
my first thought was to disable the MMCS service, but the Windows Audio service is dependent on it.
So I ran regedit, and changed the key
HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Services\Audiosrv\DependOnService
Just remove MMCS from that key in the list, and set MMCS to disabled in services, then reboot.
As soon as I rebooted I was able to copy files at 40mb/s+ while listening to audio
-Courtney
Monday, August 27, 2007 7:25 PM by Courtney
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Why is XP not having this problem then? This seems like unnecessary feature of Vista.
I've spent countless hours for couple months trying to figure out why copying files over network was going at 5MB/s
Monday, August 27, 2007 7:27 PM by Andrew
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
It seems to me that Vista has things backwards here. Rather than ensuring that music playback can be performed within its realtime constraints, and having programmable facilities within the kernel to ask for that, it's arbitrarily degrading other bits of the system "just in case" they might interfere. The dependency is incorrect. It ought to be the scheduler making these kinds of decisions - not the sound subsystem.
It smells more like a nasty hack - as if last-minute testing showed that there were glitches in playback with the latest kernel, so quick fixes needed to be bludgeoned in.
Monday, August 27, 2007 7:35 PM by barrkel
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
"While DPCs execute with interrupts enabled, they take precedence over all thread execution, regardless of priority, on the processor on which they run"
Am I reading this correct: The DPCs can all run on core #1 and multimedia can run on the other cores? -> no interruption of multimedia?
Monday, August 27, 2007 8:57 PM by zzz
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Serge: No, the MCSS service is only used by multimedia applications like WMP (actually that's probably all that uses it ATM).
You can revert to old behavior by right clicking My Computer, clicking Manage, finding the Services entry on the left pane and finding the MCSS service mentioned and stopping it. To make this setting permanent, you have to go into properties and set the startup type to Disabled. However it will not make your games run any faster. (Hmm, Courtney notes it's dependent on the Windows Audio user-mode stack and offers a workaround... I didn't know that. Thanks Courtney!)
Games are slower overall because of all the added functionality and features in Vista... even with many services, eyecandy, and programs disabled I still find programs run better in XP (and even better in Linux!). For example, BioShock runs horribly on my computer in Vista with input and audio lag making it unplayable. This didn't surprise me too much as my computer didn't meet the minimum specs in the CPU department. But, in XP, it ran quite acceptably. I was even able to up the details settings without performance degradation.
I would recommend gamers to stick to Windows XP for the time being, unless you have a DirectX 10 video card and plan on playing DirectX 10 games (and you really, REALLY need DirectX 10 for some reason). Also note that DirectX 10 cards will not be able to take advantage of new DirectX 10.1 features in Vista SP!. You'd need a new card for those.
Richard: As noted in the article, you have to have quite high bandwidth (over 100mbits/s) to be able to notice any slowdown. Also there was something broken they fixed... audio stuttering or jittering in WMP and other media applications. Now if they only did the same thing for games I might switch over to Vista permanently.
Doug: Unless you're speaking of LAN transfers on a 1gbps network, I doubt that was your problem.
I have noticed problems when running on an IPv4 network. IPv6 drivers are enabled by default for every network adapter, meaning every time you try to connect to a remote computer/website, Vista tries using IPv6 first. If your network doesn't support it, this only results in wasted time. You can disable this protocol by finding the moved "Network Connections" folder (go to Network Control Panel and click on whatever side entry relates to showing network adapters) and then right clicking Properties on desired adapters and unchecking the IPv6 protocol entries.
Andrew: XP can have this problem if enough apps are suching up the CPU. Some multimedia apps, like Winamp, solve the problem themselves by boosting their own priority (Winamp runs at High by default) but this can be dangerous if done to High or above because the application is not stable because then it may freeze the entire system (fortunately Winamp is stable. I've never had problems in that area).
Whenever I have an application which is running a tad pokey, especially games, I boost it to Above Normal using Process Explorer or Task Manager (cmon Mark, fix Procexp so it can replace Taskmgr when UAC is enabled). This works with most programs (a few games go wonky though).
barrkel: I think all programmers do this, It's called implementing the required and requested features with the least amount of work. We're a lazy people. ;)
zzz: I'm guessing you could minimize DPCs and interrupts on one core by putting only threads essential to music playback there, but most likely this would make the core underutilized. And just like with memory, you don't want to leave it unused because you just end up wasting time which you could be saving by filling it with work.
Monday, August 27, 2007 10:13 PM by Dan
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
An excellent explanation Mark.
Maybe I am oversimplifying things, but you mention it limits to 10,000 packets. Wouldn't the obvious solution be to increase this number (or make it configurable). Obviously if you make it too high, your songs can skip. If you have a multi-core CPU (as most will be in the next few years), then it would seem to me to be unnecessary. Perhaps Windows could detect whether this optimisation is really helpful.
Monday, August 27, 2007 11:09 PM by Adam
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Great post Mark!
Vinicius Canto
MVP Windows Server - Admin Frameworks
Brazil
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 12:13 AM by Vinicius Canto [MVP]
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
"I have noticed problems when running on an IPv4 network. IPv6 drivers are enabled by default for every network adapter, meaning every time you try to connect to a remote computer/website, Vista tries using IPv6 first. If your network doesn't support it, this only results in wasted time."
Actually, the time wasted should be very little. Unless the hostname has an AAAA record associated with it, the system shouldn't use IPv6 to try and communicate with the host.
The only time it becomes a major delay, is when the remote host supports IPv6, and either the local or remote host isn't properly configured for IPv6. Then, it has to time out, then switches to IPv4.
IIRC, Teredo is on by default in Vista, which means (provided the teredo relay isn't down and firewall isn't blocking) you have functioning IPv6 on your end enough to be useful.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 12:21 AM by Brie Bruns
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Windows Vista does allow a fine grained control of priority boost, you just need to find where to look for it instead of disabling the service (MMCSS).
http://msdn2.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ms684247.aspx
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 12:56 AM by Tanveer Badar
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Please elaborate on why this kludge is required in Vista, when XP degrades gracefully in both the Single CPU+High Network Load+Multimedia case, and the insufficient resources to process multimedia properly case.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 2:08 AM by F16PilotJumper
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Why do Vista need seuch a system ?
Ever an old Win2K, on un PIII 1Ghz, with 512Mb can play an audio file without glitchs during network transfert.
Today, with have "big" CPU, and Vista cannot play audio file smoothly during network transfert ? Such a shame ...
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 2:09 AM by Bill2
# re: Solution
I wrote up the details on my fix on my blog
http://courtneymalone.com/2007/08/28/a-note-on-vista-network-speed/
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 3:54 AM by Courtney Malone
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Regarding multiple network cards. If I disable the other network cards will the performance go up (you said 3 cards 1/3 network performance?)
also whats up with this key?
HKLM\Software\Microsoft\Windows NT\Currentversion\Multimedia\SystemProfile\SystemResponsiveness
seems this is an easy registry edit to allocate less cpu time for MMCSS
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 4:00 AM by Julian W
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
I developed lots of audio drivers for the older Microsoft OSes, and interestingly, had to use the DPC to process audio mixing and such so that it wouldn't glitch on systems with lots of thread activity. The trick to avoid using all the CPU cycles for audio was to keep track of how much time was being spent in the DPC vs. the scheduled threads.
In Vista, trying to "guess" how much of the CPU is being used for MM operations is unrealistic, since it spans the domain from 128kb MP3 playback to DRM'ed HD audio/video playback.
The MMCSS algorithm defaults to 8ms for MM threads and 2ms for the other threads, but the flaw in the algorithm is that the IRPT and DPC times are not subtracted from the wall-clock times.
Suppose that a really busy network transfer used up 50% of the cpu in the DPC routines. MMCSS should then see that only 4ms is available for mm out of the 8ms maximum. The audio stack must do it's part, then, by letting the MMCSS know if that 4ms was enough to process 10ms of output. For simple audio, it may need only 1ms to generate 10ms of audio output. OTOH, it may need more than 4ms to insure no glitching, and THAT is the point that the network should be throttled back.
I think Vista gives most of the info needed to do this right -- the new kernel thread time accounting now subtracts DPC (and probably IRPT) from the thread's scheduling quantum. The audio stack "pulls" output from the hardware back through the various drivers, which should allow determination of how well the computational load is being handled.
Looks like SP1 is needed now more than ever! Tell Balmer to forget the market-timing issues and just get a Vista SP out in the field. I'm even thinking seriously about ripping Vista off my new laptop and desktop if SP1 is not going to appear in the near future.
Thanks for your as usual well-stated description of the problem!
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 5:05 AM by Jerry Schneider
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Mark,
I've been following your insights for years. Once again, thank you for the excellent explanation. We have 2 users on the network who use Vista and have complained w/network issues.
Once again Mark, thanks for the years and all the great utilities.
PS: I use XP but have tried Vista. After spending over 15 hours of learning and tweaking, I finally gave up and uninstalled it. After 3 weeks of hard disk thrashing (I continually fought w/Vista services which "magically" reset to default thrash mode), it became futile. You may want to pass up the chain, it is for these reasons Vista will not be quickly adopted.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 8:26 AM by Steve
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
All good and nice, but :
1. It seems that people have this problem even AFTER they disabled MMCSS.
2. The performance impact is way bigger (from 500..1000 mbps to sub-100mpbs or even lower. This is by no means a minor impact.
3. As other pointed out,it seems like a classic problem of "Shoot yourself in the foot" because previous versions of windows do not have this issue nor audio playback smoothness problems.
4. If you really want to help maybe you should take a look on the original forum page (http://forums.2cpu.com/showthread.php?t=83112) and see that the impact reported by other users and what you explain here does not quite add up.
5. As a personal note : with today's computing power this kind of problem on dual/quad core machines is ....well I don't know if I should say "funny" or "pathetic" :)
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 8:44 AM by Gigel
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
"100Mb networks can handle at most 12MB/s, so if your system is on a 100Mb network, you typically won?t see any slowdown".
I think you need to learn a bit about networking. Not every frame is full. At half full, the limited number of frames is reached at 7.5MB/s, well within a 100Mb networks ability.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 9:02 AM by c3
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
This whole thing reeks of shoddy hack.
Seriously, who's idea was this? Have they been taken out and shot yet?
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 9:04 AM by Jimbo
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
sell out. you where all about discovering and fixing bugs/glitches, or even malware. now you are part of the MS propaganda. this kind of problem shows how flawed windows vista is. davinci would have torn the whole thing apart and started again.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 9:06 AM by tomthebomb
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Does this take into account jumbo frames if you're using a gigabit network? If your frame size is, say, 9000 bytes, at 10000 packets/sec and 8bits/packet, that's 720Mbit (theoretical) throughput. That's still less than 100% but it's not horrible...
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 9:09 AM by steveo
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
This doesnt make any sense design wise.
Why does every OS so far, even WinXP and every *NIX OS doesnt have any trouble handling multimedia + network ?
Furthermore pc hardware get faster over time not slower - the thinking behind this design implies that hardware gets slower because previously in other OS it worked fine.
Once again, braindead developers at M$ which doesnt surprise me at all
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 9:09 AM by Mr. Obvious
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
So a non-privileged userland application is able to modify global kernel parameters?
Sounds like a good idea to me.
Any other bits of the kernel I can mess with from a non-priv account?
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 9:26 AM by Dave
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Why have to guess a good value for max packets/sec while playing audio? Why not have some intelligent monitoring to find if audio playback thread is starving for cpu? Like check for empty buffers? Profile normal playback cpu needs, and make sure it receives that?
vajk
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 9:30 AM by Vajk
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
What I find most discouraging about this isn't the hack to workaround what was probably a non-issue, but the fact that copying a file takes 41% of the CPU. What kind of networking stack has that kind of processor overhead?
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 9:41 AM by Rob
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
To me, this seems like overly optimistic resource allocation...
I agree 100% that it needed to happen, (and I'm greatful for Mark's detailed response/ explanation) however, it seems to be at so much overhead that it degrades other services...
Given the multi-core CPU scenario we live in now, is this optimization even so necessary?
I remember trying to set up MS ISA 2 years ago on a SMP server (in a hurry) and got very poor performance due to "CPU's fighting over controlling the NIC's" - (I realize that now that you can pin a NIC to a particular CPU)... Is this similar?
Is there any way to pin or isolate these competing processes such that we are not stuck with such low limits to utilization?
thanks again for a great explanation Mark.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 9:46 AM by Chris
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
What I think a few posters are missing is the fact that this has nothing to do with overall CPU speed. Overall, CPUs are fast and getting faster. This has to do with priority over the course of milliseconds.
Both networking and media playback require instant results - because TCP/IP gets processed when it's received, and because most audio is sampled at over 40 kHZ. On a 2 GHz machine, that means that it's playing something every 22 microseconds (about once every 45,350 processor cycles, and it takes a few cycles to play something). If it delays too long, or drops a few samples, you hear skipping.
As a result, the concern is that if both network functions and multimedia need the CPU *right now* then you have a collision. That's why MS limited the networking so it only comes in on average once every 100 microseconds, to prevent that.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 9:54 AM by Zachary Pruckowski
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
One addition: Microsoft completely rewrote the TCP/IP stack for Vista, and doing so they surely made some... hm, mistakes. This might be another reason of strange behavior.
See http://www.microsoft.com/technet/community/columns/cableguy/cg0905.mspx and lots of other pages.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 10:05 AM by K
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Actually, multimedia glitching is a pretty well-known problem to heavy audio and video users (i.e. multitrack work, editing, not just playback). A whole alternate universe of drivers has sprung up to deal with this. It's much less of a problem than it used to be, but under heavy loads, it's still an issue.
Sounds like Microsoft tried to be over-proactive about it, and (as others have said) shot themselves in the foot. I wonder if this isn't something that went into Vista back in 2001 as an obvious necessity, and then wasn't looked at toward the end of the release cycle...
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 10:07 AM by Jay Levitt
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Responding specifically to Chris, my understanding is that Vista can't do the kind of things you talk about (segregate functions by processor) even if it would be an effective solution, because they simply can't target dual-core machines yet.
There's a significant adoption lag that Microsoft has to adapt to. Let's briefly look at the gaming world for an example, and then come back to this. Currently, game designers/programmers for many games have to make sure the game can run on computers are far back as pre-HT P4s. Therefore, they can't fully optimize for a two-core world across the line yet.
The same situation occurs with Vista. Given the average age of the PC install base, and Vista's minimum CPU requirements (800 MHz single core), they can't optimize for dual-core in that sort of a manner. Also, remember that Vista was designed in a period from 2001-2006. Dual-cores only became available in mid-2005, and weren't really prevalent in most selling models until mid-2006 (release of Conroe in July, and subsequent price war). The Vista RTM was shortly thereafter.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 10:09 AM by Zachary Pruckowski
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Something as essential as music playback and file copying should not require days of investigation by users. Someone write better docs!
PS - I have a *phone* running a 200 MHz ARM with a piddly little OS and am able to play streaming MP3's on a broadband wireless network with no hassles. And a dual-core, 2 GHz desktop uses 41% CPU to simply copy files???
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 10:20 AM by s t
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Something as essential as music playback and file copying should not require days of investigation by users. Someone write better docs!
PS - I have a *phone* running a 200 MHz ARM with a piddly little OS and am able to play streaming MP3's on a broadband wireless network with no hassles. And a dual-core, 2 GHz desktop uses 41% CPU to simply copy files???
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 10:21 AM by s t
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
I did some playing on my XP system and got similar results as Richard. I transfered a copy of Win2KSP4 while I listened to a podcast I have downloaded on my local system. I did not see any decay in the file transfer speed over the LAN. I do not consider Mark a sellout because he reported on this issue. He identified it, he did not condone it. IMHO, this seems like a misplaced performance tweak on MS part. I hope it goes away in SP1. We still have not moved to Vista, I have intentionally ordered new systems with XP. It works and I am not willing to turn my shop into a test bed for a first release of an OS.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 10:28 AM by Guy
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Hi, I am the IPv6 Program Manager at Microsoft.
Regarding the comment "Unless the hostname has an AAAA record associated with it, the system shouldn't use IPv6 to try and communicate with the host."
Even if the destination has an A and an AAAA record, Vista will prefer IPv4 over Teredo. The order of precedence is IPv6, IPv4, THEN Teredo. So a destination host with an A and AAAA record will always be reached using IPv4, NOT TEREDO.
The only time Teredo would be used is if the destination host ONLY had a AAAA record, and there are darn few of those out there. In other words, leaving IPv6 (and Teredo) enabled on your home PC have absolutely no impact on your networking performance.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 10:52 AM by Sean Siler [MSFT]
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Rob: ... copying a file takes 41% of the CPU. What kind of networking stack has that kind of processor overhead?
I regarded this kind of behavior when copying files using SMB. The same file copied from the same server using FTP was many times faster.
Regards, Lothar
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 10:54 AM by Lothar
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
@Chris re: (I realize that now that you can pin a NIC to a particular CPU)
can you elaborate? I'm looking around and can't find any info - this could be helpful on one of my servers.
Thanks
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 11:00 AM by Erik
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
I have had a ton of issues with media playback in Vista on both single core and dual core platforms, with and without Aero even when it could easily support it. My solution has been to shutdown as many ancillary services as possible, and there are a lot. Most, if not all of the security services are gone, and that was strictly for my sanity. Many of the disk services and indexing are shutdown. I do actually know where my content is and don't need any help finding it. And then I shutdown some more things that just seemed to be hanging out and not really providing any immediately useful service. The result is a fairly smooth running system that runs aero, the sidebar, other applications, and my i-tunes videos full screen without glitches. Prior to shutting all of these things down, i-tunes videos were unwatchable, streaming internet video (ie simple slideshows) were unwatchable, and the whole media experience was enough to make me beg for XP back, or even 2000 pro. My disk access has gone from essentially constant to only when I'm actively doing something. Now I have my LED for power that stays on, and my disk activity LED is no longer solid 24/7. Things that ran fine on XP systems with less than half the performance of the current system now run like they should. Moving large files across the Gigabit network also move like they should. Vista still won't play wmv files that run fine on my other XP boxes. Winamp will play them just fine on VISTA, but Media Player says there is a problem with my WHQL video card.
Why all of this? There are many other issues with Vista playing media than the one network issue mentioned here and eliminating many of the ancillary services will go a long way, but not nearly all the way, to solving them. There error codes that Windows Media Player provide are of course useless because there is no description for them. I would have thought that all of the effort going into the driver certification process and application certification process would have resulted in a more stable and better performing system, but alas this has not been the case.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 11:03 AM by Mike E
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
> Despite even this level of throttling, Internet
> traffic, even on the best broadband connection, won?t
> be affected.
This is only a valid analogy for someone downloading a single file off the Internet from a single source.
Throw in P2P-anything and you get huge number of small packets which Vista will happily throttle for you [sigh], regardless of your actual bandwidth.
One problem is you use packets/sec regardless of how 'full' those packets are. Another is that Vista apparently has a horribly inefficient TCP stack... 40% CPU usage for a file copy?
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 11:07 AM by Redesign It
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
"Games are slower overall because of all the added functionality and features in Vista... even with many services, eyecandy, and programs disabled I still find programs run better in XP (and even better in Linux!). For example, BioShock runs horribly on my computer in Vista with input and audio lag making it unplayable. This didn't surprise me too much as my computer didn't meet the minimum specs in the CPU department. But, in XP, it ran quite acceptably."
- Not to mention all the DRM throughout the audio and video stack. Benefitting who exactly? Not really the consumer, they're better off with XP arguably. DX10 runs a fair bit quicker on XP and Linux (with the "backported" un-official release), that surely means something is very wrong.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 11:11 AM by Ken Davis
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
So this explains the problems with MCE's having stutter problems? As they push data over the network while doing 'media playback' at the same time?
The Transcode360 forums are full of this problem too.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 12:09 PM by Lee
# The *MAXIMUM* standard frame is 1500
Correction: "the standard Ethernet frame size is about 1500 bytes" should be "the *MAXIMUM* standard Ethernet frame size is about 1500 bytes."
This is significant because it is a "well known fact" that most ethernet frames are a lot less than the maximum length. It is only when pumping lots of data (e.g. file transfers) that maximum size frames are used heavily, and even then the acknowledgment frames going back to the data source are typically 64 bytes (minimum size).
The minimum frame is 64 bytes, which works out to about 164,000 frames/second so throttling at 10,000 frames/second will throttle the network a *whole* lot worse than the calculation based on 1500 byte packets.
Note that there is the same amount of overhead in a 1500 byte frame and a 64 byte frame, meaning the amount of useful data that gets passed in shorter frames is even worse.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 12:33 PM by gvb
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Robert Love (Linux Kernel Developer and author of Linux Kernel Development) has a good article comparing Linux's implementation vs. Vista's - he states that even on Gigabit Ethernet Linux equivalent of Vista's DPC is unable to generate more than minuscule amount of CPU Usage.
So can it be concluded that Vista's Network performance is abysmal and to plug that Microsoft had to play around with prioritizing Multimedia and penalizing the network performance? Why would this ugly hack be required if Vista network implementation did not consume this much CPU.
Mark - Answer is really appreciated. Thanks.
Here is the URL for Robert Love's blog post - http://blog.rlove.org/2007/08/those-dang-dpcs-clogging-mmcss.html
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 12:36 PM by LinuxGuy
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
The real questions, I suppose, have to do with the various virtualization scenarios - XP under Vista, or Vista under XP, and whether this resource allocation can be "fooled" under these circumstances.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 12:45 PM by Neil Prestemon
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
I just tried killing MMCSS along with the registery hack for the audio service, and it works like a charm. I was stuck at 10% transfers, and now I hit 80%. Fantastic! The interesting thing is why I was experiencing this before. Well, the majority of my network transfers are with media files, which means that I open a folder with lots of media files (i.e., AVIs) and copy them to another folder with lots of media files. No music playing, no video playing, and yet Vista slows down. Why? Because explorer is busy creating previews of all those media files, hence kicking in MMCSS and it's silly slowdown! Well there you go, problem solved, another useless piece of software goes down.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 12:51 PM by FooBarBaz
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
And, yes, the same hardware running Linux can play back a glitch free mp3 while keeping the network link fully loaded with send and receive data.
The answer to this particular problem - switch to Linux.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 1:04 PM by Anon
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
"The minimum frame is 64 bytes, which works out to about 164,000 frames/second so throttling at 10,000 frames/second will throttle the network a *whole* lot worse than the calculation based on 1500 byte packets."
True, but how often does one send out more than 10000 little frames per second? Usually when you're transferring more than 10000 frames it's because they're part of, for example, a large TCP stream, and those frames are likely the maximum size, i.e. that of the MTU.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 1:06 PM by steveo
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Mark,
Thanks for an honest discussion of the issue. It's sad that MS can spend billions developing Vista and an obvious magic-number hack (and a buggy one too!) like this is acceptable for production release to the world.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 1:07 PM by Pete R
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
"PS - I have a *phone* running a 200 MHz ARM with a piddly little OS and am able to play streaming MP3's on a broadband wireless network with no hassles. And a dual-core, 2 GHz desktop uses 41% CPU to simply copy files???"
Does your phone transfer files at gigabit network speeds? I presume it does not so it appears you didn't read the article and are making an invalid comparison.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 1:46 PM by Leo Davidson
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
"Why would this ugly hack be required if Vista network implementation did not consume this much CPU."
It seems to be a scheduling/throttling issue, rather than one caused by something using too much CPU. The problem is that fixed magic numbers were chosen, perhaps based on the worst-case hardware, and obviously without thinking about the requirements of gigabit networks.
I don't think Vista is actually using 100% CPU in this situation; the problem is that it's still throttling the network "just in case" of something that won't happen.
With gigabit networks so common now, and for years, it's surprising that this slipped through but it looks like it's being addressed and it's great to have it explained openly, and in detail, so soon after the issue was diagnosed.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 1:51 PM by Leo Davidson
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Leo Davidson said -
"It seems to be a scheduling/throttling issue, rather than one caused by something using too much CPU. The problem is that fixed magic numbers were chosen, perhaps based on the worst-case hardware, and obviously without thinking about the requirements of gigabit networks."
If I could do network I/O without taxing the CPU I would not land into trouble with scheduling and neither would I need to do any throttling. The problem is not magic numbers themselves - the problem lies int the fact that they were needed.
There is no excuse to use more than tiny amount of CPU to do network I/O even at Gigabit speeds if the OS and networking stack are designed sanely. Read the blog post I linked to.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 2:26 PM by LinuxGuy
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
I'm not so sure that the issue as described here scopes the symptoms broadly enough. I have a 100Mb network, 3GHz PC and all the latest Realtek HD audio drivers. I generally use iTunes connected my file server where my audio files are stored, and a number of other players for DVD and movie files both locally and on the server. The PC was previously happily running Windows 2000 and 2003 Server (it's my development box), so I know it's not the hardware. Under Vista, sound output is dire- sound playback hops, skips and squeaks to the extent that I now do my editing on another PC running Win2k. I have the same problem on a Sony AR31S which also has HD Audio playback.
Using the same perfmon settings as above, I'm not seeing the same profile. My my network access is very 'spikey'- zero to 400kps spikes while iTunes plays MP3.
All these drivers are relatively frequently updated and I've noticed that the performance changes somewhat between versions (up and down), but is never resolved. Even setting iTunes to use it's max buffer size (which would hopefully overcome a variable speed network problem) does not help.
I feel that the problem is perhaps deeper in the HD Audio system that Vista introduces. The early Realtek HD drivers were rubbish and if I recall MS pushed a HD Audio fix early one- perhaps there's more to learn and resolve? Unfortunately I've not the network diagnostics and audio driver skills to provide better diagnosis. I cannot identify any perfmon counters to measure HD Audio drivers, but iTunes CPU usage runs around 5-15%.
I'm just hanging out for a proper fix (doh!) and wait for a fix and currently play music on a regular CD player. Bummer.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 2:34 PM by Stewart
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
It's refreshing to hear a valid, lucid explanation of what the issue really is instead of the background "noise" created by the FUD mongers at Slashdot. Thank you once again for leading the way to understanding core Windows technologies.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 2:35 PM by FusionGuy
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
"It's refreshing to hear a valid, lucid explanation of what the issue really is instead of the background "noise" created by the FUD mongers at Slashdot. Thank you once again for leading the way to understanding core Windows technologies."
This is a "lucid explanation" of a really BAD DESIGN.
This is not FUD, its purely bad design... Do you know another OS in the world that needs more than 40% of the processor to handle a GigE traffic?
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 2:49 PM by Lucio
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Do you even know how to measure kernel time as a percentage of total processing time in any OS? I'll give you a hint -- it doesn't show up in a typical CPU utilization chart.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 3:04 PM by Dupe
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
This is not only a Windows problem. You can find the same on many other OS.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 4:04 PM by CableGuy
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Lucio, nobody is claiming their isn't a problem here. MS (or at least two MS employees in their blogs) are being quite open about the fact there is a problem that needs fixing.
The FUD that I believe FusionGuy was referring to was people jumping to baseless conclusions that this issue was caused by the evil multimedia DRM in Vista and other such nonsense.
It's great that Mark and Larry (http://blogs.msdn.com/larryosterman/default.aspx) from Microsoft have been able to shed light on this new issue in such detail and I hope it puts an end to the FUD. The issue itself still needs to be solved but it's clear that it's being taken seriously, being worked on by the people that need to fix it, and not being hidden or excused.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 5:38 PM by Leo Davidson
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Mark - sorry, I know you're one of the most credible living authorities on Windows, but you have a lot to learn about IP networks.
A "standard Ethernet frame" isn't 1500 bytes at all - as has been pointed out, the minimum is just 64 bytes, and a realistic average for a TCP stream would be somewhere between 600 and 900 bytes. If you're using (the increasingly popular) UDP or some other connectionless protocol, the average tends to get smaller.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 5:59 PM by Mike
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
"It's great that Mark and Larry (http://blogs.msdn.com/larryosterman/default.aspx) from Microsoft have been able to shed light on this new issue in such detail and I hope it puts an end to the FUD. The issue itself still needs to be solved but it's clear that it's being taken seriously, being worked on by the people that need to fix it, and not being hidden or excused."
No. This is where you're downright WRONG.
There should be no "issue" in the first place. Have you read any of the notes in this thread? Re-read everything, re-read all of them. Everyone is saying the same thing: how exactly did a FLAW like this get 1) created, 2) pass QA/testing, 3) shipped, and 4) not noticed after the release?
What needs to happen is that Microsoft needs to fire the FTE (or terminate the contract of the dashtrash individual) who idealised/designed the methodology used, and also needs to terminate whoever was involved in the writing/production of the related code.
Yes, someone needs to get fired over this. I will repeat myself: FIRED. Terminated. No more job. No more free Starbucks coffee, no more little ball-rubbing managerial meetings with PMs, no more time wasting. Whoever wrote the code needs to be axed, NOW. Oh, but I'm sure if they're a FTE, they won't be terminated, because Microsoft never fires FTEs -- they just relocate them into other depts. and let them make the same mistakes over and over. Or maybe they'll become a PM. ;)
I'm well aware of Microsoft's business practises -- I mean, everyone who works there has taken Microsoft's SBC 2007, right? SBC talks about *taking responsibility* and making good decisions, and that's what Microsoft supposedly prides itself on doing. Was this engineering flaw even remotely a good decision? No. Was this engineering methodology discussed with other programmers? Probably. And no one chimed in with "Uh, this probably isn't a good idea, Joe..."? Fire them all.
So who's going to pay? Whose ass is on the line? Oh right, I forgot: the consumer's. Every Vista customer will suffer because one or two half-ass engineers at Microsoft decided "this way is AWESOME".
This entire engineering flaw proves that Microsoft is intentionally hiring programmers who need to "think opposite of UNIX" (and not "think outside the box"), does *absolutely NO form of decent QA* on their products, and simply put, doesn't give a rats ass about a better end-user/consumer experience -- all they care about is more services, more abstraction (WINDOWS MEDIA LIBRARY ENUMERATION DEVICE MANAGEMENT SERVICE!!!! YEAH!!!), and more CRAP.
Do not tell me Vista needs a high-end P4 CPU when you've got _engineering flaws_ like this in your device ABI. This is atrocious. Back to what I said originally: someone, or some people, need to get FIRED over this.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 6:33 PM by I like sausages
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Mark, I commend to your notice the eHome tool VPT - contact John Pennock for details. Using this tool, I generated an ~85Mbps outbound TCP stream (on a 100bT network), which immediately fell to ~42Mbps when a local media file was played. This seems a bit more intrusive than your analysis indicated.
VPT allows you to drive configurable bit-rates, as well, both in TCP and UDP protocols, using your choice of packet lengths (or msg sizes for some tests).
You might find it interesting that playing media on the sending side of this flood test results in a larger performance penalty than playing on the receiving side. (That's what's described above) Also, increasing the message size to ~10 MTU almost completely eliminates the effect, at least on the receiving side.
Hope this tool helps shed some light on the matter, when used by more capable hands than mine.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 6:51 PM by Dick Martin Shorter
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Sounds like MS still don't understand scheduling... Or just presume that no one watches a DVD while doing other things.
I tend to agree with "I like sausages"... The people responsible for this should be fired, or at least demoted to a level where they don't touch code at all (janitor, marketing, graphical people, I don't care).
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 7:27 PM by Tim B
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
"Tests of MMCSS during Vista development showed that, even with thread-priority boosting, heavy network traffic can cause enough long-running DPCs to prevent playback threads from keeping up with their media streaming requirements, resulting in glitching." I'm going to assume that it wasn't "normal" media streaming, but DRM-protected media. And probably not music, but video. However, the biggest question that I have is who designed the IP stack so that it handles packets for the TCP/IP driver. Both TCP and UDP are designed to throttle back if the CPU can't keep up with the traffic. The DPC should be moving the packet into a buffer and then returning, not calculating TCP checksums. Let someone interrupible do that; if the buffer fills up in the meantime, let the retransmit algoithms deal with it.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 8:57 PM by samwyse
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
I wish the limit was lower yet. On my wireless network, transferring data at even moderate speeds (a few megabits per second) can cause glitching in audio playback. And this is with a fast dual-core processor.
Tuesday, August 28, 2007 8:59 PM by Adam Zey
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
@Erik:
We had several Dual Processor P4's with Hyperthreading, and we were trying to set up MS ISA 2004 on Windows 2003 SP1. The servers had multiple NIC's, and we ran network throughput testing software between the servers either side of the ISA servers we were testing.
I think it was the combination of using NIC bonding (aka Gigabit-etherchannel) as well as having multiple processors.
It seemed like the nics were continually being handled by different CPU's with some sort of context switch penalty when this happened. We could only manage something like 70Mbits through these servers when the theoretical maximum should have been 2 Gigabit.
We ran out of time and so replaced the servers with linux which did not exhibit the problem, (could exceed at least 1 gigabit throughput)
However afterwards I read somewhere that there is a setting somehow to enforce each nic to a particular cpu only, which may give better performance.
http://support.microsoft.com/kb/252867 explains how to set the processor affinity to a single nic, as per the ISA recommendation in KB293640.
My point to Zachary is that it's not about optimizing code specifically for Hyperthreading/SMP, but more that since it's very common now to have HT or SMP that something would need to be done to counteract this symptom. Perhaps the TCP/IP stack was fixed past Windows 2003 SP1 or in Vista so this is no longer applicable...
Wednesday, August 29, 2007 1:05 AM by Chris
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
The whole trick is to enforce unfair rules in a way the user expects. Prioritizing audio/video playback over network traffic is very reasonable indeed! The throttling leaves somewhat to be desired though...
DPCs in the TCP/IP stack being long-running and non-preemptible (except by other interrupts) seems a little problematic. Once the critical sections of the interrupt handlers are finished, is there any reason not to queue up the remaining work so it can be scheduled fairly against other processes?
The current approach essentially results in priority inversion on behalf of the processes that are doing all of the heavy I/O because the time spent in the kernel doing interrupt processing is not charged against them. When that happens scheduler priority classes become largely irrelevant and the rest of the system starves. It might also undermine rate management algorithms depending on how much buffering is going on.
Is it possible to prevent this case through more accurate bookkeeping that takes into account the amount of time spent performing kernel services "on behalf of" a user-space process? If the consuming process can be identified early enough in the processing chain, then subsequent processing could be deferred unless the process has enough available CPU cycles in its budget for it to proceed. Thus a process that performed very heavy network I/O could only starve other processes if it resided in a sufficiently elevated priority class.
Essentially, that would make "realtime" priority classes meaningful in the face of DPCs. But it sounds like a whole lot of work.
So...
What happens when using multi-core CPUs? Are ordinary processes allowed to run concurrently with DPCs? If so, can this property be used as part of the algorithm to tune throttling?
Wednesday, August 29, 2007 1:35 AM by Jeff Brown
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Surely setting multimedia playback to the highest possible priority means that it takes all the CPU time it needs and the rest can be used for other processes (i.e., handling network traffic). What's the point of having prioritized processes otherwise? It seems like there's some kind of fundamental flaw in Vista process scheduling. God help us all if anybody tries to use Vista for important stuff like medical equipment monitoring.
Wednesday, August 29, 2007 2:30 AM by tck
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
At such a low speed this might be due to something else.
Wednesday, August 29, 2007 3:59 AM by James
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Obviously, if network was not demanding so much CPU, you could give more to the audio subsystem. But Vista would not probably be Vista if it did.
Wednesday, August 29, 2007 4:02 AM by ccj
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
I very much disagree with "I like sausages".
Someone tells a story (and I can't remember who) about a programmer who makes a mistake which costs his employer a huge sum of money (millions, maybe even 10s of millions). He gets called into see the boss, fully expecting to be fired, and gets a thorough roasting. At the end of the meeting he asks the boss about handing in his security badge, but the boss replies "I just spent x-million on your education. Why would I want to fire you?"
Wednesday, August 29, 2007 4:18 AM by Tom M
# If you think it's trivial, you don't understand the problem
"Heads must roll?". Before you pass out from over-ranting, go learn about the difference between a real-time OS and one that schedules threads of various priority.
Oversimplifying, real-time means being able to GUARANTEE a RT thread will receive cycles either periodically and/or for a specified period. A trivial example is the engine computer in your new car -- it must be able to schedule the proper sparkplug to fire within a few microseconds at high rpm.
OSes designed for real-time don't make for very good interactive, graphical user experiences, since it's not important, for example, for all threads, particular the majority that do things like draw pixel, to run at a precisely specified time. For this use, you want an OS that can schedule threads using variable priority, while avoiding priority inversion and such, to get a responsive interface.
The basic desktop PC OSes (MS, *nix) use the latter kernel scheduling design because you want a nice user experience. As you can probably deduce, there are a few types of functions running on the desktop OS that require GUARANTEED cycles at specific times, and if they don't get their "tick" EVERY time, you hear a pop or click or video streak or ....
So how do you implement such a hybrid OS? The old way (before Vista) was to schedule and run the RT-critical stuff in the Interrupt/DPC arena, leaving the scheduler to handle everything else as interruptible threads. The problem is that as your add more and more time-critical processes that need guaranteed cycles, you start writing a mini-scheduler that controls the stuff in the IRP/DPC world, and it's really difficult to sync and interact this with the other world of scheduled threads.
Vista, using MMCSS and new dynamic thread priority/importance mechanism, is attempting to move this Real-Time stuff back under a generic thread-scheduling design. One could argue that all of the DPC stuff in Vista should be converted to scheduled RT threds, and that would prevent anything except uncontrolled interrupt handlers from delaying RT functionality.
In RTM Vista, it looks like the network hardware stuff is still running in DPCs that are capable of stalling the RealTime stuff. The obvious question is why are the DPCs doing so much? If you think it's easy to do things like avoid deadlocks when you have DPCs and RT threads sharing data, then it won't be obvious to you why a network DPC may have to do more than minimal operation on a chunk of data.
Blaming "some idiot FTE" for these design problems isn't pointing the gun in the right direction. Rather, the problem is how to dynamically limit the network DPC activity based on how likely the RT threads are to miss their scheduled time. You obviously don't want to wait until you hear a pop/click before throttling back, so you must design an anticipatory algorithm to prevent interference by throttling the rate of interrupts that run DPCs. (This is extremely hard to do reliably, across all performance levels of CPUs and network hardware, making the "hack" look more appealing.)
My guess is that future Vista scheduling mechanisms will move most or all of the remaining DPC-level code into real-time threads like the multimedia is now, but until that happens, the next best thing will be to come up with a more effective algorithm to dynamically limit the DPC activity based on how likely the RT threads are to miss their scheduled time.
Read Larry Osterman's blog quoted a few comments above about how isochronous streams require RT scheduling, and realize that major redesign of the kernel is not gonna happen in a SP, leaving the likely near-term solution to be limited dynamic network throttling based on a better anticipatory algorithm for the RT stuff. (I'm glad I'm not the one who has to come up with the solution -- I've been there and done similar, and it's a brain-twister.) However, some time in the future, the beauty of converting DPC tasks to RT threads is that threads scale very nicely to dual/quad/heptapenta core processors.
And yes, I realize that Linux doesn't have this problem -- their equivalent of kernel DPCs is handled in the scheduler (which is the main reason it was so tough to get it right).
(I don't work for MS -- in fact, I often don't agree with some of the design approaches they have taken, but I hate to see great software engineers flamed just because understanding the problem is beyond the grasp of some.)
As us old kernel farts used to say, flames to /dev/null (google it if you don't grok)
Wednesday, August 29, 2007 4:49 AM by Jerry Schneider
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
I am perplexed by the claim that Internet traffic is not affected by this, and even more perplexed by its reasoning. Is the writer perhaps unaware that people with beefy Internet connections get 9 gigabits per second of bandwidth in long distance benchmarks, and still much more than 1 gigabits in real world applications?
Wednesday, August 29, 2007 6:18 AM by Erno
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
Jerry Schneider - Is it not that DPCs consuming large amount of CPU is the main short term problem for MSFT to resolve? If the DPCs operated efficiently (i.e. they did not consume more than few percent CPU) would not the scheduler have more time to give to the RT Audio task and things be fine? Why would one give up on optimizing the DPCs? With modern NICs with offloads and interrupt coalescing and such sophisticated features DPCs have no business using so much CPU.
Can anyone explain why optimizing DPCs would not work?
Wednesday, August 29, 2007 6:41 AM by LinuxGuy
# re: Vista Multimedia Playback and Network Throughput
The more I read about this issue the stranger it becomes. There are so many problems it's even hard to know where to start.
1. Why does the audio system require the following:
"For instance, in Vista, the audio engine runs with a periodicity of 10 milliseconds. That means that every 10 milliseconds, it MUST wake up and process the next set of audio samples, or the user will hear a "pop"
by gsaravin9
Microsoft is planning to ship its next major version of Windows -- known internally as version "7" -- within roughly three years, CNET.com.au has learned.
The company discussed Windows 7 on Thursday at a conference for its field sales force in Orlando, Florida, according to sources close to the company.
While the company provided few details, Windows 7, the next client version of the operating system, will be among the steps taken by Microsoft to establish a more predictable release schedule, according to sources. The company plans a more "iterative" process of information disclosure to business customers and partners, sources said.
Windows Vista, the oft-delayed most recent release of Windows, shipped to businesses in November and to consumers in January after more than five years of development. Vista's gestation period was marked by shifting product details as internal priorities changed and problems arose with development.
Like Vista, Windows 7 will ship in consumer and business versions, and in 32-bit and 64-bit versions. The company also confirmed that it is considering a subscription model to complement Windows, but did not provide specifics or a time frame.
Next up on Microsoft's agenda is Service Pack 1 for Windows Vista, which is expected before year's end.
The discussion of Windows' future isn't surprising, given that Microsoft has been criticised by business customers for delays related to Vista. Many business customers pay for Microsoft's software under a license agreement called Software Assurance.
Windows 7 was previously known by the code name Vienna. A Microsoft representative confirmed that Windows 7 is the internal code name for the next client release of Windows. The details were released "as part of our ongoing outreach to enterprise customers and partners, Microsoft has begun sharing plans for how they will continue to deliver value to businesses in the future Software Assurance customers in particular", a representative said in a statement via e-mail.
"Microsoft is scoping Windows 7 development to a three-year time frame, and then the specific release date will ultimately be determined by meeting the quality bar," according to the representative.
give or take a couple of years.
by gsaravin9
18th October 2006 James Bannan Windows
PLEASE NOTE -- there is a newer version of this tutorial available. Click here to go to it .
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
If one installation of Windows just isn?t enough, or you don?t feel like there?s enough pain in your life yet, why not install both Windows XP and Windows Vista onto the same machine?
Why not indeed. To be honest, I have no idea why you?d want to do this. As mentioned in a previous blog??? entry, Vista?s dominance of the MBR makes the process something of a one-way street. Once Vista is introduced to any system you have to play ball according to Vista Rules.
Partitioning
The actual dual-booting process is, however, relatively painless and straightforward. On a machine with Windows XP installed, the only prerequisite is that the hard drive has enough space to accommodate a Vista installation, or that you have a second drive to drop Vista onto.
If you only have one physical drive, then you?ll need some spare space on the disk for a Vista partition. This can be a drama if your XP partition takes up the entire disk, as you?ll need to resize it. Unfortunately XP won?t help you here. If you have a drive partitioning tool like Acronis, well and good. But if you don?t and you?d (understandably) rather not pay for it if you don't have to, there are alternatives.
Windows Vista CAN resize partitions on the fly, but unfortunately it won?t do it as part of the default Vista installation. However, if you can get your hands on Windows PE 2.0, then you?re in business.
Boot into PE, and load DISKPART from x:\Windows\System32. This is the Vista version of DISKPART, so the SHRINK option is available. Select the appropriate volume first (usually SELECT VOLUME 0) and type in SHRINK. This isn?t a configurable process as it is via Disk Management in the Vista GUI. SHRINK just goes through and recovers what space it can. On a 20GB NTFS partition with a basic XP installation, SHRINK dropped the partition by 10GB, which is enough for Vista (just!). It's likely that defragmenting free space on the partition you're shrinking will help a lot.
If you don?t have access to Windows PE 2.0, there?s a very powerful tool called GParted - the GNOME Partition Editor. This is a Linux-based GUI partitioning tool which can resize NTFS partitions (amongst LOTS of others).
Grab the LiveCD download, burn the ISO to create a bootable CD and fire up the machine. Accepting all the defaults should work fine, except if you?re using VMWare, in which case load the graphics modules manually and select VESA, otherwise the screen will just go black. Right-click on the partition and select Resize/Move. Drag the edge of the partition until you get the size needed, select OK and then Apply. And that?s it! Reboot and install Vista into the newly-created partition.
Boot Manager
Once Vista is installed, the system brings up the Windows Boot Manager (Vista version), with a choice between ?Microsoft Windows Vista? or a bland and generic ?Earlier Version of Windows?.
Bit boring, but unfortunately modifying the boot manager in Vista is not quite as easy as it has been in the past. You can still access boot information in System Properties (right-click My Computer, Properties, Advanced System Settings), then Startup and Recovery, Settings. Here you can select the default operating system to load and the selection timeout settings, but that?s it. To edit all the boot options, you have to use a new tool called BCDEDIT from the command line. And unfortunately, it?s not easy to use at all. Very comprehensive and powerful, but difficult.
BUT - running to the rescue is EasyBCD from NeoSmart. This gives you a GUI for BCDEDIT and makes life SO much easier. There?s a swag of options you can choose depending on how in-depth you want to get. For the moment, just go to ?Configure Boot? and change the name of the Windows XP installation to ?Windows XP? and hit ?Save Settings?. Restart and you?ll see that the changes have been written to the boot manager, and life is slightly less bland that it was.
Under ?Add/Remove Entries? you can move existing entries up and down the list, or add new ones, if you have an existing partition ready for the new operating system. In theory, you could use Vista to quad-boot XP, Vista, Linux and OSX. But you?d be very brave?or a tech writer.
If you decide that dualbooting really isn?t for you after all, the Vista MBR needs to go if you want to get XP operational again. Luckily, EasyBCD can help. Go to ?Manage Bootloader? and select ?Uninstall the Vista Bootloader? then ?Write MBR?. Restart the machine and the Vista Boot Manager is gone - the system loads straight into Windows XP. And in XP, the Vista partition is now the secondary D: partition, which can be safely erased.
Bookmark/Search this post with:
delicious | digg | reddit
add new comment
1:
System Restore has these stupid issues when you dual-boot between XP and Vista.
someone (337 days ago)
reply
2: Dual boot
I am purchasing a new HP PAVILION laptop with AMD turion 1.73 GHz Proc, 1 GB RAM and 120 GB HDD.... I thought i'll purchase a vista pre loaded machine, but dicovered that installing XP(a lower version than vista) after vista would be a real pain...
So i decided to purchase a WINXP laptop and then install VISTA HOME PREMIUM on an external USB HDD....
I am not that very technically sound as other ppl here are, but am doing a good thing?
If I am, how can i install vista on my secondary HDD so that when i boot my system with the external HDD connected, i should get a menu to choose the bootup between XP and vista...
CAN SOME ONE PLZ HELP ME? I AM LEARNING AND SO DESPERATELY WANNA KNOW THIS...
Nikhil Nagaraj (227 days ago)
reply
3:
Well I have to agree , why would anyone want to load both XP and Vista, although I'll take it one step farther - Why would anyone want to load Vista at all?? What does Vista offer that we really need, any reall new application? The only thing that Vista does has is the UI, which won't function proplery unless you have the top of the line new Core 2 Duo CPU with a lot of RAM! So why should we bother with Vista at all??
Katz (336 days ago)
reply
4: I beg to differ but not argue
I just wanted to make the statement regarding how you stated you must have a powerful machine to run Vista and why someone would want it. Yes I agree most will be in awe of the UI it is quite illuminating compared to old styles, but I want to state that I have a 1.73 GHz processor on a dell laptop with 1G of memory and Vista runs amazingly well. It runs better than XP (faster I mean). The problem I do have is the incompatibility with older software. Not even that old sometimes. Example, the new Panda 2007 can't even work. I caught this while looking for an answer to another problem I've had. I installed Vista on my computer and then setup another partition and installed XP Pro which unfortunately made it to where my Vista install won't boot now.
Michael (257 days ago)
reply
5: about that incompatibility issue...
I was reading these posts and noticed something about a compatibility issue. Believe me, I had them too. Vista does offer a cleverly convenient feature, however, which basically enables you to run any program as though you were running it in another version of Windows of your choice. So if you know the program works on Windows XP SP2, for example, you would set it to run as if it were in Windows XP SP2. What you do is right click on the icon of the program and open its properties. Click the "Compatibility" tab on the top. Check the box next to "Run this program in compatibility mode for:" and select your OS from the dropdown menu. The selections are (in exact wording): 1. Windows 95 2. Windows 98 / Windows ME 3. Windows NT 4.0 (Service Pack 5) 4. Windows 2000 5. Windows XP (Service Pack 2) 6. Windows Server 2003 (Service Pack 1). And then keeping the box unchecked obviously makes it run in Vista (DUH, you didn't need me to figure that one out!) There are also some more compatibility settings such as coloring, resolution, DPI, etc. as well as the option to always run the program as an administrator. nifty! Well, I was able to play all my games like this, but some of them went kinda off (deleted the crosshair in one! How the heck can I shoot in a game without a crosshair?!) So I went through the painful process of installing an XP partition. My programs will work there, but I'm still in the process of downloading drivers (including the one for ethernet, which means I'm typing this on Vista.) Whatever, hope that helped!
Anonymous (no, seriously!) (208 days ago)
reply
6: I have software for my
I have software for my business given to me by the company I am affiliated with and it will not run on Vista at all, even with running under the XP SP2 mode.
Anon (147 days ago)
reply
7: wow i'm running my desktop
wow i'm running my desktop with vista ultimate PERFECTLY fine with a athlon64 3000+, 512 mb pc 2700 ram (anyone remember that speed?) and a 5500 geforce card. I seriously doubt vista could run any better (no lag with aero, and has a nice index rating (everything above 3 exept gaming graphics...
I could say that I have the worst of the worst scenarios for running vista (in terms of computer performance) and i'm doing great!
marco (172 days ago)
reply
8: Sorry to call your comments into question but...
512 ram will only give a rating of 2 in Vista.
Shrax25 (148 days ago)
reply
9: the comments "Why would
the comments "Why would anyone want to install Vista at all?
or What does Vista have to offer anybody?" is lame. If you don't like it, don't use it! I have never heard so much complaining about any piece of software before. I would bet that 90% of people who complain that Vista is a horrible operating system have NEVER EVEN USED IT! I can tell you that I think Vista is the best operating system I have ever used. I've had W95,98,2000,XP home and pro, and I even have still an Intel iMac. I like the macs, but i'll never buy one again. The money is not worth spending just for adobe photoshop (imac+photoshop=at least $2100). I have never had a virus on my XP Vista machine. Photoshop works BETTER on my Vista machine. Halo and Medal of honor work better on vista. Office 2003 works better on Vista. Security is MUCH MUCH MUCH BETTER on Vista. If vista sucks for you, too bad. That doesn't mean it sucks for everybody. all my old software and hardware work with Vista. I don't WANT anything else.
FEDORAble (153 days ago)
reply
10: the comments "Why would
Hi FEDORAble,
I think you have not used many softwares like flash 8.0 which actually are having problems with Vista. When you you select a text to edit in flash, the dotted line showing the selection becomes slower and slower.
I think you are not aware of such problems occuring in VISTA.
This was your information.
Thanks
ABC
ABC (148 days ago)
reply
11:
the new magazine is out for about a week but old one still being advertised on web site. Why?
John (336 days ago)
reply
12:
Dual booting is a great way to have a peek at the new OS (64 bit version in my case) and even with its limitations (drivers and Vista compatible apps), you can always flick back to the regular XP (x64 in my case) for work or more important stuff you don't want to expose an almost complete system to.
Thanks for the tips on removing and/or managing the MBR. I'll keep it in mind when I get near the RC1's expiry date.
Rob (336 days ago)
reply
13:
"Well I have to agree , why would anyone want to load both XP and Vista?"
It could be some bizzarre experiment to see how many paper clips, software updates and flying envelopes it takes to bring a modern day CPU and a couple of G's of ram to a complete halt!
Raindog (336 days ago)
reply
14:
I Agree with Rob above. I've dual-booted XP (32-bit) with Vista (32-bit) for the exact same purpose. I prefer having seperate OSes on seperate physical drives, with HDDs being so much cheaper now a days. Really appreciate the tips on removing MBR. I know I would have had to look around for it sooner or later... :-)
I am Linux curious and was planning to add Ubuntu to my current installation and get it to triple-boot. Any idea how the Vista boot-manager reacts to an addition of Linux? Is it tolerant, or does it make life too painful (in which case I plan to install Ubuntu on a spare USB HDD I have, allowing to plug in and out as required, without affecting the dual-boot)? Some insight into this will be helpful. Thanks...
TechGermz (336 days ago)
reply
15: ubuntu on usb drive
Linux in general doesn't boot from usb drives, because of a bootstrap issue. USB support is not there until after booting. I have found some workarounds for this posted various places, but find the instructions unintelligible.
There is just enough ambiguity to make it unclear how to proceed - the old "I know what I meant" problem.
There are also dire warnings about trashing your Windows installation by altering the Master Boot Record.
Arthur Pearson (222 days ago)
reply
16:
I am running Vista RC2 without any problems, all programs working fine. More stable than XP Pro. Running on a 3.2 Pentium with 2 gig of ram. I did have XP and Vista sitting on their own drives. Only needed the Vista install disk to sit in the Dvd player when booting to load Vista. Decided to just run Vista as my main OS. Will never go back to earlier OS.
Rob (336 days ago)
reply
17:
Another option is that MS this week released a beta of Virtual PC 2007.
This allows you to run Vista as a Virtual Machine inside of XP. Thus bypassing the problems of dual booting.
Realise that it is another beta to run and that the VM will consume resources but is a good quick way to confirm compatibility of Vista on your machine
Steve (336 days ago)
reply
18:
"Why would anyone want to load Vista at all??"
In answer to that, you will surly realise the following
1. Not everyone dislikes Microsoft and Windows. Some users want (and can afford) the latest and greatest of everything.
2. Some business will go forward with introducing Vista, then there is a need for people to support this product. The best way to support an OS is to know the OS and an early start is always useful.
Personally I wont be installing Vista. I am happy with my current setup of XP SP2 + patches :)
Peter (336 days ago)
reply
19:
Is it ok to install vista on the same partion. I did this when i had 2000 and upgraded to XP. Although a mistake bothe Operating Systems work fine? would this be ok to do with vista?
Ben (336 days ago)
reply
20:
Thanks for the info on how to restore the bootloader to start XP and rid myself of Vista RC2 from my second HD. Sweet!
John (332 days ago)
reply
21:
Hi
I Upgraded windows Xp pro to Windows Vista RC1 (5600), this was installed on disk 0 partition 1. Due to compatibility issues with some programs I Installed xp pro again on a diffrent partition (disk zero partion 3. Now I dont get an option to boot windows vista. Is theie anything I can do. thanks in advance
Irfan (332 days ago)
reply
22:
I am having the exact problem. Look for solutions. Many thanks
Raj (332 days ago)
reply
23: XP Vista dual boot
Hello
About a month ago, I bought a number of HP Pavilions that have the newly released Vista OS. These workstations were meant to operate instruments in my laboratory. I quickly found out the Agilent Technologies XP GPIB interface cards I use are not compatible with Vista. My solution was to buy full installation versions of XP to replace Vista. Micosoft told me that will be possible with a ?clean install?.
A clean install does not work. XP goes through a series of file download motions, and when I get to the point of XP installation, I get a window that says ?unknown disk?, . Continuing will lock up the computer.
HP will not help because I have an issue with XP which is not a supported operating system on the workstations I bought. Agilent Technologies will not help because I have an issue with Vista which is not a supported operating system for the GPIB cards I bought. Microsoft has tried helping for hours upon hours but to no avail.
Some of the other things I have tried were formating the HD before install XP, and replacing the original HD with a new one before installing XP. Neither worked. I am told the problem lies with the computer rather than Vista.
The question I have is can I install XP on my vista workstations via dual boot.
I am about to give up hope and realize I threw away thousands in computers and XP software. Any chance you can tell me otherwise?
regards
ejz
ejz (206 days ago)
reply
24: Its far from being an ideal
Its far from being an ideal solution, but you could try the 'Virtual Machine' solution mentioned earlier, but in reverse... Virtual machine would allow you to install xp within Vista if that makes any sense, and may, in theory allow you to use your incompatible hardware... I'm not experienced with the use of Virtual Machine but the principle seems sound.
William Barber (201 days ago)
reply
25: I tried a clean install of
I tried a clean install of XP as well, and came up with other errors, so I wiped the drive using a program called DBAN (copied to a floppy drive), as it will wipe SATA drives as well as IDE. Once I did this, I was able to install XP properly (after FDISK of course). Hope this helped...Doug.
why do people bother at all
by gsaravin9
Mouse battle: is Microsoft's new mouse the most over-the-top rodent ever?
18th September 2007 William Maher PC Hardware
After viewing the ?world?s most advanced mouse? - Logitech?s MX Revolution, with its motorised flywheel transmission - we thought mice couldn?t get any more over-the-top. We take that back.
Microsoft is following Logitech?s lead with a weight cartridge system for tweaking mouse-feel. Its SideWinder mouse (pictured above) comes with four of the small metal weights, for up to 30 grams of extra weight. To add weights, open up a slide tray in the side wall of the mouse.
The weights come in a little black box, along with three sets of rubber pads with a different ?glide? feel. The pads are changeable, so you can switch depending on what works best with your mouse pad or desk surface.
FPS players will be pleased to know the SideWinder is a corded job, not wireless. The accessories box also acts as an anchor point for the mouse cord so it doesn?t catch on your keyboard/PC.
For those who consider themselves decent at headshots, there?s a potentially handy set of toggle buttons on the top for changing dpi sensitivity (up to 2000 dpi). An LCD screen built into the mouse ? no, we?re not kidding - shows what DPI you?re using.
The SideWinder isn?t cheap at $129.95 (availability scheduled for November 2007), but it?s still decent value compared with Logitech?s G5 (same price), and G9 ($169.95). Both Logitech mice have weight cartridges and customisable dpi settings.
The SideWinder is one of a few eyebrow-raising mice we?ve seen of late. The Logitech G9 also has a choice of mouse shells ? a removable plastic chassis you can switch to provide a different feel. It also has an LED display.
The other mouse that?s caught our attention is Logitech?s motion-sensing MX Air Rechargeable Cordless Air Mouse. In a move that reminds us a bit of the Nintendo Wii, the MX Air detects movement: wave it in the air to change the volume of music, or change tracks.
Microsoft has also unveiled a dual-mode mini notebook mouse with a toggle for switching between Bluetooth and 2.4GHz wireless. Representatives from Microsoft argue that using 2.4GHz reduces the possibility of crosstalk between devices in crowded offices. The USB connector also doubles as a 1GB memory key.
Kinda handy, but while the guy over the partition is copying the files you just handed him on the 1GB key, your mouse is going to be moving his mouse pointer... there's an R&D flaw there somewhere.
well who knows ms may get it right this time
by gsaravin9
Microsoft announces Vista SP1 Beta
30th August 2007 James Bannan Microsoft, Vista, Windows
This week, the Microsoft Windows Vista Team announced details about the official beta of Vista Service Pack 1.
With the private beta having been leaked and done the rounds for the last few weeks (read our in-depth analysis here), Microsoft?s announcement doesn?t carry very many surprises. Still, it?s always informative to get the update straight from the horse?s mouth, so to speak.
As expected, SP1 will contain all the updates currently available for Windows Vista. However, Microsoft aren?t holding off on deploying updates while waiting for the service pack?s release. Various non-critical but customer-driven updates have been released via Windows Update and Microsoft Download Center (namely the performance and reliability updates), and with Vista so closely tied to online Microsoft services, it?s good to see that being made use of.
However, SP1 contains more than just patches and hotfixes. It will extend Vista?s functionality in various areas, namely reliability and performance (as we?ve already seen), administration experience and support for emerging hardware and standards. All the available technical detail is in the SP1 Beta Whitepaper, but here?s a summary or what to expect:
Reliability/Performance/Security
Enhanced communication with Windows Security Center
Improved x64 kernel support for third-party security vendors
RDP file signing
Elliptical Curve Cryptography number generator (PRNG)
Improved Bitlocker Drive Encryption (BDE)
Improved reliability and compatibility for:
newer graphics cards
external laptop displays
networking
Windows XP-upgraded systems
printer drivers
entering and resuming from sleep
Improved speed when:
copying and extracting files
resuming from Hibernation and Resuming
domain PCs are operating on the domain
Improves IE7 performance, especially in CPU utilisation and parsing Javascript
Improved battery life via fewer calls on the CPU and screen re-drawing
Faster logon procedure
Faster browsing of network shares
Administration
Bitlocker can now encrypt local volumes other than the C: drive
Fixes problems printing to printers in Terminal Service sessions
Network Diagnostic tool will be able to fix problems with file sharing
Disk Defragmenter can target specific volumes
Emerging Hardware/Standards
Flash memory storage will use exFAT files system, fully supported in Vista SP1
Support for SD-DMA (Secure Digital Advanced Direct Memory Access)
64-bit PCs will be able to boot using the EFI, which is currently only supported on IA-64 machines
Added support for Direct3D 10.1
Added support for SSTP (Secure Socket Tunnelling Protocol)
The standalone service pack is likely to be fairly chunky (around 1GB in size for x86 machines), and is anticipated to need quite a lot of hard drive space to install (approximately 7GB for x86 and a whopping 12GB for x64 ? this is not insubstantial). The update will support all language packs so it can be installed on any version of Vista. Given the size of the standalone update however, an English-only version might be prudent.
The service pack will be installable via three methods:
Express ? an individual machine connects to the Internet and downloads only the necessary files. This uses far less drive space and would be a good method of updating an SOE or home machines with a broadband connection
Standalone ? this functions like a standard hotpatch and is convenient for updating multiple machines. Does require a large one-off download
Slipstream ? while users can use the standalone package to slipstream their own Windows Vista media, all post-SP1 versions of Vista media will have SP1 slipstreamed into it. Users can use this media to deploy Vista SP1 to new machines, or do an upgrade install. Volume License customers will be able to download the slipstreamed media
Microsoft anticipate that SP1 Beta will be released to the public within a few weeks, and then a later SP1 pre-release will be made available to testers via MSDN and TechNet subscribers (and via BitTorrent for everyone else).
The final release is still scheduled for the first quarter of 2008, and it?s tied very closely to the Windows 2008 engineering cycle, as has been commonly known for some time.
Given that Microsoft has been pretty good about releasing Vista updates ahead of SP1, this may reduce any reluctance on the part of users and businesses to hold off upgrading to Vista until SP1 is released. Of course from what we?ve already experienced, Vista SP1 looks to be a far better experience than plain ?ol Vista, but the Vista experience so far hasn?t been bad at all, and it?s probable that by the time SP1 is released, a fully-patched Vista machine will be largely indistinguishable from a brand-new SP1 system. However, the fate of that particular forecast is well and truly in Microsoft?s hands.
Bookmark/Search this post with:
delicious | digg | reddit
add new comment
1: M$
I really and truly hate M$ and their arrogance. How can one company survive indefinitely after angering their customers, creating lousy products, and making horrible strategic decisions time and time again? IT WILL HAPPEN....they will crumble.....I hope we all see the day when that happens
Haushoffer (19 days ago)
reply
2: I couldnt agree more with
I couldnt agree more with this post, Microsoft keep stuffing half baked software in our face and turn around and tell us its the greatest. Anybody who is running vista are just beta testers at this time.
Devon Smashh (19 days ago)
reply
3: vista
I work in a school and I am currently buying five new computers. I have had to make a request to my supplier to down grade the products to XP. How bad is that? Vista is going backwards fast. "If it isn?t broke, don't fix it"
Brian O'Farrell (8 days ago)
reply
4: Hey Brian - I work at a
Hey Brian - I work at a school as well....I'm not sure if this licensing option is open to you, but you can get Software Assurance licensing which licenses you for older versions of Windows.
For example, you license for Vista Business, and you're entitled to install anything from Windows 95 to Vista Business. The same sort of licensing is available for Office as well.
James Bannan (8 days ago)
reply
5: Will it be any good?
Well, good news that the update is coming along. We recently bought a load of Lenova laptops ("Vista-ready") and they barely work. We've had to buy copies of XP and install that as an exercise in damage limitation!
APC-UPS-man (19 days ago)
reply
6: Vista
[quote]We recently bought a load of Lenova laptops [/quote] you better get a better system advisor ... I dropped Lenova/IBM years ago.(poor service poor support poor drivers poor everything).. IBM suks worse than RCA. which is 100% junk.
Snuffy (19 days ago)
reply
7: Newsflash: IBM No longer
Newsflash: IBM No longer owns the "Thinkpad" line, a company called "Lenovo" (Not Lenova) does now.
And have you ever seen IBM's enterprise class machines? No? Didn't think so.
Windows Vista runs fine *IF* your machine has what it takes to get the job done. AMD Turion64@1.8ghz, 2gb of ram, 256m video laptop... runs like a charm. Games run better than they did in Windows XP for that matter.
Windows Vista actually gets faster as you use it, it "learns" your style of use, and configures itself accordingly...
People said the same about Windows XP, and Windows 2000 before it.
Move on or move out (to linux) MS Windows is an ever-changing thing, and will *not* stay the same for long.
IBM!=Lenovo (18 days ago)
reply
8: Bloat Ware
The system resource requirements of Vista are crazy. 15Gb install vs 4GB for Mac OS X.
Microsoft, with all of its resources should have developed an entirely new OS, unencumbered by the .dll hell that has always been Windows biggest weakness.
Instead, they have created an operating system that is not completely compatible with old software and hardware while simultaneously not completely compatible with new software and hardware - it is half-baked.
The next OS that they release needs to be built from scratch.
Apple bit the bullet with OS X and broke with the past in order to create a much more stable, efficient and powerful.
Microsoft needs to follow Apple's lead.
MacCacking myself (18 days ago)
reply
9: Redesigning Windows
It's a great idea in theory, but in practice? Microsoft have already made baby steps in this direction and look at the criticism they got for it. People constantly carping that nothing works like the "lenova" comment. Personally, I've got everything going, though sometimes resorting to forums. (I don't use older software outside of the odd game.) Apple also has the advantage of having far fewer users, and even fewer corporate users, who would be most put out if they had to redesign their systems. (The corporate firm I work for has only just upgraded to Windows XP from NT4 no less!) And unfortunately, it's the vast sales of Windows licenses to corporates that Microsoft make their money on.
Scott (18 days ago)
reply
10: The Greatest So Far
You don't have to be smart to know that Vista is the greatest version of Windows so far. Sure there are a few things that need sorting out, like every OS before it. No operating system has been able to do what Vista does and it is the best OS ever made. Fullstop. Cry about more important things.
The Man (7 days ago)
reply
11: Why does everyone slate MS?
Why does everyone slate MS? If it is that bad they should just take it off their system and see how they get on with Linux, then they would see what MS has achieved or better still they should create an inproved OS.
MD (2 days ago)
reply
12: Oh go have a cry and use a
Oh go have a cry and use a mac and try do all the million things that you cant do on a mac.
Anonymous Ranger (7 days ago)
reply
13: Best OS ever. let these
Best OS ever. let these n00bs try work out how much better it is than everything else while we destroy the world
Anonymousgagrr (7 days ago)
reply
14: To all the Microsoft slaters!
Whats the point keep slating a company that clearly makes more money than anyone can imagen? The whole point being you have to change things for the better and sometimes it's better to focas all the efforts on new ideas than it is to use efforts supporting old ideas. If you don't like change, stick with the old stuff and never spend money upgrading and stop slatting a company thats got computer technology where it is today. Any decent workable idea costs money and the upgrades after dont cost much if anything. I Bought Cubase 4 costing ?500 and Steinberg have released 2 small fixes since its release well over a year ago with no dates for more patches or updates, now thats something to moan about. So, how many of you Microsoft haters actually bought Vista and gave it 5 minutes of your time? thats the real question, and I bet you wont even want it to do more than Windows XP does already so theres not much point upgrading is there? If your into software technology and like buying new hardware then Windows Vista is the gateway to the future of the Desktop Computer.
Well i told you guys ms will not make it past the post with vista
by gsaravin9
Microsoft: the authentic smell of failure
27th August 2007 Angus Kidman Microsoft, Vista, Windows
What is the Microsoft Windows Genuine Advantage, exactly? Over the past weekend, some owners of legitimate copies of Windows had their copies of Windows invalidated by Microsoft, while users of pirated copies were unaffected.
The weekend meltdown of Microsoft's Windows Genuine Advantage (WGA) servers managed to offend the one group of users -- people actually using Vista -- that the software giant desperately needs to keep onside, and demonstrates once again why the company's anti-piracy approach benefits neither users nor shareholders.
On Saturday Australian time, Microsoft's Windows Genuine Advantage servers, which authenticate copies of Windows and Office to ensure they are not pirated, managed to royally screw up and began incorrectly identifying legitimate Vista and XP systems as illegitimate.
For people who've actually laid out good money for Vista -- itself perhaps a questionable strategy given its hoglike hardware requirements, sluggish performance and lack of driver support -- getting fingered as a pirate is offensive enough.
However, if WGA identifies your system as suspect, it also disables many features of Vista, including the souped up Aero interface, leaving you with little more than Internet Explorer to play with.
Microsoft engineers eventually managed to fix the problem around 19 hours after reports of it first surfaced, but not before it had to warn users on its forum that swearing wasn't acceptable.
To date, there's been no word on the actual cause of the problem. The official site for 'Genuine Windows' doesn't even include a reference to the problem, while Microsoft's WGA blog only includes a brief note referring to how to revalidate affected systems.
Customers who have been tagged as the Captain Jack Sparrow of the software world have to revalidate their machines again to re-enable the blocked features. (Naturally, being a Microsoft fix, this also requires rebooting your PC.) Some afflicted users have reported that since revalidating, they are no longer able to access the Windows Update service.
The issue could have been much worse for Microsoft if the meltdown had occurred on a weekday, as many more machines would have potentially being affected. Nonetheless, it still demonstrates the essential stupidity of setting up a system which requires legitimate users to endlessly prove that they're not criminals, shifting the burden of intellectual property protection away from Microsoft and onto its customers.
The impact of WGA on piracy is questionable in any case. As one poster on Microsoft's forums remarked: "Download a pirated copy of Windows with Activation Cracks and live happily." The criminals stay happy, the genuine users get annoyed, and Microsoft staff seem more concerned about forum usage policies than customer discontent. It's not a pretty picture, is it?
Bookmark/Search this post with:
delicious | digg | reddit
add new comment
1: Heil Microsoft, lol.
Heil Microsoft, lol.
Brendan (24 days ago)
reply
2: An industry problem, not just one for MS.
This is not just a Microsoft issue - sure, WGA is an example of the guilty until proven innocent mentality that activation procedures force people to endure, but they aren't the only ones.
I remember Intuit being one of the worst offenders a few years ago - forcing users to fork out at least $5.00 in calling a 1900 number to reactivate software that wouldn't activate in the first place or needed to be reactivated for one reason or another. In my opinion, that's ransomware.
And then you have Starforce and other game "copy protection" mechanisms which infest yoru PC and occasionally prevent you from actually doing other things with yoru system.
The irony is that you aren't subjected to any of these restrictions with pirated software - and you save too. I'm not advocating the use of pirated software, but to pay for software these day seems a bit like paying to get someone to insert a pool cue in your proverbial...
And of course, the same applies to the music and film industries.
What's the solution? I don't know. The old idea of reducing the price of things so that people are less inclined to pirate is probably the best way, but no software/music/film vendor will ever do that.
Sadly, the only other choice is to use product activation - until we all get suckered in to using online apps. The next time you buy a WoW voucher, you might have to pick one up for Office too...
Jarrod Spiga (24 days ago)
reply
3: Some worthwhile points you
Some worthwhile points you made there Jarrod. Copying isn't unique to the software industry. If you're a content creator you don't want to be losing all that sweat and tears to creating something wonderful, then simply have someone take your work and use it without due credit.
I think there will always be cheapskates out there who will steal things no matter what you do. I think the trick is to put extra added value and 'cherishability' to a product so that people will want to pay money for it. For example, the experience of buying a Harry Potter novel and holding it in your hand whilst reading it is much more rewarding than reading it off a dodgy photocopy or a computer screen. A quality hand printed family portrait photo is going to be cherished more than some tiny 2-inch proof prints. I think cheapening the product will just remove the incentive for going out and buying the real thing.
Software? At the end of the day we aren't paying for ownership of it - just the rights to borrow it for a while (as per EULAs). Unfortunately it feels like borrowing a favourite toy from an overprotective brother who wants to make sure you won't scratch it.
azi (23 days ago)
reply
4: I unfortunately chose
I unfortunately chose Saturday to format my system, and still cannot update, as it was a fresh install, i am simply reformating but the way microsoft has handled this has been bad.
Jordan Messenger (24 days ago)
reply
5: I hope XP starts entering
I hope XP starts entering into Reduced Functionality Mode with XPSP3+WGA.
Anonymuos (24 days ago)
reply
6: Unfortunate...
I'm no MS basher, on the contrary, I'm a Windows user, but I'm afraid if MS lets too many of these things happen, businesses will find another OS. If there's anything I've learned so far, if it doesn't work reliably, businesses won't deal with it. Such a happening is a long way off, I believe, but if MS keeps allowing irresponsible things like this happen, then they will lose money.
I've always felt the Genuine Advantage is a ridiculous measure against piracy anyway. I'm in the US, and I doubt that more than 20% of computer users are pirates...seems like a big waste of money to me, when 80%+ of the market are legitimate users, if I'm correct in that assumption.
Reghart (23 days ago)
reply
7: Microsoft: the authentic smell of failure
The world is a funny place. Despite all these Microsoft muck-ups, come two years time Vista will be on literally every PC in the world. I really have to give it up to MS.
This stuff is funny, unless your machine is flagged is illegal, of which mine hasn't beeen flagged as yet..
Beanyama (23 days ago)
reply
8: While it is a fact that in 2
While it is a fact that in 2 years most pcs will have vista, it should be noted that in 2 years every effort for WGA will have been cracked and people will browse the web with their hacked vista with no problem
Kaiser (22 days ago)
reply
9: Haaa
I'm not surprized.
Windows is Windows, nothing is new under the moon.
Prefer Unix/Linux/Mac but where are all developers?
bertilP (20 days ago)
reply
10: I love the Windows Genuine
I love the Windows Genuine Advantage it truly is an Advntage
One just wonders why ms has not stopped the
circumventing of it's products long time ago !!
by gsaravin9
Your old PC needs to meet Dr Kevorkian
10th August 2007 Dan Warne Apple, Mac, PC Hardware, Windows
COMMENT | A friend recently asked me to set up her old PC so that another member of the family could use it. "Righto," I thought... "probably won't run Vista, but it'll surely run XP."
When I saw the box, I knew that I would have no such good fortune. It was a 1998-vintage box, sans USB ports, ethernet, WiFi or any of those sorts of conveniences we take for granted. In fact, the only semi-modern convenience it had was a CD-ROM drive.
I could have suggested that my friend simply put the box out to pasture and buy a cheap Dell, but the fact was, she only wanted to do the most basic of tasks on it -- word processing, email and web browsing. Why should that justify a $700 expenditure?
I dutifully set about reformatting and setting it up, installing the most recent versions of Windows and Office that would run acceptably on the very old hardware -- Windows 98 and Office 2000 -- and then discovered that it's nearly impossible to get free or cheap anti-virus software that runs on Windows 98 any more. I did track down one eventually, after an hour of Googling, however.
But then we bought an HP printer (the only one in Officeworks that still had a parallel port), and discovered that Windows 98 drivers were no longer available. Turns out that when Microsoft discontinues support for a version of Windows, so does everybody else.
I could see that this computer was going to come back and haunt me time and time again, and I was musing over this conundrum at lunch with my friend (and contributor to APCMag.com) Danny Gorog. When he's not writing for APC or the Herald Sun, Danny's main business is a chain of stores that sells stuff on eBay on anyone's behalf. He makes his money by taking a cut of the sale, so he's intimately familiar with the cost of different sorts of goods in online auctions. His suggested course of action? Check out the prices of iMacs on eBay.
iMac on eBay: runs the latest Mac OS X 10.4, costs peanuts
Lo and behold, I discovered you can buy one of the original "fruity flavoured" all-in-one iMacs for about $50-$100 on eBay. These models are not speed demons in today's terms, but they're perfectly capable of running the latest version of Mac OS X, Microsoft Office and Firefox if you add a bit of extra RAM.
I ended up getting a Bondi Blue iMac for my friend's family member -- 400MHz G3, 10GB hard drive, 128MB RAM and a CD-ROM. I had a spare 512MB PC133 RAM DIMM lying around from an old computer, so I slotted that in and installed OS X 10.3 on it (it runs a little quicker than Tiger, because it doesn't have the Spotlight disk indexing or Dashboard widgets).
It runs smoothly and at an acceptable clip (this family member is not going to be using it for much more than word processing, email, browsing the web and downloading small batches of digital camera pictures). It's interesting to note that this computer I bought on eBay is of a close vintage as the PC I was trying to resurrect -- the iMac was a year 2000 model, while the PC was a 1998 model. It's interesting that you can run the latest Mac OS on a seven year-old Mac, but it's fairly impossible to run anything other than Windows 98 on a 1998 vintage PC.
More importantly, though, I know I'm not going to have to do weekend and late night tech support for the rest of the natural life of the Windows PC.
The simple fact is I'm sick of doing friends' and family tech support for problems that are really Microsoft's fault, not mine. It's not that I begrudge helping people, it's that I begrudge the fact that I wouldn't need to be helping them with most of the problems if they had a Mac.
Spyware, viruses, irritating alerts advising you to clean up desktop icons, dogs with wagging tails -- they're problems that just don't exist on a Mac. They might one day, but for now, they're just not an issue Mac users have to deal with.
So from now on, when anyone asks me to help them resurrect an old piece of rubbish computer that's past its used by date, I'm just going to buy them an iMac on eBay. $50 out of my pocket won't cause a ripple in my finances, but it will save me hours of tech support time in the future.
John C. Dvorak, who has made a career out of writing opinion pieces that deliberately provoke the ire of the Mac userbase, has now reached the same conclusion.
"As someone who does recommend gear to people, I have to think to myself, "Should I recommend something that will come back to haunt me, or recommend a Mac with its higher price but lower hassle factor?" The answer is simple. I hate the idea of having to do customer service for people who cannot keep their systems clean, and that's most people.
"I hate to say it, but the PC community talks a big game when it comes to security and protection. The reality is that they'll never really get a handle on the problem as long as the PC is the never-ending target of hackers. I'm certain the Mac will eventually be targeted, but when? It doesn't seem like it will be anytime soon."
For the first time ever, I couldn't agree more with Dvorak.
Bookmark/Search this post with:
delicious | digg | reddit
The Invistagator | add new comment
1: lol.. quick question.. wat
lol.. quick question.. wat would it be like tryin to work on a three gig imovie on an old mac like that?
berrd (40 days ago)
reply
2: Pretty impossible :-> Like I
Pretty impossible :->
Like I said though, this was a replacement computer for a Windows 98 one, for someone who just wanted basic word processing, email, web browsing and photo storage. 10GB and a 400MHz processor is ample for that.
APC administrator (40 days ago)
reply
3: how could you possibly
how could you possibly critisize the ability of the old imac that still runs the near-latest OS for mac, and never crashes, as opposed to the pc which will probably be plagued with the blue screen of death for years to come. Whether it can run a 3 gig video file is of no consequence, because theres no chance you could do it on the PC even semi-successfully.
Trolls...
Blah (40 days ago)
reply
4: Not impossible at all
I edited my first feature film (90min shot in miniDV) on a this very same machine in late 2000 using iMovie 2 in OS9!
You would need an external firewire HD, as my final cut weights about 25GB, but it's quite possible.
JF Leduc (40 days ago)
reply
5: I am a BIG Mac fan, but you
I am a BIG Mac fan, but you could have also just installed the latest of any Linux distro on that hardware and saved them from buying ANY new hardware, and given them all the functionality they were asking for and more...
Eytan (40 days ago)
reply
6: Agreed, the original iMacs
Agreed, the original iMacs are great machines.
I've got a 350 MHz model, and it runs Tiger at a perfectly acceptable speed.
In fact, it's used for light Photoshop work. CS2 runs at a fine speed (unless you're doing any complex filters).
Anon (40 days ago)
reply
7: Video editing
Really, digital video editing on an iMac of that age isn't too bad if you:
1. Add more RAM -- the more the better
2. Get a bigger, faster hard drive
3. Get an iMac DV or later with Firewire ports (usually 500MHz+)
As long as you stick to the basics and use iMovie to edit your videos, it is actually quite usable.
Aaron (40 days ago)
reply
8: Can you resurrect an old PC for me
I would love you to resurrect an old PC of mine, i.e. buy me an old iMac
Richard Moore (40 days ago)
reply
9: LOL!!! Sorry, the offer is
LOL!!! Sorry, the offer is limited to close friends and family ;-)
Dan Warne (40 days ago)
reply
10: $500 Dells have a place
And there I was, Dan, thinking you'd whip together an old hack to convert one of us non believers.
As for recycling old clunkers, any thing pre P-III it's really not worth the bother, can be done but seriously not worth the hassle.
I'm a little over doing those favours that have the need to keep on giving.
Word of warning when doing these favours be they MAC or PC, the recipient must take them on the condition they do not come back, relatives no exception!!!
If I gave it to you as an old box 3 years ago why would I suddenly need it back now that your done with it. Same goes for old HP Deskjets, lasers that require a 2 person lift and that carton of zip disks.
raindog (39 days ago)
reply
11: Agreed.
Several of my friends who make their living supporting PCs have converted their homes, families and friends to the Mac just to avoid dealing with the support issues at home. Give them iLife and WoW and they're good to go.
AnonymousCoward-InSoCal (40 days ago)
reply
12: Nix OS would work
There are plenty of linux distros that would work just fine on an old PC.
debiant (40 days ago)
reply
13: Mmmm.. but do they come with
Mmmm.. but do they come with drivers for the latest HP Multifunction printers?
Dan Warne (40 days ago)
reply
14: Yes, they do
HP actually sponsors the creation of Linux drivers - see HP's statement.
You can see the list of supported and unsupported devices here. Basically, everything is supported except for some really old Deskjets and Laserjets.
Linux User (40 days ago)
reply
15: Most of the big desktop
Most of the big desktop distributions would, or would have drivers that are close enough.
It'd be pretty frustrating trying to run modern versions of OpenOffice or GNOME/KDE at a comfortable speed on a made-for-Win98 machine, though.
old_misery (40 days ago)
reply
16: Don't need bloated WMs
You could simply install any lightweight distro and use XFCE, or IceWM. IceWM can even have a Vista theme, very very nice.
A good distro for old PCs is Puppy Linux, which runs extremely well on old hardware.
Brendan (39 days ago)
reply
17: In addition to this, I have
In addition to this, I have found that HP have a lot more drivers available for Linux than they do for Vista.
I have a Networked MFC at home that I can only print on with Vista - yet I can scan over the network and print using Linux. Likewise, I cannot even install the KVM over IP software on Vista, yet I can under Linux - which makes me glad that I set up my work laptop to dual-boot, because I'd be screwed if I had to remotely support something using Vista.
Jarrod Spiga (38 days ago)
reply
18: I recently installed XP on a
I recently installed XP on a 500mhz k6-2 with 128 ram,12GB drive and 2mb pci video. As far as office type tasks are concerned it runs as smooth as silk. People who buy new computers solely for word processing are paying for performance they will never use.
Currie (40 days ago)
reply
19: As my business offer service
As my business offer service and tech support for all popular platforms, including Windows, Linux, Mac, I have to point out that you still haven't realised what an 8 year old Mac can accomplish compared to a PC of that age. It's like comparing a cripple to an Olympic athlete.
Heck, I even installed in 2006, the Mac OS X Panther (ie. Windows XP) on a 1996 Wallstreet notebook. I was amazed to discover that Panther was running perfectly fine, it was able to modestly run all modern applications and also to take advantage of all the visual effects the OS featured! (ex. Expose, transparencies, etc.) Beat that on the PCs!...
MacDaddy (40 days ago)
reply
20: Lets not confuse the hardware with the OS
Lets not confuse the hardware with the Operating system.
further it is still possible to set windows 98 up with free anti virus (avast home)ie6 etc with little problems.
I'm not saying that the i-Mac was not a good solution, just that with some knowledge there probably wasn't the perceived problem in the first place...
debiant (38 days ago)
reply
21: No HP driver available for
No HP driver available for the printer we bought, though.
APC administrator (38 days ago)
reply
22: thats it!
Thats the final nail in this coffin, sub 100 and able to run the latest operating system? say no more. Ebay here i come, its mac learning time!
suicidal_weasel (38 days ago)
reply
23: Sounds great, but how much
Sounds great, but how much does it cost to upgrade the OS to OS X 10.3 ?
Andy (38 days ago)
reply
24: I like your solution
While I might be most familiar with PCs, your solution is great for your family member.
I have a story similar to yours, except I went the whole way and did restore an old PC. I wanted to give my girlfriend a computer she could use to surf the net and do word processing on, so I got an old Gateway PC circa 1998 or 1999 with a PII in it, that I had gotten from a friend, thinking of making a firewall. I stuck 512MB of RAM in it, and an old 8 gig hard drive, and amazingly, I got it running XP SP2. It works fine, and now she has a wireless internet connection on one of those USB NICs. It's fast for the things she needs to do with it, like surf the web with firefox, and put songs on her MP3 player, so I guess old PCs aren't all counted out!
Thanks though, for sharing about those dirt cheap Macs, I might have to invest in one...
Reghart (37 days ago)
reply
25: mac help
my dad bought 2 imacs 2nd hand and tried to network them but the previos user had blocked networking and they are being used to much to compleatly reset
is there a way to unlock networking so they can share files or external hard drives
m (37 days ago)
reply
26: mac help
just got my trendy imac. Plugged my mp3 player in usb, power not supported?no!! locked up with my usb connected.
great little computer all in one.
but support in programs just isnt there like microsoft.
cost of os 10 more then cost of hardware!
back to microsoft win98se here i come. load dx9,in expolorer6 win media player all good.
mac another door stop now all pretty and colourful. :-))
takecover (35 days ago)
reply
27: What MP3 player was it? If
What MP3 player was it? If it supported USB mass storage mode it should have worked, but if it used a proprietary communication protocol then it wouldn't have worked.
by gsaravin9
Microsoft Extends XP Sales to June 2008
Thursday September 27, 7:06 pm ET
Microsoft Adds 5 Months to Windows XP's Shelf Life
REDMOND, Wash. (AP) -- Microsoft Corp. said it will keep selling its Windows XP operating system beyond January, in response to demand from customers.
The company decided to extend the deadline until the end of June to give customers -- particularly small businesses -- more time to switch to the new Windows Vista.
"Maybe we were a little ambitious to think that we would need to make Windows XP available for only a year after the release of Windows Vista," said Mike Nash, a corporate vice president for Windows product management at Microsoft.
While software retailers and major computer makers like Dell Inc. will stop offering XP next June, system builders, or smaller companies that make and sell PCs, will still sell the older operating system until the end of January 2009.
Nash said Microsoft's policy in the past has been to discontinue an old operating system four years after its launch. But because Vista reached consumers more than five years after XP, the company had to revise the rules.
"Making it available through June was a little bit better" for customers, Nash said.
In April, Dell, which had all but stopped selling XP to consumers, said it would bring back more XP machines after customers asked for it. At the time, Microsoft responded that only "a small minority of customers" were still interested in the old operating system.
Microsoft is also extending the availability of a version of XP aimed at customers in emerging markets, Windows XP Starter Edition, until June 30, 2010.
by gsaravin9
WITH TWO OVERLAPPING events, Microsoft admitted what we have been saying all along, Vista, aka Windows Me Two (Me II), is a joke that no one wants.
It did two unprecedented things this week that frankly stunned us.
Dell announced that it would be offering XP again on home PCs. The second that Vista came out, Microsoft makes it very hard for you to sell anything other than Me II. It can't do this on the business side because it would be laughed out the door, but for the walking sheep class, well, you take what you are shovelled.
This is classic abusive monopoly behaviour, Microsoft wrote the modern book on it. It pulled all the major OEMs in by twisting their arms with the usual methods, and they again all fell into line. Never before has anyone backpedalled on this, to do so would earn you the wrath of Microsoft.
But Dell just did. This means that Me II sales are at least as bad as we think, the software and driver situation is just as miserable, and Dell had no choice but to buck the trend. If anyone thinks this is an act of atonement for foisting such a steaming pile on us, think again, it doesn't care about the consumer.
What happened is, the OEMs revolted in the background and forced Microsoft's hand. This is a big neon sign above Me II saying 'FAILURE'. Blink blink blink. OK, Me II won't fail, Microsoft has OEMs whipped and threatened into a corner, it will sell, but you can almost hear the defectors marching toward Linux. This is a watershed.
The other equally monumental Me II failure? Gates in China launching a $3 version of bundled XP. Why is this not altruism? Well, it goes back to piracy and how it helped enforce the MS monopoly. If you can easily pirate Windows, Linux has no price advantage, they both cost zero.
With Me II, Microsoft made it very hard to pirate. It is do-able, you can use the BIOS hack and probably a host of others, but the point is, it raised the bar enough so lots of people have to buy it. Want to bet that in a country with $100 average monthly salary, people aren't going to shell out $299 for Me II Broken Edition?
What did MS do? It dropped the price about 100x or so. I can't say this is unprecedented, when it made Office 2003 hard to pirate it had to backpedal with the student edition for about $150. This time though, things are much more desperate.
If you fit Microsoft's somewhat convoluted definition of poor, it still wants to lock you in, you might get rich enough to afford the full-priced stuff someday. It is at a dangerous crossroads, if its software bumps up the price of a computer by 100 per cent, people might look to alternatives.
That means no Me II DRM infection lock in, no mass migration to the newer Office obfuscated and patented file formats, and worse yet, people might utter the W word. Yes, you guessed it, 'why'. People might ask why it is sticking with the MS lock in, and at that point, it is in deep trouble.
So, it did the unthinkable, and dropped the price. I won't bother to hunt down all the exec quotes saying how people can't afford clean water would be overjoyed to sell kidneys to upgrade to the new version of Office, but they are out there. This was a sacred cow, and it is now hamburger backed up against the wall.
These two actions by Microsoft are proof of what I suggested three years ago. Microsoft has lost its ability to twist arms, and now it is going to die. It can't compete on level ground, so is left with backpedalling and discounts of almost 100 times.
What we are seeing is an unprecedented shift of power. It is also an unprecedented admission of failure. And the funniest part about the moves made? They are the wrong things to do. Microsoft is in deep trouble. ?
by gsaravin9
Love It
You put it perfectly. I have had enough of MS running the show. I am a sheep, correction, a very angry sheep. I am utterly stunned by the arrogance and inability to understand what users want. Hey, Bill, I just want to get something done, fast and simple. I don't need or want all the options you are clobbering me with.
posted by : Eunice Moyer, 05 October 2007
by gsaravin9
Vista? Brand XP gets my vote
Daughter got Vista upgrade on her new XP desktop last year. [Dell]. One or two nice items, but very slow and difficult. Has now reverted to XP. I used it once to transfer material from one USB attachment to another. Total confusion, very slow. Went back to nice, clear XP. I have always upgraded Windows, from early days. But not this time. Love XP. Hate Vista.
posted by : Barbara Prowse, 07 October 2007 TechFinder
Search for Software, Hardware & Services
Top INQ Stories
Windows XP SP3 goes Vista-ish
Dear Microsoft, Vista doesn't work properly
Microsoft screws up legit Vista users
Google reads your email, shocker
Hellgate DX10 comparison shows smoke and mirrors
by gsaravin9
Hands off Microsoft's reference source code
Microsoft is offering developers a view into its source code, but it doesn't want anyone touching it. According to Scott Guthrie, general manager of the Microsoft .NET Framework in Microsoft's Developer Division, Microsoft will be releasing the reference source code for the .NET Framework under the made-in-Redmond Microsoft Reference License. What is your opinion of the Microsoft Reference License?
by gsaravin9
dell says they've got incredible deals but it's to do with xp & not much with vista.
Proof that vista is allready been ditched by the business communuty is that dell prefers to offer xp with their deals.
by gsaravin9
by ang2006
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
Has not made any progress like the orher
released oses.Proof galore that its crap.
Ms does'nt even recommend it anymore.Xp is still the way to go!!
by gsaravin9
by gsaravin9
Hi,
I recently installed the newest drivers with Alchemy for my Audigy 2, following all the instructions on this forum.
After that I tested the speakers and it seems that when I use the Creative speaker settings to test my speakers front/rear right and front/rear left are both output on the front speakers now. If I test my speakers in the Vista control panel everything seems to work fine.
In the Creative speaker settings I've unchecked the sync with control panel.
Does that mean my speakers work for now or are they completely screwed up?
I'm using the Inspire 6700 speakers from Creative which are actually 6.1 speakers, but 6.1 obviously doesn't work anymore in Vista. Might this be the reason for my speakers acting weird?
10-02-2007 02:35 AM
Add This Message to My Bookmarks
Add This Message to My Subscriptions
Subscribe to this message's RSS Feed
Highlight This Message
Print This Message
Print to End (Max 50)
E-Mail this Message to a Friend
Jump to Page: 1
by gsaravin9
Unable to open saved project in Movie Maker, HELP!!
I recently (last month) bought a new HP Pavalion a1730n with Windows Vista
Home Premium. I have been using Movie Maker and DVD Maker wihtout any
problems until today. Suddenly I am not able to open a previously saved
project file in movie maker! Here's what happens....I open Movie Maker, click
on File, Open, and double click the file. It begins to load the pictures that
are in the file (they show up in the storyboard), and then apparently just
stops. The mouse spins in its little circle, and the only way to close movie
maker is through task manager, end task. I've even waited up to an hour to
see if maybe it was just taking a super long time to open my project. It is
not a large file - only 100 photos which total about 8 min long. I have also
tried opening other projects that I had previously saved. It will not open
those either.
I called HP tech support and they can't help. They wanted to transfer me to
someplace where they'd charge me for it! Microsoft is closed until Monday. I
need to get working on this project now! And instead of spending the last two
hours working on the project, I've been searching the internet trying to find
a way to open my project!! If you have any suggestions, I would really
appreciate it.
Maybe Microsoft recently updated something in vista that screwed it up? Is
anyone else having this problem?
by gsaravin9
Posted by typemismatch // Fri, Nov 9, 2007 3:10 PM
So we all know that networking in Vista is screwed up and I am amazed that 1 year after release it still doesn't work. What happens to me? well after about 8 hours of use most applications loose their internet connection (wireless and lan) - Most? you ask ... yes - things like outlook still get/send mail, IE/FF stop working, chat stops etc. maybe office just "wishes" the data over the air
So I need to reboot to get back my connection - great, here is the problem. After getting the "logging off" and then "shutting down" for an un-determined amount of time my machine just blue screens ... awesome.
That means for one I can never "shutdown" as the blue screen causes a restart. Now lets compound this - if I resume from Sleep or Hibernate I get an ACS (acs.exe??) crash and guess what - no internet. So I need to do the above BSOD sequence - (left eye twitching).
This is Vista certified hardware from Lenovo - "certified" I guess means Vista will run ... what it does while running isn't "certified" but at least I know my drivers are pretty good.
So once or twice a day I must force a BSOD to keep surfing, I can't resume,sleep,shutdown or restart with a BSOD so installing updates is fun.
Sort by Trending