233 replies
by onbliss
It would be different if they were not cooperating with the Police and investigations and posing hurdles or throwing red tapes to stall investigations.
But is it their role to monitor actively?
It will cost the subscriber. That's me.
What do you want them to monitor?
What do you want them to keep?
How long do you want them to keep the information?
Who should be allowed to get the information?
What about encrypted stuff. Should we outlaw it?
And so on.
by jdclyde
Can you show a law that makes your failing to monitor and detect all illegal activity on your network a crime?
What is the punishment to you for failing to properly monitor your network?
Does a "best effort" make you safe, or are YOU going to be held accountable for all activity? Who else is to blame, your boss? All the way to the stock holders? After all, "they own" the company that is leasing the lines. Where do you start and where do you end?
[i]"regardless of what it costs them".[/i] You sure are generous with other peoples money.
That leads us to the next question. How must this ISP monitor? All chats? All http? All p2p? All emails? What do they monitor, and how do they pull out the information you are looking for? How does an ISP know the difference between a 13 year old girl meeting a 30 year old man, and two adults hooking up?
It doesn't seem like you put a lot of thought into this. "Feeling" that someone should do something is not enough to solve a problem. "Thinking" that just because the ISP owns the lines, "they" are responsible and accountable for everything?
Would you throw everyone that works for the ISP in jail over this, or are you just looking to fine them big time? Put a company out of business with fines is a solution?
Side note:
Recently a news program (I think is was in Detroit, but could be wrong) went on-line, posing as a young girl. don't remember what the age was suppose to be, think is was 12 though. They told the preditors that their parents were gone and to come over at a certain time. When they got there and came inside, they were met by news cameras instead of a little girl. Cops would be waiting for them when they came out, even for the few that tried to make a break for it out the back.
Privacy advocates tried crying that this was entrapment and so the charges should be dropped. Others charged that the media should not get involved in law enforcement.
It was about fifty guys they nailed that day.
Of course we never hear about how these things end.
by onbliss
As a parent, I would like me to monitor my kids. Period. I will relax and enforce the monitoring as and when I deem it fit.
As a kid, I had lots of freedom but my mom made it her business to ensure her kids (me and my siblings) did not grow upto be street rowdies or get into bad habits. At that time, I thought she was interfering in my life. The only thing I could insist was that they do not open letters addressed to me. Well she did not have to worry about Internet in those days. Sometimes, I felt I did not have much privacy. Now I realize that I did not miss out anything, and that I have grown up alright. A whole bunch of credit should go to my parents for raising me.
Discpline. Monitoring. Or whatever we want to lable it, is best dispersed by the parents.
by noel_one
We aren't talking traffic, here, but content.
How is the isp meant to tell who is using the connection?
How are they meant to identify that something untoward is going on ?
It's not possible, all we can do is
educate our kids and bear in mind just like us they'll never believe it will happen to them
When we do apprehend an untoward person, make sure they never do it again.
Unless you have a benevolent AI network capable of monitoring all of us and all of our communications of course. In which case plug it in and lets be off.
We had exactly this discussion here a while back, when someone said ISPs should be responsible for stopping IP theft.
A less laudable goal, but pretty much the same technical challenge. If we could meet it, I'd be happy to pay an extra quid a month (for grooming not ip theft), but making someone responsible for the impossible is a waste of time.
by danlm
As an example of this, I met my current wife to be on IRC, which is chat rooms. In that I am the one that maintains the network where we met, I set up SSL on the servers for those that want to use it. Hell, I even wrote an article on it which I laid out several reasons to use SSL in your online chats. I also know that you can perform ssl in other types of chat forums. My main argument for using the SSL during chats was privacy. I agree there are very few privacy's left, and I agree with various monitoring by the government. But I also try to maintain what privacy I still have where it is possible. IE: SSL, encrypt emails if I feel the information is critical, .... And I am a father, and no I am not a predator. And yes, I would kill the mother that messed with my daughter. I'm a little guy, but I would spend time in jail to get the person that would hurt my little girl.
So, how is an ISP spouse to monitor what I have just previously described. I know others that follow the same secure chat/discussions that I do.
If they can monitor this type of conversation, then they can monitor my online banking. And that is something I am very careful about. If I find they can monitor my banking, then I will put my money under my bed in a shoe box and move to the mountains of Pennsylvania to rob picnic baskets like Yogi Bear.
Dan
by vtassone
by jdclyde
"regardless of what it costs them."
Of course this will force a rate increase because no matter how many times government slaps another fine/tax/regulation on a company, they will work to keep the same profit margin and pass all increases to the customer.
Will this force the smaller ISP's out of business?
by tonythetiger
by jamesrl
Is the telephone company responsible for monitoring all those who people who may use their service for evil purposes? How could they legally or logistically?
Why is an ISP any different?
The exception is anything that the ISP hosts on their own servers.
James
by onbliss
by jamesrl
I was a participant at a conference in 1993 on this and other similar topics with Canada's privacy commissioner and a retired supreme court justice.
So I had a few years to think about it.
James
by tig2
First- I agree that online predators should be stoppable. Any person who preys on children is reprehensible.
But a lot of these contacts occur in chat rooms outside of the ISP's perview. I can see the arguement that AOL should have a way to monitor. But what you suggest would be analogous to having my provider able to monitor my activities here. And I don't see how they could beyond knowledge that my IP visited TR's IP.
I tend to leave my machine logged in persistantly. So if I left now to run an errand, it would appear that I am sitting in front of the machine. Other than accessing time/date stamps from TR, how would you know the difference?
The way that watchdog organisations go about catching these guys is to insure that the transcript of the conversation is given to Police in a manner that insures chain of evidence. How would chain of evidence be gathered? Are you suggesting that my keystrokes should be visible to my ISP? What would the impact be on my other online activity? Should it all be monitored?
I am not comfortable with the reduction of privacy we currently have. I don't know that I would be comfortable with this as a solution.
I would like to see more of the approach used by Dateline and other watchdogs- get an admission, make sure it is witnessed, perserve chain of evidence, and grab the idiot when he shows up.
Edited for typo
by jdclyde
What would be the results when this data is gleened by a hacker?
Imagine, every keystroke typed into the net, in a single database?
Wow, imagine the size of that file.
Wow, imagine the network overhead to run that kind of intrusive scanning?
Does AOL or the chat rooms require some kind of age verification to setup an account?
I would think THAT would be the logical place to start. The question is, how do you verify who is sitting behind that computer when you do the verifications?
Pay memberships only?
And of course we come to the obvious part, how do you enforce local rules on a global network?
And like you pointed out Tig, what is in place to make sure that the chain of evidence can never be contested as incorrect or fraudulent?
Full co-operation with law enforcement seems to be key.
But do they need a court order? Remember we seem to need a court order to keep track of what phone numbers are calling what terrorists, and that didn't even include listening in at that point. What is being talked about here is much more intrusive.
Then the nuts will throw in "what if you discover a differnt crime with this invasion?" That was one of the big "issues" that came up when they started to check packages on the subways in NY. The simple solution is don't carry that brick of pot on the subway and you won't get in trouble for it.
Encrypt everything with de-centralized keys
Anonimize everything ... offshore.
Only way to keep the government out of your privacy.
by tonythetiger
[i]why aren't the ISPs' actively monitoring to see what is going on in their own network?[/i]
... the police don't stop and search [b]every[/b] car that enters their city. If they have a reasonable cause to search a car, they will stop that one car and search it. Likewise if the ISP has a reasonable cause to monitor and report on a certain user (say, a warrant, for example), they can and will.
by onbliss
by jamesrl
It was an analogy the judge threw out and we all thought it fit.
Communications law has the concept of a "Public Carrier", and initially it applied to phone networks. The public carrier is not responsible for what is carried on their network, and is constrained by law from monitoring, unless compelled to do so by a court order.
James
by jdclyde
If the child is able to use the home computer for this and does meet up with a preditor, do we charge the parents for child neglect?
Again from Michigan, there was that 16 year old HONOR STUDENT that dropped everything and tried to fly to Jordan to be with the 24 or 28 year old she "fell in love with" over "myspace".
She told her parents she was going shopping with friends in Canada, so that is why she needed a passport.
Being an honor student that had never gotten into trouble, she was given TRUST.
For someone smart enough to be an honor student, she is very stupid to not check out how they treat their women over there, and that she would have become a slave and prisoner once she stupidly got off that plane. Lucky for her, the FBI stopped her, and brought her home, and the courts took her passport. How can smart people be so stupid?
by tonythetiger
I think in this case not, since the girl lied to the parents and presumedly wasn't in the habit of lying to her parents.
In the case where a parent knows (or if a jury finds they should have known) that the child might not be trustworthy, then yes.
by dawgit
by maecuff
by jdclyde
sounds a lot nicer than head up her a$$ I suppose.
It is hopeful that she will get a clue as to what life in the middle east means for a woman before she is turned into a slave with no way out.
16? Wasn't that when... yes it was! It was at that age you said you bought your first real clue, maybe you could go set her straight? :p
By the way, good to see that your physically able to post! :x
by onbliss
by dawgit
by rfink
by jdclyde
They have all the conversations over the IM saved.
They know exactly how the guy is before he shows.
When he does show, they have enough to put him away.
No, they do not have to wait until after the child has been molested before they press the charges.
Intent.
'grooming' is definitely a crime in the UK.
Doesn't carry the death penalty unfortunately, but you can't have everything.
by mjwx
or some such. Even proposing sex with a minor is illegal in AU, UK and US (I think). Yes he'll get arrested, most probably fined but I doubt he'll see the inside of a jail.
Even the hardest of criminals have nothing but contempt for paedophiles. Which is why prisons generally isolate them from the general population.
by maecuff
I don't remember, but I may have. I'm not saying I was the most together kid in the world, but I did okay. I had to start taking care of my sisters at a very young age, and that makes you grow up fast.
Yep, still alive and kicking here. Alternating between very busy and VERY bored.
by dawgit
by onbliss
by jamesrl
Here it may be legal for a 16 year old to have sex with a 60 year old, but if they arrnaged to have sex through the internet, the arrangement is illegal.
James
by rfink
When the media no longer focuses on the bad stuff to sell papers or increase ratings then I'll start watching the news again, but not before then.
I'm the perfect person for a jury. I don't know 2/3 of what goes on. If it's bad enough I'll hear about it.
by rfink
If the "minor" is an undercover police person, what minor did he solicit? He solicited an image.
It's a sad day when people can be arrested for typing words on a keyboard. People should be allow to express themselves no matter how sick they are. If a crime has been committed by all means, arrest him. Don't arrest people for thinking of a crime, using that logic if I write a murder mystery throw away the key.
by jdclyde
where someone can think that is just fine and dandy.
Yes, I do blame the no-judgement people in the world for this.
Quite disappointing to see someone post in favor of being able to attempt anything, even solicit a 12 year old. Yeah, nothing wrong with that, huh?
by dawgit
It started getting a bit more emotional, and therefore too objective here. (quite understanderable, but also part of this particular problem) so, please which post 'above' were you refering to as sick? (or, sicker) -d
edited to add:
I hope you were not refering to mine, if so, let me know, as I then can tell I have been misunderstood. -d
by danlm
I consider this type of thought process being as guilty of causing children being molested and killed as the person that performed the act. With people like rfink helping to handcuff the police from protecting our children, there will be more of these sick attacks.
Known predators would be let free on this thought process. He said he was going to do this. But he didn't say it to a child, he said it to an adult pretending to be a child. His statements don't count, thrown out of court. Predator goes free. Then they go out and do it to a real child. You should be shot rfink, just like the person that performs these acts should be. You, cause you remove any and all tools in identifying them before the act happens. Them because they perform the acts.
Your murder mystery, what a line of crap. You really are warped.
Dan
by jdclyde
for planning to murder someone. Conspiracy.
If you attempt to murder someone, it is ATTEMPTED murder. They don't let you go just because you failed.
Same with the little girls.
by tig2
Undercover Vice Officers are NOT prostitutes, they are merely providing the scenario by which you may choose to hang yourself. In reverse, undercover officers that solicit prostitution (although somewhat different as a probable cause exists) may arrest any woman who accepts their solicitation.
By the same token, any person who solicits for the purpose of stated sexual acts will be charged accordingly. If the guy on the other end of a chat session asks questions such as age, and then terminates the conversation due to the minority of the person on the other end of the chat, he is guilty of being a randy guy looking for a cheap thrill. If, however, he continues the conversation and makes sexually explicit remarks after learning that the other person is underage, he is guilty of soliciting a minor for the purposes of sexual activity. If he persues this by going to the alleged home of the alleged minor, the crime committed is a crime committed by his action- namely a legal adult attempting to have sexual relations with a minor child.
Fiction is the act of writing that which is materially un-true and labeling it in that manner. Quite legal.
If, however, you want to test your theories about arsenic poisoning on your family member to insure a more vivid story, you would be guilty of murder or attempted murder.
And let's not even walk the path of thought crime. In the example of the alleged 12 year old and the internet creep, the fact that he did not stop the activity at the moment of learning the minor's age and then compounded this with a willful act, takes the situation out of the realm of thought crime.
Please feel free to check me for accuracy. You will find that I am correct. I may have missed a couple of points of law, but essentially I have it.
NeverBusted- want to check me on this?
by techexec2
Someone goes on TR. We'll call him 'Mike'. Mike meets someone, we'll call her 'Susan'. During their conversation online, Mike tells Susan that he thinks it is wrong for the police to arrest an adult who pursues a child for sex online when he merely shows up for an arranged sexual meet-up.
Susan GOES OFF! She goes freakin' berserk. Susan tells Mike about how she was violently raped as a child. Susan starts cursing him in every way imaginable. Susan starts stalking Mike on TR, cursing him after every post. One day, Susan tells Mike on TR that she has no choice. She is going to kill Mike. She knows it is wrong, will go to prison, and will go to hell for it. But, she must do it.
She continues to stalk Mike for two more weeks. Every day, after each of Mike's posts, she tells Mike she is going to kill him. One day, in one of her posts, she tells Mike that she has found out who he really is, posts his home address, and says she is coming to kill him at 5:30 pm on a specific day.
At 5:30 pm on that day, just as promised, Susan appears at Mike's home with a loaded gun.......
Do you think the police must wait for Susan to kill Mike before they arrest her?
-----
CRYSTAL CLEAR DISCLAIMER
Now, let me be completely clear here. I have [b]absolutely no intention whatsoever of harming you. None. Not now. Not ever. Not in any way.[/b] I am not angry with you. I am not even [i]upset[/i] with you. I wrote this only to make you think...think about what you posted here about this subject.
-----
In my fictional story here, Susan has committed several crimes. Susan stalking Mike online is a crime. Stalking became illegal when people recognized that it was a precursor to a crime to be committed. It makes no sense to wait for a serious crime to occur.
Susan making deadly threats is a crime (terrorism threats law). It makes no sense to wait for the murder.
Susan showing up to commit a murder she promised to commit is a crime.
This is not about making thought illegal. When a person communicates clearly that they intend to commit a crime, and then they show up to commit that crime, it is perfectly reasonable to charge them with a very serious crime.
This is not about making expression illegal. In America, you are free to express your views. But, you are not free to yell "fire" in a crowded theater because it is likely to cause a stampede where people will be hurt or killed.
It seems like it is in the news every day. Sickening adult males arrange sexual meet-ups with little girls and little boys online. The children are often killed so the "man" does not have to fear arrest (or they disappear...same thing). So, when one of these "men" shows up to commit the crime they say they only "fantasized" about, they should be arrested on the spot. No question about it.
Law enforcement is doing everyone a great service by setting up stings and catching these "men" before they harm a child.
I hope I have made you think about this. I wish you well.
P.S. I'm sure all of us here would love to hear that you've thought about this and changed your mind.
by rfink
Ok,
I can see that I touched a nerve here. For the record people having sex with minors should be locked up. No disagreement there. The problem I have is when the police break the law to enforce it. That makes them above the law. If the police break the law to capture someone who's in the process of committing a crime or has just commtted a crime fine. That's unavoidable.
My beef comes in there the police break the law first, prior to a crime being committed to lure someone into committing a crime. Let's go fishing and see what shows up.
Where I grew up, the police used to send minors to party stores to buy beer so they could write up the stores. One party store owner caught the minor working for the police with a fake ID. He called the police to arrest the minor which they did. Once the arresting officer found out that the minor was part of a sting he was released. The store owner went nuts. He filed a formal complaint against the minor. Of course the DA wouldn't file charges. The store owner wound up suing the police department in civil court. The city settled.
There's enough crime to go around without the police manufacturing it.
by techexec2
[i]"For the record people having sex with minors should be locked up. No disagreement there."[/i]
For the record, the point was that people caught in properly conducted sting operations where there is no child and no sex should also be locked up.
-----
[i]"The store owner wound up suing the police department in civil court. The city settled."[/i]
On what grounds was the suit filed?
If the city settled, it doesn't say that much about the case one way or the other. Cities settle lawsuits all the time to avoid the expense of litigation. Cost of lawyers vs. cost of getting the litigant to go away.
-----
[i]"There's enough crime to go around without the police manufacturing it."[/i]
If the police are conducting a sting, and the fake child approaches one of these guys online first and [i]invites[/i] him to meet, and encourages him with the conversation, [i]maybe[/i] that [i]might[/i] be "manufacturing" a crime (i.e. entrapment). If the police allow the bastard to approach and proposition the fake child online all on his own, that's entirely different. Wouldn't you agree?
by jamesrl
First of all, fishing isn't necessarily illegal. If it were we would have lots of charges thrown out for things like drugs and prostitution. They don't break the law when they represent themselves as prostitutes or drug dealers. They mislead but they don't break the law.
The police working in chat rooms are no different.
The key to convictions is "mens rea", roughly translated as to mean to do. It speaks to intent. You can convict someone who clearly shows intent. Attempted assualt, attempted murder, attempted robbery, all crimes here. If someone shows up at a house after arranging a tryst with someone who repsresents themsleves as a 12 year old, they are showing intent.
There is sometimes a fine line between entrapment and a sting. The difference is in who initiates the negative activity.
If you think that if the police weren't active in finding it through a sting, that it would lessen the activity, you are at best extremely naive.
James
by tonythetiger
by onbliss
would you sell alchohol to a minor, in what situations would you have sex with them?
Can't even think of the latter can you ?
There's a line you can't cross. The people they entrap in chat rooms can cross that line, that is more than damning enough for me.
by tonythetiger
by rfink
by maecuff
to write a novel that revolves around pedophilia and predatory behavior, they have the right. I'm sure there's a market for it. It's sick and twisted, but I agree they have a right to express themselves. With that being said, there is a whole big f*cking WORLD of difference between expressing oneself and stalking children online. People should NOT have the right to express themselves in that way, because it goes waaaay beyond expression and into intent.
And you know..even if the twisted f*cks have NO intention of following through with meeting up with a child for the purpose of molesting them (ruining their lives in the process), it doesn't make them any less guilty. The act of engaging a child in that type of behavior, even in a chat room, will have a negative impact on the child. It would actively HARM a child to be involved in that sort of relationship.
by jamesrl
They used actually 12 year old girls to show up at the door and then excuse themselves (I have to change over the laundry) before the camera crews came in. The perp was arrested as they left.
So its clear to me that this individual had every opportunity to a) not show up, b) not come in the house. If they get that far, they CLEARLY demonstrate intent to have sex with a minor.
Seems all perfectly fine to me.
James
by tonythetiger
by rfink
Presenting a fake ID to buy beer is a crime.
I could also argue that if the city settles then that will encourage all of the other store owners to sue as well. I sure the city's lawyers thought of that as well so there had to be something to it.
by techexec2
You're joking, right? Are you [i]really[/i] saying that people employed by the police to conduct stings cannot use fake IDs? Are you [i]really[/i] saying that if someone conducting a sting does not use their own real ID with their real name and real home address on it that the sting is invalid?
By extension, if the child in the online predator sting is fake (that is, she is not really a minor), no crime has been committed? The police have to use a real child in the online predator sting for it to be valid?
by techexec2
by techexec2
You are not addressing any of the important questions. Care to respond?
[i]~Do you think the police must wait for Susan to kill Mike before they arrest her?~[/i]
[i]~On what grounds was the suit filed?~[/i]
[i]~If the police allow the bastard to approach and proposition the fake child online all on his own, that's entirely different. Wouldn't you agree?~[/i]
by danlm
I definitely want to apologize for what I said. I can see now that I was wrong, simple as that.
But, I do disagree with your opinion. I don't feel the police are trying to grease the rails. Because I do online chats, along with forums. Shoot, I'm part of the administration of a chat network. Even if it's small, it's part of what we worry about all the time.
Let me ask you this, ok? Let me describe how I would see the sting going down, and you tell me if you still feel the police are greasing the rails.
A chatter is in channel not talking, with the nick/alias of Michele12. This person is sitting in channel, and an individual with the nick of WolfMan private messages her. This would occur so that other people would not see the conversation. When Michele12 proceeds to tell WolfMan that she is only 12, WolfMan persists until he persuades Michele12 to meet him.
From beginning to end, WolfMan has initiated, pressed, and persisted in his attempts of persuading a person he perceives as being 12 years old into either meeting him or performing some other perverted act. Michele12 is actually a police officer monitoring the channel for case's like this. Is this greasing the rails by the police? I think not, for several reasons. The police officer did not initiate the conversation, the police officer informs this individual they are not of age(non truth on the part of the police officer), the individual(WolfMan) persists.
I think this example fully shows how WolfMan has shown full intent to perform perverted actions with a minor. By the police officer offing after consistent persuasion to meet this person, in other words. Gave WolfMan every opportunity in the world to back down and go away. Then WolfMan has shown that there is no misunderstanding, he knows full well and fully intends to carry out the actions.
Do you still feel that is greasing the rails? To me, if it occurred just like I described. I would say the police officer threw sand on the rails to stop it.
Dan
by rfink
Droolin, no problem. I guess my initial message sounded like I favored the perps. Far from it.
I know everyone here wants to protect children in general and I can accept that.
All we disagree on is how to protect the children.
I can't help but think of a situation where the perp sets up a meeting with the "minor" and an innocent person shows up by mistake and the police arrest him, the media makes his life hell, and his reputation is ruined all for nothing.
Twenty years ago a co-worker of mine missed a week a work because he rented a car from Hertz that a different branch of Hertz reported stolen and his vacation became a nightmare. He wound up suing Hertz but the point remains the police believed Hertz, threw him in jail, made his life miserable, treated him like a criminal and he was completely innocent. That ruined my trust for the police. They seem to have the "arrest them all and let God sort it out" attitude.
by maevinn
by tonythetiger
going online and saying "Hey, I'm a minor. Any old geezers wanna have sex with me?" That would be clearly be entrapment.
What they're doing is responding to a person who is already showing criminal intent in the hope he'll choose them instead of a 'real' victim.
Showing intent to commit a crime has always been a crime. This is just a new-fangled way to catch the perpetrators.
by jdclyde
where he seems to think that it is just fine to attempt to solicit sex from 12 year old girls as long as you don't follow through.
When you show up to have your little session with what you thought was a little girl, but turns out to be a cop instead, that you should be able to just walk away as you have "done nothing wrong" and we should not be prosecuting "thought crimes".
Quite disgusting.
by jamesrl
The same principle applies to soliticitation for purposes of prostituition. The officer dressed as a prostitue does not offer. She waits for someone to make an offer to her.
In Canada, prostitution itself is not legal, but solicitation is. It is assumed that with every act there is solicitation. It is also illegal to live off the avails (Pimp) or provide a place for the act (bawdy house).
The principle is the same for those posing as 12 year olds. They don't solicit come ons, they wait for them.
James
James
by rfink
Mavyn,
The one occurence that I know about. How many occurences happen that I don't know about? My friend was a mess when he returned. I'll never forget that, he needed consoling.
Innocent until proven guilty is a joke. In the court of public opinion you're guilty until proven otherwise.
Maybe I feel this way because if it happened to him it could happen to me. They might have a 99% percent conviction rate catching online perps. It's that 1% I worry about.
Law enforcement goes about its business and they're rarely held accountable for its mistakes. I agree with people who sue the police whenever an innocent person is arrested. Maybe if the media and the public waited until he was convicted before they treat him like dirt then I'll feel differently.
by maevinn
by jdclyde
Dude, if you are a suspect, you go to jail, do not pass go, do not collect $200.
If they let you go until they have proof, do you think criminals will just nicely sit around waiting?
You really need to grow the F up. do yourself a favor and take a crimial law class at your local community college, because you are clearly clueless.
You ARE innocent until proven guilty, but they can and DO hang on to you until you either post bond or go to trial. Did you completely sleep through life to not know that? Are you new to this county to not know the simplest of things about our legal system?
You had better do something about your ignorance before you get your self into a lot of trouble. Free tip, "ignorance of the law is no protection". If you break a law, knowingly or otherwise, you still broke a law and you will pay the price.
by tonythetiger
by tig2
That you sound like an apologist for those who choose to prey on legal minors.
As you come across, it sounds like there must be a sexually accosted child before you would conceed that it is okay for the police to act. You refuse to even consider that the police have legal precedent on their side- as long as they do not entrap but rather allow a perp to approach and give sufficient warning (not required under the law) that further actions are illegal.
I don't get it. I have "heard" you say that you don't agree with the sexual abuse of minors- and yet you would require as much in order to take these yodas out of play?
I agree. What happened to your friend was awful. But I would contend that the situation you cite was 20 years ago and the requirements the police are held to are considerably higher.
Wasn't thinking too straight after I read it.
I'm extremely not objective on this issue.
by cls8
Most of the biggest ISPs aren't doing jack about spam coming out of or transiting their networks. Why would they be any more responsible about "online predators?"
With Verizon, Comcast, Sprint, AT&T, Yahoo, etc, it's "what the public don't know won't hurt us." It's nothing but a public relations problem until the CEO thinks he might go to prison.
by maevinn
Some junk that you delete without too much hassle is the equivalent of a child being raped? Really?
Sorry, but I'd happily deal with 10 times the spam if it meant one child was saved from molestation and assault. And I don't even have children.
by cls8
Spammers don't just create "some junk that you delete without too much hassle." These are ruthless international crime rings. They steal people's identities by the tens of thousands, drain their bank accounts and retirement savings, so they die penniless in the gutter instead of retiring comfortably. They also commission and release the most destructive email worms, trojans, and viruses, doubling the cost of consumer internet service, and costing the global economy tens or hundreds of billions of dollars each year.
The fraud spam ring organized at the highest levels of the so-called "government" of Nigeria lures Americans to Nigeria in search of their lost money, where a few are murdered each year. The US government is well aware of it but doesn't really do anything, to avoid disturbing the flow of oil. By credible estimates, "4-1-9 fraud" is Nigeria's third largest source of foreign exchange.
Spammers are also destroying the public email system. If they succeed, it will be replaced by a system owned and controlled by Microsoft, with postage fees, censorship, built-in wiretaps, and plenty of "legitimate" spam.
The big Internet carriers *could* enforce the "harmful traffic" provisions in their existing peering and transit contracts. They could enforce their Acceptable Use Policies against their customers who support spammers. They could block outbound connections to port 25 from workstations on consumer broadband. They could whack the Nigerian fraud mailboxes as fast as they're created. (Outblaze does that. Why can't Yahoo and Hotmail?) They *could* shut down the spam "industry" in a month or two, and most of the malware business would die with it. Instead, most of them do nothing. That's gross criminal negligence, and people are murdered or die in poverty from it.
If you think spam is "without too much hassle" then you have never been an email administrator, or you are an incompetent one.
If you think spammers do not hurt people then you've never had a family member's identity stolen or murdered by the 4-1-9 gang.
by cls8
Most of the biggest ISPs aren't doing jack about spam coming out of or transiting their networks. Why would they be any more responsible about "online predators?"
With the big consumer-facing ISPs, it's "what the public don't know won't hurt us." It's nothing but a public relations problem until the CEO thinks he might go to prison.
by tonythetiger
should trust the police. Anyone who does that moves from naive to stoopid in my opinion.
I would n't trust a copper as far as I could throw them, and I'm not a big chap.
by techexec2
Ok. Now I am beginning to understand where you're coming from.
You are in a very bad place. You know that online sexual predators must be prevented from harming children. But, because of what happened to your friend 20 years ago, you are so driven by fear of the police that you advocate reducing their power and ability to catch the bad guys.
By holding onto this fear, and spreading it to others, you are helping more children to be molested, raped, and murdered. In a way, their blood is on your hands too.
Now, I'm not going to bash you (anymore). You should not accept living in a broken way that leads you astray like this. [i]You deserve a better life than that.[/i]
Can you do anything about this? Yes, you can.
Overcoming the fear you have held onto for 20 years is not going to be easy. But, if you could do it, it would be a life-changing event. It can be done. I know a few people who have done it. The power to do it is entirely within you. The day that you decide to seize your power is the day that you will be free. [i]Your life is worth fighting for.[/i]
In order for you to have a life-changing event, you must do something to change your life. Here are some practical ideas:
- First of all, you cannot be fearful. You have to get angry. Then, you use your anger to overcome your demons in a [i]positive[/i] way.
- Join the police force. I'm not kidding. There are SO many reasons why this would work for you. You would become an expert on the law and police procedure. The police favor the other police you know. What better way to conquer your fear of the police than to become one of them. Choose a police department that best suits you. If chasing criminals is too much for you, join the highway patrol. Join the FBI. Join the CIA. Help the NSA computers capture and analyze all of the phone records. Become a police helecopter pilot. Doing any of these things will give you credibility and friendship with the police. No more fear of mistaken identity or mistaken arrest for you. Ever.
- Join the fire department. The police favor them as well. I know someone who is a fireman who has a friend with a Porsche. The two of them were out driving one day and got pulled over while doing 110 MPH on a deserted highway. The fireman (passenger) casually showed the officer his fire dept ID. They were let go with a verbal warning and a smile. You or I would go straight to jail for doing that. True story.
- Start or join a civilian law enforcement group like neighborhood watch or [i]one that tours the country and educates children about online safety.[/i] Work with the police in cities all around the country. Befriend the police. They are no more nor less human than you or I. With this simple step, you will have a lot more credibility with the police should anything happen like you fear might happen to you.
-----
You have the power to overcome this. The choice is yours.
I wish you well.
edit: spelling, clarity
by rfink
TechExec2,
That's an interesting thought. I never considered fear before, I assumed the police were apart of the corrupt society that we lived in and left it at that.
BTW, I still won't rent a car from Hertz.
While I won't join a police force some where (too dangerous and a nasty pay cut) I'll make an effort to be more understanding of their actions.
This has been an enlighting discussion, while some of you resorted to name calling and bashing (you know who you are and you need to work on your conflict management skills), others disagreed in a civil manner.
Thanks
by jdclyde
First of all, there has been nothing presented to support this claim of illegal activity on the part of the police of providing a minor with a fake id.
Like Tony said, that is not how it is done, ANYWHERE.
The cops send in minors to stores for beer and/or cigarettes. Many LOOK like they COULD be old enough for the smokes (18). If they do get sold to, the store gets a fine AND the clerk gets a fine. (In Michigan).
Cops do NOT send the minors in with fake ID's, because it is not the job of the clerk to verify if an ID is valid or not unless it is obvious (excuse me Ms, but have you shaved your beard since you had this picture taken?)
And that the owner would convenently "see" the cops providing the minor prior puts this directly in the urban legend section as something that never happened.
Some people will believe anything if it supports their existing beliefs, regardless of how unreasonable the beliefs are.
If we define ISP as the guy who gets you internet access for $9.95 a month, it is not their job.
Chat Room Operators, OTOH, have the responsibility to see that their system and service are being used legally, according to the laws of the ocuntry they are located in.
If oneoperates a restricted access, membership only chat room, then you know why you are there. Caveat emptor.
Since we want to meander down that slippery slope, where does it end?
I notice that one can't speak half the things one used to in common conversation some 35 years ago.
Where does it all end? One Politically Correct bowl of pablum that passes for public andprivate discourse?
by maevinn
I worked for about 3 years as a clerk in a gas station that sold alcohol. I was on duty for several of these sting operations, and can attest that I NEVER had the 'undercover' minor present me with a fake ID. They would come in, attempt to purchase, show a legal ID revealing their underage status, try and talk me into it for about 2 minutes, then march out. The cops would come in, explain what had happened, and discuss any points they felt should have been handled differenly (ie, ask for the id before handing someone smokes, to reduce the odds of them bolting with the pack). Never felt like the cops did anything wrong, the kids were always very pleasant.
Much worse were the idiotic parents who wanted to send their 10 year old down to buy smokes for them--had one lady that would go so far as to call and tell me she was sending her boy down, please sell him the smokes.
by techexec2
Won't work...
The NSA will catch your packets on the way out of the country...
:^0
by jdclyde
[b]I[/b] could NOT marry a 12 year old because [b]I[/b] have something called "standards" in my life, and 12 year old girls do not fit in any kind of sence of decentcy.
Is it just a cultural thing? Maybe, but does that mean that MY culture is the one that is wrong?
Is it a religious thing? I don't recall anything about age limits in the bible.
Oh well, I don't eat cats and dogs, nor do I perform ritualistic sacrifices.
by dawgit
they aren't free from the consequences of saying it.
So perhaps I worded that a bit wrong.
Judge Tony was amusing, it's one of my contentions that judges should not come from the legal profession, they judge the law not the issue.
There's far too much of that in fact, I bet there's law that say's a judge must have come from the legal profession.
Justice got beaten to death by heretofores and whereases along time ago. We'll never get it back while the current bunch are in charge.
by maevinn
by cls8
Yahoo is to blame for each Nigeria fraud spam which uses a Yahoo Mail account to collect responses from the suckers. Hotmail (Microsoft) is to blame for the ones that use Hotmail accounts. Outblaze (aka Mail.com) is bigger than both of them, and doesn't have the problem. That's because Outblaze whacks the accounts so fast that the Nigerian criminals can't use them. Yahoo could do that, too. They have made a business decision not to. Just like Ford deciding it was cheaper to pay off the families of people burned to death in Pintos than to make the gas tank safer.
The "typical user" doesn't know that most of the money he is spending on his Internet service goes to blocking and filtering incoming spam. Nor does he know that his "typical" service provider (big ones like Comcast and Verizon) are knowingly hosting the spam sources. The "typical user" doesn't want to know things like that, any more than the typical Walmart shopper wants to know how much of that stuff is made in slave labor camps.
And that was the point of my original article, which you seem to have overlooked. Corporations have no conscience, no ethics. Tolerating spammers is the most obvious example of large scale criminal negligence by Internet companies that I could point to.
Corporations won't clean up their toxic waste, or stop chopping down ancient forests, or throw off their spammers, or sting their child predators because it's the right thing to do. They have to be forced.
There are two ways to do that. 1. make the officers of the company personally criminally liable. 2. protect the whistleblowers and the press from the SLAPP suits the corporations use to shut them up. If _60 Minutes_ wasn't worried about SLAPP suits, they'd do stories and name names. And there'd be more whistleblowers than they have time to interview.
by maevinn
Sorry--I didn't see an article on the topic.
I won't argue--clearly there's a lot more than I know going on. I agree with corporations attitiude towards social responsibility--they do it when it's good for business, and that's about it. Consumers have power, but often don't know it, and even with knowledge, seldom use it.
by d
.. in the example there was no child. Just a lying cop posing as a minor. what they arrest the perv for is the thoughts in his addled brain.
If addled brain were a crime this would have been a short threa...
What crime? No crime.
by techexec2
[i]"No crime soliciting a grown cop.. in the example there was no child. Just a lying cop posing as a minor. what they arrest the perv for is the thoughts in his addled brain. If addled brain were a crime this would have been a short threa...What crime? No crime."[/i]
If a man approaches a "12 year old girl" online, has a sexual conversation, suggests they meet and have sex, gets "her" address, and shows up at "her" house to do so, then yes, that is clear evidence of an attempted sex crime. He should be arrested and put in prison. The police are doing a great thing to protect the public.
You're right. Having an addled brain is not a crime. I'm sure you're personally thankful for this every single day.
P.S. You obviously do not have, or should not have, a 12 year old daughter.
Trending Community archive posts
Sort by Trending