Discussion Locked

Who is (was) the best guitarist ?

0 helpful
212 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

212 replies

by jeanmarc1

If you KNOW anything about guitar, if you have any MUSICAL sense, it has to be:

1. Django Reinhardt
(see http://www.answers.com/topic/django-reinhardt or http://youtube.com/watch.php?v=c1eCkbKhQHk&search=jazz%20guitar).

His influence even today is huge:
- Chet Atkins was once asked to name the ten greatest guitarists of the 20th century. He placed Django at #1 on the list (he placed himself at fifth position).
- Reinhardt is the idol of the fictional 1930's guitarist, Emmet Ray(Sean Penn),who passes out upon meeting Django in the Woody Allen film Sweet and Lowdown (1999).
- Jimi Hendrix, is said to have named one of his bands the Band of Gypsies because of Django's music.
- The Allman Brothers Band song Jessica was written by guitarist Dickey Betts in tribute to Reinhardt. He wanted to write a song that could be played using only two fingers.
- A song titled "Django," composed by John Lewis, has become a jazz standard.
- Black Sabbath guitarist Tony Iommi was inspired by Reinhardt to keep playing guitar after a factory accident that cost him two fingertips.
- Former Slade singer Noddy Holder named his son Django.
- Country music singer and guitar player Jerry Jeff Walker named his son Django (who is also a singer and guitar player).
- Former Libertines guitarist, Carl Barat, has expressed on plenty of occasions his admiration for Django as well as his influence in his solo guitar technique.
- British guitarist Diz Disley was strongly influenced by Django Reinhart and collaborated on numerous projects with St?phane Grappelli.
and also
- Carlos Santana, B.B. King, Jerry Garcia, Toni Iommi of Black Sabbath, Trey Anastasio formerly of Phish, Willie Nelson, Les Paul, Carlos B?rat formerly of The Libertines, Bob Wills, Charlie Christian, Miles Davis, David Crosby, Duane Allman, Julian Bream, Tom Morello formerly of Rage against the Machine, Mark Knopfler of Dire Straits, Chet Atkins, Wes Montgomery, George Benson, Diz Disley, Egberto Gismonti

2. Bireli Lagrene
(see http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/jazz/reviews/lagrene_gypsy.shtml and more...)

by nccfrank

Phil Keaggy has been playing since the late 60's. His unique style of what he calls the "Glass Harp sound" came when he was playing with a group he started called Glass Harp. Many rumors have stated that he has played, taught or even been taught with the legendary Hendrix. A statement was made about Phil, since he has been playing Christian music since the 70's "that if he wasn't playing for "The Cause" that he would be the greatest rocker of all time."

by wow > work

Meh, I might get blasted for this one, but Diamond "Dimebag" Darrell (Pantera) was amazing, always voted best guitarist year after year in Guitar Magazines. Not the over all best, but one of the best. That man could shred a mean guitar.

As for best guitarists, I'll list whom I think are the best, plus they also influenced me when I started playing:

Dimebag Darrell
David Gilmour
Eddie Van Halen
Jimi Hendrix
Kerry King
Randy Rhodes
Steve Vai
Stevie Ray Vaughn

by jdclyde

Was there a reason for alphabetical order? Couldn't bring yourself to put one at the top and another at the bottom?

As far as blasted, when it is a topic based on opinion, how can you be wrong?

You just won't see many of the old timers agreeing on Darrell based on not listening to that style of music. And yes, for someone that was blasted off his a$$ everytime he took the stage, he was right on.

A strange thing to hear would be music influinced by Darrell and Vaughn at the same time..... :p Talk about different ends of the spectrum.

by wow > work

Yea, I listen to a lot of different music, my iPod list is a little odd, from Aerosmith to Led Zeppelin to Megadeth to Pink Floyd to Tool (Note: no Linkin Park.)

To me, a good guitarist isn't measured by the genre of music he/she plays in; it's whether or not he/she can make people drop their jaws at how they play. Even if it isn't fast finger work (like Gilmour,) even songs without solos, some times it's the sound they can create.

Oh, I forgot an obscure guitarist: Herman Li from Dragonforce. Youtube search for him, the guy is amazing. Lightning fast finger work.

Also, for those who love playing air guitar while listening to Stairway To Heaven, if you have a PS2 I *highly* recommend getting Guitar Hero. You can Youtube that as well to see what it's like.

by tryten

Kerry King... He is a good guitarist, but damn near ALL of Slayers best riffs were created my Jeff Hanneman. Guitarwise, Hanneman created 90% the really good riffs, or the more popular ones like War Ensamble.

Jeff and Kerry have very simiar styles but Hanneman is by far the better of the two. He just doesnt like cameras or interviews. I dont see how Kerry does it though. Nearly all of his interviews and "how to" sessions are either questions about songs that were musically written by Hanneman or showing how to play songs that were written by Hanneman. You can even find scales and such created and published by Jeff.

Kerry has the look, but Hanneman has the skills.

by phoenix1999

I have read about half of the responses to this question and have been pleased with everyone's views on who and what makes a great guitarist. Influencal bands and the music they produce is something that will live forever and damn that people who say rock and roll is dead. But anyway my favorite guitarist of all time are as follows:

1. Jimi Hendrix
2. David Gilmour
3. Eric Clapton
4. Jimmy Page (I have not seen this yet)
5. Kirk Hammet
6. Stevie Ray Vahgn
7. Dave Matthews (has some of the most ingenus music i've ever heard)
8. Eddie Van Halen
9. Mike Endzinger
10. Tim Mahonny

Now there is no way there could be any one greatest guitar player, but these are the guitar players that have inspired me to be one and filled my life with the things I love best about music.

by jon.guth

First of all, I will agree with the posters who say there is no one best guitarist. Style, genre, and time differentiate.

A couple more to add to the mix:
Michael Hedges was an acoustic phenomenon. If you havent' heard it, get it. If you haven't seen him, too late.

And possibly the best guitarist you never heard of is Scottie Anderson.

by rclark2

in that order. While they all have their best songs, as pure craftsmen, they have no equal in the acid rock genre.

I do know that there are some great musicians in the rock genre, but you have to first be able to classify what they produce as music.......(I don't) ....

by golovko99

I would like to nominate the following:
1. Mark Knofler
2. Eric Clapton
3. Jimi Hendrix
4. Django Rheinhart
5. Bonnie Raitt

I could happily listen to any of these people for long periods of time.

by rpcoopman

I'm not going to argue who is/was the best, variety is the spice of life. I tend to listen to guys "off the beaten path". I was really fortunate to see Hendrix several times, but each of these guys is just as creative and exciting in their own way. Check them out if you're looking for some new stuff:

Michael Hedges - totally transformed acoustic playing. Died too young ...
Billy McLaughlin - picked up where Michael left off. Watching him play is like poetry in motion. Then due to a debilitating disease reinvented his playing left handed!
Phil Keaggy - my favorite. He can play anything and he's incredibly creative.
John Jorgenson - Hands down the most exciting performer I've ever seen - any gendre. New hier to Django Reinhardt style playing
Roland Dyens - Classical guitarist, but not afraid to throw in some Zappa compositions. An amazing composer ... I'm reminded of Chopin ...
Danny Gatton - not my favorite style of music (rockabilly?) - but he transcended musical boundaries and his solos went to the outer limits of comprehension. He died way too young ...
Pat Methany - his solos can take you anywhere you can imagine ... still fresh after touring for 25+ years ...
Tony McManus - if you like Celtic ... he's the MAN!
David Grier - flatpicking? He turns bluegrass inside-out
Jerry Garcia - ok, lots of people think his playing was boring and his singing sucked ... but, having seen the "Dead" at least 30 times (even before they were the Dead), when he was on ... he was ON. I never saw anyone who could play so tuned in (telepathic?) with his other band members. I always liked the tinge of jazz in his playing
Don Ross - zany "four handed" fingerstyle monster ...

Try to see any of these guys live (the ones who are living) if at all possible. They are better than the CD ... ;')

by ken lillemo

Five guitarists is too short a list to cover the various ways guitarists have excelled at their craft.
On several occaisions I have shared the venue with an audience of 200 see Muddy Waters, Pat Metheny, James Cotton, Pat Fahey, Taj Mahal, John Scofield, Jim Hall, Bill Frisell, Albert King, Duke Tomato, Son Seals, Lonnie Brooks. I enjoyed all of them except for Muddy Waters; granted he was in poor health at the time so my experience is tainted.
I am still wowed by Frampton even though I have not experienced him live.
Metheny was amazing. Surrounded by a tower of electronics and the cracked case on a Syncalvier he did not let the media become the message. He closed the show quietly, alone, with an accoustic gutiar and "Hear Comes The Sun."

by wildbear63

I always loved the guitar work of Ted Nugent. I haven't heard anyone else who could literally play the feedback.

by daveslash

I've been listening to Gary Moore for over 20 years, and I've heard MANY other professional guitar players espouse his abilities.

He's done jazz-fusion (the "Grinding Stone" lp), hard rock (the Thin Lizzy Years, "Corridors of Power", "Dirty Fingers", etc), straightforward rock 'n roll ("Run for Cover" and others), and blues (most of the recent stuff).

He combines great technique, an intuitive knowledge for his instrument, and a great "feel" in his playing.

-- DaveSlash

by nabilmish

I've always thought that Keaggy was incredible - crisp, fast fingering, and great vocals, including "scat"...

by vanessaj

of Keaggy with McCartney at McCartney's wedding that twtrout posted earlier in this blog? I didn't know that Keaggy played for Paul's wedding, and it's a great pic - check it out.

by jdclyde

It annoys me to no end, dumb kids that will say "that sucks" about something like classical music.

There is a big difference between you liking something or not, and if it is great music or not. One is opinion, the other isn't.

I have stressed this to my boys, and it has helped them better see what is out there. They can listen to something for the music content instead of the entertainment content and get something out of it.

That being said, from an analytical point of view I will say that "RAP" is just noise. A way for people with no musical skills to make a buck.

Country? MOSTLY simple music for simple people. :D My idea of "country music" is Metalica while on a back road! (note: opion)

by 3xp3rt

1. Ritchie Blackmore of Deep Purple ? Childe in time
2. David Gilmour of Pink Floyd - Shine on you crazy diamond
3. Carlos Santana - Europe
4. Jimmy Page of Led Zeppelin - Stairway to haven
5. Jimi Hendrix ? Hey Joe

by blueknight

Try "Ho Ho Hoey" if you're into a rockin' Christmas.

Great list of guitarists in this string. As mentioned, it all boils down to one's musical preference as to who's the best. I haven't read the entire string yet, but haven't seen Earl Klugh mentioned for jazz guitar. I thinks he's tops.

by blueknight

I've never heard anyone play Classical Gas as well as Mason Williams. I have a friend who can play it on a 12 string, but he still needs a lot of work.

And yes, I saw that show.

by jean.poole

Guitar Shorty -- blues musician par excellent and brother-in-law to Jimi Hendrix. In fact, he taught Jimi much of what Jimi played.

by jdclyde

I am not the only one!

As I listed earlier, for over all creativity, he takes it. For technical skill, he takes it. Most versital, he takes it.

by jdclyde

First leg started out with Satriani, Vai, Johnson. I missed it and caught the second leg, but Kenny Wayne Shepard had taken Johnsons place. Booooo.

Malmsteen was on the last tour, but far from humble. Over a decade ago when Satriani was first starting to get real popular, Malmsteen said in an interview that Satriani sucked. Sour grapes all the way.

Also, while Malmsteen has GREAT skill, he doesn't have the attitude to be listed in the real greats. Everything he does is too much "in your face, see how grand I am?" and gives the impression of trying too hard to be great instead of just being great.

The difference between someone that is great and someone that thinks they are great, is the great ones have people telling them, instead of them telling people. I still love Black star.

by jdclyde

First leg started out with Satriani, Vai, Johnson. I missed it and caught the second leg, but Kenny Wayne Shepard had taken Johnsons place. Booooo.

Malmsteen was on the last tour, but far from humble. Over a decade ago when Satriani was first starting to get real popular, Malmsteen said in an interview that Satriani sucked. Sour grapes all the way.

Also, while Malmsteen has GREAT skill, he doesn't have the attitude to be listed in the real greats. Everything he does is too much "in your face, see how grand I am?" and gives the impression of trying too hard to be great instead of just being great.

The difference between someone that is great and someone that thinks they are great, is the great ones have people telling them, instead of them telling people.

by sonicbridge

New York studio cats were hot, hot, hot! But you would have to be listening to Jazz/Fusion in the 70's to know who these guys are (unless your Dad shared his record collection with you).

by jdclyde

who is a personal friend of Joe's. Matter of fact, my uncle wrote the intro in the "friends" cd.

She got me started, and I have picked up several of his since then.

[b]Trivia, DMP was the first US lable to go strictly CD and dump vinyl.[/b]

The one thing that would make this discussion better was if there were a separate breakaway for each genre. I know there is much about Jazz that I don't know, that I would like to.

by tehuti_44

If I missed their names being mentioned my apologies, but since I didn't see them I have to add:

Roy Buchanan
Freddie King
Michael Bloomfield

Obviously many people would list Stevie Ray (as would I). But if you're going to acknowledge Stevie you HAVE to also consider Albert King, who was his inspiration.

by allen halsey

In a way, you are right -- Townshend probably wouldn't win a Gold Medal if Guitar Virtuouso was an olymplic event; there are other guitarists that can play faster and with better technique. (Assuming leaping and windmilling is not considered by the judges.)

But, for me, no other guitarist captures the Rock ethos as Pete Townshend. The emotion he expresses through his guitar playing really resonates with me.

You might call it "messy," but, that's the kind of Rock I like -- the unchained chaotic energy kind.

No antiseptic guitar virtuousos for me -- I find them lacking in emotional energy.

Ultimately, I believe, musicians must be judged on their ability to convey emotional impact -- not on the athleticism of how fast they can play. In this regard, Pete Townshend comes out ahead.

by allen halsey

Although I am a big fan of Pete Townshend, I would have to say the best guitar solo ever is by Brian May in Queen's "We Will Rock You."

I also like the guitar work by AC/DC e.g. Back in Black.

I never understood why Eric Clapton is heralded as such a great guitarist. The only solo by him that I like is on The Beatles' "While My Guitar Gently Weeps".

Jimi Hendrix is definitely impressive. My favorite of solo of his is his Woodstock rendition of Star Spangled Banner.

Eddie Van Halen, while innovative and technically awesome, often doesn't carry much of an emotional impact, which I believe is the ultimate criteria for any musician. However, I do very-much like his solo in "Unchained". Another problem with Eddie is the songs themselves are pretty bad. I prefer groups with a social consious, like The Who and U2. I really lost a lot of respect for Eddie when his group did "Hot for Teacher."

by jgaskell

If you want to hear some great Clapton solos, check out the Roger Waters album, "The Pros and Cons of Hitchhiking". I think Clapton was really able to shine on that album through not being the centre of attention. He was able to just concentrate on his part.

by sonicbridge

I still think his work on John Mayall and the Bluesbreakers is what got him respect amongst other guitarists.

by jamesrl

I've got an album of Pete playing acoustic and I recently saw the Classic Albums TV doc on Who's next.

I would suggest that when I saw Pete play acoustic, his technique shows a little better.

Some of his precision I think gets distorted by the volume and by the effects pedals.

As for the suggestion about his musicality, he wrote the music for virtually every Who song(John Entwhistle did one an album or so), as well as a number of solo projects. He has written a lot of great songs, pioneered Rock Opera and was one of the first users of synths in Rock.

James

by oz_media

Eddie VanHalen, was a pioneer at working with new sounds, a la hammer-ons. He was far from a GREAT guitarist though, any 15 year old kid can dupe his work effortlessly. It was unique but not the best.

Eric Clapton, an excellent guitarist and top rank writer, but not any more talented than howlin wolf and some of the other old blues players. Again, I wouldn't say he's the BEST guitarist, or even the top 3.

Jimi Hendrix, good acid, need i say more. Yes he was a great guitarist, a legend in fact, but was he really one of the best guitarists? For the same style, I would throw Stevie Ray Vaughn on top.

So there are zillions of great guitarists, all very unique and very talented, just as there are vocalists, drummers, bassists etc. We have had similar discusisons MANY times here, and there is no real answer. Just like all teh top 10 and top 1000 lists, we would always accept some and reject some, music is purely based on taste.

Now you mustn't forget guitar teams, KK Downing and Glen Tipton (Judas Priest), phenominal!! Together simply uneqalled even in todays saturated scene (though GUitar bads are few and far between these days); independantly, well they are both good but no unstoppable talent.

Angus Young, an absolute maniac able to play virtually any style he chooses. What makes him unique? He is a string bender that guitarists just can't keep up to anymore, by far one of the best R&R and BLues Guitarists around today.

As a band manager, I can say most guitarists place Alex Leifsen (RUSH) at the top of their list, as do most mags and industry charts.

And, believe it or not, one of the most respected guitarists (even in teh heavy metal world) is Prince (or the Artist formerly known as Prince), he's absolutely incredible.

So while the mainstream and most new guitarits think VanHalen, Clapton and Hendrix rule the world, and they are very unique talents (well Clapton is a bit of a hack with his constant cloning of sounds) there are so many that are as good if not better that creating such a list is really not possible.

by jamesrl

The artist formerly known as....came out of a dispute with the record company who were trying to restrict his musical style and content, so he swore he would never record for them again. They in turn suggested that he would be breaking his contract if he recorded for anyone else. Hence he record and toured under....the artist formerly known as.

But I believe a settlement has been worked out since, so he is back to his old name.

He lives part of the year in Toronto, a few doors down from a co-worker of mine. Local paper interviewed him last year and he seems a little uncomfortable with some of his earlier rauchier work as he doesn't like to expose his kids to that content.

I've only ever owned "Purple Rain" but its a pretty amazing album and Prince is a great player.

Alex Liefson is pretty incredible too.

James

by oz_media

Prince was actually owned by teh label, he couldn't record under that name without teh label's control. He removed all traces of his name and used a symbol, his name was made up by the media as they didn't know what to call him.

His contract came to term so he left and started as Prince again.

by tr

I think you are the only poster to this thread that mentions Mark Knopfler, and I agree he's certainly one of the best currently playing. He's technically very proficient but gets extra points for developing his own style (I wish he had enough confidence in his own ability to recognise that.)

Most of the others mentioned in the thread, and pretty much every rock axeman since Woodstock, are Santana wannabees. Unfortunately, Santana is now one too. But he also gets points for being the first to use that style. Or perhaps Peter Green should get those points instead.

Thinking back I'd say Segovia, Rheinhardt, Fahey, Santana, Knopfler and maybe Tounkara are the only 20th century guitarists that could be candidates for best ever. I'm not sure about Tounkara, he's certainly different but only by Western standards, his music takes a lot from traditional kora styles.

by oz_media

Out of all the bands I've met, many dozens, of all the shows I've seen or worked, again many dozens, Billy Gibbons (and Dusty Rosde)are by far the absolute coolest guys I have ever had teh sheer pleasure of hanging with. These guys are one class act, they are the most interesting men you have ever met but they would rather talk about what you like and about collecting art than about music.

They really are two of the coolest guys in the biz.

by oz_media

Steve Harris or Geddy Lee, they are so hard to choose between but are that most incredible bassists I've ever seen

by oz_media

Yes he's a top ten guy, but there are many far better.

I think he lost his knack in the 90's, especially with his emnbarrassing stint with Mr. Big, GAWD what a trainwreck that was right out of the gate!

by jdclyde

you can still find some of the old talas around.

Ya, top ten, but hard to pick the number one.

by gptech

Rory Gallagher, Bill Nelson (of Be-Bop Deluxe) ....

Gallagher for his 'understanding' of what the guitar could/needed to do.... and Nelson for breaking new ground and not caring who he upset along the way

by oz_media

I am shocked that nobody seems to have mentioned one of the most noted guitar virtuoso's, Randy Rhodes.

At his young age he was one of the first guitarists to REALLY mix classical stylings with hard rock/heavy metal. Which we also see from Yngwie. But Rhandy wasn't playing classical on electric as Ymgwie does but more the fingering and styling to create clear, listenable solos and incredible harmonies when mized with Ozzy's high-keyed vocals (remember when mot music actually had a guitar solo?).

R.I.P. Randy Rhodes: December 6 1956 - March 19, 1982

Now we can't mention Randy Rhodes without mentioning another amazing talent, voted MVP for three years in a row by Guitar World Magazine, 2005's 'Best Metal Guitarist', 'Number 1 Shredder' and recipient of the 'Metal Hammer', 'Riff Lord' and 'Golden God' awards. Ladies and gentlemen, Mr. ZAKK WYLDE!!!!!

The man who can play the US national anthem on guitar EVEN WYLDER than Hendrix, has played with almost ANY and EVERY notable guitarist r band you can imagine. His silver screen appearance with the band Steel Dragon (also featuring DIO's, Jeff Pilson and Jason Bonham ((Led Zeppelin's John Bonham's son)) in Rock Star was VERY similar to his onstage performance with Ozzy. He is a master to watch and a sound that the most discerning ears will enjoy . Mr. Wylde I must hand the runner up to you for being so cool last summer, having such a great positive attitude and for keeping the solos alive.

by dvavassi

ok guys, Hendrix,R.Roads,Eddie V.Hallen etc
are all excellent.But come on...
Black Sabbath teached alot of bands how to rock!
Nobody mentioned the great Tony Iommi(!!!)
shame...

by dmambo

I'm 45 and when I listen to Quadrophenia, it still speaks to me like it did when I was 15.

It's cool to see my 12-year old son crank up Who Are You or Baba O'Rielly.

by maecuff

It took my son longer. He used to make fun of the music I listened to, but now (he'll be 19 next month) he says "Mom, can you burn a copy of London Calling for me?" Or, "What Pixies albums do you have?" He's also been into Rush, The Stones, Pink Floyd..never thought I'd see the day.

On the other hand, I have ALWAYS dismissed Rap music. Hated it. But I've been listening to some of Zach's (my son) music and have to admit that it ain't ALL bad. Mostly bad, but I like some of it..

by dmambo

When mom tells him to "turn that damn music down", I usually tell her to at least wait until the song is over. :D

by vanessaj

Thanks for sharing this photo. It's weird, but I like it more because it shows that he has accomplished so much with the guitar with a 4-fingered hand. I think that says a lot! And it's also nice that McCartney is in the pic, too.

Thanks.

by jdclyde

While it started a new sound, there is very little in his actual playing that would have you writting home to mom about.

Good, yes. Great? No.

Now if you want to carve out a special nitch award for innovative sounds, he would make a top 10 list. Creativity, versitility, and over all skills, if you get emotional he might be listed in a top 100, but not if you are objective about it.

After all that is said and done, can an opinon on something like this be wrong? If you state YOUR FAVORITE is, then no. If you state that he is just the best, then we have many technical points to amend your opinion with.

by jdclyde

This gets me back to something I wanted to do about a month ago. I enjoy instrumental CD's, and about 1/3 of my collection is just that. Some Jazz, but mostly rock guitar.

I would be VERY interested in spanish guitar INSTUMENTALS. don't WANT the singing to go with it.

What do you suggest?

by bubba69

In no particular order...
Jimmy Page - Led Zepplin
B B King
Carlos Santana
Mark Knoppler - Dire Straits
Jimi Hendrix
Stevie Ray Vaughn

by mindilator9

nobody is more innovative with style and effects than tom. he uses several "broken" guitars and pedals that have unique quirks from damage to make some of the sounds he makes. and his record-scratch-string-sliding technique on Bulls on Parade? the rage against the machine albums have some of the best guitar work ever recorded.

by x-marcap

If he can't be sober enough to play any of the concerts, he isn't all that good, and if he was sober, he can't play as well as my son...

George Dean has actually doubled him for studio sessions so Townsend could learn the music...

Once he has it memorized it isn't music, but memory.

by jamesrl

At one of the Toronto concerts, Joe Jackson opened for him, and someone beaned him with a beer bottle. Joe walked off stage disgusted.

I don't understand your George dean comment - Townsend wrote the music, how would Dean know it better. Yes Townsend had a problem - so have many great guitarists.

James

by maecuff

When I was a kid, my parents told me to turn the music down, now as an adult, the older kids b*tch at us for having it up too loud.

I'd say we have to wait for them to all get out of the house, but since there's a grandkid on the way, we may never get a break. At least the 8 year old likes loud music..

My older son gets migraines, so it's understandable coming from him. The 20 year old girl though, sheesh..there's no hope for her. She told me recently that she heard this old song and it was so great. I asked her what it was, she says.. The Pina Colada Song. I don't know how she ever got into our family.

by robert.manning.ctr

Was one of the strongest and best guitarist's ever. Saw him play non-stop (sober) for just over three hours and at t he end of the 3hrs, he sounded like he just walked on stage. SRV was extremely talented and paved the way for others like Johnny Lang. He was also true to his music and never deviated and always kept his sound, unlike others.

by zemi

No one has mentioned Jimmy Page. He is the baddest guitarist ever. You can take that to the bank. You're all rookies. Page pwnz!!!

by kaspencer

yes I agree - see my earlier post(s) on this topic. I wish I had put his name in the title of the post now ...

Ken.

by golovko99

On my way home last night I put on the "live" CD of Wheels of Fire by Cream. Eric Clapton sounded pretty darn good.

I would like to add a name to this discussion that I don't think I have seen up to now. What about Chuck Berry ?

by badams

I realize some people won't/can't appreciate Yngwie's speed, but the dude deserves some respect. As do John Petrucci of "Dream Theater", and Tony MacAlpine.

by ibanezoo

The answer is simple and quite obvious. *I* am the greatest guitarist hands down and without question.

Now stop your arguing and get back to work.

by jgaskell

I was just pointing out some of his better work that people may not be familiar with.

by x-marcap

He had to have someone else play it for him to learn others written music. He can create, but he needs someone else to write it down. If someone else wrote it he can pick it out, but is not a music reader for the times I have been around him. I used to be the California Dude, Long hair,Gibson (Ripper or Les Paul) over my shoulder and a trombone in my hand. I'd been all over the Christian and secular music scene.

I play trombone and have been in on some studio sessions with Townsend, Stonehill, Keaggy, and some other really good players. Townsend had someone read and play it so he could practice it and learn it. Monkey see Monkey do style. He never did play as well as Dean, On Dean's worst day drunk or sober. (Some of us are cursed with such good looks we can curdle milk with a glance.) That is a reason that studio musicians tend to be great, but ugly...

You like Townsend. I like musicians who can and do read music and play it as the music was written.

by jamesrl

Tell me what you think of Paul McCartney as a song writer and musician - he can't read a note and he composed a symphony.

Personally, I've also been recorded but not as often as you. And in a totally different genre.

I come from the classical music side of life where reading music is fundamental. When eighty voices sing in 8 parts on a piece that is 20 minutes long, you can't memorize it all. Ok, I did memorize Handel's Messiah once, but that was after three years in a row of rehersing and performing it for the Christmas season - about 8 reherals per performance times 3 years.

But for the most part reading is fundamental in classical - when you audition you always get a piece to read cold, and often you get about 30 seconds to scan it before you get to sing it. And while you get a pianist to accompany you, they don't play your part.....you have to pick it out.

So I can see where not reading hinders Townsend playing others work. But I'm sure he doesn't have to read his own songs to play them well. On the other hand I expect studio musicians to be great readers given the nature of their work. I loved "standing in the shadows of Motown" as it really highlighted the unsung heroes and showed how their virtuousity created that great sound. Too bad Barry Gordie didn't recognize that.

Perhaps I am favouring Townsend because I like what he writes, but it does kind of blur into the same thing.

James

by x-marcap

I sat in the symphony between my teacher 1st seat, and his teacher (80 years old, I'd guess) and one of the best Jazz players within a thousand miles was my first trombone student. (He is far,far better than I am at Jazz. I love it but can't play it unless I can hear it. 1,3,5 ,augmented etc.) My son sits 4th seat. 200+ years of trombone playing experience.

I used to be in California and augment my Marine Corps salary by playing in swing bands all over the west coast. I love Glen Miller, Tommy Dorsey, Benny Goodman, etc. The best Bone player living is
Christian Limberg for any Genre. The next best may well be Josh DeVore ex-Vegas player.

I have liked some of what Townsend has written, too. It is interesting to be in studio having to chart the music in those situations.

Now I only do Big Band charts from the old masters. I have trouble writing for non-C instruments, So I have a program that transposes any chart into any key I want. Simple and workable...

by leee

Hendrix. Nor Stevie Ray Vaughn. Jimmy Page and Paul McCartney still can't. Not terribly uncommon with guitarists.

by x-marcap

Hendrix for his lack of reading had a nearly photographic memory. He only needed to hear it once to memorize and a second time to start his improvisation. Hendrix at least understood the concept of a dotted note and syncopation. As I am sure did the others mentioned.

BTW, Paul McCartney does read music, after all these years. He can sit down and play the music on a Piano. I have seen him do it. He is not Chopin ready, or reading like a Billy Joel (Piano player thread begging here), but he played some Irish songs from books on TV. He isn't great, but he can at least do right hand reading (treble clef) very well.

If he doesn't read on a guitar or bass, that would be practice. I can't sing and play at the same time even now (After 10 seconds of my singing people scream to listen to Rod Steward). I can do it, but people wish I'd stick to playing trombone when they heard me sing and play at the same time.

Writing music from a piano score to charting parts is not that far from improvising from a chord chart. In studio, at that time Townsend was unable to tell a half note from a whole note, 8ths from 16ths, dotted notes, etc, and not knowing what a triplicate was. Poor George beating the rythem out is a whole different ballgame. Sorry to vent, but he is liked, but I find him not in my top 50. I would put Esteban ahead of Townsend. Charo, and even Tom Scott, Placido Domingo is absolutely amazing... I am not hammering on just his lack of reading music, but his knowledge displayed in the studio several times.

by cuteelf

Stevie Ray Vaughn
Eric Clapton
Santana
and Hendrix

in that order.

Cute Tan Elf :P

I have a job. Now let's sing da blues ...
I got da bills
I got da bills
I get such ache and chills
writin fat checks
for your damn fat bills..

by Member 25348569

Is it a good job? I know that you were getting a bit stressed. Your fans want to know that things are on the up-and-up for you in the frozen "slightly further north and a long, long way west".

Neil :D

by kaspencer

Chuck Berry - yes pretty good, no doubt about that. But better than Beck, Clapton, Van Halen, Satriani - not sure about that.

To add two more into the debate:
1. Martin Taylor - and excellent jazz guitarist whgo makes his guitar sounds as polyphonal as a piano;
2. Dominic Miller - Sting's sidekick - good as a rocker and a jazz-man.

Kenneth Spencer

by jmgarvin

Everybody always forgets that it doesn't matter how fast you play, but how you play.

Although I have to include:
Clapton, Hendrix, Kim Thayil, and BB King

by jamesrl

I began my singing career in church at the age of 5.

At nine my parents enrolled me in a music school - my older brother was already there.

I wanted to play drums but i have a little deformaty - I only have a pinky and thumb on my left hand and they thought that meant I couldn't have my first pick. So they gave me a baritone/euhphonium to learn. I did play it, and after a while I convinced them to let me do drums as well - I didn't have a problem with it. I didn't play a set - being a formal orchestra like band - I played everything in percussion from tympani to xylophone to snare and bass.

When I went to high school we had two academic streams - general and advanced(University track). I was an advanced student but the rules were flexible enough, so I actually took drums on one track and euphonium in the other. We had three bands in the school - junior, intermediate and senior - and I played in the upper two.

I had an inspiration one time and decided I wanted to play in all three bands for the Christmas Concert. So I asked the conductor of the junior band if I could sit in on the trombone - same scale and range as the trombone, and most importantly - same mouthpiece.

So I was a bit of a ringer, because I learned the positions in a few days, and I'd been playing baritone for 7 years, when many of these students had been playing for a few months. I kinda mentored the trombone section. They sounded great! But at the end of the year I couldn't do it anymore (the sound of inexperienced woodwinds will drive anyone insane).

My recent recording experience is this:
http://canbrass.stores.yahoo.net/voonhihastsi.html
This was the group we played with.
http://www.hssb.ca/indexINTRO.htm

Its a unique recording - Requiem for a Charred skul is an acquired taste. On the other hand, Reconciliation is an amazing piece and since the choir is all male for that number, you might actually hear me. The flugelhorn on piece that is amazing.

I'm very partial to Who's Next and Quadrophenia and most of Tommy. The later stuff lacks the energy.

James

by ryk

I couldn't read every reply, but I read a bunch and I didn't see a single mention of Steve Morse or Eric Johnson.

C'mon -- Morse was voted Best All Around Guitarist 5 years in a row in Guitar Player mag (almost 20 years ago) and so was retired to the "Gallery of the Greats". If you haven't checked out his solo stuff, or his work with the Dixie Dregs, you owe it to yourself to do so.

And Eric Johnson is just otherworldly. He channels an energy & spirit I've seen nowhere else. He's hands-down better than just about anyone else I've ever heard.

Also, if you've never heard of David Lindley, check him out -- he's basically a master of any picked string instrument. Phenomenal musician.

I love 'em all -- Hendrix, Van Halen, Satriani, Vai, Gatton, but the three I mention above have all literally brought me to tears during their live shows. I can't say that about any other artist.

by thefrown

You're a Rush fan then?

(Me too, still regularly listen to 2112 30 years on ... now how many of today's so-called "stars" will be able to say that about their music in 30 years' time?)

by bluesyman

AMEN!! "For The Love Of God" is such a "hot" song!!

Also Gary Moore's
"Still Got The Blues" and "Parisenne Walkways"

Listen to Eddie Hazel's (Funkadelic) "Maggot Brain" or to Frank Zappa's "Zoot Allures"

Have to add these great guitarists

Joe Bonamassa
Slash
Vernon Reid (Living Color)
Larry Carlton

by diddle

I am kind of shocked that at first glance I didn't see Jimmy Page posted under anyone's listing. That's rediculous! Okay Hendrix was the best I'll give you that but Page was a close second! And if anyone says different you probably haven't seen his live Stairway to Heaven from Madison Square Garden in the 70's or your head just needs an examination!
Check it out on youtube.com then just sit back and concede that you were wrong! Zeppelin was the overall best pure rock band ever and that was mostly due to Page's playing and writing ability. So just end the debate because there really isn't one to begin with. #1 Jimmy Hendrix #2 Jimmy Page!

by nealandonna

I believe that if there can be only one best guitarist ever then it can only be Jimmy Page. All others, however great they may be, and there are many great ones to be considered, fall short to the great Page. Before Zeppelin, with Zeppelin and after Zeppelin, Page continues to be the greatest. Nothing more needs to be said on this topic of discussion.

by jdclyde

It doesn't matter which type of music you listen to, there clearly are many that have far outshone Page. Clapton in the same era and beyond, is one such example.

Modern guitar, just try to match up against Steve Vai for skill, creativity, and originality, as well as longevity.

by robert_page

Has anyone heard the guitarist in the almost funk band (being hailed as the new U2) in Dublin.
Chris Fairclough is undeniably better then the edge. However this was to be expected as his twin sisters are actress; appearing in the critically acclaimed Commitments.

Robert Page

by boogity33

Hey, Does anyone know if STew has anything new out. WE are going to see him at the end Of Feb. and want to be familar with what he will be playing.....thanks Lisa

by john_gibson083

I'm from Scotland. I'm going to see him in May. I'm listening to him right now (the loner (live)). I have been into rock music for over 30 years. I've heard most of the tracks that are in most of these polls on whose the best guitarist. To give my opinion on Gary Moore (he's from Northern Ireland by the way), I have been asked by friends etc yes but can he play like such and such (naming names that appear in these polls). Yes I say ... but only if you break his fingers first. He's a great singer, a great songwriter, and, in my humble opinion - the best guitarist ever (so far at least). Still in Love With You - the studio version not the one from the Thin Lizzy Live and Dangerous album is just such an awsome track. Released 33 years ago. I just can't believe (and I mean that literally) how some of the guitarists got into these polls. They appear in many many of these polls (no names - no pack drills). Gary Moore could play most of this stuff blindfolded and drunk (and again I mean that literally).

by john_gibson083

They don't rate as great guitarists in my opinion. The Who have done a lot of good stuff and Robbie Robertson and The Band have (in my opinion) written some of the best songs ever - sheer craftsmanship. But that doesn't make Robbie one of he best guitarists (by the way, I think he's a good actor too).

by mimi_toma_sweety

ok, Dave Grohl sucks big time...he has a terrible voice, his guitar is so ordinary, the only thing he's good at is drums. slash rulz, he's number one, kirk is ok, but not number 3, kurt is ok, but not worthy of a top 5....maybe the best composer or one of the best singers...as for robbie, i haven't hurd his work so I'll shut up

by alex_g

I have to agree with Tryten,
1. Dimebag Darrell
2. Zakk Wylde
3. Randy Rhodes

Oddly enough, Ozzy Ozbourne has had the luck, or sence to hire a number of great axemen.