Are ISPs' doing enough to combat the fight against online predators?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by cls8
Phone companies (we're talking about the public switched telephone network here, not the packet switched IP network) are regulated public utilities. In exchange for submitting to government regulation, they are excused from responsiblility for the content of the traffic they carry. The regulations require call logging, and they have to surrender the logs to law enforcement without a court order. And they have to be customer neutral, can't refuse service to customers they don't like. (This is in the US. Other industrial nations have similar setups.)
Internet carriers aren't regulated by public utilities commissions. If they keep logs at all, it takes a subpoena to get them. They're under no obligation to sell service to Alan Ralsky or Leo Kuvayev and they *can* kick them off for content violations, or for getting their IPAs listed in Spamhaus or SPEWS. (You can look those criminals up on Wikipedia or Spamhaus.org.) They are only excluded from responsibility for content in very limited ways related to freedom of the press. Compuserve (now part of AOL) got out of the BBS business when the courts ruled that it *was* responsible for monitoring BBS chatter.
That's why companies that operate both PSTN and IP service have to put those operations in separate business units. And they really are separate, with different cultures and standards. The PSTN side of SBC/AT&T for example is one of the best anywhere, while its IP side is one of the worst.
It's one of the things that makes me uneasy about codifying the heretofore unspoken tradition of "net neutrality." Irresponsible IP carriers will still find ways to degrade transit service to competitors and critics. SBC's *phone book* doesn't list its IP service competitor ISPwest.com, how about that, must have been a "mistake." But they'll use "net neutrality" as an excuse to host big money spammers like Kuvayev.
by rfink
Deja vu?
Edited for "sounds" instead of "sound"
by jdclyde
This is well beyond "thought" when you decide to ACT on it. As soon as you go to the meeting place, you are ACTING on it and you now have intent.
I hope your neighbors know not to allow you around their children unsupervised. Family should also be aware that "Uncle D" might not be the best choice to let change the baby or keep an eye on the kids while everyone runs to the store.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
by ontheropes
Of course I'm no attorney but I think you're doing fine.
There's a fine line between legal and illegal sometimes. In my opinion you gave an excellent example above.
Here's another one. For example, I say, "I'm going to beat you to a pulp". If I make no attempt to follow thru with that statement, the way the prosecutors have explained it to me, an assault did not occur.
If I say the same thing and make even one slight step or motion towards you an Assault (not an Assault and Battery) [b]may[/b] have occurred if you had "reason to believe" that I [b]was[/b] going to "beat you to a pulp". Just so you know, if I touched someone even slightly after saying that an Assault and Battery may have occurred.
The law seems to depend upon the "reasonable person" test. Would a "reasonable person" believe that C would have taken place if A and B did? That's what the judge or jury have to "reason out", after the cops bust someone.
Is following up a conversation or statement with action simply a thought crime? No.
Thank God we can't be arrested for what we're thinking or we'd [b]all[/b] have gone to jail or prison at one time or another. It's what we [b]do[/b] that get's us into trouble.
by rfink
by kiltie
[i]"you are required to get the consent of either your parents or the court in order to marry. The 12, or 14, or 16 (depending on the state) is the age under which a marriage will [u]not[/u] be permitted, [u]even[/u] with parental consent. And I'm pretty sure that's the law in all 50 states"[/i]
That post is contradictory,
one part says consent is required,
the next says it is not permitted, even with consent
Which of the two did you mean?
I guess the word "not" in the penultimate sentence, is the mistake, omit that and it makes sense (sorta). Maybe even the word "even" should be considered for editing?
Also bear in mind that laws differ all over the world, even among the United (is that a misnomer?) States.
To try and lighten things up here (a weak attempt)
50 States? I thought there were 51? Or was that an Advert? (tongue in cheek)
I was flying Delta once, into Atlanta, from the UK, one fellow passenger, 20, from his passport was helping himself liberally to the free booze (yes they used to do that once) when the stewardess refused to serve him.
He objected initially, then she gently pointed out that while in the air, and in his own country the legal age for drinking was 18, once they landed in Georgia, if he was drunk and under 21, he was liable to be arrested by airport officials.
This sobered him up immediately,
You see, he hadn't considered a change of law when travelling, nor, at that time, had I.
"sobering thought"
....guffaw....
(love my own puns, wish others liked them as much)
Edited: Typos
by kiltie
But I would correct your last line....
[i]It's what we do (insert word: wrong) that get's us into trouble.[/i]
Essentially, it is tha ACTION that is the crossing of the line here, not the meeting, but I see both points of view expressed.
One the one hand, the LAW MUST be meticulous in its actions, one the other it MUST NOT allow that nefarious deed to take place.
It a tricky one:
For the record: I have been on both sides of this, so I am somewhat in a dichotomy, I have (had) a 12 year old daughter (18 now) in the similar situation postualated, in chat room, stalkers about (Huge story here) and on another side I have had the Police prosecute me for something I never did.
I was acquitted, the arresting officer was subsequently prosecuted himself for fabricating evidence, yes.... I had met one of those "BAD" cops, that the Force loves to hate, they hate bad cops worse than criminals.
(Another huge story here)
The point of my post here, that there are relative merits to both camps, it depends on where you come from. I would prefer NOT to see name calling amongst us so called "professionals"
If we are truly professional Techies, we would counduct ourselves in a respectable manner, regardless of any differece of opinions.
(even if this is misc topic, everything goes, but with "decorum" folks please lol)
EDIT: Correcting tags
by dawgit
by jdclyde
The IM messages everyone is in an uproar about are three friggen years. That means who ever it was that had them and sat on them until days before the election so no one else could get put on the ballot has been concealing a potential crime for years, for political gain.
Who ever it was that withheld that information should be charged.
[b]
Sad day when politics is more important than protecting children.
[/b]
What exactly IS the law about the messages to a 16 year old boy? Is "talking dirty" a crime or just disgusting? Not up on that certain law.
by tonythetiger
it could be sexual harrassment.
And the person who held the information could indeed be charged.... as well as those who ordered him to hold onto the information... in fact, that may turn out to be the more serious issue!
by dawgit
by dawgit
by tonythetiger
by danlm
Some discussions are just too disgusting to even consider following. d, you just made this one of them.
Your sick. My daughter ever gets hurt because of people like you stopping the police from trying to protect children.
1. I take a baseball bat to the perv.
2. I take a baseball bat to idiots like you that allow it to happen by hampering the police from catching the perv's before it ever happens.
And d, remeber this conversation the next time you see a distraught family. Or a child molested. You feel the policie shouldnt be proactive in protecting them. May you carry it to your grave
So much for me following this topic.
Dan
by techexec2
by jdclyde
They are all over, and I am sure the ACLU is just lousy with them.
As for you Dan, as soon as you say something I disagree with, I will let you know.
Idiots like this are directly to blame for a lot of what is wrong with the world, and I wish we could hold them accountable for the harm they cause.
by techexec2
Easy, JD...
Don't mistake optimism and confidence for complacency.
I am just optimistic and confident that the sickos will be in the minority and will not be able to stop the police from conducting their stings and putting them into prison.
The good guys will win if we remain vigilent.
[i]"Never hate your enemies. It clouds your judgement"[/i]
Michael Corleone
by jdclyde
they must never be condoned in anyway, shape, or form.
I have a couple "thought crimes" that could come and pay a visit to these people.
When someone breaks into their home and they learn that police don't prevent crimes, they punish the guilty after the fact in many cases. These same cop haters will be screaming at the top of their lungs that the cops didn't protect them.
by techexec2
Speaking of sickos, can you BELIEVE this sh*t?
Mark Adam Foley (born September 8, 1954), former republican congressman in Florida just resigned due to the disclosure of salacious IM messages with a teenage congressional page. He allegedly used the screen name MAF54.
It is important to underscore that [i]"CNN cannot verify whether the instant message comments reported by ABC actually came from the congressman."[/i]
This could certainly be a frame-up. It hasn't been proven that MAF54 is Foley. The timing of this disclosure is highly suspicious. But, his immediate resignation is essentially an admission of guilt. And, there IS some hard evidence (e-mails) and statements by the page. I withhold final judgment pending more facts.
Same old story. Priests must learn to keep their hands off the altar boys. Congressmen must learn to keep their hands off the pages.
REFERENCES
Report: Foley allegedly tried to meet page
http://www.cnn.com/2006/POLITICS/10/02/foley.quits/index.html
Congressman quits after messages to teens found
http://www.cnn.com/2006/POLITICS/09/29/congressman.e.mails/index.html/
Foley's exchange with underage page
http://abcnews.go.com/WNT/BrianRoss/story?id=2509586&page=1
edit: additional info, removed salacious IM transcript...read the web page for that
by nicknielsen
Been following this one myself. Gives a completely disgusting meaning to "Turn the Page," doesn't it?
It'll be weeks before I can listen to Seger again and it's this pervert's fault. :_|
by pscottc
If a child is caught stealing, the parent is publicly flogged for failing to teach the child properly.
In this instance, the child should be flogged too, because by 14 or 15 you have a pretty good idea as to what's right and wrong (even if you do occassionaly blow it out your a$$)
PSC
by pscottc
Do you really know what the users in your network do on a daily basis? Do you run malicious word scans on their emails? Do you check every site that they visit and file they download? If you allow access to IM services, do you know the contents of every conversation that occurs?
If you have more than 5 people on your network, I'm guessing no.
If you've written a program to do these things, sell it to the ISP's or Microsoft and make millions.
I would just like to know how they can monitor this traffic, especially if it's going to an externally hosted service?
PSC
in the case of on-line gambling.
Non-US online gambling companies will hit by by it becoming illegal for banks and credit card firms to process online gaming payments from the US. At the same time, US internet horse racing, US internet lotteries, US fantasy sports, intra-state betting and intra-tribal betting are left alone.
Just a teeny bit hypocritical not to admit that it's another dose of US protectionism.
:p
by jdclyde
and taxation.
First, everyone knows the only HONEST gambling places are in the US! :p [i](thats a joke son, in case you didn't catch that)[/i]
Second, if the US does not make a huge profit off of gambling, it ruins lives, don'tchaknow?
There really is strong oversight of gambling, even if much of it is controlled by organized crime. The local reservation casino in MidMichigan has been fined numerous times for adjusting their machines to lower the payouts to under whatever the percent is suppose to be. It cost less to pay the fines than it does to pay the payouts. No, I do not go there.
Glad you didn't admit that it was protectionism though. ;\
by kiltie
I was merely pointing out a contradiction in what you had posted, not what you were trying to say.
I agree ages vary, and may vary among US States, but I understand that the laws differ among the States, so that your example "Ohio" does not always apply.
My anecdote of the incident in the air, was supposed to emphasise this point.
I am sorry that this did not come across clearly.
by jdclyde
Oh, did he COVER Metalicas song "Turn the page"? :0 :D
Have you checked out his new CD? I haven't had the chance yet.
by tonythetiger
and still don't see it, so I'll assume it's a problem with local word usage.
I'll try to be clearer,
A person generally cannot marry in the US under the age of 18 without the consent of a legal guardian (whether that be parent or judge).
States define at what age a child can marry with the consent given above, and this age differs from state to state. If a child is under that state-defined age, they cannot get married in that state.
by ontheropes
My history shows that I have at least my fair share of trouble from doing what I thought to be the right thing. Circumstances beyond my control (everything outside of me) turned "right" into something that haunts me everyday.
I don't care to explain further. I don't think I [b]can[/b] without appearing to be stupid, bitter, morose and defeated. In my opinion, those [b]aren't[/b] my strong suits so I'll try to just leave it at that.
[b]I[/b] know what happened and that's all that really matters. I wouldn't change a thing about my actions when you get right down to it so I guess that makes todays BS alright.
It looks like [b]you've[/b] got quite a story there.
[i]"You can never go back, you can only go on".[/i] -NeverBusted
by tonythetiger
[i]"You can never go back, you can only go on".[/i]
That's good stuff, Ron.
by jdclyde
I was just poking fun, by insinuating it was Seger covering Metalica instead of it being the other way around. A devout Seger fan would have gone nuts if they had see it! :D
I love to do the same thing with Queen's "Stone Cold Crazy".
Just stirring the pot......
As for "no room". When you reach "max level", just go back to the one post a step back and respond to that. It will throw your post at the end of the line on the max level.
by dawgit
by nicknielsen
by jamesrl
I can't say I have heard many that improve on the original.
I keep telling my kids when they hear some 70s song remade by their fav artist that the original was better.
Worst - Gordon Lightfoot's If you could read my mind love, on the studio 54 soundtrack. Johnny Cash did a cover of the same song, during one of his last recordings and it was very moving. But the studio 54 strips the song of all meaning.
James
by jamesrl
I can't say I have heard many that improve on the original.
I keep telling my kids when they hear some 70s song remade by their fav artist that the original was better.
Worst - Gordon Lightfoot's If you could read my mind love, on the studio 54 soundtrack. Johnny Cash did a cover of the same song, during one of his last recordings and it was very moving. But the studio 54 strips the song of all meaning.
James
by ontheropes
by nicknielsen
Ahh, cover this! :^0
Who's Metallica? ;\
Edit: Not yet, but I've heard some excerpts. Doesn't sound too bad, so far.
by nrei25
I was more referring to other PC-sims, which have replaced such succinct references as bastard, round-heels, chairman, illegal alien, and so forth.
English was much more colorful, and less cryptic back then.
(I am heartened that my UNCF-educated Marine Corps buddy still refers to the mayor of Columbus as "nothin' but a yard-n***** in a suit".)
*Cleaned up for the PC amongst us.*
by jdclyde
I personally like Disturbed's cover on "shout", by Tears for fears.
A little more upbeat, a little more agressive, and tears for fears SINGING "shout, shout, let it all out" doesn't FIT was well as the whatever it is Disturbed does! :D
by deepsand
It is no more an ISP's job to monitor their traffic than it is for a Telco.
And, no, minors do [b]not[/b] have a "right" to use the Internet, any more than they have a right to use the telephone or drive a car.
As a parent, it's [b]your job[/b] to monitor your childrens' activities, and see that they come to no harm.
You have no right to expect that other will do your job for you.
by pscottc
Don't forget the "right" to watch TV.
Honestly we wouldn't be discussing this issue if parents would actually take the time needed to gain their children's trust. That's right folks, trust goes both directions, and so does communication. Give up your damn predjudices for 5 minutes and openly talk about good, bad, life in general, emotions, sex, personal responsibility, and responsibility to society.
I'll bet if every family shut down all their electronics for 30 minutes a day, and just talked, things would be a hell of a lot better.
PSC
by deepsand
I can attest that you are absolutely correct.
The TV, along with the widespread, easy and inexpensive availability of other forms of entertainment have made it all too easy for parents to unwittingly give control of their charges over to unseen and unknown distant entities, who are all too happy to keep their children occupied and out of their lives.
In short, the people at home are no longer the ones minding the kids, and they resent anyone trying to change what is, for them, a happy state of affairs.
by tonythetiger
by deepsand
ISP's do not own the traffic, any more than a state owns the traffic on its roads.
Your children, and the costs of protecting them, are your responsibility.
by deepsand
Is the Telco responsible for the content of the conversations that occur over their nets?
Are the states responsible for the contents of the vehicles on their roads?
No, and no.
The same holds for [b]any[/b] service provider.
by deepsand
If I contract with you to perform the service of providing me with storage space, the ability to access the contents stored in said space, etal., I am the prinicipal and you are my agent.
As my agent, you have no legal authority re. my property over and above that which I extend to you such as is necessary for your to execute your duties as my agent.
What I store on your server is [b]not[/b] your property; and, unless I authorize such, you have no right to even look at it, let alone exercise any control over it.
by dawgit
by deepsand
It is a physical fact that, while the suspect in question may have [i]thought[/i] that he was engaging a minor, he was not.
And, there is a legal term for the act of law enforcement inducing one to commit a crime, [i]entrapment[/i]. Per Merriam-Webster:
Main Entry: en?trap?ment
2 : [b]the action of luring an individual into committing a crime in order to prosecute the person for it[/b]
The pivotal issue here, with respect to whether or not one can be legally convicted, is whether or not, absent the involvement of a member of law enforcement, [i]or[/i] the involvement of an [i]agent[/i] employed by law enforcement, the suspect would have committed a like offense. If not, the accused stands acquitted by the defense of entrapment.
You are never going to atone for being a lawyer in a previous incarnation with arguments like that.
As far as I'm aware it would only be entrapment if the copper posing as the child encouraged the sicko to commit a crime, ie offered to fulfill his perverted fantasies.
Statements such as "I'm only 12" shouldn't defined as encouragement.
by techexec2
The poster is not "factually correct", and neither are you.
I am not one of those emotional ones you are speaking to. But, here's some help anyway:
[b]There is no "pivotal issue" here at all.[/b]
Apparently you did not watch the Dateline stings that are referenced in this discussion. This is a situation where the police are conducting proper sting operations where the online predator has to initiate the activity himself, do things that provide clear evidence of intent (e.g. provide pictures of his privates, etc.), and then follow through by showing up at the home of the "12 year old".
I don't judge people here too harshly for their strong emotional reaction. But, I don't offer intellectual argument and pedantic analysis that incites them further either. Perhaps you should save it for the courtroom, counsellor?
by deepsand
It is a physical fact that, while the suspect in question may have thought that he was engaging a minor, he was not.
And, there is a legal term for the act of law enforcement inducing one to commit a crime, entrapment. Per Merriam-Webster:
Main Entry: en?trap?ment
2 : the action of luring an individual into committing a crime in order to prosecute the person for it
The pivotal issue here, with respect to whether or not one can be legally convicted, is whether or not, absent the involvement of a member of law enforcement, or the involvement of an agent employed by law enforcement, the suspect would have committed a like offense. If not, the accused stands acquitted by the defense of entrapment.
by nicknielsen
I logically understand the need to protect the rights of the accused.
But my gut tells me that, regardless of how contact was initiated, an individual who knowingly makes an assignation with a minor ("I'm only 12."), then actually appears at the assigned location, definitely has intent and definitely would have committed a like offense, with or without entrapping actions.
by tonythetiger
A guy goes out to buy some weed, goes to a dealer, and buys it (no cops).
He gets home, rolls one up, and discovers it's oregano. Did he commit a crime?
by techexec2
The poster is not "factually correct", and neither are you.
I am not one of those emotional ones you are speaking to. But, here's some help anyway:
[b]There is no "pivotal issue" here at all.[/b]
Apparently you did not watch the Dateline stings that are referenced in this discussion. This is a situation where the police are conducting proper sting operations where the online predator has to initiate the activity himself, do things that provide clear evidence of intent (e.g. provide pictures of his privates, etc.), and then follow through by showing up at the home of the "12 year old".
I don't judge people here too harshly for their strong emotional reaction. But, I don't offer intellectual argument and pedantic analysis that incites them further either. Perhaps you should save it for the courtroom, counsellor?
by deepsand
Conspiracy requires an overt act towards the implementation of the plan.
Mere planning is not criminal.
by deepsand
by deepsand
If the law enforcement agent is the one who solicits, then entrapment has occured; entrapment is an affirmatice defense against conviction.
And, no, the making of sexually explicit statements, be it to an adult or a minor, does not, in and of itself, constitute "solicitation." Solicitation requires an overt petition or proposition.
by deepsand
1) There is no national "age of consent" in the U.S.; such falls solely within the purview of the States.
2) There is no single "age of consent" for any and all acts. For example, within a given jurisdiction, the minimum required attained age in order to marry without the permission of an elder may be different from that required in order to legally engage in consensual sexual intercourse.
3) With regards to marriage, there may be [b]two[/b] ages of consent. Attainment of the higher age is sufficient to marry without the consent of another; failure to attain the lower age renders the consent of another insufficient. Attainment of the lower, but not the higher, permits marriage with the consent of another.
by dawgit
by jamesrl
The precedents in each state/province/country may be different.
We can make relevant analogies with the police officers posing as prostitutes, as there is much case law and precendent around this.
The relevant point is: who initiates the discussion of the illegal activity. If the police do, its entrapment, if the the other person initiates the discussion of illegal activity, its not.
Don't foget that in the internet schemes, they are gving the person every opportunity to back out, so that the case is ironclad. The person shows intent by asking to meet, intent by discussing sex, intent by showing up.
James
by tonythetiger
by danlm
The accused being solicited? In this case, as my previous example set forth. The accused did all of the soliciting to the underage or the police officer with regard to this conversation. Thus, where is entrapment? The police officer was approached, put forward conversation signifying their supposed age was of a minor, and then was lured to meet the individual for illicit acts.
Again though, the police officer is approached and in now way set this up.
Dan
by whistl3r
It's your responsibility to monitor the activities of your children.
Parenting does not stop after your child(ren) go to school or their curricular activities... if you think it does your a "Dead Beat" parent not accepting your responsibilities.
Let's get this straight. You're saying the ISP's and the Government have a responsibility (Legal Right) to packet sniff the network, rummage through your home, monitor your banking activities, etc... just because you lack the ability to take responsibility for your own neglect.
I, for one, wish to reign in the power of the state, and give back more freedom and privacy to all citizens.
That said, I would rather put dollars into preventing things that bog network efficiency that business analysts porign over logs to look for the occasional impropriety.
by nicknielsen
freedom of action or thought though, but from consequences.
If you found someone chatting up anyone's kid never mind your own. Consequences are going to get extreme, probably for us for taking the LAW into our own hands.
The idea that the law serves us seems to have been stolen by the legal profession. You can't successfully prosecute them for it though, they'll just take the fifth and the judge will chuck the case out for lack out evidence.
Besides if you prosecuted you'd be lawyer, there's probably a law against prosecuting yourself.
Sort of legalistic suicide.
by deepsand
That's merely the age old concept that Statutory Law trumps Contract Law. Such merely means that any provision of a Contract that attempts to contravene Statutory law is null and void.
Setting aside such instances, the party providing the hosting services acquires no rights or authority beyond those granted by the client.
by deepsand
by deepsand
My statements are grounded in U.S. law, and are borne of personal experiences in the court room.
The key issue in determining whether of not entrapment occurred lies in the question "in the absence of the acts of law enforcement, would the accused have committed the illegal act?"
Answering such question in the physical realm oft time proves to be exceedingly difficult; in the virtual one it may well be nigh unto impossible.
by deepsand
by deepsand
Are you as weary of this justification as I am?
Is this what it's all about; reproducing so that we can live lives devoted to our offspring?
by deepsand
by deepsand
My statements are grounded in U.S. law, and are borne of personal experiences in the court room.
The key issue in determining whether of not entrapment occurred lies in the question "in the absence of the acts of law enforcement, would the accused have committed the illegal act?"
Answering such question in the physical realm oft time proves to be exceedingly difficult; in the virtual one it may well be nigh unto impossible.
by deepsand
by tonythetiger
by deepsand
by techexec2
by nicknielsen
by deepsand
The universe is a cold and uncaring place. It gives not a whit about our opinions.
Likewise, the Law does not bend to our opinions.
It is because of people like you that we screen perspective jurors before they are allowed to sit in judgement.
by deepsand
To repeat, no act is, by definition, a crime unless the Statuatory Law of the applicable jurisdiction [b]explicitly[/b] defines said act as a crime.
There are [b]no implied crimes[/b].
Remember there are no policemen on the information superhighway!
Nobody can effectively stop most internet crime.
We can "put the waggons into a circle" and try to hide behind firewalls and content filters, or like the wild west, we can use smallpox infected blankets and the .45 and the Gatlin gun to exterminate the "Indians" ourselves at settlers in the jungle of cyberspace.
Until we came to see ourselves a vigalente, judge, jury, executioner and undertaker and not rely on THEM to keep us safe, nothing will happen.
YOU are responsible for YOUR IT security, there is no THEM to blame.
by deepsand
Many forget, if they ever knew, that the law is, by necessity, reactive. It cannot anticipate every new situation, but only adapt as such occur and demand its attention.
Furthermore, the law is neither an independant entity nor one that is static; rather, it is but a dynamic reflection of ever changing culture and mores.
Like the real Wild West, there will come a time when the 'Net as we now know it ceases to exist, having been molded into one that is less freely accessible and ever so much more tame.
by dawgit
Remember there are no policemen on the information superhighway!
Nobody can effectively stop most internet crime.
We can "put the waggons into a circle" and try to hide behind firewalls and content filters, or like the wild west, we can use smallpox infected blankets and the .45 and the Gatlin gun to exterminate the "Indians" ourselves at settlers in the jungle of cyberspace.
Until we came to see ourselves a vigalente, judge, jury, executioner and undertaker and not rely on THEM to keep us safe, nothing will happen.
YOU are responsible for YOUR IT security, there is no THEM to blame.
by techexec2
by deepsand
by nicknielsen
From Title 16, Chapter 15 of the SC Code of Laws (http://tinyurl.com/ew278):
SECTION 16-15-342. Criminal solicitation of a minor; defenses; penalties. [SC ST SEC 16-15-342]
(A) A person eighteen years of age or older commits the offense of criminal solicitation of a minor if he knowingly contacts or communicates with, or attempts to contact or communicate with, a person who is under the age of eighteen, or a person reasonably believed to be under the age of eighteen, for the purpose of or with the intent of persuading, inducing, enticing, or coercing the person to engage or participate in a sexual activity as defined in Section 16-15-375(5) or a violent crime as defined in Section 16-1-60, or with the intent to perform a sexual activity in the presence of the person under the age of eighteen, or person reasonably believed to be under the age of eighteen.
(B) Consent is a defense to a prosecution pursuant to this section if the person under the age of eighteen, or the person reasonably believed to be under the age of eighteen, is at least sixteen years old.
(C) Consent is not a defense to a prosecution pursuant to this section if the person under the age of eighteen, or the person reasonably believed to be under the age of eighteen, is under the age of sixteen.
(D) It is not a defense to a prosecution pursuant to this section, on the basis of consent or otherwise, that the person reasonably believed to be under the age of eighteen is a law enforcement agent or officer acting in an official capacity.
(E) A person who violates the provisions of this section is guilty of a felony and, upon conviction, must be fined not more than five thousand dollars or imprisoned for not more than ten years, or both.
In this case, paragraph D specifically excludes the fact the the "target" was in fact a law enforcement official. I don't know what case law there is on this.
=====
From Title 44, CHAPTER 53 of the SC Code of Laws (http://tinyurl.com/jdl64):
SECTION 44-53-370. Prohibited acts A; penalties.
(a) Except as authorized by this article it shall be unlawful for any person:
(1) to manufacture, distribute, dispense, deliver, purchase, aid, abet, [b]attempt[/b], or conspire [b]to manufacture, distribute, dispense, deliver, or purchase[/b], or possess with the intent to manufacture, distribute, dispense, deliver, or purchase [b]a controlled substance or a controlled substance analogue[/b];
(2) to create, distribute, dispense, deliver, or purchase, or aid, abet, [b]attempt[/b], or conspire [b]to create, distribute, dispense, deliver, or purchase[/b], or possess with intent to distribute, dispense, deliver, or purchase [b]a counterfeit substance[/b].
My emphasis. The attempt to purchase or possess either the controlled substance or a counterfeit is criminal solicitation.
I'm not aware of many states where the related laws are significantly different from these cases.
Major edit: added addition reference, reorganized
by techexec2
That's what I thought! You cannot answer a direct question because it is not in the context of a trial inside a court of law. I don't see much point in your offering all of this legal argument here (more than 20 posts of it). While it is helpful to clarify the law for the layman, offering only general legal theory, and not even commenting on the specific Dateline stings at hand, is of very limited value, is mere pedantry, and is merely diametrically opposing the strong emotional reactions of some of the parents posting here.
I think the Dateline stings, conducted in cooperation with the police, where each online predator was arrested and taken off to jail, were legal, proper, and they will hold up in court.
Each "Dateline" online predator deserves his day in court with a defense attorney just like you. And, I bet you would lose your case.
by deepsand
by deepsand
by deepsand
What you've presented is one State's Statute, which explicitly defines certain acts as crimes.
This does [b]not[/b] support the contention that there exists some common set of acts all of which are crimes in all juridictions, which is the issue at hand.
by deepsand
I concur that the 'Net will most likely end up segmented, with both winners and losers.
Perhaps more importantly, individual access to it may very well become restricted to a degree that we here now gathered would consider draconian. In that eventuality, we can expect to see the re-emergence of the equivalent of phone phreaking, as people seek access to that which is forbidden them.
by nicknielsen
"intent" cannot usually be proven, thus is not a crime. I may intend to kill somebody, but if I never attempt to do so, I have not committed a crime.
In the posited situation (going out to purchase marijuana and going home with oregano), the buyer has committed a crime in both New York and South Carolina by his [b]attempt[/b] to obtain marijuana. He can not be charged with possession, but can be charged with the attempt to possess (soliciting the act).
I don't imagine the laws that apply to this case are much different in the other 48 states.
Sort by Trending