Discussion Locked

What should we do with the uninsured?

0 helpful
112 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

112 replies

by charliespencer

I remember when I first joined the Army. Our drill sergeant explained the military life insurance program (SGLI) to us as follows:

"Boys, you get $5000 life insurance free and automatically. You can also sign up and pay for up to $100,000 more (since raised to $200K). Think about it: if Uncle Sam has to send someone to war, he's going to send the guy that costs him the least."

by ansugisalas

Mine is that everybody get what they need, to find what they're missing, so they can start searching for that, instead of the pointless crap they've let themselves become preoccupied with.

by thechas

From my experience, in order to be able to buy an individual health insurance policy in the US, you need to be healthy enough to not need health insurance. Any hint of a preexisting condition and the mainstream health insurance plans will not even quote a policy for you.

The last time I was between jobs, the only viable insurance option for me was COBRA coverage from my prior employer. The cost for the COBRA coverage was nearly half of my unemployment income!

In the US, on a very real level if you do not have employer sponsored group coverage, you either cannot get or cannot afford health insurance.

Notice my use of the word "sponsored". Even if you pay 100% of the cost of your health insurance it is still significantly easier and less expensive to get employer sponsored group coverage then it is to get an individual policy.

Chas

by thechas

While I don't like the shock of the bill any more than anyone else, on a very real level, the cost of health care is a bargain.

When I compare the $25 it cost for a physical 30 years ago with the $125 by doctor's office charges the insurance company, that number is pretty close to the rate of inflation.

Take a closer look at your hotel versus hospital example.
Compare the cost of the staff and facility.
For a 100 unit hotel, you might have 2 people on staff at any time, and a cleaning crew of up to 8 people. Outside of the hotel manager, I doubt that any of them make over $35,000 a year from their hotel job.

Now look at any level of critical care unit at a hospital. Direct staff is more like 1 person for every 10 patients. Along with 24/7 maintenance, laundry, cleaning, food service and other support staff. Most of the hospital staff earns over $40,000 a year.

Your hotel does not have an oxygen delivery system to every room. Nor do most have a large backup generator for power. Most of the medical equipment is fairly expensive to purchase and maintain too.

As to the $25 aspirin. It cost the same to dispense 1 aspirin as it does to dispense any other medication. It is the individual handling and full documentation of every medication handled by the hospital pharmacy that makes the cost look high. Your hospital pharmacy does not have the benefit of the scale of volume that your local pharmacy does. The hospital pharmacist also likely earns more than your local pharmacist. Not just because he or she works in a hospital, but because their work requires a higher level of skill and knowledge.

There are some medications where the same dosage can be dispensed from the pharmacy as is available over the counter. Compare the cost to have your local pharmacist dispense say Zertec versus what you can buy the generic version for.

Of course, your hotel does not have near the cost for liability insurance. Nor, does it process anywhere near the same level of paperwork to track your stay as your hospital does.

When you consider how many people you are paying to take care of you at the hospital, the cost does not seam so bad.

Finally, as I work with an ever aging group of people, more and more of us are using more medical services than we could afford without the benefit of our health insurance. I've lost track of the number of people at work who have had knee replacements and other major procedures. One manager had at least 6 ambulance rides last year. So yes, most of the people I work with believe that the cost of insurance is worth the benefit.

Chas

This discussion is closed to new replies.