Discussion Locked

Who do you think were some of the best world leaders in the past 50 years?

0 helpful
122 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

122 replies

by montgomery gator

The Soviet Empire would have collapsed eventually, but Reagan hastened the collapse by aggressively supporting those who opposed Communist tyranny. Reagan also built up our military, made us strong after the weak Carter years, forcing the USSR to also try to build up their military. However, the USSR economy could not sustain the build up, and that hastened its collape.

As far as the "clandestine plan", I thought it worked great, and saw nothing illegal about it. Just because you disagree with it does not make it illegal. The plan provided arms to the Contra freedom fighters who overthrew the Sandinista tyrants in Nicaragua and brought freedom to that country. Reagan had to do that, since Congress did not have the cojones to support the freedom fighters in Central America. There was nothing illegal about it, despite what the liberal Democrats might try to claim.

Ronald Reagan was the greatest president of the USA in the 20th Century, although he did borrow a few ideas from other presidents: supply-side tax cuts from JFK, aggressively oppose communism from Truman, communicate well with the American people from FDR, free-market capitalism and deregulation from Calvin Coolidge. However, he combined these concepts, along with his optimism and leadership ability, to become a truly great president.

by absolutely

"...since Congress did not have the cojones to support the freedom fighters in Central America. There was nothing illegal about it, despite what the liberal Democrats might try to claim."

Nobody's opinion of who has cojones or who has none changes the facts that military support was not authorized by Congress, and that the support provided was made surreptitiously. If the action were legal, it would have been pursued in the proper channels.

"The Soviet Empire would have collapsed eventually, but Reagan hastened the collapse by aggressively supporting those who opposed Communist tyranny. Reagan also built up our military, made us strong after the weak Carter years, forcing the USSR to also try to build up their military. However, the USSR economy could not sustain the build up, and that hastened its collape."

Reagan also mis-judged the value of Islamic fundamentalists, and gave birth to the global terrorist threat that they now pose. He is stupider example of crapping in his descendants homes than even Nixon.

by montgomery gator

I guess we have to disagree about Ronald Reagan. However, I don't understand your dislike of him, since he stood for a lot of things I thought you stood for, like less regulation, lower taxes, and individualism. His support of the Contras was a stand for individualism against collectivism, since they were fighting against the Communist Sandinistas. I was all in favor with what the Reagan administration did with that, and consider Reagan and Oliver North to be American Heroes.

Again, just calling something illegal does not make it so. If it was, Reagan would have been impeached (but Congress, whose laws you say he supposedly violated, did not make any attempt to impeach Reagan), and Oliver North would have been convicted of criminal activity. But North was able to beat the trumped up charges against him, and is now a respected political commentator and news correspondent. The fact it was surreptitious did not make it illegal. It had to be surreptitious, since that is the nature of clandestine operations. The operation helped Nicaragua gain its freedom and become a democracy. We need people like Ronald Reagan and Oliver North.

by montgomery gator

John F Kennedy did have some good ideas. One you did not mention was that he lowered tax rates, especially the higher tax brackets. This is where Reagan got the idea for the supply-side tax cuts that boost the economy. JFK's worst idea was making Lyndon Johnson his vice-president.

Lyndon Johnson really screwed things up when he became president after JFK was shot. Johnson messed up the Vietnam War with his half-assed effort. He should have either withdrawn the USA from it completely, or send overwhelming force to bring North Vietnam to its knees, marching troops all the way to Hanoi. Johnson also messed up everything with his welfare give-away "Great Society", with the "entitlements" he created and/or expanded now the largest part of our budget and why it is so difficult to balance the budget now. If anyone even suggests cutting "entitlements", those on the dole and their friends in Congress throw a big hissy fit and claim Congress is "oppressing the poor." Instead, I say "entitlements" oppress the taxpayer. Lyndon Johnson was the worst president of the USA in the 20th century, with Carter 2nd worst, Clinton 3rd worst, and Harding 4th worst.

I would not be surprised if it turns out that Lyndon Johnson was behind the assassination of John F Kennedy so that he could sieze power.

by montgomery gator

Margaret Thatcher's childeren may not have turned out too well. Ronald Reagan had a similar problem, although none of his children got in trouble with the law like Mark Thatcher did. Reagan's oldest daughter Maureen was OK, she was a state legislator in California. But younger daughter Patti Davis and younger son Ron Jr. were big disappointments. Ron Jr. is now best known as a commentator at dog shows. Patti tried to get into acting, but did not do very well.

Ironically, the Reagan child that turned out the best is Mike Reagan, author and political commentator with a syndicated radio show. Ironic because he was adopted. If you saw the funeral of Ronald Reagan, Mike gave the best and most meaningful eulogy of the 3 surviving children (Maureen died a few years ago from cancer). The adopted kid inherited the skills of the "Great Communicator".

by swwbo

Nah, adopted children often take on the traits of their parents.

I, for example, have almost identical likes and dislikes as my dad. I think nurture is way more important that science gives it credit for these days.

by montgomery gator

Russia is primarily an Orthodox Christian nation, and they were the first country to go communist. The other countries in eastern Europe that went communist that are primarily Roman Catholic were forced into communism by Stalin after WWII.

I dont think North Korea was Roman Catholic before the commies took over. However, South Korea has a sizeable Roman Catholic population, althogh the Methodist Church is the largest, along with various other Christian denominations. And South Korea is definitely not communist.

by montgomery gator

But certainly not Mitterand!!

DeGaulle did his best to try to keep France relevant in the post WWII world. Mitterand only contributed to the decline of France. Then again, that might have been a good thing. :-)

by maecuff

Are fascinated with guns. My family never owned any type of gun when I was a kid. I've never owned a gun of any kind. Well, besides water guns, but they don't count.

Actually, I think your post was funny. People get their panties in a bunch so easily over things they don't understand.

by montgomery gator

Hitler was the leader of the National Socialist (or Nazi) party in Germany. Could it be that Oz admires Hitler because Hitler was a Socialist? Is Oz wearing "foggy goggles" about Hitler because of his socialist leanings?

by jck

In an overall concept...these are my answers:

Pope John Paul II - a man who cared and thought and did what he could to persuade mankind to love one another and work together

Mother Teresa - a woman who gave up everything to give to others.

Princess Diana of Wales - a woman who could have stayed behind the walls of a palace and lived the high-life, but instead chose to go see suffering peoples around the world and try to help them.

Jimmy Carter - a bad president politically, but a great leader and fine example of a man. Another person who still to this day still works to help the impoverished despite his celebrity and electoral achievements.

Sam Walton - a man who truly started out poor and worked his way up to being the richest man in the world through hard work.

Martin Luther King, Jr. - a man who strived to gain equivalency for not just people of his own race but all people, and chose to pursue it through understanding and cooperation, rather than indignation and division.

and finally...

the TR staff - anyone or group of people who could put up with all the nonsense that goes on here deserves to be granted at least "pseudo-sainthood"... :D

by absolutely

(1) I was too young to understand all of what was on the news during Reagan's presidency, but too old to have ever studied it as "history". Yet. I may spend some time doing that in the next few years. My impression of him so far does not impress me much. Less regulation seems like common sense to me, not cause to treat a person as a mythical figure. This opinion is subject to change.

(2) France gave support to the United States during our revolution. I don't believe it was quite as secretive as the US aid to the Contras, and I'm suspicious of it, especially because of the DEA's involvement in the same country and the rest of that region in the time since then.

(3) Less regulation, lower taxes and individualism are the things that I think he got right, at least partially. Unfortunately, he forgot all about individualism and less regulation when the subject of Nixon's stupid DEA arose. Economic experts know that regulation cannot reduce drug consumption substantially at any price, and increased funding for the DEA is also one of Reagan's legacies. It's still a money pit here and a destabilizing effect on fragile economies and political situations all over the world.

by jamesrl

I would have to disagree. It was Gorbachev who had the vision to take the Soviet state to democracy, through a slow and steady set of reforms. If it was not for the reforms of Gorbachev, Yeltsin would not have been elected in free elections. Even Andropov before Gorbachev was reform minded.

Gorbachev retired and Yeltsin became president and that triggered the revolt by the military that Yeltsin put down. In putting down the revolt he shut down free press and opposition parties. http://www.guardian.co.uk/russia/article/0,2763,1055272,00.html It was Yeltsin's ban on the communist party that helped trigger the revolt.

I agree with Lech Valesa, Vlacav Havel and frankly all the leaders who overcame military or other dictatorships without violence. And Mandela makes it in in my books because apartheid ended without serious bloodshed, and because the reconciliation that has taken place - but I know this won't be popular, De Klerk, even though he led a racist gov't, helped end apartheid without violent and deserves some mention.

James

by jamesrl

Hundreds of WWII books. By Kershaw, Manchester, D'este, Terkel, Ambrose, Hastings, Deighton, JFK, Keegan and many many many others. I have read books by Americans, Canadians, Brits and Germans.

The syphilus theory is just that, a theory that is disputed and in no way proven. Like the theory that Caligula had lead poisoning, there is no way to prove it short of conclusive medical records that do not exist.

James

by absolutely

Hitler doesn't qualify as the [b]best[/b] world leader because he died slightly too early! If it wasn't for that, he's be a contender!

by jamesrl

In China, Roman Catholics were persecuted by Communists even before Mao succeeded in taking over.

And in Vietnam the Roman Catholics were too closely identified with the French colonists - viewed as collaborators by the VC whether they were or not. The corrupt south vietnemese governments had a much higher proportion of RCs than the population at large.

Many of the immolations were in protest of the corrupt South Vietnamese gov't, not about Catholicism.

James

by swwbo

And I brought up monarchs because Australia remains part of the Commonwealth, so Australians still have a monarch of sorts.

What I don't understand is - if things are really as he claims - my husband and I are such good friends with 3 different Australian families - one family attended our wedding.

by swwbo

In that case, I disagree with your points 2,3,4 and 5.

A national leader leads a nation - with the great majority of the world's nations being led by misogynistic dictators, I would prefer to have a leader that does *not* make nice nice with the leaders of those countries.

by em dubyah

Hitler a clever man? By comparison to whom or what? He was a maniac AND a murderer!

I love how the dumocrats always...ALWAYS have to compare Hiter with Bush.

Get a clue, get a grip gang!!!!

I swear this makes me want to throw furniture!!!!

by swwbo

How on earth does Catholicism come into this discussion?

And what makes you think that China or Russia was Catholic?

Russia - Russian Orthodox

China - anything but Christianity.

This discussion is closed to new replies.