Discussion Locked

"a government-run insurance plan"

0 helpful
419 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

419 replies

by jdclyde

increases overhead. So an existing system that is over priced because of overhead will be made less expensive by adding governmental overhead?

by tonythetiger

Create choice.

I believe that employer-paid plans are a large part of the problem. They have their employees in a virtual monopoly! I think we'd be better off if they put the money they are currently spending into a dedicated account, and allow us to choose our own insurer to be paid from that account.

Letting employees choose their own would put tens of millions of new customers in the market. Insurers would then be tripping all over each other to get our business, and prices would fall... to the point where it would be more affordable to more people. While this won't entirely eliminate the problem, it would reduce the number of uninsured to a level that would be a lot less expensive to deal with.

We'd also have more choices... People have unique needs and each could customize their coverage to fit their needs, and change it as their needs change. And it would eliminate portability problems such as when changing jobs, since the account would remain with the employee, only a different employer paying into it. If your choice is less than what the employer pays in, the balance could be used for unreimbursed medical expenses. I would also like to see any balance in this account roll over.

Another small but real benefit would be a reduction of paperwork for the companies... time and money they could put into the VALUE of their product or service.

Families are struggling, and even though they say they only want to tax "the rich" to pay for it, we all know (or should know) that the rich eventually get it back from the consumer in the form of higher prices, so if we could figure out a way to improve the situation with a minimum of intrusion and tax money, it would be better for everyone.

by jamesrl

Why did the overhead in the US grow over time, the numbers showed that in the 70s, the size of admin(number of people involved in admin as a percentage of the total healthcare workforce) was roughly the same between the US and Canada, but the number of healthcare admins ballooned over the past three decades.

I can't speak to the system thats being proposed in the US, it looks very very complicated. In Canada, with a single payer, its simple. Someone in the doctor's office/hospital looks at the services provided. If they are on the "list", they bill the government. If they aren't on the list, they bill the patient. The government does have some auditors to look for doctors who may be billing for services not provided. But nothing like the massive infrastructure that reviews and approves and monitors and bills in the US private insurance. BTW my dental is provided by a private insurer, and I go through the same kind of bureaucracy as an HMO customer for that.

Single payer would simplify the bureaucracy, but thats not whats being proposed.

You assume that governments are worse at managing than private companies, but the recent recession has shown that bad management exists in many private companies as well. I'd say that many of the worst private companies are worse/more bureaucratic than a reasonably well run government program.

James

by jck

[i]P.S. Oz, I'd bet you $100 that you can't find even ONE sentence in any discussion in which jck even hinted criticism or disagreement with Barack Obama. The guy is infatuated with him. It's both funny and sad at the same time[/i]

Go look in the socialism thread that Max started.

I believe, in contradiction to Max's claim, that I stated that I don't believe the government should force people to buy insurance.

At the same time, I think anyone who chooses not to have insurance risks being turned away for treatment from for-profit medical providers.

I believe I disagreed with Obama's stance (Actually, Baucus' Senate draft/bill) that requires buying medical insurance.

Go check my posts, Oz. If you win the $100 from Max, you can buy me a beer if I come to BC.

BTW, Max. Do you love anyone more than you love yourself? I doubt it. Get A Bullwinkle mask on and host your own segment of Mr. Know-It-All.

by jck

[i]You either want government to decide things concerning your private life or you don't. I don't - PERIOD - and I'll let ALL chips fall where they may. How about you?[/i]

Sp you decide:

Where schools are built?
Roads are constructed?
Where you go to vote?
Where you can buy a gun?
Whether or not your wife gets a mammogram that finds the lump that saves her life?

You only think you want to make all the decisions in your life.

If you had to make (and pay for) everything government provides you, you would either live meagerly or your neighbors with more guns would come steal your stuff.

That's right. Police, fire, medical regulation, land rights, highways, etc.

All done by that evil government that makes your life safe and easier.

You should get a group together, go buy an island, and make your own way. See how great life is having to do everything yourselves.

by tonythetiger

[i]If Tony tells me all the time that he is for people being able to spend their money that they earn the way they want, why won't he back me in being able to spend the money my employer takes from my paycheck and funnels to one insurance firm they brokered a deal with?
[/i]

You SHOULD be able to take the money your employer pays for insurance and buy your own. I've said it over and over again... on this board, on other boards, in letters to my representatives...

The government doesn't have to go to the extremes it's trying to to fix that problem.

by jck

It is a compensation I earn at my job, yet my employer is not required to pay that to me if I choose not to have insurance.

Say I was married, and I don't want their insurance. My spouse has a far superior coverage. I want to take that money and buy supplemental life insurance instead, or AFLAC for specialty coverage.

My employer doesn't have to give me squat.

You are saying on one hand I should get the money.

On the other hand, you are saying that even though there is no way on God's green earth I can get that money that the intervention of the institution whose duty it is in this world is to protect my rights and serve to make the country better...shouldn't be mandating my employer give me that option you say should be that way?

What's wrong with this picture, Tony?

I should have it, but yet when I don't have it there's no way I can get it and government shouldn't make a bill that requires them to do so?

Jesus.

by tonythetiger

at the preamble to the United States Constitution.

"Promote" the general welfare does not mean "provide". If they'd have meant "provide", they would have specifically said "provide", because in the previous sentence, they did ("provide for the common defence,")!

by charliespencer

I too would like to see employers removed from the system, and also support putting that money (and decision) in the employees' hands.

We differ over the government involvement. I don't want the feds as a 'single payer' or 'sole source' system, but as one alternative to the private system. I'd like to hear more details about co-op systems too.

What I'd really like to see in 'A Perfect World' is people over 18 who don't buy even the most basic insurance being held financially responsible for their treatment, to the point of denying treatment for those who repeatedly abuse the system. I believe society has a responsibility to offer affordable health care, but individuals who want to utilize it have the financial responsibility to cover their expenses.

by jck

"...secure the blessings of liberty..." I guess means the right to screw someone else over as long as a law hasn't been written against it?

Of course back then, "...establish justice, ensure domestic tranquility..." included public hangings.

Maybe we should go back to horse and buggy too?

Fact is, part of your "common defense" is that which things like HHS and CDC and NIH provide in the form of basic care and treatment to the public, medical research, statistical gathering, and monitoring of possible widespread medical issues.

You should join Max's "I do everything for myself" club and go buy your own island and build/do everything for yourselves, including providing your own military for defending your property, and medical research labs and universities and hospitals for curing disease.

Besides that, Tony. If this whole thing cuts $829B out of the total federal spending for medical over a 10 year period, isn't that really gonna make you happy?

After all, they'll be spending less of your money like you want.

by charliespencer

Maybe if a few more people saw what an execution actually looked like, they'd think twice about committing crimes that might lead to being the guest of honor.

Also, was this post intended as a response to someone else?

by jck

I put it in the wrong spot...sorry...it was meant to go to Tony back up wherever.

That's what I get for trying to write English and VBA and Java all at once.

Go figure. Working means screwing up.

BTW, I have been a proponent of Pay-per-view public hangings, or mandating them as well as gas chamber and lethal injection as part of government broadcasting that is done on cable.

I think showing your kids "This man killed a little old lady for the $64 dollars and a watch she had. This is what he gets for being a mean, cruel, sick person." would make more kids think twice about going out and beating homeless people to death and torturing animals.

If you know you're gonna die for it, you are less likely to do the crap.

Just like if you know you're gonna starve and not get a hand-out and get shot if you try to steal, you will work to get something to eat.

by fregeus

Thanks Max. I must admit that I find this debate most entertaining.

Keep up the good work!

TCB.

PS. I am not being sarcastic.

by fregeus

I am not being sarcastic, swear! I'm a fan of psychology and I find the discussion fascinating. I don't agree with Max point of view, but I find the discussion, enlightening.

Very geeky of me, I know.

TCB

by oz_media

Well?

Well, you're a man of the world, squire.

Well, yes.

You've uh, been around a bit...you've uh, ....slept.....with a lady.

Well, yes.

Tell, me. wot's it like?

by charliespencer

except the sheep will shut the @#$ up afterward instead of wanting to talk about where your relationship is going.

by fregeus

I often find that most Americans say they have the best health care system in the world, until they get sick. Most Canadian say we have the worst system in the world, until we get sick.

Its all perceptions. ;-)

TCB

by jck

Government wages tend to be lower than private sector by 14-40 percent outside the management band.

As well, the US government gets bigger discounts on their benefits for employees, or self-insures.

So, yes...it is cheaper for them.

by jck

[i]Create choice.[/i]

The bills in both houses of Congress do that. It's called an "exchange" where people can go to compare and contrast plans offered by multiple carriers.

[i]I believe that employer-paid plans are a large part of the problem. They have their employees in a virtual monopoly! [/i]

I've been telling you they're doing that to me every month.

[i]I think we'd be better off if they put the money they are currently spending into a dedicated account, and allow us to choose our own insurer to be paid from that account.[/i]

There's one problem with that:

Fund management costs, and that means employees would have to pay for some fund management of that account to some company. That's a waste of money we should not be spending. So, you want to advocate spending more of the employees dollars on unnecessary things?

Put the money in the hands of the employee.

Not some money fund management group.

[i]Letting employees choose their own would put tens of millions of new customers in the market. Insurers would then be tripping all over each other to get our business, and prices would fall... to the point where it would be more affordable to more people. While this won't entirely eliminate the problem, it would reduce the number of uninsured to a level that would be a lot less expensive to deal with.[/i]

Insurers will never chase "individuals" for their business.

What would happen?

Insurers would meet with groups of employees, rather than the HR department to woo you into their plan. And, they'd offer a speel about "the more of your co-workers you can get to sign up for our plan, the cheaper it gets for all of you!"

You'd basically set up a lot of pyramid schemes doing it through a managed fund at work.

[i]We'd also have more choices... People have unique needs and each could customize their coverage to fit their needs, and change it as their needs change. [/i]

Nothing mandates that insurers open a la carte options to their plans as of now.

What makes you think sticking money into an account at your place of work will do that?

[i]And it would eliminate portability problems such as when changing jobs, since the account would remain with the employee, only a different employer paying into it. [/i]

If this money isn't going into an account with your employer, who is going to host it between employers? Do you realize the tax/finance management burden this represents?

[i]If your choice is less than what the employer pays in, the balance could be used for unreimbursed medical expenses. I would also like to see any balance in this account roll over.[/i]

That's where medical reimbursement accounts work differently from what you want. Most of them at the end of the year get to keep any unused amounts.

That's why I avoid reimbursement accounts. You go to submit stuff in November...they take 40 days to process it. They deny it all. You don't have time to re-file. They make a quick $400 off ya.

[i]Another small but real benefit would be a reduction of paperwork for the companies... time and money they could put into the VALUE of their product or service.[/i]

As i've pointed out, your ideology would increase the management required to maintain, monitor, file things for the account you've proposed establishing.

[i]Families are struggling, and even though they say they only want to tax "the rich" to pay for it, we all know (or should know) that the rich eventually get it back from the consumer in the form of higher prices, so if we could figure out a way to improve the situation with a minimum of intrusion and tax money, it would be better for everyone.[/i]

Um...a question about finance for you.

If you don't take the revenues you have and use them, and you don't increase your customer base to generate more revenue to spend...how do you pay for something?

Just curious about your answer to that.

No new revenue = no new spending...unless you want to put off those resurfacing projects on I-80 for 10 more years?

That'll save several hundred million there. That's a nice start. ;)

by oz_media

Americans don't buy anything they manufacture themselves, the cost is too high from all of your overtaxed 'richies' (stole that term from Pretty in Pink).

Americans only buy cheap, Chinese knock-offs as that way they can afford the industrial sized bags of Potato chips at Piggly Wiggly.

by jck

By God! I'll have you know!

- My car was made in KOREA!
- My speakers were made in UTAH!
- I buy chips at 7-11!

I am a good American. I diversify. :^0

by oz_media

I know you don't support him blindly. So do you REALLY think Maxwell is going to mail off $100.00 though? Nope, just words to display self assurance, which we all do. (besides, at the rate you're going it would need to be more than $100.00 US anyway)

Max, I know very well you didn't support all of Bush's actions, and we have discussed that on several occasions. What you fail to realize is I see the same in JCK, he feel does actually weigh and consider presidential actions before he supports them too.

As for weight of my comments, I remember things very well (especially verbal conversations, I can recall the tone of voice used, specific comments that I can re-quote exactly etc.) and perhaps that's why I find a need to remind you of your double standards when you accuse others of the exact same things you do yourself.

If it bores you to be reminded when you accuse others of things you do yourself, you could stop doing it or bite your fingers to stop accusing others of it too.

As for 'hypocrisy', what else do you prefer I call it when you hold such double standards?

by oz_media

You are kidding right?

"I don't buy into the class warfare, [b]nor all the race-baiting of [i]anyone[/i][/b] who would disagree with Obama or his policies."
-JDClyde

To my comment that Obama does not race bait, you then said:
"No, he doesn't.
But his supporters sure do!" - TonytheTiger

Yuo then reiterated:

"Not "some people"...
People [b]who are working with and for the President[/b]pushing their putrid agenda." TonytheTiger

In what way does Jimmy Carter, commenter in your first link, work with or for Obama?

"WASHINGTON (Reuters) - [b]President Barack Obama's spokesman publicly disagreed with former President Jimmy Carter[/b] on Wednesday over Carter's contention that some conservative opposition to Obama is based on race.

"The president does not think it is based on the color of his skin," White House spokesman Robert Gibbs told reporters."

You have NO point there at all, Obama's staff publicly denied Carter's 'theory', who neither works for or with Obama.

From yoru second link of hopeless "proof":
ACORN neither works for or with the president, it's a collection of small community groups. That's like saying just because a group of peers on TR says something about racism that they represent "People [b]who are working with and for the President[/b]"

From your Washington Post BS:
"Jan Erickson, NOW Government Relations Director"...

NOW is the National Organization for Women. I suppose in your mind they too represent "People [b]who are working with and for the President[/b]"

She noted racism because she "saw (protesters displaying) images of President Obama juxtaposed with the Nazi swastika and charges of socialism and a government "take-over" of health care."

Since when was displaying images of a swastika NOT racist?

She was pointing out how protesters, those who support the republican agenda and oppose Obama, are displaying racial images. How is that wrongly portaying racism to further their own putrid agenda?
Based purely on your own criteria, it is then fair to say that those {b]who are working with and for the Republican party[/b] are displaying racial images.

You are WAAAAY of base Tony, you DON'T have a point that you can support.

Actually it was JD's false claim that you tried to defend, with garbage unrelated to the comment itself and one even proved that such accusations were indeed accurate against Obama protesters.

by tonythetiger

No, and you don't have to work for any employer who doesn't compensate you in the manner you want (but see note at end).

Jck, I agree with you that you SHOULD get the money he is paying... The only difference between it and money on your paycheck is that you're not paying income tax on it.

What I disagree with is that employers give some more than others based solely on whether you get family coverage or single. It's should not be his burden whether you choose to marry or have children. Every employee should have the same dollar amount paid toward their insurance (or as I would prefer, their health spending account).

(Note: As more "transfer of wealth" policies go into effect, that will probably change... Human nature says that eventually, people will decide not to work as hard if they're only going to have more of the fruits of their labor taken away and given to someone else. As work output starts to decline, less money will go into the government coffers, and more will go out. The government will then have no choice except to force labor. At that point the collapse of the country is imminent!)

by charliespencer

"Insurers will never chase "individuals" for their business."

Then I wish that duck, gecko, and the gal with the heavy makeup job would go the heck away. If that advertising isn't chasing individuals, what is it?

Well, actually, the chick's kinda hot, kinda like a high-end mannequin or a very expensive inflatable.

If the only thing we're quibbling about is whether the money goes to an administrated fund or directly to the employee, we're closer to an agreement than our elected officials.

"That's where medical reimbursement accounts work differently from what you want. Most of them at the end of the year get to keep any unused amounts."

Must be nice. The reimbursement account where I work now is 'use it or lose it', as it was at my previous employer. My understanding is the law establishing them also specifies 'use or lose'.

by oz_media

What yuo are failign to see is that such a system would correctly NOT allow patients self diagnosis and self treatment as they do now.

I Canada, I can't go in and DEMAND an MRI or CAT scan, I can DEMAND to see a doctor and he/she will detrmine my treatment options.

$80 Aspirin? Private system

by jck

[i]No, and you don't have to work for any employer who doesn't compensate you in the manner you want (but see note at end).[/i]

You earn that insurance. They are paying $x for it. That is YOUR $x. It should be YOURS to spend as you wish.

And you're right. They don't have to.

But if the health insurance reform passes, your employer will have to let you CHOOSE. They are required to pay, and you will be allowed to shop for what you want.

[i]Jck, I agree with you that you SHOULD get the money he is paying... The only difference between it and money on your paycheck is that you're not paying income tax on it.[/i]

Actually, I looked at my stub online now and looked at the tax tables on the IRS site. I don't know if it's difference in state law or what, but my insurance is pulled out post tax.

[i]What I disagree with is that employers give some more than others based solely on whether you get family coverage or single. It's should not be his burden whether you choose to marry or have children. Every employee should have the same dollar amount paid toward their insurance (or as I would prefer, their health spending account).[/i]

My employer doesn't do that. They pay wholly for single coverage. If you do single + 1 or single + family, you pay the difference in premiums.

[i](Note: As more "transfer of wealth" policies go into effect, that will probably change... Human nature says that eventually, people will decide not to work as hard if they're only going to have more of the fruits of their labor taken away and given to someone else. As work output starts to decline, less money will go into the government coffers, and more will go out. The government will then have no choice except to force labor. At that point the collapse of the country is imminent!)[/i]

That's foreshadowing that it will kill the country, like we weren't already going to hell in a handbasket.

Fact is, public healthcare would save money in the long run. It stops conditions from worsening that require more expensive and lengthy treatment, more hands on care vs medication, and better prevents spread of communicable disease.

That's why I would like to see us have a public health system. That way, ERs don't get tied up by the "splinter in a finger" folks. And, someone doesn't have to worry whether or not they can afford going in to see someone for chest pains or blood in their stool.

Preventative care provided by public services would be far cheaper than critical care by public services, which is what occurs when those who can't afford it don't get the basic care they need and their problems compound from something only needing an ointment to something requiring surgical procedure and rehabilitation.

Besides if your theory were true, I'd have quit working and gone on welfare years ago.

Maybe I should.

by tonythetiger

[i]Fund management costs, and that means employees would have to pay for some fund management of that account to some company. [/i]

I have my electric, gas, phone, and cable bills automatically come out of my checking account. Doesn't cost me a cent.

(perhaps you misunderstood. Employers would pay into an individual account for each employee. Not one account for multiple employees. This is no more complex than the direct deposit most employers now do.)

How is this different?

[i]Insurers will never chase "individuals" for their business.[/i]

They're already doing it. Can't watch TV for an hour without seeing at least one add wanting you to "change your car insurance and save hundreds a year". Health insurance will be no different.

by jck

I had a med. reimb. acct. once. I had over $400 of it left. I filed prescription receipts plus cold meds and stuff from when I was sick in the calendar year. They refused over 90 percent of my claims, citing the receipts "didn't have enough information of qualifying purchases".

What a crock. It said "ACE BANDAGE" and "CVS Pharmacy" at the top. I would say that means...I bought an ACE bandage at CVS.

They're a scam. I agree.

by charliespencer

The problems you describe are more due to the administrator chosen than the concept. I don't have a problem with giving the money directly to the employee, but I think an administrator is needed to ensure the money is spent on medical expenses and not blown on cigs and lottery tickets.

It takes some planning every fall when I decide how much to allocate for the next year. I collect the previous years receipts and add in any anticipated one-shot expenses like new glasses and a filling or two. I usually exhaust the allocated amount by early November. If a person can't make an close estimate on how much to allocate each year, he or she probably isn't capable of selecting a health care plan and should consider paying an administrator to make those decisions for him.

by jamesrl

In Canada, there are two parties involved, the patient and the doctor. If the doctor says, get an MRI, then the patient will get an MRI. If things are urgent, then the patient can be bumped up the line. It happened with my son, he got one in hours when he had an espisode of turning blue. My wife went to a CT scan as soon as she was stable (about 90 minutes) after a head injury.

You can of course get a second opinion, but if you are a doctor who is too "liberal" with tests, you may come to the attention of the college of physicians and surgeons.

In the US, with no HMO and cash, you need a doctor's referral. With an HMO, the doctor has to submit the treatment plan to the insurer for analysis.

James

by tonythetiger

[i]If you don't take the revenues you have and use them, and you don't increase your customer base to generate more revenue to spend...how do you pay for something?[/i]

was who pays for tax increases on the rich. I don't know what you're talking about.

Suppose I own a company. Hell make it simpler. Suppose I own a rental property.

I have costs for repairs and upkeep and taxes, and I'd like to make a little income (else what's the point, right). I consider that when I set the amount I charge for rent.

Now suppose my property taxes go up. I guarantee that the rent is going to go up by the same amount (as soon as the current lease period expires).

A company is no different. Everything's a business cost, which gets included in the price of the product or service. If any of those costs increase, you either have to cut something else, or raise prices.

by jck

[i]I have my electric, gas, phone, and cable bills automatically come out of my checking account. Doesn't cost me a cent.

How is this different?[/i]

Your employer has a bank

You have a bank

When you earn money, your employer puts it directly to your account (or pays you a paper check you deposit where you wish)

An account like you're talking about, where gross proceeds are held in escrow, are not individual accounts.

If they are kept individually as you would like, then you tend to either require hiring more accounting/auditing people to keep track of those accounts, tax liabilities, dividends earned on such monies, etc.

Or, you end up hiring a money management firm (like is what are done for most group funds of individual accounts, such as group retirement funds).

Either way, you are going to spend MORE just to have/manage/run/administrate that account, than you would just to pay the people to deposit the check and spend it how they wish.

by tonythetiger

[i]but I think an administrator is needed to ensure the money is spent on medical expenses and not blown on cigs and lottery tickets.[/i]

It needn't be elaborate. You can have "health checks" (or a health debit card) that takes qualifying purchases from that account. This is simple for today's retail technology... identical, in fact, to how they figure what items are food-stamp eligible.

by jck

It was the plan...period.

When I am told "you get reimbursed for any out of pocket medical expenses up to the value of your savings", I expect when I submit a CVS pharmacy receipt that shows "ACE BAND" which is pretty clear to me that an ACE bandage was bought by me at CVS...that I'll get my $6 or whatever back.

The receipts even had item codes on them that would prove what the item was. It was like the plan was requiring me to get a dump of CVS' database for them to prove what the thing was.

I can understand not paying for cigarettes and stuff. But, my God. I had legitimate, illness-oriented purchases that they refused and had told me my money would be paid back to me for buying.

To me, that's fraud.

by jck

[i] What I was talking about was who pays for tax increases on the rich. I don't know what you're talking about.[/i]

The rich can pay for it. It's called decrease in profit.

[i]Suppose I own a company. Hell make it simpler. Suppose I own a rental property.[/i]

Okay.

[i]I have costs for repairs and upkeep and taxes, and I'd like to make a little income (else what's the point, right). I consider that when I set the amount I charge for rent.[/i]

Yep.

[i]Now suppose my property taxes go up. I guarantee that the rent is going to go up by the same amount (as soon as the current lease period expires).[/i]

Not necessarily. You can eat the cost if it's only $80 a year. Or, you can charge another $100 a year and make a 25% profit on that $80 tax bill.

[i]A company is no different. Everything's a business cost, which gets included in the price of the product or service. If any of those costs increase, you either have to cut something else, or raise prices.[/i]

Not everything is a business cost. That's why companies take a business loss sometimes and write it off their taxes and end up getting back monies.

You don't *always* have to roll an associated expense into your turn-around.

For example:

I operate a business. Part of my expenditures is insurance for my employees. I get to write off that liability as an operating expense and it decreases tax paid on gross funds.

Then of course, I file for a capital loss because I depreciated the value of my assets over a 5 year period, and lost the last 20% value of them which decreased my income level to a deficit in net.

Nonetheless, it's a misnomer that business always has to increase rate based on expense to make a profit.

If your profit margin is adequate and you bankroll enough, when you reduce profits later because of small increases...you don't have to worry about making minor rate alterations all the time.

Sorry, but the floating profit model of business is just a reason for poor business and finance management, and not a real reason to increase a price based on any cost shift occurring for or within an organization.

Otherwise, Wal-Mart would increase or decrease the cost of your can of pork and beans weekly.

by tonythetiger

[i]An account like you're talking about, where gross proceeds are held in escrow, are not individual accounts. [/i]

I'm talking about nothing more than a standard checking account in your name but only for health care purposes. You employer pays (the amount he is paying for health insurance) into that account. The health insurer of your choice withdraws premiums from that account. If the insurance you choose costs less, you can use that account to pay for your band-aids from CVS by using a card or check on the account (clearly identified as a health care account) when you pay for health care related purposes.

If the insurance you choose costs more than what the employer pays, you will have to add more money to that account.

What's so difficult about it?

by tonythetiger

prostitution should be legal... You're not really paying them for sex... you're paying them to LEAVE after :)

by jck

For every individual holder, you have to provide statements, end of year totals, constant customer care, etc.

No bank is going to do that for free.

Hell, they won't even let you talk to a teller free more than 2 times a month at Bank of America. They charge you per counter visit now after 2 times. So if you get paid weekly and want someone to deposit it for you, it costs you $3.50 per week after the first 2...to put money in their bank!

But what you are proposing spends your employees' money, and according to you that is something that no one should do for them.

So, why do you advocate it?

by tonythetiger

[i]Otherwise, Wal-Mart would increase or decrease the cost of your can of pork and beans weekly. [/i]

but here they nearly do! Some things even more often! Milk, for example, can go up, down and back up in the same week. It's almost as bad as gas :)

by jdclyde

when you have a government that is willing to do the stealing for you and deposit the money directly into the bank for you, it even removes the risk from that.

by jck

Go look at the total net taxes paid to the U.S. Government by Wal-Mart and Microsoft Corporations after re-filings, net losses on divisions, etc.

You'll find they are not paying the net taxes near to what you would be led to believe they are.

Your tax dollars and that of small business are being funnelled to sponsor things like "corporate development programs" and "energy investment credits" which are legacy programs left over from the Bush years that fund what is essentially corporate welfare.

Like me. I paid in some $14,000 in taxes last year. I about 15% of that back in a refund, because of paying extra in plus writing off homeowners interest on the mortgage.

Some companies that have $1Ms in income, after refunds, rebates, and tax credits pay in 0 in income tax because they get to take credits, write off operating losses in whole, etc.

So, beware of the numbers Wall Street spits out at you as to what Corporate America pays of the tax bill.

I guarantee you. Wal-Mart making $300B in a year sure as heck isn't paying in the same tax bracket I am or they'd be writing a $60B check to the US Treasury.

by jdclyde

ALL governmental theft is wrong. You can pretend I had said something I didn't, but that doesn't change what I wrote, then or now.

If someone works hard for something, it is NOT the place of government to forcibly take that and give it to anyone else.

And before the rabidly dishonest of you start up, this is NOT saying all taxes are wrong and blahblahblah infrastructure. A government does need money to run, the problem is people that have abused the power of government to do things it was never intended to do.

by maxwell edison

..... corporations that look for ways to make the tax laws more favorable to themselves as [i]theft[/i]?

Really?

Moreover, you said, [i]"Go look at the total net taxes paid to the U.S. Government by Wal-Mart and Microsoft Corporations after re-filings, net losses on divisions, etc.....You'll find they are not paying the net taxes near to what you would be led to believe they are.[/i]

Prove what you say. Please provide the amount of corporate taxes (any year) paid by the companies you mentioned. How much did they pay? Be specific. What were the total (gross and/or net) earnings, and what was the amount of taxes paid. Provide the numbers.

If you can't answer that question, you better start back peddling.

By the way, which nation's corporations pay MORE in corporate taxes? The United States' corporations or Ireland's corporations? Therefore what? And how does that reconcile with your accusations?

P.S. Corporations NEVER pay taxes anyway. They ALWAYS pass those expenses onto the consumer in the form of higher prices.

by maxwell edison

..... he doesn't pay enough money in taxes. I have no idea what he pays, but whatever it is, it's not enough - and it's theft.

Kinda' like what jck just said about Wal Mart. He has no idea what they pay, but whatever it is, it's not enough and it' theft.

Talk about a nonsensical comment!

by jck

One lasts 2 weeks. The other lasts 5 years.

If you had to pay for major work or an overhaul on a rental house every 2 weeks, you'd fluctuate your rates too. :^0

Stuff like pork and beans, little debbie snack cakes, bottled water, etc., have a pretty stable price.

It's high volatility with short lifetimes that are priced in more rapid fashion.

Hopefully businesses aren't always restructuring every couple of months.

by jdclyde

I was born with standards and work ethic, where I believe people need to pull their own weight in life.

I am not looking to take anything from anyone else, that I have not earned.

Actually, been spending more time lately helping people less fortunate than myself.

by oz_media

"...been spending more time lately helping people less fortunate than myself"

Why can't THEY pull their own weight in life? Do they have no standards or work ethics or are there exceptions to your blanket assertion ?

by jdclyde

they are people that I know have been laid off, are actively looking for work and are doing what they can to take care of their families. It is the people that are looking for a handout for nothing that I have no use for, but if you are working to make a go at it, I will do what I can to help.

I believe people should work to pull their own weight in life, but sometimes there are setbacks, and that is what friends are for. Something, it sounds like, you are not familiar with.

If they are making the effort and just not making ends meet, I am more than willing to help out in any way I can. Looking right now at what I can give to the food pantry, since thanksgiving is coming up soon. over a decade ago, they had provided me an my family with a good meal, how can I not do the same now that I am able?

Not everyone has to be legislated to help. How about you, just going to be a dick to everyone, or will you be doing anything to help those around you?

by jck

I thought that it was going to require Americans to "purchase" health insurance, and provide assistance to low-income people.

BTW jd...in case you didn't know:

Welfare people already get free-healthcare...it's called Medicaid.

So, that's not gonna increase any. In fact, the want to revamp that to cut out the fraud and save money.

Doom and gloom. Doom and gloom. Obama is satan. Pelosi is a demon witch. And, Baucus is the Anti-Christ cometh.

Doom and gloom....

by jdclyde

the requiring EVERYONE get in the pool is the central point of all the health care schemes right now, to get more and more of the healthy people paying more and more for the unhealthy people. That IS the key.

As for jck/jd, they both start with a "j". His observation skills are not as keen as his recall skills..... :D

by jdclyde

And I could not, would not support him, regardless of the letter behind his name. Something jck can't recognize as NOT blindly following a political party.

I believe he would have been a disaster, had he been elected, if a slightly different but similar disaster than where I see Obama taking us.

by jdclyde

network/system admin. B-)

It is what [b]I do[/b] that ALLOWS what [b]YOU do[/b] to work! :D

[i]yes, joking aside, I recognize both professions are ineffective without the other, and neither is more important. A perfect network is nothing without something to run on it, and great software is useless if the user can not reliably access it.

by tonythetiger

[i]The bills in both houses of Congress do that. It's called an "exchange" where people can go to compare and contrast plans offered by multiple carriers.[/i]

means the choice to "not choose". Believe it or not, some people are perfectly capable of paying for their health care needs out-of-pocket, and should not be penalized by the government for choosing to.

It's just crazy. On the one hand, they want to penalize you for not having a plan, and on the other, they want to penalize you for having one that's "too good".

by jamesrl

Milk is a staple. People buy it often, and often the need for milk alone initiates a trip to a store.

So stores use it as a loss leader. Milk sometimes gets sold even below cost, as stores are betting that people who come in for milk will buy a few other items, and in the end they will profit.

But no one wants to lose too much, so they try and stay at or near the lowest price but not by much.

Thats why milk prices fluctuate.

James

by jck

Tony:

[i]means the choice to "not choose". Believe it or not, some people are perfectly capable of paying for their health care needs out-of-pocket, and should not be penalized by the government for choosing to.

It's just crazy. On the one hand, they want to penalize you for not having a plan, and on the other, they want to penalize you for having one that's "too good"[/i]

I agree. If you can pay for all of your medical costs out of your own pocket, you should be considered "self insured". Period.

But if you take the risk and don't carry it and can't pay, I want doctors and hospitals to have the right, without fear of being sued, to be able to refuse treatment. Period.

JamesRL:

Milk, like bread and cheese, has more spoilage too.

That's why you'll also see bread going on sale every week at a store because of it's diminshed shelf-life.

But, that high turnover and higher than normal spoilage drives prices up and down based on consumer demand.

That's why you don't see a can of pork and beans $1.09 one week and $2.50 the next.

Plus, pork and beans are just fine food :)

by jck

*cough cough bull$hit*

I help do the Cisco routers where I work, administrate the DBs on SQL Server, Oracle, and MySQL, etc etc etc.

I wear your hat [b]AND[/b] mine at my job.

My main function is programming software for end-users, but I still have to help do everyone else's job. We are a shop of 11 people supporting all the IT needs of almost 1,000 end users on 5 campuses.

Plus i do all my own network, database, systems, programming and HTPC systems work at home too.

I don't need your services. I can configure Start->Control Panel->Network just as easily as I can use ipconfig, iwconfig, etc. ;)

So, I'm self sufficient in every aspect. I just don't have MCSE, MCSD, CCIE, CCNA, or CNA behind my name. :p

Thanks tho. Nice of you to offer. :^0

by jck

[i] Everyone has their own ideas of what is important
And I could not, would not support him, regardless of the letter behind his name. Something jck can't recognize as NOT blindly following a political party.

I believe he would have been a disaster, had he been elected, if a slightly different but similar disaster than where I see Obama taking us.[/i]

Do you remember what I even said about voting?

Did I say I'd vote for Obama in EVERY case?

See, this is where you're just talking out of your arse.

I preferred Huckabee to Sarah Palin as a candidate for VP. He represented a moderate, conservative view with sensible ideals on how to implement change without shoving it down everyone's throat.

I even told you I would have voted for a McCain/Huckabee ticket because I felt it was a more balanced, more experienced ticket.

I would have voted for Rudy Giuliani before any of them. The guy knows how to manage a big budget, lots of diverse people, etc. He knows how to get things done.

Anyways, you're either just trying to yank my chain or don't remember the conversation we had about a year ago of the candidates we preferred.

I have never EVER been party line...EVER. Democrat or Republican. PERIOD.

I think for myself. Unlike you.

by stvroy22

Name one instance where the government did anything cheaper than the private sector could. How does adding unnecessary bureaucracy save money?

A PWC study found that the average family policy rate will increase by $4000 in the next 10 years if the bill is passed as-is.

Furthermore, the tax rates in countries with socialized health care are astronomically higher than our own despite the fact that their health care systems are inferior. (on the basis that we have a longer life expectancy)

by jck

I'm self medicating tonight.

I have written 2 modules, 1 patch, reindexed tons of DB data, and helped troubleshoot a routing issue.

I need lots of booze soon.

I'm going home. Good night, Lucy.

by oz_media

I would never cross your names up again, just the way it works for me.

When I'm typing a reply I might be thinking of something one of you said, while replying to the other, and will typpe out the wrong name. I'm pretty danm usy right now, so posting is just something I do while thinking of what to type into an email, what to send to a client, what to say to move a client in a certain direction etc. I don't always have my mind fully on TR.

On the other hand, it seems you were bright enough and still managed to figure out who I was referring to though.

I haven't even gone back to figure out where I screwed it up, I just assume I mixed up the reference somewhere.

EDIT: Okay the title was wrong. Sorry, jck.

by oz_media

First of all the government is just offering an option to people needing insurance.

Currently your tax dollars, as well as insurance premiums, pay for this ewho are in dire need.

If those same people were paying a portion of their own costs, how does that put the government in control of your private life in any way shape or form, that they don't already have control of now?

You are not giving them more rights to control your private lives, by electing them you have already given them that right. The government that is elected by the people is entrusted to spend your tax dollars.

If you think paying taxes is the same as allowing the government to control your private life, they are already spending your tax dollars to help those who pay nothing in taxes OR premiums. YOU DO IT NOW.

How is allowing them a way to balance the cost, by having people pay a portion of what you already pay for now, seen as giving them more control?

This greater government control kick is absolutely illogical.

If you DON'T allow them to charge these people for what you already pay for, you are therefore accepting the government paying for the entire cost out of your tax dollars.

by jamesrl

Mom and Pop convenience stores with local ownership may focus on having sales to reduce stock levels to reduce spoilage, but I can tell you that supermarkets/Walmart/Costco do not. They focus on the market. If you go into a mom and pop, there isn't much to impulse buy. Walmart/supermarkets try to price to get you to come in.

The big national chains have target prices for these things, but they allow for regional pricing, and they allow local regions and even stores to adjust prices to match or beat competition.

One proof of this is when a new Walmart comes into an area. They will try to have the lowest price on milk and bread. But there have been monitors that show if some of the local competition close their doors, the prices on these items creep up.

Big store buyers adjust their orders and schedules to try and reduce the amount of spoilage.

James

by oz_media

RBH is based in Layton Utah. They were actually 'assembled' in China. RBH products come in boxes that say made in China, I am not sure how the EMP boxes are marked though.
Final assembly is cheaper there.

RBH designs the product, manufactures the crossovers, driver cones etc. They are then shipped to China, where they have a private plant for the purpose of assembly, using MDF cabinets that most likely comes from their high demand for Canadian lumber.

Hey, have you even hooked the bloody things up yet?

The assembled parts are then shipped back to Utah for distribution.

Signature series models are designed, and handmade in Utah, they just don't have the facilities to accomodate assembly of other products locally.

As for 7-11 (Southlands Corp.), your pure blood, Texas originated company; Toshifumi Suzuki is the Chairman of Southlands and Masaaki Asakura is the EVP/COO. Couple of good ole down home Teaxas boys I suppose. :D

I forget which Korean car you have though, isn't it was a Toymotor Prius?

In contrast I drive an American designed SUV, built in Canada, with a German engine. :D

My speakers (The Scandyna's) were made by a merger between a Scandinavian (Scanspeak) and Danish (Dynaco) company, a second set was designed by good old UTAH based RBH Sound (woop woop RBH!!)and assembled in China and another set was hand made in Utah.

Many of my clothes are European imports (nothing beats European suits for cut, tailoring and design).

Damn free trade and world affairs, you don't know where ANYTHING comes form these days. It is really nice to have such a HUGE marketplace though, as long as you avoid teh cheapo knock-off's, you can get superior quality products by buy each nations specialty exports.

by oz_media

LOLO, just a French Canadian thing, ha-ha-funny and all that (or should that be "a-a-funny and all dat?") ;)

And before you ask, no there is no B key on my keyboard, just a little tin pad I have to pound to get a B. That's why my typos now include missing B's.

by fregeus

I hate French Canadians that can't pronounce their 'H's. That or speak "franglais". English with a thick French accent you can cut with a machete.

Can't stand it.

TCB

by jamesrl

Having gone to school in Ottawa, we learned to distinguish the accent from across the river by the way they pronounce Hull and Aylmer, two local towns. If they say "ull and Haylmer", then they speak the west Quebec accent.

James

by oz_media

It means that Congress may provide legislation that acts in a general best interest of a nation.

If AFFORDABLE health care for millions of uninsured Americans is not acting in the best interests of the nation, you have some really screwed up thoughts towards your nation.

by oz_media

The people I hear moaning in Canada are people who get into a bar fight at 2AM and have to wait in the emergency room for an hour before getting their broken nose fixed.

or

People who haven't needed to be in hospital for a while and have listened to teh NDP whiners going on about poor nursing conditions, crowded hjospitals etc.

The people who have just come from a doctor or have recently been released from hospital say how awesome our system is and how greateful they are for our health care plan.

Great oservation TCB!

by oz_media

Is that it's from the same people who thought Bush was a worthy president and did a good job, for the most part.

How can you defend Bush's actions and downplay Obama's when Bush's was for his personal betterment (though he CLAIMED it was to save America...and the same people bought it), or at least he hoped it would be that way, and Obama is more focused on making it a better place for the people of America.

To top it off, people are whining because Obama wants use other people's tax dollars to balance costs and make the lower class start paying medical premiums, instead of getting freebies. Yet they supported Bush when spent many trillions of other people's tax dollars on a futile war in Iraq!

I often wonder if some people even deserve a voice with such warped mentalities, that's democracy though. Maybe the voting prerequisite should be an IQ test or something.

by av .

Personally, I'd rather pay into something with a fixed cost instead of not knowing how much of the insurance premiums I pay now cover the uninsured.

I don't like government control but in this area it makes sense. Everyone needs healthcare and we all should support basic needs.

We pay anyway. Maybe we can cut costs.

AV

Edited: Whoops! Lousy editing.

by av .

Not just the rich. We need affordable healthcare for everyone in this country and it's going to cost us.

AV

by maxwell edison

A [i]public option[/i] means a government (public) option will compete with a [i]private (corporate)[/i] option.

Consider this:

Corporate must operate with a profit, while government can run unlimited deficits.

Corporate is limited to operating under monetary limits, while government can print money.

Corporate must operate under existing laws, while government makes the laws - which is exempt from following.

I could go on.

Do you really understand what you just suggested?

If you were [i]private[/i] and I was [/i] public[/i], would you like to compete with me if I could make (and change) all the rules all the time, and you were forced to be profitable while I could run unlimited deficits?

Have you really considered the true difference?

P.S. Let's play a game of poker. The only thing is, you must play under the private option rules, while I play under the public option rules. After all, there's nothing like a public pair beating a private full house.

by oz_media

Firstly, your examples are such extreme exaggerations they become laughable analogies. Secondly, a private is only a forprofit organization because they have no restrictions as to how badly they can rip off customers and deny others access to affordable options.

In your poker game, the private would also insist that your bets cost double the value of the chips you play and if you didn't have enough to anti up you would be left out of the deal.The public would ensure that you can still play as many chips as you wanted but would also lower the anti to make it an affordable game for others to join too.

You are just forunate that you are still able to afford your premiums, others who may also work hard and pay taxes may not be so lucky.

by jdclyde

the poor poor already DO get free healthcare, and no pipedream passed now will improve on free.

But people like you are just not honest enough to admit the scam.

The poor poor will NOT be helped one bit by any of the proposed legislation.

just like obama is not honest enough to admit it is not evil republicans stopping him, (because EVERY republican added together could not stop anything from passing) but rather it is Democrats that recognize bad legislation that are refusing to follow party line lockstep that are his sole problem. Neither he, nor you, have the honesty to admit that.

by jck

[i]the poor poor already DO get free healthcare, and no pipedream passed now will improve on free.[/i]

Did I not just say that?!?!?!?!

[i]But people like you are just not honest enough to admit the scam.[/i]

Actually, it's no scam.

What's the intent?

To provide affordable healthcare coverage to ALL Americans.

That doesn't mean just the poor...or the poor poor...or the doom and gloom like you who are semi-poor and semi-unemployed. But, also the working self-employed business owner who makes good money but is being drained by insurance costs.

[i]The poor poor will NOT be helped one bit by any of the proposed legislation.[/i]

You're absolute right about something FINALLY.

Too bad you said it after I'd already said it, or you might have gotten something on your own.

[i]just like obama is not honest enough to admit it is not evil republicans stopping him, (because EVERY republican added together could not stop anything from passing) but rather it is Democrats that recognize bad legislation that are refusing to follow party line lockstep that are his sole problem. Neither he, nor you, have the honesty to admit that.[/i]

Shows what you know. If the majority is not 60% or more in the senate, Republicans may filibuster and practically stop and kill the legislation.

Go back and take Civics over and learn something.

by jdclyde

and you will see that Obama does not have the complete support of every Democrat in the house/senate, and THAT is what is stopping him.

by jdclyde

that is NOT the pipe dream that the mindless cultists of obama believe will happen. They still believe it will be free for them and "the rich" will foot it all.

by jck

Are you really that ignorant?

jd, Barack Obama and his wife reported in 2007 $4.2M in income. They paid some $1.4M in tax, and donated over $240k to charity.

The Obamas fall in that "rich" category who will be taxed heavier.

Talk about mindless turds. Get a grip on reality. Most Senators and Representatives make enough per year between salary, investments, honoraria, etc., to be hit by the legislation they're passing.

Those mindless cultists are going to pay for YOU to have affordable coverage.

Amazing, huh?

by jdclyde

AS IT IS NOT health care that is being debated in congress and the senate, but INSURANCE. The two are NOT the same thing.

NOTHING is being done to increase affordable health CARE or improve quality of living for anyone.

And the proposed plans will do nothing but increase the costs, not lower them. That is the reason sane people oppose these half baked and RUSHED plans.

by jdclyde

you voted Democrat again, I voted independent. Tell me all about it, and following party lines.

NO ONE that was going to vote for McCain would change their vote for Obama because of ANY VP pic. Just a lie. total lie.

You loathed her, because you are just that way.

There was never a single thing about Obama, past or present, that would make me vote for the man. there is very little about McCain that would get me to vote for him, and I refused to vote "lesser of two evils".

I was hoping to get more votes for Barr to ate least get the Republicans attention that they can no longer take votes for granted and throw anyone in front of us and expect our votes.

I will not vote for McCain.

by maecuff

My current boss defines himself as a fiscal conservative. He always votes Republican. He said he WOULD have voted for McCain, but with Palin as his running mate he had to vote for Obama because the risk of having Sarah Palin in office was too scary for him to contemplate.

I'm sure he's not the only one. To difinitively state that NO ONE would ever change their vote based on a VP pic is ludicrous. How could you know that?

by jck

I just remember my English classes.

I can't do any gymnastics anymore. Effects of a neck injury.

by jck

[i] Bottom line
you voted Democrat again, I voted independent. Tell me all about it, and following party lines.[/i]

Again? Hm. Who did I vote for in past general elections that wasn't Democrat?

1988 Bush Sr. (not Dukakis, the Democrat)
1992 H. Ross Perot (Not Clinton, the Democrat)
2000 Harry Browne (the libertarian)

Wow, I vote REAL party line there.

You're wrong again, jd. Admit it.

[i]NO ONE that was going to vote for McCain would change their vote for Obama because of ANY VP pic. Just a lie. total lie.[/i]

So I'm a liar now because I don't make choices like you? That's rich, oh all-knowing one.

As I said, I feared that if something happened to McCain, I wanted someone I believe could take over and manage the country. I didn't think she could. I think Huckabee could.

[i]You loathed her, because you are just that way.[/i]

I loathed her? I thought she was hot. I just thought she was incapable of national leadership, and that she was a poor example of someone who supposedly espoused living and raising her children to have "family values".

I never loathed her. I loathe child molesters. I don't loathe hot women who I think are not capable or qualified to be 2nd of command of our country...just like I wouldn't vote for a half-ass male candidate like Mike Dukakis in 1988.

[i]There was never a single thing about Obama, past or present, that would make me vote for the man. there is very little about McCain that would get me to vote for him, and I refused to vote "lesser of two evils".[/i]

So you voted for the least of all the evils?

[i]I was hoping to get more votes for Barr to ate least get the Republicans attention that they can no longer take votes for granted and throw anyone in front of us and expect our votes.[/i]

Oh well, there ya go. Vote for Bob Barr. Guy jumped ship on the Republican party (weak candidate because he didn't STRONGLY hold their values...remember?), waffled on same-sex marriage when he flipped parties (car salesman...says what you wanna hear), and supposedly opposes abortion even though he had his ex-wife get one (can you say... hypocrite??).

No wonder you endorse him. He's such a "strong" candidate.

[i]I will not vote for McCain.[/i]

That still doesn't change the fact you're wrong. I don't vote party line. Never have.

Rant on someone else you know things about that are factual, rather than what you want to think are.

by jck

I've done it before too.

I am busy too. I just fixed an issue where I had to research crap in 5 tables. *5*!!!!

And, they won't let me re-engineer the app to make it more efficient. Go figure.

by jck

I think the parts are made in China. I think the speakers are made in Utah.

I have 3 hooked up. The two I can't put on the back wall yet because they didn't come with built-in hangers on the back of them so I either have to get some or get and make space for floor stands.

The sound is much better, but that's comparing them to the cheapo Sony's.

For $200 though, you were right. They were a steal.

Thanks again for the tip.

by walstib77

The myth of a health care "market" is a big part of the problem.

The US continues to forge forward inseting private profit into the insurance formula, and the industry defends the need to have "market driven" health care.

Where is this market? When people get sick or hurt and go to the emergency room, where is the list of prices and competitive analysis?

When doctors prescribe medicines, where is the discussion about comparative pricing?

Fact is, it's not market driven. Supply and demand, Price and Quantity are not the drivers of the market, and that is the problem.

Consumers typically are not impacted by typical economic factors when making medical decisions, because insurance clouds the issue. Same for the suppliers--insurance eliminates many of the economic relational factors that make markets work.

The main thing insurance is supposed to do is spread risk as broadly as possible. As the rest of the civilized world has learned, the only cost effective way to do this for health care is through one federalized system.

If having "socialized health care" makes a country communists, we need to gear up the miliatry and get ready to invade Canada, The UK, Germany, Australia, France, Austria, Belgium, Japan, Norway, Spain...

The dominos have fallen!

by jck

Cause, that's "just how you are". :^0

BTW, jd. No matter how generous or giving you are, if someone is not paying for their way in life they are "not pulling their own weight".

Yeah, there are setbacks. But, not doing is not doing no matter how hard you try.

Oz was right. Your support of those in need is admirable, but your assertion that people who don't pull their weight don't deserve things was very generic and poorly expressed, and did not make your opinion and standing you said here meet with how you practice in life.

Just thought I'd interject that.

by jck

So you have approved of EVERYTHING that YOUR government has "forcibly" taken from you?

It is that YOU don't want anything spent a way YOU don't like.

Well, tough cookies Mr. Helper. This is America. It's a melting pot, and a national community that works together for the betterment of all...not of just jdclyde.

If you want things all your way, go with Max and buy an island and make all your own things the way YOU want them.

At least when I didn't like the way my country was being run, I tried moving...not just sitting and whining about having to participate in something I saw as wrong.

by jck

Any year?

2009
Wal-Mart's gross revenue: $405,607,000,000.00
Wal-Mart's gross profit: $95,086,000,000.00
Wal-Mart's income tax: $7,185,000,000.00

As for what their net is? That isn't how tax is calculated. You don't get to write-off what you pay your children in allowance, give your wife for buying shoes, etc., buying magazines to figure out what car to buy. That's considered part of the cost of life.

Source: SEC filings, 12 mo. period from 1/31/08-1/31/09

Anyways, there's your numbers.

And as far as I can tell, 7B out of 95B is about 7.4 percent.

Wouldn't you like to pay that out of your gross profit after you paid all your bills?

by jdclyde

I base people by their efforts, not their results. Not everyone is going to be successful, and many of the hardest workers I have ever known make less than 24K a year.

I am living in a state unreal unemployment thanks to Granhom "blowing us away".

Wonder if we can sell/give Detroit to Ohio?

by jdclyde

I do not believe anyone that says that. Doesn't mean they are lying, just that I do not believe them.

There is no conceivable way anyone that is a "fiscal conservative" would have supported Obama, ever. Ask him how fiscally conservative his vote turned out to be, if what you/he said is true.

IF Palin scared him away, he would have turned to the next closets match to his ideals, Independent, as I did, although I did because of McCain and all of the Republicans in Congress/Senate.

I believe someone could not vote for McCain because of it, but no, I do NOT believe for a second anti-Palin would make someone Pro-Obama in the voting booth.