Discussion Locked

"a government-run insurance plan"

0 helpful
419 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

[i]"A key Democrat voiced confidence on Sunday that Senate leaders will include a government-run insurance plan in the healthcare bill they bring to the full U.S. Senate for consideration -- and suggested it might even pass."[/i]

Source and full context:

http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20091018/pl_nm/us_usa_healthcare

What's wrong with this picture? Or, if you're bold enough to show your true colors, what's right with it?

419 replies

by charliespencer

I frequently hear the stats that 1/6th of our economy is tied up in health care, and 1/7th of the population are either not covered or inadequately covered. Some regard that 1/6th as making health care too large a slice of our economy for the gov't to interfere. I regard it as too large a slice to allow to remain at that size, especially with the level of service provided.

I think the private sector has done a very poor job providing what I consider a necessary service. I don't advocate any new programs; instead, this service should be provided by expanding those eligible for existing programs.

For-profit providers costs are out of reach for a substantial number of consumers. Instead of getting routine preventative care, they wait until a problem is critical or use emergency rooms for non-critical issues. Some claim putting these people (including illegal aliens) under a gov't run program will mean the rest of us will be paying for their care. In reality, their costs are already shifted to the rest of us through the portion of our insurance premiums used to compensate providers for those losses.

In short, I just don't see how Uncle Sam can manage this any worse than it already is.

by maxwell edison

So many people seem unable to back-up a step and consider the more important underlying premise - or principle upon which we govern ourselves. People should have the right to make personal choices in their lives without being dictated to by government. This is another case in which personal choice could be - and most likely WILL BE - infringed upon even more than it is already.

Spare me the rhetoric about proposed plans allowing people to choose their own insurance options, choosing their own doctors, blah, blah, blah. Those choices - as well as other life choices - WILL BE affected.

Do you choose to smoke? Do you choose to consume foods that pack on the pounds? Do you choose to have a diet that raises your cholesterol level? Do you choose activities in life that pose a greater risk? If so, be prepared to have some government (or insurance) bureaucrat dictate to you how you need to alter your life choices or pay more - or both.

And possibly, do you choose to live your life without any insurance at all? There are people who might want to be self-insured. Go to the doctor, pay cash, end of story. In those cases, it might only be the catastrophic cases that throw a wrench into the system. But then again, back-up and consider the whole premise of the system as we currently know it to be.

A citizen will be forced to buy insurance, whether they want to or not - freedom of choice will be denied.

A citizen will be forced to alter lifestyle choices or pay more, or be penalized - or both - etc. - freedom of choice will be denied.

More nanny state equals less choice. It's simply not possible to have more of the former without having to give up more of the latter.

I don't know about you, but being dictated to by anyone in government - presuming government knows what's best - is most distasteful. In fact, it's simply not acceptable to me.

by delbertpgh

The country needs to provide medical coverage for its people. To me, that's simply a given. If we're going to use the insurance model to cover medical costs, then everybody has to buy it. I think that insurance isn't the best way; costs have gone out of control under insurance. But insurance seems to be what we're going to do.

In any case, people deserve medical care that won't bankrupt them. It's the mark of a decent civilization that has achieved a certain level of prosperity. We already do guarantee all people necessary coverage; we just limit it to people who will fit under certain government programs, and to anyone else in emergency cases, and pass the costs on to the insured base and to the taxpayer. It's not efficient and not effective.

There's lots of choice that's already gone. Try not paying your taxes, or not buying auto insurance, or remodeling your house outside of the building code, or printng your own money, or walking naked in the streets. When I was young, there was a draft; you couldn't disregard it, at pain of going to jail; and if you cooperated, you could be sent into combat. There's too much that is compulsory about life to pretend that you'll be saved by basing medical care (i.e., life and death versus bankruptcy) on private choice and private resources.

by charliespencer

I don't see a government option as an alternative to private insurance as automatically leading to government dictation.

I too am opposed to mandatory insurance. In particular, it makes no sense to mandate insurance and then compensate people to buy it. This in particular makes the argument for a government option more persuasive. Why fund another program to launder tax money through private citizens on it's way to insurance companies. Expand an existing program and keep it all under one roof.

I don't see anything in the linked article that references the personal choices you mention. I'm opposed to government interference in those areas, but are the topics you raised included in any of the proposed legislation? If so, I'd appreciate links; I've been unable to find anything.

I don't buy into 'slippery slope' arguments; I find concerns about what might be are too often used to prevent any change at all. I believe you and I have a philosophical difference on this subject.

by jck

If you give the person the right to choose whether or not to have medical insurance, then you must give the medical establishment open right to choose who they treat.

Because, most hospitals are open to tort if they do not treat someone with illness or injury. Yet, they can not be guaranteed to make any income if that person can not pay.

Therefore, you must either provide both person and establishment the right to choose. Otherwise, you give the person all the power and the business no option in many cases.

BTW, the government-run insurance is an *option*. The privately-run insurers will still be there to choose from.

Also, it's funny when you say this:

[i]Do you choose to smoke? Do you choose to consume foods that pack on the pounds? Do you choose to have a diet that raises your cholesterol level? Do you choose activities in life that pose a greater risk? If so, be prepared to have some government (or insurance) bureaucrat dictate to you how you need to alter your life choices or pay more - or both.[/i]

There are government-run health systems all over Europe, and none of them charge different rates for different people. How do they survive?

You and other Americans would have people believe they can't. However, look at Holland, Italy, England, Australia, Israel, etc. They all still exist after decades. I wonder why?

Doom and gloom. Doom and gloom.

But I have to agree with you. Being dictated to by most anyone in government is distasteful. Maybe because of the fact that most of them are paid-for and bought by special interest.

If I had people up there who actually knew what it was to work for a living (instead of a bunch of silver-spooned capitalists), I might have less doubt.

by forum surfer

If we're forced to go with whatever specialists our gov't run health care providers deem necessary, I'll be highly displeased. My son has a condition with allergies and a problem with range of motion in his right foot. I take great care in going to the most highly reputable specialists within traveling distance, expenses be damned. If I am forced to go with whatever half assed joe schmoe md is close by, words cannot describe my outrage.

The healthy lifestyle bit is already being forced upon us. My health-care provider requires that I take physicals and "readings" by their "health-care team professionals" once per quarter. I always schedule physicals with my regular doctor on the same days, and my results are always predictable worse with the insurance doctors. Go figure. I still like to walk in with my own charts and histories just to be an ass about it. Then they tell me I should exercise more often because I'm in the upper regions of my bmi. I then explain that I have been exercising regularly 1.5 or more hours a day, 7 days a week in order to gain weight. The fact that BMI means nothing escapes them. The fact that my doctor says I am more healthy than I was ten years ago also escapes them. That isn't covered on their little insurance exam placard. These people have just enough medical certifications to write down readings taken from samples they barely understand on machines they can barely operate. Yet their finding directly impact my wallet.

Insurance companies already suck. :(

I for one, believe the government will screw up health-care even more. The only difference is that I'll be paying for all these people out there who elect not to have insurance because their premium's high prices affect their lifestyle. I'll also be paying insurance for people who are too lazy to work. We need "lazy ass" reform in this country, not health care reform. I'm a firm believer that people who need help should get it, but I'm also a firm believer that you should attempt to help yourself first.

-end rant-

:)

by oz_media

Look at Canada for example, our government spends a lot of money campaining about healthy diets, smoking cessation, drinking less etc.

Before I go on, I do agree that the bans have gone to extremes, in the sense of truckers being fined for smoking in their trucks, as it's a workplace etc.

Health Canada has also pushed fast food joints to offer better menus, less fat, salt etc.

They have also made EVERY food manufacturer sellign into Canada, include the full dietary and nutritional contens on all food packaging, in the same format for easy recognition.

THESE are the invasive health practices we have forced upon us due to the govfrenment payign for health care. If i eat myself to a heart attack, it isn't effecting my 'insurance' in any way shape or form. If I smoke myself into tripple or quadrouple bypass surgery even multiple times, my health plan is still nto effected.

They let consumers do as they please, they enact rules agains the manufacturers of such products to ensure the consumers have a choice and know exactly the dangers of their habits or chocies, they don' thowever restrict those choices from the consumer though.

[i]"I don't know about you, but being dictated to by anyone in government - presuming government knows what's best - is most distasteful. In fact, it's simply not acceptable to me."[/i]

Me neither and that's not the case here at all.

by tonythetiger

Private insurance increasing in costs... deductibles rising... new taxes...

"I see a bad moon a-rising."

by charliespencer

I suspect we'd have more participants on this discussion if this PTBs would drop the bomb on this idiot and his buddy. The topic is buried in all the 'updated' zombies.

by darryl~

People just can't figure out which are the active discussions because of the amount of spam these people are generating.

For the most part, I'm staying out of this discussion....but I know people in Canada are watching what's going on down there with great interest. They've been "trying" to fix our health care system for years....it seems like it just keeps making things worse.

We may have free visits to the doctors/hospitals/specialists but we are taxed heavily for that & we have long waits for many procedures (years...not weeks), and when it comes to medications you darn well better have Blue Cross or some other insurance up here....so in addition to the taxes, I'm also forking out a couple hundred dollars a month for my Blue Cross.

So like I said earlier, many up here are watching with great interest & hoping we can grab a few ideas to sort out our messed up health care system.

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]The country needs to provide medical coverage for its people. To me, that's simply a given.[/i]

What do you mean, [i]the country needs to provide [/i].....? We're a nation of self-governed individuals. For someone to say that [i]the country needs to provide[/i] anything is just another way of saying that one individual [i]must provide[/i] something for another individual.

Moreover, [i]medical coverage[/i] and medical care are two things that are distinctly different, yet talked about as though they're one in the same. They're not one in the same.

by jck

Or, self-indulgent?

If all people would govern themselves properly, you wouldn't have cases like Caylee Anthony, Adam Walsh, Nicole Brown, Sharon Tate, and Matthew Shepard.

Until then, you and I both need government to provide.

Otherwise, someone might self-govern you with a gun if you switch lanes too fast and cut them off.

After all, it would be their choice. Right?

by maxwell edison

Self governed and individual rights - AS LONG AS THE RIGHTS OF OTHERS IS NOT INFRINGED UPON.

Why do you insist on citing such silly examples?

The role of government is to protect individual rights. One person does not have the right to, as you suggested, [i]self-govern (me) with a gun if (I) switch lanes too fast and cut them off[/i] - just like there is no right to force me - or you - into any medical scheme.

by delbertpgh

"Medical care" is something you periodically need to keep on living. "Medical coverage" is paying the bills for care, so that you can get what's necessary if you don't have money, and so you won't go broke in case you do have money. The threat of bankrupting one's self would discourage a lot of people from getting care. In fact, it does so today, in a minority of cases, but still frequently.

To say that a country of self-governed individuals is nothing more than individuals, and that to pay somebody else's medical bills is to financially favor one individual over another, is a fallacy. First, a country is more than the sum of its parts; it is beyond an aggregation of individuals. America means history and purpose, as well as laws, money, roads, the army, police, food inspection, free markets, etc.; lots of rights, rules, and freedoms that don't come into being just because a dozen people get together in a room. Second, the wealth and opportunity we enjoy is due to the common work of all America; individualism counts, but the individual can leverage his initiative with social institutions that confer him wealth beyond his own powers to create it. Third, however your background may improve or limit your power to choose freely, sickness and accident are not in most cases the results of choice. You may choose to smoke or not, and either way you go, you may or may not get cancer; and the same goes for your dependent child, who never smoked. Of course, smoking, drinking, motorcycling, and overeating all increase risk, but there is more to health than statistics.

The government has an interest in the welfare of individuals. Its duty to care for individuals by overriding the rights of other individuals is accepted in the cases where children are removed from the homes of sexual abusers, or firemen break through doors to rescue somebody. Medical care is life over death, or well-being over suffering. Coverage is necessary to the care. Government is obliged to guarantee it.

by tonythetiger

[i]"Medical care" is something you periodically need to keep on living.[/i]

Someone who's never been sick "needs" medical care?

by jck

What's right? Providing affordable healthcare insurance. If you've ever had to pay over $10k a year just for a health insurance policy out of your wages, you would know why this is the right thing to do.

What's right also? Maybe a government-run healthplan that's priced fairly will make insurance companies either operate at a fair rate, or run the ones out of business who can't compete with an insurance group outside of the ones whose executives they can schmooze with at the country club on Saturday to collaborate on rates and profitability.

What's wrong? There are already regulations that, if enforced, would cut the cost. This is just double spending. The federal government needs to get off their arse and do their job, rather than pandering to each special interest that comes along.

Moral to this story: Never trust politicians to fix things.

Send a housewife or a farmer to represent you next time, who actually has to do something in life all day long to make things work.

Not some overly educated ninny who thinks his high-cost diploma makes his feces not stink.

Nuff said.

by oz_media

I think many people see this, as healined often, as a way for the government to compete with private, free enterprise.

I don't see that at all.

In countries with socialist, government run programs, such programs are monopolized and VERY expensive as a result. Offering government ALTERNATIVES to private business doesn't compete with them, it offers what they refuse to offer themselves.

If all policy providers were offering affordable health care and the government competed to drop prices, that's a different story.

What I see is a government filling a long needed hole that insurers were more than aware of in the past and have failed to provide a solution to, as they are focused on a much more proftable market segment.

by jdclyde

I thought I had heard in Canada you could not pay to go to a private health care provider?

by jdclyde

[i]"Send a housewife or a farmer to represent you next time, "[/i]

This, the one that has nothing but hate for Palin (someone he has never met, based only on what reporters have said about her) and her lack of qualifications, while has had nothing but praise for the current sitting president thanks to his education level.

Consistency, you know it not.

by oz_media

"Consistency, you know it not."

Talk about hypocrisy. You jump on anythign that is printed abotu Obama withotu hesitation, whether correct, a ridiculous spin etc. ANYTHING th media says you will jump all over and start a thread dedicated to teh crap they sling. However, when it is anyone but Obama or someone else you opt to dislike for the sake of it, you quickly dismiss anything the media says against him/her and throw it out as media BS.

I also agree with Max in that you two are very alike, in that specific manner anyway.

by maxwell edison

[i]Not some overly educated ninny who thinks his high-cost diploma makes his feces not stink.[/i]

Of course, if it's a conservative Republican [i]housewife[/i], that person will be deemed unqualified for the job because she's not an [i]overly educated ninny (with) a high-cost diploma.[/i]

Kinda' like you were saying a year ago about Sarah Palin.

by jdclyde

just how personally hateful people got towards her. It is one thing to disagree with someones politics or even dislike them based upon the way they are presented in the media, but to just be foaming in the mouth hateful like that?

I have disagreed with just about everything Obama has said or done, but I don't recall attacking him based on his personality or lack of one? He is arrogant, true, that that isn't what I disagree with, nor WHY I disagree.

by jck

Does your job make you pay for insurance out of your check?

Mine does. They won't give me the hundreds per month they pay. I get no option.

So, cry me a river. That's already happening to millions of working Americans and you failed to write a big rant about that.

Or is it business' right to push things on you, but not government?

So please. Make your assessment of process fair and equal whether private or public...before you put the onus of responsibility on the shoulders of your government alone.

by jck

Tears of laughter.

I know how to block people from my website...hilarious this isn't nipped my some web admin deep in the bowels of CBS Interactive.

by maxwell edison

[i]...hilarious this isn't nipped by some web admin deep in the bowels of CBS Interactive.[/i]

Exactly. Why can't they stop this guy?

by jck

Each website should have its own log and IP exclusion list.

It should be a matter of finding the submission for one or all of those spams...then shoving it in the exclusion list.

Maybe they already have, and the spam bot just posted that fast.

Oh well.

by maxwell edison

You said, [i]Or is it business' right to push things on you, but not government?[/i]

Those are two distinctly different entities with two distinctively different issues. You choose to work for your company. Any benefit and compensation issues are negotiable.

If I work for you, as an example, absolutely yes, you do have a right to dictate terms of employment, and I have a right to either accept or decline. Competition (for employees) in a free market system tends to create a lot of companies that treat employees pretty well. If you're at a place that doesn't treat you fair, well, it's your choice to remain.

If your analogy had any merit at all, I could choose to opt out of any government mandated program, which I don't.

Business: I can choose to opt out of a company sponsored 401(k) plan. Government: I cannot choose to opt out of the Social Security ponzi scheme.

Don't you see the distinction between the two?

by jck

[i]Any benefit and compensation issues are negotiable.[/i]

It's not a negotiable set of benefits at this job, or any other job I have.

They say "This is what we offer." not "This is what you can choose from."

I don't get a la carte or even yes or no choice to getting benefits or receiving the compensation they'd otherwise pay for me.

So, why not? Why can't I have the money ($1,000s a month) instead of accepting insurance.

Reason: My job doesn't give me the choice.

Besides, government is going to give you more choice than I have. You can choose from a plethora of plans from different carriers.

Whereas now, I get to take a choice of 2 plans from 1 carrier.

So, this government health insurance will be good for me. I can shop around and get the best rate, then make my employer let me have the choice where the benefit I EARN is spent.

by jamesrl

In Canada, we can sign up with any specialist we like, and I'm sure many of the other countries that offer government programs are the same.

Like I've mentioned here before, my mom chose to go to a specialist in Toronto, about 100 miles away, for shoulder surgery, because she had heard he was the best in the country. Her family doctor wrote up the referral. The point is she could chose anyone at all. All of them would be covered by insurance (in the province, if she went outside, they may or may not cover it, depending on the situation).

And we don't have quarterly physicals, nor in fact any requirements for physicals. I have to think your insurance company is trying to find a way to exclude you.

I have heard of a doctor (one in all of Canada) who decided to exclude smokers from transplants because they had a lower probability of success. Many other doctors mused they wouldn't, when this story hit the news. But the doctors make that choice themselves, not government bureaucrats.

James

by Member 23340214

The problem with your system is "the best doctor in the country" is paid exactly the same as the worst. There is no incentive under a government program to be the best in your field, except maybe as a matter of personal pride. And I'm sure that while you have your choice of specialists, the expense of getting to that specialist is on you. In our system the better a doctor is the more he is paid, so we have many specialists and many people all across the country who are truly great at what they do.

by jamesrl

The only thing that fixed about pricing in Canada is the price of the actual procedure.

But of course the better you are, the more complex procedures you can do, the more money you get paid. Open heart surgeons get paid more per procedure than docs who do tonsilectomies. And the best in their field get asked to do more of them.

Also doctors can be part of their hospitals administration, teaching staff etc. So there is an incentive to be good, because the fees(salaries) they get paid for those tasks aren't at all regulated.

Doctors here aren't civil servants who scrimp and save. They make big incomes, and the best make small fortunes. The head of a big hospital makes more than the Prime Minister and the Governor General combined.

James

by delbertpgh

American doctors aren't paid based upon their greatness. They're paid based on what they bill and how many patients they see. Surgeons and radiologists are paid more than internists and generalists. Does that mean a scale of greatness has been applied?

Actually, Canadian doctors are paid varying amounts of money, based on a lot of factors. They are hospital and clinic employees, not government employees. In Canada, you are usually reimbursed for the cost of visiting a physician, if travel is involved. You can also see any specialist you want; you aren't restricted to a few (like in an HMO, something a lot of Americans depend on.) There is no less or more a financial incentive to be superior in Canada than there is the United States; in both, the physician is paid through a third-party network of accountants and bureaucrats, government or private insurance, who are not connected to the actual work of patient care.

by tonythetiger

[i]Does your job make you pay for insurance out of your check?
[/i]

But you are not being FORCED to work for them... yet!

by oz_media

But if you really feel that one's support for an individual program, also deemed imperative by large percentage of your population, illustrates the true character of the supporter, so be it. Either way your protective claim does not scare me away from offering my opinion.

[b]Fears of government control[/b]
You have to realize that what you are seeing as social reform is actually very different from what socialist programs actually offer.

Government run insurance companies in socialist countries are usually monopolies, those monopolies often come at a higher price due to lack of competition and offer the consumer less choice.

[b]Socialist programs result in monopolies[/b]

Take for instance, the Insurance Corporation of BC (motor vehicle)for many years they had a monopoly. They were extremely overpriced, offered the worst claims services and literally screwed each and every driver in BC for decades. Now the ADDITIONAL insurance is opened up to other market players, meaning your base insurance is still covered by ICBC but you have a choice of more options when it comes to third party protection, theft, comprehensive etc. They aren't much better in most cases but there are options and thus their prices are slightly lower.

For many MANY years, Stentor was an umbrella encompassing most provincial telephone services in Canada. The price for long distance calls was insane, features were expensive and there was no competition. Stentor was a monopoly, available in some provinces where the local telephone service was not owned by the provincial government, such as in BC. However THAT monopoly was owned y US giant, GTE, but again protected and supported by Canada's government. Opening up that market to private companies has lowered the cost of such services dramatically again.

[b]The American answer to such programs[/b]

In the US, this form of government provided medical insurance works in the opposite way. Your PRIVATE system is flawed, overpriced and unaffordable for many. The government is offering an affordable alternative for those who cannot afford or choose not to deal with a private insurer, the absolute reverse of what has happened in Canada and the UK.

Private insurers are soaking consumers as there is no reasonable limit to how much they can charge and how little they can offer for it. For years the issue of competition has been raised, but they refused to act in a way that made services available to a wider portion of the US population.

At this time, in order to protect Americans health, to retain the nations strength and power, the government realizes that people need to be healthy first and foremost. People must be ale to go to work, must be healthy enough to support the military, must be fit enough to outperform competitive nations.

[b]Retaining or recovering America's strength and power[/b]

PEOPLE offer your strength, not just independence and capitalism. PEOPLE's strength and determination made America rise to the top, not private, free enterprise.

So for your government to offer an affordable alternative to an already overpriced rip-off of a system, despite what your fears of losing individual liberties may be, it is something people have asked for and supported in America for years, only to be completely ignored as the rich get richer and the poor get sicker and weaker. (sorry, long sentence there)

So yes I support ANY system that affords the poor access to more affordable health care. I support ANY system that opens up new opportunities to the downtrodden. I support ANY system that will offer an equal playing field and afford more people opportunity to better themselves.

[b]The free ride[/b]

I know you've worked very hard to get to where you are and don't like seeing others being handed a free ride, and YOU know that I am not different in that respect either.

But this is just basic health care, not opportunity or riches, it simply opens doors for others.

[b]Government competing with private business[/b]
In the case of government competing with business, I don't think the objective or even possible outcome is competition with private business.

You will always choose your own insurer and will pay the premiums that you deem fair for such a service. That is your freedom which is afforded to you as a result of your own hard work resulting in a higher income that affords you such choice. I don't think fears of lower quality due to their being forced to offer lower rates should be an issue. I think that IF they decide to offer a low cost alternative to low income clients, the cost for your insurance and the additional benefits/services provided will be superior still.

[b]Socialism[/b]

Government control of a program in order to monopolize and control a market segment is not what this is at all. In fact it is the absolute opposite. They are offering an alternative to private care, it's not changing from government control to very limited private care.

by Member 23340214

It's true that the government program is not in competition with the Insurance companies. It cannot be because it isn't subject to the same laws and regulation it imposes on insurance companies, nor does it have to make a profit (it can always raise taxes).

What does this mean? It means that it's not a level playing field, for one.

Secondly, in the beginning you'll see insurance companies dumping their most costly clients into the government program to free up more capital within the company. This will necessarily cause the government to raise taxes to pay for their program. With everyone paying those taxes many will figure, 'Why pay twice for coverage?" and drop their private coverage for the government "option". This expansion of the government program is expensive, so taxes are raised again...

Think of it like the public school system. Many more people would send their kids to private schools so their kids will get a better education, but they can't afford it. If they weren't already paying for public schools through their taxes they would have the money. It's the same thing with a government health program.

by oz_media

Yes, a level playing field with private insurers has worked oh so well for you up until now. How well does it work for those who cannot afford it?

You are complaining about paying increased taxes when the existing system is failing your nation by not supporting those without coverage. THOSE people are paid for today from YOUR tax dollars and don't pay premiums. In a government run system, those less fortunate will at least be paying premiums and not relying on YOU, Joe Taxpayer, to foot the entire bill for them.

Your argument is nonvalid, you already pay for what yuo will be paying less for.

As for insurers giving up costly patients, that's absurdity. Insurance companies make the most momey off of their most costly patients by denyign them coverage and raising their rates, THEY are the reason your premiums are so high too, to further counter that cost.

And stop whining about taxes. You are an American, you MUST pay taxes.
If your taxes weren't allocated to health care, they are not going to lower your taxes, you will always pay them and that's part of living in a democracy. They will raise or lower your taxes as they deem fit.

Chances are, a republican president will come in and need money for something else entirely different, he will then blame the cost of subsidized health care for a rise in taxes. That raise in taxes will be allocated elsewhere, get support for his dismissal of the program entirely and you'll be spending more tax dollars anyway but to something else instead...and spending more money on your premiums again, while those less fortunate than you just perish.

But hey, as long as they don't raise your taxes to support health care for the less fortunate, who cares who suffers; as long as it isn't your wallet?

by tonythetiger

[i]The government has an interest in the welfare of individuals.[/i]

It only has that interest as long as the individual is contributing to society more than he's taking from it.

by jamesrl

I did have an employer who did this.

Of course major medical was government, short term/long term disability was fixed, but the areas of the plan where we had options were in dental, prescriptions, life insurance, optical etc.

This allowed not only the ability opt out (why pay for optical if your eyes are perfect) but also for better co-ordination of benefits - if you are married and you can get a benefit from your employer or you partners employer, you can taylor your plan to cover the things your partner's plan is weak in.

James

by oz_media

So you are now FINALLY ale to afford medcial?

or are you assuming that you will lose yoru current option to pay the insurer of your chocie?

Either way, noody dictates who you can or can't see, THAT is the result of private insurer's that only want to pay for the level of care YOU pay for.

Under our government subsidized system, I can see the same professisonals and specialists that Bill Gates or President Obama could in Canada. I can walk into any hospital, doctors office, walk in clinic etc. ANYWHERE in Canada, and be accepted and seen to just the same as anyone else is.

by jdclyde

It isn't the poorest that don't have health insurance because they don't end up paying for major medical issues.

Who is it you wish was covered, yourself?

My biggest problems:
We can not just run around and have the solution for every bleeding heart program be "lets make someone else pay for it!".

We can not make ANYTHING "free" or it loses value to the user and overhead shoots out of control. Think UAW workers with zero deductible vs someone that has a high deductible. Who is more likely to go in for every splinter to have removed?

There is not a successful government model ever to show that "the government" will provide a workable solution. We are suppose to learn from history.

by jdclyde

as they currently get FREE health CARE, why would they want to pay for health INSURANCE?

The only people that have to fear losing everything because of medical bills are people that have something to loose.

If the current negotiations in congress/senate were honestly for our best interests, it would be about health CARE, but it isn't.

by Member 23340214

Government health coverage is far from the utopia you make it out to be.

1. You say if the consumer has choice then the hospital/doctors must have a choice for who they treat. doctors, and to a lesser extent hospitals, do have choice. They can transfer or discharge patients for most any reason (there are exceptions, of course).

2. The government run "option" will only be an option for a limited time. It is not a slippery slope, nor is it guess work that the government plan will become the only plan. The government doesn't have to compete for customers the way insurance companies do, they don't have the overhead private companies do and they are not subject to all the same laws companies are. It is not a level playing fields. Many insurance companies have already come out saying they would gladly dump their more costly patients into the government "option".

You ask how European health services survive, and the answer is "they don't". Most of them are bankrupt, or close to it, or severely limit care, or put off procedures in hopes the patient will die before it can be performed. There is a reason the worlds wealthy come here when they need serious care. Did you know there are more MRI machines in my home state of Colorado than in all of Canada and Europe combined?

The problem with our insurance coverage isn't the industry, its the current level of government involvement. The government tells insurance companies they cannot compete across state lines, and require certain expensive but rare medical problems to be covered. Insurance companies would love to offer ala cart options, but government regulation makes it impossible. Get government out of the industry and you will see prices drop.

The one way the government could help is (1) go to a loser-pays legal system and (2) limit the damages that can be assessed for malpractice suits. This would lower doctors insurance rates and lower health costs all around.

And as long as we're throwing out our own version of heath care utopia, I'd like to see a system that more closely approximates auto insurance. If I become seriously ill I should be able to call my "agent" who comes out and works with the hospital to help control costs and improve coverage. My agent could make sure I'm not being charged $10 for a single aspirin and assure I'm receiving the attention my case deserves.

by delbertpgh

Government... "only has that interest as long as the individual is contributing to society more than he's taking from it."

Supposing that a person has contributed his life long, and is now retired. Does anybody have an obligation to him, in light of contributions past, though little is left of him?

Suppose a person, a child or a student, has not yet begun to contribute, and has only absorbed resources. Is it in anyone's interest to guarantee his wellbeing, in light of contributions yet to come?

by Member 23340214

That's why your system is bankrupt, why it takes forever to get an appointment with any specialist or to line up any kind of specialized procedure.

As I mentioned in another post, we have more MRI machines in Colorado than you have in all of Canada. Yes our coverage is expensive, but only because it is the best.

by delbertpgh

It's not because it is the best. Canadians provide better, on the average, than Americans do. American care is expensive because there are no controls on it. In most free market transactions you have a consumer exercising choice, but in health coverage, the consumer doesn't make a contract with the insurer; his employer does. When the consumer gets health care, he doesn't see the bill; the insurer does. The consumer makes no choices regarding cost or the composition of services he receives. The bills keep going higher. The doctor charges more; the insurer pays more; the employer pays more. The more it costs, the happier you are that you have insurance, 'cause otherwise, you'd be shafted.

In Japan, it costs under $100 to get an MRI, usually in no-waiting walk-in clinics. Why does it cost $1200 here? We have more machines to pay for, and nobody bothers to operate them in a cost-effective way.

by jamesrl

System isn't bankrupt, its under pressure, its not perfect, but neither is your system.

More MRIs in Colorado than Canada? Really - do you have a citation for that?

As for time to get an appointment with a specialist, thats another myth. There may be situations in some areas where it takes time, but I've read studies that say it doesn't substantially differ from the uS, and certainly I've had many instances where I've seen no waits, or little waits.

Yes my Mom had to wait three weeks to see the best guy in the country for shoulder surgery, but it wsn't an "urgent case".

When my wife had an accident that caused brain damage, specialists were there within hours to help make assessments and map out treatments. One of them recommended a rehab program at another hospital and it took under a week to get her enrolled.

When my son had an medical issue as a toddler, he got an MRI in 2 hours, and that was after he was "stable" and in no immediate danger.

James

by oz_media

Our system is bankrupt. Our system is SLOWLY falling apart but still nowhere near the level seen in the USA under yoru existing private structure.

As for takign forever to get an appointment, what BS media spin have you been reading?

A friend was told he needed a CAT scan a few weeks back, that particular hospital had a 3 week waiting list, they then asked is he could make it to another a few miles away, which I took him to the very next morning.
He is now ack at awork, and EVER SO THANKFUL that he left Alaama 8 years gao to start his family in BC. He said withotu our health care, he couldn't provide insurance for his kids, would have died himself (diagnised with a kidney disease that threatened his life but he wouldn't have even been diagnosed in Alabama)and now would have been immobile and suffering from acute sciatica. As he lives in Canada, his children are healthy, he is still alive and was able to see the specialists he needed and get the treatment he needed right away.

Having suffered severe spinal injuries for most of my life, I have seen more specialists than I can possibly count. Not ONCE, have I had to wait for anymore than a few days to see a specialist, get an MRI, CAT scan or any otehr treatment.

What you are parroting is the horror stories from people who demand non emergent support.

Something that Americans don't understand is that people in teh most need get seen to first, people who have lots of money don't take precedence over those who are the most sick. You WILL be made to wait, if you are ASKING for scans or treatments or specialists when other people in real need for such treatment are in line.

I find this upsets Americans, as flashing their money no longer gets them what they want.

Sick people taking priority over wealthy people when it comes to health care? Whatever next?

by jdclyde

why does the profile still exist?

I can see the need to put in anti-spam efforts in place.

First, the most posts by a valid users (or jck) is only about 300/400 over a week. Clearly, something like a 20 post cap per day on anyone who hasn't been a member for a few months is not rocket science. There is already a 10 peer limit per day, why not in the discussions?

Another option, people that have not been members for at least a week should have to do the visual confirmation of a pic of text for every post.

by delbertpgh

It'll still be insurance-company-run health care. That's the Baucus plan. So, you won't be going to see doctors under a hammer and sickle, each one with a commissar behind his back, guessing whether or not your treatment is worth it to the people. (Check Tony Tiger's posts for an example of that sort of thinking, by the way.) It'll still be under the sign of Aetna and Metropolitan, with an accountant behind every care provider, making sure it's them who swindle you, and not the other way around.

Insurance companies will still determine whom you can see, and whether you pay extra for preferred specialists, if they give you anything at all. However, they won't refuse you the freedom to see anybody at your own cost, the same as now.

by delbertpgh

"Only up to the point the accounts equal out. After that, no."

Sounds like an actuary gets to figure out which boy gets chemo, under your social justice. "Let's see, Jimmy doesn't have the grades that Joey does, so his future value is reduced. If his dad was anything but a forklift driver, the boy might pull out of it, but he's looking like he'll always be a working class loser. So, let's give the $40,000 leukemia treatment to some more deserving kid." If Darth Cheney were given the mandate to work up medical cost savings, death panels is what he'd think of. It explains why the phrase comes so naturally to Republican lips.

by jamesrl

So yes, its different in each province to an extent, although it federal legislation that outlines the high level rules (no extra billing etc).

Prescription drugs aren't covered here in Ontario or Nova Scotia (except for those on welfare, or in Ontario some co-pays for the elderly). But as Oz mentions, his province (BC) has generous government drug plans.

And things change over time. I remember when Alberta made big cuts and everyone from there complained, but now their system is generally acknowledged to be well funded.

That may be somethign to consider in the US, Canada is much smaller in population than the US (33 million versus 300). It would not be easy to force one system onto a population that large.

James

by oz_media

The people are undeniably some of the nicest people that walk on Earth. It is one of the most friendly and homely and welcoming places I have ever experienced.

It also sux in every other aspect though: Took cold in winter, too many black flies in summer. Education is a complete joke, I couldn't believe how backwards the school was when I moved to Cape Breton, I swore I had just fallen from grade 4 to kindergarten again. I rememer laughign to my mother befor eexpressing concern tha i wasn' tgoing ot learn ANYTHING living in Canada, thankfully when I moved out West things got better, but not to European standards by any means.
Health care, I remember my dentist in Cape reton, not that i could possibly forget such horrors. Belt drive drill, hard seat with little round pads for a headrest. a nightmare for sure.

But again, nicest people on the planet, warmest neighours and community spirit you will ever encounter.

by jamesrl

First of all, the hospitals, walkin in clinics, doctors ARE private health care providers. Where there is a law, it says that you cannot charge someone for a service that is mandated as medically necessary by the province. Prinvate organizations, who bill the government for their services.

For example lets use cirucumcision. Most North Americans take this for granted that newborn boys get circumcised, whether they be Christian or Jewish (though its less common than its used to be). It used to be on the list of "covered" procedures, so no one could charge. Now its not, so if a doctor does do this, they can hand the patient (or their parents) a bill.

The ones pushing the envelope, in Vancouver and Montreal, are "wellness" clinics who are looking to do more proactive diagnosis. They want to sit with you and do a whole battery of tests before they recommend lifestyle, diet changes etc. They would order up MRI, Cat scans etc., but not to diagnose an ailment but to get an overall picture of health. And they charge big $$. The courts have not yet ruled about whether it violates the principles of the Canada Health Act.

by jamesrl

If they were screening on something from your family history - genetic predispositions. But they seem to be on a fishing expedition.

The one I heard about in Vancouver charged a big upfront $$ and they expected to have periodic appointments for checkups forever. It was kind like joining a gym.

James

by oz_media

It's abotu time the government caught on to such fraud, and teh consumers who believe in such S too. It's like Feng Shui, you can pay THOUSANDS for a Feng Shui 'master' to come and rearrange your furniture. Another who claims to be equally qualified, will then turn up and exlpain how everything is wrong and should be the reverse.

Bottom line it's a fabricated trade, like hollistic medicine at al. It's not really a trade its no different than religion, it just maks people mentally secure in their own minds without any science or fact to support it.

by oz_media

But nobody does.

My brother did a while back. He had a spinal injury that they said could be cured by a US doctor now owning a private practice in Vancouver. He was told it was a proven procedure that had been used by the same doctor (as well as may others) with great results in the US for a numer of years, yet unapproved in Canada. He researched it and all American medical teams seemed to think it was a great operation to undergo. My brother's one rich mofo so he forked out the dough and was VERY impressed with the no wait line, the in and out service, the fancy office and gorgeous nurses.

He still suffers from the exact same acute pain, is now seeing a normal specialist and undergoing therapy which is helping a lot more. The spinal surgery he got in such quick time, at a premium price was absoluetly pointless and completely useless.

In fact it lengthened his pain as he had to recover form that before he could seek a more viable treatment.

So yes there are options, for those who actually want to pay more for it.

by jdclyde

It is like in a programming class, other than the names of the variables, if you follow a consistent form of logic, you will repeatedly come to a similar outcome.

It is when you are illogical or just lying that there is the deviation we see among many, especially where politics are concerned.

Emotional justifications always fall flat.

by oz_media

Okay, now that I stopped laughing...consistent form of logic.

The only consistency you show here is to take ANYTHING the media claims about Obama and run with it as if it is gospel.

Logic? yeah right, logic. :D

by tonythetiger

[i]Sounds like an actuary gets to figure out which boy gets chemo, under your social justice. [/i]

No, you decide, by choosing to earn it.

The fact of my birth creates no obligation in anyone else except perhaps my parents, and only then for a specific time. It also creates no obligation in ME to anyone... It's a contract I didn't sign!

Also, I don't think I should be allowed to CHOOSE to partake in risky lifestyle choices and expect the cost of the consequences of my choices to be forced onto others (If I CHOOSE to go skiing and break my leg, that should be on me. The alternative would be that since others are going to pay, they get to decide if I'm allowed to go skiing. You may value liberty less than safety, but I do not). The only time you should be obligated to pay for my illness or injury is if you were the cause of them.

None of that, however, prevents one from ASKING for help, nor from CHOOSING to provide help. But it should be voluntary. Otherwise, what's the point of even trying? Why should I bother working, for example, if you're just going to take it away from me and give it to someone else?

by jdclyde

Isn't it amusing that so many people that support the Theory of Evolution would work to fight the benefits of that system on the human race?

If Evolution is natures way of improving a species, what happens to that species when nature no longer plays any roll? DEevolution.

by jdclyde

I do not take one stance one day, and then another as time passes on. That is what consistency is.

I have been consistent with my objections to what Obama stands for, so? Disagreeing doesn't make me inconsistent.

And I would never consider being compared to Max an insult.

by oz_media

You seem to be confusing stubborn blindness with consistecy and again, Max does the same, sorry Max, I know it wasn't your comment.

The ability to evolve, learn and change opinion as new information is found is what it takes to offer reasoned, rational thinking.

That is the core foundation of science, good scientists seek to be proven wrong, such proof illustrates fact as a result of theory.

Someone who is bent on simply sticking to their own biased beliefs, regardless of changing facts and sceintific proof, is a religious minister.

An inability to see beyond a predetrmined conclusion, regardless of contrary evidence and an ever changing landscape results in blind stubborness.

You have been consistent with your "feelings" towards Obama, unfortunately the stories you are being consistent with are NOT consistent except in their vengeance against Obama. It makes you a blind naysayer who wouldn't accept anything Obama did as being correct, whether it is or isn't, you simply will not allow youself to open your mind up and accept that he is actually a great benefit to your nation, because you didn't vote for him. That unwavering dedication to dislike is not consistency beyond being consistently without justification.

In fact you are so blindly stubborn that you can't even recognize how stupid and ignorant such a narrow, biased view really is.

Even I gave Bush credit where credit was due. I even supported McCain through some of his campaign speeches against Obama because he made more sense on certain subjects, THAT is being aware and paying attention to what is actually said without bias. It is easier for me to see your government without bias as it isn't MY government, my only vested interest is that they don't cause more problems for us than they already have; whether that means a republican or democrat in office makes NO difference to me at all.

You, on the other hand, are hell bent against ANYTHING Obama says, without questioning validity, application etc. It is simply Obama so it's wrong and must be opposed, and YOU see that as being consistent. Consistently biased perhaps but not consisntent in that you weigh issues carefully and seek out the best solution.

th reverse is just as lind, supporting a president through al actions whether right or wrong, and withotu question. Why do Americans do that? "I voted for him so I have to support everything he does." or "I didn't vote for him so NOTHING he does is correct."

I would never think that being compared to Max is an insult, I was actually apologizing to Max for bringing his comments up in a post to you, I really don't like to use third party references to support my comments.

You simply don't understand the terminology or application behind half of what you speak of.

To recognize blind conformity as being 'consistency', in a good way, is simply a result of blindness, a poor education and a complete misunderstanding of morals and justification.

by jdclyde

I reject the notion of adding one more government program after another, and the only "solution" offered is to go after "the rich".

I don't buy into the class warfare, nor all the race-baiting of anyone who would disagree with Obama or his policies.

Not agreeing with the likes of you is not a basis of being correct or logical, and while there are many adjectives people would use to describe you, "rational" is not one of them.

You are also not anyone I would ever take morals lessons from.

by maxwell edison

You seem to be confusing a principled based position with, as you called it, [i]stubborn blindness[/i].

Actually, my eyes are wide open, and I don't like the direction the country is going.

I don't presume to dictate to others how they live their lives, but others on the left can't make the same claim. That's what they do; that's who they are; and those are the kinds of policies they support.

For as long as we've engaged in various discussions, to see that you still misrepresent me is rather surprising. I often wonder why you do it. I suppose if I had to guess, you probably get more out of challenging me than trying to understand me. (Talk about [i]stubborn blindness[/i].)

by oz_media

JDClyde and logic in the same post, I could barely type it myself without laughing.

You are one of the most biased and easily lead people I've read on TR, you just seek out that which complies with your predetermined mindset and then parrot it as if it was truth.

by oz_media

I think after the bumbling insecure fool you had ruin your global reputation for 8 years while sinking you into a deficit you are not likely to see the end of in your lifetime, ANYONE would seem arrogant.

The fact that Bush WAS arrogant was completely lost on you as yuo velievd all he said. He was the lord to never be questioned or you shall be deemed anti-Ameican and they'll take your flag away so you can't wave it aimlessly in the shower on Tuesday mornings.

Taht cocky Texan Prick was teh epitomy of arrogant Americans. "we are right in every way, you are either with us or against us.

There is no room for individual thought, I am correct and you shall all follow blindly or I shall spite thee.!"

So you then elect someone who actually HAS a thought process, and a few brain cells to support it and you call HIM arrogant for actually focusing on bettering your own nation, instead of trying to fix what he displays as someone else's problems that he needs to resolve for the benefit of his own friends and family.

by jdclyde

and I did disagree with Bush on many issues. He was NOT a fiscal conservative.

As for the stance on countries that openly and knowingly harbor terrorist training camps and their leaders, he was right.

Of course, most of your attacks, be it against Bush, someone else in global politics, or even someone on this board, usually just turn into personal attacks instead of discussing the ideas presented.

Have fun with that. moving on....

by maxwell edison

A cut and paste of the introduction and table of contents (lost its formatting):

To provide affordable, quality health care for all Americans and reduce
the growth in health care spending, and for other purposes.
IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES
llllllllll
Mr. BAUCUS, from the Committee on Finance, reported the following original
bill; which was read twice and placed on the calendar
A BILL
To provide affordable, quality health care for all Americans
and reduce the growth in health care spending, and
for other purposes.
1 Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representa2
tives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,
3 SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE; TABLE OF CONTENTS.
4 (a) SHORT TITLE.?This Act may be cited as the
5 ??America?s Healthy Future Act of 2009??.
6 (b) TABLE OF CONTENTS.?The table of contents of
7 this Act is as follows:
2
O:\FRA\FRA09275.xml [file 1 of 7] S.L.C.
Sec. 1. Short title; table of contents.
TITLE I?HEALTH CARE COVERAGE
Subtitle A?Insurance Market Reforms
Sec. 1001. Insurance market reforms in the individual and small group markets.
??TITLE XXII?HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE
??Sec. 2200. Ensuring essential and affordable health benefits coverage for
all Americans.
??PART A?INSURANCE REFORMS
??SUBPART 1?REQUIREMENTS IN INDIVIDUAL AND SMALL GROUP MARKETS
??Sec. 2201. General requirements and definitions.
??Sec. 2202. Prohibition on preexisting condition exclusions.
??Sec. 2203. Guaranteed issue and renewal for insured plans.
??Sec. 2204. Premium rating rules.
??Sec. 2205. Use of uniform outline of coverage documents.
??SUBPART 2?REFORMS RELATING TO ALLOCATION OF RISKS
??Sec. 2211. Rating areas; pooling of risks; phase in of rating rules in
small group markets.
??Sec. 2212. Risk adjustment.
??Sec. 2213. Establishment of transitional reinsurance program for individual
markets in each State.
??Sec. 2214. Establishment of risk corridors for plans in individual and
small group markets.
??Sec. 2215. Temporary high risk pools for individuals with preexisting
conditions.
??Sec. 2216. Reinsurance for retirees covered by employer-based plans.
??SUBPART 3?PRESERVATION OF RIGHT TO MAINTAIN EXISTING COVERAGE
??Sec. 2221. Grandfathered health benefits plans.
??SUBPART 4?CONTINUED ROLE OF STATES
??Sec. 2225. Continued State enforcement of insurance regulations.
??Sec. 2226. Waiver of health insurance reform requirements.
??Sec. 2227. Provisions relating to offering of plans in more than one
State.
??Sec. 2228. State flexibility to establish basic health programs for low-income
individuals not eligible for Medicaid.
??SUBPART 5?OTHER DEFINITIONS AND RULES
??Sec. 2230. Other definitions and rules.
Subtitle B?Exchanges and Consumer Assistance
Sec. 1101. Establishment of qualified health benefits plan exchanges.
??PART B?EXCHANGE AND CONSUMER ASSISTANCE
3
O:\FRA\FRA09275.xml [file 1 of 7] S.L.C.
??SUBPART 1?INDIVIDUALS AND SMALL EMPLOYERS OFFERED AFFORDABLE
CHOICES
??Sec. 2231. Rights and responsibilities regarding choice of coverage
through exchange.
??Sec. 2232. Qualified individuals and small employers; access limited to
citizens and lawful residents.
??SUBPART 2?ESTABLISHMENT OF EXCHANGES
??Sec. 2235. Establishment of exchanges by States.
??Sec. 2236. Functions performed by Secretary, States, and exchanges.
??Sec. 2237. Duties of the Secretary to facilitate exchanges.
??Sec. 2238. Procedures for determining eligibility for exchange participation,
premium credits and cost-sharing subsidies, and individual
responsibility exemptions.
??Sec. 2239. Streamlining of procedures for enrollment through an exchange
and State Medicaid, CHIP, and health subsidy
programs.
Sec. 1102. Encouraging meaningful use of electronic health records.
Subtitle C?Making Coverage Affordable
PART I?ESSENTIAL BENEFITS COVERAGE
Sec. 1201. Provisions to ensure coverage of essential benefits.
??PART C?MAKING COVERAGE AFFORDABLE
??SUBPART 1?ESSENTIAL BENEFITS COVERAGE
??Sec. 2241. Requirements for qualified health benefits plan.
??Sec. 2242. Essential benefits package defined.
??Sec. 2243. Levels of coverage.
??Sec. 2244. Application of certain rules to plans in group markets.
??Sec. 2245. Special rules relating to coverage of abortion services.
Sec. 1202. Application of State and Federal laws regarding abortion.
Sec. 1203. Application of emergency services laws.
PART II?PREMIUM CREDITS, COST-SHARING SUBSIDIES, AND SMALL
BUSINESS CREDITS
SUBPART A?PREMIUM CREDITS AND COST-SHARING SUBSIDIES
Sec. 1205. Refundable credit providing premium assistance for coverage under
a qualified health benefits plan.
??Sec. 36B. Refundable credit for coverage under a qualified health benefits
plan.
Sec. 1206. Cost-sharing subsidies and advance payments of premium credits
and cost-sharing subsidies.
??SUBPART 2?PREMIUM CREDITS AND COST-SHARING SUBSIDIES
??Sec. 2246. Premium credits.
??Sec. 2247. Cost-sharing subsidies for individuals enrolling in qualified
health benefit plans.
??Sec. 2248. Advance determination and payment of premium credits and
cost-sharing subsidies.
4
O:\FRA\FRA09275.xml [file 1 of 7] S.L.C.
Sec. 1207. Disclosures to carry out eligibility requirements for certain programs.
Sec. 1208. Premium credit and subsidy refunds and payments disregarded for
Federal and Federally-assisted programs.
Sec. 1209. Fail-safe mechanism to prevent increase in Federal budget deficit.
SUBPART B?CREDIT FOR SMALL EMPLOYERS
Sec. 1221. Credit for employee health insurance expenses of small businesses.
??Sec. 45R. Employee health insurance expenses of small employers.
Subtitle D?Shared Responsibility
PART I?INDIVIDUAL RESPONSIBILITY
Sec. 1301. Excise tax on individuals without essential health benefits coverage.
??CHAPTER 48?MAINTENANCE OF ESSENTIAL HEALTH BENEFITS COVERAGE
??Sec. 5000A. Failure to maintain essential health benefits coverage.
Sec. 1302. Reporting of health insurance coverage.
??SUBPART D?INFORMATION REGARDING HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE
??Sec. 6055. Reporting of health insurance coverage.
PART II?EMPLOYER RESPONSIBILITY
Sec. 1306. Employer shared responsibility requirement.
??Sec. 4980H. Employer responsibility to provide health coverage.
Sec. 1307. Reporting of employer health insurance coverage.
??Sec. 6056. Large employers required to report on health insurance coverage.
Subtitle E?Federal Program for Health Care Cooperatives
Sec. 1401. Establishment of Federal program for health care cooperatives.
??PART D?FEDERAL PROGRAM FOR HEALTH CARE COOPERATIVES
??Sec. 2251. Federal program to assist establishment and operation of nonprofit,
member-run health insurance issuers.
Subtitle F?Transparency and Accountability
Sec. 1501. Provisions ensuring transparency and accountability.
??Sec. 2229. Requirements relating to transparency and accountability.
Sec. 1502. Reporting on utilization of premium dollars and standard hospital
charges.
Sec. 1503. Development and utilization of uniform outline of coverage documents.
Sec. 1504. Development of standard definitions, personal scenarios, and annual
personalized statements.
Subtitle G?Role of Public Programs
PART I?MEDICAID COVERAGE FOR THE LOWEST INCOME POPULATIONS
Sec. 1601. Medicaid coverage for the lowest income populations.
5
O:\FRA\FRA09275.xml [file 1 of 7] S.L.C.
Sec. 1602. Income eligibility for nonelderly determined using modified gross income.
Sec. 1603. Requirement to offer premium assistance for employer-sponsored insurance.
Sec. 1604. Payments to territories.
Sec. 1605. Medicaid Improvement Fund rescission.
PART II?CHILDREN?S HEALTH INSURANCE PROGRAM
Sec. 1611. Additional federal financial participation for CHIP.
Sec. 1612. Technical corrections.
PART III?ENROLLMENT SIMPLIFICATION
Sec. 1621. Enrollment Simplification and coordination with State health insurance
exchanges.
Sec. 1622. Permitting hospitals to make presumptive eligibility determinations
for all Medicaid eligible populations.
Sec. 1623. Promoting transparency in the development, implementation, and
evaluation of Medicaid and CHIP waivers and section 1937
State plan amendments.
Sec. 1624. Standards and best practices to improve enrollment of vulnerable
and underserved populations.
PART IV?MEDICAID SERVICES
Sec. 1631. Coverage for freestanding birth center services.
Sec. 1632. Concurrent care for children.
Sec. 1633. Funding to expand State Aging and Disability Resource Centers.
Sec. 1634. Community First Choice Option.
Sec. 1635. Protection for recipients of home and community-based services
against spousal impoverishment.
Sec. 1636. Incentives for States to offer home and community-based services as
a long-term care alternative to nursing homes.
Sec. 1636A. Removal of barriers to providing home and community-based services.
Sec. 1637. Money Follows the Person Rebalancing Demonstration.
Sec. 1638. Clarification of definition of medical assistance.
Sec. 1639. State eligibility option for family planning services.
Sec. 1640. Grants for school-based health centers.
Sec. 1641. Therapeutic foster care.
Sec. 1642. Sense of the Senate regarding long-term care.
PART V?MEDICAID PRESCRIPTION DRUG COVERAGE
Sec. 1651. Prescription drug rebates.
Sec. 1652. Elimination of exclusion of coverage of certain drugs.
Sec. 1653. Providing adequate pharmacy reimbursement.
Sec. 1654. Study of barriers to appropriate utilization of generic medicine in
federal health care programs.
PART VI?MEDICAID DISPROPORTIONATE SHARE HOSPITAL (DSH)
PAYMENTS
Sec. 1655. Disproportionate share hospital payments.
PART VII?DUAL ELIGIBLES
6
O:\FRA\FRA09275.xml [file 1 of 7] S.L.C.
Sec. 1661. 5-year period for demonstration projects.
Sec. 1662. Providing Federal coverage and payment coordination for low-income
Medicare beneficiaries.
PART VIII?MEDICAID QUALITY
Sec. 1671. Adult health quality measures.
Sec. 1672. Payment Adjustment for Health Care-Acquired Conditions.
Sec. 1673. Demonstration project to evaluate integrated care around a hospitalization.
Sec. 1674. Medicaid Global Payment System Demonstration Project.
Sec. 1675. Pediatric Accountable Care Organization Demonstration Project.
Sec. 1676. Medicaid emergency psychiatric demonstration project.
PART IX?IMPROVEMENTS TO THE MEDICAID AND CHIP PAYMENT AND
ACCESS COMMISSION (MACPAC)
Sec. 1681. MACPAC assessment of policies affecting all Medicaid beneficiaries.
PART X?AMERICAN INDIANS AND ALASKA NATIVES
Sec. 1691. Special rules relating to Indians.
Sec. 1692. Elimination of sunset for reimbursement for all medicare part B
services furnished by certain indian hospitals and clinics.
Subtitle H?Addressing Health Disparities
Sec. 1701. Standardized collection of data.
Sec. 1702. Required collection of data.
Sec. 1703. Data sharing and protection.
Sec. 1704. Inclusion of information about the importance of having a health
care power of attorney in transition planning for children aging
out of foster care and independent living programs.
Subtitle I?Maternal and Child Health Services
Sec. 1801. Maternal, infant, and early childhood home visiting programs.
Sec. 1802. Support, education, and research for postpartum depression.
Sec. 1803. Personal responsibility education for adulthood training.
Sec. 1804. Restoration of funding for abstinence education.
Subtitle J?Programs of Health Promotion and Disease Prevention
Sec. 1901. Programs of health promotion and disease prevention.
Subtitle K?Elder Justice Act
Sec. 1911. Short title of subtitle.
Sec. 1912. Definitions.
Sec. 1913. Elder Justice.
Subtitle L?Provisions of General Application
Sec. 1921. Protecting Americans and ensuring taxpayer funds in government
health care plans do not support or fund physician-assisted suicide;
prohibition against discrimination on assisted suicide.
Sec. 1922. Protection of access to quality health care through the Department
of Veterans Affairs and the Department of Defense.
Sec. 1923. Continued application of antitrust laws.
7
O:\FRA\FRA09275.xml [file 1 of 7] S.L.C.
TITLE II?PROMOTING DISEASE PREVENTION AND WELLNESS
Subtitle A?Medicare
Sec. 2001. Coverage of annual wellness visit providing a personalized prevention
plan.
Sec. 2002. Removal of barriers to preventive services.
Sec. 2003. Evidence-based coverage of preventive services.
Sec. 2004. GAO study and report on medicare beneficiary access to vaccines.
Sec. 2005. Incentives for healthy lifestyles.
Subtitle B?Medicaid
Sec. 2101. Improving access to preventive services for eligible adults.
Sec. 2102. Coverage of comprehensive tobacco cessation services for pregnant
women.
Sec. 2103. Incentives for healthy lifestyles.
Sec. 2104. State option to provide health homes for enrollees with chronic conditions.
Sec. 2105. Funding for Childhood Obesity Demonstration Project.
Sec. 2106. Public awareness of preventive and obesity-related services.
TITLE III?IMPROVING THE QUALITY AND EFFICIENCY OF
HEALTH CARE
Subtitle A?Transforming the Health Care Delivery System
PART I?LINKING PAYMENT TO QUALITY OUTCOMES UNDER THE
MEDICARE PROGRAM
Sec. 3001. Hospital Value-Based purchasing program.
Sec. 3002. Improvements to the physician quality reporting system.
Sec. 3003. Improvements to the physician feedback program.
Sec. 3004. Quality reporting for long-term care hospitals, inpatient rehabilitation
hospitals, and hospice programs.
Sec. 3005. Quality reporting for PPS-exempt cancer hospitals.
Sec. 3006. Plans for a Value-Based purchasing program for skilled nursing facilities
and home health agencies.
Sec. 3007. Value-based payment modifier under the physician fee schedule.
Sec. 3008. Payment adjustment for conditions acquired in hospitals.
PART II?STRENGTHENING THE QUALITY INFRASTRUCTURE
Sec. 3011. National strategy.
Sec. 3012. Interagency Working Group on Health Care Quality.
Sec. 3013. Quality measure development.
Sec. 3014. Quality measure endorsement.
PART III?ENCOURAGING DEVELOPMENT OF NEW PATIENT CARE MODELS
Sec. 3021. Establishment of Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation
within CMS.
Sec. 3022. Medicare shared savings program.
Sec. 3023. National pilot program on payment bundling.
Sec. 3024. Independence at home pilot program.
Sec. 3025. Hospital readmissions reduction program.
Sec. 3026. Community-Based Care Transitions Program.
Sec. 3027. Extension of gainsharing demonstration.
8
O:\FRA\FRA09275.xml [file 1 of 7] S.L.C.
PART IV?STRENGTHENING PRIMARY CARE AND OTHER WORKFORCE
IMPROVEMENTS
Sec. 3031. Expanding access to primary care services and general surgery services.
Sec. 3031A. Medicare Federally qualified health center improvements.
Sec. 3032. Distribution of additional residency positions.
Sec. 3033. Counting resident time in outpatient settings and allowing flexibility
for jointly operated residency training programs.
Sec. 3034. Rules for counting resident time for didactic and scholarly activities
and other activities.
Sec. 3035. Preservation of resident cap positions from closed and acquired hospitals.
Sec. 3036. Workforce Advisory Committee.
Sec. 3037. Demonstration projects To address health professions workforce
needs; extension of family-to-family health information centers.
Sec. 3038. Increasing teaching capacity.
Sec. 3039. Graduate nurse education demonstration program.
PART V?HEALTH INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
Sec. 3041. Free clinics and certified EHR technology.
Subtitle B?Improving Medicare for Patients and Providers
PART I?ENSURING BENEFICIARY ACCESS TO PHYSICIAN CARE AND OTHER
SERVICES
Sec. 3101. Increase in the physician payment update.
Sec. 3102. Extension of the work geographic index floor and revisions to the
practice expense geographic adjustment under the Medicare
physician fee schedule.
Sec. 3103. Extension of exceptions process for Medicare therapy caps.
Sec. 3104. Extension of payment for technical component of certain physician
pathology services.
Sec. 3105. Extension of ambulance add-ons.
Sec. 3106. Extension of certain payment rules for long-term care hospital services
and of moratorium on the establishment of certain hospitals
and facilities.
Sec. 3107. Extension of physician fee schedule mental health add-on.
Sec. 3108. Permitting physician assistants to order post-Hospital extended care
services and to provide for recognition of attending physician
assistants as attending physicians to serve hospice patients.
Sec. 3109. Recognition of certified diabetes educators as certified providers for
purposes of Medicare diabetes outpatient self-management
training services.
Sec. 3110. Exemption of certain pharmacies from accreditation requirements.
Sec. 3111. Part B special enrollment period for disabled TRICARE beneficiaries.
Sec. 3112. Payment for bone density tests.
Sec. 3113. Revision to the Medicare Improvement Fund.
Sec. 3114. Treatment of certain complex diagnostic laboratory tests.
Sec. 3115. Improved access for certified-midwife services.
Sec. 3116. Working Group on Access to Emergency Medical Care.
PART II?RURAL PROTECTIONS
9
O:\FRA\FRA09275.xml [file 1 of 7] S.L.C.
Sec. 3121. Extension of outpatient hold harmless provision.
Sec. 3122. Extension of Medicare reasonable costs payments for certain clinical
diagnostic laboratory tests furnished to hospital patients in certain
rural areas.
Sec. 3123. Extension of the Rural Community Hospital Demonstration Program.
Sec. 3124. Extension of the Medicare-dependent hospital (MDH) program.
Sec. 3125. Temporary improvements to the Medicare inpatient hospital payment
adjustment for low-volume hospitals.
Sec. 3126. Improvements to the demonstration project on community health integration
models in certain rural counties.
Sec. 3127. MedPAC study on adequacy of Medicare payments for health care
providers serving in rural areas.
Sec. 3128. Technical correction related to critical access hospital services.
Sec. 3129. Extension of and revisions to Medicare rural hospital flexibility program.
PART III?IMPROVING PAYMENT ACCURACY
Sec. 3131. Payment adjustments for home health care.
Sec. 3132. Hospice reform.
Sec. 3133. Improvement to medicare disproportionate share hospital (DSH)
payments.
Sec. 3134. Misvalued codes under the physician fee schedule.
Sec. 3135. Modification of equipment utilization factor for advanced imaging
services.
Sec. 3136. Revision of payment for power-driven wheelchairs.
Sec. 3137. Hospital wage index improvement.
Sec. 3138. Treatment of certain cancer hospitals.
Sec. 3139. Payment for biosimilar biological products.
Sec. 3140. Public meeting and report on payment systems for new clinical laboratory
diagnostic tests.
Sec. 3141. Medicare hospice concurrent care demonstration program.
Sec. 3142. Application of budget neutrality on a national basis in the calculation
of the Medicare hospital wage index floor for each allurban
and rural state.
Sec. 3143. HHS study on urban Medicare-dependent hospitals.
Subtitle C?Provisions Relating to Part C
Sec. 3201. Medicare Advantage payment.
Sec. 3202. Benefit protection and simplification.
Sec. 3203. Application of coding intensity adjustment during MA payment
transition.
Sec. 3204. Simplification of annual beneficiary election periods.
Sec. 3205. Extension for specialized MA plans for special needs individuals.
Sec. 3206. Extension of reasonable cost contracts.
Sec. 3207. Technical correction to MA private fee-for-service plans.
Sec. 3208. Making senior housing facility demonstration permanent.
Sec. 3209. Development of new standards for certain Medigap plans.
Subtitle D?Medicare Part D Improvements for Prescription Drug Plans and
MA?PD Plans
Sec. 3301. Medicare prescription drug discount program for brand-Name
drugs.
10
O:\FRA\FRA09275.xml [file 1 of 7] S.L.C.
Sec. 3302. Improvement in determination of Medicare part D low-income
benchmark premium.
Sec. 3303. Voluntary de minimus policy for subsidy eligible individuals under
prescription drug plans and MA?PD plans.
Sec. 3304. Special rule for widows and widowers regarding eligibility for lowincome
assistance.
Sec. 3305. Improved information for subsidy eligible individuals reassigned to
prescription drug plans and MA?PD plans.
Sec. 3306. Funding outreach and assistance for low-income programs.
Sec. 3307. Improving formulary requirements for prescription drug plans and
MA?PD plans with respect to certain categories or classes of
drugs.
Sec. 3308. Reducing part D premium subsidy for high-income beneficiaries.
Sec. 3309. Simplification of plan information.
Sec. 3310. Limitation on removal or change of coverage of covered part D
drugs under a formulary under a prescription drug plan or an
MA?PD plan.
Sec. 3311. Elimination of cost sharing for certain dual eligible individuals.
Sec. 3312. Reducing wasteful dispensing of outpatient prescription drugs in
long-term care facilities under prescription drug plans and
MA?PD plans.
Sec. 3313. Improved Medicare prescription drug plan and MA?PD plan complaint
system.
Sec. 3314. Uniform exceptions and appeals process for prescription drug plans
and MA?PD plans.
Sec. 3315. Office of the Inspector General studies and reports.
Sec. 3316. HHS study and annual reports on coverage for dual eligibles.
Sec. 3317. Including costs incurred by AIDS drug assistance programs and Indian
Health Service in providing prescription drugs toward the
annual out-of-pocket threshold under part D.
Subtitle E?Ensuring Medicare Sustainability
Sec. 3401. Revision of certain market basket updates and incorporation of productivity
improvements into market basket updates that do not
already incorporate such improvements.
Sec. 3402. Temporary adjustment to the calculation of part B premiums.
Sec. 3403. Medicare Commission.
Sec. 3404. Ensuring medicare savings are kept in the medicare program.
Subtitle F?Comparative Effectiveness Research
Sec. 3501. Comparative effectiveness research.
Sec. 3502. Coordination with Federal coordinating council for comparative effectiveness
research.
Sec. 3503. GAO report on national coverage determinations process.
Subtitle G?Administrative Simplification
Sec. 3601. Administrative Simplification.
Subtitle H?Sense of the Senate Regarding Medical Malpractice
Sec. 3701. Sense of the Senate regarding medical malpractice.
TITLE IV?TRANSPARENCY AND PROGRAM INTEGRITY
11
O:\FRA\FRA09275.xml [file 1 of 7] S.L.C.
Subtitle A?Limitation on Medicare Exception to the Prohibition on Certain
Physician Referrals for Hospitals
Sec. 4001. Limitation on Medicare exception to the prohibition on certain physician
referrals for hospitals.
Subtitle B?Physician Ownership and Other Transparency
Sec. 4101. Transparency reports and reporting of physician ownership or investment
interests.
Sec. 4102. Disclosure requirements for in-office ancillary services exception to
the prohibition on physician self-referral for certain imaging
services.
Sec. 4103. Prescription drug sample transparency.
Subtitle C?Nursing Home Transparency and Improvement
PART I?IMPROVING TRANSPARENCY OF INFORMATION
Sec. 4201. Required disclosure of ownership and additional disclosable parties
information.
Sec. 4202. Accountability requirements for skilled nursing facilities and nursing
facilities.
Sec. 4203. Nursing home compare Medicare website.
Sec. 4204. Reporting of expenditures.
Sec. 4205. Standardized complaint form.
Sec. 4206. Ensuring staffing accountability.
Sec. 4207. GAO study and report on Five-Star Quality Rating System.
PART II?TARGETING ENFORCEMENT
Sec. 4211. Civil money penalties.
Sec. 4212. National independent monitor pilot program.
Sec. 4213. Notification of facility closure.
Sec. 4214. National demonstration projects on culture change and use of information
technology in nursing homes.
PART III?IMPROVING STAFF TRAINING
Sec. 4221. Dementia and abuse prevention training.
Subtitle D?Nationwide Program for National and State Background Checks
on Direct Patient Access Employees of Long-term Care Facilities and Providers
Sec. 4301. Nationwide program for National and State background checks on
direct patient access employees of long-term care facilities and
providers.
Subtitle E?Pharmacy Benefit Managers
Sec. 4401. Pharmacy benefit managers transparency requirements.
TITLE V?FRAUD, WASTE, AND ABUSE
Subtitle A?Medicare and Medicaid
Sec. 5001. Provider screening and other enrollment requirements under Medicare
and Medicaid.
12
O:\FRA\FRA09275.xml [file 1 of 7] S.L.C.
Sec. 5002. Enhanced Medicare and Medicaid program integrity provisions.
Sec. 5003. Elimination of duplication between the Healthcare Integrity and
Protection Data Bank and the National Practitioner Data
Bank.
Sec. 5004. Maximum period for submission of Medicare claims reduced to not
more than 12 months.
Sec. 5005. Physicians who order items or services required to be Medicare enrolled
physicians or eligible professionals.
Sec. 5006. Requirement for physicians to provide documentation on referrals to
programs at high risk of waste and abuse.
Sec. 5007. Face to face encounter with patient required before physicians may
certify eligibility for home health services or durable medical
equipment under Medicare.
Sec. 5008. Enhanced penalties.
Sec. 5009. Medicare self-referral disclosure protocol.
Sec. 5010. Adjustments to the Medicare durable medical equipment, prosthetics,
orthotics, and supplies competitive acquisition program.
Sec. 5011. Expansion of the Recovery Audit Contractor (RAC) program.
Subtitle B?Additional Medicaid Provisions
Sec. 5101. Termination of provider participation under Medicaid if terminated
under Medicare or other State plan.
Sec. 5102. Medicaid exclusion from participation relating to certain ownership,
control, and management affiliations.
Sec. 5103. Billing agents, clearinghouses, or other alternate payees required to
register under Medicaid.
Sec. 5104. Requirement to report expanded set of data elements under MMIS
to detect fraud and abuse.
Sec. 5105. Prohibition on payments to institutions or entities located outside of
the United States.
Sec. 5106. Overpayments.
Sec. 5107. Enhanced funding for program integrity activities.
Sec. 5108. Mandatory State use of national correct coding initiative.
Sec. 5109. General effective date.
TITLE VI?REVENUE PROVISIONS
Subtitle A?Revenue Offset Provisions
Sec. 6001. Excise tax on high cost employer-sponsored health coverage.
Sec. 6002. Inclusion of cost of employer-sponsored health coverage on W?2.
Sec. 6003. Distributions for medicine qualified only if for prescribed drug or insulin.
Sec. 6004. Increase in additional tax on distributions from HSAs not used for
qualified medical expenses.
Sec. 6005. Limitation on health flexible spending arrangements under cafeteria
plans.
Sec. 6006. Expansion of information reporting requirements.
Sec. 6007. Additional requirements for charitable hospitals.
Sec. 6008. Imposition of annual fee on branded prescription pharmaceutical
manufacturers and importers.
Sec. 6009. Imposition of annual fee on medical device manufacturers and importers.
Sec. 6010. Imposition of annual fee on health insurance providers.
Sec. 6011. Study and report of effect on veterans health care.
13
O:\FRA\FRA09275.xml [file 1 of 7] S.L.C.
Sec. 6012. Elimination of deduction for expenses allocable to Medicare Part D
subsidy.
Sec. 6013. Modification of itemized deduction for medical expenses.
Sec. 6014. Limitation on excessive remuneration paid by certain health insurance
providers.
Subtitle B?Other Provisions
Sec. 6021. Exclusion of health benefits provided by Indian tribal governments.
Sec. 6022. Establishment of simple cafeteria plans for small businesses.
Sec. 6023. Qualifying therapeutic discovery project credit.

by delbertpgh

or as if you don't need them around for long. Since I don't believe that, I can only conclude you don't mind talking no sense.

by maxwell edison

..... I think it simply illustrates how passionate people are on the issue. And actually, I'd concede that both sides of the argument have merit (even though there are more than two sides). Our medical delivery system, in so many ways, really sucks. The difference, however, is agreeing on how to fix what's broken. Another difference is defining what's really broken.

But a government controlled fix, in my estimation, will not only fail to fix what's really broken, but it will actually make matters worse - much worse. And those things that I estimate will be worse actually extend well beyond the delivery of medical care.

Consider this (regardless of the service provided). In almost every case of commerce, if Entity-A receives a service from Entity-B, then Entity-A somehow compensates Entity-B for the service provided - or Entity-B freely gives the service to Entity-A. That's the way a free enterprise system works. However, if Entity-A receives a service from Entity-B, but Entity-C is expected to pay for the services delivered, AND Entity-A pays Entity-C to pay Entity-B (in some form, either directly or indirectly), then problems are inevitable.

In my opinion, we need to go back to square one and design a system that makes the most sense - AND make it one that doesn't violate the principles upon which our country was founded and allowed us to prosper - but the bottom line being, DO NOT violate these principles.

We need to also acknowledge a couple of facts of life. One: No one will escape this life alive; we will all die; there is no cure for death. Two: Life is not fair; some people are born into better circumstances than others; some people will make their lives better than other people can or will make life for themselves; some people have better breaks in life than others; some people have worse breaks in life than others; and any attempt to make life fair for some will only result in making life unfair for others.

The medical delivery system is broken, to be sure. But if we rely on government to fix it, then the broken pieces will only be smashed to smithereens. At least that's what I believe. And that's what I want to prevent.

P.S. Ask yourself this. When did the medical delivery system start on its path to be broken? My answer is this: when another entity was expected to pay for such services. Therefore what?

by delbertpgh

If it gets more expensive under a government-mandated structure, we can at least console ourselves with the fact it was getting more unaffordable every year anyway. I am not satisfied with the insurance model, for the reasons you point out; it has allowed the health care sector to price itself out of affordability, and removed the marketplace pressures that would govern the cost in a more typical environment. It will get worse.

However, what's worst of all is to leave care unaffordable. It's unfair. Granted, life doesn't work out equally, and the lower orders have to accept what is their share, and they generally do, which is what makes it possible for prosperous guys like you and me to be so comfortable. I'm not saying we're rich; the rich get their share, too, and we all of us generally accept that they're entitled, as well. However, the French found in 1789 that a decade of bad harvests and declining living standards brought the country to revolution; apparently the poor decided they had an entitlement to eat that nobody had been aware of for previous centuries. Call it a social contract: the poor and the working class put up with the pretensions and comfort of the middle classes and the rich, provided they get their due, too. They accept less, but it has to be enough to give them hope for their kids and a working man's dignity until death. Cross that line, and you risk revolution. As society gets richer, the line moves.

I don't believe we can end poverty; I don't believe we can stop the working class boy from tattooing himself and quitting school to prove that he won't fit into anybody's box, and thereby boxing himself in for the rest of his life. The kind of society we run needs a high proportion of underachievers, anyway: guys who party hard on Saturday night, and keep their heads down and work their 40 hours the rest of the week, and women who will stand by them, pregnant and patient, and knowing that nobody in the family will get too far. We can congratulate ourselves, some of us, on not having made the choices these others have stumbled into. But we have to provide for them, both as a matter of justice and as an issue of enlightened self interest.

(Edited to remove a gratuitous slap at the Palins. Sorry.)

by tony hopkinson

It's also not that expensive for basics, as the NHS being free at the point of demand cuts the amount of potential profiteering.

Some would consider that a cloud round the silver lining. :D

However you do or even don't fund health care, the cost, which is f'ing huge will pop out somewhere.

Saying you don't want to pay for others care is fine as far as it goes. But that just shifts the cost, employment, welfare, crime, defence, policing, insurance, cost of being civilised.

The thing about government funded healthcare is, like welfare it's another vote buyer, and you can bet your arse politicians of all persuasions will start cashing in on it at the first opportunity.

by av .

The government run insurance plan covers preventative care only and some basic health issues, but nothing catastrophic. You have to buy extra insurance if you want that.

Taxpayers can't afford any other kind of public option. Where is the money coming from anyway?

AV

by maxwell edison

If you consider ONLY the service provider and the service receiver, preventitive care and basic health issues are EXTREMELY cheap and easy to deliver. Those are the things that a person should pay for out of pocket OR have provided as a matter of charity (voluntary and private charity, not forced government charity). Why should a [i]government run insurance plan[/i] pay for those things? That's crazy!

Moreover, and I tire of harping on this, but the role of government in the United States IS NOT to cater to the needs and wants of the individual, but rather protect the individual's right to determine those things for him/her self.

by av .

It has to be guaranteed. Basic healthcare should be provided by the government. Just preventive care. If I had to pay for that out of pocket, it would cost too much.

Government does have a limited role. Anything more is individualy responsibility.

AV

by jdclyde

That is what you do when a majority voting block are lead to believe they have a "right" to "free" health insurance. Vote away other peoples rights.

We are moving backwards as a country.

by jdclyde

for her opposition to get so down, dirty and personal with her, it had to come from a need to destroy something they were afraid of.

You have to admit it was very shrill. When has there EVER been a time when a candidates family was attacked like that? Never.

by nicknielsen

I didn't think she was any more qualified to hold the office of Vice-President than the then-current incumbent and definitely didn't feel that she would be ready to be President should something happen to John McCain.

As for the way she was presented, both by the media AND the Republican party, the impression I got was that she was a female GWB; that didn't improve my opinion. Don't doubt it played well to the party faithful, though.

by maxwell edison

Basic health care should be provided by government? Really? Guaranteed health care? Is that the role of government? By what authority? At its lowest common denominator, are you suggesting that my health care should be guaranteed by forcing you (through government) to pay fot it?

Okay, AV. I go to the doctor, but I insist that you pay the bill. What a deal.

by maxwell edison

Take ANY one person in government (or any group of people), either party, either gender, any sexual orientation, any religious preference, etc., and give that person full and total control over your life.

Are you really that unsure of yourself?

Who can decide better, you or them?

I apparently have more faith in others than they have in themselves.

There ya' go.