Discussion Locked

Why do IT people really bash Windows?

0 helpful
719 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

719 replies

by jforan

Give me a break about it being "your fault"... how many BSOD's, kernel panics, etc. have been caused by security patches, updated "compatible" drivers, and plain old OS bugs? Enough so that serveral MS service packs for NT (4, 4a, 5, and 6) and 2000 (3, 4) had to be revised an re-released. Read the MS Knowledge Base - there are reams of pages contradicting your post.

Why keep supporting something old "when you need to keep moving forwards"... probably for one very important reason - the business needs to keep the current application as they are. Maybe it's for financial reasons, maybe it's for usability, maybe it's because the app vendor is out of business and a mission-critical product isn't going to ever be updated again. Forward isn't ALWAYS good, sometimes its just motion for the sake of motion, and that leads to slamming into walls.

I get your point... unfortunately it's moot.

Businesss trumps technology. They pay for IT to play with the toys, so they can tell IT when we can't buy new toys.

by chewybass

We in the USA have a thing called free speech. We may not like what others are saying and they may be ignorant, but even the lowest of the low have the right to voice there opinion.

by mswanberg

Or actually, it's all numbers.

Here's my take, in a little analogy. Let's say you and I are OS authors and we support a group of 100 people. Each of them has a different hardware config. 99 of them run your OS and the 100th runs mine. How often is a problem going to appear in your OS as opposed to mine? You would think, if our skills are similar, that you would see issues 99 times as often as I do, simply because you have 99 times as much software and user input banging away at your OS.

Now, let's say there is a rival company (let's pretend the 100 people and us are a company 102 strong) that wishes to ruin us by corrupting our computers. Are they going to write malicious code that attacks my OS, or one that attacks yours? If they have half a brain, they'll attack the most machines at the same time; i.e. your OS.

Now, onto the "fixed once and forever" idea. When one of your 99 users finds a problem in your OS, you have to fix it and make sure the fix doesn't break the other 98 computers under your care. All I have to do is fix it on the 1 computer that is running my OS. Fixed once, and forever.

Are you starting to see where this is going?

When it comes to Linux and Windows, I have my own opinions. I do not disagree that Windows has its issues. But I also agree that Linux has its issues. I find Windows to be easier to use for the low-level user. Unfortunately, the default installation of Windows doesn't lock stuff down for the average user like it should, but that's another story.

OTOH, I find that installing new software on Linux is such a nightmare that I just don't do it. That tends to keep an OS stable when you never install anything new.

Furthermore, I have found that Linux distros will ignore any hardware that it can't readily recognize. Many of my boxes go without sound support under Linux. Windows, OTOH, will install a driver that may be unstable, but at least there is sound. You may disagree, but I would wager that if you took ANY PC, install Windows, and then disable all but the most basic of hardware (take away the sound, reduce to VGA, no USB, etc.) then you will have a very stable box (as long as there is no outside influence such as new drivers, virii, software, etc.). The point is, M$ goes for maximum compatibility whereas Linux seems to go for maximum stability. Each end user should choose what they want. I can see that a server needs to be stable, but an end-user box should have maximum compatibility, IMO.

In the end, I am all for Linux becoming 50% of the industry. Competition is good and I think M$ has gotten too bloated to be effective anymore.

In the end, I agree totally with the original poster: there ARE ways to make Windows stable and if the user doesn't take advantage of them, then shame on them.

-Mike

by tommy higbee

I've never been much impressed by the "market share" argument. Certainly, the comparative market share of a platform is a factor, but let's not claim it's the only factor. That would mean that a secure design doesn't affect security, and that careful code scrutiny doesn't affect security, and that proper testing from a QA department doesn't affect security.

It's pretty well known that about two-thirds of web servers are running Apache, and about 22% are running Microsoft IIS. Yet some time back, people were being advised to migrate from IIS to Apache to improve security. By the market share argument, that doesn't make sense.

But there's a better example of what's wrong with the market share argument. Windows 95 and Windows XP had similar market shares in their day. Does anyone want to claim that Windows 95 was therefore just as secure as Windows XP? Or that it was just as stable?

On a different topic you raised, I have never known anyone using Debian Linux or any of its derivatives, such as Xandros, Mepis, Libranet, or Ubuntu, who complained that installing software was "a nightmare." So it's hardly a given that installing software under Linux is hard.

by hebbeson

I think that one of the main problems with Windows is that it is so widely used, moreso than any other O/S, that finding issues with it is commonplace. The more people use something, the more things are going to be found wrong with it. It is the nature of the beast, so to speak. Since Windows has been adopted (or forced, as some would view it to be) as the standard, so many different ways of configuration exist. It is expected to find errors in it. The main problem is that the O/S is so wrought with stuff that needs to be fixed, that they almost cannot fix them all in a timely manner. So we find fixes ourselves, or interface with other systems to take care of those issues.
I do not neccesarily think that it is simply 'lack of experience or operator error' as described in the original post, but rather a combination of both the vendor and the user. The vendor is responsible for giving us a product that truly works; not something that kind of works, and then prescribes bug fixes during the life of the product that really should have been addressed before releasing the O/S. Again, therein lies the issue....it is hard to address every possible scenario, since it is being used in so many different ways. On the user side, it could be (and probably is most of the time) a matter of finding the resources to fix the problems outside of Microsoft themselves. I know from experience that sometmes, I cannot find all of the resources to fix a problem that I have encountered. I consult other admins when that is the case and often times, a matter of experience or knowing which website to go to for additional help is the key.
Since Windows is the main O/S that most people use, it is easy to overlook the other O/S options and their faults.
I remember back to Linux in the beginning and the difficulty in finding programs to run on it. Since it was open source, many joined in and that problem has decreased significantly.
I agree that maybe if Windows were open source, most of these problems would go away.
Personally, I am experiencing that now with Powerpoint....how I wish it were open source, as the fixes I have read about are not working...

Thank you for my space in this. No offense or malice was intended (seems to be the best way to voice an opinion without offending anyone....)

by ole88

We have all had these users! Those users that will always find something to complain about. You stated "I think people were hit with so many patches that they told Microsoft to can it, and when they slowed down, they complainted even more."

When you think about it, there are users who will find something to complain about when their machine is running at peak performance levels. For some of them, it probably boils down to the fact that Bill Gates dropped out and became a millionaire and they are just jealous.

I see windows as a good general use platform, but when it comes to photo editing, MAC tends to be the better (and chosen) platform. All I have to say to the complainers is, if you don't like what you have - get something different. If you don't like that, you can still find typewriters for sale out there. :D

by kyuso

The problem is, there is no OS that fits everyone's simple needs, and those OS which CAN be made to fit the simple needs don't, so people complain.

For example, Windows OS had a tendency to be less than well designed and not conforming to standards. They crashed because the OS design allowed sloppy drivers or applications to bring down the whole OS or not interoperate. It is not the user's fault that they had to wait and patch the bugs and update the drivers (what if the updated drivers were not ready yet for a few months, which usually happens?)
The GUI was not well-conceived to be consistent and natural, needing repeated changes in the interface.

Linux has a one of the stablest design for an OS (as with any unix variants). Almost no application or driver can bring down the OS, the OS is very scalable (embedded to supercomputing), and the security can't be matched. The problem? Not much in the commercial game or education area running natively.

MacOS has all the desktop goodies that Windows lack (naturally consistent and cohesive GUI, etc.), and also includes all the goodies of unix. The problem? More expensive, can't run many commercial games that run in Windows.

In the end, each OS has a potential to be up to par to the simple needs of stability and usability of an automobile, but is not there yet.

How often does a brand new car need parts replacement as soon as you get one? When was the last time installing a new oil filter broke a car? Can you find any usual parts like windshield wipers that exist for only certain brands of cars (a vendor usually carries wipers for all contemporary brands of cars)?
How often do interface to cars change between models drastically that you need to re-learn how to drive?

All the OS will be up to par if:

They can run all the popular software, does not need manual software driver update just to make it function okay, and is well designed based on a consistent and secure fundamental structure that doesn't change often.

In the end, I want a Linux-like stability and security and scalability, with MacOS-like consistent GUI, and with Windows-like availability of applications, especially in the areas of games, education, and references.

I use Linux because it's stable and robust and has all the tools I need for work. I have Windows for kids' games and education. I have a Mac for my wife because my wife can't stand Windows or Linux way.

But we sometimes dual-boot or use one other's computer precisely because none of the OS has everything: My kids use the internet, email, word processing, and multimedia from Linux for security and ease, and we all use Windows to play Red Alert 2 Yuri's Revenge (don't exist in Linux or Mac, and it's such a cheap way of doing family entertainment because it costs about $50 nowadays to buy 4 user license for multiplayer!)

It's the fault of software (including OS and application) manufacturers. Application vendors should port their software to all popular OS, and OS vendors should make their OS more secure and stable and better conforming to standards so that application and driver writers don't write sloppy codes.

I'd rather see in the future at least three major OS (Linux, MacOS, Windows) competing at the same level, just like in the car industry, and parts (application/driver/hardware) vendors provide for all brands, but with enough differentiation that different people choose different OS or model.

I guess in the much further future, OS may become public utility, just like water, electricity, or highway.

by eddie, gh

Whenever a problem occurs, and blame or responsibility for correction must be assigned, the typical organisation man would want to shift this somewhere else if he can. And in my experience picking up my computing knowledge on the job, I think that dishonest or inexperienced Tech 'Gurus' go a long way to give a bad impression of a good product.

I have seen a case when a scarzy server was replaced with a regular P4 PC without configuring system backups, intelli-mirror or other features - simply because the service provider who recommended the replacement did not know the difference, or was dishonest about it. Another provider who offered a second opinion sought to use the opportunity to push another brand of OS to the user.

Users should get definite information on the capabilities of the OS they use - compatibility with other systems, hardware requirements, etc.

But the OS makers have to share in the blame for OS bashing. Every OS maker knows its virtues and vices when compared to that of its competitors. Unfortunately, in selling their products, they sell the virtues, not the limitations.

As more novices become experts in PC handling, the grain would be sifted from the chaff.

by simon

Everyone hates Windows, because no matter what, however many years, however many programmers, Microsoft's ineptitude never ceases to amaze.

If Microsoft's programmers are so wonderful, how come their programms are so bloated? Using notepad, one could build a web page in 1k, using Microsoft's 'Front Page' the same web page would be 19k.

Upon install why are there 1000's of K to download in service packs, patches, critical updates.

No programmer is perfect, we all make mistakes. However, no one, I repeat NO ONE, programms 'bloatware' more ineptly, insecurely and slowly with more bugs and bulsh*% than a Microsoft programmer. FACT

by joe90fluke

The main problem at Microsoft is that they are probably so much under pressure that they do not revised and test their code enough before releasing it.
For an example:
How come in the dial up in Win2k you still cannot check the box "SAVE PASSWORD" and rely on it.
This bug was there in Windows 3.1 and is still there in Win2k.
Not enough. Microsoft did got the world used to the repeated crashes.
You take a Linux system like GNU Linux Debian
you will keep these machine up for years.
The only stop will be an hardware failure.
Reboot, Forget that word. If you use logical volumes you can repartition and resize those partitions without rebooting. The only time you need to reboot is when you decide to upgrade the kernel. Stable ? No, the word is not strong enough I would say granite ! Plus it is a real multitasking OS, Windows is not. Why ? Because in many cases some application will keep the ressources for themselves and not pass back the task token to the Windows OS.
Other major weaknesses of Windows: Apps don't track all the DLLs they copy in that common folder %System% \system32.
The registry is a labirynth where spywares can hide their starting orders for these adverse softwares to run.
Linux on the other side is a system that is purely file and library oriented. In Debian Gnu Linux for instance when you run an update the system checks all the libraries dependencies and re-align what need to be. The process is most of the time all done with no user intervention.
A security hole in Debain GNU Linux is found an posted to their site: The update is available within 24 hours. We can not say the same about Microsoft can we ?

So the ones that are asking themself why some IT people are bashing on Microsoft? Because we know
a lot better.

by deadly ernest

Most people who bag MS Windows do so because they are frustrated at seeing MS constantly claiming that the latest version is the most secure ever and almost immediately have to release a patch to correct a security flaw that they new about in earlier versions but have not corrected in the basic kernel code. The constant patches take time and effort to keep up with and often cause problems with other apps, but not all the time.

Then when you look at how much they charge for the latest product that is sold new with a known flaw. In the early days MS was very cheap and made for the lowest common denominator, it still is made the same way but the price is not so comparatively cheap now. Marketting is very sharklike and people don't like the aggressive marketting for a product with basic flaws.

That is the why of the bagging.

Another aspect is that the majority of the baggers were not around in the early days and do not know how much of what we see as the IT industry today is due to MS releasing very cheap software - MS Dos was about A$100 whilst the Mac OS was a few thousand, ditto Word and Excel. Using MS software could cut over A$15,000 off the total cost of a system.

by pbiss

The original development platform for Word Excel and Powerpoint was the Mac!!!
I have the diskettes to prove it - in my museum.

by codfieri

A large (very large) part of the problem of modern Operating Systems can be tied to bad programming and security flaws. Granted that those two things have existed since PCs have been around but the old DOS days had a much better track record w/ flaws in the OS, bugs in the software, and open security holes versus today w/ bloated OpSystems and sometimes incredibly buggy programming and more open security holes than ever. True we are doing much more w/ them but I am convinced better programming as well as better software QA and no real "rush to market" deadline would result in much better views on the OS and software in general.

by greenpirogue

Codfieri: Interesting point, but I would like to make an analogy. DOS was like a house with no windows and one door. All you had to do is deadbolt the door and you were safe. Windows is like a bigger house which has more rooms, more doors, windows and sliding glass doors out back. The trouble is that the architect (MS) has spent more time adding on than ensuring that the new additions (features) are secure.

I prefer MacOS but I exclusively use Windows at work. There are problems with the OS, but I griped about Mac OS 9 not having true multi-threading. Its all about give and take, and some of us are concerned about security, more so now that there are so many other threats out there.

by hal 9000

quite a lot of the places that I do work for don't use servers and only have rudimentary networks if at all. One place springs to mind where I've just put in a DSL router and all 4 stations are connected to this router for E-Mail & Internet but they refused to allow me to setup a network of any kind. Prior to that they where using Dial up and had 1 phone line for the 3 workstations that required Internet connectivity so short of using my own hardware and ghosting their drives I just live with what I've got to work with and get on with the job.

Generally when I need to reload one of these workstations it takes me well over 48 Hours to complete the install but I'll add a caveat to that for the first day or so I'm hunting all around the HDD saving their data before I even start to do a reinstall. While I do have storage in the Terabyte range I still can not store their entire drives contents on one of my drives and save time saving the data as then I would have to sort through the saved data and transfer across just the data that is necessary and not a lot of program & OS files that would only make a mess on a clean install.

For most of us reloading workstations is more than just pushing out software and an OS we have to first save the Data and then we can start doing what is required and at the same time scan the drive for any problems generally they have various infections of Viri, Worms, Trojans and the like as well as a almost unlimited supply of Spy Ware. That is where most of my time is spent doing a reload and after the thing is reloaded I then have to transfer the data back to where it came from so it is useful to them.

So while people like Jacqui and myself may say reload we actually mean something quite a bit different and far more involved. Most of us do not have the luxury of just being able to wipe a drive clean and reinstall and when the owner or worker asks where their data is we can't just shrug our shoulders and say too bad. :)

Col ]:)

by mike.morris

I would think that with an IQ of 180 you would know the definition of the word "dumb". In essence, are you stating that your users cannot speak? Most of my users can speak just fine, but are inherently stupid when it comes to computers, and some more so.

by gordon

Windows crashes because it is not a stable operating environment.
1. The native code is filled with thousands of lines that, it is reported, even the MS gurus aren't sure what it's there for - but they have to leave it because windows won't boot without it.

2. Please don't forget the meglomaniacal browser embedding, windows media embedding, etc designed to make you use MS products and nothing else.

3. The Free BSD we use to run our web servers has been up and stable for 8 years - without crashing through upgrades, hardware changes etc.

4. Mac OS is Unix with a cute GUI.

5. Windows has always been unstable and I've been running some version of windows since 2.0 - which usually crashed the system on the first boot and never worked again.(don't take my word for it,this one is part of history now).

6. Go to Microsoft.com and search the knowledge base for the phrase "Microsoft has confirmed this to be a problem".

7. If the IT folks and Techies didn't bash it, we'd never see an improvement.

8. check out http://www.us-cert.gov/cas/bulletins/SB05-201.html.

by beranekj

I'm happy for you that things seem so simple, so black & white. The MS OSen are inheritantly unstable, so blame the end-user for trying do actually use applications instead of just running notepad and calculator.

I co-supervise running Windows 200x, but also NetWare, Linux and AIX. The Windows boxen are babied to the point of only a single app per server, which is exceptionally expensive, but seems the only way to keep those systems with an uptime that comes close to the multi-purpose functions of the other 3 platforms. Everything is certified compatible, patched and configured exactly as each vendor has requested, yet MS still crashes, often.

MS is bashed because it has earned it, not because some poor end-user is just trying to do use what an OS is, in theory, supposed to be designed to do: an interactive environment for applications to run on various hardware.

by hal 9000

Was doing a pretty good job of trashing Sony a little while ago.

Not so much the appliance stuff but the company in general when they had a strike in Japan. :D

Col ]:)

by alan

I can't resist joining in this great topic! So many good points made here; I have yet another perspective to offer.

For one, I think many hate MS just because they are so big, so dominant and so rich. After all, we Americans just love the underdog and hate the big bully.

Secondly, I believe that at a certain point a company just becomes too big to operate effectively. MS tries to be everything to everyone and it just isn't really possible to do that effectively. They are a huge company with far too many programmers at varying levels of competence. As a programmer I am quite aware of the pitfalls of having too many cooks in the kitchen.

Strangely enough I really do believe that Windows earned its spot as the top dog, I've been around long enough to remember many of the alternatives and how they were lacking... things like OS 2 for instance. Back many years ago it was all too clear to me that Windows NT4 was vastly superior to OS 2. Even Linux is problematic, talk about a steep learning curve! You guys complain about the time to install Windows but neglect to mention how hard it is to learn Linux and all its quirks.

To conclude, I'm no great Windows lover but I do appreciate the user friendliness of the OS and the wealth of features that they offer.

by rosaticrew

As OS's such as Microsoft, Unix and so on first came out, they were touted as the end all to end all and were reviled by the mainframe folks, the operating system is always the target for some one who cannot do it his way because of limitations, cost or security. So there will always be a sence of jealousy or frustration by those who want all the bells and whistles that are no longer there or were never meant to be.

by ken lillemo

If you already are the top dog, you do not need to rub it in everyone's face. Microsoft has demonstrated a lack of tact that makes them seem more like a playground bully than a real leader. Microsoft sometimes responds to legitimate criticism with bluster and attack instead of an honest appraisal of their actions. Granted, they only do this sometimes, but it only takes once to undo a whole lot of good will achieved by many others at Microsoft.

As to the legitimacy of the criticism, the untold thousands of ways that an OS can be screwed up will mean that everyone will be blindsided by some small detail at some time. It is like the Sword of Damocles, just waiting to drop. It is this seed of numerous minor flaws in their product, along with Microsoft's failure to demonstrate an attitude of humble leadership, that grows into full fruition as Microsoft bashing.

Microsoft has it in their power to act differently, indeed, they occasionally do, but most often, after months of doing exactly the opposite. Consequently, Microsoft gets credit for succumbing to the will of the marketplace instead of leading the market to a new convergence. So Microsoft makes themselves a target by their own character. They have it in their power to be something better.

by xt john

How many times have you or I had to shrug and tell our users, 'it's just one of those Windows quirks'? Print spoolers crashing, BSOD, unexplained reboots. Upgrade 50 PC's to Srvice Pack 2, and 5 out of 50 will not boot back up, no matter how careful you were, making sure the computer was clean, etc. I agree, the whole Microsoft Monopolisitc mentality is NOT good for the IT world, but until Linux or whoever goes mainstream, Longhorn will be the next thorn in our sides, as well as all the patches for Office, ad nauseum.... BTW, Angus, most of us ARE careful about drivers, DO check the Event Viewer after a crash, visit Microsofts site often, run all updates; and have come to the conclusion, it IS a buggy, unpredictable, adequate operating system, that could be better.

by tundra gregg

Despite our daily reviews of the logs and extensive monitoring tools it still goes down for no apparent reason. I agree that their is always a reason and many times it is a patch from Microsoft that takes it down not our abilities unless you count star gazing, black magic and witchcraft.

by hellums

Microsoft is hated not because of jealousy or ineptitude, or 1000s of installed apps (it's unstable with just the OS, media players, Adobe reader, and MS Office installed, and you know it). Microsoft is hated because of:

1. Antitrust, what's that? Who, us? No!!! (note 0)
2. Predatorial tactics
3. Reliance on FUD marketing--nobody likes being manipulated and played
4. Unstable architecture under the hood (note 1)
5. Perpetual unreliability (note 2)
6. Blue screen of death, and those cool app freezes that allow you to make spiffy designs and patterns of window frames as you drag your dead soldier all over the screen
7. Default wide open security and then immediate denial of any "critical security flaw" and slow response when finally acknowledged (note 3)
8. Incessant attempts to imbed privacy-robbing features in software and hardware, then reluctant acquiescence to its user base
9. Incessant and needless baseline interface paradigm shifts (Search vs. Find... why? wgaf?)
10. Repeated failure to follow their own consistency model--Ctrl-F is find function in virtually every text-centric application (ever try it on Outlook? what next, play with Alt-F, Ctrl-C, and Ctrl-V too?)
11. Poor customer focus and service, with incessant, never-ending, weekly, monthly, and quarterly hotfixes, patches, and security releases (Service Pack? SERVICE?!?) (note 4)
12. Long-term inability to give us close to Apple quality at the Microsoft price they know is all we can afford, despite the quadrazillion billion dollars they've raked in over the decades (the Mac mini might be a junior Robin Hood, but we'll need more where that comes from)
13. We'll make it a baker's dozen--because realistically we have very little choice (Linux too complex for average user, Mac too expensive for all but elite). Microsoft knows this and exploits it, gets plumply rich on it. Nobody likes having spinach or brussel sprouts jammed down their throat time and time again, especially when the server sups on caviar, lobster, and Dom Perignon.

Note 0 - Hey, I was alive and kicking and reading the Compaq CEO's quotes in the trades when they were being squeezed out in the early 90s, but they eventually rolled over and played stupid for the Justice Dept (who didn't read the trades), before being slyly pardoned as expected by the Republican Party... saved by the bell

Note 1 - why does multitasking in Unix/Linux allow me to perform floppy operations yet still stay productive? try writing to a floppy or connecting to the Internet and see how impossible it is to get anything else done at the same time... it's still DOS under there in too many ways

Note 2 - esp. IE, esp. with multiple windows up--God forbid they add the obvious Tab feature Firefox finally "discovered"

Note 3 - and we usually find out that the flaw is in some useless chunk of crap architecture or software that allows God only knows who to let their PC talk to their refrigerator or toaster

Note 4 - and how is the normal user expected to get the patches installed? by connecting to the Internet, of course... problem being that before the first patch is installed the system has been compromised by hundreds if not thousands of vulnerability probes, often successful (and how many hours does it take to download XP SP2 over a 56K modem?)

by avid

i love the security flaws in M$ products. it is now and will always be a reliable income for me! :) but seriously, we all know that bill is a hell of a business man. if his product work well and was easy to use for everyone, he would not be able to make so much money from forcing recertification on us every year with the excuse that so much has "changed" that our previous certs are no longer "sufficient" for the IT market. just a thought..

by ironrose

In my job, most of the customers are using Windows. Any version of windows is job security. I work for a large ISP and we give limited support for windows. Our job in tech support is to make sure that the customer can get on the internet and get their email. We don't help them with any other windows problems, but we can advise them on possible solutions. Newbies to the internet are bombarded with spyware, browser hijackers, and blown winsocks. Windows has a nice, consistant GUI interface and so it is easy to guide people thru checking settings. If it wasn't for spyware & other windows problems, then we would need very many people in tech support. I love Mac OS X, but the only customers calling in with Mac OS X help are just wanting to get setup, mostly the people switching from Windows to Mac OS X. I have had very few problems with my Mac, but I am always "fixing" Windows, by doing spyware & virus scans, etc.

by bkiegel

And it's wrong to frivolously (sp?) 'bash' an OS just because you use another one (i.e. 'my team is better than your team' pass the testosterone)... However, my argument against windows (and I am an MCSE/MCSA so I come from the 'windows world') is that you can do all that correctly and still have problems. You can make sure every device is on the HCL, you can make sure that each and every program is still 100% MS compliant, and you still have issues. That's not to say that you wouldn't have some issues with other operating systems, but I do tend to have far fewer of those issues with my Linux boxes, and I have tweaked them in ways that Linux was never designed for... My gripe with Windows is that they have grown complacent, and it's probably because they are the 'big fish.'

by gvnmtwrkr

The only real complaint I have with Windows (server versions) is the way it initially assigns permissions. If you have Group Policies in effect this is not an issue but on the start-up it (Windows) basically gives you all rights until they are taken away whereas with, lets say Novell, you get no rights until they are assigned. With Windows I can never be sure I have taken away rights a User does not need and even then some of the rights are overlapping. Then you do have a work-around by setting them individually where needed and if you have a lot of Users this will create a lot of work unless you can Group them.
Otherwise I like Windows client and server versions.
Now security patches: that is a whole other topic and I believe that has been discussed at some length already!

by dvawter

Like you make a very good living off of Microsoft, I would be carefull bashing too much, if they make the software flawless you won't need to Fix it anymore, and I think that will affect your bottom line :)

David

by hal 9000

I work on a commission basis and it doesn't matter if I spend 1 hour or 600 hours per month at a clients I still get paid the same.

But the point in issue isn't my income but the way that I have to rush around when these business computers fall over.

It's the down time that is the killer as these places are "Mean & Lean" so they only have the bare minimum and when it fails it has to be fixed immediately as the down time is costing them money and lots of it.

I would much rather be paid on a hourly basis and be able to do routine maintenance once a month rather than having to drop everything at a moments notice to save several 100 K for one company because one of their computers has failed.

Lets face it I'm basically lazy and I do this because I love the work not for the money which I already have enough of anyway. If I wanted the money I would be back working for places like IBM as State Service Manager.

Col ]:)

by holv2279

I believe Angus is correct. These OSs now in day are so robust and strong and can do so many things, and vertually run anything. The biggest problem is having so many things running together at times. But the worst is the users that abuse, or don't know how to use a computer that cause the problems.

by keyguy13

I'm sorry, but that's crazy. I believe your translator is broken. Because I'm quite sure he was asking "Why would you want to do that?", not because he didn't want to change, but because changing to windows from Unix would be stupid.

And I think it's the Admin to your CEo that is afraid of change more than your IT guy. That's just dumb.

If the Admin to your CEO got used to using Linux, he'd never go back to Windows.

There are numerous reasons why linux is actually a better OS choice than windows. But my main reason is reliability.

I have two Linux boxes set up here where I work. One is a red hat 9 box and the other is a Mandrake 10 box. They have both been up and running for 187 days with no signs of quitting.

I have several windows 2003 servers that won't even go 14 days without needing a reboot because of memory leaks and other inherant flaws in the OS.

The idiot that said "you can't blame the OS" is obviously a serious rookie.

Spyware, Malware, Viruses, they all mess up Windows machines because Windows was written poorly and is a crappy OS. Period.

I don't get spyware on my linux boxes, nor do i get any trojans or other problems, because Linux is a relatively secure OS. Windows is not. And I seriously doubt it ever will be, because Bill Gates makes money off of software products that he sells to get rid of the stuff. Why would he just make his OS work properly when he can make more money leaving it the way it is? And since most people are either too stupid or too lazy to learn a different OS, Microsoft has dominated.

Those of us that expect more from our OS can certainly blame Microsoft for it's deliberate shortcomings and we won't stop bashing M$ until they provide an OS that is up to our standards.

by jmschattke9

Windows was made long after protected mode was implemented in hardware - but they STILL ave not got protected mode used properly.

Windows NT was made long after hardware MMUs were in the chips one would want to run it on. Windows NT derivatives still do not use hardware MMUs.

A simple test can be done to test the robustness of an operating system: write random data to random addresses, and see how many you can try to write before the thing crashes. Score a system where only the reandom write app crashes as perfect. The last figures I saw had Windows crashing at 25%; Unix was 75% IIRC.

Bad design and bad engineering. That's why Windows gets panned.

by jrussell_fl

My head's going to explode here. Basically because of Angus McLaren's cluelessness. Reality check time - you state "I could sit here and bash linux, windows, mac os and anything else, but that is just pointless and pedantic." (pedantic good word :) )

The real point is no one bashes mac os, linus, unix, aix, etc. At least no with the regularity that comes with windows bashing. I do agree that a large part of the bashing comes from either newbies who couldn't tell a printer driver from a NASCAR driver or tha mac os cultists. But the fact of the matter is that Windows (you pick the version) in many many instances just doesn't function as advertised.

As far as crashing for a reason; I absolutely agree. You just shouldn't have to spend days and days searching for the reason only to find out the Microsoft neglected to document that if you install A before B the OS doesn't like that so much basically because the overworked, overburdened team of developers never got around to testing A before B because the sales team was running around shouting - "we have to launch! we have to launch!" Unfortunately this environment breeds the heck-that's-what-patches-are-for mentality.

To end my tirade I must say that while a lot of the "Win-doze" bashing has some merit it does get a little tiresome and people in IT need to welcome into their lives that MS Windows is here and a large part of their customer base uses it. So learn it. Talk to people to try to avoid some of the frustrations and quit whining.

by bcbachman

To put things in context I know my tech profile is worthless. I am a MCSE for NT4 so I know something about windows. I have maintained VMS Unix adn M$ systems. My most current complaint with M$ is when installing the Win2K SP4 rollup on a perfecly good machine caused a BSOD. The quality of patches, service paks is questionable at best. When I call M$ it is a known problem, but do you see any acknoledgement in M$ Also customer at M$ is problem? If my company treated our customers the way M$ treats the buying public it would not stay in busines!!

by dvawter

I think any IT person that does not recognize the value if windows (even with all of it's flaws) is so burried in thier technology they have forgotten what it's like to not understand a PC. Sure Linux is Great, and would be my first choice for most server applications. But if you spent 2 weeks at my job, and delt with the end users that I have, you would quikly realize that Windows is far supperior as a desktop product, simple because it is easier for non computer users to understand. I have people that can't even recognize when their username is wrong, there is no way I am going to teach them to use a linux desktop.

David

by cabr

I run a 40+ WINDOWS server farm; I haven't had any crashes attributed to the OS. It's either poorly written hardware drivers or 3rd party software that is ALWAYS the culprit. If you aren't smarter than the computer, then you're in the wrong field. After all, they're only machines that do what you tell them to do...

by taylor.carl

Was Windows ME perfect? Why isn't CPM still around? It is up to the software developer to create a robust system or other software that WILL NOT CRASH. A system that serves the user, not the other way around. When I was taught programming (30 years ago), it was unheard of to turn in any software until it was throughly tested under all imaginable conditions. Today, it is accepted practice to produce crap, full of bugs, just to beat the competition to the market, and then issue patches and service packs later. I think it is time to ditch Windows, Linux, Unix, MacOS, and all others, and ditch the present day outdated hardware architecture, and start over to design a real operating system, and hardware based upon the best of what we know about all operating systems and hardware, and how computer science should REALLY work. The systems of tomorrow should be backwards compatible will all previous platforms, as user-friendly as your own mother, and as secure and robust as can be imagined. Then made to be the world standard. Of course it can't happen. On the one hand, the old and tired technologies are MOSTLY replaced by new, improved models. But, also, big business and under the counter wheeling and dealing sometimes work together to produce and foister onto the public inferior products. Example: The early macintosh, an obviously superior and innovative technology, at the time, overshadowed by an architecture based on older, and less innovative designs, simply because of money and marketing. The obviously superior Beta-Max being ousted by the inferior VHS technology because of under the counter wheeling and dealing. None of this based upon which is actually the superior technology, but upon which rich fat cat kisses which other rich fat cat's butt, leaving the public to suffer the consequences.

Just kidding, of course, but, on the other hand, computers should be, and eventually will be practically nonexistent in the form we know of them today. Keyboards and mice will practically disappear along with mechanical harddrives. Software will become firmware everywhere, and will be easier to use than a toaster, by anyone, without training. Really, the general public should NOT have to gain a PHD just to use a piece of hardware or software intended from the start to be a tool. We are forced to concentrate upon and bend to the whim of the overly complicated "hammer" when we should be concentrating upon "building the house" by using the hammer.

by hellums

If one more person tries to tell me that my keyboard and mouse will be obsolete in the near future, I'll shove a boot up that person's rear, if I can get it around their daydreaming head. I'm sick of such tripe. Voice recognition software has improved from 90% reliability to probably 96-97%, but do you see the mainstream using it? No. Why? Because it's hard to build a better mousetrap than the keyboard and mouse. Certain input and interface devices will not change considerably in our time. QWERTYUIOP.

by taylor.carl

I am sorry that I pushed a hot button with you, and got you so upset. I come by it honestly, though. I have degrees in Biology, Computer Science, and Electronics Engineering, and due to that I gravitated toward, and have done a far amount of work in Alternate Interface technologies for the physically impaired (particularly for the blind and quadriplegic). Therefore, it is a passion for me to see interface technologies progress rather than stand still, as you can surely understand. Personally, I use a keyboard and mouse, and would definitely prefer to continue to do so because I love it, and because I am not particulary physically impaired. I just wish my hands didn't have to leave the keyboard to use my mouse. (Maybe I could make a rectal joystick shaped like a boot!)

Getting back to the original topic of discussion, viewing your other posts, I was sure, and still am, that for the other statements I made on my rant, you would mostly tend to agree.

by leonard j rivera sr.

To say all OS problems is the fault of the user is crazy and on another note, to say all OS problems are the vendors fault is just as crazy.

I've hosed Windows plenty of times by making simple mistakes during the course of my "learning years" which BTW I am still learning, something new everyday.

I've also seen new patches hose the OS and have seen fixes to fixes consistantly published by M$ and other OSes.

People will always bash what ever it is they see as inferior to what they prefer.

An OS is a tool not matter which one you choose.

Hey old timers.... remember the days of the Amiga Workbench? Best OS I ever remember using for it's time. We were the biggest bashers of windows in those days. Look at it now (at best it exists in an emulator with vapor promises of return), and please don't lie to me and say you've never seen the red blinking Guru Meditation error.

As long as those tools remain troublesome (no matter what or who's to blame) I know I'm getting paid to fix it.

Be careful what you ask for, right behind that perfect, secure, easy to configure user friendly OS is your pink slip.

by lachandler2000

I have been there for all the Microsoft OS releases. Some have been outright buggy here-and-there, but what else was there? I admit my experiences have taught me a lot of new swear words.
Over the years Windows has become more and more stable, even for the non-tech. But, as to proper installs, even new drivers can be designed wrong. What I like about XP is that when a machine suddenly crashes the OS can report on what happened and if you like, can let Microsoft know about it.
I think that today the biggest problems I see with Windows is that many hardware and software manufacturers don't make their products to play nice. They tend to be proprietary to the point that it is near impossible to be productive using compeditive products on the same machine. Plug and play becomes plug and suffer. Though most times I don't see the hardware being as faulted as the accompanying software. This is probably one of the central reasons XP reports incompatability issues before upgrading.
I think Microsoft has a great developer raport and they do listen to our problems. How many software makers offer so much help and free stuff to make your computing experience smoother. Everything can't be fixed by complaining, but recognizing a problem is the first step to a solution.
Bash no more!

by johnofstony

Angus McLaren sounds like a Windows fundamentalist. If no-one criticises Windows, how will Microsoft know what Windows users are dissatisfied with? As an IT professional there are many things I dislike about Windows, not least is its tendency to crash rather often. I used to work for a security company supplying equipment to prisons which just had to be reliable. We used Motorola 68020 processors running the OS9 operating system and in over 10 years of continuous operation on 16 sites I never encountered a single crash due to the operating system, only to hardware failure. Another major irritant about Windows is the way Microsoft keeps changing the look and feel. Then there are the "security" features which make it impossible for anyone who hasn't got administrator privileges to do anything beyond data entry. Then there are the frequent patches to attempt to stop hackers getting access to users' PCs. Yes, Windows has provided a universal common platform for software developers and I'm not saying that Windows doesn't have its good points, but if Microsoft would concentrate on making Windows reliable, compact and fast instead of adding more and more bells and whistles which require ever more powerful hardware to run merely so that today's software runs almost as fast as that of 10 years ago, then I'd be more than happy to give Microsoft my wholehearted support.

by rajkpb

This is the reason, A gentleman earlier said that if you can't maintain windows and you are not aware how to go about it, then shame on you!

Raj

by jkmasters

There is a reason why M$ has used those 3 keys to bring up the login, users of the earlier versions got used to the key combination.

by rmuldavin

Good coments from Angus, but I have some confusion over the term "operating system", so this post.

My HP pavilion ze4560us laptop no longer shuts down through the MS windows system, this I've been experiencing for three window computers since 1997, it occurs when other licensed vendors' software of MS are allowed to use the MS systems.

My rationale is that the computer when turned on from the power source must wake up from the CMOS where a battery or some other powerless way is made to store the manner in which the BIOS is set by the vendors.

Thus if the MS shut down does shut down, MS owns the machine.

Ofen I watch the MS Task Manager as the CPU is ranked, to see which of the .exe, cc, or system ranks, often there is a lower level.

My i-mac offers the 0,1, 2, 3 ranking, that is consistent with my understanding of "ownership", that follows the remote programming control (rpc) within a networking system.

For my above laptop, the lower right corner dual monitor, the forefront one, send, the background one, recieve, the MS automatic download, it appears this dual monitoring system does not show activity, and, I recall, neither does th "status" window.

Add that last week when flying from our local airport where all laptops are scanned with an instrument the size of almost 3 by 3 feet with a probe attached, my laptop, the attendant expalained, was identified as containing something, he showed, at its center bottom.

Filling out a form, he said that this was not a normal result.

Being on our local American Civil Liberties Board, I was interested, but not concerned in the sense that if my computer has an ID tag, much like the VIN (vehicle identification number) it might be a way of tracking potential owners of laptops.

Subsequently upon returning from my destination to my hometown, the departure airport waived all computers by without checking.

So, since I've learned as the above post cautioned that my own tendency to blame the operating system and vendors for operational problems, in fact to blame "others" for my own "ignorance" (an understandable human trait) I was asking myself questions, since at a motel at the destination Santa Fe, my wireless laptop was unable to connect to the Internet in the evening, but early in the morning, using the motels own desktop, got one post off.

At the departure airport, busy with many laptop users both before and after securtiy (that waived throug laptop users) their systems worked well.

So I'm still thining about this:

(1) Does NSA (or other type "snoopers") have a "backdoor"?;
(2) If so, what type, that is, and ID system is one thing, but could they have a way of blocking access to the Internet if a laptop?;
(3) And, did the fact that by having to shut down my laptop with the power button, even after going though the Windows shutdown that does not shutdown prevent a possible NSA type insertion through the center bottom of the laptop?

None the less, the important issue is my trying to dicipline myself from being "paranoid" as I tend to do for most robot and machine failures.

Best, rmuldavin

by hellums

To answer your questions in order:

1. Yes, NSA has a backdoor into your laptop and PC
2. We can't tell you the type or how it's done, because it's obviously classified--even if we release it by court order all the good parts will be blacked out (just like we do random UFO document requests)
3. Yes, the manual power button shutdown is one of our biggest backdoor entry mechanisms (of course, now we may have to come up with another one, since you're on to us, at least--there may be others, and we can't risk it)

Many people may think that we at NSA don't have the resources to monitor all communication from everyone and create backdoors that we can exploit in every mechanical, electronic, or digital communication device. This is not true. We can. We do. We will as long as we can. Why do we do this? Because underneath we're really just an ancient and secret religious cult that is trying to prevent you the citizen from downloading porn or talking bad about elected officials, not to mention kids using foul language and hacking computer games. We have to stop this somehow, and we have to do it now. Thank God there are like-minded people at all the hardware device manufacturers that allow us to do this for little or no fee (we need all our funding for monitoring, naturally), and luckily nobody has ratted us out yet or confirmed suspicious like yours. Good luck, and may the Force be with us (not with you--you're the evil one here, you porn hound, and you sicken us).

by tewman2

I grew up with a Texas Instruments TI-99, and following that an 8088 with MSDos-4.5. I?ve used Linux, All different versions of Windows, Novell for Networks, Macs, from the old apple IIe to Mac OSX .
The worse operating system that I?ve seen was windows me, it had the most bugs, and compatibility issues, I read some place shortly after it?s release that Microsoft released it as an unfinished product, they did this to help promote sales of windows for people who didn?t need the network capabilities of windows 2000. I almost refuse to support windows me. I have customers that will be having problems with there AOL software, and once we get the AOL fixed, the computer no longer boots properly, all we had done is reinstall the AOL software, and reconfigure the modem inside of AOL, not windows, yet it still messed it up.
Windows is by far my favorite OS, simply because it has the most vendors offering software for it, and it is the most widely used OS out there. Mac and Linux both have some great features, but they have the same problems as Windows, if they were as widely used, as Windows they would look like the worst OS out there, as more people would be trying to exploit the flaws in that operating system.
For networking, it seems that Novell requires far less work to keep a network stable and secure, however, I?m not as proficient with Novell as I am with the upper Microsoft products, I have one of our other admins service it.
It really comes down to a matter of personal preference, if you like doing a little more configuration to configure things to what you are using a pc for, go with Linux. If you want a PC for high-end graphics and video, go with a Mac. If you want a good everyday use pc that?s easy to use, and has lots of software options go with Windows.
It?s ignorant to bash Windows, just because it?s flaws have been more exploited then the one you prefer. It?s just as ignorant to bash Linux when you are not familiar with the ends and outs of the OS.

by hellums

Microsoft is hated not because of jealousy or ineptitude, or 1000s of installed apps (it's unstable with just the OS, media players, Adobe reader, and MS Office installed, and you know it). Microsoft is hated because of:

1. Antitrust, what's that? Who, us? No!!! (note 0)
2. Predatorial tactics
3. Reliance on FUD marketing--nobody likes being manipulated and played
4. Unstable architecture under the hood (note 1)
5. Perpetual unreliability (note 2)
6. Blue screen of death, and those cool app freezes that allow you to make spiffy designs and patterns of window frames as you drag your dead soldier all over the screen
7. Default wide open security and then immediate denial of any "critical security flaw" and slow response when finally acknowledged (note 3)
8. Incessant attempts to imbed privacy-robbing features in software and hardware, then reluctant acquiescence to its user base
9. Incessant and needless baseline interface paradigm shifts (Search vs. Find... why? wgaf?)
10. Repeated failure to follow their own consistency model--Ctrl-F is find function in virtually every text-centric application (ever try it on Outlook? what next, play with Alt-F, Ctrl-C, and Ctrl-V too?)
11. Poor customer focus and service, with incessant, never-ending, weekly, monthly, and quarterly hotfixes, patches, and security releases (Service Pack? SERVICE?!?) (note 4)
12. Long-term inability to give us close to Apple quality at the Microsoft price they know is all we can afford, despite the quadrazillion billion dollars they've raked in over the decades (the Mac mini might be a junior Robin Hood, but we'll need more where that comes from)
13. We'll make it a baker's dozen--because realistically we have very little choice (Linux too complex for average user, Mac too expensive for all but elite). Microsoft knows this and exploits it, gets plumply rich on it. Nobody likes having spinach or brussel sprouts jammed down their throat time and time again, especially when the server sups on caviar, lobster, and Dom Perignon.

Note 0 - Hey, I was alive and kicking and reading the Compaq CEO's quotes in the trades when they were being squeezed out in the early 90s, but they eventually rolled over and played stupid for the Justice Dept (who didn't read the trades), before being slyly pardoned as expected by the Republican Party... saved by the bell

Note 1 - why does multitasking in Unix/Linux allow me to perform floppy operations yet still stay productive? try writing to a floppy or connecting to the Internet and see how impossible it is to get anything else done at the same time... it's still DOS under there in too many ways

Note 2 - esp. IE, esp. with multiple windows up--God forbid they add the obvious Tab feature Firefox finally "discovered"

Note 3 - and we usually find out that the flaw is in some useless chunk of crap architecture or software that allows God only knows who to let their PC talk to their refrigerator or toaster

Note 4 - and how is the normal user expected to get the patches installed? by connecting to the Internet, of course... problem being that before the first patch is installed the system has been compromised by hundreds if not thousands of vulnerability probes, often successful (and how many hours does it take to download XP SP2 over a 56K modem?)

by middleagednewbie

I can't address why other OSs might get bunged, but this post *nails* why MS draws complaints; rapacity, design issues and a smug mindset. Users are flocking to MS alternatives because they like the way issues are handled better, for one thing.

To draw a parallel from applications, Mozilla has been quick to acknowledge and patch problems with Firefox, while MS has ignored known problems and left IE users out to the wind. Who's growing faster, and getting plugs from security experts like Dan Golding? Firefox.

My conclusion? Competence may play a role in some gripes, but a great many are self-inflicted by the vendor.

by ronaldm

Couldn't say it better. There is plenty of ignorance on both sides of the fence as has been so clearly demonstrated by yourself.

by sheeva

Hellums' post was quite succinct and outlined correctly many of the reasons MS is the "monster under the bed". Through their business model they have coerced a majority of the North American computing community into believing in all those marketing slogans, i.e. "Where do you want to go?" as if they are the only ones capable of providing such grandiose dreams.

Like others, I appreciate MS for their creativity and thank them for my continuing employment. Bashing is not what comes to my mind. However, MS is the biggest and brashest and puts itself in the "brag lane" every minute of every day. So although other vendors or PC products may well deserve some criticism, MS has truly and honestly earned it. So these posts and any industry published articles espousing "poor MS" - get a life. We're global and MS has not been very good to everyone globally.

As an aside, one thing to remember is that O/S as MS has promoted is a means to an end that's different for HOME users than BUSINESS users. But we are stuck with the current mode of thinking that one flavor should fit all because MS (and previously IBM) told us so.

O/S should be as ubiquitous as good 'ole POTS (your telephone land line). In the early days even POTS had it's detractors (users and businesses); it was a monopoly with predatory bushiness practice; and service stunk in many locations for many years. But now we all take POTS for granted and have begun to direct our "b**ch & complaints" onto the mobile phone service arena.

So do I feel sorry for any of these guys? No and no way. So why should we all be concerned about MS bashing at all?

To vendors, MS not withstanding, we need to make them understand our consumer mantra which is, "Give me what I want, when I want it, for little or no cost and make sure I never have to talk to you again unless I tell you that I want it different."

by mipsv

Anybody who is a real IT or has anything approaching knowledge of computing platforms knows very well that Microsoft and Intel together couldnt make a real computer system if they stole the designs from companies who could (they used to be able to take the money though). Maybe MS hires "really smart people" but the really smart people are just for show and they don't have a damn thing to do with what gets released to customers.
And about "install the correct drivers"... good luck - more like try to install the drivers and hope Windows takes them. Its not the technology its the business majors who have no business being in technology companies who have ruined the IT field with Wintel garbage. There are plenty of ways to make Linux (or Solaros or AIX of all things) work just fine for the "ordinary user" - scripts, a few new drivers, oh and how about do it see your job leave for China, India or some other place where they don't care about things like freedom, shopping malls, food, human rights, and they think women are disposable (India and especially China)? Oh these places shoot people like Gates and Barrett when they get in the way they don't bother with justice departments and IRS audits. Windows sucks because these companies just don't think they can fail. They need to look at GM and decide if they want to suffer the same fate... only it took GM a lot longer to get where they are though they had plenty of warnings and plenty of time to fix themselves.

by dvawter

If the Admin got used to using linux he/she would be about ready to retire. Linux is not as easy to learn as microsoft, I am sorry plain fact. Yes it has flaws, yes it's less stable, but you have been doing IT so long, you have forgotten how frustrating trying to learn a computer can be. Linux is not polished, it's not intuitive, it seems to be to you, because you are used to it. Users are like sheep, they say "oooh the pretty colors" and it's a done deal. Linux will need 2 things to replace windows on coperate desktops.

1) More cosmetic polish as to appeal more to the non computer user.

2) Support, Support, Support. Small companies that cannot afford IT staff are going to want to be able to call Red Hat to find out how to restart thier PC.

Since most employees enter the workforce via small companies, they get trained on Windows first. To use an analogy, Stick shift is way better than Automatic. Anyone who drives a stick will tell you this. Better Gas Mileage, more control. How many drivers that drive automatic exclusivly are willing to learn stick?

You are not going to get the support, or the cosmetic polish is not going to come without a corperation driving the development, and if that happens, it's not open source anymore.

If you can't keep your 2003 box up more than 14 days, you have no business administrating one. I have a production install of small business server that runs for 2 and 3 months at a time, and only needs to be reboot due to updates.

No one gets spyware on their linux boxes:

A) Because people running linux are smart enough not to click "Yes" on any box that appears.

B) Because Windows having over half a market share, so noone is writing spyware for linux.

by tech

Angus,

I have worked over 30 years in the IT field, and have experience with many different operating systems. From the Honeywell/GE GECOS, through the Burroughs OS and DEC O/S 10, into the Mini-era (RSX-11M on the PDP-11/70 is still the most elegant computing platform ever created.) and on into PC's. Out of all of them, Windows is the sloppiest written piece of code I have ever seen. I describe it to my clients like this: "Windows is made up of abhout 80 million lines of programing code, written by 20,000 different people, and none of them talk to each other." I have seen Windows spontaneously blue-screen for no reason whatsoever, and then not have that particular problem for months at a time. Windows is just a bad piece of software with an 800 pound marketing gorilla behind it. Remember: Everytime we by a Microsoft Windows product, we pay for the privlege of being a beta-tester for Microsoft! All of their stuff is market-driven software...

by mark.paris

Windows has great familiarity because it's been forced upon most folks. However, speaking from a perspective of using 12 different operating systems for many, many purposes over the last 20 years: the ONLY unstable operating system in the bunch is Windows. Of their collection, NT is the most stable, but I give it a 90%-95% rating. It's not a 'drivers' issue, it's an 'intolerance of hardware failure' issue. The heart of Windows requires a PC running at 100% reliability, with 100% response to the OS's whims. It is the ONLY operating system that is so egotistical as to think that hardware failures, delays, or self-diagnostics should never happen, that all of their time should be devoted to running Windows. Hence, the root problem.

For space reasons, I will only note 2 other OSes in comparison: DOS (non necessarily Microsoft's version) and QNix. Both of these can load the entire OS (and drivers) into RAM, ROM or a different swap hard disk upon boot. This allows for redundance when running: if a call is made to, say, a "sleeping" or 'suddenly dead' hard disk and no response comes within, say, 0.500 second, the OS then can remake the call to the alternate location, like in RAM or EPROM, to complete the task. The result in a failure situation is a slight delay, along with a 'hook' to let someone know that something is wrong.

In this situation, all versions of Windows simply crash. This makes Windows unsuitable for any kind of reliable computing, including Servers. In fact, I have Windows NT Server, Windows 2000 Server and (briefly) Windows 2003 Server running here: all 3 versions leak memory and require rebooting at some point because none of them can effectively manage their own resources. AND...no other server I've ever used does this - not VMS, not PDP-11 machines, not Linux, not QNix.....

'Nuff said? If not, I can go on and on....

by paredown

Per previous post:
"You just shouldn't have to spend days and days searching for the reason only to find out the Microsoft neglected to document that if you install A before B the OS doesn't like that so much basically because the overworked, overburdened team of developers never got around to testing A before B because the sales team was running around shouting - "we have to launch! we have to launch!" Unfortunately this environment breeds the heck-that's-what-patches-are-for mentality."
Sadly confirmed several years ago during an after-dinner conversation with a very senior M$ person, who felt that the marketers dominated the release cycle to such a degree that a large number of v. gifted senior M$ players who wanted to write (in Steve Jobs's words) "insanely great" code left to start their own ventures . . .
??And whose bright idea was it to integrate an exploitable browser into a server O/S, leave the default security settings so open (now partially "fixed") AND allow a server side install to be finished using NO password--Really!!!
The famous hack of M$'s own development system took place because someone had not put a password on the admin account...
Say no more--they deserve criticism.

by keyguy13

How can you sit there and say that M$ is only getting bashed because they have a higher market share, when you admitted that you have only dabbled in UNIX/Linux?

You don't really have a leg to stand on...

When you actually spend some time with UNIX and Linux, then come back and argue your case. I highly doubt you will be defending M$ at that point...

by donpeach

There are a couple reasons I sometimes bash windows.First, it
the number one system out there. You are almost forced to use
it. Everyone like to bash the top dog.
This is not to say I don't bash the other OS's. I do. But when you
are the top dog, and have an endless amount of money to back
up your product, you'd think you could make it nice and clean
running.
I've been using Novell's SUSE 9,3 lately. It hasn't crashed yet. It's
not perfect, but it's fast and clean running. I also use OS X on a
Mac. Seems super stable. No crashes for me so far.
Windows has improved over the years, but i believe they have a
ways to go to make it as stable as others on the market.

by Member 28898618

So you count stability as two reasons?

There are several millions lines of code in Windows, there are thousands of companies worlwide using it. It provides support in dozens of languages and cultures. It is so vast, that you have to have special training just to properly support it.

All of this, and your prime criteria is how often in crashes. Which is often not the OS at all, but the hardware, the skill of the operator, the loading of third party crap that is not tested properly to run with it, the attachment of non suppported hardware, the lack of sufficient resources in memory or disk, the late application of patches, the probability that the infrastructure is not clean, on and on and on.

The mac is not an enterprise machine, it is a toy. The Unix flavors are still user unfriendly, and are not mature on the client side. Windows is just as "stable" as any of the others. It is an emotional statement to say otherwise. Notice noone has published empirical data on this statement, it comes from the fantasy, and myth among techies who just need to bash something larger than themselves.

by norm cimon

Windows 2000/XP Pro are very different beasts than the junk we started with. Gates and his minions realized - after they saw what was emerging from Apple via Xerox PARC - that MS-DOS was not the future of computing. (For their earliest thoughts, get hold of some of the quotes on memory needs, multi-tasking and whether color screens were needed for a real yuk).

But by then, they had a base of users who would have to be brought along. What followed was almost 20 years of outdated code embedded in Windows right up to Win 98 (with a few shards still floating around in there even now).

This was the equivalent of placing a semi on 26" bicycle wheels: the system fell over all the time. I probably mis-spent 6 months of my life reviving systems that had died for the oddest of reasons. We were simply given a lot of very bad code to support for quite a long time.

This ties in with many of the other comments as well. Users often had no idea what was going on and blamed themselves or their IT people. So that we're all on the same page here, it was not unusual to have individual systems lockup just about every day, not because of poor support but because of untested drivers, memory trashing, shared address space that fell to contention and a thousand other ills to which the Windows flesh was heir.

by david.marchesi

Like all sweeping statements it just isnt true...
Windows can have issues such as security flaws and exploits you cannot do anything about, you cant call someone who slates windows OS's rubbish just because they dont like windows.

by tlea

Fist of all, I agree that installing hardware improperly can cause a systems to crash. That said, what do you do if the OS identifies the hardware improperly and causes itself to crash? My first install of Windows XP improperly identified my ATA 100 drive as a SCSI device without telling, yet still installed the OS. Needless to say the OS would not boot properly. (Actually I was pretty amazed that the install got to the point of booting at all.) The work around was to install Windows 2000 and upgrade to XP. This issue has been fixed, but it was not MY fault that the OS did this.

I have also had Linux fail for various reasons associated with hardware. Like faulty PCMCIA card drivers. Once again I don't this it is unreasonable to expect the provided software to function correctly with the provided hardware.

Don't even get me started on Mac OS. I will say that I have yet to use OS X (Which is a huge improvement) but their previous OS's had plenty of problems. If they had more market share, you would see more vulnerabilities.

That said, I like Windows (2000 or later). The OS is easy to use, and I have NEVER crashed it with just software (Once again 2000 or later). I also liked OS/2, too bad IBM had their heads up their butts on marketing that product. I also like Linux.

From a security standpoint the 'nix OS's have had their fair share of issues over the years, but that experience has translated into a more secure OS and better practices. Windows has experienced some of the same growing pains, and had a lot of catching up to do.

Now for my point, I half agree with you. The user, admin, operator, whoever can have a large impact on the security and stability of an OS. But, better design and default settings can help mitigate these issue. Like in Windows or 'nix case, not having every service under the sun running for a default install. Some of my first distros of Linux has BIND and FTP installed and running by default! Nice. MS is VERY guilty of have bad default settings for its OS installs, but they have gotten better.

The thing is, not everyone that uses a computer is an IT person. My mom, for example, used here computer for e-mail, web browsing, and digital photography. That's it. She shouldn't need to know how to configure a firewall or how to shut down services. Is it her fault that she didn't spend years learning about computer security and maintenance? No, because she shouldn't have to.

That said, yes Windows gets a bad rap. Is it deserved? Yes, because MS is a profit driven orginization that has historically the bottom line before stability and security. (The many versions of Windows up through ME were hunks of crap in terms of stability.) On the other hand the amount of people that still bash the OS's stability have obviously not used one of their latest incarnations.

Personally, I use Linux for my home servers because I'm not willing to shell out the big dollars for a commercial OS, but I do use Windows XP and 2000 on my desktops. For my wife and kids it is the best solution.

If you really want to see stable and secure OS's check out the mid-range and main-frame crowd.

Disclaimer: These are just my opinions. I have not researched any facts to support these opinions, they are based on personal experience. I can't remember what day it is most of the time so what I say should taken with a grain of salt, as my opinion may be completely different tomorrow, whenever that is.

by raymond danner

Windows v1.0 was an /unauthorized port/ of Macintosh OS to the x86. Things have gone downhill from there, frankly.

1. Flaw #1 in Windows: Monolithic architecture.
This means that any app can kill the whole OS (or vice-versa.)
2. Flaw #2 is much worse. Microsoft has a long, sordid history of not caring to fix bugs. (They knew of a showstopper bug in one of their programming languages from version 1.0 on; fixing required a /single-byte/ patch, and they /publically/ stated that they had /no/ interest in /ever/ fixing it.)

Just those two flaws causes Windows to be a huge kludge and (IMO) a massive set of security risks.

by tlea

1. The first version of Windows ripped off the Mac GUI elements, not the actual code. Apple was suing MS for copying their look and feel, not for stolen code. Apple lost.

2. Windows NT/2000/XP uses a microkernel architechture based on the principles used in Mach. Applications and services as well as drivers run in protected memory spaces preventing them from inadvertently thrashing each other. NT class OSes are considered microkernel architechture not monolithic.

3. I am curious as to what this one byte patchable critial flaw is. Could you please tell me so that I can determine if I need to change this one byte myself?

by Member 28898618

Most IT Techs are:

1. Young and immature
2. Trained on the job, not formerly
3. Often have hacker-like personalities, that is, they are arrogant, and often anti-social personalities.
4. Tend to blame things they dont understand - and often characterize their users as acting the same way.
5. Do not have a background in software engineering, which does not stop them from making remarks about the software they are charged to install and maintain.
6. Are self-important, often try to create job security by not sharing their experiences and knowledge - these are the primary types to make silly remarks about the strengths and weaknesses of Windows. In other words, they are threatened by Micrisofts power and success.

The truth is pretty raw, those who get defensive about these truths will reveal many of the attributes above. Personal attacks, or references to "you dont know what you are talking about" come from the mind of a mentality of inferiority.

by kelly.nelson

What??? Can you please look in your add/remove programs and count how many "updates" there are in an XP install without SP2?? Now ask yourself WHY are there SO many patches?? I thought there wasn't anything wrong with the OS?? What are the patches for if it's just a "compatibility" issue? Patches admit fault, admit something wasn't right to begin with - so it needed to be fixed. And your telling me that's the techies fault?? Gimmee a break buddy. So I guess the shuttle Discovery's crash was the astronauts fault. If they were better astronauts then the shuttle wouldn't have been damaged at launch? You're right any OS crashed for any reason and I'll put my money on those who designed it. I mean come on, even the some of the update names say it all... hotFIX (Fix being the keyword)

by marcel lecker

Everyone knows Stability/security are mutually opposed to Usability/Complexity. MS chose to listen to the customer. That makes them a good business. They opted to complicate things in order to make them more appealing to John Doe in accounting.

John Doe doesn't have the time or inclination to figure out how to use NetWare, or some Unix Variant, but can be serving up files and print-jobs in no time, because MS is easy to use.

There is certainly something to be said for that ...in an ideal world.

The reality is this early choice created a difficult problem. Namely Crackers, viruses and worms etc. were able to exploit the inherent weaknesses that were a by-product of the complexity that allowed it to be more usable than anything at the time.

Without re-engineering the OS from the ground up, it is difficult to take the code base and turn it from an orange into a mango. They've (MS) been trying to do it bit by bit and only making small scale improvements. Longhorn, might be a big step toward a more balanced state because it is apparently largly a re-write. We'll have to see how that plays out. We've been promised things before....

Another point is they are a business. A really big one. Open source advocates see this stifling (not fostering) growth and innovation, much like patents, NDAs, etc. do to science.

The Open Source community works much more like a scientific/academic body. Unhindered exchange of information is a priority and growing the body of knowledge as whole rather than in commercially controlled silos is also a priority. Amateur astronomy is a classic example of public participation in the development of a body of knowledge.

Why people bash Microsoft? Because they failed to adapt quickly enough to what other OS developers realised was happening (i.e. increasing need for stability and security). They also failed to adapt quickly enough to the changes in the software development ecosystem and while they are doing so they are insisting they are the better product. That leads to a credibility issue.

Marcel

by jpaullanier

if
everyone bashes Windows
and
anyone who hates Windows is not a true techie
then
no one is a true techie!

regards, Paul

by keyguy13

While I agree that they continue to improve SOME aspects of their OS with each new version.In my opinion, they don't address the fundamental issues that most techs bash windows over. They claim they are working on the security problems but all that seems to happen with each patch, is more security problems. They HAVE made it more stable, but considering the older versions reliability, it is still WAY inferior to Unix, Linux and other OSes when it comes to crashes.

They need to stop reinventing the wheel with their office upgrades and their live meeting crap and focus ALL of their attention on making the OS at least close to as reliable and functional as the other OSes out there.

We don't bash microsoft just to hear our voices. We have legitimate concerns with M$ and windows. There are REAL problems with it. And just because your standards might be lower than ours, doesn't mean we are going to stop striving for a better OS. I mean, if we HAVE to work with windows, we want it to work properly for the unbelievably inflated price we pay for it.

by unixwolf.edu

After reading your post I could not help but laugh out load, especially when you wrote ?You don't ever bash the OS, in fact if the OS crashes then it's your fault not the OS?. It is true for some of the problems that happen on the Wintel platform the blame could be placed on the admin of that machine; but after everything is said and done the responsibility falls back onto the OS and its developers. I am sure you have never downloaded an update from the OS developer and had your system crash. Oh, and lets not even consider that after all the patching, driver, and virus definition updating is done, how the Windows platform is still one big security hole. While every OS has its share of problems in this area, and the market share does dictate the size of the problem, the Windows developers have allowed, yes I say ?allowed?, this OS to continue to be easy prey for those who want to gain access. If you use the internet you are bombarded by every form of attack, illegal and legal, and unless you use some THIRD-Party software to defend your Windows OS (virus protection is third-party and while we have all come to consider it a standard installation that we ignore and take for granted, it is still third-party), it would be just a matter of time before your patching, driver, and virus definition updating a new Windows OS installation; again.

Please understand, I actually like the Windows OS, I have a job because of it, but I do my personal work on Mac and Linux.

by amartin

It's the users fault because MS designs a product so easily broken? The whole world of users need to be techno-nerds familiar with the intricate details of the OS so they fully understand every possible repercussion of their actions when installing a new piece of software or hardware? Windows is pretty impressive most of the time but it's basic design concept of sharable components that can be altered by developers is a flawed concept. I'm an IT professional and I fully understand how to prevent real problems but millions of users have no clue what a driver is and I'm not sure they should have to. Why in the world do I have to use a memory recovery program to defrag memory after putting my machine through some very intensive programs? Why can't a program running in Windows simply recover every last scrap of memory when a program terminates, no matter what the reason? Why, when I distribute a VB app package created with the VB6 package and install wizard, do I have to manually tweak the included components to ensure they don't crash some percentage of workstations. For crying out loud. The same company wrote both the OS and the development system. Can't they ensure absolute compatibility?

No profit-oriented company is going to have a goal in sight of creating software that eventually is done and runs without problems. As long as that motivation for bucks is there, MS will constantly rush out, unfinished and buggy OS software with the latest bells and whistles that few will ever use.

Art

by joe90fluke

The problem with the Windows system is of a second order... Meaning really deep sh... nine.
The problem I mean to underline here is:
in the Microsoft product line the bugs are unstable.

And the rest of the world will just smile and be happy because luckily the system accidently was able to boot ... WOW ! :)

You want a serious system and not a toys 2 Words
Linux , Apple

by awatson

Thank you for that. I can't tell you how frustrating it is to hear the Linux crew speak of the evils of Microsoft, when truly, it is superior in so many ways - and, suffers from much fewer driver issues and incompatibilities than Linux does - not that I'm bashing Linux. But you're right - each OS has it's purpose and place in the world.

by Member 28898618

Is what people do when they blame MS for what hackers do to it.

Techs shoot the messenger and bit the hand when they blame users for their problems. Techs would not be working were it not for the user.

MS bashers are little more than men with small penises, or women with small breasts that believe anyone cares they are so ill-equipped.

by codfieri

Somehow I doubt physical endowments are the reason for all the MS bashing in the world. Much like die hard Ford fans would never drive a GM car and can do nothing but point out flaws the same goes for MS/Apple/Linux/Unix users. As for our jobs and such...if it weren't tech work we were doing it would be something else so while I am happy w/ what I do I feel like I don't owe MS or any other company anything for the job. Its a job...not a gift.

by keyguy13

I can't believe you think so little of your users, that you don't believe they could ever use linux. Typical arrogant geek. And if they are too ignorant (notice I said ignorant, not stupid) to know how to use windows then they don't know computers at all, and a linux solution would be JUST as easy to use as windows. Plus it would be more configurable to the users tastes, looks better (and yes some of the x-windows packages look WAY better than XP) and won't frustrate the user by crashing all of the time. It won't slow down, because it won't have viruses and spyware. I can't think of ANY reason to go with Windows vs. Linux on the desktop if it is the user's first experience with a computer.

You claim it's easier to learn Windows than Linux, but that is because YOU'RE used to windows, probably because it was YOUR first OS.

The fact is, Linux is FAR superior as a desktop solution and costs so much less that I can't even believe we're comparing. And don't quote me the bullsh*t statistics that microsoft put out there about total cost of ownership. Because anyone in this industry knows that is total crap. And if Linux weren't an open source development but instead was owned by a company, they would have sued microsoft for liable over it.

Wake up and smell yourselves. Linux kicks M$'s a$$ every time. No comparison.

And your transmission analogy doesn't work in your favor.

You are making a comparison of stick shift (supposedly Linux), to automatic (supposedly windows). You said stick shift is better. Like that is a fact. Not hardly. I own a stick shift and I would switch to an automatic in a heartbeat.
The difference in gas mileage is so minute as to not even be noticed and it's a pain in the a$$ to be shifting all the time (especially when I'm trying to eat) But I wouldn't switch if it didn't work or failed a large percentage of the time. Hell no I wouldn't. And that is what Windows is: an automatic transmission that doesn't work properly most of the time.

When the automatic (windows) works like a real automatic (that is, doesn't fail a large percentage of the time) then I would definitely switch. But as you can see the analogy doesn't work.

And as for you having a windows 2003 server up for 3-6 months, show me your logs, cause that is crap. Having to reboot because of updates is still having to reboot. And I administer our servers just fine, and have the confidence of everyone I work with. And they all like the linux servers and the linux desktops far more than windows. because they've been shown that it saves their departments money, is more reliable and less prone to attack. And they aren't too stupid or scared to learn a better way to do things.

by eric.p

People somehow feel superior when they bash things, and who doesn't want to feel superior? The main reason they pick on Microsoft is because they're the biggest. And the reason the Microsoft OS is most vulnerable is because it is by far the most used OS, so attackers focus on it. If all the effort that goes into hacking into Windows went into the other desktop OS's I'm sure they would be pretty much as vulnerable.
If I were you I would just chalk it up to human nature, the same as the jerks that bash you for what you wrote. IT just seems to have more than its share of such people.

by captg

'Round here troubleshooting takes place in order of this simple acronym, UDAS. User, Data, App, System.
Most problems start betweent the keyboard & chair. Be it, an issue with perception or action, trouble calls are initiated when the computer doesn't behave as expected. Human input is the single truly unpredictable factor in computing. The "machine" & the "program" can only do what they're told to do. The perception of unreliable performance comes when the "mahcine" & the "program" respond to instructions they we're given by some programer up to 20 years ago.
The infamous blue screen of death is Windows responding according to design. Most of us don't like it because we don't know the logic that caused it to occur, and we likely never will because Windows is a proprietary OS whose source code is not available to the public. Therefore, because we don't understand it, and we don't want the fault lay with our lack of understanding, we blame the OS, and by proxy the people who designed and coded the OS, and the underlying hardware instruction sets.

my $.02 worth

by eric.p

Anyone who has this much time to devote to writing this kind of answer to such an unimportant question really might need to get a life. ;)

by gerrit scholten

So if I buy a new PC with preinstalled Windows + Office, and it crashes after I switched it on, it's my fault?!

Or if I buy e.q. a new printer, install the supplied drivers, and Windows crashes, then it's my fault too?

Angus, your posting makes the incorrect implicit assumption that the 'right drivers' do exist. No matter how professional you are, you can't "make sure that it was using the right drivers" if the best available drivers do not exist (yet).

I'm sorry to say, but your 'reasoning' needs as much debugging as the average Windows install ...

'nuff said

by gherryt

Many of the posts mention windows crashes and causes thereof. This surprises me, because since we moved to Win 2000 Pro and Win 2000 Svr, we've experiences minimal O/S crashes. I have met and worked with a number of self-proclaimed techies who managed to corrupt their own (and sometimes my) systems through implementing what they thought were brilliant tweaks, hacks, and custom drivers. Not the O/S system's fault. People who claim that Windows should have stopped them from doing such things, also want a sign on the kitchen stove warning them not to put their hands on the hot burners.

Face it; computer code, including operating systems, are vulnerable, especially ones that allow the flexibility and functionality of Windows. Put them on the net and when you own as large a piece of the O/S market as does Windows, you attract a lot of malicious attention and are victim of a lot of mistakes by well intentioned developers.

by techcleaner

I understand your point, but you really can't blame the user for something that should never have happened in the first place. A system crash should only happen because of a physical cause, like dropping the unit in water, or shooting it with a howitzer (which, as an aside, the AS/400 could probably survive...).

A buffer overflow is a very basic programmer error, and should never exist in any OS. Windows and other MS products have tons of these. Because these Windows OS programmers work for Microsoft, it is a Microsoft issue. Remember, an exploit exploits a _flaw_, a flaw which should never have been there in the first place.

Same for a faulty third-party programs. The program may have serious bugs, but the OS should be able to keep itself from crashing because of errant code someone else has written.

I think your argument has some validity in the case of programs like trojan horses that are written properly but are programmed to do bad things, like erase data. Even then, the OS should not crash. What it should do is faultlessly execute the instructions you told it to do (the code of the trojan) which is to destroy itself or other data. In this one case the blame is due to the user's (or IT management's) ignorance and lack of proper security measures.

by telecommuting developer/analyst

I once attended a Tai Chi workshop in the late '90's and started talking with some other IT folks. I was exclusively working with a SUN workstation at the time, and these other folks were using NT4. They complained of either crashing or having reboot daily. They asked me when the last time I had to reboot. I thought hard, then realized it had been several months.

Make no mistake, Windows has made great strides in reliability. I find that I have to reboot at least once a week on XP Home, and about every other week on XP Professional. By comparison, I think that I have reboot about once on month on MacOS.

I think that those who are well experienced with other OS's find at least some problem with Windows. I particularly dislike the way that Windows handles window focus --- I might launch several applications at once, but want to continue working in one window. On a SUN, I can do that as windows appear underneath my current window. On Windows, well, you just get your patience tested until everything finishes opening.

I find my XP Home consistenly system locks up when I start a separate user session, then try to go back to the first. I cannot blieve that this is because of drivers or hardware compatability. I can easily do that on my Mac or Linux system without a problem, with a compariable amount of RAM.

There also is no doubt that Windows has the most viruses, worms, trojans and spyware. I realize that this might be because almost every fool writng code to compromise someone else's system is aiming at the #1 player, but, hey, I just do not see these type of problems on our Mac.

by techcleaner

I'm in full agreement, and I'm a PC guy. Every computer on the market today is "not there yet." Usability is a software issue, not a hardware one. Your point about hitting Start to stop, and another poster's point about basic function keys, like ctrl-F, changing meaning between applications written by the same company, are non-intuitive, to say it kindly.

I worked at a major company writing PC applications in a mainframe world (early nineties), and boy, those mainframers sure were over protective of their baby. Their view was "attach a PC to my machine, and anything can happen!" which was true. I found them extremely difficult to work with because of the resistance to change. I could recompile my programs as many times as I wanted when I wanted, and deploy them now, but a mainframe program, that was a different story. Schedule a recompile. Recompile. Fix errors, if any. Schedule again. Recompile again. Ask permission to migrate to test environment. Migrate to the test environment. Schedule recompile (because you can't migrate a binary, only source and you have to recompile in each environment, to ensure it will work in each environment). Etc., until you finally are ready to move to production, which required an act of congress and two heyholders to unlock the secret vault.

Not to bash mainframers, but to point out that we have flexibility and resources we never had before, thanks to the PC and internet revolutions, but that does not absolve MS, or any software or hardware developer, from doing the right things: Make the system impossible to crash, and make it extremely easy to use. And by easy to use, I mean by accountants and moms, not us propellerheads.

by jck

sniffing too much floor sanitizer or something.

I've loaded MS OSes several times on PCs...and...out of the box...the OS would fail.

Their default drivers were to blame. And, this was in the day Microsoft wrote a lot of the basic "generic" device drivers (as well as Oak and some other small shops).

So...if I've done a base install of their product according to their spec and it fails...how am I at fault?

Most people pick on Microsoft because their software doesn't do what it's advertised...like provide secure and reliable performance.

Plus, I love their new campaign...how you can do so much with their software...like digital music production. OH YEAH! They didn't mention the hundreds of dollars extra in software and equipment you have to buy to do it! How convenient.

BTW...in case you think I'm not experienced...13 years professional programming, 18 years building/maintaining/configuring PCs and their peripherals.

by bkinsey1

As the admin of a moderately-sized, predominantly Windows shop, I have no problem with people pointing out the problems that do exist (as you point out quite correctly, this is also MS's apparent position). What makes me not even bother to read the vast majority of threads like this are the following things (not pointing fingers at you, btw, this just looked like a good post to make this point on):

1) Some people really do just bash Windows, without any more basis than "I knew a guy with a Windows PC that crashed all the time, and my Linux PC never crashes". As the original poster pointed out, that may or may not have anything to do with the OS; it may be the user, what he/she has installed, etc. . . . And I have seen *nix machines that crash more frequently than my Windows machines; that doesn't make me think bad things about *nix; it makes me want to know the reasons.

2) Basing any evaluation of Windows on old, no longer supported versions. A great, great many of the problems I STILL see "zealots" bashing haven't been part of any shipping product from MS since the Win98 days. The currently shipping XP/Server 2003 combo is highly stable, at least in my network. If I had to use 98, it wouldn't be stable, I wouldn't be happy, and, if I were my boss, I'd probably fire me for using a crappy OS. (Which doesn't address the question of whether it was crappy compared to the alternatives when it was released; it just admits that it's really crappy now. . . )

3) An alteration of the above point, which might not even be intentional - suppose I "know" from past experience, that 98, ME, or whatever, were terribly unstable, crashed at a whim, etc. This turned me off from Windows, so now I only see Windows boxes on rare occasions, when someone calls me because they have a problem. I assume this is the same old, same old from MS based on my old experience with 98, not based on wide experience with current Windows products. Like I said, that may not even be a conscious thought process with some people, but it's there.

4) People who simply parrot what somebody else has said, with no real idea of what they're talking about. I realize you can't always tell someone's capability or experience from a post, but sometimes it's pretty obvious, and it's not always the Windows defenders. . . . :-)

That said, there are problems with even current Windows, as there are with any other OS you can name. Scale and scope of those problems is another thing, and you have to consider things like extent of use and class of user when evaluating "problems with an OS" that in many cases are "problems with how you run an OS" (and in that area, it's hard to deny that *nix users are far and away more technically competent, on average, than Windows users; naturally they see fewer problems - and would see fewer on Windows, as well, compared to the average Windows user.)

Finally, there are definite things not to like about MS's business practices, licensing, pricing, etc. I won't defend them in that area, but I'll continue to use their products until the alternatives suit my end-users and my situation.

by mikestilesky

I'd rather work many hours trying to fix a problem before having to pay M$ for the support that should be offered free...

by djameson

This is really simple, you are right about having consistent hardware, but it doesn't have to be the same machine, I use all Dell workstatoins and all of them are p3s and p4s with 512 Mb of memory or more. what I do is load the os which has been modified with all the drivers for all the machines, but then all the hardware is removed from the system config, by editing the image with the image browser and removing it from the registry. all the software is pre-installed word excel all our standard apps and some of our custom programmed stuff this gets 90-95 percent of the systems. then I log on as the local administrator of the machine using the hashed password that is standard to the image and run a script that will prompt for the machine name and ask what OU it needs to be put in in AD once then it re-boots the computer. I have software policies and MSI's for all the rest of the software I install per OU so it installs after that. The user data is stored as roaming profiles so as soon as the user logs back on they're back in business. The disadvantages of this is I have to keep a clean workstation to image and a complete system with all the softare to image and everytime we do a major system change it requires re-imaging fangling with and testing.

by keyguy13

The original poster said it takes 48 hours, because he's probably using a modem and has to do all of the damn patches. That could EASILY take 48 hours. Even with broadband, I have trouble keeping a complete windows xp install with office and OS updates under 6 hours.

by myrdhrin

I completely agree with that statement.

more over... ever tried giving a PC to your mom? I did, with Linux onto it... all stable all nice! After 2 weeks I called her to see how she was enjoying the machine; to which she answered, I can't get the thing to work! (not just before somebody says she might be stupid, she's been playing with all the machines my Dad brought home).

So I took the PC back and install XP with Office. Gave it back to her. Ok, I have to go there to clean it up and I usually get a quick call as "it's not working" but at least SHE can use it because the OS is simple enough for a non-computer literate person.

I understand I don't have 900 PCs to support (I'd probably go crazy) but it does prove a point, no matter how stable, good, bulletproof a software (of in the case of this thread, an OS is) what matters to the USER is not how good it is but how quickly they can get to do what they want to do with it!

Anyway... my 2cents

Jean-Marc

by sendbux

Now that MS has pretty much captured the OS world (by actually creating one, rather than SAYING they had one in Win95 and Win98), think of this: both Mac and OS/2 had actual operating systems almost ten years before MS caught up and stopped using what many believe was essentially DOS, with its memory limitations. OS/2, for example, had a flat memory model which would address 144GB of memory, out of the shrinkwrap. And just about never crashed.

Now, MS is not motivated to innovate (cynical: to say they innovate when innovation is what they prevent) because there is no competition.

All I ask is competition. That's how business thrives. Not by dominance of a market. Dominance is no more healthy for a company in control, than it is for the public.

by jaqui

you may only be doing once in a year, or less?

if I was doing it more, I could see doing images, but for something that is a rare occurance it's not worth the time and effort to me.

by regloff8

No - there are more people looking for ways to hack into Windows - so you end up with more "percieved" holes than the other operating systems...

Although - I do digress to a point, not every OS is going to have the same number of holes.

Like houses - while yours may be more secure than mine - it's not going to matter if someone wants inside your house and not mine. If I have nothing to steal, there's no reason to get into mine, regardless of how easy it is to break into.

Also, along with that - is the size of the hole. I think I'd rahter have a thousand little pin holes in my house, over a half a wall open. I'm not trying to compare any OS to a certain style of "hole" I'm just saying it's true...

I mean, so you can cause a Windows machine to crash - whoopie wow, that's fantastic. On the other hand, you can hack into a Unix system and download an entire credit-card database - again, for the zealots, you can switch that around too. i'm not a fan of one OS over the other really, even DOS has it's uses.

I've worked with quite a number of Operating Systems, and like them all for different reasons. Windows is far easier to use, even when loading the machine, Linux is plain cooler has a ton of flavors and can do just about anything you want it to, Solaris is as stable as I have ever seen. Macintosh has a lot of very cool features you won't find anywhere else, at all - wonderful remote network management right in the OS. Netware is easy as pie to manage and has file Salvaging capability that far surpasses any other - out of the box, not to mention Groupwise does what most other Groupware packages only claim to do. FreeBSD is just as stable as Solaris and it's a nice streamlined OS, that can handle about whatever you can throw at it. Try running some Chassis systems on anything but VXWorks - good luck. QNX has the coolest Desktop, I've ever seen.

That's all opinionated of course, just judging on what I've seen.

The best thing to keep in mind is that none of them are secure - heck, there's more theft going on now than before computers --- by far... Since when was identity theft ever an issue before. Years ago, if you wanted to rob someone, you'd have to mug them, or walk into a business or a bank with a gun. Now, you can hack some database and walk away with tons, if you do it right.

I love watching those TV commercials that claim "our system is just unstoppable" - hehehe, yeah right...

"Even god can't sink this ship" Hmmmm, where did I hear that before?