Why is IT nearly all male?
This is page 6 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 6 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by oz_media
by oz_media
They just opened up a new Tandoori Hut Restaurant in East Vancouver, they specialize in battered women.
ba-dum-dum :p
by oz_media
I went to the hospital when I was drunk and thought the nurse was a waitress, I slurred that I wanted a bottle in front of me but got a frontal labotomy instead. :D
Hey it's ony Thursday but tommorrow's a holiday.
EXCEPT FOR QUEBEC AND ONTARIO!!! HAHAHAHAHAHA You should have heard it when I said my partner and I were closed in Vancouver tomorrow! You could hear the wheels in thier heads, squeaking away. 'but is EVERYONE closed?" ...Yup, talk to you Monday! :D
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
As far as a soft spot for women's rights...
I've always placed women on a pedestal, I find women astonishing and think too many ignorant guys give males a bad rap, thus creating more rightly defensive and insecure women, something I can't stand. I am into power women, not mice and many women could be more than they are forced to be by a f***ed up society.
Okay, rant over...I almost lost it there, phew.
by jdclyde
by oz_media
I was being sensitive, don't muck it all up now!
I think women are fascinating, well many women, some are too busy being who they aren't, so it's like watching a cheap movie, others are just real and are so intriguing to be around. A woman delivered the most precious part of my life, more than I've seen any guy do. Women rock, bottom line! I find guys to be the most boring and ignorant beings on Earth most of the time, my cat was far more interesting than guys.
Guys are good for sucking down beer and being a pig at the racetrack with, that's about it.
If you want a really thoughtful and interesting conversation/companion, find a woman. I've had so many male friends and party buddies, they are all the same though. I've had many women in my life and each was so unique it was always exciting.
by oz_media
by itgirli
by rapell
by cuteelf
Go there buddy.
You know how many of the male techs stare at my boobs?
You know how many of the male techs are AMAZED that I'm a woman EDUCATED with IT?
You know how many of the people asking for help WANT A GUY INSTEAD OF ME? (WHEN I'VE DONE IT TWICE AS LONG?)
Sir, revoke the comment above or write an apology statement, as I'm taking High Road offense to it.
And yes I do have a nice rack.
Filled with Sun & HP.
CuteElf
by gary
Yeah ok then well my posting was a bit of a wind up, so sorry to anyone who took offence!!! But I suppose us IT pros should know how to take the knocks and bangs prescribed to us days in and day out LOL
So shame you have no pics of your rack or anything else you'd like to share, oh well, finished teasing for the day now where did I put that large hammer to throw at this Blade Server!!!
Gary
by ldyosng
by jamesrl
I don't know about you, but I have mixed feelings.
I loved the first books, but the Order of the Phoenix was a bit of a rude awakening. JK needs an editor that will stand up to her. There were chapters and chapters in the middle that didn't seem to advance the plot or develop the charecters or do really anything.
The Half Blood Prince was an improvement over Order of the Phoenix but not her best work.
On the other hand, I found the last film to be darker and more interesting than the previous ones.
James
by ldyosng
by ldyosng
you are old enough to actually HAVE a job with one of us women in IT.
BTW - If you are ever that boss, I hope "she" has a chipped tooth and hiccups.
by oz_media
Now THAT was just plain 'king NASTY!
But probably what the poster deserved, even though it was said in jest.
by merrua
Viewing a problem from mulitiple-angles,
I think works well in IT, and problem solving in generally.
Whether its why a server isnt working correctly or why a table isnt showing properly, its easy to be frusterated and lost after the first leads fail.
Properly controled, problem solving patterns help get the job done.
by itgirli
by jdclyde
Two people of comparable knowledge, I will ALWAYS take the geekette over the geeks! They tend to have something called "social skills" that make it enjoyable to talk with.
Only (as apatheon correctly labled it) a complete Id10t would discredit women and dismiss them in such a crude way. As long as they have a great sence of humor and can "take a joke", they are a GREAT addition to any and every workforce.
I go to a lot of trade shows and seminars and I do NOT see the women being pushed aside just so a man can be talked to. If you see this where you are, your in the wrong place.
by jdclyde
This queen discussion was something she knew nothing about until it was shown to her and was well underway by MEN that have read what she has to say and respect her for who and what she is.
Sure, sometimes her posts aren't all flowers and honey and will ruffle your feathers some. Right to the point, with no fluffy BS. Again, this can be a good thing. (as long as it's not aimed at me! ;\ )
[i]"Just a woman who takes pride in her accomplishments and gets tired of having some "lord of creation" insist he could have done it better and faster. Well, then-why did they call me in to finish the job?"[/i]
As for this part, get over yourself. If you had been paying attention to other discussions over the last few years, you would have picked up that MEN also have that same thing of having to clean up after some id10t. I have to clean up after BOTH men and women equally, and don't see myself cleaning up more for one or the other. I also have women friends that I consult with on a regular basis to get to the bottom of a problem.
There are jerks out there, sure. Always will be. There are also women out there looking for the smallest thing so they can be insulted and cry discrimination.
There are just as many women that are pathetic humans as there are men.
At least some of us have a sense of humor and don't allow others to dictate what kind of day we will have.
[i]
"Now get in the kitchen and make me some pie", Eric Cartman
by jdclyde
by oz_media
It is accessible form My Discussions page.
I have already had a nice rant in TRI, hoping they will uncheck it as a DEFAULT. If you edit a post, the checkis back in that little bastard of a box again! It's just another posting step now, ALWAYS uncheck that danm box before sumbitting comments, edits etc. 'kin TR, GET IT TOGETHER !!!
by hal 9000
In a shop once I had to resort to pulling out a wad of money and fanning myself with it to get some service. :)
All the salespeople where way too busy talking about last nights Soap and where not interested in wanting to serve the customer particularly as the item that I wanted was in a locked glass display cabinet. When a salesperson eventually came to me after about 15 minutes they had the gall to ask "Do you want something?" Needless to say that shop is now out of business and quite rightly so. :^O
Col ]:)
by oz_media
My life is good, what can I say?
I escaped to the Island long enough to clear the city out of me and get a grip on life for a while.
I'm back in the city now but life is pretty easy, so I haven't reverted back to seeing everyone as just plain f******g stupid, YET. I am not fighting with record companies as I have new outlets, I have released a lot of my label obligations, making it easier to conduct business and no longer have a constant line of pricks around me...well there's TR but I'm too busy to be here most of the time.
by itgirli
Was that a poke?
Anyway, I'm glad to see you in good spirits for whatever reason and I'm glad thing are going well.
by hal 9000
Edit your previous user profile? When you do that you can change your e-mail address and anything else that you like. You do not need to create a new identity for yourself unless of course you've done something to bring into question your credibility. :p
Incidentally you don't even need to be logged in from your original ISP to edit your User Profile I constantly log in from different ISP while working On Site for various White Papers that are not stored on my NB and one of the first options that I'm given every time is to Edit my Profile. :)
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
"She Who Must Be Obeyed!" My wife. :)
I've been using that one for so long that everyone has insisted that I just shorten it down. But I too know a few chiefs and they are mostly male and I to have seen them go all weak at the knees when something new comes around. ;)
Currently I've just spent the last week working at an all female workplace fixing their computers and installing a network and generally saving them a lot of money, and despite one of the girls there learning from her father ways to drive me nuts I enjoy the work and much more importantly I enjoy working with the women even if one of them is defiantly her fathers daughter and I will never be able to make any piece of technology "Renee Proof!" :^O
But on the upside I saved then well over 1K with just one phone call and sorted a major problem for them in about 15 minutes. Now I've got to get back to reloading their main computer which was previously on a dial-up connection and is now a Zombie and when I brought it home to work on I was hoping that I only had to install the LAN drivers. :(
Col ]:)
by oz_media
I didn't say I turned into a suckhole. I just managed to get some of the burdens out of my life and made it more enjoyable to the point that I don't give a crap anymore, which is really all I have ever attempted to do in my life, make it easier and more enjoyable.
After all these years, all the places I've been I STILL find BC the most stunning place to be in the world. It's just that sometimes I get so wrapped up in the world's BS and forget that I have so much that others don't, this province is a real jaw dropper you know!
okay, well that was a pretty suckhole comment afterall, so just f**k off then! (skanky bitch thinks she's got it all figured out) ;)
by oz_media
You are simply a sexist pig. Nice point well made.
All women in a vet clininc? Mine are all men.
Wouldn't send a lady onto a frozen rooftop? Why not, watch your step dear and don't lick the metal.
:D
by jdclyde
You talk about how hard women have had things in the past, yet it is now you giving a woman a hard time?
I would think after what you say you have gone through, you would be more understanding and less hostile?
by maecuff
by itgirli
by m_a_r_k
It was a silly idea in the first place to have it turned on by default.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=96&threadID=184381&start=0
by oz_media
by m_a_r_k
by gojints
I had to fight my high school guidence counselor to take Mechanical Drawing (Drafting) rather than Home Ec - this was in the 70's. I already made my own clothes and cooked dinner every night. If they wanted me to teach the Home Ec class, fine.
Women can do just as good a job (sometimes better) as men in IT if given the chance.
Don't exclude half the population just because their 'bumps' are in different locations.
by ldyosng
I work for a small shopper newspaper and I tech Macs. I got my
start at my workplace as a Graphic Designer.
Having worked all shifts, I learned on my own how to tech a Mac
and the need to troubleshoot on my own.
I became the official Mac IT in 2000.
I have held that position for 5 years, while men before me at my
workplace averaged 9 months in my position.
Coming from the "pits" of this job has more to do with my
success than being a woman, but in the same respect, I find that
whenever I give a suggestion, I need to show management in
triplicate why this is or why I need something - the Windows IT
guy says something and it's gospel. No triplicate forms needed.
Despite my success in the Mac Tech field, I find this situation
happening over and over again.
It is extremely frustrating, too, to know I am making $3 less
than the Windows IT.
by oz_media
Does the Windows tech have more experience? Certification? Seniority? More users to support? Was he HIRED as an MS tech or was he also hired for another position and just adopted the MS tech job?
These factors that often warrant a different pay scale.
by cyberjan
Thanks to all of you who wrote descibing your experiences. I too could not take shop in high school if I could I would probably would have changed my life. [btw, 1 guy was allowed to take home ed as a trial] [also we girls had no sports before title XX all through school.]
Science and math was not encouraged as a matter of fact anything that had to do with fixing things was not encouraged...and funny thing ..it still isnt...tho i get a lot of encouragEment to teach or do counseling which of course pays much less.
Anyway, If these things were encouraged i probably would not have wasted 15 yrs in social work before doing what i do best...fixing things. I moved from social work to central office writing case-practice. Then Putting the CP manual on desktop publishing, then got a job in tech writing, then network admin...for the State of MA. The only reason i got the job is i could move with a lower job rank. I was in a unit with only 2 women IT people. We both were NOT getting the higher "tech Pay" But we got the training then we both moved out due to the money. I have had my own business for 5 years, and lots of people love my training and technical skills and the fact that i am a women. However, men still doubt my advice...when dell sends them stuff that doesnt work together, and i tell them they orderesd the wrong thing they cant believe that i know more then a dell employee!!
It is nice to know there are many more women out there facing the difficult conditions, and the lack of money still...because we can support eachother and women who are trying to get into the field.
When i was being trained, a male senior it person said to me," Never tell anyone how easy this is."
Since then I have been telling as many women as i can how easy it is!
by swwbo
I was using an email from a now-dead ISP and I just decided to change it all. Basically, someone "borrowed" my alias with a difference in punctuation and people kept attacking me for the other's postings. It was a while back, but still....
I know that I can change it and access it from anywhere, but I just did it all at once. Easier that way.
by em dubyah
Could it be that a lot of women out there just aren't interested in IT? Why must there be a mandate to have at least 1/2 to majority of women? As with any other field for that matter?
Funny, I don't see anyone questioning or bitching about how many women there are in construction. Waste disposal comes to mind too. I think there must be affirmative action and quotas and the whole nine yards to make sure that ALL employment and ALL levels of employment must be split down the middle!!!!
IF it's good for one vocation, it should be good for all.
Sure, then goes your right to CHOOSE what field you want to go into.
I firmly believe that there are not many women, because they CHOOSE to not go into the field.
I work in a traing facility that hosts IT and medical office training. Guess what? VAST majority of the IT trainees - GUYS!! The medical office trainees - GALS!!
It's their choice, it's their preference.
Any attempt to change ratios in industries disturbs me. The imbalance is because of choice. IMHO.
by bluelizard
So many girls are used to having things done for them, that the prospect of having to figure things out for themselves is daunting. It's less acceptable for a guy to act "helpless" than for a girl. Only girls who were raised to help themselves feel comfortable in IT, which is how I'm trying to raise my own daughter.
Note that this doesn't really apply to the tech grrlz who frequent this web site, obviously.
.
Okay, I will admit that I haven't read each and every message. But I did just read each and every title; and I read quite a few messages that appeared to show promise, but nothing of real substance was revealed.
There were SO MANY WRONG ANSWERS. People just make stuff up, and then go on about it. Did anybody even bother to look it up? DUH!
Correct me if I'm wrong, but is there even one message above this one that was posted by someone who actually bothered to find the real and true answer? I sure didn't see it.
Someone point it out to me, and I will sit down, shut up, and stand corrected. (Yes, it was intentional.)
Here's the CORRECT ANSWER:
The discussion originator's observation is correct. There are more men in IT jobs than women. If you listen to various women's activist groups, you'll be told that the ratio is 25 percent women to 75 percent men. To their credit, however, they're not too far off.
The percentage of women in the information technology work force declined from a high of 41 percent in 1996 to 32.4 percent in 2004, according to a report by the Information Technology Association of America trade group. The report is based on data from the U.S. Department of Labor's Current Population Surveys.
Now that you have the true facts, you can post another 543 messages discussing the reasons. Or am I gonna' have to post that too? (I should get paid for this.)
by hal 9000
I listed above that the women where just to Darn Smart to be involved working IT and the few that did where only placed there by their sisters to prevent other women from entering a thankless field where you are expected to perform the Impossible immediately. Miracles before you even get near the offending machine and it's always your fault when something breaks. ;)
It doesn't matter that you or the IT staff in general where not responsible for choosing the Hardware/Software combinations that have been forced upon them but it's our fault when these substandard units don't work properly. :)
But even your figures don't tell the full story I've yet to run across a woman working with mainframes or in server farms where they are on call 24/7 with no life away from the hardware that they keep running. There where a few females in the service side of the PC industry and the bulk of the women who I worked with where actually Help Desk workers. So the few females that there are, are not spread out evenly through the entire IT industry but tend to remain grouped in isolated sections of the industry, which I find unfortunate as when I was working Big Business I liked working with female techs. :D
But even Jessie admits that [b]"Paper Qualifications"[/b] are viewed as more important than actual experience so most places want people with their MSCE even though they are running predominately Nix or Mac boxes which is stupid but then again I've never been one to describe a Head Hunter as being overly bright. :p
Col ]:)
Here's one that is on call 24/7 and is working on a holiday weekend while her child is at the sitter's. I'm wiping hard drives for DoD disposal since I can't do anything to the local segments of our network this weekend.
Am I in the minority? Yep, but there are at least 40 of us in my agency that are also at work, family at home without us because this is our job. (What really sucks is that our weasly supervisor took two weeks off after telling us we couldn't have the weekend). I've never worked Help Desk a day in my life and don't know as I'd want to.
by surflover
I kind of suspected that at least part of the reason that the field seemed to be mostly male (at least from my experience) had to do with our culture... As children I think boys are encouraged to play with building toys... I got my first can of legos when I was 3 (and my daughters to this day still give me legos and other building toys for christmas and birthdays, and I have to admit, I still enjoy the legos :^O)...
These teach abstract reasoning which develops an affinity to, and perhaps a greater ability for designing/engineering and problem solving which is a fundemental skill requirement in IT. I just think that while many women possess the ability, they are not AS encouraged to pursue technical careers as men...
I also had NO IDEA that it would recieve so many responses (on and off topic) :^O
.
.....to spout off (again) about one of my pet-peeves, all in good humor, of course. I'm amazed at all the "fact and figure" assumptions people make.
I pointed this out in a different discussion thread, for example, about how the "rich" always get away with paying no, or very little, taxes; but I showed just the opposite is really true, and how they actually carry the primary tax burden.
Some of the messages above this one, and some were from women, said that your observation was false. I suppose, however, it was based on their observation. Some of the messages above this one said that it was because there weren't nearly as many women in the workforce to begin with. Wrong again. Women make-up 47 percent of the current work force. Not exactly half, but close enough to make that statement pretty much off base.
Why in the heck don't people bother looking things up before making such assertions? Personally, I think it's because a lot of people don't really want to know the real answer, but rather want to believe their own, regardless of the topic. Or maybe it's because the reality of the world is assumed to be equal to the reality in their particular corner of the world. (Corner of the world? Does the world really have any corners at all? And if so, how many?)
Personally, I like Colin's answer. Women choose other fields because they're too damned smart to choose this one! That answer should win the coveted TechRepublic coffee mug.
Or how about this reason. >>>SARCASM ALERT - SARCASM TO FOLLOW <<<<<
Maybe the real reason is because women are all Republicans. And since jobs in this field are mostly held by Democrats, they choose different ones. Well yes, of course!, This must be true! Most IT jobs ARE held by Democrats because all people in IT, as we all very well know, are subject to losing their job due to outsourcing, and Democrats really care about protecting our jobs from outsourcing. There ya' go. That's the answer. And we all know that it's true, don't we?
>>>END OF SARCASM ALERT <<<<<
Maybe this thread will go on for another 543 answers!
by rayjeff
I would think that most of us, even me, who've replied to this long topic replied from our own experiences with working in IT & women and drawing an opinion from that. I wouldn't say that my answer is the "end all-be all" answer, but it's an answer that is plausible, just like everyone elses. The numbers you product still don't get to the question of why there aren't more women in IT. Numbers mean nothing with out that. I've just finshed a 2 year project where assessment of data was the more important than the figures it produced, so just seeing numbers without the trail makes me a little suspect.
So, is there a real answer to this question? We will probably never know.
by cmh_datec
After 25 years of I.T. I've heard all this and plenty more. And yes, I'm female, and started at the bottom when the ratio was about 1 in a hundred I reckon. It was marginally better than the 1 in 300 that being a chemical engineer student afforded me!
The ratio has changed but who cares. As long as people are choosing something that gives them satisfaction in life. Both genders should be encouraged to pursue something they have a passion for. THAT's the bottom line, and that's where parents and teachers must focus their energy. I'm sick of having staff that do what they do just because of the money or just because....!
So give up on the ratio rubbish and start encouraging our kids to pursue a life they can get something out of and ENJOY!!!!
by rayjeff
by czarina_ote
by rjworx
by andy
... you know like when you get a new car and suddenly everywhere you look people are driving whatever-new-car-you-happen-to-have. Its not that there are more its just that you notice them more because you are one.
But that being said, dont think I've ever seen a girl up to elbows in hard drives. Lots of female trainers for sure, but not that many techs.
I'm sure there are loads of them but we just dont work in the right places ;)
by rayjeff
Thatis what I'm noticing. I've ben working in IT in the education (higher) field for almost 6 years now. And what I'm seeing is an increase of women who have maybe started off as has having their undergraduate degrees as teachers. And then sometime later when they go to graduatye school, instead of getting an graduate degree in pure teaching education, they get a degree or a certificate in technology education or being an educational technology specialist. And this seems to be typical (from my P.O.V.)of women to go this route. Teching others to teach or use technology in the classroom.
How does this connects to the previous post? Well, if teaching isn't a typically male field, which it historically isn't (but that is changing), maybe if more males were in education, we could see that? Does it seem like I'm rambling on? I believe so...excuse me all, first day back at work since Wednsday *laughing*.
OK, this is mischievious and slightly tongue-in-cheek, but has nobody questioned the underlying assumption we're all making that somehow the world would be better if the ratio was 50:50?
Most people would accept that male and female brains do have differences (that's been alluded to in numerous posts). So maybe typical IT tasks are better matched to typical male brains? (Note the "typical"s with which I qualify that sentence). Is there anything wrong with that view?
by apotheon
Some may be assuming the ratio should be 50:50, but others among us are just questioning why it's not closer to 50:50 without making assumptions about whether or not that would be an appropriate ratio. Well, I'm not making that assumption, anyhow.
I know there are those in this discussion that absolutely believe it must be 50:50 (roughly) or else Something Is Wrong, though.
I, for one, am simply curious about the why. Until we sort that out, we don't know whether anything should be done to change the ratio.
by hal 9000
I was just speaking from my general experience over the last few years since 1974. :)
The female techs that I had working under me when I worked "Big Business" where great but they where honestly few and far between, I had a few programmers under my supervision no females working main frames and the majority did work help desk and like you that is one job I wouldn't want to do a day in my life. I can not understand what benefit people get out of it. :p
As far as your boss goes he's a bad one if he can not lead by example and takes all the "Perks" and leaves the staff to do all the dirty work. Everyone who has ever worked for me has always known that I never ask for anything that I'm not prepared to do myself and I would never expect any staff of any sex to do something while I was away enjoying myself. Personally if I was running that place he would be out the door so fast that his feet wouldn't touch the ground as I find it unconscionable to expect staff to do work that I myself am not prepared to do. But then again I used to get up the nose of middle and upper management all the time as well. :D
Col ]:)
by oleta.garcia
by crabbyabby86
16+ years is what makes the difference there.
I'm a freshman at the University of South Dakota. In our computer science department, we have twenty-something students (close to semester now we have some majors changing, but we're still holding onto 20-something), and we are down to FIVE females.
This is a national trend. And it is a RECENT trend. Enrollment and retention are down across the board, and the m-to-f ratio has skyrocketed as the female population in CSc departments plummets. Give it a few more years, and maybe it'll bounce back, but in the meantime, we are dealing with a very real lack of females.
by cmh_datec
by rayjeff
"I proved that if you just GET ON WITH IT, tolerate opinionated people, keep learning and don't whinge, then success can be had. Do what makes you happy and don't waste energy on grizzling or analysing the situation."
That's something even men are still trying to work through, present company included *laughing*.
.
Most employers don't care if a person is male, female, or anything in-between. They just want to get it done, and they don't like any "excess baggage". I won't hire anyone who drags that "excess baggage" into the interview room, whether that baggage be gender related, race related, sexual-orientation related, or anything else. And if a person doesn't know what I mean by "excess baggage", he/she doesn't "get it". (But I'd guess that chenderson does know what I mean.)
I once interviewed a guy whose resume was literally overflowing with "achievements, goals, and interests" that covered just about every race-related activist cause you can think of. (I didn't see the resume before-hand, or I would have never called him in.) Okay, I thought, I get a good idea about your political activism, but what can you do for the company? And he just didn't "get it". People wouldn't hire him because of his race, he openly complained. I didn't hire him either, but his "race", as he saw it, had nothing to do with why.
The women on my staff, by the way, out-number the men by a factor of 2-1.
by hal 9000
I know it you're just a Dirty Old Man who likes looking up the legs of the womens pants or whatever and down their cleavage at every opportunity. :^O
But seriously you are quite right it's the attitude of the people who come along not the number of outside interests that have no bearing on this field. :p
Col ]:)
Try instead looking at the home environment. When I first expressed an interest in Electronics the males in my family trotted out the line that it was "a mans job" and I should forget going into that field. Being stubborn I ignored all the pressures and did what I wanted and went to university and studied electronic engineering. Because very few women have the nerve to go against their family only the stronger willed go ahead, with the result that you have all noticed.
Before you will get women going into the engineering and IT fields a change will have to take place in male attitudes to what is mens work and what is womens work. In other words they will have to accept that any job can be done by any sex.
BTW I am a qualified electronics engineer who switched to IT about 15 years ago and now run the IT department for the European arm of a multinational. It was a tough climb, far harder than for my male colleagues as I had to battle that same attitude about what is mens/womens work.
by gkiss
by jcheatham
by maecuff
by road-dog
IT is one of those disciplines that requires a fair amount of focus on mathematics and specification.
I find that (generally, not absolutely) men are able to "compartmentalize" things better than women. This leads to an advantage in IT, or more importantly, a greater level of satisfaction in the field; making IT a more attractive career choice.
Women have a more advanced corpus callosum which is the connection between the right and left hemispheres of the brain. This leads to a more holistic view of the world. This being the case, women gravitate toward disciplines that offer a wider array of challenges.
I don't see this as discrimination, but as each making their career fit their needs for personal and professional satisfaction.
Sociologically speaking, we tend to end up in career fields that suit our personalities and gifts when options are available to us.
As for efforts to artificially create a gender demographic within a career discipline that is similar to population is a recipe for economic disaster.
Quite frankly, I don't see the need for it. Social engineers are always trying to bash people to suit some sociological ideal that doesn't mesh with human nature or our innate desire for self-determination.
by computab
by domiles
Schools have not changed, bright young females are shunted into liberal arts prep courses unless they and their parents scream and yell. It was that way in 1960 when I graduated high school, in 1980 when my daughter graduated and a few years ago when my grand daughter graduated.
I wrote programs and adapted them to business use when desk tops were brand new. I could not get a job in IT. I could not get accepted into companies classes for IT. It is better now but not a whole lot.
Diane
.
I know a good thing when I see it!
by gretel111
I am female, 57, and in IT since 1984.
From my experience, my female contemporaries were encouraged to get educated to teach or to nurse, not much else.
Then there was the subject of math - boys were expected to do well in it, but not the girls.
My college professor in philosophy was convinced that females could not be logical.
Being a rebel, I gloried in proving him wrong.
Then the early sample of programming went on for pages trying to show how 2 and 2 would come out 4 using so many lines of code that it boggled the mind. I thought I was smarter than the computer because I could do it the math in a split second.
No one bothered to explain that it was the larger tasks that would benefit from the computer doing the drudge work. This made it easy to not consider IT as a career.
That brings us to having better things to do than to chase an ever expanding and improving technology. The females I know value family life and want time for it, as well as doing non IT related activities. Hours of overtime and personal time spent studying just trying to stay a year(or worse) behind the new stuff becomes old fast.
So, maybe the guys don't have wide interests and the gals do, because bottom line, IT requires a 24/7 loyalty if one wants to really succeed in it.
Add this to females generally getting lower salary for the same kind of work and being valued less, I wouldn't advise any of the next generations to pursue IT. I would tell them to find something that would pay the bills and allow them to have a life.
So, for what it is worth, there is around 20 years of experience having it's say.
by b8zs49
by rayjeff
that the women accountants would be yawning when you brought up work. I'm curious to know if they would say anything to you if you yawned when they would be talking about their work to you?
I've been "lucky" to have gone out with women who have been genuine in listening to me talk abouyt IT and have actually asked me questions about what I do because it fascinating to them.
by mark miller
This goes back to the 1980s. I was very interested in computers and software from an early age. When I was in junior high school we had a "career day" and some girls showed up for the meeting for the career in computers. For the most part, what I noticed was that girls, once they got exposed to the technology and what it could do, weren't that interested in it except as a word processor, something that made getting the homework done easier. In the actual computer programming classes there were a couple girls who were high achievers. I noticed there was something different about them compared to most of the girls in the school. They had more of an appetite for spending a long time on a logical problem and weren't "social animals" like most of the other girls.
I think that people who go into IT have a combination of traits. They have the capacity to think logically, like solving puzzles (I mean this in the most general sense), are a bit of a control freak, and don't mind spending a lot of time with machinery, tinkering with it, figuring out how things work.
In high school, there were a few girls in the computer classes, but again, most of the time if girls were using computers, they were using them to write papers for assignments. They seemed to like using them for that purpose, too. Much easier than using a typewriter.
At the university I attended, in the computer science major, early 1990s, there were about 270 students. As I recall, I could count the number of women in the major on one maybe two hands. I think they went all the way through it as well. I don't recall any of them dropping out of it. A couple were very social and seemed to be just "typical women" in their attitude and personality. Most were more "mental" though, again seemed to have a focused interest in working with machinery, and working for extended periods of time on logical problems. I think a majority of them were either graduate students or "non-traditional aged" undergraduates. One woman I knew in the major was very interested in computers, particularly system administration. She'd enthusiastically show me how to do stuff on Unix, much in the way I had seen my fellow male students interact with me. To use a phrase, she seemed just like "one of the guys", and in all my time working with computers from when I was a kid, up until then, she was the first female I knew who I could tell had a real enthusiasm for this stuff. It was good to see, but it was also so rare.
The situation seemed a bit different over in CIS, in the Business college. I took a couple courses there while in school, and I vaguely remember there seemed to be more women in the classes, but it was still male dominated overall.
Out in the work world, I've generally worked for small businesses or small IT departments in a larger company, writing custom software solutions. I've seen a few female programmers in my time. A couple were okay in skill level, the third was pretty good. It's mostly been working with fellow male developers. I had the opportunity to ask one of the female programmers I worked with about her interest level in it. She indicated it was just a job to her, nothing more. I asked her if she ever had an interest in doing programming on her own time. She responded with disgust, "Yuck! Why would I want to do that??" From a different perspective I suppose this was like me asking an accountant, "So, do you like doing bookkeeping on your own time?" Nevertheless, at the time this surprised me. She was the best female programmer I had met so far, out in the work world. She was competent and bright, but she didn't share a trait I had seen with my male counterparts. Most of the male programmers I've known have done some "hobbyist" programming at one time or another in their lives, and some, like me, were still doing it occasionally, outside of work.
In my time in the field, I've seen one female software architect, and she seemed pretty competent. Granted I haven't met many software architects.
At the management level and in QA testing, on the other hand, I've seen plenty of women in IT. A peculiar thing I've noticed is it seems if women choose to get into the "IT trenches", doing technical work as opposed to management, they tend to gravitate towards QA for some reason. I've talked to a couple of female QA personnel, and the common characteristic they have is a penchant for breaking software. They really enjoy it. Couldn't tell you why though. Personally I'm glad they're out there, enjoying what they do. I've tried QA testing and it bored me to tears. I enjoy writing software much more.
The common thread throughout it seems, is that if anything, women in IT are drawn towards positions that allow them to be computer users, with varying levels of technical competence and responsibility involved, as opposed to digging down into the guts of what makes it all work. Men in the field seem to have more of a penchant for wanting to understand the machine or the software, how it really works underneath it all, and then use that knowledge for solving problems. From my own observation, women in the field seem to feel comfortable managing technical projects, managing people to solve problems, and men like to "get their hands dirty", dig into the guts of the technology and do the technical work to create a solution. Not saying one is better than the other. All of these functions are necessary for getting the job done. I'm just talking about proclivities.
by cmh_datec
I know in my case (old fart female in Aussie), and also with some of my female friends in IT, that we rightly or wrongly don't help with this whole situation. I will admit that I am guilty of ageism, racism and sexism. Why you ask?
Well human beings use life experiences when making decisions as to 'what to do' in any situation that they previously encountered. We learn a lot from experience and it doesn't matter how many policies are put in front of me I will use my experience first.
I've been hiring IT people for close on 25 years now and this gives me a depth of experience which has seen me build extremely successful teams.
All things being equal (skills etc) which seems to be the situation I end up in when looking for people, I will quite consciously :(don't read any further if you're easily upset!)
1. The over weight, introverted Australian or young quiet asian male with a young family gets the a/p job.
2. The short extroverted female gets the BA job.
3. The tall, slim confident male or female with no kids gets the DBA role.
4. The introverted, ask a lot of questions female gets the Testing job.
5. The older female gets the design job.
6. The older tall female gets the PM job.
7. A young energetic, can't sit still poke his nose into everything male gets the networking and sysop job.
So generally I end up with all male developers, a male dba, male network tech, male sysop, female ba, female designer, female tester and female PM.
I'll sit back and wait to be thumped now. :)
by hal 9000
Don't knock it if it works for you the end result is all that really matters and if the job is getting done effectively who cares?
I must admit that I have had slightly different experiences with some females in IT than you appear to have had but I think that you are pretty well spot on in your observations. From the point of view of working for one of the big computer suppliers I did find that the females where the ones that didn't want to do the field work but where more than happy to stay in the office and do their job. Of course there where always exceptions to this but that was the way that the majority of the woman involved with me wanted to work and it's how I left them go about their jobs. The only real shame is that there where so very few women who actually applied to work with the company in the IT Tech field. :(
Col ]:)
by xxgeek
by curly70000
by keithkings
For the entire 20th Century, how many women do you know who 'MASTERED 'MECHANICAL DRAWING and DESIGN'...worked for RCA, and there was only
1 Woman in the field of 'Mechanical Drawing and Design'...among over 30 males....including myself....
How may 'females' love reading 'blueprints, editing them, and working on CAD Autocad,
Intergraph, other.....do not know a single female of the over 25,000 Intergraph users in the USA...can you 'name one'...
How many women are in 'high-wire' construction 'steel erections' for the 'sky-scrapers' and/or 'Bridges' in the world...
Of the 1,000,000 Steam Engine Cab 'engineers' and/or 'fire-men' were 'women'....how many women are 'DIESEL-ELECTRIC' 'driver-engineers' in today's global operations.....
How many 'women skippers' are there for the 1,000 CONTAINER SHIPS in the world....
Even in a 'field' self-evident, potentially 'FEMALE' how many Restaurant Chefs' are 'female'....
How many 'women miners' are there working below the surface of the world's 'mines'.....
On 'standby'..
keithkings@roges.com
.
http://usa.autodesk.com/adsk/servlet/item?siteID=123112&id=348263
http://usa.autodesk.com/adsk/servlet/item?id=2260446&siteID=123112
http://www.intergraph.com/investors/officers.asp?sname=pulusani
http://www.intergraph.com/investors/board.asp?sname=green
http://www.directionsmag.com/article.php?article_id=63
http://www.womenchefs.org/displaycommon.cfm?an=1
http://www.womensmaritimeassoc.com/intropage.html
http://www.keywomeninenergy.com/it/press.html
http://www.geocities.com/Heartland/Meadows/1099/woman.htm
http://www.wvculture.org/HISTORY/labor/womenminers03.html
http://architecture.about.com/library/bl-morgan.htm
http://architecture.about.com/library/bl-torre.htm
http://www.swe.org/stellent/idcplg?IdcService=SS_GET_PAGE&nodeId=5
by techlady1
I have read several of the responses in this discussion. I agree and disagree with many of them. I am a women in IT and have worked in this field for about 16 years. I started on the service side supporting pc's and printers, became a network engineer, and now I am in IT Project Management. I have had my struggles being a female in this male dominated market, however, I do feel I have succeeded. There are men that I have met along the way that were skeptic of women in this field and made it a point to cause friction. I have also met just as many men though who were supportive and respectful.
I do feel that IT is primarily male because men are drawn to technical fields and gadgets more than women are. I don't believe it is becuase they are better at it, they just have more interest. I also think there are more women in IT today than there were 10 years ago. I work with several women in my IT Department and I am seeing more and more every year, so our numbers are growing!!!
My message to all of us in IT would be to support the women who enter this field as they do have to work twice as hard to gain respect from a lot of their mail co-workers! Women don't want to take over the IT market, but they do want to enter it knowing that if we have the same skill set as a male co-worker, that they have equal opportunities to succeed.
Thanks.
The majority of capable women have chosen to ignore the current propaganda, and instead ply their considerable talents to raisng and rearing their children, thus leaving a smaller percentage available to compete in the workforce (I realize that is perhaps a longshot, but I stillkeep hoping that women are wiser than men have been in this respect over the years)...
Or maybe it is simply that the majority of women are smart enough to pick a career which offers better benefits and more respectable hours *smirk*...
by itmomma
I've been working in IT for about 15 years...In those years, I've noticed that within IT there are specialties (ie. SysAdmin, NetAdmin, telephony) where there is a male dominance... and then there are others (Application Development, DBAs, Operators - who do more nowadays then just push buttons) where I see a strong female population....
I happen to be a senior unix admin. To date, I've come across only 2 other women within my field...
In every position/job that I've come into, I've had to prove myself. Which should happen no matter what sex I am... It's like TRUST... you earn it.. it's not a given...
by itmomma
that study conducted today.. You always hear about 'studies show'... from what decade.. ?
I think the stats would show a different picture if done more recently.
by desertwman
BALoney!!
I haven't worked on a 300 lb server in years... and no one ... no man.. no woman.. in their right mind would try to "lift" one of them.
Maybe a showoff macho type who sleaps and eats with a weight bench.
We has special equpt to move our prime and vax computers I expect you do too...
If your supervisor allows you to "lift" 300 lbs then she/he doesn't value you much, cause you will end up with a hernia or a bad back and won't be able to do the fabulous job your co workers are so intent on passing off to you.
If your co worker was "running" away (I have seen men with this "tatic" as well as women) then that person is not a good employee and the supervisor is either not aware of the situation or is asleep at the wheel.
Don't blame gender for these problems... they are work issues and should be dealt with as such. If you are left to "ASSume" these are gender issues and not job related problems then your management is at fault. And you are jumping on a bandwagon that will take you right out the door eventually.
by hypatia
I have come late to this discussion and have not yet been able to read ALL the posts so I hope I am not being repetative here.
Studies show that biologically there are some sex linked behavioral differences between male & female which can affect behaviors. There is observed evidence that males in general are more aggressive in social situations. The culture then reinforces this aggressiveness in males and seeks to deter aggressive behaviors in females. Due to the power of 'Nurture' the differences are acerbated as the child matures. But Nurture can also over come the differences as well... biology is NOT destiny.
Even though girls excel in ALL achedemic areas when they are pre-adolescent this changes at adolesence. The change is primarily attributed to cultural expectations.
Now, what has this to do with Women in IT? Well, although computers (technology) has become less & less expensive... not every home has one, not every child has their own computer, and schools usually can't afford a computer for every child in every grade while they are in school. Studies have shown that when girls & boys must 'share' a computer the boys get more computer time... BECAUSE THEY ARE MORE AGGRESSIVE. Studies have also shown that children who have access to a computer at home are more computer literate than those who only have access at school.
The vast majority of 'computer games' (or video games) are targeted toward boys and what appeals to boys in this culture... usually, very aggressive and action intensive.
Boys are more likely to 'own' a computer of some kind than girls of the same age & demographics. Boys are also more likely to 'own' one or more 'gaming' machines as well.
So who, boys or girls would be more likely to feel comfortable with computer technology? Yes, access to computers is changing... as they become more affordable more homes have them and more young girls own them. And yes, subject matter of games has expanded greatly but the balance is still very targeted to what boys want.
I'm not surprised that the % of women in IT is less than men in IT. Like any endeavor... train a million people from Y and train a quarter million from X and you can't be too very surprised that you have more people from Y than people from X. In fact I think it's amazing that there are as many women in IT as long and as skilled as they are... We all know the well trod path is easier to travel than those who must blaze the trail. In computer IT the path girls must travel in this culture is extremely difficult to find where it is a 6 lane super hiway for boys.
I can say then that I am doing it right with my daughter. She has had a computer of her own from a very young age, she has never been denied things because they are for "boys" and she is the one the boys go to when they need help with the computers at school.
She doesn't want to go into the IT field because she sees the junk I put up with. But I shouldn't feel too bad... For her 10th birthday, she has requested a book about string theories. Right now, she can't decide if she wants to be a geologist or a physicist. I'm easy--I'll support either choice. :)
(BTW--my father supported my love of gadgetry when I was a kid and let me putter around his workshop. My mother was the one scandalized that I liked power tools and cars as much as I liked sewing and handicrafts. She came from that period when women were raised to be wives, mothers, and maybe teachers or nurses-NOTHING else was appropriate.)
by ruthie56
perhaps many of the females are self employed... or work on a contract basis... or perhaps they don't apply for the network admin jobs because so many men DO apply they figure.. why bother... i tend to think we go for more focused positions... or software. Myself, I started out with Unix, moved into HTML coding, and then into Lotus Notes... all focused positions... not a general network position. So perhaps this is why you have trouble seeing them... but we are out there... and I hope it continues.
ruth
ruth.inman@imwebworks.com
by jterry
Men dominated those majors because the men teaching them discouraged women from even crossing the thresholds to the classrooms.
I wrote elsewhere that there wasn't a single female allowed near the PET 80 in our high school and that the math department had no girls in classes beyond Calculus 2.
Why? "Because girls don't like math!"--every math teacher at my HS in the 1970s. Heck, that was news to me, but the college I went to was the same way. So, computing being the frontier that it was, I went out and learned on my own. At my first IT job, I was expected to be a "secretary" to the boss, even though I knew more than he.
As long as people want to keep saying "That's the way it's always been!", there is always going to be a topic like this and that is so wrong.
by jterry
by vanessaj
by jgtechie
by hypatia
That's probably why you never heard one ;-(
Although I am not quite as 'mature' as you... I was in High School in the 60's. I wanted to take 'shop' instead of 'home ec' and was flat out told that wasn't goin to happen because I was a girl and girls took 'home ec' & boys took 'shop'. The Math teacher(s), however, were less dense... I was never prevented from taking a math course and never was hassled.
There were many different things that I was interested in but were 'verbotten' for a girl. It was rare that I ever said anything to anyone... partly because of 'that's the way it just was' and partly because of the societal response I got when I did question / challenge the norm.
I was fortunate in that my Dad was a programmer and a bit of a math nut as well and did everything he could to incourage me into getting involved with computers & programming. Unfortunately my teenage rebellion got in my way of taking full advantage of his efforts. BOY, do I regret that now!
by sstever
I think part of the reason there are so few women is because IT has traditionally been a job for techies (typically men). I know I wanted to be a techie way back when I was a secretary. I thought it would be really cool to know all that stuff!! I had three small children and started working on my BS, while working in the field.
Here I am now, 23 years later, children grown and working as a network administrator doing a little bit of everything there is to do. Have my BS in Information Systems Security and working on masters in same. It took a while and some of the men I worked with over the years didn't take a short goodlooking blonde seriously. But I kept working at it until I got there.
You have to imagine being what you dream of. If you can't imagine it, you'll never get there. I think a lot of women (not all) think it is too technical of a field to tackle. And, let's face it -- the technology does keep us on our toes with all the constant change. The biggest obstacles I faced were men and there attitudes toward women in the field. Now don't beat me over the head with a stick.....I'm just giving my personal experience. I also worked with some really nice and helpful guys.
Just my humble opinion!!
by curly70000
It is obvious that women (in the past, not as intensely as the present) are discouraged from the "technical fields." Some of the most intelligent co-workers I have had the experience of working with are females (the weren't jammed into the "conventional way" of thinking, they are capable of thinking "out of the box").
Unfortunately, many women stick to the "poor me, I'm a woman so the cards are stacked against me." My advise for these people is "stop living in the past." Dictate your future and help other women with the cause.
What happened during the 60's and 70's in high school to females is different from the situation today. Granted, it is still not a level playing field, but there is the opportunity to achieve success and respect in the community. Yes, it takes more effort, but if someone doesn't blaze the path, the situation won't change. The strives women have made in "technology fields" have come from hard work, blood, sweat, and tears. Not "I feel self pitty so I gave up."
I'm glad to see someone has an open mind about this situation, but blaming the structure of society reminds me of the "minorities" that are over-riding the "majorities" in this country and still b!tching about their "lack of opportunity." My words to these people are "Carpe Diem" (look it up it's Greek).
I had to work two jobs to put myself through my Bachelor's degree (being a poor white male not quite in the poverty level doesn't help much with Pell Grants and Finacial Aid). I didn't feel angry with the world, or sorry for myself. I was bound and determined everytime someone told me "you won't make it" to make them eat their words (a very satisfactory feeling when viewed in retrospective).
The real thing that bothers me about this string is the people mainly posting, and b!tching the loudest cannot spell. Maybe the "lack of education" is the problem......
Sort by Trending