Discussion Locked

Why I'm voting for GWB to be impeached

0 helpful
272 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

272 replies

by maxwell edison

I appreciate the words.

By the way, I lived in Shelburne, Vermont (overlooking one of the coves of Lake Champlain) for a year in the late 80s when I took a job with a small firm on the Church Street Mall in Burlington. Bernie Sanders was the socialist mayor at the time, but I loved my year there anyway.

Woodstock, Vermont has to be on my top 10 list of favorite places.

I actually consider my year in Vermont as one of my best.

by maxwell edison

I appreciate it. I have taken a few weeks off, however, without as much as logging into TR. A break is good once in a while.

by hal 9000

I thought you where undergoing a 12 step program for your Computer Addiction Glad to see it hasn't been successful. :D

Now if we can only keep up the pretense that more times than not we disagree with each other the illusion will be perfect.

Anyhow have a great weekend Mate as I believe that you have a long weekend coming up so enjoy it and once in a while between drinks think of me doing last years Taxes. :(

Col ]:)

by maxwell edison

(And I won't tell anyone that you might even agree with me once in a while. We have to keep up appearances, you know.)

I'm sure we'd get along just fine, disagreements and all, especially over a yard or two of beer.

by av .

But not compelling enough to go to war. Iraq was weakened by sanctions and the Gulf War. Maybe Saddam had WMDs at one time, maybe he moved them so they couldn't be found. He was still not an imminent threat to the US or connected to 9/11.

It didn't matter though, because GWB had always planned regime change for Iraq to finish what his father started. The Downing Street memo brought to light that GWB and Britain planned to go to war with Iraq secretly in July 2002. The Iraq WMD threat and Saddam's connection to 9/11 were the supposed reasons. There was just not good enough evidence to support going to war.

GWB did not have the approval of Congress or the American people at the time. We were all lied to and mislead. It is all about politics, palm greasing and oil, as you say. I hope this is Bush's Watergate.

by absolutely

Primarily, it was done incompetently. They screwed up, because they're more evil than clever. The evil genius of Hollywood is a myth. If technical expertise were compatible with a sociopathic mindset, we'd be living in a very different, much less efficient society.

I'd characterize 9-11 more as a lucky break for the bad guys than evidence of any change in strategy, potency, or scope. I'm skeptical that Al-Qaida has gotten bigger or more sophisticated. I expect they've always been as rabid as they are now, and the only difference is that since Sept. 2001, we've seen every one of their videos broadcast on US TV, but the nature of those recordings has not changed much, I would guess.

They were able to hijack planes with utility knives because nobody expected a hijacking to be lethal. The traditional hijacking up to that point was just for ransom and rarely cost any passengers their lives. All of those attempts could have been stopped if all the adult passengers had decided to fight back, like they did on the plane that crashed when the passengers learned what was in store for them, and I'm sure every passenger on future hijackings would fight back, except it probably won't happen again for that exact reason!

For almost four years now, Al Qaida has done nothing more than the occasional exploding disco, mostly in tyrannical Muslim countries, India and the Philipines. Yes, they're evil, but they're not a military organization with global reach, as they're sometimes portrayed. They're a band of misfits who can be stopped with better bookkeeping, specifically stricter enforcement of immigration laws as they stood 10 September 2001.

Disrupting the center of operations in Afghanistan was probably the right thing to do. Claiming - even once - that liberation of oppressed Muslims was any part of our motivation, is false and immoral. Liberation was a happy consequence, but not why we invaded the Taliban's Afghanistan. I'm glad that women there can vote, and that men are allowed to shave without being scourged, but the purpose of the US military is to protect the US, not to liberate the world. Changes in policy of governments that have not declared war - as Afghanistan effectively had - should be handled by diplomats, not the military.

The fact that Ramzi Yousef had an Iraq passport doesn't mean anything to me, except that maybe we should not take passports from countries on certain State Department lists - at all. That does not tell me that there had to be a tie to top levels of Iraq's government. Just as likely, they were pleased to give anybody papers so long as they weren't an enemy of the Iraqi government.

I think that the Al Qaida threat has been blown out of proportion every time it has been mentioned by our representatives in Washington, on both sides. Both parties resort too much to hyperbole to be believable, even if one day they should tell the truth. I blame the sheeple for taking so much of it at face value.

by absolutely

If a stopped clock shows the correct time twice every 24 hours, how often is a leftist politician right?

The Iraq Liberation Act of 1998 did not result in military invasion, and was not based on claims that proved to be fabricated. The present military action in Iraq was based on fabrication, except where it was based on exaggeration.

Even if John Conyers is an extremist on the opposite side of the spectrum from the extremist GWB, the text of the memo, if verified in impeachment hearings, would lead me to find GWB guilty of treason. My reaction is not reflexive. My reflex was to disbelieve such a wantonly immoral scheme, reminiscent of JFK conspiracy theories. But most of what I've found online leads me to conclude that the truth should be conclusively ascertained, and that the best way to do that is to get all interested parties to submit sworn testimony in an impeachment hearing.

by maxwell edison

Your argument sounds like a desired conclusion in search of justification. This (WMD issue) is light years removed from impeachable offenses; and to even mention treason is an "absolutely" preposterous suggestion. You presume too much. You presume that you know the whole story. You don't. Or perhaps you presume that you should know the whole story. You shouldn't.

I've debated that WMD issue with the people around here more times than I can possibly remember. And the last thing I want to do (or will do) is get involved in yet another one. But suffice it to say that I couldn't disagree with you more. I will say a few things, however; some food for thought, so to speak.

First of all, define "stockpiles of WMDs". I get the feeling that most people conjure up images of piles and piles of weapons bunkers and factories, as much WMDs in Iraq as corn in Iowa. That's a false notion. The chemical WMDs in question could fit inside a tractor trailer; and the biological weapons in question could fit inside a briefcase. How easy would it have been, in the days, weeks, or months leading up to the war, to smuggle out of the country and/or hide within the country, such small items? Considering the borders and political climate that exist, and considering that Iraq is a nation about the size of California, it's easy to see that it would be quite easy.

And then there are the world political implications of the "discovery" of such weapons. If you don't think that some things are kept from the public in order to avoid an absolute meltdown in world politics and/or to avoid world-wide political embarrassment and/or implications, you're absolutely naive. Could (and would) this (or any) administration keep some things secret to pacify international relations with France and Russia, for example -- or the United Nations, itself? Absolutely they would, absolutely.

And the last thing I might mention is the ties to terrorism angle. If anyone doesn't think that absolutely every middle-eastern country, not just Afghanistan and Iraq, had and/or still has some ties to, or culpability in, supporting world-wide terrorism, they're naive. And yes, this certainly includes Saudi Arabia. Did you know that much of the funding for such terrorism flowed through, in some way, Saudi Arabia? You probably did, or you wouldn't be surprised. Did you know that in the months following 9-11, the Saudis were unwilling to do anything to help in cutting-off such funding? Most people don't. Did you know that the Saudis suddenly started to "cooperate" when there were a couple of armored divisions parked at their northern border? Interesting, don't you think? It's amazing what a little arm-twisting might do.

And did you know that, "OSAMA BIN LADEN and Saddam Hussein had an operational relationship from the early 1990s to 2003 that involved training in explosives and weapons of mass destruction, logistical support for terrorist attacks, al Qaeda training camps and safe haven in Iraq, and Iraqi financial support for al Qaeda--perhaps even for Mohamed Atta--according to a top secret U.S. government memorandum...."

http://www.weeklystandard.com/Content/Public/Articles/000/000/003/378fmxyz.asp

Like it or not, the middle-east is a vital player in the health and vitality of the world economy. So simply isolating them and/or cutting off all ties with them is unrealistic. For better or for worse, the nations of the middle-east are, as you might describe, a devil we are forced to dance with. And considering that just about every nation in the middle east is, or has been, either supporting terrorism or turning a blind eye to terrorism for the past forty years, it's a devil that the world has allowed to flourish. It will be a long process to turn the tides, and it's probably one of the most politically delicate dances in which we've been involved for a long time.

You should read retired Lt. General Michael DeLong's book, Inside CentCom: The Unvarnished Truth About the Wars in Afghanistan and Iraq. And then you should read George Friedman's book, "America's Secret War". (George Friedman's private global intelligence firm, Stratfor, has been described as a Shadow CIA.)

There's more to this story than you know. And there's more to this story than you should know. And there's more to this story than you will ever know. And the mere fact that the "reasonable" opponents of this administration (both domestic and international opponents) aren't beating the impeachment or war crimes war-drum (and these are people in a better position to know), should be reason enough to dismiss in entirety the extremist and "loony" opponents such as John Conyers. Besides, he's so far out there that he doesn't even have a watch, broken or otherwise.

by absolutely

What has been very easy for me to find are accounts of the contents of that memo which portray Bush and Blair as conspiring to fake the "information" that would be offered to the US and British public. If Iraq's ties to Al-Qaida and their military ability turn out to be completely untrue, there is a major problem somewhere. If that problem is a deliberate lie by our President, I stand by my evaluation of such deception as treasonous.

However, I had not seen this http://www.weeklystandard.com/Content/Public/Articles/000/000/003/378fmxyz.asp article, which tends to exonerate our leader.

I have to agree that existence of any biological weapon is cause for alarm, but on the other hand, Iraq is not the only country that has WMDs and "bad intentions". In support of GWB's decision, Iraq was probably the most formidable nation to have invaded another sovereign nation without provocation in the last 20 years, and more.

I am generally aware of Saudi Arabia's role in supporting geopolitical instability, with their apparent strategy (according to my casual analysis) being to hold a wildcard in trade negotiations and the like. Aside from your use of religious imagery, I agree with your characterization of the Middle East as generally hostile to civilization: as I see the entire region as backward, superstitious and brutal, with a few (frequently exaggerated) exceptions. Pragmatic, Machiavellian opportunism have been on display since US and British oil wells were [i]nationalized[/i] following WWII, with no sign of giving way, except through force or at least the threat of force, as you mentioned with Saudi Arabia.

Finally, I have no problem with keeping strategic military information secret, nor with keeping some other secrets in order to maintain working relationships with strategic allies. I would object to lies being the basis of military action though, and I do not agree with dismissing in entirety the input of opponents such as John Conyers, who can just as easilty portray GWB as a loony [i]to their supporters[/i] as GWB and his supporters do the opposite. If either side is rational, that side ought to prove it by [i]showing[/i] the other's claims to be false, not by [i]only[/i] criticizing the person making the claims most loudly.

Whether both sides have equal claim to correct analysis or moral validity, or recognize the others' position as valid, both represent US voters who have the right to representation under the Constitution, and to dismiss an opposing view out of hand dismisses the views of all those voters as well. I know this isn't how it works, I have watched C-Span, but they [i]should[/i] be arguing the facts, not the personalities behind each view...unless politics is only a popularity contest?

by maxwell edison

What? What "religious imagery"? None was implied.

If you read any "religious imagery" into my message, you've fabricated it yourself.

Which makes me wonder how many people fabricate something that was neither implied or intended from anything they may read.

by maxwell edison

If there was anything of substance to that Bush-Blair thing, the major news outlets would be on it like stink on you-know-what. And so would the United Nations. It's some of the most nonsensical stuff I've ever seen. It's right up there with space alien babies. That's why I'm so surprised that someone who seemed so rational to me would buy into it. It's pure nonsense. In my opinion, you've been duped on this one.

And as for the people who want an investigation "just in case", in order to get all the facts, they're only playing politics in an effort to discredit either Bush or Blair -- or both. I remember one loony-tune Senator (maybe a congressman) who once said that it didn't matter if it was true or not (I forgot the exact "false charge" to which he was referring), but the seriousness of the charges warranted an investigation just in case they were. Of course, that would only give legitimacy to the charges, and another "false truth" would be in the papers day after day, which would, in effect, discredit someone with falsehoods. And that's all these extremists want. That's all John Conyers wants.

You know, there's so much going on behind the scenes, that we'll never know all of it. But it will all make for good spy movies twenty or thirty years from now. So I suppose a lot of it does indeed come down to "trust". Of course, those on the left will never give the appearance that they "trust" President Bush. That's just the way the game is played. But who do I "trust"? President Bush, or the middle-eastern $!@#%^& who've been terrorizing the world for the past forty years? In my book, the answer's a no-brainer. And as for John Conyers, he's doing exactly what Osama bin Laden would want him to do. And that should be enough to send chills down your spine. And speaking of treason..........

by maxwell edison

The basis of military action was not "lies". A lie is an intentional deception. In my opinion, that did not happen. Misleading, or false, or exaggerated intelligence reports? Maybe, but only to some degree. And the jury is still out on that one, at least in my opinion. But lies? No way. And perpetrated by Bush, himself? That's almost laughable.

In General DeLong's book, he goes into great detail about what he thinks about the WMDs. And he was certainly in a position to know. Perhaps you might find it interesting to do an Internet search of him and/or his book, and I'd guess that you could find the text of an interview or something. It might be worth your while. (Or just buy the book.)

by oz_media

Firstly, happy fourth of July to all of our US peers!

Perhaps without realizing it, your comments actually prove that the invasion goes against what we as citizens are alowed to act upon in our own society, a case of NOT leading by example.

"...in the days, weeks, or months leading up to the war, to smuggle out of the country and/or hide within the country, such small items?"

[i](Yes I removed a snippet from your post, but it is in the correct context for my comments and doesn't change the view shared by yourself in anyway.)[/i]

IF, Saddam had removed the weapons from Iraq prior to the invasion, according to all North American laws, this removes any justification for action upon Iraq.

If you hold a gun to someone and they knock it out of your hands and then proceed to punch you and break your nose. YOU have legal grounds ot sue the person for breaking your nose, because the threat was removed before they caused bodily harm to you. I have seen quite a few security guards dragged off to court befor ebeing fired and fined over just this. Someone waves a baseball bat at a security guard, the guard knocks the bat out of his hand and then hits the guy, supposedly in self defense, but it is only self defense WHILE the person has the baseball bat in his hands and is capable of hitting you with it.

In the case of Iraq, once the threat is removed you no longer have justification to take military action upon them, they are no longer a threat, the threat is somewhere else at that point.

Now they didn't know then nor do they know now, if weapons were smuggled out of Iraq, it's a convenient assumption that supports the actions, but it really DOESN'T support the actions taken at all. It's a poor excuse if an excuse at all.

There was QUESTION of a threat, though inspectors attempts to confirm allegations were thwarted many times, the recent inspections preceding the invasion WERE being completed in a timely and effective fashion. Inspectors had been allowed to continue their search without problems and were finding useless/unsused war heads and some small arms etc.

MY personal feelings, that also tie quite well with the title post here, as well as what people from the White House and CIA are claiming, is; with the knowledge that inspections MAY come up dry and no invasion would be justified under GWB's term, they had to move FAST, convince the uncertain and shaken up citizens that they were threatened and go ahead with a premptive strike against Iraq.

There WAS another way to deal with this and many allies said so, much to GWB's disain. So he turned America against the allies that opposed his ideas and again, instilled a fear of threats from Iraq into the people to further justify his cause.

IF inspections finished and it was shown nothing existed, he could hardly justify invading Iraq at that point and his interest in becoming a hero president would come to an end.

IF inspections finished and they concluded that the arms MUST have been moved, then he had to find a needle in a haystack and would HAVE to due to the fear of WMD that he instilled into the people.
He would then have ot divert his attention from Iraq and focus on finding these WMD, which I don't believe were really the main objective now or then.

It was just convenience and timing that made it all come together, a well planned invasion based on years of planning by both the US and UK governments. After 9/11 and the war in Afghanistan, it was just so easy to impose a threat upon the people, even when no threat was found nor confirmed, and justify an invasion. Despite intelligence that suggested otherwise.

When it was confirmed by his CIA operatives that Saddam had NOT sought weapons grade plutonium and that SAME day he confirmed that Saddam HAD sought it on national TV, isn't THAT a little bit of a fib, if not a blatant and outright lie to the people?

In closing, for what it's worth I never read any religious insinuations in your post at all.

To be quite honest but not to take shots at you, you speak with sytong conviction regarding the facts, yet you also agree that we really don't know what is going on nor should we, which I can agree with in the case of security of course. How can you so quickly dismiss such compelling information from SO many sources that all points to the same scenario, and merely stick to the information that YOU feel is accurate?

Is anything not possible at this point, and judging by all of the actions and people who WERE in the know that have since come forward, I see this as closing your eyes to what may be reality to favour what you would prefer is reality.

As for the comments that made me post, unless you are under a direct and imminent threat of attack, you cannot justify offensive action against an attack whether in government or in our own society. Just because someone HAD a weapon and WANTED to hurt you, this does not give you legal grounds to attack the person.

Our governments say that IF the person HAS a gun and DOES point it at you, you can do whatever is within your power to remove the threat. Yet when it comes to themselves, laws they themselves enact, seem to be a moot issue to be brushed aside when it comes to their own devices, no matter what they REALLY are.

by maxwell edison

You said, "IF, Saddam had removed the weapons from Iraq prior to the invasion, according to all North American laws, this removes any justification for action upon Iraq."

This assumes that it was the weapons, themselves, and nothing else that was the intent. The real intent, however, was to eliminate the means and/or the regime that allowed it. Whether or not the weapons are ever found is immaterial. What is material is that Saddam will never support the production of WMDs or terrorism again.

by absolutely

First, I dislike analogies because of their tendency to distract from analysis of the actual topic, and to introduce assumptions that provide false impressions of simplicity and clarity.

That said, if a man attacks me with a club, or points a gun at me, then I knock the weapon away, the very next question to consider is: who is now closer to that weapon? If the weapon falls to the ground closer to the attacker, I'm going to continue to consider him dangerous and beat him unconscious if I can, because he demonstrated unwillingness to behave reasonably and he initiated the use of force. The way I see it, when force is initiated, the victim has the right to render his attacker harmless, not just non-lethal. I know that is not how law is consistently applied, but it is just.

In general, I cite pre-Revolution English common law, and claim the right to defend myself against any clear and present danger. I also assign my government the responsibility to act likewise on my behalf against foreign and domestic enemies. That's why governments exist, dating back to the days of the Huns and the Barbars and even before that. Humans first formed tribes to defend against wild, predatory animals. We remain organized in much larger tribes to defend against wild, predatory humans.

If I disarm [i]and incapacitate[/i] an attacker, I would accept Oz's scenario, and would be willing to consider it in the case that I disarm an attacker and retrieve his weapon, or stand between it and him. But no such analogy applies to the Iraq situation. It's more like concealing evidence or impeding an investigation into a crime.

If a mugger takes my wallet at gunpoint, then sets his gun down when a policeman walks by, he's still a mugger and punishable by law. If he throws the gun in the ocean, I have more trouble proving that he used a gun to commit a crime, but he still owes me my wallet. Well, now you can see why I dislike analogies.

I still tend to agree with you about the lying, though, Oz. The administration has been inconsistent in their characterization of the threat that was, or is, in Iraq, leading me to [i]suspect strongly[/i] that they were dishonest in the first place.

by jck

If you're going to read a book and expect nothing to be exaggerated by the publisher, editor, etc., then you are misled.

Usually when I want to know something (which I know isn't confidential or classified), I'll talk to someone I know who works at CentCom (whether civilian or military) to find out the real deal. I'll trust a normal person over a journalist or writer.

I don't trust books...especially the ones that come out about debated topics. Content usually ends up getting "improved" by either the author, the editor, or the publisher so that they can sell more copies.

I mean, look at the Jessica Lynch story. She went through hell, but she wasn't the "hero" she was made out to be at first.

Nonetheless...don't count on those books for totally accurate information. And, I wouldn't use them as a reference tome for your kid's book report either. They might be interesting, but they're not guaranteed to be right.

by absolutely

but not why the Constitution guarantees freedom of the press. I think the expectation of journalistic accuracy is implicit, and completely reasonable.

If the price of freedom is eternal vigilance, then most of the largest news organizations (owned by entertainment corporations, btw) should have their free press status revoked for failure to pay their dues!

by maxwell edison

I both read General DeLong's book and heard several in-depth interviews he personally gave. The things he wrote in his book were spoken by him as well. I both read the words and heard the words.

You said that you would trust, "someone (you) know who works at CentCom".

Lt. General was the vice commander at CentCom - the second highest ranking person there.

I'll believe General DeLong. You can believe the janitor, for all I care. You may not want to trust the general's word, but if it doesn't support your desired conclusion, I suppose you'll find some way to justify it.

by montgomery gator

It is very possible that Saddam Hussein sent some of the WMDs to Syria or Iran for "safe keeping". Also, some caches of WMDs have been found in Iraq, particularly, chemical weapon stores. The intelligence used by Bush and Blair may not have necessarily been wrong, Saddam Hussein took measures to hide or give away his WMDs before the liberation of Iraq by the Coalition.

by oz_media

Iraq was not an immediate threat, some other country was harbouring the weapons.

by oz_media

WhenBush spoke about expecting stockpiles of WMD in Iraq (I think with Babawa Wawters) he said, "Sure...I expected to see STOCKPILES (while drawing a big circle with his arms).

GWB thinks he should have found a few pallets all wrapped up and tagged for the USA too.

by oz_media

A group of CIA agents were sent to Iraq to investigate whether Saddam had the means to aquire nuclear arms (weapons grade plutonium) or had attempted to do so before.

After much underground work, they returned and reported that they did not find that he had, nor had he the means to even try to do so.

That evening, Bush was on a press conference where he stated that Saddam had the means to or had already aquired WGP (can't remember which but it's irrelevant). The CIA member was interviewed and was shocked that his report had been changed. They then interviewed the person who writes his speeches. He was told to NOT write that it had been an unconformed allegation, he was also quite shocked but said he rarely actually spoke to Bush but was told to write what HE thought Bush would say, or how he would say it.

So if Bush or his adminiatrtion had changed this FACTUAL information and reported otherwise, then that would constitute as a blatant lie.

It all depends WHO you believe, or even moreso, who you WANT to believe. Not actually who is telling the truth. You CHOOSE to believe Bush, you have placed your faith in the fact that the Republican administartion has done no wrong in this conflict and you buy what they say is true. Not everyone does though, and there is just as much compelling evidence to the contrary.

by oz_media

And nary a sole in the world would have supported such an action. WMD were the catalyst to get the public on th egiovernment's path. It was used to coerce poeple into support.

Now I know you have said over and over again that there wer emay reasons for Invading Iraq, and I agree and I also feel they go WAAAAAAAY beyond removing Saddam, that is also another catalyst for those savvy enough not to buy into the WMD BS.

As I said, it was all convenince and damn good timing in my mind.

WMD was not brought up by me, I merely read the posts and offered my perspective, they do NOT justify invding ESPECIALLY if they cannot be located and pointed to. If they don't exist, which is what other allies wanted to have confirmed BEFORE the invasion, why inspectors had been back and forth for years etc, then you cannot justify an invasion.

The allies agreed Saddam had malintent, they also cited that that is NOT justification for an invasion, IF WMD were in fact being harboured in Iraq then the use of military force to remove them was just. With no WMD, a little heresay and no threat, you cannot justify invading a country because they don't have your best interests in mind.

It is simply bad form, was not just and is looking worse and worse everyday, thanks to the guy who decided to say stick with the best and F**k the rest.

This is probbaly the dirtiest and most unjust iunivasion of another country since Hitler decided to take over Western Europe.

Diplomacy my ass.

by maxwell edison

I believe President Bush; you don't.

I trust President Bush; you don't.

I give President Bush the benefit of the doubt; you don't.

I believe that President Bush has acted, and is still acting on the best interest of the United States; you don't.

I will believe President Bush over any and all middle-east leaders, the Russians, the French, the Germans, and the entire American Democrat Party; you don't.

I'm an American who will admit that I prefer to put American interests over and above those of any other nation; you're not.

You believe that the whole world could live together as one big happy family; I don't.

We'll never agree or find common ground in this regard. So what else is new?

by oz_media

Well if we are gonna point fingers;

You believe president Bush, I would LIKE to think I could but I don't. I have doubted him since I first saw his speeches where his marrerisms are a detailed example of what ANY criminal investigation uses to peg a liar.

I would like to give Bush the benefit of the doubt, but the odds are against him, again he has specific mannerisms in his public speeches that point him out to be a liar. The world's police forces and psychologists have studied and detailed such mannerisms and he fails(ed) every one of them. If it's good enough to determine who should and shouldn't be in front of a US court, it's good enough for him. No matter what his position of trust and faith, he is a man who has failed miserably at being a credible speaker in the eyes of professionals.

I TOO believe that Bush has acted and is still acting on the best interest of the United States, or what HE feels is in their best interests. This doesn't justify his actions. There are many ways I can act for my own benefit or those around me that is completely unjust to most others.

I will ALSO believe President Bush over all the middle east leaders, perhaps even Russa or France, this doesn't excuse him for an poorly justified invasion of another country, even one of those that I don't really trust. Nobody was being protected, nobody faced a threat imminent enough to make such an invasion acceptable or neccesary. As for democrats, you are implying you do not trust half of Americans, this is the sad part of political affiliation in your country as I have iterated too many times to count. You place people's political affiliation way ahead of people themselves, this to me is reason to seek help. When politics outweighs personal action, and when politics clouds your ablity to see an alternative viewpoint, it leaves you blinded to all but a single concept.

You should know by the amount of history you've studied, that people make mistakes and use their power to their personal advantage, that happens to all kinds of people regardless of political affiliation.

I am a Canadian who thinks we should consider all interests of the allied nations before making a rash decision to ditch forged alliances for an unconfirmed allegation. Unfortunately too many Americans think America comes first, instead of, as well. You see America as the end all, not simply a piece of a massive puzzle.

I DON'T believe the world could live as one happy family, that is just some pigeonhole you place all who don't see your views into.

We never find common round on this regard. Well I was hoping you'd understand by now that I am not trying to convert you. NOR am I a democratic supporter, I just don't support YOUR current administration, I couldn't care less which party GWB represents, it's the actions not the party that matter to me.

My point is that you constantly and very quickly dismiss ANY opinion but your own by supporting your own claims with what that YOU believe to be true.

You are not even CONSIDERING alternatives to what you believe, you don't even give other concepts a single moment of your time before you defend what YOU wish to believe. This affords you a very one sided and extremely uneducated and biased approach to all political discussion.

The part that gets to me, is that you insinuate anyone who DOESN'T see and believe what YOU believe is stupid, uneducated, disingenious, and all those other colorful phrases you like to discredit others beliefs with.

"LOOK AT BOTH SIDES OF THE COIN BEFORE PASSING JUDGEMENT."

YOU came into this whole issue admitting completely biased favour toward Republicans and GWB. Nobody else CAN be right, there's no possiblility of a Republican president being wrong or making incorrect decisions or working to further his own cause.

This is simply a ridiculous view of ANY party in ANY country. Politicians do NOT have a record of credibility, justice, truth, honesty or acting only on behalf of the people, never have and never will, they MUST be questioned when questions are raised that is what we call democracy and freedom.

So really the MAIN difference between you and I is that I open myself to all sides of the story, I know what Bush thinks and what the Republicans think, it's been in the daily news for what, 5+ years now?

I allow myself to look into and consider what the other side says, I won't discount an opinion due to political affiliation, especially when it is often well supported. I bash Republicans for the reasons you have cited that make you a Republican, 'no other opinion counts'.

My objective here was simply to prove once and for all that YOU are the one who is completely biased and is admittedly a blind follower as you openly refuse to even consider any alternative.

Yet you constantly accuse others of being disengenious, poorly educated or simply stupid for claiming that they are interested in alternative viewpoints, thus opening their eyes.

Again, it has nothing to do with MY political preference, it has nothing to do with your clouded vision that anyone Against bush is a tree hugging democrat who feels the world should just be one big happy place.

As you have demonstrated, it has EVERYTHING to do with one American who feels HIS choice should never be questioned, that HIS country should have ultimate control, HIS country should request the acceptance of nobody and HIS opinion is the only correct one.

It is 100% self-centered and closed minded, blinded by faith that YOUR personal decision is the only valid one to be found.

Your comments, to justiify invading Iraq, completely ignored aspects of the law that we as a society have been expected to follow for many years. When it is done in the name of YOUR faith it's okay though? When does the crusade begin?

[i]I wouldn't take it as too much of a personal attack, there's no grudge involved, I am merely using you as one example of many. And THAT'S the viewpoint that has the world seeing you as arrogant, uneducated, political sheep.[/i]

no personal offense intended, you are just one member of a collective. A perfect rube for some whacked-out commune like Waco was.

All I am saying is open your eyes and question your faith once in a while, it's actually quite healthy.

by hal 9000

Happening behind the scenes really we will never know for sure and I hope I'm not around in 30 to 40 years when the current "Secret Documents" become public.

But I suppose that the proof of the pudding will be in where the Incumbent President of the US is willing to travel once he leaves office. Marie Thatcher was unwilling to travel to many parts of the world because she feared arrest and trial I think that Tony Blair, John Howard and GWB will place similar travel restrictions upon themselves after they leave office or they will be advised in the Strongest Terms Possible not to go to some places where they could be arrested and placed before the International Courts for their actions while in Office.

I guess we'll have to wait and see what happens.

Col ]:)

by absolutely

It doesn't exist outside of religious myth.

[i]For better or for worse, the nations of the middle-east are, as you might describe, a devil we are forced to dance with. And considering that just about every nation in the middle east is, or has been, either supporting terrorism or turning a blind eye to terrorism for the past forty years, it's a devil that the world has allowed to flourish.[/i]

by maxwell edison

But no, it wasn't intended to be a Christain is good and anything else is evil kind of thing.

I was usng "the devil" in a different context.

Kinda' like the old saying, it's better to dance with the devil that you know than the devil that you don't know. (Or something like that.)

by absolutely

I myself feel perfectly comfortable calling all theocratic governments evil, regardless of what "wholly book of words" is used as the basis of the claim to rule by divine right.

If humans are flawed, as all theologians insist in different contexts, then the evil inherent in ascribing absolute power to a human, in the name of any deity, is not an accident I can forgive as an honest oversight. But now I'm getting off-topic. Back to you.

by absolutely

...that they were robots controlled by Dick Cheney! He seems to me more credibly the evil mastermind from Vega, the other two seem like clowns, but I'll take your word that they're aliens, and wait for you to enlighten me on Cheney's species and planet of origin.

;)

I have to admit that I'm also moved to suspect Bush on account of his family's alleged business with the Saudi royal family's businesses, and I'm interested in what you know about that. You do seem to have done more extensive research than I.

by oz_media

There are clear answers to what you consider anologies here.

If a mugger takes your wallet and throws away the gun, he is still a mugger and a criminal. If you proceded to beat him to get your wallet back, you become th eassailant and teh criminal.

If the penalties for stealing the wallet are less than the assault charges, you will be getting the short end of the stick, while the person who stole your wallet will be treated and possibly get a financial settlement from you for damages incurred.

When you knock a weapon out of someone hand, even if it's between the two of you or closer to teh attacker, you DO have a right to restrain the person or fight with him to get the weapon safely away from him, but you DO NOT have a right to assault him. Secure the weapon YES, hit the offender NO, unless it is needed to secure the weapon. The threat is the weapon, not the offender.

Iraq was SUSPECTED to have WMD, GWB removed inspectors who were there to confirm the allegations and they were successfully doing so, despite years of setbacks. This is removing the ability to provide evidence of the claims, not one OUNCE better than Saddam refusing them access to begin with, which incidentally is another reason for th einvasion. It's like stepping into crime scene and removing inspectors because you think the accused may be freed. Any evidence would be deemed inadmissible, in Bush lingo this means the accused must be guilty.

You fight for years to get your inspections completed and when they are finally working you remove the inspectors?

First it's inspections will not be allowed by Saddam, unless they can continue we will use force to continue them, then it's remove the inspectors because he has WMD and will harm the USA, then it's we are not there to get WMD, we are there to Liberate the poor Iraqi people?

What happened to using force to finish inspections? It wasn't needed because they WERE inspecting as planned and had found little of any importance. That use of force is what Kerry had agreed to, NOT invading Iraq, he didn't flip flop on that issue as so many seem to believe.

Bush has proven that his every move needs to be scrutinized, his every comment needs o be confirmed, his every move may NOT be in the best interests of the people of the USA.

I suppose that's why he was elected for a second term, just to prove himself? This isn't Monopoly or Chess, it's lives, YOUR lives.

Saddam would have had a hard time killing as many Americans as Bush has, he must be one happy camper/inmate and I would suspect that after he is granted his US citizenship, he will also vote Republican and will quickly dismiss anything but his views, in truly democratic style.

by maxwell edison

....."Saddam would have had a hard time killing as many Americans as Bush", you lose me entirely. Statements like that are absurd. They show a person's naivete. They show a person's ignorance. They show a person's bias. They show a person's lack of realistic understanding. That is a most ridiculous thing to say. It's no wonder you and I can't even agree to disagree most of the time. We are on totally different intellectual levels of understanding. It's no wonder I simply dismiss everything you say. And that's why you simply cannot be take seriously.

Try to step it up a few levels, Oz. You're in a bar room; I'm in a board room. You read comics; I read serous opinion. You crack jokes about serious matters; I take serious matters seriously. You base opinions on feelings and whims; I base opinions on well thought-out principle. You lack political understanding; I study political matters. I could go on and on.

It's no wonder I generally quit replying to your messages. I might as well read Dr. Seuss, Sam I am. So go have some green eggs and ham with your beer, and leave the serious matters to serious thinking individuals.

by oz_media

Instead of actually offering some form of an opinion on the subject you just make some pathetic attempt at determining my intellectual level and even more f'd-up, take some bizarre leap by insinuating you are of a higher being than someone else? ANYONE else!

The truth seeps out from you doesn't it?
First you prove you have 100% blind bias towards your own choices and aren't open to considering any others.

Then you prove that you feel you are intellectually superior to people you don't know.

You have carefully avoided both of these accusations here for years and yet you spew all of this in a mere two posts?

Well lets see what you claim to actually know here shall we?

The comment you quoted is completely taken out of context, as anyone with such high intellect as yourself should know. It was simply a lighthearted closing comment and obviously an exaggeration considering the following lines, which you completely omitted, that place the preceding comments in context.

This in iteslf makes the rest of your comments unqualified and irrelevant but lets keep going anyway.

I'm in a bar room? Sorry, people in bars here don't talk about politics, so your comment is once again entirely incorrect. I don't live in the USa, there is life outside of politics and nobody gives a crap who you vote for.

Totally different intellectual levels of understanding?
You arrogant Yankee you! First of all, your comment is not relevant because the entire point you have made is incorrect, secondly you haven't the vaguest idea of what my level of intellect really is, this is a forum where I enjoy my time with lighthearted banter. You can't possibly expect me to believe that if I make a compelling argument you will see my point, so what's the point in trying?

You have no idea what I do or don't know, nor do you know what ANYONE'S intellectual level here is. You know I like to study Latin and Psychology, does this mean I have a higher intellect than other people who DON'T read this material?No.
It would be extremely arrogant to even think so. What do you do when YOUR car breaks down Einstein?
Who drew the plans for YOUR house?
Maybe you should study Psyche for a while, read some old Freud, you'll love it, all based on the ego and male dominance!

Step it up a few levels? I won't even address that your highness/heinous.
You're in a board room? How about you get a grip on reality for a day or two.

I read comics? Are they funny? I haven't read a comic since I was a kid, I didn't collect them either. You don't read serious opinion, you have already said you only follow one side of the story, one that favours your own feelings, but you may as well read Popeye comics I suppose.

I tell joke about serious matters, yes I do, you can't tell me that ANYTHING in life isn't laughable, don't try and tell me what's important and serious until you've tried death, nothing here on Earth is SO important that it can't be considered with humour, including the Iraq war. (just remember to read that carefuly before you quote it later).

I base opinions and feelings on WHIMS? Well yes I don't let other people dictate how I 'feel', if I want to be in a good mood I will be, despite others. I guess you could say feelings are a whim, that's how I feel and that's how I'll be. What does that have to do with the price of eggs?

Opinions based on whims though, no. I base opinions on what I hear, read and seee from many sources all over the world, without instantly dismissing them as BS. How I feel about that may be positive or negative depending on how I feel that day, so I guess my PERSONAL feelings are a whim, but aren't everyone's? Something you might want to try one day, it will show you what an open minded opinion is about and perhaps that not ALL contrary opinions are complete BS if they don't support your predetermined conclusion.

You study political matters and I lack political understanding? Who the hell are you trying to kid?

[i]"I will believe President Bush over any and all middle-east leaders, the Russians, the French, the Germans, and the entire American Democrat Party; you don't."[/i]

That sure sounds like someone not willing to actually study political matters but will spend all day seeking those which again support his own predetermined conclusion, THAT'S what you consider political understanding? Understanding what? One side's point of view? Get real!

As for leaving serious matters to serious thinking individuals, you can simply get stuffed. You arrogant SOB, I've seen people claim you are arrogant and self centered but I've always just seen a determined side that poses facts from his side of the debate. I went to bat for you thinking you would add some new views or at least some fact from your side of the fence. I was proven wrong, you are just running around on your typical 'disingenious' BS again. My mistake, you can disappear back into hiding anytime.

What a teet! (.)(.)

by absolutely

Oz:

"When you knock a weapon out of someone hand, even if it's between the two of you or closer to teh attacker, you DO have a right to restrain the person or fight with him to get the weapon safely away from him, but you DO NOT have a right to assault him. Secure the weapon YES, hit the offender NO, unless it is needed to secure the weapon. The threat is the weapon, not the offender."

I believe that when people use force, they are evil and deserve to be treated accordingly. Whether they use handguns, jets or virulent microorganisms as their weapon, it is the human choice to initiate the use of force (usually to acquire unearned property or prestige) that is evil, not the existence or possession of a weapon that may be used in self-defense.

by oz_media

I would be th efirst to admit that if you pull a gun on me, you better hit me with the first shot.

I couldn't care less if the person turned and ran or dropped the gun, I'd still inflict as much pain as possible upon him.

BUT, by doing so, I understand that I would like ly be the one to be charged with an offence if it was taken to court.
Unfortunately, morals and law have very few crossings with each other.

BUT, legally, once the threat (the weapin not the person) is removed, I cannot t=legally take offensive action unless the person continues to assult me and I ned to defend myself form bodily harm.

My comparisson to Iraq was that IF (and that's IF) we are to actially believe that WMD were the main reason for the invasion (as it was initially sold to the public), then once that THREAT is removed, you cannot justify further agressive or offensive action. It is no longer defense at that point, it is an offensive movement by invasion of another country.

So whie STILL many Americans speak of defending their nation as a way to justify the war, it is not really defensive at all.

IF they had waited as recommended for the inspections to finish, what is estimated to be anything from 2 weeks to 6 weeks depending on the source, then perhaps it would NOT have been found that the use of force was neccessary and the invasion would have never happened. Bush I am sure would not stand fo rsuch a chance at losing so close to achieving a personal goal for his term in office.

Th ethoing that still irks me is how he constantly insists that it had to be done, this was a needed resolution yet while nobody has ever contested that, he never addresses the fact that it wasn't immediately neccessary, it could have been a planned invasion conducted by a larger gloal force and that would have definitely reduced teh US burden of money and lives. The hit on the US economy would have been eased, the number of US lives lost reduced etc.

He just keeps plodding on with more of the same, and right now that seems to be too little too late. It COULD have been different, Bush didn't want to seek that avenue though, he had is mind set and went in like a bull in a China shop, only to be quite surprised that they didn't all break down like the starved and ill equipped Taliban.

Allied forces are now starting to offer a little more support, just to see an end to the madness he began.

He knew very well that IF things started to go bad, that his allies would turn no matter how he'd treated them or ignored their wiches. SO the rest of the world is being dragged into a war against their wishes and better judgement and foresight.

Way to go America, a great way to make friends.

NO I don't like Bush. AT first I figured hey, he's a new president, big deal, great, Canadians place politics behind life.

But when I saw him making his assertions against Saddam, I noticed all kinds of mistakes in his mannereisms, which many like telltale eye movements and hand motions seem to have been addressed since the early days. I have studied criminal psychology in some depth and understand interrogation techniques and he FAILED the visual lie detector test miserably. This form a PRESIDENT? A public speaker for the entire nation?

Then one thing after the next just smelled bad and has turned out bad ever since.

He lost my trust form the get go, and as I have said before, it matters not that he is a Rpublicanor Democrat to me, we don't label people in our society or grade their credibility based on political preference. We leave the bum-sniffing introductions/interrogations to dogs.

by beads

At what point does the "attacker" become ineffective? That is to say when has the attacker been effectively neutralized? Is it when the gun/bat/club/... is removed or should you wait to detail if he/she/they/them are going to clench thier fists and counter attack? Leaving me to counter-counter attack?

Fortunately, I am not a security guard but if attacked first I will neutralize the attacker until such a time I am stopped or feel that the first attacker is no longer a threat to me or anyone accompanying me. The hypothesis doesn't make the best analogy as I never saw Iraq as being a front line threat to the United States, its Allies or nieghboring countries. So the point is mute for all real purposes. If found to be on the 'wrong' side of this its going to be because I had poor representation in court. If it made it that far in the first place. Also, many states have laws precluding this argument. For example, you may have the right to use deadly force if you see a violent felony in progress. You have the right to stop that act in order to save anothers life. There isn't a jury that isn't going to say you didn't act in the defense of another or in self-defense in such a case.

Now, we started an unprovoked 'war' and have to finish it as gracefully as we can. Hence we cannot claim that the US was under iminent attack by any stretch of the imagination.

Can anyone clarify when Congress declared a state of War against Iraq. Otherwise we are really talking about a nice 'police action'. I really don't remember Congress passing a War Act but I could be wrong. Buried in some tech book somewhere.

Yes, Absolutely. I do agree that: "I believe that when people use force, they are evil and deserve to be treated accordingly..." Its also called being a bully. Evil begets evil and the cycle goes on and on. Now, if your attuned to such things you would have noticed that the US is now in serious disfavor with the rest of the world. Not that we were super popular before its only getting worse.

Don't think I'll wanting to take a trip abroad any time soon, lets put it that way.

- beads

by beads

Thats fairly well what I have been saying about my fellow Americans for years. We are political sheep and we are becomming more and more blind by the day.

Heres the reality of the American political meltdown: So called liberals try to convince people with facts. Using facts doesn't work with Americans. Conservatives use feelings. How does that make you feel? How do you feel about the subject. Just ask Carl Rowe, et. al. They will tell you quite blantantly, thats how they "won" the election.

- beads

by oz_media

That and the fact that US news is so censored and controlled by the Republican party ythat it doesn't even come close to actually being a news report when the same stories air in Canada with much mroe live video, full interviews etc.

To this I was told, I had no idea what I was talking about, no idea what US news was about (though most of my Tv channels are US networks) and that Canadians being socialist country are completely misguided by our warped censored news.

It IS funny though to flip form a US network to a Canadian one and see the difference in teh news reports. Ours shows pretty much both sides, has interveiws with people in the middle east as well as Canada, US and UK. The US is ONLY US speakers, ONLY US focused news and never shows anything but the negative views of others.

For example, teh EXACT same news reel in Canada runs 8 minutes, in the US that SAME peiece of video footage will be 3 minutes. Yet we only get part of the story I hear?

Just try bringing up politics in Canada, you'll clear the room. Someone just peer mailed me on this subject actually and I was showing comparissons on the differences. It's funny, in the US, you rpolitical affiliation is mroe imortant that your sex. People meet each other and pose political preference like two dogs doing the bum sniffing thing before they can even talk together.

It's laughable form the outside looking in, but it's horribleto think that some of you guys are forced to live that way against your wishes.

One could say it's quite BAAAAAAAAAAD ! ;)

by jck

because none of them have been totally vigilant in reporting accurate information, whether in military conflict, government elections, foreign policies, etc.

About the best news source I've found on American politics is CSPAN. That guy who runs and owns it has always questioned anyone on their policies when they come on his shows because he believes in confirming all agendas...not just ones he sides with.

Otherwise, I don't watch too much news for its truth. I only use it to keep abreast of general happenings so I can get information on things that interest me and congeal my thoughts from several places.

Also, freedom of speech was mainly put into place to avoid government control of it. In the day, you could be killed by the King if you spoke out against him openly.

Of course, you can be killed today too in that fashion. Just go talk trash at a corner ristorante about a Sicilian mob boss in NYC. hehehehe :)

by beads

Try the BBC as well. Its always good to get a different or fresh perspective from a non-US based news organization.

You should be able to find the BBC on Public Radio, Internet and TV. Though some of the times may hasten your reach for the TiVo. LOL

- beads

by jck

BBC News on PBS or BBC America.

And yes, it's refreshing to get a perspective outside of the American media's spin.

by jck

That General has about as much idea of what really goes on at the ground level as the President.

Generals don't have their hands in the day-to-day of operations at SAC, CentCom, or any other command in the United States military.

BTW, civilians are not only janitors. So, your over-exaggeration just proves how crass you can be in trying to prove your points.

Some of my friends have included:
Civilian trainer to USAF computer security
The (now former) head of the USAF CERT
The (now former) head civilian advisor of USAF Computer Operations
A civilian advisor to CentCom in procurement

So yeah, I believe what my friends say when it comes to what goes on at the ground level rather than a general who gets "briefs".

I'm not saying he didn't know anything...he just isn't going to know all the particulars and that leads to conjecture on his part about what happened day-to-day.

Not even I could remember that much information if it were put in front of me...and God knows, he didn't walk out of the military with his file cabinet.

by beads

Having worked in the Intel field for the US Government I can tell you theres little the General or anyone else could really say without getting into one heck of alot trouble seems a bit naive unto itself.

Oh yeah! Here it is. Everything I know from working in Central Command. Yep! The governments is going to let me tell all. All that classified above Top Secret information (SCI, by the way) its all here in my book. Hogwash!

The general would be foolish to publish anything more than conjecture and most likely conjecture that has been dismissed.

- beads

by jck

I wouldn't ask or expect my friends to divulge confidential or classified info.

I have held several clearances. I know the routine and not to dig for more info. I take what they give me, whether it's facts or hints.

I even knew before CNN did about guided missle cruisers firing on Iraq in the first gulf fiasco. Was just told by a friend in the navy "Keep an eye on CNN. It'll be interesting soon."

Of course, glad I knew about something going to happen. I got to hear Bernard Shaw yell "Oh sh*t!!" over his phone live on the air.

That was funny...no censor would have caught that when that missle flew down that street in Baghdad past the Al Rasheed hotel.

Hotel room in Baghdad: US$80
Satcom uplink: US$275,000
Bernard Shaw almost messing his pants and swearing on live TV as a tomahawk flies by his hotel window: Priceless.

by oz_media

"There isn't a jury that isn't going to say you didn't act in the defense of another or in self-defense in such a case."
Yes there is and they do and have done. If YOU step in a stop someone from being attacked, that is fine and dandy. If you stick around and beat the attacker up, you will be found libel for assault. once the threat is removed you can no longer claim self defense, it is offense at that point.

As far as threat from Iraq, Iraq MAY have become a threat to others but as it was, Iraq posed no immediate threat to anyone's life or security. IF anyone had reason to fear attack, it was the UK. Saddam had a far greater logistical ability to inflit harm upon Europe than look to North America for an attack on US citizens.

So why weren't the British citizens scared into thinking they were going to be attacked? Blair stated from teh onset the cause was to liberate Iraqi's, a fair and nobel task really, and people did support it to some extent. a document representing 3000 Iraqi exiles was presented to Blair and he acted upon their requests. It was GWB who started the whole WMD scare, not Blair.

Sorry to be so rude, but this is NOT in the interests of most Americans, America is first and foremost and others will be taken care of if and when it effects Americans. So to pose that American spend several hundred billion dollars to free Iraqi's in the Middle East, while costing American lives and a heavy blow to the economy (and the American checkbook) there's was no hope in hell Americans would have supported a war.

Instill fear into them, instill a need to save the country, a threat of security etc. and they will follow in droves. Unfortunately, this is how most of the world views the US mindset.

"America must not ignore the threat gathering against us. Facing clear evidence of peril, we cannot wait for the final proof -- the smoking gun -- that could come in the form of a mushroom cloud." -- George W. Bush, 10/07/02

What kind of message does that send to people of America other than we will be attacked by nuclear arms if we don't act NOW! ?

So it was justified as a retaliation or DEFENSE against a threat, that never existed, therefore in a court of law, GWB would/should be doing time by now.

As for favour, as I've said before, I had a Canadian band booked into a club outside of London
when they arrived someone thought they were American because of thei accents and all hell broke loose, they were ALMOST cancelled but they quickly showed their passports and some were actually UK citizens that hadn't be speaking, so the show went on and they were treated like royalty. Not to boast but Canadians really are treated well in England. You're money is no good, they won't let you buy a round or dinner or anything, the just love Canada as Canada was at their side early on and helped save England from Hitlers attempts to claim air superiority in WWII, as well as being the first to attack France (though miserably, DIEPPE) and the first to land and secure sites on D-Day.

Bush and Americans who claim they are so superior than th erest of the world have pretty much trashed that.

You'd still be welcomed I am sure and woul dinfd people realy nice, just don't bring up WWI or US politics and all is well. :)

You'd love Europe I am sure, if you haven't been there already. The people and the places are fabulous, the music is non stop and the sights are countless.

by jamesrl

The name Scot comes from an Irish tribe the Scotti, who came over from the Ulster area during the Dark Ages. Of course, the Scotti mainly settled in the Highlands and Islands and the west part of Scotland. Also living in Scotland at the time were Picts and some Vikings and quite a few english(who at the time were Angles and Saxons and other Germanic tribes). So from 1000 years ago the Scots were a mixed group, which may explain 1000 years of infighting.

In the early 1300s Robert the Bruce, King of Scotland, invaded Ireland to attack the English castles. He invited the Irish to join him, some did, some didn't. After a famine occured his troops raided nearby villages and it turned into a bit of an Irish Civil war. Though after Robert's death the Scots left, it sowed the seeds of rebellion in the Irish.

In the early 1600s the English decided to send over some of its Protestant english friendly scots(not all were of course) to Ulster and granted them land(Ulster plantations).

After about 1750 (after Culloden when the last Scottish rebellion was brutally crushed) the English decided to get rid of the tennant farming class in Scotland so they could convert from cattle to the highly demanded sheep(to feed the northern english wool mills). The tennants were evicted, or as in my ancesters, told they would go on trial tomorrow for horse theiveing, forcing them to pack up and flee for the nearest port that night. My ancesters went to northern Ireland for a time and then a generation later to Canada.

So its quite possible, that since there has been so much intermingling over the years, you aren't half and half, but a whole something.

James

by maxwell edison

I know you're not accusing me of religious bigotry.

I just found it interesting that you saw a religious reference when none was really intended. Sure, "the devil" certainly has a base of origin in something religious, or spiritual, or anti-spiritual, or whatever; but I believe it has found its way into the secular. At least I think it has.

A small point, to be sure. But the devil's in the detail, or so they say.

I haven't given much thought to the notion that "all theocratic governments (are) evil". Does that mean Israel is "evil"? Is the Holy See (the vatican) evil?

by beads

Don't give the Bush administration any more ideas. They'll be using that as the next excuse to invade Jordan or Syria.

In the first Gulf War for Oil I personally saw tons, metric or imperial, tons of leaking and intact creates of ammunition lying about. Some of which was detected as having chemical weapons. Most of those boxes were labled in English and Farsi: Jordanian Ministery of Defense.

You can tell the chemical weapons when they have that nice green band on them. Just like the American chemical weapons do! Yellow is High Explosive; White: White Phospherous, etc.

The only reason the Iraqi's didn't use chemical weapons that they had orders to use? The wind shifted in our direction. South to North right before we went over the berm. Also to note our very sophisticated 'Fox' chemical detection vehicle the German's lent us was the first vehicle to hit a land mine 50 meters into Iraq. This after telling us, the lead unit for 1st Armor Division, that chemical weapons were indeed present!

- beads

by oz_media

I don't think anyone's ever doubted that Saddam had WMD, they KNEW he had them becaus ethey had provided him with them.

But what happened to them is the mystery to be solved 'before' starting a war.

by jmgarvin

Iraq probably just shipped them out to some folks for safe keeping in another country. Sure, there are lots of holes in the desert, but when it comes down to it...I would bet somebody has an itch to use Saddam's old WMDs.

by beads

Most everything we could find was immediately mapped and transported for destruction. One cute little story though was when we found a bunker site so big and so massive, not to mention booby-trapped no one was allowed in much past the first 100 feet/30 meters.

In come the Engineers on a nice warm afternoon and packed the place full of explosives or atleast as well as they could. The bunker was HUGE! Set it all off - at once. Well. Here we were having a nice boring day when from 5 or 6 miles away 8-10km down come all these nasty high explosive rounds in our encampment. Never ran so fast in my life.

We did run accross a few open chem rounds but nothing in sufficient quantity to really worry anyone. Those were disposed of after the war by the UN.

Did we catch everything? No, of course not. Did Saddam have the capability to manufacture more. Probably not but atleast his scientist lead him to believe so. Its that or be shot out back. Easy enough to lie to him and survive another day.

Still if there actually were any weapons even if in another country the storage and handling of such weapons is still very technically difficult to manage. Anything left of these missing weapons is probably more dangerous to anyone close by than to the US or its Allies.

- beads

by hal 9000

All of those countries listed where his bitter enemy either.

Actually he took them to Kuwait and hid them there with that Governments approval. :D

Col ]:)

by areloader

I am not voting for the idiot. He can't stop car bombings or people raming their vehicles into our convoys. Arabs and bushes stealing us bling over fuel prices. He is a mexican lover and they dont pay their way.

Lordy, how bad it would have been if limber spine kerry had won>
But why do i have my downloads converted to some foreign dialog or character. All unreadable. & I am unable to post a ? on techrepublic. Any ideas on the above problems?? Thank you.

by absolutely

But we won't have another chance to not vote for him. The majority of Americans did that twice, and he was still appointed ruler of the land.

I'd have to wait for a female confirmation, but I suspect that "mexican lover" is too close to "Latin lover" to be really derogatory, as GWB deserves. I do agree that illegal immigrants don't generally pay taxes, and a lot of illegal immigrants in this country are Mexican. But considering the threat of terrorism that is supposedly important enough to compromise our Constitutional rights, and considering how long the "immigrant problem" has been impossible to even slow I think it makes more sense to focus our efforts on identifying immigrants and welcoming them. If that were our southern border policy, anybody who is sneaking over can be assumed to be a terrorist or drug trafficker, or at least to have something to hide besides just wanting to work. As it is, aspiring gardeners are treated just the same as aspiring bombers, and all ethical issues aside, that makes for larger crowds in which the violent criminals can hide.

As for paying their way, illegal Mexican workers do not generally compete for jobs that legal US citizens are willing to do for the wages offered. I like having fresh produce to eat at reasonable prices, and I'd rather have a Mexican harvesting it than a convicted US-born felon. If anybody who is not terribly poor is picking it, the wages will drive the prices of fresh fruits and vegetables far beyond the price of oil.

by bobbyajr

So, you are a member of congress and have the authority to vote for impeachment?

Listen, if you want to Bush bash, there's plenty of room for that on Yahoo's message boards. That place is crawling with liberals who hate Bush. This is a tech forum. Not an arena for political debate.

by jardinier

Where have you been for the past four years since you joined this website?

There is a section in discussions called "Miscellaneous." Here we talk about ANYTHING that someone wants to talk about. Politics and various social issues are discussed regularly.

If you are not interested in discussing politics, then stay away from these discussions.

Actually what has occurred at this website during the past two years is that almost all members who were formerly staunch Republicans have wakened up to what a shameful disgrace of a president this man has turned out to be.

by rob mekel

the "lefty's" are coming in. :D :D
(or should that be "marchin'in", but those were the Saints, and that they sure ain't :D)

Rob

by montgomery gator

There are plenty of us Republicans still here, and more joining, and some moderates posting who do not go to the extreme of either view (like our friend rob.mekel). :-)

And GWB is definitely not perfect, he has allowed Congress to run away with spending, but he is still much better than Kerry would have been.

by av .

First, miscellaneous is miscellaneous in my book. We can discuss anything we want here, and I think thats great; but more than that, there has been a public vetting of the values of left and right, politically speaking.

I think that Bush is out of control. Some people think he is a patriot. Over the years there has been lots of very spirited discussions about "W". Its an interesting read.

I think Republicans need a new role model. Is Bush a disgrace? Yes, he is in my opinion. I don't see his vision.

by jdclyde

And in such tech forums, we learn how to look at the DATES of the postings, and not get worked up on a conversation that everyone else forgot about six months ago.

Your second mistake was assuming liberals hate Bush. They hate Bush just because he is a Republican, and all this hate was here from the moment he started running for the office because the mindless masses of liberals don't follow politics and are controlled only by getting them emotionally involved through hate.

Democrats don't stand FOR anything anymore. They stand AGAINST Republicans. That is their entire platform.

Hopefully they didn't learn their lesson on not being able to win an election simply be stating that they are not Bush.

We will see a new person that is hated just as much when the election comes around again. It is the most powerful tool of the "party of tolerence".

by sleepin'dawg

I was in Boston at a red light and the car in front of me had a bumper sticker with a picture of GWB on it and the caption read," Will somebody please give this guy a blow job so we can impeach him." What I haven't been able to figure out, was that a Bush bash or a shot at Clinton and the Democrats but I thought it was so funny, I couldn't move when the light changed because I was laughing so hard.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jdclyde

because the don't seem to remember that while Clinton was empeached, he was never removed from office.

Nor would Bush be removed.

It is all just payback, and shows that most people in the world have no idea how our system works (especially the US citizens). X-(

by jdclyde

Much better than Gore would have been too.

Can you imagine having that madman in the whitehouse? He is clearly insane.

by puppybreath

both Gore and Kerry would obviously made much better presidents if you look at their comments about world events. They evaluate everything that Bush has done, evaluate what happened as a result, and then proclaim that they would have handled the situation differently if they had been in charge. As Monday morning quarterbacks, they are almost perfect in their decisions. Who could ask for anything better than that?

by jdclyde

He is just short of foaming at the mouth!

He has killed his political career (thankfully)

by old guy

this is an example of why it is so important to read some things more than once. You almost had me on this one...:^O

by jdclyde

The fact that Bush does what he feels is right, not what the daily polls tell him is popular.

He is there to do a job, not be popular.

And before you start with the "will of the people", remember we would still have segregation if we went by the "will of the people".

doing what is right, isn't always popular.

Dems intentionally try to distort this as being pig headed and a BAD thing to not waver everytime a new poll says something.

convictions. They should try it some time.

by puppybreath

but wouldn't you be foaming at the mouth if you just found out from Hillary that you were working on a plantation but weren't in charge? That would make him a ________ (fill in the blank but please be politically correct when doing so).

This discussion is closed to new replies.