Discussion Locked

Win2K3 SBS setup, routing / firewall question

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm doing a Win2K3 Small Business Server installation, and it's REALLY SURE that it wants to configure the server with 2 NICs, one to the Internet and one to the LAN, and control the LAN's Internet access through the server. I've never setup a Windows Server in this role and wonder if it's really a recommendation in the real world. How secure is Win2K3 SBS in this configuration? I could see it might make some configuration issues easier, if these is automatic linkage between services enabled on the server, and ports opened or closed in the firewall / router.

Bottom line, Small network, 5 workstations, Win2K3 SBS, DSL access.

1. Should I trust Win2K3 SBS to perform the firewall routing function behind a simple NAT router to the Internet?

2. Or get a real firewall, put only 1 NIC in the server and let the server talk through the firewall just like all the other PCs ?

I need a fast simple solution installed yesterday.

Thanks, Cla

6 replies

by faradhi

Sonicwall make some that are ideal for small business. I am a windows administrator and under no circumstances would I use windows as a firewall.

by bfilmfan

Never ever use Windows as a software firewall when it is running Active Directory.

Ditto on the advice of get a real firewall.

by jnyphoto

I would suggest that you subscribe to the SBS newsgroup. You will find many posts that say the dual NIC is a standard install. You will also learn a lot about SBS 2003. Enjoy

John

BTW I have several installs with one NIC and a hardware firewall that I use to VPN to other sites.

by clabrown

Which SBS newsgroup do you recommend?

Sounds like even though you've read posts about dual NIC SBS you install yours with one NIC and a firewall.

The Installation Wizard indicates that IT considers dual NIC to be THE standard method. Kind of gives me the "willeys" given Windows security history.

On the other hand I'd like a path of least resistance, and I know sometimes it's better not to fight Microsoft if they REALLY WANT a particular configuration.

by richard

this is the quickest why to set it up. just close of any port/services on your router that you do not use.

by info

SBS Standard edition comes with a basic firewall based on the RRAS service and is usually better with a SonicWall/Netgear/PIX/Linksys type firewall/router in front of it. On the other hand, I have many installations with SBS Premium Edition which has ISA2004 as a firewall and they are perfectly protected. I suggest you see http://www.smallbizserver.net/ for the main types of configurations.

Steven Teiger [SBS-MVP]
http://www.wintra.co.il/

This discussion is closed to new replies.