Are certifications destroying the world?
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by advancedgeek
the problem with this is that there is no way to get 6 months of experience unless you have the mcsa...but this would be a good way to get rid of all of the kiddies out there that think they can just take a test and automatically start out making big bucks.
Hell that's what I thought when I was just getting into the arena...I was A+ certified in 2000 (maybe early 2001) and I thought I was supposed to be making 18 bucks an hour starting out (found that on a website). In reality, I made 10 bucks an hour, and I was lucky I had that.
by crowemag
by jdclyde
Don't listen to them.
I am getting my BA in networking, AND getting CERTS WHILE I am working in the field getting experience.
The biggest problem I see it people make the mistake of letting some outside influence decide if you like your job or not.
If you enjoy what you do, where you do it is worth so much more than to have that huge check and HATE getting up every morning and having to go the THAT place again.
Ignore any fool that says your not making enough unless they are willing to pay you more.
by mollybigd
I totally agree with what you're saying. I'd rather learn from a well seasoned Networking Adminstrator with or without a degree. These types of individuals know their stuff as long as they keep up with technology.
The guy doesn't want to expose certain knowledge. The trainee that works under him now, is only given so much information to ONLY WORK on certain things. O/S knowledge.........forget it. So if any of the servers go down..trainee has to call the administrator to get that certain information to FIX the problem. Poor trainee is definately in the dark. You want to hear a shocker....I used to have this guys(administrators) job before I went back to university full-time. Received my degree, came back to the same company, received the job as Webmaster, but you know what, I am missing the Networking arena. I really loved doing the Admin job...the only problem now is, I am not up to par with Windows 2000 server..Know of any good books to start refreshing my mind! Thanks
are your best bets for that sort of thing. I'm a software developer, so I just use the network and then blame the admin when it doesn't work. LOL
Not true actually I go ask them if they can see what I'm doing wrong and all of a sudden it starts working by the time I get back to my desk.
My network admin stopped with VMS 6.* and NT4, back in 99
by house
The MCSE route (if you want to go that far - you can judge for yourself what you think you should know). Sybex books are the best publications for MS, Comptia, and junior to intermediate Cisco certs.
For general networking technologies, both the Network+ and CCNA combined are well worth the effort in pursuing. Now... when you think CCNA, you think switch and router configuration right? Well... half right... half of the CCNA exam is devoted to some very important networking fundamentals. Working through this text with a solid simulator, like the Boson Netsim, will definitely help you fully grasp the concepts involved.
The A+ cert is almost a necessity. Work towards this one to fill in the holes in your knowledge. The cert is always a bit outdated, so in real life, you will need to keep up on products, technologies, and trends out of personal interest.
For your Microsoft studies, I recommend going through the MCSA texts in order to grasp 2k, but then tackle the 03 for your actual certification in the end. You might not deem the certification necessary, but it will be very valuable in it's pursuit. Work with the OS while you are going through the text - this is vital - do not think that you will remember anything unless you do it hands-on.
Sybex publications have a way of laying out the information at a very "reader friendly" pace, with the occassional blip of humour.
Have fun... if you wish to pursue certification, these are my entry level suggestions.
by jdclyde
It always amazes me when people get their feeling of self worth by what they do instead of how they do.
Living in Michigan I see that all the time. When you meet people and ask where they work instead of saying they are a chemicl engineer they say the work at dow. Where they work is more significant than what they do there. Sad.
It says your management? do you see this in your shop?
by warnerit
I own the company and we are a small custom software firm, only 10 employees, but we are very big on customer service. Most of my colleagues here are people I knew from other jobs and admired for their customer service philosophy and work ethics.
There is definitely no room for egos here if we want to stay afloat, the customer is king. I wear many hats, CIO, partner, LAN admin, web programmer, accountant, janitor, etc.
But I worked at a large state university which shall remain nameless for 6 years before leaving to start my company and boy there was a big problem with egos there. In fact one of my good friends is still there as a mid level IT manager, we had lunch a couple months back and were talking about a fellow who was a friend of ours, he was the head network and system admin of an engineering department and he just lost sight of what his job really was. He got in this mode that it was HIS network and the employees he was supposed to be serving were only going to be allowed on HIS network under HIS conditions. He forceably switched everyone to Linux, even the little old lady secretaries who had a hard enough time just trying to do their jobs with Windows - bless their hearts.
Anyhow, he got away with this for a short while, then a new Dean came aboard. The Dean wanted Windows, the wayward IT guy said no way. The Dean put egomaniac in his place and ordered him to put at least all the secretaries back on Windows immediately and then anyone else in the department who preferred Windows. The guy gave the Dean a bunch of condescending crap and the Dean told him -you're outta here, don't let the door hit your butt on the way out.
My friend and I thought our wayward friend of ours was a good case study of how not to be as an IT person. He totally lost sight of what his mission was supposed to be - to serve his clients. Unfortunately he doesn't see what he did wrong either, in fact at the moment he is not talking to either of us because we aren't "on his side".
by jdclyde
Let them see what they want to see.
(not that I would know....) :<
But the idea is the same. If someone thinks your a good worker, then you are. Facts are interesting, but irrelevant.
by jdclyde
If the company is going good, I will do good. If the company does poorly then so will I at lay off point.
I see all the time people that over pay for items and don't care because it isn't their money. If the company spends it's money on supplies, then that comes directly out of the profit, leaving less to throw around at bonus and raise time.
Glad to see people of a like mind out there.
by warnerit
So true. It's amazing how many people can't/won't see the bigger picture though. Even when I was just an entry level peon I always held to the notion that I was there to serve the company and that I was a representative of the company and it was my job to represent the company well to others both inside and outside the company.
At the risk of sounding egotistical, here's my story: See, when I was nearly done with my BS in Telecommunications with not quite a minor in business I decided I wanted to be in law enforcement like my father. Well I had wanted to be in law enforcement for some time but my mother had huge objections, especially with me being her only biological child. But there came a point where I finally felt I should pursue my own career objectives, not hers. I didn't even know much about computers when I graduated from college other than how to write papers on Macs and Windows 2 & 3. Oh and how to run Mambasa and Porno-Writer on the Mac, LOL. Anyhow, upon graduation and while waiting for local police candidate testing I took a job through a temp agency where the only requirements were to have a BS/BA in anything and familiarity with Windows. It turned out to be a jr. level Windows programming job at an educational software company. Scary minimum job requirements I know, but this was the very early 90s too. It was there that I found I had a knack for computer science and that I really liked programming. I quickly became the head jr. programmer and was offered a nice salaried permanent job which was way better than I would make as a cop. It wasn't just because I had a natural talent that I excelled, it was because of my work ethic, I took great pride in doing the very best job I could, still do, and I was eager to learn whatever anyone would teach me. I wanted to be a good representative of the company, so whomever I came in contact with would be left with a better impression of the company than they'd had before coming in contact with me. I was always looking for ways to do my job more efficiently. When the IT guys couldn't get around to fix my computer problems or network connection problems for 3 days, I figured out how to tech support myself. Pretty soon my co-workers were asking me to troubleshoot their problems too. The IT guys were actually grateful for the help, it got the bigwhigs off their backs about the programmers having down time and possibly missing deadlines. I never missed a deadline either. Sometimes I had to work 2-3 days straight through to make the deadline but I always made them, and with the fewest bugs to boot. Because I took pride in my work and worked hard to do things right the first time. The IT guys gave me more and more permissions to help them out, soon I was helping with the Netware servers (yeah, I worked a lot of overtime). When there was downtime between my projects, either because I'd beat the deadline by a week or so or because the planning process was a little off and the next project wasn't quite ready for me yet, I'd work with the IT guys or in QA, wherever I could help out. I was willing to do and learn anything. It served me well too. I survived several layoffs, a couple of them were massive, even though I was one of the least senior employees by a long shot. And it wasn't just because the others made more money either, there were people who made less than me who got let go. They gave me a leave of absence to go to MCSE training for 6 weeks after I'd been there for 3 years. I had to pay for it myself, but they gave me the 6 weeks off and I came back to a huge raise. This was back in the NT 3.51 days. I left that company on good terms to go on to learn and experience more than I could if I continued there and I'm told by former co-workers that the President and VP of Development still speak highly of me to this day.
Anyhow, I have pushed this work ethic and customer service attitude on every team I've ever been on. In fact, my friend that I mentioned in another post that is now a respected and well-qualified mid-level IT manager at a large university was once my protege and says he learned it all from me. There were others who have worked with me in the past and took what I had to say about work ethics and customer service to heart and they have gone on to excel and do very well for themselves.
But enough tooting my own horn, my honker is worn out. I hope the point that I am trying to make comes across. The point is not "look at me, I am great" but that a good work ethic and customer service attitude can take you far. I am living proof, I'm really just an average person who learned to have an attitude of service.
OK, that's all I can say on this subject, I've got to break the grip this discussion has on me and get back to my duties.
by jdclyde
You just validated Certs.
If they get the job because of the Cert, then it would seem rather silly to knowingly put yourself at a disadvantage by not getting one? (used silly as it is the nicest word I could come up with).
I laugh at people all the time that post their resume on a job site and wonder why people don't call them, EVER.
You have to have something on that resume that the next person doesn't.
That means more exp with bigger companies and more certs and degrees to show you are commited enought to see something through.
If you have so much exp, you shouldn't have to spend the $2500 on the class. Just buy a book and write your test. If you can't pass like that, what does that REALLY say about your 10 years experience? That is the point. If you COULD pass the test and you were a working professional you would take that test.
Do you HAVE to have a cert or degree to do good? No.
but you are really stacking the deck against you.
by jdclyde
by jdclyde
How about the people that surf the web looking for nudie sites to add to blacklists? Now there is a job.
"So, what do you do for a living?"
"I surf porn."
Ain't life grand?
by jellimonsta
by jdclyde
They are too busy wanking to document what they find short of a bookmark for later "research".
[:>]
It must be rough, so try lotion.
by jdclyde
or bad old movies do I ever hear anyone say "BAH".
Why would someone type something they would never say? (or do you actually say that?)
Sorry, off the beaten path. It is just something that makes you go "hmmmmmm".
by doug m.
by rsgdmn
The problem with being self taught, is that there are gaps in your knowledge that will only be addressed when you run into a situation where you have to teach yourself more. Anyone who thinks the NIC handles DNS has experienced nothing and learnt less.
Experience might help you talk complete rubbish better, don't know many people who want to be certified as doing it well. Except press officers, market researchers , lawyers and politicians of course.
you lie to your customers, everything's fine
No ?
I've said in other posts while I believe the cert by itself has doubtful value from a technical point of view, you can't argue with it's commercial value, either on a personal or in your case a company point of view.
means, can't verify that you've got it and don't know how/whether/if it applies. A bit of paper makes their life a lot easier.
You've got to play the game, to be a player basically.
by alltech
One thing to consider is that the MS degrees in Technology and related fields do not seem to meet the test any longer nor does experience.
The exam is considered to be a test of specific knowledge. If they study the exam, they must have the specific knowledge -- correct?
Have a great day. The opinion stated here is my personal comment and does not reflect the position or opinions of any organization or other person.
by advancedgeek
by jdclyde
Would have been really funny to see the look on your face as soon as you realized what you just said.
Did the others catch it or only you?
I have found you can get away with saying a lot to people because they just don't listen anymore.
Feel free to BAH as much as you want. I was not complaining, just making an observation. Although you might have to change your login ID to advancedDORK if you do! hahahahahahahaaaaaaaa!
(I crack myself up)
Have a great day. Someone might as well.
by jdclyde
that there are still people out there that believe in putting in a honest days work.
With all the union labor in the country where they want as much pay for doing as little work as possible, it gets depressing. Gee, I wonder why companies would want to offshore. Maybe because so many people have such poor work ethic and an entitlement attitude.
When I first started where I am now, people would see that when I fixed something it STAYED fixed. It wasn't long before people would walk past my senior co-workers office, down the hall and around the corner to my office when they would have a problem. That is a good feeling.
by jdclyde
on a personal level?
I have seen friendships end because one of the friends had DE-volved into a completely different person over a few years.
It is a shame, esp when they are good at what they do just not HOW they do it.
Good luck with the hat stack. I have about 7 hats, but they are all IT related and working for someone else.
by comp1systems
Well, I would have to say that I agree with you. You think of
all the individuals who spend their time in school to learn
the trade while others going along on a free ride reading
books, learning from others, and at the same time,
pretending to know what they are doing. If you spend
enough time in the library and read as many books as you
can possibly read, taking a certification exam is as easy as
riding a bicycle. And the internet doens't make things any
better because you can find just about anything there and it
doens't help those of us who are really trying to make a
legitimate effort to do the trade to honestly earn a living,
while others are simply doing it to take people's money.
We are in for a rude awakening if better restrictions aren't
set, and if things are made tougher for hackers and other
computer frauds.
by david_heath
by oz_media
Having a neccessity for certs makes EVERYONE need a cert, in their mind, in order to find work.
I was just talking with a friend who VP's a Career Management Firm, one thing we discussed is people who THINK they need certs to get work, but then these same people get a cert and still end up making 24k a year. This isn't the certs fault (as many coem here to suggest), it is the person who is completely void of self marketing ability.
But the WORLD is making people believe they need certs, and ths ANYONE will do ANYTHING to get a cert, legitimate or not.
Truth of the matter is, MOST companies that advertise a need for a bachelors in BA will also gladly accept and consider a resume from someone with some drive and experience over a cert anyway. Often THESE people get the jobs and the grad doesn't, because they can't even sell themselves in an interview, just flash around paperwork in hopes of finding a job.
by advancedgeek
I just put that as the title so people would read it. I'm so clever :)
But think about this one...
Somewhere out there in some reactor or canyon in some nuclear facility, a computer is sitting there unmanaged, with no patches, with sensitive material on it, that could lead to the world being destroyed because some administrator cheated to get his job. Therefore, cheat on your tests, and destroy the world.
How's that for a guilt trip?
by mtucker
As a IS Manager that has the responsibility to hire and fire and as a previous MSCS , CCSA, CNA and Checkpoint Firewall Cert owner. And working very hard to get them I had a lot of respect for cert. I no longer do. I don't even put them as a job requirement, I want experiance. If I see someones resume with certs that has less than 3 years experiance it gets trashed.
In my interview process I give each candidate a exam. Those that cant get a 90% don't talk to me. They get stopped by HR. My exam is only 20 questions and I have never had anyone take less than 40 minutes on it, it's hard.
When people ask me if they should get certified I tell them take the classes at a community college forget the bootcamp and 4 month classes. Then find someone who will give you a low paying job, get a couple years experiance and then you might make the big bucks... If you work hard, study and learn something new everyday.
by madengineer
by oz_media
"But I look at job openings and they want you to have them. At least CCNA and MCSE/MCSA."
look where? NEwspapers? less that 4 % succcess rate. ONline, kess than 2% success rate. Coupled with other advertisements for positions, ADS acount for BARELY 20% of the total number of jobs available. 80% of jobs ae never advertised, THOSE are the positions you need to seek, they don't look for certs, they look for solutions.
by mtucker
You are doing it right. Get the two year college degree, Great way to start, I did it that way. That was a long time ago, before certs. I laos like the learn it, use it, master attitude. I always say "I am one of the few that get to work at their hobby and get paid well to do it."
What are you working for? The answer is simple, you said it in your post, '...for the love of the game.' I would tell you learn everything you can in school, keep it for fundamentals, you need fundamentals, lake baseball and golf, no one can take an education from you, use what you learn and learn more everyday.
Good luck to you in your career
My test, It is confidential company information that my employer owns, Sorry I can't give it away.
by tmalandro
by house
by madengineer
by oz_media
ANY company in the phone book that YOU would like to work for.
Visit their website and learn as much about their goals and operations as you can from the info provided. YOu can often get the executive directory there too.
Call the company, if you DON'T have the bosses name, just ask who is in charge. You'll get questioned by the gate keeper and it takes some practice to get around it but with a little work you will find it weasy to be put through.
I find what helps people th efirst few times out is to actually WRITE down a putch, not have on ein oyur head. Introduce yourself and summarixe your skills REALLY quickly, then ask if you can talk to the person incharge of company operations or the owner/preseident.
YOu will often be told, "HE/SHE is not here, do you want to leave a meesage? NEVER leave a message!!! just say,
"Well I would but I am on the phone all day or in and out myself, so it's best I just call back another time instead of playing phone tag. Can I ask his NAME so I know who to ask for when I do call back?" (Always smile when you're on th ephone, you can even place a mirror in front of yourself so you can make sure you're smiling, smiles can be heard on the phone and are very well received)
You've asked a direct question that even the best gatekeeper can't get around without blatantly being rude and just saying NO, but you were smiling so you WILL get the name. ONce you have the name, ask when th ebest time to call back is, often you will be told it is uncertain but other times you will actually book a call back time. At this point you will have NO problem beig put through directly when you call back. "Hi it's Ben calling again, you mentioned 8:30 would be a good time for me to speak with MR. Reeves"
If the receptionist/gatekeeper DOESN'T give you a name, just move to the next company.
Another thing that's important, always WRITE DOWN th erecpetionists name as the phone is answered and use it in your conversation.
If you are told BY the receptionist, "HE's not interested", you can again SMILE and say, "I understand that 'Shelly', that's probably why HE hasn't called me yet!" DON'T STOP SMILING!!!
But I just wanted a minute to quickly introduce myself.
So anyway, you're PAST the gatekwwper and Mr. Reeves, introduce yourself, QUICKLY list some of your skills and objectives and without hesitation, ask if you can meet with HIM to discuss opportunities with his firm.
This will go one of three ways here;
1) You will be told to go through HR, in which case get him to transfer you directly to HR. They will be FAR more responsive and accepting of you and will take more time to flag and read your resume if the call is passed on by the boss.
2) He will agree to meet with you, you will be surprised at how many times THIS happens, far more often than being passed to HR that's for damn sure!
3)He will say they have no room and he doesn't have time, at that point thank Mr. Reeves VCERY much for accepting your call and listening to you, then ask HIM for a referal. I have found mroe work from referrals off poeple who say they have nothing available but 'no wthat you ask, a freind of mine is looking for someone'.
This happens all the time, too.
YOu see, SOME people think NETWORKING is meeting with similar individuals in coffees shops or little monthly get togethers some even CHARGE you for the priovalege, for the most part you are just meeting peers not potential employers though.
If you get meetings with the employers they are usally lunch meetings, coffee stops etc. These pople have PROVEN to be more than happy to help, more than happy to pass you on to others and more than happy to offer some good advice. Ask them the best way to get into their field, they will talk your ear off at this point.
It's HARD at first, most people think such an approach will be laughed at, or shunned due to corporate structure. the truth of the matter is, this is how the best jobs are found every time.
I have done it more times than I can count, I have taught job clubs using these skills that are proven to be effective.
Timelines:
For basic, entry level work, you will be employed within 2-3 weeks of well planned personal marketing this way.
For a senior or entry level management position, you will need up to 6 weeks.
For that KEY executrive role you will need 2.5 - 5 months.
It WILL work, it DOES work and FAR more effectively than a newspaper or online ad.
Why take a more competetive route that inevitably pays less when you can market your skills for a better position with higher pay?
Good luck! Keep in touch if you get stuck, I've got all kind of ways to get around the gatekeepers and to the boss! ;)
by mtucker
I know you hear it all the time. Network, friends, family, teachers, neighbors. All good but hard. Let everyone you know and talk to know you are in the IT field and looking for a job. Get a web site and post your resume, Get some inexpensive easy to read business cards with your contact info and web address to give to everyone that will take it.
True story, I met a guy in a line at the theater. He was just laid-off from a major bank. We started talking, He gave me a card as described above, I gave him mine, He e-mailed me his resume, Not thinking I would ever hear from him the next morning I did. i was impressed. I sent his resume to a freind at the other bank, she sent it to her freind in the banks IT dept, he had a new job a week later. He took me to lunch to say thanks.
NETWORK
by madengineer
by oz_media
SOmepeople think networkin gis joining a networkin group that meets monthly though. THis will result in meeting peers every month, not employers though.
IN addition to those you know and see daily, get potential employers to meet you for llunch and use THEM to network from. IF you present yourself well, you will have no problem when asking THEM for references, they also meet THEIR peers and know who is looking for whom. THey get kudos for finding a friends company the right employess and will do it just for the recoignition they get, as well as to help you out of course.
I have actually been told MORE THAN ONCE, by potential employers, that I have old called and got out for a meeting, "We need to find you the right job!" WE.....they said WE!!!!
This is from people who can't help me themselves but have given me names, passed on my name and put a good word in for me. Resulting in jobs or contracts as needed.
Seems far fetched and yes, nobody YOU know does this. THAT'S why it is SO effective. People pay BIG bucks to take career management courses that teach you these skills.
A good resume, a good presenttion and some DRIVE in seeking work pay off EVERY TIME, without fail. Just kleep going and calling DOZENS of contact each day. You will soon be deciding WHICH of the top dollar positions you want to acept. I promise you!
by andeanderson
I've been messing with thse things called Computers since they were bread boarded and used key punch cards.
There has always been some kind of certification available.
But, in the business world it never mattered what Cerification you had, your boss didn't know where the power switch was and you had to repair the damage caused by your department managers and supervisors. Instead of promoting the capable, those who could talk a good story about their Certifications received the attention and promotions.
It was once said "Those who can, do. Those who can't teach."
In the world of business it is "Those who can, do. Those who can't are promoted." That has been a constant long before computers and will continue even after our archaic form of computers have been replaced.
Certifications are nice "Eye Candy" but fail to prove your abilities beyond being able to read and remember what you have read. If you want a promotion get those Certifications and talk about how good you are every chance you get. You will never have to prove that you know it, your bosses will already know how good you are because you were able to snowball them with your rhetoric.
by davidpmartin
If certifications didn't hold some value, all of these "CCNA and MCSE bootcamps" would disappear. But they don't disappear. So we have to ask the question "Why don't they disappear? And why don't the certs disappear?"
The reason is pretty simple. Cert's diferentiate. Period. While I would not hire a "paper cert" (someone who has a cert but no experience), someone with the certification AND experience goes right to the head of the pack. It tells me that they care enough about their IT career progression that they are willing to 'go the extra mile' to show me that they know what they are doing.
The other reason that certifications hold value is while there may be cert cheaters out there, there are also people who grossly inflate their resume. And these days, most companies will not give out a negative reference because they fear lawsuits (and that's another story). The cert as an add on to experience is an indication to a potential employer that the person is at least knowledgable enough to be trainable.
Dave
by david_heath
not sure I understand that comment... 'hasten their departure.'
My employees were completely happy... they were getting lots of training to do their jobs. they know (coz I told them) that they were welcome to sit exams, on my time if necessary, but they'd need to pay for the exams themselves.
The over-riding reason being that the company needed trained employees, the certs added nothing as far as the company was concerned.
by vic
by gary.nowels
... a good intention gone wrong. As soon as companie$ realized the money potential in courses, test centers and people markets, the personal value of certs was lost. If they are so vital to identifying competent IT staff, why is it that a total computer-illiterate HR or headhunter makes that assessment? Could it be that the smart IT managers distance themselves from such a useless gauging system.
Oh yes, a person's worth (or worthlessness) will eventually surface. But how many good IT folks just throw their hands up in the air and say goodbye to a doomed profession?
In my opinion, the best study guide right now would be Linux server administration. These infestations that are sucking the Windows market dry appear to be afraid of tackling the Linux arena. Let's all regroup and start a new line of offense.
by cweb
When I first started in this career field (IT) Certs were the hottest thing! That was the first thing all recruiters asked for and there was that pained expression if you didn't have an MCSE. My favorite story is about the first MSCE I ever met. He was convinced that the serial ports on the back of PC were SCSI connectors. And that it was our fault that we couldn't connect scsi scanners to them. "We must be using the wrong connectors" And he spelled in on the install sheets as scuzzy! When I told him there was no "Y" in SCSI. What did he do? Yep, "Scuzzi"
I recently changed jobs and was glad to see almost no requirements for certs, but all looking for experience.
by jmgarvin
Certs and HR get along really well. Both are brainless monsters that couldn't do a real job if they had to. ;-)
The problem with certs is that it is TOO EASY to get a cert. If I go to a "boot camp" so that I can pass, I can't fail! They basically give you the test and the answers. While some certs retain a shred of credibility, most don't.
MSCE is the prime example of the bogus cert (CompTIA also comes to mind). Anyone could get this cert. There some decent certs to get, but for the most part I'd say education and experience help out more now than certs.
Will certs go away? Probably not. Will they have to clean up their act? YUP! Will it happen any time soon? Nope. HR loves the things because they can put you in a neat little box and not have to worrry about actually thinking about a canidate.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending