Well, it seems that GWB has been spying on DOMESTIC calls as well!
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by x-marcap
If the rules didn't get changed in mid-stream Gore didn't win...
He lost the Electoral college...
ALGORE won popular vote!!! Yippeee!!!! We elect our President by the electoral college.
You conceivably could win CA, TX, NY, FLA, OH, IL, VA, MA, MI, and I think PA by a grand total of 10 votes, lose the rest of the other 132 million registered voters and still be President.
Gore tried to cherry pick the precincts. This was at the direction of Richard Daly. That made it illegal, via the equal protection clause of the 14th amendment to do that...
The Florida Supreme court had the judgement remanded to them for review twice. Then the Supreme court stopped the BS...
Don't rewrite history. The FLASC tried to stop the State constitutionally mandated filing of electors. (unethical, and illegal by state and Federal law.)
When FLASC tried to stop Florida's electoral votes from being cast on Nov 21, that would have affected the Federal electoral college. By FLA state law the electors are then selected by the legislature. (Which is Republican) Then the electors in that situation wouldn't have gone to Gore in that case...
by x-marcap
I will be happy to apologize. The problem is most of the anti-Bush crowd are so tainted with Gore-Clinton love it is nauseating.
Sandy, and his ilk, want to rewrite history. Apparently they don't want to hear the truth, again. Gore tried to cherry pick counties... He wanted a different standard applied to the disadvantaged areas over the more affluent areas...
The desire is to Hitler-like tell the lie over and over until it is believed by the masses... Gore still lost, Sandy... Even in Broward Co. Fla...
by x-marcap
The fact is the evidence was never allowed to be presented, and only one Senator viewed the evidence.
This is normally done in all trials. After the opening motion to dismiss, which was rejected by the CJ , there are to be opening arguments, followed by evidenciary procedures... The procedures closed after opening remarks, without a final vote...
The CJ presided over a circus, not a trial.It didn't follow the Johnson precedent, as it was a full criminal type trial.
by x-marcap
If passed by enough states, as the last group of amendments.
And a kudo to the next person who knows the other way and percentage... No fair looking...
I'm certain Sandy, and Max both know this, they are both inelligible for the kudo...
by x-marcap
Therefore their opinions aren't hindered by what they should do Constitutionally.
Law is predominately precedence. I wish that the Federalist papers were recognized as a foundational document by Supreme clowns like Suter, Kennedy, and Brewer. Then the New London decision would have had to have been decided for the property owner...
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
1. That just proves the lefties are wrong everytime they start out.
2. If they eventually change enough they may get it "right". Usually they throw more money at the situation and go more wrong...
3. When they start heading "right" they tend to go wrong again..
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
The Democrats had long thrown out many ballots. Now they can't... Ken Blackwell is investigating...
He understands this. Keep the corrupt hands off the ballots and you get a good accurate count... This seems to be changing the power structure in Cleveland. No more Vote fraud, Democrats loosing in the Metro area... Interesting at least...
BTW the may be Ohio's first Black Govonor...
by x-marcap
by deepsand
I should know, given the number of times it's happened to me.
Ah, well, nothing to fret about.
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
Both of them belonged to it. Bush resigned... Kerry is still reputed to be a "boner"
A Skull is a Skull. The people they are close to are the same kind of people with different names and ages...
by x-marcap
The big weapons of his day were much more limited.
That being said, this is legal for the CINC to do as per the any enemies foreign and domestic part of oath, and the war on terrorism resolution...
by cactus pete
As hard as it may be sometimes to admit, particularly when it could aid safety, the government has no power to do anything unless it is expressly given that power from the people by their representatives.
If two constitution points appear to be in conflict with one another, it is for the Supreme Court to sort it out.
Back in the late 1970s (the Carter Administration, I believe), in an effort to expand law enforcement efforts in the bogus, expensive, and individual-liberty trampling war on drugs, Congress passed legislation to allow any law enforcement agency of government to collect and analyze, without any need for further warrants, any and all records of phone contacts, including the number that made the call, the number that received the call, and the date and time the call was made. I forgot what this law was named, but with your legal connections, perhaps you can verify this for us.
For Pete's sake. Just watch CSI-Tulsa, or CSI-Bangor, or CSI-Anywhere, and you see them have access to a database of "who called whom and when" week after week, I mean night after night. If CSIs can do it legally (and "real ones" can), why not the NSA?
That's all this is. And if a red flag pops up over a phone number of a known or suspected terrorist, then another law that's already passed allows them to take it to the next level, whatever that might be.
My bottom line position is this: Regardless of any "outcry" by whomever, I'm certain that the Bush Administration has their legal ass covered. This is purely political, and any reasonably intelligent person knows it, or at least should know it. I'm really amazed at the otherwise intelligent people around here who are spouting-off in such a way. Geesh! Get real, is what I say.
There are SO damn many laws, and acts, and resolutions, and so on, that have been previously passed, that the government can "legally" do just about anything they damn well please. And no, I don't like it. However, I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt when it comes to waging the war on Islamo-Fascism. (And watch some fool come-back and misrepresent what I just said.) It's all the other crap that I want to put a stop to. Why are so many people bass-ackwards on this point?
I find it strange that most people who are up in arms about this kind of thing won't join me in advocating reducing the size and scope of the federal government, in general, by about 50 percent (and that's only for a start). If the role of the federal government was confined to primarily a role of representing and defending the USA in the world arena, and keeping their noses out of ALL business domestic, things like this would be a lot clearer and easier to reconcile. All of the idiots who have voted for all of the idiots and idiotic ideas over the past forty years to ensure their "domestic security from womb to tomb" now have exactly what they asked for. And they're now crying about it. Well boo-hoo. All the idiots only got what they wanted.
(You're about the only one, at this point, that I'd leave a reply for. I'm getting tired of these same old, worn-out arguments and discussions. I'll read some of the messages, but not all, and I'm tired of replying.)
by peachcobbler
Can I surmise, then, that your comment (Franklin's comment) on security will apply equally to "Social Security? And will you join me in supporting the abolition of the government mandated retirement program called "Social Security", so as to remain compliant and consistent with Mr. Franklin's sentiment, "He who would give up a small essential freedom for a little temporary security is a scoundrel, and deserves neither freedom nor security"?
I support abolishing the entire Social Security system, reimbursing those, in an equitable manner, who have paid into the system, and phasing it out over a forty year period.
Do you agree?
by x-marcap
by deepsand
I view the Supreme Court decision that allowed such to stand as a lawful exercise of Congressional power, ostensibly implicitly granted by the phrase "general welfare," along with other such decisions so gorunded, to have been contrary to both the general spirit of the Constitution as well as the intent of the 10th Amendment.
Our Constitution was intended to be one of enumerated powers, none of which support the claim that Congress has such powers as were here exercised.
by cactus pete
I wasn't totally disagreeing with you. Your point about the law is true enough. The question seems to be whether or not the feds are supposed to have a warrant or not. Hell, they might, but it could be issued from a secret court. That makes is legal.
Of course, the government should be smaller. I doubt anyone rational disagrees with that. Most people jsut argue HOW that should happen.
All of these discussions can be much better if universal agreements are acknowledged and sides work towards a center solution. Unfortunately, that's harder than basking one's preferences through, most of the time...
For once, I'm leaving the office when I'm supposed to - remind me tomorrow to send the query to the librarian.
by dawgit
by x-marcap
According to public reports...
Princeton was at one time a religious institution. Thus the Small church and graveyard belong to Princeton. The Mausoleum belongs to Princeton.
by nicknielsen
During the 2000 Presidential campaign, I placed a Bush sign to the right of my front yard, a Gore sign to the left, and a banner in the middle that read "This is a choice?"
Then I wrote in the future Secretary of State.
by nicknielsen
We haven't really had a choice except between the lesser of two evils for the past 16 years.
Unfortunately, since Watergate took the selection of the candidates out of the smoke-filled rooms and sent it to the primaries, any serious candidates get chased out in the first few caucuses. The one criteria that was always met in the back rooms - "He won't shame the party." - is no longer even a consideration.
by nicknielsen
It's called "reliability." Young people don't seem to have a problem calling in sick whenever they don't feel like going to work. Enough absences and poof! "We won't need you after Friday."
My son learned this lesson the hard way.
by nicknielsen
by nicknielsen
by nicknielsen
Serve in the military and you may vote.
Edit: Besides, what makes you think that an accomplished mathematician is more politically aware than, say, an accomplished mechanic? How about you have to pass the citizenship exam before you can vote? As native-born Americans, we should already know this information anyway. Sample questions: http://sfpl.lib.ca.us/librarylocations/main/pracquest.htm
by cactus pete
I don't know about a 50% reduction across the board, or even by simply eliminating particular agencies, etc.
But I'd start with the elimination of (likely) all subsidies. (And yes, I have a good idea what that would do to the economy, if anyone wondered.)
(Business is not the business of the government)
Then I'd remove most foreign aid that goes in the form of defense spending. In other words, I wouldn't GIVE weapons away, or give money for the purpose of buying weapons. (including loans)
(Money would be better spent protecting human rights in developing areas than helping defend already rich, industrialized countries.)
I'm not an expert, so I won't commit to this one, but I would certainly ask the chiefs why we have so many bases around the world all the time. I understand the need to be able to deploy, but I also see staffing/maintaining all these sites all the time as a drain. I'd love to hear other ideas from people involved.
Redundant agencies - there must be some. Things are too huge now that there wouldn't be.
The recent remodeling of the Pentagon was done on time and under budget (IIRC, after an initial lame contractor was removed), I want the guy who was in charge of that in the cabinet somewhere.
I'd hate to say it, but I'd build fences along the borders and monitor it with the Guard. I don't see a better way to maintain safe borders at the moment. I would, however, encourage our neighbors to do the same. It just seems more amicable that way.
I would invest Federal money in cost reduction methods where energy is concerned. Spending the money now would be a short term expense that would increase jobs to rehab, retrofit, research, etc... The spent money would hit the multiplier and increase revenues enough to offset most of the expense. And in the long run, money would be saved. We would also be more selfsufficient where energy is concerned - I think we all know the various benefits of that. Win-win-win
There's more, I'm sure, but that's from the top of my head and I have to get back to some work...
by x-marcap
At that point the information requested is on a third party's shoulders.
You have a right not to incriminate yourself, but on request you are required to testify against others.That is subpoena power.
This is now, the Susan McDougal hole... She refused to testify under oath. Not to her own actions, but to others' actions... That isn't protected by any law... But, thanks to a gutless Judiciary they let her out without a even a sworn statement... That allows Omerta to be recognized by the judge as legal.
That was a terrible precedent.
by deepsand
by x-marcap
That is my opinion anyway. External enemies stay quiet. The internal ones make noise...
A lot of noise....
by x-marcap
Max is right on all but one point. Dang near 100%.
Bush is covered by the over-reaching declaration of the War on terrorism, completely...
Congress was too vague, again...
by deepsand
by nicknielsen
by x-marcap
But I will defend your right to say/write it...
I do not think disagreement is treasonous, but it may be sedicious... The actions you recommend can take the comments from Nasty disagreement into sedition...
by deepsand
Stratfor.com Services Subscriptions
GEOPOLITICAL INTELLIGENCE REPORT 05.16.2006
Civil Liberties and National Security
By George Friedman
USA Today published a story last week stating that U.S. telephone companies (Qwest excepted) had been handing over to the National Security Agency (NSA) logs of phone calls made by American citizens. This has, as one might expect, generated a fair bit of controversy -- with opinions ranging from "It's not only legal but a great idea" to "This proves that Bush arranged 9/11 so he could create a police state." A fine time is being had by all. Therefore, it would seem appropriate to pause and consider the matter.
Let's begin with an obvious question: How in God's name did USA Today find out about a program that had to have been among the most closely held secrets in the intelligence community -- not only because it would be embarrassing if discovered, but also because the entire program could work only if no one knew it was under way? No criticism of USA Today, but we would assume that the newspaper wasn't running covert operations against the NSA. Therefore, someone gave them the story, and whoever gave them the story had to be cleared to know about it. That means that someone with a high security clearance leaked an NSA secret.
Americans have become so numbed to leaks at this point that no one really has discussed the implications of what we are seeing: The intelligence community is hemorrhaging classified information. It's possible that this leak came from one of the few congressmen or senators or staffers on oversight committees who had been briefed on this material -- but either way, we are seeing an extraordinary breakdown among those with access to classified material.
The reason for this latest disclosure is obviously the nomination of Gen. Michael Hayden to be the head of the CIA. Before his appointment as deputy director of national intelligence, Hayden had been the head of the NSA, where he oversaw the collection and data-mining project involving private phone calls. Hayden's nomination to the CIA has come under heavy criticism from Democrats and Republicans, who argue that he is an inappropriate choice for director. The release of the data-mining story to USA Today obviously was intended as a means of shooting down his nomination -- which it might. But what is important here is not the fate of Hayden, but the fact that the Bush administration clearly has lost all control of the intelligence community -- extended to include congressional oversight processes. That is not a trivial point.
At the heart of the argument is not the current breakdown in Washington, but the more significant question of why the NSA was running such a collection program and whether the program represented a serious threat to liberty. The standard debate is divided into two schools: those who regard the threat to liberty as trivial when compared to the security it provides, and those who regard the security it provides as trivial when compared to the threat to liberty. In this, each side is being dishonest. The real answer, we believe, is that the program does substantially improve security, and that it is a clear threat to liberty. People talk about hard choices all the time; with this program, Americans actually are facing one.
A Problem of Governments
Let's begin with the liberty question. There is no way that a government program designed to track phone calls made by Americans is not a threat to liberty. We are not lawyers, and we are sure a good lawyer could make the argument either way. But whatever the law says, liberty means "my right to do what I want, within the law and due process, without the government having any knowledge of it." This program violates that concept.
The core problem is that it is never clear what the government will do with the data it collects.
Consider two examples, involving two presidential administrations.
In 1970, Congress passed legislation called the Racketeer-Influenced and Corrupt Organizations (RICO) Act that was designed explicitly to break organized crime groups. The special legislation was needed because organized crime groups were skilled at making more conventional prosecutions difficult. The Clinton administration used the RICO Act against anti-abortion activists. From a legal point of view, this was effective, but no one had ever envisioned the law being used this way when it was drafted. The government was taking the law to a place where its framers had never intended it to go.
Following 9/11, Congress passed a range of anti-terrorism laws that included the PATRIOT Act. The purpose of this was to stop al Qaeda, an organization that had killed thousands of people and was thought to be capable of plotting a nuclear attack. Under the same laws, the Bush administration has been monitoring a range of American left-wing groups -- some of which well might have committed acts of violence, but none of which come close to posing the same level of threat as al Qaeda. In some technical sense, using anti-terrorism laws against animal-rights activists might be legitimate, but the framers of the law did not envision this extension.
What we are describing here is neither a Democratic nor a Republican disease. It is a problem of governments. They are not particularly trustworthy in the way they use laws or programs. More precisely, an extraordinary act is passed to give the government the powers to fight an extraordinary enemy -- in these examples, the Mafia or al Qaeda. But governments will tend to extend this authority and apply it to ordinary events. How long, then, before the justification for tracking telephone calls is extended to finding child molesters, deadbeat dads and stolen car rings?
It is not that these things shouldn't be stopped. Rather, the issue is that Americans have decided that such crimes must be stopped within a rigorous system of due process. The United States was founded on the premise that governments can be as dangerous as criminals. The entire premise of the American system is that governments are necessary evils and that their powers must be circumscribed. Americans accept that some criminals will go free, but they still limit the authority of the state to intrude in their lives. There is a belief that if you give government an inch, it will take a mile -- all in the name of the public interest.
Now flip the analysis. Americans can live with child molesters, deadbeat dads and stolen car rings more readily than they can live with the dangers inherent in government power. But can one live with the threat from al Qaeda more readily than that from government power? That is the crucial question that must be answered. Does al Qaeda pose a threat that (a) cannot be managed within the structure of normal due process and (b) is so enormous that it requires an extension of government power? In the long run, is increased government power more or less dangerous than al Qaeda?
Due Process and Security Risks
We don't mean to be ironic when we say this is a tough call. If all that al Qaeda can do was what they achieved on 9/11, we might be tempted to say that society could live more readily with that threat than with the threat of government oppression. But there is no reason to believe that the totality of al Qaeda's capabilities and that of its spin-off groups was encapsulated in the 9/11 attacks. The possibility that al Qaeda might acquire and use weapons of mass destruction, including nuclear devices, cannot be completely dismissed. There is no question but that the organization would use such weapons if they could. The possibility of several American cities being devastated by nuclear attacks is conceivable -- and if there is only one chance in 100 of such an event, that is too much. The fact is that no one knows what the probabilities are.
Some of those who write to Stratfor argue that the Bush administration carried out the 9/11 attacks to justify increasing its power. But if the administration was powerful enough to carry out 9/11 without anyone finding out, then it hardly seems likely that it needed a justification for oppression. It could just oppress. The fact is that al Qaeda (which claims the attacks) carried out the attacks, and that attacks by other groups are possible. They might be nuclear attacks -- and stopping those is a social and moral imperative that might not be possible without a curtailment of liberty.
On both sides of the issue, it seems to us, there has developed a fundamental dishonesty. Civil libertarians demand that due process be respected in all instances, but without admitting openly the catastrophic risks they are willing to incur. Patrick Henry's famous statement, "Give me liberty or give me death," is a fundamental premise of American society. Civil libertarians demand liberty, but they deny that by doing so they are raising the possibility of death. They move past the tough part real fast.
The administration argues that government can be trusted with additional power. But one of the premises of American conservatism is that power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Conservatives believe that the state -- and particularly the federal government -- should never be trusted with power. Conservatives believe in "original sin," meaning they believe that any ruler not only is capable of corruption, but likely to be corrupted by power. The entire purpose of the American regime is to protect citizens from a state that is, by definition, untrustworthy. The Bush administration moves past this tough part real fast as well.
Tough Discussions
It is important to consider what the NSA's phone call monitoring program was intended to do. Al Qaeda's great skill has been using a very small number of men, allowing them to blend into a targeted country, and then suddenly bringing them together for an attack. Al Qaeda's command cell has always been difficult to penetrate; it consists of men who are related or who have known each other for years. They do not recruit new members into the original structure. Penetrating the organization is difficult. Moreover, the command cell may not know details of any particular operation in the field.
Human intelligence, in order to be effective, must be focused. As we say at Stratfor, we need a name, a picture and an address for the person who is likely to know the answer to an intelligence question. For al Qaeda's operations in the United States, we do not have any of this. The purpose of the data-mining program simply would have been to identify possible names and addresses so that a picture could be pieced together and an intelligence operation mounted. The program was designed to identify complex patterns of phone calls and link the information to things already known from other sources, in order to locate possible al Qaeda networks.
In order to avoid violating civil liberties, a warrant for monitoring phone calls would be needed. It is impossible to get a warrant for such a project, however, unless you want to get a warrant for every American. The purpose of a warrant is to investigate a known suspect. In this case, the government had no known suspect. Identifying a suspect is exactly what this was about. The NSA was looking for 10 or 20 needles in a haystack of almost 300 million. The data-mining program would not be a particularly effective program by itself -- it undoubtedly would have thrown out more false positives than anyone could follow up on. But in a conflict in which there are no good tools, this was a tool that had some utility. For all we know, a cell might have been located, or the program might never have been more than a waste of time.
The problem that critics of the program must address is simply this: If data mining of phone calls is objectionable, how would they suggest identifying al Qaeda operatives in the United States? We're open to suggestions. The problem that defenders of the program have is that they expect to be trusted to use the data wisely, and to discipline themselves not to use it in pursuit of embezzlers, pornographers or people who disagree with the president. We'd love to be convinced.
Contrary to what many people say, this is not an unprecedented situation in American history. During the Civil War -- another war that was unique and that was waged on American soil -- the North was torn by dissent. Pro-Confederate sentiment ran deep in the border states that remained within the Union, as well as in other states. The federal government, under Lincoln, suspended many liberties. Lincoln went far beyond Bush -- suspending the writ of habeas corpus, imposing martial law and so on. His legal basis for doing so was limited, but in his judgment, the survival of the United States required it.
Obviously, George W. Bush is no Lincoln. Of course, it must be remembered that during the Civil War, no one realized that Abraham Lincoln was a Lincoln. A lot of people in the North thought he was a Bush. Indeed, had the plans of some of his Cabinet members -- particularly his secretary of war -- gone forward after his assassination, Lincoln's suspension of civil rights would be remembered even less than it is now.
The trade-off between liberty and security must be debated. The question of how you judge when a national emergency has passed must be debated. The current discussion of NSA data mining provides a perfect arena for that discussion. We do not have a clear answer of how the debate should come out. Indeed, our view is that the outcome of the debate is less important than that the discussion be held and that a national consensus emerge. Americans can live with a lot of different outcomes. They cannot live with the current intellectual and political chaos.
Civil libertarians must not be allowed to get away with trivializing the physical danger that they are courting by insisting that the rules of due process be followed. Supporters of the administration must not be allowed to get away with trivializing the threat to liberty that prosecution of the war against al Qaeda entails. No consensus can possibly emerge when both sides of the debate are dishonest with each other and themselves.
This is a case in which the outcome of the debate will determine the course of the war. Leaks of information about secret projects to a newspaper is a symptom of the disease: a complete collapse of any consensus as to what this war is, what it means, what it risks, what it will cost and what price Americans are not willing to pay for it. A covert war cannot be won without disciplined covert operations. That is no longer possible in this environment. A serious consensus on the rules is now a national security requirement.
Send questions or comments on this article to analysis@stratfor.com.
Cut through the clutter with timely insights & analysis straight to your inbox every day with Stratfor?s new Premium Direct Email Service.
In response to your need for quick, to-the-point, relevant intelligence, we have launched a new level of service designed especially for our clients on the go. With little or no time to waste, we understand your requirement for fast, meaningful information you can use - in your business decisions, research endeavors, and even networking efforts.
Premium Direct is a new email-only service crafted to provide a comprehensive, on-the-move source for objective situation reports and analysis on the most critical developments of the day and their implications. Delivered in quick-reading executive formats, the line-up includes Morning Intelligence Briefs, Intelligence Summaries, Geopolitical Intelligence Briefs, Global Market Briefs and Daily Terrorism Briefs. At only about a quarter a day ? less than your morning paper ? staying confidently informed has never been easier or more affordable! Click here to learn more now!
Distribution and Reprints
This report may be distributed or republished with attribution to Strategic Forecasting, Inc. at www.stratfor.com . For media requests, partnership opportunities, or commercial distribution or republication, please contact pr@stratfor.com.
Do you have a friend or acquaintance that would benefit from the consistent actionable intelligence of the FREE STRATFOR Weekly Geopolitical Intelligence Report?
Send them to www.stratfor.com/subscriptions/free-weekly-intelligence-reports.php to sign up and begin receiving the Stratfor Weekly every Tuesday for FREE!
Newsletter Subscription
The GIR is e-mailed to you as part of your subscription to Stratfor. The information contained in the PPI is also available by logging in at www.stratfor.com . If you no longer wish to receive regular e-mails from Stratfor, please send a message to: service@stratfor.com with the subject line: UNSUBSCRIBE - GIR.
? Copyright 2006 Strategic Forecasting Inc. All rights reserved.
by deepsand
Stratfor.com Services Subscriptions
TERRORISM INTELLIGENCE REPORT 05.17.2006
Tactical Realities in the Counterterrorism War
By Fred Burton
The British government last week released two reports concerning the July 7, 2005, suicide attacks in London. The first, by Parliament's Intelligence and Security Committee (ISC), examined government efforts to collect and analyze intelligence pertaining to the case; the second, by the Home Office, outlined findings about the bombers, their backgrounds, motives and actions in greater detail. The reports have, not surprisingly, generated political reactions: Some members of Parliament have claimed that MI5 was not completely forthcoming in response to the ISC queries, and a few MPs have called for an independent investigation into events surrounding the attack -- similar to the 9/11 Commission in the United States.
Be that as it may, the reports do provide a very interesting window into the internal workings of the British intelligence and security services. Even more significantly, they speak to problems of collection and analysis that occur whenever a Western government, through its intelligence and security apparatus, attempts to pre-empt vague, potential threats or to thwart an amorphous enemy. The same problems and issues now have surfaced several times following attacks by Islamist militants, whether in the United States, the Netherlands or Spain. In short, government bureaucracies do not deal well with ambiguity -- and jihadist groups, particularly at the grassroots level, are nothing if not ambiguous. They are insular and dedicated, and they might not be meaningfully connected to the command, control and communication mechanism of any known militant groups or actors -- which makes them exceedingly hard to identify, let alone pre-empt, before an attack is carried out.
As the political debates in London and, predating that, in Washington have shown, there is an expectation that governments somehow must prevent all terrorist attacks. When one occurs, there are political investigations into the cause of intelligence failures and, on occasion, finger-pointing and reorganizations result. The public, after all, needs to feel secure. But the uncomfortable truth in the war against jihadists is that there is no such thing as complete security. Given the nature of the threat and the enemy, no intelligence or security service in the world is capable of identifying every aspiring militant who lives in or enters a country and pre-empting their potential acts of violence. This is impossible even in states that employ draconian security measures; the challenges obviously are amplified in societies that value civil liberties and due process.
Within that context, the tactical challenges and expectations faced by counterterrorism agencies are useful to consider.
Threat Assessments
Before the July 7 rail bombings occurred, British authorities recognized the high risk that London would be attacked by jihadists. Government ministers and police had stated publicly on several occasions that it was "not a matter of 'if' such an attack would occur, but 'when'." This assessment was supported not only by external analysis and al Qaeda's targeting criteria, but also by the fact that several significant terrorist cells had already been neutralized in Britain. These included the group behind the ricin plot, the al-Hindi cell and others. Furthermore, following the Madrid attacks in 2004, both British and American authorities assessed the passenger rail systems in their countries and found them vulnerable.
It is little surprise, then, that in the period directly before July 7, the British government's official assessment was (to quote the Intelligence and Security Committee's report) that "available intelligence and recent events indicate that terrorists have the capability to mount an attack and that such an attack is within the group's current intent. It is assessed that an attack is likely to be a priority for the terrorists and might well be mounted." And following the arrests of Richard Reid, Babar Ahmed, Sajid Badat, Abu Qatada, Abu Hamza, Sheikh Feisal, and other militant operatives and leaders -- all British citizens -- it clearly was possible that some attacks could be planned and carried out by homegrown militants.
With all of that knowledge, then, why was it not possible to keep the strike against London's rail system from being carried out?
Puzzles
If the July 7 bombings are viewed in isolation, it would seem obvious that there were clues -- pieces of a puzzle -- that could have been fitted together to indicate the existence of a cell that posed a threat and warranted focused intelligence collection efforts -- including physical surveillance, signals intelligence (sigint) and human intelligence (humint) penetration.
Anyone can be brilliant after the fact, but it is very difficult to read tea leaves in real-time -- especially considering that the bombers did not exist in isolation. London is not Pyongyang, a heterogeneous society where the few resident foreigners can be easily monitored. Britain's capital has not been dubbed "Londonistan" for nothing; it is a huge, multicultural city, home to many religious and political dissidents and refugees from the Middle East. Within the large Muslim populace are many of Pakistani origins. Thus, even when using profiling techniques, locating radical Islamists -- who proportionally make up only a small percentage of this population -- would be a tremendous undertaking. Within that, there is the further challenge of differentiating between what could be called "jihadist cheerleaders" -- radicals who voice political or ideological support for al Qaeda and its cause, but are not actually violent -- from the combat-hardened veterans of Afghanistan, Bosnia and other jihads, as well as all those falling in between.
In order to cope with this and sort through the galaxy of potential suspects, the British government developed three categories for targets -- and allocated intelligence resources to each accordingly. The levels were:
Essential: someone likely to be directly involved in, or to have knowledge of, plans for terrorist activity.
Desirable: someone associated with people involved in, or with knowledge of, plans for terrorist acts; who is raising money for terrorist purposes; or who is in jail and would be an essential target if at large.
Other: someone who might be associated with people directly involved in, or who have knowledge of, plans for terrorist activity.
If someone is known to be directly linked with al Qaeda, it obviously would be a no-brainer to classify them as an "essential" intelligence target. These suspects would merit 24x7 physical and electronic surveillance -- an endeavor that, on the back end, could tie up as many as 100 surveillance operatives, supervisors, snipers, technicians, photographers, analysts and interpreters.
But in the real world, intelligence is seldom, if ever, so black-and-white. And the very structure of al Qaeda, its offshoots and sympathizers is a further problem. Al Qaeda has been described as a "network of networks" or a "network of relationships" -- a characterization that is ever more apt as the capabilities of the central leadership are degraded in the war. In application, this means there may no be any clear-cut chain of command, a specific building to target or communications structures on which to focus intelligence resources. The organization itself is nebulous, the targets hard to map and quantify.
The existence of grassroots operatives further complicates the equation; by definition, such jihadists might have limited or no interaction or relationship with known militants. This means that, without hard intelligence to fall back on, government agencies must place these operatives squarely into the "other" category, which warrants the least intelligence monitoring. And the difficulty of gathering hard intelligence about a person's true status and intentions is at the crux of the dilemma facing the British and other governments.
Resources and Limitations
From a practical standpoint, how does one go about developing information that can identify or pre-empt terrorist plots? Three tools are standard: humint sources, signals sigint and analysis. All of these are useful, but none are perfect.
Recruiting human sources from the communities in which militants are likely to live and move is invaluable, but any source can only see what is within his field of vision. Militant cells are built on relationships and trust -- which are difficult to establish quickly. And when the concern is about militants at the grassroots level, the universe of people that human sources would need to establish close relationships with becomes very large indeed. Moreover, even if a source is well-placed, it can be difficult to judge a suspect's intentions unless one knows him or her intimately. In the case of the July 7 attacks, even many who knew the bombers well were surprised to learn of their involvement.
The utility of sigint also is limited; it does not work well when suspects practice careful operational security (such as, in al Qaeda's case, foregoing the use of satellite telephones, which emit trackable signals). In the case of grassroots operatives, escaping scrutiny simply would mean not committing acts that would bring someone to the attention of authorities -- such as communicating with known members of terrorist groups or visiting radical Internet sites.
In any setting, intelligence is little more than raw data until analysis is applied -- but drawing the correct conclusions is difficult if one has incomplete data, is given the wrong kinds of material to analyze or lacks the proper mindset and training to make useful inferences.
In terms of pre-empting the July 7 bombings, then, the cards were stacked against the British intelligence community. The ability to identify the plotters and their plans was not a matter of putting a few puzzle pieces together, but more like sifting through the pieces of thousands of puzzles, all jumbled together in one big pile, and creating a picture -- without the benefit of a box to show what it should look like in the end.
The July 7 Puzzle
As it turns out, the British still do not know all the details about how the July 7 attacks were planned and carried out, even with nearly a year of hindsight to aid them. From the pieces that have been connected so far, they have learned that Mohammed Siddique Khan -- the apparent leader of the cell -- visited Pakistan in 2003, and that he returned and spent several months there with another of the bombers, Shahzad Tanweer, between November 2004 and February 2005. The piece that would tell authorities who the men met with while in Pakistan is still missing, but it is believed that they had some contact with al Qaeda members. Indeed, al Qaeda distributed a copy of Siddique Khan's martyrdom video -- which was likely taped in Pakistan -- along with edited footage from Ayman al-Zawahiri, supporting the notion that the July 7 cell was somehow connected to al Qaeda. It also is likely that the cell leader was trained in the manufacture of explosive mixtures and devices during one of his trips to Pakistan.
Siddique Khan has been a troublesome figure for British authorities, because he first came to their attention in the course of another matter: He was identified as a figure on the periphery of the investigation begun by the arrest in Pakistan of another suspect, computer expert Muhammed Naeem Noor Khan, and that led to the rollup of the al-Hindi cell in Britain. When one reads the ISC report, it is hard to understand how Siddique Khan even rose to the level of an "other" when authorities had not been able to identify him by name in the earlier investigation. However, Siddique Khan was among hundreds, if not thousands, of people whose names surfaced during the course of that investigation, and authorities did not have other evidence at that time that would have pulled him from the "other" category into the "essential" or "desirable" tiers for further monitoring.
The fact is, the resources available for surveillance, recruiting human sources and completing analysis from the field are finite for any government. In the British case particularly, one of the problems was that authorities had to devote significant resources to monitoring the "jihadist cheerleaders," like Abu Hamza and Omar Bakri Muhammed, in the "Londonistan" environment. Steps have, of course, been taken to address such problems in the months since the attacks. The Prevention of Terrorism Act of 2005 was passed to make it easier to imprison some of these targets or force them to flee the country, and police and MI6 have received funding to hire more staff -- thus giving them ability to expand their intelligence coverage.
But none of this addresses the problems inherent in the "other" category -- those who have not been identified as being directly involved in terrorist planning. It is from this tier that the July 7 bombers and the follow-on cell, which failed to complete a similar attack on July 21, arose. The question becomes, how, with limited resources, does one justify monitoring a group whose connections to terrorism are highly questionable, when one is also fully engaged in monitoring groups whose connections, it is believed, are not in question at all? This is how grassroots jihadists can slip through the net, sometimes with deadly effect.
There is a further tactical consideration here: How does one track the sale or purchase of materials that are used in building bombs, when the buyers are not otherwise of much interest to authorities? It is significant that the devices used in the July 7 attacks were much smaller than some of the massive "lorry bombs" employed by the IRA, and not nearly as sophisticated as many of the IRA devices. They cost very little to assemble, and efforts to collect the materials and assemble the devices would not have drawn much attention. Nevertheless, the devices used by the July 7 cells caused more deaths than any terrorist attack in Britain since the Pan Am 103 bombing over Lockerbie, Scotland, in 1988. The cell purposely chose soft targets and then used suicide operatives to guide their crudely assembled devices into the heart of the strike zone.
Conclusion
It is impossible to tell how many jihadist cells are or might be planning attacks in Britain, or even in the United States, at this time. There are many variables involved, and no government agency could be expected to provide complete security against potential -- but unknown -- threats. Moreover, with each arrest, each intelligence find, each videotaped speech or warning, the game changes: Each side shifts, adjusts and adapts to the moves being made by the other side in order to attain or maintain an advantage.
During the Cold War -- which pitted two monolithic entities against each other -- it sometimes happened that a single, extraordinarily well-placed informant or agent of influence could deliver a breakthrough that could, at least for a time, shift the advantage to one of the players. But in the game of grassroots jihad, hundreds such miracles would be needed.
None of this is intended to argue that the missions of intelligence and security agencies are futile, that funding should be cut off or efforts abandoned. In a world where complete safety is not possible, the question becomes one of funding and aligning resources to prevent the most serious threats to a society and mitigating the effects of attacks that cannot be prevented. Clearly, operations involving weapons of mass destruction would be viewed as unacceptable in any society, and government reasonably can be expected to use every available means to protect its citizens from such attacks.
From the public's perspective, acknowledging that it is impossible to prevent all acts of violence ideally could be the starting point for creative discussions about new and smarter ways to focus efforts, collect information and turn it into actionable intelligence. It could be argued that if unreasonable expectations of government were shattered, members of the public will view more seriously their own need to assist in identifying and reporting potential threats -- for the sake of their own safety, if no other reasons.
Send questions or comments on this article to analysis@stratfor.com.
Cut through the clutter with timely insights & analysis straight to your inbox every day with Stratfor?s new Premium Direct Email Service.
In response to your need for quick, to-the-point, relevant intelligence, we have launched a new level of service designed especially for our clients on the go. With little or no time to waste, we understand your requirement for fast, meaningful information you can use - in your business decisions, research endeavors, and even networking efforts.
Premium Direct is a new email-only service crafted to provide a comprehensive, on-the-move source for objective situation reports and analysis on the most critical developments of the day and their implications. Delivered in quick-reading executive formats, the line-up includes Morning Intelligence Briefs, Intelligence Summaries, Geopolitical Intelligence Briefs, Global Market Briefs and Daily Terrorism Briefs. At only about a quarter a day ? less than your morning paper ? staying confidently informed has never been easier or more affordable! Click here to learn more now!
Distribution and Reprints
This report may be distributed or republished with attribution to Strategic Forecasting, Inc. at www.stratfor.com . For media requests, partnership opportunities, or commercial distribution or republication, please contact pr@stratfor.com.
Do you have a friend or acquaintance that would benefit from the consistent actionable intelligence of the FREE STRATFOR Weekly Terrorism Intelligence Report?
Send them to www.stratfor.com/subscriptions/free-weekly-intelligence-reports.php to sign up and begin receiving the Stratfor Weekly every Thursday for FREE!
Newsletter Subscription
The TIR is e-mailed to you as part of your subscription to Stratfor. The information contained in the PPI is also available by logging in at www.stratfor.com . If you no longer wish to receive regular e-mails from Stratfor, please send a message to: service@stratfor.com with the subject line: UNSUBSCRIBE - TIR.
? Copyright 2006 Strategic Forecasting Inc. All rights reserved.
by deepsand
The New York Times
May 14, 2006
Cheney Pushed U.S. to Widen Eavesdropping
By SCOTT SHANE and ERIC LICHTBLAU
WASHINGTON, May 13 ? In the weeks after the Sept. 11 attacks, Vice President Dick Cheney and his top legal adviser argued that the National Security Agency should intercept purely domestic telephone calls and e-mail messages without warrants in the hunt for terrorists, according to two senior intelligence officials.
But N.S.A. lawyers, trained in the agency's strict rules against domestic spying and reluctant to approve any eavesdropping without warrants, insisted that it should be limited to communications into and out of the country, said the officials, who were granted anonymity to discuss the debate inside the Bush administration late in 2001.
The N.S.A.'s position ultimately prevailed. But just how Gen. Michael V. Hayden, the director of the agency at the time, designed the program, persuaded wary N.S.A. officers to accept it and sold the White House on its limits is not yet clear.
As the program's overseer and chief salesman, General Hayden is certain to face questions about his role when he appears at a Senate hearing next week on his nomination as director of the Central Intelligence Agency. Criticism of the surveillance program, which some lawmakers say is illegal, flared again this week with the disclosure that the N.S.A. had collected the phone records of millions of Americans in an effort to track terrorism suspects.
By several accounts, including those of the two officials, General Hayden, a 61-year-old Air Force officer who left the agency last year to become principal deputy director of national intelligence, was the man in the middle as President Bush demanded that intelligence agencies act urgently to stop future attacks.
On one side was a strong-willed vice president and his longtime legal adviser, David S. Addington, who believed that the Constitution permitted spy agencies to take sweeping measures to defend the country. Later, Mr. Cheney would personally arrange tightly controlled briefings on the program for select members of Congress.
On the other side were some lawyers and officials at the largest American intelligence agency, which was battered by eavesdropping scandals in the 1970's and has since wielded its powerful technology with extreme care to avoid accusations of spying on Americans.
As in other areas of intelligence collection, including interrogation methods for terrorism suspects, Mr. Cheney and Mr. Addington took an aggressive view of what was permissible under the Constitution, the two intelligence officials said.
If people suspected of links to Al Qaeda made calls inside the United States, the vice president and Mr. Addington thought eavesdropping without warrants "could be done and should be done," one of them said.
He added: "That's not what the N.S.A. lawyers think."
The other official said there was "a very healthy debate" over the issue. The vice president's staff was "pushing and pushing, and it was up to the N.S.A. lawyers to draw a line and say absolutely not."
Both officials said they were speaking about the internal discussions because of the significant national security and civil liberty issues involved and because they thought it was important for citizens to understand the interplay between Mr. Cheney's office and the N.S.A. Both spoke favorably of General Hayden; one expressed no view on his nomination for the C.I.A. job, and the other was interviewed by The New York Times weeks before President Bush selected the general.
Mr. Cheney's spokeswoman, Lee Anne McBride, declined to discuss the deliberations about the classified program. "As the administration, including the vice president, has said, this is terrorist surveillance, not domestic surveillance," she said. "The vice president has explained this wartime measure is limited in scope and conducted in a lawful way that safeguards our civil liberties."
Representatives for the N.S.A. and for the general declined to comment.
Even with the N.S.A. lawyers' reported success in limiting its scope, the program represents a fundamental expansion of the agency's practices, one that critics say is illegal. For the first time since 1978, when the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act was passed and began requiring court approval for all eavesdropping on United States soil, the N.S.A. is intentionally listening in on Americans' calls without warrants.
The spying that would become such a divisive issue for the White House and for General Hayden grew out of a meeting days after the Sept. 11 attacks, when President Bush gathered his senior intelligence aides to brainstorm about ways to head off another attack.
"Is there anything more we could be doing, given the current laws?" the president later recalled asking.
General Hayden stepped forward. "There is," he said, according to Mr. Bush's recounting of the conversation in March during a town-hall-style meeting in Cleveland.
By all accounts, General Hayden was the principal architect of the plan. He saw the opportunity to use the N.S.A.'s enormous technological capabilities by loosening restrictions on the agency's operations inside the United States.
For his part, Mr. Cheney helped justify the program with an expansive theory of presidential power, which he explained to traveling reporters a few days after The Times first reported on the program last December.
Mr. Cheney traced his views to his service as chief of staff to President Gerald R. Ford in the 1970's, when post-Watergate changes, which included the FISA law, "served to erode the authority I think the president needs to be effective, especially in a national security area."
Senior intelligence officials outside the N.S.A. who discussed the matter in late 2001 with General Hayden said he accepted the White House and Justice Department argument that the president, as commander in chief, had the authority to approve such eavesdropping on international calls.
"Hayden was no cowboy on this," said another former intelligence official who was granted anonymity because it was the only way he would talk about a program that remains classified. "He was a stickler for staying within the framework laid out and making sure it was legal, and I think he believed that it was."
The official said General Hayden appeared particularly concerned about ensuring that one end of each conversation was outside the United States. For his employees at the N.S.A., whose mission is foreign intelligence, avoiding purely domestic eavesdropping appears to have been crucial.
But critics of the program say the law does not allow spying on a caller in the United States without a warrant, period ? no matter whether the call is domestic or international.
"Both would violate FISA," said Nancy Libin, staff counsel at the Center for Democracy and Technology, a civil liberties group.
Ms. Libin said limiting the intercepts without warrants to international calls "may have been a political calculation, because it sounds more reassuring."
One indication that the restriction to international communications was dictated by more than legal considerations came at a House hearing last month. Asked whether the president had the authority to order eavesdropping without a warrant on purely domestic communications, Attorney General Alberto R. Gonzales replied, "I'm not going to rule it out."
Despite the decision to focus on only international calls and e-mail messages, some domestic traffic was inadvertently picked up because of difficulties posed by cellphone and e-mail technology in determining whether a person was on American soil, as The Times reported last year.
And one government official, who had access to intelligence from the intercepts that he said he would discuss only if granted anonymity, believes that some of the purely domestic eavesdropping in the program's early phase was intentional. No other officials have made that claim.
A White House spokeswoman, Dana Perino, said Saturday, "N.S.A. has not intentionally listened in on domestic-to-domestic calls without a court order."
President Bush and other officials have denied that the program monitors domestic calls. They have, however, generally stated their comments in the present tense, leaving open the question of whether domestic calls may have been captured before the program's rules were fully established.
After the program started, General Hayden was the one who briefed members of Congress on it and who later tried to dissuade The Times from reporting its existence.
When the newspaper published its first article on the program in December, the general found himself on the defensive. He had often insisted in interviews and public testimony that the N.S.A. always followed laws protecting Americans' privacy. As the program's disclosure provoked an outcry, he had to square those assurances with the fact that the program sidestepped the FISA statute.
Nonetheless, General Hayden took on a prominent role in explaining and defending the program. He appeared at the White House alongside Mr. Gonzales, spoke on television and gave an impassioned speech at the National Press Club in January.
Some of the program's critics have found his visibility in defending a controversial presidential policy inappropriate for an intelligence professional. "There's some unhappiness at N.S.A. with Hayden taking such an upfront role," said Matthew M. Aid, an intelligence historian and former N.S.A. analyst who keeps in touch with some employees. "If the White House got them into this, why is Hayden the one taking the flak?"
But General Hayden seems determined to stand up for the agency's conduct ? and his own. In the press club speech, General Hayden recounted remarks he made to N.S.A. employees two days after the Sept. 11 attacks: "We are going to keep America free by making Americans feel safe again."
He said that the standards for what represented a "reasonable" intrusion into Americans' privacy had changed "as smoke billowed from two American cities and a Pennsylvania farm field."
"We acted accordingly," he said.
In the speech, General Hayden hinted at the internal discussion of the proper limits of the N.S.A. program. Although he did not mention Mr. Cheney or his staff, he said the decision to limit the eavesdropping to international phone calls and e-mail messages was "one of the decisions that had been made collectively."
"Certainly, I personally support it," General Hayden said.
President Defends Pick
WASHINGTON, May 13 (Bloomberg News) ? In his weekly radio address on Saturday, President Bush defended the qualifications of General Hayden to be C.I.A. director and sought to ease concern about the domestic eavesdropping program that the general helped create.
In General Hayden, "the men and women of the C.I.A. will have a strong leader who will support them as they work to disrupt terrorist attacks, penetrate closed societies and gain information that is vital to protecting our nation," Mr. Bush said.
He urged the Senate to confirm the general "promptly."
by deepsand
The New York Times
May 13, 2006
Questions Raised for Phone Giants in Spy Data Furor
By JOHN MARKOFF
The former chief executive of Qwest, the nation's fourth-largest phone company, rebuffed government requests for the company's calling records after 9/11 because of "a disinclination on the part of the authorities to use any legal process," his lawyer said yesterday.
The statement on behalf of the former Qwest executive, Joseph P. Nacchio, followed a report that the other big phone companies ? AT&T, BellSouth and Verizon ? had complied with an effort by the National Security Agency to build a vast database of calling records, without warrants, to increase its surveillance capabilities after the Sept. 11 attacks.
Those companies insisted yesterday that they were vigilant about their customers' privacy, but did not directly address their cooperation with the government effort, which was reported on Thursday by USA Today. Verizon said that it provided customer information to a government agency "only where authorized by law for appropriately defined and focused purposes," but that it could not comment on any relationship with a national security program that was "highly classified."
Legal experts said the companies faced the prospect of lawsuits seeking billions of dollars in damages over cooperation in the program, citing communications privacy legislation stretching back to the 1930's. A federal lawsuit was filed in Manhattan yesterday seeking as much as $50 billion in civil damages against Verizon on behalf of its subscribers.
For a second day, there was political fallout on Capitol Hill, where Senate Democrats intend to use next week's confirmation hearings for a new C.I.A. director to press the Bush administration on its broad surveillance programs.
As senior lawmakers in Washington vowed to examine the phone database operation and possibly issue subpoenas to the telephone companies, executives at some of the companies said they would comply with requests to appear on Capitol Hill but stopped short of describing how much would be disclosed, at least in public sessions.
"If Congress asks us to appear, we will appear," said Selim Bingol, a spokesman at AT&T. "We will act within the laws and rules that apply."
Qwest was apparently alone among the four major telephone companies to have resisted the requests to cooperate with the government effort. A statement issued on behalf of Mr. Nacchio yesterday by his lawyer, Herbert J. Stern, said that after the government's first approach in the fall of 2001, "Mr. Nacchio made inquiry as to whether a warrant or other legal process had been secured in support of that request."
"When he learned that no such authority had been granted, and that there was a disinclination on the part of the authorities to use any legal process," Mr. Nacchio concluded that the requests violated federal privacy requirements "and issued instructions to refuse to comply."
The statement said the requests continued until Mr. Nacchio left in June 2002. His departure came amid accusations of fraud at the company, and he now faces federal charges of insider trading.
The database reportedly assembled by the security agency from calling records has dozens of fields of information, including called and calling numbers and the duration of calls, but nothing related to the substance of the calls. But it could permit what intelligence analysts and commercial data miners refer to as "link analysis," a statistical technique for investigators to identify calling patterns in a seemingly impenetrable mountain of digital data.
The law governing the release of phone company data has been modified repeatedly to grapple with changing computer and communications technologies that have increasingly bedeviled law enforcement agencies. The laws include the Communications Act, first passed in 1934, and a variety of provisions of the Electronic Communications and Privacy Act, including the Stored Communications Act, passed in 1986.
Wiretapping ? actually listening to phone calls ? has been tightly regulated by these laws. But in general, the laws have set a lower legal standard required by the government to obtain what has traditionally been called pen register or trap-and-trace information ? calling records obtained when intelligence and police agencies attached a specialized device to subscribers' telephone lines.
Those restrictions still hold, said a range of legal scholars, in the face of new computer databases with decades' worth of calling records. AT&T created such technology during the 1990's for use in fraud detection and has previously made such information available to law enforcement with proper warrants.
Orin Kerr, a former federal prosecutor and assistant professor at George Washington University, said his reading of the relevant statutes put the phone companies at risk for at least $1,000 per person whose records they disclosed without a court order.
"This is not a happy day for the general counsels" of the phone companies, he said. "If you have a class action involving 10 million Americans, that's 10 million times $1,000 ? that's 10 billion."
The New Jersey lawyers who filed the federal suit against Verizon in Manhattan yesterday, Bruce Afran and Carl Mayer, said they would consider filing suits against BellSouth and AT&T in other jurisdictions.
"This is almost certainly the largest single intrusion into American civil liberties ever committed by any U.S. administration," Mr. Afran said. "Americans expect their phone records to be private. That's our bedrock governing principle of our phone system." In addition to damages, the suit seeks an injunction against the security agency to stop the collection of phone numbers.
Several legal experts cited ambiguities in the laws that may be used by the government and the phone companies to defend the National Security Agency program.
"There's a loophole," said Mark Rasch, the former head of computer-crime investigations for the Justice Department and now the senior vice president of Solutionary, a computer security company. "Records of phones that have called each other without identifying information are not covered by any of these laws."
Civil liberties lawyers were quick to dispute that claim.
"This is an incredible red herring," said Kevin Bankston, a lawyer for the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a privacy rights group that has sued AT&T over its cooperation with the government, including access to calling records. "There is no legal process that contemplates getting entire databases of data."
The group sued AT&T in late January, contending that the company was violating the law by giving the government access to its customer call record data and permitting the agency to tap its Internet network. The suit followed reports in The New York Times in December that telecommunications companies had cooperated with such government requests without warrants.
A number of industry executives pointed to the national climate in the wake of the Sept. 11 attacks to explain why phone companies might have risked legal entanglement in cooperating with the requests for data without warrants.
An AT&T spokesman said yesterday that the company had gotten some calls and e-mail messages about the news reports, but characterized the volume as "not heavy" and said there were responses on both sides of the issue.
Reaction around the country also appeared to be divided.
Cathy Reed, 45, a wealth manager from Austin, Tex., who was visiting Boston, said she did not see a problem with the government's reviewing call logs. "I really don't think it matters," she said. "I bet every credit card company already has them."
Others responded critically. Pat Randall, 63, a receptionist at an Atlanta high-rise, said, "Our phone conversations are just personal, and to me, the phone companies that cooperated, I think we should move our phone services to the company that did not cooperate."
While the telephone companies have both business contracts and regulatory issues before the federal government, executives in the industry yesterday dismissed the notion that they felt pressure to take part in any surveillance programs. The small group of executives with the security clearance necessary to deal with the government on such matters, they said, are separate from the regulatory and government contracting divisions of the companies.
Reporting for this article was contributed by Ken Belson, Brenda Goodman, Stephen Labaton, Matt Richtel and Katie Zezima.
by nicknielsen
Over the years, I've become convinced that many Republicans are closet fascists, based on their response to criticism of government policy during Republican presidencies or times of conflict:
- Love it or leave it.
- If you're not with us, you're a traitor.
- We know what's best for you.
These comments demonstrate to me that the person making them believes that the State is more important than the individual. That is definitely NOT the American way.
by x-marcap
by deepsand
just like last year's Penn State - Michigan football game.
The point is that we'll never what the true outcome would have been.
by deepsand
Nearly half are unable to locate major world countries on a globe or map; a disturbingly large number cannot even locate the US!
Most have never read the US Constitution; fewer still, that of their respective State.
I would much prefer that these people [b]not[/b] vote, but confine their electoral participation to watching the results as reported on tv.
by deepsand
the vast majority of the populace has'nt read it either.
The frightening aspect of this is that many claim to have not read it becaus they consider it irrelevant by virtue of its being merely a historical document.
by deepsand
This, from a story whose title and author I no longer recall:
1) People cast votes for policy proposals, not candidates for office.
2) All voters must record both the premises that they considered and their reasoning which led them to conclude to support or oppose a proposal, as well as the consequences that they foresaw of both its passage and defeat.
3) All voting records are public.
4) Governmental positions are filled by those whose predicted outcomes best match the realized ones.
5) The highest office is called the "Prime Predictor."
by deepsand
Try not to take it too badly.
Have a good weekend.
by deepsand
by ontheropes
by deepsand
who are far more knowledgeable in these matters than either of us, who hold otherwise.
Do understand that I do not hold that maintaining either liberty or security without the other is easily obtained. For a balanced analysis of such, see my below post, at
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=194614&messageID=2012936
by x-marcap
by deepsand
by x-marcap
It is time for you to think, If I agree with this crowd I have made a mistake.
Your allies in this viewpoint are Wesley Clark... Yuck, Nancy Pelosi, Ew!!!, Murtha, (I regret to say he was ever a Marine) and many of the Moonbat left.
by deepsand
by deepsand
Furthermore, I do recognize that balancing the need for securing both liberty and security is [b]not[/b] easily obtained. All the more reason to both insist and ensure that the law be followed.
For a balanced analysis re. this delicate balance, see
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=194614&messageID=2012936
As for Bush having his ass legally covered, I remain quite unconvinced. Cheney in fact advocated [b]not[/b] seeking warrants. See
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=194614&messageID=2012986
As for seeking to connect the dots, the difficulties in doing so make the potential payoff in this instance so small that it may have been unwise to risk the public trust. For more on this see
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=194614&messageID=2012984
by x-marcap
The resolution to procecute the War on terrorism put no limits to the actions, or should there be in a time of war...
An interesting tidbit is that there is no formal design for a declaration of war in the constitution... Virtually any joint resolution could be declaration of war if it recommends any action...
by x-marcap
The executive branch is the branch charged with determining the Foreign surveilance... It is a Liberal landmark that the executive branch was dumb enough to let the Legislative branch get in the way...
I think Carter was not only the worst President of the 20th century but the weakest... FISA was enacted in his term... Clinton ignored FISA. Bush at least paid it lip service for a while... Then
leaks came out of FISA...
The FISA judge who resigned and is disclosing information should be tried...
by x-marcap
Make this unquestionably in the perview of the Executive branch... Is it legal? the only question is did Congress authorize Bush to go after terrorists.
Since they did authorize actions and the use of the Military in a joint statement it is a Declaration of war...
by x-marcap
By the fourth grade...
It should be mandtory as civics classes used to be...
by av .
We are losing more rights everyday and Americans are not making their voices heard enough. We need to demand accountability of this government.
The Bush Administration operates in the shadows just like Al-Qaida and is incompetent to boot. Even if we are at war, I don't trust their intentions in any venue. If they wanted real security for this country, they would close our southern border.
I'm not sure if I'm more afraid of Al-Qaida or the Bush Administration. They're both pretty scary to me.
I have a couple of links.
Opinion: Why NSA spying puts the U.S. in danger
A former analyst looks at the agency's current controversy
Surveillance society: Growing daily?
by jdclyde
[i]""We have got to collect intelligence on the enemy." I fully agree. But the enemy numbers in the hundreds at best. "[/i]
The author believes there are only a few hundred terroritist? So much for crediblity?
by av .
Here is the context of that statement:
"I think Sen. Jon Kyl, a strong supporter of the NSA domestic spying program, said it best: "We have got to collect intelligence on the enemy." I fully agree. But the enemy numbers in the hundreds at best. the NSA is collecting data on hundreds of millions of people who are clearly not the enemy. These numbers speak for themselves."
I think he means there are more efficient ways to find the terrorists than this program. There may be only "hundreds (at best)" found through the domestic spying program, but there are better, more productive ways to use our resources. Instead, the NSA is collecting information on people who have done nothing wrong, with little gleaned as a result. I'd like to see just how many terrorists they found this way.
If they really want to make a difference, they should take control of our ports and borders. We have no idea who is in this country. Find out. What about people who have overstayed their visas? Use resources to track them down and start keeping better track of them.
I think the American people can do a better job than the NSA. Here's a true story. My friend lives in a condo community. Her fairly new neighbors seemed nice enough, a middle-eastern type couple and their grown son. They were very quiet. They didn't fit into the community though. Their blinds were always drawn. They never went out much. One day, one of the other neighbors ran into them unexpectedly as they were coming out of their door. Their door was open and she saw that they had no furniture after living there for almost a year! She thought something was funny about that and called the FBI. Shortly thereafter, they disappeared. No noise. No moving trucks. Just gone.
by x-marcap
The math would show you can perform higher mental functions...
I think it would be be interesting to combine both ideas... The military service shows your care and responsibility, and willingness to do the difficult the Math the weighting of your vote...
by x-marcap
by deepsand
The fact remains that the game on the field was never played in full.
And, no, there was no pending Constitutional "crisis," as the Constitution does [b]not[/b] require the swearing in of a President by a date certain. In fact, this would not have been the 1st time that such had not occurred.
Do not fall into the trap of believing that I hold Gore to have been the winner in Florida, but only that I and others do not know, and will nver know, with certainty.
by deepsand
by deepsand
Please see my post at below, and then give me your honest assessment of the correlation between military service and being an informed and thoughtful voter.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=194614&messageID=2013787
by deepsand
by Phil Ochs, particularly the version record by Jim & Jean?
excerpts -
"The spanish bulls are beaten; the crowd is soon beguiled.
The matador is beautiful, a symphony of style;
Excitement is estatic, passion places bets;
Gracefully he bows to ovations that he gets;
But the hands that are applauding are slippery with sweat,
And saliva is falling from their smiles"
"And the cross is trembling with desire."
by deepsand
And, bear in mind that Bush was a National Guard officer, who, despite his low score on the pilot's aptitude test (a 25, the lowest score allowed), was [i]sworn in as an airman the day he applied.[/i]"
Yes, he may have been a pilot, but, so what?
by deepsand
not international ones.
The present furor is regarding calls which both originated and terminated within the US.
As for a Declaration of War, the definition of such is far from being as clear and precise as you would hold. See
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Declaration_of_war_by_the_United_States
by deepsand
In particular, it was the illegal spying by the CIA and FBI on US citizens, within the US, that led to the formation of the so called Church committee, which ultimately inspired the FISA and FISC.
Re. Church committee, see
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Church_Committee
Re. FISA, see
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_Intelligence_Surveillance_Act
[b]FISA[/b], enacted in 1978, [b]predates Clinton[/b] by many years. Furthermore, his use or abuse of it is irrelevant to the present matter.
by x-marcap
You don't hand the bilge pump to somebody who is retarded or suicidal. That is what happens with the liberal on the FISA. It is extra constitutional. It is not one of the District or appellate courts. It is made up by Congress to limit or direct executive power and answerable to Congress, the worst leakers of the bunch.
I hope they try Rockefeller and Durbin for their actions... Let a jury decide if what they did damaged US actions against the terrorists, or gave them comfort.
by deepsand
strict construction or that of implied power.
You take issue with the attempt(s) by "[i]Congress to limit or direct executive power [/i]." In fact, it was the intent of our Founders that Congress in fact have such power to keep the Executive in check.
Furthermore, for the Executive to claim powers over and above those [b]specifically[/b] granted him by either the Constitution or Congress is a claim grounded in the doctrine of implied powers; yet, from other posts of yourself, you have given the impression that you are a strict constructionist.
How do you reconcile these seemingly contradictory stances?
by x-marcap
I am also a pragmatist at some level.
If my neighbor Saladin wants to go on a AK47 spree, I merely want to be warned in time to get my .55 caliber Boys out of the safe, chamber a round and protect my family.
When his safety come off, He is in the X ring... If the law was broken to get the info I am not as concerned about the surveilance as 7.62 lead flying in my general direction. First things First.
1. Aim.
2. Fire,
3. Clean your weapon.
4. Hide it somewhere it will never be found.
5. Look very concerned.
6. Explain that most of the 45 propane canisters aren't full. and that it takes 2 shots to set one off. one regular round to puncture and one tracer round.
by deepsand
I will, however, add the point that [b]no[/b] Congressional resolution stands superior in all regards to prior law.
The "Congress granted ..." argument just does'nt cut it.
by nicknielsen
I've seen it too, including some letters signed by senior officers that would have made a teacher shriek. The American military is a microcosm of American society: therefore, the ignorance and laziness of the general public is reproduced on a smaller scale. The only difference is the neat toys.
As far as testing voters, in my experience, solving quadratic equations might be too complex for most Americans today. How about finding their rear ends with their hands tied behind their backs? We could get at least a 25% success rate with that one.
by nicknielsen
From Merriam-Webster: a political philosophy, movement, or regime (as that of the Fascisti) that exalts nation and often race above the individual and that stands for a centralized autocratic government headed by a dictatorial leader, severe economic and social regimentation, and forcible suppression of opposition
From The American Heritage Dictionary: A system of government that exercises a dictatorship of the extreme right, typically through the merging of state and business leadership, together with belligerent nationalism.
Don't see no socialism in there! Fascism is, by either definition, as anti-socialist as you can get.
by x-marcap
It is amazing how bad that definition is...
What it got right was central control...
and a dictatorial leader, severe economic and social regimentation, and forcible suppression of opposition. It is 180 degress wrong in it coming from the extreme right.
Italy was socialist and Fascist under Mussolini.
Nazi Germany was Socialist and Fascistic.
So was Argentina under Peron.
The problem is to become a dictatorship you need overwhelming support, that comes from the people... Then you can become state centered and control the means of production.
Fascism in implementation always has come out of a socialist movement, historically. It really isn't right wing. That is a poor definition if it doesn't recognize the root situation... The USSR was cretainly fascistic as is Cuba.
Don't believe everything you read. Just because an total idiot wrote that definition, you need look at the best examples, and make sure it fits the definition...
by nicknielsen
So sorry to confuse you with facts, but I believe you are confusing populism and socialism.
Edit: clarify
by jdclyde
I don't WANT it in the news.
If you have a way to catch them, and then advertise on the news the way we will catch them, how many do you think this will catch? The reporting of what would be effective ways to catch the terrorists only undermines our security and should be treated as the treason that it is.
As for the phone logs, I do have a theory about that. If they KNOW they will not be able to find the needle in that hay stack, what better way to block that avenue than to let the terrorists KNOW they are listening so they will stop using that method of contact? Sounds like the only thing that makes sence and is great thinking.
They WERE monitoring cell phones to look for ben laden until dumbass reporters tipped benny off to it by reporting it. Accident? You decide.
As for sleeper cells, a single family that is clean cut living in a white neighborhood is more likely than in the muslim communites, as per documentation taken from raided terrorist training camps. The muslims living in a nation are less likely to be sympathetic to a plan to launch a terrorist attack.
by deepsand
by jdclyde
on why they would allow this to get out like they did.
Also, it drives me nuts then people think they "have a right to know" everything that is being done.
The reporters were going nuts when they weren't told in advance where we were going to do OPs. People seem to forget that the enemy listens to the news too.
and Sandy, I would say for most, they never knew.
by av .
I, didn't know MY phone was tapped! I would be very surprised to catch any terrorist of value with this method of intelligence gathering.
I'm kind of mixed on the disclosure of the program on the news. On the one hand, I think it is a breach of the public trust by the government, but then I understand what it's disclosure to the public means to national security.
I would have felt better about it if Bush did it with a warrant. There should always be oversight from the courts.
Did you see this on eweek? http://www.eweek.com/article2/0,1759,1965853,00.asp?kc=EWMS102049TX1K0100487 I didn't read the entire document, but what I did read bothers me.
They didn't know a couple of years ago, but they damn sure know now.
Isn't that just great?
by deepsand
I'd say 21.428571%, tops.
Query: What's so perfect about this number?
We could give them bonus points for the correct answer.
by x-marcap
Look at the charges that were laid at FDR about using St. Elizabeth's asylum as a prison without trial for leakers...
He pointed to the all enemies foreign and domestic with his cigarette holder in 1943...
That was even more insidious than looking at phone records. Look at the internment of the Japanese Americans. Don't say there is no precedence. FDR had the mail opened.
by deepsand
by x-marcap
The one thing that Heinlein asserted was that if you put your keister on the line for the body politic, you should have the stake in it. I know of only a few who have served who don't vote.
There are exceptions, of course, but then we would have less stupidity if the Math suggestion was implemented. Rarely is someone who can prove they can do that level of Math going to vote for the Bread and Circusses that we now have coming out of Congress.
If we recognize that it is a conflict of interest for a lawyer to be in Congress, or prevented them from returning to law practice, or ban them from being a lobbyist, we'd eliminate much of the corruption, and the old boy network...
by deepsand
How do you reconcile your position here with the fact that ex-servicemen are no more informed and well reasoned than others, as witnessed by the perviously mention posts on boards such as military.com?
And, how many ex-servicemen truly put their live on the line. In fact, I would suggest that firemen consistently put themselves at greater risk than does the average serviceman.
by deepsand
If I did such, I could conclude that you and Max are "allies," a position that I do not hold.
People and positions are distinctly different entities.
by deepsand
how many would truly [i]understand[/i]?
I long ago gave up the notion of ever being able to "make sense of it [i]all[/i]." I figure it's a good day when I can make some sense of just that small portion that impacts my life. Anything beyond that is a bonus, and cause for celebration.
by nicknielsen
"If we recognize that it is a conflict of interest for a lawyer to be in Congress, or prevented them from returning to law practice, or ban them from being a lobbyist, we'd eliminate much of the corruption, and the old boy network..."
I actually agree with you here. We need to do something, but what? And even if we ever come up with a solution most can agree on, it will be almost impossible to get it through both houses of Congress (See Ethics improvement bills, 1978-2006) and even two-thirds of the various statehouses would be difficult.
But there is that third method that might work if enough people were to actually quit bitching and stand up for something.
by x-marcap
If you get all the info and achieve the wrong answer consistantly, that is a Goofus MacDuff.
I think in this case you are floating close to that line.
If I ever agree with ALGORE, I rethink my position. He is as close to Goofus as you can be and still breath.(but he hasn't though about that, yet)
by x-marcap
If you get all the info and achieve the wrong answer consistantly, that is a Goofus MacDuff.
I think in this case you are floating close to that line.
If I ever agree with ALGORE, I rethink my position. He is as close to Goofus as you can be and still breathe.(but he hasn't though about that, yet)
Sort by Trending