Are ISPs' doing enough to combat the fight against online predators?
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jdclyde
that it has gone on for a week before anyone (me) even noticed we were arguing the wrong point.
I don't WANT them to [b]combat the FIGHT against predators[/b], I want them to [b]HELP the fight against predators[/b].
How did we all miss that? :0
:8}
by techexec2
Excellent catch, JD.
I guess we all missed it because the idea of [i]combatting[/i] the fight against predators would never enter our minds!
Funny how the mind works sometimes...
by deepsand
by jdclyde
It was my own observational skills, that I allowed myself to get lazy in my reading and had skimmed right over that for a whole week. Very disappointing.
I don't knock the originator, as anyone (EVEN ME) can have a typos or a misspelling.
The question is, how many people that have come here NOTICED what was typed, not what we assumed was intended? If you saw it, congrats. I completely missed it until last night.
by techexec2
Argue with these facts, counsellor.
Now, I don't want to hear any more of your pathetic false pedantic legal bullsh*t. You are WRONG WRONG WRONG. X-(
And, I am right. B-)
I rest my case.
-----
[i]"Number of predators jailed due to Perverted-Justice.com since June 2004: 86"[/i]
These people work with Dateline and on their own to sting and get convictions of online predators.
Perverted Justice Website
http://www.perverted-justice.com/
-----
[i]"The NBC Web site says the show has helped catch 129 male predators in a total of 14 days between 2004 and 2006; at least 71 have been convicted so far."[/i]
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,207356,00.html
-----
[i]"A Rockville, Md., rabbi caught in a Dateline NBC sting of online sexual predators, was found guilty last week on charges of ?coercion and enticement? and travel with intent to engage in illicit sexual contact with a minor. Each count carries a maximum sentence of 30 years; the minimum is five years. Sentencing will take place Dec. 1."[/i]
[i]"On its Web site, Perverted Justice trumpets the Kaye conviction, noting that it is the group?s 75th conviction since 2004 and 35th this year, and that it was ?one of our most anticipated convictions of 2006.? "[/i]
Convicted Maryland rabbi awaits sentencing in ?Dateline? sting case
http://www.jewishsf.com/content/2-0-/module/displaystory/story_id/30324/format/html/displaystory.html
by deepsand
by deepsand
With respect to illegal drugs, for example, intent to sell and sale are 2 separate acts, differentiated by whether or not the transaction was completed. As with any contract, there are 3 basic required elements: offer, acceptance and consideration (generally a monitized payment.)
While the 1st, offer (to sell), is both necessary and sufficient so as to display intent to sell, all 3 are required for a sale to have occurred. And, since the latter incorporate the former, one can in fact be charged with both offenses if a sale is deemed to have occurred.
An offer to buy, however, can be a gray area. There is a large body of case law dealing with the distinction between, on the one hand, an inquiry and an offer to buy, and on the other, between an offer to sell and an invitation to make an inquiry. Needless to say, given the number of extent jurisdictions, there are numerous different & conflicting decisions.
These issues come into play in many different types of criminal cases, with the result that to attempt to give an answer certain to hypotheticals that contain such issues is to undertake a fools errand.
by deepsand
With respect to illegal drugs, for example, intent to sell and sale are 2 seperate acts, differentiated by whether or not the transaction was completed. As with any contract, there are 3 basic required elements: offer, acceptance and consideration (generally a monitized payment.)
While the 1st, offer (to sell), is both necessary and sufficient so as to display intent to sell, all 3 are required for a sale to have occurred. And, since the latter incorporate the former, one can in fact be charged with both offenses if a sale is deemed to have occurred.
An offer to buy, however, can be a gray area. There is a large body of case law dealing with the distinction between, on the one hand, an inquiry and an offer to buy, and on the other, between an offer to sell and an invitation to make an inquiry. Needless to say, given the number of extent jurisdictions, there are numerous different & conflicting decisions.
These issues come into play in many different types of criminal cases, with the result that to attempt to give an answer certain to hypotheticals that contain such issues is to undertake a fools errand.
by deepsand
With respect to illegal drugs, for example, intent to sell and sale are 2 seperate acts, differentiated by whether or not the transaction was completed. As with any contract, there are 3 basic required elements: offer, acceptance and consideration (generally a monitized payment.)
While the 1st, offer (to sell), is both necessary and sufficient so as to display intent to sell, all 3 are required for a sale to have occurred. And, since the latter incorporate the former, one can in fact be charged with both offenses if a sale is deemed to have occurred.
An offer to buy, however, can be a gray area. There is a large body of case law dealing with the distinction between, on the one hand, an inquiry and an offer to buy, and on the other, between an offer to sell and an invitation to make an inquiry. Needless to say, given the number of extent jurisdictions, there are numerous different & conflicting decisions.
These issues come into play in many different types of criminal cases, with the result that to attempt to give an answer certain to hypotheticals that contain such issues is to undertake a fools errand.
by deepsand
On Sunday [b]she[/b] was allowed to listen to her favorite gospel radio program.
My sisters and I became ever so tired of the hymn "[i]Throw Out the Lifeline.[/i]"
by deepsand
by techexec2
You are "batting 1000" on being wrong. Now you are wrong about me.
[i]"Your are the person for whom the jury screening process was intended to bar from sitting in judgment; you are given to prejudgment, based on your opinions rather than on the facts."[/i]
Without exception, every single time that I have been on jury duty, I have been chosen to be a juror in a trial.
There is a big difference between being objective in the context of a criminal trial, and having basic common sense and speaking openly in a discussion here on TR. All it takes is basic common sense to appreciate the value and righteousness of the Dateline "Catch a Predator" stings. If you've ever seen the show, you would know that. There are solid reasons why the conviction rates in these stings are so high.
But, "Dateline" is not a trial. Were I on the jury of one of these trials, I would carefully judge the actual evidence presented in the trial. If the police did not get the sting right, if they entrapped the accused, if in my mind the accused was not guilty beyond a reasonable doubt based on the actual evidence presented and the explanation of the applicable laws, I would surely vote to acquit.
It would not matter if he had already been convicted of a similar crime before (although that would likely not be shown to the jury...too prejudicial). It would not matter if I have a 12 year old daughter at home. Why? Because, that is how our legal system works. Like it or not, the definition of a "crime" is what the law says it is. None of us, including the judge, the jury, the police, or the attorneys, get to make up the rules.
Like "rfink" said in this discussion, what about the case of mistaken identity where some innocent guy shows up accidentally at the home where the sting is being conducted? The prosecutor has to PROVE that the evidence is true and that the evidence is sufficient to vote for GUILTY. Merely showing up accidentally MUST be exposed during a trial and that man must go free. It is more than obvious that this is not what occurred in the Dateine stings ([i]but the prosecutor must prove it to me as a juror[/i]).
I really don't understand you. If your point is that we all must remember to be objective and keep our emotions in check regarding these cases, you could have said it in one post. It is not necessary to run around and "whack" everyone who is posting here with your legal theory. The emotional ones would not even get on the jury. The defense would see to that. Just as you opposed the emotional ones here, I opposed you. That's the only reason why I have posted back to you so many times.
Like I said in my very first post back to you, save it for the courtroom, counsellor.
by tig2
Deepsand, I really appreciate your clear view to legal objectivity as much as I appreciate TechExec's command of what has been proven factual. I think that perhaps you are both valuing the same things... but coming at consensus from two different paths.
Deepsand- we can never forget that the accused is innocent until proven guilty. Unfortunately, I think that many of us experience a knee-jerk response to danger to a child. It is good to hear an objective voice as it helps us to understand how we must view the legal system and what it is able to do- and NOT do. I have had to keep legal records that at any time could become an exhibit in trial. There is a mindset that forces one to seperate opinion based on observation from factual evidence. It is difficult for many to develop. I have been hearing you say that it is important to consider that which is FACTUAL when considering guilt and innocence.
At the same time, TechExec has presented the arguement that there are points of law that permit one to be accused based on proof of intent. I get that too- after the fact, after a child has been molested, is not always the best time to stop a predator. So law has been extended to permit a person to be accused (not necessarily convicted) based on what is known about their intention. The fact that there are convictions (TechExec provided citations) indicates that this is acceptable.
At the end- I think that both of you came to the discussion, not to change each other's or any one elses mind, but to present salient viewpoints that- to me, at least- converge. To Deepsand's point, we have to remember that objectivity is critical; to TechExec's point, there is a flexibility in law that permits an arrest based on intention. And especially in these cases, it is critical to consider only the objective evidence.
by nicknielsen
that you feel so threatened by my logic that you have to post your arguments multiple times... ;)
TR strikes again! :^0
Edited to add second thought: Having re-read this branch from the initial post "So" (http://tinyurl.com/neypx), I am tempted to research and post the appropriate statutes from the remaining 48 states, but will forebear. My strong impression is that it would only result in the splitting of more hairs, and I need all I've got.
by deepsand
For this I was vehemently attacked.
At best, this is a case of the attacker having been being bested by his emotions; at worst, intellectual dishonesty.
I make no apology where none is due.
by deepsand
1) Once
2) Again
3) And yet again
I had thought the days of 404's and multiple posts were behind us, but TR proved me wrong, yet again.
Have a good weekend. With TR being down for the phase-over to the new site, it's a mandatory vacation.
by deepsand
Your brain simply did what it's supposed to do, and filtered out the noise, leaving you to free to attend to the desired signal. Absent this ability to apply a discrimination function to incoming sensory data, we would see nothing but blur, hear nothing but cacophony, etc..
It is only when the signal-to-noise ratio is too low that we are forced to re-evaluate the raw data, thus becoming aware of the noise elements.
Furthermore, the [i]purpose[/i] of, in this case, reading determines which, and to what extent, discrimination functions are employed. For example, an English teacher, evaluating a student's writing, would be deliberately looking for an error such as here occurred, whereas those hear gathered are seeking to quickly grasp the intent of a post, as preparation to deciding if and how to reply.
As for myself, I cannot say if it was the case that I saw it and dismissed it, or was unaware of it, as it was not of sufficient import to me so as to be remembered. Quite possibly I did not even read the title in full, as I tend to ignore them and go straight to the body, returning to the title only if deemed necessary for a full understanding of the post.
In conclusion, I think that your brain is functioning as intended.
Enjoy the vacation mandated by TR.
by nicknielsen
[i]This does not support the contention that there exists some common set of acts all of which are crimes in all juridictions, which is the issue at hand.[/i]
The following acts, at least, are crimes in all jurisdictions in which I have resided (my observation):
* the intentional taking of a human life without legal sanction (murder), a felony
* the taking of property without legal sanction (theft), felony or misdemeanor, depending on the value of the property
* the unprovoked striking of another person (commonly called assault or battery), often a felony
* exceeding the maximum allowed speed on a public highway (speeding), usually a misdemeanor
Of course, committing these acts usually violates the law :D
by techexec2
[i]"My posts were confined to facts alone; they were countered with opinions. For this I was vehemently attacked."[/i]
It takes two to "fight". You must admit that you "fought" back. And, you must admit that you refuse to accept defeat, even when proven wrong. I admire your determination, but would suggest some moderation.
You also must admit that I countered with irrefutable facts (86 convictions), not just opinions.
If this were a real-world discussion, I would [i]insist[/i] on ending it over a beer. This is not a personal attack. It's about ideas.
-----
[i]"At best, this is a case of the attacker having been being bested by his emotions;"[/i]
I am not made of wood and I make no apology for that. But, I have more than clearly shown that I am not overcome by my emotions here. I have a position, and I defended it vigorously.
-----
[i]"at worst, intellectual dishonesty.[/i]
Except for when you were discussing my prospects as a juror, you confined your posts to legal facts as you saw them. But, as my citations clearly showed, [b]your facts are not correct in this case.[/b]
It's not entirely clear to me what you are doing. It appears that you entered and continued in this discussion with a hidden agenda. My guess is that your agenda is that you oppose the Dateline stings and you have a problem with the power of the government. And, you are using your legal argument all over this discussion to advance that agenda. If that is true, then YOU would be guilty of intellectual dishonesty. But, I cannot accuse you because I don't know that.
One thing is clear. When I presented you with solid irrefutable facts (86 convictions), you disregarded them. Explain that.
-----
[i]"I make no apology where none is due."[/i]
I don't think any apologies are needed by either of us. I have not viewed this as a personal attack by either of us. This has only been about ideas, perhaps with a toe over the line here or there. There's no need to apologize for that, especially since we would be having a beer by now.
-----
I'm going to end with a qualified compliment for you. I think you would be a great asset on the defense team of someone accused of a crime. But I would be concerned about you being the lead attorney. I would be concerned about your ability to adapt your tactics given the moves made by the prosecutor. You seem to hold onto your position too tightly even when you are losing your case.
So...What is your favorite beer? My current one is Beck's non-alcholic. I like to enjoy my beer regularly and keep a clear head at the same time. At those other chosen times, it's Glenlivet on the rocks.
by techexec2
by deepsand
It's been my experience that that's always been a [i]summary offense[/i] as opposed to a [i]criminal[/i] one.
Your mileage may vary.
by deepsand
My post dealt [i]strictly[/i] with the general issue of [i]entrapment[/i].
The facts offered up by you were irrelevant to such, and therefore immaterial and inconsequential.
In short, in that your replies failed to address the subject at hand, they were non-substantive.
What, then, was the point of continuing with them?
by techexec2
[i]"My post dealt strictly with the general issue of entrapment.
The facts offered up by you were irrelevant to such, and therefore immaterial and inconsequential.
In short, in that your replies failed to address the subject at hand, they were non-substantive.
What, then, was the point of continuing with them?"
[/i]
This discussion is not about [i]~the general issue of entrapment~[/i]. It's about the Dateline stings that have repeatedly been proven to be proper in court. [b]Your post is irrelevant! Motion to strike is upheld![/b]
I am beginning to think Maxwell is right about you.
P.S. I take it back. I don't want you on a defense team. Even a strong lead attorney could not keep you focussed on the best interests of the accused.
by techexec2
by ontheropes
by nicknielsen
by deepsand
not the root.
Mis-direction may work with some, but not here, not with me.
by deepsand
by techexec2
by deepsand
It did not work before, and it will not work now.
Do you wish to discuss, entrapment, which is the subject of my post to which you replied?
by techexec2
You must read what other people post in order to have a discussion. You clearly do not do that very well. If you did, you would not have asked your last question. And, you would not go off on your irrelevant tangent about entrapment. Nobody is changing the subject except you.
No question. Maxwell is [b]definitely[/b] right about you.
Here's some help (if you actually [i]read[/i] it):
[b]done[/b] [i]adj[/i] (14c) [b]1 :[/b] arrived at or brought to an end [b]2 :[/b] doomed to failure or defeat
Using the word "done" in a sentence:
[b]Definition 1:[/b] Our discussion done.
[b]Definition 2:[/b] You are done.
by deepsand
factually incorrect.
See
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=201505&messageID=2101067
and
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=201505&messageID=2103816
and the resulting sub-threads.
by mgordon
"Chat Rooms" exist that are monitored and safe, but who wants to use them? One must pay for someone to monitor chat rooms, and the person who would most enjoy being the chat room monitor IS the pedophile. I know of a few in my state, operated by members of a church, that perform this service -- but not for free. You can also have proxied web surfing. Very safe, but it is not FREE.
*I* monitor what my children are doing on the internet. I'd love to see the automated monitor that can pry loose the true meaning of what teenagers are IM'ing to each other. It can be quite a surprise to some parents to discover that the secret lives of their children are SO different than they 'day lives'.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending