Discussion Locked

What to do? Talk about carrying the flag!!!

0 helpful
264 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

264 replies

by susan

About 50 employees...harassing the only IT person. Hiden personal agendas are driving this train. My assessment: There are problems that are happening in other departments and there are looming layoffs. No one wants to look like the only incompentant person. You're easy to pick on -you're the only guy in your department, you probably don't play politics so the politicos will have you for breakfast. There is at least one person who is misdirecting management attention towards you. Your best defense is a stiff upper lip. Do not smile at these people, look them not in the eye but right above the eyelid (establish dominance). If you are asked to sign anything remember you have the right to add any comments you wish at the bottom, strike out any statements you disagree with. Write "I disagree" and initial and date. Write at the bottom that you have been presented with non-specific complaints, management has repeatedly directed personal and professional insults towards you, meetings with management have not resulted in clear communication of the problems, and that you have completed your work assignments, and that complaints appear to be political in nature. That's more than enough to ensure you will never hear from these people again, and that they will not complain about you in the future after you move on, which should be tomorrow.

by relaxdiego

R. Young,

Are you sure you're asking for advice, or are you just posting here to get uninformed reassurance.

It's rather rare for a group of professionals (50 at that!) to go against one IT guy simply because they feel like it. Check yourself first. Ask them for the exact issues and tell it to us here straight so that we can give you a better set of advice.

by rattyratt

Hi there relaxdiego,

I was posting to possibly get both, I have noted all the advice and through that I have seen much concurrence (ie: agreement) and confirmation that I am doing the right thing by looking for work elsewhere and bailing out of this situation.

Although I have been told during one of the meetings I have had "everyone has noticed..." and "we 'all' have felt that..." I sincerely have noticed myself that there is a undercurrent of satisfaction with my work from staff, and my own manager (for his own need) polls the staff to determine if I am doing my job to 'his' satisfaction. Either way, I have noticed some people have a tendancy to make an issue larger through exaggeration of the amount of 'unspecified' people who are unhappy with my work. This happened at the first meeting, and while I didn't like hearing that 'unspecified' people were unhappy, I let it gloss and looked at the nuggets of information they were stating as the core of their argument. Some, were perhaps founded in truth (always there is truth in all things, u just have to find it.) And some in outright lies. My own manager worked on quashing the lies, but unfortunately I think that was when this HR manager had decided that my own boss was unreliable. (Considering he is one of the best bosses I have ever had, probably because he cares for his staff a great deal.)

Everything went downhill from there.

Taking that into perspective with my first post (and some subsequent update posts) the advice/information peope have been giving me has been excellent, and I have really been encouraged also. (And I really do need encouragement at this time. This is just taking a ludicrous turn every update I get... see my last post at the bottom...)
So, it's as straight as I can make it, (barring having to change a few minor things to avoid the organization and the 'people' being directly pinpointed = not very good thing!)

?

by rattyratt

Hi Spadata,

You are essentially correct on that. I do admit that with everything there is always a small kernal of truth, (Even my own boss has pointed that out, and I am in agreement with him.)
In terms of 1. The accuser left the organization after firing this parting shot (probably because I pi&&ed them off by enforcing the Policies of the organization) but 2. is what they said they were going to do - but it has spiralled out of control, with the weighing in of my executive manager. :-/ I suppose that is typical.
Ahem, however you are wrong with the unionized workplace - what union?? :-)
Most people here are whiners and unfortunately very loud whiners. I suppose that is the problem of it all, even my boss said that to me. :-)
There are 3 people who are practical/pragmatic and realists in this place, and they include the dbase admin, my manager (IT) and me. Everyone else runs around in the clouds... :-(
Sigh!

by g.m.bakker (cne, self employed)

Hi,
Hunt for a new job, and if found, take it. Then
I'd wait my month's pay cheque to arrive, presuming it is to arrive before the end of the month (here in Holland we get paid halfway the month for the whole month), work through the end of the month, go to your boss and tell him you have health problems and can no longer work in such a hostile environment, and therfore have decided to quit immediately. Give him the letter of resignation shake his hand and pi&& off. Next day, new job, however never discuss the previous group of a&&holes in your new work environment, and never discuss where you worked before (@ the a&&hole plant). Too bad no severance, but hey, no heart attack either, that compensates it all

My 2 and a half cents!

by sjeffreys

Dr. Phil would say - "You teach people how to treat you." He would also advise you to have a plan or strategy in place detailing what your goals are and how you are going to handle these situations the next time they occur. There has been some great advice given...decide what your goals are and apply the applicable advice - Maya Angelou says "When I knew better I did better." Make it work for you - turn it around or find a new job - whatever you decide find the lesson you were to learn and learn it.

by reverend_shifty_greenbacks_ii

Maybe this guy is a damn serial killer. I dont know what caused his problems but i dont think people just naturally aspire to hate someone without some reason. Jason..... clean your tools.

by rattyratt

One issue that although I can see some potential parallels, it goes a bit off the rails when:
My own boss is supporting me in the fact that I have been doing my work to a high standard, performing my tasks in a excellent manner, and frankly has exceeded all his expectations. This organization has had a run of bad IT Admin's (or atleast ones that are not totally with it...)
My probation report had a string of 'good' and 'excellent' markings. My boss has over 47 years in work environments, including the military and he frankly is pi$$ed as hell over these younger executive types coming in and just 'totally ignoring' him when he is my direct manager and not them.
I suppose the crux of the issue is that they have stopped listening to him totally.
We did go down the path you metioned above, (although based on accusations that 'may or may not have had merit') but things have gone from bad to worse.
My immediate boss (whom I respect greatly) had to sit in a meeting with these two 'persons' (I use that term loosely) and listen to them arguing over how to escalate this to the point where they can fire me. Tell me, is that rational?? He had to go bat for me, by slapping them in the face verbally (he's due to retire soon, so he doesn't care who he pi$$es off anymore.) They wanted to kick me out that day, and he hit them over the head first off with the moral obligations of that, "how can you fire someone on the grounds you have, which is nothing when his wife is expecting a baby in a few weeks, and he hasn't done anything to deserve it. Also it contravene's policy."
Unfortunately, I think they heard the bit about 'contravening policy' only. :-) Now they are trying to do it within the policy guidelines.

:-) I am trying not to get paranoid - but it is hard. :-(

Frankly I am worried that I will accelerate the situation if I tried to go directly to these people - especially since I was not 'officially' supposed to know the contents of that meeting.
For that I am grateful to my boss, that he wouldn't keep any secrets from me on this.

I measure my time here in hours and days...

:-(

by dugga6

Sounds like your workplace has a case of "too many chiefs, not enough indians". All these junior executive manager types p**sing on everything to mark their territory. I've seen it before and eventually it all ends in a management restructure. Life is too short to spend in a crappy workplace - you deserve better.

by g.m.bakker (cne, self employed)

Hey, read the responce I gave shortly, and just get out of there, don't wait till you go flipping paranoia, find another place, businesses are picking up again, so there will be a job picking period arriving. And when you leave give em all a carrot to stick up there a&&!

by rattyratt

There is no real IT related Union in Australia - there are unions that are close, but I think for IT, the Industrial union is the only real option.
Unless you are a public sector employee, then you get the PSU to cover you, (regardless of speciality, since you are PS member)

by mharris

APESMA, the Association of Professional Engineers, Scienists and Managers Australia (APESMA)represents many professional employees in the IT industry. Find out more at www.apesma.asn.au or www.itpa.asn.au

The IT Professionals Association (ITPA) is a special interest group within APESMA set up to represent the interests of IT employees.

We are currently active in a number of workplaces, including EDS Australia. You can visit the campaign website at http://www.apesma.asn.au/eds

by rattyratt

I am very careful in workplaces, especially these days with harassment cases all over the place. I have once had someone accuse me of verbal harassment (last job I had) but nothing came of it, since when it came out, it was a disagreement that they called verbal abuse. Go figure.
Since then, I especially do my job and stay out of issues that could infringe on anything in the harassment areas...
HOWEVER, I had a feeling (nothing more though) that the person who took a dislike to me was of the same ilk as the girl you mention, that she hated men also. I know she was pregnant and that she left to go on Maternity leave (one reason why I suppose I should leave especially before she returns... 12 months...)
:-) Considering that she was on the opposite side of the building from me at the time of the complaint, and that I may have passed her desk a few times a week, (but had not much contact with her...) it is more plausable to believe she just took a dislike to me for her own reasons, not anything I could have done. (I keep records of all jobs I do, so looking back at jobs in her name - da nada!)

Anyway....

by grapevine-biz

As I read your post I could feel your attitude. Your attitude is 180 degrees out of sync with any kind of support position. Did you quit your last job as a waiter because the tips were so bad? Loose the ego! But until then, "Your FIRED!"

by rattyratt

:-) Yes, to some extent I have had to abbreviate the story - and while I can write excellent documentation - I know that putting up my story here means that people could identify the organization if I went into too much detail.
You are correct in that there are many facets to a problem, including this one that I face - I am not infalliable, and I know my faults. In fact, I won't deny that within this entire episode - there is a small germ of truth to some of the accusations that have been thrown at me. At the first meeting between my boss, the HR manager and myself - we discussed that, and in turn I emailed my boss afterwards with my comments to all the accusations, being brutally honest. (He prefers honest people... and so do I!)
Out of that, I recogised that I can be prideful, as many can in IT, and this can sometimes spill into a touch of arrogance that my users see. I continuously work to improve myself and overcome faults as I find them (and get them pointed out to me.)
The only problem with this, is that it went from perhaps a 'semi-sane' start to totally irrational on the parts of some of the players of this horrible game.

This shows in the 2nd meeting with my boss & the HR manager, when they said that in response to the first meeting my work excellence level peaked so dramatically high, it was an incredible improvement. (reading between the lines from my side: I stressed that I was not even making 'acceptable' and over achieved to try to get through this, verging on burnout!)
NOW: here's the funny (or not) part. When I said that to the HR manager, in my response to her pointing out the fact that I was gradually coming down to a more reasonable pace to do work, HER response to it was: But Why Don't You Stay Up There?
(Now, both my boss and I had pointed out that it is difficult to sustain that kind of excellence, without burning out....) When we pointed that out again - she still didn't get it. She expected me to perform to a standard... erm, for example:
Response to all problems coming in: Instantly.
If not instantly, then the problem must be given next priority. The person who has the problem however must be 'instantly' informed, including when it will be fixed.
I must respond to problems quickly, resolve them quickly, (hell, I have even been told to powerwalk between jobs!!!) All work must be done quickly and efficiently, as fast as possible.
(hmm, you think - that doesn't sound so bad...)
The organization I work for has 50 people in it, on the one floor. This means that I have to prioritize a server failing - on the same level as changing bl88dy toner in a printer. However, the toner takes priority if it is the HR Manager's printer. Oh, hang on... if it is the mail server, that should take priority too...
hmm, perhaps both should be fixed at the same time...
LOL, this kind of thinking is what they expect. (And it was told to my face. My manager heard it too, and after the meeting told me that it was the biggest load of crap he has ever heard.)

Anyway, back to work -

by yanipen

Sorry for the late reply.

The way I see your problem, initially it has something to do with your relationship to your co-workers. Although it has escalated to something bigger, it still the underlying problem.

A question first, have you ever thought about your interpersonal skills? It is a very good starting point on how you treat others in the workplace. Hey, I am not blaming you for what happened. I was in a very similar situation a few years back. Its just that it has a lot something to do with it.

Next, stick and know your policy. And evaluate it from time to time. Times are changing fast for policies to be followed. So you must adapt your company's policy to suit the situation. And, they must know that there are policies for a reason.

In relationship with your users, it is like holding a sand in the palm of your hancs. Hold it too tight, it will still find a way out. Hold it too loose, and the wind will just blow it away. The way to do it is to hold it just about right.

I was in one of the world's biggest project a few years back. We have our own policies, common office envirentment and things like that. When you follow your policies to the letter, you may notice that a lot of the users are cracking up. Cracking up, up to the "C" level managers. Boy, we sure were swimming in hot waters that time.

So what we did? We starting evaluating ourselves, our policies in place, and the rapport with our co-workers. Especially the rapport. People tend to follow once it is explained to them in a nice way. Even if they dont like it. And may I repeat, policies are there for a reason, it is matter of approach on how to deal with both.

Eventually, you may have to re-establish your relationship with everybody if you want to see it through.

Now, in any case that you want to move on, and make again a fresh start, my advice is still the same.

I hope this helps.

by ivy clark

I'm sorry to hear about all that you've been going through. Your situation reminds me of exactly what happened in one of my unfortunate employment experience. To cut the story short, I joined a creative team in an IT Solutions company, and there were a couple of trouble makers. Sad to say, they were the 3 senior members. I'm still not sure what they got from discrediting everyone else, as when it came to the crunch and work needed doing, they always had some excuses to get them out of it. What made it worse, was they were close friends with the team manager, so when the time came for a performance evaluation... well, you can guess what happened. I received one of those... "i've received numerous complaints about you" talks. I challenged my ex-boss and he crashed under the pressure as he never expected me to question the claims, one of which was: "team members are saying you are offering help, just to show off what you know". What a load of nonsense! I was hoping for an increment, and i got it alright... $50. I was insulted. My boss proved his inapt by basing his evaluation on hear-say instead of my actual performance.

I stayed on for a couple more years, as I refused to give up and let them win. During that stressful time, I only offered help when people approached me directly, and I kept to myself most of the time. I also learnt that the fault didn't lie with me through assurances from other team members, some of which joined after me, and was just as shocked my the attitude of the 3 seniors. Then I decided to leave, as that job didn't do my morale any good. I was a more confident person before that job.

Looking back now, i feel rather stupid to have let that bring me down. That was the only job in which i encountered the problem. I was happy and appreciated in previous jobs and jobs I took on after that. Nevertheless, I learnt from that experience, and am a more patient and tolerant person. =)

I think it's a good idea to do a self evaluation. If this is the only job that's been giving you such problems, chances are the problem doesn't lie with you.

So, now it's time to move forward. Not quit. NO, you're moving on, and forward to the next phase of your life. Hey, good luck with your job hunt.

by ivy clark

oh yes, I forgot to mention... my ex-boss left the company eventually, and ended up in another job, in a lesser position. And that company suffered losses and couldn't bear the costs of the creative team, so everyone got retrenched eventually. I heard that the trouble makers had trouble finding jobs for a long time, serves them right. If they had been nicer, perhaps the rest of us would have helped to recommend them something huh. For their sakes, and those who have to work with them, I hope they are better people now.

by uberman

I've been in your situation before many times. Sometimes I refused to realize it until the axe fell. Sometimes I saw it coming and got out of the way. Believe me it is must less messy if you do the later and get out of the way. It is also much easier to look for a job while you have one.

by john_tillman

Presumably people are unhappy because they don't feel like they are receiving service.

It sounds like the organisation doesn't understand the true costs of running an efficient it infrastructure, but rather see it as a costly expensive exercise which doesn't benefit the company much. They are blaming you for a company wide "our support sucks" kind of mentality, the userbase doesn't know any better. You are probably busting a gut to get everyone serviced with insufficient resources and copping flak because the expectations are too high given the resources you have. So in your meetings Educate management
Prove to them with concepts that they can understand. Show them real reasons why what they want is not what they get. Draw up a cost model of their approach to the IT service needs versus and show them why it doesn't work explain in black and white on paper where the inneficiencies are. Introduce them to best practice concepts like ITIL and various levels of incident,problem,change management Provide them a high level understanding of the knock on affect of lack of process.
Once the decision making kind of people in management start understanding the cost of providing the type of service and realise it's not your fault then they will, I think be more trusting of you. I would imagine the whole responsibility of doing this should lie with your manager so Who knows they may turn on your manager and you go up the promotion tree.

by rattyratt

Hi all,

I am blown away by the responses, and i thank all of you for your responses so far. I am still trying to read through them all. :-)
A quick update that I am taking into stride, is that the HR Manager has upped the ante and is now getting the corporation's legal team into this to make sure that the letter they give me leaves 'no' recourse and so they can avoid any kind of unfair dismissal. (Very lame of them of course!)

I had to admit, when I heard this I was really really worried, but my boss said that they were not going to be doing anything more than making sure there were no loopholes that I could exploit in making a case (if I did.) Ultimately, he said that they (I am trying to be nice, but I see them as the opposition now) were really just hoping that I will find another job and leave. Solving their problem for them, LOL!

I am looking, believe me! I have heard many of you saying to do that, and I completely agree. Despite the intricacies of this issue, I am not going to try and justify anymore to these people, for my position or myself. They have made up their minds, and they are taking steps to get rid of me. I suppose seeing the amount of people leaving over the last 6 months should have been a warning also. We just had someone become permanent from being temporary - and they quit only a month ago for reasons unknown.
The real reason - their boss took their head off over a reported incident to their boss. And DIDN'T bother to listen or ask what happened with the staffer in question. (ie: one sided.)
I am really understanding the 'Guilty until kicked OUT!'

Anyway, I won't begin to spiral down, as I know I am better than that. I have to admit that it has been a learning experience for me, and certainly I have looked at my attitude to myself and others around me. I have heard some people here ask about that, and I believe yes they have have had hit some grains of this also.

I don't believe it to be right to campaign against an employee on the basis of something that should have been worked out at a 'much lower' level. Especially when I am happy to admit when and where I am wrong, and work to rectify that. :-) I am not up myself that I cannot work on self-improvement.

Anyway, I am cleaning out of here as soon as possible. It is sad, as i wanted to stay here until around 2007, see our migration through and help with the 2003/XP rollout.

Thus is thus! Thankyou again all for your inspiration, encouragement, constructive criticism and generally positive attitudes. :-)
It has been very appreciated in a sometimes (very much now) mad world.

Cheers

R. Young

by ivy clark

Hiya,

been a while since i posted a reply to this thread, thot i sheck in and see what the outcome was.

how are you doing now?

cheers,
Ivy Clark

by loydfam

Talk about your typical small business scenario. I have worked for several organization small to large scale (ie. Exxon, Phillips 66, Compaq/HP) corporations. No matter where you work, you are always going to be held accountable of your daily activities one way or another. Whether it by call tracking software or by day end reports, etc... No big deal right. We all have been there.
Depending on how long this has gone on, I suggest sitting down with your managing director to get to the root of this situation. Worst that could happen is you loose your job which sounds like you are thiking about leaving anyway. Find out what happened and what you can do to rectify the issue. Hope everything works out.

by kyuso

In summary, it's all about how fitting you are to the type of organization. No matter how smart or super-technical you are, people make decisions, not machines. It's all about people, communicating with people.

Usually they don't want to fire you, but just want you to change to fit their organization.

If you can learn non-technical skills, you can survive comfortably. There are two types of non-technical skills: managing skill, and leadership skill. If you adapt yourself to get along with those 50 people, then you got managing skill. If you can change those 50 people to fit you, you have leadership skill.

If none of the above apply, the organization didn't fit you and you didn't fit them. The solution is to move on, or get a religion and pray that God changes either you or the organization or both to fit each other.

For the 'managers' who think managing means telling people to do what they are supposed to do, that is not correct. Managers adapt incentives that fit the workers to be their best. Leaders are the ones telling workers what to do. Not all managers are leaders, and not all leaders are managers. Managers who try to act like leaders usually hire incompetent workers, and leaders who try to act like managers make workers lazy and incompetent.

by gardnermandy

Hang in there mate, at least till another job materialises.

Having worked for Aust DoD (and nearly going postal b4 i jumped with a lil johnny redundancy package), I know how damn frustrating it can be.

It took me many years to get over the mental repercussions of 7 years working for our govt.

remember, it's not paranoia when they really are out to get you.

best of luck

by akujenga

I think that's a very good approach that Richard recommended. Not to offend anyone but I think he should have just plainly said, "If you are a Christian..." I personally feel that's the best way to go!

by tmalandro

You really don't have a choice if this is escalating. What that means is they are looking for a sound way to terminate you. You would be better off finding another job and quiting.

by gary.crispens

You might have had a chance when it was just you and HR and boss. BUT when they pull in the big gun, it is time to wise up and beat feet for the door. No matter what you try to do or how much you try to improve, the decision has already been made and they are just running the clock out and putting the finishing touches on the documentation.
Next time go with a larger company where you are not the only IT guy. Also the buddy buddy good old boy system is strongest in small companies where they have know each other for years. It is tough being the "new guy" in this situation.

by pdalton1

You may not think this helpful but we have (many of us) been there too. Don't fight it. Consider yourself fireproof by (a) finding another post quietly (b) arranging some references and then (c) quit before they fire you just for the hell of it. I have done it twice in London and I felt much better for it AND found there were much more satisfying jobs to do where I was appreciated.
There is no way to fight bullies (legally) so be thick-skinned and leave them to it. If you keep going out of "hope" you could end up in severe depression and be too ill to work anywhere!!
Get it right - always do what you know is best for YOU and move ass NOW.

by jim

First let me say I wouldn't quit if normally you like the job and are just going through a rough period; your employer is large enough that they are under the rules of state and federal employment rules which are designed to give you some level of protection (I'm not a legal consultant but had filed a complaint many years ago against a firm who had illegal overtime policies; you learn a lot when you are put on the spot). If management is requiring you to keep a detailed log of what you do, make sure you also keep a copy for yourself in case they decide to fire you and you want to make a claim against them.

However, I've been in the workforce for 33 years and have had on more then one occasion had to remind myself that as long as I wasn't being asked to break the law or violate my moral values the job is still paying me. While that didn't make the problem go away it did help me focus that I'm not here for social reasons but rather to make a living. It is nice to be liked and fit in (that's management 101). Long term I found that if I continued to be an outstanding employee, regardless of how I was treated, I came out on top. Remember, you do not have control of other people but you do have control over how you act and react even if you are currently the innocent by-stander. That said, now that I am a small business IT consultant I get to see that in some businesses doing a good job is not as important as the political alliances. Since I didn't grow up in the IT world and I've been on both the management and employee side of the fence I can honestly say that some employees felt they were "The Gift" when in fact they were only "Legends in their own minds." I will also say that IT employees probably are in the same class as "Used Car Sales" and legal professionals. Some of that reputation is un-earned but I've been around long enough to see much of the reputation is our own fault in how we treat people.

Bottom line? Technical people like us are often less in tune with the social aspects of the workplace then other professions. Too often I've seen the "network Nazi" come down on people like they own the operation when in fact we provide a support function to the business. Personally, in this support role (IT boss or not) I have never "told" end-users to do anything; I ask or suggest. If the person or department refuses to listen after a reasonable time and I think it could impact the company, I turn it over to their manager not in an accusatory fashion but as an FYI. I let them decide on the course of action and place the responsibility where it belongs, on management. I normally follow my verbal conversation with an email in case I ever get accused at a higher level of not doing my job.

I'm sure you do great job and have a reasonable personality. But make sure you do a self-assessment occasionally to ensure you aren?t contributing to your own dilemma. If this kind of treatment is business as usual at your firm and it just so happens that it is your turn in the bucket, are you sure you want to work their? On the other hand if the company is a good place to be and it is just one or two individuals, do your job well and if they still fire you there will be nothing to feel bad about?besides, if possible you can take the time on unemployment to relax before finding that next perfect position. Good luck.

by g.m.bakker (cne, self employed)

Yes I agree, I'm the guy that can give a user shit for messing up the network (extrovert), But....I'm also the guy that will help them recover...and hey, it only happens once! And that's because I gave 'm hell...but I never get shit back, because I helped to get the show on the road. And I'm just protecting corporate data and infrastructure!

by ChrisP547

There is really nothing you can do that will not further imperil your job and make daily (work) life more miserable. I would start looking for another job, and when I had one, lay you whole scenario out for whomever it is most appropriate and then explain to them why they can kiss your ass (probably best done in polite terms tho )

by lord-of-the-token-rings

A similar situation happened to me, where the General Manager's brother was the Art Dept. Guy, who in the eyes of the owner (an imigrant to Canada During the War era, with no education) is the most talented person, and if the art guy has to go home early to "clear up his mind and find his muse" kinda crap, then it's okay.

But I digress, One day this joker decided to pull the scam of the century. He had been given a specific task about 3 months ago to complete a catalog of parts, and he had been doing his personal stuff, without completing the task. when the managing director approached him, he decided to go down the path of "I can't find the files I put on the network, maybe the Network guy (me) would know what happened to it". The GM decided to have a "talk" with me. The very next moment I was up in the MD's office with evidence of the art guy's internet activity, gathered through the Proxy server logs, his email activity through our spam filter etc. the 40 page report was a shocking revelation! The MD ran all the way to the GM's room to have the guy fired on the spot... BUT>>>>

The GM again decided to have another talk with me. This time the tack was on a different track. He opened up with, I know that you dont like "X", and you have formed an opinion about him. I decided to let fly. The reply was, "I protected him all this time because I respect you, but he stepped over the line when "X" decided to point the finger at me when he had not even started on the project. I also snuck in "evidence" through different kinds of "Network Reporting Tools" that allows me to "figure out" if "X" ever even started on the Job. Well "X" is still here, because he's very "talented" and he would be an asset to any company out there, and at this time, letting him go would cost the company more, because to retrain a new person to do a catalog would take more time..

My Advice??? As most people mentioned. Gather evidence ETHICALLY!! you are within your rights to do so as the company's Network guy, as it may be required by the HR Dept. Take a duplicate of this info home. It WILL save your ass, or atleast make sure the company will not just fire you with "Just cause".

by lord-of-the-token-rings

During tenure with the last company I worked in the states, I had the pleasure of a Psyhc Major who had turned "tech" (Built a couple of pc's in the basement, got a couple of certifications by reading the press books etc.,) He would analyze everything to death, without trying to finish the job on time. We finally decided to loan him out to a Client because we didn't have the heart to fire him.. Boy, was his Freudian slip showing ;)

by christineeve

Hi,
I have experienced what you're going through. It's horrible. If everything is right about the job, then fight for it. The suggestions about documenting, following up, and proactivity will help. You'll never forgive yourself for giving up.

However, if the job really isn't where you see yourself in 5 or 10 years, maybe it's time to let go.

Sometimes it is personal. But don't personalize it, because as we've all learned people see things through their own motivations and filters. So, unless you're intentionally jerky and unreliable, it's not your fault and do not take the blame.

This happened to me two times in my career, once I was able to fight it out and win. It was worth it. The other time, the job just wasn't right and I was beating a dead horse. I went on to better things.

Good luck, and I really mean that!

by john

Sorry R.Y,
Very sticky spot, 20/20 hindsite says that you weigh the situation....turn in a boss, warn him,
touch his personal cpu. Have his equal (on your side speak to him) ..Tuff spot...
What exactly was your duty ?
Reporter or Enforcer ?
And did you have the power to enforce it and
if not enforced how much of a factor would it be.
YIKES...
Circle the wagons and get together with the ones in your org that know and trust you and want to
work with you and see your value and get the strongest one to stick up for you to address these unhappy users, boss to boss.
Please blog this someplace with a steady report.
I'd like to hear more.
Good luck, be honest and tactful and always weigh your choices if there's time.

by thewineman1

I had a similar thing happen to me back in 1996. I went to a new job to find someone else working there who had worked for me previously. I was his direct supervisor before and we were now working together again, but in different departments. He went to management and described me as a dirt bag and problem child right after I arrived. The manager, Deputy Director of Operations, called me into his office and explained to me that he didn?t like me and didn?t want me working there. He went on to say in time he would have me replaced. I wasn?t given the chance to give my side or defend myself and I almost quit right there. Instead I went to work and did my job. In time I identified problems with operations and quietly made changes, developed an application to increase productivity, and all the while pushing credit off on others who needed a boost. Almost a year later the Deputy Director of Operations called me into his office. He apologized for jumping to conclusions before and went so far as to tell me that what he was told before was reversed and that he now wanted to work with me instead of against me. I thanked him for his honesty and told him that I wouldn?t accept his apology, that I didn?t need him, that his leadership skills sucked, and that he was extremely unprofessional. In all, the two of them turned several people against me and my first year in the company was a bitch. I stayed with the company for seven years in all and outlasted them both. Bottom line, jobs are hard to come by and sometimes you can turn it around a bad situation. Several times during my tenure the CEO told me to drive on and gave me free rein to operate how I wanted. I all it was one of the best jobs I have ever had.

by gobs

A very similar thing happened to me. I tried to stick it out, knowing I was right and others were wrong. The result was not a happy one. Unfortunately, management started to believe the people against me and eventually they spun enough to force my resignation. They even got a court ruling preventing me going public! This happened due to management changes.

I strongly suggest that you talk to the person at the top of your organisation. If they are on your side then that buys you time. Think seriously about finding another job. Those high up the tree will understand your situation and write you good references. If the Management is against you, or changing, look at bailing out as soon as possible. remember that your next employer will most likely contact your current bosses so try to leave on good terms.

My situation ended badly, but now I am in a better job and my bosses and staff appreciate me. Should have resigned earlier before it turned to mud!

It's a very hard decision I know, but it will end well. All the best.

by the verne

thanks for the link, doesn't feel like I'm being bullied though, just that the manager doesn't want people "invading her territory". Got my own little bit of revenge coming up though, gonna be running a few wires from her office, and maybe even taking the internet control away from her

by deesy58

All organizations have both a personality and a character. These traits are influenced, but not always controlled, by senior management. It is clearly obvious from your stated observations that your present organization possesses a deeply flawed character, and a personality that is incompatible with your personality and value system. Top management is apparently not willing to deal with these issues, so it is not possible for the situation to ever improve.

Acknowledge that you made a mistake when you joined this organization, and get out before matters begin to adversely affect your health. There is no shame in leaving an incompatible organization after only a short stint on the job. It is time to get on with your career, and your current employer is obviously not a step on the ladder upwards.

by deesy58

Joe@'s analysis is overly simplistic. Sometimes, it really is true that "nobody likes me." If a manager doesn't fit into the esatablished organizational culture, then he/she will be distrusted and feared. The result will be attacks that might be either personal or professional. Confrontation will never work! It is a bad idea! It could result in unexpected termination and unfavorable employment references. Don't do it!

The solution is to start looking for another position immediately. Keep your head down and hope that the timing of your departure from this flawed organization will be of your choosing, rather than theirs.

by deesy58

Documenting what's really going on in the organization won't help at all. It would only serve to emphasize management inadequacies. If you can't verbally discuss these kinds of matters with your boss, then you have no chance whatsoever for success in this organization. Get out before you are asked to leave. Make sure you are in control of the timing of your departure. Also, do not overlook any other opportunities because of a misguidaned notion that you somehow owe this organization any kind of "two week notice."

by deesy58

I've seen the same kinds of "conflict resolution" techniques used in the US. Particularly by those US companies that are owned and managed by Europeans. Never again!

by deesy58

Sounds like deliberate employee sabotage to me! And, it is being countenanced by management. I had a similar experience about thirty years ago with an IT installation for a major Eastern US railroad. The union employees believed that their jobs were being jeopardized by the installation of computers, so an active program of employee sabotage began. It was frustrating, but those of us responsible for the installation were able to take comfort in the knowledge that railroad management knew what was going on, and they handled it in a responsible, low-key manner. Unfortunately, you don't seem to have that luxury. It's time to get out. You can never win in such a "sick" organization.

by deesy58

Is this your very first job? If so, then perhaps the offered advice might be good. But, if you have worked in other organizations and not experienced these types of problems, don't waste your time with a lot of useless soul searching. It isn't worth it! Get out of that "sick" organization and go someplace where your abilities are needed and will be appreciated. Such organizations really do exist. You just have to find them.

by britontn

Hey I think that problem has come on the lap of almost every IT tech pro.
Some people take things personal when we implement the company policy which, I might add, we don't make!
IT has never been liked in almost every organisation I've worked for. They all think we are a mutant breed or something. If you don't do personal favours for them(which compromise your job. Like allowing them to surf for porn or give them access to resources) you are Staff Enemy 01.
I worked for an organisation where all the things you've described and a whole lot more happened to me. I did more paperwork than any clerk anywhere. I had to list what I did, when I started and when I finished. And when I left the office, the guard had to sign me off on a time sheet. If I put in extra hours because there is need to do so, I'd have to justify it in writing before I could hope to be compensated for it. then All those hours were converted to off days which I never got the chance to use because I would never be allowed to take an off day.
Solution 1:
Set up a meeting and have all the people to lay it out why they think you are not doing a good job and why they think you have a rotten attitude. But beware; if one of those people is up there then they are not going to like you for embarassing them by proving that they have nothing but personal problems against you.
Solution 2(which i think you should take first)
MOVE!!!!
My mistake was I tried to fight it out and I lost. I still have a pending case in labour court! Very bad for my resume. companies won't employ me because of it too. I'm out of a job. I'm not asking you to be a coward. I'm just asking you to be smart. Heroes die!

by rsears

I'd get out while the getting is good. Get a new job and resign your position on good terms. Forget court. Forget revenge. Let it go and move on. Sounds like you are incompatible with the company.

by gazoo

I work in a unionized workplace, and this sort of thing doesn't happen without the union weighing in. Unions are good for you, not bad. I have seen one fellow who was wrongly fired getting a settlement of circa 140000 dollars, because he was a member of a union. Of course, I live in a terrible socialist country where unions are accepted instead of combatted.

by phattius

Option A-Change is good, often times we become complacent to a steady paycheck. If you ask most people why they leave a job, its not because they couldn't hack the work. They just couldn't take the B.S. anymore and cut to greener pastures. If you really like a challenge, start your own business.

Option B-Stay and DOCUMENT, DOCUMENT, DOCUMENT!!! You should have already been doing this. If you had record of everything going on it would be hard for people to make accusations. Comes with the territory. Just remember your number 1 goal as an IT professional is to keep the customer happy. That doesn't just mean keep their computer running. Talk to them, make alliances, companies have a unique culture and if you don't fit in, either conform or find a different job. The key is honesty and communication.

by erekose mcne

I have been down that like soo many others. It is tough to have to enforce policy. I took the blame for installing corporate wide antivirus software on the Owners machine afte the network was decimated by the nimda virus. The old man had a fit because he the group of us managers did what we were supposed to do. He just never bothered to read any of the months worth of emails that were sent to all users. When the software came down in a push, he freaked and ejected his laptop from the docking station. From then I, was famous because he was a tool. The moment the started paper trailing you, that was the time to find a new job. That is how the managers and weasels in HR operate. I realise that a new baby and job shortage makes it tough and I have been consulting on and off here in the US for 10 years. The key is to check out the place you work. Google for any mention of the company good or bad. Also remember to never truly trust anyone. AS IT you are a necessary evil and after all these years, the opinion never changes. You are the first to be blamed when it hits the fan and the las to bre praised when you do a good job because it is what is expected of you. RUN AS FAST AS YOU CAN FROM THESE LOSERS!!!! I would check to see if you can get anything in writing about what has transpired because you never know if a lawyer might take a frivolous pro bono case just to make the lives of these people as miserable as they have made you. After all you are IT and you should be able to find the trail of bread crumbs. User are dumb and they don't delete incriminating information.
I hope you find a company worthy of your skill.
Hope you and family end up okay.

by turbogeek

Sad to say, but you are doomed. Somewhere, someone has it in for you and it might have nothing to do with you at all. It might be that the person who is in a snit had a friend whom they'd 'recruited' for the job and lobbied hard for and they didn't get it, so they figure there's another chance if they get you out of there. Perhaps your presence has put the brakes on some unsavory or illegal activity that was going on for fear that your access to various system might enable you to stumble upon it, so they are trying to get youout of there. Perhaps you are interfering with some extra-cirricular sleeping arrangements just by being there and they want you out.

The best thing to do is counter-document and if there is anything that they are doing that could in anyway be discriminatory because of a potentially protected class of person you belong to, play that up so that they will be more likely to be more generous with a severence arrangement to entice you into signing an agreement not to sue them. And also do some snooping of your own to see if you can uncover any dirt. Given the way you described the situation, it definitely there, hiding someplace. You need to find what rug it's under and make copies of it to have for 'future reference.'

You should accept the fact that the eventual outcome of this situation is going to be termination. You should start working on the attitude adjustment now so that when it comes, you can just laugh at them. Certainly work on your resume, review job posting, and start looking for something else as well. But don't waste any more emotional energy in trying to salvage this situation. It's already turned to poop.

Oh, and one more thing. If that PC that the person you thought was behind this that they got annoyed about cleaning up is still around and hasn't been reimaged, etc. Perhaps you might want to do a little 'compliance checking' and see just what they do have on there that was gumming up the works.... Never know what interesting things you might find.

--TG

by andrew_ockrim

It may not be 100% "ethical", but you need to find the root cause of the animosity towards you.

All the good intentions and performance planning may not be enough to save you from a boss who has alterior motives.

If you have access to the email system, i suggest you have a snoop around their accounts (as any good administrator would do when an employee complains of harassement). You may well find the underlying reasons for your harassment.

I have had similar situations in the past. You will need the evidence for any future repercussions that this may generate, so covre your butt. They have obviously not shown you any loyalty - so why are your showing it to them?
If they want you to document every thing you do - do so, even if it impacts your service - that is more supporting evidence for yourself.

It may also be a good idea to send (via registered post) any important documents or information relating to this and not open it. If you end up in court over this it will be irrefutable.

Good luck

by bwilkes82

Dear R.Young, I feel your pain in this story but, realize you do have options. I believe, if you have been honesty and upheld your integrity that you can prevail although, you may feel like poopy when this is all over. One, stay and tough it out (be prepared to get battered and beaten). Two, start looking for another job. After getting out of the Army several years ago, I promised myself (if I could help it) never to work on a job that I did not like and was not having fun at. I have kept that promise to myself. I have gone unemployed a time or two but I now have the job of my dreams (not without some scares getting here). I believe, if you know your stuff your performance and record will speak for you and rebut any false accusations thrown at you. Is it for the principal of the matter or vindication that you want more? R.Young, hang tough.

by mikebentley

All very good replies. As long as you stay true to yourself, and understand that the company's main goal is itself, and you keep your goals aligned with the company's (as well as their mission), whatever happens, you will go to bed with a clear conscience.

I know that doesn't pay the bills, but as long as you pray, things will work out one way or another.

I'm not pushing anything on you religion wise, because I don't know what (if any) your faith is.....I just meant in general.

Keep your head up! I went through almost exactly the same thing, and the company I worked for started fabricating a paper trail on me.

I left the company, but only because of an outburst that I couldn't control - at least I got to go off on my boss (he looked like he thought I was going to kill him!). I look back and don't regret my decision, but if you see light at the end of the tunnel, don't quit your job until you find something better, and by all means, keep your cool and don't let them know they are getting to you.

Mike

by kmf98

Had similar problem a few years ago but in a larger organization. Had multiple compaints that I did not finish jobs and did not effectively communicate what solutions to the problems were. Finally used a form similar to what our maintenance department used when making repairs with a few additions. Maintenance had someone in the department to sign a form to validate that work on the existing problem was performed. I had a field for the date the problem was first reported, date I came to look at the problem, if the problems was taken care of, to give an explaination in their own writing of what I communicated to them concerning the problem and the fix and for them to date and sign the form. Withing a month and a half, all complaints had stopped.

by pka

Tell them if you gotta put up with all this new crap you need a lot more money because it wasn't part of the job description you hired on to do.

by rm3mpc

It's possible you're too focused on doing things your way instead
of learning the company's culture and fitting in. It's more likely
that they have decided (for whatever reason) to dump you, and
this is simply going through the motions on their part.

Get your resume up to date and start looking for another job.
NOW. The suggestions to document everything are good, simply
to protect yourself if you have to go on unemployment.

Ask yourself if you can stomach working with these people in
the future, even if you get past this immediate crisis. Odds are,
you won't be happy if you stay. Some situations simply aren't
worth dealing with, and you'd be a lot better off landing another
job you like before the ax falls.

by theohkm

So called policy is something that is apparanetly built for better environment or in favor of their own rules of game.

IT guy faces many people. Life is more than challenging. Useless staff start with the IT department to divert the attention of their own faults. It is a natural phenonmenon. (Everyone needs you no matter the strong one or the stupid ones) Some baseline must be kept to protect yourself.

In fact, you are the most threatening to them (if you know their tacts). Their tacts reveal from time to time and will eventually become non-effective.

If you know who looks scared when you pass by, it is a scene that they are shined by System Administration's Holly Power. What Holly Power is that we do not stand by any side, we survive the whole system, the whole things up and running. The definition of up and running can be refined, depending the situation, target, atmosphere, time and in favor of most people. We let freedom, not without control.

Starting from daily tasks, we face several level of responsibility. Although hard to be perfect, at least not too bad.

Football has no side. People go off-side. People deny their fault and say it is ball's fault - ball speed too slow at first and too fast after hovering on top of their heads ? Or ball doesn't fall at either side, either direction.

The judge, cannot judge, is threatened by the environment.

Who know who will leave first ? Who know when leave, there is another better sky ? have seen the way of living of numerous useless people doing. In an Island, there are animals, don't like them, still need to live with them.

Let they smart, let they do, let they fall.

It is not easy, not easy, not easy.

by dshisler

Appologize and mean it, but same day make serious plans to go to another job ASAP! You need to 'suck up' just long enough to find another job. I've warned my sons to watch their backs. There are bosses and supervisors who are pleased to steal the credit for an employee's hard work. There are supervisors that have absolutely no consciences. Sign and date your good work. Detail (in a journal) everything that you're suspicious of, so that in your exit interview with an HR person you can hand over a COPY of your suspicions and concerns, complete with dates, times. I had a super who told me that the job is not done until the paperwork is complete; that the paperwork is more important to his boss, than the actual work. Be able to back up your activities with facts, in writing, not typed. When you are asked by your boss to restore files or fix the server, write it down, - (complaint and effective repair). Try to do it in the presence of the person that sits at that computer. Don't whine or complain in the presence of anyone. The walls have ears, and you never know who's listening. Also, there are hidden cameras and microphones everywhere, now. All e-mail is monitored! Be friendly, be a good listener, but don't broadcast your own feelings to anyone. Keep your opinions to yourself. You are your own worst enemy. Remember this, because it is critical to your success.... Apologize to your boss. Be humble, and tell your boss that you've been defensive, that you appreciate your job, because it gives you a sense of accomplishment and stability, and that you really want to get all this behind you. Admitting that should immediately relax your boss. You accepted the job offer in the first place because you wanted to learn and advance when you got more experience, and what better place to gain that experience. Here is where you want to be. Meantime, keep your sights on opportunities. On your first vacation, scour the area for a new job. Learn all you can, when you can. Study in view of the door where your boss leaves for lunch. Don't be obvious. Good luck from a veteran job-seeker. I once worked at a small company where I went to work at the same time that others did, except I did it for free! After awhile they put me on part time, then a year went by before they made me a full time employee. Software engineers overheard me discussing the complex design and behavior of electronic filters. One of them, and then others began to talk to me in more serious terms. They were astounded that I was able to teach the head Engineer about these things, and they were shocked to find out that I wasn't an engineer at all. Hell, I never even got a passing grade past eighth grade high school!
I hope that this revelation helped you. I hate to lose good people, and I hate it when people are so greedy that they'll do a hostile takeover of a whole country, based on a pack of lies. You know who I mean.

by macdonald00

Here is a quote from "How to Resolve Conflicts?"

http://www.scientologyhandbook.org/SH8.HTM

Such a thing would have to be some natural law unguessed at by himself.

And there is such a law, apparently, that answers these conditions of being deadly, unknown and embracing all activities.

The law would seem to be:

A THIRD PARTY MUST BE PRESENT AND UNKNOWN IN EVERY QUARREL FOR A CONFLICT TO EXIST.

or

FOR A QUARREL TO OCCUR, AN UNKNOWN THIRD PARTY MUST BE ACTIVE IN PRODUCING IT BETWEEN TWO POTENTIAL OPPONENTS.

or

WHILE IT IS COMMONLY BELIEVED TO TAKE TWO TO MAKE A FIGHT, A THIRD PARTY MUST EXIST AND MUST DEVELOP IT FOR ACTUAL CONFLICT TO OCCUR.

It is very easy to see that two in conflict are fighting. They are very visible. What is harder to see or suspect is that a third party existed and actively promoted the quarrel.

The usually unsuspected and ?reasonable? third party, the bystander who denies any part of it, is the one that brought the conflict into existence in the first place.

The hidden third party, seeming at times to be a supporter of only one side, is to be found as the instigator.

This is a useful law in many areas of life.

It is the cause of war.

One sees two fellows shouting bad names at each other, sees them come to blows.

No one else is around. So they, of course, ?caused the fight.? But there was a third party.

by Member 32650361

The line about all people lighting up a room-- some when they enter, some when they leave-- has a corollary:

All people eventually see the light-- some when they arrive, some when they leave. All things being even, it's time for you to look for the light-- you won't find it where you are.

by rascal1981

And while you?re wasting your time trying to solve what could be an irreversible problem, you might as well start planning for the firing portion of this downward spiral. I got a better idea (unless you are as *brave*? as Ron is here apparently?); start looking for another job. Why is this so hard to do? Take a look around on monster, career builder, etc? even contacting your local head hunter place wouldn?t be a bad idea but don?t try to make a fight with higher ups that is going to end the same way it started and that is, unfortunately with you on the losing end (if you had something going for you I would maybe say different but since you are already seeing a trend, what?s the point?). I know this may sound negative but think about your situation right now and tell me that finding a new job would be worse then living with anxiety and fear? I don?t know about you or Ron but I know what I would be doing; but as I said if you are that confident as Ron to run into the fire then I wouldn?t cry too loud if you get burned by the obvious?

This discussion is closed to new replies.