Discussion Locked

What would you do if you were me?

0 helpful
36 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

We redesigned TechProGuild 6 months ago and have been working hard to add features to the site, improve the quality of offerings, and make it more valuable to subscribers.

If you were Senior Editor for a day? What would you do? What new things would you like to see in TPG? And what would you change? Let's talk about it.

36 replies

by tony hopkinson

Add a reply to parent function.
Bring back my discussions.
Return to discussion locating you where you were would be real nice as well.
So would the ability to collapse posts with nothing new on them.

by tony hopkinson

Stupid User Syndrome.
Guilty

TPG.
Never used it. Not seen many reasons to use it.
If you had a trial, I might give it a go, but most of the topics I've seen would be irrelevant in my current position.
If they are given by vendors, about the only thing I'd learn is they had something to sell. I've been to some good face to face ones. Ken Holman on XML and Dr Bob on Delphi. I'd much rather listen to some practical ways to use a technology, than some sales type trying to sell me a product.
It's also interesting to meet vendors and tell them what they should be doing as opposed them telling us what we should be.

by j sheesley

Actually, there is a 30 day free trial. It does require a credit card for sign up, but it's not charged for the first 30 days.

As for the topics, they're not written by vendors. Everything's written by IT folk who are in the field doing the same things they're writing about. If and when we write about products its how to use them, not sales literature or product reviews. And the people writing about them do so because they like the products in the Introductory articles. Not because they're paid shills.

I do however like the User Group/Vendor Feedback suggestion you had... that's something we can look into. Thanks!

by j sheesley

These features are actually controlled by Jive, which is a different engine for discussions and Tech Q&A than we had before. I know that this has been an issue for a long time, and Im reasonably sure that the developer guys are trying to do something about it.

by stress junkie

I suppose I'm entering this post because you asked and most businesses are run by people who are so arrogant that they would never ask their customers how to improve their service.

Regarding TechProGuild, a pay to use service, I have made this observation in this forum on previous occassions. I have noticed and stated that many of the free technical how-to articles offered on this site are often lacking in depth. I have, on several occassions, read some article on the TR site that covered an area of interest only to find that I already knew as much or more about that subject than the article covered. A case in point was an article on data storage backup strategies several months ago. The article focused exclusively on tape backup. There was no mention of DVD-RW backup. I wanted to learn more about software that could handle DVD-RW, robotic libraries such as those available from Plasmon that could use DVD-RW drives, etc. The article could easily have been written in the 1980s. If I remember correctly the article didn't even discuss at any length the issue of off site backups. After reading that article I posted a message expressing great disappointment in the lack of information presented in the article.

So, when TR has books to sell or a pay to use service I have to look at my exprience with the free technical resources to make a decision. My only conclusion is that I would not be very happy paying for the level of expertise that I have come to expect from TR writers. So I keep my money in my pocket and only occassionally write about my disappointment in the technical content.

This is the reason that I would not pay for a TR service or product.

by crd

I started paying for the service a couple of months ago because I thought the paying articles would be different.
Up to now, I am not convinced to say the least, and I am seriously reconsidering my decision.
I don;t feel I am getting any bang for my buck.

by j sheesley

Is there something in particular you'd like to see different in the articles? Length? Topic choice? Writing style?

by j sheesley

Thanks for the comments Junkie. :)

It's always difficult balancing the expertise level to write about in technical articles. What's obvious to you is over the heads of some readers. We usually try to aim for the average expertise level so as not to talk over the heads of most people while talking down to others. There are some articles which are more technical than others.

The decision was made a long time ago to put the more in-depth technical articles in TPG, as opposed to TR. Not to debate the business model, but there's an added value to the indepth content as well as significant investment in content that we need to recover. There are several TPG reprints that we do feature in TR free to give people some samples of what they can find on TPG. Id encourage you to take a look at some of those. Plus, there is a free trial period where you can look around at will for free.

Finally, beyond the Original TR technical articles, there's also the Tech Book library which contains the complete online readable and searchable text over 250 books from Sybex, Sams, Microsoft Press, and others. They're updated every 90 days to make sure they're not stale and cover the latest topics.

Thanks for the input!

by tech.systems

I agree with the previous postings that the articles are often times lacking in depth and details on how to exactly do something. I also understand John's comment that not everyone is at the same level. I would suggest the following to address both concerns. There should be a series of articles about a given subject. I have seen this on occassion where the first article gives the overview of the subject matter and successive articles dig deeper and get more detailed. The problem with what has been done in the past is twofold. One, this drilling down on the subject matter was rarely done and two, that when it was done the articles were months apart and I would have to wait a month or more to get the details.

Here is what I propose. When the articles are contructed, the author should write an overview of the subject matter to address the people that are new to the subject matter. Within this article would also be a small outline of what will be in successive articles. If possible, release the overview and successive articles all at once, so we aren't waiting to get the full story and the details. This type of structure will address those just wanting to get basic information about the subject matter and also those who like my self want the details, examples and how tos.

The authors that can't afford the time or don't have the skills to do this should limit their articles to the free area. Technology changes so fast that we need fresh perspectives, solutions and complete information quickly and timely. Otherwise we can just go buy a book or look up the information in the online books.

The online books have proved to be useful to me on several occassions. I think this part of TPG is worth the dollars alone. Where without it, I would have to buy a whole book to get just the one chapter of information I needed. With TPG I can quickly find the book and go directly to the chapter I need.

One other idea that I think I have seen here which I would like to see more of is compiling of information from members into an article. The author would start off a discussion about something such as Enterprise Antivirus software and let the members comment and provide the content. The author with his own experiences and research would then compile the comments and his own information into a well organized article or article(s). I have found the comments and input from members to be valuable, but often times I don't have time to wind through the long list of posts to find those gems of information.

Hope this helps with some ideas.

by maxwell edison

.
Make it available on a trial basis WITHOUT having to sign-up for it first, or WITHOUT having to provide any information about yourself.

For X number of days, for example, just have a TechProGuild "Open House". Serving sodas would be nice, but they might spill over onto our keyboards.

by j sheesley

We actually did that back in 99. It was a technical nightmare dealing with the gating... and it's also problematic for legal reasons with our partners.

However... we've been publishing TPG Reprints in TR for some time now. They've just been hard to find. Taking your comments into suggestion, we're going to create a TPG Preview center that makes it easy to find these free versions of TPG content as well as free downloads. If possible, we'll even try to surface some of the Tech Books library.

Thanks for the comments!

by oz_media

People flock here because TR is one of the best resources for tech support, that I've found, outside of manufacturer sites, even then it is usually better.

There is SO much free information here that people find it next to impossible to justify paying for content nowadays I think. There is just TOO much free help available on the net, the more people get used to searching and digging for answers and information, the easier it gets to find. With more and more people finding their own info, the need to pay for content is reduced.

Now I fully understand that TPG has some valuable resources, but how much MORE valuable are these resources when compared to the free help available?

I am wondering WHO would find the greatest benefit from TPG, consultants? Security staff? Project Managers? But I don't see the value to the AVERAGE IT professional.

Don't get me wrong, John, I am not trying to demean the value of TPG, just wondering is perhaps the market position is correct. If you are focusing on the right groups of people and that sort of thing. But as I obviously cannot see your tracking stats and build demographics from it, it is really hard for me to say, just throwing some ideas out for thought.

by mrafrohead

It will protect you...

I promise ;p [/me grins]

Though I think the idea that you posted Max and Oz below are good ideas.

I wouldn't mind seeing that. I have no clue what's in TPG and considering it's a pay site, I'm very less inclined to find out. But wouldn't mind taking a look. Though I will admit, it would have to be SUPER impressive for me to hack up funds to pay for a websites access, as most anything can be found somewhere on a free site. Just depends on whether you want to look for it or not.

by oz_media

I think that is your main ogre to face John.

I remember as a newbie here I got the trial on TPG, I was away most of the trial period and didn't get much time brfore it was history. Since then, I have heard of many changes, many new improvements etc. Yet no "open house" as Max suggested.

I personally don't think I'd pay for content, unless it is really some stunning resource that I can't equal elsewhere, even if taking more time to search various places.

Then again, my line of work isn't realy complimented THAT much from MS tech talk or security tech talk etc. as it is very proprietary.

As you can tell,I have no idea what's available in TPG anymore, I vote yay on Max's idea of an open house. Maybe even just a FREE MONTH FOR EVERYONE!!! Get some site sponsors to donate their banner impressions for a month, give some stuff away for participation or quizzes based on the site layout or something, get some feedback and give away a few TR or sponsor T-Shirts or something.

Think of a car lot when they have a sale, they hang all those little colored flags all over the place and show off.

So put on your plaid blazer and drum up some biz!

by jaqui

I missed out entirely on the opening of tpg, so have no idea what's there, or the quality of the offerings.

from the tr offerings I wouldn't be impressed.
no real content on linux, documents in proprietary m$ formats.
quizes in proprietary format. ( flash )

very few of the downloads do me any good, as they don't touch linux, even those few that do, most are in windows format. ( just brainless to do that )

best format is plain text, or pdf for downloads, never in .doc

by j sheesley

I could go on and on about what's in TPG, but you can get a quick overview by taking a peek at the TPG Tour on the TPG home page.

We actually do use PDFs for most of the downloads in the TPG Download Center, although admittedly many of them are in .XLS and .PPT formats.

As for Linux content, there's an entire track in TPG devoted to Linux topics. Naturally there's more MS content because that's what more people use, however we try not to be completely focused on Micrsoft products. As Linux grows, especially with its further adoption by Novell, we'll be covering Linux even more going forward.

Flash quizzes are a great idea. We've been considering a TPG Training Center. This may be a good way to start.

Thanks for the comments.

by jaqui

are a terrible idea!!!

I do not install flash player.
nor have javascript.

so with either used it locks me out.

(editing to add )

section 342.1,.2 of CCC ( criminal code of canada )
unlawfull access of computer equipment.

need to have explicit okay we can run our application ( flash / javascript ) on your computer without paying you for cpu usage.

also, check laws re ms .net framework for distributed computing. clientside scripts are distributed computing...pay up for cpu usage.
[ this is part of why no flash javascript ]

the rest is, why do I need fancy moving crap wasting data transfer capacity? answer:
I don't need it.

by cuteelf

I'm kinda curious about the layout of the site.

I've noticed threads will be referenced in 2 or 3 different subject matters...good.
Do you have to hit next to open the next reply..or can we just view the text instead..
like ----
blah
---- instead of having steps.

And, why do I see on my screen..about 3 or 4 inches of wasted real estate?..the 2 large fat gray columns on left or right side. You could widen the body and take less space.

And..I havent seen a link on "my account" for any of the PM's i get..Or have I received them without knowing? :)

Just some thoughts.

by taipan

I was a TPG member several years back and was finding there wasn't enough value (see tech junkie's post). It would we great to see partnerships to other sources to compliment the content such as with Gartner, Forrester, and Metagroup. This could be an "outsource of depth" that may bring me back.

Cheers!

by j sheesley

Traditionally, TechProGuild has been focused on a more tactical audience such as support professionals and network administrators. Therefore, I can understand as an IT Manager how you might not have seen 'value' in the site.

We've considered adding more strategic content to TechProGuild, but what we've found is kind of a Chicken/Egg scenario. Strategic articles don't get pageviews because the audience isn't there. And the audience doesn't come because the strategic audience isn't there.

We're slowly trickling in more stratgetic content however. We've added a few articles, and quite a few of the new downloads in the TPG Download Center have a strategic bent. There are also over a dozen IT Management books in the Tech Book library.

The outside partnerships might be a good idea to pursue. Thanks!

by j sheesley

A lot of the new features in the Discussion Center are driven by the Jive engine. I'm not directly involved with that development, so I can't tell you what's involved there.

As for the PM's that's a new community feature they're still working on for the site. I don't think it's fully implemented yet, so there are still some things which arent fully implemented.

As for fat gray bars... The web pages are designed for 800x600 resolution. That's to maintain a consistent look and feel between the different resolutions. Unfortunately, that also means that the higher your resolution, the fatter those gray bars on the side of the screen. If you were set to 800x600, you would hardly see them. At 640x480, you'd have to scroll the screen.

We still have a signficant number of people using 800x600, so for now we havent changed it for a default higher resolution. If we did, then THOSE users would have to scroll the screen right to left to get the content. Yes, we could have the page auto size, but then that distorts the overall text flow. They're trying to maintain a consistent positioning of items.

by j sheesley

These are great suggestions! Thanks for making them. I've already started moving in this direction. I've been running a series on ISA Server 2004 that follows much the same layout as you've suggested. We'll also have a series on Live Communication Server 2005 and Project Server which are going to follow a similar path.

You're right about Tech Books. This has been a long overlooked feature I think. Our site redesign helped make the books more visible. Before, they only appeared low on the page and were difficult to find. I've been trying to make them more prominent on the TPG home page and in the TechProGuild Note. I think sometimes people think those are advertisements for books to buy rather than fully searchable and readable online versions of the books.

On your last suggestion, it almost sounds like an Open Source article. :) Readers make suggestions and changes on a particular topic. I think this is the pattern followed by Wikipedia and others. That might be something worth looking at. Thanks for the ideas.

by oz_media

You don't like clicking Next to move through the thread, you don't like the body size.

In the discussion pages, there is a Print link too. Right beside the 'subscribe' link.

Use this to display the ENTIRE thread will all posts in formatted text form. A LOT easier for larger threads. ;-)

by cuteelf

OOOH
I likey! Honestly, I didnt hit print b4 due to thinking: great, my printer's gonna start spitting pages...

by oz_media

I was expecting a print dialogue too. They would be better off with 'Print Preview'or 'Text Only' instead.

One day when I was not connected to any printers, I decided to give it a try, "WOW where did THAT come from!!" I still forget to use it half the time and scroll and click endlessly through posts though, DOH!

Glad it works for you! It really is much easier, now if I could only remeber to use it more often. I have a prety quick connection and usually don't have issues, but when I do, I always forget to use the Print Icon. It seems whenever someone asks, I always offer that advice though? :)

by techno1

When you visit the Infrastructure area of TechProGuild a great deal of the information is Microsoft servers and server invironments. It would be nice to have an area strictly for infrastucture such as Cisco, Netgear, 3Com ect. With a focus on Routing, Switching, Wireless, Security and patches.

Thanks!

by j sheesley

You're right, there is Microsoft server stuff mingled into the Infrastructure track. Ideally, we'd keep all of that stuff in the Windows Server tracks, but when it crosses a gray line into being an Infrastructure issue, such as using ISA Server 2004 as a firewall, then I'll put it in the Infrastructure track. It's not always perfect.

Generally, the break down in the tracks is:

Windows Server: NT, 2000 Server, WS2k3, Exchange, Active Directory, etc.
Windows Client: Win XP, 2000 Pro, 9x, Office, IE, etc.
Netware: Netware, Groupwise, BorderManager, anything Novell
Linux/UNIX: Redhat, Solaris, FreeBSD, MacOS
Infrastructure: Protocols, firewalls, net security, wireless, etc.
Troubleshooting: Troubleshooting issues, desktop software, desktop hardware

by mkfme

Seems to me that TPG (paying member for years) has a lot more flat out, and embedded, advertising than it used to. I find I'm paying less and less attention to the TPG e-letters I subscribe to because of this. The main reasons I have continued to subscribe - so far - are Q&A (I have received a number of valuable assists from other members) and helpful tech articles (of which there seems to be less and less.) I feel less attached to TPG than I used to, though I should check out the online books section sometime. My advice - less commercialism, more good tech content - pare it down. I'd rather pay (somewhat) more for membership to get better content and less advertising. Please don't start going more strategic - Gartner, etc. There's enough of that out there already.

by j sheesley

Actually, we've eliminated all advertising from the TPG Home page and the TPG Download Center. There's only one specific TPG newsletter, the TechProGuild Note, which is also now ad-free. On the article and download pages, there are no banners, pop-ups, or skyscrapers anymore.

Occasionally some advertising does creep into TPG pages. Most of this is contractually obligated to be there or is due to technical limitations. For example, there are still ads here in the TPG Discussion Center because of architectural reasons.

The links on the articles are entirely for other TechRepublic/CNet resources and again are there architecturally. However, we've gone a long way to eliminating third party ads and banners in subscription content.

by mkfme

The simple fact is the content of your newsletters now contains a lot more advertising _content_ than it used to IMO. This makes the newsletters of less interest to me. Also, I find there's less original content, and a lot more repetition of previously published content. For instance, the 2-18 Desktops NetNote touted a download featuring 75 Excel tips. But I downloaded the same file over a month ago. I have been sending out your Office app tips to my users but find more and more they are repeats of previously published info. So I'm feeling like I'm getting less for the money, to the point where I'm not sure it's worth bothering with anymore.

by peveht

Prior to your latest changes I was having difficulty downloading most of your articles and files. Since the makeover they have been very user friendly.

by j sheesley

The Newsletters, with the exception of the TechProGuild Note, are actually seperate from TechProGuild itself. They're offered as a part of TechRepublic, which does derive income from advertising.

TechRepublic content, including newsletters, downloads, and articles do indeed contain advertising. That's how they pay for the content. Premium content in TPG and in our Book and CD product derive most of their revenue from the subscription and cover fees. It's in those areas where we've worked to eliminate as much advertising as possible.

by dmoor

I am usually multitasking when browsing for a book in TechProGuild (reading mail, doing other things in my browser). However, when I click on Tech Books under Resources the delay is significant (15 to 30 seconds). Even worse, it completely freezes my browser, all windows (Netscape 7.1 on Windows Professional 2000). And every subsequent click on a link as a drill down does the same thing. This makes TechProGuild, for me, virtually unusable since I am unable to do anything during these delays.

Dave

by blackcurrant

I rarely get any delays or persistent problems when using TPG. Certainly no more than when I browse other sites, though I have never used Netscape.

This discussion is closed to new replies.