As industrial or spycraft technology becomes commoditized, side-channel attacks such as photographing keyboards with FLIR cameras presents a security risk.
Researchers at University of California Irvine have demonstrated the ability to recover passwords from the thermal residue of computer keyboards, in a recently published paper. The attack type, called "Thermanator," was tested using a commodity-level FLIR SC620 infrared camera, and four standard PC keyboards. The researchers indicate that "entire sets of key-presses can be recovered by non-expert users as late as 30 seconds after initial password entry," while partial sets can still be viable to recover one minute after entry.
The idea is a longstanding science fiction trope, appearing as a plot point in (among others) Max Headroom. The researchers note that "many niche computational and sensing devices have moved from Hollywood-style fantasy into reality." As the cost of thermal cameras have become within reach of attackers of average means, this type of attack extends beyond deep-pocketed state-sponsored actors.
Of particular interest, FLIR brand imaging devices are available at a variety of price points—the researchers highlight the X8500sc, which they claim to be available for about $100,000, as being at the high end of the market. Conversely, the FLIR One Pro is available for $400 and can attach to any Android smartphone, while the CAT S61 smartphone integrates a FLIR camera into the phone itself.
In their research, the researchers attached the camera to a tripod, set 24 inches above the keyboard. Both secure and insecure passwords were used for the experiment. For "hunt and peck" typists, the participants guessing passwords from images were able to correctly guess "12341234" on average "45.25 seconds after entry." For comparison, the weakest result, "football" was recoverable after 25.5 seconds, on average. When using secure passwords, the researchers note that full recall was possible between 19.5 seconds and 31 seconds.
For touch typists, the researchers indicate that the best (most secure) was "12341234," which took 47.6 seconds on average, with "jordan23" at 17.8 seconds. The researchers indicate that full recall was only possible, on average, in the first 14.33 to 18.5 seconds, as images after this time were too indistinct.
SEE: Cybersecurity strategy research: Common tactics, issues with implementation, and effectiveness (Tech Pro Research)
In terms of efficacy, the researchers note that so-called "hunt and peck" typists are particularly susceptible to having their passwords recovered through Thermanator-style attacks, as these typists use their forefingers to type, thereby using a larger fingerprint for a longer period of time for each keystroke than touch typists. Accordingly, touch typists generate a great deal of "thermal noise" by resting their fingers on the home row of keys on the keyboard, making it more difficult to analyze infrared images of keyboards. The researchers also note that typists with with long acrylic fingernails are "virtually immune" to Thermanator-style attacks, because users with those leave nearly no thermal reside when tapping keys with fingernail tips.
Insider attacks like this, as well as lunchtime and shoulder-surfing attacks that rely on the carelessness of users are increasingly appealing modes of extracting information from organizations. Enterprises should have policies in place to limit access to sensitive files to users who have no need to interact with that data, as well as employ two-factor authentication in an effort to reduce the efficacy of these attacks.
The big takeaways for tech leaders:
- By measuring "thermal residue" using FLIR cameras, it is possible to recover passwords typed on keyboards.
- According to researchers, "entire sets of key-presses can be recovered by non-expert users as late as 30 seconds after initial password entry."
- You've been breached: Eight steps to take within the next 48 hours (free PDF) (TechRepublic)
- The dumbest passwords people still use (ZDNet)
- Cheat sheet: Two-factor authentication (TechRepublic)
- Windows 10: We're going to kill off passwords and here's how, says Microsoft (ZDNet)
- Security researchers want to force people to use different passwords for every website (TechRepublic)
- The best Mac apps to manage all your passwords (Download.com)