Discussion Locked

Well, it seems that GWB has been spying on DOMESTIC calls as well!

0 helpful
207 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Now, why am I not surprised?

----------------------------------------------------
http://images.military.com/pics/mlpfv.jpg

Subscribe to free Military Insider Newsletter
Military.com

Firestorm Over NSA Surveillance

Associated Press | May 11, 2006

WASHINGTON - Congressional Republicans and Democrats demanded answers from the Bush administration Thursday about a government spy agency secretly collecting records of ordinary Americans' phone calls to build a database of every call made within the country.

Facing intense criticism from Congress, President George W. Bush did not confirm the work of the National Security Agency but sought to assure Americans that their privacy is being "fiercely protected."

"We're not mining or trolling through the personal lives of millions of innocent Americans," Bush said before leaving for a commencement address at Mississippi Gulf Coast Community College in Biloxi.

The disclosure, first reported in USA Today, could complicate Bush's bid to win confirmation of former National Security Agency director Gen. Michael Hayden as CIA director. It also reignited concerns about civil liberties and touched off questions about the legal underpinnings for the government's actions and the diligence of the Republican-controlled Congress oversight of a Republican administration.

The top-ranking Democrat on the Senate Judiciary Committee said he was shocked by the revelation about the NSA.

"It is our government, it's not one party's government. It's America's government. Those entrusted with great power have a duty to answer to Americans what they are doing," said Sen. Patrick Leahy of Vermont.

AT&T Corp., Verizon Communications Inc., and BellSouth Corp. telephone companies began turning over records of tens of millions of their customers' phone calls to the NSA program shortly after the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks, said USA Today, citing anonymous sources it said had direct knowledge of the arrangement.

The Republican chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee, Sen. Arlen Specter, said he would call the phone companies to appear before the panel in pursuit of what had transpired.

"We're really flying blind on the subject and that's not a good way to approach the Fourth Amendment and the constitutional issues involving privacy," Specter said of domestic surveillance in general.

The companies said Thursday that they are protecting customers' privacy but have an obligation to assist law enforcement and government agencies in ensuring the nation's security. "We prize the trust our customers place in us. If and when AT&T is asked to help, we do so strictly within the law and under the most stringent conditions," the company said in a statement, echoed by the others.

Bush did not confirm or deny the USA Today report. But he did say that U.S. intelligence targets terrorists and that the government does not listen to domestic telephone calls without court approval and that Congress has been briefed on intelligence programs.

He vowed to do everything in his power to fight terror and "we will do so within the laws of our country."

On Capitol Hill, several lawmakers expressed incredulity about the program, with some Republicans questioning the rationale and several Democrats railing about the lack of congressional oversight.

"I don't know enough about the details except that I am willing to find out because I'm not sure why it would be necessary to keep and have that kind of information," said House Majority Leader John Boehner, a Republican.

Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham told Fox News Channel: "The idea of collecting millions or thousands of phone numbers, how does that fit into following the enemy?"

Democratic Sen. Dick Durbin said bringing the telephone companies before the Judiciary Committee is an important step.

"We need more. We need to take this seriously, more seriously than some other matters that might come before the committee because our privacy as American citizens is at stake," Durbin said.

Republican Sen. Jeff Sessions argued that the program "is not a warrantless wiretapping of the American people. I don't think this action is nearly as troublesome as being made out here, because they are not tapping our phones."

The program does not involve listening to or taping the calls. Instead it documents who talks to whom in personal and business calls, whether local or long distance, by tracking which numbers are called, the newspaper said.

NSA spokesman Don Weber said in an e-mailed statement that given the nature of the agency's work, it would be "irresponsible to comment on actual or alleged operations issues." He added, "the NSA takes its legal responsibilities seriously and operates within the law."

NSA is the same spy agency that conducts the controversial domestic eavesdropping program that had been acknowledged earlier by Bush. The president said last year that he authorized the NSA to listen, without warrants, to international phone calls involving Americans suspected of terrorist links.

The report came as Hayden - Bush's choice to take over leadership of the CIA - postponed some visits to lawmakers on Capitol Hill. Meetings with Republican Sens. Rick Santorum and Lisa Murkowski were delayed at the request of the White House, said congressional aides in the two Senate offices.

The White House offered no reason for the postponement to the lawmakers. Other meetings with lawmakers were still planned.

Hayden already faced criticism because of the NSA's secret domestic eavesdropping program. As head of the NSA from March 1999 to April 2005, Hayden also would have overseen the call-tracking program.

Democratic Sen. Dianne Feinstein, who has spoken favorably of the nomination, said the latest revelation "is also going to present a growing impediment to the confirmation of Gen. Hayden."

The NSA wants the database of domestic call records to look for any patterns that might suggest terrorist activity, USA Today said.

Don Weber, a senior spokesman for the NSA, told the paper that the agency operates within the law, but would not comment further on its operations.

One big telecommunications company, Qwest Communications International Inc., has refused to turn over records to the program, the newspaper said, because of privacy and legal concerns.

207 replies

by bfilmfan

Based on this information and their failure to protect the borders of the United States of America, it is time to call for the impeachment of George Bush and Dick Cheney.

I am wondering at what point the American people are going to realize the serious issues facing this nation?

by jardinier

It equals temporary embarrassment and shame, after which the "disgraced" former president can become a zillionaire on the lecture circuit.

by jardinier

When Cheney's puppet, Bush, invaded Iraq three years ago, all the world except for about 150 million Americans realised that he was running his own agenda which was NOT necessarily in the best interests of either America or the world.

And yet there were enough ignorant, besotted Americans to re-elect him in 2004.

He has already destroyed whatever goodwill the once great nation of America had in the eyes of the world.

With almost three years still to run in office, he may succeed in sending America bankrupt.

With the steadily declining quality of presidents over the last few decades, America has really hit rock bottom with this guy, so there is nowhere to go but up.

America needs a wake-up call to remind the people of what the country used to be.

For the sake of America, and the sake of the world, I hope the good people of America make a better choice at the 2008 election.

by ontheropes

and Amen.

The economy in my local immediate area is in deep trouble mostly due to long-standing economic policies put in place by our elected officials. There are some job openings for unskilled workers but they're at subsistence level wages.

One of the companies I was contracted to has just sold. The new owners came in, fired all 73 employees, and is keeping them on as temp's until they fill out a new application for employment and pass a urine and hair drug screen by this afternoon at 2:00.
Twelve people have not filled out apps. so if they're let go they can get unemployment. The new owners expect to lose over half of the people. The one's they're going to keep, even if they have 20 years in, will be offered their same old jobs for less money and reduced benefits. There's not many places they can go if they choose to keep their jobs.

There are four other large plants that easily come to mind within a 20 mile radius that have announced closings or major staff reductions, mostly due to products made in China.

Consumer debt has reached record levels here. Somebody has to pay that back. Without jobs...

I just keep saying, it's going to get to be a lot worse before it get's better.

by deepsand

It is possible that such would result in irrepairable harm to both the US and the world.

By the time we hit rock bottom we may be unable to go up; or, there may be no up to go to.

by x-marcap

Much of the world's problem is that we have toppled what was supposed to be the 4th most powerful army in less than a week. We routed out a dictator. What can stop the US from doing what it desires?

Only the US itself can reign in the US.

Sandy, I think you are all wet on this, still.

Once it is understood that Congress (as usual) was stupid in it's knee jerk reaction to 911, and the the resolution in which Bush was given direction to prosecute the apprehension and suppression of terrorists was too broad and gave him too much lattitude, and people place the blame where it belongs, (on Congress) the US can make progress.

Congress was stupid as any committee is. A committee is many bodies and only one brain. At the time that brain was Angrey and wounded. We may start to get some cleared thoughts, but not until we get a strong and successful third political party. A party for the moderates, not either side's extremists.

by bfilmfan

Villany has a character. Without a strong villan, Disney stories would never have their power.

I am recalling the quotation on the small-mindness of evil that we see so much of in the world.

by x-marcap

I am sure that you revere Clinton.He is a probable rapist, who was a perjuring, womanizing, coward who was a draft dodger. Is this the hero for a clown like you?

You claim that a guy who attends church, tries to do what is right, and is trying to protect the country is evil.

Get a grip. Gore lost... Gore lost....

by deepsand

Sure beats the heck out of a veto; there's no provision in the Constitution for over-riding said statements!

So, it's basically a game of catch-me-if-you-can; and, if caught, bust me if you dare.

Of course, is'nt this precisely what we need in any good Commander-in-Cheif?

by mr stumper

If some of his "Bushisms" are more of freudian slips than simple slips of the tongue.

"If this were a dictatorship, it'd be a heck of a lot easier, just so long as I'm the dictator." ?Washington, D.C., Dec. 19, 2000

"See, in my line of work you got to keep repeating things over and over and over again for the truth to sink in, to kind of catapult the propaganda." ?George W. Bush, Greece, N.Y., May 24, 2005

"Our enemies are innovative and resourceful, and so are we. They never stop thinking about new ways to harm our country and our people, and neither do we." ?George W. Bush, Washington, D.C., Aug. 5, 2004

"Let me put it to you bluntly. In a changing world, we want more people to have control over your own life." ?George W. Bush, Annandale, Va, Aug. 9, 2004

"Security is the essential roadblock to achieving the road map to peace." ?George W. Bush, Washington, D.C., July 25, 2003

"So I don't know where he is. You know, I just don't spend that much time on him, Kelly, to be honest with you." -George W. Bush, Washington, D.C., March 13, 2002. Regarding why Osama Bin Laden has not been captured.

by x-marcap

Clinton put US parks into the perview of the UN. That is MY country he is letting Ahmed, or Jose, or Francois have control over.

The executive order is overused. Clinton tried to make the Presidency immune from special prosecutorial investigation. He was advised that that act alone would be grounds for impeechment...

Clinton did similar things with funding. As did Carter. I don't know about Reagan and Bush because I was in an apolitical mood and not paying attention...

What is new is that Bush states what he will do and does it. Rather than hide it, he admits what he is doing. He at least is honest about it.

Rather than hide the truth, Bush reveals it, and even I get completely pissed about it...

by deepsand

Pennsylvania recently adopted the "2003 International Property Maintenance Code," (Google it and get ready to gag) and required that all municipalities implement and enforce it.

It does little, if anything, with regards to improving public safety, over and above the pre-existing local codes, but does add a lot of requirements that go toward appearances.

The local Code Enforcement Officer got on my case re. the vegetation, various wild flowers and elderberrys, under my White Pine tree, insisting that it was "weeds" and must be removed. It was obvious that, not only was he clueless as to what will and will not grow under such trees, but he did'nt care either. I demanded that he provide me with a copy of the new code, which he did. After reading it, I informed him that, per said code, I was designating the area under and around my pine to be a wild flower garden, and claiming it to be exempt from the general rule re. "weeds."

As I had him dead to rights, and he knew it, he backed down on that issue. Of course, I'm now constantly in his sights.

So, now we've a bunch of foreigners telling us what our properties must and may not look like, all with the co-operation of the Commonwealth.

by the admiral

Please - If that was the case then everyone all the way down to John F Kennedy should have been impeached.

You have to look at it as a whole and not as a nit picky person who does crap based on how they feel and how the intelligence is.

Terrorist A calls from an AT&T line based in South Dakota to Terrorist B in New York (DOMESTIC CALL) who then calls Terrorist C in North Carolina (DOMESTIC CALL) who then calls Terrorist D in Florida (DOMESTIC CALL) who then calls head Terrorist E in Saudi Arabia (INTERNATIONAL CALL) who then relays a message to Terrorist F in California (INTERNATIONAL CALL) who relays a message to Terrorist A in South Dakota (DOMESTIC CALL)...

You see how this works? I think that you folks who are having a cardiac about it are putting too much feeling into it without doing much logical thinking...

by jamesrl

Unless I misunderstand, this isn't wiretapping, where the agency gets permission to collect the data based on some evidence of possible wrong doing.

This is a massive collection of data from millions of people, in a fishing expedition. How far do you extend it. Do you abridge the privacy rights of a million people to find a dozen terrorists? How about 10 million? How about 100 million? Do you not feel like you are staninding with wet feet at the top of a slippery slope?

James

by deepsand

Were he to employ it universally, he would not have been able to suggest impeachment for JFK.

Therefore, he's signaled his bias.

The result is that he believes that the [b]his[/b] desired ends justify [b]his[/b] chosen means.

As such, he's not concerned with collateral damage to those who do not agree with him. Nor does he consider [b]all[/b] of the possible future consequences.

He may one day find out that the Law of Unintended Consequences has snuck up on him from behind and bit his ass!

by ontheropes

Let's spend Billions to surveille everything everyone does, all of the time in the hopes of catching a few crooks. After all we're living in terror.

by bfilmfan

This isn't about targeting known or even suspected terrorists. This is asking for the phone records for everyone. This is a clear case of the government further sliding down the slope of feeling they are not answerable to the people.

I will point out what Thomas Jefferson had to say on the subject:

Does the government fear us? Or do we fear the government? When the people fear the government, tyranny has found victory. The federal government is our servant, not our master!

by maxwell edison

In this case, a record of phone calls (numbers only) is being kept in a database which is then compared to known phone numbers of terrorist suspects. If a match is made, the phone calls are tagged. If no match is made, no further action is taken. I think that about sums it up. I can certainly understand why people would not like it, at least on the surface, but it seems to me people are being selective in their outrage. What other personal records and/or information is being gathered in government databases? And consider that some of the records are MORE intrusive than this silly phone call flap.

1. Income records are the first to stand out. You can't earn a friggin' penny without the government knowing about it.

2. Bank records of all deposits and withdraws.

3. Credit card purchases. If you buy a slurpie at 7-11 with a credit card, some federal agency can find out about it.

4. Cameras on the roads that could be (and are) an eye in the sky to follow you around.

5. The census records. I left my race blank (intentionally) on the last census form (2000, before Bush), and a census guy "coincidentally" knocked on my door to "verify" some things.

6. Voting records.

7. Driving records.

8. Birth records.

9. Death records.

10. Marriage records

11. Public library records.

12. Employment records.

13. Any lawsuit or court records.

14. Your physical description, and in some cases, facial recognition systems.

15. Satellites in the sky could take a picture of you tanning your fat ass in your own backyard.

16. Business records: You can't legally open a stupid lemonade stand without filing the proper papers.

17. Postal address information: Why do you think it's been illegal for private, house-to-house mail delivery companies to compete with the government's Postal Service?

18. School records: You can't take a class at a public school or state university without it being recorded in a government database.

19. I have to empty my pockets and take my shoes off at an airport. I'd much prefer racial profiling.

20. Personal property records. I can't buy real estate, a car, a boat, a gun, fertilizer (thank you Timothy McVeigh), spray paint, or many other items without it being approved and/or recorded in a government database.

21. I can't go to Las Vegas and gamble (since I often win!) without it being reported to the feds.

22. I can't go to a football game without being frisked.

23. There's a GPS transmitter in my cell phone.

I could go on and on. I'll bet my list could reach 100 or more!

All of these things -- AND MORE -- are ALL before Bush. They ALL transcend any one president, any one party, and any one congress or administration. And these things have been going on and building for decades.

Point being, there are FAR MORE intrusive government "spying" programs and tactics that actually affect me and my life than this, which doesn't affect me in the least. Moreover, whoever's making a big to-do about this is not doing it for "privacy" reasons, but rather political reasons. If "privacy" was really the issue, where is the outrage concerning the REAL privacy invasion issues?

Personally, I don't care if the phone call I place to my mother gets put into a data base. Hell, I don't even care if they listen (which they're not). It's put into the phone company database, anyway; and the government's ALWAYS had access to those phone company databases; and they've had access well before GWB took office. But I'm damn glad that if my neighbor make a call to Osama bin Laden, that a red flag will automatically pop up someplace.

ALL OF YOU PEOPLE ARE HYPOCRITES unless you show equal outrage to ALL of it.

Be outraged at all of it, or be outraged at none of it.

And if you're not outraged at all of it, shut up about the most insignificant part of it.

by deepsand

If you did, you would not have made such a specious argument.

"He who would give up a small essential freedom for a little temporary security is a scoundrel, and deserves neither freedom nor security." - Ben Franklin.

by x-marcap

He wants to have it applied the way he wants it applied. He is three steps left of center and wobbling to the left.

I think the real issue is this. Do idiotic people understand that the terrorists want to kill us?

by deepsand

GWB too seems to believe that, as Commander-in-Chief, he is both more knowledgable about war than is the military and destined to succeed.

Let's not forget that Bush believes that he is but God's servant in these matters.

I can hardy wait for the stadium rallies!

by x-marcap

You can't claim Bush is a great Orator like Hitler. There is no factual basis to that claim...

Back up from the abysss.

by x-marcap

Let's realize that socialism and totalitarianism were the NAZI goals.

Hitler was a dictator.

If we want to be wise and break the cycle, keep the Princeton Skull & Bones guys out of any office, or advisory role in the government. It would have been much the same with Kerry another Skull & Bones guy...

I suspect that socialist dictatorship isn't one of GWBs goals.

by dawgit

Princeton and bones and a VietNam Vet named John Kerry, do NOT go together.!. And the Nazis (as National Socialist Party) were any thing but.... It was 'Nationalism' at it's very worst. (Hitler himself despised Solalists and Comunists as well, He thought them all as 'Jewish', as most German Jewish people who were political at the time were.) You know nothing of then or the VietNam error either.

by deepsand

I am not being sarcastic when I say that, I'm not certain that he has any long term goals. He seems to be more a person who just wants to be in charge.

Recall that it was his brother, Jeb, not he, who was being groomed by his father for the national stage.

by mickster269

Traditionally, the Republican Party has held the belief that less governement = better government. They've always been the Party that wants less government restrictions on Business, less government intrusions on Individuals, and have been the Party of "Traditional Values".

I'm not sure if this current Administration is following the Party line - collecting information on private citizens, secret courts , holding prisoners for years without charging them of crimes, Search and Seziure without warrents, etc. It seems as if this current Administration wants unfettered government involvement in every aspect of it's citizen's lives.

Just my $ .03 worth (adjusted for inflation).

by deepsand

This is why some of the older pols, such as Sen. Spector, are taking public issue with Bush's policies.

Concurrent with this is the problems that have arisen out of Bush's continued defiance of Congress, as witnessed by the voluminous number of Presidental "Signing Statements," over 750, issued by GWB.

The Republicans are caught in a trap of their own making.

On the one hand, they stand for smaller, less intrusive government. But, they also stand for big military and law enforcement, which entails a good deal of governmental control, not to mention considerable costs.

In times of peace and prosperity, there is less call for the latter of the aforesaid, so that the former can more easily be championed. But, in the absence of either peace or prosperity, they are faced with a dilemma.

by maxwell edison

.
In this case, a record of phone calls (numbers only) is being kept in a database which is then compared to known phone numbers of terrorist suspects. If a match is made, the phone calls are tagged. If no match is made, no further action is taken. I think that about sums it up. I can certainly understand why people would not like it, at least on the surface, but it seems to me people are being selective in their outrage. What other personal records and/or information is being gathered in government databases? And consider that some of the records are MORE intrusive than this silly phone call flap.

1. Income records are the first to stand out. You can't earn a friggin' penny without the government knowing about it.

2. Bank records of all deposits and withdraws.

3. Credit card purchases. If you buy a slurpie at 7-11 with a credit card, some federal agency can find out about it.

4. Cameras on the roads that could be (and are) an eye in the sky to follow you around.

5. The census records. I left my race blank (intentionally) on the last census form (2000, before Bush), and a census guy "coincidentally" knocked on my door to "verify" some things.

6. Voting records.

7. Driving records.

8. Birth records.

9. Death records.

10. Marriage records

11. Public library records.

12. Employment records.

13. Any lawsuit or court records.

14. Your physical description, and in some cases, facial recognition systems.

15. Satellites in the sky could take a picture of you tanning your fat ass in your own backyard.

16. Business records: You can't legally open a stupid lemonade stand without filing the proper papers.

17. Postal address information: Why do you think it's been illegal for private, house-to-house mail delivery companies to compete with the government's Postal Service?

18. School records: You can't take a class at a public school or state university without it being recorded in a government database.

19. I have to empty my pockets and take my shoes off at an airport. I'd much prefer racial profiling.

20. Personal property records. I can't buy real estate, a car, a boat, a gun, fertilizer (thank you Timothy McVeigh), spray paint, or many other items without it being approved and/or recorded in a government database.

21. I can't go to Las Vegas and gamble (since I often win!) without it being reported to the feds.

22. I can't go to a football game without being frisked.

23. There's a GPS transmitter in my cell phone.

I could go on and on. I'll bet my list could reach 100 or more!

All of these things -- AND MORE -- are ALL before Bush. They ALL transcend any one president, any one party, and any one congress or administration. And these things have been going on and building for decades.

Point being, there are FAR MORE intrusive government "spying" programs and tactics that actually affect me and my life than this, which doesn't affect me in the least. Moreover, whoever's making a big to-do about this is not doing it for "privacy" reasons, but rather political reasons. If "privacy" was really the issue, where is the outrage concerning the REAL privacy invasion issues?

Personally, I don't care if the phone call I place to my mother gets put into a data base. Hell, I don't even care if they listen (which they're not). It's put into the phone company database, anyway; and the government's ALWAYS had access to those phone company databases; and they've had access well before GWB took office. But I'm damn glad that if my neighbor make a call to Osama bin Laden, that a red flag will automatically pop up someplace.

ALL OF YOU PEOPLE ARE HYPOCRITES unless you show equal outrage to ALL of it.

Be outraged at all of it, or be outraged at none of it.

And if you're not outraged at all of it, shut up about the most insignificant part of it.

by ontheropes

Young people even have a hard time getting a job at the fast-food restaurants because management seems prone to choose from the large pool of senior applicants trying to support their retirement or Social Security.

by bfilmfan

Stating an opinion that you believe the government is wrong in a decision does not make him or anyone else a traitor.

It's truly a shame that we can no longer have a discourse on any issue in this country without resorting to name calling.

I truly do expect more than this from one of my literate and insightful friends.

by maxwell edison

I do go over-board on the "name-calling". And it's probably happening with more frequency lately, as it's something I never did (well, not too much) in the past. It's probably the frustration coming out. Ever since 2000, President Bush has been literally under attack by his political enemies, both in government and politics, and in the press. (If you think he doesn't have "political enemies" in the press, let me just say the names Helen Thomas, Molly Ivans, Dan Rather, et al, as only a few examples.) Say what you will about the guy, but it's one thing after another after another, and almost all of them are mischaracterization at best, or blatant lies at worst. This is just another one of the mischaracterizations or lies.

No, I don't think he's doing everything right. But he's not doing everything wrong either. When everything -- ABSOLUTELY EVERYTHING -- he does gets torn apart, attacked, and mischaracterized in the press, it's obvious what's going on. Only the most ignorant among us can't (or won't) see it.

In this case, see my "for the record" message below.

And an added addition to that "for the record" message. If people are indeed trying to bring down the President of the United States, for reasons that are purely political, and they undermine his efforts in waging a war with an extremely dangerous and elusive enemy, then yes, I do indeed believe they are traitors.

Is deepsand a "traitor"? Hell, I don't know. But if he's not, then he's extremely ignorant and stupid. (Not "name-calling", per se, but rather only to show my perceived alternative.)

Well, okay. Maybe there is an alternative to being either a traitor or a person who's extremely ignorant and stupid.

People are like cattle. Have you ever seen how one or two cowboys can take hundreds of cattle down a path? They just round up a few, get them going, and the rest all follow.

Okay, deepsand's a cow.

by maxwell edison

Just because some terrorist-loving blow-hards SAY it's illegal, it doesn't make it illegal.

How many times have these SAME blow-hards claimed that President Bush was acting illegally, but for some strange reason, they NEVER bring the activity in question before a court to decide its legality? They don't ever bring the issue before a court because they are only spewing political rhetoric, not truth, and they know it.

The practice described in this discussion IS legal, and the government has been doing it for quite some time.

And in this case, they won't challenge it in court, because they would be laughed out of court, because it IS legal, because of, in part, the Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act (CALEA), which was passed by Congress and signed by the President (President Clinton, that is), in 1994.

http://www.usdoj.gov/criminal/cybercrime/usamay2001_4.htm

You're violating the oath you "claim" you took, deepsand. You're a disgrace.

by mr stumper

Specializing in constitutional law? If not, then your assertation that ?This IS legal? makes about as much sense as me diagnosing the insulation problems on the external tanks of the space shuttle by reading the New York Times. If it were so clear cut, we (the nation, the politicians, the pundits) would not be having such a debate. Politicians are not that stupid as to purposefully put their foot in their mouths.

Your quote??How many times have these SAME blow-hards claimed that President Bush was acting illegally, but for some strange reason, they NEVER bring the activity in question before a court to decide its legality?? Umm?yeah?in case you were unaware, the republicans control all three branches of government. The Dems in congress HAVE brought activity to question, but continually get shot down by the majority?which is?wait for it?the REPUBLICANS.

BTW, dispense with the ?But?Clinton did it!? attitude that has turned into such a defense of the right-wing. Two wrongs do not make a right. Our nation and our constitution are far more important than bi-partisanship.

I am not a lawyer, so I cannot definitively say that this is legal or not. However, the link to the DoJ that you posted says that?

?Section 105 of CALEA seeks to ensure systems security and integrity by requiring that a ?telecommunications carrier ensure any interceptions of communications or access to call-identifying information . . . can be activated only in accordance with a court order or other lawful authorization and . . . in accordance with the regulations prescribed by the Commission.??

That is ?with a court order or other lawful authorization?, which implies a search warrant. It is my guess that the ??or other lawful authorization? will become the point of debate. Can the Prez give authorization? It?s gonna become another ?It depends on what the definition of ?is? is? situation.

One thing that should be kept in mind is that Bush?s current campaign for more Presidential power will have long lasting effects. Guess what?if Bush can do these things?so can Hilary (god forbid) if she is ever elected President. I, personally, am NOT comfortable with ANY President having powers that go unchecked (let alone a candidate to head the CIA who cannot even quote the 4th amendment?but that?s another story).

One more thing regarding your ?terrorist-loving blow-hards?, ?deepsand is a traitor? comment as well as similar comments you have made in the past. By doing this you are using a tactic that was outlined by Herman Goering who said that?

?The people can always be brought to the bidding of the leaders...tell them they are being attacked, and denounce the peacemakers for lack of patriotism and exposing the country to danger.?

Do you realize that you are using the tactic of a key member of the Nazi regime? Good job, Max! (actually, I?m sure you are just reciting from right-wing pundits such as Savage, Colter, Hannity, Limbaugh and O?Reilly who just LOVE to spout the same rhetoric).

Max, I do not doubt your patriotism, but I?m afraid it has been tainted by the pundits I listed above. I?m sure that your true colors are ?red, white and blue?, but by spewing such filth it makes you look like your true colors are ?red, white and black?.

by maxwell edison

....because nobody has successfully challenged it to determine that it's illegal. And believe me, if it was illegal, the Bush enemies would have had it in court already. You know it, and I know it.

Spare me the Hitler crap, please.

by x-marcap

Any accusation of a capital crime should be reserved for actions such as material help such as the direction of launch systems to the Red Chinese. We should be going after The person who signed the executive order sending Loral missile launch systems to China.

Max, I believe the term is sedition, not treason...

by maxwell edison

And I'm sure that all those fine Americans, many of them service men and women, the one's that are indirectly being falsely accused of "spying" on American citizens, who are serving in a capacity to defend the United States, might make the same accusation. He's actually helping the enemy by spreading false propaganda and by aiding in exposing one of our defensive measures.

by deepsand

And to think that I understood that it was the Law which defined such.

Thanks for setting me straight.

This is going to come in real handy if I ever get busted.

by maxwell edison

You have to have a court challenge before you start talking about conviction or acquittal. The political demagogues who are making such a charge are PROVEN to be shallow and dishonest by merely observing that they are presenting no such court challenge.

You're an idiot -- and wrong

by deepsand

The important distinction here is the charges against Nixon were ones of a grave and substantive nature, for which he quite likely would have been convicted had he not resigned.

Clinton, on the other hand, was acquitted of his impeachment charges.

Clinton - winner; Nixon - loser.

by x-marcap

Only one Senator even bothered to look at the evidence. That man was Joe Lieberman. That is why he was calling for Clinton's removal.

The problem was that 42 democratic Senators had stated Clinton wouldn't be removed regardless. With the situation that Al Gore was in with the Bhuddist temple fund raising scandal, we could have had Gingrich go from speaker to President in months. No Dem would allow that.

Since there was only one Dem who looked at the evidence, and not 59 others who would look at evidence. It was a sham...

That is the current problem with our system. With three parties at 40% 35% 25% there is a possiblility of impeachment. If there was an impeachment, I'd first go after Supreme Court justices for allowing McCain - Feingold. or the New London, CT cases... Suter first, Ruth Bader Ginsberg next. Like that'll ever happen...

by bfilmfan

I know this was written to illustrate amount of snooping that is done into our lives.

And you well know that I am an advocate of individual freedoms, which cannot be exercised with the amount of snooping that is being done by both the government and private citizens.

For the record (in addition to being able to recall the written message when it is asked in the future), the best government is a small federal government and enpowered state and local governments.

And there is far too much federal government in our lives...

And yes, I am damned well outraged at the snooping into our private lives.

by maxwell edison

...
You said, "For the record (in addition to being able to recall the written message when it is asked in the future), the best government is a small federal government and empowered state and local governments. And there is far too much federal government in our lives."

I'll buy the beer for that sentiment!

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=194614&messageID=2010219

And an obvious question. How do you think we can get back to having a small federal government and empowered state and local governments? And do you think we'll ever see it?

by bfilmfan

I think Thomas Jefferson was correct that there needs to be a revolution every 20 years and the people need to take control of their lives and their government.

Do I think it will happen? Not without a great deal of bloodshed. It took an armed rebellion to start our path to freedom when our nation was born. I am afraid that is exactly what it will take in the future to re-establish it.

by deepsand

Recent polls show that, while only one-half of Americans trust Bush re. privacy, nearly two-thirds have no problem with giving their phone records to the government.

Assuming that the samples in these 2 surveys are statistically equivalent, how to explain this apparent contradiction?

Is it that they believe that Congress and the Courts will serve to check abuse by the Executive branch? Or, that phone records provide no opportunity for abuse? Do they cling to the notion that only the "guilty" need fear?

Or, is it that they fail to follow their beliefs to their logical consequences, thereby failing to see the inate contradictions between their professed beliefs?

My bet is on the latter.

by dawgit

Is: Do they have any 'mind' at all? I can't even believe that Americans can really think for them-selves any more. Out side of the few I've met here at the Tech-Rep. It's almost impossible to sit down and have 'intelegent' conversion with the 'average', 'normal' American. They're clueless as to anything not presented to them from the 'box' (TV). And most of that is mindless garbage. (or worse, if anyone realizes that most past civilizations are studied by their garbage) -d

by x-marcap

The problem is most of us do want these domestic terrorist caught.

Most of us aren't doing anything illegal, so this is on no relevance to us. It is a future danger, but we are all very short sighted.

by deepsand

"Too many OB/GYN's are'nt able to practice their love [b]with[/b] women all over the country." - 06SEP04

"After all, Europe is America's closest [b]ally[/b]." - 22FEB04

"Free societies will be allies against these hateful few who have no concience, who kill at the [b]whim of a hat[/b]. - 17SEP04

"[b]September[/b] the [b]4th, 2001[/b], I stood in the ruins of the Twin Towers. It's a day I will never forget." - 18OCT04.

"That's why I went to Congress last September and proposed [b]fundamental, supplemental[/b] funding, which is money for armor and [b]body parts[/b]. - 04SEP04

"We are in no way, shape or form [b]should a human being play[/b] God." - 14JAN05

"I think we were welcomed. But it was [b]not a peaceful welcome[/b]." - 12DEC05 - on US forces in Iraq

"We look forward to hearing your vision, so we can [b]more better[/b] do our job." - 20SEP05

"I'm looking forward to a good night's sleep [b]on the soil of a friend[/b]." 29JUN05 - on Denmark

"He was a [i]state sponsor of terror[/i]. [b]In other words[/b], the government had declared, you are a [i]state sponsor of terror[/i]." - 23JAN06 - on Saddam

"You took an oath to defend our flag and our freedom, and you kept that oath [b]underseas and under fire[/b]." 10JAN06 - to US troops

by georgeou

The name of the caller and the audio portion of the call were never given to the NSA. Only the source, destination as well and time of the call was disclosed. If they want any more than that, they'd have to get a subpoena. You can debate all you like but at least get your facts right.

by x-marcap

The content of the calls would not be known anyway, but the contacts would allow them to find out who is contacting the terrorists.

That should be cooperated with. If you had no contact with terrorists, you should not have to worry.

by deepsand

and so do I.

To prevent such was precisely why the 4th Amendment to the US Constitution was set forth.

"The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized."

by x-marcap

He has been lied about more than Clinton's personal life.

Bush wasn't the one who initiated lawsuits over the 2000 election. His appeal, not lawsuit, stopped the lawsuits, and the cherrypicking of districts to recount. It has been claimed the was picked by the court, and they basically said, "Apply the same standard statewide and to every precinct. and use what process was in place before the election"

Gore still lost.

by x-marcap

My son ran high school cross country.

I was at a road race a few years ago with my wife.
I said that I thought a woman looked hot... She was young, and attractive, had just finished a 5k. She had collapsed after a hard run and took down her top to douse heself with water. I did look, we were in public. I said she looked really hot. She was sweating very heavily. A 5K in 17 minutes is hard work. My wife was peeved for months...

I even wrote that I agreed with Julian once or twice... But, not on this.

by jardinier

does not put you in the same league as Bush.

Not that he is in a class of his own. Perhaps Colin would like to tell you about a certain long-term conservative premier of Queensland who had a lot more difficulty with the English language than George Bush.

Joh Bjelke Petersen was, however, a good financial manager.

by x-marcap

To preserve lives sometimes it is necessary to do what isn't 100% kosher.

FDR imprisoned Japanese Americans. Why wasn't he impeached. Some strategy critics he put in Mental hospitals without a trial for their sanity. These heineous acts were continued by Truman until long after VJ day.

Compered to these acts trying to find domestic terrorist connections is rather benign. Any impeachment call is a joke.

by x-marcap

Your Secret ballot is no longer really secret.

It is even worse with the advent of computerized voting machines.

I volunteer at the board of elections. Politicos can get access to the database of past votes. They can check who voted for them and cross reference it against your registration entry. If they wnat to know how you vote, they can find out. They would have had to cross reference the stub number with the paper ballot at one time. Now they can do a single line of SQL to get that info...

by bfilmfan

Excellent comment.

I am also concerned with some of the issues that are being reported on the voting machines concerning the OS security and how easily they can be manipulated for vote fraud.

We won't even had a dimpled chad to point at!

by x-marcap

Kennedy did violate Cuban sovreignity. Without either UN or congressional approval he attempted the Bay of Pigs invasion. Via Executive orders. That was also to protect our country. It was never even considered something worth impeachable.

Aren't you doing the same selective employment with your own actions?

Were you trying to get Clinton removed, Sandy.

Did you file military charges against him? For his bombing of the Sudanese Aspirin factory, For his indiscriminate bombing of the Slavs, or any other action unbecoming an officer for his other acts?

If these charges were filed by a serving officer those charges have real teeth and a fatal end. It would have been more significant than an impeachment, it would have been a military tribunal, and it would have been a simple conviction.

You show your bias, and your unthinking hatred. I at least admit and revel in my bias as a moral position.

by deepsand

Firstly, the issue at hand is a present one, not one of the past.

More importantly, a government's acts against its own citizenry is felt more deeply and strongly than is one against a foreign sovereign, owing to the very nature of such.

As an analogy, being struck by one's parents is quite a different matter from being struck by a stranger; you live with the parents, not the stranger.

by jardinier

It won't happen, period.

What you need is a better quality of candidates for the presidency. How you will achieve this, I have no idea. It is a weakness embedded in the US process for electing a president.

The two other leaders of the COW which invaded Iraq -- Tony Blair and John Howard -- are, simply, more capable and more honest leaders than Bush. While America is getting ever deeper and deeper into debt, the Australian Government is producing a healthy surplus each year.

Your constitution needs revising and updating.

As John Howard sent troops to Iraq, then what happens in the American leadership is pertinent to certain "furriners" -- especially Australians.

Quite frankly your electoral system sucks. Because Australia is such a young country -- we only became a Federation in 1901 -- our constitution is still quite up to date.

I think that if certain Americans stopped worshipping your outdated constitution, and if more Americans took a real interest in what is happening at home and abroad -- and if they demonstrated a willingness to become part of the solution rather than part of the problem by VOTING -- then maybe you would have a chance to turn the tide.

Repeatedly Americans say in these discussions that the majority of Americans are not interested in keeping up with the news. They watch Fox, if anything at all, and if it is not on Fox it didn't happen.

Please don't blame foreigners for a situation which America has gotten into all by itself.

America is probably Australia's most important ally. It is not in our interest to see America self-destruct.

The only "Australian" who is contributing to the decline of awareness in America is Rupert Murdoch, who is no longer an Australian anyhow as he changed his citizenship years ago.

Australians will continue to post their opinions in these forums, and if you don't like it, then at least try and understand that in the longer term we want only what is best for the USA.

by dawgit

The US Constitution for the peoples lazy ignorance. Most can't even read it, little on understand it. It was written by some of the finist minds of the time. That level of thinking no longer exists in the American political sys. ( or the majority of the populace either )

by jardinier

Can you offer any explanation as to why the "people" have become lazy and ignorant?

Is the social disease curable?

I hope you can come up with something more original than the oft quoted welfare system.

by maxwell edison

1. When the news media stops putting people through the mill, forcing them and their families to undergo what's tantamount to a public anal exam for anything and everything in his/her life, regardless of how it pertains to the merits of that person holding office.

2. When people get over their strange obsession to love seeing others succeed in a rags to riches story (both literally and figuratively), only to then love to see them torn down. (This is also advanced by the media.)

3. There are a lot of good people who could hold any public office effectively. But a drunk driving arrest in the past as a college student, having smoked pot in the 60s and 70s, past family issues, getting fired from a job, a visit to a psychologist, or any number of "skeletons" that a person would prefer stay in the closet will prevent those people from entering the arena. (A favorite of the news media.) People can overcome past mistakes, and can actually use them as a way to better themselves.

4. When political mudslinging, usually carried out in the media, is either eliminated or exposed for what it really is.

5. When the news media begins to understand it's their function to simply report the news, not create the news. I believe the news media actually took-on a new "perceived" role after our Watergate scandal, and today, they actually see themselves as a fourth branch of government -- the accountability branch.

It might sound as though I'm "blaming the media", and I suppose I am to some degree. But they're the vehicle for all those things to be brought to the public, so in the very least, they act as co-conspirators, so to speak.

Okay, and here's one that doesn't really involve the media.

When people get over their stupid notion that the role of government is NOT to provide an answer for every problem in their lives from the time they're born to the time they die. Oh, but wait a minute. People didn't think those things until that "stupid notion" was advance to them through the media.

by maxwell edison

Julian, with all due respect, I believe I know more about our constitution than you, and that you simply don't know what you're talking about.

You've made several references (in the past) to it being "outdated", but you've not been real specific. Please enlighten us. Specifically, how is our constitution "outdated"? Sure, you might not agree with the gun clause or such, but that's just an opinion; others will surely disagree.

Actually, I disagree that our constitution is outdated. In fact, I vehemently disagree. I don't believe that our constitution should be brought up to current times at all, but rather the current times should be adjusted to reflect our constitution as originally intended.

There are plenty of Americans who share your sentiment, however. They believe that our constitution is a "living and breathing" document that can be changed to reflect "current times". Although that's true to some degree, considering the built-in methods to amend the document, but the original intention should remain intact. I believe our individual rights, as guaranteed by the original constitution, are literally being trampled upon. And those people (people who share your sentiment) only want to bring the constitution "up to date", so to speak, to justify their trampling. That's bass-ackwards, if you ask me!

A related comment regarding your opinion that our "electoral system sucks".

No it doesn't. It works just as it was intended to work as defined in our original constitution. (And remember, I believe that the current times should be adjusted to reflect our constitution as originally intended.)

If we were to do away with our electoral system, we might as well do away with our individual states and state lines.We're almost there right now, considering the federal government has wielded so much power over the states. But it was intended to be the other way around. The states are the entities that were to ensure that the federal government didn't grow too large, especially with all issues domestic. To do away with our electoral system is to concede that argument, and capitulate to a large federal government wielding even more power over the states.

That might be the one thing left (our electoral system) that's the states' "ace in the hole". If we're to change our federal government in a major way, "states' rights" might just be the way to do it. (See note below.) What's the difference between a state and a province? I know the answer (as do you, I'm sure), and that's why we shouldn't do it. (But for those reading this who don't know, do your homework and find out.) We're the USA, not the UPA.

Sorry, but I'm not willing to make such a concession. I don't want to become the UPA, either in name or in practice. I still believe there may be a glimmer of hope to change current times to reflect our constitution as originally intended.

Note: Another way might be a new political party spun-off from one of the major two parties. (Most likely the Republican party to reflect a more libertarian viewpoint, but I'm not holding my breath.) And to address another one of your comments, that's how "third parties" have been formed in the past -- but only to eventually become one of the two major parties. This sentiment is why my libertarian views aren't advanced by way of supporting the Libertarian Party, but rather trying to get the Republican Party to revert to its more Libertarian viewpoints, i.e. the Republican Party of Barry Goldwater.

P.S. And for the record, Julian. I don't "worship" our constitution, nor does (if I may be so bold to attempt to speak for others with a like sentiment) anyone else. What I do "worship", however, is my individual liberty as guaranteed to be protected under our constitution. If you can't see the distinction, then you don't understand me (or us?) at all.

by maxwell edison

Question: What are the viewership rating numbers for Fox News, CBS News, ABC News, NBC News, and CNN News? And let's throw in PBS for grins?

I didn't think you knew the answer (But I do).

Hint: Your comment was silly.

by jardinier

After three and a half years at this website I am fully conversant with your views on just about everything which are repeated ad nauseum and never change.

I have reached a stage where I will adopt the attitude which you have adopted towards another peer, and simply not waste my time reading your posts.

So: "Blah, blah, blah .... " I am not interested in being repeatedly reminded of your very narrow and bigoted views.

In case you are not fully conversant with the meaning of the word "bigot" I will help you out:

[b]bigot // n.
an obstinate and intolerant believer in a religion, political theory, etc.[/b]

[Oxford dictionary]

by maxwell edison

.....
A. He didn't like how I correctly pointed out how the media obviously takes pleasure and profit in destroying people's lives, destroying the political process, etc., and since Julian is an admitted "card-carrying" member of the media ....... well, you figure it out.

B. He couldn't answer my questions and rebuttal concerning our constitution, and since he can't win this debate, he runs from it.

C. He realized that the viewership of Fox News is really pretty small, when compared to all the other major networks, thereby making him look rather silly by his repeated Fox News nonsense.

D. He is displaying intolerant behavior towards another's political theory (What is that, he said, being a bigot?).

E. All of the above.

And the correct answer is..........

by dawgit

Is definately a good question. (and perhaps another discussion) No, it's not the welfare sys., in fact, that is only used by the people to remain that way. No, I think the media has a much greater role in this present conundrum. (no, not only TV) There's always the danger when people are kept (or trained to be) dumb. They then can be easily controled. (and we have a flat Earth again)

by mr stumper

and are continually blocked. Dems do not have subpoena powers as they are the minority, we will most likely have to wait until after the elections this year to get any investigation.

Here is a quote from a letter signed by over 50 members of congress on May 11th to Bush.

"It is time the American public and the Congress had more than press reports to establish the facts about NSA's domestic surveillance programs. Several Members of Congress wrote to you nearly three months ago asking for the appointment of a Special Counsel to investigate the NSA's surveillance of Americans. We still have not received your response.

Every practical avenue for investigation has been stymied based on the feeblest of excuses. When Members of Congress wrote to the Inspector Generals of the Justice and Defense Departments, they refused to investigate. The Justice Department handed the matter to its Office of Professional Responsibility for an investigation of professional legal misconduct, and then denied security clearances to its own investigators. The Defense Department handed the matter to NSA's Inspector General, who never responded and who approved the eavesdropping at issue. The Government Accountability Office refused to investigate, anticipating you would block access to records by designating them foreign intelligence or counterintelligence materials. While the House and Senate Judiciary Committees have held hearings, they have not issued a single subpoena for witnesses or documentary evidence. Instead of investigation, all that emerges is a pattern of resisting investigation into the facts that Congress and the public deserve."

by georgeou

Clinton was impeached by the House; he just wasn't convicted by the Senate. After he left office, he was disbarred by the Arkansas Bar association for committing perjury.

by deepsand

I wholeheartedly agree that the fault does not rest with Bush alone; both parties in Congress are culpable as well.

However, there are obviously certain functions that are within the purvue of the Executive branch that are not easily moderated by either of the other 2 branches without the co-operation of the Executive.

For example, in addition to the issues of "spying" on citizens, which was supposedly long ago settled, there is now the issue of 750+ Presidential "Signing Statements," which amount to private, non-overridable, line item vetoes. Here the Executive branch is asserting that it is the final arbiter of what is and is not Constitutionally allowable, by virtue of the President also being the Commander-in-Chief, and that Congress has no Constitutional power to challenge such, and that the Executive is therefore not answerable to Congress.

There are many, myself included, who find this to be greatly troubling. We do not accept the premise that we have nothing to fear from our government.

by deepsand

It's not clear who the "he" in the title of your post is; neither is the reference to an oath.

by deepsand

who intervened in what was a matter for the State.

Yet one more example of the trampling of the 10th Amendment to the US Constitution.

by deepsand

You're the one attempting to evade the issue, by obscuring it with that which only seems to be it.

If you understand this, then you are being deliberately evasive; if not, then you lack the ability to employ logical reasoning.

The choice is your's to declare.

by mr stumper

...Is absolutely astounding! See my post above entitled "They have tried". Just because the Republican majority in Congress (not to mention the Bush administration) do not want to investigate this issue does NOT make it legal.

Jonathan Turney, professor of constitutional law at George Washington University (and a libertarian BTW) said on MSNBC, regarding the collection of phone records, that "there is NO law that allows the government to do this type of operation"

AND...Verizon is being sued by two NJ lawyers for violating privacy laws. Big kudos to Qwest for standing up to the NSA. Qwest asked the NSA for a letter of authorization from the US Attorney General's office and the request was denied, so Qwest did not comply with the NSA's request. If it's so LEGAL, Max, why not get a signoff from the US Attorney General?

So whom is one to believe? A respected expert on congressional law or some guy on TR? Sorry Max...It's not you!

So go ahead, put your hands over your ears and go "LA LA LA LA LA...I can't heeeeaaarrrr you!"

by deepsand

And, I shall not presume to claim to know all of them; nor do I now have the time to enumerate all of those that immediately come to mind.

I will, however, here mention one that I recognized many years ago, with the result that I was labeled an elitist by some. That is that we have too many ill informed voters.

Now, we have always had, and shall always have, those who are less than adequately able to vote in an informed and intelligent manner. Until fairly recently, though, a substantial portion of such [b]did not vote[/b].

In the past several decades we have seen any number of measures intended to increase participation in elections, with the result that an increasingly large number of votes being cast are of no value other than to those who can sway such their way.

In short, we have too many stupid people voting.

This brings to mind a science fiction story in which:

1) People cast votes for policy proposals, not candidates for office.
2) All voters had to record both the premises that they considered and their reasoning which led them to conclude to support or oppose a proposal, as well as the consequences that they forsaw of both its passage and defeat.
3) All voting records were public.
4) Governmental positions were filled with those whose predicted outcomes best matched the realized ones.
5) The highest office was called the "Prime Predictor."

by maxwell edison

.
I'm not crazy about the practice either, but we are at war. I think this war is an absolutely HUGE deal, and apparently not too many people think so. At a time of war, we have to make allowances for certain things. Look at all the things Americans had to endure from 1941 to 1945. This is just one of those things -- just like having to take my shoes off at the airport.

And it's being mischaracterized in both the original discussion message and in the media.

First of all, "President Bush" is not listening to anyone's phone conversations. To what end would he, specifically, want to listen to anybody's phone conversation?

And why would anyone in government want to listen to you, deepsand, making an appointment with your psychiatrist, for example? Nobody cares that you call him 5 days a week. Nobody cares that you call Victoria's Secret for home delivery of your panties. Nobody cares that you order inflatable dolls to snuggle up to. And nobody cares that you call all those 900 numbers day after day.

Nobody cares about you, or me, or any other everyday American citizen. Nobody is "spying on Americans". They're too damned busy and focused on trying to connect the dots between terrorists operating within the USA and those operating outside the USA.

And I seem to remember a LOT of criticism placed on the Bush administration (and the Clinton administration, for that matter) for failing to connect the dots that could have prevented 9-11.

They're just trying to connect the friggin' dots, no more, no less.

What would you have them do? Not do it?

Go ahead, dipstick. what's the alternative?

Here is where you're going to say that it should be done, but that "proper channels" weren't taken to do it. To which I would say B.S. I'm sure President Bush has his legal ass covered. Besides, if you do make this argument, you'll only be confirming that this is no more than an attempt to bring down the president -- and it's helping the enemy in the process. Way to go, traitor.

by jardinier

If this is the case, then I feel a sadness for the once great nation of America.

Almost ALL Australians take a serious interest in keeping up with the news. Sometimes I will encounter a female who does not follow the news because "it is too unpleasant."

However for the most part Australians are very aware of events which directly affect our country, which of course includes Iraq. They follow politics very closely and hold strong views.

Once again I must refer to our preferential system of voting. In any given electoral division (known as a "seat") there will be a number of candidates. These will include a candidate from each of the major parties, and any number of representatives of minor parties and independents.

All boxes on the ballot paper must be numbered, in the order of preference of the voter. You may express your dissatisfaction with representatives of the major parties by not listing them first on the ballot paper.

HOWEVER, after minor parties and independents are eliminated because of attracting too few votes, your preferences will then count as your primary vote.

I think Australia has a particularly good electoral system. Voting is "compulsory" but only in the sense that you must register at a polling place. If you don't wish to vote, you simply put a blank ballot paper in the box.

While I may not like the outcome of an election, at least I have the reassurance of knowing that it represents fairly accurately the feelings of the majority of Australians who go to the ballot place quite well informed of the issues presented by the various parties.

by bfilmfan

I didn't vote for Al Gore, John Kerry or Bill Clinton.

I thought Bill Clinton should have been impeached for lying to a grand jury under oath.

I also didn't state that President Bush was evil. I do believe that he should be impeached for failure to defend and protect the borders of the US, which is a constitutional duty.

My comment on the small mindness of evil, which perhaps should be called the mendacity of evil, was a commentary on how totalitarian states operate by violating the rights of the people by faceless people in agencies of the state.

A further observation is your erroneous belief that a person that "attends church, tries to do what is right, and is trying to protect the country" is inherently good. I offer Benito Mussolini (Catholic), Adolph Hitler (Raised Catholic, but became a Deist) and Pol Pot (Buddhist) as examples as to the fallacy of this statement.

Now that you have discovered that you were incorrect, would you care to state a retraction?

Or do you prefer to simply make statements on matters of which you have absolutely no knowledge?

by ontheropes

I think that's a reasonable question.
You are so vague and/or full of ******* BS that ya' beggar the imagination. It's a game is it!?! What game? Where?

Naval academy? More like Navel academy wannabe. OOOO... ya bet we're all impressed. I know I am. Fer sure, fer sure. DH!

Oh... Wait. I know you'll kick serious a** with your tired lame, infamous, full of **** one-line remarks, DA ,so your fan(s) can go wild. I'm skeered over here. You betcha. FYVMYFA!

No offense...AH!

edited to clean it up. DA!

by peachcobbler

Everyday I'm growing more and more disappointed with the American people. America has been a nation of people who have been able to see through Bull Fertilizer regardless of who the applicator is. Then why hasn't America said enough to this Bush administration as to their spreading of "Bull Fertilizer"? This is the most egregious Administration ever to be in office, and I can't understand why the American people are being so tolerant of this egregious behavior.

It has gone far beyond party affiliation; this has started to make Bush's own party sick. Bush is not Presidential material; he doesn't posses the qualities a leader of such an amazing country need. Most of the world hates America because of this Administration, who has managed to undo all or mostly all of the good deeds that America has been able to accomplish in the last 20 years. I'm not going to mention the most egregious things that he has done, just the most recently.

Domestic spying has its place in a society where there is threat of annihilation of that society by outside forces. But first lets clean up the inside forces that are against us, before we go and spy on the very people who he believes elected him! Why hasn't anyone raised the question about the spies who have been caught spying in the higher ranks of our Government? We've heard about them being caught but why haven't we heard about what has been done about it and with these traitors who were caught red handed? Some of who have been in very close proximity to George W. Bush in the White House!

What about the Vice President and his involvement in scandals that hasn't been addressed that sheds bad light on our Country and the administration in place now. GWB and all his cronies need to be healed accountable for the egregious things they have done and are still doing. How can anyone expect other citizens to abide by the law when the heads of this country doesn't? Some Presidents have been brought up on Impeachment charges for far lesser offensives than what is at hand today, and I haven't heard one suggestion about Impeachment of this President!

by dawgit

It's not that egregious to the American People. Ask them instead about the latest on Britney Spears, or whom ever they're told is important today. (and every one 'knows' the world is only 10,000 years old and is flat, the rest is heresy!) and of course 'IT' and 'Science' in general is 'Voodoo'(evil us).