Discussion Locked

Who is (was) the best guitarist ?

0 helpful
212 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I've been in this raging debate on another mesage/chat board about who was (is) the best guitarist.

For reference, I cited these sources:

http://www.digitaldreamdoor.com/pages/best_newguitar.html

http://guitar.about.com/library/bl100greatest.htm

http://www.rollingstone.com/news/story/5937559/the_100_greatest_guitarists_of_all_time/

and this new kid:

http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewprofile&friendid=59292432

My take?

Eddie Van Halen, Eric Clapton, and Jimi Hendrix.

Now, since everyone here at TR are an Eclectic lot, I'm wondering what you think about it.

Ironically, I view an Excellent Guitarist on the same level as a Gifted Tech. The tech that intutively understands the problems, the general goal, and the means to achieve the purest and best way to achieve the goal.

For criterea, I present the following :
Style, technique, and creativity. Anyone can mimic another's work. Anyone can duplicate (to some extent) another's style. But creativity is the crux.

Now, excuse me while I go listen to "Layla", Eruption", and "Voodoo Child".

update: edited to add vid of the new kid

212 replies

by mjd420nova

Jimi Hendrix is one of the top three, But among the living I really like Carlos Santana. Eric has his rightful place, but is more of a writer I feel, than a performer.

by mjwx

Dave Grohl - Foo Fighters. The best guitarist still touring.

Slash - GNR.

Kirk Hammet - Metalica.

Kirt Cobain - Nirvana.

Robbie Krieger - The Doors.

Really hard to limit myself to five. I'm younger than the average poster (I'm guessing) at 23 these are the guitarists I grew up listening too. the people who inspired me to (at the age of 23) to buy a guitar and learn how to play.

Listening to "Everlong" "November Rain" "Fade to Black" "Heart Shaped Box" and "People are Strange"

by maxwell edison

....quite some time ago, who he would like to always have as a session gutarist. His answer might surprise you. Chet Atkins. The guy was amazing.

by maecuff

Jimi Hendrix, Eric Clapton, Stevie Ray Vaughan and Robert Johnson (who reportedly sold his soul to the devil for his talents)

by tryten

Just about any blue player can be listed in my top 5, But these 5 are listed as my number 1
1. Muddy Waters
T-Bone Walker
Magic Sam
Blind Willie Johnson
Billy Gibbons
2. Stevie Ray Vaughan
3. Lance Abbott (Dimebag Darrell)
4. Jeff Hanneman
5. Zakk Wylde

by omnifice

Glad someone remembered Billy Gibbons (my favorite)...and Muddy Waters. Add to that Mark Knopfler. Joe Satriani is great too.

Cheers!

by obviator

But my top 5 are:
Leo Kottke - Got booted from their "bests" by Guitar Player magazine in about '75 for winning too many times
Doc Watson - Who ever heard of playing fiddle tunes on a guitar?
Tony Rice - quick, clean, and inventive
Django Reinhardt - A two fingered master!
Stevie Ray - What else needs be said?
i started listening to almost all acoustic music in the mid-70's after realizing that some of these guys were as good as any electric guy and all that was between them and the mic was air, no fancy foot pedals, etc.

by gaijinit

1. Leo Kottke is just amazing.
2. Nobody has ever been as smooth or exciting as Django Reinhardt.
3. My personal favorite of all time? John McLaughlin. Knocked my socks off when I first heard his early East-Indian influenced electric jazz on the album "Birds of Fire" in 1973. His later acoustic work shows how truly great he is. I like Santana when he slows down, but on the album "Love, Devotion, & Surrender" with McLaughlin, while reaching for those high notes at a frantic pace, Carlos just didn't have a chance.
4. Okay, a rocker. Johny Winter. If you want to hear REAL Texas blues rock, this is it.
5. The best for last - Andre Segovia, the ultimate classical Spanish guitar vituoso.
5.

by x-marcap

For classical Guitar plying, Phil Keagy is amazing. He is as good as the "Legend of Guitar" 90 year old pickers with his amputated finger.
I didn't bother to read the first post as my younger days were spent playing Guitar and trombone when I wasn't flying something. I finally got curious to look at the lists that were made up. Phil Keagy is a master on the guitar, but he was not given the level of exposure the others on the list were given. The reason he had limited exposure is that he was a Christian artist. He did make only one of the lists at 16, and that proved to me that the people who put the information together weren't pickers...

For Rock & Roll Jimi Hendrix, and I really like Ted Nugent.

For County Chet Atkins & Roy Clark tie. Clark is also the best I've heard on a banjo.

For Bass Guitar Stanley Clark has no peers.

I have and play a Les Paul Blond that looks like the one Roy Clark played in the early '70s. In 20 years a guy named George Dean may be up there...

If you want to hear the best Guitar Christmas music get Merry Axemas.

by jdclyde

there is a follow up CD to the Axemas?

I have and love the first, but haven't had a chance to get the second yet.

Anyone got a review on it they would like to give?

by x-marcap

I'll dig through my collection of Christmas music, if I don't find it I'll ask Jr...

I don't know names of Mannheim Steamroller CDs either, and love them too.

by sitizn wille

I would have to say...

1. SRV
2. Dimebag Darrel
3. Jimmy Hendrix
4.John 5, This guy is amazing, a wide range of talents from hard rock to bluegrass style, all mixed togather.
5.Stevie Via

Hard to pick just 5....

by thefrown

Richie Blackmore (Deep Purple)
Michael Schenker (UFO - Strangers in the Night is still the best live album ever cut)
Rory Gallagher

Ooooh I could go on; think I'll have to break out "Machine Head" when I get home ...

by dmambo

I'm no musician, but for sheer listening enjoyment, John Entwistle is my hands-down favorite. I absolutely can not believe that anyone could move his fingers so fast and stil make it music and not noise. RIP.

by jdclyde

yes, HAMM is killer.

But if we start talking Bass, no one can DARE not include Billy Sheehan in the top ten.

When he and Vai did the solo for the Eat em and smile tour..... goose bumps!

To get both go here

http://bx3tour.com/main.html

There was the G3 tour, now there is the Bx3 tour! Sweet!

by leee

I'm shocked - SHOCKED! - no one mentioned Pete Townshend.

I also love Robbie Robertson.

by jamesrl

Mark Knofler....

I've seen Dire Straits and the Who live a few times. Been to 2 separate Who farewell tour events.

There are so many.

Personally many of the greatest players were session musicians, see "Standing in the Shadows of Motown".

Terry Kath from Chicago. (Listen to 25 or 6 to 4)

Buddy Guy or BB King?

James

by jamesrl

There is Jeff Healy.

Of course thats a personal one, I've met him, he was a friend of my wife's. I don't know many people with the cajones to cover Clapton, but he pulls it off.

James

by x-marcap

Townsend really wasn't quick, and not clean. His fingerings are sloppy...

If you can't read & play music, and I don't mean chord charts, then you are an idiot savant, not a guitar player... You make noise creatively, but aren't worth mentioning with more serious artists.

by jdclyde

A man that is not accused of sounding like anyone else.

A man that is VERY creative and not afraid to do something in different directions. His "Flexible" CD he put out himself because most of the work is way out there and big lables didn't want to touch it "as is".

Have seen him several times live, both touring on his own and a few times for the G3 tour. He is always graceful to the other musicians on stage and often takes a back stage to them to give everyone a chance to shine. His most memerable quote was "The best thing about being Steve Vai is I get to jam with great musicians like these!"

He plays a wide range of music, from his early days of being listed as "Strat abuse" for Frank Zappa, playing with David Lee Roth when he first went solo, the time with White Snake, his solo work (which I have all of) and even playing Blues in the movie "CrossRoads".

He can play things that are very beautiful, and others that just make your jaw drop.

He can stand beside ANY guitar great, from any time.

by jdclyde

Just didn't think it was the most relevent parts to add, as people don't want the entire life story.

Who the teacher is does not make you who you are, but as far as teachers do go, he couldn't have chosen better.

Hammet was also a student.

Does anyone remember Vai playing the star spangle banner for the "rock and jock" softball game back in the late 80's? Can you say OMG?

by wyzard

Joe Satriani said in an interview one that Steve Vai was the best guitarist he's ever seen and that even though Satriani was his teacher, he said that Vai has surpassed him and can go places he can't reach. Course, these guys are all pretty humble when talking about eachother. :)
On that note, i'll toss out my faves. Steve Vai, Joe Satriani, Etic Johnson, Yngwie Malmsteen...man, there are so many but these go well with my musical tastes. There are so many more styles.

by btljooz

has had a LOT of students. He's a GREAT innovator, but not quuuuuite like Hendrix. When we lost him we lost all that could have come NEXT!!! Just imagine what Hendrix could have continued... it's UN-imaginable!!!:)

by jdclyde

was that he was so wasted all the time, that he wasn't aware that humans can't do what he was doing.

It was like in a Road Runner cartoon. One day he looked down....

Satriani is a GREAT player. I don't give him as high of marks on the originality/creativity scale as Vai. I will still go see either any/every time they come in the area, and I take my twin boys with me and they LOVE it.

Thing One went with me to one, and it was his favorite concert yet. Dream Theater, Satriani, Kings X. my boys (age 12 at the time) was hanging on ever note played. Took them both to the G3 tour with Yngwie. A good time had by all.
[i]
(Thing One and Thing Two are my twin boys) B-)

by mickster269

I have a CD of his made in 1990. It's called "Still got the Blues".

I haven't seen anything since then from him here in the States. Anyone in Europe hear of him?

by thefrown

Used to be in Thin Lizzy. Whilst on the subject, the best bass player for total charisma and presence on stage has to be the late great Phil Lynott.

by leee

I remember that one song - came out when I was in college. Oddly enough, one station in that town still plays it.

by kiwilinz

has a huge collection of albums available, some very recent, some compilations and "Best Of" releases.
Visit http://www.vh1.com/artists/az/moore_gary/albums.jhtml for info and availability on around 60 albums in total, plus singles and videos.

"Ballads & Blues" 1982-1994 is one I have and is a superb album. Since this discussion started I have been playing it in my car and the range of guitar work including some beautiful acoustic playing is outstanding.

And the guy has a great voice as well with styles ranging from ballad to soul to blues. A real "all-rounder".

by kaspencer

We heard Gary Moore a few years ago (maybe 4 ...) in a Guitar Festival. I agree, fantastic. And, wasn't he on the Strat for the Fender 50th anniversary of the Strat concert in 2004 ? I saw that on video, and it was an amazing performance.

Ken.

by jellimonsta

I have so many favorites, and they are all amazing. But I think I may have to go with the late Randy Rhodes who played with Ozzy.
That dude could shred!!! :D

by puppybreath

No one mentioned Robert Fripp. His technique is outstanding.

My 5 would be:

Hendrix
Jimmy Page
Robert Fripp
Van Halen
Ritchie Blackmore

by jdclyde

there is no way Page is ahead of Van Halen. Live, he is soooo sloppy even when sobber.

That is the problem with really old guys like Page. He gets more credit than due compared to people that have had just as much if not more success.

What has Page done of value in the last 30 years? Nothing but try to trade on his name, and it never worked.

by Member 25348569

My philosophy in all art is "less is more" so Metal is out.

I have to go for blues and like styles - Peter Green of the original Fleetwood Mac in the '60s and '70s, Paul Kossoff of Free, sadly another drug casualty and "Slow Hands" Clapton - obviously.

Anyone who plays good blues is up there for me.

On another tack, Hendrix - how not? Another one cut short before we'd seen his best?

Finally, Dave Gilmour of Pink Floyd. Never put a note out of place. I must have seen them play live around a dozen times.

I don't really know why - probably just the excitement - but I also [b]love[/b] Flamenco so a vote for Vicente Amigo and two - Ok, 47 - for Paco de Lucia. Now [b]that's[/b] a man who can play a bit!

by vanessaj

(years ago.) And since it is accepted as common knowledge that when Hendrix was asked who he considered the greatest guitarist ever he named Keaggy - I got to ask him if that were true. He said that everyone always asked him that, but that he didn't know. He was a really humble, cool guy, for someone with so much amazing talent. And it was a meeting I will always remember.

by sleepin'dawg

I'm more into jazz than most other genres, so my favourites, not all jazz, in no particular order:

Joe Pass

Eric Clapton - surprisingly excellent jazz player, heard him jamming, unpluged in the bar of the Meridan Hotel at the Montreal Jazz Festival while he was there as a tourist. You haven't lived until you've heard Clapton, Guy and Healey in the same room together, just throwing it back and forth. Great stuff.

Pat Metheney

Stevie Ray Vaughn - Clapton said he was better than he is.

Buddie Guy

Django Reinhardt - dead but if you can find a remastered CD......

Jimi Hendrix - saw him at Woodstock in 79(?) c/w rain and mud and never saw him again. Have some transparencies of that somewhere.

Les Paul - good enough for Gibson to name a line of guitars after

Liona Boyd - a lady no less, classical and still hot, even if she is getting on.

Jeff Healey - blind - Canadian

Don Felder - Eagles - the guitar lead in to Hotel California

Joe Walsh - Eagles - Same

And many others that I enjoy listening to but those are the ones that stand out at the moment.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by mickster269

Mason Williams played 'Classical Gas'.

He first perfromed it on 'The Smothers Brothers" show (#125)
He was joined by:
1. Don Lineberger
2. John Hartford
3. Glen Campbell
4. Roni Stoneman
5. Steve Martin

Now, who besides me saw the show the night it was broadcast?

by tr

Williams was pretty damn good, I don't know of any modern players that good, apart (of course) from John Williams who is in a class of his own. Of all the dead guitarists there's no way to tell who was the best, 99% of them died before music could be recorded. Of the ones that did survive to modern times, Segovia is probably the best with maybe Manitas de Plata as a distant second.

by glennaaa1

Best Ever - Jimi Hendrix (obviously), Stevie Ray Vaughn, Al Di Meola (have you heard of him?), Gary Moore, Eric Clapton.

by wgstokes

I do not dispute that these guys are all great guitarists but based on the criteria you have set how can you go past Steve Vai, who incidently has been acknowledged for the last ten years as the world's best guitarist.

I am a huge Hendrix fan but like any discipline the art of guitar improves over time. Athletes are faster, programmers are producting more sophisticated software than they were ten years ago and guitarists play faster with more precision and greater sound quality than what they did ten years ago.

Check out some of the guys who came to prominence in the nineties, Vai, Yngwie Malmsteen, Andy Timmons and Paul Gilbert.

by Member 25348569

Perhaps we have different choices to yours because "speed, precision and sound quality" are not highest in our criteria for judgement.

Speaking for myself, I value most the effective emotional content and then the intellectual and physical means by which that is attained. That does take in precision and quality but "fast"? Fast is meaningless without the rest of the package. I'm not a guitarist so Vai's technical virtuosity only comes to me via third partiy recommendation. Judged by my rules - "do I like to listen to him?", "well, not much really", Vai is well down my list.

To judge a guitarist just because he's "fast" is pretty shallow.

by wgstokes

when your not a guitarist is pretty stupid!

Besides you miss my point.... I don't judge guitarists on speed alone. I think Dave Gilmour is one of the greatest guitarists of all time and he doesn't play fast. Speed alone does not a great guitarist make. But speed with precision and feel is an immense quality for any guitarist. The emphasis on feel. You can't judge the quality of musicianship on the basis of whether or not you like the music ..... that's just nuts. I liked the sex pistols but they were not good musicians. I don't like Stanly Clarke's music but he is one of the greatest bass players of all time.

by kiwilinz

along with electric guitar players, Brian May (Queen), Gary Moore (for sure), Mark Knopfler (Dire Straits), Clapton (almost God), Dave (The Edge) Evans (U2), Jeff "Skunk" Baxter (Doobies and others), Carlos Santana (another almost God), George Harrison, Stevie Ray Vaughn, then going back a bit there was Hank B Marvin (The Shadows, Cliff Richards backing group in the 60's & 70's ... oh well, guess you had to be there), Glen Campbell and of course Les Paul (father of the modern electric sound) while Chet Atkins is right up there. So many great and talented guitarists, how about the Top 55!!

by 123speedy

Tough choice but I'd have to say Stevie Ray Vaughn Hands down. That dude was a musical conduit. The Mozart of our time.

by fneily

The question presented is "Who is (was) the best guitarist"
Andre Segovia. Anyone out there have any class??

by spin2nz

I agree with all of the above, though there are two or three I've never heard of.....but I am shocked that no one has mentioned Kenny Wayne Shepherd. The first time I saw him play he was still just 19 years old. He can definitely rival any of the afore mentioned axe slingers.

by wgstokes

Kenny Wayne Sheppard is one of the best blues guitarists around now and probably ever. I guess if we were just rating blues guitarists he'd be right up there.

by lloydpc

Yes, Eddie Van Halen, Eric Clapton, and Jimi Hendrix are valid picks although for pure feel I would be more inclined to go with Jimmy Page.

by mboling

One of the finest acoustic OR electric players in the world today is Phil Keaggy.
There's a classic urban legend about him that states that Jimi Hendrix was asked how it felt to be the best guitar player and his answer was,"I don't know, you'd have to ask Phil Keaggy." Never happened, but the legend has been around since the 70's. Snopes.com even has it on file.

by ontheropes

are "Fresh Aire" and "Christmas Live" which has traditional Christmas music with Steamroller style.

by fordice

My God!-----the only one to consider is Les Paul---he started it all!!!!!!!!!!!!

by rmazzeo

...the style of music being discussed & also the type of guitar, such as rhythm, lead, bass. It seems that most replies refer to rock guitarists, most of whom were greatly influenced by the great blues guitarists of the past. Certainly one of the best has to be the late great Stevie Ray Vaughan, & one cannot mention him without mentioning B. B. King. I don't know of many more blues guitarists except by name, since I am not a blues afficionado, but I do have a small list of the greatest rock guitarists, IMHO. I'll start with the usual suspects, including Joe Satriani, Jeff Beck, Steve Vai, & of course Clapton, Van Halen, Jimmy Page, Hendrix, Robin Trower. While I'm sure that I've left out a few, I will add Yngwie (sp.?) Malmsteen to that mix. But let's not leave out one of the MOST underrated guitarists of all time - Alex Lifeson of Rush. I have never seen anyone play so many styles so exceptionaly well as he has. Not to mention that his life (or talent) has not been messed up with drugs & alcohol, as so many others have. No one knows what Hendrix could've done had he not killed himself. Even if you are not a fan of Rush's music, listening to Alex Lifeson jump from an intricate classical "jam" into the hard rock theatrics from one moment to the next is absolutely incredible (of course I am talking about live performance, not studio stuff). So my vote for all time best, most versatile guitarist, both in terms of solo performance & in terms of performance with other musicians, has to go to Alex Lifeson of Rush. Lastly, if we discuss bass guitar, Geddy Lee has to be mentioned as one of the absolute best as well. When we get to a discussion about drummers, lemme know, I'll vote for one of the best pure percussionists I've ever heard - Neil Peart - past, present or future...

Just my $.02...

by gaijinit

Thank you. FINALLY someone mentions Jeff Beck. Of the 3 original Yardbird guitarists, Jimmy Page was the rowdiest, Clapton the fastest, although limiting himself to only playing blues (and he is a TERRIBLE singer, although he has written some nice melancholy songs), but Jeff Beck shows the most true talent & style.
Why has nobody mentioned Harvey Mandel?
Or Michael Bloomfield?
Clapton's best work? with 'Cream' with bassist Jack Bruce & drummer Ginger Baker (1966-1970?)
A personal favorite: Robin Trower - especially his latest work "Go My Way" - absolutely hypnotizing. He's been great since the Procol Harem days.
Best 12-string guitarist EVER? (you'll all flame me for this one) Glen Campbell.
Best 'heavy' (no pun intended) guitarist? Leslie West of 'Mountain'.
And as always, Peter Green (disappeared after LSD overloading knocked him off track - he's now picking up where he left off-with great guitar playing). He wrote Santana's first/biggest hit 'Black Magic Woman'
(Off track) Drummer? Mitch Mitchell-drummer for the Jimi Hendrix's 'Experience' band - unreal.

by kaspencer

Dont give up - see my reply post under "The world's greatest guitarist has to be ...", and then "Don't forget Gary Moore".

Have you seen Jeff Beck recently ? We saw him in Bristol last year. He is as extreme in his playing as ever, but no doubt a true technical wizard. Quite like Gary Moore in many ways.

See you

Ken.

by lensdoc

I would have also added John Maclaughlin, but I guess that is another kind of music. Agree with you

by morlock77

I was wondering if John Maclaughlin would be remembered here. Alan Holdsworth, Adrian Belew, Rick Derringer, Steve Howe, Roy Buchanan, Donald 'Buck Dharma' Roeser, Larry Coryell and Andres Segovia could also be considdered fuel for this bonfire.

by dlogan

I have watched this debate rage on for 40 years.
Its an adolescent argument. Its like asking whats the Best Food? Music preferences are completely subjective. There is no single 'Best' guitarist, musician,Auto mechanic, computer tech, Person race,country,opinion.etc. There is no right answer to this question.
However..MY opinion IS the BEST!!

by excogitator

Alex Lifeson from Rush is my choice for the greatest guitar player ever. His work on La Villa Strangiato (Hemispheres) is awsome. The album Permanent Waves has some of the best riffs and solos that have ever been done.

They also have my vote of the best drummer in the world as well with Neal Peart as well.

Geddy Lee is right up there with the Bass too.

You do not hear much from bands in Canada, let alone individual performers. Most do not get the recognition that they deserve.

Check them out, you will be very pleased with their work. For a (Canadian) band to last as long as them, Over 20 albums, says alot.

by ashby

...that there is so much commonality among TechRepublic members - perhaps we have more in common than we think!

My selection:
George Harrison
Mark knofler
Eric Clapton
Muddy Waters
Jack Falk
and the best guitar tuner, if not player - Keith Richard

Your mileage will vary.

by tnt93

Without a doubt my friend, Clapton is the man.
Tarry, (Also a guitarist)

by mullinsj

I saw Clapton play in Milwaukee several years ago. When someone asked me how it was I replied 'it was an honor and privilege'. But I'll date myself...and a bit of a story for the person who weighed in from Manitowoc, Wisc - my hometown. I was sitting in a coffee house in 1968 next to a guy named Jim Krueger. He was a friend who had a local band and was a pretty good guitar player himself...blues licks made me cry. While sitting with Jim someone put a JEFF BECK record on the stereo and Jim just sat there grinning. He said, 'he's the best and one day I'm going to play with him!'...like Jim, I've always loved Beck and do count him among 'the best'. Jim made it to L.A. and played with Dave Mason for several years...Jim wrote the song, 'We Just Disagree'...I was always sorry he moved away from blues to tunes that would maybe chart. Don't know if he ever did play with Beck...he moved back to 'Manty' in the mid 1980s and passed away quite suddenly in 1993. post script ...for the person who mentioned Pat Methany...his mom's from Manitowoc...must be the water

by Member 25348569

I can't judge a guitarist without being one myself? How very strange. This means that you believe that one cannot judge anything unless one is an expert in that field. Judgement of paintings, sculpture, all musical and theatrical forms are barred to me because I cannot paint, sculpt, act or play an instrument to any standard?

All art is subjective.

You started by arrogantly labelling the posts to date as "living in the past". You went on to state "guitarists play faster with more precision and greater sound quality than what they did ten years ago." And this makes...what? Better musicians - arguably but I don't think so. Better music? Not to me. And I'm all that matters to me. I simply don't like over-elaborate guitar playing. It's not a crime.

Let's just agree to differ and go our separate ways.

by wgstokes

The question is not on taste here. Its who is the best guitarist. You have the right to your opinion as I do. You have the right to listen to anything you want.

I don't know much about art(painting) I know what I like as I am sure you do as I am also sure the same applies with your music. But I would not rate or judge an artist because I don't know anything about painting.

I can accept your opinion that is your right. I hope you can accept mine.

By the way I didn't say you had to be an expert guitarist to judge another. But I feel to make a valued judgement on a guitarist you have to have some understanding of the intricacy of the art.

by lsd.fraser

based on originality craftmanship and technical prowess on his instrument, foe me hands down bar none David Gilmor from Pink Floyd

by bluron

if you have ever had the oportunity to watch and listen to the late great Stevie Ray Vaughn, you would agree that no one could play like him. He had a 3 pce band, drummer, keyboard and himself. if you closed your eyes you would swear there were at least 2 rythm guitars as well as his lead playing. open your eyes and there was only Stevie. He credits Hendricks as one of his inspirations but I know he far out performs him. His is a talent that will be sorely missed as he died at the begining of his peak. I can only imagine that greatness that he would have done had he lived.

by wgstokes

It is almost impossible to say who the greatest guitarist is because there are many styles. It would be more appropriate to rate guitarists within their genre.

Rock: Steve Vai, Eddie Van Halen, Gary Moore, Joe Satriani and others

Jazz: Al DiMielo, Robert Fripp

Blues: Hendrix, Page, Clapton, Stevie Ray Vaughan,
Gary Moore

Heavy Metal: Yngwie Malmsteen, Steve Morse

Slide: Johnny Winter, Dave Gilmour, Pete Wells (Rose Tattoo)

Originality (no classification): Dave Gilmour (Pink Floyd), Steve Vai

It would also be easier to rate the greatest female guitarist, there's only one Bonnie Raitt.

by kaspencer

... Jeff Beck. A highly technically gifted guitarist, individual and quirky. Maybe a difficult bloke to get on with though.

And wasn't it amazing that Eric Clapton, Jeff Beck and Jimi Page all lived and worked in Surrey, played for the same band (although not exactly all at the aame time).

Also Eric Roche was an excellent guitarist and a truly "nice" chap. A great loss to the guitar scene.

And. finally, didn't Jimi Hendrix actually entitle his composition "Voodoo Chile" rather than "Voodoo Child" ?

My guitars are at http://myguitars.mine.nu but I haven't yet added my recent 60th anniversary Fender American Strat to the site - will do soon.

Ken.

by kaspencer

I should have given Gary Moore a mention. He is truly a "blow-you-away-every-performance type of guitarist.

So what's the secret, how do you rustle up the energy and inclination to play brilliantly every time ?

Ken.

by southbound

1-Frank Zappa (who else has double CDs of just guitar solos? BTW- He hired Steve Vai right out of Julliard and Eddie Van Halen would hang out in Franks recording studio.
2- Duane Allman - Dreams,Layla, Mountain Jam.......enough said.
(Freebird was written about him).
3- Jimi - Timeless, turn him up!

by jgaskell

Obviously this is a very subjective topic, but I'll throw my bit in.

My Top 5:

1. Mark Knopfler
2. David Gilmour
3. Eric Clapton
4. Jeff Beck
5. Slash

A great guitarist is determined as much by what they leave out as by what they put in.

And then there is the most overrated guitarist of all time - Carlos Santana. Seriously, if you have heard one Santana solo you have heard them all. He wasn't bad in his early days, but these days he is pretty much a caricature of himself.

by jdclyde

was just cool. Good listening.

Now he is just padding his retirement fund, like some other washed up losers, The Rolling Stones. Tell me they have done anything creative in the last three decades.

Both are still trading off of their names from the 70's. Sad actually, but at least Santana is making new music again. Not great music, but good music.

by agieryic

As an experienced guitarist, I can not claim one greater then the other. I personally believe the three guitarists mentioned above are some of the best. There are guitarists such as Eric Johnson, Chet Atkins and Stevie Ray Vaughn who have their own styles that will just blow your mind. I even recall seeing great guitarists in small pubs who never received deserved recognition. There is an amazing number of great guitarists who the best for their particular styles.

by paul.stanley

Your nominees are without question great guitarists, easily top 10, arguably top 5, but there can be only one "best". I used to think that the greatest guitarist I had ever seen or heard was Mark Knopfler. Then I moved to Texas, grew my appreciation for country music, and ran across Knopfler's own idol - Vince Gill.

by jasper_jay

I have been a guitar player fanatic since I was 12 yrs old. Although music (especially guitar playing) has evolved thru the years, my personal favorites are still staying true to their musical roots of rock n roll.

- John Petrucci(Dream Theatre)
- Paul Gilbert(Mr. Big)
- Yngwie Malmsteen
- Joe Satriani
- Steve Vai
- Vito Bratta(White Lion)
- Van Halen
- Vinnie Moore

by andrew_ockrim

You must include some of the more technical guitar gods in order for it to be a complete list.

Some of the people who have inspired most of the guys i know in bands to are:
Yngwie Malmsteen
Eddie Van Halen
Jimmy Page
Zack Wyld
and if for entertinament and quality of performance on stage Steve Vai..

Then theres Hank Marvin from The Shadows (back in the 60's), BB King/Ry Cooder for Blues and lets not forget Jerry Garcia (Grateful Dead)..

Does that get some minds ticking over?

by oisleach9

HAve you ever listened to "surfing with an alien", "Crystal Planet", or "Eight Steps" ?
Eric I have never liked
Andre' Segovia I like Joe Satriani I like Eric I just don't like his music.

by desmodeus

I have yet to hear anyone play anything on a guitar that comes within light years of the second solo from Comfortably Numb (particularly the live version from Delicate Sound of Thunder). I'm also a big Ritchie Blackmore fan (the live version of Highway Star from Made in Japan is positively unbelievable) although I recently saw Deep Purple live sans Ritchie and was pleasantly surprised by the quality of Steve Morse's guitar work in his stead.

by dmambo

I heard David Gilmore interviewed for his new solo album. He said that he developed his style because he just could not move his fingers fast, so he knew he could not be the typical rock and roll axeman. He called his style long and lazy.

I agree with you on "Comfortably Numb". The Wall is such a schitzo disc. Half Waters, half Gilmore. Perfect for the story it conveys.

by twtrout

Phil Keaggy is a pretty amazing guitarist. I have been trying to find a picture that I have seen before of Phil and Paul McCartney together taken some time back in the '90s.

Found the picture. It was taken after the wedding of Paul's sister-in-law (Linda McCartney's sister). Phil played guitar and sang at the wedding. The photo shows two mirror image custom Olson guitars.

http://www.olsonguitars.com/artists/pm_pk2.jpg