Discussion Locked

What do you think of our new look?

0 helpful
116 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

116 replies

by av .

I love the pictures, but I think its too busy. There is too much information crammed into a page, not enough white space. Your categories are confusing. They aren't explained well enough. They aren't highlighted enough to separate them from other parts of the web page.

I love the pictures though. Its great to see a face associated with an opinion.

by rodo

It's true that there's more info in this new page but to be true it's not better than before....
It may impress new comers in TechRepublic but I liked best the previous look, thanks!

by jimntz

Ok... I've given the new homepage several days now and I still don't like it. And apparently, neither does quite a few other people around here.

However, let's face facts. We can gripe and complain in this forum all we want about how miserable the new design is, but what they're going to be most concerned about is page-views. If page-views go up, which they probably will if for no other reason than we're all confused and wind up clicking all over the place in a desperate attempt to find what we're looking for, they'll pat each other on the backs and say "Look! It's great! Look at how high the page-views are now! Those people in the forums are nuts!"

However, if page-views remain the same or drop, then they'll realize what we're saying.

Fortunately, they haven't messed up the tabs yet. They still have the Classic TR look. I'm going to bookmark my favorite tab (Support) and only go there. If I go anywhere else, it will be to another tab, NOT the homepage. I suggest that everyone else do the same. If the Classic TR pages increase page-views, then maybe they'll get the hint.

Think of it as New Coke vs. Coke Classic.

by smorty71

JimNtz:
First, I'm not sure I buy your assertion that pageviews will go up out of confusion. While there are more links on the home page, I don't think the links themselves have become more confusing. All of the Resources have retained the same labels as before. And most of the other items on the page are links directly to individual pieces of content. So unless, the titles of articles/downloads/tools have become more confusing since the redesign, I don't think your assertion is correct.

Second, pageviews are just one of the many metrics we look at to determine the success of a page. Customer satisfaction is one of them. That is why we solicit feedback in this forum.

sm

by oz_media

In fact it is quite the opposite.

If the home page is even the sligtest bit confusing or jumbled, visitor is gone. This isn't theory, it is just the way the web works.

6 - 12 seconds to find something interesting or find what they are looking for then it's off to the next site.

I think the new layout will prove to be a detrimental change, it breaks all the rules of web design and looks like someone has used a free Tripod template based account to just plop everything on to a long scrolling home page.

Adding the grey background was a nice touch, smoothing out the overall look ws a good idea, but the heap'o'links is still there and really doesn't belong on a home page.

IMHO, nice idea, big mistake. Personally, I would have pulled this page an hour after posting it and come up with something useful. But it's not my site so I can just bypass the home page until the rest of the site is changed anyway.

by wordworker

...it's going to pi** people off. Shawn, you haven't addressed the whole "Click here to view full article" thing. What possible benefit does that provide to the reader? There are at least three threads in here where people say, "I don't like having to click to see the rest of the article, then scroll down to where I left off." Still you and your colleagues are silent about why. The only possible reason I see for the "two-clicks to finish the article" rule is......extra page views! So with all due respect, how do you splain the rationale behind that "design" decision? It's so...cheesy and inefficient, at least from the user's point of view.

by jdclyde

A Home page is supose to be a intro and lauching point, not your entire web site.

If it doesn't fit on the screen, it isn't broken down and organized well enough.

This doesn't mean to make everything 6 links deep, but if you had page that sends you to the section you need, then give the detailed view.

Just my humble opinion.

by wordworker

This issue doesn't just affect the home page. Two clicks just to view an entire piece of content? Pourquoi, oh pourquoi??

by john.m1

please scroll up and see "Cnet homepage" by John.M1

is this the answer for me too?

Thanks Jeff

by john.m1

in business its the shareholder over customer.
in websites its advertiser over visitor / member.

tv, newspapers and mags have had to find the balance or suffer losses, there must be less intrusive ways to earn revenue.

remember this, after you lose your readers, the advertisers also go away.

by tlyczko

People read left to right, and you put all the content on the right side...

Please get rid of the annoying, in-your-face ads!!

Or put them way down at the bottom, out of sight, where they belong.

Did you do any usability studies before putting this up??

:) tom

by oz_media

As much as I hate to compare TR to others you may get a few tips on how a discussion group should be laid out by viewing techvibes.com although I don't really care for member pics EVERYWHERE, the overall breakdown of the various discussion groups is very well done.

I almost think you've seen the site already judging by the first home page revamp you tried.

This discussion is closed to new replies.