Yah, I am a lurker. I was one of the very first members but didn't visit frequently enough to remember my original account and hence no contribution so far :((
The set up has worked quite well for us having a AT&T T1 and Timewarener highspeed cable. It happened at least 4-5 times in the past three years when a connection to an ISP was completley lost due to bad weather, bad T1 card, or a big specialized truck ripping the overhead cables off. We never lost our Internet connection because of the redundancy.
Loadbalance is of course not optimal due to the fact that these are two different ISPs with different public IP ranges assigned to us. We couldn't do BGP with our own public IP because we were givenn just a Class C network. However, our Cisco routers are able to "quasi-balance" between the two ISP connection by source-destination pairs. So we do double our bandwidth, except that each application/connection can only take advantage of pipe size of whatever ISP it is switched to. And without higher-end routers and netflow, it's hard to track who goes out through where.
The reason we didn't get a large pipe T1 is because of the more stringent redundancy requirement for diff. ISPs and cost. What we are paying for the T1 and Cable right now is under $1000/month. You can't beat that for a medium-small size company who is very conservative in budgeting.
As to the poorman's internet setup, a 2620 with T1-DSU WIC is connected to AT&T, a 2515 is connected to Timewarner on E0, and a 2514 sits behind them as the loadbalancer using an Ethernet conn. to 2600 and a serial to the 2514. We are a Cisco shop so IOS and protocols config is not a problem.
Performance-wise, we have sporadic problems on our cable side upstream from us, which affects half of our connections when it happens. Cisco has features called Object tracking and Optimized Edge Routing that will probe and track remote router and destination performance through ICMP and connection statistics. But I am always open to a lower-cost solution.
We do have SNORT on the outside and inside and Cisco ASA5000 as firewall.