Discussion Locked

Windows 7 (can you say "Vista")

0 helpful
26 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have been using the Windows 7 Beta on my system for the last two weeks. Overall I find it a great disappointment.

First the system I am running this on:
Asus P5K Motherboard. Bios AMI 1201. Intel Wolfdale E8400 at 3.0 GHz (not overclocked), 4 Gb of DDR2 1066 OCZ Gold (not over clocked either), Hiper 780w PSU, HIS Radeon HD 4670 Turbo Graphics Card, Dual 22" LCD monitors on DVI (one is a ViewSonic the other an X2GEN), Seagate 500 Gb HD (16 mb cache), Logitech G11 Gaming Keyboard, Logitech USB trackball.

Now for some of the issues:
The repeated issues with Windows 7 is the incompatibility errors with hardware and software I had been using on my XP Pro SP3 system configuration. BTW; I do have the XP Pro system installed on a different hard drive on the same computer. I select with OS to run during POST.

ATI Catalyst Control Center Beta (designed for use with Windows 7)keeps turning off. I can only use one monitor for the last several days.

Internet Explorer 8 Beta will not install on Windows 7. Incompatibility issue.

Trying to launch games (specifically Crysis and World of WarCraft) freezes the system requiring a forced restart.

Antivirus options are listed as three recommended providers. I don't subscribe to any of those so I am required to buy a new Antivirus.

Microsoft Office Pro 2003 will not install. I get an "Unsupported" error with Windows 7.

Every time I run certain programs (like speedfan) I keep getting a pop-up asking if I want to permit that program to run and make changes to my system and I am not able to turn the messages off. A complete nuisance.

I am not able to locate the start-up folder so I can place a program in it to automatically launch when the system boots (like speedfan).

In short the current configuration is useful for browsing the internet (thankfully Firefox 3 runs perfectly).

Until Microsoft gets the software makers, Bios writers, and hardware suppliers the option to write patches for this operating system Windows 7 is nothing more than Vista revisited.

If Microsoft insists on keeping the same kind of Vista security system (instead of using the model of XP Pro) the operating system will remain cumbersome at best.

If Windows 7 is a slick way to repackage Vista to convince business license contracts to subscribe to Windows 7, then I think Microsoft will be surprised to discover people flocking to Linux instead.

Windows 7 needs a great deal more work before it can hope to begin living up to the pre-release hype about it.
Benjamin

26 replies

by benjaminbsawyer

Of course it is a Beta. Much of my disappointment is the realization that the Beta is far rougher than the pre-release hype had been leading us to believe.

I am consistently surprised to see so many people posting rave reviews about Windows 7. I consistently see people saying the OS is so smooth and runs perfectly.

I had the expectation, (obviously a nieve one) that Microsoft would have done much more work to integrate the operating system with software already on the market prior to releasing the Beta. Especially with their own software. imagine; Microsoft not permitting Microsoft Office Pro 2003 from installing on their own operating system (and, "yes" it is a legal disk of MS Office Pro 2003).

I don't think it is unreasonable for me to expect Microsoft to have checked with the motherboard manufacturers to make sure the motherboards are compatible with the operating system. I had forgotten to mention that after the first install of Windows 7 I kept getting error messages that the motherboard drivers were not compatible with the operating system. The Asus P5k motherboard is only about 2 years old in design. Getting such a hardware incompatibility error is simply unacceptable from a new operating system.

It was only after Microsoft released the first update for the Beta was I able to connect to the internet and that motherboard compatibility error message stopped. The original release of the Beta wouldn't let Atheros Ethernet drivers install and run on the operating system.

by slayer_

It means I have tested the snot out of it on my hardware and my conditions. Then, the beta is released so others with their hardware and conditions can try it out, of course i expect it to have problems. That is what the beta is for!.

by dhcdbd

If you would have read the documents on the MS site about Windows 7, you would have found that M$ patterns W7 as a minor revision. Loosely translated this means W7 is Vista with a few tweaks.

It looks like you think that a beta version is suitable for everyday work. You will find that "Bleeding Edge" technology will make you bleed when M$ pulls the plug on the beta in July.

As to your complaints about AV, they are frivolous. I have tested many different AV packages against W7 and they work. Some of them I had to use compatibility mode set to Vista.

Games. I don't know. Have you tried compatibility mode? Probably not. Especially since there are benchmarks online that use both of the games you mentioned as benchmarks.

Drivers, especially Video -? This is beta. But I have found no problems with ATI nor NVidea.

W7 Security Center. It can easily be turned off.

Office 2003 - Compatibility mode.

Start up folder is not hard to find when you look in the right place. try the users folder.

Speedfan. You failed to allow it to "Always run as administrator," else did not install as administrator.

OS: Vista kernel 6.1, W7 kernel 6.1.

Problem diagnosis: PEBKAC (Problem Exists Between Keyboard And Chair).

Oh, I deliberately infected W7 with Trojans and virus then rolled the system back. It completely removed both. This is something that no other M$ offering has done.

This is from a native Linux user who expects that he will have to support users like you who want a toaster, which a computer is not.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I've been wondering why that platter thingy isn't big enough for a decent slice of bread. Guess I'm not supposed to use it as a cup or plant holder either?

Bummer, dood.

:D :D :D

by dhcdbd

That platter thingy is big enough to hold my cup of coffee.

Hey there, Boxy.

by the scummy one

an e-PC, you know those small toaster looking things? Remove the CD drive and put some bread in it. Watch out though, it has a habit of catching on fire because the toast does not pop out. And you need to dump the crumbs out after every use.

by benjaminbsawyer

Thank you for your suggestions. I have either tried those or those options (e.g., "Run as Administrator" during installation)were not offered during install.

If you check TechRepublics recent note about User Account controls having been effectively turned off by the Beta the effect has been I am not able to access some of the simple controls normally available.

Your blatant hostility is not appreciated.

Please be sure I have noted who you are and will make a point not to seek your services for computer repairs (should I actually need them).

But since you are obviously a legend within your own mind I'm sure you don't need to have normal social skills to maintain a healthy customer service reputation.

by the scummy one

Compatibility mode should work for several of your issues, and what the previous poster said should have worked. However, I do not have the BETA version (read BETA, not Finished and ready for everyday use).

You could have pointed out that there are features unavailable for your beta, however these are available in other versions and should be available for the release version. Going by this, the problem is that you are using a BETA version and expecting a full blown release version.

by dhcdbd

Not at all. You have not seen me being nasty.

Now, you noted and would not use my services. Perhaps you can tell me my name, either personal of business will do. Otherwise, well... let me give you a little jingo I have seen used: "Razzle them with your dazzle. If you cant razzle them with your dazzle, then buffalo them with bu!!sh!te." Guess which part is appropriate for you.

Now, the fact that you lack the experience or the knowledge to right click on an icon and select "Run as Administrator" simply shows your ignorance, not only of W7 BETA but of Vista and XP. Having shown your ignorance of the Windows OS, how can you form a qualified judgment that that a BETA version has some problem. Based on this I can conclude that you have determined that a computer is a toaster in which you stick in a piece of bread and a few minutes later you have toast. This is not true of a computer, you really do need to know more than where the power button is.

Putting all of this together, it can be determined that you are the problem and not the OS. This is not a hostile observation, just a true one that you take issue with.

by nfields191

I'm just curious why you tried to install IE8 Beta, when it comes auto installed in Windows 7.

Thus far, Windows 7 Beta has effectively replaced my XP install flawlessly. All drivers on my 5 year old system auto installed and work perfectly. Office 2003 works flawlessly, though I admit I haven't tried to uninstall it.

The following software works flawlessly on my windows 7 install.
CoD4
Left 4 Dead
FFXI
Dawn of War
Sins of a Solar empire
Office2k3
Kaspersky
Firefox
Acrobat

Turning down, or off, the UAC in user accounts takes care of the annoying "Do you want to continue" messages.

The only issues I have are a moderately longer startup time over XP (About 20 seconds longer) A LOOONG startup time for IE8 (though it's pretty snappy after it finally starts, plus firefox rocks) And it gives me fits streaming videos from either browser.

The last guy sounded hostile, because your initial post was little more than an uninformed rant, because you don't understand the concept of, nor the effort that goes into, a BETA version.

And why not look at some of the positives of windows 7. Less memory usage, less clutter, more control over your system, and I for one LOVE the auto resizing if you drag a window to the edges of your screen.

by benjaminbsawyer

I know what a BETA is. I am not expecting a full blown version. If anyone actually read my original post the message at the beginning and repeated at the end was that Windows 7 needs a great deal of work before it will live up to the hype of the pre-release press.

Name calling seems to be the way many are communicating on this list.

I chose not to detail every point that hasn't worked in my attempts to correct the issues I described in my post (please note the comment; ". . a list of SOME of the issues . . "). I believed people would have expected I would have taken the prescribed solutions to correct the problems. Perhaps I was wrong to believe the nasty responders were actually not so obtuse (I include you in that group).

Before you try spreading your venom (or male bovine fecal matter) around next time I suggest you try taking a few deep breaths first (at least).

by the scummy one

as I am not flustered, upset, or anything. Your post was hostile to the other guy, while b!tching that he was hostile. I had to join in on that -- just the Scummy thing to do :^0

As for your original post, I replied in a non hostile way, then I started reading the other posts here.
I would have to agree that there are/were some things that you may not have been aware of while trying to install. On a beta release, be prepared to spend time in the Beta forums for problems/fixes.
I understand that you were upset at the lack of win 7. I have had a copy downloaded from MSDN from before the Beta was released. However, I havent had the urge to install it yet, as what I have read makes it very little different than Vista.
From other places, I have also read that the amount of differences really does not justify a new OS version, but instead it should be a Vista service pack. But in any event, if it doesnt work for you, remove it. Personally, after testing Vista early, I started a move to Linux.

by dhcdbd

I can give you a list of M$ beta's that I have been involved with over the years: 95, 2000, XP, Vista, W7, Office 2007, Visual Studio 6, 7, & 8.

You wish to speak of the poor qualities of the beta's. To be blunt, you have no idea of what you are talking about. This is the most refined beta I have seen out of M$. It is of a better quality than most RC's and some RTM's.

On a Linux forum you would have been flamed or ignored because you failed to mention what, if any, steps you had taken to resolve the problem(s) and also failed to list any error messages. Number two, you do not apparently know that if W7 has a problem, the bug report starts, collects information and sends it to MS.

The next thing that you do not understand is that the people here are involved with computers to a greater extent than most and learned a long time ago that the user is more often confused, ill informed, or just plain ignorant of how a computer functions. Your original post clearly shows this. The assertion that you chose not to elucidate what steps you took to remedy the problems is, on its face, a lie.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

Hey there, yourself, DHCDBD. Whaddaya think. A small tropical for the platter thingy?

:D :D :D

by Member 19291532

That this is a case of a Linux person making a knee-jerk reaction to a Beta release of a Microsoft product and that the discussion is going to be a heated exchange, back and forth, between Linux defenders and Microsoft defenders that centers around this core fact.

With that said, of *course* Win 7 is a "repackaging" of Windows Vista - as certainly as they're all a repackaging of Windows 3.11. Windows is an evolutionary product. 7 is going to share a lot with the version that directly preceded it - fine tuned to address the concerns, complaints and feedback Microsoft received on Windows Vista. Vista is , contrary to popular belief on boards with a high percentage of Linux users, a *bad* OS. It got off to a rocky start, was a bit over-reaching in what it tried to deliver, and didn't have the most efficient code underneath it. Windows 7, though, seems to be well received so far throughout the industry by the most critical of reviewers. An example of how Windows 7 aggressively places itself is how it is already being adopted by a significant portion of Netbook users who claim it is running very well (at least in regards to performance) with those limited resources.

But the point is, a rational person knows that you can make certain judgments about Windows 7 based on the beta, for example, "It looks like they're keeping the aero interface mostly intact, and my subjective feeling is that I do not like the Vista theme that remains in Win 7"...

But going beyond that to get into arguments about stability and gaps in the HCL list on a BETA application just looks like a desperate desire to see Microsoft fail, not an argument based in anything relevant.

by dhcdbd

makes me think that you failed to read any of the responses and then threw hot air behind a fan.

There is exactly one post that jumps M$ for Linux. There is exactly one other post that mentions Linux (mine). That post does not jump M$ but rather informs the user of how to fix the problems and also tells him that he is all wet.

When the OP took offense with being called the problem because of inexperience, the posts culminated in my calling him a liar.

As to the Linux issue: all OS's have their places and applications in which they excel and their places and applications that they miserably fail. That I may prefer Linux over Windows is a personal and a subjective choice. That you may choose Windows or OS X or what ever is a personal and subjective choice for you. The fact that I can use any OS currently on the market and many that are now only historical notes does not make my choice any more or less informative - they are what they are.

That being said, it is you who have chosen to attempt to make this a flame war between Windows and Linux. I for one will not participate.

by neon samurai

Most of the responses are pointing out that that this is a beta release and issues are expected. Many of the comments admonish the original poster for going to such lengths to complain about a beta release not functioning like an SP2 release.

Some of the people pointing out the obvious flaw in the original poster's rant are "those Linux heathens" too.

Your hardon against a particular OS kernel may be showing.

This discussion is closed to new replies.