Discussion Locked

Why is IT nearly all male?

0 helpful
630 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
It may just be the places I've worked, but why don't more women go into IT?

630 replies

by jdclyde

The public sector has more "diversity" because they will look to fill quotas, descriminating against anyone who is not the brand of person they are short on.

I personally DO see a lot of women in IT, but it is still a good 5 to 1 odds. I seem more women in IT SALES than actual administration. That would be more of a 3 to 1 odds.

NOTE: as many expect the women to not be good, I have found most work even harder to know their field better than many men. Then there are some that are just beotches because they feel they aren't taken seriously or feel threatened. I personally know both type.

by han810p9

I've been in IT for 32 years (yes, 32), and I've never seen so FEW women entering the field. I just posted two openings on several websites for network admins, and got an overwhelmingly (98%, actually) male response. I've also recently attended events by Cisco and Dell, and found myself the only woman there. It is sad to see it falling off like this. Back in the late 70's early 80's we were closing in on half....

I have joined mentoring groups in hopes of turning this around.

by m_a_r_k

Surfer, you've swallowed too much salt water. I hate to admit it ;) but girli is right. There's a higher percentage of men in the overall workforce and there is also a higher percentage of dudes than women in IT. But I wouldn't say IT is "nearly all male". There ARE more women in IT than there used to be. The IT world is not as lopsidedly skewed in the guy-to-gal ratio as, for example, the construction industry or the U.S. Army.

by surflover

said, it could just have been the places I've worked... at my last company, there was only one girl (out of ~50) under me when I started ... and about a dozen (out of 120) when I left.

by m_a_r_k

From 1 out of 50 to 12 out of 120. I'm not the world's sharpest mathmetician, but I'm thinking the odds of you finding a date went up from 2% to 10%. ;)

by montgomery gator

As I previously posted, males have only a slight numerical advantage (55-45) in IT where I work (insurance company). However, the Auto Underwriting department is 95% female, and the Propery Underwritng department is 85% female. Customer Service Representatives in our field offices are 99% female, but insurance agents are about 70% male. Building Maintenance department is about 90% male. The construction workers building the addition to the corporate headquarters are 100% male. IT is the only department that is close to even.

by itgirli

why you have so few women under you is anyone's guess. I think it's you. But what does that have to do with IT?

by charliespencer

17% of the Army's recruits in 2004 were female. Due to the Iraq war, that's down from 22% in 2000. I suspect that's higher than the percent of women in IT, but I'm sure someone will look it up.

by beoweolf

all mothers are women...100%. Maybe we ought to have a congressional investigation as to why women are keeping men out of the conception industry. We need to have parity. Something like Title IX might be in order?

Yes, men dominate some industries, but the concern seems to be directed exclusively at high pay, traditonal occupations. Men do, have done the dangerous, dirty jobs...that, over years, left them broken and used up. In the recent past, we have come to understand that occupational safety is not a bad thing...so women are being included in the work force.

I still don't see the clamor for women being represented in occupations further down the "glamor" tree. I think having women in the work force is actually a good thing. It forces society to take an honest look at hidden stressors, danger in occupations...thus making it safer, more fufilling for men too.

by jck

I smell gender bias...hahahaha

now you're keepin the man down!! :D

personally if the IT gal is attractive enough, she can keep me down anytime...after work hours, of course...none of that on-the-job closet shenanigans.

I'll keep my job, thank you.

I'll just save the shenanigans until I run the place ]:)

by jck

the man is keepin em down...

Women revolt!

Bra burning at jdclyde's...Friday...he'll collect them from you personally! :D

by m_a_r_k

We're not as bad as such crummy notorious keep 'em down places like Saudi Arabia. Oddly enough, Karen Hughes was in Saudi Arabia this week to try to furhter the spread of democracy and the American way. She gave a speech to a bunch of Saudi women. These stupid women almost unamimously told Ms. Hughes that they were living happy lives and didn't mind being oppressed, unable to vote, have a job or drive and being mentally and physically abused by the male gender. You can lead a horse to water but you can't make the damn thing take a sip.

by jck

that's similar to all those people who were doing the Lord's work in Jonestown by drinking cyanide-laced kool-aid too.

If you're abused long enough to be broken, you'll begin to believe anything you're told.

by jdclyde

how could they think differently?

I am sure you have heard similar things from people that have been in prison for long stretches. They will do something so they can get put back in because it is the only life they know.

You have these women that have been issolated for centuries. No education, so if they were to decide to become independant what would they be able to do?

They have been beaten down and don't know which way is up. Pity is a fitting word.

Although I DO like SOME of the polocies over in Saudi Arabia. Did you know if your wife has an affair you can bury them up to their necks and then throw stones at them until they are dead? How cool is that? ;\

by montgomery gator

I noticed your location in Islamorada. Getting tired of having to evacuate when hurricanes come through the Straits of Florida?

I grew up in Miami, and when I was little, we used to vacation in the Florida Keys (mostly on Key Largo). My parents used to own some land on Islamorada, but sold it about 20 years ago, when my Dad retired for retirement income.

by m_a_r_k

I did some scuba diving off of Islamorada a few years ago. One of my fins is laying at the bottom of the Caribbean near there. Good thing that was my last dive of the trip. I had crummy old fins anyway; needed to buy a new pair sooner or later. Do they actually have much IT there? Ain't much there but hotels and bars.

by surflover

the property has skyrocketted in the last 5 years (absolutely insane)... most place have gone up 500 to 700% in the last 5 years...

by jdmercha

Male brains and female brains are different. Males and females think differently. Although there are plenty of exceptions, studies show that males tend to be better at focusing in on a single problem. Females tend to be better at managing multiple problems. Females have a tendency to act from emotion. While males tend to act from logic. Thus more males tend to enter scientific work while more females tend to enter human services work.

The result: more male engineers
more female nurses
more male IT professionals
more female social workers

by itgirli

I have a female body and a male brain. First I worked with engineers, now I'm in IT. I think logically and have almost no emotions whatsoever.
(except about politics)

by maecuff

This drives me nuts. My female staff can focus on a single problem just FINE. And they are NOT the exception. That is ludicrous. Men act from logic??? Women from emotion?? How many times have you seen women ranting and raving at work?? I don't see it often, but the men sure have a tendancy toward that behavior. I would put that in the 'acting from emotion' bucket. I am not going to deny that men are logical, but no more or no less than women. It's a HUMAN thing, not a gender thing. As far as your example goes, I would say a nurse damn well better be able to focus and act logically in the course of his or her job.

by jdmercha

The ability to focus on a single problem and the tendancy to do so are two completely different things. My comments did not not state that one gender is better at something than the other. Only that they have a tendancy to behave in a certain way.

For that matter if you compare 100 female engineers to 100 male nurses, you will probably find that the males nurses will tend to act from emotion while the female engineers will tend to act from logic.

by neil higgins

is interesting.I tried to understand Freud,but got lost in the translation.Where I work,both male,and female IT workers tend to be different in the way the company "uses us".The guys go out and do the field work,at whatever company needs our help,whilst the girls answer calls at the main office,sort out the "hardware" and "software" IT stuff we may need,issue the contract documents,and log our schedules.I'm not saying this is the "norm",but such is life.Just for the record,many of my female collegues know as much about IT as the guys.My boss is female,or God as we call her.What she does'nt know about IT,would'nt fill a postcard.She's one cool lady and respected by everyone.

by absolutely

Which females? Which emotion? The only emotion I've seen women express more than men is grief -- they cry. Men scream until they're blue in the face. Have you ever seen a woman do that? Exclude screaming at their own children or family, and the answer is of course, no. Men are much more prone to outbursts of anger.

The average female scientist is a better science student than the average male scientist. I suspect that a lot of the women who are not scientists are equally or more capable of doing the work than the excess males who do study science. The difference is not ability, but honest recognition of the limits of their ability.

by tony hopkinson

propeller heads with no social skills, incapable of holding a conversation about none IT topics.

Where can I get help with this self esteem problem, I seem to have.

by surflover

the organization (if you noticed, the ratio went from 2% to 10% in less than a year, under my leadership)... so I don't think it's me, I guess I've just moved to places with that (low) level of female staff...

by jdclyde

that there are MANY here at TR that would love to meet Girlie or her astral twin somewhere.

My only grip is that she has read so much more than I have, and I have a "few" years head start.

The rest of the package though does seem more and more rare these daze. A young woman that is strong willed? Conservative? LOVES Monty Python? What isn't there to adore?

Then throw in the little skirt and oh my!

by av .

Places I have worked at in corporate America always had women in the IT department in a support or administrative role, but mostly all of the managers were male. IT is a male dominated field, as far as management goes.

I would even say that in some places there is a "boys club" where the male support or administrative workers bond with male management. Female IT workers are not part of that bonding.

I don't think most women are interested in the nuts and bolts of computing. There are more today than 10 years ago, but its far from balanced.

by jamesrl

I worked in corporate Canada, in a firm with tens of thousands of US employees. My first boss was female. In fact she rose up from being an admin assistant to a project manager, to a departmental manager. When I left she was a director. My other female boss in the same company was a former programmer - she was my remote boss, in North Carolina.

I've worked with lots of female techs, programmers and project managers, as well as female managers.

I haven't experienced the boys club, except with one outsourcer I worked with, with a bunch of junior PC techs who were sexist pigs with one of their collegues, and a supervisor who ingnored it. I sent off a lightening bolt and that situation changed.....

James

by av .

I think alot of men have a problem with women bosses. You are an exception. Of course, maybe its more acceptable in Canada.

I have a friend that works for a large financial corporation in the US. She is in charge of the all-male network guys. They absolutely hate her and try to do everything they can to give her a hard time. She was promoted into that job from another area of the company and I guess some of the network guys thought they were more qualified to do the job.

I just think if a guy was promoted into that job from another area of the company he would have been accepted into the "club". I'm sure there would have been power games, but the male bonding would still happen.

I've been a woman in IT for over 20 years and I was hoping to see more of a shift away from a "boys club" mentality, but it still exists today, too much.

What did you do to stop it? I'm not sure if you're talking about a sexual harassment type situation or just plain head games.

by charliespencer

IT is for anally retentives who think technology is more important than people. They develop this attitude after failing to achieve success with the opposite sex. Women realize people are more important than technology, and they have a much better success rate when trying to score. Hence they have better things to do.

Ain't nobody here but us pasty-face, basement-dwelling, sci-fi reading geeks.

by surflover

success rate when trying to score... to quote Rita Rudner, A guy goes on a date wondering if he'll score, the woman KNOWS" :-)

by jck

I didn't think you sounded like the judgemental feminist type.

You actually always reminded me of my boss at the government contractor years back. She was my coolest boss ever. Actually talked with me at my interview about Z80 programming. She wasn't just management...she actually knew what projects involved besides a cost and timeline.

Good to know you're not a Schafly-wanna-be.

by maecuff

I do, expect equal pay for equal work...would like the respect that goes along with having a penis, all that jazz, however, I'm far from militant.

I hope I'm a good boss, I treat my employees with respect, I'm as flexible as I can possibly be. My only issue, is that we were all peers before I took this job, so we had already related on a more personal level than most bosses do with their staff. I should probably be a little more removed than I am, however, given the small size of my staff and the close quarters we are in, that isn't likely.

by jck

don't grow a penis. I'd respect you less. Although, that probably matters little to you professionally since I'm in no way tied to you in that regard.

As for the before and after, don't worry about it. As long as they know they have to do their work and do it, be friends...co-workers...drinking buddies...whatever you were before you moved up.

I don't think like the establishment does. I try to be buddies with everyone I work with. If someone disrespects me personally, I don't carry it into the workplace. If I'm needed to work with them, I do it and do it efficiently. And, it goes the other way. When I was a supervisor, I didn't crack the whip in the office then buddy-up after hours. I wasn't out to prove anything to my boss other than I ran the department well as anyone else. And, I didn't have to alienate others to do so.

Keep your womanly parts. Keep your attitude. Keep your professionalism. Nothin wrong with you I've seen yet. In fact, you're one of the most professional, well-demeanored women I've talked to on this site.

So if the brass above you tries to change you professionally...tell them to buck off and come back when you've broken a term of your employment agreement.

Otherwise, you can call me and I'll come up and show them places their ties fit that they wouldn't have thought they would. :D

by absolutely

What is the traditional muslim punishment for women who do not submit to their husbands? Stoning would dissuade a lot of people from the exercise of free speech if their government considered it a crime instead of a right. Comparing those women to horses led to water and refusing to drink is insulting and dishonest.

by jdclyde

There is a big difference between not realizing what these women have been subjected to, and trying to minimalize it.

I don't think MARK was trying to minimalize.

by jdclyde

big time.

Even before they started suppling broad band to the rooms, you had normal operations of the hotel.

Then if they are a chain, it is even more important.

Many IT jobs today are NOT with Tech firms.

by jck

that doesn't sound too bad...I have flannel shirts and am good at driving.

Thanks for the professional advice, sir! :D

by maecuff

The old boss was a male putz. He was the epitome of misogyny. Which, for him, having a predominantly female staff was a good thing. He had more people he could abuse.

by m_a_r_k

Who said anything about sexism or prejudice? If you noticed in one of [b]MY[/b] posts, I said diversity is a good thing. I think most guys feel that way about jobs like IT.

by m_a_r_k

I got it right away. I chose to ignore it for as long as I could because I'm trying to learn how to become a saint. I was doing pretty good too. But when jd replied about it, I lost my will to resist.

by jdclyde

Knowing Girlie and the way she posts, it would have to be the fifth friday in Feb before she would mispost something like that.....

Although, she usually isn't so quick to join us on the dark side like that! ;\

by m_a_r_k

...that girli will some day turn over a new leaf and become a good little church girl. Hell, what am I thinking? I should know better by now.

by itgirli

Nope. I tried that. parochial school for 10 years (K5-9th). little plaid skirt and all. Ran from it. (well, kept the skirt).

by m_a_r_k

jck, having a dry spell lately?

girli, I did the parochial thing for my first two years of school. Boys had to wear khaki clothes. Girls had to wear church-girl blue skirts and white shirts and those funny church-girl white shoes with the big black stripe. We had nuns for teachers. They were mean as Dobermans. And most looked like Dobermans too. One time one of them asked me to get out my little reading book and read something. I didn't understand what the hell she said. So I asked her to repeat whatever the hell she said. She got pissed at me for asking. She reared back and walloped me across the cheek. If I hadn't been so yellow, I would have taken her out and become the school hero.

by jdclyde

that is a nice visual! Woo woo!

LITTLE plaid school girl skirt, do you put your hair up in pony tails too?

"Come to butthead, ah heh heh heh!" (while in the santabutthead costume)

by montgomery gator

Both went through the south Florida area. Rita went closer to you, if I am not mistaken. My mother was without electricty for 4 days after Katrina went over Miami, the eye went right over her house. Good thing a cousin of mine had a ready supply of ice to give her.

by montgomery gator

I have always thought Vulcan women were hot!!! Especially T'Pol (however its spelled) from Star Trek Enterprise. ITGirli, you look anything like her? :-)

by charliespencer

In the interest of furthering everyone's technical competence, please post any new photos of yourself in the aforementioned little plaid skirt. Inquiring geeks want to know.

(Now, why is IT mostly male? 'Cause this kind of harrassment runs amok, and most women are repulsed by us.)

by itgirli

That's okay. I'm not repulsed, nor do I feel harrassed. I think things should be taken for the joke they are, or if not a joke, it's still funny anyhow.

by jdclyde

isn't important. IF you follow through with the requests, THAT is what is important! WooWoo! ]:)

Heck with pictures, I want VIDEO! :x
[i]
Wow, uncharted territory! Not used to this conversation with you. You usually seem to stay above most of the smut talk it seems. Just not as depraved as the rest of us is how I always saw it.

by jdclyde

territory for me with girlie so I made a point NOT to go down the position road. (It is the thought that counts!)

]:)

by m_a_r_k

and [b]I[/b] was trying to steer it in a totally opposite direction with the church-girl theme. :) But [i]some[/i]body veered it back again. Is "totally opposite" a redundant phrase?

by surflover

I got it, but I have already posted that she IS the perfect girl in other posts (any woman who is against marriage, distrusts government, and celebrates love by getting drunk with a bunch of friends IS the perfect woman!!!)... (DUH, isn't that your response to the "mouse jiggling" Girli ?)...;-)

by bfilmfan

I saw Rita at New York, New York in Vegas about 3 years ago. I hope your wife's jokes aren't as stale.

And the next time she channels rudner, you should try channeling Ralph Kramden, Fred Flintstone and Gilligan. She will either run screaming from the house in total panic or be in hysterical giggles.

by neil higgins

you will have noticed that I too have a female boss.She has a first in computer science and maths,worked for her masters,and now is THE senior manager of the company.She worked her way up from making the tea,running errands,programming,junior office manager,senior line-manager,and finally God.She aint a director yet,but no doubt she will be. :)

by av .

I think you're referring to the "this brain study" post.

It sounds like you are the kind of guy that will look beyond gender and respect your boss, male or female, if they know their stuff. But you still did say "My boss is female,or God as we call her." You can take that 2 ways. Either you're in awe of her capabilities or you think she's too controlling.

It sounds like women are cast in a more supportive, administrative position at your company. Don't they have women and men doing field work? I just don't understand why not.

Maybe you can accept that hardware/software as the norm because you are a man, but for a woman in IT, thats a real kick in the skirt. I would like to think that if you know IT as well as the guys, there would be an equal opportunity.

by absolutely

it's bad for my self-esteem to constantly wonder if I would have gotten my job if some women hadn't been eliminated from consideration because of their gender. Or it would be, if I believed that. What I actually believe is that studies showing that women make $0.70/$1 that men make are themselves biased. They ignore time taken off for maternity leave, which has two effects. First, it is time they are not doing work (for their employer), and not being paid. Second, they are not acquiring new skills or even maintaining the ones they have. They return to the workplace less qualified than they left it. Finally, those studies compare "similar", not identical, jobs. If there were a true pay discrepancy for equal results, no men would ever be hired. Businesses pursue profit, not gender bias.

by maecuff

Nope. You can't hide behind the word 'TEND'. I'd have to say that this 'study' is bullsh*t. There are differences between men and women, but I don't think they are as black and white as you say. It's insulting and wrong to imply in ANY way that men are more logical than women. Some PEOPLE are more logical than other PEOPLE, it isn't based on gender.

by jdmercha

I never claimed that men are more logical than women.

It is entirely in the realm of possibility that a women who tends to act out of emotion can still be more logical than a man who tends to act out of logic.

by apotheon

When you can tell me why there aren't more women at LUG meetings, maybe you'll have an answer to why there aren't more women in IT.

by jez

sorry luv we're just better at it.

this is not a serious answer because it is not a serious quesiton. Why are more women nurses? Why are most soldiers men ?

This is to do with women and what they want. There is no reason why women should not do it in the same way men do, its just down to personal choice, honey.

by dc guy

More women are nurses because--for whatever reason--they care more about other people than we do.

More men are soldiers because we care LESS about other people than women do. We're actually willing to go out and KILL STRANGERS because some other testosterone-crazed madman tells us to!

This illuminating little exchange doesn't speak very well for our gender.

by charliespencer

My father, a retired Air Force officer, use to have a plaque in his office that read:

"A woman must work twice as hard as a man in order to be thought half as good.

Fortunately, this is not difficult."

by jamesrl

I seriously doubt there is anything innate in men that makes them better in IT. I did read about how math is taught in primary and secondary schools which said that the prevelent teaching methodology in math favoured the way boys learn, and that when the methodology was changed girls were ahead of boys.

As for nurses and women - role stereotyping. I am sure we all know women who would make lousy nurses and men who would make lousy soldiers. But typically women were encouraged to take up nursing or teaching as a "respectable" profession decades ago, and its still stuck. There are some physical apsects to nursing that would favour men - the requirements to lift patients for example.

Similarly I think more men are soliders due to part physiology(ability to carry large burdens), part history (women confined to certain roles, career limitations). In the hand to hand sphere men still have an advantage, but with good training the gap is narrowed.

I don't have any problem with women in the military at all levels and roles.

James

by itgirli

A real one. My ears have no lobes and one of them is pointed. Oddly enough, the other one isn't. I guess I'm only half-elven.

by jamesrl

I didn't see my female bosses in any different light - I tend to think that it always has to be case by case and generalizations based on sex or race or religion are dangerous.

I don't doubt that in the first situation that I and my co-workers were more qualified to be desktop techs than she was. But the point was she was more qualified to manage, deal with difficult customers, work with senior management etc. She was a good boss. Thats all that mattered.

The sexual harassment situation was not an overt touching or propositioning, but it doesn't have to be that to be harassment. It was more lewd comments designed to make her feel uncomfortable. What did I do to stop it? I spoke to my boss to make sure my management was onside, then I spoke to management at the outsourcing company. They replaced the supervisor with an older no nonsense type and voila, it went away.

James

James

by surflover

just makes you that much more intriguing... are you real? or are all us geeks we just having group male fantasies? :^O

by m_a_r_k

I hate to tell you guys this but if you wanna know the truth, girli told me that she's really a 6'3", 298 lb out-of-work plumber who lounges around all day drinking Schlitz and watching reruns on The Weather Channel. ITgirli's real name is ITRalph. Don't tell girli I told you all this. This is supposed to be a secret. I swore that I'd have to kill my 9th-born son if I told anyone.

by jck

And my name's Victoria and I own a lingerie store...

And...I do climatology studies for the Bush administration. :D

by m_a_r_k

You're Republican. You own a lingerie shop. You're interested in science. All sounds good but are you single? haha

by itgirli

No. I'm not a Matron Mother or any other level of drow society. Perhaps you have spent too long in Menzoberranzan yourself.

by smallfred

I have read all 99 posts on this thread and do not know what I want to reply to first.

I am one of two females in my group of about fifteen, but my boss and her boss are both female. In all of the other IT departments at my company there are females. Yes, there are more men, but I don't mind. :)

In what I have seen in IT a lot of the grunt work has been handed to men, while the management type positions have been given to women. I am sure that in other companies the reverse is true, which tells me it has little to with gender as a whole, but rather the climate of the company you work for.

Ok, next issue - women vs men and logic vs emotion. Again I would have to say that it is not a gender thing. I am a women, and I am an airhead (this is something I have learned to accept about myself) but I am not prone to answering problems with emotion. I am not overly emotion, nor am I extremely logical, I am middle of the road. Interestingly enough I do a VERY good job and am told that although I am not the most technical in my group I do a better job because I can relate to the client better. Is this because I am a girl, I think not. I believe it is because I am an airhead and people feel more comfortable admiting that they do not know how to do something or that they spilled coffee on their laptop to me than to a technophile who talks above their understanding. So neither more logic, nor more emotion help or hinder my job. It is a completely individual thing.

by jck

Remember...I'm old school...do you mean the computer game, or the City of Menzoberranzan, City of the Spider Queen? you know...Lolth?

Too much time in something? Not the computer game I assure you.

More like Monster Manual or Dungeon Master's Guide or Deities & Demigods from back around 1981 or so.

yeah...I played the real D&D...when you had to make up your own character sheets...none of tha pre-fab crap.

btw...did I mention my middle name is Drizzt? King Drizzt Swill? ;)