Discussion Locked

What do you think of all the big brother stuff?

0 helpful
624 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

624 replies

by absolutely

You have the right to stop responding any time, xgi.

For the record, here is where you said you expect people to defer to your status as a former Marine:

"The "Hats off to Google" remark makes my blood curl. As an elder in the IT community and an ex Marine, I am tired of hearing people automatically assume our government is up to no good whenever they do something we don?t understand."

Government of the people, by the people, and for the people means that if the government is doing something without telling us all, they are up to no good.

Anti-government: not me. Government is better than anarchy, unless it's tyranny. If you were an honest individual, you would see that when I rail against any government policy, it is on the grounds that the policy is tyrannical. If you were intelligent and observant, you would see that I have never once called for abolition of government. I am not anti-government. I am pro-liberty.

by krazykyngekorny

[quote]Anyone trust a group of people spying on you? It's for your own good. They are fighting "terrorism" or "porn" or any other buzz word no decent individual could oppose.[/quote]

And, so are the cops investigating suspects for the commission of a crime. Of course, all you liberals want the cops to have no tools to work with, but you also yell, "they ought to string such and such up."

Do you want some slime-ball selling porn pictures of your children, or kid sister? That's what you are advocating. If crime goes unpunished, criminams will have a field day. Think, if you are capable of it.

by absolutely

Because I think a warrant is a reasonable requirement for eavesdropping logically implies to you I "want the cops to have no tools to work with".

"Think, if you are capable of it."

by id10tnolonger

dont like the government OR microsoft?
quit looking up the anarchists cookbook, kiddie porn and crystal meth recipes.. then go learn linux...
Think BUSH is some kind of hitler? Too bad you are likely too stupid and YOUNG to have a clue. Sadly i must admit age does not seem to be any guarantee of intellect.
BUSH has the worst job on earth, with 270 MILLION people or more second-guessing him while he tries to PROTECT YOU and YOUR KIDS whether you have the brains to see it or not. This seems to be part of YOUR problems, because some of you have zero FAITH in your own government... too bad, so sad... those of you who would rather support and defend kiddie porn and other BIGGER threats out of sheer ignorance and paranoia have no choice but to accept the fact that not everyone is as paranoid, corrupt, or mentally and morally LOST as you happen to be.
If you do not happen to be a snake, why do you fear those who HUNT SNAKES?
Go order yourselves a tinfoil beanie.

by bruce

If they were looking at actual searches, there are on average about 625 million searches done every day, using Google and Yahoo, which account for over 60% of all search engine traffic. If the average search used say 50 Kb of data (I am making an educated guess), then that would be about 31,250 Terabytes (PER DAY ! ). Where would you store all that? Even using computing power to filter for targeted content, who has time to read through millions of search results?

by gprinsloo

They are violating in the USA the forth ammendment. Internationally a large number of countries laws as well.

They have the right to request the info. But the searching thereof is a very sticky affair.

Unless they have/had a Search Warrant for very spesific data anything they encounter MAY NOT be presented as evidence and ALL of it will be tainted and useless in a US court of law.

They may however do statisitical analysis on the data but it must be done with anonymous specified searches. Anything they do with that data has now compromised ALL pending cases in which ANY SEARCH data is presented in court.

Be greatfull for those of you who are not on the straight and narrow, they have just done you a favour my giving you liberty in violating your privacy.

They have converted the data into pure HEARSAY evidence, they have also placed the providers into the category where trust and confidence is questionable to the legal defendant.

Sure the gov is happy but the effect of their methodology will be seen in courts for a while yet.

by tonythetiger

The 4th amendment only curtails the government from illegally searching YOUR property and using the results against YOU. It does not prohibit them from using legally obtained information for any purpose they see fit.

Using a wiretap as an example, if they are (legally) monitoring Gary Gangster's phone and he gets a call from Tommy Terrorist saying he blew up something, Tommy cannot claim a 4th amendment violation and his statement to Gary can most certainly be used against him.

by simplyshaman

mark i can't say i actually agree with anything you just said.. let me clarify, in order for the statement you said to be true... if you're gonna give your information to the government.. why not just post a sign that says hack me... and invite every hacker in the US to come tear your server apart...

yes, the internet is about free information... however.. it's moreso about free information limited to what people choose to share.. not every aspect of every search made for personal use

i personally can't stand kiddie porn and do agree that it needs to be put to a halt.. but this sort of method is going entirely too far..
this country was founded on freedom for all.. not those that the government sees fit...

just my two cents,

Shaman

by tonythetiger

name ONE freedom that has been relinquished because the government got information from search engines. Because I honestly cannot see it.

by geozuk

I agree with you 100%. I like to listen to these liberials. They make me laugh. Busk won Back to Back and the American people aren't fooled by the bias of the media.
Anyway the spying under this administration I feel safe for them to do because I'm not doing anything to hurt this country. But say some other non-pro American becomes president it could be a different story.
GO NSA and PRESIDENT BUSH save AMERICA and crush TERRORISM

by simplyshaman

but it's not just the bush administration... the government's been throwing us treats like dogs for centuries... but the fact is.. we blame entirely too much of our country's problems on the presidency...

why not look towards the larger problem... the president is 1 voice.. 1 vote... and that vote can be overridden by a 3/4 vote of congress...

congress who gets to vote for it's own pay raises... congress who got to vote in it's own retirement fund... how many of you realize that most of the federal government does not pay into social security at all.. in fact they have their own retirement program... and the lowest paid congressperson makes over 150k per year whether they're in office or not for the rest of their lives.. is that fair...

but yet somehow we find the need to gripe over a $2000 haircut... or that hurricanes choose to make landfall while the federal govt is on vacation... or that some states have governors and mayors who actually do thier jobs vs states that "needed a few days to figure out the outline" and cry "why has the federal government abandoned us"

it's all a crock of BS that we've been forcefed for way too long.. once upon a time the idea was to maintain a balanced ticket... now it's just republican vs democrat.. once upon a time we actually did have freedoms... but face it.. welcome to the socialist states of america....

shaman

by brokeneagle

Are you sure it is the Bush administration doing this and not just the bureacracy just trying to justify its existance?

by nicknielsen

If this was being done by a Democratic administration, the same people who are currently trying to justify it would be screaming bloody murder about the invasion of privacy and the potential for governmental abuse.

by #1 kenster

The point is you can use it for anything. You could target Right Wing think tanks. You can get a warrant after the fact already. Why trample the freedoms we are supposed to be protecting in the name of freedom? I brace for the next attack from someone who will say I have forgotten 9/11 or that I don't want them to have the tools for going after child porn.

by peter_es_uk

But who decides what is wrong? Once you have the data the trap is laid - it does not have to be sprung for years and future administration may have very different ideas about what data is good. "Find all people with gold fillings and get the gold" could be worth a fortune to some future tax inspector???

by nicknielsen

You have the right idea, but for the wrong reasons. As an IT geek, you should know better than to accept anything that you receive via email as gospel, yet you spout emailed inaccuracies like a fountain.

All of the claims you make about Congress, pensions, & Social Security are false; that entire diatribe is debunked in many locations, the most prominent of which is here: http://www.snopes.com/politics/taxes/pensions.asp

Additionally, I don't doubt for a minute that you take advantage of many of the "socialist" amenities made available in our society: public roads, police protection, fire protection, public hospitals, unemployment insurance, etc.

Don't be a hypocrite. Learn to think for yourself and don't "ditto" like a Rushie.

by gfz660

To Whom It Nay Concern: What concern,s me the most. There just doesn,t seem to be an end in sight One day i will wake up to find cameras on our power poles directed at my home. And sadley enough people for the most part,take all this with a grain of salt. Sincerly George Zajicek

by fore_thought

Im certain that by writing this I will probably be flagged by some bit somewhere that labels troublemakers and freethinkers as terrorists sending a digital signal down some line and into the VOX of some white collar follow orders type person who is annoyed by run on sentences who then logs in and checks this post only to discover that there is indeed a run on sentence who then calls his pals at the Congress to make a new law that stipulates that run on sentences are now illegal and not to forget the grandfather clause just to make sure I see at least 10-15 years on jail for every letter of this one.

Just because you dont like it...

Doens't mean you have the right to take it away from someone else...

All men created equal remember?

by jhughes

Obviously with a president and administration who don't believe in the bill of rights, we are in a precarious position as a free society. It is necessary to take risks to defend freedom. I am not willing to let any administration, on their own motion, determine what is legal. The checks and balances of three branches of government are critical.

Yea to Google for standing up. More of us need to make our feelings known. Write your congress person and senators. Don't let W take away all our freedom!

by fore_thought

Why havent they repealed Income Tax?

It was created to wage war...and it's still in effect today...

Your money goes to KILL PEOPLE!

And your money goes to pay those who VOTE to kill people...

It's my fault...and it's your fault.

We are to blame for all those people who are dying right now because we didn't stand up and say no and our parents didn't stand up and say no.
Unpatriotic?
If keeping the money I earn in my own pocket than in the pockets of power hungry madmen with no intelligence is unpatriotic...then so be it.
Let's repeal income tax.
Then see what happens.
Its ours anyway...they shouldnt be able to take it.

by tonythetiger

Then stay home, don't use the internet, or the phone or anything else which will let another member of the public know that you exist. When you pull into the adult bookstore parking lot, you are not protected from people knowing you went there. It's public information.

by wknaack9

Would you,those opposed to the government keeping an eye on the net, rather have the " towel heads " in our " back yards "? Then, after the" libs " take away the guns, you can watch your familys heads being sawed off! ( check out Michael Savages web site and see for yourself)We have to stop these religious fanitcs some how! Wake up America !!!!!!!

by woodrow

In principal I agree, the law should be enforced
evenly. However it is not practical in the age of
multipal modes of communication. A message from
Pakistan could be relayed through multiple countries
and modes before it arrived in the USA. It could have started as an oral phone message and arrived as
an encrypted JPEG attachment of an email. There is no way to track all of this using warrants.

by kirby5

It doesn't matter the route of the communication, we only need to get a warrant on the destination, if they are in the United States.
FISA court would approve a warrant fairly quickly and then the FBI could legally monitor the person for as long as they wanted.
As for international traffic... We are already monitoring international traffic. Eschelon comes to mind immediately... and there is not need for warrants in oversea intelligence work.

Now you do bring up one point ... IFF the eavesdropping would have been focused on the on International side one could argue that it falls under current international espionage. The problem was, from what we have been told, we targeted US citizan on US soil ... this still requires a warrant as I read the law.

by azson

I hate child porn sickos also, but with Bush doing the illegal wire tap thing to spy on his war critics. I think he just wants another tool to spy on Anti-war protestors.

by jacksonian

Zlito,

Whats the big deal? According to the article the information that was requested did not contain " any information identifying the query". Why do so many people feel that they are so important that their on-line activity should be beyond reproach? I am a law abiding citizen. I dont care if "the man" knows what I am searching for. Do what ever needs to be done to ensure I am not on a list of suspected terrorists.

I am not saying that a police state is justifiable. But knowing if people are looking for maps or information about specific locations such as nuclear power plants, water treatment centers, areas with dense population, and other similar searches ensures that security is applied to locations that are not already having security bolstered. Think of all the areas in the United States that can be considered targets of opportunity. Out government is trying to be proactive, not reactive. I personally applaud this type of thinking, for the sake of freedom and the lives of all Americans.

Instead of getting wrapped around the axle about the "privacy" issue, I am more concerned about sexual predators and pedophiles having free reign on the internet frontier, hiding behind my freedom of speech. Is our country so morally bankrupt that people dont see what the real evil is? This type of activity (child pronography)should be the bane of our society. Law enforcement and civilians alike should do what they can to ensure that this type of content is not present on the internet. You wouldnt tolerate someone giving away these types of pictures on a street somewhere would you? Whats the difference?

You said that "refering to this now is lame and just another way to see what we are doing". I say whats lame is your complaint ...

This is just my opinion. Flame if you want, but this is what true freedom of speech is all about.

by biginjin

First of all, the government doesn't have enough prison cells to accomodate all you criminals out there who want to break the very laws established by that same government to protect you and me from each other! Now we have a new delima, muslim terrorists by the thousands who want us all dead. If you had the responsibility of the President of the United States on September 11, 2001, how would you respond? How would you be responding to it today? We citizens nearly five years down the road tend to forget that what happened that day got us where we are today. When we as individauls are breaking the law or doing some unscrupulous thing like searching porn sites and we find out our government might be "watching" us, we get all paranoid and bent out of shape. I don't think the government is going to bother with the legal expense and effort it would take to track down and arrest or even expose you with your pecker in your hand! However, if you are doing something serious enough, I think the government should be able to use whatever means available to take your ass down! I hate people who use and abuse inocent children as much as I hate terrorists and if what some call "violations of privacy" by our government make you uncomfortable, then start obeying the laws of this country and you won't have anything to be paranoid about!
One last note; I bet that any one of you who has children and responded to, or responds to this post bitching about our abusive government will be ever grateful when that same "invasion of privacy" finds and arrests the pedofile living next door to you who is on the verge of abusing or killing your child!

by vtassone

I was watching a show on the boob tube a few days ago. It was about the meth problem in the country. They said that meth was easy to make and there were thousands of sites on the net with instructions. Being a parent of teen aged children I decided to check some of these sites. I went to trusty old Google and typed in:
meth labs
making meth
crystal meth
and a bunch of other things. Needless to say, The DEA is watching every move I make now. My phones are taped, All the drug stores in the area have been alerted to call if I purchase Sudefed. My kids have been questioned at school and told to narc on me for my own good. Child Welfare is trying to find them a good home.......

I wonder what would happen if I Googled
Boy Scouts.........

by mwatch

You should obviously be arrested because you are obviously "on the verge" of making METH.

by bitmeister

We've all been hearing in the news how our intelligence folks dropped the ball with regards to 9/11 and Iraq. To a degree it's true, but you can thank reductions in Congressional funding going back to the budget years following the "Fall of the Wall" for this. Having spent much of my early professional life in "that" business, I can safely tell you the U.S. Government simply doesn't have the manpower and technical resources to dedicate to listing to, or reading, every communication out there. Their systems are set to flag specific keywords & phrases, repeated seemingly nonsensical communications to specific recepients, etc. that are key to specific projects/cases. If you've got nothing to hide, and you're not doing anything stupid, you're never even going to appear on their radar for futher analysis by other systems or by an actual human analyst.

by chernick.ron9

You know that in some countries like france and germany its illegal to buy Hitler stuff, so if you started your search for historical medals and your search engine switched you to google France and it show some medal from Hitler's army and offered it for sale, you might be trialed and in France then extradited to be jailed in FRance, just because you commited the crime on France's Google search engine. Oh and by the way the supeona was for Google's search engine so the Goverment could see what children found on the internet when seaching for porn, not child porn. And Google would have to turn over the search engine which is thier only business and hope no one leaked the program out after signing documents saying they wouldn't, like someone is going to turn down $10,000 or more on the side just because they signed the non-disclosure document.

by jlh23

zlito writes: "I hate child porn and anyone who looks at it and they should be put behind bars!"

But obviously not enought to want law enforcement to have any useful tools for combating it. So the end result is: child porn goes on unabated, while you sit and stew over alleged violations of your "privacy rights" to search for child porn on-line. Where did you ever get the idea that you have a reasonable expectation of privacy on the web? It's a public resource, accessed over public infrastructure. To put it another way, stop having sex in your car in the mall parking lot if you don't want people seeing you having sex.

by russt

This includes people who want to save the environment, use bicycles, believe in freedom from religion, etc.
They are able to plant and frame opponents and steal elections.

by rzimmerman

I have just started reading "State of War" and the part about the government having extremely close relationships with key executives at the major telecoms is troubling. Eisenhower was prescient in warning about the military industrial complex and the erosions of our freedoms. The McCarthy hearings took place in my youth and I remember the fear he generated about the "Red Menance". We are going through a similar period now. But I'm not sure we have an Edward R. Murrow out there to expose these shenangigans. It seems the press is just about as bad as the government in spinning the facts. We don't seem to have a lot of leaders today with any integrity.

by pse

Watch out! DO NOT SAY ANYTHING AGAINST THE CURRENT
MANIFESTATION OF THIS WAR MACHINE!

YOU will be labeled "liberal" "unpatriotic" "wimps",
or horror of horrors, "Democrat".

by lampman55

If Big Brother is monitoring my searches, I could care less. I don't have a thing to hide, not does any member of my family.

The present climate is that of war. If we understand that the attack on Sep 11 was an act of war, then we would accept far more 'intrusion' during this contentious period.

The press has been all over the Patriot Act and other mechanisms that they need to protect us. The truth is, our military personnel are being killed each day in Iraq and Afghanistan by our enemy. We of course kill scores a day, but that never appears on our TV or in our print.

Our government must protect us - if that includes looking at our searches, so be it. THey don't care that I like SitePoint, DevShed, MSN, and Yahoo. I don't illegally download software, I seldom view naked ladies, and there is no reason for me to fear what is intended to protect me.

Let's not get paranoid. We must all make an investment if we want to remain free, and sometimes that includes giving up a portion of our freedom during a national crisis. Are we Men or Girly Men, to paraphrase Gov. Arnold?

We will be able to get back any control or abuse that occurs - the fact is, there has been no abuse!

Thanks,
LAMPman

by mwatch

"Anyone that is Muslim is a target, and should be."

Have you ever heard of Buchenwald? Pop it into Google if you don't.

by american_it_guy

I think that if you don't log into to a service you are paying for then we have no rights to privacy, or expectation of privacy. However if it is a service we are paying for, any "normal search" legal activity should be kept confidential unless I say otherwise or one has clicked the "accept button" on the policy agreement that allow such information disclosure. IN other words, I doubt many if any folks have any say so in any of this. On the other hand, I gave up on information privacy when they outsourced our SSN's to every Tom, Dick and Harry.

by tonythetiger

Freedom was never total. It has always been restricted when it interfered with the rights of others. It's just that in this day and age, people get in each other's way a lot more. The process of getting a license is itself such a restriction. The state has an interest in making sure you are qualified (to fly, drive, or hunt) because of the potential consequences (to others) if you're not. Hell, even a traffic light is a restriction of freedom! Why should you have to stop at an intersection?

When you do something in public, the public has the right to reasonable safety from the consequences of what you do, and it is the government's responsibility to provide that safety. In fact, that is their ONLY function!

by richard

"It's to protect the children"
"The Communists are taking over"
"9-11, 9-11, 9-11"
"If you're not with us, you're against us"

Benjamin Franklin: "The man who trades freedom for security does not deserve nor will he ever receive either."

by rixmail

The Ben Franklin quote is right on and we should all think about that. This isn't about political party its about democracy and the preservation of our constitutional rights.
Call or email your senators to support a filibuster on Alito. The Unitary Executive will be the end of liberty and democracy in America.

Richard is also dead on in using their 9-11 justification for everything.

give up your rights, 9-11
I am the king, 9-11
Torture is illegal for everyone but me, 9-11

They also hired some professors from Duke who theorize that the American people will buy into anything if your say the words FREEDOM, and VICTORY enough times.

I broke the law for "terrorist surveilance", 9-11
I can spy on anyone with no accountability or judicial oversight, 9-11 , so we can have Victory and preserve freedom.
9-11
Victory
victory
9-11
Terrah terrah
mushroom cloud
9-11

By the way, if you do a little research you will find that they started tapping our phones and reading email shortly after Bush took office. Long before 9-11. later a republican senator offered a bill to loosen the restrictions of the FISA court and the Administration refused saying it wasn't necessary and that it might violate the constitution.

Bill Clinton used surveilance. He added physical searches to FISA. This is not the same thing, because it was done LEGALLY. They changed the law and they obtained the proper FISA warrants using the due process of law guaranteed by the fourth amendment. Everyone on Fox news will tell you this is just as bad as what Bush did, but I think anyone can see the huge difference between LEGAL and ILLEGAL.

by tonythetiger

"By the way, if you do a little research you will find that they started tapping our phones and reading email shortly after Bush took office."

While certain methods may have been initiated under Bush's administration, I suspect they were doing it for a lot longer than that! They've been monitoring international phone calls for decades (both before and since the advent of communications satellites), and I'll bet that the second email ever sent in this country was read by someone from the government :)

by maxwell edison

You said, "By the way, if you do a little research you will find that they started tapping our phones and reading email shortly after Bush took office. Long before 9-11. later a republican senator offered a bill to loosen the restrictions of the FISA court and the Administration refused saying it wasn't necessary and that it might violate the constitution."

Why don't YOU provide the research before you make such a silly comment. I say that you are wrong; I say that it did not happen like that. It's up to you to prove that it did.

Here, I'll help you -- help you correct yourself, that is.

You are mistaken about the details and the outcome of Senate Bill S2659.

http://www.fas.org/irp/congress/2002_cr/s2659.html

http://www.fas.org/irp/congress/2002_hr/073102transcript.html

Perhaps you should read the bill and the congressional record instead of reading the blogs.

by havacigar

You're a clueless dolt,
and Franklin probably never said that.

You have all the freedom you want. You can search for whatever you want (unlike the fascicst Google who limits their Chinese patrons results).
Whatever you search for may be of interest to certain authorities for various reasons, but you can still search for it. You aren't giving up your right to search, unless you are in China, then Google has taken that freedom away from you.

Or is it Franklin's much heralded freedom of anonymity that you are worried about losing?

What liberty has been taken from you?

by rixmail

The Ben Franklin quote is right on and we should all think about that. This isn't about political party its about democracy and the preservation of our constitutional rights.
Call or email your senators to support a filibuster on Alito. The Unitary Executive will be the end of liberty and democracy in America.

Richard is also dead on in using their 9-11 justification for everything.

give up your rights, 9-11
I am the king, 9-11
Torture is illegal for everyone but me, 9-11

They also hired some professors from Duke who theorize that the American people will buy into anything if your say the words FREEDOM, and VICTORY enough times.

I broke the law for "terrorist surveilance", 9-11
I can spy on anyone with no accountability or judicial oversight, 9-11 , so we can have Victory and preserve freedom.
9-11
Victory
victory
9-11
Terrah terrah
mushroom cloud
9-11

By the way, if you do a little research you will find that they started tapping our phones and reading email shortly after Bush took office. Long before 9-11. later a republican senator offered a bill to loosen the restrictions of the FISA court and the Administration refused saying it wasn't necessary and that it might violate the constitution.

Bill Clinton used surveilance. He added physical searches to FISA. This is not the same thing, because it was done LEGALLY. They changed the law and they obtained the proper FISA warrants using the due process of law guaranteed by the fourth amendment. Everyone on Fox news will tell you this is just as bad as what Bush did, but I think anyone can see the huge difference between LEGAL and ILLEGAL.

by maxwell edison

Your misquote corrected:

"They that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety."
-Benjamin Franklin, Historical Review of Pennsylvania.

Your misinterpretation corrected:

Franklin's intention with this sentiment is a warning to those who are willing to live under the tyranny of an oppressive government in exchange for a little safety. And instead of applying to national defense measures taken by the United States, as you would suggest, it would apply more to the people of Iraq who are content living under the tyranny of Saddam Hussein instead of dealing with the radical Islamists who put their safety in jeopardy because they want to deny it.

by maxwell edison

You said, "I got the chain of events on C-SPAN, from a Democrat (sorry)..."

Well, that alone is reason to be [b]extremely [/b] skeptical. Moreover, on one hand, I believe you've agreed with me that Democrats are only looking for one thing after another to discredit the president, and this is only the smear-tactic of the day; but on the other hand, you cite THEM as your source! Give me a break!

And you guys (you and jck) keep saying the same thing over and over, and I keep replying with the same answer. Words mean things, and try to be VERY specific, at least I am in this case. For example, the word "asked" is a significant difference in what you two claim and what I rebut. The president [b]never [/b] admitted to doing that in his December 17th speech, but, for some reason, you two continue to claim that he did. I suppose it's because that's what the Democrats are saying. In the case of jck, the idiot even posted a link to the speech as proof that he did, but one read of the speech makes it clear that he didn't.

But my reply is still is still here:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=188275&messageID=1936122

Neither you or jck has said anything to convince me. I'm amazed at how people make-up their own version of events just to satisfy a desired outcome. I've come to expect as much from jck, but you?

Don't tell me what ANY Democrat has said about it, especially when it comes to what the president has [b]admitted[/b]. Use his own words, please.

by sailnow

Bush, Cheney and the rest of the "War Cabinet" are very adept at deception! First filtering & deleting information regarding Iraq and the "call to war". Then they selectively left out the deaths of support troops and non-military support people who were killer or injured. And I've read that they intentionally have left out those who became psychologically disabaled due to the war experience.
How can you trust such a team to be honest about their itentions, and their proclaimed "safe guards for personal invasion"? Their record is proven - NOT TRUSTWORTHY !!

On principle I oppose such mass invasion of privacy in the USA. The Bush campaign pushed "Conservative Compassion" I've missed both a true "conservation value" in much of Bushes actual performance. I've also missed most all of the promised compassion (when in New Orleans after Katrina - Bush was featured on a "stage the blocked out the tragedy & destruction" He made it all look quite 'pretty' and promised immediate & complete help and rebuilding. But investigations later and now point to graft, mismanagement, avoidance of reports fromt he field and a lot of denial from the top on down in the President's office and in FEMA.

We voted for clean government. That as a hoax. The truth hurts - he's a fraud, and a clever deceptionist.

Do not trust the word of the government at risk of your life and liberty !!!

by charliec

I'll keep this short and sweet. If you aint doin nothin wrong you aint got nothin to worry about.

by dryflies

Who decides what is right and what is wrong? If I want to search the web for something that offends some government clerk which in turn gets me on to the list of those being wiretapped without a warrant even though i have done nothing against the law does tha mean my rights are not being violated? I am not worried about being arrested. But now when I apply for a federal job and they do the required background check. I will have a red mark because of the goverment dweeb I pissed off 10 years ago. I will not get the job because that goverment dweeb violated my rights.

by pse

I want to do wrong and not have to pay the consequences, isnt that the "American Way"?

I want to get filthy rich without concern about how I do. ........As many have done already and will continue to do. All I want is a piece of the pie.

are you talking about honesty? In government? Are you serious?

by conquistador

Any government prosecutor can destroy you just by making accusations. They can keep you in court for the rest of your life. Your children and grandchildren will spend their entire lives paying off your legal bills. EVEN if you're innocent. I've seen it happen more than once.

by networthy

You can't pay for the entertainment that liberals give us everyday. Kerry Lost, thank God, get over it. Your whinny tookus' are safer because of Bush.

by rixmail

Bush has never won an election. He cheated in Florida, and he cheated in Ohio. Thats the truth and its history so I will focus on right now. You talk about tunnel vision and paranoia. You guys are just blind. You are so wrapped up in partisan "our team won" BS that you can't see right and wrong. Conservative hippocracy is ridiculous. Ken Star spent 60 million trying to pin something on Clinton, all he got was a half truth about his personal sex life and you guys impeached him claiming it was all about the "rule of law". THIS presidend LIED us into a WAR (www.downingstreetmemo.com), he lied about wiretaps (broke the FISA law and the 4th amendment), the list goes on and on. Suddenly the "rule of law" isn't so important. As long as you get to be on the "winning team" you turn a blind eye to the crimes of this president and continue to vote against your own best interests. Laugh it up, sit there in your blind ignorance and make fun of the whiny paranoid liberals. I feel sorry for you, and I feel sorry for the generations of our children and grandchildren who will pay with their health and their freedom and their tax dollars for the crimes of this administration.

by pse

Not much more I can add except to say that Bush should be held accountable for his incompetance and lies.

by networthy

I love it when you Libs get your panties in a bunch over this stuff. It proves yet again, that you guys can't be trusted with National Defense or the economy. Keep spewing the BS talking points from the left! It's so entertaining to watch you guys implode.

by crashoverider

If google is made to turn over their search records to the DOJ the next step would be for the DOJ to get a warrent to collect all the notebooks of every person in the USA and search these papers for any unlawful writings (i.e. writings that call for action against the goverment) the American public needs to wake up and stop there rights from being violated or we will wake up one day and see people being put in to concentration camps or as we call them now prisions for just thinking about speaking out against a unconsitiutional law.

by jensonee

corporate fascism is a concept we should get used to with the present republican administration. that's the government and the corporations working hand in hand to make a better world for them. you and me? well as i said we just have to get used to it.

by mikebytes

I find this very ironic if not hypocritical that most of us work in a field where our job is the security of networks and we believe we can "sniff", monitor keystrokes, review email etc. to maintain security because it is "the company" that owns the data and resources used". Then we turn around and piss and moan about the government doing the same thing we do on a network they own for the sake of helping to protect us from Muslim terrorists. I will not go into a litany of lives lost around the world to these jerks but I will close by reminding you that Constitutionally we have NO RIGHT OF PRIVACY. That arguement is a red herring.

by jterry

I don't beleive their looking at everyone search queries. If they are they should be able to hire the millions who are out of work in this country. If their spending their time looking at my search queries they have a pretty boring job.

by comp1systems

I always knew that Microsoft had they're hands in the
spyware industry. It's no secret, although they want you to
believe that you are protected with their firewall and other
security features, that have managed to let Microsoft users
down by practically saying, "hey, here's all of the queries--
take a look." It's bad enough the government has their
hand in every cookie jar, that now even searching the
internet is being scrutinized at every level. Therefore, when
you think of all the porn sites that are visited and videos
downloaded from these sites are being monitores and
possibly targeted for investigation-- go figure. It's
something to think about.

I think in the very early stages of the world wide web, we
should have seen this coming. It shouldn't be anything new
to us that "Big Brother" is going to have a hand in
everything we do. Don't be surprised if every man, woman,
and child be ordered to have chips surgically inplanted in
us for identification purposes, credit, driving, and other
privileges we used to didn't have to have permission to get.

You never know. Times are changing and with the many
changes we experience, it is likely that even using the
bathroom may just be scrutinized.

by jamesg

Yoiu are a fool of the first order, or maybe just simpleminded:
Thank God a decent patriot like GW is at the helm protecting your right to say whatever you want.
Remember Ari "the liar" Fliescher?? "Americans better watch what they say?"
This is an administration crooked to the core. GW is a snake oil salesman from Connecticut, and there ain't no cattle on his "ranch".
You are an idiot.

by networthy

Well Sir, You have just proven how simpleminded and uninformed you are by stooping to personally attacking me and our president. I guess that is all you folks on the left can muster since you are clearly void of any ideas or common sense for that matter.

by mwatch

More of the same from an administration that in many ways has run wild.

We don't need to talk about WMD any more they have served the intended purpose. Unless of course they were moved to Syria, Iran...

This administration basically has told the citizens of the US that they are subject to search without warrant. It's to stop terror after all.

This information will be misused to create a statistical fiction that will be the foundation for MORE laws allowing warrantless surveillance. It's to stop child porn afterall.

What EVIL DOOER is next?? Perhaps Gays? OOPS forgot the "Anti American Gay Agenda" that won him reelection. Maybe Episcopalians they are not Christian enough afterall.

by mejpsimard

As per my work in law, I know that most criminals or terrorists have extensive networks they already know of, mainly by word of mouth. They discuss on IM's the existence of sites and repository of interest to them. They just don't search for the worst crap on a search engine... they already know where they are going before they get online. The real networks are offline and often, quite tangible.

Any use of info from queries on a search engine will trap neither a criminal in the proper sense or terrorist. At best, the info could be used against the overly curious or the slight troublemaker that doesn't even know what he's doing.

In such circumstances, it's no wonder people around the world don't trust their government or big companies. Also, it leaves to think that the code of an OS should be know... so you may be able to truly know if the machine is your's or not! In other words is it really doing "only" what you tell it to do?

The conclusion is that nothing but abuse can be reaped from such seeds. Far from anything useful in face of the facts, it is only our right the read the information we wish to on the net, which will bite the dust... not those dirty porn peolpe.

by f8271955

A simple point of view: These tactics being implemented by bodies of Government are by the same token terrorism in another realm. I applaud the Governments ambition to stop global terrorism but I deplore their assumptions that every individual is a suspect in the war on terrorism. The realms of internet surfing are vast and varied and are not always limited to the idiology of what is legal and what is not, for example downloading a song. What the hell does that have to do with National Security? And how does it fit in with Global Terrorism? These tactics are more in line with Hitler's SS. Everyone should take the time and effort to express their thoughts to their "ELECTED OFFICIALS" and let them know that the public thinks they are overstepping their bounds. gfm

by networthy

'These tactics being implemented by bodies of Government are by the same token terrorism in another realm.'.... Hitlers SS?

Do you see Black Helicopters flying over your house too?

You just can't pay for entertainment like this!
LOL

by f8271955

by all means you grant them explicit priviledges to any and all of your important information. who needs black helicopters when we have the illuminati....."eye in the sky" watching us. I must say the asshole-ometer is registering high volumes here.

by one_of_bunch

That would only be 91 people, but I get what you're saying. I agree that this data should not be monitored mainly because it really isn't useful data to begin with.

by vicdelta

(Hmmmm. Nobody cared about GI's when we returned from Asia in the 1970's. Now everyone is a GI lover. My guess is that most of the 'lovers' were never in a uniform. I have found that the closer one was to war, the less likely he or she wanted to talk about it.)

A while back we guarded our freedom and believed in democracy. We wanted to show the world what democracy was like. It's pretty hard to show what democracy is like when you are spying on your own citizens. It's pretty hard to say to China, don't censor the internet and then do the same through duplicity by making your own citizens uneasy about what they do in private.

Every time I read articles and discussions about these topics, Ben Franklin's quote on liberty and security come to mind. Lately I have been thinking about Ben a lot.

by rixmail

I also know that if there was one US citizen that has been damaged by our governments anti terrorist activities, we would see that person in every news medium available, every day. I haven't seen that.

by one_of_bunch

I agree to the Full Stop on monitoring, but your error is in your logic. The data generated on the Google server. That is where the transaction takes place. Since Google is a company in the U.S. and Google's server resides in the U.S., then the transaction occured in the U.S., regardless of where you personally are.

This fact is what enables the "off-shore" gambling sites to remain open. They are in countries where the U.S. has no jurisdiction, even though the majority of users are from the U.S.

by rixmail

I also know that if there was one US citizen that has been damaged by our governments anti terrorist activities, we would see that person in every news medium available, every day. I haven't seen that.

sorry for double post....

I can tell by that statement that you believe in the "liberal media" myth. Very little of the truth makes it to the incompetent(or corrupt) media in this country. I urge you to visit www.mediamatters.com. I'm sure Bill O'Rielly has told you that they are communists, but check them out anyway. You will see how useless our media really is.

by shearne

As I understand it the government is(was) looking for information on search terms in a broad sense i.e. was a particular subject being searched and how often. I don't believe there is any issue in providing that information so long as there is no personally identifiable data attached to it. That is what Microsoft, Yahoo et al provided. Aggregate information only. While Google may be taking a stand on this issue I don't really understand why. What privacy right is being breached? Privacy of the indivdual is not being compromised by the governments request. Is the government fishing? That would appear to be the case here, so what? I would agree that if data was being sought that could point to an individual we would truly have a problem. Until that time everyone ought to calm down. YMMV.

by oz_media

Applying such a law, OUTSIDE the USA, would be akin to balancing a hair upright on your fingertip. Good luck with that.

For the same reasons that file sharing is not deemed illegal copyright infringement in Canada, this woul dalso be next to impossible to impose here.

AOL, YAHOO etc. would be facing so many massive countersuits it would send them reeling. That would be a breach of Canadian constitutional law, not gonna happen anytime soon, the RIAA has been unsuccessfully trying for YEARS now, but they face much steeper penalties for tracking users via the ISP than the user does for file sharing, (which, by the way, is not deemed copyright infringement here).

by azson

He lied to us about the war, he's spying on fellow americans. Hes giving our econamy to his oil buddies. SUPPORT OUR TROOPS IMPEACH BUSH!

by oz_media

If they stood one behind the other (not a stretch for those two I'm sure), it would only take one high power shot. A cost of less than $2.00 to US citizens, peace restored in Iraq, peace restored to the rest of the world that has to put up with the clown and his little car full of minions and a better global economy.

by rixmail

It has been going on for some time. FISA was enacted because it was found that the government was abusing the power and spying on private citizens in violaton of the 4th amendment. Shortly after taking office Bush authorized changes and started recording the NAMES of people that were being scanned. FISA doesn't get in the way of the "war on tera", it just ensures that there is some degree of oversight to make sure the 4th amendment standard of "probable cause" is met. The FISA court approves thousands of warrants, so the question is. If they are only spying on terror suspects then why not let there be a record? Why not obey the law and allow for judicial oversight?

by pse

Hey, ya want to meet my little sister? I can hook ya up with her.

She's forty-one, but hey, she'd love to meet you.

by technicity99

Why should I trust somebody who doesn't trust me. In other
words the government wants us to trust them but they don't
trust us. Guard your privacy and your data. This is beginning to
look more and more like a fascist state instead of a democracy.
Honest law-abiding citizens should not be subjected to this
nonsense. Then again who's going to decide who's a law-
abiding citizen, them? If that's the case, then we're all in-
trouble.

I'm sorry to hear that MS is going along with this nonsense. XP
will be my last purchase of a microsoft product. I guess that's
why windows (all versions) has so many holes in it, to make it
easier for the government or whomever to spy on/steal from ya.
And I will also stop using yahoo's search engine. I've never used
AOL and don't have any intention of doing so.

I wonder what's next, concentration camps?

by dumblogic

People shpuld read the book 1984 or see the movie, The book was written in 1948 about what life would be in 1984, I think were heading pretty close to what the books said and toward the apoclypse.
Ever since 9/11 people gave up certain freedom in order to be safe, but the government took it and ran with it. With the recent NSA scandels and Bush doing what he pleases with out regard to the constitution, and Microsoft throwing it's two cent in too by wanting to put a black box on it next operating system. I don't like it one bit, what would our fore fathers think of nation today, they would turn over in their grave with disgust.
I applaud Google at the moment cause they refuse to turn over their stuff citing the first amendment right and violation of fare trade pratice.
Google stated that their trust with their people will be violated and their trade secret will be revealed if the government goes forth. What's next camera in our house spying on us. Were are fixing to head to the new world order one ruler one nation of the world. I ask Tech Replublic members one person can't change it but if we band together we can make a difference, and hopefully send a message to the government were not going to take it any more.

by curtispnkrtn

If you go to the SEC and check out qwest or DEX you wil see that Ma Bell sells the program Big Brother Professional for businesses and many other distubing facts. When there is,and has been a phone in every home, business and government office around the world, owned by one corporation since its invention. How much info do you think this corporation owns and/or has used? Big Brother?

by aapjanaya

Collective paranoias and myths had been there since the dawn of history.
Nowadays comic books and films bias so many people minds that they can't tell apart realm from fiction.
Leaders and empowered people, no matter how evil and vicious they could be, they're not supervillians fighting supeheroes in a world of defenseless guys.
There are so many other things to really worry about, that fears on technological espionage sound irrelevant.
Lets try to live happy, without paranoias...

by conquistador

I've spent most of my career dealing with government agencies. One thing I have learned is this: NEVER, NEVER, NEVER believe the government when they want to pass a new law, and they state, "Don't worry. We only want this law for (fill in the blank with some unlikely event)." Once the law is passed, there will always be some jerk government agents who will figure out how to use the law to hurt as many people as possible. It ALWAYS happens.

by itchem

Remember that each of these search engines has a user agreement which specifies your level of expected privacy and what State or country has legal jurisdiction. For example MSN is governed by the State of Washington and Google is governed by the State of California.

When you use these sites you are agreeing to the terms specified by the user agreement. This often includes a provision such as the following from MSN "We may access and/or disclose your personal information if we believe such action is necessary to: (a) comply with the law or legal process served on Microsoft; (b) protect and defend the rights or property of Microsoft (including the enforcement of our agreements); or (c) act in urgent circumstances to protect the personal safety of users of Microsoft services or members of the public."

Therefore there is no absolute expectation of privacy. If one is not comfortable with a provision like this then one needs to find a search engine with better protections.

by saintgeorge

I agree with you completely. Even to the point to suggest that Americans who break the laws of other countries while sitting in their sofas should be extradited to the offended countries.
Be serious. You are the world police because you have the gun, not because you have the right.

by anelson159

After supporting this administration for what I thought were the right reasons after 9-11 , I have now decided that they are pursuing a right wing agenda and hiding behing the "TERRORIST THREAT" agenda to get whatever they want. Now it fear of kiddie porn -(another buzzword) to get what they want about all Americans. I think I may be dropping my AOL and MSN accounts as a means of protest. I have never had a Yahoo account and won't do one now.

by networthy

analson, do us all a favor and drop all of your accounts with whomever! Your way to paranoid.
Once again, if you aren't doing anything wrong...you have nothing to worry about.

by hharms

I couldn't care less if the Government is watchng my every move on the Internet. I do nothing that I am ashamed of nor that I would like to hide from anyone. I DO want our Government to find and do away with child pornographers, child molesters, The Taliban, aberant Mullas and other Muslim extreemist who would do harm to Americans.
Henry

by oz_media

It's no wonder you cry about personal liberties, freedoms being taken away and other technological advances that you fear such as RFID.

The country that claims to be so free is actually far from it. You don't need socialism, you have all of the restraints of HEAVY socialism without the benefits of the systems in place.

In Canada, we have socialist medicine, but we also have freedoms and our government is usually the first to go to bat to protect those freedoms/invasions of privacy.

by bbaltas

A criminal in another country can be prosecuted in the United States, if the appropriate treaty is in place.

Using your example, if the gangster in Tahiti uses the Internet to recruit and hire a hit-man to assisinate someone like Kenneth Lay, for example (I'm not saying this should happen). If a United States procecuter had evidence that our gangster was the employer of said hit-man, the gangster could be extradited from Tahiti to the US to stand trial.

There are some assumptions here, first, a treaty between the US and Tahiti must be in place. Second, the act of hiring a hit-man must be illegal in Tahiti, and third, the procecuting attorney must have enough evidence to convince a Tahiti judge (or some other official) that the person to be extradided is the employer of the aforementioned hit-man.

If you spend some time looking for child porn legal cases on the net, you will find that some of the bigger cases have involved multiple countries.

by networthy

I take it you fought in nam? If so, thank you for your service to our country.

Knowing what the enemy is up to whether they are "citizens" or NOT is a very complicated, yet necesary matter. I am a Network manager for a division of DHS and hold a security clearence that makes me privy to classified information. Believe me when I say that what Bush is doing is right on when it comes to the inside/outside threat. We are at war with an enemy hell bent on either killing us, or converting us. I can't explain it any clearer than that. It's not something that the average uniformed citizen can grasp without seeing the threats that are truly out there. Think of it as "bad poker". Showing your cards before playing your hand is a pretty silly thing to do. A hate-filled left-wing media with an agenda for "getting Bush" has really done an injustice to the American people. It really undermines the serious work ahead of us in the Government. Xgi knows this all to well.

by stephenwl

An airline passanger ID computer system was a total failure.
A revamp of the FBI system was a total failure.
Over the last week a couple of stories in the news about one of the NSA systems a $$ failure.

No reason to trust them.