Discussion Locked

"a government-run insurance plan"

0 helpful
419 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post

419 replies

by jck

I can swim and float.

Sorry if you need life jacket. Decide on you or your kid.

I'm swimming back to shore. lol

by jck

Doctors' fees are already being screwed by insurance company patient contracts.

The ambulance that transported me got 90-some percent of their submitted fee...to have a guy drive me 115 miles and one to sit in the back and do nothing but fill out paperwork. I got no pain med. Nothing.

The neurosurgeon who did my procedure got less than one-third of his billed amount.

Why is it that someone who goes through a decade of education and training and gets certified in an expertise...gets less than a company who employs only paramedics?

In the immortal words of Bill Murray from the movie Meatballs:

"There's something very wroooooooooooong here."

by jdclyde

haven't you been following the debate in Washington?

The docs and hospitals are over charging us, which is why no one can get health care, or so we are led to believe.

Does anyone think that if someone knows their bill is going to be only partially paid, that they will not increase the bill a like amount so that after the discount, they are getting the same amount?

Raise the price and then have a sale, not a new idea.

by jck

[i]The docs and hospitals are over charging us, which is why no one can get health care, or so we are led to believe.[/i]

Someone who worked behind the scenes in the medical industry, and whose family has/had 3 members in medical jobs.

Do you know why doctors bill cash patients $35 for a level 2 office visits and $96 to an insurance patient?

It's because of the contract with the insurance company.

Between insurance trying to scam down a doctor or hospital so that they can rake all the profits in themselves, and the medical manufacturing community charging exorbitant premiums for their products...it's a wonder we have medical care at all.

BTW, I will still point out to you:

Of all the Top 10 industrial nations of wealth, we are the only one without public healthcare.

And besides that, all those "communist" countries you put down with your rhetoric, such as Norway, Sweden, Denmark, Canada, etc., are all getting higher ratings as having more "freedoms" than we have too.

I see a trend here, and it is: you're wrong about how things are.

If you were right, their societies would have collapsed in anarchy, plagues would have infested them, and the USA would still be the land of milk and honey.

Because the government doesn't do what you want, it doesn't mean the sky is going to fall Chicken Little. Get over your doom and gloom and come to the realization: all the Americanista propaganda you've chewed up and swallowed for years isn't the absolute truth.

It's okay to step outside the box for a look sometime, jd. Trust me. I was once convinced the USA was faultless and #1 too. Then, I read more than my local newspaper and watched more than the ABC Evening News with Peter Jennings.

by oz_media

I worked for a company that sold a specific product to retail clients for $846.00 when the government ordered teh same product, or was replaced by an insurance claim, the cost was $1475.60.

That's the way it goes when you don't have to be competitive for business, it's just thrown at you regardless of cost, and thus you that's where you make your margins and you can afford to lose margin and offer better pricing to the price shoppers.

by jck

So many Americans think that "competition in private industry" only means that business should compete with business.

The thing is, with the status quo in the American society, that people who run these companies engender and endear themselves to one another through personal channels, e.g.- company lunches, conferences, golfing outings, etc.

Thing is because they don't get pecuniary benefit *directly* from it, it's not "insider trading" and Americans are taught to think "Oh, that's just business."

Thing is though at the same time, if several gas station owners go for a beer and set gas prices in a city/region it is then "collusion" simply based on the fact that it's not done at an exclusive location.

I think that a health insurance plan, equivalent and/or similar to the property insurance that Florida offers in comparison/competition to private insurers, would benefit the American people.

It would sort of "set the bar" for private industry to have to meet without solely talking amongst themselves to set levels and decide only what is best for their industries.

Business that is set to regulate business will always, eventually in a capitalistic society, solely look out for their best interests.

That's what the greed of business breeds: greed.

by oz_media

First off I agree with lowering the employment prerequisite for more menial jobs. YOU don't need a high school education to work in a gas station, Subway, etc. A good command of spoken English is sufficient. They don't even do math, count change or anything else anymore. That in itself would see more people gain employment.

The job bank just provides qualified candidates: Thus the job bank is a recruiter for entry level positions, a recruiter paid for by the government.

[u]Substandard workers[/u]

[i]Anyone who abuses the system that way should be treated like someone who scams it. You do it, you get punished. Lose your benefit. [/i]
So right back to square one, street people. One of many reasons welfare is needed is to keep people from living a life of crime, disturbing working citizens, stealing from them, selling drugs etc. The number of people who would fail at such a job offering and would wind up on the street is immense, I would not doubt that the number reached the millions, however I have not sought out current stats and it can't only be a guess at this point.

[u]Illegal workers:[/u]

[i]
a) enforce immigration law, rather than hmm-haw at it.

b) make it non-beneficial for companies to offshore the work and reduce the tax base.
[/i]

I think the laws exist today, however the NEED and DEMAND for lower cost products and manufacturer's being forced to resort to cheaper labour perpetuates the use and acceptance of illegal workers. You can't enforce a law against something while creating a demand for it. Americans are used to paying less than anyone else for what they have, they are used to a surplus of cash and spending so little on their actual needs. It seems that most simply don't have the mentality that you get what you pay for and those that do seem to accept getting second rate product for a lower cost, the bottom line HAS TO be the lowest cost. A competitive market drives manufacturers to push suppliers for lower costs than they are able to provide, again pushing a need for illegal workers.

If the government started shutting down such producers and prices soared, republicans would freak out over government control of Americas largest corporations and democrats would be freaking out over enforcing greater regulation and forcing prices back down.

[u]Headhunters and recruiters:[/u]

Don't cost companies money at all, it is paid for by the hired employee. Such services operate on a percentage of the employees first year's wages, up here it averages 12% but can be as high as 30% if the rep can sell it. So a job normally offering $50K will now only pay $44K to the worker and the other $6K to the recruiter. So it's essentially free and that's why everyone does it these days.

[u]Outsourcing[/u]

While the current trend shows offshore workers mainly in IT and telephone support roles, increasing the cost of US employees would only make companies seek more imports at lower costs.

[u]Corn:[/u]

I suppose I should have said largest export, but even then it is VERY close to wheat production now and is used on a much wider scale than wheat products and costs less to farm now.In the past, wheat was cost less per bushel to produce, as costs have since soared, corn growth has nearly doubled. Corn is used in almost EVERYTHING you consume.

http://www.ers.usda.gov/Briefing/corn/trade.htm

Mexicans are NEEDED in the USA.

No they're not. That's a fallacy.

Coming from corn farming backgrounds in Mexico, they are the ones that are willing to pick corn at reduced rates, which is when corn production and the US export economy rose. I watched several US corn farmers on TV the other day saying how they couldn't possibly run their operations with US workers because the companies they are contracted to only want to pay $X per bushel. They are pushed by their buyers or they lose the contracts, just like WalMart pushes their manufacturer's into offshore business in order to remain competitive. The buyers are forcing the need for cheaper labour that can't be found in the USA with above board workers. One farm goes out of business and there are two more waiting to buy the patented, hybrid corn seed and farm it with Mexican labourers. What happens often is the farm pays steep fines for hiring the labour, that they had no choice but to hire due to the demand for low cost products. They go out of business, another farm steps in and is pushed to do the exact same thing, yet the company forcing them to stoop to illegal practices doesn't pay a dime in retribution to anyone.

[i]"Actually, most of the stuff I get is local when it comes to foods"[/i]
Unless you buy everything from a local farmers market, you are buying mass produced food.

Ever buy soda pop? Potato chips? Hamburgers (especially hamburgers), fuel, medicine, any product that uses dextrose, corn syrup, even paper and other textiles use corn byproducts.

As for not funding WalMart, you are one in 330 million, if the rest of America felt the way you do, WalMart would not be the biggest store on Earth. However, supporting foreign workers is unavoidable as most product you use in a day incorporate corn byproducts in some way.

[u]CONCLUSION[/u]

[i]"I don't think it would be easy. But, I think it's possible.[/i]
And that's where we choose to differ I suppose. Actually I don't CHOOSE to differ, I just don't see it as a reasonable reality to consider, though still a nice concept.

FACT: In general, Americans are cheap people, they are raised that way, have never had to think any other way and don't care for quality over quantity. until Americans understand that they need to pay premium prices, to get high quality, American made products, this mess will never go away. What's worse is that the machine is driven by corporate, capitalist greed. That greed showed Americans how cheap things COULD be and thus they are now forced to offer cheap, low quality products. That in theory is not so bad but when those same corporations decide to retain strong margins at the same time, you sacrifice quality and health too.

Compared to other products made worldwide, "American made" now sits in with Chinese or Taiwan made, cheap, low-end, dollar store junk. Even American bands that go on tour can't sell USA made T-Shirts at their merch booths as they are such poor quality, shrink instantly, fade out etc. I was talking to Zakk Wylde's merchandisers in Seattle and they said they make very little on T-Shirts sold in the US, because they buy Canadian shirts (in Europe they buy European shirts) and have them printed locally. They don't sell many shirts in Canada otherwise.

Their prices are very low for concert merch, so in the US, people wont' pay for quality and they make very little margin. In Canada, people jump all over the lower pricing but it is still slightly higher than US pricing and nets them more than in the US.
They keep money in a Canadian or European bank respectively and convert it when the dollar is in their favour.

by notsochiguy

...but I think it was one of the old Merry Melodies ones.

Of course, they'll never air it again. They won't even show the Tom & Jerry episode where Jerry and his kid/friend/brother/lover(??) get sloshed on wine, and start singing:

I'll take the high road
and you'll take the low road
And I'll be in Scotland before thee
(hiccup)

Political correctness sucks!

by jck

[i]First off I agree with lowering the employment prerequisite for more menial jobs. YOU don't need a high school education to work in a gas station, Subway, etc. A good command of spoken English is sufficient. They don't even do math, count change or anything else anymore. That in itself would see more people gain employment.[/i]

Actually, they need to know math. If the power goes out, they still need to be able to do math for cash customers.

[i]The job bank just provides qualified candidates: Thus the job bank is a recruiter for entry level positions, a recruiter paid for by the government.[/i]

America's Job Bank is already there and funded, just like welfare. Why not use both programs to run each other out of business and eliminate all the cost you can.

I think in business it was called "leveraging synergies" in the 90s.

[i]Substandard workers

So right back to square one, street people. [/i]

If you have ever been to New Orleans, you'd know all people on the street are not destitute.

And as I've said before, if they have no food or money...they'll starve or work.

[i]One of many reasons welfare is needed is to keep people from living a life of crime, disturbing working citizens, stealing from them, selling drugs etc. The number of people who would fail at such a job offering and would wind up on the street is immense, I would not doubt that the number reached the millions, however I have not sought out current stats and it can't only be a guess at this point.[/i]

Actually, there's two things to stop that in America:

1) Let law enforcement do their job...some druggie is mugging someone, let them shoot them.

2) The right to bear arms - if an American's house is being broken into by some miscreant, let them shoot them.

You let those two things happen, America would be a lot safer and a lot more prosperous.

[i]Illegal workers:

I think the laws exist today, however the NEED and DEMAND for lower cost products and manufacturer's being forced to resort to cheaper labour perpetuates the use and acceptance of illegal workers. [/i]

Yep. Sad, but true. But, it's not need. You don't need to save $.05 on a can of mixed vegetables so you can afford a cup of starbucks per week on Fridays.

It's an expectation really, but not a NEED.

[i]You can't enforce a law against something while creating a demand for it. Americans are used to paying less than anyone else for what they have, they are used to a surplus of cash and spending so little on their actual needs. It seems that most simply don't have the mentality that you get what you pay for and those that do seem to accept getting second rate product for a lower cost, the bottom line HAS TO be the lowest cost. [/i]

Can't argue with you there. Most Americans are cheap.

[i]A competitive market drives manufacturers to push suppliers for lower costs than they are able to provide, again pushing a need for illegal workers.[/i]

Actually, the truly competitive market drives innovation. The buyer's market with an unlevel supply-to-demand aspect is what drives prices down...where vendors want to push more out for larger discounts from their supplier.

Of course, that model is pretty much gone now since Wal-Mart tells makers what they will pay...then if the seller doesn't agree, Wal-Mart goes to a Chinese or Afghani or Kazak maker to see how much they can make the cheap version for.

[i]If the government started shutting down such producers and prices soared, republicans would freak out over government control of Americas largest corporations and democrats would be freaking out over enforcing greater regulation and forcing prices back down.[/i]

Funny thing: The Republicans had no issue with lowering the prime with the Federal Reserve to give privately held banks super cheap rates while they were still pushing out home loans at 7 and 8 percent.

Yay Dubya?

[i]Headhunters and recruiters:

Don't cost companies money at all, it is paid for by the hired employee. Such services operate on a percentage of the employees first year's wages, up here it averages 12% but can be as high as 30% if the rep can sell it. So a job normally offering $50K will now only pay $44K to the worker and the other $6K to the recruiter. So it's essentially free and that's why everyone does it these days.[/i]

Um. I used to work at a firm, and it was at no-cost to the employee. The company looking for people paid a $2000-7500 fee (based on the job) for successful recruitment of a candidate.

It happens both ways, I guess.

[i]Outsourcing

While the current trend shows offshore workers mainly in IT and telephone support roles, increasing the cost of US employees would only make companies seek more imports at lower costs.[/i]

Thing is:

Those jobs are not going to get hiked.

A $24k telephone support tech is making $11.20 an hour or so. Not $7.50.

[i]Corn:

I suppose I should have said largest export, but even then it is VERY close to wheat production now and is used on a much wider scale than wheat products and costs less to farm now.In the past, wheat was cost less per bushel to produce, as costs have since soared, corn growth has nearly doubled. Corn is used in almost EVERYTHING you consume.[/i]

Even my tap water? :^0

[i]Coming from corn farming backgrounds in Mexico, they are the ones that are willing to pick corn at reduced rates, which is when corn production and the US export economy rose. I watched several US corn farmers on TV the other day saying how they couldn't possibly run their operations with US workers because the companies they are contracted to only want to pay $X per bushel. They are pushed by their buyers or they lose the contracts, just like WalMart pushes their manufacturer's into offshore business in order to remain competitive. The buyers are forcing the need for cheaper labour that can't be found in the USA with above board workers. One farm goes out of business and there are two more waiting to buy the patented, hybrid corn seed and farm it with Mexican labourers. What happens often is the farm pays steep fines for hiring the labour, that they had no choice but to hire due to the demand for low cost products. They go out of business, another farm steps in and is pushed to do the exact same thing, yet the company forcing them to stoop to illegal practices doesn't pay a dime in retribution to anyone.[/i]

Most corn (and wheat) is harvested mechanically.

Only smaller operations use manual labor.

[i]Unless you buy everything from a local farmers market, you are buying mass produced food.[/i]

My fruits, vegetables, and what not. Yeah, I do get it from a farmers' market.

Most grocery store stuff tastes like crap.

[i]Ever buy soda pop? [/i]

Ever? Yeah. Now? Not a lot. Usually get water.

[i]Potato chips? Hamburgers (especially hamburgers),[/i]

Rarely anymore.

[i]fuel[/i]

My fuel comes in from the Gulf of Mexico refineries.

[i]medicine[/i]

Lilly, Pfizer, etc., offshored those jobs to Mexico with NAFTA.

[i] any product that uses dextrose, corn syrup, even paper and other textiles use corn byproducts.[/i]

Not sure. Probably. I imagine the sheet rock in my house has corn in it too. :^0

[i]As for not funding WalMart, you are one in 330 million, if the rest of America felt the way you do, WalMart would not be the biggest store on Earth. However, supporting foreign workers is unavoidable as most product you use in a day incorporate corn byproducts in some way.[/i]

My computer? My car? My plastic coffee mug? My cotton boxers? :^0

[i]CONCLUSION

And that's where we choose to differ I suppose. Actually I don't CHOOSE to differ, I just don't see it as a reasonable reality to consider, though still a nice concept.[/i]

I think it's a reasonable reality.

I just think most Americans are too lazy to pursue it.

[i]FACT: In general, Americans are cheap people, they are raised that way, have never had to think any other way and don't care for quality over quantity. [/i]

Absolutely. That's why I am not afraid to buy hand-made stuff that I know is better than some machine popped-out dollar store job.

[i]until Americans understand that they need to pay premium prices, to get high quality, American made products, this mess will never go away. [/i]

Actually, you don't necessarily have to pay premiums. If labor costs don't skyrocket in the advent of job creation (which most local governments don't try to regulate in an effort to take as much taxes as they can), you can have a long sustained business with quality products at a reasonable (not cheap, not expensive) price.

[i]What's worse is that the machine is driven by corporate, capitalist greed. That greed showed Americans how cheap things COULD be and thus they are now forced to offer cheap, low quality products. That in theory is not so bad but when those same corporations decide to retain strong margins at the same time, you sacrifice quality and health too.[/i]

That is so well-said. Thank you.

[i]Compared to other products made worldwide, "American made" now sits in with Chinese or Taiwan made, cheap, low-end, dollar store junk. Even American bands that go on tour can't sell USA made T-Shirts at their merch booths as they are such poor quality, shrink instantly, fade out etc. I was talking to Zakk Wylde's merchandisers in Seattle and they said they make very little on T-Shirts sold in the US, because they buy Canadian shirts (in Europe they buy European shirts) and have them printed locally. They don't sell many shirts in Canada otherwise.[/i]

Yeah, I heard that from a tour manager once for an American artist. He was telling me that the premium they had to pay even for foreign made improved materials was getting out of control. And, finding product that would sell and be financially beneficial when organizing things for a tour was getting more and more difficult.

[i]Their prices are very low for concert merch, so in the US, people wont' pay for quality and they make very little margin. In Canada, people jump all over the lower pricing but it is still slightly higher than US pricing and nets them more than in the US.
They keep money in a Canadian or European bank respectively and convert it when the dollar is in their favour.[/i]

Yep.

by oz_media

With respect to the power going out at Subway, or some other fast food joint.

When that happens here, they just can't serve you, period. No receipts, no inventory management and asset tracking in play means no sales either. It's the old, many kids can't read an analogue watch anymore, routine.

[i]"America's Job Bank is already there and funded, just like welfare[/i]

So they work just as our unemployment offices do? They offer a job board, help writing a resume etc.?

[i]If you have ever been to New Orleans, you'd know all people on the street are not destitute.And as I've said before, if they have no food or money...they'll starve or work.[/i]....or steal.

I have (loved it too) and I agree that there are many on the street by choice that could do something better for themselves, it happens here and most other places too I think. However many of those people live in the street by choice, they don't want to work and they get their food etc. by stealing, robbing, selling drugs too. You can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink.

Law enforcement should be there to serve and protect as best they can, given the limited number of police compared to criminals.

A shoot now and ask questions later policy is fine, a little extreme and wild west but people in America seem to accept it. However, how much time are they then held up in courts, not on the streets and costing the city money in overtime wages? Police forces are usually not that well funded.

Same with houses, it gets out of hand. The Castle doctrine has been a proven failure in many state already and thus several have already abolished it.

But hey, shoot to kill is okay for many, have at it. It does just make criminals buy bigger guns, more body armour and they don't care or respect human life anyway, in most cases.

What I meant by competitive markets is one where others have been knocked out of the game by much bigger companies that rule and dominate an industry. I had mentioned (without reverting to past posts, something like Monte's?)they have a hybrid, la designed corn seed that all contractors working for one of the 4 major corn producers MUST use due to it's fast growth.
They are so tightly controlling that they have several thousand security enforcers that respond to accusations and check the farmers as they are not allowed to KEEP a single seed. One farmer was using his own seed and has been fined tens of thousands of dollars and may face court time. His farm was between two others who use the proprietary seeds and the dust and debris blows across the farms and can breed a unique strain of seed, any trace of the manufactured seed's chemicals and he gets nailed. In other words, they are just bullying him into compliance. That's not healthy trade or competition in any way, it's market domination. Same goes for chickens, a naturally farmed chicken takes months to grow, a chemically farmed chicken takes weeks, and again illegals are used to farm them (gather and collect them from barns at night). Those chickens often can't walk either as their bones do not develop at the same rate the meat does. Even worse is that because chicken breasts are so popular, they even breed chickens to have extra large breasts (not implants), again in weeks instead of months. It's manufactured food sources, not natural foods. Nice to think I only buy free range, eggs and chickens.

[i]Yay Dubya[/i] Well...yeah, nothing to say about that, that I haven't already said. ;)

Outsourcing, telecoms jobs were my exception which you seem to have taken as an example. My point is, if products can be bought cheaper elsewhere, they will be. Then someone else's workers can work for low pay, if THAT doesn't work, the American company opens up and in said country and shuts down all local competition by removing the export demand. Been done here with a few resources already, fish and lumber to name just two.

Corn, in some form, yes is used in almost 90% of consumer products. if you go to a grocery store, over 78% of the products in the shelf, including imported foods, have some by product of corn in them.

Don't eat hamburgers? Again you are definitely the exception there, MacDonald's doesn't survive on selling salads (though I am very happy they have them on the menu these days, and they aren't that bad either!)

Tap water, I don't know but I honestly wouldn't be surprised in the least. All tap water is treated with some chemicals to remove impurities, many such nontoxic chemicals and pesticides use corn by products also.

I see you choose to eat healthy, don't like processed foods and care about where you buy and what you buy. I'm also sure that there are MANY Americans who do the same to some degree anyway. However with 330 million people I think it's it's safe to say the vast majority do not. The demand for corn in the US is intense, farmers that once grew small farms have now needed to farm thousands of acres and in quick time too. Mexicans are still used in such farming operations, perhaps not for the actual collection and processing of corn but in many other areas of the farming process. There was a Canadian agricultural documentary on a while back that detailed it all, illustrating that Canadians may soon follow suit, however I can't remember too many specifics. Corn is Americas largest export though, whether for just agricultural exports I don't know.

Yup, y'all is in a bit of a pickle. It's too bad that the forward growth momentum and the mighty and big mentality got as far as it did before people began to realize what they had initially supported. I also think there are many who still do support it and feel it is just and fair in some way. Which is sadder I'm not so sure though.

Cheers, GREAT chat!I thoroughly enjoyed tossing around you idea.

by oz_media

But I download them all the same.

A while back someone posted a group of all teh Tom & Jerry deadly chases. All teh cartoons with the most violent chase scenes in them, awesome collection.

"If you is or if you ain't my baby"

Ton in his zoot suit made from teh curtains is one of my favorites, as well as the one where Jerry's cousin (a baby French mouse) visits and they have it out on the Thanksgiving table.

"Touche' monsieur pooosy cata" :D Priceless!!!

by oz_media

Bit a blatantly illegal practice.

Raising the price before the sale is VERY illegal, and comes with severe penalties that are enough to shut the doors on most businesses. Law, something medical practitioners are seemingly exempt from, especially in Canada where they don't even get sued.

by jck

I totally understand your points, and they're well-taken.

Sure, the shoot to kill thing is a bit old west. However, too many people here who commit the crime have the mindset that they won't be punished for their acts. It is a mindset that has gone throughout here now.

I think if more people knew that law would have summary act allowed for seeing a definite crime committed, they would be less likely to go and rob, mug, kill or rape.

I think that would stop some of that.

[i]Yup, y'all is in a bit of a pickle. It's too bad that the forward growth momentum and the mighty and big mentality got as far as it did before people began to realize what they had initially supported. I also think there are many who still do support it and feel it is just and fair in some way. Which is sadder I'm not so sure though.[/i]

I just hope we can change the mentality here. However, I've not seen it in the past decade, which troubles me.

And now, you know why I have spoken often of looking to relocate. If something seems to offer me fairness in life to earn what i keep yet others above *AND* below me can move on with me...why should I choose to live where my contribution is no more cherished by those around me than a rock in a rock pile.

It has been a nice discussion. Thank you too.

by oz_media

I added a zero to my government quote, good thing that wasn't a real quote! :D

bascially, if the government orders something the price is raised above list/retail levels, others get much better pricing.

An oops that completely reversed the intent of my post. lol!

by tonythetiger

[i]If you have no insurance, I pay through my private insurance premiums for your being uninsured.[/i]

Do you mean that since there are fewer in the pool who don't use as much in medical services as they are paying in premiums, each member of the pool pays more?

So what? If bread is $2 a loaf or 2 loaves for $3, do you have the right to demand someone to go in with you so you can have the one loaf of bread you need for $1.50?

This discussion is closed to new replies.