Discussion Locked

Who do you think were some of the best world leaders in the past 50 years?

0 helpful
122 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

And PLEASE I am sick of hearing about US Democratic presidents versus US Republican presidents.

As most of the input to these discussions comes from the USA, Canada, the UK and Australia, perhaps it would be best to list leaders from any country other than these four. However I will not make this a mandatory requirement if someone feels particularly strongly about a leader of any of these countries.

To get the ball rolling I will mention Nelson Mandela.

Here is a little blurb about him:

Nelson Mandela was the first black president of South Africa and a legendary figure of the African National Congress, or ANC. From 1964 to 1990, Mandela was imprisoned for opposing South Africa's white minority government and its policy of racial separation, known as apartheid. Instead of disappearing from view, Mandela became a martyr and worldwide symbol of resistance to racism. In 1993 Mandela and the president who released him, F.W. de Klerk, shared the Nobel Peace Prize. Mandela was elected the country's president in 1994. He served until 1999, when he was succeeded by his deputy Thabo Mbeki.

122 replies

by master3bs

There has been no greater leader in the last 50 years.

He helped stimulate economic growth, curbed inflation, employment went up during his terms, and the US national defense grew. He cut taxes; and stuck by the need to cut taxes even when the defensive spending grew the deficit.

By the end of his presidency, the USA had the longest period of peacetime prosperity without recession or depression.

Three words come to mind about his foreign policy, "Peace through strength." Defense spending went up 35% in his presidency; but he also negotiated a treaty with Gorbachev, to eliminate intermediate-range nuclear missiles.

He declared war on international terrorism; and followed suit against Libya.

Through his leadership, we won the Cold War that many thought would destroy the world. This was accomplished without a shot being fired.

I end with this quote; "I hope that when you're my age you'll be able to say, as I have been able to say: we lived in freedom, we lived lives that were a statement, not an apology."

by swwbo

The question was who was the best 'world leader', so Ronald Reagan is the only person who comes to mind - the man broke the back of the Soviet Union - the map of the world changed.

Nelson Mandella was a great leader of his country, perhaps, but I would not put him in the ranks of world leaders.

Most all the UN leaders have ended up being crooks, so they are not world leaders, either.

Only one left is Reagan.

by montgomery gator

I go along with your assessment of Ronald Reagan. However, Winston Churchill helped set up the resistance to Communist tyranny that Reagan brought to the end. It is Winston Churchill who coined the phrase "Iron Curtain", referring to the Soviet Empire's grip on Eastern Europe.

Winston Churchill was also the first world leader to oppose National Socialism, warning that Neville Chamberlain's "Peace in our Time" deal with Hitler would not work. Churchill was fighting National Socialist Germany under Hitler when France rolled over and played dead, and Stalin's Soviet Union was splitting up Poland with Hitler. I would say that Winston Churchill was the greatest leader of the 20th Century, a true freedom fighter. Reagan was of the same mold as Churchill, and runs a close second to him.

by absolutely

The fact that the Iron Curtain fell during his watch looks a lot like coincidence. Spending more than produced eventually leads to bankruptcy, whether Ronald Reagan is in charge or not. Also, forgetting about a clandestine plan to exchange guns for money, blatantly illegally, was hard to believe.

by jardinier

to realise that the American members of this website are so besotted with their own country that they don't give a rat's a*s about what is happening in the rest of the world.

And Americans wonder why the rest of the world thinks they are arrogant and insular?

by maxwell edison

.
Since 1955, the best "world leader"?

Since the best leaders lead by example, I'll have to say Mother Teresa of Calcutta.

By the way, why do you give a rat's a*s about what Americans may or may not say or do in these threads?

And how do you reconcile the conflict between two opposing things you've suggested? On one hand, you should have had the foresight to realize that the American members of this Web site are so besotted with their own country....., but on the other hand, you've charged that Americans should mind their own business?

Which would you really prefer? Or is this a case of damned if we do and damned if we don't? Or perhaps we should just check with you, and do whatever you think we should bloody well do?

by jardinier

Now who's being disingenuous?

I said nothing of the kind. I SUGGESTED that peers from the four countries who post most often should perhaps select a world leader who was not from their own country.

Please direct me to the portion of my post which states or IMPLIES that "Americans should mind their own business?"

by stress junkie

How does anything in your discussion support your conclusion that Americans don't care about the rest of the world? Is it because the one and only person who showed any interest in your discussion is probably an American and said that an American is one of the best world leaders in the past 50 years? Are you criticising master3bs? Isn't he entitled to an opinion? Does one person's opinion support the conclusion that all Americans are parochial and insular?

You insulted the only person who showed any interest in your discussion by insulting the probable nationality of that poster. Apparently you think that master3bs is a bad person for honoring an American president. You then use his post to insult all Americans. Your comment is irrational and rude.

I believe that you are just whining that your discussion wasn't more popular. Then, like many people, you blame Americans and America for your misfortune when, in fact, America has nothing to do with the popularity of your discussion. In your mind America is bad and you'll figure out why later. In other words you start with your own bigotry and then try to back fill supporting arguments for your prejudice.

Your ignorant comment has done some good. When I read it I realised that my most regretable comments in this forum are not half as ignorant as your comment here.

by jardinier

I added this member to my "contacts" because after no response for a couple of days, he was the only person who took the time to post to this thread, and gave a list of reasons for his choice of Reagan.

Where were all my detractors during those first two days? And would you have bothered to post to the thread if I hadn't made my anti-American response?

And thank you Maxwell for suggesting a leader who was NOT from the four countries I listed.

by maxwell edison

.
....of your question. By definition, a "leader" takes people where they want to go (or where they must go). Your country and your country's leader may have a different destination in mind than mine. And the people of Germany and France, for example, might actually want to go the way of Democratic-Socialism, and their leaders may very well take then there; but I would consider that an abysmal leader because I would not want to go there. So I won't be presumptuous enough to suggest what kind of leader is the best for Australia, France, Germany, China, or whomever else.

Your question also presumes that all the world's leaders, both past and present, and all the world's population actually want to be led to the same place, which is very far from reality. Your question is impossible to answer because of perspective. I would guess that the majority of the world's population might even choose Mao Tse-Tsung as the best, but I would not. And your choice of Nelson Mandela isn't even close to what I would prefer. I've got huge problems with Mandela, although I understand why a lot of people might agree with you.

My choice for the best leader of the past 50 years would be based on my perspective, which is an American perspective, and my values, which are American values; and we already know what you think of those. So what's the point?

Therefore, I'll stick with Mother Teresa.

by absolutely

nothing from j. but personality critique and name-calling.

What exactly do you have against America? Is it our general respect for the individual's right to mind one's own business, or is it the fact that having this right (and its logical corollaries) has enabled us to mind our own business [b]better[/b] as a group than any other nation on Earth, and better than any period in history? Are you just annoyed that collectivism has been conclusively proven inferior, not only for the most talented individuals, but for the entire collective?

If you named any [b]reasons[/b] for the names that you call the individualists at TR, I wouldn't [b]have[/b] to guess at your motivation. Do you even have one?

by jardinier

Well that's a classic remark.

Since the death of colonialism, and the collapse of the U.S.S.R. I can think of NO country that meddles in the politics of other countries remotely to the extent that the USA has done and continues to do.

And that is how you define "minding our own business?"

by oz_media

Man, what a crock!

"Is it our general respect for the individual's right to mind one's own business, or is it the fact that having this right (and its logical corollaries) has enabled us to mind our own business better as a group than any other nation on Earth, and better than any period in history? Are you just annoyed that collectivism has been conclusively proven inferior, not only for the most talented individuals, but for the entire collective?"

Max, just said it well. A given country's leaders generally act upon the desires of the citizens of a given country. If those citizens PREFER thier style of life and government to your own, who the hell are YOU to claim that you have proven thier style inferior? Because it is what YOU want ffrom a government then it's better?

"...mind our business BETTER as a group.?" Who the hell are you trying to kid? Are you showing yourself now as a person who feels America is the most prosperous and secure nation on Earth? Have you even looked at your country in the last 10 years?

Success is not an individual opinion, everyone else see thier country as propserous, everyone else think thier chosen country has a better government than the USA, everyone else has pride in what thier country has achieved.

Your pompus comment is exactly what Julain is talking about, you merely see America as the only country worth a damn and others have merely failed at becoming America, asif that was every thier intent to begin with, completely ignoring the FACT that America is seen as one of the most indesrirable homes on the planet by most others nowadays.

by jardinier

because you are an American and presumably like most other Americans on this website you are most likely unaware of why people from other countries dislike America and Americans in general.

I had no negative views about America or Americans before I joined TR. I soon found that it was my obligation as a foreigner to dislike America and Americans.

You can think and say what you like but it won't have an iota of effect on the Australians to whom I talk who speak in one voice about the arrogance and insularity of Americans in general.

I have heard this from mature, reasonable people who have visited America. Only the other day I was speaking with a school girl who said: "Well of course we don't like Americans."

I have a great respect for you fairness, knowledge and scholarship but this is not my personal view alone -- it is a universal view. The only American with whom I am currently in contact -- an escapee from Santa Monica -- would put Oz to shame with her derogatory views on Bush, his administration and Americans in general.

by Member 25348569

If you take the condition that his country was in when he became leader and where it was at its peak, surely one of the greatest leaders was Adolf Hitler.

by absolutely

As long as jardinier doesn't define any standards, the rest of us are left to imagine our own, and if territorial expansion is your only criterion, Hitler must be at or near the top of the list of dictators whose domains expanded the most during their reign.

On the other hand, if you count the cost of conquest in terms of global [b]productive[/b] capacity lost during wars, Hitler, Mussolini, Hirohito and the various communist dictators of the 20th century together have overseen the most enormous waste of human potential in all of history.

The nomination of Nelson Mandela strongly implies that personal liberty and equality before the law are important criteria for jardinier's definition of best, but I'm curious about the exact standards for choosing the best leader in the world according to jardinier.

by jardinier

best: adj. (superl. of good) of the most excellent or outstanding or desirable kind.

I don't think that any of the bad guys you mention would fit this criteria.

by oz_media

If it wasn't for sickness he could have been one of the greatest disctators of all time, Buch is giving him a run fo rhis money though, yet not anywhere near as well as Hitler did. Bush would have to pen up all democrats first and get them to wear a gold star, better be quiet, he might get ideas.

At least Hitler was a clever man, to begin with.

by maxwell edison

.
Criteria: Ability to inspire, especially, but not necessarily, in the face of adversity or crisis, or the ability to initiate drastic change, also especially in the face of adversity or crisis.

Rudy Giuliani
Martin Luther King Jr.
George W. Bush
Victor Frankl
Rosa Parks
Billy Graham
Menachem Begin
Ronald Reagan
Nelson Mandella (I hate to include him, but I will anyway)
Lech Walesa

That'll do for now.

by bfilmfan

I would add the following names to your list:

Aung San Suu Kyi, Nobel Prize winning non-violent, pro-democracy activist under house arrest in Burma.

Tenzin Gyatso, the 14th Dali Lama for keeping the freedom of the people of Tibet in the news for so many years.

Richard Nixon, Jimmy Carter, George Bush, Sr and Bill Clinton for being the elder statesman the current president can't seem to be...

Jonathan C. Lewis of Freedom from Hunger, a group that uses over 90% of its donations to feed hungry people.

by oz_media

No I am not comparing Bushto Hitler, I actually give Hitler more credit than that. But what YOU deem one of th ebest leaders of our time, others deem one of the worst and most destructive to a healthy nation.

So therefore, if Bush is allowed, as many Americans would deem himthe best also, then Hitler should be no different, or are German leaders exempt?

by jdclyde

If you look at around the world, you do not see an American flag flying over their capital. Nor will you ever.

Bush has not had anyone of ethnic difference marched in to be mass murdered.

Go back and read a history book of what Hitler did to his country and the world, and you will realize just how stupid and disingenuous you sound when you bring his name up to intentionally slam someone/anyone else.

Saddam, a real bad man, was NEVER on par with Hitler. Yet you can sit there and snivel that Bush is? So much for Canadian education?

by jardinier

but it is now moving steadily in the direction that was intended.

So I guess I will have to tickle the old grey matter and come up with a few myself.

The Dalai Lama who has already been mentioned would be on my list.

by jardinier

When starting a discussion I try and think of a topic that hasn't been covered recently.

In my three years at TR I don't recall any discussion which asked for suggestions for "good" world leaders. There may well have been, but I don't recall it.

It is now obvious that I worded this thread too loosely, but that has not prevented a variety of views being expressed.

by jardinier

1. Restores or maintains economic stability and growth.
2. Highly respected by other world leaders.
3. Establishes good rapport with other world leaders.
4. Through (1) and (2) is able to beneficially influence international matters.
5. Introduces ?unpopular? legislation for the longer term good.
6. Demonstrates excellence of personal character with no ?skeletons in the closet? and maintains personal morality during term of office.
7. Establishes and/or maintains separation of Religion and Government (except in the case of countries such as Tibet and some existing Muslim countries).
8. Introduces legislation that will decrease unemployment without increasing taxes.
9. Has a thorough knowledge and understanding of history so as not to repeat past mistakes of others.
10. Maintains an adequate but not excessive defence force.
11. Strives to simplify the existing taxation system.
12. Strives for reduced government.

by jardinier

but I hate with a vengeance our current conservative Prime Minister and his government.

The "liberal" party in Australia -- The Australian Labor Party (of which I am a member) is altogether different to your Democratic Party if I am to believe what I read in TR discussions.

One of the most liked and effective governments in recent years was the Hawke - Keating Labor Government which was in office from 1983 to 1996.

Bob Hawke, who had previously played a very effective role as president of the ACTU (Australian Council of Trade Unions) was a pragmatic person who recognised that the socialist platform of the Labor Party was outdated, and moved the party towards the centre. So close to the centre in fact that many people complain that they can't tell one party from the other.

The only real statesman that Australia has produced in the past few decades was Gough Whitlam, who brought Labor back into the game after 16 continuous years of conservative government.

Our current Prime Minister, John Howard, has been an MP for 30 years. He is a shrewd and cunning politician, so it goes without saying that he has the ethics of a rattlesnake.

However I will give credit where it is due and say that he is a strong and effective leader, even though I don't like the road down which he is seeking to lead Australia -- which is as close as you could get to a fascist state within a democracy.

by Member 25348569

To define "good" in those terms for a leader is not acceptable even if you did start the thread.

Best for who? The people he is leading? Mandela hardly qualifies. His figurehead status was a purely passive role used by the "real" leaders in the ANC - and by lovable, cuddly, mudering Winnie. De Klerk was the man who did it all up to and including letting Mandela out. Mother Theresa is not a leader. She is an example and a role model and a dig at our consciences. Regan? Nah. Gorbachev was the [b]man[/b]. He did it all.

Leaders lead. "Good" leaders lead lots of people and they usually lead them a long way from where they started. The only reason that Hitler and other like leaders - Pol Pot? - don't really qualify is that they got it all wrong in the end and went [b]too[/b] far. Judged in 1941, however, Hitler looked pretty damn good! Leader? He was certainly that! Others who spring to mind are religious cult leaders, some of them who lead their followers to penury, near slavery - sexual or otherwise - or even death.

If you had titled your thread "Who was the cuddliest leader?" or some other wimpy cop-out then I wouldn't have posted.

This is Miscellaneous, Jules. We go off-topic. Live with it.

Neil :D

by jardinier

You always help to bring discussions to an even keel and point out oversights on my part.

by Member 25348569

Julian is now happy that the thread is progressing how [b]he[/b] wants it to go! What are you, fellow TRers? Sheep? Follow me off-topic and I will promise you, Max, lower taxes and a guarenteed place in Heaven for everyone except Absolutely! Join my campaign and I will guarentee pen:s extensions for all men (except for me who, as your leader, doesn't need one).

No? Ah,well.

Anyway, lets have some [b]leaders[/b]! Everyone is posting role models and "nice" people. Julian wants to define everything in nice cuddly terms and there's never been and never will be anyone to fit his list. Politicians in democracies are out for themselves. Any appearance of statesmanship is coincidental.

I still reckon you'd have to a long way to match what Hitler achieved between 1933 and 1942. Hitler took Germany from the economic and social wreckage that it was post-World War I and to rebuilt the economy and military. At the height of their power during World War II, the armies of Nazi Germany dominated much of Europe.

Leaders in Julian's timescale? Has to be Gorbachev. His reforms led to the inevitable breakup of the Soviet Union and the "freeing" of Poland, Hungary, etc. Hell, Margaret Thatcher famously remarked: "I like Mr. Gorbachev - we can do business together". (I know you Americans would like Reagan to take the credit for all of that but it just happened on his watch.)

Neil

p.s. Thatcher - though I never liked her - qualifies in spades! The changes she kicked and handbagged through were radical.

The problem with this discussion is that we all have to suggest our own country's leaders or those who loomed large enough on the world stage to affect us. The leader of Iceland between 1962 and 1975, Vilhjamur Vilhjamursonssonssonssonsson, was the greatest leader in the world and fitted all of Julian's list.

pps. I made VV up. :)

by oz_media

The one we loved to hate. In the same sense, she was one tough leader that got things done.

But I haven't mentioned any of Canada's leaders, but then again, Canadians don't either. In a series called Canada's heroes, politicians never made a slot above our top hockey players. :D

Yeah, Canadians are into politics, not. :D

by oz_media

Bests that also fit are:
"Competent; skilled" Hitler WAS both competent and extremely skilled

"Complete; thorough" HItler was also EXTREMELY thorough, moreso than most were prepared to deal with.

WHile Hitler was seen as a horrible dictator by MILLIONS around the world, he was seen as the answer and saviour to those whom he lead. And lead his chosen ones he did, much better than many ave since.

by thechas

Despite all the pain he brought to his people and the world, Hitler was an effective leader.

GWB on the other hand, has a hard time keeping his support base on his side.

Hitler lead Germany out of a post WW1 depression and made it a world power that nearly took over the entire globe.

GWB is leading the US along the path to becoming a third world country.

Chas

by jamesrl

If a great leader is one who manipulates, lies and decieves, then Hitler would suit your criteria. But I would argue that building a country on such false pretenses builds a house of cards that will not stand.

Even if Hitler had stayed within his own borders, his economic system would not be self sustaining, just as that of the Soviet Union was not able to sustain itself(and that more than Reagan lead to the end of the Soviet Union).

On a military scale, Hitler made several vain stupid decisions that cost hundreds of thousands of lives of his own troops. You can claim insanity, but I am not willing to give him an out so easily.

Uniting a country by creating a scapegoat....thats not great thats pathetic.

James

by oz_media

One of the most brilliant leaders of all time. If you can't see it, you have those foggy goggles on again.

Hitler commanded his people as no other has ever done since the Romans. His peopel believed in him, sure he was a terrible dictator that detroyed millions of lives and eventually his own peopls too, but he was not always a syphillitic madman, he did a far better job of gaining the trust and respect of HIS people than Bush has done that's for damn sure.

Despite his intentions, f you do not recognize Hilter as one of the most influencial leaders and most powerful men to ever take office, then you sir are extremely clueless or are simply in denial due to your partiotism. If BUSH did what Hitler did you'd deem him a hero and saviour.

by swwbo

I hope everyone else thinks the US is a bad place to live, then maybe they will stop trying to move here, eh?

Yeah, we work harder than the Europeans and Canadians, but we get more out of that work.

Socialism is a huge failure - all the socialist countries are becoming bankrupt.

What is so good about paying people to not work?

Nah, I prefer the USA to any other place on earth, and I can only hope more and more people will dislike the USA so they will stop invading our borders!

by jdclyde

For a while there it would annoy me to hear people in other parts of the world always talking down the US and proclaiming on high that the US would be lost without them being the ones to sell us this or that.

I would even try to point out that this is total BS and that if anyone knows ANYTHING about business they know that if people stop buying things from a vendor, the VENDOR gets hurt more and a lot quicker than the purchaser. It is a LOT easier to find another Vendor than it is to find another customer.

I think you now have the right idea. Let them dwell on their hate, somewhere else.

Of course these same "everyone HATES the US" people, would raise a fit if we were to finally crack down on illegal and legal immigrations. Funny how everyone hates the US and would rather live somewhere else, yet we have the hordes at the gates to come into "The land of opportunity".

Guess the people trying to get into the US didn't read the same anti-US flier?

by oz_media

Next time try reality.

You have CLAIMED that the world needs US money to survive, over and pover again.

And though it has also been proven that said countries have many other markets and they suffer from US consumption of thier resources, you STILL believe that people woul dperishwithout the USA. I suppose that makes it easier to stomache, or at least easier to accept the way your government abuses it's international treaties without a valid reason or excuse. In the same sense, anyone who doesn't fit YOUR ideals of a trading partner is flamed and eventually invaded to TAKE thier resources instead.

Canada sells the US heat, hydro electric power, grains, meats, produce and has also provided h eworld with some of the most important and life saving technologies and inventions. Yet you think you could cut off th eworld and go at it alone, perhaps explain that to the large portion of your population that is living in cold darkness when you stop bastardizing your allies resources and not living up to your end of the bargain.

The resources you get from Canada, are in demand worldwide, Canada also supplies Europe and Asia with those same resources and is paid a much greater price for them while that demand increases annually. You see, Canada HAS allies, Canada HAS friends, Canadian's ARE welcomed with open arms pretty much worldwide.

Now, if the world wasn't giving into US demands, what would you do besides invade everyone for your resources?

Will you be trading US lumber for Asian grains?
Perhaps you could have European power plants break ecological laws in order to increase production and then send heat and light to the USA? Perhaps you coul dget your oil from Iraq, ooops, sorry, you are already working on that one aren't you?

What would the price of gasoline be in the USA if it wasn't for Canada's oil?

You certainly wouldn't be able to buy a house, yet alone run power into it.

That's just the WEST coast, and the most minimal of your stoleb resources, yet you seem to think others would perish without you?

Europe wants Canadian oil, Europe wants Canadianlumber.

Asia wants Canadian lumber (and pays top dollar for it, unlike the billions the USA still hasn't coughed up over the softwood lumber issues). Aisans pay more than 30X what the US pays for Canadian fish. The US fishing boats would no longer be able to fish in Canadian waters, which they push for more and more of every year.

I know, you have military might! But again they rely heavily on allied countries to provide what they lack also.

So when you REALLY take a look at it, Canada MAY suffer an economic struggle for a short time, perhaps even a reduction in teh annual economy. Not anywhere NEAR the effect it would have on the USA though, you are used to just having whatever you want and then some more just in case. Without others, your captalistic society woul dnot seem so superior when you were broke and outof work, th epeople of America would be lookign to the government to fix the issue or hand out the cash.

You can only live in your 'suerior' capitalistic society because of the immense abundance of resources you welch of the rest of the world, dont't fool yourself, you are living in a reliant and very needy country.

by oz_media

You can continue to live in fear of everyne and everything.

You can continue to believe the absolute lies and deceit fed to you by your government, and those wanting thier turn in office too.

I chose not to live in the USA, I have never evenconsidered invading your border, nor have I ever met someone who DID want to live in the USA. Most simply want to avoid the paranoid population of the USA, it seems that you have more and more right to be paranoid daily though, so I an accept that, my country doesn't have a national threat meter that warns the people when to not trust any living soul.

Everyone in the USa seems to have som eridiculous notion that everyone wants to live there, everyonethat can't live there just flames the USA because they are jealous. This is the attitude that causes people not want to live there though.

Just a while back, Americans were bragging that they were the most mulitcultural and globally acceptingnation on Earth, which I see is echoed in your comments too. You guys are suh hypocrites merely for teh sake of being overly defensive of any comment toward your country, as if it is your problem people complain of and not your sad government's. THIS is yet another reason people wouldn't consider living there.

Sure, you have third world immigrants knocking at the door,or crawlig under the fence, walking across the beach into the US etc. (Yes you can walk the beach from Canada to teh USA without even realizing you have crossed into the USA) what a joke that is and yet you have overly paranoid border security?

No, people living in free countries do not pinefor the USA, this isn't 1976, there's nothing there worth anyones time nowadays.

YOu couldn't drag my cold dead body from BC to the USA, it's way to nice up here. Unless you've actually laid eyes on BC you simply have no idea what's here that you don't have. That's why most visitors become residents when they visit here from all over the world, in fact, BC has been in th elist of the top 5 most desireable places to live in Earth for over 5 year straight now, the US has not yet had a single city or state make the top 25 list.

Yeah, fool yourself all you like, buy into your government's lies all you like, just remember; the truth is out there, and it certainly isn't what you are lead to believe.

by jdclyde

That people in other countries confuse us being better than everyone else with arrogance.... ;\

[/sarcasm]

Seriously for a few seconds (can't keep it up much more than that so I have to be quick) it really is a shame for a few reasons.

one, thanks to the entitlement state a certain political party has been fostering, we have more stupid people than ever. I would say it is a safe bet that if you go it inner cities and find many people that vote for that certain political party they couldn't even tell you how the vice-president of the United States is, or Secritary of State.

These same people couldn't tell you WHY they HATE Bush, they just know they are suppose to.

For the most part, it isn't arrogance, but ignorance.

So it isn't nice to go around hating a bunch of stupid people you have never met based on the reported policies of one administration or another.

Remember, for the most part what you know about us is based on biased media reporting that starts with that same attitude against America that doesn't talk about the good we do, but delights in any misfortune.

And yes, ALL media today is biased.

by jardinier

Biased in favour of or against who or what?

I don't want to make an issue of this but I have spoken with certain people I know (mature aged, fair minded, intelligent) who have visited America and have formed their opinions based on their direct experience with Americans.

As for the media -- you pose a conundrum.

I was under the impression that the American media is owned and controlled by energy barons and a very right wing former Australian citizen. So why would it be reporting anti-American propaganda?

I don't find any particular bias in the Australian media. In opinion articles by various journalists, yes of course, but not in the selection or emphasis of general news stories.

The reporting of our own political parties and leaders appears to be quite impartial. If it's a story, it's a story and will be published "without fear or favour."

by swwbo

Whey don't you come to the US and see for yourself. I invite you to come to Leavenworth, Kansas, my home town.
Then I invite you to make up your own mind about US Citizens.
I travel to other countries as often as possible - often for work. I have really not run into the anti-Americanism that you are so happy to take part in.

As for the Oz guy - I've been to Vancouver. You can keep it.

by jdclyde

All people have opinions.

This opinion taints the way they view things as well as WHAT they chose to view.

There are many ways to be biased in the new. One, is the showing of only one side (good or bad) of a story based on if you favor or not the story.

While some are more biased than others, I don't believe ANY media outlet is completely without bias, nor is there any person without bias.

By CHOSING to only show the negative things about the US in the world media, this feeds the ANTI-American movement.

Like ALL countries we have our bad, but we also have our good. Think back to the last 10 stories you have heard about the US in the world media. How many were positive vs negative?

When the tidal wave hit, did you hear of America stepping up and giving large sums to help out, or did you hear that they weren't helping enough, fast enough? Do you hear about the GOOD stories that come out of Iraq? What IS the last GOOD story YOU heard come out of Iraq?

As for media in the US, it is a joke. Fox leans right and is always used as an insult of some kind by wingnuts from the ffffaaaarrrr left of, "do you believe everything you hear on fox?" Anyone with a little honesty could see that they are right leaning, but not extremists. And they DO bring on TOP demorcatic officials and give them a fair chance to express their side. You don't see that out of the others.

The other major broadcasts are all left leaning, just some more than others.

Then even our public station has been hijacked by accademia and has moved to the very far left. It really is a CRIME to use government funds to promote one side or the other.

But a mentality of "at all costs" of pushing the agenda of the extreme left have taking over, and even the Democratic party in the US has been hijacked and is not even recognisable to what it was 40 years ago.

by absolutely

So what? You're clever enough to see through that bias, and let's be honest: you're no genius. Everybody else sees through bias, too. Bias is not difficult to detect. Just watch and listen for deviations from logic. Every single deviation is the result of a wish to reach a certain conclusion, with or without support from the facts.

Fabricating events, evidence, "facts" has recently been excused with a sincere apology, but in fact Dan Rather and everybody involved in that fiasco should have been sacked and blacklisted. The problem is that the public doesn't care enough about truth in reporting. In my opinion, many are too preoccupied with calling any opinion other than their own "bias." Which is fine, as long as we each recognize our own opinions as bias as well.

All the babbling in the world will not change the fact that every person has a perspective, and that nobody reports news because they don't care about the [b]significance[/b] of events. Their care about the significance of their reports will inevitably be expressed in a bias. Why anybody is bothered by that, or expects anything else, is what I cannot understand.

When objectivity is valued more in the general culture, it will be shown more in the news. When objectivity is practiced more, and more pride taken in the moral value of objectivity, it will be valued more in the general culture. As long as petty bickering decides elections and ratings, petty bickering will be what we get.

by maxwell edison

.
All media is biased in some way. It's best to recognize it, see through it for what it is, and be balanced in receiving your information. Quite frankly, however, I'd rather see someone (a reporter, a commentator, etc.) admit his/her bias (such as John Stossel) rather than one who vehemently denies having one (such as Dan Rather).

by jdclyde

is then you get the many who WANT to believe something is true running around parotting what they heard as if it was gospil from on high.

The liers are leading the stupid and dishonest.

Yes, I do recognise my own bias and except the fact that other people are wrong.

by m_a_r_k

[i]"I had no negative views about America or Americans before I joined TR. I soon found that it was my obligation as a foreigner to dislike America and Americans. You can think and say what you like but it won't have an iota of effect on the Australians to whom I talk who speak in one voice about the arrogance and insularity of Americans in general."[/i]

Maybe I misunderstood what you wrote. First you said that Americans on TR caused you to dislike America. In the next sentence you wrote that what we say won't have an effect on what you tell your compatriots about us. Which is it? Do we or do we not influence you?

by jardinier

The following statement was kinda tongue-in-cheek:

"I had no negative views about America or Americans before I joined TR. I soon found that it was my obligation as a foreigner to dislike America and Americans."

Before I joined TR I thought only of the positive features of America (which I described in a post in another discussion).

The birthplace of jazz; the source of all the great stage musicals; the producer of the kind of movies that I like best -- those that keep me glued to the edge of my seat. [I quite enjoy a Coke from time to time also]

But more importantly I viewed America as the ally in WW II without which the Brits would be speaking German and the Aussies would be speaking Japanese.

However as this knock America stuff came up so often in discussions, I started to ask Australians what they thought of America and Americans, and that was when I learnt that in my neck of the woods the vast majority of people hold a very negative attitude towards America and Americans.

So my answer to your questions is: TR has brought to my attention an attitude of which I was previously unaware. Has TR changed my views on America and Americans? Yes to some extent. However I probably would have remained neutral if it were not for the fact that our Prime Minister -- for reasons unknown as he never discussed his decision in parliament -- chose to make Australia a member of the COW.

There is no doubt in my mind that this has made Australia a primary target for terrorism and no doubt you have heard of the recent incident in which a major terrorist attack in Australia was nipped in the bud.

Regarding this excerpt: "but it won't have an iota of effect on the Australians to whom I talk," I did not mean to say that I intend to pass on these negative views that I have noticed in TR, but that I have found that people ALREADY have these views.

In various discussions I have stated very positive things about the Americans I have met in Australia.

During part of the war in Vietnam, I was living in Kings Cross which was a favourite destination for R & R. I was living in a rooming house which included among its tenants some girls who were dated by American servicemen.

I noted that the Americans were extremely polite and the girls they dated found them gentlemanly in their behaviour.

Of course this was more than 30 years ago and I now very rarely meet an American. I would like to add that this computer which I use as my workhorse was purchased from an Afro-American IT guy at a school fete. He was extremely polite and helpful.

I hope that this clarifies for you my original post.

by maxwell edison

Americans today are no different than the ones you met 30 years ago at Kings Cross. In fact, some of the Americans that are "criticized" today may very-well be the same ones!

I'll tell you what, while these discussions have altered your views of Americans for the worst, they've built my resolve to dismiss what the rest of the world (as you may define it) may say about us.

And I'm absolutely sick of seeing these incessant slams and criticisms from Oz_Media and others like him, but he certainly leads the charge. If you or your country were verbally assaulted in such a way, you wouldn't like it either. And I strongly doubt that you would give-in and capitulate to the opinions of such people. Instead, just like me, it would probably build your resolve.

by kevin dubya

Neil,
Not sure about that.
Look at Carol and Mark - their track record is dubious to say the least.
Take Mark - he got "lost" for six days on Paris Dakar rally, and had some irregular dealings in SA.
Carol refused to pay her Council Tax - saying "Mum won't give a sh1t" - not the brightest of comments...and recently has decided to do the unspeakable (I'm a non-entity get me an Agent...) TV program...
We cant blame Dennis for all that methinks?

by jdclyde

It was in the middle of his indoctrinations (I mean education) that he got dragged from the splendor that is England over to that forgotten realm known as Canada.

And as early education just teaches you which paste tastes the best, I let it fall on the door step of the Canucks for the finishing touches that you see before you today.

I blame you. ;\

by jamesrl

I figure by the time someone finishes grade school, they are pretty much the person they will become. Their core values are set. The rest of what experience teaches us, and some people seem to be immune to those lessons. I am not suggesting you don't learn anything in hig school, but if you are messed up, its too late.

I know you are teasing me. I blame you. He was probably fine before exposure to rabid dog republicans. He wouldn't meet many of them in Canada (Conrad Black the exception that proves the rule).

James

by oz_media

Can you tell me when I came to Canada and what grade I left, entered ? Perhaps you could also tell me when I returned to England and went back to school too. You seem to have a grip on everything else you CLAIM to know here anyway.

by oz_media

NObody's CLAIMING insanity, Hitler was disgnosed with severesyphillis that eventually deteriorated his once very powerful mind. This resulted in his defying his own military advisors in order to power trip on Stalingrad and making those mistakes that helped Russia see the end of WWII.

There was no CLAIM of insanity, he was medically insane and had been going that way for several years as WWII progressed. Who knows what he could have achieved if Britain hadn't fouht him off in the battle of Britain and if he wasn't over zealous in his arrogant attempts to take Staligrad. Have you never actually read any WWII history, real history, not the comic books you sudied in high school social studies?

As for a leader who manipulates, lies and decieves, did you forget that you are living in America? Under GWB's government? Give your head a shake and you may just see the hypocrisy in your comments that the rest of the world sees.

by oz_media

Canadaian and British education.

Public opinion throughout the globe, except America of course, which to you IS the globe.

Nobody said that we wre looking for the most ethical leaders, if so Bush certainly wouldn't fit that bill either, the issue is one of who was able to lead his people. Now if you don't think that leading Germans into believing and fighting for his madness was not a sign of a true leader of HIS people, then you are simply clueless, but you've proven that many times before, no need to stop now.

You seem to be looking for the most herioc leader or the most righteous leader, in both cases Bush would not be on that chart either, though I would agree many past presidents may have been.

by jdclyde

When I read the title of the discussion [i]"Who do you think were some of the best world leaders in the past 50 years?"[/i] I had mistakenly taken the word BEST to be something positive. But then, I am usually the one that looks at the positive side of things, while you usually are the one that looks at the negative side of things. Not much has changed, huh?

And once you get over yourself and your Bush hate, you could clearly see I never nominated Bush as qualifying for the "best leader" in the last 50 years.

Dadburn facts, just keep tripping you up.......

by maxwell edison

.
I've never seen a more pompous, conceited and self-righteous person in my life. And I won't even get into crass, .......

by maxwell edison

.
It means whatever it has to mean for Oz to justify his incessant verbal assault on the USA and/or President Bush. Don't you know that by now?

by oz_media

Proving what little you actually know about me and simply wish to believe as it makes all your beliefs come true. I've seen more of America than most Americans, at one time it was a place I pretty much lived and was CONSIDERING moving to, but then woke up and watched your country change for the worse.

by oz_media

That was more than 50 years ago, thus excluded by the title of this thread.

I also consider Caesar o a great leader, but that was befor ethe iven timeline too.

Go figure, Hitler and the Romans, and I am British. Goes to prove there's no bias in my choices though, I can see beyond my own backyard at least.

by swwbo

Gee, Oz,

Canada? Oh yeah, Canada - Canada who depends on the USA for military protection?

Right.

by Member 25348569

I'm interested. Who do you think that Canada needs protecting from? Who were the last people to invade? Just asking...

by Member 25348569

Possibly that's Denis's genes but he was a successful businessman. Maybe it skips a generation and Thatchers grandchildren (are there any?) might come good.

More likely, she's a mutant or even an alien life-form.

Yes, I heard that Carol was going on "I'm a Celebrity? Get outa here!". Sad.

by maxwell edison

.
...but conceited and full of himself. The great OZ, knows it all, is always right, is smarter and better-read than everyone else, and whose perspective is always the correct one. Idiot doesn't even begin to describe you.

by jdclyde

How do you stay in business?

If people BUY a product, whether finished goods or raw resources, they are not stolen, nor welched.

If Canadians could make more selling to someone else, THEY WOULD. That or you are telling me Candians are stupid? Come on.

While you smoke this pipe dream in your own little misguided world, the rest of us will get along just fine.

World market, and while yes we currently purchase a lot of goods from Canada, list exactly what product you provide that can not be found elsewhere?

We could and would find other vendors as they would line up to get the contracts, while you would be stuck with your resources and no income.

Canada MAY? I see that this was all satire after all, and you were just trying to bring humo(u)r to my day and I was too dense to get your subtle wit! You really had me going there.... :^O

by jdclyde

tell you all this? If you can't remember, then maybe you should write it down somewhere?

B-)

(more of the Canuck influinces showing through....)

by spidershrek

Wheather his is a communist or not i got to tell you Fidel Castro has his merit. Even thought i don't agree with his political views he has managed to stay in power for over 30 years.

Castro remained fairly popular in Cuba. Many Cubans seemed to benefit from the redistribution, education and health policies of his regime. Those who opposed Castro often tried to flee the country for the United States before the regime could arrest them. Although Castro has never held an open election, many scholars argue that during the early years of his regime, he could have won one. Internationally, Cuba was solidly in the Soviet camp, also receiving considerable economic support from Moscow. During the 1970s Castro sent his own military intervention force to civil war-ridden Angola to support the communist side. The end of Soviet aid after 1991 has exposed the weaknesses of the Castro system, causing the regime to initiate some cautious reforms.

Part of this info was taken from:

http://history1900s.about.com/gi/dynamic/offsite.htm?site=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.cnn.com%2FSPECIALS%2Fcold.war%2Fkbank%2Fprofiles%2Fcastro%2F

by maxwell edison

.
....then the world should join forces and invade us, overthrow our government, and kill us all for being so pitiful and devious. Hey, at 300 million against 6 billion odds, it would be a cake-walk for them. Oh, but wait. We're even WORSE than Hitler's Germany, and they let him get away with being the scum of the earth as well. So I guess we can get away with it for a while longer.

But they certainly have other options as well, apart from invading the USA and overthrowing our corrupt government. If we're THAT bad, where are the economic sanctions against us? Where are the UN Security Council resolutions condemning our actions and behavior? Where are the nations that should, in all rights, cut-off trade with us? Gee, if we're as bad as we're made out to be, what is the rest of the world doing about it?

Or then again, maybe we're not all that bad after all.

by jdclyde

but you can always hope that someone that feels at enlightened as he feels he is, would be just a little more enlightened to be able to be a little more open and maybe be a little posititive once in a while.

He has already been judge and jury, and now has set himself up as executioner. Everything he see and hears goes through his preconcived conclusions and pulls out anything that is bad or can be distorted to appear bad to justify his miserable disposition.

It really amazes me how he has ALL the answers, yet Americans for the most part are all in the dark.

Either this is total greatness in our mists, or a total lunatic with a Napolianic complex.

by sleepin'dawg

The man every American seems to despise and yet who was it that got the US out of Vietnam and who was it that re-established diplomatic dialogue and economic ties with mainland China??? If it were not for the Watergate business, which he [b]did not instigate of his own volition[/b] but which he royally screwed up by his handling of it; he could possibly be considered one of the better presidents, definitely on foreign policy if not domestically.

When Canadians start getting overly proud you can always remind them that their previous two Prime Ministers, Mulroney and Chretien, departed office under clouds of scandal. Mulroney in what is now known as the Airbus scandal wherein over $90 Million dollars of tax payer's money and bribes managed to disappear and yet he was able to walk away scot free. Chretien was involved in what is called the Sponsorship scandal where over $240 million tax payer's dollars ended up in the pockets of some very strange people. If I recall correctly Dick Nixon didn't dip into the public purse at all. He was nailed for covering up certain political hijinks but I'm fairly certain there was no theft of money involved.

Every now and then there is a dearth of competent, charismatic leadership throughout the world. We seem to be going through one of those patches right now. How could the US have got itself into such a position that its only choice in leaders was either Bush or Kerry???

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

Roman Catholicism was the brand of choice amongst China's christians and one of the major points of the struggle in South Vietnam was the ruling class were Roman Catholic while the rest of the population was Budhist. Budhist monks were self-immolating in protest to the spread of Catholicism, not because they were pro North Vietnam or communist.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jdclyde

Now he is adding symbols to his name! How pretentious can you get?

The poster formally known as Dawg?

How am I suppose to pronounce ]/b] ?

Get off your high horse there and go back to being just Dawg!

by absolutely

I'll interpret your use of the word meddling to exclude the positive influence of Americans in Medecins sans Frontieres, Red Cross, Habitat for Humanity and other do-gooder groups, as well as the positive influence of American loans to former colonies.

The worst foreign policy of the United States, in my opinion, has been in supporting religious fanatics' resistance against the USSR and various unsavory characters in Central and South America. I suppose those are the actions you meant? The worst foreign policy of the United States is also pretty easily traceable to two industries: the oil industry and the prison industry (via the "War on Drugs").

Neither industry speaks for the United States any more than Al Qaeda is accepted by all Muslims as their spokespeople.

I hope that clarifies what I did not mean by "mind our own business". I believe our Constitution needs an Amendment drastically limiting the powers of government to take any action abroad, as shown by the novel ways that various presidents have found to send soldiers and spies abroad without declaring a war. What I did mean by "mind our own business" is that with guarantees of the legal rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of one's own happiness, Americans are among the very most productive people on Earth. The few nations as wealthy as the United States are also among the freest.

The best thing GWB has done in his worthless life has been to illustrate the meddling that has occurred in foreign nations, especially to the south of us. Iraq is not the first foreign country that has a US-built "representative" government, just the most conspicuous.

Most Americans, however, do mind our own business. The freedom to do so makes many of us wealthy. Unfortunately, the amount we pay in taxes permits our government to pursue witless and immoral policies planned by people who have never set foot in a foreign country. That brings me back to the subject of personal freedom, and the US government's encroachment on that right since World War 2, after which government spending as a percentage of GDP decreased less than after previous wars. Since then, each "leader" has found new and ridiculous ways to "provide for the common defence" by spending money abroad and "promote the general Welfare" by taking from the rich -- who know how to make money -- and giving the poor, who evidently only need to know how to be given money.

http://www.house.gov/jec/growth/govtsize/govtsize.pdf

Page 8

With that, my answer to the original question: Ayn Rand, for reminding the world that every atrocity begins with the premise that some collective goal negates the absolute rights of the individual.

by absolutely

what about a definition of a "world leader"?

Maxwell's nomination of Mother Teresa is a good example: although she had no political title, she was certainly influential. Did you mean to include anybody that influential in the world, or only political professionals?

by jardinier

I plead guilty to lacking the foresight as to the many ways my post could be interpreted.

I meant a political leader of any country.

Therefore presidents, prime ministers, monarchs, dictators and ... well you get the idea.

In another later post I have listed some suggestions of criteria for assessing a good leader.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=184205&messageID=1883031

And no, I didn't mean a "cuddly" leader as Neil suggests, but an effective leader -- effective on his/her home front as well as in the world arena.

Some people have suggested Hitler was a good leader. No doubt he was for Germany up to a certain point in time but the havoc he wreaked in the global arena more than outweighs any good he may have done initially.

Among some of the leaders others have mentioned, I would agree strongly with regard to Thatcher and Gorbachev.

While some have suggested that Mandela didn't really do much I think that in his role of martyr rather than mover, he provided the inspiration that led to the end of apartheid.

by jardinier

Yes Max, I certainly would come forth to defend the honour and reputation of my country.

by maxwell edison

.
And can I assume that you could have continued that sentence as follows?

".....and I understand why you do as well."

by major kong

My nomination is for John F. Kennedy. I believe the start of his adminstration was shady at best. The last six or so months of his life is rather different. It appears he began to understand the reality of the seeming government within the government. (No this is not some sort of conspircy rant.) His ideas on the welfare culture were designed to help bring it to an end (at least as a form of intitled slavery.) He attempted to wrestle control of the economy and currency back from the elite banks. He saw the hopelessness of becoming embroiled in the Veitnam War and started a withdrawal of the US envolvement. He recognized there were unbelievably frightening people pulling many of the strings of the US policy, both domestic and foriegn. In short he was empowering the people to take back control of their government and lives. He spoke constantly about people taking responsibility for themselves and their destinies. I am aware there are many things to fault during his tenure, but I feel they could have been overlooked had he had the opportunity to see them to fruition.

I also like Dwight D. Eisenhower. If for no other reason than his farewell address upon leaving the presidency. If you have not read it I cannot recommend it strongly enough. He gave us (all citizens of the world) some very heavy things to consider. Many of his warnings still hold true today.

by swwbo

Seems to me that you are stereotyping all Americans. And disliking people because they are from a country you don't like is such a European thing - and look how peaceful Europe has been for the last century. Oh, gosh - they all get along eh?

Seems to me that you don't like Americans who don't agree with your politics, hon. That's the best thing about the USA - our Bill of Rights.
I can say what I want, when I want, where I want. I can own my guns without being dubbed a criminal. I can believe in whatever faith I choose. I don't have a monarch to pay for.

Australia is a beautiful country. Oddly, I have Australians as friends who love coming to the USA as often as they can. I guess you would not like their politics either.

by Member 25348569

Jardinier's an Aussie.

I assume from your subtle mention of monarchs that you think he's British. (Monarchs don't cost anywhere near as much as Presidents - especially bad ones - by the way. They have lots of palaces and other crap that attracts mug tourists.)

OK. He's not. I am. Have a pop at me if you think you're hard enough.

"Believe in whatever faith I choose" - Yes. And some of them are pretty weird! You can certainly keep your Southern Baptists and the like. I'm at very little risk of being called a "Servant of the Antichrist" in a bar in the UK. Happened to me in your country, though. (I am, by the way) ]:)

As for your guns - keep 'em as well. At least I can give someone the finger on the M25 and not risk getting shot. Can't do that on some of your freeways!

I can say what I want, where I want as well. Don't need a Bill of Rights. I will, however, not say what I think here.

Yet.

Have a nice day... :)

by maecuff

I am soooo sorry about that day when I called you a servent of the antichrist. I hadn't had my pills yet and I just spoke without thinking..

by montgomery gator

Since you suggested naming someone who was not from US, UK, Australia, or Canada, then I nominate Boris Yeltsin. Boris Yeltsin led Russia to freedom from Soviet tyranny, overthrowing the Communist dictatorship of Mikhail Gorbachev. He showed leadership and bravery when he stood up on that tank to resist the Soviet oppressors and lead his people to revolution. Russia was free for those few years that Yeltsin was president. Unfortunately, it seems that Vladimir Putin is returning Russia to totalitarianism.

Other leaders I would suggest are Lech Valesa of Poland and Vlacav Havel of the Czech Republic. They too, led their countries to freedom to throw off the yoke of Communism.

by Member 25348569

Really happened, by the way, in a bar in Arizona. I probably deserved it as I was in full "pisstake" mode at the time.

First trip outside Florida so I didn't properly understand the American love of guns at the time, else we might not have wound them up so much. It got quite heated when my Dad started drawing pentagrams in beer on the bar and muttering poems in Welsh (the National Anthem and songs about Llanelli Rugby Club - but they didn't know that).

Mae hen wlad fy nhadau yn annwyl i mi,
Gwlad beirdd a chantorion, enwogion o fri;
Ei gwrol ryfelwyr, gwladgarwyr tra m?d,
Tros ryddid gollasant eu gwaed.

Can sound quite sinister if you don't know what it means!

My Dad's where I inherited my tactful nature.

Neil :)