Discussion Locked

What do you think of all the big brother stuff?

0 helpful
624 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The US Justice Department confirmed yesterday that Microsoft, Yahoo! and AOL have already complied with its request to hand over the details of queries submitted to the search engine - a fact that was disclosed in court documents this week. The DoJ wants the information, not for a criminal prosecution, but as background material to bolster its attempt to revive a Clinton-era anti-pornography law.
This is from http://www.theregister.co.uk/2006/01/21/gonzales_vs_google/
It looks like the government is looking at what ever they want and using what ever they can to do it. I hate child porn and anyone who looks at it and they should be put behind bars! But refering to this now is lame and just another way to see what we are doing.
What do you think?

624 replies

by av .

Most definitely, Google, AOL, Yahoo and Microsoft have a treasure trove of information about all of us. I don't think the government should be allowed to data mine this information to bolster a porn law. No one likes child porn, but I don't like my right to privacy being violated either.

It certainly makes me think twice about what I might search on on the internet. Maybe I could be the next "person of interest" if I search on the wrong words.

The truth is, you don't know what the government will really do with the information. I don't trust the government's intentions and I don't like losing the right to be free to search on what I want without them looking over my shoulder.

I also don't agree with Bush's wiretaps without warrants either. He says its necessary to fight the war on terror, I say if he really wanted to fight the war on terror he would do something about our open borders and our illegal immigrant population, aside from offering them temporary worker permits.

Hats off to Google. Finally, a company thats willing to defend the right to privacy for its customers. I'm truly surprised that the others were so willing to comply. Maybe they forgot what country they're in.

by mjwx

First of all Kudos to AmericanVoter more people need to take a stand against this kind of invasion of privacy.

Second of all, the information the US gov has requested contains a great deal of data on people outside the US. This is something the US gov defiantly has no right to do (it can even go so far as to be considered espionage).

To keep it in perspective this isn?t like placing CCTV cameras in public places (these have actual helped solve crimes) or confiscating computers that contain kiddie porn. The US will have access to all searches not just the ones related to this law (which again only exists in the US). How can we be sure that the US gov is not also looking for ?Subversive Content? (I am also attacking china for doing this but at least they admit doing it).

Can a society maintain its freedom when a government is permitted to conduct searches without reasonable proof of any wrong doings?

?The only thing necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing? - Edmund Burke

by m_a_r_k

[i]"the information the US gov has requested contains a great deal of data on people outside the US. This is something the US gov defiantly [sic] has no right to do."[/i]

I disagree. I'm not saying the govt does or does not have the right to any search engine information. But suppose they DO have this right. Then, with Google being an American company traded on an American stock exchange and operating within the US, the govt certainly would have every right to access data regardless if that data was generated by a US citizen or not and generated from inside the US borders or not. Since when does being a foreign citizen give you higher standing than American citizens when American laws and regulations are concerned?

by av .

To be honest with you, I never really thought about how people outside the US would be affected by this, but you're absolutely right. We're a global society now, especially when it comes to the internet. Governments work together, so this affects all of us.

Like you say, the whole problem is how the US government will use the information. Personally, I don't trust them to use the data the right way. All I see is my rights as an American slipping away.

What really gets me is that there isn't a revolt in this country. There should be absolute outrage that we are losing our right to privacy. Instead, most people aren't even aware of what they're losing. Apathy. Disinterest. Loss of rights is always because of the war on terror. I just don't buy it.

This is such an important issue. Americans will lose basic rights if they don't stand up to the challenge. Otherwise, welcome to the United States of China.

by xgi

I was with you until the last paragraph. The "Hats off to Google" remark makes my blood curl. As an elder in the IT community and an ex Marine, I am tired of hearing people automatically assume our government is up to no good whenever they do something we don?t understand.

Here is what I understand: the basic function of government is to protect its people. There are a tremendous number of people in this world that would rather see us gone. I also understand that recently Google launched a search engine in China. The Google.cn version of their product is helping to enforce the Chinese governments? censorship of ?material about human rights?, as reported in our local newspaper. The ?cn? suffix is reserved for official Chinese government sites. Any search pertaining to ?democracy?, ?human rights?, or anything else the Chinese government deems subversive to its cause are redirected to official government sites.

I must assume Google entered into this business arrangement to increase its profit margin. So perhaps they would not comply with our governments requests because there wasn?t any profit in it.

I also know that if there was one US citizen that has been damaged by our governments anti terrorist activities, we would see that person in every news medium available, every day. I haven't seen that.

by absolutely

"I also know that if there was one US citizen that has been damaged by our governments anti terrorist activities, we would see that person in every news medium available, every day."

How do you know that? Wiretaps do not make the phone click, or the Internet "hiccup" or leave any other observables to the parties being tapped. THAT'S WHY THEY WORK! So how would somebody know that any damage they suffered was caused by an illegal wiretap?

The only way to learn about abuses of government power is via a whistle-blower who still understands that laws exist for a reason, and that the reason for the Constitution is to keep individuals from becoming too powerful even when they are employed by the government.

Finally, why should I care that you're an ex Marine? As a citizen of the United States, I am tired of former soldiers who treat their military experience as a trump card in every discussion. In this discussion, past employment by the government only calls your objectivity and credibility into question.

by pete russell

I think the busch administration is forgetting what america is built upon. FREEDOM!! I feel like we are not free any more and that we are being punished for a bunch of losers actions.

I get mad when I hear about children being exploited BUT I should not have my freedoms taken away because of it. I agree that it is not right I have to worry about what I search on.

I Applaud google for taken there Users privacy seriously.

by kniht

I have been on this planet since the Truman presidency, and every administration from then on has been guilty of some sort of spying. Jimmy Carter - 1978, Bill Clinton - 1994 (Bill authorized the physical breakin and search of private homes without warrants!) I hate to see this discussion turn into "Bush Bashing", study real American History and lets bash them all.
I was 13 years old and remember John Kennedy at a speech in, I think, Berkley when he stated, and I quote "The office of the President was created to destroy the American people, I must bring this plight to the people." Ten days later John Kennedy was shot dead in Dallas.
We Americans need to keep our minds open and not cloud our thinking with hate for one administration or another, or we will be destroyed by the very government we elect.

by absolutely

The US "Justice Department", that is, and any other fearmongers pretending that the cure to rape and sexual abuse of children involves spying on law-abiding citizens.

Once the pictures or videos have been taken the most important crime has already occurred -- the damage to the victim occurs in the predatory sexual act, not in the transmission of the images. Surveillance of the transmission of those pictures misses the point. The only solution to sex crime is cultural. As long as being a victim of abuse is taboo, reporting will be less frequent than abuse. As long as the public employees in the "justice" system treat delayed reports of abuse with suspicion instead of concern, they don't deserve the trust bestowed to their positions. Instead of asking "Why didn't you report this sooner" police should be encouraging immediate reporting and reminding plaintiffs that they did nothing wrong. The incompetence and immorality to which I've only alluded above is well known and pervasive in this country. That system certainly cannot be trusted with more power over private citizens until it learns to wield responsibly -- uniformly, at every level -- the power already assigned to it. We don't give kids their driving licenses until they've proved themselves responsible with a learner's permit. What morons put more faith in the anonymous strangers in government than in their own offspring?

This example of expansion of government power into one more medium is inexcusable, as in previous cases, because the government has already failed miserably to effectively and morally exercise the power it already had.

by jdclyde

did you recycle this from a different board or just forget it is "[" and "]" here?

Just asking.

This also does sound very similar to a post you did about a month or so ago?

Are you really recycling or just repeating yourself?

by absolutely

but only plastic, paper, that sort of thing. If I repeat myself here, it's only because I'm trying to make the same point a second time. I type fast enough that I don't actually copy and paste, though.

I just forgot that we use [] instead of <> here. Thanks.

by jck

I'm opposed to the law enforcement and government administration circumventing or "getting around on a technicality" of the legal process established to do it in the legal manner.

If I'd been president, taps would have been done legally. And if I found out ANYONE under my employ broke the law, they'd be summarily fired and I'd present the evidence to law enforcement and direct them to pursue charges.

Law is there to be followed by everyone, or changed if it is found not to be fair and just.

Not to be followed only by those who don't have a way around it.

by noyoki

wiretaps are legal now (if you were president), anyone can do them? I can spy on you too? Gates can spy on Jobs? Hmm... I'm confused...

by jck

to the government thing...where Bush's own investigators were not getting court approval to tap communications mediums as they were legally supposed to.

I think it'd be funny if the head of the DOJ just were to walk out one day and say "You're wrong. You've committed a crime." and had U.S. Marshals arrest all the guys who were involved.

I'd laugh my ass off.

Neither position, nor appointment, nor affluence...should give you a free pass on circumventing the law.

by absolutely

Shall I keep ringing?

Republicans have not been emphasizing small government for several years. Definitely nothing like they did when led by Newt Gingrich. I'm so sad that I miss him.

:(

by mjwx

?And this from the party that professes its desire to get government out of peoples' lives.?

Maybe they meant "we want to keep average people from interfering in our governance"?

I find that a major problem with the Australian government is that it has become not only out of touch with the average Australian but inaccessible to the average Australian. Most people don?t know who their MP (member of parliament) is let alone how to contact him/her. Once apon a time poly?s (politicians) would travel seeking to communicate with the average Australian. Now it seems they will only sit in party meetings with their supporters and bash the opposition.

This is my view of the Australian political landscape, but it seems to me (looking in from the outside) that the US and UK gov?s are in similar states.

by jdclyde

you will continue to to convict "all the guys who were involved" based on nothing more than what is fed to you through the news?

I thought you were one of the "innocent until proven guilty" guys? Or does that only apply to people you like?

I also thought you were smart enought to know that you never get the full, NOR clear story through the media. EVER.

Doesn't matter, because it fits right in with everything you have WANTED to believe anyways.

Enjoy your crusifiction. Try not to look so gleeful as you do it though....

by bcramer

i think your not paying attention to what the news is feeding you. If you remember right, the President him self stated that he didn't have time to get the required search warrents that were needed becdause it would slow things down. SO! I say whats good for the goose is good for the gander. What puts him above the law??

by jdclyde

Will just have to see how this shakes out, but I don't for a second believe that we are getting the whole story.

If congress really was informed of this, I don't know what the impact on all this is.

I do know that if it wasn't a person that jck and many others HATE, they would be calling waiting until he has had his day in court. (that was my point all along)

by jdclyde

It goes to the courts where they have to be proven "beyond a reasonable doubt" blah blah blah.

You don't know how the US legal system works yet? :D

The key wasn't that I was saying he didn't do anything, but that if it wasn't someone hated by the left, the same people screaming for his head on a pike would instead be demanding to wait until he has had his day in court.

Now you know, what the therefor is.

by jck

Bush went on TV and admitted they (the NSA) did it and with his approval...but insisted it was not illegal even though none of the 30 times he reauthorized it, it never went through the FISA Court for approval as is LEGALLY required.

There was no judicial review for those taps. Bush admitted that openly...and was even so bold to say that he would continue doing it. Others in the government have also confirmed it had happened.

So, you have free admittance of it from multiple sources in multiple departments.

And, please don't jest the man doesn't know he could take the 5th...he can't be *that* stupid...can he?

That means they committed a breach of judicially established process. And whether that is law, regulation or code...it is illegal to breach that process.

Now, are you saying they should be above the law simply because they (the NSA) are investigative personnel who are doing work approved by the president and with no regard to judiciarily established legal process?

I'm not trying to crucify anyone. I'm simply saying...if you break a law...you should pay for it...especially when you get on TV and grin about it when you answer you approved it and say you'll approve it again even though it breaks the legal process they are supposed to follow.

Sorry man...Bush ordered them to break the law...they broke the law...why shouldn't they be punished like any other American?

Don't worry about it...if it did lead to his impeachment, Cheney would pardon him.

by jdclyde

If I understand correctly, and as you have yourself stated, there were "loopholes" that were used to get around this. While you may not like loopholes, it doesn't make them illegal, maing your entire argument invalid.

Now, do you want to talk about loopholes?

Oh and about impeachment, you know that is just bs talk and ONLY to try to get revenge for the impeachment of Americas first black president.

Also, you seem to forget, impeachment does NOT remove you from office, NEEDING to be pardoned for anything. I know, you were just trying to be cute. Better luck next time. Maybe you should leave the humor to me or your pop? ;\

by tonythetiger

since he did it without the FISA court. Or, as they say in southern Ohio: "It ain't illegal unless you're doin' time for it!"

by jck

The NSA was in breach of established legal process that requires approval of taps from the FISA Court when they deployed them.

Bush's approval to move forward with those taps without FISA Court approval was also a breach of the establish legal process that is required for such programs.

Henceforth, Bush and NSA personnel broke legal process...whether law, regulation or code.

Therefore, there should be adequate punishment for the illegal activity in which those who participated in all were involved.

Is that clear enough?

Have a nice day

by maxwell edison

All you're doing is repeating the rhetoric of your Democrat Party buddies. Until a "ruling" by a legitimate legal authority is announced, just because you might say it's illegal, it doesn't mean that it is.

You guys have trouble differentiating between political rhetoric and fact; and all too often you try to get away with passing-off the former as the latter.

by mjwx

I'm sure knowing what teenage asian slut$ are up to is of vital importance to national security

by derryck

Big Brother is Watching!

With regard for the concern about the Federal government wanting permission to conduct espionage upon the private lives of Americans, and anyone they deem a terrorist or terror suspect.

This is my TAKE on this issue:

No government or private enterprise has the right or authority to peek into the private affairs of citizens or customers without their permission, (written-oral or implied). With the advent of the National Patriot Act-2002, the Federal government have used this Act., to un-scrupulously peek into the lives and affairs of citizens "willy nilly," and without their prior knowledge.

Now that they were found snooping, and 'the cat is out of the bag,' The White House administration is adamant about this infringement on people's privacy. And has the temerity to say to the American people, that these action/s were done in the national security interest.

Oh give me a break!

Snooping into the affairs of anyone is wrong, malicious, evil, contemptuous, and disregards the civil liberties to personal privacy.

On Shanti.
Derryck S. Griffith.
Educator & Advocate.
Greenwich Village.
New York City.

by maxwell edison

While I am a privacy advocate and a passionate civil libertarian, I'm also a realist, realizing that nothing is absolute.

You said, "Snooping into the affairs of anyone is wrong, malicious, evil, contemptuous, and disregards the civil liberties to personal privacy."

Is this an "absolute" sentiment on your part? And if so, how would law enforcement agencies investigate suspected criminals -- rapists, murderers, and embezzlers, for example -- or are you suggesting they should not? The same applies to investigating suspected terrorists.

Personally speaking, I see the Internal Revenue Service as posing more of a threat on privacy and civil liberties than almost all other government agencies combined.

(By the way, welcome to the TR forums.)

by too old for it

I agree with you about the IRS. I heard a guest on one of the local radio talk shows express the opinion that all talk about campaign reform is a joke until you shut off the tax spigot.

I am a huge privacy advocate and take it one step further: Who the blazes are we to say that something perfectly legal in another part of the globe is illegal simply because the internet / phone / radio / TV / snail-mail brought it here?

I remember the big dust-up over Club Seventeen in Holland, where the legal age for photographing ? naked teens and posting said images on the internet is lower than the US. I notice, with some bemusement, that the US government has not succeeded in shutting them down or blocking their sites from US internet users.

The government likely doesn't care even now, unless it involves a politician or activist that needs to be made to heel like a proper lap dog.

(Maxwell, nice to see you out here again.)

by bcramer

you have an interesting outlook on the law. I'll remember to use your analogy of breaking the law the next time I get stopped for speeding.

by jck

which I purposefully defined for you in the last post to you (because I knew you'd nit-pick), there were no loopholes...they were caught red-handed. The FBI and DOJ used loopholes in the past...but not in the case of the NSA that came out in November/December 2005 timeframe.

You seem to try and find loopholes too in arguments to make your case...glad I've caught onto your rhetorical cat-and-mouse debate game. Good republican zealot...good good republican zealot...GOTCHA! :^O

As for impeachment, removal is part of the established process of impeaching a president from office. Therefore, you are wrong. Otherwise, why would an impeachment process exist?
And I quote:

[i]"The President, Vice President and all civil officers of the United States, shall be removed from office on impeachment for, and conviction of, treason, bribery, or other high crimes and misdemeanors."

--U.S. Constitution, Article 2, Section 4[/i]

just let that run through your head for a minute

...shall be removed from office on impeachment for...

Impeachment *is* the process by which you remove a sitting president.

You're talking about the "impeachment inquiry" where they basically inquiry and then decide whether or not to accuse the president and get a trial in the senate.

By the way you think things are, looks like you've been reading too many newspapers.

The process of impeachment is TWO PART...and involves the hearings by the House of Representatives inquiry, and trial and possible removal by Senate vote on the grounds of the president being found guilty by the Senate "trial" as overseen by the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court.

let me line it out for you...in simple terms so maybe you can get more than a Limbaugh-esque understanding of how impeachment works:

The House Judiciary Committee deliberates over whether to initiate an impeachment inquiry.

Then, said Judiciary Committee makes resolution seeking authority from the entire House of Representatives to conduct an inquiry.

The Judiciary Committee then holds the impeachment inquiry. At the end of it, articles of impeachment are prepared and require approval by majority of the committee.

Finally, the House of Representatives debates the articles. Each article requires a majority vote of the entire House to pass.

Once an article is approved, the Senate holds trial on the articles of impeachment approved by the House. The Senate sits as a jury, and the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court presides over the trial.

At the end of the trial, the Senate votes on whether to remove the President from office, requiring a two thirds vote for removal.

Saying you have been impeached a president after the House moves the Senate to try him...is like a prosecutor saying they're convicting a criminal when they file the indictment with the court.

Also, there have been supreme court decisions also stating subsequent to the writing of the United States Constitution that the sole power of impeachment does not lie with either body of the legislature...but, the legislature as a WHOLE. So under legal finding as well, neither body of legislation can "impeach" a president.

This has been your civics lecture for the day.

As for America's first black president, I assume you're referring to Clinton.

I don't know if you think he's black cause you looked at his willie (get it...slick Willie? that's funny) or if you're tryin to be slick (there I go again! :^O)...but...

a) You need some new glasses.
b) Clinton is about as black as Bush is smart.

As for humour...I'll leave that to Bush, seeing as he seems to be a big joke in almost every country in the world...including his own. ;)

I encourage you though...keep backing Bush. It's good for the economy...guys like Leno and Limbaugh wouldn't have a job without him. :^O

by maxwell edison

I offered no analogy, at least not according to my definition of the word. Your speeding example, however, is an analogy. And since you offered that analogy, I'll comment on it.

If you get pulled over for speeding, but you weren't violating any speeding laws, I sure hope you speak up. And if there's a disagreement on whether or not you were, in fact, speeding, then here come da' judge; here come da' judge.....

And in the case brought up in this discussion, I'll wait for "da' judge" to speak up, rather than listen to a bunch of partisan politicians.

(Due credit given to the late great Flip Wilson.)

by jck

understanding legal establishment of authority in government.

I encourage you to go read about the establishment of the FISA Court and what it has jurisdiction over the approval of under its legal establishment within the government.

Then, go back and deny Bush [b]admitted[/b] to approving it, re-approving it "30 plus" times, and said he'd keep doing it in a December press conference.

His comments are even on the White House website. Go look for yourself. December 17th, 2005.

Also, it would have been okay if he or the NSA notified them (the FISA CourT) of it happening within 72 hours. According to several sources, that never happened either.

After you have read all that, come back and tell me what you found and deny neither Bush nor the NSA did wrong in approving and using those wiretaps that require the approval of the FISA Court, and never subsequently informed the FISA Court within 72 hours as they are supposed to do.

Civics and governmental process class #2 of the day is now done.

You and jdclyde go compare notes now and see if you both understand how the wiretapping process through the FISA works for the NSA...ok? ;)

BTW...damn I'm glad my father worked with the government. :^O

by maxwell edison

I didn't post my message in an attempt to persuade you to change your mind. That won't happen, and I'm not even gonna' try.

I posted for the benefit of others who might be reading this, to give them some different perspective. I state again, just because YOU and/or your Democrat Party loonies CLAIM that illegalities are taking place, it doesn't make it so.

Care to wager on the outcome of the upcoming Senate hearings on the matter? Senate hearings, by the way, that President Bush welcomes. This will be just like all the other false, hollow, and obviously partisan charges levied against President Bush. Nothing will come of it, and it will soon make way for the next smear campaign of the day.

I recently watched some pretty extensive interviews conducted by PBS's Jim Lehrer on this very issue. He interviewed both Attorney General Alberto Gonzalez (Republican) and Vermont's Senator Patrick Leahy (Democrat). The attorney general was much more persuasive than the senator. And one thing that struck me very odd about Senator Leahy's answers was his incessant suggestion that this is ONLY about capturing Osama bin Laden, while conveniently overlooking the tens of thousands of other terrorists intent on destroying America.

And in the spirit of being open to sharing BOTH sides of the issues:

Senator Leahy's interview:

http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/law/jan-june06/leahy_1-23.html

Attorney General Gonzalez's interview:

http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/law/jan-june06/gonzales_1-23.html

You're too full of yourself, jck, for me to go round-and-round with you. You're a first-class, know-it-all, bore with nothing but left-speak spewing from your partisan mouth. And like I said, I won't change your mind, so I won't even try. The links are for the "open minded" among us -- and that ain't you.

by stargazerr

The Goverment will have every right to monitor a non US citizen if he/she is generating data inside US borders but they do not have the right to monitor data generated outside the US borders.

Any data generated outside US borders will come under the jurisdiction of the courts of the country the person belongs to. American Laws are only applicable within american borders, not outside.

]:)

P.S I just think monitoring a search engine is wrong. Full Stop.

by m_a_r_k

...monitoring a search engine is wrong. I'm not sure how useful it would be for any government to be able to obtain records of searches made on a search engine. They can't trace any search to any single individual. They could only trace it to an IP address. If I have 9 criminals living in my house and we each have 9 criminal friends that visit on a regular basis and all 100 of us use the Internet from my house, how can it be proven which of the 99 criminals used the Internet at any point in time to commit a crime (that rhymes!)? Notice I didn't say 100 criminals. The one person of the lot that's not a criminal is me.

I only used an American company and American laws in my post because the subject is about Google, an American company. You could substitute Ericsson and Sweden or Sony and Japan and the point would have been the same. I have a lot of college degrees ;) but a law degree isn't one of them. When you said "Any data generated outside US borders will come under the jurisdiction of the courts of the country the person belongs to", were you saying that based on knowledge or opinion? If the US govt can't force Google to turn over search records, then a foreign country has no chance at all of doing so. I suppose all this e-commerce stuff is new territory even for legal experts. Transactions over the internet have to be viewed and regulated differently than transactions made in person. The main question appears to be this: if you commit an illegal act over the Internet, who has jurisdiction? The location from which the person made the transaction or the location which electronically processed the transaction? The point I was making was that, if it were up to me, I would say the country with jurisdiction over the electronic records should be the country in which the transaction was electronically processed. In reality, if such laws exist, it may depend on agreements between the two countries. The data is still held in one location. Who has jurisdiction over that data?

This may all turn out to be a good thing for an enterprising criminal. Which I am not, by the way. I already told you that I am not a criminal. I may be enterprising but I'm no criminal. President Richard Nixon said he wasn't a criminal but look where that got him. He resigned in disgrace. But I digress... Let's use you as an example. You're a gangster, aren't you? ;) If you were a citizen of, say Tahiti (I'd love to go to scuba diving in Tahiti some day, but I'm digressing again...), and you used Google to commit a crime in the US, you would get away with it scot-free. Tahiti cannot force Google to provide information from its database because Tahiti laws do not have jurisdiction over an American company. And the US cannot get information about the crime from Google because it was made from a foreign country by a foreign citizen. Hmm... I think we're on to something here... :D

I think I just wrote a chapter of that book... :^O

by stargazerr

Sure ... I'll play along :D

If I am a citizen of Tahiti and use google to commit a crime in the US, I will not get away scot free. The crime has been committed in US ... The US courts have the right to trial a non US citizen, if the crime is commited inside the US borders ... But, only because Google is a US company, the government of USA has no jurisdiction over non US citizens,if the crime has not been commited in the US ....

Knowledge or Opinion?? Lets say ..... A bit of both :x

]:)

by absolutely

I would have assumed you meant that some "fair and balanced" reporter always has all the right answers. I'm glad I asked!

It's true that depending on whether corruption occurs on the "Right" or the "Left" certain people agitate for swift, harsh justice or for slow, deliberate investigation. In fact, they all get their thorough investigation followed by their tedious, evasive days in court.

Not only do I know how the US legal system works, I know pretty well how lawmakers and journalists avoid work!

:D

by absolutely

Although admittedly I haven't heard GWB's answer to the following: Bush asked for legislation allowing the NSA et al to skip the FISA courts, and was refused. Asking permission is an implicit admission of a need for permission, which he didn't get. He has now admitted to the very action for which he asked permission, but was refused. That makes good sense to me, and I haven't seen Bush or any member of his administration address that specific argument. I don't mean to say that I know that they haven't, but if they have, it was not aired or re-aired during one of the times that I was watching C-SPAN. I'm [b]extremely[/b] eager to hear how they will answer that!

[title edited for clarity]

by jck

First of all, you chastise me because you claim I'm the know-it-all and blindly partisan, when you and others sit here and do nothing but same...chastise the Democratic party and the liberal left partisanly in a highly-biased, self-important manner.

Your demeanor and tone, and those of select others, show that you simply think your views on topics to be matter-of-fact and that your references are the singular point of fact for others to consider and live by.

I have often addressed the wrong doings of others, including Democrats, who had done wrong. In fact, I'd be glad to address people such as Dan Rostenkowski, Tipp O'Neill, or Tom Foley and their shady dealings during their time as public servants as well.

It would have been very different if President Bush had said nothing. It would not have made his act any less illegal. However, he confirmed he approved those wiretaps freely and openly. He, like any other American citizen, has the right to protection under the 5th Amendment.

So, let's run down facts for you so that you and your wonderously open mind might actually grasp the concept that Bush approved the taps as I have said he did in a manner which is illegal without the review and approval of the FISA court:

Fact: Story by NY Times that Bush approved the NSA to proceed with wiretaps that were not reviewed and approved by the FISA Court, which is the body whose approval is required for those taps.

Fact: In a December 17, 2005 address, Bush confirmed that he had approved the program of wiretapping Americans who had communications outside of the country, and that these were wiretaps "to intercept the international communications of people with known links to al Qaeda and related terrorist organizations."

Fact: The 1978 Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act makes it illegal to spy on U.S. citizens in the United States without the approval of a special secret court (the FISA Court).

So:

Bush knowingly approved wiretaps that were illegal without the approval of the FISA Court.

The NSA executed those wiretaps illegally without the FISA Court approval.

It's pretty cut and dry.

And if these individuals are "known" associates of Al-Qaeda, I believe they can be arrested for such for helping to plot, organize, or facilitate terrorist acts.

I believe Bush's statement was misleading to the American people, because people who are [b]known[/b] to participate in terrorism themselves are criminal and can be prosecuted as such.

I think a more appropriate word for Bush to use would have been...[b]suspected[/b], since none of them have been prosecuted for the crime of committing or plotting terrorist acts, or assisting those doing so, under the Patriot Act.

That is, Bush is blowing a lot of smoke to try and cover his arse.

As for the Senate hearings...I'm sure they'll be about as unbiased as any other...not at all. I have little faith in our federal legislative system as a whole. It is, and has been for years now, more about controlling the political power for self-interest and personal gain rather than doing what is best for all American citizens.

It's both sides of the ball. And, I'd blame Democrats just the same for this if they had done it.

But the fact is, Bush is the president. And, he has approved an illegal act to take place. He is, at a minimum, an accessory to illegal activity by approving wiretaps not having gained FISA court approval mandated under the 1978 FISA.

I encourage you to offer proof to the contrary.

by krazykyngekorny

If you checked to see what the DOJ is actually looking at, you would see they are reading cold statistics- how many people looked at (a), (b), etc. What can they learn from that? ZIP!

XX people searched porn sites- so what? Were they all adults? Maybe. Were they all children? Maybe. Or , what percentage of each? Can't tell from statistics. So, the government is wasting money. The Rupublicans have adopted a Democrat tactic- whatever works FOR THEM!

Have a nice day.

by stargazerr

Or laws to go to Jail?? :D

Hmmm ... Holiday in Fiji ... Sounds Good .... I am in ... Who's gonna book the tickets?? You will pay of course .. but i can book ... ;)

]:)

by maxwell edison

The Democrat Party in general, and the Democrat Party leadership specifically, has been relentlessly attempting to smear and discredit President Bush ever since they lost the 2000 presidential election by a slim margin of ~500 Florida votes. It's been one bogus charge after another, none of which have had much -- or any -- substance at all. If anyone believes a single thing uttered by those buffoons, he's either uninformed, or an idiot, or both. They've cried wolf too many times to have any credibility. Moreover, they're blatantly lying about what's even going on! And it's absolutely pointless debating it with an obvious partisan.

The only Democrat giving the president the benefit of the doubt, not passing judgement until the Senate hearings, is John McCain (sarcasm intended).

It all boils down to this: You guys, and you know who you are, believe the like of Ted Kennedy, John Kerry, Howard "screamin" Dean, Harry Reid, et al. And I pity you poor fools.

by jck

I see you couldn't contradict my facts. Thanks for the recognition through non-action.

BTW, I quoted the NY Times directly.

Bush's speech is available at http://www.whitehouse.gov or in a news story at http://www.cnn.com

The facts about the FISA are available at several websites findable by using http://www.google.com or your favorite search engine.

BTW, another great Democrat named Arlen Spector (R-PA) (sarcasm noted here) is doubting Bush's choice to move forward the NSA with the wiretaps and whether he had constitutional right to do it as Bush has claimed.

Must be a migration of GOPers to the Demos side of the fence now...wonder why that could be?? Maybe there's too much crap in the GOP pasture?

Get ready for the pendulum to swing back left starting this year, Max. Bush is not helping his party any with his policies, decisions, and regular mistakes and breaches of law, policy, and etiquette.

Most of the old folks I know around here (most of my neighbors are 60 and over) said they don't understand what Bush is trying to prove, their standard of living has diminished more since his re-election, and that Congress is doing nothing to help them sustain a decent life.

You better let your boys know to lobby the AARP harder, or Bush is gonna cause the GOP to lose the majority of 20M+ voters.

As for me, I'll just keep quoting news sources and government websites and let you keep telling me I'm spewing Democratic material.

Kam sa ham ni da

by m_a_r_k

You're getting good at booking things. You can book the trip. Of course I'll pay. I was planning on paying for the trip through my criminal activities once we got to Fiji. Or Tahiti. But alas! Fortunately I have a Plan B which has been created due to unfortunate circumstances. I haven't had done any vacation travelling in four years. So my vacation fund is brimming with extra cash. I'll use that. Hell, I even have a Plan C. I'm co-authoring a book, you know, and I'm expecting a windfall of profits from that best-seller.

by jck

that's your opinion, Max.

I presented logical facts about what Bush had done (confirmed by his own admission, I might add), and you went back to whining about Democrats.

You didn't even present one counter to the Bush facts I'd given.

Hence, you cried...not me.

I tried to keep this argument logical and maintain some mature decorum in it, in hopes that you'd actually present something to me that might be influencing.

I see I've been let down yet again.

I encourage you again. Present facts to the contrary of what I have presented about the NY Times story about Bush approving illegally exercised wiretaps, Bush confirming he'd done it, and what the FISA says about not conducting those activities without proper approval.

Other than Bush simply saying it was his constitutional right...what other backing do you have for your interpretation of these events that validates what Bush did?

It's pretty cut and dry. QED.

And again, I think the Senate hearings on it that will be exercised by Senator Spector will be a mockery. Nothing will come out of it but the "good ole boys" scratching each others' backs and declaring no harm, no foul.

Congress is a den of snakes...the whole lot of em.

by jdclyde

are what the laywers of yesterday were. Bottom feeders and ambulance chasers.

Not looking to inform, just hype a story to get ratings.

"Is your house KILLING you? Watch tonight to find out!"

Then the blantant ones with a politcal agenda are the worst kind of scum as "we the people" have to sit and be insulted by the lies by and about the opposing political parties.

Channels with an agenda. What a scary thing.

by techytype

People, both in the United States, and around the world have always been willing to let "them" (be it government, dictators, business, etc.) take care of things. Until it becomes obvious there is a problem and often when it is too late to do anything.

Yes, people should be paying more attention and ensuring that their opinions are heard. This is not as simple as it appears though. Remember one of the first steps to silencing unpopular (with authorities) messages is to belittle and make offending person appear to be a member of a lunatic fringe. Failing that they work to destroy you financially. If that doesn't work and you don't have the ability to protect yourself you may find yourself experiencing unfortunate accidents. Of course in countries where human rights don't count for much you just disappear.

Now this would never happen in the United States right? Minor details like wiretaps without warrants, holding people for years without charge, or sending people to other countries for torture are not related and you can feel safe knowing your government is working to protect you. The same way there was such an efficient and immediate response following the hurricane Katrina.

Now stop thinking, forget everything you have seen and read today. It hurts your little brain all these complicated topics. Go back to sleep and let your government do what you elected them to do. You did elect them right?

by av .

I'm part of the people that didn't vote for Bush in the last election; the other almost 50% of the country.

When you say the people are willing to let "them" handle things, you're right. They are. Thats what they are supposed to be elected to do. The problem is that the system itself is corrupt and the people that run for office are part of the system.

The Bush Administration likes to paint a rosy picture of any situation, but the facts speak for themselves. Its response to Hurricane Katrina was horrendous, an embarassment for our nation. The Iraq war. Scandals. Deficits. I could go on, but suffice to say that our government does not have the people's best interests in mind.

I never thought I would see the day that I would have to fight for freedom of speech or privacy in America. But now is the time to fight for the right to continue to have those same freedoms online.

Its a very interesting fight to watch between Google and the US. Google supplied the censored search engine to China and has no regrets, yet it won't give the US government (at least right now) what it wants. I think if Google turns that information over, we will begin to see the beginning of the United States of China.

by mjwx

hitler was voted into power. voted head of the nazi party but then forced/usurped/subverted his way into the top job. but his was a time when it was 5 marks for a loaf of bread.

My point is if people get desperate enough (or scared enough) they will readily accept a tyrant.

by too old for it

The whole "kids viewing porn" (which is different from "kiddie porn") argument is the same faded red herring that was waved during the "mob scare" and the "commie scare" before that.

Accepting for a moment the proposition that:

Kids view porn on the internet.
Organized crime is growing.
There were and are communists in the government trying to bring down the United States.

[b]NONE[/b] of the above would be an excuse for the government prying into the private lives of US citizens and businesses, had the forefathers had the foresight to put a right to privacy in the Bill of Rights (and if said right had not been shitcanned, along with all other individual and states rights during the reconstruction era).

But they didn't, so it wasn't and hasn't been necessary for the government to bother much with a right that doesn't exist. Still a red herring.

That said, I think that throttling back the power of the government should be the goal of the next 20 years or so, lest we have root the government out of out lives with a full-blown revolution at some future date.

by techytype

People, both in the United States, and around the world have always been willing to let "them" (be it government, dictators, business, etc.) take care of things. Until it becomes obvious there is a problem and often when it is too late to do anything.

Yes, people should be paying more attention and ensuring that their opinions are heard. This is not as simple as it appears though. Remember one of the first steps to silencing unpopular (with authorities) messages is to belittle and make offending person appear to be a member of a lunatic fringe. Failing that they work to destroy you financially. If that doesn't work and you don't have the ability to protect yourself you may find yourself experiencing unfortunate accidents. Of course in countries where human rights don't count for much you just disappear.

Now this would never happen in the United States right? Minor details like wiretaps without warrants, holding people for years without charge, or sending people to other countries for torture are not related and you can feel safe knowing your government is working to protect you. The same way there was such an efficient and immediate response following the hurricane Katrina.

Now stop thinking, forget everything you have seen and read today. It hurts your little brain all these complicated topics. Go back to sleep and let your government do what you elected them to do. You did elect them right?

by bcramer

reading some of these, makes me think back and wonder where some of these people were at when the topic of world history was discussed. It's amazing how it can repeat and go unnoticed.

by techytype

I agree. All we can do is bring forward the ideas as fairly and openly as possible. Then hope enough people can act before it is too late.

by jck

I can eat a 32 oz steak...and it comes out about half of that...hahahaha :^O

by maxwell edison

And as an after-thought, I'm absolutely amazed at the people who are crying foul with privacy issues when it concerns the NSA monitoring ONLY international communication in search of ONLY terrorist related activities, but they are ignorantly (or politically) quiet when it comes to the REAL invasion of people's privacy at the hands of the IRS and the like. The reason is because, for the most part, it's the left crying about it, and it's the left who LOVES the IRS. This tells me that they don't give a rat's behind about "privacy"; they only want to attack President Bush, and this is their tactic of the day. (And they wonder why I overuse the word disingenuous to describe them -- because they are.)

Senator Kerry, I call for the abolition of the IRS because, not only do they violate my civil liberties, but they invade my privacy! Will YOU support this? I didn't think so. Enough said.

by too old for it

The NSA wire tapping is not nearly enough. We (Homeland Security) are so hypocritical regarding terrorists. For instance, every single hijacker on 9/11 was an Arabic male with ties to al-Quida. So we, as a security measure, take Granny Clampett?s knitting needles away and give her a full cavity search.

The security chief over at El Al has to laughing his arse off.

Senator DeWine, I call for the abolition of the IRS because, not only do they violate my civil liberties, AND invade my privacy, cutting off the flow of tax money to Washington is the only way to halt the corruption in government.

by absolutely

The word "discriminate" means to choose. In the case of Al Qaida, there are a few relevant observables which dictate that Arabs are scrutinized more closely than others where suspicion of terrorism is involved.

(1) All Al Qaida are Moslem.

(2) Many Arabs are Moslem, and many Moslems are Arabs.

(3) Most known Al Qaida are Moslem, and from what I have seen, most suspected members are also Moslem.

Terrorism is always ideological. Anglicans did not join the IRA and only Moslems join Al Qaida. It's idiotic to claim that racial profiling of Arabs is racist. It is not discrimination against Arabs for being Arab, it is the correct, intelligent way to find more Al Qaidas. You don't go to a shoe store to find a computer, and you don't look for Al Qaidas in nursing homes or up white grannies' bums.

by absolutely

"The Democrat Party in general, and the Democrat Party leadership specifically, has been relentlessly attempting to smear and discredit President Bush ever since they lost the 2000 presidential election by a slim margin of ~500 Florida votes. It's been one bogus charge after another, none of which have had much -- or any -- substance at all."

Agreed. However, Bush has also [b]admitted[/b] that he ordered wiretapping without warrants after asking for permission to do so and being declined. Those are facts, not exaggeration or political rhetoric.

"Therefore what?" you may ask, if you respond at all. Therefore, I say, he has committed a felony and must be removed from office posthaste.

by absolutely

Via advertisers, you, the sheeple. Visiting 5 different conservative blogs or 5 different liberal blogs does not sum to an unbiased perspective, it's just repetition of essentially the same bias. And journalists are no more at fault for the frivolous quality of journalism than IT helpdesk techs are at fault for the instability of certain operating systems and configurations. Businesses respond to demand, and professionals utilize the abilities that get them employed. If you don't like a television program or station or newspaper, you don't like its audience!

by stargazerr

do we manage to ram headalong into a topic alltogether different every single time ?? :D

WARNING !!! This comment has nothing to do with what I am about to say ..... HOLIDAY?? YOU'RE ON ... :D

]:)

by jdclyde

I don't. ;\

media IS accountable for the substandard decpetions they spin out as "truth".

I personnally listen to more "liberal" media than "concervative" media until I just can't take how stupid the ranting and raving gets.

Next thing you know, some clueless sheeple will start about how because the High court in FL didn't allow Gore to change the established rules for disputing an election half way through, that the courts "gave" the election to Bush. It is amazing that people are that STUPID, but many are.

by jamesrl

or the English translation "to know to do".

Its a fundamental principle of law. Its the basis for which insane people can't be found guilty because they lack the mental capacity.

In this case, I am not calling Bush insane. But if this is a situation where the "law" is in doubt, either the existing law, or what power have been given the president through the Homeland Security Act, then the President essentially gets a free ride. If the White House Advisors had enough confidence and legal advice to tell the president he could legally do this, than he isn't guilty of anything unless and until the court tells him otherwise(and then he is only guilty if he ignores the court ruling and continues).

This is not to say I agree with what he is doing. I'm sure Max can quote Jefferson on the topic. But calling for his removal from office is a little over the top, unless you can show where he ignored legal advice and knew (mens rea) that he was committing a crime - and I do believe on that question there is a reasonable doubt.

James

by maxwell edison

You said, "However, Bush has also admitted that he ordered wiretapping without warrants after asking for permission to do so and being declined. Those are facts, not exaggeration or political rhetoric."

You asked me to comment on that, and I'll be glad to do so -- if, that is, you will be kind enough to point me to a source where I can read and reply to [b]exactly[/b] what the president said, in his own words, and in full context.

But I don't really want to comment on what you said he said. That's pointless.

by m_a_r_k

Brilliant minds think alike and all that. We should write a screenplay. It would be like a schizophrenic drug trip with all the jumping through a series of seemingly disconnected and unrelated scenes. It would be hilarious as hell. Can I write your acceptance speech for the Academy Award? I promise to stay on topic.

Tahiti or Fiji? :D

by stargazerr

The screenplay is also a great idea ...

Lets start with pushing Bill Gates off a cliff .......He falls down down down .... screaming .....and we switch to a scene of Road Runner going ........ Beep Beep !!! :D

Hands over paper and pen to Mark and pushes him into comfy chair and orders him to complete speech ...

]:)

by jck

Bush's December 17, 2005 radio address concerning approving the NSA to wiretap.

http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2005/12/20051217.html

In the speech, he admits he gave the nod to the NSA to [i]"intercept the international communications of people with known links to al Qaeda and related terrorist organizations."[/i]

He follows this up with examples of two of the terrorist hijackers who were in the United States that [i]"...we didn't know they were here, until it was too late."[/i]

I guess the guys didn't have to show ID or anything coming into the country.

Then of course, he implies whomever leaked the story committed an illegal act by saying:

[i]"Yesterday the existence of this secret program was revealed in media reports, after being improperly provided to news organizations. As a result, our enemies have learned information they should not have, and the unauthorized disclosure of this effort damages our national security and puts our citizens at risk. Revealing classified information is illegal, alerts our enemies, and endangers our country."[/i]

Ooh...they learn the government is listening into calls? That's a shocker? Right...

And being the silly nut he is, he then lines out what the process of review of the information is within a classified program is by stating:

[i]"The activities I authorized are reviewed approximately every 45 days. Each review is based on a fresh intelligence assessment of terrorist threats to the continuity of our government and the threat of catastrophic damage to our homeland. During each assessment, previous activities under the authorization are reviewed. The review includes approval by our nation's top legal officials, including the Attorney General and the Counsel to the President."[/i]

He just leaked more detailed information about the program than the NY Times.

Guess by his own standards, he should be arrested for this illegal act as well? Isn't this divulging operational aspects of a classified program a treasonous act?

By the way, it is. I know. I held clearances. You don't talk about who, what, when, where or why of a classified program to anyone outside of it.

The guy is such a dolt.

And you guys tell me I'm so bad? Yet, you respect this guy as a leader?

Give me a break.

by m_a_r_k

That was a quick decision that you made. I flipped a coin. Wouldn't you know it? The damn thing landed on its side. OK...Tahiti it is! :D

As for the screenplay, if there's going to be scene with Wild Bill Gates morphing into Road Runner, then the Road Runner has to have a goofy-looking haircut and has to wear glasses. Oh...and we have to have an antagonist for Road Runner. I'm thinking that we need something to substitute for Wile E. Coyote, though. It has to be something really outlandish. Something that nobody in their right mind would think of. Umm...an iguana maybe?

By the way, which one of gets to push ol' Billy boy off the cliff? Somewhere in the recent past I remember a bit of a discussion about ME getting pushed off a cliff. ?:|

by stargazerr

You cannot do the actual pushing ... since you might fall off and hurt yourself .. I dont have the money to buy any titanium parts ... ;) ... If you like, I can buy you Alimunium ones though ... :D

An Iguana will be great for the part of the coyote ... What do you know, we might even find the one that has my torpedoes strapped on its back ... !!

]:)

by maxwell edison

I did read your entire message, and I did read the entire speech. I'm amazed at the things you took from that. They're so silly that they speak for themselves; no need for me to comment any further.

However, in the speech you referred to, the president did not say what absolutely said he said.

I'll wait for absolutely's reply. At least he usually [i]seems [/i] a bit more rational that you, at least more often. You're just a total idiot.

by jck

that's your opinion, Max.

However, I quoted Bush and gave you the link.

And yet again, you give no opposing information.

He discussed the interception the international communications of individuals in respect to catching those like the two terrorists who flew the plane into Pentagon that were [b]in[/b] the United States.

I don't know what you drew from the speech, but if you didn't see what he was referring to when he spoke of approving the program to stop people like those two...then, you are the real idiot.

Maybe you need everything spoon-fed to you in little bites so you can understand them?

Jesus...you're obtuse.

by m_a_r_k

I already have titanium. I don't know if putting aluminum next to titanium will cause an adverse chemical reaction. I'd go up in smoke like a suicide bomber. Maybe we could try a controlled experiment to see what happens. If it does cause an explostion, that can be one of the iguana's props to try to kill Road Runner. In the next scene the iguana can fire one of the torpedoes at Road Runner.

I could still do the pushing. We could tie a rope around my waist and fasten the other end to an apple tree. Can I trust you not to cut the rope just for the thrill of watching me tumble over the cliff and seeing if I survive the fall? I will survive. I already survived a fall from an airplane when my parachute didn't open.

by maxwell edison

I'm not claiming that the president did not approve the monitoring. Of course he approved it. I fully admit that he did approve it. Moreover, I fully support what he did. If you do not support it, fine; we'll agree to disagree.

What you and absolutely have said, however, is that it's illegal. I disagree.

You two have also said that he [b]asked [/b] Congress for [b]specific [/b] approval for the monitoring; you said that Congress [b]specifically [/b] said no; and you suggest that he did it anyway. Again, I disagree. That is not what happened. Moreover, you two claim that the president has admitted to this sequence of events, which he has not.

And you wonder why I see you as an idiot!

by xgi

There is an entire political party and a couple of million Bush haters out there spending 24 hours a day trying to find some proof that our government is harming our citizens. It they found just one thread of evidence we would all know about it.

I replied to a post from "American Voter? that label was already taken. The fact that I am an exMarine is only to empathize that I am just as committed to my country as any ?American Voter?. Why should you care? If not for the military and their commitment to our country people like you would be stuck in the ?free? world that everyone else on this planet enjoys. Perhaps you should get treatment for your paranoia instead of looking for conspiracies behind everything the government does.

Like most government haters you seem to have ignored the fact that Google has no problem in assisting the Chinese government in suppressing the freedom of its people. Why does my military service bother you and Googles two-faced attitude doesn?t? If you are so jealous of the ex-military guys perhaps you should join up and get an understanding of the experience.

by absolutely

"Perhaps you should get treatment for your paranoia instead of looking for conspiracies behind everything the government does.

Like most government haters you seem to have ignored the fact that Google has no problem in assisting the Chinese government in suppressing the freedom of its people. Why does my military service bother you and Googles two-faced attitude doesn?t?"

You assume that I think the neo-cons' conspiracy is shared by all bureaucrats at all levels of government. I do not. You assume that I hate the government. I do not. You assume that I approve of putting the most efficient search engine on the planet at the service of the most powerful communist power on Earth. I do not. You assume that your military service bothers me. I do not. I meant [b]exactly[/b] what I said, no more and no less. You, as a former Marine, have every right to be proud of your effort and the ideals that motivated you to join the military. You do not, as a former Marine have any right to expect others to withhold their opinion in deference to your status. [b]The[/b] great thing about my country is that everybody's opinion is considered on the merit of the opinion, not based on their profession or any other aspect of their social status.

edited to add: That's how the best ideas win.

by xgi

First: I never said at anytime that I expect anyone to withhold their opinion because of anything I think or have to say. I will say that there is no reason to turn a discussion into a personal attack. Your statement,? Finally, why should I care that you're an ex Marine? As a citizen of the United States, I am tired of former soldiers who treat their military experience as a trump card in every discussion. In this discussion, past employment by the government only calls your objectivity and credibility into question.? is something less than a discussion of the facts. In my original post I said that I agreed with everything the gentleman had to say, but he left out an important part of Google?s story.

I have read most of your posts and you sing the song of a rabid anti-government hater in every one. You have not given attention in any response to the real story. The government is attempting to revive the Child Pornography Online law. It was struck down by the liberal Supreme Court as unconstitutional. Frankly, I can not understand what part of our constitution protects child pornography. In Google?s response they stated that they would not comply because ?it would violate the privacy rights of its users and reveal company trade secrets? As a programmer I can tell you their fear is revealing the fact that they collect far more information about us than our government ever did. Perhaps you are unfamiliar with cookies and temp pages with no expiration date, IP address tracking and many other of the techniques employed by Web pages to track our activities. I don?t know about anyone else but I have never input any personal information when doing a search on Google, so what part of my privacy are they protecting? In theory they don?t know I exist, what habits of mine are they trying to hide? I despise people who deal in child porn and really don?t give a damn if my government decides to shoot them on site. American Voter said his hat is off to Google. My hat is off to Microsoft, AOL, and anyone else that assists in squashing these scum.

by jck

I didn't say that...I think that was Ab.

I said he had the wiretaps have to go before the FISA Court, which they do. Otherwise, it's illegal to tap in such a manner.

I gave you references...links...and you still call me an idiot?

Get it straight...go back and read...

I'll give you a pass though...cause...I've been so ragged in the head from being busy I couldn't keep names and things said straight either.

You see, that's what nice about being unbiased...I can give a break to the guy who busts my balls...as quick as the guy who helped me out.

I know I'm human...and you are too.

Now I just gotta convince jdclyde he is as well. :^O

by absolutely

I got the chain of events on C-SPAN, from a Democrat (sorry) during the "briefing" on the wiretapping issue.

Bush's admission occurred on December 17, 2005, I think. I did not watch that, but have seen many second-hand references to it since. I hope that qualifies it as common knowledge, or at least that you are familiar enough with the entire speech to comment on it. My understanding is that Bush stated that he had in fact ordered surveillance without approval from the FISA court that has jurisdiction and proudly continued that he has every intention of continuing to do so. Allegedly, he asked Congress for that exact privilege the last time they considered FISA rules, and was rejected. I'll find sources if you like. Just tell me which facts are unsubstantiated in your opinion, and I'll see how well I can document them.

by jdclyde

you will ruin his rant! Let him have his fun. I think he even might start to believe it if allowed to say it a few more times. ;\

by jdclyde

they don't have a RIGHT to be scumbag terrorists?

Or does that offend people? "freedom fighters"? No, scumbag terrorists was right the first time.

by noyoki

did basically create the Al Quieda.

But if you are going to tell me that everyone is something, then I'm going to tell you that:

All black people are gangsters,
All white people hate black people,
All mexicans are skeevey perverts,
All jewish people are greedy & "thrifty",
All italians are with the mob...

The list goes on and on. If any of these are 100% true, I'll give your list a second thought.

But they aren't.

by noyoki

Excuse the double post. I couldn't get to the other one to edit it.

> "I despise people who deal in child porn and really don?t give a damn if my government decides to shoot them on site."

The my issue with that statement, comes with 'grabbing the wrong guy'. You can't bring an innocent back to life once you've shot him/her. You can bring them out of jail, but it's never the same. (Once branded a child-molester/child-porn-maker/etc, the inmates don't make your life "easy", and the guards turn their backs on you while they do it.)

Google collects your IP address and places a cookie on your computer. put simply (it's alot more complex than this), your IP can lead anyone straight to your house, and the cookie tells you which computer AND the cookie is stored under your personal login ("c:\documents and settings\tears\cookies" for Windows 2k/XP (NT as well I believe)).

If 4 people use 1 computer with the same login, that's a bit different and harder to trace, but most people either have their own computers or at least their own logins.

And what happens if my brother was using my login when he was doing his thing? (I don't have a brother, this is hypothetical. Insert roommate, friend, sister, cousin, whomever you like.) Then *I* look like the culprit for all intents & purposes. All the downloaded pics are somewhere under my account, the cookies are all on my account, and there's not a thing I can do or say if the brother doesn't turn around and say, "It wasn't her, it was me." (Which, if he was using my account instead of his in the first place (trying to hide), I doubt he would do.)

Makes me glad I'm the only one that uses this computer and I have a lock on my door. (At least I don't THINK my flatmate has a key...)

Paranoid much? Not really IRL. But would you trust just anyone (cousin comes over, wants to check his e-mail) with unsupervised usage of your computer with this law? I wouldn't.

by #1 kenster

a political philosophy, movement, or regime (as that of the Fascisti) that exalts nation and often race above the individual... Merriam-Webster
Anyone trust a group of people spying on you? It's for your own good. They are fighting "terrorism" or "porn" or any other buzz word no decent individual could oppose. It is true that commercial interests spy on us and sell our information. The role of the state should be to protect citizens from such intrusions into their lives, not to actively participate. We have yet to come to "a dictatorial leader" and "forcible suppression of opposition" but it might help in the fight against terrorism. Every little step down this road brings us closer.

by absolutely

I did not say that all Arabs should now be rounded up and put in camps as if they were Japanese US citizens during World War II. It does make sense, though, to limit the list of suspects to plausible suspects, which means, when trying to find Al Qaida: Arabs. All Al Qaida (so far) are Arabs. That does not mean that all Arabs are Al Qaida, but it does mean there is no rational excuse for performing random searches in airports on non-Arabs.