Discussion Locked

Who do you trust, [i]Big Oil[/i] or [i]Big Carbon[/i]?

0 helpful
166 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

166 replies

by tonythetiger

It came to me during a discussion about taxes, and someone cried out the "But what about the children?" remark.

It applies to a lot of situations... Welfare, Disaster relief, Global Warming, and probably many others.

Some people don't want do DO anything! They'd rather pay for it to be done, just so long as they don't have to see it. They don't have enough money themselves to make the "problem" go away, so they propose raising taxes (of course, the fact that that has never, and will never solve the problem is irrelevant. It will, however, make them feel like they've "earned" the right to no longer be bothered with it (Kinda like "I gave at the office.")

While talking with an acquaintance about the trials and tribulations I had dealing with "social services" as it relates to one parent's treatment of her children, she said "I don't even understand why you'd [b]know[/b] people like that." I retorted "People with that attitude are the reason there [b]are[/b] people like that. Those children don't need more money so their mother can buy more drugs, those children need to be picked up and loved, and taken away from that environment!"

She got a little pissed and walked off in a huff. GOOD!

Another situation happenned right after Katrina. A couple of prominent people in town called for a meeting. It soon became clear that all they were interested in is seeing how much money they could take credit for "collecting". When she asked my wife and I what we could give, I replied, "We have three spare bedrooms and a big dining table." She quickly moved on to the next person. Nobody there would look me in the eye.

I would like to be able to say that all of those people I talked to were liberals or Democrats, but that would be decieving you. There are a lot of my Republican acquaintences who feel this way too, which is itronic, since in a way, they've become just as lazy and thankless as those they used to bitch about.

One lady got mad, and others couldn't look at me, as I said, GOOD! They need to feel (guilt and shame would be a good start), then they need to DO (something with your hands... or something with your mind... something that proves that your human, not some automatic payroll deduction, anyone can do that.). THAT, is the only thing that's going to fix any of our problems!

(I wish to apologize for any gramatical or spelling errors, improper syntax, or anything that just doesn't flow smoothly... You'll get that a lot from a half-Scottish, half-Irish, half-Maimi Indian, and half-redneck guy with ADD :) )

by ontheropes

In his State of the Union address, Bush set a goal of saving 8.5 billion gallons of gasoline annually by 2017.
"We need to reform and modernize fuel economy standards for cars the way we did for light trucks - and conserve up to 8.5 billion more gallons of gasoline by 2017," Bush said.
Though he urged Congress not to legislate a specific number, Bush said he would like to seen improved mileage on passenger cars for the 2010 model year and for light trucks in the 2012 model year. He said the details should be left to the secretary of transportation.

Ok. Fine. What mileage ?improvements? make the most sense?

Depending upon where you look the number of gallons of diesel fuel consumed varies.
From:http://www.greencarcongress.com/2006/11/study_improveme.html

The calculation of one billion gallons is based on the Census Bureau?s 2002 Vehicle Inventory and Use Survey (VIUS). It assumes 750,000 tractor/van semi-trailer combination-unit trucks in operation traveling a total of 60,101 million miles. A 10% improvement in average fuel economy from 5.5 mpg to 6.05 mpg results in saving approximately 993.4 million gallons of fuel per year.

It's been several years since I began driving a so-called ?big-truck? or lorry for our overseas friends. It wasn't long before I realized that there would be great benefit to increasing diesel fueled truck mileage.
I don't know how many millions have been spent in researching diesel fuel mileage improvements but if even a small mileage increase of 10% could possibly save 1,000,000,000 gallons it seems that perhaps the millions spent increasing gasoline engine mileage and the creation of the CAFE laws and monitoring compliance was something of a wasted effort.

The average gas mileage for new vehicles sold in the United States was 23.1 miles per gallon in 1980 and 24.7 in 2004.

Wait... What???

The CAFE laws have obviously done a fine job. I'm sure the soon-to-be forthcoming ?carbon credit? businesses and transactions will do as much to improve overall fuel efficiency.

Any diesel engine manufacturer who produced a 500HP Class 8 diesel engine that consistently gets 7 mpg while under a load of 80,000 pounds would have a winning product.

Is it possible?

I don't know.

I do know that biodiesel may be a good alternative fuel. Chinese scientists succeeded in breeding rapeseed, for use in biodiesel, with a record high oil content (54.72 percent), nearly two percentage points higher than the previously reported highest variety.

Dynamotive Industries has developed a process called fast pyrolysis, they convert forestry waste products and sugar bagasse into a #2 fuel oil that is a replacement for diesel.

Heh heh, I said, ?bagasse?.

This new product is CO2 neutral with only trace amounts of sulfur. They have started their first commercial shipments this year and are licensing the technology worldwide as we speak.

It's my opinion that corn produced for ethanol production is a waste of time, money and effort.
http://tinyurl.com/2wopdk

by jamesrl

Everyone seems to want a magic bullet.

But if we want something more short term and achievable, say a 10% reduction, we could with some effort achieve it.

For many, just keeping the car in better shape, making sure the tire pressure isn't too low, having a good air filter, and keeping the car tuned up makes a difference.

Adjusting your driving habits; not warming up the car too long, shutting down the engine when waiting for extended periods, not jackrabbiting away when you finally get the green - this can all impact your mileage.

And of course getting a smaller vehicle when yuo got to replace your current one.

Taking transit when its feasble.

Making more efficient use of your travelling time - combining trips.

Think if you did all that you could save 10% - sure you can.

James

by danlm

Walk to work if you can(yes max, I seen your reply). Walk to the corner store if it's close enough. And I am as guilty of that one as much as anyone, just jumping in the car and going to the corner store. It's called laziness.

I use to walk everywhere, hell I didn't start driving till I was 30. Now I can't get off my fat a$$ to do twit.

Dan

by des949penn

I fear that most people don't have either the motivation or the self-discipline to incorporate that sort of thinking into daily life.

The usual grousing over the recent $.60/gallon rise in the price of fuel (just in time for the summer vacation/cruising season) is going on at work. But no one seems to understand that the demand for fuel for those activites is more elastic than that portion of the demand driven by contractors, etc, and other seasonal businesses which require nearly the same amount of fuel at any price, and can pass the cost on to the consumer.

The same rules apply to commercial trucking, the typical fleet manager or owner-operator knows the requirements of his operation, and is not going to splurge on an "18-wheeled Cadillac". Any dressing up of the vehicle is for cosmetic purposes only.

The principal economic trend I have noticed since returning to employment in the motor-carrier industry is a decline in the longest hauls for the least-valuable freight. A move is underway to develop larger central cold-storage facilities near the traditional warehouse centers of Albany, Harrisburg and Richmond. Produce traffic can then be moved in larger "unit train" shipments and broken up for distribution along the Eastern Seaboard, a vast improvement over the unreliable scheduling of individual carload shipments.

But for an overnight delivery of a mixed load of retail merchandise from a distribution center to your local store, the tractor/semitrailer will remain dominant, and most of the waste in this area has already been eliminated.

by danlm

http://www.myninjaplease.com/green/?p=495

It's where they use magnesium pellets and water to produce hydrogen. I could have swore I seen an article about GM and this also. But I can't find it right now. It's an effort to solve the distribution issue of hydrogen.

Chuckle, yea I know. Magnesium and Hydrogen. Can you say Hindenburg? It's an interesting concept though

Dan

by av .

But really, if a monorail, and I'm no expert on monorails, could reduce the truck traffic for freight that would reduce greenhouse gases. That would be a good thing.

Sure, we're still paying anyway, but wouldn't it be better for the environment, not to mention the traffic?

AV

by hal 9000

All you are doing is moving the source of pollution to a different spot and if anything making the current level of Pollution slightly worse because of the Drops experienced in the long Travel lines required to distribute the electricity.

Maybe Douglas Adams was right all those years ago when he was writing the scripts for Dr Who and had the Good Doctor insist that Humans Reliance on Fossil Fuels is wasteful and amusing and they they would never achieve anything till they started to use Hydrogen as a clean renewable fuel source without any adverse side effects. Currently I don't think that we have the available technology to incorporate this technology yet but it's getting there.

Col

by maxwell edison

I don't do it with any grand illusion that I'm saving the planet, or even conserving energy, but rather to exert my own energy in my never-ending battle with the bulge of middle age. Saving a few gallons and a few dollars is bonus. I will say this, however, I have intentionally structured my life as such so that a long commute is not part of my routine. The fact that I am within walking distance to not only work, but even stores and restaurants, was not by accident. My day-to-day life is (could be) pretty much confined to about a two mile radius. (I save my fuel consumption and planet destroying activities for when I load my gas guzzling pickup full of camping gear and head to the mountains! Or drive half-way across the country. Or.....)

by danlm

I didn't mean it as you was trying to save the world or anything Max. I think it was more of an observation about how so many people wouldn't think of doing that, even though they know it's better for their health. The saving of energy is just a side benefit from it.

Now that I think about this, I also was less stressed when I walked more. I don't know if it was just the ability to look around and enjoy the view instead of screaming out the window at the idiot that cut me off. Or if just the exercise had a calming affect in itself.

Dan

by maxwell edison

I wouldn't want anyone to think I want to save the planet, or anything like that. I have an image to uphold, you know -- as one who's greedy and selfish, destroys the planet, wants to starve children and impoverish old people, wishes homeless people to die on the streets, loves polluted air and poisoned water, and all that stuff.

by hal 9000

Absolutely no interest in AU Politics let alone other countries politics unless there is something that is said and reported that I can not help but laugh at. I just try to ignore them all completely no matter who they are.

I really wanted to know who was responsible in the US for the [b]Reds Under The Beds Crap![/b] Over here it was Menzies a Conservative Prime Minister and as I read your post I gathered that it was some Daemon-crat who was responsible for that in the US. But don't bother I'll look it up some time when I'm not busy if I remember to. :D

Col

by hal 9000

Second serious thing that I've posted here so Abs had better get ready to eat his hat this time. :(

Do you know why you feel so much better after a brisk walk?

It's because the body releases endorphins which act as pain killers and mood enhancers in the body and while these are short lived substances there have been many Medical Drugs modelled on the way that these work most of all the Opiates fall into the catagory.

So Max unfortunately your reputation has been ruined as you are getting [b]High[/b] by walking. Doesn't matter that this is a natural reaction of exercise it's just a fact of life so as you are a self confessed Addict you'll need to undergo the 12 step program to stop you exercising and getting High on the experience.

But don't worry I'll soon have you back to being the lazy slob sitting in their petrol guzzling motor vehicle that sitting at a set of street lights at idol you can watch the fuel gauge drop toward empty when you only filled the thing up 30 seconds ago. :D

Don't worry I'll have you back to your old image of [i]as one who's greedy and selfish, destroys the planet, wants to starve children and impoverish old people, wishes homeless people to die on the streets, loves polluted air and poisoned water, and all that stuff[/i] in no time at all. :p

I'll even throw in chasing street people around attempting to run then down if you like and you can drive past all the bike riders and knock them off their bikes as you tool around the place without a care in the world. Sounds good doesn't it? :^0

I'll even see if I can manage to throw in a Toorack Tractor if you like that sort of thing.

http://tinyurl.com/8osdd

Sorry but Jeeps are not big over here so that's the best that I can offer complete with Nudge Bars, Roof Racks, Side Bars, Extended Fuel Tanks [i] these look like a 44 gallon drum strapped to each side[/i] and God only knows what else.

But personally I prefer my VW Beetle on the last motor that I had in it I could get 8 Miles Per Imperial Gallon not one of those small US Gallons. This motor I don't expect to get that much Gas Mileage out of as I'm using much more Valve Overlap so I'm sure that the cylinders are really filled so it runs better. I don't care if the 20 cars behind me can run of the fuel fumes that I'm pumping out the exhaust pipe and not notice any performance difference. I've even perverted by daughters boyfriend away from Yank Tanks as he's now looking for a Beetle to play with and isn't buying any more Vintage T Birds. He's still unable to believe that I could get so much performance out of a little engine and he was impressed that the speedio actually acted like a Tacho. :0

Col

by ontheropes

and if you're already doing those things how do you shave off another 10%?

In the link I posted, no mention was made of the amount of extra weight the aerodynamic ?improvements? add to the GVW. As you likely know every effort is made to lighten a semi-tractor because of load weight restrictions. Some people can easily bend a semi-tractor's flimsy chromed-steel front bumper with their bare hands.

Weight is an issue. I think Volvo makes a better power unit than Freightliner but an owner-operator with a Volvo won't be able to take some loads because the tractor is (I recall) a couple of thousand pounds heavier. One of the first things I did when I had my Freightliner Century was to strip the fiberglass covers from the sides. Although they weren't 200 pounds total there were several times when I could still only legally carry a half-load of fuel (or less) because some customers/shippers make use of all of the legal load limit. Besides the weight fiberglass adds they're just one more costly item to replace when you crunch them against something in a blind spot

There's another fuel-related problem for OTR drivers, that being idle time. When parked for sleep, most drivers don't use the computerized controller to turn their trucks off and on according to battery charge and comfort level of the interior; it wakes them up every time it starts the truck. So, when a driver isn't rolling his truck engine is still running, sometimes 24/7. It's definitely not as fuel-efficient as an available add-on diesel generator but that adds weight and extra costs too.

I think that a lot more freight is being shipped long-distance by rail for local delivery. I live within sight of a railroad track and see entire train loads of nothing but semi-trailers every day of the week. That's a good thing.

I've always thought that it would make sense for the largest cities to have drop yards where an OTR driver could leave a trailer for a local driver to deliver, something similar to the central cold-storage facilities you mention. It would take a lot of logistics but I believe it could be done efficiently and save fuel too.

by ontheropes

I should sell WWJB, What Would Jesus Bomb, bumper stickers.

Edited by me, for you, free of charge.

by f4a6pilot

We have higher well head pressures than in 1950... We should pump Mid West oil not use Mid East oil...

by absolutely

I got high on endorphines (you still can't spell worth sh1t, even if you are occasionally right, Col) so the flavor of my hat wasn't that bad.

by f4a6pilot

Anybody's government.

All we should want is to be defended and left alone.

Power corrupts, absolute power...

A buraucracy exists to perpetuate itself...
(corrected for typo)

by hal 9000

We need a Live Web Cam Feed and prior notification to be sure that you are not stretching the truth even a little bit. :0

Col

by Member 25348569

Don't misquote to a pedant!

Power [b]tends[/b] to corrupt; absolute power corrupts absolutely. Lord Acton

Anyway.

The charge that you appear to be making is that the UK government has suborned the country's main meteorological and climatological centre for the purposes of manipulating the political environment for the purpose of raising taxes and concentrating their power in other ways.

However.

If The Met Office has been manipulated in this way and there has been no major complaint from British scientists in climate-related subjects (and there hasn't), this would generally tend to suggest that either the UK scientific establishment is in on the conspiracy or the media has been similarly corrupted to toe the government line and suppress dissenters or the Met Office scientists just happen to believe that significant climate change due to human activity is likely.

So?

I do not intend to speak for the people in the US political and scientific arenas as they are, I reckon, radically different in many ways but I will just say that I do not believe that our politicians are that clever or our scientists are that stupid. There are also sufficient jornalists with at least some integrity so that chicanery of the order that you are suggesting would not remain hidden for ever.

Neil

by Member 25348569

I have no reason [b]not[/b] to believe it. The page that I referenced is probably the simplest collection from a (to me) reliable source of simple science covering the main questions posted by pro- and anti-.

I've followed quite a lot of this further and I haven't found too much to detract from the Hadley Centre's reports. What their reports do not do is suggest that the Gulf Stream will shut down or Greenland ice will melt in five years or any of the Gore frighteners.

I [b]am[/b] much less happy with some of the emotive language that now seems to be coming from the activists and I do worry that we will be railroaded by these same activists into measures that are inappropriate and just plain stupid. My big fear is that the treatment will be worse than the disease and there I do agree with you more than you might imagine and I would care to admit in public.

Neil :D

"Raindrops keep falling on my head..."

by absolutely

Not only am I not stretching the truth, I'm not even touching the truth! Better to leave it alone entirely than to stretch it by accident. Instead, I'm inventing it all as I go, except for what I extract from the [b]Millenium Year Application Software System![/b] I thought you knew. Now, please see about that airlock.
:D
http://www.ugcs.caltech.edu/~karlh/fun/millenium.html

by absolutely

"When did anybody start thinking Government was right? Anybody's government."

Those who hold that opinion do not do so as the result of thinking, but as the result of their failure to think.

by absolutely

The skeptic cannot be dismissed quite so easily as you are trying to do, with just the word "conspiracy". You have argued with me on religion and you know that conspiracy is unnecessary where there are shared assumptions.

by hal 9000

I'll wait till you are not expecting it and pop open an airlock as you are passing by. :D

Hell I may even blow a hatch when you are in one of the storage bays so you don't stand a chance of getting out of Discovery alive unless of course you are one of the few than can survive W.O.O. for several days at a time as Mr Flibble likes this form of Punishment. :

OH BTW [b]W.O.O.[/b] means With Out Oxygen. And Mr Flibble is a slightly out of control Penguin who likes getting his own way straight from Red Dwarf. :^0

Col

by maxwell edison

[i]Okay, I now have TWO plans: Start a Carbon Credit company; and then invest ALL my profits in Archer Daniels Midland! If we start burning our food, those prices will skyrocket! ..... And let's not overlook beef and hog futures. A lot of those critters are corn-fed, you know. And I should, after all, diversify my investment portfolio. (Didn't Hillary once 10x her money buying cattle futures? Man, the price of corn-fed beef will skyrocket!) [/i]

http://business.timesonline.co.uk/tol/business/industry_sectors/consumer_goods/article1642746.ece

by jamesrl

Out of yanking your chain....

I anticipated that you had read it, even if I hadn't recalled seeing the post.

The impact in Mexico is much higher. Beef in US and Canada may go up a few percent, but beef prices have been lower historic highs, so it won't have a huge impact. Tortillas will be twice as much as usual.

I oppose these subsidies too, both in my country and other countries, as the law of unintended consequences applies. Rice and Sugar in the US, many items in Europe are all heavily subsidized. In Canada, we have fewer subsidies, but more marketing boards, which while not as bad as subsidies, still stifle the market and create anomolies. The current Conservative government is trying to dismantle the Canadian wheat board, which is the "holy grail" of these things here. I support the effort.

If the government wants to tax ethanol buyers less than gasoline buyers, that can do what they want to do more effectively than subsidies.

My federal government also introduced subsidies for Fuel efficient cars and financial penaties for gas hogs.

But the problem with that concept is that it only applies to new vehicles (and many people buy used), and it does nothing to encourage people not buying cars this year (the majority me thinks) to do something now to use less gas.

In general, I don't think governments should provide $$ to companies, and should be very careful about selective tax cuts(same effect). I include farmers in that, and I do know many farmers who agree.

James

by deepsand

As long as you insist on blind obeisance to the belief that policy trumps facts, you will continue to be part of the problem.

You would better put your intellect & energy to use by setting aside your biases, seeking first the factual truths, and only then choosing a course of action.

by deepsand

What I [i]did[/i] say is that such holds for all, not just those on one side of an issue.

by Former member

We just have to rethink a few things.
For example, instead of using oceanic Oil rigs to pipe fossil fuel to land for processing and burning, why not use them as power generators, and distribute electricity from them, utilizing wind, wave movement, and hydrogen collection and burning? (Distance might be an issue with respect to distribution, not sure...)

I think at this point we are pretty Darn close technology-wise, are main problem now is our overabundance of tunnel-vision, and a#$-holiness.

But then, maybe that is what I get for thinking.

by f4a6pilot

It's not like Al Gore was a glue sniffing, pot smoking guy in Vietnam who had a whole squad of Marines to escort him all over SE Asia rather than carry the fight to the enemy...

And likewise Kofi Anon, It isn't like he was one of those lying UN officials who were involved in the oil for food scandal up to their lying necks.

by f4a6pilot

I dislike, and personlly know Al Gore. I know the Marines who escorted him through SE Asia...

I despise Kofia Anon, and his policies.

It was supposed to show stupidity of trusting or believing Gore,Anon, etc...

by deepsand

Carbon is a pre-requisite for hydrocarbons, and that petroleum is a collection of hydrocarbons, and that combustion of hydrocarbons yields, among other things, CO & CO2, there exists a very definite circularity.

by absolutely

With all his economic data, maxwell edison must have observed, as I know I have, that imposed market externalities tend to favor existing major concerns by erecting prohibitive barriers to entering their markets. Those barriers tend to exceed any "harm" done to the major players, with a few notable historical exceptions, which are commonly misinterpreted as evidence of generally "beneficial", to society, effects of imposition of such externalities.

by deepsand

in this case, having not been discounted by the other observer.

Experience here evidences a tendency by many to either overlook the Law of Unintended Consequences, or believe that their desired course of action is somehow immune to it.

by absolutely

the dependence of certain policies to certain alleged facts is itself a fact, and worthy of discussion for that reason.

by f4a6pilot

On the other planets of the Solar systems shows that there is warming, but the biomass called humanity is approximately .0000000001% of the mass of this planet. There seems to be less than %of error difference to the rate of change from Earth to Venus, Earth to Mars, Earth to Jupiter. Therefore, I consider it the height of arrogance to blame the warming on Humanity.

If we set off enough Nuclear weapons that would put enough Dust into the air, we could effect cooling... But I think the cure is much worse than the disease.

I also think that the Gores, Bonos, and other globe trotters, who fly in private jets and ride in hybrid limos should be regarded with the scorn they deserve. Their flights burn more fuel daily than I will in my life...

They want me to cut back, when they could fly one time first class and do more to save the environment that I could by never using a drop of petroleum based fuel in my life...

by deepsand

I'd thought that the "trust but verify" body would have made that clear.

Perhaps I should have written it as "trust but [b]verify[/b."

by deepsand

Where is the data to support the claim of the syncrocity of temperatures?

How was this data collected? Over how long a time period?

Considering that we've yet to set foot on any other planet, to place probes on the surfaces of any but Mars, and have gathered but meager data from Mars, I should be quite surprised that anyone could substantiate said claim.

by absolutely

Cute!

In the popular context of the phrase, "Big Oil" means companies as an interest group and/or political lobby. That suggests strongly to me that maxwell intended the phrase "Big Carbon" to mean the opposing political interest. You reply with chemical analysis! No wonder maxwell doesn't post very long replies to you very often!

:)

by deepsand

With all the sh!t that comes out of DC, it's got to be a major source of methane.

by f4a6pilot

before physical probes landed we (humans) have been measuring the albedo, frequency emission, and since the 16th century... (Copernicus had this as a life's study. He was just another stupid Polack...)

We found that our estimates of moon and mars temperatures were basically bang on for dark side and lit side. On the moon it was almost a 400 degree swing. That is why we know surface temperature on Venus is about 600 degrees and atmospheric pressure so many atmospheres on Jupiter... We have inferential data.

That is how we have found planets in other galaxies which do not have high enough albedo to reflect light. Radio waves wouldn't get there for another couple of centuries. Gravitational references as well as dark and visible wavelength measurement let us know what is really there.

Since I know the curricula you studied at Annapolis, You were just too lazy to bother to explain this to the great unwashed...

Shame on you, and shame on me for biting on your baited hook...

by deepsand

it seems that I've actually caught something!

Those who dismiss GW as unfounded, do so by way of dismissing that which you refer to as [i]inferential[/i] data. But, as I've elsewhere pointed out, what's good for the goose is good for the gander; i.e., GW's detractors cannot use such as both a means to rebut GW [u]and[/u] as support for their counter-claims.

by deepsand

following the principle of form follows function, the issue of policy follows the finding of facts; therefore, absent an agreement as to the facts, to debate policy is an exercise in futility.

by absolutely

I see the policy debate as having feedback characteristics on the factual debate, analogous to those of the greenhouse gases on temperature. I speak accordingly sometimes, ignoring the fact that the former is a human process wherein forms follow the various functions of those employing them, while the latter is a strictly mechanistic process wherein form is strictly dictated by empirical observation of function.

by deepsand

Tonight's the Finals of the Scripps National Spelling Bee, and I need to be at my best.

This discussion is closed to new replies.