Discussion Locked

What's the best book to film sci-fi (or SF) transition and..

0 helpful
122 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

122 replies

by tony hopkinson

That reminded me of my favourite quote in a BBC review of the film Fellowship of the Ring.

Disappointing lack of closure oh and the female characters were insipid.

Pity he didn't read the book, and I can't imagine what this pratt would have done to LOTR to fix these problems.

by nicknielsen

if those around you can stand it.

Thomas Covenant. Hmm. It could be good, but I doubt Hollywood would let it; all that angst wouldn't play well at the box office. I wouldn't expect blockbuster status, but it would definitely become a cult classic.

by tony hopkinson

do with the idea that only guilt is effective for good?
That's the difference between Eddings and Donaldson, one of them has something worth saying, the sheer brilliance of the way he illustrates it is an added bonus.

How would you do Revelstone, Lord Mhoram's victory, Drool Rockworm's corrupt malice anyway.

Mordant's Need would be easier.

As for the Gap, Angus Thermopyle goes hollywood, it would be awful wouldn't it.

by battlestartardis

the complete Hitchhikers guide to the galaxt series was absolutely brilliant, yet the movie was a horrible adaptation

by cbalness

Nobody mentioned John Varley... Titan, Demon or how about the Barbie Murders...

or or or Steve Perry's Matadora Trilogy , or what about Piers Anthony and the Orn stuff or Battle Circle ??

Also as a tadpole I recall Clifford D. Simack had some great stuff like the Goblin Reservation. Also what was the one by Simack with the end of the world, the talking dogs and the robots ?? something like "City" ??

by augustmason

The sci-fi novel A Canticle for Leibowitz is absolutely timeless, and this is evident considering the book has NEVER been out of print since it was published almost 50 years ago.

The story itself has a wholeness which incorporates a major world religion (old Catholicism), trying to pick up the burnt-out pieces (books, artifacts) after present civilization destroys itself with nuclear weapons. There is plenty of Latin, arcane but somehow understandable, the rumblings of truth and hilarious dogma), juxtaposed with human power struggles, both selfish and pure, scientific and heretical, on very individual levels.

The drama or this novel is so intense, the situations so bizarre and personal, the whole thing could just as easily be written as a Broadway musical, if the right creative artists were inspired to do it.

Leaving all that Broadway stuff aside, it seems certain this project would become a once-in-a-decade smash as a satirical, futuristic, and dramatic film, done by a great director, writer, magnificent special effects people, and a PARADE of great actors playing a myriad of juicy, in-your-face roles offered throughout the story.

For example, I see Whoopi Goldberg as Mrs. Grales, the two-headed mutant woman of great faith, one head always asleep, but alive and whispering things, the other head in charge, trying to get the sleepy head baptized. That's at the end of the novel when the world blows up again, and the sleepy head comes to life and walks around after the living head of Mrs. Grales is killed. The new living head, named Rachel, won't even let a dying priest baptize her. Perhaps she is immaculate. How dramatic and mind-popping is that?

It's my prediction that A Canticle for Leibowitz will someday make an outrageous splash as a film and maybe even a musical. It's just that rich. I'm surprised there has not been more interest in making it happen.

If anyone could compose a musical score for it, I'm thinking it's Rufus Wainwright. His music has the educated cynicism and formal understanding of his native Catholicism, and his boundless immagination can produce wonders of arch musical phrasing. Rufus Wainwright (also an actor/singer as well as composer) would be well-suited to the role of the priggish Thon Taddeo in the middle part of the story, a man just re-discovering electricity and the lightbulb and demading respect for bringing lowly mankind out of the dark.

by deepsand

I'm surprised that of the rest of us here remembered such; perhaps that's a result of having read so much, over so many years, that one reaches the point where the trees fade into a forest.

As for Rufus, are you familiar with his father, Loudon Wainwright III? I think it possible that he might be an even better choice than his son.

by ed woychowsky

I thought it was Deathworld, a trilogy and a short story all revolving around a character named Jason.

by portable123

It seems that now producers have to "add" to a great book, so I don't see any doing real well. The only standout I remember is the Andromeda Stain. Book to movie the lead changed gender, and curare tiped darts changed to lasers (really dumb change as then the lasers had to make them dizzy). But otherwise it was extremely faithful to the book.

by chevvy55

Won't mind seeing an up to date 'Day of the triffids', the last War of the Worlds was a major dissapointment.
Hunters of the Red Moon by Marian Zimmer Bradley would be a good sci/fi action.

by iondover

heinlen's great work ignored again! if you haven't read it, please do. it will change your outlook on life, forever!

by tony hopkinson

Icky sentamentalist pap in my opinion, like most of his later stuff.

Starship Troopers done properly, or better yet the Moon is a Harsh Mistress, now those I'd pay to watch if there was someone brave enough to do them.

by gracebt

I would love to see this as a film. I always thought that it should be one. Another topic
that would make a good film is the "space elevator" concept. Several authors have written about this.

Regards,

73
-Grace
NNNN
z

by tony hopkinson

Not sure Hollywood could take the lack of explanation either. To me space elevator and even visits from aliens are scenery. The interesting bits for me, are things like waht impact a cheap way into space or knowing that we aren't alone would have on society. That sort of thing is hard to get over on film, which is why Hollywood misses most of what's good about sci-fi.

by purpleskys

I know, really old film...but it was one of the first sci fi movies I watched as a kid. I would likely consider it to be the movie that started the interest for me in sci-fi. I read books by Stephen King whose movies always intrigue me (note: Stephen almost always plays some sort of minor roll in most of his movies). Then there was A Wrinkle in Time by Madeleine L'Engle; I think after her book, I was completely hooked on sci-fi.

by tony hopkinson

I thought the movie was crap. The most interesting thing was, not one person of colour in the film, as though they had no part in the future.....

Pretty sure the book came after the film on that one as well.

by occallie

I think they did a pretty decent job with 'The Stand'. It follows the book for the most part and may be long, but at least it held my interest throughout the whole thing.

by tony hopkinson

when I did the original post.
Must confess it's another I don't see as sci-fi, because of King's horror background, it fits the genre though so may be I'm being a snob. :p

by .sherwood

Orson Scott Cards "Enders Game" could be a great movie if done right, along with many of the series.

Ben Bova's "Grand Tour" series.

Vernor Vinge's "A Fire Upon The Deep" was a great book, but I don't know that it could be translated onto film.

Brin's "Earth" would translate well.

Bear's "Darwins Radio" and sequel "Darwins Children".

This discussion is closed to new replies.