Discussion Locked

What do you think of our new look?

0 helpful
116 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
TechRepublic has a new front door! We redesigned the page to show you more articles, tools and resources and improve the organization of the information. What do you think? Share your feedback in this discussion.

116 replies

by guruofdos

I would imagine that cosmetics are the least of peoples worries. The functionality of the site still needs to be addressed.

Extra spaces in URLS, broken or missing links, unable to access discussions, to name but a few problems the members constantly point out. What happened to members photos?

I'm sick of getting emails for Q&A posts to say "Your Answer Has Been Rated!" only to click the link and get a message stating "The requested thread has been withdrawn". Searching the Q&A manually the threads are most definitely still there, along with the answers.

Please, please, PLEASE make the site navigate correctly. Most of us couldn't give two hoots what it LOOKS like!!!

by oz_media

But didn't I used to be cute?
I think it was my pre-millennium short-hair phase.

I noticed the page is harder to navigate and the Discussions and Technical Q&A links haven't been moved, users could never find the right place before, wonder what'll happen now.

I would be really curious to see how the visit length per NEW visitor drops due to navigation diiculty or how the number of new page views also drops. Sorry, that should be IF it drops.

As I said in my other response, it looks like some one with great technical knowledge has designed the layout, it is NOT user friendly though and doesn't encourage a non pc-savvy user to explore, it just looks confusing and technical, like a big whitepaper.

Personal FIRST impression is that it is far worse than before as far as simplicity in design, ease of navigation and content layout, which were the main probalems with the last page.

Oh well, it's not for MY clients.

by cptomlly

I emailed TechRepublic regarding the very issue you describe: Click the link and get "Requested Thread has been withdrawn". They informed me that you must have TechRepublic open (and be logged in) to avoid this error. They suggested circumventing the issue by clicking the link a second time after the erroneous page loads, which has worked well for me. Why this known issue hasn't been corrected does peeve me a bit. I'm not sure what my $9.95 a month pays for, but apparently its not code updates.

by oz_media

Well it looks harder to navigate and much busier than the old home page.

Discussions link, once found, is still above the Technical Q&A link, thus ignoring he constant badgering of TR members to change the links.

The ld home page was MUCH easier to navigate yet still too complicated for most new users. I think this is a backstep instead of an improvement, BUT...the page is new and change from the familiar takes time. This is just my first impression as someone who has 'fixed' a LOT of ineffective websites.

It looks like someone with extremely high technical knowledge and no end user knowledge has built it. No offense, but it looks like a white paper as opposed to a user friendly homepage.

Only time will tell.

PS. Didn't I look cute with short hair? Those were the days. I guess you don't need to mention I have no idea how to perform Microsoft Support, I'm an MCNE not an MCSE. I wonder how I responded to the quote stated by my name, uuuuhhhhh, buy NOVELL!!?

Change s always welcome though so lets see how it works? I'd be interested in comparing your # of unique page views and visit length per visitor with your old stats.

by smorty71

First of all, thanks for taking the time to provide feedback.

Second, what specifically makes the new design difficult to navigate? I'd be interested to hear more specific examples on that.

Thanks again,
sm

by jimntz

Easy... Just looking at the page, all you see is links and WORDS... too many words... the amount of text on the page is overwhelming. There's no quick way to find out what's where on the page. There's just one huge mass of text and letters.

Once you actually spend a few minutes looking at the page, you can see what's where. But I wonder how many people are actually going to take the time. It's not readily apparent, so I'd just click on.

This was the exact same problem that made the old ZDNet pages so unviewable... too much text all jumbled together.

by oz_media

From memory, as I don't have the page open right now. There is no easy navigation bar or central navigation of the site. The links are text wchich is fine, but you have multiple sized fonts on a single page, marketing booboo, you also have almost everuthing in a blus text link style. What's a link and what's information or a caption?

Your last start page had a left pane with a beige colored background with you page links easily and clearly defined within it. THis one, even knowing what link I was looking for, had me wondering what was a navigation link, what was a link to an article and how to enter you main sections without opening a specific Discussion link etc.

Too jumbled, bad font sizing, and undefined menu bar creates a messy and hard to navigate home page.

I would recommend a cell based layout that appears to look like a frame layout. It is browser friendly but still has the appearance of older (easier to navigate sites).

I've had the same problem when clients want too much information on a home page.

The Homw or Welcome page should be inviting, links should be easily found and branches should be kept simple. Once I've found the MAIN Discussions page I would then expect to see links to articles, headlines for discussions etc. but not on a home page, it scares visitors away.

Just my 2 cents, and I'm Canadian so in the US 2 Canadian cents are pretty much worthless.

I certainly don't want to offed anyone, it seems like you have been building the site for some time now, it just appears to be hodgepodged together and all crammed into the home page, which I will avoid from now on and just bookmark Discussions and Technical Q&A.

Can I say it looks amateur without offending you? I certainly don't mean to detract from anyone's hard work, I just think it is ineffective and your last home page was better even though it needed improvement.

by john_wills

If I look at an entry in a discussion and then return to the diagram I find myself not at the point of the discussion I was looking at but at the top of the diagram. That means I have to scroll down to the entry to find the entries made in response to it (or the entry to which it is a response).

by oz_media

despite many suggestions to move the Technical Q&A link below the Discussions link, the layout has stayed the same and the same improperly posted questions will once again remain a major annoyance of the site.

Why not simply change the 'technical Q&A' link, which on other sites will point to problems viewing or using the site itself as opposed to getting answers to your own problems, and rename it "GET HELP", "SOLVE PROBLEMS" or "FIND ANSWERS" or anything but Technical Q&A, you may as well call it FAQ's. If I was new and had a question, I wouldn't even consider 'Technical Q&A' before looking to 'Discussions' for my answers.

The two are not clearly defined and it is the biggest irritation for many of us here.

by smorty71

Oz,
Although I don't want to get too far off topic, you touch on a subject that I'm very interested in.

How about a single area where questions and comments are intermingled (instead of in two separate areas)?

Would that be more convenient and/or easier to use?

sm

by oz_media

It would work ONLY if the two were easily defined on a doorway page.

The problem is, people se Discussions/Forums in other sites and that's where they get help. Technical Q$A or SUPPORT is usually a place to find help from the site administrator to update FLASH, view images etc. in the site itself, not a place to find help for your own problems. The two are VERY different and shouldn't be cluttered together.

The top navigation bar, CIO, Net Admin etc. makes me think, how many people actually use these links? If THAT navigation bar was Discussions, Getting help, Security, etc. I think it would be FAR more effective.

Instead of trying to reinvent the lightbulb, people are used to a common payout for MOST sites and wil not find the same user friendly interface here. As soon as you get to the old pages, navigation is MUCH easier. Now I know I've been using the site for while now (just got my Happy Anniversary email note:the survey link isn't working but I have no use for a MS whitepaper anyway.) even though I am familiar with the old layout, it is far easier to navigate. I've NEVER used the actual nav bar on the page header though, I wonder if others do? It may be useless and you could rebuild it with more popular links as described above.

by guruofdos

As Oz pointed out, this is the biggest gripe that users have. We try desparately to keep the two separate!!!

We WOULD like Discussions split into two areas. Serious Discussions on IT related subjects on one...call it 'Tech Talk' or something equally catchy, and a separate one for 'water cooler' type discussions which are offbeat, leary or just plain geeky!

But PLEASE do NOT call it 'Water Cooler Talk'. That is just 'too' American. You will see that the livliest debates attract a big non-US following, and we'd like something 'international' in flavour. Can you also make the ads relevant for the same reason. Most good 'international' sites are not only browser aware, but can work out the origin of visitors, and can thus apply relevant advertising!

Sorry, but the Brits, Canadians and Aussies get sick of the same old crap adverts for IBM, Dell and HP, which have no relevance to us whatsoever. I calculate that 30% or more of the traffic on this site is from outside the US (not necessarily 30% of the membership!!), which means you are losing a potential 30%+ of possible advertising revenue by ignoring the fact that there is a BIG WIDE WORLD outside the US!!!

by oldefar

I am sure you are hoping for more input than just from Oz.

First regarding the problem with finding the question when we receive the email notifying us that our answer has been rated - works fine if we have TR open in our browser, but as GuruOfDos points out if we don't it seems to say the discussion no longer exists. This frustrated me until I understood the need to have TR open when using the email link.

Next, the Q&A needs to operate in some sort of dialogue, similar to the Discussions. Three reasons for this. First, a dialogue that kept active Q&A at the top of the list make comments/replies from the original poster easy to find. Second, we all learn from the answers others give. Third, Accept/Reject as the only options is poor human relations.

I would also like a larger achive of my questions and discussions. It is tough to find particular responses from months or years past, and yet the solution is often there if we can only find it and send the poster to it.

I also miss the Favorites, where key articles worthy of being marked for future reference could be kept.

As for the new front page format, there have been some excellent comments made. However, a big part of the negative response may be from a sudden change. I would hold off for at least a week to see if the comfort returns.

by oldefar

There are a couple of posts on how to have a good discussion, one by Jules and one by Vladolar. Both are about what is acceptable.

Now it seems to me that a timer on postings within a particular discussion or thread might be a good idea. Most of the flaming seems to come in fast sequences, and having a forced delay before responding might cause some additional thought to go into a posting. The timer would be user specific - I could not post in this thread again for some time period (30 minutes, 60 minutes?) or until say 3 others had added comments.

The opposite makes sense in the Q&A section, where a series of quick posts and comments, plus responses, can aide in resolving an issue. Often the issues are urgent and delays are a problem.

This indicates to me that the two sections are rightly separate areas.

by smorty71

Oz,
Don't worry about offending anyone with your comments. This is the type of candid feedback that we like to hear.

Thanks,
sm

by guruofdos

We tell you the redesign was a waste of time and money. The site was 'erratic' in operation at best before the change and now it is much much worse. It is too cramped, too crowded and very hard to navigate without a lot of scrolling.

Spare a thought for us people without the latest hardware. We don't all have scrolly-rolly mice and hi-res 19" TFT screens. Spare a thought for the users with 14" VGA and a basic two button mouse.

Web sites should also be keyboard friendly, that is to say, navigable by using the tab key....TR? Forget it!

And as for Netscape, Opera and Mozilla browser compatibility...I won't even go there!!

by generalist

Initial response: Okay, why didn't the TR homepage download properly.

Next level of response: You need to do something about the way the text links run together. Under IE 6, a number of the text links tend to merge together. While this may load faster than icons, it gets a little confusing. Perhaps using list tags would help out here.

by guruofdos

Put the advertising at the bottom of the page so we do not have to scroll past ads to find links to the content we want! A homepage should be navigable WITHOUT scrolling.

Also, btw, it is a nightmare in 800x600 or lower resolutions, requiring scrolling in both directions to navigate. I run my screen resolution at 768 x576 (PAL video format) as I do a lot of video work and this site does not rescale. Any web-site worth a light should be browser resolution-aware and rescale content accordingly, not force users to change resolution to work with the site.

by mrsguru

Go back to the way it was please. It looks terrible now. My husband just logged off, and I could not log in. The 'Log In' link has gone. I searched everywhere on the very cramped page and then found I had to click My Account. Put it back the way it was please. I have only been a member for a few days, and really do not like the new look. No Siree. If it wasn't broke don't try to fix it.

by oz_media

Did you finally take the keyboard away from Mr. guru so you could keep things clean, or are we in for even more fun now?

Yes the page is kinda yucky, I think It looks better on my notebook than my desktop but it;s all so......BLUE!

I am still confused by all the links down the right side, Newest, Most popular, most active WHAT??? Not discussions because the links shown are neither. Oh, I thoink it's for ARticels. Needs a header then, no that would just be MORE BLUE! This is like Soilent'Blue', the sequel to Soilent Green.

Oh well, hiya, nice to have you join in!
OzMedia

by smorty71

So, it sounds like better naming of those two features (Tech Q&A and Discussions) would go a long way to fixing the problem you described?

by oz_media

The problem I have is the number of people posting Tech questions in the discussion forum.

If I spent an hour digging up links for people and typing detailed descriptions of repair proceedures, I want a break when I look at the discussions. TO find 8 out of 10 discussions are just people asking about viruses, monitor and graphics card problems etc. is annoying.

I think if the two were CLEARLY defined by the links and were EASY to find on the page,it would be much more effective, that's id you can find the links to begin with.

Center them in a cell, colour a background in the cell. Title it and have clear links instead of MORE BLUE TEXT ?!?!? Anyone would think you've hired the Blue men from Intel.

by oldefar

The fonts on the links under Resources really are annoying - they simply don't fit the rest of the page and so seem like grafitti!

The rest of the layout is beginning to grow on me. (or is it just a rare snow fall in North Texas???)

by oz_media

Yeah the jumbled links are still hard on the eyes.

The overall page is looking a LITTLE nicer in that the grey background helps center the columns.

Still seems like a LOT of article links that should be inside a doorway page for the articles.

by voldar

Grate job you did when changing and setting the same fonts size for the what I call "the tabloids" (Security str..., Newest, etc.), or is just an impression? If it's just an impression, I really need to go for an eye-check to the doctor. :))

by voldar

I think it would be great to have something like a "go to top" on the page, at least at the bottom of it, because it's hard to scroll up and down :D.

by oz_media

Technically a PUB is a public house and NOT neccessarily a place to purchase alcolhol (heaven forbid).

The Backyard, The Lunchroom, The PUB, The...you get the idea.

by guruofdos

If Ty-Phoo put the 't' in Britain, someone has to put the 'pub' in the Republic!

Call it anything, just so long as people (weeners?) dont post 'How do I fix my....' or 'Where can I download....'

by oz_media

Yes Oldefar Favorites would be nice.

You can also get by the WIthdrawn error by just closing and reopening the page. I think it grabs your TR ID the first time around and the second time you click the link it's OK as you are logged in.

Also an EDIT feature for posts (Like all the OTHER sites use would be handy!!)Spell check too while you're at it.

As for the site being 'new'. Of course I took this into consideration vefore making my comments and said as much. Although change takes adjustment, there are obvious mistakes that are detrimental to ANY website.

I noticed that the text displays properly now whereas I was getting multiple font sizes at first. BUT, even though TR is a BLUE company, there's TOO MUCH BLOOOOOOOO!!! It's like EVERYTHING is a link and you just don't have any guidance without reading the page. Get bored and you've lost another visitor.

One thing I focus on is site friendliness and navigation, this is what keeps people coming back and new people interested. The stats will fall without ANY doubt whatsoever. Hits mean nothing, visitors, durations and page views are everything.
The easier to navigate, the longer they stay, I have reams of visitor stats to prove the success of simple navigation in sites I've built.

by cactus pete

The first time I saw the page, I thought the left side bar must have failed to load. I actually refreshed several times before thinking someone must have ripped it out while screwing around with the layout. Then I saw your post...

The top of the pages have always been too loaded with things in which I have no interest. Almost every page I want to read, I have to page down to see the meat of the discussion, or question, or list of items and options. This certainly was not addressed in your latest release, as I did not even bother to look for the discussion and Q&A links since they weren't on the left anymore, and only the very tops of the letters for the links were peeking up from the bottom of the window. Please make you most popular links easy to get to, and quickly.

You have advertising everywhere. Yes, I know that's how you're making money, but it does seem a bit invasive. And when I happen to load them from older PCs, the animations really chew up the procesor and memory. [Luckily, I've just upgraded again...]

I like to tell designers to try to make the sites simple and elegant. Ease of use trumps mounds of content every time. Thin out the nav bars, and place the different categories up there, not just different groups within the same category...

The resources in the middle of the page is usually a bad layout, too. Links belong at the top, bottom, or side.

Also, the new page is wider than the old one by a few pixels. I used to size my IE window to fit your site, now I have to do it again...

The three column idea doesn't usually work, and I don't think it does here, either. Particularly when they aren't all the same length. This makes your footer one heck of a drag [forgive the pun] to get to...

Things need to find a place where they fit well, and they need to stay there. Change your theme, change your content, but don't change how easily I can find what I want to see.

That's what I have for first impressions.

by cactus pete

The site still doesn't appear attractive to me. Sorry.

I think you may be trying to hard. There is still too much information, to much of a visual load to make sense of it all quickly. I want to immediately see what I'm trying to get to, then go there.

If you want to leave the advertisment column at 40% of the width of the window, taking up almost half of the height in my config, then I think you should remove the lower information - drop the survey from the home page, or at least trim it considerably.

Also, I just noticed that I've completely ignored everything undet the ad on the right side.

I think the boarder is a waste of space.

by cactus pete

OK, it's lunch and I have a few minute sto look again...

I noticed that the leadin isn't under a title section. Is it the "Topic of the day" or is this what the site is all about? "Protecting your network" is the first thing someone will see when looking to the natural placement for the site's layout. So I feel like you need to compartmentalize that a little.

I think that should carry through with the other columns, as well. There really aren't any subjects to give you context about what you're looking at. I know TR is about more than what you make it appear to be at first glance.

For instance, under the "Advertisement" you have "Newest". Newest what?? Newest ads? You have to scroll down considerably before seeing that "newest" is to contrast "most popular", "most active" and "from vendors" - which I won't bother to read, as it seems likely to just be more ads.

I like the fact that you labeled a compartment as "Resources" but it doesn't belong at the same header level as "what keeps you up at night?" Shouldn't that header be "Surveys" with a subheading for the particular survey's name? Then, under that heading, you have two columns with numbered sections 1-4. These lead themselves to be part of the survey, so if I don't care for the survey, I skip it. You need a different header for a different section.

Also, you can probably save yourself a lot of anxiety and formatting woes by getting rid of the pictures. Personally, I don't care what anyone looks like on the teaser to your article [no offense]. The picture can go into the article itself, but save the valuable room [and layout appearences] in the home page.

by voldar

that you guys gave a lot of good advices, but still, I say to myself, what a heck, why not to post my impressions too?
So, for starting, when first time I entered the site, I thought something is happening with my browser and I start it again (at least two times - yeah, I am getting old I think), and then I finally got your post about "new look".
Okay! I said to myself, lets look!
Honestly? Too much "chaos" at first time see, but in the following hours, after becoming more familiar with the new page, it was not that bad. Only maybe the fact that you use of a lot of different fonts sizes. You should try to use at least the same type-size on the fonts of ALL the "TABLOIDS titles" (Newest, Security ... , Resources).
From what I see, they are not! Try also to put some "back to .." links, because even with a scrolling mouse, it's hard to go up to bottom and then back to the top, and remember, we all (or at least myself) use "that finger" :P.
And I would like also to know what's the difference between "Newest" and "What keeps you up at night?" ?
My opinion, these should have to be reported to another page, not belonging to the so called index page. A link and a little description or some "starts" of articles (not links to articles) of what contains that page would be just fine. The same thing for the Resources. I'd split in two tabloids: one called "Resources" (Downloads, Books and CD-s, E-newsletters) and the other one called "Join our club" (Discussion Center, Peer-Directories).
As Oz_metal and lot of others said not only in this thread but also in others, I think it is good to have a in the Discussion Center, a distinction between the Tech-Discussion, the Miscellaneous Discussions and, the "Share your knowledge" section (I mean the Q&A area).
For the rest ... blue is fine, I like it, but if you can "aerate" a little bit the page would be even better.

by oz_media

Somone wanted help in asking the right questions when trying to evaluate service of hids customers.

Some mentioned asking an open qestion and others suggested several general Probing wuestions or closed questions.

Well, THIS is what happens when you ask an open question. It was brave of you to ask in such a way and a very inviting way to get honest feedback. You've taken quite the beating and now I'm harping about how you asked the question to begin with!!

Oh well, tomorrow's another day right?

by smorty71

Oz,
In order to get the kind of feedback we need, it has to be open-ended. Otherwise, we don't get any information on the specific issues users are having. Asking a "yes" or "no" question would only leave us with, in this case, a bunch of "no's". That's not all that helpful for us in evaluating what elements aren't working.

Plus, we have more than enough quantitative data pouring in about pageviews, unique visits, session length, etc., etc.. I really wanted to add some qualitative data, too.

sm

by supermonch

I like it. The page has a cleaner look and feel to it. Previously, I felt like the information was all over the place, but the page has better flow now. Good Job!

by maxwell edison

.
Like anything new and different, it might take some time to get used to. First impressions may be important in job interviews or asking a girl out on a date, but when people are afforded the benefit of that second, third, and fourth impression, things may eventually be seen in a different light.

If your intent was to "show more articles, tools and resources", I think you've done that quite well. I do think, however, that your desire to "improve the organization of the information" fell a bit short. On the former comment, there certainly are quite a few more links readily available. On the latter comment, it seems as though everything runs together. The resources links, for example, although the text is larger, the color of the text and background is all the same, and there's nothing to separate it from the rest. The subtle yellow background is gone, as is the obvious separations with distinct borders, both of which made the resources links and/or the different subject areas stand out a little better - and easier to look at.

Although you have more links, they just don't seem to stand out like they should. Like I said, I think they need some kind of distinction between the subjects (I liked the mild yellow background and distinct borders that used to act as a separator), and the smaller text seems harder to focus in on - especially for these 50 year old eyes.

by oz_media

Yes it does look better today than yesterday, I think it actually has chaned but don't really remember.

My 2nd impression is better than the first but that doesn't work with websites.

The ruls of thumb, you have 6 seconds to grab attention and if the person doesn't find a suitable link in 12-20 seconds, your SOL and they're gone.

There is no 2nd and 3rd impression if people aren't absorbed at first lance. Sure we all keep coming back and will adjust, but it could be hot pink now and I'd probably stick around.

Needs to be simplified into simple navigation bars or columns with more complex and detailed info on the various doorways inside the different sections of the site.

Too long, too much scrolling.

by ron vought

Outstanding job! Keep up the great work! Have always valued TechRepublic's services and this is another fine example of creative workmanship geared towards the members needs!
Thank you.

by harry.shipley

Here's what I found when downloading the page, all this junk just to read a page, what a shame. Who's watching your puter;
Cookies=78
Web Bugs=21
Data Spills=17
Ads=10
Style Sheets=4

by bruce timberlake

The new pages don't render nicely at all in
Konqueror... and KHTML is one of the best (and
standards compliant) HTML rendering engines out
there! Major gripes: a huge blank spot at the
top of each page (below the logo and above the
section selection area (CIO, IT Manager, etc),
and fonts are HUGE by default. Overall, very
confusing compared to old layout IMO.

by oz_media

TO add a delay or timer/restriction to multiple posts would be OK for stopping arguments but repressive for a fair discussion.

If I am takling with two or three people in the same thread but on slightly different aspects of the thread, would i not then be restricted from answering all the posts I want to adress in a single visit?

If a discussion is lively and positive, it would stop quick discussion by slowing down response times and making the thread drag out. Sometimes a quick succession of comments is needed.

The only problema these days seem to be with Max and myself. I simply cannot post with out it being questioned and turned upside down, lately incorrectly. I have asked nicely, I have emailed an aside in an attempt to stop the badgering etc. all to no avail. Then get accused by Max of constantly flamig HIM! It's one side and one side only, it definitely isn't my side that is accepted whether for or against posts.

10 people disagree without repercussion, if I disagree, all hell breaks loose.

It will stop though, it's inevitable that it must because I'm gettingas tired as the rest of you with it.

by dc_guy

I like the look, I like the way it's organized, and I like the navigation. I also like the things you resisted adding, like blinding contrast, indecipherable fonts, dancing paper clips, and drifting banners.

by oz_media

Wothout predjudice:

I would say that the more technically inclined or text learned people would see this as a nice site.

Those that have a more creative or artistic thought process (as opposed to technical) would see it as jumbled and busy.

From a new visitor or general user perspective, which I think would be the main target, people will be turned away my the immense amount of information and busy layout. This is based on prior experience working with site targeting and positioning.

Newbies and those who can't figure out how to view jpegs in Outlook are going to run screaming at first glance.

by wordworker

I like the changes to the home page layout in general, but it sure does look more like a classic ZDNet page than a TR page.

I don't like one bit that it takes two clicks to get to an article. Whazzup with that, trying to generate double the page views? Click on a title, then "Click to view entire article" isn't exactly user friendly.

Ditto on the discussions about rearranging the links to the Discussion and Tech Q&A. Customers are talking, but apparently no one is listening to that particular thread.

Finally, it's actually nice to see links to the CDs and books with prices right out front. But.... where are the TR/CNET T-shirts? the polo shirts? mouse pads? light-up pens? Every other site on the 'net with a logo sells their "stuff," so why can't TR figure out how to do it? Does anybody remember when a certain VP came on board from Infoworld and announced that a full 20 percent of their sales came from selling "stuff?" Get with it, CNET/TR/ZDNET. You're missing out on easy, easy money.

by wordworker

Would anybody else cough up twenty bucks US for a nice TR polo shirt? Or fifteen bucks for a cool TR t-shirt? Maybe TR is saving those goodies for when someone finally makes an executive decision about what to do with all those TechPoints we're accumulating (besides spending them in TechQ&A).

by maxwell edison

.
I'm waiting for them to live up to their promise to exchange merchandise for techpoints. That's what they promised years ago - before I gave them all those hours (for free) answering all those questions. What else am I going to use my gazillion points on?

The least they could do is offer a free TechProGuild membership in exchange for some lousy points.

by oz_media

I have never seen advertising you have to pay for in order to wear, outside the designer labels that have created so many problems in todays youth.

Why would I wear a $20 TR T-Shirt when Novell's are free?
Why would I buy a TR cap when NEC's are free?

You don't (shouldn't have to) buy advertising.

by jack

What is the purpose behind half-page previews of one-page articles?
Silly me - It's to show more advertisements.

by wordworker

One thing I thought would have been changed in a site upgrade is the design of those TechPoints graphics, the ones that identify members with 5,000 and 10,000 TechPoints earned. 4 pixels by 4 pixels, black lettering on dark blue background.... Hmmm...what's wrong with that picture, other than the fact that they're illegible! Make them bigger, or change the background color, otherwise they're a giant waste of screen real estate.

by smorty71

Fasthands,
You've brought up some excellent points; however, I would just like to clarify that this wasn't a full site redesign. It was only the front door.

We hope to be able to address the other items soon.

sm

by oz_media

I had assumed, possibly incorrectly, that the front (index) page was an example of the future site desugn. As it was still being developed, other pages had not aquired the 'new look'.

Perhaps another angle would have been to create a TEST front page. Just a URL to a 'possible' redesign or designs instead of actually changing the most important part of the site, index.html until confirmed as a viable change.

Either way, what's done is done, right?

Will the rest of the site adopt the same look and feel as the index? If not, why ? ( I don't really think you would do that though, TR has always been uniform even if it needed changes).

The thing I think that turned me off was the thougth that ALL of the pages would be laid out as the home page is, heaven forbid you paint my sandbox blue too!

I hope that you are really looking for input to change things and not just tweak the monster you've already created, because even though I've noticed font sizes are a little more uniform, the mess of links and impossible navigation are still there though. Please tell me you will fix navigation. As a designer yourself, you MUST realize that multiple navigation systems is the worst site mistake made.

The top of the page has a navigation bar that I'm sure not too many people use, I would be interested to see how and why it was used by visitors.

the old style had two nav bars but they were easily seen. You look at the top and then the left pane for navigation, in this case, just the top.

if I was a NEW user or someone (heaven forbid a newbie)seeking help, I wouldn't have even let the page fully load before hitting BACK to find something a little less intimidating to navigate.

Even AS a regular, I was all over the page before noticing the Discussion and Q&A links, they don't look like navigation links, they look like text links or article links, not a way to 'surf' a site.

by oz_media

I usually haven't paid much attention to them (they're just to hard to see) but I have noticed that there seems to be only two levels shown anyway, I could be wrong due to the tiny print.

10K is dark blue, and 5K is lighter blue.

That's pretty much the only distinction I know of. Are there multiple levels within these colors too or is it all 5K light blue, 10K dark blue? If so, it's good enough as is I guess.

by wordworker

Is this new or maybe it's just my machine - but I can no longer get to profiles when clicking on the member's alias-link. I get "The page you've requested cannot be found."

by oz_media

I guess TR figures we don't want them, actually it's probably just a restructure/database thing that will be ironed out.

by wzeig

I like it..it is alot easier to navigate & find what I'm looking for..keep up the good work!!!

by wordworker

Oz, where can one get the aforementioned free Novell shirts? I'll take one! I'm a cool-t-shirt-aholic.

All I can tell you Oz is when I was running the "Pop Quiz" and giving away a TR t-shirt every week, I got dozens if not scores of requests from people dying to buy them, since their names weren't selected in the random drawing. Those were customers dying to pay for what I called viral marketing/advertising for what was at that time a brand-new site. Get the shirts out, get the name out.

People who are willing to buy your stuff should have the opportunity to give you their money! When you're monetizing a web site, selling t-shirts and other stuff is low-hanging, easy fruit. What's the harm?

Actually I own some of the coolest original TR-wear from first two years. Let's test my theory: What am I bid on men's large short-sleeve black polo or a long-sleeve denim, both with the original red-and-black logos, both excellent condition? ;]

by oz_media

I'd offer to pay HALF the shipping.

I also have three leather tour jackets though from well known world famous bands, a polar fleece from almost every vendor I've dealt with or company I've worked for (very popular here).

I've been offered over a thousand for one of my jackets but it's mine.

As for standard non-collectible vendor wear, if you give it to me, I may wear it at home, under the car or in the garden, but I don't advertise vendors in public, OK my picture on the homepage is cropped but I'm wearing a Guineess T-Shirt (at home). I have real clothes I wear outside.

Novell t-shirt, after attending a thousand of thier little breakfast and dinner seminars, I still hadn't been given one. I sent them an email asking how to get one and they mailed one to me within a week.

When studying for my MCNE test, I was unable to get the normal laptop case and shirts, pens etc. you get by attending the course. I wrote and passed the test, sent them an email and now have a Novell laptop case, polo shirt and cap.

APC power had several meetings I was unable to attend, they were also haning out kryptonite laptop locks, I wanted one so I sent them email, three days later Loomis dropped it off for me.

Squeaky wheel gets the grease? Ask and you shall receive? Whatever, if you ask for it, you will get it. If you offer to buy it, someone will sell it to you.

Off topic, I was at lunch 8-9 years ago and was teaching a sales rep how assumptive closing worked. While in the food fair at lunch, I got up and walked over to a table and asked a man for his lunch, within one minute I walked back to my table with his tray in hand. I gave it back to him with a thank you but made my point.

There's a wat to get things and a way to buy things. Everyone knows how to open a wallet, if they practiced opening doors instead, they wouldn't need the wallet.

by mra2

Don't like it! Perhaps it will take time for me to be more comfortable with it......

by sordito

Once again, users have to learn a new home page to find the resources that they need. Eventually they learn the new page that they need, just to have it change again-thus starting the process all over again.

The information overload on one page does not help either.

Image having to learn to drive all over again every year because pedals, steering wheel, levers, gauges, etc. moved every year, rendering prior knowledge irrelevant.

Just my two cents.

by jimntz

It's still a horrible design.

Someone commented that there's too much navigation at 800x600. I find that's the only way the silly choice of fonts for the new site make it viewable at all.

And there is still too many words and too many links on the page. Any earlier commenter (OZ I believe) was right, if someone comes in from Google or elsewhere and doesn't see what they want in a few seconds, they're going to be GONE. This page doesn't make it easy to find anything.

Words words words... links links links... The page practically screams "Please click SOMETHING, we're desperate for pageviews. Yes, there's SOMETHING here for you, even if our 'Search' engine couldn't find it if its life depended on it."

by smorty71

Sordito:
Thanks for your feedback.

I would like to comment on your use of the driving analogy, though. A page redesign isn't necessarily like having the pedals and steering wheel of your car moved around. Your monitor, mouse and keyboard are the elements most like the car's "hardware" you mentioned.

A page redesign is more like highway construction. The route that you use to get from one place to another may change a bit; however, the tools you use stay the same.

So prior knowledge of the route may change; however, your prior knowledge of how to drive the car remains intact.

by smorty71

Hi John:
This thread is intended to discuss the new front door design, so I'm a little confused about where you are experiencing the problem you describe? Is this on the new home page? Please advise.

by john_wills

I was thinking of the site as a whole. The change in the home page is not a change in convenience, just in aesthetics, but as you were asking I thought I might mention a place where improvement is possible.

by rr1

Well I find the frontpage kool, personal, orderly and more to the point. The colors are not so hard on the eyes and the text human relative. That makes it easy reading and comprehensive. oops

by csmith

The error of "The requested thread has been withdrawn" still occurs every time one of my answers has been accepted.
This error has been present for quite a while (Last 65 answers accepted?), but is only a minor irritant,
yet, it is a sign more work is needed.
Regards, Chris

by oz_media

I asume you know that if you have TR open when you click the email link, it will work. or Simply close the page and the link should work the second time around.

I know it is still annoying but that's how you work around it.

by csmith

Thanks for the comment.
I also received several emails.
This was my error.
I did not make it clear that this problem, although minor, has been around for a while, and should have been fixed.
I should have put "Why is this problem not yet fixed?" as the subject, and started, in the first sentence, complaining that I did not like the workaround.
Oh well, I need to start proofreading before I hit submit.
Regards, Chris

by john.m1

Most things already covered,,,,BUT,,,,

Sidebar navigation has become a standard, widely used, familiar to all surfers, neat, tidy, easy, so TR decide to dump it! (shakes head in disbelief).

Ads on a homepage is poor design, index pages should be clean, clear and offer easy to navigate options or contents (here's a clue, guess why it's often called the "welcome" page).

I am 100% with 'Oldefar' I MISS MY FAVOURITES, it P'd me off when i suddenly found that my "reference archive" just went, it was like losing a hdd and realising that i hadn't made a backup, except that would have been my dumb choice! TR gave me no choice (and i must've missed the warning too).

please can you get rid of the spyware from TR (adware) i refer to "Avenue A"
The Avenue A cookie is a notorious cross-site navigation privacy invasion which is activated by banner ads on each page.
sorry but i don't like being watched.

thats it from me in old blighty.

by john.m1

Yeah, and another thing,,,,

i agree that the log in button should be displayed.

i went to the peer directory, it said that i need to be a member, ?, i thought i was, so i followed another link that allowed me to "log in" again but it still tells me that i need to be a member. i could get paranoid about not being wanted!
??)

by frank-mw

Just love it to have additional links everywhere. Sort of best search results without googling.

by andy raffalski

Where can I log in, since I usually prefer not save my password ? There should be a login near the top.
I didn't like the layout. I feel like I am coming from my chaotic world and entering another chaotic world. I instantly felt lost, and didn't want to look any further.
Please simplify the site look and feel. Give me one simple homepage, and provide quick access links to what your audience mostly want and need. At least quick access to a site map. Functionality needs to be king here.

AR

by john.m1

day 2, nah still don't like it

please, someone help me.

TR e-newsletters, how come every interesting article has a link straight to the cnet.com homepage?
Thats it!
they just dump you on the index page, bye bye swim home if you can little surfer.
where are the interesting articles that have tempted me, do they exist?
Or,
what am i doing wrong, why does TR make Me feel like i'm the one who's doing something wrong?

I manage to get around hundreds of other sites without so much bother!

JohnM

by Jay Garmon

Which e-newsletters are you receiving that have malfunctioning links? Also, if you don't mind saying, what is your OS, e-mail client, and ISP?

We may be able to solve this problem rather easily.

by john.m1

Thanks Trivia Geek

Win2K
Tiscali (Lineone.net)
NTL cable broadband
________________________

Typical Header

From: "Disaster Recovery at TechRepublic.com"

?

Add to Address Book ? ? Block sender ?
To: john.m1@lineone.net
Cc:
Subject: [TechRepublic] Eliminate the need for backup windows
Sent: Tue, 17 Jun 2003 01:28:19 -0700

_________________________

Example of some Links

NEW AT TECHREPUBLIC

ZARCA INTERACTIVE MAKES SURVEY RESULTS MORE MEANINGFUL
Zarca Interactive is taking some of the pitfalls out of large survey
deployments. Its outsourced approach to survey creation and deployment

can
help IT managers easily build custom surveys without a steep learning
curve in statistical sampling.
http://cl.com.com/Click?q=70-3vcJIdpCybPogEmBKd3_w_OcBk9Y

PREVENT BOREDOM WITH THESE CLASSROOM TRAINING TIPS
When the lights go down in the classroom, the projector's hum can lull
your students into a pleasant slumber. Use these tips to wake them up

and
keep them interested in your training program.
http://cl.com.com/Click?q=85-2GOoQ7KXeJObVyCGmvM1yKXhUBeZ

FIND POTENTIAL PROBLEMS ON YOUR SERVER WITH NETWARE'S ERROR LOGS
Although you can't constantly watch your server to make sure
everything's working correctly, you can check system logs to see what

happened while
you were away. We'll tell you which NetWare logs you should check and
how to interpret them.
http://cl.com.com/Click?q=9b-7-VFQSIH1AMLzLZJI-wLtrul0Tlg

_________________________________

As i said, all roads lead to rome, well Cnet.com home page anyway.

again thanks, JohnM ??)

by imancomp

It seems more atractive and fast to move between pages.
What about the organization?

Greetings.

by john.m1

as in (pub singer mode)"hemabey its-a becoz i'm a londoner"

The answer is, i think, because i didn't put a title a default one was taken from my answer which was soooo long that it caused the thread to drop down and overlap the wrong thread.

hope this helps, it's not the nanoo nanoo aliens.

by maxwell edison

.
How is it possible that imancomp@yahoo.com replied to a message two days BEFORE john.m1 posted it?

The original message was posted on 02/22/04. The answer was posted on 02/20/04.

Dang, I wish I could see two days into the future.

(Or do I just need a cup of coffee this morning?)

by dberdick

I like the new home page layout EXCEPT FOR THE ADVERTISEMENT in the upper right hand corner.
We're bombarded with enough of that junk already. TechRepublic is my home page and I like the articles and information there.
Get rid of the ads please.

by fwapelz

I don't know about your new look as i am new to this place. there are a few things, though, that i don't like the looks of.
1. when i do a select all and print one of your pages, i don't like to look at a piece of paper with only an advertizement on it.
2. when i download from a page and close the download manager i would like to look at the page where i originated the down load, not a blank.
3. after a download i don't want to go back to the page that was emailed and have to start the search process to find the page where i originated the download.

by k4k

Great look , Great Work.

but most of the good articles moved to Techproguild . we miss out some needy articles on this.

Thanks

Kiran

by smarti5734

It looks clear and is easy to identify what you are looking for. It also gives you choices on how in depth ou want the article to be. Good job.

by deback2u

I like the new look. It is easier to find the info required. It used to take two or three clicks or scrolls to find the article from which I launched the site. Now it appears without being masked with the necessary ads.

Good job!

by philospher

I like the way th new page is organized. It shows the directly what you need to goto without hunting. It looks cleaner and more professional.

by vbs7

I have been noticing that it is much harder to locate the content especially from links that are distibuted in the email. Here is one such example: This article outlines the specific parameters of SQL Server DTS, walks you through sample usage of the DTS Import/Export wizard, and illustrates how to customize the system for specific data migration scenarios.
https://www.techrepublic.com/article_guest.jhtml?id=r00720020201rnw01.htm&fromtm=e060

I was very interested in this but am unable to find the content purported to be here. It may well be but I don't have time to drill into everything

-Dave Vantine

by wordworker

Somebody at CNET assumed no one would notice when they nuked everybody's Favorites, but they did. Why'd they do it? Because keeping them would have required making sure all the URLs saved would continue to work.

But...since they changed the structure for content URLs, the old-style links, like the one you posted, resolve to the TR home page (instead of going flat-out 404).

Others in this forum have said that TR committed one of the cardinal sins of Web design by orphaning those old links. Perhaps they (whoever "they" are) thought there were performance benefits or some such crap that outweighed the negative effects on the customer's experience.

I'm aware of a LOT of sites that gave TR free publicity by publishing links back to the older content. Too bad so many of the people clicking on those links now will have the same negative experience David V. had.

by mike page

I don't like the Article Excerpts feature. It is an extra step that makes no sense. The excerpts in no way save me time, but clicking on the "View the entire article" link adds an annoying extra step.

by fesmith49

Change is sometimes good. A gradual transition may have been better. I don't like the layout. Fro me to diffuclt to find the things I am looking for. Things appear to be on top of each other.

by toddj

Looks like a lot more information but I am thinking it is not really much more than before. It is a little hard to follow where before topics and links came right out at you and now they seem more obtrusive.

by boxwood

THE LOG IN SHOULD BE IN THE UPPER RIGHT CORNER AS WITH THE OTHER PAGES.
[WHEN YOU TRY TO ACCESS, "MY DISCUSSIONS",ON THE
DISSUCION PAGE" AND HAVE NOT LOGGED IN, THE LINK TAKES TO A PAGE THAT SAYS "...MUST LOG IN FIRST...", ON THAT PAGE IS: HOME/....LOGIN BUT YOU CAN'T CLICK TO LOG IN-JUST GO TO HOME.
ON HOME PAGE YOU CAN'T LOG IN IN UPPER RIGHT CORNER AS THE LINK IS NOT THERE.
SO I FOUND A CIRCLE OF DO NOTHING.]