But if you really feel that one's support for an individual program, also deemed imperative by large percentage of your population, illustrates the true character of the supporter, so be it. Either way your protective claim does not scare me away from offering my opinion.
[b]Fears of government control[/b]
You have to realize that what you are seeing as social reform is actually very different from what socialist programs actually offer.
Government run insurance companies in socialist countries are usually monopolies, those monopolies often come at a higher price due to lack of competition and offer the consumer less choice.
[b]Socialist programs result in monopolies[/b]
Take for instance, the Insurance Corporation of BC (motor vehicle)for many years they had a monopoly. They were extremely overpriced, offered the worst claims services and literally screwed each and every driver in BC for decades. Now the ADDITIONAL insurance is opened up to other market players, meaning your base insurance is still covered by ICBC but you have a choice of more options when it comes to third party protection, theft, comprehensive etc. They aren't much better in most cases but there are options and thus their prices are slightly lower.
For many MANY years, Stentor was an umbrella encompassing most provincial telephone services in Canada. The price for long distance calls was insane, features were expensive and there was no competition. Stentor was a monopoly, available in some provinces where the local telephone service was not owned by the provincial government, such as in BC. However THAT monopoly was owned y US giant, GTE, but again protected and supported by Canada's government. Opening up that market to private companies has lowered the cost of such services dramatically again.
[b]The American answer to such programs[/b]
In the US, this form of government provided medical insurance works in the opposite way. Your PRIVATE system is flawed, overpriced and unaffordable for many. The government is offering an affordable alternative for those who cannot afford or choose not to deal with a private insurer, the absolute reverse of what has happened in Canada and the UK.
Private insurers are soaking consumers as there is no reasonable limit to how much they can charge and how little they can offer for it. For years the issue of competition has been raised, but they refused to act in a way that made services available to a wider portion of the US population.
At this time, in order to protect Americans health, to retain the nations strength and power, the government realizes that people need to be healthy first and foremost. People must be ale to go to work, must be healthy enough to support the military, must be fit enough to outperform competitive nations.
[b]Retaining or recovering America's strength and power[/b]
PEOPLE offer your strength, not just independence and capitalism. PEOPLE's strength and determination made America rise to the top, not private, free enterprise.
So for your government to offer an affordable alternative to an already overpriced rip-off of a system, despite what your fears of losing individual liberties may be, it is something people have asked for and supported in America for years, only to be completely ignored as the rich get richer and the poor get sicker and weaker. (sorry, long sentence there)
So yes I support ANY system that affords the poor access to more affordable health care. I support ANY system that opens up new opportunities to the downtrodden. I support ANY system that will offer an equal playing field and afford more people opportunity to better themselves.
[b]The free ride[/b]
I know you've worked very hard to get to where you are and don't like seeing others being handed a free ride, and YOU know that I am not different in that respect either.
But this is just basic health care, not opportunity or riches, it simply opens doors for others.
[b]Government competing with private business[/b]
In the case of government competing with business, I don't think the objective or even possible outcome is competition with private business.
You will always choose your own insurer and will pay the premiums that you deem fair for such a service. That is your freedom which is afforded to you as a result of your own hard work resulting in a higher income that affords you such choice. I don't think fears of lower quality due to their being forced to offer lower rates should be an issue. I think that IF they decide to offer a low cost alternative to low income clients, the cost for your insurance and the additional benefits/services provided will be superior still.
[b]Socialism[/b]
Government control of a program in order to monopolize and control a market segment is not what this is at all. In fact it is the absolute opposite. They are offering an alternative to private care, it's not changing from government control to very limited private care.