E-mail clients are often loaded down with too many features; sometimes a simple e-mail client is all you need. Jack Wallen compares three Linux e-mail-only clients.
I don't like suites. I avoid using one large application that uses smaller applications to take care of business, or large applications that do it all. I'm also not a fan of groupware. However, I am a fan of small, reliable applications, which is why I often search for solid applications written to handle one job at a time.
E-mail clients are often loaded down with too many features. Rather than one big groupware package like Outlook or Evolution, sometimes a simple e-mail client is all you need. I'm going to hold three Linux e-mail-only clients up to today's standards and see how they fare. The e-mail clients we'll look at include Balsa, KMail, and Sylpheed.
When I finally came into my own with Linux, I discovered a beauty of a simple e-mail client: Balsa. At the time, this client freed me from relying on text-only e-mail.
The Balsa application helped me learn that Linux could hold its own in the PC realm. Even 10 years ago when it was still in beta, this application was solid, reliable, and user-friendly. It didn't have extensions, spell check, or junk mail. Balsa simply read, replied to, deleted, and saved your e-mail.
Balsa was the first GUI tool that I used in Linux whose sole purpose was to process e-mail. It wasn't part of the quickly outmoded Mozilla; it actually integrated with my desktop in both look and feel, which was important. I'll always remember how different Mozilla looked when it fired up; at the time, I was trying desperately to make my Linux desktop to not look like the old-school UNIX-like desktop, and Balsa gave me that ability.
Today, Balsa is an e-mail client for the GNOME desktop. At one time, the developers at GNOME were going to create an office suite, and Balsa was going to be the e-mail application for that suite. Balsa is still stand-alone, however, and offers the following features:
- Local mailbox format support (mbox, maildir, and mh)
- Allows nested mailboxes
- POP3 and IMAP support
- Printing support
- Spell check
- Multi-threaded e-mail retrieval
- MIME support
- SMTP or local MTA support
- GNOME-integrated address book
- Multiple character sets for composing and reading messages
- File attachments
- GPG/OpenPGP signing and encryption
Installing Balsa is simple. If you are using an rpm-based distribution, you can run yum install balsa. If you are running an apt-based distribution, you can run apt-get install balsa. The installation will fetch the requirements -- at minimum, it will install libESMTP and GMime -- and do its thing.
The first time you run Balsa, you'll need to set up your account. The first screen is a simple Welcome screen. The next screen is where the real action occurs. Figure A illustrates the information needed to setup your e-mail account with Balsa.
The next screen, Figure B, allows you to fine-tune your Mail Files directories.
The final screen asks if you want to use Balsa as your default e-mail client. By selecting Yes, you'll configure Balsa to be used when you click mailto: links within a Web site or document.
Once Balsa is configured, you'll see the default Balsa window, which reveals the simplistic beauty of this e-mail client. This window is shown in Figure C.
During the initial setup, there was a place to name the incoming mail server; this isn't actually a name for the server, but the actual address. No fear, though: You can go into the Settings menu and select Preferences to take care of this. Select Mail Options to show the remote mailbox settings. Figure D shows the three strange accounts that Balsa creates.
Balsa's address book
Balsa behaves much like your standard e-mail client. One of the few differences is getting an address book up and running. To get started, select the Preferences entry from the Settings menu and then select Address Books.
Let's add an LDIF-type address book. From wherever the source, you'll have to export your address book as a LDIF list. Once you have that, back in Balsa, press the Add button and select LDIF from the list. A new window will appear, which is where you'll search for your exported address book. Find that address book, name it, and press Add. Your addresses are now available in Balsa.
Balsa handles junk mail filtering through procmail, an outstanding tool for the filtering of e-mail. Procmail is far too complicated to tag onto this section of this article, however. Outside of handling junk mail, Balsa is a standard e-mail client. The learning curve is nil.
KMail is part of the Kontact suite of tools, but can be run as a stand-alone client. KMail is installed with a standard KDE installation, but, like many KDE applications, does not depend on KDE to be up and running. KMail is a bit more complex (read: Feature Rich) than Balsa. KMail includes the following features:
- Maildir support
- Address book
- Older message expiration
- Auto-encryption using OpenPGP
- POP3, IMAP support
- SSL/TLS support
- Pipelining for POP3
- On-demand downloading
- SMTP authentication
- SMTP over SSL/TLS
- DIGEST-MD5 authentication
- Nested folders
- Mail filters and local delivery
- Mailing list aware
- External mail client importing
- HTML mail support
- Spelling check
- Threaded viewing
- Multiple identities
- Color quoting
- Background sending/receiving
- KDE integration
- POPUP address completion
- Mail bounce (anti-spam)
- UTF-7 support
- PGP/MIME support
- S/MIME support
- Custom icons and dates
As you can see, the feature list for KMail is much longer than for Balsa.
Setting up an e-mail account is almost self-explanatory with KMail. Simply go to the Settings menu and select Configure KMail. From the new window shown in Figure F, press the Accounts button and then press Add.
One of the most interesting features of KMail is the Certificate Manager Kleopatra, a KDE tool used for managing X.509 certificates in the GpgSM keybox and for retrieving certificates from LDAP servers. This tool is more of a power-user tool because it allows you to manage encryption keys used in OpenPGP signatures. You can even generate new key pairs from within Kleopatra.
Another nice feature in KMail is the ability to set expiration dates for folders or mail. Suppose you have a particular folder that you want emptied every thirty days; to do this, right-click on that folder and select Expire. A new window will open -- shown in Figure G -- where you'll configure this action.
Once you have decided which types of e-mail will expire, you can set up their configuration.
KMail also includes both an anti-junk and anti-spam filter wizard. The anti-spam wizard configures SpamAssassin, and the anti-virus wizard configures ClamAV. Both tools are quickly becoming standard in Linux; both wizards make setup easy. To get these tools, simply go to the Tools menu and select which wizard you want to start.
Outside of these tools, KMail is exactly what you would expect from a modern e-mail client.
Sylpheed is another stand-alone e-mail client that contains all the features you'd expect in an e-mail client:
- Includes an outstanding UI
- Handles Junk filtering
- Supports multiple protocols
- Filters and searches
Installing Sylpheed with an rpm-based distribution is as simple as issuing the command yum install sylpheed. Once installed, issue the command sylpheed. You'll have to configure your first account before using the client. Configuring an account is fairly straightforward: Figure H illustrates the necessary items.
Once set up, Sylpheed behaves exactly as you would expect. One of the nicer tools available is the filtering tool. This tool can be invoked two ways. If you're reading an e-mail, you can select Create Filter Rule from the Tools menu and choose from the following:
- By: From
- By: To
- By: Subject
You can also create rules by starting up the Filter Settings from the Configuration menu. In the window shown in Figure I, you can add, edit, or delete rules.
There is one other feature unique to Sylpheed that bears a bit of attention. The Actions tool -- invoked from the Configuration menu -- allows you to configure external commands to process message files. Suppose you want to view a selected message in an external viewer (i.e., gedit.) To do this, fire up the tool and enter the following:
- Menu Name: Gedit
- Command Line: gedit %p&
Press the Add button and your new action will appear in the Registered Actions window. You can see this in Figure J.
This tool can become very powerful if used correctly. Like KMail and Balsa, Sylpheed is an e-mail client that meets today's demands, but adds a bit of extra oomph in a way only a Linux tool can.
I have run the gamut of e-mail clients over the years, and can therefore safely say that all three of the above clients will satisfy most of your needs. The biggest downfall for two of these clients -- Balsa and Sylpheed -- would be their inability to successfully view HTML mail, but each make up for this by either having developed plug-ins for external viewing of HTML mail, as in the case of Sylpheed, or having enough outstanding features to render this a non-issue.
Of course, for some, the ability to view HTML mail is crucial; for those folks, KMail is the client to use, since it is able to render HTML mail. Outside of HTML mail, each of these clients does an outstanding job. Any Linux user would be remiss to not give at least one of these clients a chance.